Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jimma University: Jimma Institute of Technology (Jit)
Jimma University: Jimma Institute of Technology (Jit)
Jimma University: Jimma Institute of Technology (Jit)
PROJECT ON
January, 2016
i
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
ii
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Table of Contents
DECLARATION ........................................................................................................................... vi
INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 1
1.4.1Methodology ................................................................................................................... 4
2.1.2 Review of the components and theories used in this project Definition of power
system stability........................................................................................................................ 6
2.4.1 Some Advantages of the TCSC in power system transmission and distribution lines. 15
iii
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
5.1CONCLUSIONS.................................................................................................................. 35
Reference ...................................................................................................................................... 36
APPENDICES .............................................................................................................................. 37
iv
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1 angle curve of equal criteria ........................................................................................... 12
Figure 2: TCSC basic Module ...................................................................................................... 15
Figure 3: Operational region of TCSC.......................................................................................... 16
Figure 4: Single line diagram of the power system ...................................................................... 18
Figure 5: The mathematical modeling of the swing equation....................................................... 20
Figure 6: post-fault power-angle curve ......................................................................................... 26
Figure 7: the internal sub system for TCSC model...................................................................... 29
Figure 8: Simulation diagram of the system with thyristore......................................................... 31
Figure 9: The matlab simulation results of with TCSC system .................................................... 32
v
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
DECLARATION
We declare that the work entitled “POWER SYSTEM STABILITY ENHANCEMENT BY
USING SERIES COMPENSATION” is our original work. We have not copied from any other
student’s work or from any other sources except where due reference or acknowledgement is made
explicitly in the text, nor has any part been written for us by another person.
Declared by:
1, Masresha Melkei ______________
Signature
2, Workenrh Alemu ______________
Signature
vi
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Firstly, we would like to say thanks to us what we are today. words can’t express our gratitude for
all they have provided us our appreciation and heart full thanks also goes to our project advisors,
Mr. Alebachew Tenna for their guidance to follow the right way in our project and a heart full
thanks to for his responsible to help us and thanks to all school of electrical engineering
departments of jimma university for their encouragement, love and emotional supports that they
had given to us throughout the progress of this project.
vii
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
ABSTRACT
The stability of an interconnected power system is its ability to return to normal or stable operation
after having been subjected to some form of disturbance. Transient stability analysis has recently
become a major issue in the operation of power systems due to the increasing stress on power
system networks. This problem requires evaluation of a power system's ability to withstand
disturbances while maintaining the quality of service. A Thyristor controlled series capacitor
(TCSC) belongs to the flexible alternating current transmission systems (FACTS) family of
devices. It is a variable capacitive and inductive reactance device that can be used to provide series
compensation in power transmission lines. One of the significant advantages that a TCSC has over
other series compensation devices is that the TCSC's reactance is instantaneously and continuously
variable. This means that the TCSC can be used not only to provide series compensation but can
also be used to enhance the stability of the power system .In this project, performance of TCSC is
analyzed. Initially, Real and reactive power flow through the transmission line have been analyzed
for fixed and then after the same parameters are evaluated by inserting controllable capacitor in
the same transmission network. The considered topology of TCSC consists of back to back
thyristors that controls the reactance of the TCSC. By changing the firing angle of these back to
back thyristors it is possible to vary the reactance of the TCSC.
As per the TCSC characteristics, in inductive region at the firing angle α=90 to 130 the power
flow decreasing and in capacitive region at the firing angle α=140 to 180 degree respectively the
power flow increasing. The simulation of 3-phase model is the appropriate degree of compensation
to increase power transfer capability. The simulation is carried out by using software package
MATLAB Simulation.
viii
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
The classical model of a multi- machine may be used to study the stability of a power system for
a period of time during which the system dynamic response is dependent largely on the kinetic
energy rotating masses. The classical three-machine nine bus system is the simplest model used in
studies of power system dynamic and requires of minimum amount of data. Hence such studies
can be connected in a relatively short time under minimum cost. Among various method of load
flow calculation Newton Rap son method is chosen for calculation of load flow study. If the
oscillatory response of a power system is during the transient period following a disturbance is
damped and the system settles in a finite time to a new steady operating condition , we say the
system is stable, if the system is not stable, it is considerable unstable. This primitive definition
stability requires that the oscillation system should be damped. This condition is the same times
called asymptotic stability and means that the system contains inherent forces that tend to reduce
oscillation. Power system stability is the ability of an electrical power system, for given operating
Conditions, to regain its state of operating equilibrium after being subjected to a physical
Disturbance, with the system variables bounded, so that the entire system remains intact and the
service remains uninterrupted.
