Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

who'll Go?

A Review of Factors
Associated with Employee
Willingness to Work Overseas
Patricia C. Borstorff.Assistant Professor, College of Commerce and Business Administrationjacksonville State University,
Stanley G. Harris, Associate Professor of Management, Auburn University, Hubert S. Fei Id, Torch mark Professor of Management,
Auburn University, and William F. Giles, Professor of Management, Auburn University

U
.S. firms competing in inter-
national markets generally
employ individuals working
as expatriates, i.e., employees who
relocate overseas to work for their
organization for a specified time
period. However, expatriate
programs are frequently
unsuccessful, with signifi-
cant numbers of managers
returning prematurely
from their assignments.
Because of problems per-
ceived to be associated
with expatriate programs,
many employees are reluctant
to take expatriate assignments
when offered. Thus, a key ques-
tion facing many corporations is,
"Who is willing to accept expatri-
ate assignments?" Based on a
review of the hterature, this article
addresses this question and offers
guidelines for managers concerned
with expatriate program assign-
ment and success.

HUMAN RESOURCE PUNNING 29


Relocating employees to work as expatriates Expatriates have also noted a consistent
in overseas locations is a competitive strategy decrease in career development and promotion
adopted by many organizations. Developing high opportunities upon repatriation {Oddou & Menden-
potential managers, enhancing a firm's global hall, 1991). Within a year of repatriation. 25%
perspective, controlling overseas subsidiaries, leave their company (Black, 1988; Gregersen
transferring technology, and setting up new & Black, 1990), and some estimate that organi-
operations are some of the justifications given zations lose almost half of their repatriates
for moving managers to international settings. within three years of their return to the U.S.
Because the trend toward expatriate use is an (Carter, 1989).
expanding one (Black, Gregersen, & Mendenhall.
1992). mobile managers who are willing to move Employee Reluctance to Take Expatriate
internationally and work as expatriates are major Assignments
corporate assets (Brett, Stroh, & Reilly. 1993). Problems associated with expatriate assignments
Such managers serve companies' requirements influence potential expatriates. They hear about
for managers who can identify and relate to failures of their colleagues as well as stories
headquarters what is needed for successfully involving family dysfunction exacerbated by the
competing in the international arena (Tung & assignments. Occasionally, they see unimportant
Miller, 1990). jobs given to repatriates at reduced salaries,
confirming suspicions thai returning expatriates
Problems in Expatriate Assignments are worse off now than when they left (Tung,
Although expatriates play an important role in a 1988). The evidence clearly suggests thai
firm's international strategy, failure of expatri- through their actions (or inactions), many organi-
ates, such as premature termination of the zations may be seriously undermining the suc-
assignment, is not uncommon. In fact, failure cess of their expatriate programs to the point that
rates have been estimated to range from 15% the employees they want lo involve are reluctant
to 70% (Copeland & Griggs, 1985; Fuchsberg, to participate. High-potential managers may
1992; Mendenhall, Dunbar, & Oddou, 1987). and refuse expatriate assignments, often seeing them
associated costs for each failure estimated from as a detour or derailment of their careers (Feldman
$55,000 to $250,000 (Copeland & Griggs, 1985; & Thompson, 1992; Tung & Miller, 1990).
Tung, 1982; Wederspahn, 1992; Zeira & Banal, Practitioner and research literature has con-
1985). firmed that a growing reluctance to accept job
Even if their assignments do not end prema- transfers stems from considerations of financial
turely, expatriates who are unprepared or ill-adjust- and career costs, family disruptions, spouses"
ed can make serious mistakes that reflect poorly on careers, a growing awareness of employee rights,
the organization and damage the overseas opera- and personal stresses associated with moving
tion (Tung, 1988). The indirect costs of expatriate (Brett, 1984; Harvey, 1995; Magnus & Dodd,
problems include loss of business and company 1981; Pinder. 1981). Financial stresses of expa-
reputation, failed negotiations, expatriate depression triation can include loss of a spouse's income,
and loss of self-esteem, and family dysfunction selling and buying a new home, and the possibil-
(Adler. 1991; Black, 1988; Kobrin. 1988). ity of dual taxation. Familial stresses can include
Further evidence attests that the expatriate career problems for spouses, disruption of chil-
experience is frequently a negative one. For exam- dren's schooling, loss of friends and community
ple, in a survey of repatriated managers. Black et ties, restrictions on personal freedoms and
al. (1992) reported that 80% felt their global movement, boredom, isolation, and culture
knowledge and experience gained overseas were shock (Stephens & Black, 1991).
not valued by their finns. Only 11% of American Obviously, expatriate programs are threat-
expatriates studied by Oddou and Mendenhall ened with ineffectiveness if those targeted for
(1991) said they received a promotion upon such assignments refuse to take them or take
return to the U.S. In other studies, 77% of repa- them unwillingly. Employees refusing interna-
triates across industries reported a demotion in tional assignments could affect human resource
their jobs, 50% had less autonomy, and 70% did planning and the adoption of global strategies, as
not know their specific job assignments upon well as add to the loss of international control
arriving in the U.S. (Black, 1992; Black & and coordination. Employees undertaking these
Gregersen, 1991; Gomez-Mejia & Balkin, 1987). assignments unwillingly could be subject to even

