Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Falstrom 1997
Falstrom 1997
Basic Investigations
One main area of focus has been to explore alternative Virginia Health Sciences Center, Charlottesville, Virginia
2Division of Cardiology, University of Virginia Health Sciences
methods of achieving hemostasis safely and more effi-
Center, Charlottesville, Virginia
ciently at the arterial puncture site following catheter 3Division of Biostatistics, University of Virginia Health Sciences
removal. The most common complications of percutane- Center, Charlottesville, Virginia
ous interventional cardiac procedures have been attrib-
uted to hemorrhage at the site of catheterization [3,4]. Of *Correspondence to: William D. Spotnitz, M.D., Department of
Surgery, University of Virginia Health Sciences Center, P.O. Box
the total number of patients undergoing these procedures, 10005, Charlottesville, VA 22906-0005.
the complication rate averages about 1% [3–7], with
hematoma (0.9% of total, or 90% of those suffering Received 6 September 1996, Revision accepted 3 December 1996
safe and rapid hemostasis with reduced complications purpose of the study, both femoral arteries were cannu-
would allow earlier mobilization. More rapid mobiliza- lated with size 8F introducers and sheaths (Hemaquet II,
tion might permit more outpatient procedures which have 6468, USCI, Tewksbury, MA). 30 min were allowed to
been found to cut costs [11–13] as well as ease patient pass prior to any efforts to remove the sheaths. The dogs
anxiety and discomfort [14,15]. A new hemostatic tech- were anticoagulated with systemic doses of heparin
nique might also eliminate the need to reverse hepariniza- chosen and administered every 10 min to maintain an
tion at the end of the catheterization which can lead to elevated activated clotting time (ACT) from 350 to 400
coronary arterial thrombosis. with a mean of 396 6 107 (mean 6 S.D.) using a
Of the alternative methods being explored, some previously published algorithm [44].
involve using a collagen plug device to seal the arterial
puncture site. Collagen has a long history of surgical use Composition and Preparation of Fibrin Sealant
for its hemostatic properties [16–18]. For this application, Enhanced With Collagen
several different collagen plug devices have been devel- This adhesive is a composite of fibrinogen and throm-
oped and investigated in extensive laboratory and clinical bin derived from human-pooled, purified, and virally
trials over the past several years [19–30]. More recently, inactivated sources enhanced with bovine Type I colla-
the application of fibrin sealant has been considered as a gen. Each application involves the preparation of two
method for sealing arterial puncture sites. This biological separate components. The first component consists of a
tissue adhesive combines fibrinogen and thrombin to 60 mg/ml fibrinogen mixture with fibrinogen and colla-
form fibrin. Fibrin sealant shares with collagen its exten- gen as the main constituents, plus trace amounts of Factor
sive clinical use as a hemostatic and sealing agent in a XIII and fibronectin. The second component consists of
wide variety of applications [31–42]. A previous study 50 U/ml thrombin in a 40 mM calcium chloride solution.
has suggested the potential of fibrin sealant for success- The two components are designed for application approxi-
fully sealing femoral artery catheterization sites [43]. In mately 5–10 sec following their mixture in the delivery
this new study, we evaluated the effectiveness of an system.
investigational product, specifically, fibrin sealant en-
hanced with collagen, Collasealt (Cohesion, Palo Alto, Delivery of Adhesive and Observation
CA), for sealing arterial puncture sites. We hypothesized The fibrin sealant enhanced with collagen was deliv-
that by applying this combined agent percutaneously ered to the soft tissue space adjacent to the arteriotomy in
following femoral artery catheterization, safe and rapid order to obtain adequate hemostasis at the puncture site.
