Professional Documents
Culture Documents
GEST 12 406 Edition 1
GEST 12 406 Edition 1
GEST 12 406 Edition 1
GEST 12/406
Edition 1
April 2014
Euro Chlor
***********
This document has been produced by the members of Euro Chlor and should not be reproduced in
whole or in part without the prior written consent of Euro Chlor.
It is intended to give only guidelines and recommendations. The information is provided in good
faith and was based on the best information available at the time of publication. The information
is to be relied upon at the user’s own risk. Euro Chlor and its members make no guarantee and
assume no liability whatsoever for the use and the interpretation of or the reliance on any of the
information provided.
This document was originally prepared in English by our technical experts. For our members’
convenience, it may have been translated into other EU languages by translators / Euro Chlor
members. Although every effort was made to ensure that the translations were accurate, Euro
Chlor shall not be liable for any losses of accuracy or information due to the translation process.
Prior to 1990, Euro Chlor’s technical activities took place under the name BITC (Bureau
International Technique du Chlore). References to BITC documents may be assumed to be to Euro
Chlor documents.
It has been assumed in the preparation of these publications that the users will
ensure that the contents are relevant to the application selected and are
correctly applied by appropriately qualified and experienced people for whose
guidance they have been prepared. The contents are based on the most
authoritative information available at the time of writing and on good
engineering, medical or technical practice but it is essential to take account of
appropriate subsequent developments or legislation. As a result, the text may
be modified in the future to incorporate evolution of these and other factors.
This edition of the document has been drawn up by the GEST (Storage,
Transport and Safety Working Group) to whom all suggestions concerning
possible revision should be addressed through the offices of Euro Chlor.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................... 6
3. PRODUCTION ............................................................................ 7
5. SAFETY .................................................................................. 23
6. MAINTENANCE ......................................................................... 24
7. APPENDICES ............................................................................ 25
8. REFERENCES ........................................................................... 25
1. INTRODUCTION
In the past, Euro Chlor was mainly focused on chlorine. In the production of
chlorine by the electrolysis of sodium chloride or potassium chloride, caustic
soda or caustic potash is co-produced. Caustic is very corrosive material to the
eyes and skin. It can cause severe burns, permanent injuries, lifelong scars and
even blindness. Therefore, safety in handling caustic soda/potash has a top
priority. While handling caustic, special care must be taken to protect yourself
and the recommended procedures for loading/unloading, maintenance and
inspection, Lock-out, Tag-out, Try-out (LoToTo), etc. must be followed. Based
on the fact that periodically incidents and accidents are reported, Euro Chlor
took the initiative to provide two documents describing the risk and the
precautions that can be taken to prevent incidents.
This document describing the best practices in the production and
handling caustic soda and caustic potash.
The Health 9 - Code of Practice-Control of Worker Exposure to Caustic
Soda in the Chlor-Alkali Industry.
For reasons of simplicity, the text in this document will mainly refer to
“caustic soda”, even if it can evenly be applied to caustic potash. The only
difference comes in appendices 1 and 2, dealing respectively with the
physical properties of caustic soda and caustic potash.
Remark: in this document, the concentration values of the caustic are expressed
in “weight” percentage.
3. Production
3.1 Generalities
Caustic soda is one of the oldest man-made chemicals. Excavations in Egypt
show samples dating back to 3000 BC. In its solid form, caustic soda has a white,
crystalline appearance.
Figure 1: Typical paths from raw brine to storage of caustic soda with
different processes
In the mercury process, the anode reaction involves chloride ions being
converted into chlorine gas. Mercury flows over the steel base of the cell and
acts as the cathode.
The sodium dissolves in the mercury and forms a sodium amalgam. This is
carried into the secondary cell where it reacts with water releasing sodium
hydroxide and hydrogen. To increase the rate of this reaction, the secondary
reactor contains carbon balls or plates, which catalyses the reaction. The
produced caustic soda solution contains about 50% NaOH. The free mercury is
returned to the electrolytic cell. The caustic soda solution is treated to remove
mercury and then stored in a storage tank. The solution is shipped to the
customers in cargo tanks, rail road tank cars, pipes and barges to the various
customers. For some uses, caustic soda can be diluted to 18-23% solution, which
can be handled without the risk of freezing.
The diaphragm was made of asbestos, today mostly replaced by synthetic fibres,
and separates the feed brine (anolyte) from the caustic-containing catholyte.
Purified brine enters the anode compartment and percolates through the
diaphragm into the cathode chamber. The liquid leaving the cathode chamber
consists of a mixture of water, NaCl and NaOH. The composition of this solution
is approx. 12% NaOH and 14% NaCl in water. This solution is normally
concentrated to a 50% caustic solution by means of evaporation and the NaCl is
removed as a solid salt.
For diaphragm process the produced caustic (approx. 12%) and salt solution
(approx. 14%) is generally also concentrated in multi-effect evaporators to a 50%
caustic solution. During the evaporation process the NaCl crystallizes as solid
salt and is removed from the caustic solution. The remaining caustic solution
normally contains less than 1% NaCl.
