Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Journal of Materiomics: Sciencedirect
Journal of Materiomics: Sciencedirect
Journal of Materiomics
journal homepage: www.journals.elsevier.com/journal-of-materiomics/
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Plasma spray-physical vapor deposition (i.e., PS-PVD) is a promising method for obtaining advanced
Received 24 October 2019 environmental barrier coatings (EBCs). The EBCs must meet some requirements in the application, in
Received in revised form which the thermal cycle performance affects the service lifetime. The preparation of artificial vertical
1 December 2019
cracks in Yb2SiO5 coatings is an effective approach for meeting the requirements above because vertical
Accepted 6 January 2020
Available online 16 January 2020
cracks provide a strain tolerance. To clarify the formation mechanism of vertical cracks during the PS-
PVD, the effects of coating thickness and substrate temperature on the formation of vertical cracks
were investigated. In addition, the interactions of spray powder and plasma flame during coating
Keywords:
Environmental barrier coatings
deposition were also characterized by optical spectroscopy. It is indicated that vertical cracks are formed
Yb2SiO5 coating due to a thermal expansion mismatch between Yb2SiO5 and mullite coating, transient cooling after
Vertical crack deposition and the nucleation of evaporated Yb2SiO5 as well.
PS-PVD © 2020 The Chinese Ceramic Society. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access
article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmat.2020.01.002
2352-8478/© 2020 The Chinese Ceramic Society. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://
creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
X. Zhang et al. / Journal of Materiomics 6 (2020) 102e108 103
vertical micro-cracks produced in each splat layer due to the O3CP plasma gun with a double feeding tube. In order to investigate
shrinkage of the deposited splats [18]. It was found that the the vertical crack formation mechanism, Yb2SiO5 coatings with
shrinkage strain could be absorbed or compensated by pores if the different thicknesses (i.e., 20 mm, 50 mm, and 100 mm) at different
coating density was less than ~88% of its theoretical density [18,19]. substrate temperatures (i.e., 600 C, 800 C, and 1000 C) were
A recent work reported that plasma spray-physical vapor deposi- formed. Table 1 shows the parameters of EBCs prepared by the PS-
tion (PS-PVD) also forms some vertical cracks due to the high spray PVD. The preparation parameters of Si and mullite coatings were
power (~180 kW) and low work pressure (~150 Pa). The feedstock fixed.
powder in plasma jets can reach supersonic speeds [20], and the
feedstock powder can be melted or even vaporized at a high tem-
perature of plasma, thus depositing dense coatings readily. Based 2.2. Characterizations
on various coating deposition mechanisms, the vertical crack for-
mation in the PS-PVD EBCs appears different from that in the APS The plasma flame spectra before and after injection of Yb2SiO5
DVC EBCs. The aim of this paper is thus to clarify the mechanism for powders during the PS-PVD were determined by a model IHR550
vertical crack formation in the PS-PVD EBCs. optical spectroscope (HORIBA, Japan). In Fig. 2, a raster model was
530e27-141 in the measurement range of 400e1400 nm. A filter
UV-S1 window (slit width: 0.02 mm, exposure time: 0.3 s) was used
2. Experimental to filter ultraviolet rays. Specimens mounted and polished by
standard metallographic techniques were characterized by a model
2.1. Coating preparation Gemini 300 field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM,
ZEISS, Germany). In addition, the microstructure of EBCs samples
Tri-layered EBCs (Yb2SiO5/mullite/Si) were prepared by a PS- was also analyzed by a focused ion beam (FIB, SMI3050MS2, SII,
PVD system (Sulzer-Metco Multicoat) with an O3CP plasma gun. Japan) and a model Titan Themis 20 transmission electron micro-
Fig. 1(a) and (b) show the PS-PVD facility, and Fig. 1(c) shows the scope (TEM, FEI, USA).
Table 1
Parameters of EBCs prepared by PS-PVD.
Materials Current (A) Ar (NSPM) He (NSPM) H2 (NSPM) Spray distance (mm) Work pressure Thickness (mm) Pre-heating
Temperature ( C)
Fig. 3. Microstructure of EBCs on SiCf/SiC substrate with different Yb2SiO5 coating thicknesses: (a) 20 mm, (b) 50 mm, (c) 100 mm.
