Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Doty 2008 Annals of Neurology
Doty 2008 Annals of Neurology
Environmental agents, including viruses, prions, and toxins, have been implicated in the cause of a number of neurodegenerative
diseases, most notably Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases. The presence of smell loss and the pathological involvement of the
olfactory pathways in the formative stages of Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases, together with evidence that xenobiotics, some
epidemiologically linked to these diseases, can readily enter the brain via the olfactory mucosa, have led to the hypothesis that
Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases may be caused or catalyzed by agents that enter the brain via this route. Evidence for and
against this concept, the “olfactory vector hypothesis,” is addressed in this review.
Ann Neurol 2008;63:7–15
The causes of Alzheimer’s (AD) and Parkinson’s dis- ogy in the formative stages of AD and PD, together
eases (PD), the two most common neurodegenerative with evidence that airborne xenobiotics viewed as dis-
disorders, are obscure. Familial concordance, genetic, ease risk factors can enter the brain via the olfactory
and twin studies suggest that, although heritable factors mucosa, has led to the hypothesis that these disorders
play a role, environmental factors are prepotent.1 Thus, may be caused or catalyzed by agents that enter the
despite the fact that numerous genes have been identi- brain via the nose.9 –12 This review assesses the viability
fied for these two diseases, they usually relate to early- of this “olfactory vector hypothesis” as a potential
onset familial forms and account for less than 10% of explanation for the induction of some cases of AD
all cases. Although largely distinct phenotypically and and PD.
pathologically, AD and PD exhibit identical olfactory
dysfunction early in their course,2 are often coex- Evidence That Xenobiotics Can Enter the Brain
pressed,3 share a number of common risk factors (eg, via the Olfactory Mucosa
age, head trauma, the apolipoprotein ε4 gene),1 and The anatomy of the nose is well suited for the transfer
exhibit similar pathologies in brain regions such as the of exogenous agents into the brain. Although some xe-
locus coeruleus.4 nobiotics, notably viruses, can enter the brain via sev-
Among environmental risk factors reported for AD eral cranial nerves, the olfactory nerve (cranial nerve I)
and PD are viruses, aerosolized metals, and toxins.1 In- is uniquely vulnerable to such penetration (Fig). Thus,
creased expression of -amyloid (A) and indicators of the dendritic knobs and protruding cilia of the 6 to 10
brain inflammation have been found in the olfactory million olfactory receptor cells that make up this nerve
bulbs and other olfactory-related brain regions of peo- provide an exposed surface area conservatively esti-
ple and dogs exposed to extreme air pollution, likely mated at 23 cm2.13 These cells are widely distributed
reflecting exposures to airborne particulates and aero- throughout the rostral nasal cavity, embedded in a spe-
solized metals.5 Previous occupational exposure to her- cialized neuroepithelium that lines the region of the
bicides, as well as 20 or more years of occupational cribriform plate, the dorsal septum, and sectors of the
exposure to manganese (Mn), have been associated superior and middle turbinates. Unlike other receptor
with 3- to 10-fold increased risks for development of cells, these cells are also first-order neurons, projecting
PD.6,7 Most cases of Mn-related parkinsonism, how- axons directly to the brain without an intervening syn-
ever, differ from classic PD on pathological and other apse. Although they receive little benefit from the pro-
grounds.8 tection of the blood–brain barrier or the blood–nerve
The presence of smell loss and olfactory bulb pathol- barrier, they are afforded some protection by secretions
From the Smell and Taste Center and Department of Otorhinolar- Address correspondence to Dr Doty, Smell and Taste Center, Uni-
yngology: Head and Neck Surgery, University of Pennsylvania versity of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, 5 Ravdin Pavilion,
School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA. 3400 Spruce Street, Philadelphia, PA 19104.
Received Nov 6, 2007, and in revised form Nov 28. Accepted for E-mail: doty@mail.med.upenn.edu
publication Nov 28, 2007.