The anhydrous forms are obtained through further concentration of 50% caustic
soda. Solid caustic soda results when hot molten caustic soda, from which all the
water has been evaporated, is allowed to cool and solidify. Flake caustic soda is
made by passing molten caustic soda over cooled flaking rolls or belts to form
flakes of uniform thickness. The flakes can be milled and screened into several
crystalline products with controlled particle size.
The manufacture of caustic soda beads involves feeding molten liquor into a
prilling tower under carefully controlled operating conditions, producing a
spherical bead.
In some cases the molten caustic is simply filled into drums where it solidifies.
4.1. Evaporators
Design
The materials of construction that can be used are depending on the caustic
concentrations and temperatures, for this see appendix 4.
Safety provisions
The separation chamber must have two independent level instruments against
overfilling and preventing the pump from dry running, especially if a magnetic
driven pump is used.
The vapour coming from the evaporator that receives caustic from the
electrolysis section will contain some hydrogen. In the design it should be
arranged that after condensation of the water vapour no explosive mixture can
be formed. An option could be to add some nitrogen gas.
Operation
Figure 2 shows a typical falling film evaporator. The caustic soda is sent to the
top of the heat exchangers from where it flows into the pipes. The pipes are
provided with special inlets to provide an even distribution of the liquid.
V-3
FC
Caustic
soda
V-1 V-2
V-4
Steam
Condensate
Vapors
PI
LC
H(A)
TI
LS
E-101
PI
M
V-9
V-5 V-8 Concentrated caustic soda
to Off-spec tank or
Another falling film
V-10 V-11
evaporator
V-12
V-6
P-101
Water
V-7
Drain
A mixture of liquid and vapour leaves the exchanger at the bottom and is
separated in the chamber. The vapour flows through a demister or a separator
to the next evaporator or condenser. The caustic soda flows either to the next
evaporator or the storage.
On the shell, either steam or vapour from the previous evaporation step is
applied to drive the evaporation process. On the bottom and top of the shell, a
vent is connected to prevent build-up of inert gas. Special care should be taken
if NH3 is present in the steam as this can cause corrosion of the (Ni) piping.
The steam flow to the first evaporator can be controlled via a concentration
(density) measurement or boiling point elevation calculation (based on
measured p, T values) of the produced caustic.
The heat exchangers used for cooling and/or heating caustic soda are plate type
or shell and tube heat exchangers.
The materials of construction that can be used are depending on the caustic
concentrations and temperatures, for this see chapter 6.
Safety provisions
When the cold medium can be blocked in the heat exchanger it is required to
have a safety relief valve taking care of the expansion of the liquid when
heated.
For plate type heat exchangers normally splash protection sheets/covers are
installed.
4.3. Pumps
Design
Sufficient drain and flush facilities should be installed to drain the remaining
caustic from the pump and piping connections and to have facilities to wash out
the remaining caustic after draining.
PI
Water
V-5
V-4
Caustic
V-6 soda
Caustic
soda
V-1
V-2 P-101
V-3
Drain
Safety provisions
In case of large pump and/or long lines (i.e. for ship loading, transport pipelines
to consumers/customers), care must be taken to prevent water hammer e.g. by
using:
Slow opening/closing valves
Soft starter or frequency converter for pumps
The risk for water hammer should be checked by calculation. Especially if the
pipeline is empty, it has to be filled carefully before the full flow is applied.
Putting the whole capacity of the pump on an empty line can lead to severe
water hammer which makes damage on the line.
4.4. Filters
In the caustic processing unit, filters can be used on intermediate product
streams (e.g. caustic from the electrolysis to the evaporation unit) or on final
product (e.g. to storage or from storage to a transport loading station or
pipeline).
Design
In most cases candle type filters are used. The filters have a specific pore size
(e.g. 10 micron). Depending on the temperature and concentration the filter
can be insulated and/or traced in order to keep the temperature of caustic soda
solution above melting temperature.
Safety provisions
The filter should be ventilated properly to prevent build-up of inert gas. In the
loading filters, the inert gas cannot be sent to the air. Because of this, the vent
should be connected to the drain and the drain should be sent to a safe
location. In the filters on the caustic coming directly from the electrolysis, the
vent is connected to the H2 vent section due to the presence of H2 in 32% caustic
soda solution.
Figure 6: Caustic soda filtration from caustic coming from the electrolysis
section
Normally 18 - 50% caustic soda solution is stored in a tank. Especially for the
higher concentrations (30 - 50%) it has to be ensured that the operating
temperature is kept above melting temperature of the solution to prevent
solidification. This can be achieved by feeding relatively hot caustic soda
continuously to the tank or the tank can be heated by an internal coil or by
external circulation over a heat exchanger. Additionally, the storage tanks can
be insulated.
Safety provisions:
The storage tanks should have 2 independent level instruments with high alarms
against overfilling and of which at least one is acting as safety trip (e.g. closing
the inlet valve and or stopping the supply pump). By using two level indicators
(instead of one indicator and one switch), both measurements can be
continuously compared which allows a significant increase in reliability.
Besides this overfilling protection, the tank is protected with an overflow line.
The overflow line should reach close to the floor to minimize splashing.
Additionally, an independent vent is required to prevent over- and under-
pressure.
