Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Group 03 EE&PS Project
Group 03 EE&PS Project
Environmental Engineering
Submitted to:
Submitted by:
Group 03
2019-PE-12
2019-PE-23
2019-PE-25
2019-PE-29
1
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
2
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
ABSTRACT
In this project, the problems of solid waste disposal have discussed. With the increasing
population, waste is also increasing day by day. We also discussed about how Karachi is affected
by this waste and its result in the form of air pollution, water pollution, soil erosion etc.
According to survey at household level, the waste generation of high income class has Greater
than the middle and low income class. Waste generation on Sunday are higher than the other
working days because all family members at home. In higher income class, the composition of
recycle waste is higher on working days. But the composition of food remains constant
throughout the week. Solid waste at fruit and vegetables market level, the waste generation of
middle class income has higher than the high and low income. Average waste generation was
found to the highest on weekend because the sale of vegetable and fruit is high due to greater
consumer demand.
Table of Contents
ABSTRACT................................................................................................................................................3
3
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
Table of Contents........................................................................................................................................4
1 INTRODUCTION...............................................................................................................................5
1.1 Waste...........................................................................................................................................5
1.2 Solid waste...................................................................................................................................5
1.3 Types of solid waste....................................................................................................................5
1.4 Solid waste disposal.....................................................................................................................6
1.5 Solid waste disposal in Karachi...................................................................................................7
1.6 Problems occur due to Solid waste in Karachi.............................................................................8
1.6.1 Air pollution:.......................................................................................................................8
1.6.2 Water pollution....................................................................................................................8
1.6.3 Soil Pollution.......................................................................................................................9
2 Literature Review:...............................................................................................................................9
2.1 During 1947 to 1967:...................................................................................................................9
2.2 During 1968 to 1988:.................................................................................................................10
2.3 During 1989 to 2009:.................................................................................................................11
2.4 During 2010 to 2018:.................................................................................................................11
3 METHDOLOGY AND FINDINGS..................................................................................................12
3.1 Household Level Survey:...........................................................................................................12
3.1.1 Household Level Waste Generation and Composition:......................................................13
3.1.2 Solid Waste Management at Household Level:..................................................................13
3.2 City Vegetable and Fruit Market Level Waste Generation and Composition:...........................18
3.2.1 Solid Waste Management at Fruit and Vegetable Market Level:.......................................18
3.3 Commercial level survey...........................................................................................................21
3.3.1 Commercial level waste generation:..................................................................................21
3.3.2 Market chain analysis:.......................................................................................................21
3.3.3 Municipal services:............................................................................................................21
3.3.4 Data compilation:...............................................................................................................21
3.3.5 Existing Solid Waste Management System:.......................................................................22
3.3.6 Waste Management at commercial level:...........................................................................23
4 Recommendation:..............................................................................................................................25
5 REFERENCE....................................................................................................................................26
4
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 Waste
Waste is the unusable and unwanted materials present in the environment.
For example, hazardous waste, waste water and radioactive waste etc. are included in waste.
that are disposed of as undesirable and futile. Mechanical, private and business exercises are
main source of production of solid waste. Solid waste includes nonhazardous institution and
industrial waste, street sweeping, agricultural waste sludge, commercial refuse, water treatment
Industrial/Commercial waste
Used oil
Waste tries
5
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
management. It gives solutions for reusing the things that don’t have place with trash or garbage.
How solid waste can be utilized as an important asset and can be recycled can be depicted by
who live in the trash as well as residents who are responsible. Karachi with a center populace of
6
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
13 million and another 4 million living around it is Pakistan’s most populated city and 20 th most
populates metropolitan on the planet. It has consistently battled to keep its road clean. No solid
information exists on the specific measure of trash produced, however authorities quote a figure
One of the serious issue which influence the administration of strong waste, however
aggregate of 19 government, corporate area interest, common and neighborhood and land-
claiming offices, worldwide, military cantonments control lots of city and formal and casual
designers of the city. Nobody substance has civil authority over whole city [3].
Because of the absence of technical and financial resources, the districts in creating nations
neglect to oversee strong squanders in a protected and feasible manner. This raises the significant
issue of how to convey quality assistance not withdrawing monetary and ability limitations of the
public area. Roughly 9000 tons of solid waste is produced every day in Karachi. Industrial states
and new housing sectors quick establishment, development action and variety of institutions
contribute to waste generation. With the rapid growth of economic and population activity, the
Lack of planning, poor management and inappropriate technology are main areas of concern, it
On the other hand transportation and solid waste collection management existing in Karachi is
not good. There is an absence of long haul plans, therefore in various incoherent, impromptu and
foundation development has been lingered behind by the monetary turn of events, which
7
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
becomes the jug neck to ruin the quicker and better improvements of civil economy. Squander
assortment, removal and transport just as road sweeping duty lie with the city authorities.
