Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Historical Development of Stylistics
Historical Development of Stylistics
Historical Development of Stylistics
autonomous domain on its own, but it can be applied to an understanding of literature and
journalism as well as linguistics. Sources of study in stylistics may range from canonical
works of writing to popular texts, and from advertising copy to news, non-fiction, and
explaining particular choices made by individuals and social groups in their use of language,
such as in the literary production and reception of genre, the study of folk art, in the study of
spoken dialects and registers, and can be applied to areas such as discourse analysis as well as
literary criticism.
Common features of style include the use of dialogue, including regional accents and
individual dialects (or ideolects), the use of grammar, such as the observation of active voice
and passive voice, the distribution of sentence lengths, the use of particular language
registers, and so on. In addition, stylistics is a distinctive term that may be used to determine
the connections between the form and effects within a particular variety of language.
Therefore, stylistics looks at what is 'going on' within the language; what the linguistic
Stylistics has have a very unique history and development over the years. We should
1
1 Formalism Stylistics
Formalism which was originally the name of a Russian art and literary movement
before the first world war started in the16th century. And then it became used by
Bolsheviks(soviets) for any kind of art that was for its own sake where we got the valid
It began in two groups:OPOYAZ, an acronym for Russian words meaning society for
the study of poetic language founded in 1916 at st. Petersburg (later Leningrad) and led by
Viktor Shklovsky; and the moscow linguistic cicle founded in 1915. Other members includes
Osip Brik, Boris Eikhenbaum, Yury Tynianov and Boris Tomashevsky. Other notable leading
figures noted for formalist approach were Heinrich Wolfflin(1864-1945) And Henri
Focillon(1881-1943)
Although the formalist based their assumptions partly on the linguistic theory of
Ferdinard de saussure and partly on symbolist notions concerning the autonomy of the text
and the discontinuity between literary and other uses of language, the formalist sought to
make their critical discourse more objective and scientific than that of symbolist criticism.
Taking forward the ideas of the Russian Formalists, the Prague School built on the
apart from non-literary background language, by means of deviation (from the norms of
background language isn't constant, and the relationship between poetic and everyday
Roman Jakobson has been an active member of the Russian formalists and the Prague
school before emigrating to America in the 1940's. In 1960, Jakobson's lecture was credited
for being the first coherent formulation of stylistics, and his argument was that the study of
2
In 1940, American art critic, Clement Greenberg, in an influential piece in Partisan
Review, argued that the value of art was located in its form, which is inseperable from its
content.
1) The importance of form and technique were stressed over content and the specificity of
2) Emphasis were placed on the medium by analyzing the way in which literature was
able to alter artistically common language so that everyday world could be defamiliarized.
3) The formalist studied the various functions of "literariness" as ways of seperate poetry
4) The formalist school assigns a central role to textual features of the poetic text i.e. The
and composition, and putting these together to analyse artistic style rather than iconography
2. Structuralist Stylistics
Stylistics arose out of a structuralist desire to be able to use the newly emerging
science of mordern linguistic as a descriptive tool. For literature, the discipline took on
dinstinct identity in the 1950's'and 1960's, though it could trace its root and ancestors back of
the Russian formalists of 1920's'and further back through the practice of Rhetoric and ancient
academic study.
The work of Ferdinand de saussure concerning linguistics is generally considerd a starting
point of 20th century structuralism. Evidence of this can be found in course in General
linguistics, written by saussure's'collegues after his death and based on students note, where
3
he focused not on the use of language(parole)but rather on the underlying system of
The term 'structuralism' itself appeared in the works of french antropologist Claude L`evi-
Strauss, and gave rise to the structuarlist movement in france, which spurred the work of
thinkers like Michel Faucault, Louis Althusser, the psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan as well as
Gradually, the limiting structuralist approach gave way in the 1970's and 80's to an interset
2) Structural analyst equalize all texts by reducing them to the same underlying universal
system. This system was articulated through the vocabulary of classical structural linguistics.
3) Applying structuralist methodologies to individual literary works and genres, Tzventan
Todorov claimed that narrative fiction can be studied on 3 levels: the semantic, syntactic and
the rhetorical.
4) European Structuralist argue that 'real' art was expressive only of a thing's ontological,
5)Structuralist focused on how the creation of art communicates the idea behind the art.
communication.
