Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Use of Artificial Dermis in The Reconstruction.9
The Use of Artificial Dermis in The Reconstruction.9
R
econstruction of complicated defects cre- flaps is complicated in the face of preoperative
ated by tumor excision has primarily in- irradiation, previous surgery, and larger defect
volved the use of skin grafts and either size.
local or distant myocutaneous, myofascial, or fas- Free tissue transfers have revolutionized on-
ciocutaneous flaps. Although these options offer cologic surgery. Even in the most experienced
adequate coverage, they often fail to provide hands, they are time consuming and often
good aesthetic results and require additional re- require more than 1-day hospital stays. Irradi-
visions to correct muscle atrophy and contour ation, previous surgery, and comorbidities can
abnormalities.1 Skin grafts will provide coverage make these operations challenging and less
but are subject to contraction and are often predictable.1 In addition to the primary surgi-
unstable, particularly on bony prominences and cal site, the patient also experiences, in many
calvarium.2 Similarly, skin grafts are often unsta- cases, significant donor-site morbidity and ab-
ble, particularly in the face of adjuvant radiation normality. Although every attempt is made to
therapy.3 Full-thickness skin grafts, though ex- reduce this donor-site morbidity, the outcome
hibiting less contraction, are often not adequate is largely dependent on the resection defect
to cover large defects. The use of locoregional and site selected for donor tissue.
Biosynthetic composites have been in use for
From the Divisions of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery and over 20 years in the management of complicated
Pediatric Surgery, Department of Surgery, The Johns Hop- wounds. Artificial dermis is a synthetic bilami-
kins School of Medicine. nate composed of a bovine collagen lattice co-
Received for publication October 9, 2005; accepted March valently linked to chondroitin-6-sulfate and cov-
10, 2006. ered with a Silastic epidermis.4 At approximately
Copyright ©2007 by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons 21 days after application, the Silastic sheet is
DOI: 10.1097/01.prs.0000270298.68331.8a removed and a skin graft is placed on the vascu-
638 www.PRSJournal.com
Volume 120, Number 3 • Artificial Dermis
larized neodermis. Artificial dermis has also struction was carried out in the same two-stage
been used in reconstructive surgery with success. process. The time interval between these stages
In burn reconstruction, patients with severe and the time to the last follow-up visit were also
burn contractures and deformities have re- recorded.
gained good functionality and aesthetic results, The first stage involved removal of the tumor
with improved color, texture, and contour.5–7 and application of the Integra dermal template.
There is some debate on the recurrence of post- The template is a bilayer xenographic dermal sub-
burn contractures in reconstruction of the neck8 stitute composed of a collagen-glycosaminoglycan
and chest9 despite use of Integra (Integra Matrix matrix layer, which promotes dermal regenera-
Wound Dressing; Integra LifeSciences Corp., tion, and a semipermeable silicone layer, which
Plainsboro, N.J.). Even in the field of posttrauma functions as a temporary epidermis. All wounds
reconstruction, artificial dermis has been dem- were fresh surgical resections down to and, in some
onstrated as useful in correcting posttraumatic cases, including periosteum, fascia, and bone (Ta-
deformities, particularly depressions and ble 1). In fact, six surgical wound beds extended
adhesions.10 Despite the necessity for a two-stage to bone. Defect size was determined by analogue
procedure, artificial dermis offers many advan- rulers used to measure the greatest cross-sectional
tages, including immediate availability, ability to length and width with resultant area calculated.
cover large defects, minimal donor-site morbid- Areas of breakdown and ulceration were likewise
ity, good cosmetic results with optimal contour- measured and their area deducted from the total.
ing, and reduced scarring and hypertrophy.11 After tumor excision and adequate hemostasis,
The role of artificial dermis in general plastic the artificial dermal template was sutured into
and reconstructive surgery is not well defined. place using absorbable material (Figs. 1 and 2).
Recent case reports indicate its successful use in In each case, the Integra was meshed before
the reconstruction of defects created by giant implantation to minimize the risk of hematoma
hairy nevi excision12 and complex scalp defects13; or seroma formation. A silver-coated antimicro-
however, there have been no large patient re- bial barrier dressing (Acticoat; Westaim Biomedical,
ports of its use in the reconstruction and resur- Calgary, Alberta, Canada) was placed over the In-
facing of defects created by tumor excision, es- tegra. A bolster dressing was applied to the graft and
pecially larger defects where flap reconstruction left in place for 5 days. Thereafter, the dressing,
would usually be required. It is our goal to ex- along with the Acticoat, was changed every day and
plore the utility of artificial dermis as a successful the surgical site was examined for signs of infection,
tool for reconstruction of tumor resection de- silicone detachment, and neodermis formation. Be-
fects and its ability to function under the rigors fore all surgical procedures, all patients were given
of adjuvant therapy. prophylactic antibiotics as dictated by our institu-
tional protocols.
