Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2008-05-11 Potential of Geothermal System in Syria
2008-05-11 Potential of Geothermal System in Syria
March 2008
1. INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 3
1.1. Background .................................................................................................................... 3
1.2. Problem .......................................................................................................................... 4
1.3. Solution........................................................................................................................... 5
1.4. Objective......................................................................................................................... 6
1.5. Theory............................................................................................................................. 6
5. Conclusion........................................................................................................................ 19
6. REFERENCES................................................................................................................. 21
2
2/22
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1. Background
The global energy consumption is 1.3.1011 MWh/year, partly covered by a daily oil
consumption of 82.6 Mbbl (2004 est.)1. The CO2 emission, which is supposed to play a
leading role in global warming, is about 2.65 ton-CO2/m3 of oil2, which means that oil
alone results in an annual emission of 1.25.1010 tons of CO2. Global oil production peaked
more than two years ago3-4. Since there is no possibility to increase the global oil
Space heating/cooling systems consume about 30% of global energy consumption5 (oil,
gas, coal etc.), i.e. 3.9.1010 MWh/year corresponding to emission of 2.9.1010 tons CO2/year.
Countries used to export energy, here exemplified by Syria, have usually a less efficient
energy system. Reduced oil production and increased oil consumption will call for a
changed energy policy. The Syrian oil production, which has declined from 600.103 bbl/d
3
3/22
After 1996, when the Syrian oil production peaked8, the oil consumption increased steadily
25% during 6 years, while the oil production decreased in the same ratio. In 2011 the
development. In this regard, more efficient use of energy and increased use of renewable
energy (RERs) appear to be the most efficient and effective solutions9,10. However, the
problem is that most types of renewable energy are available when the demand is low11.
One example is that the summer heat is available during the warm season, when heating
demand is low, and winter cold is available when the cooling demand is low.
Ground source heat pump (GSHP) systems (incl. underground thermal energy storage) are
the most energy efficient and environmentally clean of all the heating and cooling options
Here, we focus on the very important chicken industry in Syria to show how underground
thermal energy storage, UTES, enables a more efficient use of energy and increased use of
renewable energy.
1.2. Problem
Almost 150 000 people work at the 13,000 chicken farms in Syria, which produce 172,000
ton of meat13. The total investment in this important industry is 130 BSP (70 SP = 1 €).
Even though the annual mean temperature in Syria is ~ 15-18oC (figure 5) heating of such
farms, consume considerable amounts of energy. The reason is that the air temperature is
close to freezing during three winter months and that chickens require a relatively high
temperature, 21-35oC, depending on age (Table 2). The estimated total annual heating
demand of these plants is 1170 GWh (Table 3). The conventional heating systems, i.e. coal
furnace, consume 168.103 tons of coal14 assuming an conversion efficiency of 85% and that
4
4/22
the specific heat of coal is 8.141 kWh/kg. The chicken farms have no cooling systems since
conventional cooling is too expensive, though the ambient air temperature could reach
A suitable temperature is important for the chicken growth1, which is ~60% during the
winter and ~45% during the summer. The explanation is that heaters controls the
temperature in the chicken farm during the winter while it is often gets too hot during the
summer. Furthermore, since lots of chicken die from overheating during hot days
1.3. Solution
Ground coupled heat pump systems (GCHP) exploit effectively the heat power of the soil15.
It can be used anywhere in the world to save energy and environment16 and presently more
than one million systems are in operation in US and Europe, mainly in Sweden, Germany
and Switzerland. From an economical point of view, low operating and maintenance cost
mean that these systems generally have attractive life-cycle costs. The construction cost of
the ground heat exchangers (GHE) is critical for the economical competitiveness of GCHP
Despite Syrian local conditions in many ways are more favorable than Sweden, such
systems do not exist in Syria. Using the ground as a heat source means a sustainable and
less expensive heating of the chicken farms. During the summer the resulting colder ground
can be used as a source for free cooling, i.e. it can be used directly for cooling of the plants
1
A chicken growth of 60% means that the weight increase is 60% of their feed.
5
5/22
1.4. Objective
The objectives of this study were to investigate the applicability and efficiency of ground
increase productivity in chicken farms. The feasibility of GCHP systems was investigated
for a typical farm size from which general conclusions are drawn on its potential in Syria.
1.5. Theory
second law of thermodynamics, the coefficient of performance (COP) of a heat pump cycle
highest COP is obtained when the cycle is reversible (without exergy losses i.e. the
adiabatic operations are isotropic and heat transfer operations are isothermal) and operating
at the Carnot limit, Figure 3. In this case, the COP is a function of the high temperature
6
6/22
1- During winter (heating machine):
Thigh
COPh = T
Thigh − Tlow Thigh Condensation temperature
100 C
Figure 4Error! Reference source not found. shows the theoretical COP for heating and
cooling machines.
