Professional Documents
Culture Documents
K 12 Alliance 2021 Survey
K 12 Alliance 2021 Survey
K 12 Alliance 2021 Survey
Page Topic
2 Methodology
3 Key Findings
28 Cross-tabulation Report
70 Appendix A: QUESTION 7
76 Appendix B: QUESTION 16
METHODOLOGY
The Glengariff Group, Inc. conducted a Michigan statewide survey of parents with children in public schools. The 600 sample, live
operator telephone survey was conducted on August 23-26, 2021 and has a margin of error of +/-4.0% with a 95% level of confidence.
100.0% of respondents were contacted via cell phone telephone. This survey was commissioned by K-12 Alliance of Michigan.
* By a margin of 79.8%-18.5%, Michigan public school parents approve of the quality of their child’s education. 52.1% of
public school parents – a majority – STRONGLY APPROVE of the quality of their child’s education. Only 11.9%
STRONGLY DISAPPROVE of the quality of their child’s education.
The highest levels of disapproval came from Unvaccinated parents (36.5% disapprove), Rural parents (36.1% disapprove),
Trump Republican parents (34.3% disapprove), and Strong Republican parents (32.8% disapprove)
* By a margin of 69.0%-24.8%, Michigan public school parents approve of the way their school supported their child during the
Covid epidemic last school year. 45.3% STRONGLY APPROVE while only 16.0% STRONGLY DISAPPROVE.
There are strong correlations to party affiliation and political philosophy to the degree of approval of how their school
performed. But the strongest disapproval came from parents in rural school districts and parents who are not vaccinated.
* 48.9% of public-school parents believe their child has fallen behind academically as a result of the pandemic last year. 49.9%
of parents believe their child is on track or ahead academically.
63.0% of Detroit public school parents, 60.2% of Trump Republican parents and 62.0% of unvaccinated parents believe their
child has fallen behind academically.
* Of those parents who believe their child has fallen behind academically, 60.9% believe their school has the resources and
support to put their child back on track academically. 20.7% believe their school does not have the necessary resources, and
17.4% of parents just are not sure.
Those parents most likely to believe their school does NOT have the resources are parents with a skilled trades education
(29.4%), Independent parents (29.2%), and parents with a college education (24.5%).
26.6% of men believe their school does not have the required resources while 15.6% of women believe their school does not
have the required resources.
* By a margin of 77.0%-22.4% public school parents are largely comfortable with sending their children back to the classroom
this fall. 53.0% of public school parents are VERY COMFORTABLE sending their children back to the classroom. Only
8.7% of parents are VERY UNCOMFORTABLE sending their children back to the classroom.
Parents most uncomfortable with sending their children back to the classroom were African American parents (43.0%
uncomfortable), Detroit parents (42.9% uncomfortable), Sanders Democratic parents (40.7% uncomfortable), and Strong
Democratic parents (36.4% uncomfortable).
Parents who were uncomfortable with sending their children back to the classroom were asked why they were uncomfortable
in an open-ended question:
* Parents were asked if they agree or disagree that schools will need to institute strict new safety protocols to make schools safe
for students’ return. By a margin of 57.1%-38.2%, public school parents agree that new safety protocols will be required.
41.8% of parents STRONGLY AGREE while 23.7% of parents STRONGLY DISAGREE.
* By a margin of 49.4%-45.3%, Michigan public school parents are statistically split on whether students and employees should
be required to wear masks in school. 38.7% STRONGLY SUPPORT mandating masks while 36.5% STRONGLY OPPOSE
mandating masks.
* By a margin of 54.5%-41.7%, Michigan public school parents believe parents should be left to make the decision about mask
wearing for their child. Suburban parents are statistically split on this decision. Urban parents strongly support mask
requirements. But Small Town and Rural parents believe it is a parental decision by wide margins.
* By a margin of 57.2%-38.0%, Michigan public-school parents would support going back to remote learning if Covid cases
spike again until the caseloads decline. While 39.2% would STRONGLY SUPPORT remote learning, 30.0% would
STRONGLY OPPOSE remote learning if Covid cases spike again.
The split among parents continues by party affiliation and political philosophy. But there are sharp differences that develop
by race, type or town, gender and vaccination status of the parent.
* Respondents were asked their vaccination status. They were then asked if they had children aged 12-17, what was their
child’s vaccination status.
Among parents: 58.2% are vaccinated. 3.8% will get vaccinated. 28.3% will not get vaccinated. 9.7% declined to answer
the question.
Among their children aged 12-17: 45.5% are vaccinated. 49.3% are not vaccinated. 5.3% declined to answer the question.