30 HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING


more stresses than those normally encountered ingness to move domestically. Inversi; relation-
by employees willing to work in unfamiliar, ships (i.e., younger employees were more will-
international environments. Thus, a key question ing) were reported by Gould and Penley (1985),
facing many organizations making overseas Sell (1983). and Veiga( 1983), while Angle and
assignments is: Who is willing to accept expatri- Manz (1988), Brett and Reilly (I988\ and Brett
ate assignments (Stroh. Dennis. & Cramer. 1994)? et al. (1993) found no significant relationships.
In this paper, we review and summarize From an international perspective, no significant
research on factors associated with employee relationships were reported in two studies that
willingness to take expatriate assignments. examined age and employees' willingness to take
Where appropriate, research on ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ expatriate assignments (Brett et al.,
domestic relocation will also be ^ ^ ^ ^ 1993; Brett & Stroh. 1995).
cited to provide additional insights.
Because the trend
The study of employee relocation Sex. Employee sex has generally
decision-making processes should toward expatriate revealed a consistent pal tern of
help organizations reduce the num-
use is an expanding relationships for domestic moves;
ber of employees who reject reloca- females have tended to be less
tions or are dissatisfied once relocat- one, mobile man- willing to relocate (Anderson,
ed (Turban. Campion. & Eyring. agers who are Milkovich, & Tsui. 1981; Angle
1992). In addition, it may also assist & Manz, 1988; Markham. Macken,
those organizations attempting to willing to move Bonjean. & Corder. 198?; Markham
enhance employee adjustment and internationall/ & Pleck, 1986). However, from the
performance overseas. perspective of intemational relocation,
and work as expa- Brett and Stroh (1995) ieported a
In our review, we examine rela-
tionships of the following four fac- triates are major nonsignificant association between
tors with employees' willingness to employee sex and willingness to
corporate assets. relocate.
take expatriate assignments: (a)
employee personal characteristics
(e.g.. age. sex. marital status); (h) employee job Marital status and children. Single individu-
and relocation attitudes (e.g.. international inter- als would be expected to be more willing to
est, ethnocentrism, organizational commitment); move internationally than married individuals.
(c) spouse characteristics and attitudes toward Domestic transfer research (e.g.. Angle & Manz.
relocation; atid (d) organization relocation sup- 1988) as well as intemational transfe' studies
port activities (e.g., career planning, training, (e.g., Brett, Stroh, and Reilly, 1990) generally
repatriation support). Each of these factors support this notion. Perhaps more important than
appears to furnish relevant, unique information marital status, however, is the effect of children
toward the prediction of employee willingness on international mobility. Evans, Lank, and
for an expatriate assignment. For example, Farquhar (1981) reported that resistance to geo-
employee personal characteristics are easily graphic mobility peaks for families with teenage
assessed but less capable of change than reloca- children. Parents of teenage children have been
tion attitudes (whether those of the employee or more reluctant to relocate because of social and
spouse). Employee attitudes may be affected by educational disruptions (Gould & Penley, 1985).
spousal attitudes as well as impacted by demo- Married couples without children at home have
graphic characteristics and organization reloca- generally been more willing to move overseas
tion support activities. Clearly, the relocation than couples with children (Brett & Stroh, 1995;
support activities are those most under the control Brett, Stroh. & Reilly, 1990).
of the organization.
International experience. Prior intemational
Factors Associated with Employee experience has been suggested as being impor-
Willingness to Take Expatriate tant to employee adjustments during intemational
Assignments assignments as well as an attribute associated
with willingness to accept overseas assignments.
EMPLOYEE PERSONAL CHARACTERISTICS Theorists (e.g., Torbiorn. 1982) have argued that
Age. In domestic transfer studies, employee age individuals initiate anticipatory adjustment to a
has shown mixed results when coupled with will- foreign culture before their actual arrival, and

HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING 31


their motivation to adjust strongly influences the primary reasons they would be willing to
their subsequent cross-cultural experience. accept international assignments. Similarly,
Because prior international experience is linked Miller and Cheng (1978) as well as Gonzalez
to anticipatory adjustment as well as attitudes and Negahdhi (1967) discovered employees'
toward international assignments (Black, 1988), interests in living abroad and having overseas job
prior international experience should be related opportunities were associated with their accep-
to willingness to accept these assignments. tance of expatriate assignments.
Previous international experience should lessen Camithers and Pinder (1983) posited that
the uncertainty normally associated with a relo- expectations regarding a new location have an
cation, and reduced uncertainty should result in impact upon relocation decisions, and these
higher willingness for international assignments. could be instrumental in influencing international
Some work tends to support this suggestion. willingness. If employees perceive international
Louis (1980) found that more realistic expecta- experiences to be something desirable, then it is
tions regarding international assignments were logically compelling to believe that employees
formed by those having had prior international would be more willing to relocate. We would
experience. anticipate that employees' interest in a specific
Ronen (1989) reported that employees with international destination would be particularly
previous international experience were more likely important. Although not confirmed in an interna-
to succeed in foreign assignments, even if their tional study context. Noe and Barber's work
previous experience was in a different country. (1993) supported such a result for domestic
He concluded that exposure to multicultural transfers. Finally. Dunbar (1992) reported an
socialization processes improves individuals' interest in culturally-specific information, and
chances of success in an expatriate assignment. cross-cultural social relations enhanced expatri-
Black's (1988) work suggested that previous ate adjustment and performance. As we have
international experience predicted expatriate suc- suggested, a case could be made that this interest
cess in work adjustment. Finally, other research could also influence willingness to take the
(Brett, 1982; Butler, McAllister, & Kaiser, 1973) assignment as well.
has suggested that many anticipated negative
outcomes of relocation do not actually occur in Ethnocentrism. Hthnocentrism is the belief
practice. Therefore, if individuals do not experi- that the values and attitudes held in one's culture
ence anticipated negative outcomes, then having are superior to those held by people of other
had international experience may make them cultures (Wortzel & Wortzel. 1985). Ethnocentric
less fearful and more willing to move overseas individuals have tended to exhibit more adaptation
in future assignments. and adjustment problems and less overall success
in working abroad (Fumham & Bochner, 1989).
Employee Job and Relocation Attitudes Although a specific link between employee ethno-
Because overseas job transfers interrupt important centrism and willingness to work internationally
learned behaviors and routines, they generate has apparently not been studied, a negative rela-
feelings of loss, uncertainty, and lack of control tionship would be expected. That is, ethnocentric
(Brett, 1982). Since foreign environments are individuals would probably have less interest in
likely to hold significant amounts of uncertainty working where people had views, beliefs, and
for potential expatriates, their interests in and ways of behaving different (and perceived to be
attitudes toward working in a foreign country inferior) from their own.
would appear especially important to their will-
ingness to take a foreign assignment (Gregersen & Career focus. Career focus concerns the extent
Black, 1992). Several such interests and attitudes to which individuals focus on and plan specific
have been found to be particularly important. strategies for their careers. Research on domestic
transfers has confirmed that employees who are
international interests. Adier's (1986) survey committed to their careers are more willing to
of over 1000 graduating MBA students revealed relocate (Markham & Pleck, 1986). Individuals
that they listed opportunities for cross-cultural who have a firm resolve about their career goals
experience and personal growth (i.e., wanting to and engage in greater career planning would
see other cultures, learn new languages, gain a also be expected to consider more seriously
greater understanding of another way of life) as expatriate assignments. For example, Sugalski