The relatively stable ground temperature means that GCHP systems can operate close to
optimal design temperature. Since the ground temperature equals the annual mean air
7
7/22
temperature it is colder and warmer than air temperature during the summer and winter,
respectively. Therefore, ground source heat pump (GSHP) systems are inherently more
efficient than an air source heat pump (ASHP) system2_19_20. Theoretically, the COP of GSHP
heating systems in Syria will be 190% greater than that of ASHP systems, see figure 4.
During recent decades, Syria experienced a significant raise in meat prices. This led to
increased poultry production, which has a relatively low price because of its short
production cycle and efficient “feed to meat” conversion. Syria’s moderate climate
contributed to the prosperity and fast growth of this industry. In less than 30 years, Syria
4. Annual energy consumption for heating: 1170 GWh corresponding 168000 tons coal.
6. Most chicken houses are located in western Syria (figure 5) where ground temperature
The Kharseh chicken farm in Hama, Syria, (Figure 5) was selected as a study case for a
8
8/22
Reasonable assumptions were made for e.g. the thermal properties of the ground. In a
planned and more detailed study, these ground properties will be determined by situ
3.1. Climate
3.1.1. Temperature
The region of this study is semi-dry with prevailing west winds and an annual mean
9
9/22
Table 1. Climate properties of farm region
Month Mean Air 10 y Min Air 10 y Max Air Daily Min Daily Max Rel Wind Irradiation
Temperature Temperature Temperature Temperature Temperature humidity direction
Ta (oC) Ta, min (oC) Ta, max (oC) Ta,dmin (oC) Ta,dmax (oC) RH (%) (kWh/m2)
Jan 6.6 -3.4 17.2 2.3 10.8 88 78 72
Feb 8.3 -2.6 17.5 2.8 13.4 74 78 93
Mar 11.6 0.1 25.1 5.8 17.2 67 213 148
Apr 15.9 3.5 30.7 8.9 21.8 60 213 186
May 21.1 7.6 33.8 13.2 28.1 47 213 229
Jun 25.8 14.2 37.9 17.7 32.4 40 213 250
Jul 28.2 16.9 40.2 20.7 34.8 41 213 258
Aug 27.9 17.7 38.9 20.5 34.5 44 213 232
Sep 25.3 13.5 36.1 17.6 31.9 47 213 191
Oct 19.3 7.1 34.2 12.4 26.0 58 213 143
Nov 12.7 0.1 25.8 6.4 18.3 65 213 101
Dec 7.9 -0.9 18.7 3.6 12.1 87 78 70
The most important condition, in using the ground as a source of heat and cold, is a climate
with seasonal temperature variation - the greater is better23. Figure 6 & 7 show the annual
and daily temperature variations, respectively. It shows that the diurnal air temperature
difference is appropriate for short-term heat storage for both heating and cooling.
Temperature variation
32 36
30 35
out side air
28 34 t emper at ur e
26 33
32
24 ground
31 t emperat ure
22
30 at 0.3 ground
temperature
tem p eratu re
20 t emperat ure
29
at 0.58 m
18 28
16 1 31 61 91 121 151 181 211 241 271 301 331 361
27 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
14 26
12 25
24
10 air temperature
2m underground 23
8
4m underground 22
6 8m underground
21
4 20
time tim e, hour
Figure 6. Annual air temperature variation Figure 7. Daily air temperature variation
and ground temperature at different depth and ground temperature at different depth
The seasonal temperature variation in Sweden is favorable for GSHP as underlined by its
300,000 GSHP systems in operation16. Figure 824 shows that the annual temperature
10
10/22
difference in Syria is similar to that in central Sweden, which indicates that also Syria has a
The global mean solar raditaion is shown in Figure 925. It seen that the solar energy, which can
be collected over year in Syria, is about twice as that in central Europe. This means that combined
solar and geothermal systems in Syria have greater economic potential than in Europe.
11
11/22
Figure 9. Mean solar radiation received at ground surface
The length of the hangar is parallel to the main wind direction. Some relevant data are:
¾ During their first day, the chickens occupy about 85 m2 of the building. This area is
increased 14 m2 per day until they occupy the full area after about one month.
¾ Ventilation rate 20 m3/m2,h (ventilated area of chicken farm varies with chicken age)
¾ The capacity of hangar is 5000 chickens (50-55 days each cycle life), with 5 cycles/year,
12
12/22
3.3. Conditions inside chicken house (hangar)
etc.) for the health of the chickens and efficient feed conversion into meat.
