127 ResearchCamote Tops 2 2

You might also like

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 50

LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

CHAPTER I

INTRODUCTION

This chapter contains the background of the study, statement of the problem, hypothesis,

conceptual framework, scope and limitations, significance of the study, and definition of

terms of the research.

Background of the Study

Ink has an important role in writing. It is used in markers, highlighters, ball pens,

and also in printers in making permanent writings. Aside from it is used in writing, it is

also used in making art works and calligraphy. Due to the continuous usage of

highlighters, markers, ball pens and printers, there is a great consumption of ink.

Sweet potato leaves are also known as Camote tops, which have been mostly

consumed in the island in the Pacific Oceans including Asian and African countries. It is

very useful in treating and preventing some types of diseases. It is also used as an organic

alternative medication. It also contains minerals such as sodium, potassium, aluminum,

boron, copper, and more. Camote tops can treat and prevent numerous diseases such as

diabetes, cancer, kidney stones, etc. and it also kills bacteria that can cause some diseases

(Jay Nelz, 2017).

1
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Little did we know that sweet potato leaves can surprisingly, be a source of

natural pigments that are visible enough making it a possible alternative ingredient in

creating ink. Many studies have tried using different plants in an attempt to create a

cheaper, and organic home-made ink.

The use of alternative ingredient in making ink to be commercialized is a demand

for the artists, calligraphers as well as for the people. In today’s generation wherein

technology is very much used, results are, the products are more commercialized.

Therefore, the researchers wanted to produce an alternative ink that is more natural and

less expensive.

This experimental study attempted to produce a product that can serve as an

alternative to expensive and possibly hazardous commercial highlighters. This study

deals with highlighter ink made mainly with plant ingredients that are combined with

readily available synthetic ingredients to achieve the desired quality of the ink. Feasibility

tests were done semi-quantitatively due to unavailability and inaccessibility of testing

equipment.

2
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Statement of the Problem

This study aimed to determine the effectiveness of Camote tops (Ipomoea

batatas) as an ingredient for highlighter ink. The research aimed to answer the following

questions:

1. What is the efficiency of Camote tops as an ink in terms of:

a. Color

b. Drying time

c. Cost

2. What is the right amount of concentration needed to create a good quality

highlighter ink?

1st treatment: 2 mL gum Arabic solution and 20 mL Camote tops concentrate

2nd treatment: 2 mL gum Arabic solution and 50 mL Camote tops concentrate

3rd treatment: 2 mL gum Arabic solution and80 mL Camote tops concentrate

3. Is there a significant difference between the alternative highlighter ink and the

commercial highlighter ink?

3
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Hypothesis

H0: There is no significant difference between the alternative highlighter ink and

the commercial highlighter ink.

Ha: There is a significant difference between the alternative highlighter ink and

the commercial highlighter ink.

Scope and Limitations

The study focused on the use of Camote tops as the main ingredient of the

alternative highlighter ink. The study aimed to test its performance as a source of pigment

instead of synthetic dyes. The researchers will conduct various feasibility tests using

Colourmeter app and a smartphone as spectrophotometer, and observation to acquire the

effectiveness of the ink in terms of color, drying time and cost.

The study did not fully aim to recreate the results that are given by commercial

highlighters. The study will not use other plant-derived materials as source of pigment

other than the Camote tops. This study used 8.5 x 11 (216 x 279mm) bond paper with 70

GSM thickness in testing the ink because it is the standard commercial paper that is

commonly used. It also used the Sharpie fluo xl brand of highlighter (green variant) as

the control group.

4
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Significance of the Study

This study will be significant to the following:

Highlighter ink manufacturers. This study will be able to help highlighter ink

manufacturers to lessen their capital cost by using cheaper organic raw materials instead

of more expensive and potentially hazardous chemical materials in the production of ink.

Students. This study will be able to provide students, with a new way of creating

their own ink using household materials instead of continuously buying highlighters or

ink refills in the market, thus helping them save money.

Employees. This study will help employees such as teachers, office workers, and

others who usually use highlighters in their line of work to save money and help them

lessen their expenses on commercial highlighter which is usually quite expensive.