PATIENTS AND METHODS At approximately 21 days after evidence of
Medical records from 17 patients who under- neodermis formation, the patient was brought
went reconstruction with the use of dermal sub- back to the operating room for the second and
stitute (Integra Matrix Wound Dressing) were ret- final stage of the procedure. During this time, the
rospectively reviewed, and information regarding silicone layer was removed and replaced with a
clinical history; patient age; tumor type and loca- thin split-thickness skin graft. All skin grafts were
tion; defect size; and history of previous surgery, placed as sheet grafts. A bolster dressing was again
preoperative chemotherapy, or radiation therapy applied and left in place for 3 to 5 days. The
was recorded. The series represents the experi- patient was instructed on proper wound care man-
ence of a single surgeon (A.P.T.). All patients who agement and returned to the clinic for follow-up
presented to the senior author for primary or re- within 7 days. At each follow-up visit, after the
current cutaneous or subcutaneous tumor resec- initial procedure, the surgical site was examined
tion were considered for reconstruction with der- for infection, stability of the silicone layer, take of
mal substitute. Wounds that could be closed either the artificial dermis by the initial adherence of the
primarily or by secondary retention or that were material to the bed and subsequent vascular in-
easily amenable to locoregional flap reconstruc- growth, and overall wound healing. At visits after
tion were not treated with this technique. Also, the second stage, the area was examined for in-
patients whose wounds would present with a sig- fection, take or adherence of the skin graft as a
nificant contour deformity were not reconstructed percentage of total graft area, and overall wound
with artificial dermis. In every case, the recon- healing. On subsequent follow-up visits, the site
639
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 1, 2007
was examined for breakdown and ulceration, pain, gical interventions and required recurrent tumor
aesthetics (e.g., pliability, contour, color, and tex- resection. Three patients (18 percent) received
ture), patient satisfaction, function, and need for neoadjuvant radiation therapy and two patients
further surgery. The outcomes of these evalua- received neoadjuvant chemotherapy or vaccine
tions is reported in the Results section and illus- immunotherapy before undergoing reconstruc-
trated in the figures. Statistical analysis of the pa- tion, whereas five patients (29 percent) received
tient population was determined by the arithmetic postoperative radiation therapy and one re-
mean and SD. ceived postoperative chemotherapy. The surgi-
cal bed notably was bone in six cases and peri-
RESULTS osteum in seven cases. The mean defect size of
Patient Characteristics the surgical bed was 172 ⫾ 260 cm2 (range, 20
A total of 17 patients underwent reconstruc- to 1080 cm2) (Table 1).
tion of tumor resection defects with Integra der-
mal substitute at the Johns Hopkins Hospital from Reconstruction and Follow-Up
December of 2003 to May of 2005. The mean age There were no complications associated with
of the patients was 54 ⫾ 21 years (range, 15 to 79 the Integra template application. Two patients ex-
years). Of the 17 patients, 12 (71 percent) were perienced minimal (⬍10 percent) silicone de-
male and five (29 percent) were female. The 17 tachment before skin grafting. In these cases, the
cases involved 10 different tumor types, including unattached silicone layer was excised and routine
melanoma (five cases), dermatofibrosarcoma pro- daily dressing changes were carried out. In all
tuberans (three cases), angiosarcoma (two cases), cases, well-vascularized neodermis formation was
squamous cell carcinoma (two cases), basal cell observed before the second procedure. The split-
carcinoma, desmoid tumor, metastatic renal cell thickness skin graft was applied as a sheet graft on
carcinoma, malignant nerve sheath tumor, lipo- postoperative day 23 ⫾ 6 and sutured with absorb-
sarcoma, and angioblastoma. The tumors were able material. No staples were used. Sixteen pa-
removed from six different anatomical locations tients had 100 percent take of their grafts and one
including the scalp (six cases), face (three cases), patient had approximately 97 percent take. Clin-
neck (three cases), chest wall (two cases), lower ically, these patients experienced excellent con-
extremity (two cases), and posterior auricular tour and cosmesis without complication. The
area. Twelve patients (71 percent) had prior sur- mean follow-up was 12.3 ⫾ 7.3 months (range, 3
640
Volume 120, Number 3 • Artificial Dermis
641
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 1, 2007
radiation therapy subsequently developed mild ra- varia, particularly in the presence of an outer table
diation-related complications, including blister craniectomy, is often unstable and exhibits fre-
formation and minimal graft ulceration. On sub- quent breakdown and ulceration. Figure 4, below
sequent follow-up visits, these three patients shows a 6-month postoperative photograph of pa-
healed well, without residual deficits. Notably, the tient 5 with a recurrent malignant nerve sheath
longest follow-up is in a patient with postoperative tumor. The reconstruction is soft and supple, with
radiation therapy, and those patients undergoing no evidence of breakdown, as is also illustrated in
postoperative radiation therapy had on average a Figure 5 (patient 12). This photograph was ob-
longer follow-up (17.8 ⫾ 7.5 months) without any tained at 6 weeks postoperatively and demon-
sequelae besides those noted above. strates a patient with a well-healed sheet graft on
For a reconstructive technique to be accept- neodermis. Likewise, Figure 6 is a 3-month fol-
able in oncologic resections, it must be able to low-up photograph from a similar complex prob-
tolerate adjuvant radiation therapy. Figure 1, below lem of grafting on the calvaria. The sheet graft is
shows patient 1 at 8 months after resection and supple and pliable and the skin easily wrinkles with
adjuvant radiation therapy. The patient has a sta- movement and is not fixed to the underlying bone
ble result, with no significant contraction or dis- (Fig. 7).
