Professional Documents
Culture Documents
May2020 Hnb860 BM HL Ia
May2020 Hnb860 BM HL Ia
May2020 Hnb860 BM HL Ia
Rationale:
Stainlessinox international fzco. aims to expand and grow the company’s outreach in a
profitable way and be one of the leading shareholders, suppliers and exporters of the
During my first interaction with the CEO of the company, he stated that the company is
planning to construct a new factory in Khapoli, Mumbai given that India’s per capita
consumption of stainless steel touched a new peak of 2.5 kg in 2019, against 1.2 kg per
capita in 2010, registering a 100 per cent growth in barely eight years.1
This investigation will enable the company to get various aspects about the market of
India and why the area Khapoli has been chosen. Furthermore, how will this factory
make an informed decision about the feasibility of expanding into the Indian market.
1
"India’s Per Capita Consumption of Stainless Steel Touches New Peak in 2019." The Economic Times, 18 Nov. 2019,
economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/indl-goods/svs/steel/indias-per-capita-consumption-of-stainless-steel-
touches-new-peak-in-2019/articleshow/72109244.cms.
2
3.8 Investment Appraisal
Theoretical Framework
To estimate the financial risk involved in this investment and evaluate its
external factors that may influence the company’s stability and accordingly try to
enhance the company’s strengths and emphasize on the risks and recommend
Methodology:
Primary Research:
Interviews:
organization, and also to know why the area, Khapoli is being considered.
Sales manager: to gain information regarding the potential demand in India and
prices used by competitors and effective sales and marketing strategies to face
them.
Secondary Research:
3
Review the company’s Annual Reports and accounts to examine their current
financial position and if any apparent sales trends have happened over time.
to do competitor analysis.
Online research about the economic, political and social conditions of India like
Assumptions made for financial forecasts To take into account the external factors
agreement.
Questions asked during the interview are Ask both open and closed questions so
obtained.
4
Unreliable collection of data (secondary) The secondary data must be an
Action plan:
5
Words: 499
6
Business Management Internal Assessment HL
Session: May
Word count:
7
Letter Of Authentication:
8
Acknowledgements:
I would like to thank the entire team at Stainlessinox fzco., especially the director and
owner of the company, Mr. Hitesh Sanghvi, for his indispensable guidance with this
Stainlessinox fzco. who took out time to take the interview. Lastly, I would like to thank
9
Table of Contents
Executive Summary……………………………………………………………………. 11
Introduction…………………………………………………………………………….... 12
Methodology…………………………………………………………………………….. 13
Conclusion: ............................................................................................................ 25
Recommendations: ................................................................................................ 26
Limitations to research…………………………………………………………………...27
Bibliography ............................................................................................................29
Appendix ................................................................................................................ 31
10
Executive Summary:
The company’s chairman has expressed his scepticism about the growth prospects of
this company, as it was aiming to enter the global steel market and thus fulfil the
growing demand in India. The director was bothered about the lack of finance he could
enrol without comprising quality in order to expand. Hence, leading to the question:
After I collected data through interviews and online research, I gained information which
suggested that Stainlessinox fzco. there is a high probability of making huge profits as
there is high return on investments, additionally, Khapoli has its advantages of efficient
labour and cheap land and even the market is competitive, the company can use pricing
The conclusion suggests that the firm's optimal profitability and return on investment
ratios correlate with the opportunities to expand their market segment by accessing the
Indian market. Furthermore, they can increase low-cost revenue streams to strengthen
their market position. This justifies the construction of a new factory. However, further
suggested.
11
Introduction
chairman, Mr. Hitesh Sanghvi. The company is located in Jebel Ali Freezone, Dubai,
UAE. This company belonging to the secondary sector, manufactures and trades
stainless steel sheets, coils and plates which are further used for architectural and
industrial requirements. It’s vision statement “keeping our name synonymous with
Growth rate of stainless steel demand in India is to the tune of 6-7 per cent CAGR2,
which is among the highest in the world, as stainless steel demand is directly linked to
the economic growth.3 Thus, this potential demand is a major motivating factor for this
company to expand.