Environment. This study will be beneficial to the environment since it will

introduce a new way of ink-making by using biodegradable and organic materials.

Future researchers. This study will be helpful to future researchers because it

will provide them with factual information that can help in their research attempts in

creating alternative ink.

5
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Definition of Terms

The following important terms are defined based on how they were used in the

study:

Additive– ingredient added to improve a specific quality of the ink

Alternative - the availability as another possibility

Biodegradable – capable of being decomposed

Commercialized - designed principally for financial gains

Concentration – is the amount of substance in a solution

Dye–colored substance that chemically bonds to the substance

Extraction – separation of the juice in the organic material used

Feasibility- capability of the test equipment to be done

Fluorescence – the discharge of light by a substance that has absorbed light

Hazardous- chance of risk or danger from the chemicals in commercial ink

Ink - used to produce colors to the surface with the use of Camote tops as ink to

form an image

Lucrative – producing a great deal of profit

Organic – produced without the use of chemicals

Pigment - material that provides the color

Spectrometer – an instrument used to measure the color level of the ink

Synthetic- ingredients that are formed artificially

6
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

CHAPTER II

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This chapter presents the related literature and studies after the in depth search of the

researchers.

Related Literature

As stated in the book Bioprospecting of Indigenous Bio resources of North-East

India (pp 77-99). Fibers and dyes both are derived from plants used by human society.

Natural dyes are used in coloring textile, drugs, cosmetics etc. Because of its non-toxic

effects, it is also used for coloring various food products. Due to lack of availability of

precise technical knowledge on the extraction, dying technique, it has not yet

commercially succeeded like the synthetic dyes. Natural fibers are getting an increase in

significance as renewable and environmental friendly raw material for technical

applications as well as civil engineering and building, construction materials.

The natural dye industry has been viewed as an upcoming and

lucrative industry given the right source and technology for commercial dye

production. The solvent-solvent extraction method proposed in a study found in the

International Journal of Environmental Bioremediation & Biodegradation, 2014, Vol. 2,

No. 1-4, was able to extract yellow dye from Ipomoea batatas L. lam leaves, which is a

common agricultural waste. A yellow dye, which devoid of pesticides and is stable up

to 2 years have been successfully reckoned as the next alternative to natural yellow dye

(tartrazine).

7
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

According to Elsevier (2019), mordant not only give the dye an affinity, but in

many cases, they produce different colors and improve the fastness of a dye. There are

many plants which may yield a color that is brilliant and pleasing but fades easily, unless

fixed by using a mordant. Examples of mordant are citric acid (lemon juice), acetic acid

(vinegar), and bicarbonate (washing soda).

Gum arabic, also known as acacia gum, is a natural gum made from the hardened

sap of the acacia tree. It is used primarily in the food industry as a stabilizer (helps to

preserve a foods structure), and it is edible. It is used in ink making to help prevent

bleeding, improve viscosity and help in binding the pigments together (Fait, 2017).

 Spectrometer is an instrument that separate and measure

the insubstantial components of a phenomenon. The instrument has a prism separated the

incoming parallel into monochromatic sources than only focus to the sample and outcome

of the spectrum analyzed. Spectrometer is a scientific field that utilizes the remote

sensing mechanism to study the components of plants, stars, or other chemical

compounds of a substance (Morumbi, 2013).

 Smartphone applications can be used in gathering the spectroscopy of a sample

solution. Spectrophotometer has three basic components which includes light, sample and

detector. RGB colors should be use as a light detector to compliment the color of the

sample (Kuntzleman, 2016).

8
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Related Study

Pigments and dyes can be categorized into two broad categories and five families:

natural pigments and artificial. The first one of these five families comprises mineral

pigments. Organic dyes that have vegetal origins compose the second family and those

that have animal origins form the third family. The fourth family includes pigments came

from chemical reactions. The other family is made of the miscellaneous inks. At the end

of the 19th century, all of these pigments have been replaced by synthetic dyes from the

oil industry. But the scarcity of oil regains interest in natural way of making pigments

(Despy, et Al., 2014).

