Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pneumatic System - Three Phase
Pneumatic System - Three Phase
Pneumatic System - Three Phase
2
E-70 Brake System
3
E-70 Tri-Plate Panel
• Tri-plate panel provides a compact mounting
base for various brake valves.
• The to & fro pipe connections are taken at
the loco pipe bracket which is permanently
piped in the locomotive.
• The loco pipe bracket is fixed in the loco at
the bottom roof floor to aid inlet outlet port
connections.
• Tri-plate Panel attached to Equipment
manifold and then mounted on to the loco
pipe bracket manifold.
• Various timing / cushioning volume
reservoirs have been mounted on the rear
face of the panel assembly
4
Brake Electronics
Pressure Switches
E-70 Control
Valve
Distributor Valve
Tri-plate panel of E-70
Brake system
E70 PANEL REAR VIEW
8
DRIVER BRAKE CONTROLLER
1. Release
2. RUN
3. Initial application
4. Full service
5. Emergency
6. Neutral
• There are two potentiometers inside DBC, which convert the angular position
(braking demand) of the DBC to proportionate voltage signal.
• The control card compares this voltage with pressure transducer voltage
signal coming from E-70 control unit and generates output to energize or de-
energize the application and release EP valves of E-70 control valve unit.
11
12
• The control card output modulates
E-70 control unit EP valves in a
controlled manner in order to drop
or increases CR pressure.
• Consequently the E-70 control unit
creates or drops BP pressure for
auto brake application and release
in the train as desired by the driver.
• This is a closed loop control of BP
pressure. 13
DIRECT BRAKE CIRCUIT
• In both cab SA9 is used for loco brake or direct brake it has Two
Position apply & Release.
• EP 115 (31) & EP 115 (32) are Provided on direct brake manifold of
Pneumatic Panel.
DIRECT BRAKE CIRCUIT
16
THERE ARE 6 EP VALVES, FUNCTIONS OF IS AS UNDER
EP valve Function
15 F.B. Energizes to allow charging of BP with full bore
16 REL. Energizes to charge pressure CR pr. at 5.6 kg
17 APP. Energizes to vent CR
18 LP.O.C. Low pressure overcharging
19 RUN Energizes to keep BP pr. charged in run position
36 ISOL. To isolate EP valve when no cab is selected. 17
E-70 CONTROL UNIT
EP36
EP17
When energised, a supply of reservoir feed air flows through the valve to
keep the piston lifted and open to a restricted position.
When de-energised, it closes and cuts off the air supply to the bottom
chamber of combined restricting isolating and check valve.
The running EP valve is energised and open in all position except emergency
on the leading loco and on slave loco it is de- energised and closed in all
position.
E-70 SYSTEM FEATURES
• Electronically controlled Brake Pipe pressure monitoring.
• Pipeless driver’s automatic brake valves (DBC) simplifying the cab layout.
• Only emergency control pipe is connected at DBC.
• Automatic isolation of in-operative cab.
• Automatic low pressure overcharge (LPO).
• Automatic Restricted Brake Pipe charging in RUN position.
• Electronically controlled dynamic brake blending. Actually substitution
method is adopted when dynamic brake trips.
• FP charging through a high capacity transmission valve at which the FP
pressure can be increased or decreased.
• Automatic anti-skid braking for poor rail adhesion conditions.
• Auxiliary flange lubrication equipment.
29
E-70 System Features
• Wheel sanding in addition to automatic anti-skid braking.
• Pantograph selector switch on panel controlling the pantograph equipment
manifold to select the desired pantograph.
• UIC type break-in-two protection between locos in MU service.
• Retention of MR pressure at a safe level in case of parting between locos in
MU service through duplex check valve
• All EP valves are surge protected and also against reverse polarity in a
suppression box.
• Pneumatic parking brake application and release feature through a latched
solenoid valve with manual push knobs.
• Built-in vigilance control unit.
• Venturi type air flow measuring and indication system.
30
E-70 System Features
• Latched isolating cocks with micro-switches for BP cut-off and Vigilance cut-
off.
• Only direct brake is equalized in trailing locos.
• Different BC pressures in automatic and independent brake.
