COMMENT RESOLUTION SHEET
Project : RDMP RU V Balikpapan
TR. No.
Document No. 26071-203-U1-341-30103
No. Reference/Page No.
1 1
2 1
3 2
4 CRS
5 CRS
6 CRS
JO Transmittal PMC Comment Transmittal
26071-JO-KPB-TR-P-00582 JO's Doc. Cat. E3-1 TR. No. PMC-01-TRANSMIT-031822 Review Code S1/S2
Title FIRE AND GAS DETECTION SYSTEM LOCATION TANJUNG BATU CONTROL ROOM (341-TCR-001) Revision 000
PMC Comment JO Response or Conclusion
Address CRS Comments and reissue the drawing Noted. Refer to response No. 4 - 6.
CRS indicates HOLD for Heat detector Ex rating , all l HOLDS shall be listed in the drawing. No hold listed in this drawing.
There is mistake in the previous revision of CRS. No heat detector installed in this building.
this shall also be ex rated. This is a general comment and shall be implemented in all layouts Confirmed. All gas detectors are explosion-proof type. Symbol and legend have been updated and implemented in the layout.
Heat detector Vendor data or reference to be attached wit next CRS No hold listed in this drawing.
There is mistake in the previous revision of CRS. No heat detector installed in this building.
Only smoke detector applied in this building and the listed spacing based on vendor data are as follow:
to be clarified in next revision No hold listed in this drawing.
There is mistake in the previous revision of CRS. No outdoor heat detector installed in this building.
Only notification appliances (e.g. beacons) are installed at the external wall of the building. As per TQ No. 26071-JO-KPB-TQ-00753 (Rev.
02), for onshore building, the notification appliances at the external wall of the building are weather proof.
In the previous revision specific query was raised whether any detectors are deleted from the Noted.
layout presented in FSA . This query was not addressed in CRS .Reply specific, lot of During FHA, the layout presented is Fire Alarm System Layout (drawing under CI discipline) due to at that time Fire and Gas Detection
discrepancies are observed in the first revision F& G layout, and was not inline with FSA. .Discuss System Location Plan had not been developed.
internally before populating the response. After Fire and Gas Detection System Location Plan is developed, there are several update of the detector quantity. The details are as follow
This comment shall be addressed in the next revision. ie if any detectors are deleted say deleted (Layout used in FHA compared with this drawing Rev.001):
and justify the deletion. for addition say added. 1. Control Room
For ex- Smoke detector additional qty added on the layout used in FSA - Smoke detector : No Change
- Heat detector qty reduced due to....... - MAC : No Change
- Notification Appliances (indoor) : 1 set of audible and visible alarm (alarm bell and beacons) is reduced. Refer to Project Specification
Fire Alarm Control Panel (Doc. No. 26070-203-3PS-JQ05-J0002), the audible alarm applied in the building shall be located so that the
distance from any portion of the building to the alarm devices does not exceed 25m measured horizontally on the same floor. Therefore,
1 set of audible and visible alarm is suffient to cover all the control room area.