ALCAIDE | JERR ENRIC C. OBLIGATIONS CASE AND CONTRACTS DiGests Quant Freight Srtrmational , Tne v Kachin - Coorett Fouaraing Company, Ino Facts Keihum - Cyorsth entinad “into os “aching Youico Opuemant with : Matuwhto- Under thy Ognumand Kachin - Cynutt Moulds Provide Abrwicr for Metuatita's Trucking repurremente. Yar, duwicte int bubcortracted hy Rathin - Gusatt to Qian Frsept, trough Ae oun Prucking Abie Oppuemsnd. Secukicl ow the fame day- th pik to02 , Mobunhita cali Kidin-Goutt about o coburn in Be Oprtl 14, 2002 jawas of He tabloids rommpapon fumes This hey, forte that Me Oph 17, 002 ‘urtencaphiom by Cateccan Chy poticn oy totem, tuck filled wi) abipronk oy vitles monitor ond CeTV Ayctrma ume Ay Matai, - hethen - Greet directed Grunt Fraigtt Yo inweatigah te matter « Bunung “th Aprst. 20, ove fucting why Kenhin - Goerett anc Matuwhito. , Orisnt Truight putinated Bat re buck monly bake dawn ard fod to be sted floweyer , when Be, Adiprant Orined in ffekohama appar, sf waa ducoinsd gat 10 pallet of te phyment'e Uk carton core, tawny Hidun Gott icipandanthy wmesigated the, mudunt or gbtanod o pe nfo Ad, dry Ok ME A Mo ope da rfoded ty Opuno. Gust Fruglt at "Ba Tuck hid ane =“Hon the uch ute intinapti by te fulica long C3 Read tear By comen o Paget Rogaton Cusnur in, Catascon Cy, Cudaa escapid Gr became Ty Aiigck o a manhunt: Crisnt Fruipt saan admetad Pat “oh pravioun MpOt unk Luorsoue onl tht puljroge wa panty grou. Matwohite, tovmmatid “ye In- Hower Brokerage Aowicr Ognesment iutth, Malier- Guabk , tid fsa oy confidones for tonuncaing the, contact, Waring Hot Rikon = Grott'e way q fantlung me sncident ard “pa Tordiachonu, tlie irewunt» rulwant facta “amowbd to praucl and. Hynpid On uaitin diiugard of He pula of few” Ruthin, - Gooncht, demanded (yer Quint Friigt Pe,500,000.00 a8 eominy fem ak of come, a argud Hak Owat thighs tuahardlling 4 He Aitualion cowed ty, toxranation of Ravhin - Coanctle Contract tsth Matas Oriank Frage laumad. “tht “Aa inal: nating of filjerage, cand in pod (eA 24, mransfeatid fy He uapdrmatiionn from ia Prpleyene and, the good Cots and, tes tiny Pipmns of te cone. Uuletn on ot Ornile Ie g te Cuil Coda ‘wo applicable whbtin on rat Orient Freigtt uns Augigent for fouling Le duictors He pets uonourcing te hyactoig meidont , which tel to Be founi- fation He Fucking Aowicn Optesmort batsssr, Rahim - Cuote onc fratehit,. ho Crttole 27 w tot applicable . Paibonon'a -pegigones did pot esate a, incubus unis on gal ralateinchipwith the Respondent ; which wauld, fave athowias gun fine, “too guaai~ chlict- Potiuner's cafy to raporcnd txiokd rioy to tt realayrt act Wi agpondint ontecid pings Mgarckng Hn youd roport ard asec Ho thuwttigats, “Be wnedant » _potitiontnla oblpdlin we cntdte- flascptn, Pablinan wae Ulgd po have foxyouned ‘ds oblgalion Aeghigectly , danting damage th respond Jo te tune, Hors ane Uectiin on He pak op tle dyancant tolish Cousd damegt to te Panyy , bt Bow ia potuig Alea Dat de diyurdont iptyrticl To comesall the, “huith, 0» to Qasied Shabu. When she, fom becama oppaunt to Aapandant thy, satin riadily opelagued ‘to Retin amd Mectruorita, for or *rictake « Conca urtly , Qrttee 170, 072 rt 173. of Ae Caitl Cds on taglgpnece ws He ferpprmance Oo Gn obligation Aout apply 2 Her Giants Frog une sglige: fugigenco Ant too ton ated oy “He, fail fe ebaowe at agua oy Cars, Pracouctiny on digilone Hat te Creunctonces jt domard, thay Hat atl rion syne ny" Ye Ld on coat des tot provide for to ditty of dihgenc tm by Syreittdh, ton he Reguind idence, 1a Hak of a peed fot, of ov family, Thy gil gy Gin Eig to imp ply a itt ort waa a tly OE ene agama Gey, Bina hop fall Wanair du datigencs im ditching te, rus fact 4 ty nicbat te Plountif Pidin arc Mathaba, » Cv a reault, plaintiff Leitin, Mfgric Ancome Soars hy fhason of Matouahe Camllothin, 4 Bein compact whtA, pourtandy aa Couns by tiplaina gf Olan Fruigyt.Tangy». Cant 5 Gye Patiluorey , toeinto M- Tarp ding tuum Linden fe fama o TMT. Goginering ard Roanaly Merchandiaig prepaid fo rapondort Vecunte, Hin, Gt to conaticl ov wirdinll ppb for fine far a Concidlanutiiny of F60a0.00 and a Cruryon garady fron te date of Complution « Pontuarl to Me agnument titpendadt paid palitinor a, downy