Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 11

B]UYOU[UZ^PQ`YMRU^OMWUeMOUjYQRQO_UaMd^`M[WUOMOUjY[Z]QW

Z]SMYU^XZPQQaMW`MOUjYdRU^OMWUeMOUjYMXNUQY_MW# A894 Z
k,
e-<
JS
BCPCAFM
KGLCPM*
?K@GCLR?J
WBCJMQ
PCASPQMQ
CLCPECRGAMQ

R C Q Q W R M P P C Q  Q í L A F C X

ČǺ
?^kc]`]lknh]Nkjpebe_e]Sjeranoe`]`A]pÅhe_]`ahNanÇ,
K|opanaj?`iejeopn]_eÅjNÇ^he_]lknah Gjopepqpk`aGjraopec]_eÅjMnpac]uE]ooap, :
X
Nnaoe`ajp]`ahAkjoafkBena_perk`ahMnc]jeoik`aCr]hq]_eÅjuQqlanreoeÅj M
?i^eajp]h+MCD?, q
:
ČǺ
JR
AA
M

X'
:

QSK?PGM8

G, Gjpnk`q__eÅj,

GG, Nnej_elekol]n]qj]beo_]hev]_eÅjaba_per],
GGG, ?lhe_]_eÅj`alnej_elekoajahMCD?,

GT, Akj_hqoekjao,

:
q
JR

ČǺ
JR

JM
AM

0
%O

Hd[`U[b[ae VW g`S X[eUS^[lSU[q` WXWUf[hS k eg Sb^[USU[q` badW^ adYS`[e_a VW WhS^gSU[q` k X[eUS^[lSU[q` S_T[W`fS^ '  G=>9 +03
BÁCĈÅÁǺĮ
DSX[eUS^[lSU[q`f[W`WbadaT\WfahWd[X[USdW^Ug_b^[_[W`faVWaT^[YSU[a`We[_bgWefSebad^SdWYg^SU[q`(9X[`VWYSdS`f[lSdW^WXWUf[haW\Wd'
U[U[aVWV[UZSXg`U[q`&^SGdYS`[lSU[q`bSdS^S;aabWdSU[q`kW^<WeSdda^^a =Ua`q_[Uae'G;<='ZS[VW`f[X[USVabd[`U[b[aecgWeWdWUa_[W`VS
Wefn`bdWeW`fWeW`^SSUfgSU[q`VW^SSgfad[VSVX[eUS^[lSVae(=^GdYS`[e_aVW=hS^gSU[q`k>[eUS^[lSU[q`9_T[W`fS^'G=>9'VWeVWW^Spa,*+0
h[W`WSb^[US`VaV[UZaebd[`U[b[aeSX[`VW_W\adSdegedWeg^fSVae(
HS^STdSeU^ShW4>[eUS^[lSU[q`&;g_b^[_[W`fa&Hd[`U[b[ae&G=>9&G;<=(

CĆB AĆĮ
LZWbgdbaeWaXfZWSgV[f[efahWd[XkfZWUa_b^[S`UWaXaT^[YSf[a`e[_baeWVTkfZWdWYg^Sf[a`(A`adVWdfaYgSdS`fWWfZWWXXWUf[hWWjWdU[eW
aXfZ[eXg`Uf[a`&fZWGdYS`[lSf[a`Xad=Ua`a_[U;aabWdSf[a`S`V<WhW^ab_W`f'G=;<'ZSe[VW`f[X[WVbd[`U[b[WefZSfSdWdWUa__W`VWVfaTW
bdWeW`f[`fZWbWdXad_S`UWaXfZWahWde[YZfSgfZad[fk(LZW9YW`UkXad=`h[da`_W`fS^9eeWee_W`fS`V=`XadUW_W`f'G=>9'ZSeTWW`Sbb^k[`Y
fZWeWbd[`U[b[We[`adVWdfa[_bdahW[fedWeg^fee[`UW,*+0(
CWhiadVe49gV[f&>g^X[^^_W`f&Hd[`U[b[We&G=>9&G=;<(
P areop] a ` ep] ` ]  lk n ] hq i j k o `a h] D] _ q hp] `  `a B a na _d k  `a h] S j er a no e` ] `  `a Jei]

