Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2nd Sem Research Group 1A
2nd Sem Research Group 1A
2nd Sem Research Group 1A
Marxist Critique of The Story “Ang Pamana” by Lamberto Gabriel: An Analysis of The
by:
Laplana, Lovely L.
Secillano, Tiffany B.
Abad, Samantha H.
Paunil, Eljay P.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Agriculture, where farmers are mainly involved, is presumed to be one of the main
sources of the different necessities that people consume to survive on daily living. Agriculture
fills a significant role in the development of the Philippine Economy. Involving about 40 percent
Product. This output comes mainly from Agricultural Business, which in turn accounts for about
70 percent of the total agricultural output (CIDA-LGSP, 2003). Agriculture in the Philippines is
one of the fundamental industries in the country. It mainly consists of forestry, crop production,
livestock farming, and aquaculture cultivation. Its output sustains the local demands and is
considered to be essential commodities and products within the country. The Commercial crops
assist both the agricultural export industry as well as the domestic demand and consumption of
commodities. Due to that, growing crops such as rice, millets, fruits, vegetables, and fibers for
daily consumption have been a lifelong activity in the Philippines. That's why in the last few
years, developing a million hectares of land has steadily increased and improved. In 2018, the
agricultural sector's GDP growth in the Philippines was approximately 0.9 percent. It is
forecasted that the growth of the agricultural sector in the country will reach only one percent in
Agriculture wherein it vastly affects the factors such as the Industrial and Economic sectors.
Furthermore, farmers working in agriculture are a great source of revenue for the nation's
development and progress. However, as of now, there are a lot of prevailing factors that
negatively affect the livelihood and resources of small and big farmers. Factors such as nature
vagaries, overproduction, pandemic, global warming, lack of infrastructure, labor problem, lack
of post and pre-harvest facilities, pests, diseases, lack of irrigation system, and low prices of
agricultural products.
In 2012, Philippine farmers were the least modernized in Southeast Asia, using only
the equivalent in the power of a small electric fan per hectare of farmland, leaving the rest to
sheer manpower. In that case, the labor probably has become more improved, easier, and
productive if the different government agencies give more emphasis on the development and
progress of farming. However, instead of executing more effective and sustainable policies such
as block farming, the Department of Agriculture has merely given band-aid solutions to long-
term problems — dole-outs and insufficient capital for increased farming capacity. The sum of
all these inadequacies and more traps made farmers into a life of “subsistence farming" – living
from paycheck to paycheck, where one bad harvest season could mean starvation and poverty for
their families. The problem is systemic and cyclical, and it demands a systematic solution
(Pansensoy, 2020).
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Due to that, the farmers from the different agricultural sectors are deemed as the "poorest
of the poor". Based on the Philippines Statistics Authority (PSA), agricultural livelihood such as
farming and fisheries are considered as the livelihood that has the highest poverty incidences or
rates wherein it is estimated as 31.6 percent for farmers and 26.2 percent for fishermen (ABS-
CBN News, 2021). As indicated above, workers from the different sectors of Agriculture in the
Philippines, mainly the farmers, are the livelihood of the people who have a low social status as
The main problem of this conducted study mainly focuses on the Social Stratum of the
Farmers in the Philippines. Due to that, the researchers make use of the Marxist Approach in
Criticizing the story entitled Ang Pamana by Lamberto Gabriel. Marxism is a Political and
Economical theory that was developed by Karl Marx, this theory shows the division or
distinction of social classes that are experienced in society even today. Social Classes is a term
used to separate the different individuals based on their positions in society. Nowadays, the
discrimination between social classes is quite contemporary. For instance, the characters in the
story of " Ang Pamana" wherein Mang Karyas and his son Kiyel, encounter both discrimination
and prejudice due to their livelihood. Furthermore, the story focuses on farmers' lives and their
ambitions for their families to succeed in life. According to Mudjekeewis Santos from the
National Academy of Science and Technology, Agriculture, in general, is being treated as a poor
man's sector, youth are no longer interested in farming as a livelihood and opt to move into urban
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
areas. That's why the main role of this study to society is to achieve a goal which is to provide
enlightenment to every person with the liable information gathered from the different resources
and researcher's observations about the essence of avoiding discrimination on the social stratum
of the farmers, their importance to the daily basis of every individual, and the significance of the
Agriculture as one of the main key for the development of economy, industry, and society.
According to Karl Marx (1999), a socialist, economist, and historian, social status or
classes are divided in every society in the world. In the historical context of the Philippines
during pre-Spanish colonization, citizens in the Philippines have already been divided into social
classes. The distinction between these classes has expanded during the Spanish colonization.
Wherein it mainly consists of the low-income, middle-income, and high-income classes. Those
are the three primary classes that distinguish the social stratum in the Philippines wherein said by
the experts can negatively and positively affect people's living in many ways such as in terms of
The general problem of the study is about the Social Stratum of the Farmers in the
Philippines. The story “Ang Pamana'' written by Lamberto Gabriel tackles the pros and cons of
being a farmer. This literary text conveys the issue about the social rank or classes that an
agricultural country such as the Philippines is facing today due to discrimination in terms of
livelihood. On the other hand, since the story connects and focuses on the life of farmers, the
Q1: What are the reasons why people in the Philippines often perceive that agricultural
Q2: In what circumstances does the author show the farmer's social stratum in the story?
Q3: In what part of the story shows that there is social conflict on the part of the farmers?
Hypothesis
By applying the Marxist Theory to the novel, Ang Pamana by Lamberto Gabriel, this study
will prove that the story is related to the societal problem that is about the agricultural problem
and social class. It will show the precise reasons why people experience discrimination because
of their social stratum and present the problems faced by farmers based on their social standing.
The researchers have opted to criticize the text using the Marxist criterion because the key
objective of the analysis is to address the topic of socio-economic problems of farmers in the
Philippines.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
The short story entitled "Ang Pamana" by Lamberto M. Gabriel tackles the issue within
the social status of the farmers in the Philippines. Lamberto M. Gabriel was born in San Miguel,
Bulacan. He became a teacher in secondary education from 1966-1974 and was appointed
Educational Specialist in the Bureau of Secondary Schools. Apart from being a storyteller, he
also won several awards in the field of Filipino poetry. He earned the third honor in the 1972
Golden List in his work "Consciousness", a collection of his poems. "Ang Pamana" narrates the
will of a father for his son to become a successful graduate in a course that is far from being a
farmer. However, his son disobeyed him and took agriculture instead. The particular reason for
his son to pursue agriculture is to express that being a farmer is something that should not be
ashamed of.
This research about "Ang Pamana" by Lamberto M. Gabriel only focuses on the
issue that is faced by the farmers and it aims to determine the problem of social stratum in the
Philippines. This study is only limited to the actual data that is provided by the literature that the
researchers chose and the other studies that are related to researchers' literary text. Furthermore,
the result of this research may affect or redirect discrimination towards the farmers in the
Philippines in a positive manner. The researchers may link this analysis to how our actual culture
functions. Filipino farmers are still seeking equality and recognition towards their social status in
life. This opens the topic of how they are being devalued and discriminated against in today's
society. The researchers will look further to the stated issues and details of the story.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
The review of this study would show how relevant the issue being discussed is to the
society of the Philippines. In today's society, the distinction of social stratus is still a growing
problem. "The social differences between very poor and very rich have increased over time and
are much more excessive than the other cases under the communist regime." (Müller, 2012).
Students
This study may help students to be more knowledgeable about the circumstances of
social division. Also, this may help them to understand more about the concept of reality that
Farmers
The Farmers are also among the beneficiaries of this research because this study may
educate the people about the idea that in some parts of the society, many people still experience
social inequality. Also, the concerns of the farmers can be brought to the attention of the
community and government by the use of this research, which may allow them to be viewed
equally.