Payment of 0,000.00 ard “ywatattmont payrrurt of 5,000.00 , Leaving a hadame of 15,000.00. Aug Ho He Rfucak ard falune of Meperdant fo poy Me balloncs , pélilvendr Had a conploint to colltct te Amount. Reipontint dunied a chim dying tak Me tod obeady poids is Omowt te SPGMI atch Conmbructed Be dep wil to hick te, tandmclll dytory aaa to be connacted Morsouon, aatumumg “tot Me Quad Pitioney a. balance of P15,020-00 ,thia Arould he ofpask by tie dapucto inv the oundmeld Which, Counad, He thudtine te collagen afer & thieng irl hit ta place. Pothibren denad Hot Be conrbuobin of & dup well wad vreducted uw He oppaimart fy wild te endl ayptim, He alee dueownscl ang ablgalion te pain or Macontbuct He Ayptemy ond Inaisti Hak fe detiinsd “HE in quad arc uierking Condity Yo Bipenderde who Occaphd He fame woblou proket, Buvidea , da collaprr lune attribtably pa Hiphoon | 0. Jorn opuns , which Teluwad him of ony Daily. When ox tet puttionn id under abligalion #0 Kecorbuct the wurdmadll aftr i collapind .ye Petitioner ia under abigatin to recoutuct subpot difaclue, cour egitim , iw aecardoner inith, He ora yearn guaranty - dn un fur o- party claim skenplion por Wabiity by Maton af PPrtaitoun cuomt rca Oriole 174 a, ty Cuil Code He aunt Would bi Aa dle ard prague Count G fhe lad on dutrctin of se obeet be contact - Foun Gi) peguatie mutt cancun + (2) fle cand ¢ te buck 4 He oblige mat ML sivlpincint op le will g ato, dabtor ; Cb) Fe swat putt ty itloy wnpovsaable en wnaoidable; (2) He ewoet must By bch ao te pando, ‘i mpterble for te, cabtor fo fetfll, lia cbc ten tn av ovina manner; arc) He aabtor must js pus rom ang Parsipalion lw ex gaprauation of the upny To He Cadden. Patitmer faudids to Alo Hat the collaphn af Ae wircmidl ure cg a ov fertuttun soext. faitionn manay abated pak tone uaa o "chong wird - Buk a Atiwng wind im hin Cane cannot bo portutoue — unforosable for yraveidable, én te contrary a, chy ward Mould dy preort im Piacoa ley yyrdmlla are conbuctid , tome te wirdmule wl rot wa. In raciprccal, obligations , neiter party inane w delay iy Wa oto, done nok comply Ov it nok mady fo comply in a propor Manner ith whet 1g snowmbent spor him. lila rie, windmill failed, fo function prpindy “st hgeaml uncymbort upon prion Ho jmottute He, proplr ropaina J Accor dare with Ue quoranty atid in te cabaot. ‘Tat responds Comat fe foid tor hoe tweed in daly 5 muttod rb a pisttionsr whe thot fron fa syepantst fon te pucontbintion, of Me murctnuld - Oticte, G7 of Ae Cuil Code ia oxphicit le i Ye do pvmettung ala to de ik, ty fone Mall te erecuted a hia (oak} PHILCOMSAT y- Qobe Telecom Fada PHILCOMSAT and Hlobe entord, jato any Sgpusmont uoveby PAIL COMSAT” ablgadsd “ay tr satabhah, opurate ond provide om IBS Honda 8 sarkh hatin (earth Matin) wither Cabi Point for the syoturine ee of Me US Mires, ommumcatira Gpuney (USDCA), Sv tuna, , Mabe, promiasd fo fey PHL Comsar mariNty rarkala por tach hatich Gnauit muelved Or He Hine of He Sacuition gy He Agpsumant , doth partise Reaw tat Be Malitoyy Bato Agravmont epoern shy public of whe, Philyop ares ard te US (RP-uS Tlity Boer Ogtumert),, which at te ba0id for He Geeupancy of We ark Gr Bars ard Rubies Punk Base un Cubi Point , waa Jo Mpa iw lag). Aubeiquontly , PAlLCOMSAT natal ard Subabhihed He zor Matin at Cubi Punt ond ty, USDCA mode uty of He Ang Oy Aptember He, 1441, Be Jarcte posed and adapted fanaty Raalunin, fa. 141, Sprouting ‘ch deen tot ta com bv He halipicalion q te Feuaty 4 Frusrdahip , Coperersin, arc acundy ord “rh Lugplementary Gorn pomta pat Way Augpautd, to getued He Tm of He Hike, ty He US 4 Aubic foul Bane, among atten dev Micamdor 3), 1941 the Phelpping, ovsvvment fark a fay denbole tr the US fowmmnt Hoar ‘He US Grong aainyag i Me Aitgpnae'Zomumaton ge $P-US Png Boars Os parmant Lote tolpisd FALCOMSAT o Ue ntirliin to diicontinad Te wie gy He sort alin in Ow) Of He uutthovawal of US military peracrnel, from Jubi Posok fast oper Ae feymiratn, of Lh RP-US dito Bone Ograsmest. ob, auth ata wich to fort Mopars en foilubiusduant - Apter Ale US riliony frre Left Aube, foval baat, PHILCOMSAT demandud. from Mobs payment of de auldtarchiy payment abigaliina unten -Lle Cguemsect dmauitng A US$ 4,910,154 00. Hawevor, Mabe rpuaec