Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Building Back Better Starts Now.: Covid-19 Socio Economic Impact Analysis For Guinea-Bissau
Building Back Better Starts Now.: Covid-19 Socio Economic Impact Analysis For Guinea-Bissau
Building Back Better Starts Now.: Covid-19 Socio Economic Impact Analysis For Guinea-Bissau
3
ally, sexual and reproductive health support the conversation and actions on mitigating the
will be limited during the pandemic. While socio-economic impact this pandemic will have
school closures for children are temporary, on the livelihoods of Bissau-Guinean citizens.
they bear long-term risks for higher drop- We see this moment of crisis also as an oppor-
out numbers. Child work, teen pregnancy tunity. It is a chance to start a path to structural
or wedlock are likely hazards especially for reform, overcoming old habits and building a
girls in vulnerable families. future where the focus is the sustainable hu-
man development.
This multifaceted crisis unveils – not only for
Guinea-Bissau – that there is no going back
to the pre-COVID-19 times. The forced lock-
down of entire countries and economies has
provoked profound changes to global systems
CHILD WORK, TEEN
and human behavior, which will affect the PREGNANCY OR WEDLOCK
country’s prospects for sustainable growth.
The country’s inability to build enough mo-
ARE LIKELY HAZARDS
mentum for reform and its missed opportuni- ESPECIALLY FOR GIRLS IN
ties to embark on a path towards sustainable
development came at a time of a deep and on-
VULNERABLE FAMILIES.
going political crisis, exacerbating the effects
of the pandemic while making recovery hard-
er. We therefore emphasize the importance of
accountable, democratic governance and the
investment in institutions as a condition to bet-
ter navigate this crisis. It is equally important
that all stakeholders, both in the public and
private sectors, take on this challenge as a col-
lective responsibility.
This impact analysis argues that the response
cannot be achieved in a linear fashion by suc-
cessively addressing first the health and hu-
manitarian aspects while waiting for the so-
cio-economic response to start. Undoubtedly,
the health crisis claims our first and foremost
attention throughout the response. This, how-
ever, does also mean that we need to expand
4
CONTENTS
Economic Structure: Raw cashew nuts are the primary source of economic activity in Guinea-Bissau 8
Counteracting resources: Fiscal situation is too poor to respond adequately to the crisis 10
Food security 13
Migration15
Gender inequality 16
6
1.100
1.000
900
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
25-Mar
26-Mar
27-Mar
28-Mar
29-Mar
30-Mar
31-Mar
1-Apr
2-Apr
3-Apr
4-Apr
5-Apr
6-Apr
7-Apr
8-Apr
9-Apr
10-Apr
11-Apr
12-Apr
13-Apr
14-Apr
15-Apr
16-Apr
17-Apr
18-Apr
19-Apr
20-Apr
21-Apr
22-Apr
23-Apr
24-Apr
25-Apr
26-Apr
27-Apr
28-Apr
29-Apr
30-Apr
1-May
2-May
3-May
4-May
5-May
6-May
7-May
8-May
9-May
10-May
11-May
12-May
13-May
14-May
15-May
16-May
17-May
18-May
Active Recovered Deaths
ment health expenditure averaged 3.5% of ity to COVID-19, but still lack equipment and
total expenditure (or 0.7% of GDP), most of better coordination with the overall response
which went to salary expenses and negligible to the pandemic. The international communi-
investment levels. Prevalence of many diseas- ty is spearheading to equip the country with
es, poor infrastructure and recurrent strikes in the necessary equipment facing the pitfall of
the public sector make the outbreak of COV- supply shortages in the international markets.
ID-19 a complex emergency, and constitute Outside Bissau, where lack of any medical
substantial obstacles to adequate response in- treatment usually prevails, no hospital is yet
terventions to prevent the spread of the virus. prepared to treat COVID-19 cases.
As the fragile health system does not reach The spread of COVID-19 in the country is diffi-
the bulk of the population, it is bound to col- cult to contain. Due to limited staff availability
lapse once the virus spreads through commu- and constrains of COVID-19 diagnostic capaci-
nity transmission. ties, the National Public Health Laboratory, the
The health workforce is scarce and under-re- only laboratory in the country, is struggling
sourced to face COVID-19. Italy, one of the to keep up with daily testing, given the rapid
countries hardest hit by the pandemic, has spread of the disease. Fueled by high social
one doctor for every 243 people. In Guin- stigma associated with the disease and the
ea-Bissau, there is one doctor for every 5,964 economic inability of the population to comply
inhabitants and one nurse for every 1,223 in- with isolation or quarantine, patients continue
habitants.3 The country has no intensive care to show little interest in testing. With physical
unit (ICU) specialist, no fully equipped ICU distancing measures in place, closures of eco-
bed, and continuous supply of oxygen is not nomic activities, and the approaching rainy
ensured in the main public hospital in Bissau, season, financial and geographical barriers
the Simão Mendes Hospital. Two missionary to testing and treatment will further increase.
hospitals in Bissau offer some response capac- Furthermore, the political crisis and the deeply
rooted distrust in public systems and controls
make rigorous testing and case tracking more
3 Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS) 2014 difficult.
