Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Article ايبي
Article ايبي
2018;22(2):216-221
© Serdi and Springer-Verlag International SAS, part of Springer Nature
Abstract: Objectives: Previous studies found that tea consumption was related to a reduction in the risks of some
chronic diseases, but limited data are available on bone health. This study aimed to examine the associations
of tea consumption with hip bone strength in Chinese women. Design: Cross-sectional study. Setting: The
participants were from the ongoing Guangzhou Nutrition and Health Study. This was a cohort study started
in 2008. The examination data conducted between June 2010 and December 2013 were used. Participants: A
total of 1,495 Chinese women aged more than 40 years were included. Measurements: Tea consumption, socio-
demographic information and lifestyle habits were collected by a face-to-face questionnaire. Hip bone mineral
density (BMD) and geometric parameters, i.e. cross-sectional area (CSA), section modulus (Z) and buckling
ratio (BR), were generated by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry. The associations of tea consumption with bone
phenotypes were detected by analysis of covariance and multiple linear regression models after adjusting for
age, body mass index, years since menopause, physical activity, dietary-protein intake, dietary-calcium intake,
calcium tablet intake, drinking status and smoking status. Results: Tea drinkers (n = 732) had approximately
1.9% higher BMD (p < 0.05) and 3.6% lower BR (p < 0.05) than non-tea drinkers (n = 763). The dose-response
relationships of BMD, BR or CSA with total tea consumption were identified (p-trend < 0.05). Tea drinking was
found to be a significant and independent predictor of BMD (β = 0.068, p < 0.05) or BR (β = -0.079, p < 0.05).
Conclusion: Tea consumption was associated with increased bone strength in middle-aged and elderly Chinese
women.
Key words: Osteoporosis, tea consumption, bone mineral density, bone geometry.
osteoporosis and cardiometabolic outcomes (19). The data for BMD, CSA, Z and BR at the FN, respectively.
from the first follow-up examination conducted between June
2010 and December 2013 were used. Women over 40 years of Assessments of covariates
age were recruited by posting local advertisements, by sending Dietary intake was assessed using a quantitative and 81-item
invitation letters to residential buildings, by giving health talks food frequency questionnaire (22). For each food item, the
or from referrals in the local community. All of the participants subjects were asked how often (never, per year, per month,
were residents of urban Guangzhou, China for over 5 years. per week and per day) they had consumed over the past year.
Excluded were subjects with chronic diseases or conditions Dietary nutrients and total energy intake were calculated based
that might affect bone mass and metabolism, such as having a on the China Food Composition Table (23). Calcium tablet
history of metabolic bone disorder or left hip fracture, chronic intake was recorded if the subjects had taken the calcium
medical illness, endocrine diseases including hyperthyroidism, supplement over 30 times within the past year. The subjects
medications that might affect bone and calcium metabolism, who smoked more than 100 cigarettes in their lifetime were
bilateral oophorectomy, major gastrointestinal operations, defined as active smokers. Those who lived or worked in a
premature menopause at age < 40 years, or being prescribed room with an individual who smoked more than one cigarette or
medicines such as calcitonin, bisphosphonates, selective more than 5 minutes per day for at least one year were defined
estrogen receptor modulators and active vitamin D3 as passive smokers. Drinkers were individuals that had ever
metabolites. Ultimately, 1,495 women with bone measurement drunk alcoholic beverages at least once a week for more than
data and who responded to the questionnaires were included in 6 months. The daily physical activity including occupational
this study. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee activities, leisure-time activities and household-chores but
of the School of Public Health of Sun Yat-Sen University, and except for sitting and lying, was evaluated using metabolic
written informed consent was obtained from each participant. equivalent (MET) hours per day (24). Weight (kg) and height
(cm) were measured at the same time, and body mass index
Tea consumption (BMI, kg/m2) was calculated.
