2003 Sexual Activity and Cardiovascular Disease

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Sexual Activity and

Cardiovascular Disease
Melvin D. Cheitlin, MD

Cardiovascular disease and erectile dysfunction (ED) are of sexual activity are modest, and regular physical
frequently comorbid. Therefore, it is important to con- activity can almost eliminate the increase in risk
sider the risk of renewed sexual activity after successful occurring during sex. In addition, it is unlikely that any
treatment of ED in men with cardiovascular disease. This direct effect of a phosphodiesterase 5 inhibitor increases
article reviews the limited existing knowledge of the cardiovascular risk in patients with cardiovascular dis-
metabolic and cardiovascular demands of sexual activ- ease, absent the coadministration of organic
ity. Evidence suggests that there is a small increase in nitrates. 䊚2003 by Excerpta Medica, Inc.
cardiovascular risk related to sexual activity. Overall, Am J Cardiol 2003;92(suppl):3M– 8M
however, the metabolic and cardiovascular demands

HEMODYNAMIC EFFECTS OF SEXUAL


Itheyntextbooks,
1969, after reviewing almost 3 dozen cardiology
1
Hellerstein and Friedman reported that
had found ⬍1,000 words on the sexual aspects of
ACTIVITY
Data that characterize the effect of sexual activity
heart disease. In the same decade, Masters and John- on metabolic demand, especially MV̇O2, are limited.
son2 were the first to study scientifically the physio- In 1984, Bohlen et al6 studied 10 healthy men, aged 25
logic response to sexual activity and to record heart to 43 years, during 4 specified sexual activities (car-
rate and blood pressure responses to intercourse. ried to orgasm) with their wives: (1) self-stimulation,
However, clinical trial data on both the effect of (2) partner stimulation, (3) coitus with the woman on
sexual activity on myocardial oxygen demand (MV̇O2) top, and (4) coitus with the man on top. The men were
and the magnitude of increased risk that sexual activ- monitored for heart rate, blood pressure, and oxygen
ity poses to patients with cardiovascular disease are consumption (V̇O2). A subsequent symptom-limited
still sparse. exercise test (using the Bruce protocol) determined
maximal heart rate and total body V̇O2.
The paucity of such studies is all the more striking
Depending on the activity, the stimulation stage
because so many patients with erectile dysfunction (ED) averaged 3 to almost 6 minutes, orgasm averaged 10
have coincident cardiovascular disease, and vice versa.3 to 16 seconds, and the resolution phase averaged ⬍40
This is not surprising; endothelial dysfunction, which is seconds for noncoital activity and 1 to 2 minutes for
common in patients with ED, is important in the patho- coital activity. Relatively small increases in heart rate
physiology of hypertension and coronary artery disease occurred during foreplay and stimulation (Figure 1).7
(CAD). Moreover, drugs used in the treatment of hyper- The highest heart rate, a mean maximum of 127 beats
tension can cause ED as a side effect.4 Patients with per minute (67% of maximum heart rate), occurred
life-threatening congestive heart failure or a history of with man-on-top intercourse. Similarly, total body
acute myocardial infarction (MI) also have a high inci- V̇O2, which at baseline averaged ⬍10% of maximum
dence of some degree of ED, the etiology of which may V̇O2, increased to 22% of maximum V̇O2 (equivalent
be organic or associated with depression and anxiety.5 to 3.3 metabolic equivalents [METs]) during stimula-
The known concurrence of ED and cardiovascular tion and orgasm with man-on-top coitus (Figure 2).7
disease should alert physicians to the importance, Vigorous sexual activity may increase the energy cost
when discovering one condition, of looking carefully to 5 to 6 METs.6 (Note: 1 MET ⫽ ⬇3.5 mL O2/kg per
for the other. Unfortunately, cardiologists, as well as minute [the amount of oxygen consumed while sitting
internists and family practitioners, rarely inquire about quietly in a chair].8)
the sexual function of their patients with cardiovascu- Blood pressure and heart rate responses were in-
lar disease. However, ED markedly diminishes the creased only briefly for 1 to 2 minutes during sexual
quality of life of some patients, and its detection and intercourse (Figure 3).9 Compared with the METs of
treatment can make an important contribution to pa- ordinary daily activities (Table 1), the total body ox-
tient care. ygen demand and increase in MV̇O2 during sexual
activity are modest, and the duration of the increase is
brief.6,8

