Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Buhatan River Ecoadventure: A Case Study: Ntroduction
The Buhatan River Ecoadventure: A Case Study: Ntroduction
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Asia Pacific Journal of
The Buhatan River Ecoadventure: A Case Multidisciplinary Research
Study Vol. 5 No.3, 71-78
August 2017 Part II
Cyra Mae R. Soreda1, Aldrin John J. Estonanto2 P-ISSN 2350-7756
Sorsogon State College, Sorsogon City, Philippines E-ISSN 2350-8442
1
cyramaesoreda@gmail.com , aldrinestonanto@gmail.com 2 www.apjmr.com
Abstract - This explanatory study focused on the ecotourism project in Buhatan, Sorsogon,
Philippines. It highlighted the potentials of ecotourism as a developmental tool for biodiversity
conservation, economic, and social development. It sought to determine the implications of having
ecotourism, who or what sector(s) would best benefit from ecotourism and what are the things needed to
be done to maximize the potentials of ecotourism. While qualitative design was employed, triangulation
was used to reduce the risk of bias and inaccuracies the analysis of data. Findings revealed the common
implications of ecotourism in Buhatan such as job opportunities, fostering cooperation, balanced
economic and environmental activities, discipline and inter-sector linkages which profits most the
boatmen, culinary group members and cooperative. The study concluded that the ecotourism in Buhatan
has a potential in promoting economic and social development, and environmental conservation could
benefit the community as a whole if private-public sector linkages and active participation of the
community members are improved. It was recommended to include the tourists‟ perception about the
ecotourism project in the data gathering procedure since it would provide useful insights on the
implications of ecotourism to its target clients
Keywords: ecotourism, establishment, sustainability, economic and social development, ecoadventure
Data Analysis
Since this case study utilized an explanatory
framework, guided by research questions, it made
used of analytic analysis in form of descriptions. The
study used emergent framework to group the data and
then the relationship were identified. In order to
present the analysis, narratives and framework Figure 1. Embedded, single case study design
approach were employed. Pattern matching and
explanation building techniques were also used to Process for Developing the Solution
support the data. Summaries and self-memos were The researchers involved community residents
also used as tools for the analysis. Triangulation of and local officials during the interview to provide
evidence from multiple sources was also applied to their perceptions regarding ecotourism and also
establish converging lines of evidence which make the insights about the organizational structure of
findings as robust as possible and reduce risks for bias ecotourism and its relationship to the community.
and inaccuracies. These criteria in data analysis Empirical data were collected in the attempt to
strengthen the data and claim for this study. identify patterns that exist in the community as well as
to provide a deeper understanding on the subject,
The Solution ecotourism.
This study made use of an embedded, single- case The researchers interviewed different persons
study design in targeting a community that was from the community of Buhatan, Sorsogon since April
establishing ecotourism as one of its economic 6, 2015 when the Buhatan River Ecotourism
development tool through identifying its implications Ecoadventure was first launched by the local
and providing insights on the common problems government of Buhatan as its major tourism project.
regarding ecotourism and ways of addressing these The participants include persons like the barangay
problems. The empirical data collected were utilized chairman, person-in-charge for tourism, president for
to gain deeper understanding on the subject while the cooperative handling the project, as well as four
targeting the community residents and officials as residents of the barangay who all provided their
participants of the study as they could provide the opinions and knowledge about the ongoing project.
necessary information. It also focused on the grass- The researchers found out during the process of
root level of the society to give the locals “voice” in making the study that residents were reluctant at first
which to present their perceptions on the ecotourism to share their honest perspective about the ecotourism
development and to avoid influences from “big community project in their barangay that it took some
people” in the society, hence, this study really more questions or time for them to confidently share
centered on who really benefits from the ecotourism their standpoints. This situation led to the decision of
project. The study used two variables as a unit of the researcher to employ triangulation as a process of
analysis. The first was the implications of ecotourism gathering information from different resources to
as cited by the participants and the second was the reduce the risks of bias and inaccuracies associated
common problems the participants cited with regards with getting info from only one source.