7
Economic Structure: Raw
cashew nuts are the primary
source of economic activity in
Guinea-Bissau
The authorities responded to the pandem-
ic with an early nationwide lockdown with Shrinking
Falling Disappearing
external
short notice. Even before the first case was remittance tourism
borrowing
flow revenue
options
reported, authorities of Guinea-Bissau had
shut down the airport and land borders, mar-
kets, bars and restaurants, and restricted pub-
lic transport, emulating the response of other
SMALL ISLAND DEVELOPING ECONOMIES
countries around the world with little time for
the population to prepare for these impor-
tant restrictions in their daily lives and liveli-
hoods. What followed was a national state of High debt servicing cost
emergency allowing only essential businesses High reliance on food imports
Low domestic savings
to open beyond the imposed curfew.4 Due
to the restrictions, overall economic activity
slowed considerably since measures were in-
troduced.5 There has been little discussion so
far about how to adapt measures to the reality Figure 1: Transmission channels of COVID-19´s
economic impact on small island developing
of Guinea-Bissau. economies
The pandemic hits Guinea-Bissau at a very SOURCE: UN DESA
4 Open hours were initially 7 to 11am, later extended to 7am to 12 noon and
then 7am to 2pm.
5 Due to poor prevalence of smart phones in Guinea-Bissau, only in-
dicative: Google (2020, April). COVID-19 Community Mobility Report.
Retrieved from: https://www.gstatic.com/covid19/mobility/2020-04-30_
GW_Mobility_Report_en.pdf
6 National Statistics Institute (INE) and Ministry of Finance: Between 2015
and 2019, value added by the primary sector averaged 33.7% of nominal
GDP.
8
In billion XOF
10%
200
180 8%
160
6%
140
120 4%
100
2%
80
60 0%
40
-2%
20
-4%
0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
FOB export value of raw cashew nuts (left scale) Real GDP growth (right scale)
Figure 2: High economic dependence on raw cashew nut exports and spillover effects
SOURCE: BCEAO AND MINISTRY OF FINANCE
Island Development State (SIDS), the econ- tween 1.5% and 1.9% in 2020, considering the
omy characteristically depends on a single impacts of the pandemic. 11
sector: Raw cashew nuts make up more than
COVID-19 jeopardizes the 2020 cashew cam-
90% of total goods exports7 and the govern-
paign and poses risks for 2021. The shutdown
ment generates around 13% of their revenue
of the two main export markets for cashews
from cashew-specific taxes and fees.8 Cash-
from Guinea-Bissau, India and Vietnam, put the
ew involves 80% of the country’s labor force
cashew campaign under acute stress as demand
in form of smallholder farming and seasonal
for the nuts fell sharply. Like other internation-
daily labor.9 Revenues from cashew nut sales
al commodities, the price for raw cashew nuts
during the marketing season, between March
dropped significantly. Early indicators are the al-
and July, are an important component of the
ready low prices for raw cashew in Ivory Coast.
yearly household income, particular in rural ar- Despite some indication of a recovery,12 market
eas. While cashew accounts directly for only uncertainty continues to be very high. Nation-
around 11% of the GDP,10 other domestic ser- al movement restrictions and border closures
vices in the value chain, such as trading and do not only prevent international and regional
transport, and the revenue received by house- cashew value chain agents from entering the
holds, provide substantial economic stimulus country, but also limit the movement of seasonal
to other sectors and investment. Hence, cash- workers and the farmers’ ability to manage the
ew provides important spillovers to the econ- labor-intensive collection of cashew nuts. Wor-
omy. Macroeconomic forecasts carried out in ryingly, the lockdown situation has delayed the
April 2020 point to a contraction of output be- start of the cashew campaign, which was origi-
nally envisioned to begin on March 30.
7 Central Bank of West African States: Between 2015 and 2019, FOB Raw
cashew nut exports averaged 90.4% of total goods exports.
8 Ministry of Finance: Between 2015 and 2019, the three cashew related 11 The Central Bank of West African States estimates -1.9% for the 2020
taxes/fees (IEEC, CPR and ACI) accounted for 13.4% of domestic (fiscal real GDP growth and the International Monetary Fund forecasts -1.5%,
and non-fiscal) revenue. see: IMF (2020). April 2020 Regional Economic Outlook: Sub-Saharan
9 African Development Bank (2018). Country Gender Profile: Guinea-Bissau. Africa. Retrieved from: https://www.imf.org/en/Publications/REO/SSA/
Retrieved from: https://www.afdb.org/fileadmin/uploads/afdb/Docu- Issues/2020/04/01/sreo0420
ments/Generic-Documents/Guinea-Bissau_-_Country_gender_profile.pdf 12 Market Prices for cashew are slightly increasing as demand from India and
10 National Statistics Institute (INE) and Ministry of Finance: Between 2015 Vietnam is slowly picking up, see: N’kalô cashew market bulletin (2020,
and 2019, the weight of cashew in total nominal GDP averaged 10.6%. May 7). Issue 334.