• Panel mounting facilitates feature-wise grouping of valves for quick response.
• Dead engine hauling possible either in MU formation or as a part of the
trailing stock through the towing cock
• Control for compressor unloading and auto draining of reservoirs is provided
on the panel itself.
• All EP valves are surge protected and also against reverse polarity in a
suppression box.
• Pneumatic parking brake application and release feature through a latched
solenoid valve with manual push knobs.
31
E-70 SYSTEM OPERATION
32
E-70SYSTEM
SYSTEM OPERATION
OPERATION
33
Air Generation, Treatment and storage
• Compressed air produced in two stage reciprocating compressor. FTIL supply 2A320D
compressor with combined inter-after cooler.
Compressor
• Compressed air charges through NRV and a drip cup auto drain valve into 1st main
reservoir.
NRV Auto Drain Valve
• From 1st MR it passes over air dryer and charges into 2nd MR through a rubber
seated check valve.
Air Dryer
NRV-RUBBER
34
MR charging into panel equipment
Compressed air branches off and is piped to port no. W of panel and 2nd MR into
port no. U of panel.
From port no. W air charges into : Go to schematic
• Duplex check valve and the MR equalizing pipe through port X.
• Unloader EP valve and to the auto drain valves and Unloader exhaust valve
through port T.
• Pantograph equipment manifold through a built-in check valve.
• From panto EP valves air goes out of panel from port R & S to each pantograph.
• To sanding equipment manifold, break-in-two protection valve as a pilot.
• To transmission valve both as control and source supply.
• To the brake supply reservoir, pilot of vigilance emergency exhaust valve.
35
MR charging into panel equipment
36
Auto-Drain Valve and Unloader Valves
When MR pressure reaches the cut-out level
in pressure switches 35 & 36,
37
Cab/PT Selection and Auxiliary Air Circuit
Automatic cab and pantograph selection and Auxiliary compressor circuit :
• When the pantograph selector switch is positioned into panto-1 or panto-2 the
required pantograph is selected,
• The direct brake pilot valve of the in-operative cab is energised isolating the FD1
valve from in-operative cab from the direct brake relay.
• In the pantograph equipment manifold, EP relay valve 6 corresponding to panto-1 or
2 (as the case may be) is energised to open.
• In this condition, MR pressure charges into pantograph to raise
• Pressure switch 9 in the corresponding panto circuit set at 4.5 and 5.5 kg/cm2
provides signals to Loco Electronics on the status.
EP RELAY VALVE
PANTO CIRCUIT
CENTRIFUGAL STRAINER
38
System Operation
39
System Operation
Rubber seated check valve 24 prevents MR air to charge into the auxiliary
compressor.
Safety valve 23 set at 8.5 kg/cm2 to blow excess pressure build up in auxiliary
compressor circuit.
Isolating cocks 38 and 8 are venting type in the panto equipment manifold for
maintenance purposes to remove either the panto EP valve or the pantograph
pressure switch when MR pressure is still charged into the panel.
40
Electronic Brake Pipe control and automatic brake system
41
Electronic Brake Pipe control and automatic brake system
• If the signal voltage from DBC is more than the transducer voltage signal, the
control card energises the release EP valve and allows MR pressure at a regulated
level of 5.4 kg/cm2 into the control reservoir.
• When the pressure builds up in the CR, the constant feed back from the
transducer to the control card allows the control card to de-energise the release
EP valve as soon as both the signals match.
• The CR pressure being built-up by the control card is charged into a one litre CR
volume and into the control port of a transmission valve (under the pressure
plate).
42
Electronic Brake Pipe control and automatic brake system
• When DBC handle is moved into the application zone, the signal voltage to the
control card is reduced depending on the handle position by a pair of pot meters in
the DBC.
• Both pot meters being connected in parallel circuit, whichever is the higher voltage is
taken by the control card for the BP pressure regulation.
• When the signal voltage is reduced, the closed loop servo is imbalanced due to which
the control card de-energises the application EP valve to vent the CR pressure to
atmosphere.
