Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Study On Efficiency of Passive Cooling Strategies On Thermal Comfort Attainment Within Tropical Climate
Study On Efficiency of Passive Cooling Strategies On Thermal Comfort Attainment Within Tropical Climate
net/publication/275768895
CITATIONS READS
2 2,640
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Potential of Wall Cladding as Rainwater Harvesting System for Multistorey Buildings View project
Experimental study on thermal performance of a large office building with natural ventilation in the tropics View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Ardalan Aflaki on 23 May 2015.
Abstract
One of the imperative functions through the design of built environment which have been considered
by scholars is thermal comfort. It is defined as the sensation of well-being of an individual and
condition of mind which explain satisfaction in particular environment. Achievement of this
environment is affected by air and radiant temperature, relative humidity and air velocity. Although,
there are numerous studies related to thermal comfort and thermal sensation in different climates to
appoint comfort zone for occupants, limited researches have been implemented on strategies to
achieve comfortable indoor environment. Passive cooling strategies have been applied recently
through primary stage of building design in tropical climate whilst reduction of operation costs,
preparing satisfactory thermal comfort and prevention from climate changes will be attained. Based
on these studies, further investigations on various passive cooling strategies are carried out in this
paper to finalize the relevant strategy for thermal comfort achievement within tropical climate. In
particular, this research looks into related review of literature and their significant results to suggest
more effective and adequate cooling strategies that would reduce the high amount of temperature and
humidity in tropical climate. Results from these findings would be useful for designing architectural
elements in new buildings within hot-humid climate hence reducing the energy consumption and the
amount of green gas emission.
Keywords: comfort zone, energy efficiency, passive cooling strategies, thermal comfort, tropical
climate
1. INTRODUCTION
Today‘s, demand for high amounts of energy for cooling and heating of buildings is not avoidable.
High consumption of fossil energy especially in developing countries makes complicated challenge
namely as global warming, air pollution and carbon distribution which may be as a constraint for
human life due to obvious consequences on the environment. According to these challenges,
attempts are done in different scales to deduce cooling and heating load in whole of the world. Under
design and construction zone, bioclimatic design, utilizing renewable energy and passive design
strategies have been considered as the main solution for the decrease of environmental load by
scholars recently. Passive design strategies which are applicable solution at the first stage of
designing process is the main concern of this research. The most effective passive design techniques
for confrontation with harsh climate are reviewed in this study to finalize the best ways to reduce
energy consumption within tropical climate.
As explained by Martin (1989; ref.Cook 1989, p.139), radiative cooling is a long process during the
day while the heat is absorbed by building materials and then during the nighttime when the weather
is more cooler, the heat radiate to the sky in the form of infrared radiation. Based on field studies in
different climates, it is found that this strategy is more efficient in hot-arid climate where the
temperature swings between day and night is more considerable. For hot and humid climate, high
amount of humidity and cloud cover in the sky decrease the rate of heat transfer and most of the time
heat trap inside the building and cause uncomfortable thermal condition. Evaporate cooling is
another sufficient technique which is used by designers in hot-arid climate. Unfortunately the high
amounts of humidity in tropical climate persist against application of this strategy. Yellot (1989; ref.
Cook 1989, p.85) claimed that evaporate cooling effectively work when the tangible heat in air
stream is changed for the latent heat of water droplets or wetted surfaces. However, in hot-humid
climate, firstly there is need to remove moisture from indoor environment where it condenses into air
or even on surfaces and then apply air velocity from outdoor to achieve applicable evaporation and
bring sensible thermal comfort for residence.
Refer to Balaras in 1996; all strategies to avoid building from solar radiation can be included into
heat avoidance techniques. Appropriate shading especially for apertures, building orientation,
vegetation surrounding building and relevant materials for façade is some intelligent strategies to
prepare comfortable indoor temperature. These strategies are applicable in different climate and they
are suggested for tropical climate where high amount of solar radiation is not preventable.
According to Kenneth Labs (1989; ref. Cook 1989, p.197), in earth-coupled buildings the indoor
spaces is thermally coupled into the subsoil by conduction and convection through the building slabs.
In this technique, the earth acts as a heat sink and gains overall heating from indoor environment.
However, the main priority for application of earth-coupling technique is earth temperature range.
This strategy is more applicable where the earth temperature in comfort zone (Labs, 1989). It is
applied in temperate climate where earth temperature is within the range of standard comfort zone
(ASHRAE, 1998). Although this technique is more sufficient in temperate climate, there is no
research on application of this strategy in tropical climate such as Malaysia.