Jo les PHIL COMSAT's dumand « Whar or fut warto contig fore majuure occured ond pcp Re spon payment of Miobe e Nankale fon th. pomaundon cy she tom of te Gapesmont Yr Goonta conctiiting pore majpunt, eccurad and pubupecl Hiobi'e non - Payrant Quaicke, 7A wich Cxemple an sbiger from Hiabily or account of fortuitous enty ar fore Mayne , wefre tot Only Jo wore teat are uaporoacable , but olen fo HOw which Ore foraenble , but snadtable, OL fortuttous avant wurden Qrdicle N74 gay eon ty an "act oy Hod” on ferred accumsncee uch Ga fds o> Typhoons , or am “aot y an; dich de lta , atridse O wane PAILCOMSAT andy Hobe oppasd im hadhion © of te Oguumart tor He folbuing suyeta stat by dumicl cwurio contitng pret mapure : Cary fou, andor rapullation , Anachion Gr mequuct of He Prdippin, Lairrvmant 5 (2) Miskan or ether Labor dypoulnin 5 (8) fraumschin 5 (4) Resta ;(6) Atoms orn cis) () Wan; (7) deta of public tramia ) (8) Fira ptasdn, typhaone Or othe, catamrophiza ox ace o Med} ard, (4) ether cincumatancea Beyerch He contrat of eps,Usarly ta foregoing ont sitlon unppuuiable ,@r porastable ct beyord. Ue control of tle ports Toa ia tating ia He crumvaion that uur, Conbrores to, or wpardty Ln cumcapt of a fortuitous went unchr Qatelg 1174. Gy odin Hot Hobe my fv Saampt pony ton-complance vith ite Obligation to poy rinkala wndin Aiction 8, te Concwnente, af te followeng slonento tuck hey aatabuiked, : (1) the cat put be sncopandant Be Jaman wid 5 (2) Pa accwronce, must render it imporiuble for He dobtor fe fusfull Ha obligation in toured, manor, ancl, (3) He ebligarn Must be Pr of panticxdadiin im , ay aggnavedlion of the sngury of be Orsdibr Jha obavmertiined reguinitia are prussrt im the incart caas + PH COMSAT ord Hobe fod 40 coitrol avin te tom puntutal ay Ha tom, of He KP-US Thildony Gasee Oprarnnt whine fone opined in (24 pucnwes Me pre negating a ray He Auaty MMtnding te Liye Hoaoy Blond we He arate - feather did He pontiia prot conta Gor He duboaguart Cuthdrawal of te US tity furces, arch firuormels fom Qubi Faint mw fecomban 1992 fhe opowmentinsd, suvris ads, unpatsble tle, Continudidn of “tk, Opntomet undil AL nd of ae fat -gton teow wcblouk gaubt on te part of atlov pasty. Tle Aappuring of Auch fostutous worte randowd Hote oyampt poor parent 5 Rertala fan te amaundor of He Tom eg He CgpavmontTouity Bonk 5 Tut Gnpary Court of Opeate Facto: Pred, Nespordact Yomael C- Fomor uss contrac by Nerem patidrara acuity Eank, arc Bruat Conpary (SBTC) and, fatto © Mandi 0 conbiner fa building q SBTC fon te price of F1,740,000-00- Rapondont naw abi, to comple te conatruchin as tla building Within the Contracted Peed pot hy une Compeled fy a, hatin sncmiaae w the cost oy Cottuclin atouala To peur dfisrase of about F 300,060 00 en tap Gf He arigina caet Ragordurt oman mode finaly dimande fo Pyrat 4 Bx Urrsarid Coat SBTC auufied Fame alain fon oddiiénal cast, @ pecommuendation wad tlbn mode fo settle Fon’ claim but erty for F d00,000.00+ SBTC, initead % PYM Ae Meommendicl additiénall arount , dunied, swan outhorining paynont of any snus hy He eign cc pe, SBTC tikewine domed ory Habildy for rte ditional cut pats on Anika IX af te budkeing oat Yporack C Fomsr thew filidl a compliimt gon buach o Contiack udth domagst- Ho ial, Court’ radi for Foner, ar te Count of npaate oppose — By bua curt dicinion- Witte, ov tt piiionene (re able to poy Amowits abo te Orginal contnack pricy - Your Paditinore cry Kable to pay puch mount Orie, TQ of the wi Code, which ombadige te taxem , Memo ugtnewmenade, dab Cecwptdtnd (to tam aught 0 fe made rich out So maTe'e ings) atin Oicke 12 Gang porcon wha Hirsagh an act @ panfovmance by aration, S Onf GA Tuona | anguine or Come ‘plo fauuadion, 24 konathig at Re spre of Me dat aisnout pt or til, ground, dla ribon te tome to hum: Ye ia tet anced tat private pondeit sisonacl adtional sypsncee hm Gnu palibintn bank'a Juildig dus, to a dractic, awl snoypactic MMR oN conoucliin Coat. funy, raxpercant'y chim for tho unortocrd One tom ote gatly pun, Undow Grtche 1182 of ta will (ede » a conditional ablgaliin prall fu osicL, Hf Bt futpllmont: lpn upon Hy old will a th, ably, Yn te, prodint Cat , la tuitial ognemat , ty abusmt, of Which palttiiner barb nolieo upon