The temperature of the tank must be safeguarded against a too low (to prevent
the solidification of the caustic soda) or too high temperature (to prevent
exceeding the design temperature of the tank), in general via a high and low
temperature alarm, independent from the control of the tank temperature.
When the caustic solution from the electrolysers is stored, since it contains
hydrogen, the tank must be vented to atmosphere to prevent build-up of an
explosive mixture in the tank. When nitrogen is used, special care has to be
taken when the tank is taken out of operation and inspected. In those cases it
has to be ensured that the nitrogen connection is removed and that the tank is
sufficiently purged with air to ensure safe working conditions.
Operation
Pipelines for 32-50% caustic can be traced and insulated to prevent freezing of
the caustic. In general, electrical tracing is used. The maximum temperature of
the tracing must be safeguarded in accordance with the design temperature. For
carbon steel piping, the temperature must stay below 50 oC for 50% caustic soda
solution to prevent stress corrosion (See Table 9 in Appendix 4).
Safety provisions
Control and block valves in long pipelines should have dedicated closure times to
prevent water hammer.
Pipelines should have sufficient connections for draining and cleaning the
pipelines before opening.
4.7. Dilution
In some cases, the caustic soda has to be diluted with water for use or
transportation to customers. Considerable heat is generated by this operation
and proper handling procedures must be followed (if necessary by cooling) to
prevent boiling or eruptions of the product. Also the compatibility with the
materials has to be checked for the increase of temperature.
In-line dilution, with use of static mixers can also be applied at the inlet of
storage tanks or trucks.
4.8. Instrumentation
Instruments should be installed in a way allowing sufficient isolation and
decontamination for maintenance (see chapter 5).
4.9. Valves
When isolating a section, the design should allow for a slip plate or blind flange
to be used in addition to the closure of the manual valve. For the main isolation
valves, the installation of double block and bleed can be considered.
Due to the relatively high freezing point of the usual 50% commercial grade,
precautions have to be taken to avoid that the material solidifies during
transportation; in some cases the vessels will be equipped with heating coils and
steam connections.
Before loading activities can start a check which contains at least the following
items should be executed:
Wear the required personal protective equipment before starting the
loading/unloading (see GEST 92/171 and Health 9)
Switch off the vehicle and prevent movement (rail and road tank-cars,
ships)
Fill in the shipping paper with the required information such as:
o Customer references
o Concentration of the solution
o Amount (every country has different regulations for the amount
loaded to the vehicle)
Check the following:
o Be sure that the tank is appropriate for the product that has to be
loaded
o Cleanliness of the tank. If the tank was used before for other goods
a cleaning certificate must be available
o The vehicle is immobilised in proper position
o Capacity of the tank is appropriate for the amount to be loaded
(not greater than the maximum and not lower than the minimum)
o All connected piping, fittings, gaskets and covers are in good
condition
o All outlet valves are closed
During loading, check will be performed for possible leaks on the filling system.
After loading check all valves and covers for transport; check also the gross
weight does not exceed the permitted maximum.
Regulations
The loading, transport and unloading has to comply with the relevant legal
requirements. Specific regulations apply for the various transport options.
For road transport the ADR (Accord européen relatif au transport
international des marchandises Dangereuses par Route)
For rail transport the RID (Regulations concerning the International
carriage of Dangerous goods by rail)
Inland waterway the ADN (Accord européen relative au transport
international des marchandises Dangereuses par voies de
Navigation intérieures)
For ocean/sea the IMDG (International Maritime Dangerous Goods)
code
4.11.2. Truck loading
Design
The truck is connected to the loading section via a loading arm. A position
switch or restraining mechanism ensures that the loading arm is correctly
mounted. If the arm is not in the right position, loading cannot start. The truck
loading facilities are normally placed on a liquid tight floor with drain
connections to a dedicated collection facility where the dripped caustic can be
collected and neutralised.
Safety provisions
The access to the top of the tank should be safeguarded against possible fall.
The loading equipment should have one level instrument with high alarm against
overfilling of the truck. Besides, as another safety consideration, the truck can
be loaded on a weighbridge. The flow to the loading arm can be controlled by a
flow controller. In case of overfilling, loading must be stopped by closing the
valve in the supply line to the loading arm or stopping the loading pump.
After filling, wash the area of the tank around the loading point to remove
possible caustic drops.
Operation
Caustic soda is pumped (P-101 in figure 8) to the truck through a loading arm.
Minimum flow by-pass back to V-101 is ensured to protect the pump from
heating up.
Design
The truck is normally connected via hoses to the unloading pump or unloading
vessel via the on-board pump. The unloading place should be located on a liquid
tight floor with drain connections to a dedicated collection facility where the
dripped caustic can be collected and neutralised. In the unloading connection or
vessel a detector is placed detecting no flow in order to stop the pump.
Safety measures
Open the cover of the tank car before unloading to prevent under-pressure.
Level switch alarm on the receiving vessel (V-102 in figure 8) in order to prevent
overfilling.
If the top of the tank has to be accessed, safeguard against possible fall should
be provided.
For the design, operation and safety measures, see Truck Loading and Truck
unloading here above.