to ecotourism in their community and how these
problems can be addressed. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The design on making the final deliverable can be
The Participants
illustrated on the figure below wherein the first unit of
The researchers interviewed seven (7)
analysis will be the implication and the second unit of
participants, three (3) of which were key persons for
73
P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com
Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, Vol. 5, No. 3, August 2017 (Part II)
Soreda & Estonanto, The Buhatan River Ecoadventure: A Case Study
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
this research considering that they have a direct role to in charged for preparing the food ordered by the
play for the ecotourism project in Buhatan, Sorsogon tourist that are usually for their lunch or dinner. This
while the other four (4) participants were common was confirmed by the report provided by the president
residents of the barangay in order to get perceptions of cooperative handling the ecotourism project for
regarding the ecotourism project in the grass-root Buhatan River wherein just from July to September
level. The first part of the interview includes the 2015, the total income of the boatmen, in general, was
name, occupation, and age of the participant since this Php 42, 350.00 while there had been a total income
basic information may elicit diversity of opinions for the tourism council and OD for Php 6, 600.00 and
among the participant. The other half of the interview Php 13, 300.00 respectively. There was also an
was guided by the research questions in determining amount of Php 3, 267.50 given to the barangay. As
the implications, problems and solutions associated one of the key persons told the researcher:“Dati, yang
with ecotourism in Buhatan, Sorsogon based on the mga bangkeros, umaasa lang sila sa huli nilang isda
perceptions of the participants. The key persons were: na madalas wala kapag masama ang panahon o
Edwin Divina, the chairman of Brgy. Buhatan and one maulan. Ngayon, basta may tourist na darating, may
of the persons-in-charge for the Buhatan River sigurado silang income „pagbumiyahe sila (In the
Ecoadventure Project; NenitaAlpas, one of the past, those boatmen only rely on the catch (fish) that
counselors of Brgy. Buhatan, Sorsogon and person-in- are rare when the weather is bad or it’s raining. Now,
charge for Brgy.Tourism and; Myrna Fulo, president as long as there are tourists visiting the place, they
of Buhatan River Ecoadventure Cooperative (the have a sure income if they’re the one assigned to the
organization in-charged for the project). The key cruise).”
persons were interviewed during their scheduled time. At this time, the key persons admitted that
Other participants were: Analiza Deliosa, former although it is a source of income, it is still limited to
Samahan ng Kababaihan culinary group member; 15 boatmen since there are only 10 kayaks (donated
Lourdes Dato, 62 years old and nipa maker; Katrina by the City government Mayor Sally Lee), four
Lizano, a midwife; and Efegenio Dato, 68 years old, a floating cottages namely: Regina 1 & 2 (donated by
retired government employee. The resident- ABS-CBN foundation), Lagrimas (donated by a navy
participants were interviewed by chance, during their officer), and Archangel (donated by a priest) who both
most convenient time. wished to be unknown donors, and a reserved floating
cottage that the cooperative rents if ever there is a
Implications of Ecotourism in Barangay Buhatan, need. As one of the key persons said, more fisher
Sorsogon City folks will be able to get additional income if only
While there are many advantages and there are more boats and floating cottages to be used.
disadvantages that one can name when it comes to This also limits their capacity on accommodating
ecotourism, participants gave common answers when large number of guests at a time. Role of the tourist
asked what are the implications of having ecotourism guides were also given to cooperative members and
project on their barangay. other officials who know the place and the project’s
features in order save money and also due to lack of
Additional Source of Income resource persons. This resonates Ghimire[5]statement
All of the participants agreed that having the that local communities not only lack financial
ecotourism project in their barangay had provided resources to begin tourism schemes but also have
additional source of income to the community difficulties in meeting high level managerial capacity
residents, particularly for the fisher folks and women building to manage these projects. Another key person
who have skills in cooking. The barangay council, in added:
cooperation with the Buhatan River Ecoadventure “Niyan, ang kababaihan, imbes magtsirismisan,
Cooperative, made two groups for these people—the may pagkakaabalahan na sinda na makadanun pa sa
boatmen (bangkeros) and the culinary group (women kanira magka-income (Today, women here in our
who are member of the Samahan ng Kababaihan). The place, instead of spending their time gossiping, can
boatmen, as discussed by the key persons include 15 have something to do where they can get an income).”