to duppot ple ton Maatuhby fon he snorioal nerbuclion Coat , be iv epptck —% — Concilibn capandlnk on futons danke ola wild , ace pont, miporcnt unuldy tually amt lepicalty gun eoneant tm auch an aghumont Which wlguldy allow Aim ruccuony of re prcrtacsd) cout. Hance, to allow) pentiontr ark To ccquiny the Conbuictid building at a, fuce for fulew 2 actual, conchuctisn Cott woul ndubractly coacduty Anjuct uonchment fon te hank m He prypchicn pourate poxpordont. un snp tmuchrsat 1 Nat allay fy Sow.ee Aelia Honea tre ua Facte’: Cpt 7, 1980, petitioner obich for, fre. pal 40 the Aubdivuuon fat, Andina i Flruary RES, to spouses Uy Wl te dome tat fo forir “perderta the spouse, Yom by neaton a hich ‘le, poomor mg wae, Canc ont ryplacd inv ruporcinte! flank From thas on, respondent Cail ein prpanty Ov umbin oy inte, only te fut aot te lad, eta Suelipmot Hosat, how wow M4 wppastuclint ancl ubliy bysno f= tat mawnoge, ay Ok gle, ab annouecack a He ofpaned plane and aduerdiument oy Ae cubdision. Were, Aquattore Secupy Hur det ancl Ha uomoundling Quan. Qu short thine toa beam NQ dwelopment ot all. spouse Uy a, Thaecapi , Te bot Mak maguire He tame of Hh Iya. Oowrdlrgly , neeporcerta Aumandidi on pulitinen to provide Lhe reacted by Spire On Chan Me omens of equine ord, thn, ducting ty He ord Gag capone PD to. 7 which an Gunar on duuelopdrv of ay wutdulstion propck to divelep the same within ONL Hoan prom phe ratucnca “tte “Uconae « Hawg recewsd np rapty prow pitino , seypondon fled with to Fusnd, Opie of Be Housing and dane tne Aulatoyy Bearck (HLURB, NCR a, dimplant for quapic, prfovmanct art domay sewin. The fusing orc arch Ul Grbstn undone pdqnort (0% Be rexponctents he pice te fraudint aypiomecl iy cucusion of te HLURB, ‘te ca afwmed the ducution of ‘te ALURB Hance, putuoror', — prawn McpuntdWheto er ot raspordiante’ right Yo fring to inatoat cath agoirt Pltioran hae Bbuody prescribed To. The rigur tow pat putcnibid, Ue fo pulonar'y pocurd that ruepordenta! ryt te bring Be aston appinat ot faa abucely prosoubid , anguing Hat tle 10-year prusouphit, piuoel seer alodd Br ruckonad prom dpiul 7, ABD vlan fadiiontn orginally told. the at im quucin po a, gpounie Uy at te fat prom, Tabuary, 1985, lon rupordonte acquired We fone tat prom He Uy ypoucee fence , ard. ae juepordns! action uot filid with Me ALURB Fibld Gyr only on Oph 1, 14 an after nang Har for (1) yore, followa Hat the dana waa piled out time and, Bouporr , ouput fo hag heen deimibned - foywumarce ae kara) prucubee inv an (io) yeare Mia ta to provided ov Qrticte 1144 4 te Guid Code - Tr daw) » w caer o actin opiate wien He following naquaastne contin to ot Ow ight in peur of te Pantiy, By wlatwo teana and. under abitour foun it aruasa on ib wate }(2) an cbigaion on the past om He dfondant to aspect Auch Nett; arch(3) an act en omittion on He part os fuck dyendant oiolatuin of He royit of He plowiyy, Se in only upon He appari of a fact olermnt when ot com ko daucl tok a cama, of ation hea auton, dn Mort, it id prom He time an act ie pergorred or an Omuntuer srw uch W alating of He. posnsift '» fught, Bat pgpate tte dcowal ofa, came oy alin « Ont ib uw from that tine thot Ha IO-yar Peicuplut powed conmencoe To awn -Hire it wae only on Recomber 18, 1995 len hapercorta pike a wnibter terol Wir patnen to omebact eubdiviti ra, at op tly Ble Orch hid he forwmiaen of quate , abigatune olich are unguscurnably *% He fal of Om ebigation te do, Ord undar Orbéle 64 of we Code, & forty wip under opigttion Yo de somebrig mrad duloy only pom Bo pry Hak ae euiper dumonda ather pdicially on mbraqucncialty , for He fiplliant qe abligalion With Hie meaty ak o able Coxe, mpporctocta made tein unter Gomard vpn pcliientn fa pirfoum what id Wrcumbert Upon it onty om Aicombor ‘sg, 1945, ik wah ondy fom tat date when He lo- fA Patent pound sunetin Qriiole 144 Commamcadd tg mun Ord. ince, raspordtants! camplat for qaape puyourancd wae pid tith tig, Faald Spr oy te HLURB rty om April 1,194, o> ao than fain (4) monte optr dhe oleate Han dhmand. , pocihinar maa on puxcupliin of ction ia cumply without any eg to dank on-Parkaivon v. Umsucan Spruce Litrmatinal, | dre Fact, Tha patitionsr , tampon Pete Rombauon , hin iipe , doughter and bon , pumach Om tensile op tn Ging Carin by Pafalyan Tana of Gnaps. , The tou group tock amined fits inv He Cy, thy foil to Sgt A Oy HE Aig Std, woe opt pn hat fy wet Hook torly te Ret day to far Me pile Cy bjore acing He Toor The fatouing day, whe group was tack to a Atore'e alounpom te allow Hon fo tuleck toma for purchate fhe. Rantalaon panchosid ‘come all of which Hated US $13,826-00- Te Ay for tae punctaten , fartagion posantic ha Gnorican Giprane Oudit Card fiftun ninute bhow He tour group wana lati “te dapat fmm the tine Ton rimadin Cain, He dow chnk mrftrmd, Patatoon that hia OnaxCarch fad sot yet bar, opprouecl: Gory fyfteen monatua te Ate manager rpormel oxtafon that jeapordnt bad tomar fork nine tn on iy Peale of de tan group wae suppor tb how opt He ow, Cpotrr divided fo mhaw Hie dome won wicthouk expended» appnoual 64 He purchaos Often He ean -crorned, tBun hat andi, Ho Rantateor fomdy proceeded to He Wied Beatin befor ttunwing fo Manila, While in US, fetolon vontiivact to uae bin OmayCord with tw Oar Uevdents aymular ta He Anatartam boukata Or coning bach Yo Monta, Fartalinw foto tn Te Ae responiont ,dirantag Qn apoligy for te "wcorvoniinct , luruliaiin ard vnbomotansrt be ond hie fry auty topo” Sr mapnne | magick fat a ttn , Sty ance ata Pat te ddloy wm ating ua pinche pom Coiter woe athubutany to He Concumitance Hat He choged puckaee "wna aut o Pe Haual porctane pation waabhihed * Ye opgrasied carfhelder imetlusticl O” achin» damagee Wit the RIC. The AIC nando 0 atodion in fur of fotation th Cost of gece Nandi OQ decison Muang thy avord of domagoe , holding “that raperdunt fod tat bwackel Wi ebbegatine pitiner. than om act feb” puted, a bach 4 abtping to. pti GR Rapencnt toed commited a. bach ch oblgalicn and 12 Hable fe damage, Patdinwn comity Gites tat undn mors Aboard, he tren mequiitio fon a, irc default ow Yok He, obigation ia dkmandatle and, Laquidatd « He deter delay Reyomamch; OT He radi ciraly & SrPrucucialy requinsa He dabton'y prforerarmee . Honurally , te rabationehyp Aetuean % Credit Card prowcloy ak de dard Juda ig that a uditen-clbtor | wit, the Cord company de te cui Mave nds dik He Cond, Jaldor, wie ao debtor ia etlied to Topo te oust The ralatinokp abuady Tana treypion te He gana, jue Hor aa betwan & bark omch BH dapoutore je tamds it doomed ag Ya debtor while fe cypoaitor ia Cardo de The Gudutin In Orden gor He, (owt to Opprecuae pat retpondemt uaa im orcr adword, Ge will toe past raccrmine, Yat Toes wan sed aw obligation on iy pak of rseperdunk te Gc on faites prchaane with "dimaly capes, "on fr te prpente of Fhe COAL, mba rus Hrificontly four an, the tre hou ‘t ofpanertty Tack fore the punchane at Coste, te furauty ashe pond hay le rigt 4 ot he obligation to Ceriyy whetror the Crude ot ut Sting upon om Ov particular purckane wan uncded. Uortracted by he cardialdin and. that tl cortholden iw wit ha mana Ye rake lich cbaraactins the euspable failure of rugorcert horun Le nak Feira Yo “amaty dat on te fame, ubthn faurably om unfavory Se axtuming thik rapondins'e Onc dutangena did rot have kupprosnt hacia on hare bh pake a fogret ) Hu A00 no nenaon why renpordint Caulch ut foae promptly inpovmed, puttner the reaton for He delay , Ord lly oduasd um that Mealuing fhe game, coud take Wome time th tat way , ptitionan uguld fave had mofrmed avin en WALLA on nat to purse te anaachin at Cuter , quin te allerdhig Crcumatancte Sheed, fattine, uae Oyt smanpestatly dangtiig me te chibly autumn Wwe a forugn Gard Ord don ford te conpeort te uamath, of fori Y dbouich bi phage tht to raawon aly ftitonen is entitled to damage tot imply ficou xe dulay, for wich culpatulify tive under Qik N17, td wo fe Poikialan inginta prin Orde 2217 4 He Cush Osce for hich moral domagee ang ronumenattie. fhe dcmetubet mutual atttrclng iroumatoncn 1 He punchubt, at Cotter — Hat ior vin a AtokLiAs, for He Completion gy What punchane by piiliensr Bore ary delay waite cdourd to te yay of in Mave Turling conporions — gue, mae RAL tinal aheck, mania arpish ) tio amy tiaunded feline ard Maal humrluation pustauad fy jhe, potligno-Bonga v. Count of Oppeala Facts On prcerrber 41,190, pattimer Baryoga. wok ta He harduars fore 4 Tadpundant Mision to myune abot te daniabulty