32 HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING


and Greenhaus (1986) found that managers who to relocate domestically were more willing to
engaged in more extensive career exploration relocate internationally. They suggested these
and planning were more likely to have mobility- attitudes reflected the itiiportance of past reloca-
oriented career goals. In some of the earliest tion experiences.
expatriate research, (e.g., Cleveland, Mangone,
& Adams, 1960; Gonzalez & Negahdhi, 1967), Spouse Characteristics and Attitudes
career-focus variables (i.e., opportunity for Toward Relocation
advancement and recognition, opportunity to Spouses' attitudes have been found to play a
improve career mobility, preparation for advance- significant role in employees' transfer decisions
ment to top management positions) represented (Black & Gregersen, 1990, 1991; Black &
important predictors of relocation willingness. Stephens, 1989; Cetron et al., 1987), More
specifically, spousal attitudes toward job reloca-
Organizational commitment. The extent to tions (Minor, 1982) and encouragement from
which individuals believe in their organizations" family (Hill & Miller. 1981) have been shown
goals and values and are willing to exert effort to be strongly related to transfer decisions.
on the organizations' behalf is probably associated
with willingtiess to transfer overseas. Although a Spouse employment status. Over half of
number of domestic studies exist (e.g., Brett & all U.S. married couples have dual career
Reilly, 1988), no study has apparently investigat- status, with the number expected to increase
ed the relationship between organizational com- to almost two out of three by the yeat 2000
mitment and international transfer willingness. (Brett et al,, 1990). Research at Mobil Oil
As in domestic studies, we would ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ concluded that such a projected
expect that individuals holding high increase would lead to a 50%
levels of affective attachment to their refusal rate as well as a 20%
organization would be more willing The degree of
turnover rate among its employees
to move internationally. involvement spous- seeking to avoid relocation (Brett,
Stroh, & Reilly, 1992).
es have with their
Readiness for relocation. An The degree of involvement
employee's estimate of the likeli- work appears to spouses have with their work
hood an expatriate assignment will be particularly appears to be particularly important
be a negative experience is likely to relocation decisions. Cetron,
related to their assessment of their important to relo- Lucken, McFadden, and Weir
readiness for such an assigtiment. cation decisions. (1987) found that "spouse fears
Perceiving they are ready to under- career may be jeopardized" ratiked
take an international assignment as the sixth most importEmt reason
(that is, feeling the time is appropriate relative to for refusing a transfer. Brett's (1982; 1984) and
their career and fatnily situation; believing they Brett and Reilly's (1988) work on managers'
have been prepared for an intemational assignment job transfers showed that spouses'job involve-
through training in cultural and living-related skills; ment was negatively coiTelated with spouses'
believing they possess critical, job-related skills) and employees' willingness to move. That is,
would appear to be related to employee willing- the greater the involvement of spouses in
ness to relocate. Although empirical research their careers,, the less willing employt;es were
on this issue apparently has not appeared in the to move.
literature, Evans (1991) and his associates noted
that employees' readiness to be transferred was Spouses* attitudes toward movirig.
an important selection criterion for expatriates. The cross-cultural adjustment and job relocation
literature suggests that spouses' motivation to
Attitudes toward moving. In a study involv- make an international relocation has a signifi-
ing 405 managers working in 20 firms, Brett & cant impact on employees' efforts to adjust (Ratik,
Stroh (1995) reported that relocation attitudes 1982; Sharda & Nangle, 1981; Stephens & Black,
were the most important predictors of employee 1988). It might also be hypothesized that spouses'
willingness to take a foreign assignment. More favorable attitudes toward an intemiitional
specifically, managers having positive attitudes assignment would also be closely related to
toward moving in general and who were willitig employee willingness to take such ai assign-

HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING 33


ment. Forster's (1990) research, for example, especially important to employee willingness to
revealed that moves perceived to be disruptive accept an international assignment because of the
to spouses and children caused a reluctance to cross-cultural nature of the assignment and the
relocate among employees. Fox and Krausz unfamiliar managerial, organizational, and cul-
(1987) confirmed that spousal variables, i.e., tural contexts (Gregersen & Black, 1992).
work prospects of spouse and positive attitudes However, very little empirical research appears
of spouse, were most strongly correlated with to have been done on Ihe impact of such factors
employee willingness to relocate. on wiLingness to make an international relocation.
Brett and Stroh (1995) sought to determine Yet, the perceived importance of such factors
if spousal and employee attitudes toward inter- would seem most salient. With relocations, orga-
national relocation were reciprocally related. nizations intrude more directly into employees'
They posited that from a family systems perspec- lives than at any other time because the organiza-
tive, relationships between family members tion directs where and when people will relocate
tend to exist in equilibrium, with each member and what type of job awaits them (Pinder, 1981,
reciprocally affecting the psychological state of 1989). Intemational relocations are particularly
the other members. However, their investiga- stressful as they disrupt routines and are accom-
tion of 405 managers and their spouses showed panied by feelings of anxiety, uncertainty, and
that spouses' intentions regarding international lack oi' control. As a consequence, employees
relocation affected managers' relocation atti- fear what will happen to them, their families,
tudes, but managers' views did not affect those their careers, their extended families, and their
of spouses. Because of this "spillover effect" job skills while on a foreign assignment (Munton
of spouses' relocation attitudes onto employ- & Forster. 1990). Fears of failure, low visibility,
ees' views, they concluded that organizational and harmful impacts on spouse and families are
efforts to influence employee willingness preseni: due to an inability to predict, understand,
to work overseas should be concentrated on and control events (Black et al., 1992; Sutton &
spouses. ^^^^^m ^ ^ • ^ Kahn, 1987: Torbiom, 1982).
In addition, Brett and Stroh Therefore, to help allay such fears,
(1995) identified a profile of Decisions by employees search for tangible sup-
spouses supportive of intemational I port from their organizations.
employees concerh-
relocation. Spouses most willing Organizational activities and poli-
to relocate had the following pro- ing relocation arej cies offer ways to ameliorate these
file: older, well-educated, held concerns. Decisions by employees
not made in a '
positive attitudes toward relocating, concerning relocation are not made
willing to move domestically, and vacuum; corporate in a vacuum; corporate support
had no children at home. actions play a crucial role in the
support actions
development of employees' reloca-
Organization Relocation play a crucial role tion intent. This intent can be
Support Activities in the developmen dependent upon opportunities initiat-
Perceived organization support con- ed and managed by corporate policy.
of employees' Kirschenbaum's (1991) research, for
cerns employees' beliefs involving
the extent to which their organiza- relocation intent. example, suggested that organization-
tions value their contributions al practices are important variables
and care about their well-being in the transfer decision. For instance,
(Eisenberger, Huntington, Hutchinson, & Sowa, organizations, recognizing potential work-family
1990). These beliefs are based on the perceived conflicts, could offer family counseling and
treatment of employees through actions taken assistance before, during, and after a move.
by organizations, such as giving pay raises for This assistance could, in tum, engender a posi-
relocating or providing cross-cultural training to tive decision. Similar approaches could also
employees and their families before an interna- be applicable in other organizational activities
tional move. Employees tend to reciprocate associated with expatriation. Rosenbaum (1979)
offers of perceived organizational support by contended that the ability to adjust in relocations
altering their eftbrts to meet organizational goals is relat<;d to the supportive character of the
(Eisenberger, Fasolo, & Davis-LaMastro, 1990). organization. Employees want to feel that their
Organizational support factors would appear actions and sacrifices are noted and appreciated