The chart below looks at key demographic groups and provides the vaccination rate for parents compared to the vaccination
for 12-17 year-old children. The status of a child’s vaccination is directly tied to their parent’s vaccination status.
* Parents were asked once final FDA approval is given for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines for children, would they support or
oppose requiring students to be vaccinated for Covid. By a margin of 58.3%-36.5%, parents oppose requiring Covid
vaccinations for students. 50.8% of parents, a majority – STRONGLY OPPOSE requiring Covid vaccinations for students.
The chart below compares whether parents support or oppose requiring student vaccinations by the vaccination status of the
parent.
* Parents were asked on a one to ten scale, how important it was to them that children be safe from Covid in the classroom. The
higher the number the greater the importance. Parents rated their concern for safety at 8.3 on a ten-point scale. The sharpest
differences came by party affiliation, type of town, and vaccination status.
Demographic Score
Strong Democratic 9.6
Lean Democratic 9.1
Independent 8.4
Lean Republican 7.6
Strong Republican 6.9
Urban 9.2
Suburban 8.6
Small Town 8.3
Rural 7.0
Vaccinated 9.0
Will Vaccinate 8.7
Will NOT Vaccinate 6.9
On this question, party affiliation numbers flipped from the previous question on the importance of safety.
* Parents were asked which is more important: That children remain in the classroom for learning or that children be safe from
Covid in the classroom. By a margin of 49.5%-35.5%, parents said being safe from Covid was more important than being in
the classroom for learning. 11.3% of respondents said both are equally important.
* Parents were asked of six education spending priorities, which ONE was most important for them.
Skilled trades learning was the top choice for parents with a high school education or a skilled trades certification.
Individualized tutoring was the top choice for parents with some post high school education or a college degree.
Republican parents and, specifically Trump Republican parents, place a far higher priority on skilled trades learning than do
other parents.
13.2% of men chose more nurses while 23.4% of women chose more nurses.
Among urban and suburban parents, individualized tutoring and more nurses were the top two priorities. Among small town
and rural parents, skilled trades learning was the top priority.
* By a margin of 78.5%-11.7%, Michigan public school parents support making the temporary increase in public school funding
permanent. 61.8% of parents STRONGLY SUPPORT making the temporary increase permanent.
A minimum of 60% of EVERY DEMOGRAPHIC GROUP supports extending the temporary increase to a permanent
increase.
* Parents were asked if they would be more or less likely to vote for a candidate if they knew that the candidate supported
making the temporary increase in public school funding permanent. 52.4% of parents would be more likely to support the
candidate while 9.0% would be less likely. 30.7% of parents said it would not matter to them. 32.7% of parents would be
MUCH MORE LIKELY to support the candidate.
Democratic voters were far more likely to prioritize the importance of making the temporary increase permanent compared to
Republican voters. While 56.5% of Independent voters would be more likely to support the candidate, 32.0% would be
MUCH MORE LIKELY.
Hello, my name is ________. I’m not selling anything. I’m doing a quick six-minute survey of Michigan parents with children in
public schools.
A. Do you have children currently enrolled in a Michigan public school in grades Kindergarten through 12th grade?
1. Can you tell me in which county your student goes to public school? IF WAYNE COUNTY, ASK: WOULD THAT BE IN
DETROIT OR OUTSIDE OF DETROIT?
3. And do you approve or disapprove of the quality of your child’s public education? ASK: WOULD THAT BE STRONGLY
APPROVE/DISAPPROVE OF JUST SOMEWHAT APPROVE/DISAPPROVE?
4. Considering the pandemic last year, would you say it put your child behind academically, ahead academically, or would you
say your child is on the right track academically?
6. Given the current state of the pandemic, how comfortable are you in sending your child back to the classroom this fall?
Would you say you are very comfortable, somewhat comfortable, somewhat uncomfortable or very uncomfortable?
______________________________________________________________
[RECORD AS STATED/ CODE RESPONSE]
And what is the main reason you are
uncomfortable with sending your child back to
the classroom this fall? Number Percent
Covid/The Delta variant 41 30.6 %
Some kids can't get the vaccine 19 14.2 %
No mask mandate 22 16.4 %
Lack of or lax safety protocols 13 9.7 %
My child is high risk/We have high risk people at home 8 6.0 %
Social distancing is impossible in school 7 5.2 %
Too many unknowns/People don't take Covid seriously 6 4.5 %
The possibility or quarantine 2 1.5 %
I'm against a mask mandate 11 8.2 %
It's politically driven 2 1.5 %
I don't trust the vaccine 1 0.7 %
I disagree with their teaching strategies 1 0.7 %
Don't know/Refused 1 0.7 %
Total 134 100.0 %
8. Do you agree or disagree that schools will need to institute strict new safety protocols to make schools safe for students to return? ASK:
WOULD THAT BE STRONGLY AGREE/DISAGREE OR JUST SOMEWHAT AGREE/DISAGREE?
