Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Phyllodes Tumors of The Breast: Natural History, Diagnosis, and Treatment
Phyllodes Tumors of The Breast: Natural History, Diagnosis, and Treatment
Phyllodes Tumors of The Breast: Natural History, Diagnosis, and Treatment
324
Original Article
Key Words unusual fibroepithelial lesions that account for less than
Phyllodes tumors, breast neoplasms, natural history, diagnosis, treat- 1% of all breast neoplasms.5,6 These tumors exhibit a wide
ment range of clinical behavior and represent a spectrum of
fibroepithelial neoplasms rather than a single disease
Abstract entity.7
Phyllodes tumors of the breast are unusual fibroepithelial tumors
that exhibit a wide range of clinical behavior. These tumors are cat-
egorized as benign, borderline, or malignant based on a combina-
tion of histologic features. The prognosis of phyllodes tumors is Pathologic Features
favorable, with local recurrence occurring in approximately 15% of Phyllodes tumors are characterized by the presence
patients overall and distant recurrence in approximately 5% to 10% of both epithelial and stromal elements, but the distin-
overall. Wide excision with a greater than 1 cm margin is definitive
primary therapy. Adjuvant systemic therapy is of no proven value.
guishing histologic features relate to the stroma.8
Patients with locally recurrent disease should undergo wide exci- Microscopically, these tumors contain elongated ductal
sion of the recurrence with or without subsequent radiotherapy. elements and papillary protrusions of connective tissue
(JNCCN 2007;5:324–330) lined by epithelium that produce the leaf-like appear-
ance. Marked stromal overgrowth and hypercellularity
are important features that distinguish these lesions from
Historical Overview the more common fibroadenomas. These lesions are cat-
In 1838, Johannes Müller gave a detailed description of egorized as benign, borderline, or malignant based on a
a large mammary tumor with a cystic appearance and combination of histologic features, including stromal cel-
leaf-like growth pattern which he named cystosarcoma lular atypia, mitotic activity, stromal overgrowth, type of
phyllodes.1 In 1951, Treves and Sutherland2 suggested that tumor margin (circumscribed vs. infiltrative), and tumor
benign, pre-malignant, and malignant forms of this dis- necrosis.9–11 Reported incidences of each subtype have
ease existed. In 1960, Lomonaco3 proposed the name tu- varied widely in the literature. On average, more than
mor phyllodes, thereby avoiding any implication of biologic 50% are categorized as benign and approximately 25% as
behavior. The World Heath Organization adopted the malignant in most large series.7,12 Despite these classifica-
terminology phyllodes tumor in 1981, and this name has tions, histologic grade has been found to correlate poorly
since gained widespread acceptance.4 Phyllodes tumors are with biologic behavior.13
The expression of estrogen and progesterone recep-
tors is common in the epithelial component but uncom-
From the Departments of aMedicine, bRadiation Oncology, and
mon in the stromal component of phyllodes tumors. In
c
Surgery, Stanford University, Stanford, California. one series, epithelial estrogen receptor expression was
Submitted November 2, 2006; accepted for publication November
20, 2006.
seen in 58% and progesterone receptor expression in
The authors have no financial interest, arrangement, or affiliation 75%.14 In this series, expression of hormone receptors was
with the manufacturers of any products discussed in the article or
their competitors.
related to histologic grade, with estrogen and proges-
Correspondence: Robert W. Carlson, MD, 875 Blake Wilbur Drive, terone receptor expression present in 67% and 77% of be-
Stanford, CA 94305. E-mail: rcarlson@stanford.edu
nign, 43% and 84% of borderline, and 47% and 47% of
© Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network | Volume 5 Number 3 | March 2007
JN053_Jrnl_50308Telli.qxd 3/6/07 1:45 AM Page 325
Adapted from Tse GM, Lee CS, Kung FY, et al. Hormonal receptors expression in epithelial cells of mammary phyllodes tumors
correlates with pathologic grade of the tumor: a multicenter study of 143 cases. Am J Clin Pathol 2002;118:522–526; used
with permission. ©2002 American Society for Clinical Pathology.
