IStructE hosts the Young structural engineering international design competition every three years, providing a chance for young structural engineers to be adventurous, and to develop their ingenuity, imagination and inventiveness.
The competition challenged entrants to use their imagination and innovation to produce designs that provide solutions for humanitarian issues caused by climate change.
Pranav Darda- Drury Medal
IStructE hosts the Young structural engineering international design competition every three years, providing a chance for young structural engineers to be adventurous, and to develop their ingenuity, imagination and inventiveness.
The competition challenged entrants to use their imagination and innovation to produce designs that provide solutions for humanitarian issues caused by climate change.
Pranav Darda- Drury Medal
IStructE hosts the Young structural engineering international design competition every three years, providing a chance for young structural engineers to be adventurous, and to develop their ingenuity, imagination and inventiveness.
The competition challenged entrants to use their imagination and innovation to produce designs that provide solutions for humanitarian issues caused by climate change.
Pranav Darda- Drury Medal
Report: Design Choice
Registration Number: 038
For economically less developed regions, a practically viable solution is which takes into account the traditional
construction practices combined with low cost retrofits to ensure safety even at extreme weather conditions.
Mono-pod Space Design
‘Space design is based on family size and occupational needs. Generally, in flood relief housing a standardised unit is
enforced upon the affected. The space provided may not be suitable for all group sizes. Giving an option to design
spaces as per need empowers the affected. The mono-pod concept takes this factor into account to create multiple
options to live and work as per need. Consisting of portable sub-parts, the mono-pod makes the process of
construction quick and thus speeds up the flood restoration programme.
Mono-pod Flood Protection
‘A mono-pod unit with a hybrid support system (combination of stilts and floating material) addresses the extreme
weather safety aspect.
Types of Flood Protecting | TwoStoreyed | Structure Siructureon __] Structure Mono-pod
Mechanisms Structure with | elevated on Columns/stits | Floatingon | Hybrid Solution
Ground Floor | Compressed Water (amphibious)
inundated _| Earth
Flood Characteristics
Shallow (03m) | 2m) mama | a maa waae
Slow (2m/s) a ai ma a wae
Costs of Construction
Material a mama waaa maa wae
Labour @ maa meee we waa
Extreme Weather Resistance
Strong Winds aa mama waa
Earthquake aa mame Ei]
‘Type of Land Surface
levelled mee ae maa meee | eee
Unlevelled wa ma waa a maa
Suitability Index
Tube-in-Tube Mechani
Generally, for such hybrid structures (amphibious) an independent guiding pole is present whose only purpose is to
keep the raft aligned in its vertical axis. Along with it, it also requires additional connecting members having a rigid
joint. In whole, this system is labour intensive and time consuming. Improvising on this amphibious system, the
bamboo in steel tube mechanism is @ unique feature. The hollow steel pole acts as a load bearing and a guiding
member as well. Due to the simple tube-in-tube mechanism, it can be assembled easily with no additional settings.
The projections at bottom help in placing and anchoring to the ground surface even during floods.
Alternatives
Setting up community housing in floods, might lead to a case where there is shortage of flood proofing equipment.
‘The mono-pod is designed such that, most of its standard components can be substituted with an alternative. Bamboo
having a specific gravity of 0.4-0.5 is an excellent floating material. Until the drums are procured, bamboo or any other
floating material can work as a substitute. Boats can be placed inside the raft grillage system as well, thus making the
structure buoyant. The simple grillage system of the raft ensures easy replacement of any floating material. The hay
roofing and bamboo mat wall covers require tarpaulin sheets for water proofing. AC sheets in such cases can be an
alternative.Joints
‘The mono-pod was designed with the idea of its ability to be modified, replaced and repaired at any point of time. This
becomes difficult when the connections are made rigid using bolts and fasteners in bamboo. Also, drilling holes
becomes a challenge in this area with limited supply of electricity. Pre-manufactured steel joints for bamboo are
expensive. Creating perforations or modifying the bamboo surface to fit other members in it requires skilled
manpower and is a time-consuming job. Adopting the traditional practice of making connections using jute ropes
becomes advantageous. Depending on actual site conditions, joints can be easily modified and replaced without
affecting other members. With proper tying techniques, a rigid joint can be achieved at minimal costs.
Movement
During floods, the temporary pathways get completely inundated thus hampering human and animal movement.
Building a bridge on stilts is fast and easier option for movement. However, for floating houses with the water level
being a variable, the fixed stilt bridges become pointless. For coping up with the changing water level, constructing
‘temporary pontoon bridges using boats can be done. The simplest design involves, tying up unused boats and placing
a bamboo platform on the them. Pontoon bridges work wel for connecting short distances. Providing them at most
used spaces such as toilets, shopping centre and village centre ensures their proper utility. Once the flood water
recedes, the pontoon bridge can be easily dismantled and its parts used for their earlier intended use.
Movement in-between individual houses can be facilitated using personal wooden boat or a bamboo raft. Due to
proximity to a water body and majority of the occupations depending on it, most of the households possess one.
Traditionally it has been used as primary means of transport even during dry land conditions. The mono-pod has
provision for parking and storing them. Thus, instead of building infrastructure connecting all places, a boat/raft is a
convenient and cheaper way for continuing daily activities in a small community.
Village Centre
Bangladesh being susceptible to annual floods, being prepared on a local level is imperative. Availability of resources
for resuming work is a challenge. Building a village centre on elevated land solves many purposes. Being above highest
flood level, it need not be equipped with floating mechanism. A stilted structure would work, thus increasing storage
space. During dry season, the village centre can operate as a school or as common recreational space. In such times,
dedicated spaces should be allocated for storing flood proofing equipment such as scaffolding, drums, tying ropes,
bamboo, etc. These need to be procured beforehand. During floods, work of pre-fabrication of floating units can be
done inside it. Also, it can act as a shelter, community kitchen or even a rescue space for the affected. Its, proximity
to shops and toilets ensures relative comfort. Small domestic animals too can find shelter in it. Its direct connectivity
to mainland by roads ensures quick rescue and response from government in extreme weather conditions.
Sanitation
Groundwater obtained from borewells is the primary source of fresh drinking water in the rural communities of
Bangladesh. Thus, it is imperative to prevent groundwater contamination by sewage disposal by all means. Collecting
wastewater through drainage pipes and then treating it through wastewater ponds is suitable for a large settlement.
‘The costs of setting up and running this system are high. Setting up a septic tank among every few households is ideal
solution for small communities. However, septic tank is unsuitable in flood prone regions with saturated soils due to
possibility of contamination with fresh water. Pit latrines are easy to construct and have minimum maintenance costs.
In our case where the ground water tables are high, wastes from pit latrines could mix with the ground water and
contaminate it. However, the pit latrines can be improvised by creating an impermeable layer between the sewage
and the groundwater. In the sand enveloped pit latrine, a sand layer of about 500mm acts as the impermeable filter
thus preventing contamination. However, as precautionary measure, these should be located at a substantial distance
from the location of the borewells.
All the design choices presented are sustainable with the environment. The simple and low-cost solutions
make them workable among the local communities. Association with the indigenous way of doing things would
empower and make them self-reliant. Scope for improvisation in the designed structure ensures demands are met
with the changing needs. Success in a small community could inspire such adaptations on a large scale.