All of the participants completed a face-to-face interview
performed by trained staff using a structured questionnaire. Statistical analysis
Socio-demographic information, history of disease and Descriptive statistics were determined for all variables
medications, lifestyle habits and reproductive histories were according to their distribution. They are presented as the
collected. There were four questions on tea drinking. The first mean and standard deviation (SD), median and interquartile
question was: “Have you drunk tea twice or more times per range, or number (n) and percentage. Differences in bone
week in the past year?” Subjects who answered “yes” were phenotypes between tea drinkers and non-tea drinkers were
coded as tea drinkers and then completed questions on the assessed by using analysis of covariance. Further comparisons
number of times of tea drinking per week (times), the total were conducted among subgroups classified by total tea
consumed quantities (kg) of tea and the types of tea (i.e. green consumption or the times of tea drinking per week. Moreover,
tea, black tea, oolong tea and dark tea) over the past year. the assessments and inferences of the relationships between
tea consumption and bone phenotypes were conducted using
BMD and bone geometry multiple linear regression models. All analyses were adjusted
The BMD (g/cm2) at the femur neck (FN) of the left hip for confounding factors including age, BMI, years since
was measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA, menopause (YSM), physical activity, dietary-protein intake,
Discovery W; Hologic Inc., Waltham, MA, USA). DXA images dietary-calcium intake, calcium tablet intake, drinking status
of the hip proximal femur were reprocessed with the Hip and smoking status. The dietary nutrient intakes were adjusted
Structure Analysis (HSA) program included in the APEX for total energy intake using a residual method. Statistical
software (v3.2, Hologic Inc.) (20). Three HSA-generated analyses were performed with SPSS 20.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago,
bone geometry parameters, i.e. cross-sectional area (CSA, IL, USA). A p < 0.05 in a two-tailed test was considered
cm 2), section modulus (Z, cm 3) and buckling ratio (BR), significant.
were analysed in this study. CSA is the amount of (cortical
equivalent) bone surface area in the cross-section after Results
excluding all of the trabecular and soft tissue spaces, and it
indicates the resistance to a loading force directed along the General characteristics of the participants
bone axis (21). Z indicates the bending strength for maximum The basic information of the participants is shown in Table
bending stress in the image plane. BR is the relative thickness 1. The median age of the 1,495 women was 58 years old, and
of the narrow neck cortex and represents an estimate of the the median YSM was 8 years. Among all subjects, 732 (49.0%)
cortical stability in buckling. An increase in BR indicates were tea drinkers and 763 (51.0%) were non-tea drinkers.
that the bone is becoming less stable and weaker. The in-vivo For the 732 tea drinkers, the median values of the times of
coefficients of variation were 1.92%, 1.55%, 2.99% and 4.62% tea drinking per week and total tea consumption over the past
217
J Nutr Health Aging
Volume 22, Number 2, 2018
year were 7 times and 4.2 kg, respectively. The numbers of Differences in bone phenotypes between tea drinkers and
individuals who drank green tea, black tea, oolong tea and non-tea drinkers
dark tea were 109 (14.9%), 110 (15.0%), 229 (31.3%) and 284 Table 2 shows the differences in the mean values of BMD,
(38.8%), respectively. The medium values of dietary nutrient BR, CSA and Z between tea drinkers and non-tea drinkers. Tea
intakes were around 65.90 g/d and 575.03 mg/d for protein and drinkers had a higher BMD (p = 0.032) and a lower BR (p =
calcium, respectively. Approximately 29.6% of the participants 0.005) than non-tea drinkers after adjusting for confounding
had taken calcium tablets more than 30 times in the past year, factors, including age, BMI, YSM, physical activities, dietary-
28.5% were active or passive smokers and 3.3% were alcohol protein intake, dietary-calcium intake, calcium tablet intake,
drinkers. The mean (SD) values of BMD, BR, CSA and Z of drinking status and smoking status. For CSA and Z, the mean
all subjects were 0.844 (0.144) g/cm2, 10.929 (2.784), 2.434 values were all consistently higher in tea drinkers than non-
(0.394) cm2 and 1.105 (0.224) cm3, respectively. tea drinkers, although the differences were not statistically
significant in this sample (p > 0.05). The mean differences
Table 1 in BMD, BR, CSA and Z between tea drinkers and non-tea
Basic characteristics of studied women (n = 1,495) drinkers were 0.016 g/cm2 (1.9%), -0.400 (3.6%), 0.028 cm2
(1.2%) and 0.011cm3 (1.0%), respectively.
Variable Mean ± SD / median (25th~75th)
/ n (%) Table 2
Age (year) 58.0 (55.0~62.0) Differences of BMD and bone geometric parameters between
Height (cm) 155.07 ± 5.37 the groups of non-tea drinker and tea drinker (n = 1,495)
Weight (kg) 56.16 ± 8.33
Variable Non-tea drinkers Tea drinkers p-value
BMI (kg/m2) 23.34 ± 3.20
(n = 763) (n = 732)
YSM (year) 8.0 (5.0~12.0)
BMD (g/cm2) 0.836 (0.005) 0.852 (0.005) 0.032
Physical activities (MET · h/d) a 33.18 (30.31~37.24) BR 11.125 (0.100) 10.725 (0.102) 0.005
Energy intake (kcal/d) 1505.59 (1264.86~1777.62) CSA (cm2) 2.420 (0.014) 2.448 (0.014) >0.050
Dietary-protein intake (g/d) 65.90 (52.95~80.52) Z (cm3) 1.100 (0.008) 1.111 (0.008) >0.050
Dietary-calcium intake (mg/d) 575.03 (437.40~715.85) Values were expressed as mean and standard error. Bone phenotypes were adjusted for
Calcium tablets intake (n, %) 443 (29.6) age, body mass index, years since menopause, physical activities, dietary-protein intake,
dietary-calcium intake, calcium tablet intake, drinking status and smoking status. BMD,
Smoker (n, %) 426 (28.5) bone mineral density; BR, buckling ratio; CSA, cross sectional area; Z, section modulus.