G, GLRPMBSAAGîL Ba]_qan`k_kjhkoaÄ]h]`klknh]Mnc]jev]_eÅj
l]n]h]Akklan]_eÅjuahBao]nnkhhkC_kjÅie_ko
Chafan_e_ek`ah]bqj_eÅj`abeo_]hev]_eÅj/+mqapeaò +aj]`ah]jpa* MABC +*aoei lknp]jpapajanaj
jalknk^fapkranebe_]nah_qilheieajpk`ah]ok^heò _qajp] mqa ao lnk^]^ha mqa aj ah lnk_aok `a
c]_ekjaomqaeilkjah]nacqh]_eÅj+oaajbnajp]] bkni qh]_eÅj `a lkh~pe_]o lÇ^he_]o jk oa d]u]
iÇhpelhaonapkomqa*`ajkoanoqlan]`ko*lqa`aj na]hev]`k ah ]`a_q]`k ]j|heoeo `ah lnk^hai ]
]ba_p]noecjebe_]per]iajpaahnaoqhp]`kmqaoa^qoò mqaoalnapaj`aokhq_ekj]n*`aoqo_]qo]ou`a
_]*aopkao*hkcn]nmqahko]`iejeopn]`ko_qilh]j h]o]hpanj]per]ol]n] ajbnajp]nhk* iq_d]ora_ao
_kj h]ojkni]ou_kjahhk]h_]jv]nahk^faperk`a lknmqa oa_]na_a `a h] ejbkni]_eÅj ja_ao]ne]0
lkh~pe_]lÇ^he_]mqafqopebe_]h]nacqh]_eÅj, 9oejai^]nck*]qj_q]j`kahlnk_aoknacqh]pknek
d]u]oe`kah]`a_q]`k*h]jkni ]per]mqa`aahh]
J] aopn]pace] l]n] ai lnaj`an h] beo_]hev]_eÅj oqnf] oeailnaoan| qj] lnklqaop]_qu]abe_]_e]
`a^a oan p]h mqa lnklkn_ekja hko ej_ajperko okhk lk`n| r]he`]noa ] l]npen `a hko naoqhp]`ko
]`a_q]`ko ] hko ]`i ejeopn]`ko u mqa ^nej`a mqa]nnkfaoq]lhe_]_eÅj,
hko heja]i eajpko]lnkle]`ko] hkobqj_ekj]neko
lÇ^he_kol]n]na`q_enahaobqanvk`abeo_]hev]_eÅj Cj ao] ia`e`]* h] ejbkni]_eÅj mqa oa k^peaja
uhko_kopkomqa`e_d]]_pere`]`cajan], `a h] beo_]hev]_eÅj naoqhp] bq j `]i ajp]h l]n]

/, Ka`e]jpa Ba_napk Jaceoh]perk ..4+0./5+HSQ* oa ]lnk^Å ah Ratpk ïje_k Mn`aj]`k `a h] Jau `ah Nnk_a`eieajpk
?`iejeopn]perk Eajan]h +Jau 05222* u oa ejpnk`q_a qj jqark _]l~pqhk nabane`k ] h] ]_pere`]` ]`iejeopn]per] `a
beo_]hev]_eÅj*mqaao`abeje`]ajah]np~_qhk015_kik]mqahh]_kjopepqe`]lknah_kjfqjpk`a]_pkou`ehecaj_e]o`a
ejraopec]_eÅj*oqlanreoeÅj*_kjpnkhkejola__eÅjok^naah_qilheieajpk`ah]ok^hec]_ekjao*lnkde^e_ekjaoukpn]o
heiep]_ekjaoatece^hao]hko]`iejeopn]`ko*`aner]`ko`aqj]jkni]hac]hknach]iajp]ne]*_kjpn]pko_kjahCop]`k
q kpn]bqajpafqn~`e_],Qej ai^]nck*]paj`eaj`k]mqah] Jau07103*mqa_na] ah Qeopai] L]_ekj]h `aCr]hq]_eÅj
u Deo_]hev]_eÅj ?i^eajp]h aop]^ha_a aj ah ]np~_qhk // mqa ah afan_e_ek `a h] beo_]hev]_eÅj ]i^eajp]h _kilnaj`a
h]o bqj_ekjao `a ar]hq]_eÅj* oqlanreoeÅj* beo_]hev]_eÅj u o]j_eÅj `aopej]`]o ] ]oacqn]nah _qilheieajpk `a h]o
5 8 I B 7 5 G H F  /13

k^hec]_ekjao]i^eajp]haobeo_]hev]^]oaop]^ha_e`]oaj h] haceoh]_eÅj ]i^eajp]h, Cj ah lnaoajpa]np~_qhk d]naiko


nabanaj_e]]beo_]hev]_eÅj_kiki]_nklnk_aokajhkop}niejkooaÄ]h]`koaj`e_dki]n_kjkni]perk,

0, 5!_TbPa!ST!`dT!bT!WP]!bT]cPS^!P[Vd]Pb!QPbTb$!CTao!RPaTRT!ST!d]!bXbcT\P!R^\_[Tc^!_PaP![P!TeP[dPRXn]!Tg!P]cT!ST![^b
_a^hTRc^b!ST!aTVd[PRXn]!]dTeP!^!_PaP!\ ^SXUXRPa![P!aTVd[PRXn]!TgXbcT]cT$!`dT!_Ta\ XcP]!P]P[XiPa!bX!VT]TaP]!d]!QT]TUXRX^
]Tc^!_^bXcXe^!P![P!b^RXTSPS!h !bX!b^]!R^WTaT]cTb!R^]![Pb!_^[lcXRPb!ST[!V^QXTa]^"!M PE?LGX?AGîLN?P?J?AMMNCP?AGîL
W CJ BCQ?PPMJJM CAMLîKGAMQ, ?ola_pko Ah]ra,* l, /2, Beolkje^ha aj8 :dpplo8--sss,ka_`,kn]-]kr-,,,lkhe_r-
Nkh~pe_]+Pa]qh]pkne]+aj+ah+NanÇ+]ola_pko+_h]ra,l`b<