1
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
The figure below gives the overall picture of the stability problems
POWER
SYSTEM
STABILITY
2
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Out of all the stability problems mentioned above, our specific focus in this project is the large
disturbance stability which is a part of the rotor angle stability. Also, the voltage Stability due to
small disturbances is covered.
Rotor angle stability: This refers to the ability of the synchronous generator in an interconnected
power system to Remain in synchronism after being subjected to disturbances. It depends on the
ability of the Machine to maintain equilibrium between electromagnetic torque and mechanical
torque of each synchronous machine system is Instability of this kind occurs in the form of Swings
of the generator rotor which leads to loss of synchronism.
Small Disturbance stability may refer to small disturbance voltage or rotor angle stability. The
disturbances are sufficiently small so as to assume a linearized system model. Small Disturbances
may be small incremental load changes, small control variations etc.
3
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
1.2General Objective
The objective of this project is focus on power system stability by using thyristore controlled
(TCSC) Series compensation and the mathematical modeling of the swing equation.
1.3Specific objective
Stability studies are helpful for the following purpose
To investigate the power quality disturbances that arise from both the customer Side and
the electric utility side, at selected industrial plants.
Analysis of power system stability is complex and nonlinear .consequently, final design
are generally based on computer simulations.
For approximate purpose simplified calculation are used. It provided starting point, for and
checks of computer simulations.
Tools
MATLAB. Simulation
Thyristor controlled series capacitor (TCSC)
4
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Bus bar
Transmissions line
Coupled transformer
Capacitor
Control unit
TCR
Converter: - used for conversion of one form to another.
5
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
CHAPTER TWO
2.1.2 Review of the components and theories used in this project Definition of power system
stability
A large power system consists of a number of synchronous machine operating in synchronism. It
is necessary that they should maintain perfect synchronism under steady state conditions. When
system is subjected to some form of disturbance, there is tendency for the system to develop force,
to bring it to normal condition. The ability of system to reach a normal condition after being
disturbed is called stability. Under stable conditions the system stays in synchronism .Synchronous
stability may be divided in to three main categories depending up on magnitude of disturbance.
6
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Steady-state stability: Refers to the ability of the power system to regain synchronism after small
and slow disturbance, such as gradual power change.
Transient stability: The ability of the system to regain synchronism after a large disturbance. This
occurs due to sudden change in application or removal of large load, line switching operation fault
on the system, sudden outage of the line or loss of excitation.
Dynamic stability: It refers to the stability of a power system subject to a relatively small and
sudden disturbance, the system can be described by linear differential equations, and the system
can be stabilized by a linear and continuous supplementary stability control
The steady-state stability limit is the maximum amount of power that can be transferred from
the source to the load without the system becoming unstable when the load is increased gradually
under steady state conditions.
Transient stability limit is the maximum power that can be transferred without the system
becoming unstable when a sudden or large disturbance occurs.
7
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
termed as the fault clearing time.This fault clearing time primarily constitutes the time taken by
the relays and the circuit breakers to operate after a disturbance has been detected. The upper bound
on the fault clearing time is termed as the critical clearing time (CCT). The CCT is the maximum
time between the disturbance initiation and its fault clearing time such that the power system is
transiently stable. The process of determining whether the power system will reach a stable state
following a disturbance is known as the transient stability assessment Equal area criterion (EAC).
Swing Equation
Under normal operating conditions, the relative position of the rotor axis and the Resultant
magnetic field axis is fixed. The angle between the two is known as the Power angle or torque
angle. During any disturbance, rotor will decelerate or Accelerate with respect to the
synchronously rotating air gap mmf and a relative Motion begin. The equation describing this
relative motion is known as the swing Equation.
If Tm is the driving mechanical torque and Te is the electrical torque then under steady state
operation with losses neglected we have
Neglecting the losses, the difference between the mechanical and electrical torque gives the net
accelerating torque Ta. In the steady state, the electrical torque is equal to the mechanical torque,
8
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
and hence the accelerating power will be zero. During this period the rotor will move at
synchronous speed s in rad/s.
The angular position is measured with a stationary reference frame. To represent it with respect
to the synchronously rotating frame, we define
Where is the angular position in rad with respect to the synchronously rotating reference frame
taking the time derivative of the above equation we get the equation.