Based on Abrams research back in 1986, cooling effect in ventilation cooling strategy occurs by
means of convection regarding surrounding air as a heat sink. Ventilation cooling has been
established in design of building in tropical climate to create at least more tolerable indoor
environment if not perfectly comfortable. Review of studies show that thermal comfort in tropical
climate can be achieved by application of ventilation cooling. Based on Chandra‘s claim, air
exchanges at 5-500 air changes per hour is necessary to comply thermal comfort within building
(Chandra, 1989). Refer to literatures, it can be realized that heat avoidance and use of natural
ventilation for cooling are more applicable and feasible to attain indoor thermal comfort in hot and
humid climate. This implies that reducing building surfaces perpendicular to solar radiation and
applying natural ventilation system in buildings are the main design strategies to decrease the
humidity and temperature levels hence reducing the demands for energy usage. Due to these matters,
the performance of these techniques, their applicability and efficiency will be reviewed at the
following parts.
3.1.1 Orientation
Thomas and Garnham (2007) declared that building orientation is the most effective passive
strategies and should be defined based on prevailing wind and sun angle. In different study in
tropical climate by La Roche et al. (2001), it is found that building must avoid large apertures on the
east and west where it receives approximately twice amount of radiation in compare to north and
south elevation. (Figure 3.1)
3.1.2Building Form
Rectangular plan alongside east-west is inevitable alternative in the tropics where designers should
limit the exposure on east and west sides (Konya, 1980). Furthermore, shallow floor plan is more
efficient where it encourages more air-flow inside the building (Tombazis and Preuss, 2001).
4. NATURAL VENTILATION
4.1 Natural Ventilation and its Efficiency
―As advantages of using natural ventilation through built environment‖, reduction of energy
consumption and green gasses emissions have been mentioned by Kubota et. al in 2006. Furthermore,
it raises the degree of thermal comfort in indoor and outdoor environment. Another study regarding
to usage of fresh air in buildings indicates that greater occupant control and high level of
environmental quality can be achieved in compare to mechanical ventilation by application of natural
ventilation in design of residential buildings (de Dear & Brager 1998). Comparing study on health
cost saving between natural and mechanical ventilation shows that it will be rised up to 18% by
prevailing usages of natural ventilation in mixed mode systems (Brager & Borgeson & Lee 2007).
Study through office buildings by Fisk (2002) shows that sick building condition can be decreased
by intensifying use of fresh air and it saves US$10 billion to US$30 billion in the USA (Fisk, 2002).
This concept is similar to residential building where studies indicates that high indoor air quality and
thermal comfort improvement can be achieved by application of fresh natural ventilation in
residential blocks (CHPS, 2002). As the benefits of natural ventilation, compromising operation
costs reduction, preparing satisfactory thermal comfort and modifying indoor air quality, are realized,
applying natural ventilation as a passive cooling strategy of buildings has become a significant
opportunity to improve associated issues with artificial cooling buildings (Wang, Wong Nyuk, & Li,
2007).
literatures, single side ventilation and night ventilation can decrease the cooling needs by 30% if the
apertures are located in relevant part of windward side. Study by E. Gratia et al in 2004 shows that
the combination of these design strategies can reduce cooling requirements more than 40% per unit.
Study on natural ventilation design for house in Thailand was conducted to evaluate air-rate, size of
apertures, form and orientation of house in specific climate to achieve thermal comfort. Thermal
comfort and climate analysis with CFD simulation model was carried out to realize optimum site
planning and design in tropical climate. The result shows that an indoor air velocity of .04m/s may
be improved indoor thermal comfort. Furthermore, it indicates that the total area of inlet and outlet
apertures must be 40% of the total floor area roughly. Simulation program has evaluated different
conditions and clarify that ceiling fan should be used to rise up air velocity while the total size of
apertures is reduced to 25%. This study also claims that the main orientation of building may not be
to prevailing orientation which is NEE or SSW in Thailand. Simulation results indicate that north-
south direction of building could acquire more ventilation while it avoids excessive solar radiation.
Coupled with orientation, study suggests square form to enhance better ventilation in compare to
rectangular form according to land lots and house floor area values (Tantasavasdi, Srebric, & Chen,
2001).
Givoni (1994) studied on application of natural ventilation and it impacts on high mass buildings in
California. He declared that, night ventilation accompanying with exhausted fan present more
comfortable indoor environment in high mass buildings in compare to low mass building in tropical
climate (Givoni, 1998). Another study on efficiency of night ventilation in hot-humid climate was
done by field measurement. Findings shows that night ventilation strategy can be decrease indoor
temperature by 2.5 C and it may be more suitable if evaporate cooling is applied during day time
(Kubota, Chyee, & Ahmad, 2009). Study on application of natural ventilation in high density
building was carried out to propose an ideal model for reducing environmental load. Field
experiment and CFD simulation was established to evaluate reduction of CO2 emission by
application of natural ventilation in different design models. Results show that it can be reduced
CO2 emission at running stage by 30% and for whole life cycle of building by 22% when high
ventilation is enhanced by ideal porous-design models (Murakami, Kato, Ooka, & Shiraishi, 2004).