9
9
120
7
70 5
20 1
-1
-30
-3
-5
-80
-7
-9
-130
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Foreing direct investment, net inflows (BoP, current US$ mi) Current account balance (BoP, current US$ mi)
Personal remittances, received (current US$ mi) Current account balance (% of GDP) right axis
13 World Bank (2020, April). Migrant remittance inflows (US$ million). Re- 16 Ministry of Finance. WAEMU convergence criteria require a tax revenue of
trieved from: https://www.knomad.org/sites/default/files/2020-04/Remit- at least 20% of GDP.
tance%20inflows%20April%202020.xlsx
17 Overseas Development Institute (2020, April). Economic impacts of
14 UNDP Guinea Bissau(2020, May). and policy responses to the coronavirus pandemic: early evidence
15 World Bank (2020, April). COVID-19 Crisis through a Migration from Guinea Bissau. Retrieved from: https://set.odi.org/wp-content/up-
Lens. Retrieved from: http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/ loads/2020/04/Economic-impacts-of-and-policy-responses-to-the-coro-
en/989721587512418006/COVID-19-Crisis-Through-a-Migration-Lens navirus-pandemic-early-evidence-from-Guinea-Bissau-2.pdf
10
and the World Bank (WB) agreed to provide
debt relief. In the case of the West African
Development Bank (BOAD), capital maturities
between April and December of around XOF
8 billion were frozen. Some of the resources
that the country is considering for financing
the deficit are: i) XOF 15 billion from the BOAD
at a concessional rate of 2.5%. BOAD is also
open to provide some budgetary support, ii) a
possible emergency assistance from the IMF,
iii) possible support from the AfDB under the
COVID-19 Rapid Response Facility (CRF); iv)
possible loans from other development banks
and additional domestic financing through
treasuries placed with regional commercial
banks.
Investment spending might decrease sub-
stantially. In the likelihood of encountering dif-
ficulties to afford their most pressing current
expenditure, such as wages, already low ex-
penses for public investment will be the first
to be subject to cuts. International partners
are the main source of investment in Guin-
ea-Bissau. Some infrastructure projects, such
as electricity or road construction, have been
suspended due to precautionary measures.
The delay of these crucial investments will fur-
ther hold up economic development and re-
covery in Guinea-Bissau.
INTERNATIONAL PARTNERS
ARE THE MAIN SOURCE OF
INVESTMENT IN GUINEA-
BISSAU.
11
02 SOCIO-ECONOMIC
CONSEQUENCES
12
XOF per kg % of total population
1200 40
35
1000
30
804
800
25
570
600 520 20
474
15
351
400 333
273 300
260 250 10
200
200
5
0 0
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Farmgate price (left) FOB Export price (left) Food insecurity (right)
little opportunity to protect themselves during quately store the nuts during the approaching
the health pandemic aggravates the situation rainy season, which usually starts by the end
of the most vulnerable. The quality of the pub- of May. Despite the announcement of a refer-
lic response will have an impact on the already ence price of XOF 375/kg (U$ 0.62/kg), pro-
fragile social cohesion in the country. ducers are currently selling at prices down to
XOF 200/kg (U$ 0.33/kg), as a coping measure
to address immediate food security needs.23
Food security
Low revenue from cashew sales will have a
A failure of the 2020 cashew-nut campaign
significant negative impact on the subse-
will trigger increased food insecurity. With-
quent agricultural campaign, another crucial
in two years, since its peak in 2017, the farm-
resource of income and food. Liquidity short-
gate price of raw cashew has dropped almost
ages from lower cashew revenue will affect
60% to XOF 351/kg (U$ 0.58/kg) in 2019. Con-
the farmers’ ability to finance the agriculture
sequently, food insecurity rose from 20.0% of
campaign, including purchasing inputs, re-
the population in rural areas in October 2017
cruiting seasonal workers - many of them be-
to 34.2% (around 368,000 people) in Septem-
ing internal migrants or migrants coming from
ber 2019 (see Figure 4). 22 In 2019, the export
neighboring countries- and renting farming
volume was fortunately high, above 2017 and
equipment. Many farmers will face difficulties
2018 levels. In 2020, however, despite a good
in engaging in production activities during the
production outlook, Guinea-Bissau could look
rainy season with the concrete risk of a signifi-
at its lowest trade volume in years. The un-
cant reduction of the agricultural production in
certainty about the trading season pressures
2020 and 2021, which could lead to long-term
producers to sell with little bargaining power,
effects on the already precarious food secu-
further aggravated by the inability to ade-
rity situation in the country. Farmers will face
13
Liters of rain per sqm
700
Cashew nuts
600
Peanuts
500
Horticulture
400
Rice
300
Corn
200
Sweet potato / Manioc
100
Beans
0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dic
Months of harvest of corresponding crop Monthly precipitation (Country average between 2014 and 2018)
a cycle of poverty and will be more exposed Necessary mobility measures result in re-
to seasonal factors affecting food security. Re- duced livelihood opportunities, affecting
duced availability of locally grown fresh foods household capacity to access food particu-
in the markets is likely to increase Guinea-Bis- larly in urban areas. About two thirds of the
sau’s high dependency on food imports. households in urban areas have no access to
stable sources of income to meet their needs,
The risk of increasing prices in Guinea Bis-
as their daily revenues derive from informal
sau’s markets is imminent and will be fueled by
economic activities. They are characterized
more expensive imports following the depre-
by a high level of economic vulnerability and
ciation of the country’s “export currency”, the
high dependency on coping mechanisms. Re-
cashew nut. The terms of trade between rice
strictive measures affect the most labor-in-
and cashew are very likely to increase in 2020
tensive, unskilled jobs, such as transportation,
as the price of imported rice in Guinea-Bissau
construction, small businesses, and informal
has been stable at 350 XOF/Kg since August
petty traders, leading to substantial barriers
2018 and import requirements, estimated at
in accessing food and other basic goods and
140,000 tons in 2019, are expected to further
services.