hemostasis may be achieved even in a heparinized model. An identical catheter system was employed as was
described in detail and used in a previous study [43] in
MATERIALS AND METHODS order to avoid injecting the sealant into the artery. An
arterial sheath was linked to the adhesive administration
Animal Preparation assembly via an introducer, which was positioned with its
This study employed a canine model to evaluate the tip entirely within the body of the sheath. The administra-
efficacy and safety of fibrin sealant enhanced with tion assembly contained two 5-ml syringes, one contain-
collagen to seal arterial puncture sites following femoral ing 3 ml of the fibrinogen/collagen component, the other
artery catheterization. All dogs were treated in accor- containing 3 ml of the thrombin component attached
dance with the ‘‘Position of the American Heart Associa- using threeway luer lock stopcocks (Discofix, Burron
tion on Research Animal Use.’’ The study group consisted Medical Inc., Bethlehem, PA) to a single DuoFlo mixer
of nine adult mongrel dogs (30.3 6 7.0 kg) anticoagu- unit (Hemaedics, Inc. Malibu, CA). Also, attached to one
lated with heparin. The dogs were administered general of the three-way stopcocks was a 10-ml syringe half-
anesthesia intravenously using Nembutal (30 mg/kg IV to filled with saline, which was observed in order to monitor
effect) (Abbott Laboratories, North Chicago, IL), and arterial blood pulsations to indicate the catheter tip
were intubated and ventilated mechanically with a dual- position. As the entire sheath and introducer assembly
phase control respirator pump (Model 613, Harvard was slowly withdrawn from the artery, the tip of the
Apparatus, Dover, MA). Additional Nembutal was admin- sheath was considered to be in the soft tissues adjacent to
istered as needed to maintain anesthesia. In order to the artery when saline syringe pulsations ceased. At this
achieve venous access, catheters were placed in the point, pressure was applied to the arterial puncture site,
foreleg (20-gauge catheter, Critikon, Johnson & Johnson, the fibrin sealant enhanced with collagen was easily
Tampa, FL) and in the external jugular vein (16-gauge immediately injected, the assembly was quickly with-
catheter, Critikon, Johnson & Johnson). Normal saline drawn, and manual pressure was increased and continued
was administered intravenously over the course of the for 20 min. The mixture was administered on one
study to keep the dogs sufficiently hydrated. For the randomly chosen side, with the other side left untreated as
Hemostasis Using Collagen Enhanced Fibrin Sealant 81
a control. The control sheaths were removed in the same TABLE I. Observations in Heparinized Dogs*
fashion as for the treated side except that no adhesive was P Value
instilled. After 20 min, manual compression was stopped Collagen enhanced (McNemar’s
and both sides of the groin were observed for signs of fibrin sealant Control exact test)
swelling or gross hemorrhage. Swelling was defined as GB 2 9 .0156
visible increasing soft tissue enlargement, and gross *Quantitative differences and statistical significance of findings in the
hemorrhage was defined as active continuing blood loss. collagen enhanced fibrin sealant and control groins of heparinized dogs.
Neither swelling nor hemorrhage would stop without GB, gross bleeding.
resuming manual compression. In the time frame chosen,
these two observations were the only local changes
detectable. Following 5 min observation, the dogs were catheterization. Similarly, groin pressure was applied for
euthanised. 20 min following catheter removal to achieve gross
hemostasis, as is done following human cardiac catheter-
Statistics ization. This investigational product has been designed
Because this study uses the same animal for comparing for use in humans as a commercial product and has been
treated and control femoral arteries, McNemar’s test for virally inactivated in a series of steps involving solvent
correlated proportions was chosen to evaluate the signifi- detergent as a primary inactivator and heat as a secondary
cance of success of achieving hemostasis using the fibrin inactivator. Moreover, the delivery system used has been
sealant enhanced with collagen. Moreover, the limited constructed to communicate with standard sheaths and
sample size meant that an asymptotic chi-square distribu- introducers currently in clinical use. The dogs remained
tion could not be assumed when applying McNemar’s anticoagulated with systemic heparin, as are some human
test. Therefore, a Fisher-like exact test was employed to patients at the time of complex catheterization, making
assess statistical significance [45]. All hypothesis testing hemostasis even more difficult to obtain. The model
was based on a .05 level of significance and was employed 8F sheaths to create a large arterial opening,
two-sided. thereby increasing the difficulty of sealing the puncture
site.
