Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Handouts #5 III. Mariology
Handouts #5 III. Mariology
Handouts #5 III. Mariology
Eastern Orthodox Marilogical thought dates as far back as Saint John Damascene who in the 8th
century wrote on the mediative role of Mary and on the Dormition of the Mother of God. In the 14th
century, Orthodox Mariology began to flourish among Byzantine theologians who held a cosmic
view of Mariology, placing Jesus and Mary together at the center of the cosmos and saw them as the
goal of world history. More recently Eastern Orthodox Mariology achieved a renewal among 20th
century theologians in Russia, for whom Mary is the heart of the Church and the center of creation.
However, unlike the Catholic approach, Eastern Orthodox Mariology does not support the
Immaculate Conception of Mary. Prior to the 20th century, Eastern Orthodox Mariology was almost
entirely liturgical, and had no systematic presentation similar to Roman Catholic Mariology.
However, 20th century theologians such as Sergei Bulgakov began the development of a detailed
systematic Orthodox Mariology. Bulgakov's Mariological formulation emphasizes the close link
between Mary and the Holy Spirit in the mystery of the Incarnation.
Protestant views on Mary vary from denomination to denomination. They focus generally on
interpretations of Mary in the Bible, the "Apostles' Creed", (which professes the Virgin Birth), and
the Ecumenical Council of Ephesus, in 431, which called Mary the Mother of God. While some
early Protestants created Marian art and allowed limited forms of Marian veneration, most
Protestants today do not share the veneration of Mary practiced by Roman Catholics and Eastern
Orthodox. Martin Luther's views on Mary, John Calvin's views on Mary, Karl Barth's views on
Mary and others have all contributed to modern Protestant views. Anglican Marian theology varies
greatly, from the Anglo-Catholic (very close to Roman Catholic views) to the more Reformed
views. The Anglican Church formally celebrates six Marian feasts, Annunciation (March 25),
Visitation (May 31), Day of Saint Mary (Assumption or dormition) (August 15), Nativity of Mary
(September 8), Our Lady of Walsingham (October 15) and Mary's Conception (December 8).
Anglicans, along with other Protestants, teach the Marian dogmas of divine maternity and the virgin
birth of Jesus, although there is no systematic agreed upon Mariology among the diverse parts of the
Anglican Communion. However, the role of Mary as a mediator is accepted by some groups of
modern Anglican theologians. Lutheran Mariology is informed by the Augsburg Confession and
honours Mary as “the most blessed Mother of God, the most blessed Virgin Mary, the Mother of
Christ,” and “the Queen of Heaven.” The Smalcald Articles, a confession of faith of the Lutheran
Churches, affirm the doctrine of the perpetual virginity of Mary.
The Oriental Orthodox Churches regard Mary as the highest of saints and the Theotokos. It
celebrates various Marian feast days.
A better mutual understanding among different Christian groups regarding their Mariology has been
sought in a number of ecumenical meetings which produced common documents.
Outside Christianity, the Islamic view of the Virgin Mary, known as Maryam in Arabic, is that she
was an extremely pious and chaste woman who miraculously gave birth while still a virgin to the
prophet Jesus, known in Arabic as Isa. Mary is the only woman specifically named in the Qur'an.
The nineteenth chapter of the Qur'an, which is named after her, begins with two narrations of
"miraculous birth".
Development
The First Council of Ephesus in 431 formally approved devotion to Mary as Theotokos, which most
accurately translated means God-bearer; its use implies that Jesus, to whom Mary gave birth, is God.
Nestorians preferred Christotokos meaning "Christ-bearer" or "Mother of the Messiah" not because
they denied Jesus' divinity, but because they believed that God the Son or Logos existed before time
and before Mary, and that Jesus took divinity from God the Father and humanity from his mother, so
calling her "Mother of God" was confusing and potentially heretical. Others at the council believed
that denying the Theotokos title would carry with it the implication that Jesus was not divine.
The council of Ephesus also approved the creation of icons bearing the images of the Virgin and
Child. Devotion to Mary was, however, already widespread before this point, reflected in the fresco
depictions of Mother and Child in the Roman catacombs. The early Church Fathers saw Mary as the
"new Eve" who said "yes" to God as Eve had said no. Mary, as the first Christian Saint and Mother
of Jesus, was deemed to be a compassionate mediator between suffering mankind and her son, Jesus,
who was seen as King and Judge.