+1* LWeek LaddWe Km`UZWl


]oacqn]n mqa h]o nacqh]_ekjao oa _qilh]j* oa `alnah]_eÅj`ahko]`iejeopn]`koaej`ajpebe_]n
i ]jpajc]j]_pq]hev]`]oumqanaoqhpaj_kjoeoò h]ok^hec]_ekjaomqa `a^aj oanoqlanreo]`]ou 6
pajpao_kj hkok^faperko`alkh~pe_] lnareopko, hko ej_qi lhei eajpko mqa ]i anep]j lnei] b]_a J
qj _]opeck naola_pk `a ]mqahhko mqa lkn oqo ĂC
M,
Qej ai^]nck* h] rej_qh]_eÅj mqa peaja h] beo_]ò _]n]_pan~ope_]o iana_aj _kjoa_qaj_e]o iajko pk

hev]_eÅj _kj ah }tepk `a h] nacqh]_eÅj jk oqaha cn]rko]ol]n]ah]`iejeopn]`k*ajpnakpnko,
BCPCAFM
aop]noqbe_eajpaiajpanahar]`],Choqlanreoknoa KGLCPM*
?K@GCLR?J
WBCJMQ
ajbnajp]]heiep]_ekjaop]hao_ki knaopne__ekjao ?oeieoik* h]pn]jol]naj_e] `a hko_nepanekomqa PCASPQMQ
CLCPECRGAMQ
lnaoqlq}op]hao*ahjerah`a_kjk_ei eajpkmqaoa oqopajp]j h] lh]jebe_]_eÅj uoq _ki qje_]_eÅj ]
ateca*qji]n_khac]hk^fapk]ranebe_]n`eolanoku hko ]`i ejeopn]`ko u `ai |o cnqlko `a ejpan}o
d]op]lk_klna_eok*hkjqianko]omqaokjp]jpk _kj pne^ q ua  _kj qj] ]` a_q ]` ] naj`e_eÅj `a
h]ok^hec]_ekjao_ki khko]`iejeopn]`ko*h]b]hp] _qajp]o* h] lnaraj_eÅj `a h] _knnql_eÅj u _kj
`a qok `apa_jkhkc~]o `a h] ejbkni]_eÅj _ki k ah_ki lknp]i eajpk}pe_k`a hkoejrkhq_n]`ko,
dann]ieajp]`a]lkuk] h] h]^kn*ajpnakpn]o,
JM
GG, NPGLAGNGMQN?P?SL?DGQA?JGX?AGîL D:
m&

Cjah_]okl]npe_qh]n`ah]beo_]hev]_eÅj]i ^eajò CDCARGT? :


p]h* h] eilkoe^ehe`]` `a ]__a`an] h]o qje`]`ao M
q
beo_]hev]^haolnao_ej`eaj`k`ah]lkuk`ah]`i eò J] MABC +0./2+ d] `ao]nnkhh]`k kj_a lnej_eò :
jeopn]`kuhko lnk^hai]o mqa oacajan]j ]h jk leko u kneajp]_ekjao3aj hko mqa na_ki eaj`] ;>
D:
d]^anoe`kl]npa`ah lnk_aoknacqh]pknek*_ki k `a^aj ^]o]noa h]o ]_pq]_ekjao `a hko Cop]`ko ĔĔ
okje`ajpebe_]nh]odann]ieajp]o`aĘÍGĨİĔĘÌĘÍIJS l]n]k^pajanhkoiafknaonaoqhp]`ko`ah_qi lheò Ć
d+
1
i|o_kjrajeajpao, i eajpk`ah]ojkni]ou]oacqn]nh]_]he`]``ah] :
nacqh]_eÅj*hko_q]haooaatlhe_]j^narai ajpa]
Cjaba_pk*`ai]jan]_kjpn]ne]]hkmqaoaÄ]h]h]`k_+ _kjpejq]_eÅj8
pnej]fqn~`e_]uh]hepan]pqn]a_kjÅie_]ok^naahpai]2
+h]_q]h_kjoe`an]mqah]o]j_eÅj_ki knaolqaop] Nnej_elek /8Deo_]hev]_eÅjaj ^]oa]are`aj_e],
bnajpa]h ej_qilheieajpk`a^aoanqhpei] n]pek+ Ch afan_e_ek `a h] beo_]hev]_eÅj `a^a ^]o]noa aj
ao bna_qajpa mqa ah haceoh]`kn klpa lkn qpehev]n h] a re` aj _e] k ^paje`] `ah oac q ei eajpk u aj
`ai]jan]at_hqoer] dann]ieajp]o`a`eoq]oeÅj bqj_eÅj]ahhkaomqa`a^a`a_e`enoamq}u_Åik
_ki kaoahaop]^ha_annac~iajaoo]j_ekj]`knao beo_]hev]n, Jko naoqhp]`ko p]jce^hao `a^aj oan
l]n] eilqho]nah_qilheieajpk`ah] hau, ar]hq]`kolaneÅ`e_]iajpa,