increase in 2020. Annual inflation in Guinea
Bissau, generally low and stable, averaging Food access constraints will have a severe
1.7% throughout the last decade, could spike impact on the household diet affecting the
again considering that inflation reached 10.1% nutritional status of the most vulnerable,
during the 2008 food price crisis. The country namely women and children. With 26% of
might see itself confronted with a similar situa- the population, Guinea-Bissau has the sec-
tion if import bans and border closures affect ond-highest prevalence of undernourishment
the international and domestic value chains, in West Africa after Liberia. 25 Under increased
and if production levels in the upcoming agri- economic strain, households are likely to
cultural season cannot be maintained.24 switch to cheaper, less nutritious foods, pri-
24 National Statistics Institute (INE): In March 2020, annual food price infla- 25 Global Hunger Index (2019). Retrieved from: https://www.globalhungerin-
tion rose to 5.2%. dex.org/guinea-bissau.html
14
oritizing caloric intake over nutritional value. lower than male’s.30,31 Low coverage of com-
Recent data shows that already in 2019, only prehensive sexual education can expose girls
17.9 % of women met minimum dietary diver- to unwanted teenage pregnancies. During the
sity.26 Only 8.3% of children age 6-23 months 2014 Ebola crisis in Sierra Leone, in areas where
met a minimum acceptable diet with respect community activities stopped to prevent the
to all three Infant and Young Children Feed- spread of the disease, young girls were more
likely to experience out-of-wedlock pregnan-
ing (IYCF) practices (breastfeeding status,
cies and as a result overall school enrolment
dietary diversity and minimum meal frequen-
post-crisis dropped by 16%.32 These impacts
cy). The WFP school feeding program usually
will significantly dim girls’ economic prospects.
provides hot and nutritious meals in 874 out
of the 2000 national schools benefiting about With a noticeably young population and only
180,000 children in total. With closed schools one in ten young people being employed, 33
quick action will be needed to levy a high
the parents’ hardship to feed their families in-
burden off the youth. The closure of schools
creases.27
and the decline in job perspectives during the
COVID-19 outbreak may cause increased de-
Children, Youth and Education pendency rates in households, more desire to
emigrate or even urge for radicalization.34 COV-
Human development is one of the lowest in the ID-19 prevention and recovery measures need
world and school closures will further strain to focus substantially on the Bissau-Guinean
human capital accumulation. On average, stu- youth. Investments in infrastructure and ed-
dents do not finish the 4th year of school and ucation are critically needed to allow for em-
almost half of the children have never been to ployment and employability of youth and in-
school.28 As preventive measures, all schools cubators need to start providing them a voice
nationwide were closed for an indefinite pe- and the financial means to be protagonists of
riod and are unlikely to resume in the current their own economic success.
school year. Lack of technological devices
and high costs associated with internet access
Migration
make home schooling not a viable option for
the general population.29 Migration is likely to increase due to COVID-19.
The economic set-back and lack of quality ser-
Some children will never return to school, and vices will drive more Bissau-Guineans to search
girls are disproportionately at risk to drop out. for a better future in other countries. With le-
As many families see their economic activi- gal avenues of migration outside ECOWAS and
ties being stopped, vulnerable families might CPLP countries being limited, citizens will seek
require child labor or wed their daughters to the services of smugglers and opt for irregu-
better cope with the crisis. In Guinea-Bissau, lar migration while exposing themselves to ex-
24% of girls are married by the age of 18 and ploitation and human trafficking during their
female primary completion rate is significantly journey and at their destinations.
26 WFP (2019, September). Food Security and Nutrition Monitoring System 30 UNDP (2019). Human Development Report 2019. Retrieved from: http://
(SiSSAN) hdr.undp.org/sites/default/files/hdr2019.pdf
27 Center for Global Development (2020, March 24). With Schools Closed, 31 41% (female) vs. 55% (male), see: Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS)
Hundreds of Millions of Children Are Not Receiving School Meals. Re- (2014). Retrieved from: https://unesco-wide-production.herokuapp.com/
trieved from: https://www.cgdev.org/blog/schools-closed-hundreds-mil- countries/guinea-bissau#?dimension=sex&group=all&year=latest
lions-children-are-not-receiving-school-meals 32 Bandiera, O. et al. (2019). The Economic Lives of Young Women in the
28 Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS) (2014). Retrieved from: https:// Time of Ebola. Retrieved from: http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/
unesco-wide-production.herokuapp.com/countries/guinea-bissau#?di- en/452451551361923106/pdf/WPS8760.pdf
mension=sex&group=all&year=latest 33 National Youth Policy of Guinea-Bissau 2016-2020.