• The transducer on CR feeds a constant voltage signal of the pressure level of CR and
as soon as the transducer signal equals that of the DBC signal, the control card
energises the application EP valve to stop further venting of CR.
44
Electronic Brake Pipe control and automatic brake system
• When the CR pressure is vented to a new lower level, the transmission valve
moves to an application position, exhausting the BP at its exhaust port and finally
from port Z in the panel.
• The closed loop servo thus always controls precisely the pressure level in BP for
any desired application or release.
• When BP pressure is reduced, an automatic brake application is effected in the
complete train through the DVs in each vehicle.
• When BP is reduced, the C3W type DV on the valve equipment manifold moves to
an application position charging BC pressure into the control port of the D2 relay
valve of the automatic brake which is also mounted in the same manifold.
45
Brake Release & Automatic Release and Run charging capacities
46
Brake Release & Automatic Release and Run charging capacities
47
Automatic overcharge : LPO
• During dissipation cycle, the LPO card energises the LPO dissipate EP valve
on the control unit to bleed the CR pressure at a controlled rate back to 5
kg/cm2 in such a way that the transmission valve also exhausts the BP pressure at
a similar controlled rate, not to cause a re-application of brakes in the train.
49
BAIL - OFF : PVEF type FUNCTION
• During an automatic application in train, the
loco brakes can be released without releasing
of train brakes. This feature is called the ‘bail-
off feature’.
• The brake release in locomotive alone is on
such a condition, that it can be re-applied if
the situation warranted.
• The loco brakes during an automatic brake
application are governed by the DV which
functions on the basis of the differential of
pressure between its CR and BP. As long as CR
is locked at 5 kg/cm2 pressure, DV can detect
the amount of drop of pressure in BP and
builds-up a proportionate BC pressure.
• If the control reservoir pressure is equated to
BP pressure after any brake application the DV
cannot maintain the BC pressure since its
reference in CR itself is lost. 50
BAIL - OFF : PVEF type FUNCTION
• In E70 system when the driver presses the foot
pedal, the control reservoir equalising EP valve
energises and connects CR to BP thus causing
the DV to release the BC pressure.
53
DYNAMIC BRAKE BLENDING
Brake
cylinder
DYNAMIC BRAKE BLENDING
1) Blending unit has two EP valves EP-12 and EP-13 . In case of failure of
regenerative braking or tripping of OHE this valve applies brakes to the
loco. The brake cylinder pressure is decided by the software according to
braking effort demanded by the driver or by throttle.
2) When regenerative braking fails due to tripping of OHE, both EP valve, EP-
13(fill) and EP-12 (empty) gets energized and allow preset reduced MR
pressure set at 2.5 kg/cm2 to go into the brake cylinder. This pressure is
converted to its electrical equivalent signal by transducer. This signal is
sent to blender card .
3) The blender card monitors braking efforts from throttle and brake
cylinder pressure. BC pressure is vented as per speed reduction .
When blending brake demand is zero EP-13 will de- energise .
MU SERVICE
• In the trailing loco with the panto selection switch in mid position any one panto
can be selected manually by opening cut out cock 8 for the appropriate panto. In
this condition both the direct brake isolate EP valves(115) are kept energised and
will not allow the BC pressure of direct brake from the leading loco to reach any one
FD1 direct brake valve in the trailing loco where it may get exhausted.
56
MU SERVICE
• In case of parting between locos, with complete venting of MR
equalising pipe to atmosphere, the signal port in break-in-two
protection valve(46) gets exhausted to atmosphere. In such
condition the break-in-two protection valve moves to close
and disconnect its inlet port from its delivery port thus
preventing BC pressure in the leading loco to escape to
atmosphere at the BC equalising pipe exhaust.
57
MR PROTECTION
• In MU service if a parting takes place between two coupled
locos, the disconnection of all pipes between the locos
results in :
• Venting of BP causes an emergency brake in both the
locos through their DVs
• FP venting continues to drop the MR pressure
• MR equalising pipe continues to vent the MR pressure
• When the MR pressure is dropped below 5 kg/cm2 which is set as a
safe limit for brake operation in the loco, the duplex check valve 92
shuts of the inlet from its delivery port under the action of the
preset load of its spring.