General design
The ship is connected to the loading line via a loading arm or hose. A position
switch or restraining mechanism ensures that the loading arm or hose is
correctly mounted. If the arm or hose is not in the right position, loading cannot
start. The loading arm or hose should be provided with breakaway couplings,
allowing the connection to be broken at pre-defined spots and triggering shut-
down of the caustic flow if the ship moves too much away from the platform
during loading; this should take into account the risk of high surge pressure in
the pipe due to fast shut-down. The overall process is shown in Figure 9.
Safety measures
There must be two walkways between the ship and the platform to guarantee an
escape route at all times. If it is not possible to set-up two walkways, the ship’s
crew should be able to leave the ship via a small boat on the side.
The safety of the ship loading on the platform is usually provided via 2 signal
cables. One is the emergency cable which can be used by the ship’s crew to
trigger the emergency stop. The other cable is for overfilling cases. If either
cable breaks, the filling is automatically stopped.
There are several chambers on the ship to store the caustic soda. When one of
those chambers is filled, ship’s crew is responsible to change the loading route
to another chamber. However in case of overfilling or triggering the emergency
button because of other unexpected situations, loading is automatically
stopped. Loading can also be stopped by an emergency button on the loading
platform and one in the control room.
Precautions have to be taken to avoid liquid hammer due to too rapid closing of
the valve or stopping the pump.
Be aware that rapid closure of a valve on board the ship could also result in
liquid hammer and the ship’s crew should be informed and trained.
5. Safety
The safety showers and eyewash fountains should be installed in safe easily
accessible locations, for example near any acid or caustic handling area, to
allow for a rapid intervention.
The system is simply activated by pressing foot pedal or pulling the handle; it is
recommended that this activation would trigger an alarm in the control room.
5.2. Training
Al workers, including contractors, that could be involved in handling caustic
should be made aware of its dangerous properties and trained on the best
operating practices and use of the protective equipment.
6. Maintenance
Note: where there has been a leak of caustic from the equipment, the
equipment should be washed externally to remove contamination before
maintenance; particular care must be taken with insulation that could be
heavily contaminated with caustic,
Any removed insulation should be reinstated as soon as possible to avoid the risk
of caustic freezing.
7. Appendices
Appendix 1: Physical properties of caustic soda
Appendix 2: Physical properties of caustic potash
Appendix 3: Schematic installation diagrams for a caustic concentration unit
Appendix 4: Materials selection for equipment, piping, etc. based on the
concentration and temperature of caustic soda
8. References
GEST 92/171 – Personal Protective Equipment in the Chlorine Industry
Health 9 - Code of Practice-Control of Worker Exposure to Caustic Soda in
the Chlor-Alkali Industry
Figure 12: Solid-liquid equilibrium for caustic potash (data reference 17)
Tem perature(º C) at 0 º C at 10 º C at 20 º C at 30 º C at 40 º C at 50 º C at 60 º C at 70 º C
Density Concentration Concentration Concentration Concentration Concentration Concentration Concentration Concentration
(g/l) (%) (g/l) (%) (g/l) (%) (g/l) (%) g/l (%) g/l (%) g/l (%) g/l (%) g/l
1,200 20,5 245,5 20,9 251,2 21,4 256,6 21,9 262,3 22,4 268,3 22,9 274,3 23,4 281,0 24,0 288,4
1,210 21,5 259,7 21,9 265,4 22,4 270,8 22,9 276,4 23,4 282,7 23,9 288,7 24,4 295,5 25,0 302,7
1,220 22,5 274,0 22,9 279,6 23,4 285,2 23,9 291,1 24,3 297,0 24,8 303,1 25,4 310,3 26,0 317,4
1,230 23,4 288,3 23,9 294,2 24,4 299,9 24,8 305,5 25,3 311,7 25,8 317,8 26,4 325,0 27,0 332,1
1,240 24,4 302,7 24,9 308,6 25,4 314,5 25,8 320,4 26,3 326,5 26,8 332,6 27,4 339,8 28,0 347,2
1,250 25,4 317,1 25,8 322,9 26,3 329,3 26,8 335,0 27,3 341,5 27,8 347,8 28,4 354,8 29,0 362,0
1,260 26,3 331,9 26,8 337,7 27,3 343,9 27,8 350,0 28,3 356,6 28,8 362,9 29,4 370,1 29,9 377,0
1,270 27,3 346,7 27,8 352,7 28,3 359,2 28,8 365,4 29,3 371,7 29,8 378,2 30,3 385,2 30,9 392,4