malignant phyllodes tumors, respectively (Table 1). Phyllodes tumors occur at a median age of 45 years,7
Expression of androgen receptors was low in all tu- but cases in adolescents and the elderly have been well
mors. described.11,13,20,21,25 Recent Surveillance, Epidemiology,
The frequency of expression and role of the tu- and End Result (SEER) data indicate that the mean age
mor suppressor gene p53 in phyllodes tumors is highly at diagnosis is 50 years among patients with malignant
variable across series. In some but not all series, p53 phyllodes tumors.26 Bilateral phyllodes tumors are re-
expression increases across the spectrum of benign to ported to occur rarely,21,23,24 and a case of a phyllodes
malignant phyllodes tumors.15,16 tumor arising in an accessory breast has been reported.21
Clonal analysis of phyllodes tumors documents Additionally, phyllodes tumors associated with gyneco-
that the epithelial component is polyclonal, whereas mastia have been reported in men,27 and a bilateral
the stromal component is monoclonal, showing that phyllodes tumor arising in ectopic axillary breast tis-
the stroma represents the neoplastic component of sue has been described in a man.28
phyllodes tumors.17,18
Diagnosis
Clinical Presentation Unfortunately, triple assessment using clinical, radi-
The most common presentation of a phyllodes tumor ologic, and histologic examination results in low di-
is a palpable breast mass that may be rapidly growing. agnostic accuracy in phyllodes tumors.8,29 The
These tumors may exhibit biphasic growth and pa- deficiencies of this approach relate to the fact that
tients may present to medical attention only after phyllodes tumors have overlapping characteristics with
noting rapid growth in a lesion that had been stable benign breast disease in all 3 categories. Because the
for years.19 Rarely, patients present with a mass de- surgical management of these lesions differs from that
tected on routine screening mammography.13 Phyllodes of a fibroadenoma, accurate preoperative diagnosis
tumors can reach enormous proportions; tumors greater is optimal. Often, however, local excision of the mass
than 20 cm have been reported in multiple series.5,13,19–22 is required for diagnosis, and patients then require fur-
Many series have failed to show a correlation between ther surgery to ensure adequate tumor-free margins.
tumor size and histologic subtype, because even benign Clinically, the diagnosis of a phyllodes tumor
phyllodes tumors can reach great size.19,20 should be considered in the differential diagnosis of a
On examination, most patients have a smooth, large fibroadenoma. A history of rapid growth and at-
round, well-defined, firm mass that is mobile and pain- tainment of large size can be suggestive, but these fea-
less. Large lesions may be associated with dilated veins tures cannot reliably differentiate phyllodes tumors
visible over the skin, which may be stretched and at- from other benign breast disease. On mammogram,
tenuated. Nipple retraction,19,23 skin ulceration,5,19,21 phyllodes tumors appear as well-defined oval, round,
invasion of the chest wall,5,19,21 and bloody nipple dis- or lobulated masses that mimic the radiographic ap-
charge21 have been reported but are rare. Palpable pearance of a fibroadenoma.30 Associated coarse
axillary lymphadenopathy can be identified in up to microcalcifications are occasionally seen. On ultra-
20% of patients, but metastatic involvement of axil- sound, these lesions appear as solid, hypoechoic, well-
lary lymph nodes is rare.19,24 circumscribed masses.31 The presence of a cystic area
© Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network | Volume 5 Number 3 | March 2007
JN053_Jrnl_50308Telli.qxd 3/6/07 1:45 AM Page 326
Telli et al.
© Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network | Volume 5 Number 3 | March 2007
JN053_Jrnl_50308Telli.qxd 3/6/07 1:45 AM Page 327
© Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network | Volume 5 Number 3 | March 2007
JN053_Jrnl_50308Telli.qxd 3/6/07 1:45 AM Page 328
Telli et al.