• Since the compressors even in the parted locos may be still working
since MR pressure has fallen below the cut-in level, of its governor,
the duplex check valve will be lifted by rising pressure and will be
locked again when the pressure drops below its set level.
• In this condition the duplex check valve would have reached a
balance in its valve opening and would continuously discharge MR
pressure into its equalising pipe and at the same time maintain a
steady 5 kg/cm2 pressure in the MR system in each loco. (we need to
ensure availability of atleast 5kg pressure to application of brakes in
58
loco)
SANDING
59
AUTOMATIC ANTI-SPIN BRAKING :
• The system also provides for automatic
anti-spin braking in addition to sanding
during acceleration from rest when a wheel
spin occurs due to poor adhesion.
• This feature is activated by anti-spin valve
one for each bogie which makes light brake
application when energized.
• The brake application will hold the spinning
wheel and help the wheel to stabilise at
which point the brakes are released.
• The brake cylinder pressure in anti-spin
braking is different for freight and
passenger locos.
• The anti-spin valve(65) has a large capacity flow rate and is capable of
very quick application of low intensity needed to quickly hold the
spinning wheel. It is provided with a limiting valve to regulate the
signal pressure needed to achieve the desired BC output pressure
irrespective of the MR pressure level.( 64 is BC pressure switch,62,67
60
are chokes)
AUTOMATIC ANTI-SPIN BRAKING
61
AUXILIARY EQUIPMENT FLANGE LUBRICATION
62
HORN CIRCUIT
63
AUXILIARY COMPRESSOR AIR CIRCUIT
5. The air is supplied to DJ and both the EP valve of PT-1 and P2-2 via IG-38
kaba key.
6. If Pressure switch (9/1and 9/2) pick up Pressure is reached it gives the
feed back signal to loco soft ware.
MR CIRCUIT
1) Two electrically driven compressor
which feed in to the MR-1 through
NRV.
2 Safety valve in each of the compressor
leg to protect the system in case of
blockage of NRV.
3) Un-loader valve also in each leg . This
un-loader valve is operated from
Electro-pneumatic valve mounted on
the brake panel .
4) The air from MR-1 feed out single
water separator which is fitted with
auto drain valve .This auto drain
valve operated with same signal line
WATER that operates the un-loader valves.
SEPERATOR AND
AUTO DRAIN
5) This air further passes through Air
VALVE dryer , which will Extract the
condensate from the air ,the twin
tower air dryer , which gives
moisture free air passing into the
locomotive .
MR CIRCUIT
6)This air further passes through final
filter which removes dust ,can be
created from the air dryer desiccant
and then passes the air through
another isolating cock .
7) Another isolating cock which is only
used to by pass the air dryer ,If
there is any problem with the unit .
8) The air passes through another NRV
and goes to MR-2, MR safety valve
and two compressor governors -
35,36 is also apart of this circuit , 35
is being for operation of a single
WATER compressor in alternating mode
SEPERATOR AND
AUTO DRAIN between 10 bar and 08 bar and 36
VALVE being for operation of both
compressor between 7.5 bar and 10
bars.
MR CIRCUIT
Now a days Two compressor are
working at a time and a governor
35 is isolated for single
compressor in alternate mode.
10)Low main reservoir governor 37 is
also used to Interlock with
Traction in the event of the main
reservoir pressure falling below
its set point (5.6 to 6.4 kg/cm2).
WATER
SEPERATOR AND
AUTO DRAIN
VALVE
DIRECT BRAKE CIRCUIT
1) In both cab SA9 is used for loco brake or direct brake it has Two
Position apply & Release.
2) EP 115 (31) & EP 115 (32) are Provided on direct brake manifold of
Pneumatic Panel.
DIRECT BRAKE CIRCUIT
2) MR Pressure distribute the Pressure to Aux Reservoir via NRV 106 ; one Port of AR
is connected to B.P. Sensing Port.
3) As per BP dropping position ; the required B/C Pressure is released from C3W
distributor valve which is going to DCV (double check valve) 54 via EP No.52.
