Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chemistry Journal Chjv07i04p0352
Chemistry Journal Chjv07i04p0352
net/publication/316666453
CITATIONS READS
0 996
1 author:
Kachapur Arunkumar
strides arcolab Pharmaceuticals Limited
9 PUBLICATIONS 22 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Kachapur Arunkumar on 04 May 2017.
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
352
K. Arun Kumar, et al., J. Chem. & Cheml. Sci. Vol.7(4), 352-360 (2017)
synthesis has become a challenging task for the organic chemist. Since it is difficult to identify
and control the impurities at acceptable level, extra purification is required there by making
the process less competitive.
Generally it makes it even more difficult for the organic chemist to design a synthesis
for the critical impurities, which are not reported in the literature. The development of drug
substance is incomplete without understanding the impurity profile involved in the process
and this impurity profiling study will be of immense help for organic chemists regarding the
potential impurity of carisoprodol API drug substance.
The literature survey on carisoprodol revealed that there are 4 process related
impurities reported in U.S. pharmacopeia, which are identified and synthesized 3. Other than
these known impurities an unknown impurity was observed at 0.14% when analysed by USP
HPLC method during the lab optimization and commercial manufacturing of our process [ref].
As a result it was a regulatory requirement to isolate, synthesise and characterize the process
impurity. This report describes the identification, synthesis (or isolation), and characterization
of the carisoprodol impurity and a mechanistic rationale for the formation of the impurity. To
the best of our knowledge, there is no commercial vendor for this new impurity and also there
is no synthesis reported in literature.
Process Impurity. The process for synthesis of Carisoprodol is shown in scheme-1.
Thecondensation of 2-methyl-2-propyl-propane-1, 3-diol (MPPD) 2 with dimethyl carbonate
and base as catalyst gives compound 3. The reaction of cyclic dioxanone 3 with isopropyl
amine resulted in mono isopropyl carbamate 4. The carbamate 4 is carbamylated with sodium
cyanate and dry HCl followed by recrystallization from methanol water to afford Carisoprodol (1).
The developed process is efficient to remove all reported impurities, but it resulted in
a process impurity routinely observed in the API in levels greater than 0.10% (HPLC area).
Accordingly, the impurity was identified, synthesized and characterized with the aid of modern
techniques.
Scheme-1
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
A comprehensive study was undertaken to identify the unknown impurity by LC-MS
method, followed by confirmation through synthesis of unknown impurity, and by
characterization of the prepared impurity based on modern spectroscopic techniques.
Presence of this unknown impurity was detected by HPLC in synthesized
Carisoprodol (1) and the mechanistic aspect behind the formation of the impurity was studied.
The impurity was controlled by improving reaction conditions and developed recrystallization
techniques to the best of knowledge, identification, synthesis and characterization of the above
said new process-related impurity was not reported so far.
353
K. Arun Kumar, et al., J. Chem. & Cheml. Sci. Vol.7(4), 352-360 (2017)
The new process related impurity appeared at RRT 0.67 at polar end of the
chromatogram compared to Carisoprodol. We intended to identify the possible structure by
considering the molecular weights (by LCMS), followed by their synthesis and confirming
through correlating these with the impurities forming in the reaction (by HPLC). The LC-MS
details of unknown impurities were given in figure 1.
The mass spectrum recorded for the impurity in positive mode by LC-MS showed a
molecular ion peak at m/z 259 [M + H] + indicating the molecular weight of the impurity as
258. Also it contained characteristic fragments at m / z values 156, 198.
Whereas the mass spectrum of parent ion showed a molecular ion peak at m / z 261
[M+H] + corresponding to the molecular weight of 260 with fragments at m / z values 158,
176, 200. While reviewing the data we observed that the impurity had a molecular weight that
was 2 amu less than the parent ion peak. Based on the molecular weight it has been speculated
that the impurity could be an olefin compound. The probable structures are as follows.
5 6
Figure-1
From the above two compounds possible structure might be 5 as the more substituted
double bond is stable compared to less substituted double bond. The above speculated
compound is similar to the impurity observed in Meprabamate4.
The proposed impurity was synthesized by following Scheme 2, and all the spectral
data confirm the structure. Chromatographic studies (HPLC) with varying the concentration
of impurity were also conducted and concluded that the same impurity existed in carisoprodol.
Possible Synthetic Approach for compound - 9:
Scheme-2
354
K. Arun Kumar, et al., J. Chem. & Cheml. Sci. Vol.7(4), 352-360 (2017)
As per the above proposed scheme, diethyl malonate 7 was reacted with
propionaldehyde with acetic anhydride as catalyst to give compound 8 5. The reaction of
Propylidene diethyl ester 8 with methyl iodide and LDA resulted in rearrangement of double
bond to give the propenyl ester compound 9 6, followed by reduction of ester with excess
DiBAL to furnish the desired diol 10 in moderate yield.