29 Center for Global Development (2020). COVID-19 education pol- 34 World Policy (2017, August 15). Youth unemployment and the fight
icy tracking. Retrieved from: https://docs.google.com/spread- against terrorism in West Africa. Retrieved from: http://worldpolicy.
sheets/d/1ndHgP53atJ5J-EtxgWcpSfYG8LdzHpUsnb6mWybErYg/ org/2017/08/15/youth-unemployment-and-the-fight-against-terrorism-in-
edit?ts=5e6f893e#gid=0 west-africa/
15
Migrants are potentially fearful of reporting
health conditions to avoid stigma. Reduced
THE NEGATIVE
economic activity due to the emergency IMPACT ON WOMEN IS
state substantially limits migrants’ income
as they are usually depended on informal
DISPROPORTIONATE,
markets. Moreover, migrants in irregular sit- AS THEIR INFORMAL
uations may be fearful of reporting health ECONOMIC ACTIVITY
conditions and accessing needed treatment.
Stigma can undermine social cohesion within SLOWS DOWN AND THE
countries and prompt possible social exclu- BURDEN OF DOMESTIC
sion of certain groups, contributing to a pos-
sible scenario where migrants remain isolat-
CARE INCREASES.
ed from their host communities and living in
conditions in which the virus is more likely to
spread.
the overall health workforce is female.35 While
High population movements and dense liv-
72% of nurses, midwives and community health
ing conditions make Guinea-Bissau particu-
workers are female, men fulfill 82% of admin-
larly vulnerable to the transmission of COV-
istrative health work. Due to their higher rep-
ID-19. While under the current emergency
resentation in contact care duty, women face
law decrees, movements within the coun-
heightened risk of exposure to COVID-19. Pro-
try are prohibited, the onset of the cashew
tection of health workers and their adequate
nut harvesting season and the movement of
remuneration should be a paramount concern.
seasonal workers might further transmit the
disease in the country. The social and fami- Confinement measures and higher stress
ly structure of households, often aggregat- levels increase gender-based violence. The
ing between seven and nine people in the pandemic has also given rise to threats that
same house, weak health infrastructure, and extend beyond the risk of infection. Epidem-
health seeking behaviors also increases vul- ics and their attendant lockdown and high-
er stress levels increase the risk of domestic
nerability.
abuse and other forms of gender-based vi-
olence. 36 The economic effects of the Ebola
Gender inequality outbreak, for instance, led to exacerbated
sexual exploitation risks for women and chil-
The negative impact on women is dispropor-
dren. Today, as families face heightened ten-
tionate, as their informal economic activity
sions and financial uncertainties, women and
slows down and the burden of domestic care
girls are confronted with intensified vulnera-
increases. Women engage largely in informal
bilities, including early marriages, trafficking,
and daily wage activities such as selling fish,
or other coping strategies involving transac-
preparing food in small restaurants, or trading
tional sex. 45% of females in Guinea-Bissau
fruits and other foods through informal net- undergo female genital mutilation (FGM). 37
works. Mobility restrictions, closure of borders Physical distancing measures and lockdowns
and of urban markets significantly affect their
work and reduce their income. At the same
time, the burden of domestic care, which typ-
ically falls to women, increases with lockdown 35 National Health Plan 2018-2022
36 UNFPA (2020, April 27). Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Family
measures in place. Planning and Ending Gender-based Violence, Female Genital Mutilation
and Child Marriage. Retrieved from: https://www.unfpa.org/resources/
impact-covid-19-pandemic-family-planning-and-ending-gender-based-vi-
Female health workers are more exposed to olence-female-genital
37 UNICEF (2018). Retrieved from: https://sdgindex.org/reports/2019-afri-
COVID-19 than men. In Guinea-Bissau, 59% of ca-sdg-index-and-dashboards-report/
16
preclude successful community empower-
ment programs to reduce FGM. Many poten-
MALNUTRITION,
tially averted cases will now occur during the RESPIRATORY CONDITIONS
times of the pandemic, as protection efforts
are not being ensured.
AND CHRONIC ILLNESSES,
Women’s access to health has been limited
SUCH AS CARDIOVASCULAR
and risks faced by women will further in- DISEASES OR DIABETES
crease. Health centers are often less acces-
sible to women and girls due to their weak
ARE VERY PREVALENT.
decision-making power within a Bissau-Guin-
ean family and the direct and indirect costs
attached to it (such as time availability, trans-
portation costs, and childcare responsibili-
ties).38 The need for sexual, reproductive and symptoms of COVID-19, it is likely to see higher
maternal health care continues to be essential than average mortality rates among the popu-
during COVID-19. Burdensome access due to lation with pre-existing medical conditions.
confinement measures, diverted resources to
Burden of other diseases may aggravate if not
fight the epidemic, or disrupted supply chains
addressed. Lessons from the Ebola outbreak
of birth control will increase the risks for wom-
in neighboring countries in 2014-2015 have
en. Unmet needs of family planning in Guin-
shown an increase of all-cause mortality data
ea-Bissau are already one of the highest in the in Guinea-Bissau during this period, mainly
world (22%).39 During this crisis, unmet needs driven by vaccine-preventable diseases, ma-
are likely to intensify and may lead to unsafe laria, HIV and tuberculosis. Access to chron-
abortion and to an increase in maternal mor- ic medication is key for keeping HIV patients
tality. While still high, the progress in maternal suppressed and achieving higher rates of tu-
mortality reduction made in the past may see berculosis treatment. Interruptions of net cam-
a setback. paigns could see malaria related death surge
by 36% over 5 years.41 It is crucial to strengthen
health systems and rapidly reorganize service
Special attention to vulnerable
delivery to respond to COVID-19, maintaining
populations core essential services across the continuum
Pre-existing medical conditions are a high- of care so that no one is left behind.
