Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abbas I 1989
Abbas I 1989
Access to this document was granted through an Emerald subscription provided by emerald-
srm:463575 []
For Authors
If you would like to write for this, or any other Emerald publication, then please use our Emerald
for Authors service information about how to choose which publication to write for and submission
guidelines are available for all. Please visit www.emeraldinsight.com/authors for more information.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and practice to the benefit of society. The company
manages a portfolio of more than 290 journals and over 2,350 books and book series volumes, as well
as providing an extensive range of online products and additional customer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for
digital archive preservation.
Recent events in the Islamic world have captured the attention of the
general public in the west to an unprecedented degree. Many of these
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
basics of Islam. Specifically, this section explains how a system forbidding the
payment or receipt of interest is being made viable in the modern world. The
final section brings together the major findings of the study and presents the
conclusions.
affairs by standards and rules of moral conduct forged in the cauldron of Islam.
There are numerous Islamic dictates and prohibitions regarding secular transactions
and human relationships. Islam is as much a socio-economic-political system as
it is a religion[l,2,6,7,p. 11,9,11,13, p. 119].
Islamic theology is primarily based on writings in the Koran — the final recension
(or review) of God's testament. It is also based on complementary information
from: (a) prophetic sayings (the hadith or traditions — utterances and unspoken
approvals attributed to Muhammad by reliable witnesses), and (b) ideal human
conduct (the Sunna or way — reported acts and allowances of the Prophet). In
addition to these non-canonical texts, another source of Islamic guidance is the
shari'a — the laws derived from both the Koran and the Sunna. The shari'a is
considered sacred law grounded in divine revelation. There is general agreement
among Muslims on these primary sources of guidance though the different Islamic
sects or branches may disagree over the liturgical authenticity of many hadith.
The Koran, hadith and Sunna in combination shaped the institutions attending
the rise of Islam to socio-economic and political heights of attainment[2,3,6,14].
There are also two secondary sources of guidance in Islam. The first is the
ijma — a historical consensus of qualified legal scholars regarding the adoption
of existing doctrine to new socio-economic conditions. This art has significance
in many Muslim countries today. The second is the ra'y, which is one's own
determination of right and wrong based on analogical reasoning. This art is now
largely discredited[2,3,6,14].
Islam is a religion studded with socio-religious injunctions and ordinances based
on logic and rationality. The themes of reason, proof and deduction emanating
from within a predetermined frame of reference are found throughout the Koran.
A holy verse states that God called reason a religious law, and another states that
he called the mind religion. Muhammad contended that there was congruence
between revelations mentioned in the Holy Book that were received at different
times and through different prophets. Similarly, Islamic exegetes (Ulama) today
contend that there is internal coherence between Koranic writings and the hadith[1,
Islam is considered to be the final revelation and the primal religion, not just "a"
religion. The Koran has all the religious and moral truth required of mankind from
birth to judgement. This belief has set the tone for Muslim scholarship and serves
as the foundation for the Muslim states' prohibition on the practices of non-Muslim
religion[l,3,8,11].
The following are considered to be the basic fundamentals of Islam (do's and
don'ts):
(1) Acknowledging there is no god whatsoever but God. This is the essence
of Islam:
There is no God, but God.
Thy Lord hath decreed, that ye worship none save Him...
Set not up with Allah any other God...lest thou sit down reproved, forsaken.
The Islamic religion has as its foundation submission and obeisance to the will
of the omnipotent and omniscient creator, the one and only God, who admits
of no consorts or associates in the worship and adoration of him[12, pp. 103,112].
(2) Honouring and respecting parents:
And lower unto them the wing of submission through mercy, and say: My Lord! Have mercy
on them, seeking mercy from the Lord, for which thou hopest, then speak unto them a
reasonable word.
If one or both of them attain old age with thee, say not "Fie" unto them nor repulse them,
but speak unto them a gracious word.
No message which the Prophet received from Allah is so thoroughly underscored
in the revelations as honouring and respecting parents. In this area, the familiar
and communal responsibility of believers is expressed in its purest form[12,
pp. 112,126].