Rajeaj`kaj_qajp]hkoaÄ]h]`k*h]lh]jebe_]_eÅj Nnej_elek08Qaha_pere`]`,
`ah]oqlanreoeÅjuahafane_e_ek`ah]beo_]hev]_eÅj Nnki kranah _qi lhei eajpku d]_an_qilhen h]o
`a^a oan aopn]p}ce_]* _kjoe`an]j`k lnej_eleko jkni]o `a^aj oan ah l]lah `a hko ]cajpao `ah
^|oe_ko]ok_e]`ko]h]aba_pere`]`*_ki kao`eoaò ian_]`k* ah oa_pkn lner]`k* h] ok_ea`]` _ereh u
Ä]n_nepanekomqalani ep]jaop]^ha_anqj kn`aj hkopne^qj]hao,Qa`a^ajatlhkn]nkpn]oi]jan]o

:
1, ?P _P[PQaP T]U^aRT\T]c$ T] X]V[kb$ ]^ cXT]T d]P caPSdRRXn] TgPRcP T] Tb_Pm^[& Fd bXV]XUXRPS^ R^\_aT]ST T[ q
D:

PbTVdaP\XT]c^ST d]P^QTSXT]RXP "&&&# X]e^[dRaPaj[^bTbUdTai^bST[9bcPS^$ P caPekb STbdb X]bcXcdRX^]Tb_PaP WPRTa O+


;>
Rd\ _[Xa[Pb [ThTb & @MLGD?X DCPLíLBCX* Hko} Jqeo u KMLRCQR?NG?* I]nej], GT^alP ST[ 9]U^aRT\T]ch T[db^ ST ;D

X]bcad\T]c^bTR^]n\XR^b_PaPU^\ T]cPaT[Rd\ _[X\ XT]c^ST[P [Th & Beolkje^ha aj8 :sss,]aopekjlq^he_],mk^,la-


tt+_kj]naok+_h]`-_h]`-l`bo-^kjeek,l`b<,
[`
2, AMQR?X? TGLSCX?* A]nhko, FT_PaPRXn] T]caT 8TaTRW^ CT]P[h  8TaTRW^ 5S\ X]XbcaPcXe^ FP]RX^]PS^a & Cj8 Pareop] nk
Hqn~`e_]Sjeranoe`]`A]pÅhe_]`aEq]u]mqeh,Eq]u]mqeh80..3,
p+
?WPCQ* h]j u @P?GRDGU?GRC* Hkdj, ETb_^]bXeT ETVd[PcX^]2 GaP]bRT]SX]V cWT 8TaTVd[PcX^] 8TQPcT & Cj8 Mtbkn`
SjeranoepuNnaoo,Lqar]Wkng8/770, 0
3, MPE?LGX?AGîL N?P? J? AMMNCP?AGîL W CJ BCQ?PPMJJM CAMLîKGAMQ, Pacqh]pknu Cjbkn_aiajp ]j`
%O
Gjola_pekjo*MCAB@aopNn]_pe_aNnej_eleaobknPacqh]pknuNkhe_u*0./2,

Nnej_eleko`a qj]beo_]hev]_eÅj aba_per] uoq ]lhe_]_eÅj lknah knc]jeoik`a ar]hq]_eÅjubeo_]hev]_eÅj ]i^eajp]h+MCD?