The critical formation of cyclic carbonate from diol 10 with dimethyl carbonate and
sodium methoxide base was attempted under various reported conditions [ref], but it failed to
give us the desired cyclic carbonate 11. Instead the uncyclized mono ester was isolated in most
of the cases (Scheme 3). Our efforts to cyclize 10 under various conditions using various metal
alkoxides, at elevated temperature proved to be ineffectual, consequently all cases resulted in
polymer product7.
OH O
DMC
O
120 - 150 ° C O
OH
Triphosgene - 78 °C
DCM
O
O
O
Scheme-3
355
K. Arun Kumar, et al., J. Chem. & Cheml. Sci. Vol.7(4), 352-360 (2017)
impurity, the doublet and multiplet signal appearing at δ 5.41 ppm and 5.46 ppm is evidence
for the presence of olefin protons, whereas the signals at δ 5.41 ppm and 5.46 ppm
corresponding to the olefin proton was absent in carisoprodol, it was further confirmed by the
13C spectra, which displayed a shortage of olefin carbon signals at δ δ125.46, δ133.4 ppm.
Based on the above spectral data, the molecular formula of impurity was confirmed as
C11H21NO3 and the corresponding structure was characterized as Isopropyl-carbamic acid 2-
hydroxymethyl-2-methyl-pentyl ester
The ESI-MS spectrum of carisoprodol olefin impurity 5 showed a protonated
molecule peak at m/z 259.1 (M + H) +, indicating the molecular mass of this impurity to be
258.1, which is 2 amu less than that of Carisoprodol. In the 1H NMR spectrum of this impurity,
the doublet and mutiplet signal appearing at δ 5.41 ppm and 5.46 ppm is evidence for the
presence of olefin protons, whereas the signals at δ 5.41 ppm and 5.46 ppm corresponding to
the olefin proton was absent in carisoprodol, it was further confirmed by the 13C spectra,
which displayed a shortage of olefin carbon signals at δ124.4, δ131.7ppm. Based on the above
spectral data, the molecular formula of impurity was confirmed as C12H22N2O4 and the
corresponding structure was characterized as Carbamic acid 2-isopropylcarbamoyloxymethyl-
2-methyl-pent-3-enyl ester
Formation of impurity
Carisoprodol was synthesized using 2-methyl-2-propyl-propane-1, 3-diol (MPPD) as
the starting material. It is proposed that the presence of 2- hydroxymethyl-2-methyl-pentane-
1, 3-diol as impurity in Diol can undergo simultaneous bis-carbamylation and dehydration to
give carbamic acid-2-carbamoyloxymethyl-2-methyl-pent-3-enyl ester which is the
carisoprodol olefin impurity found at 0.67 RRT in the HPLC-UV method. As per the strategy,
the triol was prepared from diethyl methyl malonate as starting material, and analysed by GC
in comparison with diol (KSM). The relevant triol was not detected in GC analysis.
Mechanism
356
K. Arun Kumar, et al., J. Chem. & Cheml. Sci. Vol.7(4), 352-360 (2017)
analysis the relevant olefin impurities were not detected in the carisoprodol API intermediates.
However, since the 0.67RRT impurity in Carisoprodol appears in the USP HPLC analysis
method, the same method was followed to analyse the penultimate compound 4 (N-Substituted
monocarbamate) in the USP HPLC method. To our surprise the prepared olefin
monocarbamate 8 from schem-2 has matched with RRT 0.60 in HPLC condition USP method
of compound 4.
Chromatographic studies (HPLC) with the 1% concentration and coinjection of
impurity 8 with compound 4 were also conducted and concluded that the same impurity was
carry over to next stage forming carisoprodol olefin impurity (0.67 RRT).
Experimental section
All materials were purchased from commercial suppliers. Unless specified otherwise,
all reagents and solvents were used as supplied by manufacturers. 1H NMR spectra and 13C
NMR spectra were recorded on a Varian 400 MR spectrometer in CDCl3 and DMSO-d6, and
mass spectra were determined on an API-2000LCMS mass spectrometer, Applied Biosystems.
High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC).
An USP HPLC (Reference) method was performed for the analysis of Carisoprodol
and its potential impurities (Shimadzu series 1100 with empower software, binary pump,
variable wavelength detector, Waldbronn, Germany), where a column Inertsil C8-3 (4.6-mm
´ 15-cm; 4-mm) with a mobile phase consisting of A:Acetonitrile and water(1:3, v/v), B:
acetonitrile , with a timed gradient program of T/%B: 0/100, 0/100, 20/80, 20/80, 0/100, 0/100,
with a flow rate of 1.5 mL/min and UV detection at 200 nm was used. This HPLC method was
able to detect all the impurities.
Mass Spectrometry. The mass spectra were recorded on Schimadzu LCMS-QP8000 and
Micromass LCT Premier XE mass spectrometers.
NMR Spectroscopy. The 1H NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker 300 MHz FT-NMR
spectrometer using CDCl3 as a solvent; the chemical shifts are reported in δ (ppm) relative to
TMS as internal standard. 13C and DEPT spectra were recorded on Bruker 300 MHz FTNMR
using CDCl3 as a solvent; the chemical shifts are reported in δ (ppm) relative to CDCl3 as
internal standard.