(3) Respecting the rights of others:
Give the kinsman his due, and the needy, and the wayfarer... But if thou turn away from
them, seeking mercy from the Lord, for which thou hopest, then speak unto them a
reasonable word.
The Koran speaks often against such injustices as the wealthy lording their Islamic
wealth over the poor, or the strong taking advantage of the weak and helpless[12, Economics
p. 112].
(4) Being generous but not a squanderer:
...squander not (thy wealth) in wantonness. Lo! the squanderers were ever brothers of
the devil, and the devil was ever an ingrate to his Lord. 9
And let not thy hand be chained to thy neck nor open it with a complete opening, lest thou
sit down rebuked, denuded. Lo! thy Lord enlargeth the provision for whom He will, and
straiteneth (it for whom He will) [12, p. 113].
(5) Avoiding killing except for justifiable cause:
Allah defendeth those who are true...sanction is given unto those who fight because they
have been wronged...Those who have been driven from their homes unjustly only because
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
Islamic Economics
In recent years, many Islamic countries have proposed an Islamic economic system
which reasserts traditional Islamic values. These countries want a complete system
that covers specific patterns and areas of social and economic behaviour for believers
which does not involve a reformulation of Islamic ideology or a compromise of
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
its tenets. Economic practices are made to conform to Koranic dictates, with no
reinterpretation of the basic doctrine [5,6].
The process of Islamisation of economic systems involves a stamping of economic
institutions with a particular Islamic identity. The process seems to be gaining
momentum over time. New institutions have been established, such as Islamic
banks and development assistance agencies, with the aim of translating Islamic
economic ideals into practical business solutions [8,16,17].
As noted previously, Islamic economics is closely related to and is part of the
Islamic concept of life. Both the Koran and Sunna have much to say on economic
questions. The welfare of people while on this earth and their welfare in the
hereafter are inextricably intertwined. Islamic teaching in the economic sphere
deals with a wide-ranging set of welfare issues: justice, mercy, well-being, wisdom,
and stress on fraternity and equality. It also addresses purely economic issues
such as the system of economic decision making, saving, investment, capital
accumulation, the incentive system, the proper role of government, property rights,
inheritance laws, the allocation of resources, the types of economic freedom man
enjoys and other fundamental economic issues which have a deep-rooted
significance for the Muslim faithful[l,3,ll,13, p. 119,16,17].
In sum, the moral teachings of Islam lay down ethical guidelines for the effective
control of all economic behaviour. Economic institutions should facilitate the
achievement of the goals and objectives of Islam. Economic activities and
undertakings are assessed and measured in moral terms and must be conducted
in consonance with the ethos and norms of the Islamic value system. There must
be a positive line of action leading towards the ultimate aim of welfare dispensed
judiciously and tempered with wisdom. Specific ordinances, some obligatory and
others prohibitive, serve as guides to economic actions.
Basic Characteristics
The full impact of the Islamic religion can be derived only from the political, social
and economic institutions it sired. In the area of economics, ten fundamental
characteristics — dictates, prohibitions, and injunctions — which distinguish the
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
Ban on Interest
In the economic arena, in particular, the Islamic religion is seen not as a set of
rudimental beliefs but as an all-encompassing complex framework of theological
reference. A particularly important principle is the unbending Koranic prohibition
of the payment or receipt of interest, which is considered usury (riba).
Though there are few hadiths on the subject, Muslim scholars interpret riba
as the increasing of a capital sum before repayment — the predetermined return
on the use of money. Dicta regarding riba are more than mere moral exhortations;
they are straightforward condemnations. To accept riba is to commit the very grave
sin of haram. The moral distaste by Muslims for riba cannot be overstated and
the penalty for not observing the rule is clear. Practitioners of the black art of
usury are warned on pain of hell-fire to abstain; the giver and the taker are equally
damned[2,3,5,6,15,16].