Air pollution
Water pollution
Soil pollution
the ground and very high. Methane is a powerful ozone depleting substance and would it be able
to be in a risk since it is combustible and conceivably unstable. Carbon dioxide is the most
It causes serious environmental issues e.g. land and water pollution, infection diseases, loss of
Different strategies are drilled to control solid waste condemnation as treating the soil, reusing,
cremation, pyrolysis, removal, landfills etc. Uncollected solid waste can likewise discourage
storm water overflow, bringing about the shaping of stable water bodies that become the
favorable place of sickness. Squander unloaded almost a water source additionally causes of
8
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
is the main cause of soil pollution. The permeability of the soil formation below the waste can
2 Literature Review:
The neat and clean city represents the behavior of people living in that city. As beautiful city is
the one which is physically attracts the people from its cleanliness, nature, buildings, smooth
roads, pollution free air etc. One of the main causes of ugliness of a city is its solid waste and the
problems caused by this solid waste disposal. Here we will discuss that how solid waste disposal
Pakistan. Karachi is the largest city of Pakistan and it is the main area where people came and
settled. It was the capital of state that’s why large people attracted there for education, business,
offices, labor force etc. The population which was 435887 in 1941 before migration then it was
increased to 1064557 in 1951. It was a biggest change of amount in 10 years. The again in 1958,
many people migrate from India due to disbanded for being deserters. But at that time Karachi
was not the capital so not many people were attracted there.
In those early years, solid waste disposal management was neglected and the garbage collected
by municipal commission was thrown at open areas. Later on, Karachi was affected greatly. A
plan made in 1952 for the structure and societies of Karachi but waste disposal management was
still not under consideration, which caused great problems later on in the near future. Thus, at the
9
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
start when nobody consider the management of solid waste disposal and it was increased day by
day due to increasing population, now we can clearly see their effects.
Afghanistan Refugees
Those two situations again were the cause of increasing population. Increasing population with
lack of residences increased solid waste. But there was no management to dispose of this solid
waste. Later on in 1986, Mayor of city Abdul Sattar Afghani and his team drafted a Karachi Plan
2000. This plan was the initiative step towards proper treatment of solid waste. According to this
plan, in 1988, Mayor of city developed a Solid Waste Management department in KMC (Karachi
Financial allocations
Drafting
Due to the rejection of Karachi Plan 1974 at that time and the large crowd of population was
accepted. There was no suitable plan of solid waste disposal management till 1985. Those were
the main cause of poor condition of Karachi. Due to which, air pollution, soil erosion and water
10
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
waste system become weaken. On open roadsides, empty lands and in sewage, heaps of solid
waste had been found. This generation marked each the disruption and the improvement of
Then in 1995, one agency of Japan called Japanese International Coordination Agency (JICA)
contributed in Karachi solid waste management program, but due to some reasons, it could not
settle. The landfills, Gonad pass and Jam Chakhro, both are existing today. They were identified
by World Bank at the site of Surjani. A contract was signed with Chinese Corporation in 1997-
98 for door-to-door garbage collection, land filling, and developing of Garbage transfer Stations
(GTS). But later on, this agreement was also cancelled due to the lack of resources and
machines. Waste was increasing with increasing population, but the situation of management
was good than previous years in 21st century. Furthermore, the solid waste was burnt at that time
management and the responsibility of disposal management was done by City District
Government Karachi (CDGK). In those years, due to the fast increase of fast-food restaurants,
Sindh waste management board was established under the Sindh Act. No. 4 in 2014. They were
responsible for all the areas that were lie under KMC. Now Karachi has 12 GTS stations
according to Sindh Waste Management Board (SSWMB). Some of them are as following;
Other 4 GTS were mapped out to be scientific so that by using anaerobic bacteria they can
produce electricity in near future. This plan was quite affective almost 80% of waste was
collected and lifted from grounds and dumped into landfills. But 74.8% population is not
satisfied with this disposal method of government, because burning of solid waste causes air
Instead, we have done an online survey. So, the online survey for commercially disposal of solid
three different classes (low, middle, and high-income classes) of Karachi. For the survey, sixty
houses are choice for each class. Various zones were choice to obtain samples; the zones were
selected, according to the size of the home, the income, and the locality.
12
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
income classes to calculate the waste generation and composition at the household level.