Chaney et al.20 proposed that adjuvant chemother- tients selected for radiotherapy were probably those
apy be considered for patients with histologic evi- with larger tumors with narrow tumor-free or involved
dence of stromal overgrowth, particularly when the margins.26
tumor size is greater than 5 cm, because these patients
seem to have the greatest risk for developing distant
disease. However, because systemic therapy has had Management of Locally
limited value in patients with metastatic phyllodes Recurrent Disease
tumors, it is not expected to be effective in the adju- In approximately 15% of cases of phyllodes tumor, the
vant setting, and no randomized data are available. Tse clinical course will be complicated by one or more lo-
et al.14 suggested that the potential role of endocrine cal recurrences.7 General consensus is that these recur-
therapy in treating phyllodes tumors is limited be- rences result from failure of primary surgical treatment,
cause hormone receptors are primarily expressed on although the biologic behavior of the tumor may be
the epithelial component of the tumors, their expres- an important determinant. de Roos et al.29 found that
sion is inversely related to the degree of malignancy, the development of one local recurrence seemed to
and the stromal component of phyllodes tumors is predispose to further episodes of local recurrence re-
the component implicated in metastatic spread. Thus, gardless of the histologic subtype or type of initial sur-
there is no role for measuring hormone receptors in gery. Most tumors recur within 2 years of initial
these tumors. surgery,19,25 although tumors recurring as soon as 1
month25 and as late as 17 years36 after initial surgery
have been reported. Some series have found that the
Role of Adjuvant Radiation Therapy time to local recurrence is shortest among patients
The role of adjuvant breast or chest wall radiotherapy with the malignant subtype compared with those with
is controversial. Most experience is based on case re- benign and borderline lesions.11 Generally, phyllodes
ports of patients with chest wall recurrences. Because tumors recur with the same histology as that of the
of the important relationship between excision mar- initial disease, but cases of transformation to more ag-
gin and the risk for local recurrence, some experts gressive tumors have been reported.20,21,23,25 In most pa-
have suggested that adjuvant radiation at doses of 50 tients, local recurrence is not associated with distant
to 60 Gy be considered in patients for whom negative metastases.21,29
surgical margins cannot be attained.13,20 The use of ad- Cases of successful treatment of patients with mul-
juvant radiation in patients with a resection margin tiple recurrent tumors have been reported.3 However,
of 1 cm or larger is not recommended.20,34 However, some authors believe that mastectomy should be con-
no high-level evidence supports the role of adjuvant sidered after the first recurrence of borderline or ma-
radiotherapy in phyllodes tumors.
lignant lesions,11 whereas others believe that
In a series of 37 patients with malignant phyllodes
mastectomy should be considered after any second re-
tumors, Pandey et al.22 administered 45 to 50 Gy of
currence.13 Chaney et al.20 suggest that adjuvant ra-
radiation to 69% of patients, including all patients
diotherapy may be appropriate after resection of
treated with wide excision alone and those experienc-
ing recurrent phyllodes tumors after resection of the recurrent disease. Mangi et al.13 reported a case of a pa-
recurrent disease. In this study, the 5-year disease-free tient with a high-grade tumor recurrence that could
survival rate was 61.2% among patients who under- not be fully excised surgically. This patient was treated
went adjuvant radiotherapy versus 51.4% among those with radiotherapy to the chest wall and remained free
who did not. Cox proportional hazard survival analy- of disease for 84 months after recurrence. The NCCN
sis, however, showed no statistically significant ad- Breast Cancer Clinical Practice Guidelines in
vantage to radiotherapy (P = .47). The recent analysis Oncology support re-excision with wide margins for
of SEER data found that the use of adjuvant radio- locally recurrent disease.34 Some members of the
therapy predicted a worse cause-specific survival com- NCCN guidelines panel recommend local radiation
pared with surgery alone among 821 patients with therapy to the remaining breast or chest wall after re-
malignant phyllodes tumors. In this series, however, section of a local recurrence, but this recommendation
only 9% of patients underwent radiotherapy, and pa- is controversial.
© Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network | Volume 5 Number 3 | March 2007
JN053_Jrnl_50308Telli.qxd 3/6/07 1:45 AM Page 329
© Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network | Volume 5 Number 3 | March 2007
JN053_Jrnl_50308Telli.qxd 3/6/07 1:45 AM Page 330
Telli et al.
13. Mangi AA, Smith BL, Gadd MA, et al. Surgical management of 29. de Roos WK, Kaye P, Dent DM. Factors leading to local recurrence
phyllodes tumors. Arch Surg 1999;134:487–492; discussion or death after surgical resection of phyllodes tumours of the breast.
492–493. Br J Surg 1999;86:396–399.
14. Tse GM, Lee CS, Kung FY, et al. Hormonal receptors expression in 30. Jorge Blanco A, Vargas Serrano B, Rodriguez Romero R, et al.
epithelial cells of mammary phyllodes tumors correlates with patho- Phyllodes tumors of the breast. Eur Radiol 1999;9:356–360.
logic grade of the tumor: a multicenter study of 143 cases. Am J Clin 31. Chao TC, Lo YF, Chen SC, et al. Sonographic features of phyllodes
Pathol 2002;118:522–526. tumors of the breast. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2002;20:64–71.
15. Dacic S, Kounelis S, Kouri E, et al. Immunohistochemical profile of 32. Tan EY, Hoon TP, Yong WS, et al. Recurrent phyllodes tumours of
cystosarcoma phyllodes of the breast: a study of 23 cases. Breast J the breast: pathological features and clinical implications. ANZ J Surg
2002;8:376–381. 2006;76:476–480.