Riba is sometimes defined as "excessive" interest, but Moslem scholars today
almost universally hold it to mean all interest. The Koran says that the incentive
for interest is to accumulate money, to make more and more of it and to secure
its rates at the expense of those who need the money. It stultifies the best
humanitarian propensities. There is a holy verse which removes all doubt of the
condemnation of interest: "Ye who believe! Fear God and give up what remains
of your demand for usury, if ye are indeed believers''. Another passage compares
riba unfavourably with the Zakat when it says "Allah will wipe out riba and will
foster charity", and another reads " 0 believer, devour not usury, doubled and
redoubled". Clearly, the Koran implies that the creditor who does not seek to
profit from his loan is performing an act of pious munificence which pleases Allah
greatly[2,3,6,16,18,19,20, p. 53].
Riba is scorned and forbidden because of its pernicious effects. The faithful
believe that it is useless and a reward gained without productive effort. No benefit
comes from it. Its abolition is a consideration of equity — it was intended to protect
the poor and weak against exploitation and unwarranted hardship and at the same
time to encourage investors and labourers to combine their resources in joint
ventures. Muslim scholars usually accept this prohibition to mean not only interest
for the use of money, but any fixed or guaranteed interest payment on cash advances
or on deposits. However, as noted above, no Koranic passage admonishes the Islamic
faithful to shun trade which, unlike interest, involves an uncertain rate of return. Economics
The Koranic concern with the differentiation between riba and lawful commercial
transactions can be sensed in the following passage: "They keep saying: the
business of buying and selling is also like riba; whereas Allah has made buying
and selling lawful and riba unlawful'' [1,5,6,15,17,20, p. 33,21].
Thus, it is Koranically acceptable to sell goods and commodities and participate 15
in other business transactions. Further, it is acceptable to lend money, but only
if the return for the use of money fluctuates according to the actual profits made
from such use. Capital should earn a profit only if it is invested in productive
enterprise or in the provision of tangible services involving human effort and an
element of risk.
It is interesting to note that riba is not viewed as a commercial concept; rather,
it is always referred to in a moral context. This is in keeping with the Islamic
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
concept of unity that emphasises man's role in a larger societal context and his
moral obligation not to take advantage of other human beings. Society benefits
little when debtors live in indebtedness from which there is no hope of escape.
Similarly, society does not benefit when creditors hoard wealth for personal use
and security and do not recirculate it in the community.
To protect the interest of both parties and to reduce the risk of fraudulent dealings,
the Koran suggests that creditors have the terms of their loan put in writing and
have it witnessed by two neutral parties. The relevant Koranic passage reads:
"Believers, when you contract a debt for a fixed period, put it in writing. Let
a scribe write it down for you with fairness...". Furthermore, creditors should
be understanding to debtors who get into difficulty with repayments. An applicable
Koranic verse states: "Should a debtor be in strained circumstances, then grant
him respite, in respect of the repayment of capital sum, till a time of ease. But
if, in such a case, you remit the capital sum also as a charity, it will be better
for you." This verse suggests, first, that burdensome debt should be settled through
peaceful bilateral negotiations and, second, that interest is a source of misery and
should be prohibited. It is a vehicle through which the wealthy can exploit rather
than help the needy[5,6,7,13,16,17,20, p. 34].
Financial Techniques
In addition to a strong determination to establish an economic order in line with
the teaching of Islam, there has been a revival of interest in Islamic banking in
recent years. In general, an Islamic bank is one which does not charge or pay
interest rates on loans or deposits. To skirt the ban on interest, Islamic banks
use a profit-sharing system to replace interest on borrowed or loaned money. In
contrast to western-inspired banks, an Islamic bank enables the Muslim faithful
to conduct financial operations in accordance with their deeply held religious beliefs
without resorting to the subterfuge of calling interest by another name and
condoning it, or engaging in other practices which the faithful find
repugnant[5,15,17,22,23].
On the liability side of the balance sheet, there are two types of accounts: demand
deposit accounts, which earn no interest but entitle the holder to certain services,
International and savings deposit accounts, which may (after a period of three to six months)
Journal of Social earn a return for the depositor. The savings depositor in essence purchases an
Economics equity position in whatever activity the bank uses the capital for. Deposits are
16,5 treated as shares and their nominal value is not guaranteed. Thus, depending on
the type of account, the depositor may be entitled to share in the profit from the
bank's investment after the account is maintained for a given period. This type
16 of savings account is in keeping with the Koran's interdiction of interest charges
or payments [3,5,6,7, p. 27,15,16].