Experimental section
Preparation of 2-Propylidene-malonic acid diethyl ester 8.
To a solution of diethyl malonate (80.0 g, 0.499 mol, and 1.0 eq) in acetic anhydride
(80.0 g, 0.783 mol, and 1.57 eq) propionaldehyde (57.82 g, 0.994mol, and 2.0 eq) was charged
in an autoclave reactor. It was stirred for 12 hours at 120°C. The reaction mass was diluted
with DCM (400 mL) and washed with water (200 mL) followed by saturated sodium
bicarbonate solution (400 mL). The DCM layer was separated and concentrated. The crude
reaction mass was purified by high vaccum distillation at 120°C and 500mmHg pressure to
357
K. Arun Kumar, et al., J. Chem. & Cheml. Sci. Vol.7(4), 352-360 (2017)
afford 30 g of yellow oily liquid. 1HNMR (CDCl3, 300 MHz, δ ppm): 6.98 (t, 1H), 4.23 (m,
4H), 2.31 (m, 2H), 1.3 (t, 6H), 1.11 (t, 3H).
CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
1. (a) J.R. Stanko, ‟A review of oral skeletal muscle relaxants for the cranlomandibular
disorder (CMD) practitioner”, Journal of Craniomandibular Pract, 8(3), 234-43, (1990).
(b) T. Rohith, S. Ananda, Netkal M. Made Gowda. Method Development and Validation
of Carisoprodol and its Impurities by Ultra Violet-High Performance Liquid
Chromatography. Advances in Analytical Chemistry, 3(2): 15-19 (2013).
2. (a). ICH Guidelines, Q3A (R), Impurities in New Drug Substances, The quality guidelines
for Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients related to impurities according to the International
359
K. Arun Kumar, et al., J. Chem. & Cheml. Sci. Vol.7(4), 352-360 (2017)
Conference of Harmonization, February, 2002. (b) ICH Guidelines, Q3B (R) Impurities
in New Drug Products, The quality guidelines for Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients
related to impurities according to the International Conference of Harmonization,
February, 2002. (c) International Conferences on Harmonization’s, Impurities guidelines
for residual solvents. Q3(c), Federal Register, 62, (247), 67377 (1997).
3. USP Monograph 35, 5921.
4. K. Karthikeyan, G.T. Arularasu, V. Murali, K. Chandrasekara Pillai, Identification,
isolation, characterization and response factor determination of process-related impurity
in meprobamate drug substance. Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis 54,
208–212 (2011).
5. (a) Mingsheng Xie, Xiaohua Liu, Xiaoxia Wu, Yunfei Cai, Lili Lin, and Xiaoming Feng,
Catalytic Asymmetric [8+2] Cycloaddition: Synthesis of Cycloheptatriene-Fused Pyrrole
Derivatives. Angewandte Chemie, International Edition (2013), 52(21), 5604-5607. (b)
Krzysztof Okrasa, Colin Levy, Matthew Wilding, Mark Goodall, Nina Baudendistel,
Bernhard Hauer, David Leys, and Jason Micklefield, Structure-Guided Directed Evolution
of Alkenyl and Aryl malonate Decarboxylases. Angewandte Chemie, International
Edition, 48(41), 7691-7694 (2009).
6. (a) Sonali M. Date, Rekha Singh and Sunil K. Ghosh, The unprecedented reaction of
dimethylsulfonium methylide with Michael acceptors: synthesis of 1-substituted
vinyl silanes and styrenes. Organic & Biomolecular Chemistry (2005), 3(18), 3369-3378.
(b) Hauer Bernhard, Boudendistel Nina, Orkasa Kryzystof, Mickel Field Jason, Leys
David, Levy Colin, New Malonate decarboxylases for industrial applications.
WO 2009/068308 A2.
7. Preparation of deuterated carisoprodol as carbamate reducers of skeletal muscle tension
with improved pharmacokinetics, pharmacodynamics, and toxicity properties. Gant,
Thomas G. and Shahbaz, Manouchehr M. From U.S. Pat. Appl. Publ., 20100076074, 25
Mar (2010).
(b) Varsha Pokharkar; S. Sivaram, Poly (alkylene carbonate) by the carbonate interchange
reaction of aliphatic diols with dimethyl carbonate: synthesis and characterization.
Polymer Vol. 36 No. 25, pp. 4851-4854, (1995).
8. Robert M. Burk and Michael B. Roof, A Safe and Efficient Method for Conversion of 1,
2- and 1, 3-Diols to Cyclic Carbonates Utilizing Triphosgene. Tetrahedron Letters Vol.
34, No. 3. m. 395398.1993. (b) Andrés Villalpando, Mirza A. Saputra, Thomas H. Tugwell
and Rendy Kartika, Triphosgene–pyridine mediated stereoselective chlorination of acyclic
aliphatic 1, 3-diols. Chem. Commun., 51, 15075-15078 (2015).
9. B.J. Ludwig, L.S.Powell, and F.M.Burger, Carbamate Derivatives Related to
Meprobamate. Journal of Medicinal Chemistry, 12(3), 462-72 (1969).
360