Samples were taken daily from choice areas and transported for inspection. Samples were stored
in selected area. The sixty samples were weighted and daily waste production per capita was
calculated as the ratio between the total weight and household size. Twenty-five random samples
were taken each day in each class to test the composition of solid waste. To calculate the
composition of waste samples, these samples are divided into the following parts food waste,
the help of workers. Teams for collection of waste took less time to collect the waste in the low-
13
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
a)
b)
Figure 01: Waste Sample collection from (a) low, (b) middle and (c) high income region.
Waste collection was relatively challenging in high-income regions. To study solid waste,
Labeled garbage collection bags were provided to independent households, which agreed to
participate in the study. A personal vehicle has been rented for transport and inspection of
household samples.
14
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
that the average per capita waste generation ware varied with each class. The average for low,
middle, and high incomes was 0.19, 0.29, and 0.84, respectively. Waste produced in low-income
regions ranged from 0.087 to 0.59 kg/c/d. The level of the population in low, middle, and high-
income class amounts to 60%, 30%, and 10% individually. The average production rate of
household waste as a function of the weighted average is 2351 tones, 1793 tones, and 1731 tones
for the low, middle, and high-income classes, respectively. The density of solid waste generated
by the low-income class was 125; the middle-income class was 140 while the high-income class
was 180kg/m3. The density of waste of the high class is more than the low income and middle-
income class.
Per capita waste was found to be higher in high-income regions than in middle-income and low-
income regions. Due to their living standards, the per capita was higher as compared to other
classes. So that’s why the per capita of waste generation of the high-income class is 4.4 percent
is greater than the low-income class and 2.9 percent is greater than the middle-income class.
15
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
Food waste, including vegetable and fruit waste, is found to be higher in low-income classes on
Sundays (holidays) than on Fridays (working days). Because on Sunday, all family members at
home while on Friday, there are on workplaces and the compositions of recyclable are higher on
weekdays than a weekend. As food waste happening in the low-income class, the same is with
Friday Sunday
16
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
In high-income classes, the Composition of recycling waste was higher on working days but the
composition of food waste constant throughout the week. The percent of food waste is highest
among the three classes, ranging from 36.1% to 45.7%. The extent of food waste was most
elevated in the middle-income class and least in high-income class samples. Low-income class
tests additionally contained grass and wood waste, because they save the goats and sheep for
their livelihood.
Of the recyclables, the plastic substance is most noteworthy, while the leather, metal, and glass
content are exceptionally small. Families are isolating themselves from the source and selling
these important things. Paper and material items are not isolated at the source.
17
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
3.2 City Vegetable and Fruit Market Level Waste Generation and Composition:
To calculate the waste generation sixty samples were collected and these samples were collected
for eight consecutive days from a different shop and main market of Karachi. Twenty-five
samples were taken each day to analyze the composition of solid waste[7].
Waste collection teams start early in the morning to collect the samples of waste food at the main
superhighway market consisting of sweepers and helpers. The decision was made to collect the
waste from these workshops at the end of the afternoon to represent the actual solid waste
production figures for each shop. To study solid waste, Labeled garbage collection bags were
provided to independent shops, which agreed to participate in the study, and private transport
available for transporting the waste to the selected place where inspection of samples takes place.
After waste collection, samples were analyzed to determine waste generation and composition.
different shops. The waste generation per shop was 11.77kg/shop/day. The majority portion of
18
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
this waste is organic and the total amount of waste production is 47.08 tons/day. Average waste
generated was found to be the highest on weekends because the sale of vegetables and fruit is
high due to greater consumer demand. But we observed that on Tuesday minimum waste
After collecting all sixty samples of vegetable and fruit market waste, twenty-five samples were
selected for analyzes of the composition of waste. From recording, we have observed the lowest
generation of waste on Tuesdays and the highest generation of waste on Saturdays. But the food
waste was highest on both days and the majority composition of food waste was of origin.