In Malaysia, study by Nugroho AM et al. (2007) shows that the application of solar chimney in
terrace houses can increase the amount of air velocity up to .058 m/s. the research on solar chimney
in southern Spain revealed air velocity of 3 m/s can be achieved inside the building if it is designed
in proper size (5.6 m total height, 1.0 m wide and 0.3 m air gap width). Furthermore, results from the
potential of solar induce ventilation investigated in multi story buildings in Thailand reveals that
room temperature is 5k lower than the other buildings without this (Punyasompun et al. 2009).
Due to efficiency of solar induce ventilation; the strategy was applied with other passive cooling
techniques in other researches to evaluate degree of air velocity (Bansal et al. 1994, Chungloo S et al.
2007). Roof solar collector integrated with wind tower was examined in study by Bansal et al. (1994)
in hot and humid climate. The model increased the air flow rate up to 1.4 kg/s which was twice more
in compare to wind tower alone. In study by Chungloo and Limmeechokchai (2007), roof solar
collector combined with wetted ceiling for deducting indoor air temperature. Room temperature was
decreased by about 1k to 3.5k when the roof solar collector was established alone. However, the
mixture of both strategies decreased the room temperature up to 2k to 6.2k. Because of this potential,
Chungloo and Limmeechokchai (2007) combined cool ceiling with the roof solar collector. Results
show the system can reduce room temperature more than the application of roof solar collector alone.
These studies prove that solar induce ventilation can be a relevant alternative to induce the stack
ventilation in tropical climate (Bansal et al. 1994, Khedari J, et al. 2000, Chungloo S et al. 2007).
However most of the researches were investigated roof solar collector efficiency as its inclination
shape has enabled to catch more solar radiation in compare to perpendicular solar induce ventilation
systems such as Trombe wall due to higher sun altitude in tropical climate (Awbi, 2003). However,
the roof slope still is a challenge which influence on stack height in construction (Harris DJ, Helwig
N, 2007)
5. CONCLUSION
The present paper advocates application of passive cooling strategies in tropical climate in order to
achieve sufficient degree of thermal comfort. Based on previous literatures, the most effective
passive design techniques for dealing with harsh climate were reviewed and it was found that due to
high humidity and temperature levels in a building, heat avoidance and natural ventilation cooling
could be the best options to adapt comfort in indoor spaces. Due to this fact, studies on heat
avoidance strategy in tropical climate was reviewed and results indicate that orientation, building
form, opening and shading are four major design solutions to avoid building from high amount of
solar radiation in equatorial region. In addition, review on passive cooling ventilation is done to find
out relevant strategy for tropical climate. Apart from using cross ventilation to attain thermal comfort
in buildings, the application of stack ventilation in previous research also proves that this system
could be incorporated if tangible amount of indoor outdoor temperature difference occurs. Based on
these findings, a combined solar wall and roof collectors with in tropical regions would further
increase the efficiency of the stack ventilation processes. Results show that sufficient amount of air
flow can be achieved and indoor temperature decrease up to 6K (Chungloo and Limmeechokchai,
2007). Although these integrated techniques on stack ventilation respond to the microclimate well,
overall findings of this research indicate that there is no integrated study including heat avoidance
and cooling ventilation strategy to shield built environment from harsh climate. It is obvious that the
combination of these relevant strategies in primary stages of design can improve indoor temperature
more in compare to their separated application. Therefore, the combined strategy is offered for
further research to actualize better indoor condition and decrease high amount of temperature and
humidity.
6. REFERENCES
Abdul Rahman, S. (1999) Airflow and thermal comfort studies in naturally ventilated classrooms in a
school. PhD Thesis. University technology of Malaysia, Johor Bahru
Abrams, G.W. 1986. Low energy cooling; A guide to practical application of passive cooling and
cooling energy conservation measures. New York, Van Nostrand Reinhold Company
Allard, F. & Herrlin, M. (1989) Wind induced ventilation. ASHRAE transactions, 95, 722-728
ASHRAE. 1998. Cooling and Heating load calculation principles. Atlanta, GA: American Society of
heating, Refrigerating, Air conditioning Engineers
Awbi HB. Ventilation of buildings. 2nd ed. London: Spon Press; 2003. p. 313e37.
Bansal NK, Mathur R, Bhandari MS. A study of solar chimney assisted wind tower system for
natural ventilation in buildings. Building and Environment 1994;29(4):495e500.
