Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Environmental Behavior of Semi-Open Spaces in Medi
Environmental Behavior of Semi-Open Spaces in Medi
net/publication/314511639
CITATIONS READS
3 282
4 authors, including:
Aimilios Michael
University of Cyprus
71 PUBLICATIONS 244 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Innovative Methods for the Protection and Conservation of Bioclimatic Design Elements in Traditional Buildings in the Historic Centre of Nicosia (BioVernacular) View
project
Development of a Prototype Modular Brick Unit for Environmentally Friendly and Energy Efficient Building Envelopes (IMMS project) View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Aimilios Michael on 01 May 2017.
Abstract. The environmental advantages of semi-open penetration and ventilation to the indoor spaces. The
spaces have long been recognized. Such spaces have the ability Hellenistic peristyle court later became a distinctive
to mediate outdoor temperatures through the reduction of solar feature of dwellings during the Roman period, and
heat gains. Nevertheless, such claims lack quantitative validation comprised a vital element of Roman villas, such as those
since the majority of researches on semi-open spaces have been in Pompeii [2]. Over the centuries, semi-open spaces took
based on qualitative assessments. In order to address this issue, various forms and were applied extensively in the
the present study focuses on the environmental study of vernacular architecture of the Mediterranean.
traditional semi-open spaces of Cyprus through onsite air
temperature, relative humidity and solar radiation measurements
during different seasons of the year. Drawing from the onsite Located in the Eastern Mediterranean region, Cyprus itself
measurements, the environmental behaviour of semi-open spaces has a long tradition of semi-open spaces —namely the
in relation to different orientations and architectural layouts is remains of peristyle courts of Roman villas, the Medieval
discussed, while the environmental effect of outdoor climatic (Latin) pass-through vaulted semi-open spaces which
variables is additionally investigated. The above mentioned provided direct access from the street to the internal
parameters are considered to be the determining factors affecting courtyard, as well as a number of pointed-arches defining
the thermal behaviour of a semi-open space. The findings of this semi-open spaces— in one or more internal elevations of
study indicate that semi-open spaces may result in a variety of dwellings. Similar design solutions for semi-open spaces
microclimatic conditions which can create more thermally
adaptive environments. The assessment of the microclimate of
had, until recently, been followed in the vernacular
traditional semi-open spaces could help towards the evaluation architecture of Cyprus since such spaces respond well to
of such spaces as authentic bioclimatic elements and contribute the hot and semi-arid type of climate of the island.
to their proper conservation in the rehabilitation of traditional
buildings. As a transitional zone between indoors and outdoors,
semi-open spaces have the ability of mediating outdoor
Key words temperatures and improving the thermal comfort of the
interior —by reducing solar heat gains— while, at the
Semi-open spaces, Mediterranean climate, vernacular same time, contributing to filtering intense daylight and
architecture, environmental behaviour, onsite providing protection from rain [3]. Apart from their
measurements essential bioclimatic contribution, semi-open spaces serve
as circulation spaces and have been extensively exploited
for household and agricultural activities, as well as, for
1. Introduction
social gatherings. Although they respond well to a series
of social, climatic and functional design concerns, semi-
Semi-open spaces are significant features of open spaces have been underestimated in contemporary
Mediterranean dwellings that respond to the mild climatic domestic architecture mainly due to the limited
conditions and the lifestyle of the locals. Such structures consideration of the local context in the design process.
can be found in several public and domestic buildings in Up until now, the study of semi-open spaces from an
different historic periods. In the ruins of the ancient Greek environmental perspective has not been very extensive
settlement of Olynthos, many dwellings of the Classical and past studies have mainly concentrated on typological
period incorporate a colonnade semi-open area bordering aspects [4]. This study attempts to investigate the
the courtyard, called pastas, usually south oriented to interrelation between semi-open space orientation and
offer protection from intense solar radiation [1]. architectural layout with microclimatic conditions and the
Moreover, in the domestic architecture of the Cycladic effect of outdoor climatic variables and season shifts with
island of Delos several peristyle courts were excavated regards to the thermal behavior of semi-open spaces. The
dating back to the Late Hellenistic period. Peristyle courts aim of this research is to help towards the proper
were open to light and air, assuring natural daylight
2. Background
A0, A1, A2
its prevailing orientation is towards the east to offer similar DoE (4.4 and 4.5) have been selected (Fig. 1). The
adequate solar penetration during the cold season. The two cases differ in orientation — Case Study B faces
portico is a pass-through transitional space which links the southwest and Case Study A1 northeast. It is noted that
street to the internal courtyard. It has a narrow frontage varying results may also be attributed to other factors such
and a deep plan layout. It is permanently open on one side, as the surrounding building forms and massing, as well as
while its opposite side is configured by a double door. The to the enclosure of the internal courtyard. Nevertheless, in
portico is a distinctive environmental feature, while its these case studies, orientation is considered to be the main
openings at the opposite ends of the space and its factor affecting microclimatic conditions. Throughout the
elongated configuration, allow for enhanced natural examined seasons, Case Study B presents higher mean
ventilation and shading. maximum temperatures compared to Case Study A1, i.e.