Alcohol drinker (n, %) 49 (3.3)
Tea drinker (n, %) 732 (49.0) Dose-response relationships of tea consumption with bone
phenotypes
Times of tea drinking (times/week) 7.0 (3.0~7.0)
To assess the dose-response relationships of tea consumption
Total tea consumption (kg) 4.2 (2.0~8.3)
with bone phenotypes, the subjects were further categorised into
Types of tea several subgroups by their tea drinking habits. As displayed
Green tea (n, %) 109 (14.9) in Table 3 and Figure 1, there were significant trends of
Black tea (n, %) 110 (15.0) increased BMD, CSA (p = 0.006 and 0.042) and decreased BR
Oolong tea (n, %) 229 (31.3) (p = 0.003) with the larger quantity of total tea consumption.
Compared with those who consumed less than 1.0 kg over the
Dark tea (n, %) 284 (38.8)
past year, the individuals who consumed more than 4.2 kg of
BMD (g/cm ) 2
0.844 ± 0.144
tea had approximately 3.0% higher BMD, 4.7% lower BR and
BR 10.929 ± 2.784 2.0% higher CSA, respectively. In the 732 tea drinkers, the
CSA (cm2) 2.434 ± 0.394 differences in bone phenotypes among the subgroups classified
Z (cm3) 1.105 ± 0.224 by the types of tea (green, black, oolong and dark tea) were not
Values were presented as mean ± standard deviation (SD), median and interquartile significant (p > 0.05).
range (25th~75th), or number (n) and percentage (%). a. Physical activities including
daily occupational activities, leisure time and household chores, were evaluated using
metabolic equivalent hours per day (MET · h/d). BMI, body mass index; YSM, years
Contributions of tea consumption to bone phenotypes
since menopause; BMD, bone mineral density; BR, buckling ratio; CSA, cross sectional Multiple linear regression models were then performed
area; Z, section modulus. to evaluate the contributions of tea consumption to bone
phenotypes (Table 4). The results showed that tea consumption
was a significant predictor of BMD and BR independent of
age, BMI, YSM, physical activities, dietary-protein intake,
dietary-calcium intake, calcium tablet intake, drinking status
218
J Nutr Health Aging
Volume 22, Number 2, 2018
Table 3
Results of dose-response relationships of bone phenotypes with the studied variables of tea consumption (n = 1,495)
Table 4
Results of multiple linear regression analysis of tea consumption variables with BMD and bone geometric parameters (n = 1,495)
and smoking status. The standardized regression coefficients of also observed to have a significant and negative dose-response
tea drinking and total tea consumption were 0.054 (p = 0.032) relationship with total tea consumption. Previous association
and 0.068 (p = 0.007) for BMD, -0.072 (p = 0.005) and -0.079 studies of tea consumption and bone geometric structure are
(p = 0.002) for BR, respectively. limited. Nonetheless, the findings from the animal model study
into the influence of tea on bone may be instructive. Chen et
Discussion al (26) observed that with the 12 weeks supplementation of
(-)-epigallocatechin-3-gallate (EGCG), a bioactive substance in
The associations of tea consumption-related variables with tea, the ovariectomy-induced osteopenic rats showed increased
hip BMD and bone geometry in middle-aged and elderly bone volume, trabecular number, and trabecular thickness and
Chinese women were evaluated in this study. The results decreased trabecular separation, which suggested the protective
showed that tea drinking was a protective factor for BMD and effects of EGCG on bone microarchitecture. Recently, Ng et
BR, and the habit of drinking tea could also be beneficial for the al (27) in 2,398 individuals aged more than 55 years found
other parameter of bone strength, i.e. CSA. that tea consumption was related to the better performance in
Our data suggested that tea drinking could maintain the physical function. In addition, a 6-month randomised placebo-
cortical stability and strength of bone. BR is the relative controlled trial conducted in postmenopausal osteoporotic
thickness of the narrow neck cortex and is an estimate of the women suggested that the polyphenols in tea could improve leg
cortical stability in buckling. Gnudi et al. evaluated the ability strength (28). These studies indirectly support the role of tea in
of bone structural parameters measured at the FN, i.e. CSA, Z promoting the stability and strength of bone.