tortion of the commissure of the lip or adjacent
structures. The surgical site exhibits erythema that DISCUSSION
is consistent with the surrounding native skin’s The reconstruction of soft-tissue defects cre-
response to radiation. Figure 3, right shows such a ated by radical resection of benign and malignant
patient (patient 13) 6 months after resection and tumors presents a difficult surgical challenge. The
adjuvant irradiation for a large angiosarcoma of standard reconstructive ladder is usually applied;
the trunk. The patient developed areas of blister however, every rung of the ladder has its own set
formation and a small amount of ulceration, less of problems.1 Large defects, particularly those sec-
than 20 percent of the total grafted area. The ondary to resection of a malignancy, are not ame-
blistering and ulceration were managed with rou- nable to healing by secondary intention. The use
tine wound care and the area went on to heal of full-thickness skin grafts works very well for
without sequelae. smaller defects. Larger wounds will require a split-
A plan for reconstruction of an oncologic re- thickness skin graft. Although full-thickness skin
section must be durable on bone or periosteum; grafts will exhibit fewer of these problems, these
notably in this series, six cases included bone and grafts will exhibit contraction and can distort ad-
seven included periosteum. Skin graft on the cal- jacent structures such as lips and eyelids. Skin
Fig. 3. Patient 13 had recurrent angiosarcoma. (Left) Postoperative view, 5 days after resection and
Integra placement. (Right) Follow-up view at 6 months after Integra placement and postoperative radi-
ation therapy.
642
Volume 120, Number 3 • Artificial Dermis
643
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 1, 2007
644
Volume 120, Number 3 • Artificial Dermis
The vast majority of experience with the neo- oncologic tumor reconstruction, especially in
dermis material was obtained in the manage- patients with large defects, patients with recur-
ment of acute burns.14 –16 The problems seen in rent tumors, and patients who require adjuvant
the burn population are not seen in the onco- therapy.
logic population for the most part. Problems
with wound infection, hypertrophic scarring, Anthony P. Tufaro, D.D.S., M.D.
Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery
and the need for multiple operations and con- Department of Surgery
tractures were not seen. Even in the face of The Johns Hopkins School of Medicine
numerous previous operations and preoperative 601 North Caroline Street
and postoperative irradiation, the patients in 8130-D McElderry
our series experienced excellent postoperative Baltimore, Md. 21287
results. The standard criteria for any reconstruc- aptufaro@jhmi.edu
tion were applied for the evaluation of the re-
sults of the use of dermal substitute in our pa-
DISCLOSURES
tients: Was the reconstruction functional? Did it
exhibit contractures? Was there limited func- The authors have no commercial or current research
tion of the affected part? Was it painful? Did it relationship with Integra LifeSciences Corporation or
stand up to the rigors of daily life and adjuvant Westaim Biomedical, Inc. The authors received expe-
therapy? Was there donor-site morbidity? Were dited, de-identified institutional review board approval
the patients satisfied aesthetically? The recon- for this research. The authors have no conflict of interest
structive technique was relatively easy to carry regarding this research.
out when compared with regional flaps and free
tissue transfer. The ease of application led to
short operative times. The patients were hospi- REFERENCES
talized only overnight for the first stage, and 1. Mathes, S. J., and Nahai, F. Reconstructive Surgery: Principles,
Anatomy & Technique, Vol. 1. New York: Churchill Living-
often the second stage of surgery was performed stone, 1997.