3.9 °C higher mean maximum temperature in August, 4.9
Case Study A1, Case Study A2 and Case Study B are °C in October and 4.1°C in January (Table I). Moreover,
representative of the iliakos typology (Fig. 2). Case Study Case Study B exhibits larger mean diurnal temperature
A2 has been converted into an indoor space by the fluctuations, i.e. 4.7 °C larger mean diurnal temperature
addition of fixed glazing. Case Study A1 and Case Study fluctuations in August, 5.3 °C in October and 4.0 °C in
A2 are defined by a timber beam structure, while Case January. The results indicate that the south-oriented semi-
Study B by two pointed arches. Case Study C is open space exhibits generally higher temperatures and
representative of the portico typology (Fig. 2). All four diurnal temperature fluctuations compared to the north-
spaces under examination are enclosed by high-mass oriented one. This variation in temperatures of semi-open
adobe walls and tiled roofs. Tiled roofs are configured by spaces with different orientation is mainly attributed to the
multiple layers, made with timber rafters which are impact of direct solar radiation. Moreover, throughout the
covered with reed battens or matting, earth and tiles. examined seasons, Case Study B exhibits maximum
temperatures above maximum outdoor temperatures,
4. Results and discussion while Case Study A1 exhibits maximum temperatures
below maximum outdoor temperatures. This indicates that
Based on the onsite measurements, the main parameters semi-open spaces with southern orientation could provide
examined are: the orientation, the degree of enclosure a warmer space during a cold, sunny winter day while
(DoE), i.e. the ratio of the total surface areas over the spaces with northern aspect could offer greater thermal
exposed surface areas (openings) of the semi-open spaces, stability and a cooler space during a hot, summer day.
including glazed surfaces. The analysis also includes how These results agree with other studies [4, 8] that link
outdoor climatic variables, and the different seasons, orientation with the thermal performance of semi-open
affect the microclimatic conditions within these spaces spaces. Mean minimum temperatures are lower in Case
using correlation studies. Study B, i.e. 0.7 °C lower mean minimum temperature in
August, 0.4 °C in October and 0.1 °C in January (Table I).
A. Orientation It is interesting to note that despite the relatively large
difference in mean maximum temperatures between the
In order to examine the effect of orientation on case study spaces, the difference in mean minimum
microclimatic conditions, two semi-open spaces (Case temperatures is small. The slight decrease of mean
Study A1 and Case Study B) constructed using the same minimum air temperatures in Case Study B compared to
materials, facing an internal courtyard and having a quite Case Study A1 could be related to the wind conditions.