Fig. 4. Microstructure of Yb2SiO5 coatings at different substrate temperatures: (a) 600 C, (b) 800 C, (c) 1000 C.
X. Zhang et al. / Journal of Materiomics 6 (2020) 102e108 105
Fig. 5. Microstructures of Yb2SiO5 coatings on substrate at 1000 C, (a) upper vertical crack, (b) bottom crack, (c) surface.
a few Yb2O3 grains evaporate and nucleate to form nano-sized Fig. 7(b)). These images show that the color difference of plasma
grains [24], but most of SiO2 grains undergo these two processes flame is due to the decomposition and evaporation of Yb2SiO5
due to the lower melting and boiling points. powder. Fig. 7(c) shows the spectral lines of Fig. 7(a) of Ar (at a
The interaction of Yb2SiO5 powder with plasma flame was wavelength of 810.274 nm) and He (at a wavelength of 843.167 nm)
characterized by optical spectrometry, as shown in Fig. 7. In plasmas. Fig. 7(d) is the spectral line of Fig. 7(b), showing SiO2 (at a
Fig. 7(a), the plasma flame of Ar100-He20 without injected Yb2SiO5 wavelength of 810.274 nm) and Yb2O3 (at a wavelength of
powder appears white. The velocity and enthalpy transfer of the 810.274 nm) vapors. In Fig. 7(d), the intensity of Yb2O3 is lower than
plasma flame (AreHe) are 700 m/s and 8000 kJ/kg, respectively, that of SiO2, indicating that the amount of evaporated Yb2O3 is
thus being capable of heating Yb2SiO5 powder [24,25]. After the lower than that of SiO2.
injection of Yb2SiO5 powder, the plasma flame becomes yellow (see
Fig. 6. The results of TEM analysis on the cross-section of Yb2SiO5 coating with a thickness of 100 mm at 1000 C: (a) overview, (b) magnified microstructure of Yb2SiO5 coating,
(ced) corresponding elemental maps of Si, Yb, and O.
106 X. Zhang et al. / Journal of Materiomics 6 (2020) 102e108
Fig. 7. Spectral analysis of Yb2SiO5 coating during PS-PVD deposition, (a) plasma flame without powder, (b) plasma with powder, (c) spectral chart of Fig.7(a), amd (d) spectral chart
of Fig.7(b).
During PS-PVD of Yb2SiO5 coatings, Yb2SiO5 powder was evap- exceeded the tensile strength of the coating, vertical cracks formed
orated at a high temperature of plasma gun, and this vapor phase on the top surface, and then extended towards Yb2SiO5/mullite
nucleated on the substrate. The decomposition of Yb2SiO5 was coating interface to generate larger vertical cracks. The high per-
accompanied by a large volume shrinkage due to the phase trans- formance EBCs could be obtained as the thickness of Yb2SiO5
formation during transient cooling. The decomposition of SiO2 coating was 50 mm and its pre-heating temperature was 800 C.
resulted in an estimated volume shrinkage of 7%. The phase
transformation formed in-plane stresses along with other sources Declaration of competing interest
of tensile stress. Once the total tensile stress exceeded the tensile
strength of the coating, some vertical cracks formed on the external We declare that we have no financial and personal relationships
surface of the coating [15,26e28]. These cracks extended father with other people or organizations that can inappropriately influ-
into the coating as Yb2SiO5 further decomposed during the ence our work, there is no professional or other personal interest of
deposition. any nature or kind in any product, service and/or company that
Fig. 9 shows the entire vertical crack formation process in could be construed as influencing the position presented in, or the
Yb2SiO5 coating. Agglomerated Yb2SiO5 powder was injected into review of, the manuscript entitled.
an O3CP gun and was then separated into its original small particles
by crashing [28,29]. Small particles of Yb2SiO5 decomposed into Acknowledgements
Yb2O3 and SiO2 phases in the plasma flame. Meanwhile, portions of
Yb2O3 and SiO2 evaporated and nucleated on the substrate. In the We would like to acknowledge financial supports from National
coating, the phase transformation occurs in parts of SiO2 nano- Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 51801034, No. 51771059),
particles, leading to the volume change in spray process. During Guangdong Academy of Sciences Program (No. 2020GDASYL-
Yb2SiO5 deposition, some factors including thermal expansion co- 20200104030, No. 2018GDASCX-0402, No. 2017GDASCX-0202, No.
efficient mismatch, transient cooling, and nucleation of evaporated 2017GDASCX-0111). Guangdong Technical Research Program (No.
phases generated stresses and formed vertical cracks. 2017B090916002, No. 2017A070701027, No. 2014B07075007),
Guangdong Natural Science Foundation (No. 2016A030312015, No.