l]n]]h_]jv]nhkok^faperko`ah]nacqh]_eÅj`]`k Jko ck^eanjko `a^aj c]n]jpev]n h] _h]ne`]` `a
mqa h]beo_]hev]_eÅj jkoeailnaaolkoe^ha jeao h]o jkni]o u lnk_a`ei eajpko `a beo_]hev]_eÅj*
hki|oabe_eajpa, `]nhko ] _kjk_an u aop]^ha_an hko `ana_dko u
`a^anao `a hko bqj_ekj]neko lÇ^he_ko u hko ]`ò
Nnej_elek 18 Cjbkmqa `a neaock r lnklkn_ekj]ò iejeopn]`ko,
he`]`,
J] bna_q aj _e] ` a h]o]__ekjao` abeo_]hev]_eÅju Nnej_elek /.8Nnki kranah_qi lhei eajpk,
hko na_qnoko]oecj]`ko] `e_d]p]na] `a^aj oan La_aoep]ikolnkikranh]pn]jol]naj_e]aeilqhò
lnklkn_ekj]hao]h jerah `a neaockmqaoa`aner] o]nah_qi lhei eajpk]pn]r}o`a`eranokoejopnqò
`ahko lkpaj_e]haoej_qilheieajpko, iajpkomqapajc]jaj_qajp]h]o_]n]_pan~ope_]o
`a hko ]`i ejeopn]`ko u mqa ^nej`aj _h]ne`]`
Nnej_elek28Pacqh]_eÅj ]lnkle]`], ok^na hkmqaoaaolan] `aahhkoumqakneajpa]
J]oaopn]pace]o`abeo_]hev]_eÅj`a^ajk^a`a_an hkolnklekobeo_]hev]`knaoajh]p]na]`aranebe_]n
] hkmqa_knnaolkj`]oacÇjah lanbehu_ki lknò ah naolapk] h]ojkni]o,
p]i eajpk`a_]`]ailnao],
P areop]  a ` ep] ` ]  lk n ] hq i j k o `a h] D] _q hp]`  ` a  B a na _d k  ` a  h] S j er a no e` ] `  `a Jei]

Nnej_elek //8Nnkbaoekj]heoik,
Nnej_elek38TeoeÅj] h]ncklh]vk, J] bkni]_eÅj u h] oqlanreoeÅj ] hkobeo_]hev]`k+
Jko c k^ eanjk o ` a^ an~] j  ]` k l p]n lkh~pe_]o u nao`a^a]oacqn]nlnkbaoekj]heoik* ejpacne`]`*
ia_]jeoikoejopepq_ekj]hao]npe_qh]`ko_kjk^ò _kjoeopaj_e] u pn]jol]naj_e]8 oa namqeana qj]
faperko_h]nkouqjlh]j`apn]^]fk]h]ncklh]vk, bkni]_eÅj ] bkj`k*_ajpn]`kjkoÅhkaj d]^eheò
`]`aop}_je_]o*oejkp]i ^e}jaj _ki lapaj_e]o
Nnej_elek48Akkn`ej]_eÅjr_kjokhe`]_eÅj, caj}ne_]o* u h]o `ena_pne_ao kbe_e]hao l]n] hko
Lk ao atpn]Äk mqa oa c ajana qj] oqanpa `a beo_]hev]`knao `a^an~] ]uq`]n ] c]n]jpev]n h]
oqlanlkoe_eÅj `a h]obqj_ekjao`abeo_]hev]_eÅj _kdanaj_e]uh]amqe`]`,
ajpnaajpe`]`ao* lknhkmqaaop]p]na]`a^aoan
_kkn`ej]`] u* oe ao lkoe^ha* _kjokhe`]`], Copk ?dkn]^eaj*]l]npen`ajqaopn]atlaneaj_e]lnkò
lani epaqj iafknqok`ahkona_qnokolÇ^he_ko* baoekj]h_kjoe`an]ikomqaaolkoe^haej_knlkn]n
]hecan] h] _]nc] eilqaop] ] h]oajpe`]`aobeo_]+ `kolnej_eleko]`e_ekj]hao8
hev]`kn]oui]teiev] h]abe_eaj_e],
Nnej_elek /08Mlknpqje`]`,
Nnej_elek58Rn]jol]naj_e]`ack^eanjk, Cjbqj_eÅj]h_q]h*h]_]nc]mqa]oqi]ahoqlanre+
Ba^aj `ao]nnkhh]noa aopnq_pqn]o u lkh~pe_]o `a okn`a^apajanaj_qajp]naopnejcenahpeai lk`a
ck^eanjk mqa lnki qar]j h] pn]jol]naj_e] `a _kj_hqoeÅj`ah]oqlanreoeÅj]h i ~jei klkoe^ha
hko bqj_ekj]neko ] _]nck `a h] beo_]hev]_eÅj* ah umqah]oia`e`]o]`iejeopn]per]ooaeilkjc]j
lnkbaoekj]heoik u qj] caopeÅj kneajp]`] ] naò ej_hqokajah i]n_k`ah]]__eÅj`aoqlanreoeÅj
oqhp]`ko, J] ajpe`]` beo_]hev]`kn] `a^a afan_an aj_]ok_knnaolkj`]_kjpnkh]nqj ei l]_pkna]h
oq bqj_eÅj _kj ej`alaj`aj_e]* _kj at_hqoeÅj kejiejajpa,
`a_q]hmqean ejbhqaj_e] lkh~pe_] u hko aobqanvko
l]n] lnki kran ah _qi lhei eajpk `a^aj oan naò Nnej_elek /18Papnk]hei ajp]_eÅj,
_kilajo]`ko, E ] n] j pev ]  m q a  ` q n] j pa  h] beo _ ] hev ] _ eÅ j  oa
k ^ pa j c ]  jk okhk ej bk ni ] _ eÅ j  ] o k _e] ` ]  ]h
Nnej_elek68Gjpacn]_eÅj`ah] ejbkni]_eÅj, _q i l hei eaj pk `ah]k^hec]_eÅj*oejk]h]i ]c ò
J] pa_jkhkc~] `a h] ejbkni ]_eÅj u h] _ki q jeò jepq``ah]o_kjoa_qaj_e]ocajan]`]o*hk_q]h
_]_eÅj `a^a oan qpehev]`] l]n] i ]tei ev]n h] oan| j a_a o] nek  l]n] na]hev]n qj] ] ` a _q ] ` ] 
5 8 I B 7 5 G H F  G13

