Large - Wire-Crimping-Whitepaper-Eng

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

LARGE CABLE, LARGE PROBLEMS

Considerations for Innovation in the Large Cable Market

Introduction Current Landscape of the BEV Market


Electric vehicles are predicted to be the next wave of innovation The large cable markets are constantly evolving. Take the EV
for the automotive market. Based on predictions from Morgan market as a clear example of the changing landscape:
Stanley in 2017, as the technology matures, the electrical vehicle
EVs are not yet widely purchased, compared to ICE vehicles but the
market will surge with an inflection point around 2035. By offerings are growing rapidly. 50 new BEVs were brought to market
2050, 4 out of 5 cars sold worldwide will be battery-electric in 2019. A growing proportion of these vehicles have been designed
vehicles (BEV) and the BEV fleet may equal the Internal from the ground up for an electric drive train rather than converting
Combustion Engine (ICE) fleet for the first time just before existing models. The vehicles come from 35+ Brands, not only
existing brands but also new players to the market.
2050. To make this growth a reality, large wire crimping is
becoming a larger focus of the wire harness industry. The expanse of the available EV landscape is creating an equally
expansive ferrule and terminal offering. For harness makers, unique
ELECTRIC VEHICLE FUTURE
tooling challenges are emerging with the existence of so many
styles available with larger sizes and shapes varying widely based
on functionality and market.

This whitepaper will look at the challenges involved in preparing


and terminating both copper and aluminum stranded high
voltage cables, specifically for the Electric Vehicle (EV) market.

Defining What is Considered a Large Cable


Cables can be generally classified into three sizes: Small
wire, which is anything less than or equal to 1mm2 (18 While the market share for EV’s currently represents less than 3%
AWG), Mid-size: 1mm2 (18 AWG) - 10mm2 (7 AWG) and of global sales, industry experts do predict that EV sales are on
Large Cables: > 10 mm2 (6 AWG). the rise thanks to continual technological advancements which
These large diameter cables are used widely throughout are closing the gap in price and functionality of EV’s compared to
the transportation industry in Automotive, Aerospace, traditional ICEs. On a single charge, highway-rated EV’s can now
Light & Heavy Rail, Energy storage, Battery Systems, and travel from 128km (80 miles) to over 482km (300 miles).
more.
However, consumers are held back by high upfront costs, range
anxiety, battery safety, long charging times, and charging
availability. All items that will need to be addressed for wide
acceptance.

>6 AWG 7 - 18 AWG <= 18 AWG

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER


A PRIMER ON LARGE WIRE CRIMPING

High Voltage Shielded Cable Prep Steps to Prep Shielded High Voltage Cables
In addition to BEV’s, there are Hybrid Electric Vehicles (HEVs) Challenge: “Footballing”
and Plug-in Hybrid Electric Vehicles (PHEVs) coming to the
HEMS cabling is stored and cut from large
market. Although they are not entirely electric, they are built
heavy spools. Due to its large size, deformation
with highly electrified drivetrains in addition to a conventional
(footballing) of the wire end often occurs when
ICE. PHEVs generally can drive exclusively on battery electric
cut. Footballing of the wire interferes with the
power for around 40 miles before needing to switch to gas or
crimping process due to difficulty stripping
recharge. According to industry projections, 50% of new cars
cable that is not perfectly round and sliding components
sold by 2030 will have electrified powertrains.
over the wire. For proper termination, and to prevent tooling
Shown below is a breakdown displaying the use of large cables for damage, operators must confirm that the wire ends are
the drive train systems of electric propulsion systems. reshaped before stripping cables and crimping terminals.

Challenge: Outer Jacket

Made of a heavy silicon-based material, the outer jacket


holds on to debris making it difficult to keep clean and
crimp properly. Operators must minimize the amount of
insulation tearing along with balancing their cut GOOD
depth to minimize damage to the underlying
braiding while stripping the outer jacket.

Challenge: Foil Shield

EV’s require the addition of shielding to


reduce radio frequency and electromagnetic
interference (RFI/EMI). In most cases the
shielding is made up of a plastic backed foil
that is wrapped around a tinned copper braided BAD
shield. The foil must be completely removed before
There is overlap between HEV/PHEVs and BEVs but the
terminating the braided shield to confirm that it does not
higher current requirements of electric only drivetrains
interfere with the connection to the crimped ferule.
require the largest cables.