The Columbia Encyclopedia (2019), ink is a pigmented fluid used for writing and

drawing. It is a viscous combination of coloring agent or pigment, liquid that contains oil,

resins and chemical solvents. Ink is used for printing for various colors but most

frequently used as black. Marker ink produces opaque traces or writing surfaces because

of the pigment particles throughout the ink composition. According to an article in

Academia, “In this modern world of technology the price of the products becomes a

challenge to every users particularly the scarcity of resources in order to address the

demands of consumers. Nowadays problems to supply the needs of Markers ink will be in

demand especially in the modernized and young industrialized countries throughout the

world. Even the government encourage young scientist to discover things that can be

useful and answer to the needs of social changes.”

9
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Based on a study from (Lavalle School), the banana sap extract is an effectual

alternate natural ink. Banana saps are free and the other ingredients needed in doing the

decoction can be easy found in any household. According to (Anthis 2015), you can use

natural extracts like dried hibiscus flower petals along with natural binders such as gum

Arabic and raw honey to make an effective herbal ink.

As stated in compound interest (2015), a number of different dyes are used in

highlighter pens depending on the ink color required. Yellow highlighters commonly

make use of a pyrene-based dye, such as pyranine; fluorescein can also be used.

Triphenyl methane dyes are used to make blue highlighters, and these can be mixed with

pyrene-based dyes to produce green inks, or mixed with the rhodamine dyes used to

make pink highlighters to produce a purple ink. Finally, a combination of a coumarin dye

and a xanthene dye can be utilized for orange ink. Aside from absorbing visible light, the

chemical structures of the dyes used in highlighter inks also absorb light in the ultraviolet

portion of the spectrum. When the electrons in the molecule absorb this light, they are

‘excited’ to a higher energy. The electrons do not remain in this higher energy state, but

‘relax’ back to their original state, releasing the excess energy in the form of light. This

light generally has a longer wavelength than the original absorbed light; as such, despite

original absorbed light having a wavelength in the ultraviolet portion of the spectrum,

when it is emitted, it can be in the visible portion. These fluorescent pigments, then, are

constantly undergoing this process, and emitting visible light as a consequence of

absorbing UV light. This isn’t too noticeable in normal daylight, but under a UV light,

it’s exceptionally pronounced, and gives highlighter inks their fluorescent appearance.

10
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

CHAPTER III

METHODOLOGY

This chapter precisely defines the methods used to conduct the study. The researchers

explain how the relevant data and information used to address the research questions and

objectives were collected, presented, and analyzed.

Research Design

The researchers used experimental design in the quantitative study. Where the

researchers manipulate the independent and dependent variables of the experiment. The

independent variables are the raw ingredients and the dependent variables are the color,

drying time and cost.

The experimental design is a systematic and scientific approach  to research

wherein the researchers imposes one or more variables, and administers the change to the

other variables (Explorable.com)

Sources of Data

The researchers used two sources of data for this study. The primary sources are

through direct observation and trial and error. The secondary sources are former studies

that attempted to create ink mainly from plants and other organic materials, and internet

sources related to highlighter ink and ink making.

11
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Research Locale

The study was conducted at Lyceum of the Philippines University Cavite.

Lyceum of the Philippines University Cavite is a private institution that is devoted on the

development of the philosophy and values of the former president Jose P. Laurel’s

“Veritas et Fortitudo” (truth and fortitude) and “Prodeo et Patria” (for guard and country).

Research Procedures

A. Collection of Raw Materials:

The researchers bought the sweet potato tops (Ipomoea batatas) leaves from the

local market. They also bought a small packet of gum Arabic from a baking

supplies store in the mall. The rest of the ingredients are present in the household

pantry so there is no need to buy new ones

B. Preparing of Organic Ink:

The researchers did the following steps to create organic ink:

Step 1: Chop 0.18 kg (approx. one small bundle) sweet potato tops including the

stalk into smaller pieces.