16. Tse GM, Lui PC, Scolyer RA, et al. Tumour angiogenesis and p53 33. Hajdu SI, Espinosa MH, Robbins GF. Recurrent cystosarcoma phyl-
protein expression in mammary phyllodes tumors. Mod Pathol lodes: a clinicopathologic study of 32 cases. Cancer 1976;38:1402–1406.
2003;16:1007–1013. 34. Carlson RW, Anderson BO, Burstein HJ, et al. The NCCN breast
17. Noguchi S, Aihara T, Koyama H, et al. Clonal analysis of benign and cancer clinical practice guidelines in oncology, version 1, 2007.
malignant human breast tumors by means of polymerase chain re- Available at: http://www.nccn. org/professionals/physician_gls/
action. Cancer Lett 1995;90:57–63. PDF/breast.pdf. Accessed January 30, 2007.
18. Noguchi S, Motomura K, Inaji H, et al. Clonal analysis of fibroade- 35. August DA, Kearney T. Cystosarcoma phyllodes: mastectomy,
noma and phyllodes tumor of the breast. Cancer Res 1993;53: lumpectomy, or lumpectomy plus irradiation. Surg Oncol 2000;
4071–4074. 9:49–52.
19. Reinfuss M, Mitus J, Duda K, et al. The treatment and prognosis of 36. Haagensen CD. Cystosarcoma Phyllodes, Disease of the Breast. 3rd
patients with phyllodes tumor of the breast: an analysis of 170 cases. ed. Philadelphia: WB Saunders; 1986:284–312.
Cancer 1996;77:910–916. 37. Kessinger A, Foley JF, Lemon HM, et al. Metastatic cystosarcoma
20. Chaney AW, Pollack A, McNeese MD, et al. Primary treatment of phyllodes: a case report and review of the literature. J Surg Oncol
cystosarcoma phyllodes of the breast. Cancer 2000;89:1502–1511. 1972;4:131–147.
21. Chen WH, Cheng SP, Tzen CY, et al. Surgical treatment of phyl- 38. Cooney BM, Ruth GJ, Behrman DA, et al. Malignant cystosarcoma
lodes tumors of the breast: retrospective review of 172 cases. J Surg phyllodes of the breast metastatic to the oral cavity: report of a case
Oncol 2005;91:185–194. and review of the literature. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol
1988;66:599–604.
22. Pandey M, Mathew A, Kattoor J, et al. Malignant phyllodes tumor.
Breast J 2001;7:411–416. 39. Hawkins RE, Schofield JB, Wiltshaw E, et al. Ifosfamide is an active
drug for chemotherapy of metastatic cystosarcoma phyllodes. Cancer
23. Deodhar SD, Joshi S, Khubchandani S. Cystosarcoma phyllodes.
1992;69:2271–2275.
J Postgrad Med 1989;35:98–103.
40. Allen R, Nixon D, York M, et al. Successful chemotherapy for cys-
24. Norris HJ, Taylor HB. Relationship of histologic features to behav-
tosarcoma phyllodes in a young woman. Arch Intern Med 1985;145:
ior of cystosarcoma phyllodes. Analysis of ninety-four cases. Cancer
1127–1128.
1967;20:2090–2099.
41. Burton GV, Hart LL, Leight GS Jr, et al. Cystosarcoma phyllodes.
25. Zurrida S, Bartoli C, Galimberti V, et al. Which therapy for unex-
Effective therapy with cisplatin and etoposide chemotherapy. Cancer
pected phyllode tumour of the breast? Eur J Cancer 1992;28:654–657. 1989;63:2088–2092.
26. Macdonald OK, Lee CM, Tward JD, et al. Malignant phyllodes tu- 42. Demetri GD, Baker LH, Benjamin R, et al. The NCCN soft tissue
mor of the female breast: association of primary therapy with cause- sarcoma clinical practice guidelines in oncology, version 3, 2006.
specific survival from the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results Available at: http://www.nccn. org/professionals/physician_gls/PDF/
(SEER) program. Cancer 2006;107:2127–2133. sarcoma.pdf. Accessed January 30, 2007.
27. Pantoja E, Llobet RE, Lopez E. Gigantic cystosarcoma phyllodes in 43. Buchanan EB. Re: Surgical removal of metastatic phyllodes tumor:
a man with gynecomastia. Arch Surg 1976;111:611. this should be strongly considered for the solitary lesion as long as
28. Konstantakos AK, Graham DJ. Cystosarcoma phyllodes tumors in cosmetic and functional disability is not excessive. Am Surg
men. Am Surg 2003;69:808–811. 2003;69:633; comment 61:350–355.
© Journal of the National Comprehensive Cancer Network | Volume 5 Number 3 | March 2007