As the cables grow in size, so do the challenges involved in Challenge: Tinned Copper Braiding
preparing them for termination.
Due to the dangerous levels of electricity in the GOOD
HEMs cables are specially designed to shield electronics, powertrain of EV cables, high voltage cabling for EV’s
antennas, and sensors within a vehicle from high voltage require a rigid protective cover to minimize damage
interference produced throughout the electrified drivetrain. caused by vehicle collisions. A tinned copper braiding
The five layer cable used in cars, trucks and busses comes provides this durable and difficult to cut protective
with unique requirements due to the structure of the cable. shield. Operators must cleanly cut the braided
shielding without damaging the underlying insulation
below. To avoid short circuits, electrical interference
Cross Section of a Shielded High Voltage Cable and other electrical hazards, special care must be
made to confirm that no braiding strands come into
contact with the crimped ferule or terminal.
Outer Insulation BAD

Foil Shield To expose the silicone-based inner insulation the


braiding must be flared to allow for crimping of the ferule.
Braid Shield
Many terminals require the braiding to be unwoven. This is
Inner Insulation
often a slow manual task that requires finger protection.
Conductor

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER


A PRIMER ON LARGE WIRE CRIMPING

Challenge: Inner Jacket Challenge: Crimp Force

The inner jacket is typically made up of a As cable size increases, so does the crimp force
GOOD
second layer of a silicone-based material. required to terminate it. For small wire sizes you
Its main purpose is to shield the electrical are likely to see forces below 3,000 lbf. For mid-
current from the tinned-copper braiding. It size wires, forces are generally below 10,000 lbf.
must be stripped in a similar fashion to the
For large wire sizes, forces continue to rise with some
external jacket. Damage to the conductor
95mm2 cable terminations requiring greater than
must be minimized for proper crimp
30,000 lbf to terminate. As current requirements
performance. If the wire is not concentric
increase, and 120mm2 cable becomes more common,
due to manufacturing or processing, it
we will likely see forces approaching 40,000 lbf.
makes it much more difficult to strip the
insulation without damaging the conductor.
Challenge: Clocking
The edge of the insulation must be clean
enough to not affect termination. The clocking of the terminal
on the cable is important.
Missing strands reduce the overall cross BAD
For very long leads you
sectional area and insulation nibs that end
have some give in the
up in the crimp barrel affect hitting the appropriate
cable, but for shorter leads
crimp height. In both cases, the poorly stripped inner
and asymmetric terminals,
insulation can have many negative effects on a termination
the terminals will need to
affecting both mechanical strength and conductivity.
be installed in the proper
orientation compared
to the termination on the other end of the cable.

Challenge: Extrusion

All terminals extrude slightly during the crimping


process. This varies based on material and size. A mid-
Example of folded
sized cable of 5mm2 will generally extrude less than
braiding
1.5mm during termination. Conversely, 70mm2 cable
can extrude as much as 5mm. Die sets are designed to
In some cases, the foil braiding must be folded to allow
allow for and control extrusion but these features are
for crimping of the ferule. This is ferule dependent and
only effective when the die set is loaded as intended.
proper folding relies highly on proper cut length and
flaring in earlier processing steps.

Crimping Challenges
The crimping process for large wire applications is similar
to small and mid-sized wires, except the terminals are
largely loose piece. This requires open guarding on the
crimping machine allowing operator access to the die
set and terminal loading during each cycle. Care must
be taken to prevent additional components on the wire
entering the crimp area. Terminations must be to the
terminal application specification for terminals to conduct 5mm for a
as expected. Many issues may occur during the crimping 70mm2 cable
process, and this white paper will explore them in detail.

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER


A PRIMER ON LARGE WIRE CRIMPING

Challenge: Cracking Automation Challenge: High Mix/Low Volume

Cracking of the terminal is a big concern for large As new EV’s rapidly enter the market, new and frequent product
cable terminations and can decrease the durability developments from OEM’s enter the mix. New terminals, ferrules
of a crimp. Cracking can occur when deviating from and wire shielding developments are widening the existing high
the terminal specification such as: over crimping, voltage landscape, constantly evolving wire prep and crimping
using an inappropriate cable size, and using a requirements. The wide mix of terminal shapes, sizes, and crimping
machine that crimps at an inappropriate speed. requirements (terminals and ferrules) make it more difficult to
Cracking prevention by following the application offset equipment and setup costs with automated equipment.
specification is very important as cracking is only
visible with cross sectioning of the terminal.
High Mix/Low Volume