However, opening a new factory in different country is risky and cannot guarantee
profitability and sustainability. Besides, investment cost is high. Ensuring that this
expansion is profitable, all factors affecting the growth and sales of this company in this
This report will be a feasibility study, highlighting the benefits and limitations of
expanding into the Indian market and overall predict the effectiveness of this factory on
the company’s financial performance. Hence, overall helping the CEO to answer:
2
Compound Annual Growth Rate
3
"India’s Per Capita Consumption of Stainless Steel Touches New Peak in 2019." The Economic Times,
18 Nov. 2019, economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/indl-goods/svs/steel/indias-per-capita-consumption-of-
stainless-steel-touches-new-peak-in-2019/articleshow/72109244.cms.
12
Would it be financially feasible for Stainlessinox international fzco. to open a new
Methodology:
Primary sources:
Initially, interviews were taken with the internal stakeholders of this company. Starting
off with the CEO, I learned about the goals related to this project and why stainlessinox
Interviewing the finance head helped me gain information regarding the availability of
capital and it’s sources, ensuring that there is sufficient finance. It also enabled me to
estimate important documents like sales budget, P&L account, net cashflows, etc. which
would further help in break-even analysis and investment appraisal. Hence, ensuring
Information about the requirements in constructing, maintaining this factory, and the
most appropriate marketing/sales strategies for this company, were obtained from the
productions and sales manager. This would help to estimate the overall investment cost
and estimate sales along with knowing qualitative factors (useful for PEST Analysis).
However, this method may not lead to a valid conclusion as the interviewees can be be
Secondary resources:
The information would contain the interest rates and government regulations about
13
The company’s financial statements will aid in calculating the break-even point for the
completely.
The-secondary-data-might-not-be-reliable-as-it-may-contain-miscalculations-and-
assumptions
products are highly utilised5 indicating potential demand, besides the country being
cheap overall.
4
Refer to appendix 1
5
"India’s Need for Infrastructure Development." India Council on Competitiveness – CXOs, University Chancellors &
Civil Society Leaders Working to Ensure India's Prosperity…, compete.org.in/indias-need-for-infrastructure-
development/.
14
6
Furthermore, the consistent progress of sales of the company in Dubai since nine years
has motivated the company to expand7, and move towards its visions besides
establishing a stronger brand identity and goodwill along with higher revenue.
(1.2)Why Khapoli8 -
6
Refer to appendix 6
7
Refer to appendix 5
8
Refer to appendix 2
9
Refer to appendix 9
15
uninterrupted supply, and efficient, cheap labour available when compared to
BREAK-EVEN-ANALYSIS–
It is a management tool calculating the level of sales needed to cover all costs of
production. Thereafter, further sales generate a positive safety margin, and profits for
the business.12
The figures below are taken from the projected profit and loss account13:
10
Refer to appendix 2
11
Refer to appendix 3
12
Paul Hoang- Business Management Textbook IBID
13
Refer to appendix 7
16
Contribution-per-unit=1,36,901-88,227.69=48,673.31INR
Fixed cost=5,55,52,000INR
BEQ=1,141.32hectometres
The above BEQ is estimated by the intersection of TR and TC illustrated in the Break-
even Chart. After expansion, the company is expected to sell approximately 100-120
hectometres per month initially with the quantity expected to rise with increased
17
marketing. Therefore, the company expects to break-even in the first two years which is
considering the market situation which keeps on fluctuating, and may lead the company
Overall, the money gained as profit can be re-invested back into the business to cover
the high costs which will rise eventually as the company starts selling into several
feasible.
The net profit for the financial year 2018-19 was 17,84,75,600INR, and after providing
14
Refer to appendix 4
15
Refer to appendix 9
16
Refer to appendix 3
18
Additionally, few shareholders think of the idea as highly potential and are willing to
provide share capital of upto 5 crores17, hence, finance for capital is sufficient.
INVESTMENT APPRAISAL
To know the financial costs and benefits of an investment decision and assess its
Therefore, to find the payback period, i.e. the time required to recover the initial
investment cost19, the projected start-up cost and net cash-inflows will be utilised20.
17
Refer to appendix 3
18
Paul Hoang- Business Management Textbook IBID
19
"What is a Payback Period?" My Accounting Course, www.myaccountingcourse.com/accounting-
dictionary/payback-period.