From the Department of Medicine, University of California, San Fran-


cisco, San Francisco, California, USA.
SEXUAL ACTIVITY AND THE RISK OF
Melvin D. Cheitlin, MD, is a speaker for Lilly ICOS and Pfizer.
MYOCARDIAL INFARCTION
Address for reprints: Melvin D. Cheitlin, MD, Department of Med- In the Myocardial Infarction Onset Study, Muller
icine, Box 0846, SFGH 5G1, University of California, San Francisco, et al10 assessed the risk of MI onset during and im-
San Francisco, California 94143. E-mail: mdc@itsa.ucsf.edu. mediately after sexual activity. They studied 1,774

©2003 by Excerpta Medica, Inc. 0002-9149/03/$ – see front matter 3M


All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/S0002-9149(03)03367-2
FIGURE 1. Heart rate in men during 4 types of sexual activity carried to orgasm: partner stimulation, self-stimulation, coitus with the
woman on top, and coitus with the man on top. Bars show baseline heart rates and heart rates during foreplay, stimulation, and or-
gasm. Numbers above bars are percentages of maximum heart rates, as determined by treadmill exercise testing. bpm ⴝ beats per
minute. (Adapted from Arch Intern Med6 and Am J Cardiol.7)

FIGURE 2. Average oxygen uptake (V̇O2) by men during 4 types of sexual activity carried to orgasm: partner stimulation, self-stimula-
tion, coitus with the woman on top, and coitus with the man on top. Values were converted to metabolic equivalents of the task
(METs) using the conversion 1 MET ⬇ 3.5 mL O2/kg per minute (V̇O2). Bars show baseline values and values during foreplay and
stimulation/orgasm. Numbers above bars are percentages of maximum V̇O2, as determined by treadmill exercise testing. (Adapted
from Arch Intern Med6 and Am J Cardiol.7)

hospitalized patients who had been admitted with an Using a case-crossover study design, the investi-
acute MI. Patients were interviewed within a week of gators defined the 2-hour period immediately preced-
admission to determine what they had been doing at ing MI onset as the hazard period.10,11 Odds ratios as
the onset of symptoms. They were also questioned a measure of relative risk were calculated from the
about their frequency of sexual intercourse during the observed frequency of sexual activity in the hazard
previous year, and the interval between sexual activity period compared with the expected frequency, based
and the onset of MI symptoms. on the control data. The relative risk of an MI trig-
Of 1,633 patients who answered the question about gered by sexual activity was compared with the risk in
sexual activity, 858 patients (52%) reported sexual the absence of sexual activity, correcting for chance
activity in the year before the MI; the sexually active occurrence.10
patients were the basis for risk analyses. Of these, 27 The relative risk of triggering the onset of an MI in
(3%) reported sexual activity in the 2-hour period patients with a history of angina was 2.1 (95% confi-
before the onset of the infarction.10 dence interval [CI], 0.8 to 5.8), and the relative risk in

4M THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY姞 VOL. 92 (9A) NOVEMBER 6, 2003


FIGURE 3. Systolic and diastolic blood pressure (BP) and heart rate during rest (R), intromission (I), and orgasm (O) in 2 coital posi-
tions. bpm ⴝ beats per minute. (Reprinted with permission from Dr. Donald H. Schmidt, editor, Heart Disease and Rehabilitation.9)

TABLE 1 MET of Selected Daily Activities6,8


Activity MET Score Rating

Sex with long-standing


partner (average)
Partner stimulation 1.7
Self-stimulation 1.8
Partner on top 2.5
Man on top 3.3
Recreational activities
Walking (5 km/hr) 3.2
Golf (carrying clubs) 5.1
Tennis 6.8
Household chores
Ironing 2.0
Washing floors 3.3
Gardening (digging) 4.4
Carpentry 5–7

MET ⫽ metabolic equivalents.