Parents
The Parents are also one of the benefactors of this study because this may convince them
that agriculture is a worthy path to pursue. This study may be an eye-opener to them that people
should also be the ones who promote agriculture instead of the negative perceptions by society.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Country
The country may also benefit from this research by having more knowledge and
proficiency on the issue that farmers of this country are facing. It may help to open Filipino’s
eyes and be able to spread awareness that the oppression of the farmers is a serious issue, and
World
The World is also one of the beneficiaries of this research in the sense that it may open up
or extend the eyes and mind of the people to this issue and do something to deter or help
someone who is facing it. The information and observations done by the researchers can be used
to expand the knowledge on the reality of discrimination and unfair treatment of the farmers.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
CHAPTER II
This chapter will help the study to support it with evidence, facts, acknowledgment, and
to provide unbiased information about the research. It contains reviews of related literature and
studies, both foreign and local. It also helps the readers to learn why this research is relevant and
improves the way of finding the conclusion that might contribute to the problem in the future.
FOREIGN LITERATURE
Based on a book by Cottrell (2019), there is a statement that said that the Marxist theory by
Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels is always connected to how different classes are distinguished in
society. Marx classified two basic classes in society which are the bourgeois and proletariat, even
though Marx did not give a specific meaning for “social class” these two basic classes show the
difference in how people are classified in society before. The Bourgeois class is classified as the
ones who own most of the wealth and properties, while the proletariat class is known as the
working class or classified as the lowest class in the society even before. Like in today's time, the
distinction between social classes is still being experienced especially for those people in the
low-class section of the society because they are the ones who always experience discrimination
and they do not have the same opportunities that the higher classes have.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
According to Ofuoku and Robinson (2018), Agricultural levels of social inclusions are
very low and poor. As said in the article the social inclusions of farmers and workers under
agricultural sectors are based on their economic characteristics like; being poor and having low
levels of education. Agriculture has extensions where they help small farmers to grow and give
them proper education, but it was concluded that landless farmers are a big exemption of these
extension services. Landless farmers are facing a big challenge of lack of food and supplies even
when they are the ones who supply food to the people.
One article by Galt (2015), stated that Farmers hold a very big part of the economy of a
particular country and they should have enough income for them to support their families with
their needs, but that is not the case. Incomes of farmers are not a high priority for the government
resulting in them being considered as the low social class in the country. The study results in
ways to increase the income of the farmers and also increase the supplies of food and supplies
that they have which could lead the farmers to better treatment in society as well it could help to
According to Birthal (2015), “Crop diversification into high-value crops (HVCs) can be a
strategy to improve livelihood outcomes for farmers.” Due to farmers not getting good pay for
the work they do; it is said in this article that using high-value crops (HVCs) can help farmers to
have a higher income and is less likely to be poor, this can help farmers who experience poverty.
By using 50% of their land on HVCs, it can increase their chances of escaping poverty.
However, this also comes with a negative side, with limits such as capitals on smaller farms and
labor on larger ones, this plan on using HVCs for farmers can also be a temporary solution. Still,
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
if it's done right to avoid those HIGH
limits, this SCHOOL
can be a DEPARTMENT
good solution for farmers to have a better
livelihood.
across the world. This could provide a viable and profit-making alternative to expand in a larger-
scale of corporate farming for this is a huge source of employment that needs a higher demand.
However, the challenges and risks that young rural people increasingly face including the access
to the land and the notion that they need to pursue farming are still a barrier to them. The skills
of youth in the rural areas are still demoted by people especially in terms of agriculture-related
skills. Furthermore, the emerging issues of youth studies in the field of agriculture such as
discrimination and social status prejudice could help people to see and understand why most
people in the rural areas, specifically the youth are still turning away from farming.
In this article by Satterthwaite et al., (2010), it is stated that the amount of food producers
such as farmers is declining due to the urbanization that’s continuously happening. Even though
agriculture has kept up to be efficient for different things like energy, land, and water, it still can
lack in terms of those factors and can result in a decrease in the amount of production. Wherein it
can transpire in a lot of people to suffer from under-nutrition and poverty. Also, the demands
from food consumers for agriculture are hard to keep up with too, and with climate change
getting worse, food producers can get a harder time making the number of products fit for
everyone else while trying to make income. Also with the changes to consumers’ demands while
the population rises, or not being able to reach those demands can affect the sustainability of the
agricultural sector.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
urban places in Asia. This favors the social issues in the urban area such as poverty, scarcity, and
malnutrition. Within these issues, people who work in the field of agriculture spend their time
improving their services to the beneficiaries around them. This leads to having different
diversities of farming. However, they still face different kinds of hindrances when it comes to
social and political factors. Urban agriculture brings different impacts on today’s social stance.
The effectiveness and relevance of this will be strongly visible especially when the demand for
products in the urban and rural areas increases because of the population growth. It is good for
the environment because it reduces pollution in the area and lessens the waste in the city. This
type of agriculture is effectively useful in a way that it could help the environment and could also
benefit the farmers on eradication of social class discrimination in the urban areas. That's why
urban agriculture needs to gain more recognition from the people and government.
Wu (2019) explained in an article that urban places in China are experiencing poverty
strikes. This study analyzes different frameworks in different regions to see the things that are
lacking and needed to be fixed. The integral relationships had displayed contrasting patterns in
each region. They are said to set different budgets and expect a certain amount of income
regarding each level. They aim to have a sustainable livelihood for each family in every region.
Also, they are analyzing and exploring the regression model much further including its
characteristics and inside information. China should implement policies that will adequately
resolve and reduce its regional disparities. The overall development will benefit the countrymen
In his paper, Mahendra (2014) tackles the positions, parts, and challenges of the farmers
in India. Farmers and different business holders have their policies to obey for them to avoid
several crises in the process of farming and its cultivation. This encloses the productivity and
demand of the supplies needed to have the proper agricultural growth and improvements as well
as the act of avoiding crises that could put the farmers into poverty. Also, they included the
productivity of small marketing places and agricultural holders on how they manage their
workers. Their performances are mostly viewed on how large their scale but having small-scale
agriculture still holds lots of advantages in different aspects. These are some of the opportunities
and challenges that India has when it comes to agriculture throughout the different generations.
In this paper written by Tang (2013) said that water scarcity in China has led to different
problems in their farming. Furthermore, this article showed the possible results of the
policymaking from the officials and also it stated that having the awareness of water scarcity
could help in preventing drought. Meanwhile, people who are affected by it might not afford to
have enough water supply for the incoming water shortages and should be given much special
consideration and pay. This applies to the farmers who have limited access to these types of
mechanisms. Water scarcity is a very crucial issue since it causes a hard time in terms of their
methods of farming as well as it causes them to a low production rate that leads to the edge of
poverty. That's why it should be managed and addressed immediately by China's national
farmers. However, the article stated that it is much more convenient and powerful if people of
China would spread it on social networks rather than the media to solve this issue that adversely
According to the article by Mellor & Malik (2015), there are points made, first is to have
a decline in poverty, the productivity of the people, who are small-scale farmers, are needed. The
productivity can boost the income of the farmers by having a lot more to sell. Another one is
"Income of the rural poor is mainly from selling non-farm products locally.” This can mean that
most of the rural poor are selling items that are not from what they do or make inside of the farm,
it is mostly from items that are outside or not related to farming. For the rural poor to be
declining in poverty, these can be a great help or can be a great start to getting out of the rural
LOCAL LITERATURE
An article from ABS-CBN News (2013) stated that workers in the agriculture sector
receive the lowest income in the country that results in poverty in the industry. Many farmers in
the Philippines are indeed considered as the lowest-paid workers and it doesn't reach the
minimum wage and salary which is the opposite of workers that are non-agriculture-related.
Based on the NSBC Secretary General Jose Ramon G. Albert, the situation of the farmers in the
agricultural sector is no surprise because in 2009 the poverty incident of farmers ranges from
41.4 percent and 36.7 percent. Meanwhile, as of 2011, the economy of the Philippines in the
agriculture sector has an average of P156.8 and P178.43 as their daily wage and salary.
