Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Final Draft 2 Ebonham
Final Draft 2 Ebonham
Final Draft 2 Ebonham
Ebone J. Bonham
develops, which will act as the foundation for that child’s future academic success. “A child’s
earliest experiences—especially positive interactions with the adults in their lives—stimulate and
strengthen these neural connections as they are being formed” (Collaborative for Children,
2020). Teachers must be prepared and properly trained before entering the classroom, and
administrators should invest in continuing their teaching staff’s professional growth and
on subject-matter mastery and provide teachers with opportunities to spend time under the
have opportunities to learn through examining case studies, learning best practices, and
the time to apply their learning of theory in the context of teaching in a real classroom”
(Edutopia, 2008).
requirements for early childhood professionals in Texas and then compare them to the
requirements in Minnesota, Colorado, and Arizona; research on the training requirements for
Texas-certified teachers was conducted, but the requirements for professionals working in early
Policy Background
Arizona
Arizona’s Department of Health Services has the Bureau of Child Care Licensing “to
monitor the health, safety and well being of children in child care centers and child care group
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 3
homes” (Arizona Administrative Code and Arizona Revised Statutes for Child Care Facilities,
2010).
Article 4 includes the training requirements for facility staff. According to Article 4, the
owner or administrator is required to provide an orientation to new staff members and volunteers
within 10 days of their hire date (Arizona Administrative Code and Arizona Revised Statues for
Child Care Facilities, 2010). Arizona’s Bureau of Child Care Licensing (2010) requires that this
orientation must include the following topics: facility philosophy and goals; the names, ages, and
developmental expectations of children staff members may be responsible for; health needs,
nutritional requirements, and known allergies of children staff members may be responsible for;
lesson plans; discipline and guidance; hand-washing techniques; diapering and toileting
techniques; food preparation, service, sanitation, and storage for staff members responsible for
preparing meals; feeding infants and the preparation, handling, and storage of infant formula and
breast milk for staff members assigned to infants; recognition of illness and infestation; child
abuse or neglect; accident and emergency procedures; staff responsibilities; sun safety policies
and procedures; outdoor activity safety; transportation procedures for staff members responsible
According to the Bureau of Child Care Licensing (2010), staff members and volunteers
must complete at least 18 annual training hours in at least two topics within each subsection:
child growth and development; health and safety issues; program administration, planning,
those available to children with special needs. “A staff member who provides child care services
to an infant completes at least 6 hours in (B)(1)(a)(i) [infant growth and development] every 12
months after the staff member’s starting date” (Arizona Administrative Code and Arizona
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 4
Revised Statues for Child Care Facilities, 2010). Staff members need to obtain first-aid and CPR
training; they are responsible for maintaining current training in both topics. Lastly, the Bureau
of Child Care Licensing (2010) facility directors are required to complete six annual training
The minimum of clock hours for each subsection depends on each staff member’s
experience before their hire date at the early learning program. “A staff member who has less
than 12 months of child care experience before the staff member’s starting date, completes at
least 12 hours in one or more of the topics in subsection (B)(1)(a) [child growth and
development] in the staff member’s first 12 months at the facility” (Arizona Administrative Code
and Arizona Revised Statues for Child Care Facilities, 2010). In contrast, staff members with 12
or more months of early childhood experience are required to complete six hours in child growth
and development (Arizona Administrative Code and Arizona Revised Statues for Child Care
Facilities, 2010).
Colorado
The Colorado Office of Early Childhood of the Department of Human Services develops
the Rules Regulating Child Care Centers, which includes the requirements for staff development.
Prior to working with children, all staff must complete pre-service training, and the training must
include: “building and physical premises safety, including identification of and protection from
hazards that can cause bodily injury such as electrical hazards, bodies of water, and vehicular
traffic; and handling and storage of hazardous materials and appropriate disposal of bio
Office of Early Childhood (20187), employees and volunteers must receive training in child
abuse prevention and how to report suspected or known child abuse or neglect within 30 days of
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 5
their hire date. Furthermore, “the child care center must ensure that all staff are familiar with the
licensing rules governing child care centers within thirty (30) calendar days of employment at the
center” (Colorado Department of Human Services, 2017). In addition, the Colorado Office of
Early Childhood (2017) requires staff to complete training in Occupational Safety and Health
Administration (OSHA) requirements. Those staff members responsible for infants younger than
12 months must obtain training in safe-sleep, and staff members working with children younger
than three years of age are required to complete training in the prevention of shaken
baby/abusive head trauma (Colorado Department of Human Services, 2017). Staff responsible
for collecting, reviewing, and maintaining children’s immunization records must complete the
“All staff who work with children must complete a minimum of fifteen (15) clock hours
of training each year…at least three (3) clock hours per year must be in the focus of social
training requirements are required to be renewed annually by employees and/or volunteers. For
immunization records, OSHA requirements, child abuse prevention, and reporting suspected or
known child abuse or neglect are required every year (Colorado Department of Human Services,
2017). Lastly, the Colorado Office of Early Childhood (2017) requires that all annual training be
relevant to at least one of the following areas: child growth and development; child observation
and assessment; family and community partnership; guidance; health, safety and nutrition;
practices.