men tasked to row the boat or the floating cottage for One of the resident-participants, however, shared
the tourists during their river cruise. On the other that although the ecotourism project offers additional
hand, the culinary group, consisting of 41 women, are source of income for culinary group members, this
74
P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com
Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, Vol. 5, No. 3, August 2017 (Part II)
Soreda & Estonanto, The Buhatan River Ecoadventure: A Case Study
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
opportunity may be limited since that way it works, Promoting Environmental Awareness and
culinary members were assigned of a specific dish in Protection
the menu offered to the tourists and when a tourist All of the participants agreed that with
orders a specific dish from the menu at the start of the establishing ecotourism, the environmental awareness
cruise, one culinary group member assigned to that on their place had increased especially when it comes
dish will be contacted to prepare the food, using her to maintaining the cleanliness of the river and assuring
own money first. She will just get her fund plus its that everyone is cooperating when it comes to waste
increase after the tourist had paid for the food. So if management by not dumping in the river. The
you don’t have the money to prepare the food, then ecotourism project for the Buhatan River didn’t have
you won’t be able to have the additional income. This an easy start as the river needs rehabilitation since it
issue had been cleared by one of the key persons in had been dumped with different kinds of wastes.
one of the interviews when she shared that it was However, the community of Buhatan made it sure that
really the situation before since the project is just the natural beauty of the river was not to be destroyed.
starting and there is no extra fund for food One of the key persons said:
preparation. But now, since there had already been a “Walang ginalaw sa natural beauty ng river;
profit, the cooperative can give the budget for the food tinanggal lang ang mga basura galing sa Sorsogon
to the culinary member assigned to prepare it then Bay at dito sa Buhatan (The natural beauty of the
later, when the tourist pay for the food, the budget will river wasn’t touched, we just took away the wastes
be remitted back to the cooperative as a standing fund coming from Sorsogon Bay and here in Buhatan).”
while the income will be given to the one who There had been ordinances issued by the barangay
prepared the food. council to put a stop on illegal activities surrounding
While all of the participants were aware of the the Buhatan River and dumping of wastes in the river.
additional source of income that comes with this This action is actually supported by Pat [2] suggested
ecotourism project, most of the community residents strategies in having a successful ecotourism by having
shared their sentiments that while it is not a bad thing sound laws and policy regarding environment
to have this ecotourism since it really provides preservation. Two of the residents said that as part of
additional source of income, the people who can obeying the policies and ordinances issued by the
experience this opportunity are only those boatmen barangay council on the effort of maintaining the
and women who are members of the culinary group, cleanliness of the river, some residents have to give up
not really all of the residents of the barangay. their other source of income like the pig pens near the
One of the key persons seems aware of this river or they have to have a septic tank so that the
sentiment, said: wastes won’t go to the river. This is actually an
“Kaya ako, ini-encourage ko ang mga ka- evidence of the sound implementation of policies and
barangay ko na kung mayun sinda maski nano na laws regarding the environment protection and
produkto na gusto ipabakal, ikadi lang dini saamun conservation which is a very important factor for the
kay kung may gusto magkuha or mag-order, sustainability of ecotourism.
ipapaaram mi man sa kanira kay sayang baga san In addition to these efforts, the key persons also
income (That’s why I encourage my neighbors to shared that there had been different activities like
share to us whatever product they may want to sell so planting of 20,000 Mangroves along the Buhatan
that whenever someone buy or wants to order the River and Bantay-Suba(river guard) program to
product, we will notify them because we they can gain ensure the preservation and conservation of the river.
income out of it).” The community itself is giving conscious effort on
This strengthens the statement of protecting their ecotourism for sustainability by
Devanedara[3]who postulated that local manpower protecting the environment.
must be develop to capture the benefits of tourism.