2017A030310315), and Guangzhou Technical Research Program
4. Conclusions
(No. 201906010015, No. 201707010455, No. 201707010385).
Yb2SiO5 coatings with various thicknesses (i.e., 20 mm, 50 mm,
and 100 mm) were deposited via PS-PVD at constant parameters, References
and the coatings were formed at different substrate pre-heating
[1] Padture N. Advanced structural ceramics in aerospace propulsion. Nat Mater
temperatures (i.e., 600 C, 800 C, and 1000 C). It was indicated 2016;15:804e9.
that the tensile stress derived from the thermal expansion [2] Liu B, Liu Y, Zhu C, Xiang H, Chen H, Sun L, et al. Advances on strategies for
mismatch, transient cooling after deposition, and the nucleation of searching for next generation thermal barrier coating materials. J Mater Sci
Technol 2019;35:833e51.
evaporated Yb2SiO5 were the main driving forces for the formation [3] Mohan A, Udayakumar A, Gandhi A. High temperature oxidation behavior of
of vertical cracks in Yb2SiO5 coatings. Once the tensile stress CVD b-SiC seal coated SiCf/SiC composites in static dry air and combustion
108 X. Zhang et al. / Journal of Materiomics 6 (2020) 102e108
environment. Ceram Int 2017;43:9472e80. mechanical properties of thick thermal barrier coatings with vertical type
[4] Appleby M, Zhu D, Morscher G. Mechanical properties and real-time damage cracks. Trans Nonferrous Met Soc China 2014;24:s29e35.
evaluations of environmental barrier coated SiC/SiC CMCs subjected to tensile [20] Liu M, Zhang M, Zhang X, Li G, Zhang Q, Li C, et al. Transport and deposition
loading under thermal gradients. Surf Coat Technol 2015;284:318e26. behaviors of vapor coating materials in plasma spray-physical vapor deposi-
[5] Richards B, Begley M, Wadley H. Mechanisms of ytterbium monosilicate/ tion. Appl Surf Sci 2019;486:80e92.
mullite/silicon coating failure during thermal cycling in water vapor. J Am [21] Liu M, Zhang M, Zhang Q, Yang G, Li C, Li C. Gaseous material capacity of open
Ceram Soc 2015;98:4066e75. plasma jet in plasma spray-physical vapor deposition process. Appl Surf Sci
[6] Nasiri N, Patra N, Pezoldt M, Colas J, Lee W. Investigation of a single-layer EBC 2018;428:877e84.
deposited on SiC/SiC CMCs: Processing and corrosion behavior in high- [22] Zhang X, Zhou K, Deng C, Liu M, Deng Z, Deng C, et al. Gas-deposition
temperature steam. J Eur Ceram Soc 2019;39:2703e11. mechanisms of 7YSZ coating based on plasma spray-physical vapor deposi-
[7] Hu X, Xu F, Li K, Jin G, Xu Y, Zhao X. Water vapor corrosion behavior and tion. J Eur Ceram Soc 2016;36:697e703.
failure mechanism of plasma sprayed mullite/Lu2Si2O7-Lu2SiO5 coatings. [23] Zhang X, Zhou K, Liu M, Deng C, Deng Z, Chen B. Toughness and elasticity
Ceram Int 2018;44:14177e85. behaviors in nano-structured 7 wt.% Y2O3-stabilized ZrO2 coating. Surf Coat
[8] Lu M, Xiang H, Feng Z, Wang X, Zhou Y. Mechanical and thermal properties of Technol 2015;276:316e9.
Yb2SiO5: a promising material for T/EBCs applications. J Am Ceram Soc [24] Mauer G. Plasma characteristics and plasma-feedstock interaction under PS-
2016;99:1404e11. PVD process conditions. Plasma Chem Plasma Proces 2014;34:1171e86.