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 6
Minnesota
monitoring child care centers for compliance with licensing requirements”. The statutes and
administrative rules for licensed early learning centers can be found in the Minnesota
Administrative Rules, Chapter 9503 Department of Human Services Child Care Center
Licensing.
The Minnesota Department of Human Services (2016) requires pre-service training for
all licensed early learning center providers. “Pre-service training ensures providers have the
knowledge and skills necessary to provide a healthy and safe environment for the children in
care” (Minnesota Department of Human Services, 2016). The requirements are different
depending on an individual’s role in the early learning center. All staff and volunteers must
attend orientation that covers the “center’s philosophy, procedures for maintaining health and
safety, handling emergencies and accidents, job responsibilities, behavior guidance, and
minimum of clock hours required. According to the Minnesota Department of Human Services
(2016), staff and volunteers who care for infants will need to complete 30 minutes of training in
sudden unexpected infant death. “Staff and volunteers that care for children under school age”
(Minnesota Department of Human Services, 2016) will need to complete 30 minutes of training
in abusive head trauma. In addition, staff who are responsible for placing children in a safety seat
for transportation must complete three clock hours in child passenger restraint training
(Minnesota Department of Human Services, 2016). Also, all lead and assistant teachers must
complete first-aid and CPR training, but there is no minimum number of clock hours specified
Department of Human Services (2016), staff are obligated to complete two hours of training in
The Minnesota Department of Human Services (2016) requires ongoing training for all
licensed early learning center providers. “Ongoing training is required to ensure providers
continue to develop knowledge and skills regarding minimum health and safety standards, as
well as to promote professional development skills that in turn result in higher quality learning
Department of Human Services (2016), the amount of annual, in-service training required for
directors and staff varies between 20 to 40. The Minnesota Department of Human Services
(2016) state that staff who care for infants are required to complete 30 minutes of training in
sudden unexpected infant death each year, and staff and volunteers who will care for children
under school age will complete 30 minutes of annual training in abusive head trauma.
The frequency of training requirements for Minnesota early learning center personnel
varies. Lead and assistant teachers must complete or renew their first aid and CPR training every
three years, and staff who will be responsible for placing children in a car seat for transportation
must complete three clock hours in child passenger restraint every five years (Minnesota
Texas
Early Learning Center Educators. The Texas Human Resources Code, Chapter 42,
requires the Texas Health and Human Services Commission (HHSC) to regulate early learning
program activities in Texas and enforce the minimum standards (Texas Health and Human
Services Commission, 2020). “The Minimum Standards mitigate risk for children in out-of-home
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 8
care settings by outlining basic requirements to protect the health, safety and well-being of
The Regulatory Services Division of the HHSC Child Care Regulation Department is
responsible for developing rules for early learning programs to follow (Texas Health and Human
Services Commission). Once the rules are reviewed and adopted, they become a part of the
Texas Administrative Code (TAC). There are sets of Minimum Standards for each type of early
learning program setting, such as homes, shelter care, school-age programs, and centers. Each set
of standards is based on a specific chapter of TAC, like Chapter 746 is for centers.
According to the Minimum Standards for Child-Care Centers (2021), there are different
types of training employees are required to complete during their employment. There is
orientation, pre-service, pediatric first aid and cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), and annual
training; training on transportation safety is required if the program offers those services to
students and their families (Texas Health and Human Services Commission, 2021). Majority of
the types of trainings required have a minimum of clock hours the employee needs to complete.
Any individual who does not have ample experience in early childhood education is
required to complete 24 clock hours of pre-service training (Texas Health and Human Services
Commission, 2021). Pre-service training must include the following topics: developmental stages
of children; age-appropriate activities; positive guidance and discipline; fostering children’s self-
esteem; supervision and safety practices; positive interactions; and preventing and controlling the
spread of communicable diseases (Texas Health and Human Services Commission, 2021). The
HHSC (2021) requires teachers to receive one hour of training in shaken baby syndrome and
abusive head trauma, safe-sleep practices and preventing sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS),
and early childhood brain development if they care for children younger than 24 months of age.