Step 2: Boil 600 ml of water then add the chopped sweet potato tops and 2

teaspoon of baking soda

Step 3: Let it simmer in low fire for about 15 minutes

Step 4: Remove from heat then filter the juice using a strainer

Step 5: Dissolve 3 tbsp. of gum Arabic in 60 mL water then boil for 3 minutes

Step 6: Combine 50 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL of Gum arabic


12
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

solution

Step 7: Combine 20 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL of Gum arabic

solution

Step 8: Combine 80 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL of Gum arabic

solution

Step 9: After combining each concentrations with Gum arabic, preheat the new

concentrations in low fire for 2 minutes

Step 10: Gently transfer ink into empty highlighter barrel

Testing the newly made ink:

The researchers tested the newly made ink by using it to write on a piece of bond

paper.

Data Gathering Procedure

Measuring the color Cost of the organic Analysis of


of the organic ink and ink and the variance will be
the commercial ink commercial ink calculated using
using Colourmeter will be manually SPSS statistical
app and smartphone calculated by the tool.
as spectrophotometer researchers.
and their drying time
using a timer.

Figure 1.1 Flow chart of Data Gathering

13
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Data Analysis

The efficiency of Camote tops as an alternative marker ink is measured using

One-way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) for the drying time and Two-way Multivariate

Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) for the color. According to Laerd Statistics (2018),

One-way Anova’s purpose is to identify if there is a difference between the two

independent groups, Two-way Anova’s purpose is to compare mean difference between

groups that have been split on two independent variables. The researchers used SPSS

statistical tool to calculate the Analysis of Variance.

14
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
Testing the ink
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE
The researchers tested the newly made ink by using it to write on a piece of bond paper

CHAPTER IV

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS

This chapter presents the results gathered by the researchers and the discussions in search

to find the answers on the research problem regarding the effectiveness of Camote tops

(Ipomoea batatas) as a source of pigment for alternative highlighter ink in terms of color,

cost, and drying time.

Data and Observations

Color

Table 1.1: Treatment 1: 20 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 150 151 163
blue 127 136 141
green 143 149 157

Table 1.2: Treatment 2: 50 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 165 152 158
blue 141 149 132
green 157 159 146

Table 1.3: Treatment 3: 80 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 135 157 163
blue 117 145 149
green 132 154 161

15
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Table 1.4: Control group: Sharpie flou xl, green (commercial highlighter ink)

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 61 65 66
blue 29 31 34
green 153 153 154

These tables show the results gathered after testing inks with three different

amounts of Camote tops concentrate mixed with 2 mL Gum arabic solution namely: 20

mL, 50mL, and 80mL, along with the commercial highlighter ink which is the control

group using Colourmeter. From these tables, one can notice that the control group has

lesser amounts of red and blue than the three treatments. The treatments on the other

hand, have more amounts of red than green, and less amounts of blue than green.

Drying time

Table 2.1: Treatment 1: 20 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

In seconds
Trial 1 1.85
Trial 2 1.80
Trial 3 1.90

Table 2.2: Treatment 2: 50 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

In seconds
Trial 1 2.48
Trial 2 2.27
Trial 3 2.21

16
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Table 2.3: Treatment 3: 80 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

In seconds
Trial 1 2.11
Trial 2 2.80
Trial 3 2.53

Table 2.4: Control group: Sharpie flou xl, green (commercial highlighter ink)

In seconds
Trial 1 1.62
Trial 2 1.55
Trial 3 1.53

These tables show the results that have been gathered after testing the treatments

and the control group’s drying time using a timer.With this we can see that the control

group has the shortest average drying time of 1.53 seconds, and that the third treatment

has the longest average drying time of 2.48 seconds.

17
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Cost

Table 3.1Cost

TREATMENTS PRODUCTION COST

Trial 1: (20 mL of Camote


I50 pcs (2ml) 0.5752 cents per highlighter
tops concentrate and 2 mL
barrel
Gum arabic solution)

Trial 2: (50 mL of Camote 0.3451 cents per highlighter


250 pcs (2 ml)
barrel
tops concentrate and 2 mL

Gum arabic solution)


Trial 3:(80 mL of Camote 240 pcs (2ml) 0.3595 cents per highlighter

tops concentrate and 2 mL barrel

Gum arabic solution)

Commercial Highlighter 1 pc (3ml) 60 pesos

After the experiment the researchers found that:

Treatment 1: If you combine 540 grams of Camote tops (approx. 3 bundles), 2 tsp of

baking soda (9.53 grams) and 3 tbsp. of Gum arabic solution (42.9 grams) you will be

able to produce 150 pcs of highlighter ink that is equivalent to .5792 cents per

highlighter.