10. Do you believe all students should be required to wear masks in school or do you believe parents should be allowed to make
that decision for their child?
11. If Covid caseloads begin to spike again, would you support or oppose your school going back to remote learning until the
Covid caseloads decline? ASK: WOULD THAT BE STRONGLY SUPPORT/OPPOSE OR JUST SOMEWHAT
SUPPORT/OPPOSE?
13. Would you say that you have or have not received at least one Covid vaccine shot? IF NO, ASK: AND WOULD YOU SAY
YOU WILL GET ONE EVENTUALLY OR WOULD YOU SAY YOU WILL NOT GET ONE?
15. And would you say those children aged 12 to 17 have or have not received at least one Covid vaccine shot?
17. When the FDA gives final approval for the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines for children, would you support or oppose requiring
all students, except for those with a medical waiver, to be vaccinated for Covid? ASK: WOULD THAT BE STRONGLY
SUPPORT/OPPOSE OR JUST SOMEWHAT SUPPORT/OPPOSE?
19. And using that same one to ten scale, how important is it to you that children remain in the classroom for learning during the
pandemic. One means it is not at all important and ten means it is very important. You can choose any number from one to
ten.
SCORE: 8.3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 DK/Ref
3.7% 0.5% 1.3% 1.3% 7.0% 4.0% 9.5% 12.3% 5.2% 53.2% 2.0%
(22) (3) (8) (8) (42) (24) (57) (74) (31) (319) (12)
20. Which is more important to you. [ROTATE]. That children remain in the classroom for learning or that children be safe from
Covid in the classroom? IF BOTH, ASK: WHICH ONE IS MORE IMPORTANT?
_____________________________________________________________
8. Don’t Know/ Refused….DO NOT OFFER 2.7% (16)
22. The State Legislature gave a temporary increase in funding for Michigan public schools this year. Do you support or oppose
the State Legislature making that increase in public school funding permanent? ASK: WOULD THAT BE STRONGLY
SUPPORT/OPPOSE OR JUST SOMEWHAT SUPPORT/OPPOSE?
24. Generally speaking, would you say you tend to vote mostly for Republican candidates, do you vote mostly for Democratic
candidates, or would you say you vote equally for both Republican and Democratic candidates? IF VOTE EQUALLY ASK:
WOULD YOU SAY YOU LEAN MORE TO THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY OR MORE TO THE REPUBLICAN PARTY,
OR WOULD YOU SAY YOU ARE AN INDEPENDENT VOTER?
26. And what would be the last year of schooling you completed?
27. Could you please tell me in what year you were born?
29. Would you say you live in an urban area, a suburban area, a small town or a rural area?
30. And where would you say you primarily get your political news?
32. TELEPHONE
Yes No
UP 85.0% 15.0%
West 66.7% 33.3%
SW 61.8% 38.2%
Mid 75.4% 24.6%
E Cent 66.2% 33.8%
Oakland 68.2% 31.8%
Macomb 64.2% 35.8%
Wayne 74.3% 25.7%
Detroit 71.4% 28.6%
Det MSA 69.0% 31.0%
SCORE
UP 7.5
West 8.0
SW 7.7
Mid 8.0
E Cent 7.8
Oakland 8.7
Macomb 8.6
Wayne 9.0
Detroit 9.9
Det MSA 9.3
S Dem 9.6
L Dem 9.1
Ind 8.4
L GOP 7.6
S GOP 6.9
Sanders 9.9
Dem 9.5
Ind 8.2
GOP 7.6
Trump 7.0
High 8.5
Some Post 8.5
Skilled 8.3
College 8.2
White 8.0
Afr Amer 9.9
Urban 9.2
Suburban 8.6
Small Town 8.3
Rural 7.0
Vaccinated 9.0
Will Vacc 8.7
No Vacc 6.9
S Dem 7.0
L Dem 7.8
Ind 8.5
L GOP 8.9
S GOP 9.2
Sanders 7.1
Dem 7.7
Ind 8.2
GOP 9.2
Trump 8.9
High 8.4
Some Post 8.3
Skilled 7.8
College 8.4
White 8.5
Afr Amer 7.4
Urban 7.4
Suburban 8.3
Small Town 8.5
Rural 8.9
Vaccinated 8.0
Will Vacc 8.2
No Vacc 8.8