Challenge: Multi-conductor Assemblies

Multiconductor assemblies are common in the


automotive market, especially for battery to battery
connections. Multiple conductors are wrapped in
Automation Challenge: Time & Cost
a single outer insulation or connected together by
additional components. Due to limited break out It’s not only the cables that are getting larger. Many small wire
length and bend radius, care must be taken to properly terminals can be bought for less than $0.50/piece (USD), and in
terminate these cables. In some situations, special large quantities, you can be looking at only a few cents. Large
die sets are required as the standard die sets do not wire terminations can run from a few dollars to greater than
allow for crimping without damaging the assembly. $90 depending on capacity and quantity. The cable itself is
also expensive, running at more than $30/meter. Large wires
can double or triple the crimp time due to wire management.
All of these costs together can make setup many times more
expensive so care must be taken to design and use processes
that reduce the amount of scrap and non-value added steps.

Time Vs. Cost

Automation Difficulties
Unlike small and mid-size wire applications that can be
run by the hundreds or thousands per hour on semi-
automatic and fully automatic lead makers, EV cables are
too heavy and complex to be run on existing high-volume
machines.

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER


A PRIMER ON LARGE WIRE CRIMPING

Automation Challenge: Lead Length & Weight Aluminum Vs. Copper Conductors
50mm2: 2 meters = 1.3 kg (6.5’ and 2.9 lbs) Beyond automation, there are other ways that the industry is trying
to reduce costs while improving products. Moving to aluminum
0.35mm2: 2 meters = less than 10 g cables is one such strategy. Emission and fuel consumption
standards are getting tighter in many markets around the globe
The weight of large wires makes it
as climate change has started to worry many governments. One
unsafe to create large bundles of
of the major ways to reduce both emissions and consumption
leads as they could quickly become unmanageable
is to reduce weight. Aluminum is lighter and less costly than
for workers. In some cases, leads may be as long as
copper leading it to be the next viable choice for Original
a bus or train carriage and the limited bend radius
Equipment Manufacturers. These weight savings can be applied
of these cables dictate a large storage area.
to both ICE and BEV vehicles alike although the increased large
gauge cabling in BEVs will likely lead to higher weight savings
Automation Challenge: Additional Assemblies in that market. Aluminum comes with its own challenges, but
aluminum terminations are already used in some markets.
Ferrules, connectors, housings, and seals often need to be
placed onto the wire
Aluminum Vs. Copper Challenge: Ultrasonic Welding
before crimping. In some
cases, they need to be Many current applications also use ultrasonic welding which is slow,
put on before stripping has high capital cost, is sensitive to wire surface quality, requires large
the wire to prevent amounts of energy for large cables, has a post sealing requirement
damage to the conductor strands. to prevent corrosion, and may also need Secondary strain relief.
Although not impossible as seal
kits are available for automatic
termination, the number of
components and their complexity
would greatly increase the cost and
difficulty of an automated setup. Example of ultrasonically welded cables

Automation Challenge: Traceability Aluminum Vs. Copper Challenge: Reduced Conductivity

Traceability is an important part of any quality system. Aluminum is not a direct drop in replacement for copper. Aluminum
With the modularity required within automation, a robust is 40% less conductive than copper so to have the same conductivity,
traceability system allows for the tracking of a product you must go one wire size larger. This reduces your weight savings
through the assembly line. After completion, it allows for from 70% down to 49%. In the case of existing designs, care needs
quality control to confirm the appropriate equipment was to be taken to confirm there is enough room for the larger wire.
used, such as the die set, and also the important metrics
were maintained, such as crimp height and termination
Aluminum Vs. Copper Challenge: Lower Strength
speed. To achieve this, proper labeling of each assembly
is key. Using a wire marking system provides an easy to Aluminum has a lower strength than copper with a tensile
automate method to identify each piece produced. In the strength of only 38% that of copper. It can be alloyed but that
event of a quality issue, this information narrows down reduces conductivity, and the one-size-up rule does not resolve
the other assemblies which may have been effected the reduced strength. This lower
reducing costs and effort required to resolve the matter. strength can lead to strand fatigue,
such as necking and breaks.

It can also cause stripping difficulties as


the individual strands are more fragile
and prone to damage. To prevent metal
fatigue, extra strain relief and supports
must be used for this type of cable.