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 9
Employees, specifically teachers, are required to complete 24 clock hours each year, and
directors are required to obtain at least 30 clock hours of annual training (Texas Health and
Human Services Commission, 2021). If a program offers transportation services, the director and
any driver are required to obtain two clock hours every year (Texas Health and Human Services
Commission, 2021). Annual training for teachers needs to be completed in certain topics. At
least six clock hours need to cover content in child development, guidance and discipline, age-
Commission, 2021). According to the Minimum Standards for Child-Care Centers (2021),
teachers must receive at least one clock hour on prevention, recognition, and reporting of child
maltreatment. If a teacher cares for children 23 months and younger in age, he or she must
receive one clock hour of training covering the following topics: recognizing and preventing
shaken baby syndrome and abusive head trauma; understanding and using safe-sleep practice and
preventing SIDS; and understanding early childhood brain development (Texas Health and
Human Services Commission). The standards do not require a specific amount of clock hours,
but teachers must obtain training covering topics in: emergency preparedness; preventing and
reaction; understanding building and physical premises safety; and handling, storing, and
disposing of hazardous materials (Texas Health and Human Services Commission, 2021). Lastly,
teachers must ensure the remaining training they receive is related to: caring for children with
special needs; child health; safety; risk management; identification and care of ill children;
cultural diversity for children and families; effective communication with families; time and
assessment; attachment and responsive caregiving; minimum standards and how they apply to
caregivers; and other topics relevant to the age group the teacher is assigned to care for (Texas
The required annual training for directors is similar to the requirements for teachers, but
there is an additional training requirement for directors to fulfill. All directors, depending on
their leadership experience, are required to complete clock hours in management techniques,
leadership, or staff supervision (Texas Health and Human Services Commission, 2021). Lastly, if
the program cares for children under 24 months of age, the director is required to complete
training in the same topics required for teachers regarding infant care (Texas Health and Human
ensuring quality educator preparation programs that recruit and prepare qualified educators who
meet the needs of all learners in today’s and tomorrow’s Texas classrooms” (Texas Education
Agency). The ongoing professional development requirements for certified teachers can be found
in TAC, Title 19, Part 7, Chapter 232 General Certification Provisions, Subchapter A Certificate
Renewal and Continuing Professional Education Requirements. According to TEA, all certified
classroom teachers in Texas are required to complete 150 Continuing Professional Education
(CPE) clock hours before the end of their five-year renewal period. Classroom teachers must
complete their CPE hours on the content area knowledge and skills and the professional ethics
At least 37.5 CPE clock hours need to cover training in the following topics: collecting
and analyzing information that will improve teacher efficacy in the classroom; recognizing early
indicators that a student may be at risk of dropping out of school; digital learning, digital
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 11
teaching, and integrating technology into the classroom’s curriculum; educating diverse student
communication between teachers and students; and how mental health conditions, grief, and
trauma can affect students’ academic success (Texas Education Agency, 2019). Although there is
no set required number of CPE clock hours, “educators who teach students with dyslexia must
include training regarding new research and practices in educating students with dyslexia”
(Texas Education Agency, 2019). According to TEA (2019), educators must also participate in
training activities that include: an evidence-based mental health first-aid training program or a
training program covering grief- and trauma-informed care; suicide prevention; the use of an
automated external defibrillator (AED) approved under the Texas Health and Safety Code; the
use of technology to increase a teacher’s digital literacy; and the use of technology in classroom
Similarities
Pre-service Training
Texas, and Minnesota; for the sake of this literature review, some of Arizona’s requirements for
staff orientation were used to compare to the other states’ pre-service obligations. All states
require their staff to obtain quality first-aid and CPR training before caring for children. Other
common required topics for pre-service training are for two or more states include: child abuse
and neglect; curriculum, lesson plans, and age-appropriate activities; discipline and guidance;
safety practices; shaken baby syndrome and abusive head trauma; safe-sleep practices and
Ongoing Training
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 12
Colorado, Texas, and Minnesota each require infant teachers to complete training in
shaken baby syndrome, abusive head trauma, safe-sleep, and SIDS. Infant teachers in Texas and
Arizona require annual training in early childhood or infant development. Training in safety,
child development, and child health are required for early childhood educators in Colorado,
Texas and Arizona. Transportation safety training is required in both Minnesota and Texas. In
Texas and Colorado, teachers of early learning programs are required to complete annual training
in the following topics: observation and assessment; nutrition, as well as preventing and
Differences
Pre-service Training
Differences in pre-service requirements were found. For instance, the minimum clock
hour requirement varies for each state. Texas requires 24 training hours in pre-service, while
Minnesota requires teachers to complete six hours. Although Minnesota and Texas both require
teachers to complete pre-service training in abusive head trauma, Texas only requires teachers
caring for children younger than 24 months of age to take training on this topic. In addition,
some states required pre-service training in topics the others did not. Colorado is one state that
requires training in multiple topics that the other states’ statutes did not mention. For example,
Colorado is the only state to require all employees to complete training in OSHA and the state’s
licensing statutes. In addition, training is required for those employees who plan to collect and
pre-service training in general nutrition, nutrition for infants, field trips, outdoor activity safety,
and sun safety. Finally, Texas is the only state that requires pre-service training in the following
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 13
childhood brain development for teachers who care for children younger than 24 months of age.