[9] Zhang X, Zhou K, Liu M, Deng C, Deng C, Niu S, et al. CMAS corrosion and [25] Zhang X, Song J, Deng Z, Wang Chao, Liu S, Liu G, et al. Interface evolution of
thermal cycle of Al-modified PS-PVD environmental barrier coating. Ceram Int Si/Mullite/Yb2SiO5 PS-PVD environmental barrier coatings under high tem-
2018;44:15959e64. perature. J Eur Ceram Soc 2019. https://doi.org/10.1016/
[10] Tian Z, Zheng L, Wang J, Yang J, Yang G, Wang J. Damge tolerance and j.jeurceramsoc.2019.10.062.
extensive plastic deformation of b-Yb2Si2O7 from room to high temperatures. [26] Anwaar A, Wei L, Guo H, Zhang B. Plasmaepowder feedstock interaction
J Am Ceram Soc 2015;98:2843e51. during plasma sprayephysical vapor deposition. J Therm Spray Technol
[11] Li B, Fan X, Okada H, Wang T. Mechanisms governing the failure modes of 2017;26:292e301.
dense vertically cracked thermal barrier coatings. Eng Fract Mech 2018;189: [27] Kesler O, Matejicek J, Sampath S, Suresh S, Gnaeupel-Herold T, Brandc P, et al.
451e80. Measurement of residual stress in plasma-sprayed metallic, ceramic and
[12] Bakan E, Marcano D, Zhou D, Sohn Y, Mauer G, Vaßen R. Yb2Si2O7 environ- composite coatings. Mater Sci Eng A 1998;257:215e24.
mental barrier coatings deposited by various thermal spray techniques: a [28] Rejda E, Socie D, Beardsley B, Rejda E, Socie D, Beardsley B. Fatigue behavior of
preliminary comparative study. J Therm Spray Technol 2017;26:1011e24. a plasma-sprayed 8%Y2O3-ZrO2 thermal barrier coating. Fatigue Fract Eng
[13] Viswanathan V, Dwivedi G, Sampath S. Multilayer, multimaterial thermal Mater 1997;20:1043e50.
barrier coating systems: design, synthesis, and performance assessment. J Am [29] Xiang H, Feng Z, Zhou Y. Mechanical and thermal properties of Yb2SiO5: first-
Ceram Soc 2015;98:1769e77. principles calculations and chemical bond theory investigations. J Mater Res
[14] Xie L, Chen D, Jordan E, Ozturk A, Wu F, Ma X, et al. Formation of vertical 2015;29:1609e19.
cracks in solution-precursor plasma-sprayed thermal barrier coatings. Surf
Coat Technol 2006;201:1058e64.
[15] Richards B, Zhao H, Wadley H. Structure, composition, and defect control
during plasma spray deposition of ytterbium silicate coatings. J Mater Sci
2015;50:7939e57.
[16] Yang G, Li C, Hao S, Xing Y, Yang E, Li C. Critical bonding temperature for the
splat bonding formation during plasma spraying of ceramic materials. Surf
Coat Technol 2013;235:841e7. Dr. Xiaofeng Zhang is a senior engineer at National Engi-
[17] Li C, Li C, Yang G, Wang Y. Examination of substrate surface melting-induced neering Laboratory of Modern Materials Surface Engi-
splashing during splat formation in plasma spraying. J Therm Spray Technol neering Technology, Guangdong Institute of New
2006;15:717e24. Materials, China. He received his Ph.D. degree in Materials
[18] Cheng B, Yang N, Zhang Q, Zhang M, Zhang Y, Chen L, et al. Sintering induced Processing Engineering from South China University of
the failure behavior of dense vertically crack and lamellar structured TBCs Technology in 2016. Now, he works in City University of
with equivalent thermal insulation performance. Ceram Int 2017;43: Hong Kong as senior research associate. His research in-
15459e65. terests focus on thermal/environmental barrier coatings.
[19] Lu Z, Kim M, Myoung S, Lee J, Jung Y, Kim I, et al. Thermal stability and So far, he published 113 papers and received 11 patents.