on an outpatient basis. No patient required re- 2. Hussussian, C. J., and Reece, G. P. Microsurgical scalp re-
vision of the reconstruction. The dermal substi- construction in the patient with cancer. Plast. Reconstr. Surg.
tute held up extremely well in the face of radi- 109: 1828, 2002.
ation therapy and in sites that had undergone 3. Rudolph, R. Complications of surgery for radiotherapy skin
prior surgical interventions. In these patients, damage. Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 70: 179, 1982.
flap coverage would have been difficult because 4. Burke, J. F., Yannas, I. V., Quinby, W. C., Bardoc, C. C., and
Jung, W. K. Successful use of a physiologically acceptable
of altered underlying anatomy. Skin grafts ap- artificial skin in the treatment of extensive burn injury. Ann.
plied to the neodermis did not contract and Surg. 194: 413, 1981.
often demonstrated good pliability on follow-up 5. Chou, T. D. C. S., Le, T. W., Chen, S. G., et al. Reconstruction
visits (patient 17) (Fig. 6). Unlike flap recon- of burn scar of the upper extremities with artificial skin. Plast.
struction, defect size was not a factor. We were Reconstr. Surg. 108: 378, 2001.
successful in resurfacing defects as large as 1080 6. Groos, N., Guillot, M., Zilliox, R., and Braye, F. M. Use of an
artificial dermis (Integra) for the reconstruction of extensive
cm2 (patient 13) (Fig. 3). On the basis of our burn scars in children: About 22 grafts. Eur. J. Pediatr. Surg.
patient series, we believe artificial dermis to be 15: 187, 2005.
an excellent option for the treatment of onco- 7. Moiemen, N. S., Staiano, J. J., Ojeh, N. O., Thway, Y., and
logic surgical defects. Frame, J. D. Reconstructive surgery with a dermal regener-
ation template: Clinical and histologic study. Plast. Reconstr.
CONCLUSIONS Surg. 108: 93, 2001.
8. Hunt, J. A., Moisidis, E., and Haertsch, P. Initial experience
The current techniques for reconstruction of
of Integra in the treatment of post-burn anterior cervical
oncologic tumor defects include the use of local neck contracture. Br. J. Plast. Surg. 53: 652, 2000.
tissue rearrangement, flaps, and skin grafting. Al- 9. Haertsch, P. Short reports and correspondence: Reconstruc-
though tissue transfer is a reliable method of re- tive surgery using an artificial dermis (Integra). Br. J. Plast.
construction, it is often associated with many aes- Surg. 55: 362, 2002.
thetic complications. On the basis of this clinical 10. Yurugi, S., Hatoko, M., Kuwahara, M., Tanaka, A., Iioka, H.,
series, it appears that the use of artificial dermis for and Niitsuma, K. Usefulness and limitations of artificial der-
mis implantation for posttraumatic deformity. Aesthetic Plast.
general reconstruction of oncologic tumor defects Surg. 26: 360, 2002.
results in excellent cosmetic and functional results 11. Dantzer, E. B. F. Reconstructive surgery using an artificial
and less donor-site morbidity. Thus, it is a viable dermis (Integra): Results with 39 grafts. Br. J. Plast. Surg. 54:
alternative to flaps and should be considered in 659, 2001.
645
Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery • September 1, 2007
12. Abai, B. T. D., and Glat, P. M. The use of a dermal regen- 14. Sheridan, R. L., Hegarty, M., Tompkins, R. G., and Burke, J.
eration template (Integra) for acute resurfacing and recon- F. Artificial skin in massive burns: Results to ten years. Eur.
struction of defects created by excision of giant hairy nevi. J. Plast. Surg. 17: 91, 1994.
Plast. Reconstr. Surg. 114: 162, 2004. 15. Wisser, D., and Steffes, J. Skin replacement with a collagen
13. Komorowska-Timek, E. G. A., Bennett, D. C., Miles, D., based dermal substitute, autologous keratinocytes and fibro-
Garberoglio, C., Cheng, C., and Gupta, S. Artificial dermis blasts in burn trauma. Burns 29: 375, 2003.
as an alternative for coverage of complex scalp defects 16. Heimbach, D. M., Warden, G. D., Luterman, A., et al. Multicenter
following excision of malignant tumors. Plast. Reconstr. postapproval clinical trial of Integra dermal regeneration template
Surg. 115: 1010, 2005. for burn treatment. J. Burn Care Rehabil. 24: 42, 2003.
646