Adapted from Arch Intern Med6 and Clin Cardiol.8

patients with a previous MI was 2.9 (95% CI, 1.3 to 6.5). farction or death is estimated to be 10%, or as low as 3%
Neither value was statistically higher than the risk of 2.5 if he has good exercise tolerance.14 Sexual activity in
(95% CI, 1.7 to 3.7) in patients without prior cardiac patients with a 10% annual risk transiently increases the
disease. After correcting for chance occurrence, 0.9% of risk from 10 chances in a million per hour to 20 to 30
cases could be attributed to sexual activity within the chances in a million per hour.10
2-hour risk period before MI onset.10 However, a limi- Effect of exercise on risk of MI with sexual activity:
tation of this study was that only patients who survived Another important finding of the Myocardial Infarction
an acute MI and reached a hospital were evaluated. Onset Study is that increased weekly frequency of reg-
Based on Framingham data, the risk of an MI occur- ular exercise at ⱖ6 METs per episode lessens the relative
ring in a healthy 50-year-old man is estimated at 1% per risk of MI associated with sexual activity. The relative
year, or about 1 chance in a million per hour.12,13 Sexual risk of men exercising ⱕ1 time per week was 3.0 (95%
activity multiplies the relative risk of an MI by 2 to 3, CI, 2.0 to 4.5); twice a week, 1.9 (95% CI, 0.2 to 17.1);
increasing the hourly risk to 2 to 3 chances in a million, and ⱖ3 times per week, 1.2 (95% CI, 0.4 to 3.7).10
and only for a 2-hour period. Weekly sexual activity in a Regular exercise, therefore, can almost eliminate the
healthy 50-year-old man without known CAD would increased risk of an MI triggered by sexual activity.
increase his annual risk of an MI from 1.0% to 1.01%.10 In 1977, Stein15 studied the effect of exercise train-
For a man with a previous MI, the annual risk of rein- ing on heart rate response during coitus in 22 patients

A SYMPOSIUM: ERECTILE DYSFUNCTION AND CARDIOVASCULAR RISK FACTORS 5M


TABLE 2 Studies of Ambulatory Monitoring During Sexual Activity in People with Cardiac Disease
Study Patients and Methods ECG Findings During Sexual Activity

Hellerstein and Friedman 14 men, post-MI; Angina in 4; ectopic beats in 3; ventricular beats in 2;
(197019) Mean age, 48 yr atrial and ventricular beats in 1
24–48 hr ECG Findings were comparable in frequency and severity
during sex and during usual work activities
Johnston and Fletcher 24 men (9 post-MI, 15 post-MR); 12 (50%) had cardiac abnormalities during sex
(197920) Age range, 37–66 yr Of these, 5 had the abnormalities only, or more
24-hr ECG frequently, during sex
Jackson (198117) 30 men and 5 women with angina; 14 underwent 24-hour ECG, 4 of whom had complained
Age range, 36–70 yr of palpitations during intercourse
24-hr ECG 2 of the patients with palpitations had SVT during sex and
2 of the other patients had sinus tachycardia
Drory et al (199618) 88 men (73 post-MI, 15 with SAS); Complex PVCs were seen in 13% during sex and in 9%
Age range, 36–66 yr; mean, 52 yr during exercise
24-hr ECG Simple PVCs were seen in no patients during sex and in
30% during exercise

ECG ⫽ electrocardiogram; MI ⫽ myocardial infarction; MR ⫽ myocardial revascularization; PVC ⫽ premature ventricular contraction; SAS ⫽ stable anginal
syndrome; SVT ⫽ supraventricular tachycardia.