7) Structuralism's focus on the grammar of art reaches as far back as the work of marcel
Dunchamp. In many ways, structuralism draws on the tools of formalism without adopting
4
8)Structuralism is a theoretical paradigm in sociology, anthropology,linguistics and
3 Generative Stylistics
It was prominent in 1960s. It has to do with Chomsky’s theory of syntax. Noam Chomsky is
the source of generative grammar where he explains deep and surface structure. Generative
4 Affective Stylistics
Stanley fish is one of the foremost propounders of this theory. It was attracted by the
text.
In affective stylistics, the focus of attention is shifted from the spatial context of a
page and its observable regularities to the temporal context of a mind and its experience, that
is, a transfer of power from the text to the reader. Stylistics itself was born of a reaction to the
scientific basis.
Affective stylistics is not similar to impressionism but rather a precision because the
characteristics of language will be used exactly to specify what a reader, as he comes upon
Affective stylistics propose interpretative acts are what is being described; they rather
them verbal patterns arranging themselves in space, are the content of the analysis. Hence,
since the readers job is to extract the meanings that formal partterns possess prior to and
It was developed in 1960 by Katie Wales. Computational stylistics uses statistical and
computer-aided methods in the development of stylist5ics. It is used for large samples of data
6 Stylometric Stylistics
It focuses on an author with a distinctive style and often characterize thye style by
comparing the author’s text to those of other authors. It has to do with numerical quantitative
data in stylistics analysis. Features such as collocation, word length and sentence length in
different authorship are the basis of stylometric stylistics. It is related to corpus stylistics.
7 Expressive Stylistics
focuses on style as purely the representation of the personality of the author while affective is
reader/hearer that is reading or listening to a text. It deals with the style of expressiong one’s
8. Pedagogical stylistics
Pedagogical stylistics is a field that looks at employing stylistic analysis in teaching, with the
aim of enabling students to better understand literature, language and also improving their
language acquisition. It is also concerned with the best practice in teaching stylistics
6
Since the 1950s, pedagogical stylistics has been intrinsically linked with the teaching of
written texts (and especially literary texts) to speakers of English as a second language.
Pedagogical stylistics is a field that looks at employing stylistic analysis in teaching, with the
aim of enabling students to better understand literature, language and also improving their
language acquisition. It is also concerned with the best practice in teaching stylistics. It is
concerned with how various linguistic choices affect interpretation and thus help students to
move from working with language on the sentence level to dealing with longer, more
complex stretches of discourse and to encourage their awareness of the intersections between
1. It is concerned with the formal properties of a text; that is, analyzing the words on a
page, drawing in the main upon linguistic theory. This includes not only analysis
of phonology, vocabulary or lexis, syntax of phrases and clauses, but also analysis
of discourse, as in examining.
2. This shows that texts and their readers do not exist in isolation, but function with a
wider social and cultural context. Account has to be taken of contextual factors such
3. The knowledge gained from the study of pedagogical stylistics will help students in
9 Discourse Stylistics
Discourse stylistics was popular in 1980. It evolves round language in use. It includes
use in a social context, where discourse analysis should reveal as much about the contexts as
7
about the text.’ ‘Discourse stylistics at its best will necessarily be a thoroughgoing
In carrying out discourse stylistics, the following must be considered; the language in
use; Conversation analysis; Speech Acts; Co-operative principles; The analysis of language
in a social context, political, religious, cultural contexts; Discourse analysis relies on a wide
range of disciplines.
10 Radical Stylistics
It was coined by Burton in 1982. This type of stylistics does a critical search for the
ideological imprint of the text that goes beyond the text level into social and historical forces
11 COGNITIVE STYLISTICS
Cognitive stylistics combines the kind of explicit rigorous and detailed linguistic
analysis of literary texts that is typical of the stylistics tradition with a systematic and
theoretically informed consideration of the cognitive structures and processes that underlie
the production and reception of language (Semino and Culpeper 2003). Cognitive stylistics
analyses an author idiolect , his individual language traits.It deals with how we mentally
There is what is known as "readers -response" stylistics , this type was stemmed from
the strand of modern "subjective" criticism also known as the German School of Criticism as
a reception aesthetics.