20
Refer to appendix 9
19
The following table is formed with the help of the projected net cashflows(chart)21:
Shortfall(2026)=(10,44,55,000-9,76,00,022)=68,54,978 INR
21
Refer to appendix 8
20
Average monthly cashflow(2027)=(40080360÷12)=33,40,030 INR 174,918
The calculated PBP is a comparatively short period of time for a high investment of
making this project less risky. Although the current PBP is longer than what it was
calculated when this business was initiated in Dubai, because India is comparatively
cheaper. However, PBP does not consider profitability, because if there is a cash
crunch by the end of the PBP, the investment would be unwise. Furthermore, the-
simplicity-of-the-payback-period-analysis-falls-short-into-taking-account-the-complexity
are-not-merely-a-matter-of-one-large-cash-outflow-followed-by steady-cash-inflows.
Additional cash outflows may be required over time, and inflows may fluctuate in
Calculating the average rate of return, the average profit on an investment project as a
22
Paul Hoang Business Management Textbook IBID
21
ROI on savings=4% per-annum23
The ARR, giving a clear picture of profitability is more than thrice when used for
constructing the factory than to be saved in the bank evidently indicating that it is profitable
to invest. But firstly, a fair rate-of-return cannot be determined on the basis of ARR, it
depends on the management team to ensure that the projected figures are close to the
actual. Also, this method does not consider cash-inflows which are more significant than
Therefore, this method proves this investment to be financially favourable and in fact
beneficial for the growth of the company. However, this method fails to consider
the time value of money(TVM), where the value of money today is worth more than the
PEST-ANALYSIS
23
"Savings Account - Apply for Best Saving Bank Account Online 01 Apr 2020." Compare and Apply for Loans,
Credit Cards, Insurance in India, www.bankbazaar.com/savings-account.html.
24
"Limitations of Using a Payback Period for Analysis." Investopedia, 29 June 2015,
www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/062915/what-are-some-limitations-and-drawbacks-using-payback-period-
analysis.asp
22
PEST analysis influences decision-making by examining the external opportunities and
Political
The political parties compel businesses to employ more labour, and sign the
high regulation and compliance costs which reduces the company’s profits26, this
The Indian government has announced that new start-up industries would have
to pay only 15% income tax27 instead of 30% in order to attract sunrise industries
Economic
The 18% GST28 is another threat as it increases further costs of the company.
25
"PEST Analysis." GroupMap - Collaborative Brainstorming and Decision Making, 27 Aug. 2017,
www.groupmap.com/map-templates/pest-analysis/.
26
Refer to appendix
27
"More Startups May Get Tax Exemptions." The Economic Times, 28 May 2019,
economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/startups/newsbuzz/more-startups-may-get-tax-
exemptions/articleshow/69530999.cms?from=mdr.
28
"Understanding GST in India - 20 Common Questions Answered." ProfitBooks.net, 24 July 2017,
www.profitbooks.net/gst-india-overview/.
23
Achieving 2.5 kg/capita consumption level in short span of time, India is now the
fastest growing market for stainless steel29. This is a major opportunity for the
company as with essential strategies and resources they can gain high
profitability.
However, the threat of market prices continuously fluctuating30 can leave the
Social
A skilled workforce and very inexpensive labour can reduce the overall cost and
Although, the competitive Indian market is a major threat as the company might
Connections with the contractors, architects in India can help in planning the
Technological
29
"India’s Per Capita Consumption of Stainless Steel Touches New Peak in 2019." The Economic Times,
18 Nov. 2019, economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/indl-goods/svs/steel/indias-per-capita-consumption-of-
stainless-steel-touches-new-peak-in-2019/articleshow/72109244.cms.
30
Refer to appendix 4
31
Refer to appendix 3
32
Refer to appendix 3
33
Refer to appendix 4
24
The organization will need modern, efficient machinery, estimating to
9,00,00,000INR which is cheaper than what they had to pay in Dubai 34. This
overall becomes an opportunity for the company to take advantage of the cost-
However, the obsolete technology used in India can degrade the quality of the
threat.
Conclusion
Through the quantitative and qualitative data collected and analyzed through the PEST-
overall situation of Stainlessinox international fzco. that it is not only financially feasible
to expand to the Indian market but could also prove to be highly profitable in the long
run.