4) This EP No.52 normally de-energized when loco is running on traction mode and
allows B/C Pressure to go to double check valve and finally to D2 relay valve for
brake application.
5) When loco is in regeneration or braking mode then EP52 will be energized and
does not allow B /C Pressure to pass through hence in braking mode ; braking from
A9 is not possible.
6) During dead / towing loco ; BP pressure from lead Engine is connected to hose of
BP and charge the Aux. reservoir of dead loco and the braking function to carry in
dead loco.
AIR FLOW INDICATION SYSTEM
4) As soon as the B.P. pressure flows in pipe VCV drops. The pressure
this is sensed at L.P. side of gauge.
5) The difference of pressure MR pressure - LP side pressure this equal
the deflection of gauge middle. The gauge full reading is for 0 (LP
side) to 10kg/cm2 (HP) side.
6) Pressure Switch 44 sense the drop in pressure ; this Pressure Switch
is normally closed and set at (4.0/5.0) kg/cm2 and open at 4.0
kg/cm2 ; when Train Part ; Alarm Chain Pulling message is generated.
• The main reservoir air passes through the venturi from pipe connection A to pipe connection
B (i.e. from right to left on the drawing) and then to the feed valve.
• If air is flowing, a drop in pressure is created in the chamber surrounding the venturi choke
which is amplified by the flowmeter valve connected by a pipe at pipe connection C.
• True main reservoir air pressure is taken at pipe connection D and piped to one needle of the
pressure gauge.
• The other needle registering the drop in air pressure at the choke after amplification by the
flowmeter valve.
1 Cap nut
2 Joint
3 Valve stem
assembly
4 Venturi body1
5 Venturi
6 Venturi nozzle
7 O-ring
8 O-ring
9 Spring
10 Plug
11 O-ring
12 Valve seat
VIGILANCE EMERGENCY APPLICATION
88
PARKING BRAKES IN RELEASE POSITION
SERVICE BRAKES APPLIED
89
PARKING BRAKE AND ANTI COMPOUNDING VALVE
90
PARKING BRAKE AND ANTI COMPOUNDING VALVE
04 nos. TBU`s provided in wheel No. 2,6,7,11 with parking brake. It is
applied when loco is stand still (no pressure required). ( 1,4,5, 7 IN
WAP5)
93
2A320D Compressor
94
AUTO DRAIN VALVE
95
AIR DRYER AIR FLOW DIAGRAM
Dryer is not cycling / both towers are drying (pressure switch open)
96
AIR DRYER AIR FLOW DIAGRAM
Dryer cycling / one tower drying and the other regenerating (pressure switch closed)
97
AIR DRYER
98
COMPRESSOR CHECK VALVE – METAL SEATED
99
COMPRESSOR CHECK VALVE – RUBBER SEATED
100
D2 RELAY VALVE
101
DOUBLE CHECK VALVE
102
DOUBLE CHECK VALVE – PANEL MOUNTING
103
DIRECT BRAKE PILOT VALVE
104
EP RELAY VALVE
105
C3W DISTRIBUTOR VALVE
106
UNLOADER VALVE
107
DRIP-CUP WITH ADV
108
PANTO CIRCUIT
109
CENTRIFUGAL STRAINER
110
WAG9 SYSTEM SCHEMATIC
111
20
112
Comparison between Conventional & E-70 brake systems
Sr. Criteria for comparison IRAB-9/10 E-70
1 Basic design of brake system Wabco/USA M/s FTIL Group
2 UIC type pipe less drivers Non UIC type brake UIC type DBC
brake valve. Valve with pipes
3 System configuration Very old Latest
4 Operational system Purely pneumatic Electro-pneumatic &
Electronically controlled
5 Restricted charging of brake Manual through Available
pipe in run position of A-9 MV-4
6 Automatic low pressure Not Available Available
overcharge feature
7 Dynamic brake blending Not Available Available
8 Pneumatic parking brake Not Available Available
9 Automatic wheel slip protection Not Available Available
10 Automatic isolation of direct Not Available Available
brake valve with cab changing
11 Modular tri-plate brake rack Available Available with better
features
12 Maintenance Low High 114
CCB
• The CCB II-IR system is a modular, microprocessor based electro-pneumatic brake
control system. All logic, other than the initiation of an emergency brake applications
via brake vent or Assistant’s Emergency Brake Valve are of computer control.
