Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Impact of Patriarchy On Mental Health Issues in Indi1
Impact of Patriarchy On Mental Health Issues in Indi1
OF WOMEN IN INDIA
Gurman Kaur Chawla
Mental health can roughly be conceptualised as an individual’s inner
experiences linked to their interpersonal group experiences that entail cognitive
experiences (thinking processes), affective experiences (feelings and moods)
and relational experiences (the way in which people interact with their
environment). Lately, the concept of mental health has got broadened with the
increasing recognition and inclusion of the importance of external forces such
as interpersonal relationships, social and economic factors and organizational
and physical environments on mental health. We can all assuredly agree on the
fact that women across the globe are overtaxed and undervalued. Their
subordination in a male dominated society makes it gruelling for them to cope
with all the tacit social, physical or mental demands made upon them. It is an
indisputable fact that women are more vulnerable than men to violence, all
forms of exploitation, be it economic, social, sexual or emotional, as well as to
poverty, malnutrition, chronic diseases exacerbated by early pregnancy and
forced motherhood, and thus to worse mental health issues into the bargain.
Furthermore, men’s self-seeking and insouciant attitude towards them only adds
insult to injury.
Early psychological theories of sex differences entailed prescriptive traditional
sex roles that could be used to control female behaviour. As a result of this,
women were viewed as maternal and domestic. Additionally, hygiene manuals
described a cause-and-effect relationship between female sexual “transgression”
and their bad health thus buttressing the connection between women’s social
role and their health status. Other regressive psychological theories emphasized
the equivalence of “insanity” with “femininity” as a result of which the concept
of “hysterical woman” was born. The culturally ascertained patterns of
behaviour of women led to situational anxieties which were unfortunately
normalised in the name of gender stereotypes and gender norms. As Plath
rightly said, “as a woman you are dammed anyway; if you are normal you are
mad by implication and if you are abnormal you are mad by definition.”
Women also face violence at the hands of their husbands, fathers, brothers, and
uncles in their homes. The abuse is generally overlooked by social custom and
considered a part and parcel of marital life. It may also include rape and sexual
abuse. Psychological violence includes verbal abuse, harassment, confinement,
and deprivation of physical, financial, and personal resources. All types of
abuse and violence can lead to mental health issues, but when it is perpetrated
by someone from the family, the consequences cage the victim with problems
that become extremely hard to battle. Such issues, which mostly go unresolved
because they happen within the family setting, are followed by mental disorders
like Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), and feelings of excessive shame,
guilt and episodes of anger. It may also contribute to the development of
dysfunctional behaviour, depression, anxiety, eating disorders, somatization
disorders, etc. Discrimination and neglect can result in lowered self-
expectations, negative attitude towards self, lack of initiatives, and so on. Many
a times on probing further, the symptoms can be conceptualized as
exaggerations or stereotyping of female gender roles and sex-typed behaviours.
It is also documented that girls tend to somatize and dissociate more owing to
their status in authoritarian patriarchal society. Women are often not able to
escape abusive interpersonal relationships and the first question people ask
when they hear about a case is “why didn’t she just leave?” even when she had
the financial resources and external support to leave. This is where learned
helplessness comes in. The repeated cycles of trauma make them habituated of
it as a result of which it is mentally impossible for them to break free from the
shackles of abusive marriages.