Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Gender and Leadership
Gender and Leadership
Author’s Name
Institutional Affiliation
OBSERVATIONAL RESEARCH FOR LEADERSHIP SPECIFIC TO GENDER AND
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 2
Observational Research for Leadership Specific to Gender and Ethnic Diversity
Introduction
The gender leadership crisis has been one of the most publicly debated topics not only in
the USA but globally. It is indeed true that there have been improvements towards ensuring
gender inequality is eliminated across all spheres of society. Western (2013) cites that there is
still a long way to go concerning gender equality in leadership. The shocking factor is that there
is no lack of qualified women to fill these leadership positions. Women are the majority in the
indication that there must be something inherent in the system that continues to work against
them. This research aims to highlight why implicit and unconscious bias is the key obstacle
towards women attaining key leadership positions as it clouds people’s judgment in ways they
Data is a vital element of any research process. It is essential that a researcher ensures
credible and reliable data is gathered as it will be used in coming up with findings. A researcher
who does not select an efficient and effective data collection methodology is bound to gather
invalid and inaccurate data. In this researcher, the main data collection methodology was
observation. The main advantages of this method include offering one greater accuracy of data, it
does not require technical knowledge, and it is cheap and is a universal method. There is a
variety of observational data collection methods and this case, the naturalistic methodology was
selected. A naturalistic observation allows a researcher in studying the subjects within their
natural environments (Eby, 2011). This method eliminates the need to place the subjects in a
controlled environment, which affects their behaviors. Within the natural environment, a
OBSERVATIONAL RESEARCH FOR LEADERSHIP SPECIFIC TO GENDER AND
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 3
researcher can track the subjects’ behaviors and observe how they make their decisions without
any external influence. Naturalistic observation will enable a researcher in having a first-hand
In naturalistic observation, researchers may utilize various techniques to gather the data.
In this researcher, a video recording was used in recording the number of times a certain
behavior occurred. Observer narratives were also used whereby the researcher took notes during
the entire session. However, it is vital for the researcher to make sure that the data gathered is a
representation of the participants' overall behavior to eliminate any form of bias. Random time
sampling was used to ensure that the representative sample reflected the entire participants’
behaviors.
The data gathered during the observation was analyzed through coding. Coding
encompasses an iterative, systemic and rigorous process that allows a researcher to identify a
specific behavior from the participants’ video recordings or field notes (Pesch & Lumeng, 2017).
One must determine the coding time interval, and this is mostly dependent on the detail levels a
researcher wants to capture. The interval coding technique was used in this study as it eliminates
the challenges encountered by duration and frequency coding. In this method, the researcher
determined the occurrence of a particular behavior within a smaller tie frame during the
observation (Pesch & Lumeng, 2017). The coding schemes used in the analysis of the data were
Literature Review
According to the Great Man theory, it believes that great leaders are God-gifted and not
human-made. This indicates that leadership traits are inbuilt. The Great Man theory was
OBSERVATIONAL RESEARCH FOR LEADERSHIP SPECIFIC TO GENDER AND
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 4
popularized during the 1800s by analyzing the behaviors of main military leaders during the
time. According to the Great Man theory, the characteristics of a great leader were only evident
in a man. The theory postulated that men had intrinsic leadership traits despite no scientific
evidence proving that this was true. According to Malos (2012), one’s character is what
determined a great leader, and thus they could not be learned. The great man theory of leadership
thus sidelined the women as not being effective leaders and this explains why during the 1800s
and 1900s, most of the women were not given leadership positions. However, this approach is
still being evidenced in the modern-day work environment. In the contemporary workplace, a
considerable number of people would prefer having male leaders than female leaders as they feel
women are incapable of leading. These prejudicial beliefs by people are what contribute to the
According to the trait theory of leadership formulated in the1930s and 1940s, it proposed
that it is various traits that determine a good leader. Malos (2012) states that individuals who
were deemed to excel in certain traits were categorized as being good leaders. The Trait theory
and Great man theory share similarities as they both focused on the leader’s character quality.