We can therefore conclude that the rotor angular speed is equal to the synchronous speed only
when ddt is equal to zero. We can therefore term ddt as the error in speed. And Taking (2) &
Multiplying both side of thus by m we get
9
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Where Pm, Pe and Pa respectively are the mechanical, electrical and accelerating power in MW
In steady state, the machine angular speed is equal to the synchronous speed and hence we can
replace r in the above equation by s. Note that Pm, Pe and Pa are given in MW. Therefore
dividing them by the generator MVA rating Stated we can get these quantities in per unit. Hence
dividing both sides of (3) by Stated we get
The Equation describes the behavior of the rotor dynamics and hence is known as the swing
equation. The angle is the angle of the internal emf of the generator and it dictates the amount of
power that can be transferred.
10
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
11
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Multiplying both sides of the above equation by dt and then integrating between two arbitrary
angles 0 and c we get
Now suppose the generator is at rest at 0. We then have d/dt = 0. Once a fault occurs, the machine
starts accelerating. Once the fault is cleared, the machine keeps on accelerating before it reaches
its peak at c, at which point we again have d/dt = 0. Thus the area of accelerating in the above
fig is as
In a similar way, we can define the area of deceleration. The area of acceleration is given by A1
while the area of deceleration is given by A2. This is given by
12
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Now consider the case when the line is reclosed at c such that the area of acceleration is larger
than the area of deceleration, i.e., A1 > A2. The generator load angle will then cross the point m,
beyond which the electrical power will be less than the mechanical power forcing the accelerating
power to be positive. The generator will therefore start accelerating before is slows down
completely and will eventually become unstable. If, on the other hand, A1 < A2, i.e., the
decelerating area is larger than the accelerating area, the machine will decelerate completely before
accelerating again. The rotor inertia will force the subsequent acceleration and deceleration areas
to be smaller than the first ones and the machine will eventually attain the steady state. If the two
areas are equal, i.e., A1 = A2, then the accelerating area is equal to decelerating area and this is
defines the boundary of the stability limit. The clearing angle c for this mode is called the critical
clearing angle and is denoted by cr. We then get from Fig.by substituting c = cr
We can calculate the critical clearing angle from the above equation
Since we are interested in finding out the maximum time that the circuit breakers may take for
opening, we should be more concerned about the critical clearing time rather than clearing angle.
Furthermore, notice that the clearing angle is independent of the generalized inertia constant H.
Hence we can comment that the critical clearing angle in this case is true for any generator that
has a d-axis transient reactance of 0.20 per unit.
The critical clearing time, however, is dependent on H and will vary as this parameter varies. To
obtain a description for the critical clearing time, let us consider the period during which the fault
occurs. We then have Pe = 0. We can therefore write from
13
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Integrating the above equation with the initial acceleration being zero we get
Replacing by cr and t by tcr in the above equation, we get the critical clearing time as
TCSC is one of the most important and best known series FACTS controllers. It has been in use
for many years to Increase line power transfer as well as to enhance system stability. The basic
module of a TCSC is shown in bellow Fig3. It consists of three components: capacitor banks C,
bypass inductor L and bidirectional thyristors T1 and T2. The firing angles of the thyristors are
controlled to adjust the TCSC reactance in accordance with a system control algorithm, normally
in response to some system parameter variations.
14
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
15
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
16
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Generally Thyristor is a powerful tool for efficiency in power transmission and distribution system
by Change of impedance of TCSC is achieved by changing the thyristor controlled inductive
reactance of inductors connected in parallel to the capacitor.
The magnitude of inductive reactance is determined by angle switching thyristors α, which can
also be Controlled continuously flowing amplitude of current reactor from the maximum value to
zero. Angle switching thyristors can change inductive reactance controlled choke from a minimum
value (a=0; Xtcr=xl) the theoretically to infinity.
17
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
CHAPTER THREE
SWING EQUATION
Now we want to do an example of the most simple power system that we can consider – the so
called one-machine against an infinite bus.
18
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Let’s considering the per faults, during fault and post fault calculation
We ended our last set of notes, concluding that the following equation characterizes the
electromechanical dynamics of a synchronous machine system.
Pm=mechanical constant
19
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
20
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
We ended our last set of notes, concluding that the following equation characterizes the
electromechanical dynamics of a synchronous machine system.
Pm=mechanical constant
Consider the power system in. It is referred to as a one-machine against an infinite bus. So many
engineers use it to provide a conceptual basis for understanding fundamental machine behavior. It
would not be used, however, to provide precise machine response as the computer serves well for
this purpose we ended our last set of notes, concluding that the following equation characterizes
the electromechanical dynamics of a synchronous machine system.