after MI. He demonstrated a smaller increase in peak by Drory et al18 of 88 men with CAD (most patients
coital heart rate and coital MV̇O2 in patients with post-MI), complex premature ventricular contractions
exercise training (n ⫽ 16) compared with a control were seen with sexual activity in 13%. However, these
group who did not receive training (n ⫽ 6).15 This is events (including complex premature ventricular con-
a likely explanation for the findings of Muller et al.10 tractions) are seen frequently in patients after MI with
24-hour ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring.
SEXUAL ACTIVITY IN MEN WITH Unfortunately, there are no adequate studies of the
KNOWN CORONARY ARTERY incidence of sudden death associated with sexual ac-
DISEASE tivity. A universally cited study by Ueno21 was re-
Drory et al16 reported the results of 24-hour am- ported in the Japanese Journal of Legal Medicine in
bulatory electrocardiographic monitoring, including 1963. This was an autopsy study of 5,559 instances of
during sexual intercourse, in 88 men aged 36 to 66 sudden death, of which 34 had occurred during inter-
years with known CAD. The men also underwent a course (0.6%). Of these 34 sudden deaths, 27 occurred
near-maximal bicycle exercise test. The investigators during extramarital intercourse.
found that 31% of the group developed ST-segment This study was severely biased, however. In a
depression consistent with myocardial ischemia dur- society in which privacy is highly valued, such as that
ing coitus, most without angina. All patients with found in Japan, it is conceivable, even likely, that the
coitus-induced myocardial ischemia also had ischemia proximity of sudden death to intercourse would not be
during the exercise test. Patients without myocardial mentioned. Conversely, sudden death might be more
ischemia during the exercise test did not have coitus- likely to be reported when it occurs under unusual
induced ischemia. Thus, an exercise test in these pa- circumstances, such as intercourse with a partner other
tients with CAD identified all those who would de- than the spouse. Consequently, it is possible that the
velop ischemia during intercourse. An earlier study by incidence of sudden death occurring during inter-
Jackson17 reported similar findings. course was underestimated, and the effect of extra-
marital sex in precipitating an MI was overestimated.
SEXUAL ACTIVITY AND SUDDEN The only other mention in the literature of sudden
DEATH death during intercourse is in a 1970 study by Heller-
As mentioned above, a limitation of the Myocar- stein and Friedman,19 in which a pathologist estimated
dial Infarction Onset Study was that only patients who the incidence to be ⬍1%. No data were given, how-
survived an acute MI and reached a hospital were ever, and this percentage was based on opinion.
evaluated.10 This does not rule out the possibility of an The probability that the incidence of sudden death
increased risk of sudden death related to sexual activ- precipitated by sexual activity is low has statistical
ity, presumably caused by the development of a sud- support, however. In the United States, the risk of
den arrhythmia, such as ventricular tachycardia or sudden cardiac death is much lower than that of non-
ventricular fibrillation. fatal MI; approximately 1.2 million nonfatal MIs oc-
There is no evidence that sexual activity in healthy cur per year, 4 times the annual incidence of 300,000
men is associated with serious arrhythmias, however, sudden cardiac deaths.22 Mittleman et al23 showed
and few studies of ambulatory electrocardiographic that, although exertion does confer some increased
monitoring during sexual activity in men with known risk, the exertion-related risk of sudden death is sim-
CAD have been reported (Table 2).17–20 In the study ilar to the risk of an exertion-related nonfatal MI. The

6M THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY姞 VOL. 92 (9A) NOVEMBER 6, 2003


TABLE 3 Frequency of Orgasm and Odds Ratios for Mortality Adjusted for Age and Risk
Factors: The Caerphilly Cohort Study
Odds Ratios for Mortality (95% CI)
Frequency of
Orgasm Age-Adjusted Fully Adjusted*

All-cause mortality
Low 2.0 (1.1–3.5) 1.9 (1.0–3.4)
Medium 1.6 (1.0–2.6) 1.6 (1.0–2.8)
High 1.0 1.0
p Value for trend 0.02 0.04
CAD
Low 2.2 (1.0–5.2) 2.1 (0.9–5.1)
Medium 1.7 (0.8–3.6) 1.8 (0.8–4.0)
High 1.0 1.0
p Value for trend 0.06 0.10
Other causes
Low 1.7 (0.8–3.5) 1.6 (0.7–3.3)
Medium 1.5 (0.8–2.8) 1.5 (0.8–3.0)
High 1.0 1.0
p Value for trend 0.19 0.27

CAD ⫽ coronary artery disease; CI ⫽ confidence interval.