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER


A PRIMER ON LARGE WIRE CRIMPING

Aluminum Vs. Copper Challenge: Oxide Film Crimping Challenge: Crimp Height

Aluminum reacts spontaneously Terminals are designed to balance electrical and mechanical
with water and/or air to form performance within their crimp height range. Crimping at an improper
aluminum oxide. Aluminum oxide, crimp height setting can cause missed strands, higher temperature
Al2O3, forms a stable passive changes during load, shorter life, and a higher risk of failure.
layer that protects aluminum from
corrosion or further oxidation. Crimp Height & Reduced Conductivity
This layer is about 4 nm thick and
will provide corrosion protection
as long as this oxide layer is stable. The drawback is that
an oxide film is non-conductive. Increasing the number
of strands in an EV application requires more oxide
to break up. If not, middle strands contribute little to
conductivity. Low twist wires maximize flexibility but
minimize differential surface scrubbing between strands,
increasing the difficulty of removing the oxide layer.

Automation Challenge: Galvanic Corrosion

Galvanic corrosion is the electrochemical process in which


one metal corrodes preferentially when it is in electrical
contact with another, in the presence of an electrolyte. Crimping Challenge: Cross Sections
Aluminum is highly prone to galvanic corrosion, meaning
It is important to check for proper crimping throughout your
additional steps are needed
production run. If not using an automated crimp quality device,
to maintain a closed design
it is important to confirm the crimp profile with cross sections at
to prevent water egress
the interval dictated by either industry standard or by the terminal
into the wire harness.
manufacturer. Cross
sectioning requires
the terminal to be
Importance of Proper Crimping
cut through the
No matter the wire size, to confirm success, proper wire barrel after
crimp quality fundamentals need to be followed. crimping. This
process allows for the inspection of proper crimp height,
compression, and more. Due to its destructive nature, it
Crimping Challenge: Short Circuits
can’t be used on crimps destined for assemblies.
Loose strands, from the braid or conductor can become
stuck to the insulation and seal. If not removed before Crimping Challenge: Excessive Electromagnetic Interference
assembly, these strands can
Improper care with the braiding may lead to interference from
come loose and short two or
the high voltage drivetrain, such as radio interference, and
more terminals. Due to the
unexpected operation of equipment. As cars contain more sensing
high voltage of these systems,
equipment as well, much of which is safety equipment, preventing
this can cause tripped fuses
interference transitions from a cosmetic issue to one of safety.
or even system failure.

Crimping Challenge: Water Egress

Improper treatment of the seals may reduce seal integrity


shortening the life of the termination and the overall assembly.
Seals can be damaged by chemicals, improper storage
environment (temperature, humidity, light), and mishandling.

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER


A PRIMER ON LARGE WIRE CRIMPING

Crimping Challenge: Proper Tool Maintenance Tooling Options: Manual Hydraulic Tools

As with all tools, crimping equipment must be Manual hydraulic tools require no power supply to crimp the terminal.
properly maintained. Please follow all information They rely on the operator to manually
contained in the instruction sheets provided with pump the tool multiple times to build up
your equipment to confirm long life and quality. enough hydraulic pressure to complete the
crimp. Depending on cable size, they can
weigh more than 40lbs. The ergonomics
Large Cables: Aerospace & Industrial of this arrangement are less than ideal due
While this paper focused mainly on the challenges of large to the weight of the tools and because
wire crimping in the automotive market, large cabling is of this, they are generally better for small runs and repair work.
used in the Energy, Aerospace and Industrial markets as
well. While the standard tooling in these markets vary Tooling Options: Battery Hydraulic Tools
from the transportation segment, due to cable sizes and
Battery hydraulic tools are good options for some of the smaller
weights, similar challenges exist in these markets. cable sizes and range from 4 – 12 tons of crimp force. Battery
electric tools are much lighter and easier to manage by one person
Large Cable Challenge: Stiff Cabling while also allowing for a less manual operation without the need
to provide AC power to the crimping location. They allow for extra
Non automotive markets use high twist and large stranded control and hold in place even if a battery dies during the crimp.
cable which are very stiff. This makes them This allows for a replacement battery to be installed and the crimp
difficult to work with as you often need to completed without any sacrifice to quality. Because the batteries are
reorient your tool instead of your cable. The interchangeable, there is no need to wait for the tool to charge as you
spools must also be larger to accommodate
can charge a separate battery while working.
the large bend radius requirements.
Because these tools do not require
Most of these cables can be stripped by
manual pumping, they can help to reduce
hand but large cable strippers greatly
repeated stress injuries that may arise with
reduce the effort and time it takes to
the overuse of manual portable tools.
process the cable. As with automotive
cable, care must be taken to minimize Tooling Options: Electric Hydraulic Tools
deformation and damage of the conductor. Some
Aerospace cables often have a thin but durable insulation. Electric hydraulic tools can achieve the highest forces, up to 33 tons.
Although possible, it is laborious to strip by hand and often The most common pressure is 8200 psi but 10,000 psi heads also
requires laser stripping equipment to process efficiently. exist. Different heads are designed to run either U-dies or shank
dies, the latter allowing for higher loads. When used in an airframe,
Tooling Options for High Force the use of these tools becomes a two person task, with one person
holding the tool in place and another locating the cable and terminal.
Large cable portable tools are normally hydraulic as manual The heads are designed to use TE hydraulic pumps and some can
linkage tools would require too much human input to be used with battery powered versions for more portability.
complete a crimp. They allow for the tool to be brought
to the cable, such as in an airframe or at the top of an Although multiple heads can be used with the same pump, please
electrical pole, allowing for a cable to be threaded through always be sure that you are using the recommended pump with
an assembly before preparing and crimping. Additional the appropriate pressure to confirm quality and safety.
safety training on the appropriate treatment of high pressure
devices with hydraulic pressure ranging from 8200 psi Tooling Options: Benchtop Termination
to 10,000 psi is required to use this equipment safely.
Crimping of large cable with benchtop terminators is similar to small and
These tools use interchangeable U and Shank dies allowing mid sized cable but the terminals are largely loose piece. This means that
for one tool to crimp multiple different cable assemblies. you must open the guarding of the machine you
They come in three varieties, Manual, Battery, and Electric. are using to access the die set to load in the next
terminal. Care must be taken to prevent additional
components on the cable from entering the die set.