• The system is designed for modular expansion using the LAN network as the expansion
medium.
• The CCB II-IR system performs several diagnostic functions; Self Test and Fault Flagging.
Diagnostic access is provided by means of portable test unit software (PTU Tool) which
operates on a laptop PC.
• The CCB II-IR system also interfaces with an Operator’s Vigilance System (Alerter)
located on the locomotive.
• Various signals are exchanged between the locomotive and the Alerter to provide
operator vigilance protection. If the vigilance system is active and the operator does not
maintain inputs to satisfy the system, an Emergency Penalty Brake shall result.
• The operator commands the computer through the Electronic Brake Valve Controller
(EBV). The EBV is also on the network and signals the handle positions for automatic
and independent braking.
• Control of the Lead/Trail functions and brake pipe cut-in and cut-out is accomplished
through the use of a selector switch mounted on the driver’s brake valve (EBV).
115
Computer Controlled Brake System for 3-Phase Locos
116
Electronic Brake Valve
MODULAR CCB RACK FRONT VIEW
Modular CCB rack Front view
JUNCTION BOX WITH CABLES
The Junction Box Assembly provides a central
termination point between CCB System with the
locomotive electrical subsystems
POWER SUPPLY JUNCTION BOX
The PSJB provides electrical power source for the
CCB Brake System equipment. The PSJB receives
supply voltage from the loco battery and develops
regulated 24 VDC supply voltage for the CCB Brake
System electrical components
MULTI-PURPOSE INPUT/OUTPUT NODE
The MPIO is a modular expansion element
communicating with the core Modular CCB Brake
System via the Lon network
RELAY CONTROL PORTION
The RCP houses two high current relays with two
sets of contacts, capable of being wired normally
open or normally closed on each set of contacts
117
MODULAR CCB RACK FRONT VIEW
ELECTRONIC VIGILANCE COMPUTER
The EVC provides an electronic interface between
the Loco Pilot and the CCB Brake System. The EVC
system exchanges various timed inputs and outputs
between the operator and the brake system. If the
EVC does not receive the appropriate level of
operator activity, the CCB System will apply an
emergency brake.
AUXILIARY MANIFOLD ASSEMBLY
The Auxiliary Manifold Assembly performs the
pneumatic auxiliary functions. This manifold includes
magnet valves, isolating cocks, pressure governors,
check valves, feed valve etc.
ELECTRO PNEUMATIC CONTROL UNIT
The CCB System comprise of distributed electro-
pneumatic devices that are linked via a
communication network.
118
CCB FEATURES
Electronic Brake valve (EBV)
• The EBV is the interface
between the brake system and
the Loco Pilot
• It contains handle for
operation of automatic and
independent brakes and a
digital LCD display which Auto (A-9) BP pr. SA-9 B/cyl. Pr.
displays instantaneous BP
Release 5.5 kg Release 0.0 kg
pressure, advisory instructions
Run 5.0 kg 3.5 kg
and fault messages. Full
Min 4.5 kg
• This feature avoids the
feedback delays inherent in FS 3.5 kg
123
EPCU NODE FEATURES ON CBS
Dead Engine Cut-In / Cut-out Cock :
Out - Closes Brake Pipe connection to Dead
Engine Regulator.
IN - Opens BP connection to Dead engine
Regulator so Main Reservoir can be
charged from BP.
Dead Engine Regulator (DER) :
• – Reduces Brake Pipe Pressure to Main Reservoir
/ Dead Engine Pressure
• The DER is necessary in order for a locomotive
that is being towed dead in train to be able to
apply brake cylinder as Brake Cylinder is charged
from MR.
Service LEDs :
• Service LED’s are included on the 20CP, ERCP,
BPCP, EBV and RCP control nodes.
• The Service LED’s can be used to HELP diagnose
problems with the Improved CCB system.