In the East, devotion to Mary blossomed in the sixth century under official patronage and imperial
promotion at the Court of Constantinople. The popularity of Mary as an individual object of
devotion, however, only began in the fifth century with the appearance of apocryphal versions of her
life, interest in her relics, and the first churches dedicated to her name, for example, S. Maria
Maggiore in Rome. A sign that the process was slower in Rome is provided by the incident during
the visit of Pope Agapetus to Constantinople in 536, when he was upbraided for opposing the
veneration of the theotokos and refusing to allow her icons to be displayed in Roman churches.
Early seventh-century examples of new Marian dedications in Rome are the dedication in 609 of the
pagan Pantheon as Santa Maria ad Martyres, "Holy Mary and the Martyrs", and the re-dedication of
the early Christian titulus Julii et Calixtii, one of the oldest Roman churches, as Santa Maria in
Trastevere. The earliest Marian feasts were introduced into the Roman liturgical calendar by Pope
Sergius I (687-701).
During Middle Ages, devotion to the Virgin Mary as the "new Eve" lent much to the status of
women. Women who had been looked down upon as daughters of Eve, came to be looked upon as
objects of veneration and inspiration. The medieval development of chivalry, with the concept of the
honor of a lady and the ensuing knightly devotion to it, not only derived from the thinking about the
Virgin Mary, but also contributed to it. The medieval veneration of the Virgin Mary was contrasted
by the fact that ordinary women, especially those outside aristocratic circles, were looked down
upon. Although women were at times viewed as the source of evil, it was Mary who as mediator to
God was a source of refuge for man. The development of medieval Mariology and the changing
attitudes towards women paralleled each other and can best be understood in a common context.
Since the Reformation, some Protestants accuse Roman Catholics of having developed an un-
Christian adoration and worship of Mary, described as Marianism or Mariolatry, and of inventing
non-scriptural doctrines which give Mary a semi-divine status. They also attack titles such as Queen
of Heaven, Our Mother in Heaven, Queen of the World, or Mediatrix.
Since the writing of the apocryphal Protevangelium of James, various beliefs have circulated
concerning Mary's own conception, which eventually led to the Roman Catholic Church dogma,
formally established in the 19th century, of Mary's Immaculate Conception, which exempts her from
original sin.
Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox teaching also extends to the end of Mary's life ending with
the Assumption of Mary, formally established as dogma in 1950, and the Dormition of the Mother
of God respectively.
Pledged obedience under the covenant Pledged obedience under the covenant
Eve's disobedience resulted in the fall into sin of Mary's obedience to God resulted in the offer of the
the entire human race. The result was death, gift of salvation to the entire human race. The
physically and spiritually. result was eternal life
Eve's name means the "mother of all living" and Mary is the "mother of all who truly live" when, at
indeed all of humanity is descended through her. the cross, Jesus gave His mother to the Church as
the Mother of all who come to receive Jesus as
Savior and Lord and therefore receive the gift of
eternal life.
From the Annunciation to the Crucifixion of her Son, Mary can be seen as God's ultimate validation
of free will. The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that the Virgin Mary's obedience to the
will of God as conveyed to her in the angel Gabriel's message was no less voluntary in its
affirmation than the disobedience of the virgin Eve had been in its negation.
From the first moment of the angel Gabriel's announcement that of all women born, she had been
chosen to bear the "promised seed" [Luke 1:26-38], to Simeon's prophecy of her suffering [Luke
2:33-35], to witnessing her Son's Passion on the Cross [John 19:26], Mary submitted herself
completely to God plan for her life. The Fathers of the Church saw her as the model Christian. St.
Irenaeus praises her above all women when he writes, "Being obedient she became the cause of
salvation for herself and for the whole human race. [...]. The knot of Eve's disobedience was untied
by Mary's obedience: what the virgin Eve bound through her disbelief, Mary loosened by her faith."
[St. Irenaeus, Against Heresies, III.22.4]. And comparing her humility and obedience with Eve's
rebellion and disobedience St. Jerome writes of her, "Death through Eve, life through Mary." [St.