34 HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING


by the organization. For example, research Career planning support. Uncertainty regard-
shows thai expatriates want a return job, to ing one's career has been a concern ot expatriates
be informed, to be part of the decision making (Black & Gregersen, 1991; Black & Mendenhall,
process, to be trained, and to receive family 1990; Oddou & Mendenhall, 1991). A major
assistance (Black, 1990; Feldman, 1991; Harvey, fear of expatriates is that foreign assignments
1989; Tung, 1988). will be a "career cul-de-sac" that derails their
Following this line of reasoning, employees progress on the path to higher management
in expatriate assignment situations, perceiving positions (Feldman & Thomas, 1992). Feldman
that their organizations have given support in and Thomas (1992) and Gomez-Mejia and Balkin
areas important to them, may be more willing (1987) reported that employees' seeing a connec-
to accept the assignment. The role of organiza- tion between their expatriate assignments and
tional support activities can run the gamut of planning for their careers was strongly related
enhancing technical and social readiness, reduc- to their job performance, intent to remain in the
ing perceived risks, compensating for inherent assignments, positive job attitudes, and develop-
risk, shaping relocation attitudes, and demon- ment of constructive relationships with host The importance of
strating concern for both employees and their national colleagues. If employees perceive the
selection to subsequent
spouses. In the process of providing both sub- organization has provided opportunii:ies for
stantive and symbolic support for expatriates, advancement, meaningful development assign- expatriate success
organizational support activities help generate ments, and information regarding career prospects,
suggests that employees'
willingness to accept expatriate assignments and they will likely be more willing to relocate
increase the potential for the success of these and trust that the relocation will have positive perceptions of selection
assignments. career benefits (Lajidau, Shamir, & Artiur, 1992). practices may be
In summary, when organizations are per- Therefore, a well-organized career planning
program would seem to offer substantive and critical to expatriate
ceived by employees as supportive, employees
respond by increased effort to meet goals and symbolic encouragement for accepting an expa- willingness.
expectations (Shore & Tetrick, 1991). In the triate assignment.
international relocation arena, supportive
actions of organizations valuing international Selection support. Much of the international
experience have been found to be related to literature has pointed to poor selection practices
both expatriate adjustment (Stroh et al., 1994) as a major cause of high expatriate turnover
and satisfaction with expatriate and repatriate (e.g., Mendenhall et al., 1987; Zeira & Banai,
experiences (Gomez-Mejia & Balkin, 1987). 1985). The importance of selection to subsequent
Such actions when perceived by both employ- expatriate success suggests that empkiyees' per-
ees and their spouses would also be expected ceptions of selection practices may be critical
to exert positive influences on employees' to expatriate willingness. Employees, feeling
willingness to work overseas as well (Brett & expatriate assignments were fairly determined
Stroh, 1995). and appropriate criteria used, are more likely to
There are many organizational practices that perceive organization support for theii- selection.
can influence employees' perceptions of support In addition, effective selection procedures are
and encouragement. Brett (1980) suggested likely to enhance the feelings of readiness and
addressing those issues in relocation that have efficacy for those selected.
the greatest impact. Support practices related to Beer, Spector, Lawrence, Mills, and Walton
employees' careers, family, repatriation, mentor- (1984) stressed that employee beliefs that they
ing, selection, compensation, and training seem have been treated fairly are instrumental to
particularly important. Each practice represents organizational commitment. Feldman and Thomas
an important factor associated with employees' (1992) reported that free choice concerning
perceptions of corporate support to work over- expatriate assignments and realistic job previews
seas. Because of their important tie to support were related to subsequent success aid adjust-
perceptions, these practices are very likely to be ment in expatriate assignments. Perceptions
critical in affecting employees' willingness to of care and fairness in selection decisions are
be an expatriate. Each of the following practices salient to employees relinquishing control in a
may potentially serve as a means of reducing, relocation; employees need to feel the organiza-
or compensating for, the risks incurred in an tion has a rational selection procedure, rather than
international assignment. just sending anyone to fill a spot. Believing the

HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING 35


organization has carefully chosen the right persons environmental briefings (Black & Mendenhall.
for the assignments could reduce some uncertainty 1990). In contrast, 69%i of European and 57%
and anxiety associated with foreign transfers. of Japanese firms surveyed offered training for
overseas work (Tung, 1988).
Adequate lead time. Pinder (1981) has con- Gregersen and Black (1992) reported that
cluded that much of the bittemess toward reloca- managers saw pre-departure, culture-related train-
tion decisions is due to a lack of time to prepare ing as an important form of company support.
for the moves. People perceive little organiza- Because training offers a visible sign of organi-
tional support when insufficient warning is given zations' commitment to expatriates' readiness
that a transfer is required. Employees may infer and ultimate success, it should be positively
that lack of time indicates little consideration for related to acceptance of foreign assignments.
them as well as little career-based foresight.
Burke (1974) found the amount of lead time was Mentor support. An additional aspect of organi-
positively associated with feeling important to zational support is the use of mentors or domestic
the organization in domestic job transfers. sponsors who can relate current domestic events,
Haslberger and Stroh (1992) surveyed pub- look out for expatriates' careers, and offer assis-
licly held multinational corporations and found tance with problems (Harvey, 1989). Again, this
over 50% of the companies provided one or two form ol' visible support shows the organization
month's notice for international assignments. is committed to facilitating expatriate success.
Forster's (1990) study revealed roughly 30% of Gregersen and Black's (1990) study found
relocated employees had less than four weeks employee attitudes were related to intent to stay
notice between selection and starting a new job. and suggested that mentors are one way to sus-
He found the longer the period of notice to tain this commitment. Similarly. Feldman and
employees, the more positive job changes were Thomas (1992) reported, in a study involving
perceived, and the quicker employees settled into expatriate managers, that use of mentors was
new jobs. Extra time permits employees to logi- related to subsequent success and adjustment in
cally plan the move. It also produces a greater expatriate assignments. Research by Black and
sense of control over their situation. In addition, others (Black, 1988. 1990; Black & Gregersen,
extra time can be used for anticipatory adjustment 1991) has also provided evidence of the rela-
that helps to reduce uncertainty and stress. Expa- tionship between social support and expatriate
triates' perceptions that they have a reasonable adjustment. Perception of support has been
period of time between selection and transfer found to be empirically linked to the develop-
provide a sign of organizational support. These ment of organizational commitment (Mowday,
perceptions should have positive associations Porter, & Steers, 1982).
with taking expatriate jobs.
Contact between expatriates and the home
office helps employees feel that they are part of
Training support. Lack of employee and spouse the home organization and reduces the anxiety
training for expatriate assignments has been a and uncertainty associated with "out of sight,
concem of expatriates (e.g.. Black & Gregersen, out of mind" fears (Tung, 1988). Having a men-
1991; Black & Mendenhall, 1990; Feldman tor at the home office to watch over expatriates'
& Thomas, 1992; Oddou & Mendenhall. 1991). careers and keep them from being derailed
One indication of organizations' support of can be very important (Feldman, 1991). Ideally,
expatriates is pre-departure training that reflects expatriates who will be moving overseas should
visible support for expatriate success. have a substantial role in selecting their mentors.
Although relevant to successful intemational Research (Chao. Walz. & Gardner. 1992) has
assignments, use of cross-cultural training to shown ihat informal mentorships (those that
prepare managers for assignments abroad is very develop "on their own") produce more successful
limited (Black & Mendenhall, 1990; Mendenhall outcomes than forma! ones (where the mentor is
et ah. 1987). Earley's (1987) study confirmed a assignee by the organization). A mentor is both a
positive association between training and adjust- subst^tive and symbolic demonstration of organi-
ment to expatriate relocations. However, only zational support. Knowing that the organization,
30% of the companies operating abroad in the via the mentor, is interested in employees' well-
late 1980s sponsored training before relocation, being, needs, and aspirations should encourage
and often the training consisted of superficial intemational work assignment acceptance.

36 HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING


Compensation support. Suitable compensa- relocated (Brett et al., 1990; Harvey, 1995).
tion demonstrates to employees that the organi- Motorola noted that their expatriates wanted
zation realizes the risks and sacrifices involved preparation for dealing with culture shock,
in an international assignment for both employee in-country assistance, and information on daily
and family and is willing to compensate employ- life activities (Brett et al.. 1992). These pro-
ees for incurring these. It also gives employees a grams would reflect a visible commitment by the
sense of their worth to the company and demon- organization to not only enhancing the family's
strates the value placed on expatriate assignments. transition and subsequent successful adjustment
When the compensation offered rewards mobility but also to lessening uncertainty associated
and allows employees to maintain their current with relocation.
lifestyle, employees perceive a commitment from Other forms of family assistance (e.g., social
the organization to facilitate their performance in support from fellow home citizens who are on
expatriate assignments (Hobart, 1990). location and support of host nationals) have also
Ahhough salary and supplemental costs for been found to facilitate adjustment (Black, 1990;
expatriate assignments generally run three times Black & Gregersen, 1991) and to reduce stress
that of domestic transfers, a recent study (Black (Arkin. 1993). Implementation of family support
& Gregersen. 1991) showed 77% of expatriate programs should enhance perceived organizational
managers were dissatisfied with their ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ support. Enhanced organizational
expatriate salaries and benefits. An support, in turn, should encourage
adequate compensation package employee willingness to be an
would include meeting specific needs A contributing expatriate.
of the family life cycle (i.e., birth of factor of expatri-
children, children going to school, Repatriation support.
children returning to the U.S. for col- ate turnover is Repatriation refers to the transition
lege, elder care, travel back to the the lack of atten- from the foreign country back into
U.S.), any cost-of-living adjustments one's home country and home
tion to problems
for the particular international loca- organization (Black, 1990). Potential
tion, and facilitating reentry to the expatriates expatriates recognize overseas
U.S. and the domestic organization assignments are accompanied
encounter upon
(Harvey, 1985). by career risks, such as missed
repatriation, and opportunities for advancement
Family assistance support. these problems back home, possible failure in the
Support mechanisms are necessary assignment, and uncertainty over
influence managers' their place within the company
for successful adjustment of the
entire family in a transfer. Gregersen willingness to take after the assignment (Black &
and Black (1990) showed adjustment Gregersen, 1991). Harvey (1989)
foreign assignments. has argued that a contributing
to a foreign culture positively corre-
lated with intent to stay. They pro- factor of expatriate turnover is
posed it is important for organizations to facili- the lack of attention to problems expatriates
tate cultural adjustment through support in the encounter upon repatriation, and these problems
areas of housing, education, and spouse job- influence managers' willingness to take foreign
search assistance. Detailed information about the assignments.
new location, financial and career assistance for When employees see a repatriate given a
spouses of transferred employees, and orientation demotion, a job with little responsibility, or a lat-
workshops are examples of support offered by eral position, the message is sent that expatriate
Pinder and Walter (1984). Other studies (e.g., assignments hurt one's career. Many expatriates
Tung, 1988) have suggested similar assistance. have expressed concern over expatriate assign-
However, less than 10% of firms in the late ments and subsequent repatriation (Adier 1986;
1980s offered job-finding assistance for expatri- Harvey, 1989; Kendall, 1981). They are aware
ate spouses even though over half of the spouses promotions are often decided at headquarters and
were employed before expatriation (Black & being visible helps promotion chances. Focusing
Stephens, 1989). on, and planning for, repatriation is a visible
In general, American companies have not had sign the organization supports expatriates and
successful support policies for families being attempts to contribute to employee success in the

HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING 37


assignment. This emphasis would encourage • Individuals most committed to their profes-
expatriates to feel their best interests were sional careers (e.g.. viewing an expatriate
being taken care of while on assignment. assignment as an opportunity for advancement)
Tung (1988) found career advancement and to their employing organizations are prone
opportunities, or lack thereof, and geographic to be more willing to work as expatriates.
relocation upon return to be two problems asso- Individuals with positive attitudes toward mov-
ciated with repatriation. She noted that the atti- ing are also more likely to consider moving
tude of top management toward international intemationally.
experience was a major component in the ease • Careers and attitudes of spouses will likely
or difficulty of the reabsorption. Harvey (1989) have a significant impact on employee willing-
suggested that dealing with the repatriation ness to move overseas. The more involved a
process before the return home can reduce some spouse is in his or her own career, the greater
of the stress and anxiety associated with repatria- the reluctance to miike a move. Further, spousal
tion and can provide a sense of expatriate stability. attitudes toward intemational relocation will also
Tf a clear repatriation plan is present, the play an important role in employee willingness
plan could assist in uncertainty ^^^^^ toward moving. Organizations
reduction and increase willingness. should consider developing pro-
Repatriation activities that provide a Focusing on, and grams to assist spouses having a
comparable position or a promotion strong career focus. Such programs
from the job held before repatriation planning for,
might include offering spouses
and assistance for the employee repatriation is a assistance in locating a suitable job.
and family in assimilating back into
visible sign the • Employee and spouse percep-
their home culture demonstrates
supportiveness. tions of organizational support for
organization sup-
expatriates are critical to etnployee
ports expatriates willingness to work overseas.
Summary and Conclusions
and attempts to Organizations should adopt practices
Our review suggests several guidelines that foster positive perceptions of
regarding employee willingness to contribute to organizational support. Such prac-
accept expatriate assignments. For tices include (a) explaining how and
employee success
some of these guidelines, there is why employees were chosen; (b)
empirical evidence regarding their in the assignment. allowing appropriate time between
association with willingness to work employees' selection and their actual
as an expatriate. For others, our guidelines serve moves; (c) ensuring employees do not suffer
more as hypotheses concerning employee willing financially in making a move by providing suit-
ness for expatriate work. The guidelines include able compensation; (d) offering cross-cultural
the following: training and counseling to employees and their
• Employees more willing to serve are likely families before, during, and after a move; (e)
to be single. Married couples without children showing employees how the move will fit into
at home or those with non-teenage children will their career progress; (f) having a meaningful job
probably be most willing to move. available upon their retum; and (g) encouraging
employees to secure mentors or sponsors at their
• Prior international experience appears
domestic organization who can help with prob-
associated with willingness to work as an expa-
lems and keep employees informed as to what is
triate. In selecting individuals for expatriate
going on in the domestic organization.
assignments, consider previous international
experience (i.e., intemational travel as well as Because of continuing intemationalization
prior work assignments). Intemational experi- of U.S. corporations and freer foreign markets,
ence is likely a particularly important factor expatriate programs will continue to expand.
if it has been a positive one for the employee. However, past success rates of corporate expatri-
Similarly, employee interest in taking an intema- ate programs have not been impressive, and
tional assignment is probably also significant. many employees are not only skeptical but
Individuals having positive expectations about unwilling to participate in these programs.
overseas assignments will probably be more If attracting employees to such programs is
interested in serving. important, companies either having or initiating

38 HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING


expatriate programs would be wise to consider Carter, N, J. 1989. "Moving Managers Internationally: The Need for
Flexibility." Human Resource Planning, 12: 43-47,
carefully the issues presented here as they imple-
Cetron, M, J,, Lucken, R,. McFadden. C. F., & Weir. B. J. 1987.
ment these programs. Impact of the Changing Family on Employee Relocation. Washington.
DC: Etnployee Relocation Council.

References Chao, G, T.. Walz. P. M., & Gardner, R D. 1992. "Formal and
Informal Mentorships: A Comparison on Mentoring Functions and
Adier, N. J. 19^6. "'Do MBAs Want [nlemational Careers'.'"
Contrast with Nonmentured Counterparts," Personnel Psychology. 45:
International Journal of ImercuUural Relations, 10: 277-300.
619-636.
Anderson. J. C . Milkovich. G . T . &Tsui. A. 198! "A Model of
Cleveland, H.. Mangone, G., & Adams. J. I960. The Overseas
Inira organ izal ion al Mobility." Academy of Management Review. 6:
Americans. New York: McGraw-Hill.
529-538,
Copeland, L.. & Griggs. L. 1985. Going Iniemational. New York:
Arkin, A. 1993. "Managing the Stress of Relocation.'' Persomwl
Random House,
Managcmeni. 25: 53-56.
Dunbar, E. 1992. "Adjustment and Satisfaction of Expatriate U.S.
Beer, M.. Specior, B., Lawrence. P.. Mills, D, Q., & Walion. R, E,
Personnel." International Journal of Intercultural Relations. 16: 1-16,
1984. Managing Human Assets. New York: The Free Press.
Earley. P. C. 1987. "intercultural Training for Managers: A
Black. J. S. 1988. "Work Role Transition.s: A Study of American
Comparison of Documentary and Interpersonal Methods." Academy of
Expatriate Managers in Japan." Journal of International Businexx
Management Journal. 30: 685-698.
Studies, 19: 277-293.
Eisenberger, R.. Fasolii. R. & Davis-LaMastru, V. 1990. "Perceived
Black, J. S. 1990. "Personal Dimensions and Work Role Transitions."
Organizational Support and Employee Diligence. Commilmenl. and
Management International Review, 30: 119-134,
lnno\ alion." .lournal of Applied Psychology. 75: 51-59.
Black, J. S, 1992. '"Socializing American Expatriate Managers
Eisenberger, R.. Huntingion, R., Hutchison, S,, & Sowa, D. 1986.
O\e.YS,sas,." Group and Organization Management. 17: 171-192.
"Perceived Organizational Support." yoMrno/ of Applied Psychology,
Black. J. S., & Gregersen. H. B. 1990. '•Expectations, Satisfaction, 71:.500-507.
and Intention to txave of American Expatriate Managers in Japan."'
Evans, P., Lank, E., & Farquhar, A. 1991. "Managing Human
Intel national Journal of Interciiituiai Relations. 14: 485-506.
Resources in the International Fimn Lessons from Practice," in P,
Black, J, S.. & Gregersen, H, B. 1991, "Antecedents to Cross-cultural Evans, Y. Doz. & .\. Laurent (eds.). Human Resource Management in
Adjustment for Expatriates in Pacific Rim Assignments." Human International Firms. 133-142. Ixindon: McMillan Press Ltd.
Relations. U:A91-5\5.
Feldman, D. C. 1991. "Repatriate Moves as Career Transitions."
Black, J. S.. Gregersen. H. B.. & Mendenhall, M. 1992. Global Huma}i Resource Management Review, I: 163-178.
Assignments: Successful Expalriating and Repatriating Managers. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Feldman, D. C . & Thomas, D, C, 1992, "Career Management Issues
Facing Expatriates." Journal of Internationa! Business S'udit-s. 23:
Black, J, S., & Mendenhall. M. 1990. "Cross-cultural Training 271-293,
Effectiveness: A Review and Theoretical Framework for Future
Feldman, D. C , & Thompson, H. B. 1992. "Entry Shock, Culture
Research." .4t'i;rfcmv of Management Review, 15: 113-136,
Shock: Socializing the New Breed of Global Managers." Human
Black. J, S,, & Stephens, G, K. 1989, "The InHuence of ihe Spouse on Resource Management. 31: 345-362.
American Expatriate Adjustment and Intent to Stay in Pacific Rim
Forster. N. 1990. "A Practical Guide to the Management of Job
Overseas Assignments." ycHma/w/Mana^fmenf, 15: 529-544.
Changes and Relocations," Personnel Review. 19: 26-35.
Brett, J. M. 1980, "The Effect of Job Transfer on Etnployees and
Fox. S,. & Krausz. M. 1987. "Correlates of Relocation Intention and
Their Families." In C. L. Cooper & R. Payne (eds.). Current Concerns
Emotional Responses to an Israeli Plani Relocation." Journal of
in Occupational Stress, 99-136. New York: John Wiley.
Occupariotial Behavior. R: 325-338.
Brett, J. M. 1982, "Job Transfer and Well-being." Journal of Applied
Fuchsberg, G. 1992. "As Cost of Overseas Assignments Climb. Firms
Psychology. 67: 450-463.
Select Expatriates More Carefully." The Wall Street Jourtiai. (January
Brett, J, M. 1984, "Job Transitions and Personal and Role 9): Bl.
Dcvelopmcni." In K. M. Rowland &. G. R. Ferris (eds.), Researih in
Persannel and Human Resources Management, Vol, 2: 155-185. Fumham. A.. & Bochner, S, 1989. Culture Shock: Psychological
Greenwich, CT: JAl Press. Reactions to Unfamiliar Environments. London: Routledge.