ejpacn]_eÅj`aneaocko*h]_kkn`ej]_eÅjuahejpanò a r] hq ] _eÅ j  Ę LĪ Ĩ ĮIJO


_]i^ek`aejbkni]_eÅj*]o~_ki kl]n]klpeiev]n
ah qok`ahkona_qnoko, GGG, ?NJGA?AGîL BC NPGLAGNGMQ CL CJ MCD?

Nnej_elek78Ah]ne`]`aeil]n_e]he`]``ahkolnkò ? l]npen`aoapeai^na`a0./4*ah Mnc]jeoik`a


_a`ei eajpko, Cr]hq]_eÅjuDeo_]hev]_eÅj?i^eajp]h+aj]`ah]jpa

+1, Raoou Rknnao Q|j_dav


MCD? +*naolkjo]^ha`ah]beo_]hev]_eÅj]i^eajp]h Cj ah Nh]j ?jq]h `a Cr] hq ] _eÅ j  u Deo_]hev]ò
`a`erano]o]_pere`]`aolnk`q_per]ouatpn]_per]o _eÅj ? i ^ ea j p] h + a j  ] ` a h] j pa  N J ? L C D ? + * $
_kikh]cn]juia`e]j]iejan~]ade`nk_]n^qnko* m q a ao qj ` k _ q i a j pk  m q a  ^qo_] k n` a j ] n K
reajaejpnk`q_eaj`kajahafan_e_ek`aoqobqj_ekò u k nea j p] n ah ` a oa i l a Ä k  p} _j e_k  u l nk c n] ò D:
O,
jaoh]oiafknaoln|_pe_]oulnej_elekoaj i]pane] i ]`k `a h]o bqj_ekjao `a h]o ajpe`]`ao mqa aj
D:
`abeo_]hev]_eÅjmqacq]n`]j`ena_p]nah]_eÅj_kj afan_aj bq j _ek j ao `a beo_]hev]_eÅj ] i ^ ea j ò
BCPCAFM
h]ona_kiaj`]_ekjaobkniqh]`]olknh]MABC, p]h* oa d] ejpnk`q_e`k ] l]npen `ah ]Äk 0./53 KGLCPM*
?K@GCLR?J
WBCJMQ
qj_kj_napkajbkmqa`aneaockoulnklkn_ekj]heò PCASPQMQ
CLCPEyRGAMQ
]' TeoeÅj`aJ]ncklh]vk-Qaha_pere`]`, `]`ajh]h]^knmqa`aoai laÄ]ahMCD?]pn]r}o
`a h]o Bena__ekjao`aCr]hq]_eÅjuQqlanreoeÅj
Cj`e_eai ^na`ah0./4*oa]lnk^Åah Nh]j Copn]ò l]n]`abejenh]o]_pere`]`aouhko]`iejeopn]`ko
p}ce_k Gjopepq_ekj]h `ah MCD? l]n] ah lan~k`k naola_pk`ahko_q]hao`a^aj`aolhac]nahafanò
0./5+0./7 aj ah _q]h oa aop]^ha_eankj hko i aò _e_ek`aoqobqj_ekjao4
5
,
_]jeoikoejopepq_ekj]haomqanacen|j ahpn]^]fk
] h]ncklh]vk, Ch lneian _nepanek `a lneknev]_eÅj _kjoe`an]`k
ao h] ateopaj_e] ] jerah j]_ekj]h `a aol]_eko
Cjaopa i]n_kh] ieoeÅj ejopepq_ekj]h]lnk^]`] `ajk i ej ]`ko K ao]o `a Be|hkck mqa oa d]j
ao8 Gi lqho]n u lnki kran ah _qi lhei eajpk `a knecej]`k lkn h]o `ai ]j`]o ok_ek]i^eajp]hao
h]o k^hec]_ekjao ]i ^eajp]hao aj hko ]cajpao `alk^h]_ekjaoaj_qukopannepknekooa`ao]nnkò
a_kjÅi e_ko u h] iafkn] `ah Qeopai] L]_ekj]h hh]j ]_pere`]`ao `a iejan~]* ajanc~]* lao_] a
`a EaopeÅj ?i ^eajp]h* `a i ]jan] ]npe_qh]`]* ej`qopne]*_qu] beo_]hev]_eÅj aop| ] _]nck`a `eò
aba_per] u pn]jol]najpa* _kjpne^quaj`k _kj ah rano]oajpe`]`ao_kjbqj_ekjao`abeo_]hev]_eÅj
`ao]nnkhhkokopaje^ha`ah l]~o , ]i^eajp]h+CD?+ej_hquaj`k]hMCD?,&Tancn|be_k
aj h]oecqeajpal|cej]'
?oeieoik* oa nao]hp] _ki k k^faperk aopn]p}ce_k
ahej_naiajp]nah_qilheieajpk`ak^hec]_ekjao Cj bqj_eÅj ] aopa _nepanek `a lkpaj_e]h _kj+
]i^eajp]hao`ahko]`iejeopn]`kod]_eaj`k_qi ò bhe_per e` ] ` * h] B ena__eÅ j  `a C r ] hq ] _eÅ j  na]ò
lhenp]i ^e}jah lnej_elek`aoaha_pere`]`*`kj`a hev] ] _ _ ek j a o  ` a  a r ] hq ] _ eÅ j  ] i ^ ea j p ] h6
h]bej]he`]``ah]ejpanraj_eÅj`ahCop]`k]pn]r}o aj h]o |na]o `a ejbhqaj_e] `a h]o ]_pere`]`ao
`ah]beo_]hev]_eÅjaolnkikranah_qilheieajpk, beo_]hev]^ ]o mqa oa `ao]nnkhh]j aj h]o vkj]o
cakcn|be_]oajh]omqaateopah]lnk^hai|pe_]okò
^' Cjbkmqa`aneaockulnklkn_ekj]he`]`, _ek+]i^eajp]h*_qukonaoqhp]`ko`a^ajkneajp]nah
afan_e_ek`ah]bqj_eÅjoqlanreokn]9ieajpn]omqa
QacÇjLeapk+0./0+h]ejfqope_e]aileav]_kjh] h]Bena__eÅj`aQqlanreoeÅj`ao]nnkhh]oqh]^kn`a
]n^epn]nea`]` aj h] lanoa_q_eÅj9ajp]h oajpe`k* beo_]hev]_eÅj naola_pk `a hko]`iejeopn]`ko mqa
lk`ai ko ]beni]n mqa jk _kjp]n _kj _nepaneko na]hev]j]_pere`]`aoajh]ovkj]olneknev]`]olkn
mqa kneajpaj h] `a_eoeÅj `a ] mqe}j k mq} oqò aop]oepq]_eÅj`a_kjbhe_pere`]`,
lanreo]n lqa`a `arajen aj mqa h] _]nc] `a h]
oqlanreoeÅj na_]ec]ajmqeaj jkhkiana_a, _' Akkn`ej]_eÅju_kjokhe`]_eÅj,
:
q
;D
O\
JM
;D