*Age, social class, systolic blood pressure, smoking, and CAD at baseline. Odds ratios for mortality from CAD
were also adjusted for cholesterol at baseline.
Adapted with permission from BMJ.26

absolute risk remains small. Most convincingly, in PDE5 inhibitors prolong smooth muscle and arte-
both open-label and double-blind placebo-controlled rial, arteriolar, and venous relaxation and cause a
sildenafil trials, no increase was observed in cardio- decrease in peripheral vascular resistance. The PDE5
vascular or total deaths in sildenafil patients versus inhibitor sildenafil alone will cause a decrease in sys-
placebo controls.24,25 tolic blood pressure of about 8 to 10 mm Hg and a
Finally, evidence suggests that increased sexual decrease in diastolic blood pressure of 5 to 6 mm Hg.
activity actually decreases mortality. The Caerphilly The major cardiovascular danger recognized with use
cohort study observed 918 men from South Wales of sildenafil, the first PDE5 inhibitor approved for
aged 45 to 59 years (at the time of recruitment) for a clinical use, is the marked decrease in arterial blood
mean period of 10 years.26 Both 10-year all-cause and pressure that can result from its interaction with or-
CAD mortality decreased as the frequency of orgasm ganic nitrates.27 In patients with severely obstructed
increased (Table 3). The age-adjusted odds ratio for vessels, myocardial blood flow is dependent on per-
total mortality associated with an increase of 100 fusion pressure, and a steep decrease in blood pressure
orgasms per year was 0.64 (95% CI, 0.44 to 0.95). The could produce severe ischemia and infarction.
10-year mortality was 50% lower in men with rela- Data were analyzed from extensive double-blind,
tively high orgasmic frequency compared with those placebo-controlled studies and open-label follow-up
having low orgasmic frequency. The conclusion is studies with sildenafil equivalent to ⬎6,884 patient-
that, over a 10-year period, increased sexual frequency years of exposure and 543 placebo patient-years. The
was associated with a lower risk of death, especially incidence of nonfatal acute MI, cardiovascular death,
from CAD. and all-cause mortality across these studies was not
increased in sildenafil-treated patients compared with
patients receiving placebo.24 Therefore, it is unlikely
PHOSPHODIESTERASE 5 INHIBITORS that any direct effect of a PDE5 inhibitor increases
AND CARDIOVASCULAR RISK cardiovascular risk in patients with cardiovascular dis-
The development of phosphodiesterase 5 (PDE5) ease, absent coadministration of organic nitrates.
inhibitors, which offer effective oral therapy for ED,
has raised concern about whether these agents in-
crease cardiovascular risk. Potential direct effects CONCLUSION
might include plaque vulnerability, platelet aggrega- In general, the absolute risk of MI with sexual
tion, thrombogenicity, arrhythmogenicity, myocardial activity is extremely low, even in patients with known
contractility, vasoconstriction, and decrease in perfu- CAD. There is no evidence that PDE5 inhibitors
sion pressure. Potential indirect effects might include increase the risk of MI, although sufficient evidence
increased MV̇O2, effects on sympathetic tone, and suggests that there is a small increase in risk related to
arrhythmogenicity. These effects might contribute to sexual activity. Overall, however, the metabolic and
the development of MI or ischemia, arrhythmia, and myocardial work costs of sexual activity are modest,
sudden death. In particular, if MV̇O2 does increase, it and regular physical activity can almost eliminate the
is important to know the magnitude of the increased small increase in risk occurring during sex. In addi-
risk in patients with CAD. tion, it is unlikely that any direct effect of a PDE5