However, there are various arranged programs and policies prepared by the government to
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
support local farmers. Wherein HIGHto
it's made SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
help the agriculture sector people to comprehend
their situation because in some cases many buyers of the raw materials tend to bargain the
product from the farmers which arises in a low-income percentage. That's why, Secretary-
General Albert also states that middlemen must lower their profit in consideration to the farmers,
Adriano (2020) once stated in his article that farmers in the Philippines continue to
deteriorate because the government has neglected them by underestimating and manipulating
them which results in negative interest and income rates. Farmers often experience a low
retention ceiling, which further means that as time passes, they eliminate hectares of land,
resulting in smaller and perhaps more infeasible farm size. A small farmer growing traditional
crops like rice and corn would not be able to provide a sufficient income to sustain a family of
five to six people. It is also said that the Philippines' low retention ceiling under the
Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP) could result in the small farmers enduring
poverty continuously.
In one article Inquirer.net (2015), stated that Dr. Eufemio T. Rasco Jr. a member of the
National Academy for Science and Technology and former executive director of the Philippine
Rice Research Institute (PhilRice) claimed that rice production in the Philippines is doing more
disadvantage than good to farmers, the environment, and consumers. Also, he stated that the first
unpleasant effect of rice is on farmers involved in its production wherein farmers in the
Philippines suffer physically and economically as a result of the way rice is being produced.
Furthermore, this article also elaborated that the Farmers’ income, is expected to further decline
at the start of the economic integration of countries belonging to the Association of Southeast
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Asian Nations (ASEAN) which wouldHIGH
melt SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
down trade barriers, like duties and tariffs, and pave
the way for the free exchange of goods that would likely plunge the agricultural sector. In that
case, it could lead the farmers and other areas of agriculture in the Philippines into a higher rate
of poverty in the next few years which could probably lead them to remain in the lowest class of
society.
An article from Manila Bulletin (2021), asserts that the group of farmers demands to the
government that 1000 pesos cash aid is not enough to sustain the daily needs of the farmers in
this time of the pandemic. The Kilusang Magbubukid ng Pilipinas (KMP) stated that 1000 pesos
are not enough to supply a week's worth of food and other needs for a family of four. The cash
aid from the government is 10,000 pesos but there are remaining 9,000 pesos that have not been
distributed to the low-income Filipinos, meanwhile, the said financial support that is needed by
the farmers is delayed and in a sluggish process. In this case, the poverty rate might increase in
the agriculture community since the money serves as their hope to survive especially in this time
of the pandemic is thwarted. This article also stated, that in some cases regarding this financial
aid, there is a possibility that the farmers first might starve to death before they get the full aid
The article from Conde (2020) reported that the main dam at Mount Isarog in the town of
Pili has been entrusted to Ramon Oliva, a rice farmer from the Philippine province of Camarines
Sur. The dam supplies water to irrigate 34 hectares (84 acres) of rice farms in Concepcion
Grande, Naga City, 385 kilometers (240 miles) south of Manila. Before the pandemic, Olivia
visits the dam three times a week but during the quarantine, the dam shuts down and closes.
According to Oliva, a devastating impact might happen in their rice farms if the irrigation facility
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH
will not be maintained. Meanwhile, SCHOOLabove
the statement DEPARTMENT
proves that the pandemic affects the
farmers adversely, for instance, since the irrigation closes the risk of drying the soil increases and
the farmers will be bankrupt and the harvested materials will deplete its price resulting in them in
loss of income that could lead them in chronic poverty amid pandemic. Also, the government
funds cannot assess all those farmers who need help and that results in a huge decrease in the
agriculture economy and leads to the farmers having a lower social stratum and it is not only
applicable to the lowland farmers but also all of the farmers in the Philippines.
In one article by Philstar (2021), it stated that the rights group Karapatan recorded
multiple attacks, and harassment of farmers in Hacienda Yulo, Laguna, and on the other hand,
the Isabela provinces are distressing as the agricultural sector is already weakened by the
their landlords since they have a lower social class compared to them. Due to it, those farmers
experience hardship such as maltreatment and abuse while sustaining on essentials like food and
other necessities whose prices continually increase. Furthermore, because of the low income,
many farmers cannot afford those high-priced products and from that, they choose to work even
though they'll experience harassment. However, they know that to survive they need to endure all
the struggles, and that is the saddest part for farmers here in the Philippines. That's why many
An article by Gesite (2018) claimed that due to land monopolies by oligarchs and
landlords there seven out of ten farmers in the Philippines remain landless. Meanwhile, the
Farmers who begin to organize and fight for their right to land are labeled as insurgents or allies
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
of the New People's Army.SENIOR HIGHtoSCHOOL
According a studyDEPARTMENT
conducted by Karapatan - human rights
organizations, in December 2017, there were 126 victims of extrajudicial killings in Mindanao
wherein proves that Militarization affects indigenous populations as well. Under the guise of
"Oplan Kapayapaan", the Armed Forces of the Philippines are the main counterinsurgency force
in Mindanao, targeting farmers and local communities. Accordingly, all of these violations are
seen as the government's strategy for securing land for local and foreign investors, as well as
paving the way for foreign loans from international financial institutions for President Duterte's
"Build, Build, Build" infrastructure program. Furthermore, the government must refrain from
interfering with people's enjoyment of their rights and prohibit people from doing things.
Accordingly, the vicious cycle of a farmer's life must be broken and a farmer's life is not a toy
that can be played with at any time by a strong force. A farmer's life is valuable because it feeds
the world's population. That's why the beloved Farmers deserve better honor not discrimination
One article by Manila Bulletin (2021), stated that after finally receiving their land titles
from the Department of Agrarian Reform, more than 400 farmers in Mauban, Quezon, are now
landowners. Furthermore, a total of 423 certificates of land ownership award (CLOAs) which
cover 408 hectares of agricultural lands were recently distributed to Agrarian Reform
Beneficiaries (ARBs) in the 15 barangays of Mauban. During the title distribution, DAR Sec.
Brother John Castriciones said that since the beneficiary farmers are now owners of their land it
can never be taken away from them. Also, he stated that a quantity of P1.3 million for seeds
subsidy was also given to 90 farmers who were members of Agrarian Reform Beneficiary
Organizations in the same municipality. The money would go toward a rice retailing project, an
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH
agri-farm input project, and technical SCHOOLfor
skill creation DEPARTMENT
the three farmer organizations' members.
The program aims to improve farmers' household income by assisting them in the development
vegetable and fruit farming, food processing, and livestock raising, among other things.
Wherein it might result for the agriculture to be more prosperous with the availability of farmers'
lands and crops, and farmers' income will be sufficient to keep their families out of poverty and
deprivation that might lead the farmers to have higher social classes in the future.
An article from Inquirer.net (2020), expresses that the Department of Education (DepEd)
informed the senators that they would investigate a learning material that described a stereotype
toward farmers, stating that they do not intend this act of stereotyping especially in the
agricultural sector. However, the issue was immediately argued by Senator Francis Pangilinan,
as the Senate debated DepEd's proposed budget for 2021, the senate gave attention to learning
materials that depicted a farmer's family wearing ripped clothing. This act of Senator Pangilinan
shows that although farmers have the one of the lowest income in the society it doesn't mean that
it is okay to illustrate them by saying that if people have ripped clothes they are a farmer.