18
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Treatment 2: If you combine 540 grams of Camote tops (approx. 3 bundles), 2 tsp of

baking soda (9.53 grams) and 3 tbsp. of Gum arabic solution (42.9 grams) you will be

able to produce 250 pcs of highlighter ink that is equivalent to .3451 cents per highlighter

Treatment 3: If you combine 540 grams of Camote tops (approx. 3 bundles), 2 tsp of

baking soda (9.53 grams) and 3 tbsp. of Gum arabic solution (42.9 grams) you will be

able to produce 240 pcs of highlighter ink that is equivalent to .3593 cents per highlighter

Commercial Highlighter: The sharpie highlighter that contains 3ml of ink costs 60 pesos

per piece.

19
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Color

Multivariate Testsa (Two-way MANOVA)


Effect Value F Hypothesis Error df Sig.
df
Intercept Pillai's Trace 1.000 4429.241b 3.000 6.000 .000
Wilks' Lambda .000 4429.241b 3.000 6.000 .000
b
Hotelling's Trace 2214.620 4429.241 3.000 6.000 .000
b
Roy's Largest Root 2214.620 4429.241 3.000 6.000 .000
Color Pillai's Trace .000 .b .000 .000 .
Wilks' Lambda 1.000 .b .000 7.000 .
b
Hotelling's Trace .000 . .000 2.000 .
b
Roy's Largest Root .000 .000 3.000 5.000 1.000

Treatment Pillai's Trace 1.416 2.385 9.000 24.000 .043

Wilks' Lambda .000 39.222 9.000 14.753 .000

Hotelling's Trace 1522.639 789.516 9.000 14.000 .000


c
Roy's Largest Root 1522.033 4058.756 3.000 8.000 .000
Color * .000 .b .000 .000 .
Pillai's Trace
Treatment
Wilks' Lambda 1.000 .b .000 7.000 .
b
Hotelling's Trace .000 . .000 2.000 .
b
Roy's Largest Root .000 .000 3.000 5.000 1.000
a. Design: Intercept + Color + Treatment + Color * Treatment
b. Exact statistic
c. The statistic is an upper bound on F that yields a lower bound on the significance level.
Table 4.1 MANOVA Results

20
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Post-hoc using Tukey HSD

Dependen Concentration Concentration Sig.


t variable (I) (J)
T1 T2 .956
T3 .975
T4 .000
T2 T1 .956
T3 .798
red T4 .000
T3 T1 .975
T2 .798
T4 .000
T4 T1 .000
T2 .000
T3 .000
Table 4.2

Dependen Concentration Concentratio Sig.


t variable (I) n
(J)
T1 T2 -36.1178
T3 -30.1178
T4 75.5488
T2 T1 -19.4512
T3 -21.7845
blue T4 83.8822
T3 T1 -25.4512
T2 -33.7845
T4 77.8822
T4 T1 -131.1178
T2 -139.4512
T3 -133.4512
Table 4.3

21
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Dependent Concentratio Concentration Sig.


variable n (J)
(I)
T1 T2 -23.1186
T3 -27.4519
T4 -19.1186
T2 T1 -18.4519
T3 -22.7852
green T4 -24.4519
T3 T1 -29.1186
T2 -28.1186
T4 -20.1186
T4 T1 -24.7852
T2 -19.4519
T3 -30.6080
Table 4.4

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.


*T=Treatment number

22
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Drying Time

One way ANOVA

Sum of df Mean Square F Sig.


Squares
Between Groups 1.594 3 .531 14.584 .001
Within Groups .291 8 .036
Total 1.885 11

Table 5.1

This is the table that shows the output of the ANOVA analysis and whether there

is a statistically significant difference between our group means. We can see that the

significance value is 0.001, which is below 0.05. And, therefore, there is a statistically

significant difference in the mean length of time to complete the experiment.

23
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Post-hoc using Tukey HSD

Concentration Concentration Sig.