risk factor among Bissau-Guineans. The me- Cases of mental health issues increase dur-
dian age of only 19 years in Guinea-Bissau may ing crisis. Guinea-Bissau lacks appropriate
prevent case severity. However, malnutrition, legislation protecting the rights of people with
respiratory conditions and chronic illnesses, mental health challenges, and the provision of
such as cardiovascular diseases or diabetes mental health care and psychosocial counsel-
are very prevalent. 30% of all deaths in Guin- ling in the country remains substantially inad-
ea-Bissau even without COVID-19 were fore- equate to address the population’s burden of
cast to result from comorbidities.40 Without mental illness. With the pandemic and the cur-
critical facilities in place to manage severe fews in place, psychosocial and mental health
issues may be on the rise and people with
mental health and/or psychosocial challenges
38 World Bank (2016, June). Guinea-Bissau - Turning challenges into oppor-
tunities for poverty reduction and inclusive growth : systematic country risk being left further behind.
diagnostic (SCD). Retrieved from: http://documents.worldbank.org/curat-
ed/en/100721467968248103/Guinea-Bissau-Turning-challenges-into-op-
portunities-for-poverty-reduction-and-inclusive-growth-systematic-coun-
try-diagnostic-SCD
39 Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS) 2014 41 Hogan, AB. et al. (2020, May 1). The Potential Impact of the COVID-19
40 WHO (2018). Retrieved from: https://www.who.int/nmh/countries/2018/ Epidemic on HIV, TB and Malaria in Low- and Middle-Income Countries.
gnb_en.pdf?ua=1 Retrieved from: https://doi.org/10.25561/78670.
17
People with disabilities carry a high burden.
Infectious diseases such as HIV are more prev-
THE SYSTEMICALLY
alent in people with disabilities. The situation WEAK JUDICIAL SYSTEM
of confinement will see their daily adversities
greatly deepened. Difficult access to food, hy-
LIMITS THE PROTECTION
giene products and the inability to work are OF HUMAN RIGHTS AND
some of the obstacles faced by people with ACCESS TO JUSTICE.
disabilities and greatly expose them to the
threat of contagion. It is essential to ensure
that information about prevention and the
course of the disease is available in accessi-
ble formats for everybody, including sign lan-
guage, the use of alternative visualizations in
images and graphics, and easy-to-read ver-
obligations. Additionally, the lack of a human
sions. Special social protection programs ca-
rights protection system and access to justice,
tering to people with disability are needed in
as well as the systemically weak judicial sys-
order to allow this group to navigate safely
tem limits the protection of human rights and
through the crisis.
access to justice for the general population
and especially for those affected by violations
Governance is at the heart of of basic rights committed by security forces in
times of an imposed state of emergency.
recovery
It is in times of crisis that accountability and
A whole of government approach to the pan-
transparency is crucial. Limited oversight,
demic can have a positive impact on the re-
transparency and accountability, particular-
sponse to the dual crises affecting Guinea-Bis-
ly concerning the procurement of medical
sau, with an increase in effective measures to
equipment and food can have harmful ef-
mitigate impacts on the population while in-
fects, especially on the most vulnerable that
stilling trust in government. Moreover, the abil-
rely on the access to these goods and neces-
ity to advance in delayed reform areas is key
sities to meet basic needs. While civil society
in managing a comprehensive recovery for
organizations, and even citizens, should usu-
the post-COVID-19 period, ensuring increased
ally play an active role in holding institutions
political stability and the strengthening of the
accountable, the state of emergency poses
rule of law while creating basic conditions for
further barriers to an open and inclusive civ-
sustainable economic growth.
ic space. In Guinea-Bissau, the already weak
During the COVID-19 response, democrat- civil society struggles more than usual to find
ic values and human rights can come under mechanisms to increase scrutiny, ensure ac-
intense pressure. In a fragile context such as countability, and promote open and transpar-
Guinea-Bissau, political volatility is already ent behaviors for both the public and private
putting strains on democracy, freedom of ex- sectors. Accountability in managing the funds
pression and the press as well as the social received by the competent authorities is key
fabric in general. The negative socio-econom- in nurturing a trustful relationship between cit-
ic impacts on livelihoods eroding further so- izens and the state. Especially for long-term
cial cohesion and creating hardship will raise prospects of this relationship it is paramount
tension and could provoke civil unrest. The that, during the time of crisis, the competent
prolonged post-electoral crisis and uncertain- authorities are able to show that they commit
ty about stable political majorities may further to high standards of accountability and aim at
impact the ability of authorities to effectively strengthening institutional capacity and deliv-
respect, protect and fulfil their human rights ery of services to citizens.
18
The state of emergency challenges a whole
range of human rights. Freedom of expression
and freedom of the press, the right to infor-
mation and freedom of association and of as-
sembly are being limited. Limitations on press
freedom will contribute in the short and me-
dium term also to the shrinking of civic space,
which is already limited in Guinea-Bissau. Ad-
ditionally, the crisis raises the question of how
best to support the dissemination of factual
information and eliminate misinformation or
disinformation.