1,280 28,2 361,3 28,7 367,6 29,2 374,1 29,7 380,7 30,2 386,9 30,8 393,6 31,3 400,6 31,9 407,8
1,290 29,2 376,4 29,7 383,0 30,2 389,2 30,7 396,0 31,2 402,1 31,7 409,1 32,3 416,2 32,8 423,3
1,300 30,1 391,8 30,6 398,2 31,1 404,7 31,7 411,5 32,2 418,0 32,7 424,6 33,2 431,5 33,8 439,1
1,310 31,1 407,3 31,6 413,8 32,1 420,0 32,6 428,8 33,1 433,2 33,6 440,0 34,1 446,8 34,7 454,7
1,320 32,0 422,8 32,5 429,4 33,0 435,6 33,5 442,2 34,0 448,9 34,5 455,7 35,1 462,9 35,7 470,7
1,330 32,9 438,1 33,5 445,2 33,9 451,4 34,4 457,9 34,9 464,6 35,5 471,6 36,0 479,1 36,6 486,5
1,340 33,9 453,6 34,4 460,6 34,9 467,0 35,4 473,8 35,9 480,5 36,4 487,5 36,9 495,4 37,5 502,5
1,350 34,8 469,4 35,3 476,6 35,8 482,8 36,3 490,2 36,8 496,5 37,3 503,6 37,9 511,0 38,4 518,7
1,360 35,7 485,3 36,2 492,5 36,7 499,1 37,2 506,2 37,7 512,7 38,2 519,2 38,8 527,3 39,3 534,9
1,370 36,6 501,6 37,1 508,5 37,6 512,3 38,1 522,4 38,6 529,1 39,1 536,2 39,7 543,6 40,2 551,9
1,380 37,6 518,3 38,0 524,8 38,5 531,4 39,0 538,8 39,5 545,4 40,1 552,7 40,6 560,0 41,1 567,7
1,390 38,4 534,0 38,9 541,0 39,4 547,8 39,9 555,0 40,4 561,7 41,0 569,2 41,5 576,7 42,0 584,1
1,400 39,3 550,6 39,8 557,5 40,3 564,3 40,8 571,5 41,3 578,5 41,9 586,0 42,4 593,3 42,9 601,2
1,410 40,2 567,0 40,7 574,0 41,2 581,1 41,7 588,1 42,2 595,3 42,7 602,6 43,3 610,1 43,8 618,0
1,420 41,1 583,3 41,6 590,4 42,1 597,5 42,6 604,6 43,1 611,7 43,6 619,3 44,1 626,8 44,7 634,9
1,430 41,9 599,7 42,5 607,2 43,0 614,5 43,5 621,8 44,0 628,8 44,5 636,1 45,0 643,8 45,6 651,9
1,440 42,8 616,6 43,3 623,7 43,8 631,2 44,4 638,9 44,9 645,8 45,4 653,3 45,9 660,8 46,5 669,2
1,450 43,6 632,8 44,2 641,1 44,7 648,4 45,2 656,0 45,7 662,8 46,2 670,3 46,8 678,0 47,3 686,1
1,460 44,5 650,1 45,1 658,0 45,6 665,5 46,1 673,2 46,6 679,9 47,1 687,5 47,6 695,1 48,2 703,3
1,470 45,4 667,4 45,9 675,2 46,5 682,8 46,9 689,9 47,4 697,2 47,9 704,7 48,5 712,4 49,0 720,5
1,480 46,3 684,5 46,8 692,3 47,3 700,0 47,8 707,3 48,3 714,7 48,8 721,9 49,3 729,6 49,9 737,9
1,490 47,1 701,6 47,6 709,4 48,1 717,1 48,6 724,6 49,1 732,0 49,6 739,5 50,1 747,1 50,7 755,3
1,500 47,9 718,8 48,5 726,8 49,0 734,7 49,5 742,1 50,0 749,9 50,5 757,1 51,0 764,6 51,5 773,0
1,510 48,7 735,8 49,3 744,0 49,8 752,4 50,3 759,8 50,8 767,5 51,3 774,8
1,520 50,1 761,4 50,7 770,2 51,2 777,5
400
350
300
Temperature ª C
250
200
150
100
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Concentration % KOH
Figure 13: Boiling point for aqueous solutions of KOH at atmospheric pressure
(data reference 18)
(17) https://koh.olinchloralkali.com/TechnicalInformation/Phase%20Diagram%
200-80.pdf
(18) http://www.oxy.com/OurBusinesses/Chemicals/Products/Documents/Cau
sticPotash/kohhandb.pdf
1. General
It must be reminded that caustic reacts violently with many organic materials
(greases and oils …).
A range of engineering materials can be used for the production and handling of
caustic. Their selection for a specific application depends on:
2.1 Concentration
For carbon steel and stainless steel, dependency of uniform corrosion rate on
caustic soda concentration is not very strong. In general, 50% caustic is
somewhat more corrosive than 24% caustic at the same temperature.
2.2 Temperature
Especially for stainless steels, the uniform corrosion rates show a very strong
dependency on temperature if passivity is lost above the indicated temperature.
For heat exchangers, maximum occurring wall skin temperatures should be used
to evaluate corrosion risks. Table 9 is not valid for selecting MOC’s for heat
exchangers.
2.3 Velocity
Austenitic stainless steels and nickel alloys develop a protective Ni-NiO layer in
caustic applications. This black layer becomes thicker, less protective and less
adherent (brittle) with increasing temperature. Based on experience, it is quite
well known that high velocities can result in high degradation rates due to
erosion-corrosion effects. The temperature limits mentioned in Table 9 are valid
up to approximately 2.0 m/s. Table 9 is not valid for two phase (liquid-gas) flow;
impingement of droplets can easily disturb protective oxide layers. Extreme
care should be taken in case of plate heat exchangers in caustic service. Plates
tend to rub each other at the contact points. Because of the thick brittle oxide
layers formed, wear may easily occur at the contact points leading to premature
failure of the plates. Therefore, Table 9 is not valid for plate heat exchangers.