(I) (J)
T1 T2 .065
T3 .016
T4 .332
T2 T1 .065
T3 .740
T4 .006
T3 T1 .016
T2 .740
T4 .002
T4 T1 .332
T2 .006
T3 .002
Table 5.2

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.


*T=Treatment number

24
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

CHAPTER V

SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Summary of Findings

The main objective of the study is to determine the effectiveness of Ipomoea

batatas as a source of pigment for highlighter ink. The different concentrations were

tested through its color and drying time. The cost of each concentrations are calculated

and compared to the cost of commercial highlighter ink. The results gathered were based

on Colourmeter app and a timer device. From the results gathered, it was proven that the

Camote tops concentration and Gum arabic solution possess the ability to be a potential

source for highlighter ink.

Conclusions

After acquiring the results of the research, the following conclusions were

deduced: (1) a concentrated liquid from the leaves of Camote tops may be used as a

source of pigment for ink however, it is not as bright and fluorescent as commercial

highlighters because it only relies on natural pigments. (2) The more diluted the ink's

solution is the more that it will bleed on paper and its drying time will be slower. (3)

Alternative ink with Camote tops as its potential source of pigment is more cost-effective

and budget friendly than commercial highlighters.

25
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Recommendations

After the circumstances that the researchers have encountered throughout the

research, they recommend to look for other plants that can give off even more

pigmentation than the Camote tops regardless of its color pay-off. In addition, they also

recommend to use another binder for ink other than Gum arabic because it is quite

expensive and to add a preservative to further prolong the ink’s shelf life since it is purely

organic and it is likely to ferment or rot which may affect the ink’s color and smell over

time. Commercial highlighter ink is still of better quality than alternative ink since it has

different chemicals in it but the alternative ink is still usable especially if you are trying to

save money.

26
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Anthis, C. (2015). DIY NATURAL HERBAL INK & FEATHER PEN. Retrieved from

thehippyhomemaker.com: http://www.thehippyhomemaker.com/homemade-ink-

featherpen/?

fbclid=IwAR0BoHUUmk97Ksgd5Zqeqd9X6a72dvDdsJnfXX1thDIKxAOBnyT

WCrb7MMA

"Ink."The Oxford Pocket Dictionary of Current English. Retrieved March 13, 2019 from

Encyclopedia.com: https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/dictionaries-

thesauruses-pictures-and-press-releases/ink-0

Kuntzleiman, T. (March, 2016). Use Your Smartphone as an “Absorption

Spectrophometer” Retrieved from: https://www.chemedx.org/blog/use-your-

smartphone-absorption-spectrophotometer

Sanjako, M. (2014). "Yellow Ginger (Curcuma longa) As Highlighter Ink". Retrieved

from prezi.com: https://prezi.com/fwtp2hgqbn5p/yellow-ginger-curcuma-longa-

as-ink/?fbclid=IwAR1KZx5_qcWYKDWvy1We-y0T2Thln86RjpW-yLLvwY3n-

b_I9XWP85p68Ww

The Chemistry of Highlighter Colors (2015). Retrieved from compoundchem.com:

https://www.compoundchem.com/2015/01/22/highlighters/

27
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

APPENDIX A

LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES

28
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Color

Table 1.1: Treatment 1: 20 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 150 151 163
blue 127 136 141
green 143 149 157

Table 1.2: Treatment 2: 50 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 165 152 158
blue 141 149 132
green 157 159 146

Table 1.3: Treatment 3: 80 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 135 157 163
blue 117 145 149
green 132 154 161

Table 1.4: Control group: Sharpie flou xl, green (commercial highlighter ink)

Color levels Trial 1 Trial 2 Trial 3


red 61 65 66
blue 29 31 34
green 153 153 154

29
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Drying time

Table 2.1: Treatment 1: 20 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

In seconds
Trial 1 1.85
Trial 2 1.80
Trial 3 1.90

Table 2.2: Treatment 2: 50 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

In seconds
Trial 1 2.48
Trial 2 2.27
Trial 3 2.21

Table 2.3: Treatment 3: 80 mL of Camote tops concentrate and 2 mL Gum arabic


solution

In seconds
Trial 1 2.11
Trial 2 2.80
Trial 3 2.53

Table 2.4: Control group: Sharpie flou xl, green (commercial highlighter ink)