Accordingly, in schools, it is not appropriate to show that kind of material to children due to the
reason that it's like educating the students how to discriminate against others and it is very
negative because farmers have their rights and they are also part of the community and no one is
supposed to make any fun of them. Furthermore, about this issue, the senate immediately implies
an action wherein it's a good act to protect the beloved farmers free from discrimination
institutional, and environmental factors influencing the adoption of certified seeds and integrated
crop management practices the developers use binary logit and poison estimators. Although the
estimates of factors influencing adoption are fairly consistent between the two models, there are
now, many farmers must need to learn new ways and the use of technology to improve and
survive farming because people all know that in our current situation all of the farmers are more
affected and most of them experienced poverty. However, they'll need improvement in their
ways to raise their income because the wages of farmers don't reach the minimum to buy food or
any needed goods. In the past year's farmers have lacked communication and the idea of what is
happening to the agricultural economy since they are working on the plantation and they have no
access to modern gadgets since they prioritize food first before anything. That's why farmers
considerably have the hardest work but have small wage income and in that particular reason, the
farmers are left behind and not oriented and cause them to be deemed as one of the sectors which
FOREIGN STUDIES
One study by Hurst (2015), stated that Mr. Mark Bittman, an American food journalist,
speculates in his article in the New York Times that traditional agriculture is the sector of
peasants. Accordingly, this study also said that the word "peasant" is inappropriate since it means
"poor farmer of low social status who owns or rents a small piece of land for cultivation (chiefly
in historical use or concerning subsistence farming in poorer countries)" wherein those actions of
Bittman can be deemed as act discrimination about the farmer's capacities in life. Furthermore, in
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Bittman's actions, Hurst stated that HIGH SCHOOL
Bittman DEPARTMENT
had the choice not to discriminate against the
farmers but he chose to dishonor them. In that, it makes the farmers anxious about themselves
and it makes the people think that the career in agriculture is not a great course to take and there's
also a chance that the discrimination about farmers' social stratum might increase. Meanwhile,
due to the action of Bittman where he labels the farmer's traditional way of planting as an
"outdated" way and stated also that the progress in this method of agriculture is hard to see. The
farmers insisted that if the government helps them they would improve and enhance their
farming method.
In the previous study of Denniston (2017), he asserted that most of the poverty-stricken
people are the one that works in agriculture and from rural areas. Accordingly, the World Bank
data stated 80% of the 770 million people living in extreme poverty are in rural areas, and 64%
work in agriculture. Furthermore, the author stated that it would not be manageable to help the
farmers if the government is not ready to support them financially since based on the study it's
estimated 500 million dollars is needed for the start-up business for aspiring farmers, and
employees from the agriculture sector. Meanwhile, this study also stated that many farmers see
land ownership as the main problem which causes them to lack in storage infrastructure means
that farmers consistently lose a significant amount of their harvest due to spoilage and causes
them to trade the remaining products into oversupplied markets even if the values of it are at
their lowest. Besides, some of the farmers are not financially stable, and only a few people can
access pieces of information to find better crops to plant. Most of them lack equipment, tools,
crop insurance, or seeds. On the other hand, the author stated that The Gates Foundation is
giving options to the farmers to use the technology. The foundation explains that using
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
technology in farming will help HIGH SCHOOL
the farmers DEPARTMENTthat will assist them in aiding
to gain opportunities
According to the research article of Rajvanshi (2021), many Indian farmers are suffering
in poverty during this pandemic. He also stated that this is the first time for the Indian farmers to
conduct an agricultural strike regarding a law to help them in the dark times of Covid-19 issues.
Also, the author reveals the reason why the Indian farmer started protesting and the main reason
for this is the farmers have to pay their large amount of debt, and the said debt started since the
COVID-19 virus spread to their country and the government those times implemented the
lockdown to reduce the spreading of the virus, but the farmers are affected by it in several
adverse ways. Furthermore, the deadly effect of paying their debt is many Indian farmers see
suicide as their main help to aid their financial problems. This past few months many Indians
started suicide to ensure compensation to their bereaved families. Accordingly, the pandemic
adversely affects the Agricultural sector which leads the farmers to face extreme poverty and
hunger. Meanwhile, the article also stated that the support for the protests has also poured in
from around the world including the Indian diaspora and foreign leaders such as Canadian Prime
Minister, Justin Trudeau, wherein they imply the government to hear the Indian farmers’
demands.
A research article by Duvall (2018) states that the agriculture sector especially the
farmers are having a huge part in terms of economy in the USA, wherein this article stated that
"The Gross Domestic Product of the US has grown more than 3 percent in 2018" because of the
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Agricultural sector. Furthermore, HIGH SCHOOL
It asserts that the DEPARTMENT
farmers helped to overcome the economic
crisis and feeds the thousands of people in the United States. Duvall gives out some points to
contemplate and strengthen his claims by stating that agriculture and its other sectors as a "high
contributor" to the United States' economy with an amount of 1.09 trillion dollars contribution.
As well as he also infers that there are an estimated 43 million U.S. jobs connected to agriculture.
Duvall also points out that the "One Study" stated that members of the food and agriculture
industries and their employees pay almost $900 billion in federal, state, and local taxes, wherein
it helps to support the US's communities. However, poverty still is the main problem of the
farmers in the US wherein it's said that money that they acquired is not enough to provide
necessities for their families. Due to that, the government of the U.S assisted the farmers and
support and services. Furthermore, the government in the U.S talks about constructing a new
farm bill that will help the farmers to start their farming or ranching business, aid their financial
The latest work of Amadeo (2020) gathered information on how farm subsidies will
impact the farmers of the USA that are facing difficulties in terms of financial matters.
Meanwhile, this study stated that in 2017 the combined agriculture and food industry made up
5.4% of the U.S. economy. That's why the government increases the subsidies to increase as well
the percentage of agriculture in the US economy. According to this study, the leading five states
in terms of obtaining subsidies and assistance are Texas, Nebraska, Kansas, Arkansas, and
Illinois wherein in the year 2017, they obtained 38.5% of the $7.2 billion allocated which is
equal to more than $2.7 billion from EWG Farm Subsidy Database. Furthermore, this study
presented the pros and cons of farm subsidies on farmers. Also, the author tells the definition of
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
"farm subsidies" wherein it SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
is the financial DEPARTMENT
assistance of the government to the agricultural
sector. Accordingly, the cons based on this study are; U.S. farms are in one of the world's most
favorable regions; They have the tech advantages of a modern business; The top 10% of farms
received 78% of the subsidies; Farm subsidies block foreign trade agreements. While the pros
are; Subsidies protect the nation's food supply; Farms are susceptible to pathogens, diseases, and
weather; Subsidies help farmers weather commodities' price changes; Farmers rely on loans,
making their business a bit of a gamble. Besides, it aids the farmers when there is a problem
with their farm to avoid financial and production loss that could lead to the farmers in poverty
According to a study by Azadi et al. (2018), they asserted that climate change has a
massive effect on the farmers of Western Iran. It has a vastly negative impact on their income
that leads them into deprivation and low social class. However, to conquer this issue the Iranian
farmers are prepared methods and adjusted to their life to manage the climate change in their
country. In this study, the researchers revealed that three parts take part in the farmer's resolution.
These are farm practices, management, and government assistance. Also, they evaluated if those
methods are effective during climate change. As they summed up their findings and result, the
process and practices of the Iranian farmers are significant in coping with climate change that
could lead them to extreme poverty and discrimination regarding their social class.
The findings of the research article by Eslake (2018) summed up the economic impact of
Meanwhile, the country of Australia is highly affected by this phenomenon and the most obvious
more complicated. Accordingly, when a large drought happens in Australia, the Gross Domestic
Product (GDP) decreases. Besides, it not just affects the farmers but also the buyers since it
affects the prices in the market and it brings a crucial influence on the loss of capital of the
farmers and their families. The drought lasts for a long time and brings financial distress to the
farmers. Also, farmers think of an option to lessen the financial problems when the drought
season occurs. Then, they came up with a solution for the drought by preparing irrigation. As
they continued to report to the government, the government provided the farmers with financial
assistance. The author stated that climate change never ends, but the government should provide
A similar study by Arroyo (2018) reveals that the higher the population the higher
malnutrition and hunger. In the year 2018, officials conducted an event where all agricultural
officials were invited. The officials highlighted their investment in sustainable agriculture which
results in excellent products that are environmentally friendly and affordable. Also, they
emphasize the sustaining of free from pesticides land that will last to the next generation.