The animals were observed for a period of only five Stanley JC: Clinical characteristics and surgical management of
minutes following completion of compression. Clearly it vascular complications in patients undergoing cardiac catheteriza-
tion: Interventional versus diagnostic procedures. J Vasc Surg
was not practical to allow the control side to keep
13:593–600, 1991.
bleeding for longer than five minutes while continuing to 4. Khoury M, Batra S, Berg R, Rama K, Kozul, V: Influence of
observe the fibrin sealant side for hemostasis. In addition, arterial access sites and interventional procedures on vascular
this time was chosen because previous work has sug- complications after cardiac catheterizations. Am J Surg 164:205–
gested that once hemostasis is achieved on the fibrin 209, 1992.
sealant side, it remains stable [43]. 5. Skillman JJ, Kim D, Biam DS: Vascular complications of percuta-
neous femoral cardiac interventions. Arch Surg 123:1207–1212,
The animals were never mobilized following sealant
1988.
instillation and compression, so an evaluation of the 6. Babu SC, Piccorelli GO, Shah PM, Stein JH, Clauss RH: Incidence
length of time before mobilization could not be per- and results of arterial complications among 16,350 patients
formed. In addition, the position of the introducer sheath undergoing cardiac catheterization. J Vasc Surg 10:113–116, 1989.
must be carefully determined before instilling the adhe- 7. Wyman RM, Safian RD, Portway V, Skillman JJ, McKay RG,
sive in order to avoid injecting the sealant into the artery. Baim DS: Current complications of diagnostic and therapeutic
cardiac catheterization. J Am Coll Cardiol 12:1400–1406, 1988.
Work is currently being done to design a device to ensure
8. Ricci MA, Trevisani GT, Pilcher DB: Vascular complications of
proper sealant application. cardiac catheterization. Am J Surg 167:375–378, 1994.
Although anticoagulation with heparin simulating cath- 9. Kern MJ, Cohen M, Talley JD, Litvack F, Serota H, Aguirre F,
eterization in humans was used in this study, pretreatment Deligonul U, Bashore TM: Early ambulation after 5 French
with aspirin frequently used in the clinical setting was not diagnostic catheterization: Results of a multicenter trial. J Am Coll
employed. Cardiol 15:1475–1483, 1990.
10. Lau KW, Tan A, Koh TH, Koo CC, Quek S, Ng A, Johan A: Early
Finally, no studies currently exist comparing the use of
ambulation following diagnostic 7-French cardiac catheterization:
a fibrin sealant product to a collagen plug device for this A prospective randomized trial. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 28:34–
particular application [50]. Such a study might identify 38, 1993.
more clearly what might be the advantages or disadvan- 11. Beauchamp PK: Ambulatory cardiac catheterization cuts costs for
tages of one method in relation to the other. hospital and patients. Hospitals 55:62–63, 1981.
12. Lee, JC, Bengston JR, Lipscomb J, Bashore TM, Mark DB, Califf
RM, Pryor DB, Hlatky MA: Feasibility and cost-saving potential
CONCLUSIONS of outpatient cardiac catheterization. J Am Coll Cardiol 15:378–
384, 1990.
This study indicates that fibrin sealant enhanced with 13. Murdock CJ, Davis MJE, Ireland MA, Platell M: Day case cardiac
collagen successfully prevents hematoma and gross hem- catheterisation—a safe and economic alternative. Aust N Z J Med
orrhage in heparinized dogs upon femoral artery catheter 18:833–835, 1988.
removal. These results suggest that this material might be 14. Lemarbre L, Hudon G, Coche G, Bourassa MG: Outpatient
peripheral angioplasty: Survey of complications and patients’
used safely and effectively in human patients following perceptions. AJR Am J Roentgenol 148:1239–1240, 1987.
femoral artery catheterization, and its routine application 15. Waldman JD, Young TS, Pappelbaum SJ, Turner SW, Kirkpatrick
might lessen patient complications, discomfort, and length SE, George LM: Pediatric cardiac catheterization with same-day
of hospitalization. Short- and long-term results in clinical discharge. Am J Cardiol 50:800–803, 1982.
studies will need to be obtained in order to assess the 16. Abbott WM, Austen WG: The effectiveness and mechanism of
widespread safety and applicability of this technique. collagen-induced topical hemostasis. Surgery 78(6):723–729, 1975.
17. Diamond NG, Casarella WJ, Bachman DM, Wolff M: Microfibril-
lar collagen hemostat: A new transcatheter embolization agent.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Radiology 133:775–779, 1979.