Ongoing Training
One main difference noticed of the states’ annual training requirements was the minimum
amount teachers and/or directors were required to obtain. For example, Texas requires directors
and teachers to complete 30 and 24 annual clock hours, respectively; in-service training required
for directors and staff varies between 20 to 40. Early learning professionals are required to
complete 15 and 18 annual training hours in Colorado and Arizona, respectively. In addition, the
frequency of in-service training is different between Texas and Minnesota in certain topics, like
transportation safety. For instance, teachers and directors in Texas are required to complete
training in transportation safety each year while the frequency in Minnesota is every five years.
Finally, Arizona has a minimum clock hour requirement for teachers on specified topics
Another difference found is that many states require training in topics that the others do
not. For instance, Texas requires annual and/or ongoing training in more topics than the other
states. Texas early childhood educators are obligated to complete annual training in the following
topics: the licensing statutes and rules; cultural diversity; risk management; time and stress
appropriate activities. Staff responsible for administering medication are also required to
complete annual training. In addition, Arizona requires early childhood educators to complete
annual training in community resources for families. Finally, Colorado requires early childhood
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 14
educators to complete ongoing training regarding the family and community partnership and the
OSHA requirements.
It should be noted that Texas-certified classroom teachers are required to receive 150
CPE clock hours every five years to renew their certification. In addition, certified teachers are
expected to take training in trauma-informed care, suicide prevention, digital learning, and how
There are both similarities and differences regarding early learning programs amongst the
state policies of Arizona, Texas, Minnesota, and Colorado. With this knowledge, it is important
to determine how effective these guidelines are in preparing the educators to teach their students.
Literature Review
Method
Initially, I was only going to review scholarly works on the training requirements of early
childhood educators in Texas. The first keyword search in ProQuest was used to locate any
theses or dissertations regarding the training requirements of daycare teachers. However, this
search yielded limited results. For instance, there was a result of a study capturing teachers’
thoughts on training in recognizing the signs of child abuse and neglect, but this study was not
included because the study was conducted in California. Another result came from the search
that involved a study of teachers in New Mexico that was, therefore, excluded from this literature
review. In addition, the search provided scholarly works published decades ago; it was difficult
to find a study or peer review that was published within the last five years.
The second keyword search in ProQuest requested results in the “training requirements
for Texas daycare teachers”. Scholarly work by Shelley Ann Nicholson (2008) was included,
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 15
because the study captured teachers’ training experiences in Texas. In addition, a study by
Simesha McEachern (2019) was included because it captured former Texas early childhood
educators’ perspectives on ongoing professional development. One dissertation was not included
because it specifically focused on how social and cultural factors impact students’ learning
experiences.
The third keyword search in ProQuest requested results regarding the Texas Minimum
Standards for Child-Care Centers. Although one result was specific on the purpose of the Texas
Minimum Standards, I chose to not include it because the peer review did not focus on
The fourth keyword search in ProQuest requested results in “childcare regulatory services
professional development. Three results were found, but they were not included: one study only
examined the professional development requirements in the PDS setting; the second result
focused on understanding the identity of African American women in early childhood education
in Milwaukee; and the third result only examined the stress teachers experience and how they
management stress.
The fifth keyword search in ProQuest was used to locate theses and dissertations in
“professional development childcare regulatory services Texas and Pennsylvania”. However, this
search yielded limited results. For instance, there was a study found examining the competencies
of Taiwanese educators in preschool settings. Therefore, it was not included in this literature
review.