In seconds
Trial 1 1.62
Trial 2 1.55
Trial 3 1.53

30
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Table 3.1Cost

TREATMENTS PRODUCTION COST

Trial 1: (20 mL of Camote


I50 pcs (2ml) 0.5752 cents per highlighter
tops concentrate and 2 mL
barrel
Gum arabic solution)

Trial 2: (50 mL of Camote 0.3451 cents per highlighter


250 pcs (2 ml)
barrel
tops concentrate and 2 mL

Gum arabic solution)


Trial 3:(80 mL of Camote 240 pcs (2ml) 0.3595 cents per highlighter

tops concentrate and 2 mL barrel

Gum arabic solution)

Commercial Highlighter 1 pc (3ml) 60 pesos

31
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Color

Multivariate Testsa (Two-way MANOVA)


Effect Value F Hypothesis Error df Sig.
df
Intercept Pillai's Trace 1.000 4429.241b 3.000 6.000 .000
b
Wilks' Lambda .000 4429.241 3.000 6.000 .000
b
Hotelling's Trace 2214.620 4429.241 3.000 6.000 .000
b
Roy's Largest Root 2214.620 4429.241 3.000 6.000 .000
Color Pillai's Trace .000 .b .000 .000 .
b
Wilks' Lambda 1.000 . .000 7.000 .
b
Hotelling's Trace .000 . .000 2.000 .
b
Roy's Largest Root .000 .000 3.000 5.000 1.000

Treatment Pillai's Trace 1.416 2.385 9.000 24.000 .043

Wilks' Lambda .000 39.222 9.000 14.753 .000

Hotelling's Trace 1522.639 789.516 9.000 14.000 .000

Roy's Largest Root 1522.033 4058.756c 3.000 8.000 .000


Color * .000 .b .000 .000 .
Pillai's Trace
Treatment
Wilks' Lambda 1.000 .b .000 7.000 .
b
Hotelling's Trace .000 . .000 2.000 .
b
Roy's Largest Root .000 .000 3.000 5.000 1.000
a. Design: Intercept + Color + Treatment + Color * Treatment
b. Exact statistic
c. The statistic is an upper bound on F that yields a lower bound on the significance level.
Table 4.1 MANOVA Results

32
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Post-hoc using Tukey HSD

Dependen Concentration Concentration Sig.


t variable (I) (J)
T1 T2 .956
T3 .975
T4 .000
T2 T1 .956
T3 .798
red T4 .000
T3 T1 .975
T2 .798
T4 .000
T4 T1 .000
T2 .000
T3 .000
Table 4.2

Dependen Concentration Concentratio Sig.


t variable (I) n
(J)
T1 T2 -36.1178
T3 -30.1178
T4 75.5488
T2 T1 -19.4512
T3 -21.7845
blue T4 83.8822
T3 T1 -25.4512
T2 -33.7845
T4 77.8822
T4 T1 -131.1178
T2 -139.4512
T3 -133.4512
Table 4.3

33
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Dependent Concentratio Concentration Sig.


variable n (J)
(I)
T1 T2 -23.1186
T3 -27.4519
T4 -19.1186
T2 T1 -18.4519
T3 -22.7852
green T4 -24.4519
T3 T1 -29.1186
T2 -28.1186
T4 -20.1186
T4 T1 -24.7852
T2 -19.4519
T3 -30.6080
Table 4.4

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.


*T=Treatment number

34
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Drying Time

One way ANOVA

Sum of df Mean Square F Sig.


Squares
Between Groups 1.594 3 .531 14.584 .001
Within Groups .291 8 .036
Total 1.885 11

Table 5.1

This is the table that shows the output of the ANOVA analysis and whether there

is a statistically significant difference between our group means. We can see that the

significance value is 0.001, which is below 0.05. And, therefore, there is a statistically

significant difference in the mean length of time to complete the experiment.

35
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Post-hoc using Tukey HSD

Concentration Concentration Sig.


(I) (J)
T1 T2 .065
T3 .016
T4 .332
T2 T1 .065
T3 .740
T4 .006
T3 T1 .016
T2 .740
T4 .002
T4 T1 .332
T2 .006
T3 .002
Table 5.2

*. The mean difference is significant at the 0.05 level.


