Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Steven Wilson: Remixing Classic Albums: Wunderkind
Steven Wilson: Remixing Classic Albums: Wunderkind
TONY BACON far, he’s polished classic records by King during otherwise dead time on his extensive
Crimson, Roxy Music, Jethro Tull, Yes, XTC, tours. So far this year, he’s played over 60
“T
he equivalent of polishing the Tears For Fears and more, creating new concerts in Europe and North America, with
Sistine Chapel, that’s what I feel stereo and 5.1 surround mixes that have a further 60 or so slated toward the end of
I’m doing sometimes with these been generally praised by fans and critics. 2018 and into 2019 in Japan, Australasia,
classic records.” Steven Wilson is talking He says this sideline has grown to take North America and Europe.
about his remixing work, which he began up maybe a fifth of his working life, and “If I’ve got a couple of days off in a hotel
in 2009 as a sideline to his very successful has recently developed a laptop setup and time to kill,” Wilson says, “I can load up
career as a musician and producer. So that means he can do much of his remixing an album remix project and start to piece
location is just as important as any other solos or phrases in and out, that kind of Finally, Wilson reaches the point where
constituent of the classic recording in thing. So listening on headphones and he can actually remix the track whilst
question. “Some of these mixes were real identifying all of these mix moves and remaining true to the artist’s original vision:
works of art,” he says. “They’d spend a where things have been muted or taken he stresses that his stereo remixes provide
couple of days, and there’d be three or out of the mix maybe for a few bars — all an enhanced version of the original and
four of them, all on the faders, bringing of that takes the most time. That’s the not a wholly new experience. His task to
phasers in, bringing reverbs in on particular detective work. And it’s so easy to miss this end is often made easier by the clarity
words, panning things left and right, riding things without full concentration.” and exposure that the original multitracks
can reveal, and then it’s a case of making
adjustments only where necessary. “At
this stage in the workflow, it’s a matter of
refining,” he says, “trying to get as close
as possible to the original mix, tweaking
EQs and so on. Over a period of days, I’ll
finish the mix, and then when I go back to
it a couple of days later I’ll hear things that
aren’t quite right. Usually the artist will have
some feedback, too. Sometimes they’ll
have memories of how they did things,
which is really useful. But,” he adds with a
smile, “mostly they don’t remember much
at all. Hopefully, then the artist will come
up and listen, and maybe they’ll have some
more feedback based on listening to it in
my studio.”
At that point, with an agreed final stereo
mix, Wilson either goes on to create the 5.1
mix, if that’s part of the job, or he’ll deliver
dealer suggested C-Lab Creator. “The guys surround mixes. The next Porcupine Tree with anniversary editions and so on.” Wilson
in Apple in Hamburg that take care of Logic album, Fear Of A Blank Planet (2007), came duly made a new 5.1 and a recreated stereo
have become good friends, to the point out with a Wilson surround mix. “And it got mix for the Crimson King box that came out
that they actually changed some of the 5.1 a Grammy nomination for best surround in 2009, on the album’s 40th birthday.
implementation based on my suggestions. sound mix! So I thought wow, I must be
I can’t imagine being able to do that with doing something right.”
Buried Treasure
most companies of that size. You’d think This led to Wilson’s first remix for a Wilson’s first crack at remixing for another
Apple of all companies would be the most band other than his own, on King Crimson’s artist was also his first experience of finding
impenetrable of all, but they’ve been In The Court Of The Crimson King. At alternative takes and unheard versions
fantastic. So I’ve been a Logic guy probably among the multitracks, which can form part
for more than 20 years now.” of the draw for fans who always want to hear
In fact, when people ask Wilson what that little bit extra from the archive. Wilson’s
instrument he plays, “I tell them that for me, personal preference is to find new songs or
the studio has always been the instrument. completely alternative treatments of songs,
I’m not that interested in playing or being rather than simply alternative takes. On
a musician — I just love being in the studio, Crimson King he found a haunting version
messing about. The studio, that’s my of ‘I Talk To The Wind’ with just Fripp on
instrument. It’s that Eno thing, you know?” guitar and Ian McDonald on flute. “That was
a beautiful instrumental,” he says, “and a
In The Round completely different piece, really, not just
Wilson’s introduction to the idea of another take of what we already know. To
surround remixing came when Elliot me, alternate takes are not so interesting,
Scheiner created 5.1 remixes of the though I understand there are people out
Porcupine Tree albums In Absentia and there who would happily listen to a whole
Deadwing, in 2004 and 2005 respectively. disc of studio run-throughs of ‘21st Century
“Being the control freak that I am,” Wilson the time, King Crimson and Porcupine Schizoid Man’. What I’m excited by is when
says with a smile, “I started to feel that this Tree shared the same management. you find a performance that actually adds
was something out of my control. I wanted Like any good managers, they asked something new to the canon.”
to be able to do it myself. There were some Robert Fripp if he’d be interested in their Then there are pieces that benefit from
mix decisions that Elliot made that weren’t Grammy‑nominated client making remixes the clarity afforded by a modern mix and
the way I would have approached it. But I of the Crimson catalogue. “I guess it was digital format. For instance, the final 10
didn’t have the skills, or the technology at a perfect storm,” Wilson says. “I wanted to minutes or so of ‘Moonchild’ from Crimson
the time, to be able to do it myself.” get more involved in remixing, and I think King are very quiet indeed. “If you listen
So Wilson taught himself how to make they were looking to revamp the catalogue to the original mix, you’re literally listening
Lung Transplant
Steven Wilson has remixed much of Jethro Tull’s back
catalogue, and Aqualung in particular was an album that
cried out for a remix. Wilson knew the original well and
remembered how muddy and hissy it was, with some weird
frequency issues going on. Popular opinion seems to agree
with his own view that his remix fixed many of those sonic
problems. And here’s the paradox: it sounds better; but
perhaps also it’s a little more clinical.