8
Richard L.I and Willian Empson steered the critics of text, rather than considering the
author of such a text. This development is a departure from the Romantic conception of the
author as being totally responsible for whatever meaning that one as a reader may encounter
1. Cognitive stylistics underscores how every utterance is stamped with signs of its
2. Its concern with the cognitive elements involved in comprehending and processing
text.
3. There is an interaction between the structure of the text and the reader's response
Thus, the reader becomes an active part of the text .It evokes a situation where
b. Readers do not passively censure the meaning presented to them by a literary text.
12 Feminist Stylistics
studies and literary criticism. One of the earlier proponents of feminism who had put their
talents and ideologies into writing, particularly, as a patron of equality to women is Virginia
Woof. At the turn of 20th century, many of her works depicted her strict criticism on how the
For Woolf, certain women writers crafted a new type of sentence which is looser and
more accretive than the male sentence. Virginia Woolf asserted that there was a sentence
9
which women writers had developed which she termed the “female sentence” or the sentence
of the feminine gender. This led to a long standing debate between literary analysts over
years whether female writers produce text which is significantly different from the language
Sara Mills (1995), Simpson (1942), Annette Kolodny (1975) and Deirdre Burton
(1982) are the important figures in the area of feminist stylistics. With the advent of feminism
and critical stylistics in the late 1970s and early 1980s, feminist stylistics established itself as
relation to Feminist Stylistics published by Sarah Mills, in this book, Mills defines feminist
stylistics as an analysis which identifies itself as feminist and which uses linguistic or
language analysis to examine texts” (Mills. 1995:1). Sara Mills opens up the study of style to
feminist inquiry.
Combining insights from literary and linguistic theory, she provides a rationale for the
interrogation of texts from a feminist perspective through an examination of both literary and
non-literary texts. It is also said that feminist stylistics focuses on the solution to two
questions: why authors have chosen certain ways to express their ideas on gender issues and
how certain effects related to the two sexes are achieved through language. The label
‘feminist stylistics’ should be properly credited to Mill (1995) because, although she was not
the first stylistician to implement a feminist stylistics perspective, she was nonetheless the
one who coined the term and described more fully the practices of the sub branch
1. The model of analysis proposed by feminist stylistics takes two major aspects into
account: the production and the reception of the text. The former is dependent upon
conventions, affiliations in point of gender, race, class, nation and, last but not least,
women‟s and men‟s writings. These occur in thematic, lexical, grammatical and
graphological features. Women writers and characters are more likely to court
female writers to modify traditional modes of language use –by identifying the
dialectical features as well as the alternative forms of expression in a text. Sarah Mills
4. Feminist stylistics achieves its goals through close linguistic scrutiny and the
explication of linguistic theory to set out the rationale for feminist textual analysis.
13 Forensic Stylistics
Is the application of stylistics to crime retection. Through the analysis of language use
at the different levels of language description. It is possible to determine the author of a text ,
this may also be applied to confessional statement to the police. Issues like voice
14. Pscycho-Stylistics
This is also known as neuro stylistics. The mind of the writer and his or the
personality should be considered in analyzing texts. The features of psycho stylistics include
The use of personal pronouns such as I, me, mine, etc which reflect the writer’s involvement
in the text. Psycho Stylistics applies Psycho linguistic research to the study of literary
11
effects. So van Peer (1986) studies foregrounding from his perspective. In other studies, for
example, the salience of particular devices such as rhyme, metaphor and imagery is related
15 Critical Stylistics
Critical stylistics is mainly based on social and political factors in which texts are produced
and read. Stylistics provides detailed tools of analysis for understanding how texts work.
Proponents
It was proposed by Roger Fowler and his colleagues at the University of East Anglia. In
Fowler et al (1979), it draws heavily on systemic grammar for a tool kit and it is precisely
concerned to analyse critically the inseparable relationship between language and social
meanings.
The sociology and political ideology, context, participant, coherence and cohesion.
16 Functional Sylistictics
There is always an advance in the latter inevitably impacts on the former.It was in the 1970s,
there was stylistics movement into the areas of language teaching and pedagogical stylistics.
Halliday's work on systemic functional grammar related form to function within the context
of language system as a whole and has particular influence on the study of prose fiction.
12
References
Clark, U. and Zyngier, S. (1998). Women beware women: detective fiction and critical
Simpson, P (1993) Language, Ideology and Point of View. London and New York:
Routledge.
13