19
03 STEPS TO RECOVERY
TO LEAVE NO ONE BEHIND
This profound health, economic, social and requires rapid and effective support from
humanitarian crisis offers an unparalleled op- all stakeholders while keeping up with re-
portunity to review past government prac- quired levels of accountability. Whole of
tices and priorities. As we transition to a government approach is needed to confront
post-COVID-19 world, Guinea-Bissau should the pandemic, while bridging coordination
seize the opportunity to outline more equi- shortages is crucial to respond quickly to
table ways of managing resources and be the changing crisis environment. Policies to
cognizant to strengthen the social contract. ramp-up the health system including prop-
It is a propitious time to reverse unsuccess- er funding should be prioritized and focus
ful policies and practices. The pandemic can on the identified needs of the health sector
serve in form of a recognition by those re- with a priority on health personnel: Sufficient
sponsible that the time to start building back personal protective equipment and a supple-
better starts now. mentary wage subsidy for health care work-
Policy recommendations should follow two ers fighting COVID-19 may be considered. It
dimensions simultaneously: Firstly, emer- is important to ensure that essential servic-
gency measures to strengthen the health es and operations continue to protect the
response, minimize health risks and econom- lives of people affected by malaria, HIV, tu-
ic losses to livelihoods, and secondly more berculosis and in need of maternal and child
long-term policies and interventions orient- health or adequate sanitations. Otherwise,
ed towards recovery. All actors involved we save a few and loose many others. Fund-
need to embark on a strategic conversation ing shall therefore be supplementary instead
around how to shape the recovery stage of crowding out of other important medical
by building back better, more sustainably services.
and more equitably, including a strong lens Strengthen community response. It is crucial
on the most vulnerable groups among Bis- that COVID-19 transmission in Guinea-Bissau
sau-Guineans. is restricted as quickly as possible to prevent
a surge in cases and deaths. Foremost, this
requires awareness raising about prevention
Elements for a short-term
and symptoms of COVID-19 among the pop-
action plan ulation by community health workers. Latter
Response coordination for a responsive shall also scale-up surveillance of suspect-
and resilient system. To prevent an aggra- ed cases and their reporting to the nearest
vated humanitarian crisis from COVID-19 and health center. Ideally, real time data using
its socio-economic impacts, Guinea-Bissau technology solutions could support response
20
efficiency and decision-making. Collective pora with a waiver of costs for cash transfers
actions within communities are necessary to vulnerable families could be considered in
to contain a devastating impact. Behavioral possible partnership with the private finan-
change, such as self-isolation, shielding high- cial sector. Additionally, in-kind food assis-
risk groups, adapting markets and everyday tance and provision of agricultural inputs and
life activities in order to function in accord- cashew storage facilities to most vulnerable
ance with physical distancing. Community farmers should be ensured to alleviate the
leaders should also be encouraged to start immediate negative impact on food security,
thinking about the recovery phase and their support them during the hunger season (July
guidance to shape the communities of the fu- to October) and improve farm productivity.
ture. Special attention should be given to vulner-
One size does not fit all: Physical distancing able groups, for example to people with dis-
policies need to be adapted to the most vul- abilities.
nerable. Lockdowns and long curfews are not Provide distance-learning options that can
sustainable solutions for most Bissau-Guin- continue as complementary tools for the fu-
eans, as they increase their economic bur- ture. The pre-COVD-19 reality offered only
den. The adopted policies also increase so- limited education to students due to teacher
cial contacts during short business hours. strikes. Long-term improvement should start
Instead, measures should be better adapted through effective crisis-recovery strategies.
to the most vulnerable people. Opportuni- Providing distance teaching via community
ties to enable physical distance measures radios or even using the state TV channel
need to be created, such as proper queuing could be innovative ways to allow for contin-
measures and market stalls at a safe distance ued education during school closures. Once
such as at the newly established market in schools reopen, the system could serve as a
the Green Space. Taxis and toca-tocas are ir- complementary teaching tool. For now, on-
replaceable for many vulnerable workers in site feeding modalities should be converted
the informal sector, especially women, while
into take-home rations so that schoolchildren
policies can be adapted to safe distancing
will continue benefitting from the largest so-
of passengers. Improved access to sanita-
cial safety net in the country.
tion and clean water should be ensured. It
is important to underline the effectiveness Provide emergency plans to support the
of physical distancing, while designing inter- small and medium sized producers. Small
ventions of lockdowns that pay tribute to the and medium producers, vendors and infor-
economic and social reality of most citizens. mal workers have a difficult access to credit
and to support policies. Tailored programs
Provide for a social safety net to counter-
could provide the upholding of the chain of
act rising poverty levels. Shortfall of (cash-
small producers to vendors, with special at-
ew) income and remittances require action
tention to gender and harnessing technology
to avert rising poverty and food insecurity.
through e-platforms.
Safety net measures could go hand in hand
with financial inclusion initiatives as they Continued operations for essential govern-
must reach as many as possible, targeting ment functions. This is the time, especially
the poor, gender disparities, the informal with government officials having to operate
sector, and food-insecure regions to prevent through telecommuting to maintain the es-
reinforcing of existing inequalities. Viable op- sential functions of government operable
tions are emergency cash transfers via mo- through well-structured business continuity
bile money networks to households headed plans and equipment. In the long run, this is
by women. To face the declining remittances an opportunity to provide more public ser-
flows, a collective effort to engage the dias- vices online.
