Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PH V China
PH V China
ARBITRATION
jurisdictional
merits
pH claim ruling ruling
① China 's UNCLOS comprehensively
maritime S C Sea
engagements in Granted
'
'
allocates rights
exceed
to maritime areas
may not those established by UNCLOS
.
OH win
There is no legal
② China 's nine line
"
"
dash is invalid the
claim to
Granted basis for China to
-
to in these
watery
.
Sea -
pH win
③
Scarborough Shoal generates no EEZ Granted Scarborough Shoal
is a
rock that
or continental shelf .
generates no EEF .
PH WIN
Reef ) are LTE 's that generate no maritime entitlement , generate territorial
seas but no EEZ
to or
.
Granted
⑧ China has interfered w/ the soil 's exercise of yes ,
on interfered at
pH sovereign rights
sovereign rights over
living a non living resources to
fishing
exploration Min
a
hydrocarbon
PH win .
the PH EET
'
PH WIN
④ on has prevented PH fishermen from pursuing their Granted China violated the
PH 's trad
fishing
livelihoods through traditional fishing around 8.
Shoal
rights .
PH WIN
Shoal PH
Nih
'
Environmental protections
④ China 's occupation and construction on Mischief 's Granted were violated at MR .
artificial island
construction violated pH
Reef violate UNCLOS provisions on artificial islands
sovereign rights Min "
PH Wth
Shoal PM Nih
Scarborough
'
near .
scaly
the
and
endangering the health of personnel there land reclamation &
.
PH win .
This claim
simply ask
④ Going forward China shall respect the rights and Granted China to do what it
is required to
freedoms of the pH under UNCLOS I
comply w/ its
do under UNCLOS :
duties under uncles
.
Therefore no further
statement is
necessary
.