2.4 Oxygen
The oxygen content in the catholyte, heat medium circuit and caustic
evaporation section of membrane electrolysis plants is normally very low (ppb
range). Oxygen is an important factor in almost every electrochemical corrosion
process. It can show a positive (passivation) or negative (intensifying
degradation) effect depending on the conditions and alloy used. This is also the
case for stainless steels and nickel alloys in caustic applications. However the
precise influence of oxygen is not well established under the various conditions.
The temperature limits given in Table 9 for austenitic stainless steels will shift
to somewhat lower values with increasing oxygen level. If these limits are
exceeded, corrosion rates increase quite strongly with the oxygen level.
Corrosion rate of carbon steel also increases with oxygen content below the
limiting temperature indicated. Presence of oxygen can result in increased
corrosion rates on Ni-200/Ni-201 in evaporator units producing 73- 100% caustic.
2.5 Chlorate
Caustic from membrane plants contains usually 10 to 60 mg/kg chlorate in 50%
solution. Although chlorate is thermodynamically an oxidizing agent, the kinetics
of its reduction is quite low in highly alkaline media. Therefore, the
temperature limits given in Table 9 can be regarded as virtually independent of
chlorate levels in the range of 0 – 100 mg/kg. Only at substantial higher levels
and temperatures higher than 160ºC chlorate can have a negative effect on the
corrosion behaviour. Presence of chlorate can result in increased corrosion rates
on Ni-200/Ni-201 in evaporator units producing 73- 100% caustic.
In caustic applications, many MOC’s can suffer from stress corrosion cracking
(SCC) if loaded with residual and/or applied tensile stress. Susceptibility is often
noticed above certain temperature limits depending on type of alloy and caustic
concentration. The temperature limits given in Table 9 are based on experience
within the industry and corrosion literature. These limits for carbon steel and
nickel alloys are quite well established (Figure 12). The same is true to a lesser
extent for the 300 series stainless steel (Figure 13).
Stress relief treatment can be applied to minimize the risk of cracking. In the
following Figure 12, three areas can be distinguished: in area “A” no stress
relief is necessary, in “B” stress relief treatment of welds and cold worked parts
is deemed necessary, whereas in “C” stress relief treatment is ineffective and
other MOC’s should be selected.
Figure 12. Caustic soda service chart (carbon steel and nickel alloys)
The temperature limits to avoid SCC of higher alloyed stainless steel types and
nickel alloys cannot be presented in simple way; besides temperature there is
also a strong dependency on stress level, alloy structure, heat treatment (e.g.
stress relief) and presence of contaminants.
Although the temperature limits for carbon steel and stainless steel 300 series in
Table 9 (and also in Figures 12 and 13) present good engineering practice, it
should be noticed that these limits are not guaranteed. In constructions with
extremely high (internal) stress levels (e.g. due to heavy cold forming or
welding) susceptibility to SCC may already arise below these limits. It has been
observed at temperature well below 100°C (drain plugs and pipes).
This is especially true for threaded connections and their applicability should be
carefully evaluated in caustic service. These connections may contain highly
stressed roots that can serve as stress corrosion cracking initiation points.
3.1 Aluminium
Aluminium is rapidly attacked by even dilute solutions of caustic at all
temperatures. In the corrosion reaction with caustic, hydrogen is formed due to
the reduction of water. At pH=9 or less, the corrosion rate is low at ambient
temperatures (<0.05 mm/y) but at higher pH, the protective oxide layer breaks
down locally and pitting occurs. At pH 12 and higher, severe localized corrosion
and at higher caustic concentrations severe general corrosion occurs. Corrosion
rate of aluminium in 20% NaOH at 20ºC is >>100 mm/y. Aluminium has to be
avoided for any application where there is contact with caustic even for a very
short exposure time (e.g. due to spills).
3.2 Titanium
Titanium is widely used in chlorine absorption system containing chlorinated
caustic soda. However it is unsuitable for use in pure caustic solutions and
requires a minimum level of chlorination to maintain the passive layer
protection.
to the presence of a passive iron oxide layer. At higher temperatures, this oxide
layer provides less effective protection and corrosion rates increase.
Although corrosion rates are low up to about 45 ºC, the use of carbon steel
equipment may cause too much iron pick-up. In order to minimize iron
contamination a suitable liner or coating or an alternative material of
construction like FRP-PP, FRP-PVC or stainless steel can be considered. To avoid
excessive iron pick-up of the first NaOH batches in a carbon steel tank which has
been newly constructed, modified or out of service during a long period of time,
a passivation treatment of the tank is advised.
If tensile stresses are present, as from cold work, welding or internal pressure,
carbon steel equipment or piping is vulnerable to caustic stress corrosion
cracking (SCC) depending on temperature and concentration. This failure
mechanism is commonly referred to as caustic embrittlement. Caustic SCC is
typically intergranular, although transgranular cracking can also occur
depending on metal structure. The majority of the industrial cases of caustic
SCC in carbon steel equipment are associated with non stress-relieved welds,
typically in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and adjacent base metal. Cracking
rate is highly unpredictable; however it steeply increases with stress level and
temperature.