18. Achauer BM, Black KS, Grosmark DM, Hayamizu TF: A compari-
This work was sponsored in part by a grant from son of hemostatic agents in microvascular surgery. J Microsurg
Cohesion Corporation. Gursel Ates is a grant owner from 3:242–247, 1982.
19. Merino A, Faulkner C, Corvalan A, Sanborn TA: Percutaneous
the Society of Turkish Cardiology, supported by Boeh-
vascular hemostasis device for interventional procedures. Cathet
ringer Ingelheim International. Cardiovasc Diagn 26:319–322, 1992.
20. Schräder R, Steinbacher S, Burger W, Kadel C, Vallbracht C,
Kaltenbach M: Collagen application for sealing of arterial punc-
REFERENCES ture sites in comparison to pressure dressing: A randomized trial.
1. 1992 hospital charges for two major surgical procedures for Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 27:298–302, 1992.
cardiovascular diseases: Part II. Cardiac catheterization. Stat Bull 21. Foran JPM, Patel D, Brookes J, Wainwright RJ: Early mobilisation
Metrop Insur Co 75(1):21–28, 1994. after percutaneous cardiac catheterisation using collagen plug
2. Cardiac catheterizations: Regional variations in average hospital (VasoSeal) haemostasis. Br Heart J 69:424–429, 1993.
charges. Stat Bull Metrop Insur Co 71(3):2–9, 1990. 22. Webb JG, Carere RA, Dodek AA: Collagen plug hemostatic
3. Messina LM, Brothers TE, Wakefield TW, Zelenock GB, Linde- closure of femoral arterial puncture sites following implantation of
nauer SM, Greenfield LJ, Jacobs LA, Fellows EP, Grube SV, intracoronary stents. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 30:314–316, 1993.
84 Falstrom et al.
23. Kiemeneij F, Laarman GJ: Improved anticoagulation management of a new non-thrombogenic bio-adhesive in microvascular anasto-
after Palmaz Schatz coronary stent implantation by sealing the moses. J Reconstr Microsurg 10(6):383–386, 1994.
arterial puncture site with a vascular hemostasis device. Cathet 37. Spotnitz WD, Dalton MS, Baker JW, Nolan SP: Reduction of
Cardiovasc Diagn 30:317–322, 1993. perioperative hemorrhage by anterior mediastinal spray applica-
24. Ernst SMPG, Tjonjoegin M, Schräder R, Kaltenbach M, Sigwart tion of fibrin glue during cardiac operations. Ann Thorac Surg
U, Sanborn TA, Plokker HWT: Immediate sealing of arterial 44:529–531, 1987.
puncture sites after cardiac catheterization and coronary angio- 38. Hauser, CJ: Hemostasis of solid viscus trauma by intraparenchy-
plasty using a biodegradable collagen plug: results of an interna- mal injection of fibrin glue. Arch Surg 124:291–293, 1989.
tional registry. J Am Coll Cardiol 21:851–855, 1993. 39. Lupinetti FM, Stoney WS, Alford WC, Jr, Glassford DM, Thomas
25. Sanborn TA, Gibbs HH, Brinker JA, Knopf WD, Kosinski EJ, CS: Cryoprecipitate topical thrombin glue: Initial experience in
Roubin GS: A multicenter randomized trial comparing a percutane- patients undergoing cardiac operations. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg
ous collagen hemostasis device with conventional manual compres- 90:502–505, 1985.
sion after diagnostic angiography and angioplasty. J Am Coll 40. Shaffrey CI, Spotnitz WD, Shaffrey ME, Jane JA: Neurosurgical
Cardiol 22:1273–1279, 1993. applications of fibrin glue: Augmentation of dural closure in 134
26. Camenzind E, Grossholz M, Urban P, Dorsaz P-A, Didier D, Meier patients. Neurosurgery 2:207–210, 1990.
B: Collagen application versus manual compression: A prospective 41. Baker JW, Spotnitz WD, Matthew TL, Fechner RE, Nolan SP:
randomized trial for arterial puncture site closure after coronary Mediastinal fibrin glue: Hemostatic effect and tissue response in
angioplasty. J Am Coll Cardiol 24:655–662, 1994. calves. Ann Thorac Surg 47:450–452, 1989.
