Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Psych Dis in 620 Referrals To Psych Service at MSKCC
Psych Dis in 620 Referrals To Psych Service at MSKCC
3. Psychiatric Disorders in 620 Referrals to the and social support. Although the English version of the
Memorial Sloan-Kettering Counseling Center SBI-15-R scale has been validated in both English and He-
J. Almanza, MD; J.C. Holland, MD, FAPM; W.S. brew, the psychometric properties of the Spanish version
Breitbart, MD, FAPM of the SBI-15-R have not been demonstrated. This inves-
tigation was designed to examine the psychometric prop-
T here have been few studies of the comorbid psychiatric
disorders in ambulatory patients with cancer referred
to a psychiatric clinic for evaluation and treatment. The Me-
erties of the Spanish version of the SBI-15-R. Method:
Transcultural Adaptation: Two bilingual clinicians inde-
morial Counseling Center, open since May 1996, provided pendently performed a forward and backward Spanish
the opportunity for addressing this problem. This study ex- translation of the SBI-15-R. Two items (13.3%) were con-
amined the overall prevalence of psychiatric disorders in sidered equivalent in both meaning and word selection; six
consecutive individuals referred to the Counseling Center items (40%) were equivalent in meaning but not in word
in the first 6 months of 1997, assessing the specific disorders selection; a total of seven items (46.6%) required further
and their relationship to medical and demographic variables. discussion and revision until consensus was reached. Data
Six hundred twenty cases were retrospectively studied by Collection: A total of 83 subjects at a general hospital in
chart review: 506 (82%) had cancer, 95 (15%) had no can- Mexico City completed the SBI-15-R: orthopedic patients,
cer, and 19 (3%) did not keep their appointment. Of the 95 52 (63%); healthy nonpatient relatives, 11 (13%); and
cases that had no cancer, 42 (6.8%) were relatives of cancer medical staff, 20 (24%). The mean age was 37.6 years; 50
patients, 20 (3.2%) were patients with AIDS, 19 (3%) were (60.2%) were male, 33 (39.8%) were female; 82 (98%)
patients referred for pain management, and 14 (2%) at- were Mexican; 50 (60.2%) were married; 78 (94%) were
tended the smoking cessation program. Six attending psy- Catholic; 23 (27.7%) completed primary education; and 29
chiatrists and four clinical fellows using DSM-IV criteria (34.9%) worked for the military. The inventory was well
evaluated patients. Referrals were largely from the medical accepted by patients and required 15–20 minutes for com-
and surgical staff of Memorial. Results showed that the pletion. Preliminary Validation: The Mexico scale sample
mean age was 51 year old; 55% were women; 45% were mean (M⳱34.28) was greater than the U.S. sample mean
married; 89% were white; 98% of patients received one or (M⳱20.94) though similar to the U.S. religious group
more DSM-IV Axis I diagnoses: mood disorder (53%), ad- mean (M⳱34.16). Composite scale means for each Mex-
justment disorder (46%), anxiety disorder (27%), more than ico group were as follows: patients (M⳱35.44), healthy
one Axis I diagnosis (42%). Axis II diagnoses were per- nonpatient relatives (M⳱34.8), and staff (M⳱29.3). The
sonality disorder in 16% (primarily obsessive compulsive, total scale Cronbach alpha was 0.89 and the standardized
dependent, and borderline). The five most frequent cancer
Cronbach alpha was 0.90. Composite scale Cronbach al-
sites were lung (10%), leukemia (9%), breast (8%), prostate
phas for each subsample were as follows: patients
(7%), and colon/rectum (7%). Pain was present in 34%.
(␣⳱0.85), healthy nonpatient relatives (␣⳱0.91), and
Psychotropic drugs were prescribed in 394 (64%); psycho-
staff (␣⳱0.92). Cronbach alpha for the subscale of beliefs
therapy was conducted with 500 individuals (80%); 319
and practices was 0.85 and was 0.81 for the subscale of
(51.4%) patients received both. In 67%, therapy was con-
social support. A principal component analysis with Vari-
ducted over six or more sessions. The Clinician’s Global
max rotation of the SBI-15-R identified three factors, in
Impression Score showed improvement in 55%. In sum-
contrast to the two factors found when patients in the
mary, patients with cancer and their family members re-
United States completed the English version. The single
ferred to the counseling center of a major cancer research
center showed primarily mood and adjustment disorders. U.S. sample belief and practice construct was divided into
Concurrent psychotherapy and/or pharmacotherapy led to 1) general spiritual beliefs and practices and 2) beliefs spe-
improvement in 55% of patients. cific to coping with adversity. Discussion: This prelimi-
nary report produced mixed findings. Although the Spanish
4. Spanish Version of the Systems of Belief Inventory version produced high internal consistency between the
(SBI-15-R): Cross Cultural Research on Spiritual and two factors previously found in the United States, the Span-
Religious Beliefs ish version resulted in three factors. Religious and spiritual
J. Almanza, MD; M. Monroy, RN; A. Bimbela, PhD; beliefs in Mexico may be more specifically defined than in
D.K. Payne, PhD; J.C. Holland, MD, FAPM the U.S. sample.