Besides, the officials pointed out that to end hunger, they should not criticize the agriculture
sector but change their practices in producing food. As they come up with the ideas, the idea of
the majority comes from the smallholder farmers. Due to their low-growth crops, people with
businesses do not invest in them. In that, it became the reason why the small-scale farmers
continue to suffer from hunger. The author asserts that if the investor invests in small-scale
farmers it would be a great idea to reduce starvation for agriculturists and might improve the
economic growth. Also, it would lessen the hunger of the poor people in their country.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Meanwhile, the finalized design HIGH
that the SCHOOL
event comesDEPARTMENT
with is that they will invest in the farmers
and reshape the food systems and food-producing. Besides, giving incentives and new jobs can
help to avoid poverty in farmers and people. It will also lessen the losses of post-harvest, and this
The research article by Keil et al. (2019) evaluated the immense impact of sustainable
intensification and zero tillage on the environment. Furthermore, the article stated that
production without heightening the risks to the environment that could lead to the farmers in
poverty. However, people criticize the method of using sustainable intensification because the
farmers neglected the social welfare conclusion. Meanwhile, the researchers conducted this
research because they found out that there is a better method to use for the environment. They
studied the process of zero tillage farming or no-till farming wherein it's a practice that enhances
food production and reduces the use of greenhouse gasses. Also, in this practice there's no need
to use machines and equipment in harvesting means it can be cultivated without destroying the
soil. However, due to modern technology, the practice of zero tillage farming was not used by
some of the farmers. Consequently, the usage of technology in farming practices contributed to
the growth of the market and might lead to the farmers having a higher social class and better life
An article by Chen (2020) reveals that China has a development goal for its 550 million
farmers wherein is based on their so-called "No.1 Central Document" which serves as the means
for the government to work out a plan to support the Chinese farmers. Chen also stated that the
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR the
No.1 Central Document has outlined HIGH SCHOOL
goals, whichDEPARTMENT
will affect the lives of millions of Chinese
farmers. The document proposed eight measures to build infrastructures such as roads, water
supply, and sanitation facilities in rural areas as well as Public services such as education,
healthcare, and social security will also be improved. Furthermore, the author revealed that the
document helps China to overcome extreme poverty since it has started to address the problems
regarding poverty and Social Stratum in 2004. Meanwhile, the documents as of now
continuously help all Chinese citizens and the farmers that are experiencing poverty and
LOCAL STUDIES
The research article by Galang (2020) evaluated the text entitled "Ang Pamana" by
Lamberto Gabriel, wherein it is a short story about the family of Mang Karyas, the farmer, his
wife, and their son Kiyel. The author focuses on the events of the story wherein it's about the
farmer's life and connects it to how society works nowadays especially on the farmers. Also, the
author pointed out how Kiyel has progressed in school and taken the agriculture course that his
father does not want and connects it as well to the society's perception among farmers. This
story, which is both painful and pure, illustrates how farmers in the Philippines leave unnoticed
and underprivileged of a decent life. Unfortunately, the foundation of our country's economy is
in the worst shape. It's disturbing that this story from years ago still mirrors today's society.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Lubang (2019) once wrote in HIGH SCHOOL
a paper that theDEPARTMENT
majority of Filipino farmers are poor and
have a low degree of education and because of this they experience financial difficulties that
usually cause them to have debts. Frequently, this happens as a consequence of the government's
lack of funding and attention to the Philippines' agricultural industry. It is also mentioned that
Filipinos working in the country's agricultural industry are on the national poverty line. Then
according to statistics, Filipino farmers and other agricultural workers earn lower incomes than
manufacturing workers. Accordingly, agricultural employees are referred to as the "poor man's
sector" because farmers are stereotyped as having poor working standards, a low level of
As claimed in the study of Rapera et al. (2011), poverty is primarily a rural problem in
the Philippines, with Filipinos who work in the agriculture sector experiencing the highest rates
of poverty. According to the International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) report,
about half of the 91 million Filipinos (in 2009) lived in rural areas, with 30% of them considered
poor. Subsistence agriculture supported approximately 80% of the poor population in rural areas.
This illustrates an irony in agriculture: food producers, who are the foundation of every
agricultural supply chain, are among the poorest and considered as one the sector that has a low
social stratum. Furthermore, small Farmers face numerous generational challenges such as the
dry season, surge, the need for sufficient input usage, destitute expansion leading to wide
abdicate crevices, the need for a reliable and satisfactory water system, modification frustration,
and so on. Besides that, the researchers suggest that people must aid the country's farmers by
purchasing their goods and supporting Rural Rising Philippines, a social enterprise that promotes
"rescue buying" of agricultural goods whose goal is to help farmers to avoid poverty.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
In the research article of Cerio (2020), he stated the research of the Philippine Statistics
Authority (2016), the poverty rate among Filipinos was 21.6 percent in 2015. The number of
Meanwhile, Fishermen and Farmers continue to be the poorest basic industries in the Philippines,
with poverty rates of 39.2 percent and 38.3 percent, respectively, in rural areas. Higher poverty
rates are associated with rural poor subsistence on fishing and farming, as well as illiteracy,
unemployment, and larger family sizes. Agricultural progress may be a powerful constraint in
reducing poverty in developing countries. According to an OECD study, making rapid and
feasible progress to reduce extreme poverty is one thing, but increasing rural efficiency and
salaries for destitute agriculturists are another. Accordingly, this study recommended that the
favorable political and economic environment that benefits them, promote equality, and establish
In one study by Datu (2012), he evaluated the problems on the poverty rate among
Furthermore, this study also stated the comparison of poor agricultural and poor non-agricultural
agricultural activities in terms of its ability to reduce poverty. More than half of the reduction in
poverty achieved in the chosen countries over the period under consideration can be attributed to
increases in rural incomes. In terms of poverty and inequality indicators, regional inequalities
poverty problem, which has persisted amid recent periods of rapid economic growth. Meanwhile,
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
the researchers have concluded that aHIGH SCHOOL
free market DEPARTMENT
economy is the only way to eradicate poverty
in the Philippines. This entails removing taxes from an overtaxed society, allowing citizens
especially farmers to spend, save, and invest without the fear of the government taking their
assets.
According to the study by Reyes et al. (2012), poverty has always been linked to
agriculture in the Philippines. The poverty rate among agricultural households (57%) is three
times that of non-agricultural households (17 %). More specifically, the incidence of food
poverty or subsistence among agricultural households is around five times higher than among
shortage. As a result, tracking movements into and out of poverty is an integral aspect of poverty
alleviation programs. Furthermore, poverty and food security are intricately intertwined and the
individuals who do not have a wage or the resources to produce food are more likely to become
ill and unable to work to produce food or earn a living. Meanwhile, the authors of this study
propose that the government must assist all farmers in securing insurance and help them citing
the difficulty of their job, and evaluate the fact that they are paid less than the minimum wage in
our country which leads them to call a sector under "low social class".
Based on a study by Briones (2017), youth play a critical role in nation-building and
growth (Youth in Nation-Building Act, 1994). This is particularly true in agriculture in the
Philippines, where agricultural workers are older and less educated. The sector is also
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGHlower
characterized by high underemployment, SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
incomes, and greater vulnerability to climate
shocks. Assuming economic rationality, these factors make agriculture less appealing to young
people. That's why precision agriculture and natural cultivating are the answers as well as rural
institutions must hold training programs to teach young agriculturists about post-harvest
management and esteem enhancement to enlighten them that " agriculture" is not a bad career to
take. Also, this study stated that the agri-economy must also be organized across value chains
and market linkages using cold capacity frameworks to lessen the financial burden of the
farmers. Furthermore, the researchers also suggest that youth development policies, services, and
Based on a study by Palis (2020), she stated that most of the farmers of the Philippines
do not want their children to pursue agricultural courses because according to them their children
will not have a future once they pursue agriculture. They said that farming is simply exhausting
and for them, it is not successful work because they are economically challenged and do not
actually raise adequate income to fund the needs of their families. They prefer their children to
have a better life, a proper income to provide for their family's needs, and proper education,
rather than farming because they know the hardships of becoming a farmer. Moreover, according
to the farmers of Ilo-ilo, Isabela, and Agusan del Norte, their children are really not interested in
the agriculture industry because they prefer to have a "better" life career than it.