27. von Hoch F, Neumann F-J, Theiss W, Kastrati A, Schömig A: 42. Lindsey WH, Masterson TM, Llaneras M, Spotnitz WD, Wanebo
Efficacy and safety of collagen implants for haemostasis of the HJ, Morgan RF: Seroma prevention using fibrin glue in modified
radical neck dissection in a rat model. Am J Surg 156:310–313,
vascular site after coronary balloon angioplasty and coronary stent
1988.
implantation: A randomized study. Eur Heart J 16:640–646, 1995.
43. Ismail S, Combs MJ, Goodman NC, Teotia SS, Teates CD, Abbott
28. Bartorelli AL, Sganzerla P, Fabbiocchi F, Montorsi P, De Cesare N,
RE, Nolan SP, Powers ER, Spotnitz WD: Reduction of femoral
Child M, Tavasci E, Passaretti B, Loaldi A: Prompt and safe
artery bleeding post catheterization using percutaneous application
femoral hemostasis with a collagen device after intracoronary
of fibrin sealant. Cathet Cardiovasc Diagn 34:88–95, 1995.
implantation of Palmaz-Schatz stents. Am Heart J 130:26–32,
44. Rose EA, Haubert SN, Spotnitz HM: Programmable calculators
1995.
and cardiopulmonary bypass. JECT 11:168–174, 1979.
29. de Swart H, Dijkman L, Hofstra L, Bär FW, Van Ommen V, 45. Rosner, B: ‘‘Fundamentals of Biostatistics.’’ Boston: PWS-Kent,
Tordoir J, Wellens HJJ: A new hemostatic puncture closure device 1990, pp 342–348.
for the immediate sealing of arterial puncture sites. Am J Cardiol 46. Puncture-sealing devices stop bleeding faster. Biomed Instrum
72:445–449, 1993. Technol 27:455, 1993.
30. Aker UT, Kensey KR, Heuser RR, Sandza JG, Kussmaul WG, III: 47. Schelling G, Block T, Blanke E, Hammer C, Brendel W, Gokel M:
Immediate arterial hemostasis after cardiac catheterization: Initial The effectiveness of a fibrinogen-thrombin-collagen-based hemo-
experience with a new puncture closure device. Cathet Cardiovasc static agent in an experimental arterial bleeding model. Ann Surg
Diagn 31:228–232, 1994. 205:432–435, 1987.
31. Sierra DH: Fibrin sealant adhesive systems: A review of their 48. Sakon M, Monden M, Gotoh M, Kobayashi K, Kambayashi J,
chemistry, material properties and clinical applications. J Biomater Mori T, Okamura J: Use of microcrystalline collagen powder and
Appl 7:309–352, 1993. fibrinogen tissue adhesive for hemostasis and prevention of
32. Brennan M: Fibrin Glue. Blood Rev 5:240–244, 1991. rebleeding in patients with hepatocellular carcinoma associated
33. Ishitani MB, McGahren ED, Sibley DA, Spotnitz WD, Rodgers with cirrhosis of the liver. Surg Gynecol Obstet 168:453–454,
BM: Laparoscopically applied fibrin glue in experimental liver 1989.
trauma. J Pediatr Surg 24:867–871, 1989. 49. Berruyer M, Amiral J, French P, Belleville J, Bastien O, Clerc J,
34. Isogai N, Fukunishi K, Kamiishi H: Use of fibrin glue to minimize Kassir A, Estanove S, Dechavanne M: Immunization by bovine
bleeding of microvascular repairs in hypertensive rats. Microsur- thrombin used with fibrin glue during cardiovascular operations. J
gery 13:321–324, 1992. Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 105:892–897, 1993.
35. Wadström F, Wik O: Fibrin glue (Tisseel) added with sodium 50. Kohno H, Nagasue N, Chang Y-C, Taniura H, Yamanoi A,
hyaluronate in microvascular anastomosing. Scand J Plast Recon- Nakamura T: Comparison of topical hemostatic agents in elective
str Surg Hand Surg 27:257–261, 1993. hepatic resection: A clinical prospective random trial. World J Surg
36. Dowbak GM, Rohrich RJ, Robinson Jr. JB, Peden E: Effectiveness 16:966–970, 1992.