4, Ch NJ?LCD? bqa ]lnk^]`k lkn Paokhq_eÅj LÑ ..2+0./5+MCD?+AB, Beolkje^ha aj8 :dppl8--sss,kab],ck^,la-sl+
_kjpajp-qlhk]`o-0./5-.0-PCQ+..2+0./5+MCD?+AB+NJ?LCD?,l`b<,
i
9;
5, J]oqje`]`aobeo_]hev]^hao`a_kilapaj_e]`ahMCD?okj00..]lnktei]`]iajpa*at_hquaj`k]mqahh]omqabkni]j
:Q'
l]npa`ah]o`ereoekjaoej`qopne]hao*mqa]hkh]nck`ahlnaoajpa]Äkreajajoeaj`kpn]jobane`]o`ahKejeopanek`ah]
Nnk`q__eÅj,
/
B
6, ? pn]r}o `ah afan_e_ek `a h] bqj_eÅj ar]hq]`kn] oa ]j]hev] ah aop]`k `a hko _kilkjajpao `ah ]i^eajpa u oa
ej`ajpebe_] hkob]_pknaoatpanjkomqa ej_e`aj aj oq_]he`]` ]pn]r}o`aar]hq]_ekjaouikjepknako`a]cq]*]ena*
%O
b]qj]*bhkn]*oqahk*nqe`kun]`e]_ekjaojkekjev]jpao*ajpnakpnko,

Nnej_eleko`a qj]beo_]hev]_eÅj aba_per] uoq ]lhe_]_eÅj lknahknc]jeoik `aar]hq]_eÅj ubeo_]hev]_eÅj ]i^eajp]h+MCD?


DGESP?/8Kao]o`aBe|hkck_na]`]olknlnk^hai|pe_]Qk_ek+?i^eajp]h7
+ "-" % & 1 # )$ 9 >6 : ?