Published online Jan 30, 2008, in Wiley InterScience
(www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/ana.21327
detected in the olfactory bulbs after several days. This incorporated into olfactory receptor cells, including
virus subsequently infects cholinergic neurons in the dyes and amino acids, not all are transported across the
horizontal limb of the diagonal band, serotonergic neu- synaptic membrane to neighboring cells. For many that
rons in the dorsal and median raphe nuclei, and nor- cross the synapse, including a number of viruses, inter-
adrenergic neurons in the locus coeruleus.25 Ionized nalization into the cell initially occurs via receptor-
metals (eg, aluminum, cadmium, gold, and Mn) can mediated endocytosis. The xenobiotic is then trans-
be transported to the brain via the olfactory receptor ported within the cell via slow or rapid transport
cell neurons at rates greater than 2mm/hr,26 with systems to the transmost saccule of the Golgi appara-
some, such as Mn, subsequently targeting astrocytes tus, where it is packaged into vesicles bound for axonal
throughout the brain.27 Herbicides, such as the dioxins terminals.33 Usually there is minimal involvement of
and chlorthiamid, are selectively taken up by the olfac- glial cells, implying limited release into the extracellular
tory neuroepithelium even when administered system- space.15 Agents that are not synaptically transported
ically or to the surface of the cornea28,29 and can dam- but yet enter the cell, such as leucine and horseradish
age the olfactory mucosa by causing necrosis of peroxidase, are taken up by bulk endocytosis and pro-
Bowman’s glands.30 The pathological infectious prion cessed into protein components of the cell, not the
protein PrPSc is consistently found in the olfactory Golgi saccule.15
cilia, receptor cells, bulbs, tracts, and primary olfactory
cortices of patients with Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease, but Early Olfactory Loss and Progression of
not in the retina, optic nerves, or respiratory mucosa.31 Alzheimer’s Disease– and Parkinson’s Disease–
A number of patients with this disease first present to Related Neuropathology
the clinician with anosmia or complaints of taste and A key observation in potential accord with the olfac-
smell loss.31,32 tory vector hypothesis is that approximately 90% of
Although a wide range of xenobiotics can become patients with early-stage AD or PD exhibit olfactory
dysfunction, as measured by psychophysical and elec- all of whom exhibited substantial reduction in trans-
trophysiological tests.4 In well-documented PD, the porter uptake at baseline, had experienced development
dysfunction is unrelated to disease stage or the use of of clinically defined PD, whereas none of the 38 rela-
anti-PD medications (eg, L-dopa, dopamine agonists, tives with test scores in the top 10% did. The remain-
anticholinergic compounds)34 and rivals or exceeds the ing individuals in the bottom 10%, although not yet
prevalence rate of the defining motor signs of the dis- experiencing parkinsonian symptoms, exhibited signif-
order. Longitudinal studies suggest that, in both AD icant declines in transporter uptake across the two
and PD, the olfactory deficit precedes the classic clin- tests, implying PD-related neuropathology was devel-
ical signs by several years, serving as a “preclinical” oping.
marker.4 For example, in a study of 1,604 nonde- Congruent with the early olfactory loss of AD and
mented older adults, women with anosmia who pos- PD is the early pathological involvement of the olfac-
sessed at least 1 apolipoprotein ε4 allele had an odds
tory bulb and anterior olfactory nucleus, where marked
ratio of 9.71 for development of cognitive decline over
cell loss and the presence of disease-related pathology
the ensuing 2 years, compared with an odds ratio of
1.90 for women with no olfactory dysfunction and at (eg, neuritic plaques, neurofibrillary tangles, or Lewy
least 1 such allele.35 In another study, 361 asymptom- bodies) are present.37,38 In AD, tau-related pathology
atic relatives of PD patients were administered olfac- within these structures correlates with disease severity,
tory tests. Those with olfactory test scores in the top cortical Lewy body counts, and apolipoprotein 4 car-
and bottom 10% of the group underwent single- rier status.39,40 Superoxide dismutases, enzymes that
photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) defend against reactive oxygen species, are abundant in
with 2-carboxymethoxy-3 (4-iodophenyl)tropane the olfactory bulb, anterior olfactory nucleus, and neu-
(-CIT) labeled with iodine 123, a dopamine trans- roepithelium of patients with AD, where they are over-
porter measure of the health of this motor control expressed relative to control subjects.41 Increases in
brain region.36 At the 2-year follow-up, 4 of the 40 other indices of oxidative damage within the olfactory
relatives with olfactory test scores in the bottom 10%, neuroepithelium of patients with AD have also been