However, most of the traits used in formulating trait theory were confounded by biases based on
social role expectations. However, the trait theory did not focus on other factors such as
race/ethnicity and gender diversity (Chin, 2011). In the study of what encompasses a charismatic
leadership, the trait theory focuses more on the masculine aspects and these locks out women as
not being charismatic leaders. Trait theory views leaders as having inborn traits, it ends up
overlooking the socio-environmental factors influence leadership, and this has precluded
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 5
Discussion
Western (2013) states that one of the greatest challenges people deal with at the
workplace is dealing with diversity. This is despite diversity and inclusion being a means
through which a company use to gain competitive advantage within its operational market. One
of the greatest diversity and inclusion challenges is evidenced form the gender representation in
leadership positions. Following a boardroom meeting involving the marketing, R&D and sales
department at ABC International, 80% of the members were male. The boardroom meeting had
10 members, and 8 were males while only 2 were women. The head of the meeting was a male
while one of the women was the secretary recording the meeting’s minutes. The other woman
was a customer representative within the marketing department. The meeting took 2 hours, and
out of the 2 hours, the customer representative was only given 15 minutes to air hare views. Most
of the time, she was shut down by fellow men as she tried to air more views. The customer
representative despite having an in-depth awareness of what the customer needs are, she was not
given ample time. The males aired most of the views recorded in the minutes. This is an
indication that the leadership of the customer representative went unnoticed, as none of the other
members wanted her input. As for the female secretary, she was not allowed to offer any options
From the above results, it is evident that female representation in the boardroom is
minimal at only 10%. This is supported by an OECD 2017 report that indicated that 7 out of 8
heads of special entities and agencies and 16 out of 21 directors in the OECD nations are men
(Global Entrepreneurship Monitor, 2017).Similarly, 11 out of 1932 nations registered under the
UN are represented by 11 female head of states, and 12 nations have females as heads of
governments (Global Entrepreneurship Monitor, 2017) This is an indication that there I increased
OBSERVATIONAL RESEARCH FOR LEADERSHIP SPECIFIC TO GENDER AND
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 6
gender inequality in leadership positions. The major barriers to leadership include individual
mindsets and institutional mindsets. The managers of organizations must ensure that they
eliminate institutional and individual mindsets within their organizations, which leads to the
formation of biases. The stereotypical roles of women from society are used in making
assumptions against female leaders, and this limits their ability to advance. Managers should
ensure that they come up with a workable diversity and inclusion program that will ensure that
Summary
The research was carried out to ascertain gender inequality in leadership positions. The
study was carried out at ABC International. The study involved15 participants comparison of
marketing, R&D and sales department heads who had convened a 2-hour boardroom meeting.
The data was gathered using a naturalistic observation methodology. This allows a researcher in
gathering data from the participants within their natural environment. The participants are
allowed to behave normally, and thus the data gathered is first-hand. The data were analyzed
using coding techniques whereby specific behavior from participants was gathered. From the
entire study, it is evident that gender inequality will continue to become a major issue in the
future, as it has remained etched in society for already hundreds of years. It is vital for the entire
globe to recognize that gender inequality is an issue that needs resolving, especially concerning
References
Eby, D. W. (2011). Naturalistic observational field techniques for traffic psychology research.
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 7
Chin, J. L. (2011). Women and Leadership: Transforming Visions and Current Contexts.
In Forum on Public Policy Online (Vol. 2011, No. 2). Oxford Round Table. 406 West
Retrieved from
https://gem-report-2017.unesco.org/en/chapter/gender_monitoring_leadership/
Malos, R. (2012). The Most Important Leadership Theories. Annals of Eftimie Murgu University
Pesch, M. H., & Lumeng, J. C. (2017). Methodological considerations for observational coding
Western, S. (2013). Leadership: A critical text (2nd ed.). London: Sage Publishing. ISBN 13:
9781446269909
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 8
Spoken
(minutes)
Mr. Marketing Senior VP 20
Davis
Edward
Mr. Marketing Head of the 10
Michael department
Mrs. Marketing Head 5
Victoria Customer
representative
Mr. CEO ABC 15
Hillary International
Mr. CFO ABC 10
Joseph International
Mrs. Secretary ABC 0
Angela International
Mr. Senior VP R&D 25
Victor
Mr. Senior VP Sales 15
Jackson
Mr. Chairman ABC 10
Jacob International
Mr. Head of Sales 10
Barrack the
department
ETHNIC DIVERSITY 9
2. Does the meeting observe gender equality? Yes/No
3. If No, what is the number of women and men at the boardroom meeting?
9. If No, why?