If the risk is taken and estimations are more or less accurate, it can lead the company
into gaining high market share and the profits can be used to re-invest in the business
to cover high costs in future when the company increases production to fulfil demand in
several Indian markets, but they will simultaneously have to pay for the high taxation.
34
Refer to appendix 2 and 7
35
Refer to appendix 2
25
Furthermore, establishing a new market can reduce the effects of tight competition due
sales increase due to potential demand for steel, which is not easily prone to
fluctuations. With efficient technology and labour, the company can become a leading
the domestic producers can make it very competitive leading to price wars. Also, since
the company does not currently have recognition, achieving economies of scale via
Recommendations
Continuous research about the demands can enable the company to adapt to
should be used to enter the Indian market and attract customers initially.
2. The company might face high competition in the Indian market for stainless steel.
Price penetration strategies and ensuring high standards and consistent quality
of the product. This can be done by having quality checks at each step of the
26
quality-control, which is setting a product's specifications and then sampling a
few units from the production line to see how closely they measure up to those
variance.
3. The obsolete technology and machinery of India can degrade quality and slower
production.
Machinery-from-Dubai-can-be-imported-or-shipped-to-India. This-will-add-up-to-
the-initial-investment-costs-but-will-be-beneficial-in-the-long-run-as-the-
4. Marketing-and-management-should-be-efficient-to-ensure-the-BEQ-is-achieved-
on-time.
should-be-noted-down-clearly. The-company-can-then-reduce-the-direct-
material-cost-by-buying-in-bulk. The-company-can-also-reduce-marketing-costs-
by using-E-commerce-which-reduces-printing-and-transportation costs-without-
compromising-informative-advertisements-and-the-other-objectives-to-be-met.
Limitations to research:
27
1) The projected financial figures may not be completely accurate as it can
future economic status of the country or its demand for stainless steel.
2) The biased responses of the interviewees may hinder the validation of this
28
Bibliography:
overview/.
economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/indl-goods/svs/steel/indias-per-capita-
consumption-of-stainless-steel-touches-new-peak-in-
2019/articleshow/72109244.cms.
www.myaccountingcourse.com/accounting-dictionary/payback-period.
"More Startups May Get Tax Exemptions." The Economic Times, 28 May 2019,
economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/startups/newsbuzz/more-startups-may-
get-tax-exemptions/articleshow/69530999.cms?from=mdr.
"Savings Account - Apply for Best Saving Bank Account Online 01 Apr
2020." Compare and Apply for Loans, Credit Cards, Insurance in India,
www.bankbazaar.com/savings-account.html.
29
"Limitations of Using a Payback Period for Analysis." Investopedia,
limitations-and-drawbacks-using-payback-period-analysis.asp
30
Appendices
Appendix 1
What is the type of business? What are the business aims, as in mission
and vision statements? What do you plan to achieve out of this business?
established in 2010 with the core focus of being one of the UAE’s leading
Sheets and Plates. Success of this company in Dubai has boosted its confidence
to further expand its market to india, hence profitable growth being the main aim
Continually building our skills and knowledge to meet the growing and diverse
needs of customers.
Ensuring that the products and solutions are purposefully engineered to suit
each customer with a focus on high service standards, on time deliveries and
competitive prices.
And vision:
31
Maintaining quality, integrity and high standard at all levels of operation.
How has the business progressed from the time you have opened until now?
The business initially started operating in 2010 and since then has been continuously
progressing with minor ups and downs due to changes in market demand and
competition. However, due to growing and favorable economic conditions the business
The main objective of stainless steel fzco. was to expand and in the most profitable
way. Hence after consultation with the marketing manager, India was the best option
development, which in a way creates major demand for our products. Thus, this
Appendix 2
32
Interview with the head of production
What do you have to say about the products and its relevance to growth of the
company?
Over the years, the company has exponentially grown by consistently enhancing its
product portfolio to Long Products - Angles, Bars and Channels, and process,
the best equipment and machinery to carry out a wide range of metal services.
Will there be need for any changes/improvements in the quality of the product?
We have been continuously taking regular feedbacks from our customers regarding the
product and it’s quality, with the help of the sales department. Most of the buyers are
loyal to our brand, and insist consistent quality on regular basis being supplied to
them. However, there was a problem with the strength of the stainless steel which was
The advanced technology used for the products as in case of Dubai, cannot be used in
India which is rather backward in development. This can become a problem as the old,
obsolete machines can reduce the quality of the products, and also make the production
process slower.