Jerome as quoted in the Catechism #494].
In addition to the title of the "new Eve" the Virgin Mary is also acknowledged by the titles "The Ark
of the New Covenant," "The Mother of the Church," "The Lady of the Rosary," and "Our
Mediatrix."
The Virgin Mary is the Church's inheritance from the cross of Jesus Christ. At the very end of His
life Jesus entrusted His mother into the care of the "beloved disciple" and at the same time
announced that the "beloved disciple" became a child of Mary, at this moment in salvation history,
St. John became the representative of all the beloved disciples of Jesus' New Covenant Church. This
is the birth of the Christian family at the foot of the cross. Jesus has given Mary the maternal care of
John and all faithful disciples in her Son's Church. This is Mary's spiritual motherhood "in order of
grace" according to Vatican II (Lumen Gentium, 61,62). It is in this sense of her spiritual
motherhood that the Church has continued to honor Mary from the earliest years of the Church. The
sacramentary Collection of Masses of the Blessed Virgin Mary contains 46 Masses, twelve of which
first appeared during the Marian Year observed by the Church from Pentecost 1987, through the
Feast of the Assumption, August 15, 1988. Three of these Masses are dedicated to "The Blessed
Virgin Mary, Image and Mother of the Church."
The following are some events of salvation history which are a prophetic reference Mary or show
Mary's active participation in the redemption of mankind and which are a good summing up for us
on this topic of Mary, Mother of the Church.
1. The Protoevangelium: Mary is the 'new Eve'. She is the fulfillment of the prophetic utterance of
Genesis 3:15 which is the first scriptural announcement of the Good News which was perfectly fulfilled
in Christ, Mary, and the Church.
2. The Incarnate Word: Mary nurtured the Church at its very beginning by giving birth to our Savior.
3. Mary as Mother is the perfect example of every Christian virtue
4. The Passion of Christ: During which Jesus made his Mother our mother also.
5. The outpouring of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost: When Mary was united in prayer with her Son's first
disciples, and thus became the perfect model of the Church at prayer.
6. The Assumption of Our Lady into heaven: From which she watches over the pilgrim Church on
earth with a mother's love until we are reunited.
The Virgin Mary: Co-Redemptrix
The title co-Redemptrix is difficult because it is too easily misinterpreted as making Mary a fellow
redeemer with Christ, which is, of course, a heresy. Jesus Christ is our sole Redeemer [1 Timothy 2:5].
It is for this reason that Vatican Council II did not see fit to encourage invoking Mary by the name or
title of Co-Redemptrix. However, using this title for Mary does not suggest that she is equal to Christ
in her role. The prefix "co" means "in cooperation with" or "to aid." This prefix does not convey the
meaning "equal to." What this title has difficulty in conveying is Mary's role as one who both
cooperates and who is completely dependent upon and subordinate to Christ as the sole Redeemer.
According to the doctrine of the divine economy of salvation, man is to cooperate in securing his
salvation and the salvation of others. In Greek economy means plan or management. When applied to
God the term refers to God's manifestations to the world of His universal gift of grace and His desire
expressed in 1 Timothy 2:4 that He desires all men to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the
truth. A Christian participates in God's plan of redemption through prayer, sorrow for sin, penance,
sacrifices, and submission to the will of God. In this participation we become co-redeemers with Christ
and the degree of our holiness determines more or less the efficacy of our work of co-redemption.
Empowered by Christ we are all mutually responsible for one another's salvation and for reaching out to
others who are not members of the Body of Christ but who are called along with us [Matthew 28:18-20;
1 Timothy 2:3-5]. Christ uses all His disciples as His ministers of grace. He works with us according
to 2 Corinthians 5:18-20 in His desire to bring all men to salvation. It stands to reason then if we can
participate as mediators in assisting Christ in bring other men and woman to salvation that we can also
participate as co-redeemers with Christ. It follows then that Mary, as the first and most holy of
Christians is the co-redeemer with special merit. From her fiat at the Annunciation, to the torturous path
to Golgotha, to her vigil at the foot of the Cross, the Virgin Mother offered herself in suffering with her
Son. She participated in our salvation then and she continues to participate through her mediation in the
redemption of the human family, serving her Son as conduit of grace and merit.