The indoor temperature is crucial for the efficiency of chicken growth. If the temperature
gets too high, the chickens die because of overheating, while too low temperature increases
the humidity, which causes diseases like e.g. Kacel and Coccidia. The appropriate indoor
The ventilation of the hangar is important to provide a suitable indoor climate for the birds.
It also expels toxic gases and the excess moisture from birds and spill water. Ventilation
also regulates the hangar temperature, which prevent diseases, especially respiratory ones.
The appropriate relative humidity is 60-65%. Air humidity above 65% increases respiratory
diseases, while humidity below 60% means that dust problems will appear. Dust causes
some respiratory problems and eye infections. A 0.1 m woodchips layer covers the floor. A
most important condition is that the relative humidity of woodchips must be 20–25 %.
For open ventilation system, the hangar must be directed parallel to the prevailing wind
direction, while the direction of hangar is not important for closed ventilation systems. A
suitable ventilation rate is 20 m3/m2,h (ventilated area varies with chicken age).
13
13/22
3.4. Mean heating load
Occurring heat losses from the building is a result of (see figure 10):
¾ Ventilation air.
See
windows.
¾ Solar radiation.
¾ Ventilation air.
Figure 10. Heating/cooling transfer.
¾ Energy released by chickens.
Since the occupied area and heat emissions from the chickens change with time also the
required ventilation, heating and cooling are changed correspondingly. Figure 12 shows the
estimated heating/cooling power as the chickens grow during the hottest and coldest period in
a year. Due to increasing occupation area, which means more heat conduction through a wall
as well as more ventilation air, the required power increases with time for winter and summer.
However, during heating season, the heating power increases with time until it peaks in the
middle of the chickens’ life cycle since the appropriate temperature is lowered with age. This
peak demand does not occur during the cooling season.
Fig. 11. Monthly heating/cooling demand and solar yield Fig. 12. Heating/cooling power as function of chicken age
14
14/22
Figure 12 shows that the required heating and cooling powers are 112 kW and 120 kW,
respectively. The estimated total annual heating demand is 223 MWh while the
cooling and 24 hours of heating are required per a day during summer and winter,
respectively. The 5 cycles/year a 55 days means that the hangar is occupied by chicken
The EED (Earth Energy Design) model26 was used in per-designing required borehole system
• Number of boreholes: 10
• Borehole Diameter: 0.11 m
• Borehole Depth: 120 m
• Drilling Configuration: open rectangle (3 x 4)
• Borehole Spacing: 6 m.
• Borehole installation: Polyethylene U-pipe
• Fluid flow rate: 0.5 10-3 m3/s, borehole.
15
15/22
To keep the borehole temperature at steady state between the years the heating and cooling
demand (extracted and injected from and to the ground) were balanced by charging solar heat
The required solar collector area was determined without considering heat yield from ground:
by
1 1
Q h ⋅ (1 − ) − Q c ⋅ (1 + )
COPh COPc
A=
η⋅σ
Where;
Qh Heating demand (MWh)
COPh Coefficient of performance for heating (in this case =5)
Qc Cooling demand (MWh)
COPc Coefficient of performance for free cooling (in this case =50)
σ Yearly sun yield (in this case σ=1.973 MWh/m2)
η Solar collector efficiency (in this case η=0.86).
In this case, the required solar collector area is 85 m2. The solar heat is directly used when
needed while the rest of the heat is stored until later (Figure 14).
Heating and cooling of the hangar are distributed by floor heating/cooling (UFH) and wall
Floor heating means that warm water is circulated through special pipes that are installed in
the floor, which effectively turns it in to a large radiator. Normally, such systems are used for
low temperature heat distribution (30-35°C) though also warmer water can be used. Floor
heating (UHF) has also many other advantage
4.4. Ventilation
The ventilation load represents 20-35% of cooling demand during summer and about 60-70%
of heating demand during winter. Therefore, these heat losses are reduced by mechanically
balanced ventilation using heat recovery, as shown in Figure 15.B. The gain was estimated
17
17/22
assuming 20 0C air temperature at the ceiling and a heat recovery ε =80%. After such heat
recovery the inlet air temperature during the coldest month is 15.3 0C instead of -3.4 0C.