On the asset side of the balance sheet, the system is symmetrical in that there
is equitable risk-sharing between the provider of capital and the entrepreneur who
uses it. That is, profits and losses are shared between banks and economic agents
according to certain predefined rules. The banks are in effect investing money
rather than lending and they are sharing the risks with their clients. Muslim
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
apologists insist that the active involvement of the bank with the entrepreneur
through profit-sharing is more efficient than loan financing as a way to channel
capital into productive outlets.
Thus, the Islamic bank does not charge afixedrate of interest but does become
a partner to the borrower on investment projects. Co-operation with and advice
to the borrower is a primary responsibility of the bank, since it faces great risk
on any investment project it finances. The advice includes both technical and
economic aspects of the investment. These kinds of loans offer many advantages,
albeit there are manyrisksand requirements for participating banks[4,5,6,15,16,17,24].
It remains to be seen whether the act of abolishing riba is a powerful enough
force to engineer a smooth transition from an interest-based banking system to
an exploitation-free Islamic banking system. Fundamentalist Islamic countries in
which riba is prohibited are using a variety of traditional Islamic techniques on
both the asset and liability sides of the balance sheet to achieve profit goals within
Koranic-imposed constraints. Many Muslims sense and believe that this is an
opportunity to have the shari'a guide and direct their lives, not only in family and
social matters but also in economic and business matters. The fresh evaluation
and new interpretation of original shari'a principles is providing a reassertion of
shari'a as a valid and relevant corpus of law within which modern-day banking
and business transactions can be conducted.
Conclusion
Like the Bible, the Koran is concerned primarily with spiritual matters of an abstract
nature. Unlike the Bible, which concentrates on temporal teaching of social relations,
the Koran deals with how believers should conduct their everyday lives. Indeed,
for the Muslim faithful, no task, commitment, performance, journey, or business
transaction is undertaken without the involvement of Allah.
Koranic proscriptions and ordinances are replete with strong but not always
distinguishable ethical undertones which motivate Islamic social and economic
behaviour. Morality as ordained by the Koran is not only a strong binding and
unifying element among the Islamic faithful all over the world, but it serves as
the foundation for all social and economic behaviour. In the social arena, the moral
element is particularly evident in the stress on family ties, the respect for elders Islamic
and the injunctions in the Koran prescribing behaviour for women. In the economic Economics
arena, the moral element surfaces in the emphasis placed on justice and fidelity
in dealings, the distribution of property on inheritance, the sanctity of oath and
trust, the honouring of one's covenants, the avoidance of riba and the general
prevalence of an egalitarian sentiment. The moral element, reinforced with continual
emphasis on the need for religion in one's daily life and in all commercial and 17
occupational pursuits, is one of the most important factors which distinguish Islamic
economics from other economic systems.
References
1. Kassem, O., "Arab Aid Funds Represent the Spirit of Islam", Euromoney, December 1981,
pp. 140-46.
2. Jensen, L., "Shari'a: The Foundation of Islamic Law", Business America, 30 June 1980, pp.
12-13.
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
3. Abdul-Rauf, M., The Islamic Doctrine of Economics and Contemporary Economic Thought:
Highlight of a Conference on Theological Inquiry into Capitalism and Socialism, American
Enterprise Institute, Washington DC, 1979, pp. 1-23.
4. Pryor, F.L., "The Islamic Economic System", Journal of Comparative Economics, June 1985,
pp. 197-222.
5. Khouri, R.G., "Islamic Banking: Knotting A New Network", Aramco World Magazine, May-
June 1987, pp. 14-28.
6. Cooper, R., "A Calculator in One Hand and the Koran in the Other'', Euromoney, November
1981, pp. 44-54.
7. Ali, M. (Ed.), Islamic Banks and Strategies of Economic Cooperation, New Century Publishers,
London, 1984.