Pm=mechanical constant E
a=voltage at the generator in per unit
21
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Bus 2, the infinite bus, is so-called because it has a voltage and angle that is constant under all
conditions, and it can absorb infinite power. Although there is no real infinite bus in power
systems, a single small machine connected to a very large power system behaves as if it is
connected to an infinite bus. Given that the machine is delivering 1.0 per unit power under steady-
state conditions, we have the following objectives in this problem.
22
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Solution
Case 1 Determine voltage at the generator Ea.
Compute the impedance x between the generator terminals and the infinite bus:
Note that we have two bus voltage magnitudes, the reactance between them, and the power flowing
out of one of them, so our familiar relation for power flowing out of generator terminals will work
here, i.e.
From this we can compute the current flowing from the machine terminals (bus 1) to the infinite
bus, according to the voltage current relation.
And from this, we may compute the internal voltage pharos E a, according to
23
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Note that the above procedure is typical of what is done in full-scale commercial power flow
programs where the program will begin from a power flow solution, from which it computes the
current flow from every gen bus, and then it computes each generator’s internal voltage just as we
have done in the above.
2. Draw the power-angle (P-δ) curve we can draw the power angle curve for different angles. Some
of the choices are
Note that the electrical power (left-hand-side) is the same in all three cases since there is no
resistance in this circuit. We should choose the most restrictive power angle curve, i.e., the one
that gives the largest angle for the same power. Since the voltages are all reasonably close, the
most restrictive curve is determined by the one with the largest reactance by using the above
numerical data to find the pre fault power pre
The operating point corresponding to the 1.0 pu power condition on the pre-fault power angle
curve. This is where Pe=1.0, i.e. Solving for δa=28.44°. We can show this point on the pre-fault
power-angle curve, However, that there are really two solutions, one at 28.44° and the other at
24
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
180- 28.44=151.56°. Both of these points constitute equilibrium, i.e., a location in terms of the
problem variables where all equations are satisfied, since the two angles complementary.
Case 2 Consider the three phase fault in the middle of one of the lines between buses 3 and 2,
determine the fault-on power angle curve. The equivalent circuit diagram corresponding to the
faulted system is.
So we want to be able to write another equation in this condition To write such an equation,
however, we will need the series reactance between the two voltage sources. This series reactance
is not obvious from the circuit diagram we can get it, however, if we replace the circuit to the right
of the two marked nodes then by using the venin equivalent. The relevant part of the circuit is
shown we obtain the venin voltage
We get the venin impedance by ideal the source and computing the composite impedance, as
shown
25
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
26
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Case 3 To determine the post-fault power-angle curve after protection has operated to clear the
fault. The post-fault system is obtained from the understanding of basic protective relaying which
results in removing the faulted circuit. The resulting one-line diagram is shown, and the
corresponding equivalent circuit diagram is
27
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
The synchronous generator is delivering power to the infinite-bus through a transmission line and
a TCSC. In Fig. 7, Vt and Eb are the generator terminal and infinite bus voltages The complete
Simulink model for the SMIB with TCSC controller is shown in Fig. 8. Figs 9 and 10 show the
subsystem for the calculation of XTCSC required for the compensation. Input to the TCSC
controller block is rotor angular speed (dw) and corresponding XTCSC is the output, which damps
the oscillations and hence improves the transient stability of the system.
28
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
29
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Inclusion of TCSC device to one of the lines changes the power flow in given lines according to
level desired. This change is achieved by changing the impedance of line, in
which is installed TCSC device. With the entry values of angle switching thyristors α, TCSC can
change the impedance of the line and thereby regulates the power flow as required. When such a
change power flow, the power flow on lines is reallocated to another ratio, but the resulting flow
performance remains unchanged. First the system has been simulated in MATLAB/SIMULINK
environment. The voltages and powers in all the buses have been found out and given as a “Table”
below. Because of the variation in powers at bus 2, it is selected as the candidate bus to which
TCSC has to be installed. After simulation we have been obtained the real time voltage, current,
power variations at bus. The active and reactive powers at bus got oscillated due to large loads of
the system and which keep continuing for almost 3 sec. Because of the ohmic loads the active
power oscillations are more compared to reactive power oscillations. The preliminary controlling
systems such as governor, PSS are used for damping these oscillations. According to the figures it
is also clear that the voltage and current waveforms are closer to sinusoidal waveforms. The
voltage amplitude is 0.25 per unit and the current amplitude is 0.12 per unit. TCSC is mainly used
30
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
for controlling the active and reactive power flow through the transmission system and also to
improve the transient stability of the system. Form the simulation result it is clear that after the
installation of TCSC the active power oscillation damping time will be less than the mode without
TCSC. Also it will decrease the reactive power damping time.