Balaras, C. 1996. Cooling in buildings. In Santamouris, M. and D. Asimapolous, ed. Passive cooling
of building. London, UK: James and James Publisher Ltd.
B. Givoni, Passive and Low Energy Cooling of Buildings, John Willy & Sons, Inc., Canada, 1994.
B. Givoni, Climate Considerations in Building and Urban Design, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New
York, 1998.
Camille Allocca, Qingyan Chen and Leon R.Glicksman (2003). Design analysis of single-sided
natural ventilation. Energy and Buildings, 35(8), 785-795.
Chandra, S. 1989.Ventilative cooling. In Cook, J,. Ed. Passive cooling: Fundamentals and
applications. Cambridge, MA: MIT press
CHPS 2002, Indoor Environment Quality Overview, [online],
http://www.chps.net/info/presentations/IAQ.pdf (2 May 2009)
Chungloo S, Limmeechokchai B. Application of passive cooling systems in the hot and humid
climate: the case study of solar chimney and wetted roof in Thailand. Building and
Environment 2007;42(9):3341e51.
Claude-Alain Roulet and Cristian Ghiaus (2005). Specific devices for natural ventilation. In Cristian
Ghiaus & Francis Allard (Eds). Natural Ventilation in the Urban Environment: Assessment
and Design (pp. 158-167). London: Earthscan.
Cook, J., ed.1989. Passive cooling: Fundamentals and applications. Cambridge, MA: MIT press
Cristian Ghiaus and Claude-Alain Roulet (2005). Strategies for natural ventilation. In Cristian
Ghiaus & Francis Allard (Eds). Natural Ventilation in the Urban Environment: Assessment
and Design(pp. 136-157). London: Earthscan.
Dear, R.J., and G.S. Brager. 1998. Developing an adaptive model of thermal comfort and preference.
ASHRAE Transactions 104 (1).
E. Gratia, I. Bruyere and A. De Herde (2004). How to use natural ventilation to cool narrow office
buildings. Building and Environment, 39(10), 1157-1170.
Eley Associates (2004). Hawaii Commercial Building Guidelines for Energy Efficiency. State of
Hawaii: Department of Business Economic Development & Tourism (DBEDT)
Nugroho AM, Hamdan M, Ossen DR. A preliminary study of thermal comfort in Malaysia‘s single
storey terraced houses. Asian Architecture and Building Engineering 2007;182:289e96.
Punyasompun S, Hirunlabh J, Khedari J, Zeghmati B. Investigation on the application of solar
chimney for multi-storey buildings. Renewable Energy 2009;34(12):2545e61.
Rajeh M. Natural ventilation in terrace housing of Malaysia: Effect of air well on air flow and air
velocity. Master thesis, Department of Architecture, University of Queensland, Brisbane,
Australia; 1989.
S.M.Jafarian, S.M.Jaafarian, P.Haseli and M.Taheri (2010). Performance analysis of a passive
cooling system using underground channel (Naghb). Energy and Buildings, 42(5), 559-562.
Szokolay, S.V. (1980) Environmental science handbook for architects and builders, The construction
press, Lancaster.
Szokolay, S.V. (1986) Climate analysis based on the psychometric chart. International journal of
ambient energy, 7, 171-182
Tantasavasdi, C., Srebric, J., & Chen, Q. (2001). Natural ventilation design for houses in Thailand.
Energy and Buildings, 33(8), 815-824. doi: 10.1016/s0378-7788(01)00073-1
Thomas, R. & Garnham, T. (2007). The environments of architecture: Environmental design in
context. Great Britain: Taylor & Francis.
Tombazis A.N. & Preuss, S. A. (2001). Design of passive solar buildings in urban areas. Journal of
Solar Energy, 70(3), 311-318.
Wang, L., Wong Nyuk, H., & Li, S. (2007). Facade design optimization for naturally ventilated
residential buildings in Singapore. Energy and Buildings, 39(8), 954-961. doi:
10.1016/j.enbuild.2006.10.011
Yellot, J. 1989. Evaporate cooling. In Cook, J., ed. Passive cooling: fundamentals and applications.
Cambridge, MA: MIT press
Zaki, W. R. M., Nawawi, A. H. & Sh. Ahmad, S. (2007). Case study in passive architecture: energy
savings benefit in a detached house in Malaysia, Proceedings in the 24th Conference on
Passive and Low Energy Architecture, University of Singapore, 259-266.
Zaki, W. R. M., Nawawi, A. H. & Sh.Ahmad, S. (2008). Energy savings benefit from passive
architecture, Journal of Canada Centre of Science Education, 3, 51-63.