Brett. J. M., & Reilly, A. H. 1988. '-On the Road Again: Prediciing Ihe Gomez-Mejia, L., & Balkin. D, B. 1987. "Determinants of Managerial
Satisfaction with the Expatriation and Repatriation Process." Journal
Job Transfer Dechion." Journal of Applied Psychology, 73: 614-620.
of Management Development, 6: 7-17.
Brett, J, M,, & Stroh, L. K. 1995. "Willingness to Relocate
Gonzalez. R, F.. & Negandhi, A. R. 1967. '"Tlie United States
Internationally," Hitman Re.tource Management, 34: 405-424.
Overseas Executive: His Orientation and Career Patterns." Michigan
Bretl, J. M., Stroh, L. K., & Reilly. A. H. 1990, Impact nl' Societal State University: Institute for Intemational Business ;ind Economic
Shifts and Corporate Changes on Employee Relocation. Washington, Development Studies. Division of Research.
DC: Employee Relocation Council.
Gould, S.. & Penley, L. E. 1985. "A Study of the Correlates of the
Brett, J. M., Stroh. L. K.. & Reilly, A, H. 1992, "Job Transfers." In C. Willingness to Kt\oca\e." Academy of Management Journal, 28:472-
L, Cooper dfe I. T. Robertson (eds.). International Review of Industrial 47M.
and Organizarional P.Kychology. Vol. 7: 323-362, Chichester, England:
John Wiley & Sons. Gould, S., & Werbel. J, D. 1983. "Work Involvement: A Comparison
of Dual Wage Eamer and Single Wage Earner Families." Journal of
Breit, J. M,. Stroh. 1, .K.. & Reilly, A. H. 1993. "Pulling Up Roots in Applied Psychology. 68: 313-319,
Che 1990s: Who's Willing to Re\oa\teT' .lournal of Organizational
Behavior. 14,49-60, Gregersen, H. B., & Black, J. S. 1990, "A Muhifaceted Approach to
Expatriate Retention in Intemational Assignments." Croup and
Buri:e, R. J. 1974. "Personnel Job Transfers: Some Data and Organization Studies. 15: 461-485.
Recommendations." Studies in Personnel P.tychology, 6: 35-46,
Gregersen. H. B., & Black. J. S. 1992. "Antecedents to Commitment
Butler, E. W.. McAllister. R. J., & Kaiser, E. J. 1973. 'The Effects of to a Parent Company and a Foreign Operation." Academy of
Voluntary and Invo!untai7 Residential Mobility on Females and Management Journal. 33: 65-90.
Males.",/(JH(-/?H/ of Marriage and Family, 35: 219-227,
Harvey, M. G. 1985. "The Executive Family: An Overlooked Variable
Carruihers. N. F... & Pinder, C. C. 1983. "Urban Geographic Factors in International Assignments." Columbia Journal of World Business.
and Location Satisfaction Following a Personnel Transfer." Academy 20: 84-91.
of Management Journal. 26: 520-526.

HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING 39


Harvey. M. G, 1989, '"Repalrialion ot" Corporate Executives: An Employee Development." In K. M. Rowland & G. R. Ferris (eds.>.
Empirical Study." Journal oj Inleriiaiioiuil Hiisiness Studies, 20: 131- Research in Personnel and Humajt Resources Management. Vol. 2.
144. 187-218, Greenwich. Cr:JAI Press.
Harvey, M. G. "The Impact of Dual-career Families on Intcmaiional Rank. M. R. 1982. "Determinants of Conjugal Inlluence in Wives'
Relocations." Human Resowce Managemam Review. 5: 223-244. EinploymenI Decision Making." Journal of Marriage and the Family,
44:591-604,
Haslberger, A., & Siroh. L. K. 1992. "'Devekipmeni and Seleciion of
Muliinalional ExpytTiates." Human Resource Development Qiiarierly. Ronen. S. 1989. "TraitiiQg the Ititemational Assignee." In [, L.
3: 287-293. Goldstein (ed.). Training and Development in Organizations, 417-453.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
HiU, R. E., & Miller, E. L. 19R1. "Job Change and the Middle Seasons
of a Man's Life." Academy of Management Journal. 24: 114-127. Rosenbaum, J. E. 1979. "Toumameni Mobility: Career Pattems in a
Corporation." Administrative Science Qtianerly. 24: 220-241.
Hobarl. N. D. 1990. "Effective Expatriate Compensation."
Compensation and Benefits Management. 7: 46-49. Sell. R, R, 1983. "Transferred Jobs: A Neglected Aspect of Migration
and Occupational Change." Work ami Oaupatiiinx. 10: 179-206.
Kirschenbaum, A. 1991. "Tlie Corporate Transfer: Origin ami
Destination Faelors in tlie Decision to Change Jobs." Journal of Sharda, B. 0., & Nangle, B. E. 1981. "Marital Effects oti
Vocational Behavior. 3B: 107-123. Occupational Attainttient.",/oiiraa/d/Fam/7>/,r.vHc.v. 2: 148-163,
Landau. J. C , Shamir. B.. & Arthur. M. B. 1992. "Predictors of Shore, L. M., & Tetrick, L. E. 1991. "A Construct Validity Study of
Willingness to Relocate tor Managerial and Professional Employees." the Survey of Perceived Organizational Support," Jowtial of Applied
Journal (if Organizational Behavior. 13: 667-680. Psycholof^y.lfy. 637-643.
Lazarus, R. J. 1977. "Cognitive and Coping Process on Emotions.'" In Stephens. G., & Black, J. S, 1988. "Intemuiional Transfers and Dual
A. Monet & R, S. Lazarus (eds.). Siress and Coping. 123-147. New Career Cnuple.s." Paper presenled at ihe annual Academy of
York: Columbia University ftcss. Management meeting: Anaheim, CA.
Louis. M. R. I9H0, "Surprise and Sensemaking: What Newcomers Stephens, G,, &. Black. J. S. 1991. "The Impact of the Spouse's Career
Experience in Entering Unfamiliar Organi:?ational Settings." Orientation on Majiagers During Intern at ion a I Transfers." Journal of
Administrative Science Quarterly, 2^\ 226-247. Management Studies. 28: 417-428.
Magnus. M., & Dodd. J. 1981. "Reiocalioti: Changing Attitudes and Stroh. L. K.. Dennis, L .E., & Cramer. T. 1994: January. "Predictors of
Company Policies." Personnel Journal. 60: 538-548. Expatriate Adjustment." Paper presented at the meeting of the
Industrial Relalions Research Association: San Diego, CA.
Markham. W. T., Macken. P O., Bonjean. C. M.. & Corder. J. 1983.
"A Note on Sex. Geographic Mobility, and Career Advancement." Sugalski, T. D.. & Greciihatis. H. 1986. "Career Exploration and Goal
Social Faici'i:6\: 1138-1146. Setting Among Managerial Employees." Journal of Vocational
Behavior. 2':): 102-114.
Markhatn. W. T.. & Pleck. J. H. 1986, "Sex and Willingness to Move
for Occupational Advancement: Some Naiional Sample Results," The Sution, R. I., & Kahn, R. L. 1987. "Predictian, Understanding, and
Sociological Quarterly. 27: 12M43, Control as Antidotes to Organizational Stre,ss." In J, W. Lorsch (ed.),
Handbook of Organizational Behavior, 272-285, Englewood Cliffs,
Mendenhall, M, E.. Dunbiu". E., & Oddou. G R. 1987, "Expatriate
NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Selection. Training, and Carcer-palhing: A Review and Critique."
Human Resource Management, 26: 331-345. Torbiom, I. 1982. "Living Abroad." New York: Wiley,
Miller, E. L.. & Cheng. J. L. C. 1978. "A Closer Look al the Ltecision Tung, R. L. 1982. "Selection and Training Procedures of US.
to Accept an Overseas Position," Management International Review. European, and Japanese Multinationals." California Management
18:25-33. Review.1S\ 57-7].
Minor, F, 1982. "Items Intluencing Relocation Decisions ai IBM." Tung, R, L, 1988. "Career Issues in International Assignments,"
Paper presented at the Academy of Managcmenl Meeting, New York. Academy of Management E.xecutive. 11: 241-244,
Mowday, R., Porter, L, W., & Steers, R, 1982. Employee-organization Tung, R ,L., & Miller, E. L. 1990. "Managing in the Twenty-first
Litikages. New York: Academic Press. Century: The Need for Global Orientation." Management
International Review, 30: 5-18.
Munton, A. G., & Forster, N. 1990. "Job Reloi;aiion: Stress' and ihe
Role of [he Family." Work and Stress, 4: 75-81. Turban, D. B.. Campion. J. E.. & Eyring, A. R. 1992. "Factors
Relating to Relocation Decisions of Research and Development
Noe, R. A., & Barber, A. E. 1993. "Willingness to Accept Mobility
Employees."./(K()7w/ of Vocaiionai Behavior. 41: 183-199.
Opportunities: Destination Makes a Difference.",/()H»7ia/ of
Organizational Behavior. 14: 159-175. Veiga, J. F. 1983. "Mobility Influences During Managerial Career
Stages." Academy of Management Journal. 26: 64-85.
Oddou, G, R,. & Mendenhall, M, B. 1991, "Succession Planning for
the 21st Century: How Well Are We Grooming Our Future Business Wederspahn, G. 1992, "Costing Failures in Expatriate Human
Leaders?" Business Horizons. 34: 26-34, Resource Management." Human Re.iource Planning, 15: 27-35.
Pinder, C. C. 1981. "The Role of Transfers and Mobility Experiences Wortzel. H., & Wortzel. L. 1985. "Corporate Culture and Human
in Employee Motivation and Control,'' ln H, Meltzer & W, Nord Resource Management." In H, Wortzel & L. Wottzel (eds.). Strategic
(eds.). Making Organizations Humane and Productive. New York: Management of Multinational Corporations. 114-137. New York: John
Wiley, Wiley & Sons.
Pinder. C.C. 1989. "The Dark Side of Rcbi-'ation." Or.gn/iird/Kw Zeira. Y. & Banai, M. 1985. "Selection of Expatriate Managers in
Dynamics. 17: 48-58. MNCs: The Host-environment Point of View," International Studies of
Management and Organization. 15: 33-51.
Pinder, C. C & Walter, G. A. 1984. "Pet>;onnel Transfers and

40 HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING

You might also like