In an attempt to expand my search and build my literature review, studies and peer
reviews on the training requirements for early childhood educators in Arizona, Colorado, and
Minnesota were also included in the search criteria. Google Scholar was used to search for
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 16
scholarly articles in professional development requirements for the remaining three states. Most
of the articles resulting from these searches did not meet the criteria to be included in the
literature review. One article on the implications of teacher preparation for the early academic
achievement of Hispanics seemed promising, but I could not get access to the full text, so,
unfortunately, it was not included. Another article was involved the history of preschool in
Arizona, but it was solely on the idea and social construct of the term. Furthermore, there were
some articles that were catered to early childhood educators in other states not included in this
review. Consequently, a decision was made to not include any articles to critique or further
explore the training requirements mandated for early childhood educators in Arizona, Colorado,
or Minnesota.
Results
There were two results found regarding Texas’ training requirements for early childhood
educators. Nicholson (2008) conducted a study that captured the feedback and responses of
teachers on their training experiences. According to Nicholson (2008), most of the participants’
responses claimed their pre-service training did not prepare them for classroom instruction.
“Almost none of these teachers felt that they had been adequately prepared as teachers of young
children” (Nicholson, 2008). Furthermore, several teachers shared that they only completed the
Conclusion
Considering the time spent on doing research on the topic and collecting relevant articles,
the keyword searches did not yield enough scholarly articles to include in the literature review. It
was difficult to find current studies or peer reviews on training requirements for early childhood
educators. The findings were either plentiful yet too broad or limited.
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 17
There may be studies or research available somewhere on the early childhood education
field, specifically staff professional development, but I believe more work needs to be done.
Educators should be advocates of their students and should take action to constantly improve
References
Arizona Department of Health Services. Arizona Administrative Code and Arizona Revised
https://www.azdhs.gov/documents/licensing/childcare-facilities/rules/bccl-child-care-
facility-rules.pdf
https://www.collabforchildren.org/about/quality-early-learning-why-it-matters
Colorado Department of Human Services. Rules Regulating Child Care Centers (Less than 24-
https://dcfs.my.salesforce.com/sfc/p/#410000012srR/a/41000000Cg4h/Yz0MXFeo6c6Ie
uCcu9IZH24_bvIHdxTNbMI43gN0IIs
Edutopia. (2008). Why is Teacher Development Important?: Because Students Deserve the Best.
https://www.edutopia.org/teacher-development-introduction
https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.lib.uh.edu/docview/2170661728?pq-origsite=primo
https://mn.gov/dhs/partners-and-providers/licensing/child-care-and-early-
education/centers/
Minnesota Department of Human Services. (September 2016). Licensed Child Care Training
Requirements. https://www.lcc.leg.mn/tfcc/meetings/160921/training_requirements.pdf
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 19
Nicholson, S. (2008). “There is so much you can learn”: Child care teachers’ perceptions of
https://search-proquest-com.ezproxy.lib.uh.edu/docview/230709508?pq-origsite=primo
R.E. Martin, W.Y. Lan, C.N. Kuratko, J.A. Chappel, M. Ahmad, Nutrition Knowledge,
8223(96)00541-X,
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000282239600541X
https://texreg.sos.state.tx.us/public/readtac$ext.ViewTAC?
tac_view=4&ti=26&pt=1&ch=746
https://tea.texas.gov/sites/default/files/Teacher_CPE_2019_%2086th_TX.Leg_.pdf
https://tea.texas.gov/texas-educators/preparation-and-continuing-education/continuing-
professional-education-cpe
educators/preparation-and-continuing-education
https://tea.texas.gov/about-tea/laws-and-rules/sbec-rules-tac/texas-administrative-code-
title-19-part-7
A COMPARISON OF PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT 20
hhs/provider-portals/protective-services-providers/child-care-licensing/minimum-
standards
Texas Health and Human Services Commission. (May 2021). Minimum Standards for Child-
https://hhs.texas.gov/sites/default/files/documents/doing-business-with-hhs/provider-
portal/protective-services/ccl/min-standards/chapter-746-centers.pdf
http://file.snnu.net/res/20126/18/018526a6-3cbf-4c9d-ac0f-a0740094aa75.pdf
Yoon, K., Duncan, T., Lee, S., Scarloss, B. Shapley, K. (2007). Reviewing the evidence on how
https://www.voced.edu.au/content/ngv:56371