33
What are the requirements of setting up this new factory?
square feet will be constructed. Then there will be additional requirement of machines
like brushing and mirror machine, pvc, cutting, bending, shearing, grooving, lasercut,
and waterjet machines and all these machines will be used for fabrication for projects
like airports, hotels, metro stations, convention centres, kitchen industry, lifts, designer
stores, etc and approximately 10 labourers making the product and the other 10
handling marketing, sales and other departments. This with additional resources,
retained profit and capital added every year will increase the company from initial
production capacity as 2000 meters per year to upto 8000 meters per year in the next
five years.
Appendix 3
As the head of finance, to what extent do you think expanding into the Indian
There is a high potential for success of stainless steel fzco. in India considering the
market demand, but there is also high risks like firstly there is a very high investment
costing upto 16 crores INR, and moreover the market is quite competitive, with weak
technology used.
34
What are the sources from where this project is going to be financed?
This project’s main sources of finance are from the retained profits of the previous years
which was 9 crores INR and the additional capital will be provided by the shareholders
of this company.
What do you think are the major risks/problems that you might encounter during
this project?
The major problems can include high interference of the Indian government regarding
warehouse on the land, hiring labourers or buying scraps. (why)Even high taxes like
G.S.T. and license costs can increase the overall cost of production. (reducing
profitability)
Appendix 4
What makes you think that it can be profitable for the company to sell this
Looking at the current sales and feedback from customers, and also considering the
product demand in India, the sales in the first few months are estimated to be 500-700
35
Beind the head of sales department, what criteria do you think should be
Factors that could be considered are consistent and improving and unique designs, with
competitive prices that are affordable to Indians, hence they will be reduced as
Which marketing and sales strategies are going to be useful to you in order to
We will try and contact all the familiar architects and contractors who will recommend us
to the buyers of our products, which is similar to what we do in Dubai. There is also an
advantage as we also have several Indian buyers in Dubai who can help us widen our
market in India.
Appendix 5
The below table demonstrates increase in sales (2010-19) taken from the documents of
36
2010 532
2011 575.5
2012 693.2
2013 900.8
2014 2109
2015 4570.3
2016 6055.5
2017 6900
2018 6901.5
2019 7067.6
Appendix 6
The below table shows the sales budget forecasted, after the expansion of stainless
steel fzco. in Indian market, made with the help of head of the sales department.
2020 1300
2021 1346.9
2022 3332.5
2023 4005.9
37
2024 6113
2025 7012
2026 7066.7
2027 7050.9
2028 7113.2
2029 7100
Appendix 7
Projected profit and loss account made, with the help of the finance manager.
Profit & loss a/c of stainless steel fzco. as on 31 st march for the year 2020-21
INR INR
Sales 17,79,72,500
Pvc 2,30,00,000
Gases 1,11,64,000
38
Wages 2,37,44,000
Power 3,18,68,000
Expenses
Salaries 2,95,28,000
maintainence
Electricity 1,22,56,000
Insurance 3,84,000
Utilities 1,28,80,000
taxes
Interest(9%) 6,95,205
39
Tax(G.S.T.) (18%) 12,65,273.1
tax)
Appendix 8
Project net cash inflow of stainless steel fzco. made with the help of the finance
manager.
2020 57,00,003
2021 61,43,912
2022 79,98,432
2023 95,82,885
2024 1,57,89,800
2025 1,99,95,990
2026 3,23,89,000
40
2027 4,00,80,360
2028 5,91,00,454
2029 7,88,99,000
Appendix 9
The below table shows the prediction of new start-up/investment costs for stainless
steel fzco. for setting up a factory in India. (figures are rounded off as it is an estimation)
Insurance 3,20,000
Subtotal 4,77,000
Subtotal 4,00,00,000
41
Interior 19,80,000
Decoration 5,85,000
Bathrooms 2,72,000
Exterior 4,78,000
Subtotal 60,29,000
Shelves 52,000
Lamps 14,000
Subtotal 3,14,000
42
Grooving machines 40,02,000
KW Power 89,99,000
Subtotal 5,06,86,000
Stationery 42,000
TOTAL 10,44,55,000
43