8. Looney, R.E., "Saudi Arabia's Islamic Growth Model", Journal of Economic Issues, June
1982, pp. 453-9.
9. Hoadley, W.E., "Business Should Tax Opportunities in Moslem Nations — Particularly in
East Asia", Dun's Business Month, December 1983, p. 66.
10. Moore, A., "Will Gulf Investors Use Their Own Banks?", The Banker, December 1980,
pp. 83-93.
11. Welling, K.M., "Clash of Values: A Seminar Weighs the Impact of Religion on Business",
Barron's, 25 June 1979, pp. 9, 21-2.
12. Farah, C.E., Islam: Beliefs and Observances, Barron's Educational Series, New York, 1970.
13. MacEoin, D. and Al-Shahi, A. (Eds.), Islam in the Modern World, St Martin's Press, New
York, 1983.
14. Graham, D., "Sharia Loses Its Grip", Euromoney, May 1987, pp. 137-8.
15. Davids, L.E., "Understanding Arab Banking", The Bankers Magazine, May-June 1983, pp.
62-72.
16. Karsten, I., "Islam and Financial Intermediation", International Monetary Fund Staff Papers,
Vol. 29 No. 1, March 1982, pp. 108-42.
17. Khouri, R., "The Spread of Banking for Believers", Euromoney, May 1987, pp. 145-6.
18. Briston, R. and El-Ashker, A., "Religious Audit: Could It Happen Here?", Accountancy,
October 1986, pp. 120-21.
19. Weiss, G., "Reconciling God, Mammon, and the Koran", Barron's, 20 May 1985, pp. 57-8.
20. Saleh, N.A., Unlawful Gain and Legitimate Profit in Islamic Law, Cambridge University
Press, Cambridge, 1986.
21. "Double Jeopardy", The Economist, 3 May 1986, p. 98.
22. Wilson, R., Banking and Finance in the Arab Middle East, St Martin's Press, New York, 1983.
23. Thorn, P., "Jostling for Position in the Middle East", The Banker, April 1977, pp. 127-30.
24. Osborn, N., "Can Arab Banking Fulfill Its Vision?", Institutional Investor, June 1983, pp. 131-42.
This article has been cited by:
1. Mark Brendan Mulcahy. 2014. Purifying Islamic equities: the interest tax shield. International
Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management 7:4, 473-484. [Abstract] [Full Text]
[PDF]
2. Kamel Fantazy, Alaa-Aldin Abdul Rahim A. Al Athmay. 2014. Ethics and religion in higher
education. International Journal of Commerce and Management 24:2, 180-196. [Abstract] [Full Text]
[PDF]
3. Said Elfakhani, Zafar U. Ahmed. 2013. Philosophical Basis of Entrepreneurship Principles Within
an Islamic Ethical Framework. Journal of Transnational Management 18, 52-78. [CrossRef]
4. References 283-315. [CrossRef]
5. Alexandre Ardichvili, Douglas Jondle, Brenda Kowske. 2010. Dimensions of ethical business
cultures: comparing data from 13 countries of Europe, Asia, and the Americas. Human Resource
Development International 13, 299-315. [CrossRef]
Downloaded by UNIVERSITY OF EXETER At 23:01 15 August 2015 (PT)
6. J. Tsalikis, Walfried Lassar. 2009. Measuring Consumer Perceptions of Business Ethical Behavior in
Two Muslim Countries. Journal of Business Ethics 89, 91-98. [CrossRef]
7. Janet K. Mullin Marta, Anusorn Singhapakdi, Ashraf Attia, Scott J. Vitell. 2004. Some important
factors underlying ethical decisions of Middle‐Eastern marketers. International Marketing Review
21:1, 53-67. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
8. Ashraf Attia, Mahesh N Shankarmahesh, Anusorn Singhapakdi. 1999. Marketing ethics: a
comparison of American and Middle-Eastern marketers. International Business Review 8, 611-632.
[CrossRef]
9. Sami M. Abbasi, Kenneth W. Hollman. 1993. Business Success in the Middle East. Management
Decision 31:1. . [Abstract] [PDF]