As mentioned by Saliot (2014) in his study, Farmers and fishermen are usually considered
the poorest of the poor in the country. mostly, as a result, students are completely uninterested in
participating in agricultural courses because they tend to believe farming has no future. Farming
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH
and agriculture courses are considered SCHOOL
a decent DEPARTMENT
profession in the country because farmers in the
country are widely perceived to have small wages and malnutrition, which tends to cause people
to believe that agriculture is not a suitable road to take. Further to that, those who are the
inheritors of elderly and infirm farmers in the country choose to live in cities rather than rural
As claimed by Fabella (2014) the quality of life is now determined by whether the people
are poor or wealthy. In his terms, "below or above the poverty line." It is also mentioned in his
paper that farmers are losing the land on which to grow crops as time passes. There is a new
class of farmers who have little money but have land, and they are known as the "landed poor".
Furthermore, according to statistics, 54% of households are relatively poor, with 36% of those
being farmers and agricultural workers, and this is when the farmers and households are facing
financial hardship. Every farmer faces a low retention ceiling, under which the government takes
approximately 5 hectares of land away from them along with their crops that are supposed to be
As stipulated by Elauria (2015), the Philippines have nearly 5 million farmers, and due to
the low retention ceiling, most farmers lose hectares of land where they can openly crop, and
most farmers in the country do not have enough revenue or savings to purchase a place for them
to farm. One cause of this is the government's lack of assistance for the agriculture sector and
farmers, and it is recommended by the experts that the government must make some effort to
provide the farmers an owned land to produce their crops. Also, because of situations like this,
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
students and youth are losingSENIOR
interestHIGH SCHOOL because
in agriculture DEPARTMENT
they acknowledge the hardships of
working hard but earning only a small amount of income, which is insufficient to meet their
family's necessities.
METHODOLOGY
INTRODUCTION
This study will be dealing with how the short story entitled “Ang Pamana” by Lamberto
Gabriel tackled the issue of prejudice and denigration among people in agricultural sectors due to
poverty. Also, it will be utilized as a source of information through signs and interpretations of
data and figures for rendering evidence and proof regarding the actual status of the agriculture
sector specifically the Farmers in terms of social stratum in the context of the Philippine society.
Furthermore, the researchers will be using the theory of Marxism in evaluating this literary text.
Whereas Marxism or Marxist theory is a social, political, and economic philosophy named after
Karl Marx. It investigates the impact of capitalism on labor, productivity, and economic
development, it advocates for a worker revolution to demolish capitalism and replace it with
communism. Accordingly, Marxism posits the conflicts among social classes specifically, the
bourgeoisie, or capitalists, and the proletariat, or workers which denominate economic relations
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
in a capitalist economy and will HIGHlead
certainly SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
to revolutionary communism (Investopedia Staff,
2021).
RESEARCH METHOD
The study entitled "Marxist Critique of The Story “Ang Pamana” by Lamberto Gabriel:
An Analysis of The Farmer's Social Stratum in the Philippines" is a qualitative type of research,
wherein it's a type of research that focuses on “why” rather than “what” of the research's context'
and it employs inquiries to gain a thorough understanding of phenomena in the natural world.
Also, Qualitative research involves collecting and analyzing non-numerical data to understand
concepts, opinions, and experiences. It can be used to collect in-depth insights into a problem or
generate new concepts for the study (Bhandari, 2020). Generally, Qualitative research aims to
comprehend the social reality of people, groups, and cultures as practically as possible as its
Moreover, Qualitative research uses theories and phenomena which result in this kind of
study to have a focal point in soft sciences which include humanity, society, culture, language,
and numbers, qualitative research is commonly based on understanding and words. It enables the
researcher to study various issues in-depth and in detail without being constrained by any laws of
analysis categories and also it requires a humanistic or idealistic approach, which implies the use
data. Also, it is flexible since it allows the use of observations, immersions, viewpoints,
interviews, and history. Furthermore, as Qualitative Research examines people's lives and
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR method
experiences, it engages an inductive HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
and its data collection varies by number wherein it
because it is used to comprehend various reasons, opinions, and rationales as well as reveals the
behavior and perceptions of the intended audience. On the other hand, most of the qualitative
studies are small in scale or focusing on a single or lesser number of cases, however, this kind of
research still provides depth and conceptualized details and information on a certain topic. The
natural setting and the respondents' perspectives are highlighted in this kind of study as well as
self-reflection upon one's behavior, position, and role in society is essential to perform successful
Meanwhile, the researchers applied the concept of Content and Discourse Analysis as the
proposed type of study to conclude the main objectives of this qualitative research such as to
underline the substantial implication of the story to the society and broaden the general
awareness of the readers into a bigger setting. Furthermore, the Content and Discourse Analysis
is a commonly applied research technique primarily in the field of social science, psychology,
and other qualitative disciplines that focus on the relationship between language and social
phenomena. The major purpose of this type of research is to clarify the implicit meaning of
discourse fragments and arrange them in the context of larger frames, discourses, or narratives
(Mbrusis, 2020). Accordingly, this type of research can be done by exploring deeper into the
gathered ideas and concepts within and outside the narrative while considering the salient and
crucial portions of the story and outer affiliations such as the personal perception and
experiences of the author. Accordingly, an article online differentiates content and discourse
analysis wherein the content analysis is defined as a method for studying and retrieving
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
meaningful information fromSENIOR HIGH for
documents SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
gathering a wider sense of comprehension. In
contrast, discourse analysis is defined as the study of how language is used in texts and contexts
(Hasa, 2016). These two are distinguished as independent methods in research wherein both are
also considered as tools that are commonly used as research techniques under qualitative study.
Lastly, the researchers of this study used the Marxist Theory of Criticism in their Content and
Discourse analysis. Whereas the Marxist Theory of Criticism may maximize the concept of
Content and Discourse Analysis in performing this research since it is focused on the issue of
social stratum in the society specifically in farmers which are extremely related to the said
theory.
PHASE I. SELECTION
Karl Marx's Marxism is a political and economic theory that focuses on social class and
depicts the difference between capitalists and workers. According to this approach, the economy
in which people live is divided into different social classes: upper class, also known as elite,
see how the disparity between capitalists and workers creates a significant difference in ensuring
sequence of economic processes that have evolved (Brock, 2021). He claims that they are
motivated by enormous impersonal historical forces that manifest themselves in social class
action and conflict. Furthermore, as per Marx, every society is divided into several social groups,
each of which has more in common with its members than the interaction between classes. The
bourgeoisie, or entrepreneurs, who own the productive resources, as well as the proletariat, or
workers, whose labor develops raw materials into useful economic products, comprise capitalist
society. The barriers that can influence socioeconomic status are defined by Marxist theory. In
this situation, low-wage workers were subjected to discrimination and injustice at the hands of
capitalists who profited from their social status, prompting the communist revolution. As a result,
the researchers analyze the story "Ang Pamana'' using these theories since this hypothesis
focuses on social class and economy. Accordingly, Farmers are often vulnerable to social class
prejudice for the simple reason that they are seen as low-class in society. Therefore, the diversity
With the integration of Marxism, the Marxist theory, as well as the story being used in
this study entitled "Ang Panama '' with regards to the data exploration and interpretation of data
is presented. With that being said, the researchers will focus on the Marxist theory of Criticism
derived from (Marx, 1848) in terms of analyzing Lamberto Gabriel's story "Ang Pamana'' which
portrays the issue among the social stratum and perception of people in the agricultural sector
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
STAGE I
The preliminary reading of the literary work “Ang Pamana” by Lamberto Gabriel was
executed by the researchers to have an in-detail understanding of the elements of the short story.
Also, this enables the researchers to portray or unfold the story in a way that they will understand
the text deeply as well as in a point that they can expound the story to incorporate into the paper.
It also touches on the subjects that take place in the present time, and being able to have a full
understanding of the story can help the researchers in connecting it to the issue being discussed
in this study. For the following readings of the story, the researchers used it to have a reference
while doing other stages of the research such as in stage three of the analysis part. This helped in
finding and gathering the right information and references in writing the paper. The following
readings also gave light to the researcher on the ideas in the story that are not easy to understand.