Uniform corrosion
Note: be aware that NiO is carcinogen by oral intake and precautions need to be
taken when coming in contact with it (maintenance work …).
As carbon steel, stainless steel types may lead to stress corrosion cracking in hot
caustic however at clearly higher temperatures. Susceptibility depends on: alloy
composition, metallurgical structure, mechanical tensile stress level,
concentration, temperature and contaminants (e.g. oxygen, sulphur
compounds). In general the risk of cracking decreases with increasing nickel
content whereas the presence of oxidizing species or sulphur compounds
promote this form of failure.
In Figure 13 above, the range of susceptibility to SCC of 300 series stainless steel
types depending on NaOH concentration and temperature is shown. It should be
noticed that in this figure the influence of mechanical stress and contaminants
like dissolved oxygen is not shown. In general, susceptibility to SCC of these
stainless steel types can occur at concentration >20% and at temperatures
>100ºC. At concentrations <20%, the temperature for SCC susceptibility
increases with decreasing concentration.
A disadvantage of Ni-200 and Ni-201 is the low mechanical strength. For this
reason nickel equipment often uses backing flanges of stronger materials such as
carbon steel or stainless steel. Care must be taken in the event of leaks as rapid
SCC damage can occur to the backing flanges.
Alloy 600 and Alloy 400 show high corrosion resistance to hot caustic soda. Due
to their higher strength compared to Ni-200, they are sometimes preferred, for
instance for tube sheets. At temperatures >160 oC, these alloys may be
susceptible to stress corrosion cracking and intergranular corrosion, depending
on the corrosion potential, microstructure (heat treatment) and mechanical
stress levels. In hot caustic facilities, applicability of Alloy 600 and Alloy 400
should be carefully evaluated for each specific situation. Due to its high copper
content, application of Alloy 400 can result in highly undesired pick up of
copper.
At normal operation, there is little incentive to use NiCrMo alloys like Alloy 625,
Alloy C-276, Alloy C-22, Alloy 59 and Hastelloy C-2000 in hot caustic. Mo free
alloys like Alloy 600, Alloy 800, Monel 400 or Ni-200 should be preferred. Alloy
625 may be used for plate heat exchangers (PHE) as an alternative for Ni-200 up
to about 115oC. Only for PHE coolers for hot caustic soda using oxidizing chloride
containing cooling water, NiCrMo alloys are used, because Mo free alloys would
suffer from crevice or pitting corrosion due to the aggressive cooling water. Mo
is in general detrimental to corrosion resistance in hot caustic and this effect
becomes dominant above 100ºC with increasing Mo content. NiCrMo alloys may
suffer from caustic de-alloying; especially chromium, molybdenum and
tungsten are leached out leaving behind an almost pure layer of metallic nickel
on the surface. This layer is porous and not protective. Additions of iron (if
>15%) appear to decrease the susceptibility to this form of attack. Caustic de-
alloying is rarely observed below 100oC; however susceptibility strongly increases
with the temperature above 100oC. Also oxidizing (oxygen) conditions stimulate
this kind of failure. NiCrMo alloys are sometimes used in PHE's to cool down 50%
NaOH from temperatures above 100ºC using chloride containing cooling water.
Service life time of Inconel 625 is about 6 years. Hastelloy C-2000 may offer
improved service life but experience is limited. Applicability of NiCrMo alloys
(“Hastelloy C types”) in hot caustic should be carefully evaluated for each
specific situation.
4. PLASTICS
Because of its higher stiffness and strength, PP-H is the preferred material for
pressure piping. Although PP-B was always preferred for low temperature
applications because of its lower modulus and better impact properties; modern
types of PP-H have almost matched these properties.
In general, all PP types have a good chemical resistance against caustic soda in
all concentrations up to approximately 80 to 90°C. Contaminations with
chloride, chlorate or oxygen have no influence on this.
When manufacturing PP lined FRP for hot caustic soda, extra attention should be
given to weld quality (high strength, low stress) and liner adhesion. Weld quality
is crucial as any weld leakage will lead to strong FRP attack and loss of
containment on a short time scale. Liner adhesion is important as thermal
cycling of lined FRP puts high stress on the bond between liner and FRP and may
cause de-bonding in case of inadequate initial adhesion.
When manufactured correctly, expected life time of FRP piping with this type of
liner in 32% NaOH at about 88°C (membrane cell temperature) is currently
estimated as approximately 15 years. Crack formation around the welds is the
life time determining factor.
Polyester resins are the most economical resins, but have very limited
chemical resistance against caustic soda and should always be protected
from direct contact.
Vinylester resins have much better caustic soda resistance than
polyesters, but direct contact is still limited to maximum temperatures of
approximately 50°C, with increasing corrosion and penetration rates at
increasing temperatures
Epoxy resins have relatively good caustic soda resistance, but are more
difficult to process and have limited applications in piping and equipment
in chemical environments.