Pope Benedict XV (1914-1922) wrote of Mary's unique role in the redemption of mankind when he
offered "She renounced her mother's rights for the salvation of mankind and, as far as it depended on
her, offered her Son to placate divine justice; so we may say that with Christ she redeemed mankind."
And Pope John Paul II in his General audience of Wednesday, December 18, 1996 said: "Beginning
with Simeon's prophesy, Mary intensely and mysteriously unites her life with Christ's sorrowful
mission: she was to become her Son's faithful co-worker for the salvation of the human race."
(L'Osservatore Romano, January 1, 1997). What Pope Benedict XV, Pope John Paul II and other
theologians are saying is the Virgin Mary cooperated in our redemption under and subordinate to Christ
and that God freely willed to associate the Blessed Mother in an intimate and direct way with her Son in
the redemption of mankind.
Other quotations of Pope John Paul II expressing Mary's role as co-redemptrix:
March 31, 1985: "May Mary our Protectress, the Co-Redemptrix, to whom we offer our prayer with
great outpouring, make our desire generously correspond to the desire of the Redeemer."
October 6, 1991: "Birgitta looked to Mary as her model and support in the various moments of her life,
She spoke energetically about the divine privilege of Mary's Immaculate Conception. She
contemplated her astonishing mission as Mother of the Savior. She invoked her as the Immaculate
Conception, Our Lady of Sorrows, and Co-Redemptrix, exalting Mary's singular role in the history of
salvation and the life of Christian people." (after Mass to honor the canonization of St. Birgitta).
November 4, 1984 "To Our Lady- the Co-Redemptrix- Charles (St. Charles Borromeo) turned with
singularly revealing accents."
The title co-Redemptrix for the Virgin Mary has not been officially approved by the Magisterium of the
Roman Catholic Church, although there is an effort under way spearheaded by Catholic theologian
Mark Miravalle to have this title approved. The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith to date has
not supported this initiative.
Mary's Continuing Mission
Mary's true mission in the past and in the present is to lead us in obedience and faithfulness by her
example to her Son, Christ Jesus. It is important to understand that Mary's motherly mediation in no
way adds or takes away from her Son's unique mediation as the risen Lord in glory. Her true glory is
ever to be entirely transparent to His and to lead us by her motherly love and compassion to her beloved
Son and Savior.
On the altar of the Cross our Lord gave His Mother to the Apostle John and through him to the whole
Church. When Scripture tells us from that hour the disciple took her into his home [John 19:27] our
understanding is that John became not only the representative of the Church but also a representative of
the whole human race. Therefore, the Virgin Mary becomes mankind's spiritual mother calling all men,
as she did the servants at the wedding in the Gospel of John 2:5, to do whatever He tells you. The
wedding at Cana was the beginning of Jesus' public ministry and it was also the beginning of Mary's
role as intercessor for the human family.
Mary prayed in union with the Apostles and disciples in the Upper Room as the followers of Jesus the
Messiah, in obedience to Jesus' command, prayed 9 days for the coming of the Holy Spirit on the 10th
day the Holy Spirit came in fire to possess the New Covenant universal Church [Acts 1:13-14]. The
book of Acts of Apostles records that the leaders of the infant Church along with the entire faith
community were persevering in prayer with Mary the Mother of Jesus, and so the Church has done ever
since. Then too, in the Church has been fulfilled the Scriptural prophecy uttered by the Virgin Mary by
divine inspiration: Behold for henceforth all generations shall call me blessed [Luke 1:48]. Even
though no human being can ever pay her an honor equal to that which God has given Mary in choosing
her to be the Mother of our Savior, it is contrary to Holy Scripture as well as to all Christian tradition
and history to neglect giving Mary the honor she deserves. Mary, as our Mother, is the loving gift from
Jesus Christ to every man, woman, and child in the family of God.
My dear Students God bless you for reading comprehensively the given materials and for
answering/working the following study guide questions/activities diligently:
1. Discuss the four Marian dogmas solemnly defined by the Church and the difference between
Catholic dogma and doctrine?
3. Discuss. Why Mary is called Theotokos? Why is Mary so loved by Catholic faithful?