of oostun Pedondle To te util tw Ue, condbuiin oy & fiche, fox hin wie fe alte asked 4 te Patoucte odd te daturered at gneg Mavuma, Boncales , Qlman'a ftmrakuipar , Meplizd Mok oa had yet tw winy - Wo that palmer pt The following day, Barypya riba to dian'e icra sre Yo plow up ha punchoas of Cubuchin pratruals Ay Told te dione smployeca Bat th, mrifanale fe uae buying waid hue to ke ado a pe Momorial Cometiry sr fama rain, Cowie, by Beblack Hat movong dine Iie, hivd wierkove ane at +e buuel te ord) Dine und of te eaumcg. Moun. forcaiie apresd te dwn te Bona at He duugrated Tims, dete. ard place With than duran , Famoga purchauc tq alirials Ore pic im full te anount of F 2nooo- Yl conetwishéin ratowala did tat ane at Pe'eteck ag promurd - Gt % clock He alain waa all towhow in digit» fy Io oleleck,, thre wae ask to dation. Opler four ining , Earpaga, Wacame wybamely ypoth He dueidic, Ye cumisa ba tabowra for te day. Ae prucncich ta the police alain ard Faclgad a Gomplant ageimok Aluiar+ (phen he retumach te ce ke tow ty dino Tuck abuady tore but He madowely Je funchated att tot yot ready for Gooding: Baryaga diceled 40 cand his brangadlion wit He fire ard faoks for Conmbucticn prctouata eewhors . Petite, sou able, to buy from arctan How» jy tick ume comptitiod ancl Bonyage wife oma finally Laid to Monk - ower, i Wag ant Yop Beknd echt: Tortie, Redope by a mmibiy 0 gpl hin aipo'y ying wink, Parboger errata priate rtponchrt Anwar Glmancing Reonpanag + Coneaguentty , potion, paadi kim bors He ATC.Me tc cao upd te papi, tat tapontat uncwree in dley wr He celiny of He rbuctin, mbit roading in url prjndico pauline. Gr Gypial, Jiporcdont Count of Appucle ravenasd “Me lover Courct Ord tulad “ut toe WL ta Corlranatnall, cvmmimont aa te the Snack Une of dino tince Aho une tot uncatd i, at musica Recep Sivring ta fale. Whsttin er jot pouwate respondent a guilty of agligonce ond delay 1A He fieemance kt cerbuctial ablgation Yi Rap a ty oj gtgina ok tle for te dey foyormane ay Hie cnimackial blaine. fhe, law Uxpuely prcvicue Hak Hote ula ma tle poxowmance q Ain obligation am pully fraud, feghgance ; o diay ard Hote, whe Mary Manndn Conbrware He ror, Flora, jar Rabhe for domags Contiey to agpiltat court's factual detominatn Hoe aad a epee dome Gays How for thy dwn ¢ mrlonals to Ae comdliny. fiir wink to priate Yeipondunt's dire sa Pecomr 4 prwciaely to inquire y He matoualy ha intended tp fact, Guld, be, dibuioud imidiily. Bat ke was, told by fa Mowkupoy Pat 4 tine wow BU cilwouia 20 br MOLL tat aptoragn Kiq exdov would) fe ubiiowd tte following day eth the in nek, Brryecea dadek tm up Be corwhudtion pretonas Tk fella showing attr ke was owamred of siidiok detwoy aceordrg th hia June frome. Me argnant fot Be yruoicea saw, rrducethe ® AREY dingy Hine Puat fall in the fae q tu posite nkak —commilment of peapendant Alaratupor + Coasguontly dk ada Mingo Asan te wicks we protien Us. sxeey tine te, pnchatsd domo wht To by braugit 1 Be conttoy + dn foot PiraReepor, Boneckag acinatted Hat Ht ang, Jan cudlom tot to rdw ty,Tino of delwoy wlorwor fhe poparael dupiere . Oe frac of actin by Muperdunth wdrae Maina, Barca hak cat Be Canta abtxtiin — Hat th obits buck ovwed a Uitte fete thon wnaaual Kecauea, it Came from a dlooy of Pilar in lonpcaan , fewmaruia, Conte Appiantly | sin sipormatin wae wieMald by Borcalse prem: ation whens “a Sain wag, Ayohating wnll Ren por he furchadt of Cantluction maiowala- Couspusrty , ot ie Act unrantonable Yo duppser Ahat fod Ue tik patton of Aun fa ane Hat He daliow of #e mafbuale Wetuld orciquartly be dulaysd , piney anal foro tat boygrt He Pahovcls from Maytemdunt'e fardware Above fuk elealore whch ueuld ned hia bmg rayurunant > Me dlibomte Muipranion ey Ais “AYormatuin by ath Munfaste a Gtain digut ef beck fact, Ov He pant of Mipindnt stosskapon Yee tow iw Uerdy one of ton-foryormarce | A riciprécal ebigation » Ir, Had contract qf furdiary ar tay, falddinen ocd odrtacty compel fully sikh, what war, agus 4 Kimo panckwsr, se, He fayent of He prcrnce price oy Pajioco, & wax imeuntent open Mipondont to vunacatily foi Na, ebigation 16 dabuon ue gute ebowine delay cule alachCathey Rope Quuwaye Lid. v- Hayqusy Foote Rexporotuntd -ypouate fy- haniol, Eanmatow