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
The researchers use the idea of one leading Marxist philosopher, Karl Heinrich Marx
(1848). For this paper, the researchers use five guidelines in terms of determining the meaning
of social class based on Marx's idea. With that being said, the researchers will use the views and
insights of Karl Marx in Marxism that mainly focuses on the differences of social class in
society as well as the different treatment that people get based on their status. This idea will be
used in criticizing the literary work of Lamberto Garbriel entitled “Ang Pamana”:
1. Two “basic” classes of Karl Marx - According to Marx (1848), these two “basic” classes
are the bourgeois and the proletariat. Those who are bourgeois, in his interpretation, are
those who have financial resources and their piece of land, as well as those who invest in
companies, businesses, and factories where they eventually make their wealth. The
proletariat, on the other hand, is the class that works for the bourgeois. They are widely
known as the working class because they are those who labor for the bourgeoisie's
capital. Karl Marx's ideology simply demonstrates the disparity between the upper and
lower classes. He also said that those identified as proletarians are somehow completely
unaware that they are being exploited in society. They have no idea that the bourgeoisie
is exploiting them by using them in their establishments and paying them insufficient
salaries. The proletarians are afraid to speak up because it is the bourgeoisie that provides
them with income, so they do not bother to do so while working and earning a low wage
capitalist class would not be able to exist without the working class because they are the
ones in charge of the labor to gain wealth in the society. Karl Marx uses the word
“exploitation” in explaining the difference between capitalists and workers, saying that
the workers start with no money, no capital but just their power to do their labor or job, in
other words, all they can offer is working. On the other hand, the capitalist starts with the
capital or money and they use that to buy workers that will be providing the labor for
them so they can get more capital. In this case, the capitalist ends up with more money
than the one who is working for it and the workers only receive small wages for the time
3. Marxist class theory by Karl Marx - This entails the strong belief that not everyone in the
society is on the same level; some are higher and some are lower which is commonly
considered considerably weaker. This is based on the social fact that there are disparities
between those in positions of power and influence and those seeking help. An
society. The class divisions of people in social groups are the subject of Marxist class
theory. Individuals are classified not only by their income and educational qualifications,
but also by their gender, ethnicity, and race. This text talks about the relationship between
classes and society, as well as how the lower classes are widely viewed in society.
Individuals from the lower class face a shortage of economic and social goods such as
education and wages and benefits, as well as unequal opportunities in society, forcing
between the capitalists and the proletariat in society is that the capitalist can not survive
and thrive without the proletariat since the proletariat is the class that does the labor for
the capitalists. Contradictory and antagonistic is another example of how people can
understand their relationship because they are both associated with struggle, conflict, and
illustrates the relationships between the groups. In Marx's moral philosophy, the concept
"class" meant "class conflict," referring to the differences between people's beliefs and
viewpoints based on their social class. Marx demonstrates the disparity in society's
5. Marxist theory of inequality and poverty by Karl Marx - Capitalists, according to Marx,
are the ones who create socioeconomic public institutions and constantly need laborers,
so they are the ones who bring on deprivation and suffering in society. Inequality was
passed on from one worker to the next and possibly causing it to pass on throughout the
years. Poverty and inequality in a community and society are actually claimed to be
and injustice will continue to flourish in society as long as the capitalists manipulate and
theory's guidelines in this section of the chapter. They will demonstrate how the guidelines can
be used to derive an answer from the study's first chapter or specifically in the Statement of the
Problem part. Also, the correlation between the guidelines and the question will be demonstrated
at this stage. Besides, by reading the guidelines and looking at the arguments presented by the
researchers, people can already assume or speculate the answer to each question.
Meanwhile, at the first question, the researchers may answer it using Karl Marx's two
"basic" classes, which demonstrate that the persons who are referred to as the proletariat's
working class are the lowest class of society. Farmers are often stereotyped as being from a
lower social status. Similarly, they are also often characterized as lower-class people because
they are deemed as the members of the working class, which are the ones who do the labor for
Agricultural livelihoods are often associated with the lower class since the agricultural
workers commonly earn a low amount of wages despite the intensity of the labor they do. The
guidelines shown in stage II may also inform readers on how the author depicts the social class
of agricultural workers in the story wherein it somehow connected to the second question in the
first chapter. Accordingly, since the farmer in the story lives in a simple house and does not own
any luxurious properties, big businesses, or industry, the thought that the farmers are deemed as
Meanwhile, in the third question, there is a part in the story "Ang Pamana" by Lamberto
Gabriel where the characters determine that agricultural courses are not a good career to take,
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIORagriculture
due to the reasons that they believe HIGH SCHOOLholds DEPARTMENT
no future for individuals. By looking at the
guidelines, there is a section of Marxist philosophy of Inequality and Poverty which asserts that
farmers would not be able to flee from poverty if their production mechanism remains
unchanged and if they remain to be paid in low wages by their capitalists, whereas the notions
mentioned above serve as the social conflict that farmers are dealing with.
REFERENCES:
Adriano, F. D. (2020, August 27). Why Filipino small farmers remain poor.
https://www.manilatimes.net/2020/08/27/business/agribusiness/why-filipino-small-
farmers-remain-poor/759852/
Amadeo, K. (2020, November 10). Farm Subsidies with Pros, Cons, and Impact. the balance.
https://www.thebalance.com/farm-subsidies-4173885
Ani, P. A. B. (2013, July 30). The Overview of Policies and Public Sector Investments in the
fbclid=IwAR3myhg_-xdnzh10zjYGKzYTO5Oq-TuVFubA239uGNBytTV3c6vNzspU2JI
Arroyo, C. (2018, July 24). Sustainable Agriculture To End World Hunger. reliefweb.
https://reliefweb.int/report/world/sustainable-agriculture-end-world-hunger
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
Azadi, Y., Yazdanpanah, M., SENIOR HIGH
Forouzani, M.,SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
& Mahmoudi, H. (2018, June 04). Farmers'
adaptation choices to climate change: a case study of wheat growers in Western Iran.
https://iwaponline.com/jwcc/article/10/1/102/39343/Farmers-adaptation-choices-to-
climate-change-a
Baraoidan, K. (2015, November 13). Rice’s bad taste: Poor farmers, health risks. Inquirer.Net.
https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/739202/rices-bad-taste-poor-farmers-health-risks
https://www.scribbr.com/methodology/qualitative-research/
Birthal, P. S., Roy, D., & Negi, D. S. (2015, February 24). Assessing the Impact of Crop
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0305750X15000480
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marxism.asp
Casinas, J. A. (2021, April 4). ‘Saan makakarating ang P1,000?’: Farmers’ group says
makakarating-ang-p1000-farmers-group-says-proposed-aid-not-enough/
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332068965_Revisiting_the_Sociological_Theori
es_of_Poverty_Conceptualizing_a_Framework_for_Rural_Poverty_in_the_Philippines
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Chen, L. (2020, May 15). How China HIGH SCHOOL
improves DEPARTMENT
millions of farmers’ livelihoods. CGTN.
https://news.cgtn.com/news/2020-05-15/How-China-improves-millions-of-farmers-
livelihoods-QvlBpWJTu8/index.html
Conde, M. (2020, April). For Philippine farmers reeling from disasters, lockdown is another
farmers-reeling-from-disasters-lockdown-is-another-pain-point/amp/
Cottrell, A. (2019). Social Classes in Marxist Theory (2nd ed., Vol. 17). Books.google.com.
DwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PT7&dq=marxist%20theory%20social
%20class&ots=5vjGDEg8Ia&sig=VYYetknenKeO06lTdxf5OqbFU5U&redir_esc=y#v=
onepage&q=marxist%20theory%20social%20class&f=false
Denniston, J. (2017, July 20). Can a Farming Startup Help End Extreme Poverty? Yale Insights.
https://insights.som.yale.edu/insights/can-farming-startup-help-end-extreme-poverty
Duvall, V. (2018, November 28). Farmers are Feeding our Growing Economy. FB.
https://www.fb.org/viewpoints/farmers-are-feeding-our-growing-economy
Elauria, M. M. (2015, June 9). Farm Land Policy and Financing Program for Young Generation
Eslake, S. (2018, September 27). The economic impact of farm drought in rural Australia.
https://aicd.companydirectors.com.au/membership/company-director-magazine/2018-
back-editions/october/economist-the-big-dry
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Fabella, R. V. (2014, February). HIGH SCHOOL
Comprehensive DEPARTMENT
Agrarian Reform Program (CARP): Time to let
https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/102070/1/778119068.pdf
Galt, R. E. (2015, October 22). The Moral Economy Is a Double-edged Sword: Explaining
Galang, J. (2020). Filipino short stories we read in high school that we want to see onscreen.
scout. https://www.scoutmag.ph/entertainment/books/filipino-short-stories-we-want-
onscreen-jeloug-20200314
https://geography-revision.co.uk/gcse/agriculture/factors-affecting-agriculture/
Gesite, S. (2018, April 9). Stop vicious cycle of farmer poverty. Inquirer.Net.
https://opinion.inquirer.net/112301/stop-vicious-cycle-farmer-poverty
https://www.britannica.com/art/short-story.
Hasa. (2016, August 20). Difference Between Content Analysis and Discourse Analysis.
PEDIAA. https://pediaa.com/difference-between-content-analysis-and-discourse-
analysis/
https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/272-american-farmers-as-peasants-really
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/m/marxism.asp#:~:text=Marxism%20is%20a
%20social%2C%20political,capitalism%20in%20favor%20of%20communism
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Keil, A., Mitra, A., Srivastava, A. K., HIGH SCHOOLA.
& McDonald, DEPARTMENT
(2019, June 7). Social inclusion
increases with time for zero-tillage wheat in the Eastern Indo-Gangetic Plains.
ScienceDirect. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0305750X19301585
Lubang, S. A. (2019, July 11). Towards Liberation from Debts of Filipino Farmers.
Https://Ap.Fftc.Org.Tw/. https://ap.fftc.org.tw/article/643
https://www.academia.edu/45615635/FACTORS_AFFECTING_YOUTH_INVOLVEME
NT_IN_AGRICULTURE_IN_SELECTED_AREAS_OF_THE_DAVAO_REGION
Mahendra, D. S. (2014, May 20). Small farmers in India: Challenges and opportunities. DSpace.
http://oii.igidr.ac.in:8080/xmlui/handle/2275/262
Mariano, M. J., Villano, R., & Fleming, E. (2012, March 22). Factors influencing farmers’
adoption of modern rice technologies and good management practices in the Philippines.
ScienceDirect. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0308521X12000534
Martin, K. A. (2013, April 12). Farmers, fishermen among lowest paid in PH | ABS-CBN News.
Https://news.abs-cbn.com. https://news.abs-cbn.com/business/04/12/13/farmers-
fishermen-among-lowest-paid-ph
MBrusis. (2018, April 2). Content and Discourse Analysis. Getting Europe Right.
https://mbrusis.eu/content-and-discourse-analysis/
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
McLellan, D. T., & Chambre,SENIOR HIGH
H. (2020, SCHOOL
March DEPARTMENT
24). Marxism. Encyclopedia Britannica.
https://www.britannica.com/topic/Marxism
McLeod, S. (2019). What’s the difference between qualitative and quantitative research? Simply
Psychology. https://www.simplypsychology.org/qualitative-quantitative.html
Mellor, J. W., & Malik, S. J. (2015, September 25). The Impact of Growth in Small Commercial
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0305750X16302698
Müller, G.(2012) The relevance of Marx's ideas for today's political theory and praxis,
from https://www.grin.com/document/231598
Ofuoku, A. U., & Ekorhi-Robinson, O. I. (2018, July 27). Social inclusion of landless farmers in
Gruyter. https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/opag-2018-0024/html
Oosting, S.J., Udo, H.M.J., & Viets, T.C. (2014). Development of livestock production in the
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1751731114000548
Orsini, F., Kahane, R., Nono-Womdim, R., & Gianquinto, G. (2013, May 9). Urban agriculture
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs13593-013-0143-z
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
SENIOR
Palis, F. G. (2020, April 2). Aging HIGHRice
Filipino SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Farmers and Their Aspirations for Their
Children. Https://Philjournalsci.Dost.Gov.Ph/.
https://philjournalsci.dost.gov.ph/images/pdf/pjs_pdf/vol149no2/aging_filipino_rice_far
mers_.pdf
Pansensoy, M.(2020). Palaging pagod at Palaging hirap: The story of the Philippine
https://www.rappler.com/voices/ispeak/opinion-always-tired-poor-filipino-
farmer
8306.1975.tb01063.x
https://www.scribd.com/presentation/476110454/lit210-pagsusuri-pptx
PhilStar. (2021, January 28). Farmers' issues and updates. philstar global.
https://www.philstar.com/happens/632/amp/
Pratschke, J. (2017, November 24). Marxist Class Theory: Competition, Contingency and
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321268143_Marxist_Class_Theory_Competitio
n_Contingency_and_Intermediate_Class_Positions
Question Pro. (2018, March 27). Qualitative Research: Definition, Types, Methods and
Ramos, C. M. (2020, November 20). DepEd says it has ‘zero tolerance’ vs stereotyping after
says-it-has-zero-tolerance-vs-stereotyping-after-books-portrayal-of-farmers
Rebagay, C., (2012). Social Classes in the Philippines. Retrieved February 2021, from
https://www.slideshare.net/mobile/Noctis747/social-classes-12942253\
Reyes, C. M., Agbon, A. D., Mina, C. D., & Arboneda, A. (2017). Crop insurance program of
the PCIC: Integrative report from the five case regions in the Philippines. econstor Make
https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/210999/1/1018703942.pdf?
fbclid=IwAR1me9GQuNYs_WzzLk17U28EM1FkOskSyp3j1LcgR-
R2iAeFS7LGQYguc7A
Reyes, C. M., Tabuga, A. D., Asis, R. D., & Datu, M. B. G. (2012, September). Poverty and
https://dirp3.pids.gov.ph/ris/dps/pidsdps1209.pdf?fbclid=IwAR2dC-
YFnw5vzx0LuzTu0hUYwr1Px6rktKukhS70PdBl4WYO4IckPbjGUMc
https://news.abs-cbn.com/amp/business/02/19/21/mga-magsasaka-mangingisda-
pinakadukha-ayon-sa-mga-eksperto?__twitter_impression=true
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
Saliot, A. P. (2014, NovemberSENIOR HIGH Farmers’
5). Building SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Assets and Investing in The Out of School
Sanches, M., (2019). Real GDP growth of the agriculture sector in the Philippines from
https://www.statista.com/statistics/993333/philippines-real-gdp-growth-agriculture-
sector/
from
https://www.statista.com/topics/5744/agriculture-industry-in-the-philippines/
Satterthwaite, D., McGranahan, G., & Tacoli, C. (2010, September 27). Urbanization and its
implications for food and farming. US National Library of Medicine National Institutes
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2935117/
Tang, J., Folmer, H., & Xue, J. (2013, September 15). Estimation of awareness and perception
of water scarcity among farmers in the Guanzhong Plain, China, by means of a structural
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0301479713002235
Unite, B. K. (2021, March 30). ‘It can never be taken away from you’: Over 400 Quezon farmers
away-from-you-over-400-quezon-farmers-get-land-titles/
Escuela De Sophia Of Caloocan, Inc.
Welling, G., (2012). FarmersSENIOR HIGH SCHOOL
face hardships. DEPARTMENT
Retrieved February 2021, from
http://www.let.rug.nl/usa/outlines/history-1963/the-era-of-expansion-and-
reform/farmers-face-hardships.php
White, B. (2012, October 18). Agriculture and the Generation Problem: Rural Youth,
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1759-5436.2012.00375.x
Wu, X., Qi, X., Yang, S., Ye, C., & Sun, B. (2019, April 18). Research on the Intergenerational
https://www.mdpi.com/2071-1050/11/8/2341