Because of the limited chemical resistance against hot caustic soda, FRP is
normally used only in combination with a thermoplastic liner, e.g. PP-FRP or
PVC-FRP. Vinylester resin is preferred for these FRP applications, in view of the
much better barrier function in case of liner leakage, at an only slightly higher
cost than polyester.
5. Gaskets
For plastic equipment with low process pressure various rubber gaskets can be
used. Often EPDM is used but depending on process temperature also other
rubbers are available. However fluorine elastomers like Viton cannot be used. If
the process pressure is above 5 bar then a reinforced rubber gasket should be
used.
For all gaskets, it is important to achieve the optimum sealing pressure. The
sealing pressure depends on the combination of material of construction, flange
design, the used gaskets and the used bolts. Gasket calculations have to be
made to calculate the optimum bolt torque. Qualified mechanics are used to
place the gaskets.
Other factors like creep (PTFE) need to be considered when selecting a gasket.
Limiting
Material of
≦ 25% NaOH ≦ 32% NaOH ≦50% NaOH 72% NaOH 100% NaOH degradation Remarks
Construction
mechanism
SCC (Stress
Use of carbon steel results
relief heat
in pick-up of iron. Each
treatment may
Carbon steel 60oC 55oC 50oC not resistant not resistant application is evaluated
increase
separately on
limiting
contamination risk
temperature)
Limiting
Material of
≦ 25% NaOH ≦ 32% NaOH ≦50% NaOH 72% NaOH 100% NaOH degradation Remarks
Construction
mechanism
Useful up to
Useful up to Useful up to atmospheric
Risk on SCC at
atmospheric atmospheric boiling point Application at higher
Alloy 400 T>180°C. In
boiling point. boiling point. however may temperatures may result in
(UNS04400. general, not not resistant SCC
However, it However, it suffer from SCC. highly undesired copper
W.Nr 2.4360 ) recommended
may result in may result in Each application pick up
in hot 72% NaOH
copper pick up copper pick up is evaluated
separately
Limiting
Material of
≦ 25% NaOH ≦ 32% NaOH ≦50% NaOH 72% NaOH 100% NaOH degradation Remarks
Construction
mechanism
Useful up to
Useful up to atmospheric
Useful up to Useful up to atmospheric boiling point. SCC Condition
atmospheric atmospheric boiling point. However, it In general, not and heat
Alloy 600 At high temperatures,
boiling point. boiling point. However, it may may suffer recommended treatment
(UNS06600, only to be used in stress
However, Ni However. Ni suffer from SCC from SCC. due to high strongly
W.Nr 2.4816) relieved condition
200 is 200 is Each application Each risk on SCC influences
preferred preferred is evaluated application is susceptibility
separately evaluated
separately
Preferred
material in
boiling 72%
Sulphur contaminants at
NaOH. at T > 315°C
Fully resistant Fully resistant high temperatures may
Nickel 200 Fully resistant up However, it embrittlement
up to up to result in cracking due to
(UNS N02200, to atmospheric may suffer 315°C due to graphite
atmospheric atmospheric formation of a low
W. Nr 2.4060) boiling point from corrosion precipitation at
boiling point boiling point melting nickel sulphide
due to grain boundaries
compound
presence of
oxidizing
contaminants
Limiting
Material of
≦ 25% NaOH ≦ 32% NaOH ≦50% NaOH 72% NaOH 100% NaOH degradation Remarks
Construction
mechanism
Preferred Preferred
material in material in
boiling 72% molten 100%
Sulphur contaminants at
NaOH. NaOH.
Fully resistant Fully resistant high temperatures may
Nickel 201 Fully resistant up However, it However, it
up to up to Uniform result in cracking due to
(UNS N02201 , to atmospheric may suffer may suffer
atmospheric atmospheric corrosion formation of a low
W.Nr. 2.4061) boiling point from corrosion from corrosion
boiling point boiling point melting nickel sulphide
due to due to
compound
presence of presence of
oxidizing oxidizing
contaminants contaminant
In 60% NaOH,
Resistant up to Resistant up to Resistant up to
PE resistant up to no data
60°C 60°C 60°C
40°C
In 60% NaOH,
Resistant up to Resistant up to Resistant up to
PVC resistant up to no data SCC
60°C 40°C 40°C
40°C
PVDF Not resistant Not resistant Not resistant Not resistant Not resistant SCC
Limiting
Material of
≦ 25% NaOH ≦ 32% NaOH ≦50% NaOH 72% NaOH 100% NaOH degradation Remarks
Construction
mechanism
SCC in hot
Resistant up to Resistant up to Resistant up to
ECTFE not applicable not applicable concentrated
100°C 100°C 80°C
NaOH
Uniform
corrosion,
Bisphenol-A Resistant up to Resistant up to Resistant up to Detailed FRP
not applicable not applicable attack of glass
vinylester FRP 65°C 65°C 65°C specification needed
fibre
reinforcement
Euro Chlor
Avenue E Van Nieuwenhuyse 4
Box 2
B-1160 Brussels
Belgium
Tel: +32 2 676 7211
Fax: +32 2 676 7241
e-mail: eurochlor@cefic.be
Internet: http://www.eurochlor.org