The prevailing western winds in the region may increase converted into an indoor space by the addition of glazing
the rate of heat loss in Case Study B during night-time due (Case Study A2) and the temperatures of a southwest
to its southwest orientation. oriented semi-open space which has preserved its original
form (Case Study B). Throughout the examined seasons,
B. Degree of enclosure Case Study A2 exhibits significantly higher mean
maximum temperatures, i.e. 1.7 °C higher mean
In order to examine the influence of the architectural maximum temperatures in August, 2.5 °C in October and
layout on microclimatic conditions, two semi-spaces were 4.6 °C in January (Table I). Moreover, compared to the
monitored (Case Study A1 and Case Study C) constructed closed room (Case Study A0), Case Study A2 exhibits
with the same materials, oriented northeast, facing an significantly higher mean maximum temperatures, i.e. 9.5
internal courtyard and having DoE 4.0 (Case Study A1) °C higher mean maximum temperature in August, 8.0 °C
and 8.0 (Case Study C). These measurements show that in October and 8.0 °C in January. The results reveal that
Case Study A1, exhibits higher mean maximum the large amount of solar heat gains absorbed by the
temperatures, i.e. 1.4 °C higher mean maximum glazed surfaces raises temperatures high above
temperature in August, 1.5 °C in October and 1.1 °C in temperatures of high-mass indoor spaces and semi-open
January (Table I). Moreover, Case Study A1 presents spaces. These findings agree with the results reported by
larger mean diurnal temperature fluctuations, i.e. 1.4 °C Potvin [8]. Large glazed surfaces facing south may cause
higher mean diurnal temperature fluctuation in August, an adverse thermal effect during the hot, summer period if
1.5 °C in October and 1.1 °C in January. These results precautions are not taken with regards to shading and
indicate that the more enclosed the semi-open space is natural ventilation. Nevertheless, during the cold, sunny
(high DoE) the less exposed it becomes to outdoor winter days, spaces with large glazed surfaces facing
climatic conditions, exhibiting therefore, a thermal south could provide comfortable living conditions during
performance similar to an indoor space. These findings are daytime. Unsurprisingly, the mean minimum temperatures
in line with other studies [4, 6, 7] indicating that semi- of Case Study A2 remain higher than the temperature of
open spaces with high DoE achieve greater moderation of Case Study B due to the insulation of glazing, i.e. 3.8 °C
the external thermal inflows for a given orientation. Of higher mean minimum temperature in August, 4.4°C in
interest is also the fact that mean minimum temperatures October and 5.5 °C in January.
in the two spaces under investigation are identical in
August, October and January. Case Study A1 thus results D. Outdoor climatic variables and season
in greater heat losses during night-time (considering that it
exhibits higher mean maximum temperatures). Due to the The research has shown that maximum air temperatures
fact that Case Study A1 is less enclosed, more radiation is reached in semi-open spaces are directly related to the
allowed to escape into the night sky, which results in a outdoor climatic variables, while seasonal changes are
greater decrease of the temperatures. found to have a significant effect. Based on correlation
studies, a very strong linear correlation between maximum
C. Conversion of semi-open spaces into indoor spaces daily temperature of the case study spaces and maximum
outdoor temperature is found for August, October and
A comparative analysis was performed between the January (0.7201 < R2 < 0.9638) (Fig. 3A). These results
temperatures of a southwest oriented semi-open space
39 y = 0.7535x + 11.539
R² = 0.8441
36
y = 1.0882x + 1.6671
33
R² = 0.744
30
27 y = 0.7574x + 7.4851
y = 1.0435x + 2.7757 R² = 0.9409
24
R² = 0.7201 y = 0.6325x + 10.527
21
R² = 0.9091
18 y = 0.9505x + 0.1228
R² = 0.9504
15
12 y = 0.8878x + 0.1352
y = 0.7917x + 2.0179 R² = 0.8765
9 R² = 0.9638
6 y = 0.746x + 1.7519
3 R² = 0.9613
3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41
Maximum Outdoor Temperature (°C)
42
Maximum Temperature of Semi-outdoor Space (°C)
39
36
y = 0.0712x + 15.984
33
R² = 0.7155
30
27 y = 0.0416x + 16.137
24 R² = 0.4051
y = 0.1096x + 5.8912
21 y = 0.0426x + 14.467
R² = 0.8468
18 R² = 0.4505
15 y = 0.0527x + 7.486
R² = 0.5787
12
y = 0.0539x + 6.5166
9 R² = 0.6279
6
3
0 25 50 75 100 125 150 175 200 225 250 275 300 325
Mean global Solar Radiation (W/m²)
42
Maximum Temperature of Semi-outdoor Space (°C)
y = -0.1918x + 45.016
39
R² = 0.6442
36
y = -0.1434x + 38.8
33 R² = 0.7042
30 y = -0.1148x + 36.509
27 R² = 0.6247
24
y = -0.1751x + 31.299 y = -0.251x + 39.428
21
R² = 0.6448 R² = 0.7124
18 y = -0.1787x + 29.939
15 R² = 0.7114
12
9
6
3
15 23 30 38 45 53 60 68 75 83 90
Minimum Outdoor Relative Humidity (%)
– Case Study A0 + Case Study A1 o Case Study B x Case Study C
Fig. 3 Correlation between maximum temperatures of case study spaces and A. maximum outdoor temperatures, B. mean global solar
radiation and C. minimum outdoor relative humidity. Yellow, blue and red colors represent January, October and August respectively