Name: Andal, Carlos Miguel L Score: ________

Course & Year Level: BSN1-C Date: __________

Analysis: How credible the 3 account in explaining the Cavite Mutiny of

1872?
Report of the governor Vidal’s Account T,H de Tavera’s
general Account

Governor General Vidal’s account was Pardo De Tavera

Izquierdo insisted that considered as the most was a native Filipino
the Cavite mutiny was reliable source. Almost historian. He didn’t
stimulated and all of his claims are agreed on the way how
prepared by the native notably same from what did Governor Izquierdo
clergies, mestizos and actually happened. sees everything around.
lawyers as a way on Armed also with a
expressing their His credibility rises primary source of
disappointment on the due to that he lived here knowledge as he was
injustices of the in the Philippines from part of the said actions
government . One good 1869 to 1896. He was and happenings within
example was not paying sent to create an the time frame.
tobacco crops, wasn’t expedition and
able to pay tribute and observation to what is Tavera believed that
often ask to render happening here in the the Spanish friars and
forced labors. Philippines. Izquierdo used the
Cavite Mutiny as a
Although him powerful lever by
considered as a primary Jose Montero y magnifying it as a full-
source, he still have this Vidal, was known as a blown conspiracy
instances of committing prolific Spanish involving not only the
favoring statements on historian documented native army but also
one side of the opposing the event and included residents of
groups. He was known highlighted it as an Cavite and Manila, and
as a Spanish governor, attempt of the Indios to more importantly the
and also known for overthrow the Spanish native clergy to
being biased towards government in the overthrow the Spanish
the Spanish men.That’s Philippines.  government in the
the reason why he Philippines.
acclaimed that the Vidal’s work was
following mutiny were considered as a the most He identified such
all trying ti overthrow conclusive and known reasons for the
and cease to exist the to be as the most occurrence of the
Spanish government credible as this mutiny. And that was
occupying Cavite. compliments the work the way how did Pardo
However in the end of Gov. Izquierdo. De Tavera claimed that
Governor Izquierdo they were not originally
took offense to it Although aiming for a said revolt.
Izquierdo’s and Vidal’s
Governor work compliments each What do they freally
Ezquierdo almost has other Vidal’s work was want was to express teir
the same content of more acclaimed as it disappointments due to
account with Vidal”s presents a complete and the unequal transactions
work. The problem detailed information with Spanish men.
there was he was noteb that was all necessary to Originally it was
to be biased upon his make it justified and expressed as a strike to
account and that was a informative. express the
big turn around in discontentment towards