*T=Treatment number

36
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

APPENDIX B

SAMPLE RSEARCH INSTRUMENTS

37
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

PREPARATION OF INGREDIENTS AND MATERIALS

Figure 2.1 the ingredients

Figure 2.2 pot

38
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Figure 2.3 Strainer

Figure 2.4 Empty highlighter

39
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Figure 2.5 Bowl

40
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

MAKING THE INK AND TESTING THE INK

Figure 3.1 Chopping the Camote tops

Figure 3.2 Adding 600 ml of water

41
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Figure 3.3 Adding 2 tbsp. of baking soda

Figure 3.4 Boiling for 15 minutes

42
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Figure 3.5 extracting the Camote concentrate

Figure 3.6 transferring the ink to the highlighter barrel

43
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Figure 3.7 testing the newly made highlighter ink

44
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

DATA GATHERING

Figure 4.1 Gathering the data of the three treatments

Figure 4.2 Gathering the data for the control group

45
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Researchers’ Profile

RESEARCHER’S PROFILE

Personal information
Name: Alolod, Gwyneth Star B.
2x2 Picture
Sex: Female
Date of Birth: April 15, 2000
Place of Birth: Quezon City
Civil Status: Single
Citizenship: Filipino
Present Address: Blk 15 Lot 26, Belgium St. Metroville Subd, Imus Cavite

Educational Background
Senior High School – International School
Lyceum of the Philippines University – Cavite
On-going

Seminars and Training Programs Attended


N/A

Other Skills and Competencies

Flexibility/adaptability

Technical skills

46
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Researchers’ Profile

RESEARCHER’S PROFILE

Personal information
Name: Ardina, Alyssa Marie A.
2x2 Picture
Sex: Female
Date of Birth: July 15, 2000
Place of Birth: Cavite City
Civil Status: Single
Citizenship: Filipino
Present Address: 171 Sanja Mayor Tanza, Cavite

Educational Background
Senior High School – International School
Lyceum of the Philippines University – Cavite
On-going

Seminars and Training Programs Attended


N/A

Other Skills and Competencies

Organizational skills

Attention to detail

Punctual

47
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Researchers’ Profile

RESEARCHER’S PROFILE

Personal information
Name: Arlos, Hazelene A.
Sex: Female
Date of Birth: July 10, 2001
Place of Birth: Pasig City
Civil Status: Single
Citizenship: Filipino
Present Address: Marycris Complex Subdivision General Trias, Cavite,
Philippines

Educational Background
Senior High School – International School
Lyceum of the Philippines University – Cavite
On-going

Seminars and Training Programs Attended


N/A

Other Skills and Competencies


Microsoft Office – Word, Excel, Powerpoint
SPSS statistical tool
Proofreading

48
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Researchers’ Profile

RESEARCHER’S PROFILE

Personal information
Name: Caguete, Anndrea P.
2x2 Picture
Sex: Female
Date of Birth: March 9, 2001
Place of Birth: Pasay City
Civil Status: Single
Citizenship: Filipino
Present Address: Blk. 5 lot 17 phase 2 Villa Antonina San Nicolas II Bacoor
City, Cavite

Educational Background
Senior High School – International School
Lyceum of the Philippines University – Cavite
On-going

Seminars and Training Programs Attended


N/A

Other Skills and Competencies


Teamwork
Methodical Approach

49
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM
LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY CAVITE

Researchers’ Profile

RESEARCHER’S PROFILE

Personal information
2x2 Picture
Name: Camo, Samantha Louise S.
Sex: Female
Date of Birth: April 6, 2001
Place of Birth: Tanza, Cavite
Civil Status: Single
Citizenship: Filipino
Present Address: Blk 56 Lot 3 David St. Sampaguita village Trece Martires
City, Cavite

Educational Background
Senior High School – International School
Lyceum of the Philippines University – Cavite
On-going

Seminars and Training Programs Attended


N/A

Other Skills and Competencies


Multi-tasking
Writing

50
INTERNATIONAL SCHOOL, SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL PROGRAM

You might also like