Tuesday Saturday
19
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
banks, restaurants, general stores, offices, mart, & travel agents. To know about the waste
website online & promoting extraordinary dealers, marketplace chain evaluation became the use
of participatory appraisal method where communication have been performed and applicable
interviews have been carried out from the important thing personals of related departments with
earlier appointments. There production of the request for facts with the concerned personals is
provided. A list of questions has been organized to advantage facts on contemporary waste
stage for Karachi. The assessment of solid waste specimen collected from the commercial area
20
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
day w.r.t (2005) and about 15.12 million populations were present. However, not actual current
facts are get table associated with the waste generation; because of this the facts for (2012) have
extrapolated the use of the presentation available accurate facts. The assumed solid waste
creation is 12,280 tons that is 0.595 kg/c/d for a present population of 20. 61 million with a
With respect to CDGK (City District Government Karachi), solid waste of about 80% of town is
controlled with a novice group of workers of CDGK; also the ultimate 20% of the solid decay is
controlled by Defense Housing Authority and Cantonment Boards. With respect to Master Plan
2020, the CDGK gathers 84% of the overall produced waste and shipping to detailed treated
These sites had been designed as right landfill sites however at the moment are being treated like
dumping sites. The allotted region for each& every turned into 5 hundred acres, but due to
assault by land mafia, much little2 hundred acres is attainable for solid waste control. CDGK
21
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
gathers solid waste from 4085 particular Kundi, the use of five hundred and sixty seven (567)
cars the waste carried to the above landfill sites. With respect to Karachi Master Plan 2020,
almost 50% of the overall waste produced is gathered with aid of using the town domestic
services department having lifter, garbage lot, loader, and tractor trollies. The ultimate waste is
dumped of on streets, ducts (pipes), and open spaces. 11,843 groups of workers are hired for
wastage series whilst 11,974 groups of workers are hired in wastage control in whole. It is
expected that the fair (charges) of solid wastage series and conveying from numerous places of
town is about Rs.294/ton. Now, resource accretion and the 3R method aren’t practiced formally.
However, the maximum aid accretion is achieved by casual areas. In specific, teenage Wala and
junkyard stores are main players with inside the accretion process.
helpers. It becomes observed that maximum of gathering taken place in the past due12 in the
noon, as the industrial sports begins off evolved in the afternoon. The waste collection becomes
relatively hard in business regions to analyze with households. Huge classes of business
organizations like: bank, tour advisors, academic places, grocery stores, offices, mobile phones
shop, and shopping mart. Garbage gather luggage with chits had been furnished to independent
grocery shop, agreed to take parting this case. This workout facilitated in study of solid waste. A
personal transport becomes employed for conveying the waste for evaluation.
22
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
e
11 Travel agency 0.48 0.06 1.2
22 Grocery store 1 3.78 1.08 9.12
33 Grocery store 2 1.35 0.87 2.2
44 Bank 1 2.43 0.15 4.3
55 Bank 2 3.57 0.50 6.3
66 Mobile shop 0.8 0.45 1.32
77 Educational institution 0.71 0.05 1.1
88 Office 0.99 0.1 1.67
99 Restaurant 2.69 0.74 7.83
110 Mart 1.16 0.43 2.16
Average of all groups 1.795
After gathering of waste was done, samples were studied for waste production which is
discussed below:
was noted. The waste evaluation confirmed that common in step with business institution waste
generation changed into 1.795 kg/d/shop. The minimal waste production is from tour agents even
as most was from grocery store It was noted that waste produced from tour organization was low
even as from general store was maximum. Many of the tour businesses now conduct e-tickets
and this could be purpose of his or her quantity of low waste production. The maximum waste
production was discovered from general store, like this kind of business institution offers
discovered that very best waste production changed into at some point of last days (Saturday and
23
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
4 Recommendation:
Currently landfill areas are available for solid waste management. The vicinity available
for those it isn't good enough to meet the land filling of waste produced within the city.
Moreover, those areas have positioned a way and it isn't economically feasible to convey
waste through big distances. There is need to increase new landfill areas.
problems.
1. Introducing skips.
Source estimation needs to follow thereby presenting bins used for natural fraction and
gathering. This will help recycling industries and improvement in center for bio-fertilizer
manufacturing.
24
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
system.
Organic fraction of domestic solid waste from family, fruit & vegetable marketplace may
5 REFERENCE
1. An Introduction to Solid Waste Management. 2021; Available from:
b) https://www.thebalancesmb.com/an-introduction-to-solid-waste-management-2878102.
3. A portrait of Karachi's garbage crisis. July 12, 2021 July 12, 2021; Available from:
https://www.thethirdpole.net/en/pollution/a-portrait-of-karachis-garbage-crisis/.
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00022470.1976.10470229#:~:text=The
%20revised%20data%20show%20that,presented%20in%20widely%20published
%20data.&text=The%20revised%20data%20show%20that%20the%20contribution
%20of%20solid%20waste,4.5%25%20originally%20reported%20by%20Walther.
5. Land Pollution: Causes, Effects, and Prevention: TDS. 2021; Available from:
https://www.texasdisposal.com/blog/land-pollution/.
6. Evaluation of Municipal Solid Wastes Based Energy Potential in Urban Pakistan. 2019;
25
Environmental Engineering and Processing Group 3
26