• Green - Power
• Red – Fault
• Yellow – Programming 124
CCB-IR CLOSED LOOP PRESSURE CONTROL
Compare
reading to
target
125
CCB FEATURES - IPM
126
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Sr Item/Feature E-70 system CCB-II Remarks
1 Complete Brake Single brake rack Single brake rack Though the complete brake is
rack and for main & aux. for main & aux. interchangeable as a whole
interchangebility functions functions unit, but it is not possible to
connect E-70 brake rack to
EBV of CCB or CCB brake rack
to DBC of E-70 system as
individual components and
2 Header bar for Single header for Single header for valves are of different design.
pneumatic loco pneumatic loco pneumatic Due to this, sheds/shops are
connection interface interface
bound to keep spares for both
the systems thereby inventory
carrying cost increases
3 Main system Three circular Similar to E-70 significantly. All spares are PAC
wiring harness connectors for brake system items and the OEMs charge
Input/Output Input & Output heavily.
signals signals and
vigilance signal
interface
127
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Sr. Item/Feature E-70 CCB - II Remarks
4 Driver’s Brake Separate pipe less Single pipe less The DBC of E-70 system
controller brake controller for Electronic Brake Valve is identical with
Auto (A-9) and piped for both Auto & conventional loco A-9.
Independent (SA-9) independent brakes
brake
10 Self Diagnostic Not Available A special feature in CCB Additional feature with
feature guides both operating CCB
staff & Maintenance staff
11 Self Test Feature Not available A special feature in CCB Additional feature with
which performs complete CCB
system self test
commanding thru WPTU
program using a laptop
130
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Sr. Item/Feature E-70 CCB-II Remarks
12 Fault Not Available A special feature in Additional feature with
Downloading CCB which facilitates CCB, helpful for
Facility thru WPTU program Maintenance staff
using a laptop
13 Technology French US technology by More number of
Technology. NYAB. Combination transducers in CCB
Combination of of pneumatic, EP, system than in E-70 for
pneumatic with electronics & precise control. As such
EP valves & computer based CCB is more electronic
electronics, use control with in nature and E-70 is
of P/V networking, Sensing more pneumatic in
transducer for by P/V transducers at nature.
sensing of ER. pilot pressure as well
Closed loop as main pressure
control. stage and close loop
computer control
14 FRPCPY and High FRPCPY Highly reliability CCB is comparatively
Reliability compared to compared to E-70. new, hence it is too
CCB early to conclude 131
COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS
Sr. Item/Feature E-70 CCB-II Remarks
15 Back up Emergency Provision of P 16 With CCB, section can be
protection in case brakes gets automatic switch cleared at 10kmph speed
of Brake applied. over and PER with PTDC, whereas in E-70
it is not possible
Electronics Failure manual switch over
16 Maintenance Needs Needs overhauling The only maintenance is
overhauling after eight years replacement of filter
after five years after 12 months.
17 Component level Not yet Not yet possible Staff needs to be trained
repairing of possible and firms needs to be
equipments and pursued for giving
electronics cards technical support.
18 Downloading of Not possible Not possible Only limited data is
VCD data available, full details of
each item not available.
19 OEM FTIL KBIL
20 Cost of loco set at Rs.29,78,995 Rs.30,63,156 From CLW sources.
present
132
CONCLUSION
• Both E-70 as well as CCB-II systems are time proven highly reliable technologies.
CCB-II appears more reliable with technologically advanced features, however as
CCB-II has been introduced recently in IR, hence it is too early to draw any
conclusion.
• Compared to the conventional system, the E-70 & CCB systems looks elusive and
complicated. A handful of staff is having proper knowledge of these brake systems.
Further OEMs are also not ready to reveal the details of their systems in order to
protect their interest and monopoly. To keep pace with the advancements in
brake system, IR should gear up for development and up-gradation of skill among
the staff and engineers with proper professional training.
• As a long term objective, IR should select any one of the brake systems, should
buy and transfer its technology with full details and standardize it . Then IR should
develop its indigenous design and sufficient number of vendors to supply the
standardized product and its components. This should be done for reducing the
dependence on the foreign countries and for healthy competitive rates.
• It is still a long way to go.
133
136
137
WAG9 SYSTEM SCHEMATIC
138
20