Noyguiay and. Maria, duc, Iadriged Paygaty ame fguont Ure of pliner Cty Re, nung , Lit» at Grn Bald Cart umber 4 de Mave fale Cub fe Hopqueagen , Hegethon bh, thu mad arc tap pruonda, trode Cay ard (ouupina, tergel de di, Wout Jo Hongkong for pluaune ond buvimear - For tian potum fight to Marlo, thy wow bookid on Crbbhay's Nligne Cx-405 Cuuniee Clare Archon. When, doarding tine, waa announack , a gourd atardark oppreached Mr Unyquty) and sath Kim Hut He thyquagd accomo- Ailing wera upgandid. to Fibut Clare dr. Vayqutry refused, HO upgracle , reabeting —Utak UF woul Act Looky tice for Tom aw acti to brawl in Fok Care ond tur quad , in He Buginean Caan ; and. Maragusr , way worn gang © dtowre purimeen matkow cunwny He Het: bh Vospusn Cuntinusd, Fo nojueh | do He ground) Atowarclar to Bom shat if My Om tot anal Hama oh nile ly antl nat be allawed e fake he ppt, Cooctily , ofr salty to lia tue frond , By. Usyquen Gaver inv Upon tier pstunn to Morita, He ‘Uyqutyne snotiutte fone te RIC op Trak: Cy on Ain, fav damage opanot Catt Gy a nowen » Cato ably ik ie a, prccicn aang Commtreal cubvies ‘upgrade pasangon fo He tet fetter Chane of Uconacation , alonsosy Orv efpertundy Qyiaes y Ack at akin av Coram ation Ho pully nok Print of uppracting «g gem fe i fagunt pyre , whee Ore, cained, fasorad Passengers fit, He apquanen.Whether or rut falutionen ounlino'a smplayer acted Praudlutently on jin bis fas fh Cant ia tet conor teak a yprading tie, breach of cant aide, atterdid, by fraud on bac faith Fraud foo buon diprsd to indude an indurcoment roygh tntidaius Mckumaliin, haidiour mackination refine fo a, decutpul solome on plat with an oil, or Sauxova frpoet » heck sak whe he party, vith sata to dectue,, Concealin on ome fe iat, matouall jacks and, by reawon a tuck onuiawon On Creaalmark , Be ston party waa anduced he gut Conant Hat would, not CHonear fave hun quan. Bad poise daey tot pinply onnote fod pdgront or niglgince 5 it imports a duusonset funpoet, > dome Tonal ob-igudy are concious ding 0 wrong , a bonch of o Rrown city ough fone, frat, intact o WL wll phat partake of He fate of poud. The Couide fire no poruodina proof of fraud o» bak ffeth sm ths cag: Tha Aayguyee rt tat ciel to gp A He uppading too india UBrda Or decutful, tmackmalion on through wild conceatmsit q metoyal) facts» Upon anion, Mur Oli, fle Hs Tougutyaa thot ain accomadations Wow M Fak Clot im diay of Mair hung fold Cord tambo of Cabra flence Fate Club Ae, ae lorect jin Tig Hom tat Meir aecte Wow abwady gui Ao othr pass ard He Bodine Unor lection ung fatty bookad Pa Olin night fave, fed He Cdn tumedy of aoung th, Fiat Chua tata A ten patton But HL Coust finde 10 bed path th len fuling fo do 8, eosn that amount 1 An piorcier of poor pognant = Mati oo it Danifin of #2 Thayquinca eficted for pone exif an layin pupal « Pudlosa 0 tats an upgpucing 8 for tie kattn eyn Cin ct, cipily, fon He aj of paseMERALCO vu Keane Fada Un gpa 1967 Ha NPC filed vie Ho MIC of Qutyon Cy o came for gore paint tans prune chly gplly cepying ‘ts psp Uncrg Hie dysrctonle Ww Te sytment cout uss Lancia Ramay, one of He Plante in fa Came at ban. te MTC nindned focgmast fan He plot NPC ond, "oxduweg te diysndosta to domalioh 6 namoue He, building arch Pucinso ty built on Be lard yf tte plamfiy Ord to wc He promscia NPG wast. io MeseL CO Npustip. fo He "wimedicle duconneclio. of declue power duppiy to aly potidential ord commercial eatablebmgnte barsath A NPC pburwmutin Bits) which ince pinsiya’ utabiakmests AIRALCO dacidec to comply iat NPCS raquaet and owupon eau tahices of dscornccliin te all wablolnard oppetd vue plaints Gv due time, the ictus, price Cormiotion of He plantije wp, diaconnected,. Plait, Famay tas ot ly ded bin Wi ore He mgrsbeice cunre of fel op (wd cceupid, fy Aerain playa han “ha, MERALCO emplayenn ore duxcannechig plamtijy's. power connecln, Ramey obyictid by inpomaig ta, MERALCO furan or ie paupory ra qulads a NPC propuity. However, ke was thubred ond tote tot to mitoyore by He armed man lg Aoconpanuch te MERALCo tnfulqyete Abusing He, denlor “anapictions orclned, by thy Count it wae four out Hat me rabctonce of plardiy -Apounes Ramey wow Anderd gutride te NPC propery - RTC are MERALCO to nettere He ftleetuc