What seems to be the issue of not experiencing this Improving Community Linkages and Inter-Sector
benefit of ecotourism is not the absence of the Linkages
opportunity itself but the ways to embrace the Establishing ecotourism in Buhatan with its
opportunities for additional source of income are not pioneer project on Buhatan River Ecoadventure does
visible to common residents. not only offer additional income to local residents but
also improve the linkages of within the community
75
P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com
Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, Vol. 5, No. 3, August 2017 (Part II)
Soreda & Estonanto, The Buhatan River Ecoadventure: A Case Study
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
and its linkages across the different sectors and “Di mo man mahahali na minsan may pasaway
institutions. talaga na matapok man gihapon basura sa river
All of the residents had been made aware that maski aram na bawal pero ang publicity san project
there were a cooperative organized to act as the tapos makita niya na sya nalang an di nagsusunod,
steering committee for the ecotourism project namely: masunod man yun. Mararaw-ay man siya sa sadiri
Buhatan River Ecoadventure Cooperative and other nya kaya mapundo siya (It’s really hard to make
groups such as the group for the boatmen (bangkeros) everyone obey the ordinance at one. There will be
and culinary group for the women (Samahan ng someone who will still dump in the river though they
Kababaihan), and also a Buhatan Tourism council was know that it is prohibited but the publicity gained by
organized. The good thing is the cooperative is open the project and he will realize that he is the only one
to all who would want to join the group and is not obeying the ordinance, he will follow. He will be
prioritizing residents of barangay who want to join. It ashamed of himself so he will now follow).”
was also through linkages that the cooperative was The ecotourism project in Buhatan as a
able to gain donors for the floating cottages and community-based project really needs the cooperation
kayaks. As reported by the key persons and one of the and discipline each member can offer to attain its
resident-participants who had a connection with the development goals.
Bantay-suba program, it was the City Environment
Organization (CENRO) that is in charge for Promoting Ecologically Low-Impact Experience
deputizing river guards and giving them salaries. Like the Maasi community that is promoting
The community of Buhatan believes that with that ecologically low-impact experience to the visitors,
through helping each other and sourcing out, the Buhatan River Ecoadventure also offers a variety of
project will have a better outcome. This is also put activities like kayaking, floating cottage experience,
into focus by Murphy [6]as cited by Timothy[7] and fireflies and birds watching, and fishing that are all
Tuson[8] that tourism relies on the goodwill and safe and ecology-friendly. It stresses the idea
cooperation of the people. Although there were presented by Devenadera[3] that economic activities
struggles making the people cooperate right away, the and environment protection must be balanced in order
participants agreed that the first year of the project had to sustain ecotourism. This only implies that one can
been a success because people are cooperating and have a rich experience close to nature without
ready to help just like what it share by three of the harming the environment. In fact, as the key persons
participants that in making the restaurant for the shared, most of their visitors are tourists who already
project, the people and members of the cooperative experience the adventure but would want to do it
really lend a hand to each other in other to minimize again with other people. Just from the opening of this
the costs considering that budget were limited. ecotourism project, April, to July 2015, they already
As stated by four of the participants, they have had 1, 436 recorded tourist visits.
seen many people coming to help in their community
and many of the members of their community putting Who profits then?
efforts on participating in the project. This was also When participants were asked about who or what
shared by Relampangos[9]on his case study that sector(s) do they think profits or benefits the most
sustainability offered by ecotourism may be achieved from the Buhatan River Ecoadventure project, all of
through the efforts of business, tourism industry, the participants agreed that at this time, the boatmen
community, and government. In fact, the Buhatan and culinary group members as well as the
barangay council wants to make partnership with the cooperative benefit the most from the project. This
education sector of the community for training tourist may be attributed to the idea that only those who have
guides in the near future. direct relations to the project can benefit from it as the
project only provides menial jobs for the community
Fostering Discipline members and considering that it is still on the process
All of the resident-participants admitted that of establishing the industry on the community. This
although they may not get an additional income from resonates the concept revealed by Tuson[10] that
the ecotourism project, they are positive to it since it ecotourism projects usually can only be seen to
promotes discipline. This was affirmed by one of the benefit only a segment of the community, this being
key persons’ own words: the committee members. However, one of the key
76
P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com
Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, Vol. 5, No. 3, August 2017 (Part II)
Soreda & Estonanto, The Buhatan River Ecoadventure: A Case Study
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
persons also added that since they are using a suggested giving the people active participation to the
community-based approach on this project, it is project by providing them fund and capacity building
actually designed to benefit even the grass-root level. for locals so that they can run and manage their own
The benefit of the ecotourism, like other industries, ecotourism project. This can be also done by
takes time to be seen in all level. Given the time, these informing the people on what are the direct benefits
benefits may extend on its context. they can get from the project.
78
P-ISSN 2350-7756 | E-ISSN 2350-8442 | www.apjmr.com
Asia Pacific Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, Vol. 5, No. 3, August 2017 (Part II)