and BR, to predict the risk of hip fracture. They found that BR The positive association between tea drinking and BMD at
was the best predictor, and its ability to predict fracture risk the hip was also observed in this study. This was consistent
was equal to that of FN BMD (25). In the present study, the with the findings in previous studies conducted in both Chinese
tea drinkers had lower BR than the non-tea drinkers. BR was and other populations (15). Hegarty et al (29) carried out
219
J Nutr Health Aging
Volume 22, Number 2, 2018
a cross-section study in 1,256 Britain women aged 65-76 EGCG was shown to reduce the levels of excessive reactive
years. They observed that BMD in tea drinkers was around oxygen species, increase the activity of alkaline phosphatase,
3.0% greater than those who did not drink tea. A study in and up-regulate the expression of runt-related transcription
Taiwanese found that tea drinkers had an increased BMD factor 2 through the bone morphogenetic protein 2 signalling
than non-tea drinkers at the total body, hip regions and pathway, thus promoting the proliferation of osteoblasts and
lumbar spine, especially in tea drinkers with a larger quantity formation of bone (32). The chemical constituents differ for
of tea consumption (30). In this study, we also identified different types of tea with varied levels of fermentation (33).
the significant and positive trend of BMD with total tea The amount of EGCG was found to be much lower in other
consumption over the past year. In addition, a prospective types of tea than in green tea (34). Theaflavins and thearubigins
analysis in 1,027 Australian women found that after a 4-year are the representative substances in black tea. Recently, Das
follow-up, tea drinkers lost about 1.6% hip BMD, but non- et al (35) observed that the extract of black tea could protect
tea drinkers lost approximately 4.0% (31). All these results against ovariectomy-induced oxidative stress of mononuclear
supported that tea consumption was favorable for bone mass. cells and its associated progression of bone loss by reducing
the activated osteoclasts. In addition, studies also found that the
Figure 1 bioactive substances in oolong tea or Pu-er tea had the strong
The relative values of bone phenotypes of each subgroup of (a) antioxidative effects and the scavenging capacity of free radical
total tea consumption or (b) times of tea drinking per week to (36, 37).
the reference group The findings in this study might be generalisable to ordinary
urban middle-aged and elderly women in southern China. The
results were obtained from a considerable sample size of 1,495
women recruited from communities in Guangzhou city, with
consideration given to a relatively large range of confounding
factors and with good assessments of bone phenotypes.
Nonetheless, there were also several limitations. This study
only investigated the tea drinking habits of subjects over the
past year, which might not accurately reflect their long-term
habits of tea drinking. However, tea drinking is generally a
relatively stable habit, and Guangzhou is a city with a very
long history of tea culture and with a large proportion of tea
drinkers. Approximately half of the studied subjects were tea
drinkers, and the times of tea drinking per week and the total tea
consumption over the past year were highly correlated (r = 0.94,
p < 0.001). Thus, the present data might reflect the long-term
habits of tea drinking to some extent. Finally, this was a cross-
sectional study, and thus the findings cannot establish temporal
relationships or causality. A future longitudinal analysis of the
effects of tea consumption on bone strength will be of interest
when the ongoing cohort study is completed.
In summary, this study suggested a protective effect of tea
drinking on both bone mass and geometric structure in middle-
aged and elderly Chinese women. As tea is a traditional and
Vertical bars were the percentage differences of each sub-group relative to the group of popular beverage in China, its role in bone health merits further
total tea consumption < 1.0 kg (a) or times of tea drinking per week ≤ 1 time (b). Error
bars were the standard errors of the mean values. Values were adjusted for age, body mass investigations.
index, years since menopause, physical activities, dietary-protein intake, dietary-calcium
intake, calcium tablet intake, drinking status and smoking status. *p-trend < 0.05. BMD, Acknowledgments: This study was supported by the National Natural Science
bone mineral density; BR, buckling ratio; CSA, cross sectional area; Z, section modulus. Foundation of China (No. 81273049, 81400857), the Natural Science Foundation
of Guangdong Province (No.2014A030313132), and the 5010 Program for Clinical
Researches by Sun Yat-Sen University, Guangzhou, China (No. 2007032). We thank other
The bone-protective effects of tea may be attributed to team members for their contribution in the data collection.
the chemical compounds in it. Animal studies found that a
Conflicts of Interest: The authors declare no conflict of interest.
moderate intake of tea polyphenols could enhance bone strength
and quality (12). Tea catechins, including EGCG, epicatechin- Ethical standards: The experiments comply with the current laws of China in which
3-gallate, epigallocatechin and epicatechin, are the main they were performed. The protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of the School of
Public Health of Sun Yat-Sen University.
components in tea polyphenols. These substances can benefit
bone via their antioxidant activities and their capability to
scavenge reactive oxygen species (12). As a potent antioxidant,
220
J Nutr Health Aging
Volume 22, Number 2, 2018
221