Using with thyristoered (TCSC) controlled series compensation at the time interval between
0.02sec≤t≤0.024sec and the output of voltage and current results will be shown below At firing
angleα=70°
Note that in the simulation result when we used thyristore controlled capacitor TCSC the fault
clearing time become fast as we compared to without TCSC Without TCSC fault clearing
times=0.0234sec. The fault cellaring time with TCSC=0.0231sec
31
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
CHAPTER FOUR
Case2: during fault conditions (fault occurred 0.02sec < t < 0.023sec.)
32
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Considering the above cases the behavior of the line is examined here. The MATLAB simulation
result of the power system is shown in the figure given below. The fault occurred during the period
between 0.02to 0.023sec.after0.023sec the line is removed. The relative variation in rotor angle
and the change in angular speed of the rotor are examined after 0.023 sec the relative variation in
rotor angle and relative change in angular speed starts to damp out. After 0.023sec the line is
restore
The simulation result of single machine connected to infinite bus bar system by using mathematical
modelling of swing equation as shown the figure 8. This is clearly far from the solution behavior
we desired. Since it is continuously unbounded limit of the result.
The simulation result of single machine connected to infinite bus bar system by using mathematical
modeling of swing equation as shown figure 9. This is clearly for the solution behavior we desired.
Since it is bounded limit of the result. Note that the transient stability depends on the time when it
required to transiently stabile or unstable. The power is interrupted in small time interval, even in
micro second level.as we shown in figure 8 unboundedly unstable systems the reason why we have
pensioned. But in figure 9 shows that the system is transiently stable after relatively longer time
interval. The above two figures (figure 8&figure9) are drawn the rotor angle vs. time for the
mathematical modeling of the swing equation.
During when we used with out of the thyriostered controlled series capacitor (TCSC) case the time
of fault occurrence in the interval between 0.02sec.≤ ≤ and the output voltage and current results
are shown the above. But when we used thyristore controlled series capacitor (TCSC) technique
the time of response is fast .the response is taken at the time interval between 0.02sec≤t≤0.024sec
and the output of voltage, current, active power and the reactive power wave forms are shown in
the above figures 16&17
33
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
The simulation result and the fault clearing time become fast as we compared to without the
thyristored controlled series capacitor (TCSC) Without TCSC fault clearing times=0.0234sec. The
fault clearing time with TCSC=0.0231sec
34
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
CHAPTER FIVE
5.1CONCLUSIONS
Power system stability is the property of a power system that insures the system remains in
electromechanical equilibrium throughout any normal and abnormal operating Conditions.
Because the power system stability is an electromechanical Phenomenon, it is thus defined as the
ability of designated synchronous machines in the system to remain in synchronism with one
another following disturbance such as fault and fault removal at various locations in the system.
This paper presents the study of transient stability analysis and also the transient stability analysis
using the TCSC. This paper presents systematic procedure for modeling, simulation of TCSC
controller for enhancing power system stability. A MATLAB/SIMULINK model is developed for
a single-machine infinite bus power system with TCSC model. The controller is tested on power
system subjected to large as well as small disturbances. The simulation results show that, the TCSC
controller improves the stability performance of the power system and power system oscillations
are effectively damped out. Thus, it is observed that the proposed TCSC controller is effective in
damping low frequency oscillations resulting from small disturbances conditions like increase in
mechanical power input and reference voltage settings.
35
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
Reference
[1] Power system dynamics: stability and control second edition, Jan Machowski, Janus W. Bialek,
James R. Bumby.
[2] Dommel, H.W., and Sato, N.,’Fast Transient stability solutions”, IEETrans, PAS-91, pp.1643-
1650) October, 1972.
[3] Martin German-Sobek, ubomír Bea, Roman Cimbala Using of the Thyristor Controlled Series
Capacitor in Electric Power System
[5] Design and Implementation of Firing Circuit for Single-Phase Converter Tirtharaj Sen, Pijush
Kanti Bhattacharjee, Member, IACSIT, Manjima Bhattacharya
36
Power system stability enhancement by using series compensation 2016
APPENDICES
37