Since heat distribution starts from floor the lowest air temperature in the hangar is at the
ceiling, Figure 15.A, while the opposite situation occurs during the summer. Therefore, to
reduce ventilation load the ventilation system absorbs the air from ceiling level and feeds
During the wintertime, water is pumped from the borehole through the solar collector to
increase its temperature figure 16.A. The temperature increase which is about 0.8 0C during
the winter is much greater during the summer. The heat pump cools the water before it is
again pumped through the borehole, where it will be warmed up. The extracted heat is
emitted into the hangar. Error! Reference source not found.13 shows the temperature of
During summer time Error! Reference source not found.B, the ground temperature is cold
enough for free cooling, so the water is pumped directly to the heat exchanger. Due to the
heat exchange with indoor air, the water temperature will increase. After the heat exchanger,
water passes though the solar collector and back to the borehole. Then, its temperature will
18
18/22
Figure 16. Schematic of the solar coupled to ground source heat
pump system
5. Conclusion
• A typical average size chicken house in Syria has the estimated heating and cooling
demand given in Table 3, which also shows the corresponding total demand for all
19
19/22
heat pump with heating and cooling powers is 112 kW and 120 kW, respectively, meets
the heating demand. The boreholes supply free cooling during the summer.
• The maximum fluid temperature delivered from the boreholes is 27oC in the summer
• The ground coupled system results theoretically in a 23-40% lower electrical consumption
• The floor heating system, in which the minimum temperature occurs at the ceiling during
the summer and at the floor during the summer, decrease the heating demand by 22%.
• Heat recovery on the ventilation air increases the inlet air temperature during coldest
month to 15.3 0C instead of -3.4 0C, i.e. ventilation load will be decreased approximately
62%
• The climate conditions in Syria are favorable for seasonal heat storage, which means that
there is a great potential for such systems in space heating/cooling of buildings in Syria.
• Solar energy is more suitable in Syria than in most of Europe, which means that there is a
20
20/22
• By implementing suggested system in all Syrian chicken farms, the annual oil
consumption would decrease ~0.72 million barrel (see figure 17), i.e. 72 M$ at current oil
price.
• The estimated installation cost of borehole system for one typical chicken farm is $15000,
6. REFERENCES
1-
CIA, The World Factsbook
2-
Yutaka Genchi, Yukihiro Kikegawa, Atsushi Inaba, CO2 payback–time assessment
of a regional-scale heating and cooling system using a ground source heat–pump in a high
energy–consumption area in Tokyo. Applied Energy 3 (2002), pp. 147-160
3-
Oil production has already peaked. The New Scientist, Volume 196, Issue 2627, 27 October
2007, Page 5
4-
Peak Oil, Carrying Capacity and Overshoot, www.paulchefurka.ca
5-
Mia Ala-Juusela, Heating and Cooling with Focus on Increased Energy Efficiency and
Improved Comfort. Guidebook to IEA ECBCS Annex 37.
6-
Energy Information Administration: www.eia.doe.gov
7-
Syria Energy and power, Encyclopedia of the nations: www.nationsencyclopedia.com
8-
Green Car Congress: www.greencarcongress.com
9-
Arif Hepbasli, A key review on exergetic analysis and assessment of renewable energy
resources for a sustainable future. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 12 (2008)
pp.593–661
10 -
Bo Nordell, Water and Energy - Global Issues for the Future
11-
Bo Nordell, Mohamed Grein & Mohamad Kharseh, Large-scale Utilization of Renewable
Energy Requires Energy Storage.
12-
Arif Hepbasli, Thermodynamic analysis of a ground-source heat pump system for district
heating. International Journal of Energy Research, 29 (2005) pp.671-987
13-
Syrian meat production: http://www.awaonline.net
21
21/22
14-
Coal consumption in chicken houses in Syria: http://thawra.alwehda.gov.sy
15 -
Georgios Florides and Soteris Kalogirou, First in situ determination of the thermal
performance of a U-pipe borehole heat exchanger, in Cyprus. Applied Thermal Engineering
2-3 (2008), pp.157-163
16-
John W. Lund, Derek H. Freeston and Tonya L. Boyd, Direct application of geothermal
energy: 2005 Worldwide review. Geothermics 6, (2005), PP. 691-727
17 -
Bo Nordell, Solar Energy and Heat Storage. Luleå University of Technology
18 -
Abdeen Mustafa Omar, Ground-source heat pumps systems and applications. Renewable
and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2 (2008), pp.344-371
19-
Onder Ozgener, Arif Hepbasli, Modeling and performance evaluation of ground source
(geothermal) heat pump systems. Energy and Buildings 1 (2007), pp. 66-75
20-
Nairen Diao, Qinyun Li, Zhaohong Fang, Heat transfer in ground heat exchangers with
groundwater advection. International Journal of Thermal Sciences 12 (2004), pp. 1203–1211
21-
Number of chicken house in Syria: http://www.asharqalarabi.org.uk
22-
temperature distribution in Syria http://www.worldtradepress.com
23 -
Bo Nordell, Mohamed Grein, UTES for Space Heating and Cooling in North Africa.
24 -
Bo Nordell, Natural sources of heat and cold
25 -
Renewable Energy Resources: www.geni.org
26-
EED (2008). http://www.buildingphysics.com/earth1.htm
22
22/22