A SYMPOSIUM: ERECTILE DYSFUNCTION AND CARDIOVASCULAR RISK FACTORS 7M


inhibitor increases cardiovascular risk in patients with 14. Moss AJ, Benhorin J. Prognosis and management after a first myocardial
infarction. N Engl J Med 1990;322:743–753.
cardiovascular disease, unless it is coadministered 15. Stein RA. The effect of exercise training on heart rate during coitus in the post
with organic nitrates. myocardial infarction patient. American Heart Association Scientific Statement.
Circulation 1977;55:738 –740.
16. Drory Y, Shapira I, Fisman EZ, Pines A. Myocardial ischemia during sexual
activity in patients with coronary artery disease. Am J Cardiol 1995;75:835–837.
1. Hellerstein HK, Friedman EH. Sexual activity and the postcoronary patient. 17. Jackson G. Sexual intercourse and angina pectoris. Int Rehabil Med 1981;3:
Med Aspects Hum Sex 1969;3:70–96. 35–37.
2. Masters WH, Johnson VE. Human Sexual Response. Boston: Little Brown &
18. Drory Y, Fisman EZ, Shapira Y, Pines A. Ventricular arrhythmias during
Co, 1966.
sexual activity in patients with coronary artery disease. Chest 1996;109:922–924.
3. Benet AE, Melman A. The epidemiology of erectile dysfunction. Urol Clin
19. Hellerstein HK, Friedman EH. Sexual activity and the postcoronary patient.
North Am 1995;22:699 –709.
4. Miller TA. Diagnostic evaluation of erectile dysfunction. Am Fam Physician Arch Intern Med 1970;125:987–999.
2000;61:95–104. 20. Johnston BL, Fletcher GF. Dynamic electrocardiographic recording during
5. Taylor HA Jr. Sexual activity and the cardiovascular patient. Am J Cardiol sexual activity in recent post-myocardial infarction and revascularization patients.
1999;84(suppl):6N–10N. Am Heart J 1979;98:736 –741.
6. Bohlen JG, Held JP, Sanderson O, Patterson RP. Heart rate, rate-pressure 21. Ueno M. The so-called coition death. Jpn J Leg Med 1963;17:330 –340.
product, and oxygen uptake during four sexual activities. Arch Intern Med 22. American Heart Association. 1995 Heart and Stroke Statistical Update.
1984;144:1745–1748. Dallas, Tex: American Heart Association, 1995.
7. DeBusk RF. Evaluating the cardiovascular tolerance for sex. Am J Cardiol 23. Mittleman MA, Maclure M, Tofler GH, Sherwood JB, Goldberg RJ, Muller
2000;86(suppl):51F–56F. JE, for the Determinants of Myocardial Infarction Onset Study Investigators.
8. Jetté M, Sidney K, Blümchen G. Metabolic equivalents (METS) in exercise Triggering of acute myocardial infarction by heavy physical exertion: protection
testing, exercise prescription, and evaluation of functional capacity. Clin Cardiol against triggering by regular exertion. N Engl J Med 1993;329:1677–1683.
1990;13:555–565. 24. Mittleman MA, Glasser DB, Orazem J, Collins M. Incidence of myocardial
9. Pollock ML, Schmidt DH, eds. Heart Disease and Rehabilitation, 3rd ed. infarction and death in 53 clinical trials of Viagra (sildenafil citrate). J Am Coll
Champaign, Ill: Human Kinetics Publishers, 1996:372. Cardiol 2000;35(suppl A):302A. Abstract 807-6.
10. Muller JE, Mittleman MA, Maclure M, Sherwood JB, Tofler GH. Triggering
25. Cheitlin MD, Hutter AM Jr, Brindis RG, Ganz P, Kaul S, Russel RO Jr,
myocardial infarction by sexual activity: low absolute risk and prevention by
Zusman RM. Use of sildenafil (Viagra) in patients with cardiovascular disease:
regular physical exercise. JAMA 1996;275:1405–1409.
11. Maclure M. The case-crossover design: a method for studying transient ACC/AHA Expert Consensus Document. Circulation 1999;99:168 –177.
effects on the risk of acute events. Am J Epidemiol 1991;133:144 –153. 26. Smith GD, Frankel S, Yarnell J. Sex and death: are they related? Findings
12. Anderson KM, Odell PM, Wilson PWF, Kannel WB. Cardiovascular disease from the Caerphilly cohort study. BMJ 1997;315:1641–1644.
risk profiles. Am Heart J 1990;121:293–298. 27. Webb DJ, Freestone S, Allen MJ, Muirhead GJ. Sildenafil citrate and
13. Anderson KM, Wilson WP, Odell PM, Kannel WB. An updated coronary risk blood-pressure–lowering drugs: results of drug interaction studies with an organic
profile: a statement for health professionals. Circulation 1991;83:356 –362. nitrate and a calcium antagonist. Am J Cardiol 1999;83(suppl):21C–28C.

8M THE AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY姞 VOL. 92 (9A) NOVEMBER 6, 2003

You might also like