“That’s almost inevitable,” he says. “Honestly, to me,
bearing in mind I don’t know a lot about analogue tape, it
sounds like the original was mixed on to a faulty machine
or a machine that wasn’t lined up properly. And it’s always
sounded a bit like that: very muffled and hissy. I was able
to fix that, because the source multitrack tapes sounded
beautiful. The remix has clarity missing from the original, it
sounds beautiful, and to some it’s the definitive mix now.
But understandably, other people would probably still rather
hear the original analogue mix with all its flaws. I accept that.
That’s not something that can ever be reconciled with a remix
project, which is why I always try to encourage the record
company to include both the original and the remix on a
reissue set, as two different experiences.”
Many of the Tull records that Wilson has remixed provided
an unusually rich seam of unreleased or little-heard songs. In
his estimation, the Tull tapes generally reveal at least twice
as many songs as were selected for the final album. With
Aqualung, for example, there was enough for an entire disc
of such material, most of which was in an almost-finished
state. “The Tull series has been a lot of fun,” he says, “finding
all these completely unreleased songs that even Ian can’t
remember recording. Apparently they quite often went into
the studio, recorded a song, and then literally forgot all about
it — didn’t even mix it!”
Topographic Equalisation
Wilson has so far remixed five Yes albums, and he’s
particularly pleased with the results on Tales From
Topographic Oceans, a recording that has had its critics since
it was released in 1973. You’ll recall that it’s the one with four
Virtual Vintage
The biggest move forward in technological capability in recent years for The availability of good plug-in recreations of vintage gear makes Steven
Steven Wilson’s remixing work has come with plug-ins that recreate vintage Wilson’s job a lot easier, as here on Jethro Tull’s ‘Aqualung’.
studio effects. These make it easer to get sounds in the digital domain that analogue compressors, like the Fairchild or the 1176, and the EMT 140
are closer to the original analogue effects used on many classic records. “I’m plate — many of the things they were using at the time. The last couple of
using a lot of the Universal Audio plug-ins, which are fantastic emulations years I’ve been adding the UA Oxide Tape plug-in to the output bus, too,
of original analogue stuff. Now I’m able to use emulations of a lot of the old which definitely seems to give things a little more of that analogue magic.”
long pieces spread over four sides of the example, it might start off as a percussion fantastically ambitious, but he knows
original double vinyl album. “I was happy part, then there’d be a little bit of bass, that must have made it a nightmare to
with what I achieved with that one and then a backing vocal would come in, and mix originally. “So I come along 40 years
with Relayer, because I later, and of course I
don’t think those albums can load up the 24-track
sounded sonically as good original and split out
as the earlier ones,” he everything on to its own
says. “I’ve tended to most channel. So a 24-track
enjoy working on albums tape ended up being
that perhaps had some maybe an 80-channel
kind of problem with the session, because I’ve
original mix. So I figured given every little piece
OK, now that we’re its own track. And that
remixing, we can maybe means I can treat each of
fix some of those things.” those parts with its own
His aim on these two EQ, its own compression,
albums was to give them reverberation, treatment
more sonic richness and and placement. In that way,
clarity, more definition, and to make them then a guitar overdub, then it would go I was trying to get a little more out of it than
a little less harsh to listen to. “Topographic back to the percussion. And every track they possibly could in the original mix.”
Oceans was a particular challenge, with of the multitrack was like that. They were
these huge 20-minute pieces of music cramming every inch of every channel
Picking Up The Pieces
which were recorded on 24 tracks — on this 24-track tape. If Yes had had the At the time of writing, Wilson’s 5.1 remix
because what Yes were reaching for was limitless possibilities of digital recording of Seeds Of Love by Tears For Fears is
something way beyond the capabilities of available to them, they’d probably have awaiting release some time in 2019, its
24-track tape. I’d be taking one channel gone even further with their vision.” 30th anniversary year. It has been his most
in isolation on a 24-track tape and, for Wilson describes Topographic as complicated remixing job so far. It’s also
follow us
on Twitter
find us on
Facebook
go to the SOS
YouTube channel
visit the
SOS forum
All contents copyright © SOS Publications Group and/or its licensors, 1985-2019. All rights reserved.
The contents of this article are subject to worldwide copyright protection and reproduction in whole or part, whether mechanical or electronic, is expressly forbidden
without the prior written consent of the Publishers. Great care has been taken to ensure accuracy in the preparation of this article but neither Sound On Sound Limited
nor the publishers can be held responsible for its contents. The views expressed are those of the contributors and not necessarily those of the publishers.