power Aupply of retponcterre Ch faatied MERALCO for 10t mequuuig pum NPC 0. anit Yeciliin on dunalition ard in tot cuvedinating sid a Cou Joys, or ela proper appicn, Lye cng sal a APC rau:Wheter ay rot MERALCO in tgiigert ulsn ct ditconmecti the Aubyect Uichic Mowicn | Ritpordoala - Yo. MERALCO ia Tapigert «Tie haing 6, o& ie able, for domi urcin Grbicle 1770 oh te wid Cade NERALCO adm tht raspondula ant’ ua cudomens Uttin o iawica Gitnact MMaby ik ia abl fo apply Mapondonla with dctdity Orch He Sovies Contract "a. customer q abd, Miia Muck Qhow his right Om proper whet cuer He propo in adin Yat Ae vil Ay provided. with arch assured, O continous ohobue sais” Ceanly ; reaporciant a cauae of Ocho Gganat MERALCO ia archoracl en culpa, Conbractua 6 Waach o conbrack for te Mattes chucontinucner 4 8 Cries He roxperdeot uroy Got, 1170 4 te Cid Gide which, ponder bot” hoe who inv Bo pinjordre, of Hn eblgaina cre quid) 4 frou , upigence er dilay , amd, Ape, wha Um Any mannan Conbrawens she finan Bardo» are fable of damages." Grice 1173 abeo provicia Bak te fautt a Agogenca of se cbdigon condits tr te Gmianion of that diligence which me nequned ihe reine of He Obligation ard wwaspondy ith He Crowmatancen of te puntone , of He tine ard, oy Be place Ch a pualic, ailipy , MERALCO hho the cbligatin to ducharge, “he fanchina cd ulmoot Care ord chigce « Undine pol tabu g He print care, MERALCO failed “i oxorciag He inbmook Aigran of cow ord dalgemce nequinad op st, St ama pet for MERALCO Ho Mody mi om te Mean of He TC wit aang whiten Ue tad bicome foil ar recto(jenny Co a. Cont of Oppo Fact dr Suby 5, 400 , petitionan tatiaatid, No Con Jo prune psapondert Breadiory Maton Yaka Corporation fOr home pain inching batty rqplocemst , He fats | vaduitahing Ration she vole on uly 1940 fully tenvrced, rch fupplucd in accordance woth He pp contract » But came Yuly 2, 1940, He latter could tot ralonne A, wohicle an iy hatyy ane sok ard uae sot yt mplasd: Lift with to gption , patihinan Jumecly bought a. cw) pattory Rarky ard deiwowd it to prwate reapondart por sratallahion OA Ble fame chy Hoover j te tatioy ua tot ingtaled Ont He dulwoy 4 He car ada, Nacheduled to Gay 24, (490. When, patios pought to Paclaum, a can 1m she Aftmoon of fly 24/900, le way told tak “ot was Cammpped Qarlun Hak moving uli, being Rectal Jy an employee of foruute ruapondeat The RTC jim a tuk fordamagin filed ty chine, paunat fruiah nupondent, found He tattin pully of deloy am He poyormame qf dt ablgatin and. Kid uk fiddle to plitionsn fon Yo Ualuc of te foot urhicle and He accestouce pllua Urbirsat and, attorey’a pera. On appeal He Count of Cppecta Navpreed He Cowtr court's pling St rated Hat He whole una fact dug Jo a fortuitous wart - homey He plibr, (Or review) Ualethon or net raqporclnt a guilty of deloy) + ye frivate, ronpondont io gully of doy and wu hcrdls fon damepua Sov Neasnaing tHe (A, the Apron Guuct fata tak Canmoppng fk Canmgt fe conaidvad aa a fortuitoun sount «le by coneidontd Oe wweh , conmappriny anfela MOE Tor he mony porcapel Ming of anclin's prporty » maak pyproved and potabliolsd tak Yo wwit wae an act of Hock an war done, fulaly fy Mod poxlua Orc, ta nach te Uawmant apn Ho poroon AUtigeck wb we Ngiget Ma ay partipalion » In accordance wth te Rulea o Cuchince, Ya burdan of proving that te Loa wat due to a. forduictoun wert not on hin wh woke it San axguning nquseds tat Connapfung wat duly Wabloked a2 a. poduitans went atl pruwor raspondint cannot monpy Labiity Antiotn i165 of Ae fuw Gui Coda rakes an abligar wha we guilty eo duloy reponastla, su9n, foro, porustaue oust until he pax sppctid He culuoy. Qn cack , prusrte pupdndert wae adwady iv duloy ae ut wan yppacecl Jo alwar puttionesa cor Pose (3) oye bfow iF iupe deat - Pautiner's agnaumant to te rwccludulid delwoy dam set deat fia Claim an prarete Respondent fad oluad) buacled de epligalon » Root, tuck accauon cammot be Continued, ad wawor of patitionon'y rught to Aolc. prutake sipondont fable hecauts He (ar WO Unmable and tun , pailionon fod 1 Crtion put ta Cave & Purauont te Cyiclea N74 amd 1262 of He tu Cul Code , flbiliy abtackes win ip He tne aaa dua to a, foatoue emeh of “te reine of He obigatuin, haguinse fe aAtumelion of Pak