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER


SUMMARY TE CONNECTIVITY
Large wire crimping presents a unique set of challenges, FIELD SERVICE
but harness makers can overcome these challenges with the
help of the right application tooling partner. TE Connectivity SERVICES
works diligently to maximize the quality of its tooling so wire
Standard Service VALUE-ADDED
harness manufacturers can produce the best crimps. SERVICES
• Includes
Here are six keys to high quality large wire crimps:
troubleshooting and Preventive
1. Use only high quality tooling making repairs Maintenance and/
or Inspection
High quality tooling includes the applicator, terminator, crimper, Equipment Installation Certification
and anvil. The applicator must be easy to set up and must
• Providing installation, • Provides service for
maintain consistent quality. Users must select a crimper and anvil
set-up and training periodic visits to
designed and manufactured for initial quality as well as longevity.
at time of equipment perform Preventive
2. Set up the applicator properly delivery Maintenance and/or
Inspection Certification
Users must properly load the terminal into the die set and the crimp Training Service on hand tools,
height must be setup correctly to match the terminal specifications. applicators and bench
• Basic Crimp Theory
equipment. Inspection
3. Understand Proper Cable Prep
• Hand tool, applicator of the finished product
High voltage cables require a much more involved and equipment set-up, is made to confirm it
process to confirm proper termination. Understanding the operation and meets TE application
makeup of your cable assembly is critical to success. maintenance specifications.
Documentation is
4. Multi-part Assembly Process available upon request
for traceability to
High voltage cable assemblies have many parts that need to be
support your facilities’
completed in order. Proper preparation and the right tooling will
quality system
speed up production, allowing you to stay efficient and profitable.
requirements.
5. Process is the Key to Quality

Creating a standardized process will maximize your efficiency.

te.com
Contact us today to learn more
TE Connectivity, TE Connectivity (logo) and EVERY CONNECTION COUNTS are trademarks. All other logos,
products and/or company names referred to herein might be trademarks of their respective owners. North America (US, Mexico and Canada)

The information given herein, including drawings, illustrations and schematics which are intended for illustration • Wire processing equipment:
purposes only, is believed to be reliable. However, TE Connectivity makes no warranties as to its accuracy or 800-722-1111 or 717-810-3434
completeness and disclaims any liability in connection with its use. TE Connectivity‘s obligations shall only be
• Board processing equipment:
as set forth in TE Connectivity‘s Standard Terms and Conditions of Sale for this product and in no case will TE
888-782-3349 or 610-893-9680
Connectivity be liable for any incidental, indirect or consequential damages arising out of the sale, resale, use
E-mail: fieldservicesnorthamerica@te.com
or misuse of the product. Users of TE Connectivity products should make their own evaluation to determine the
suitability of each such product for the specific application. • Web: www.te.com/fieldservice

© 2019 TE Connectivity Ltd. family of companies All Rights Reserved. For locations outside North America visit tooling.te.com

8/19 www.te.com/fieldservice

APPLICATION TOOLING /// LARGE CABLES LARGE PROBLEMS WHITE PAPER

You might also like