21
Medium- and Long-Term agricultural transformation and benefit from
employment. Meanwhile, more value addi-
Planning for post-COVID-19
tion to the cashew value chain should happen
The short-term recommendations rightly focus in country and a strategic plan for increased
on the immediate humanitarian needs. Howev- cashew processing should be elaborated, so it
er, short and longer-term solutions need to go does not fail as previous ambitions did.
hand in hand.
Focus on micro, small and medium enter-
No more ‘business as usual’ in the health prises. Diversification efforts have to go well
sector: The COVID-19 pandemic has put the beyond cashew: sustainable tourism, the blue
flaws and gaps in the Bissau-Guinean health economy, and solutions to creating conditions
system into the spotlight. Poor public health for a more formalized economy are all areas
investment and missing accountability have that will need to be part of recovery.
undermined health and welfare in Guinea-Bis-
Better social cohesion and trust building
sau. The government and its partners should
between government and citizens: The so-
take this opportunity to accelerate health in-
cio-economic impact of the pandemic has
vestment not only for medical dimensions of
exposed key social fissures in the society,
the pandemic but also for immediate, medium
where certain communities and groups are
and long-term primary health care in all re-
simply left behind, and inequality is on the
gions of the country. The focus should be on
rise. A serious focus on the regions needs to
health staff training, infrastructure, and water,
be ingrained in any policy response around
sanitation and hygiene, aiming to accelerate
COVID-19 and beyond. Social cohesion should
progress towards universal health care cov-
be strengthened in and within communities
erage. Basic treatment should be available to
through the creation and support of inno-
everyone without discrimination, serving the
vative dialogue platforms, with engagement
most vulnerable and marginalized. This means
and empowerment of women and youth. En-
addressing pre-existing barriers to access and
gaging community leaders, making linkages
ensuring that no one is denied timely and ap-
with national policy dialogue and supporting
propriate treatment because they lack the fi-
inclusive dialogue processes will be instru-
nancial means to pay for it or because they
mental. These platforms could also lead to an
are discriminated on bases of age, disability,
increase in demand for governmental trans-
gender, sexual orientation, among others or
parency and accountability.
because stigma prevents them from getting
treatment. Accountability is key. With the inflow of re-
sources and rising expectations by citizens as
Agricultural diversification and promotion
to the response to the crisis, it is paramount
of local value chains: Guinea-Bissau’s raw
to ensure the transparent and accountable
cashew nut dependency is exacerbating the
use of these resources. It is an opportunity to
socio-economic impact. Food insecurity, mal-
restore the link of trust between government
nutrition and poverty can be mitigated by di- and citizenry.
versifying the local food production. Inclusive
food systems42 that support smallholders to Involve the youth in the recovery and give
invest in basic market infrastructure and pro- them a voice. The potential of involving young
mote inclusive local agribusiness models pres- citizens in the recovery should not be forgot-
ent a more sustainable solution. Vulnerable ten by both authorities and partners. Build-
population, especially women, could lead the ing in a youth perspective and investing in
the creativity and entrepreneurial spirit of the
youth throughout the country will lead to in-
42 IFPRI (2020, March). 2020 Global food policy report: Building in- novative solutions to local challenges for the
clusive food systems. Retrieve from: https://www.ifpri.org/publica-
tion/2020-global-food-policy-report-building-inclusive-food-systems post-COVID-19 recovery.
22
Better data for better policy advice: Guin- plied when designing the socio-economic re-
ea-Bissau is in need of timely data to allow covery.
for better policymaking. For example, the
The national development plan needs to be
most recent published public national account
updated and should be effectively imple-
statistics are from 2017 and the results from
mented to achieve the 2030 Agenda. The
the Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey 2018 are
crisis exposes that lagging behind in the im-
still to be expected. Such data is essential for
plementation of a consistent development
good policymaking in order to react proper-
plan is detrimental to the capacity to prepare,
ly to crises. An in-depth multisector impact
react and recover. There is both the need to
assessment of COVID-19 is necessary to help
update and accelerate the implementation of
strengthen the response to the current crisis.
the national development plan to allow for
Additionally, regular food insecurity evalua-
some of the above-mentioned recovery to
tions and mapping of real time vulnerability
materialize. Strategies should be adapted to
are important to monitor changes and tar-
its SIDS reality, taking advantage of its geo-
geting the most vulnerable households. Data
graphic diversity including islands, waterways
should be sex-disaggregated to be able to
and a recognition of the potential of a blue
monitor gender inequalities and include indi-
economy and sustainable tourism while prior-
cators for GBV.
itizing environmental protection and conser-
Think regionally! Not only when it comes to vation of its vast biodiversity. Advances must
health care, many of the capacities in border involve sustainable energy independence to
areas could be strategically shared if designed allow for increased productivity in many sec-
using a regional approach. As to the pandem- tors, while also bridging the digital divide.
ic, joint testing capacity, data analysis and Substantial investment in human develop-
treatment, especially in border regions, could ment and the delivery of basic public servic-
be leveraged The lens of regional integration es including health, education, and justice are
and cross-border cooperation needs to be ap- fundamental.
23
The ideas and opinions expressed in this report are the
sole responsibility of its authors and do not necessarily
reflect the position or views of the United Nations.