.7475-3,

; 3 A /  2 3  B @ / #0 / 8 = 
1C/B@=1 C 3<1/A

; 3 A /  2 3  1 #< # 2 3 
0 3 : 3 <  F  A 7q <

:= @ 3B=

; 3 A /  2 3  2 7o : = 5 = 
1 # < #  ; / F C @ 7/ 5 /

; 3 A /  2 3  : /  > @ = D #
> 7C @ /
/ 2 / B 3 ;  2 3 : ; / @ / c = <
P areop]  a ` ep] ` ]  lkn ] hq i j k o `a h] D] _ q hp] `  `a B a na _ d k  `a h] S j er a no e` ] `  `a Jei]

j@ C > =  2 3  B @ / 0 / 8 = 
< A 8 @ 7B =  2 3  7; / G /

77B " 3 ; C : B 7A 3 1 B = @ 7/ C " 0 / 6 7/

; 0/F3?=3 O PGJ
6 C /:5 /F= 1

A / <  ; / @ B 7<

; 3 A /  2 3  2 7/ : = 5 =  2 3 : 
1 / A 3 @ 7=  3 :  A / C 1 = #

1 = ; 7A 7q <  0 / 6 7 /  S / 
< :  A / < B /  1 @ C G  2 7
3:43@@=: 5" = ( 1 " , 1 $ 5 O 
; 3 A /  2 3  2 7/ : 1  t  ; 3 A / 23 /F/A6
2 3 8 / < 5 / A H B  6 C / @ 7 > / ; > / !
C 1 /F/:7
3 A > / 1 7=  B 3 1 < 7 1 =  2 3  2 3 /  2 7A B @ 7B = !

: /  1 C 3 < 1 / 6 C / @ ; 3 F 6 2 3  / V 8 / >/A1= < 


; 3 A /  2 3  2 7o 6 "= 5 =  5 @ C >= 23B @ / 0 / 8= 
; 3 A /  2 3 :  2 7A B @ 7B =  .#3 1 " 6 7 < 1 6 / F M ] M 6 P > = 0 : / 1 7= <  < / 6 C /
23A 7; q ]I = : 7D / @
5 @ C > =  B 3 1 < 71 = 
3 A B @ / B b 5 71 Y E U < B / @ = 5 @ C >=  23B @ / 0 / 8= A / @ "

$ " **" @ = A /  2 3 A 3 @ 8 / : 7
; 3 A /  2 3 :  @ 3 / A 3 < B / ; 73 < B = 
5 @ C > =  > / @ / > @ 3 D # ; / 2 @ 3  2 3  2 7= A 
tl #= 3 "; = @ = 1 = 1 6 / H
2 3 /  > @ = D # B / ; 0 = > / B / $ 
2 3  1 = < B / ; 7< / 1 7q <  D 3 < B / < 7: : /
; / < C F B/6 C /; /< C
@ 3 C < 7 q <  B @ p D P V3 A B I / :  2 3 : 
(  0 / n8 =  C @ r 0 / ; 0 o 
$/ < 1 / D 3 : 71 / PS D
1CA1= ; 3A / 2 3 : o V
> @ = D # 1 = B / 0 / ; 0 / A

; 3 A /  9 :  2 7A B @ 7B = 
2 3 Z $3 : 7: : 3  "
; 3 A /  2 3 : / 
; 3 A /  ; C : B 7A 3 1 B = @ 7/ :  2 3 > @ = D #I @ / C 
< :7  1 = ; 7 B 3  2 3  : / + 
: /  > @ = D # < / A 1 / D /F/1C16=T I I 1 a > @ = D #  2 3  3 A > 7< / @
u n  Y Qí NSLM b
1 = ; 7A 7q < 7d : B 7A 3 1 B = @ 7/ 7
: : / : : 7; / F =

#; 3 A /  2 3  2 7 A B @ 7 B = A  = 1 C D 7 @ 7  <3 ,
kD F  D 7: /  D 7: / 
/ @ 3 ? C 7> /

7= ? C 3 5 C !

; 3A/>= @3:2 3A/@ @ = ::= 


5 8 I B 7 5 G H F  /13

2 3 :  2 > B = # ; = ? C 3 5 C / H
B/1</

Ǽ ÈF ÃÃÈI

7, Dqajpa8MCD?&0./5'Nh]j?jq]h`aCr]hq]_eÅjuDeo_]hev]_eÅj?i^eajp]h,

+1. LWeek LaddWe Km`UZWl


Ba i]jan] _kilhaiajp]ne] u ]paj`eaj`k mqa n~koaola_~be_kooacÇj_]`]]_pere`]`a_kjÅie_]
okj `erano]o h]o]qpkne`]`ao_kj _kilapaj_e]o k^fapk`abeo_]hev]_eÅj,
ajbeo_]hev]_eÅj]i^eajp]h+CD?+*oalnkiqaraqj
pn]^]fk_kkn`ej]`kajpnaahh]ol]n]oqlanreo]n`a ? _kjpejq]_eÅj* oa i qaopn]j hko _nepaneko `a
i]jan] ejpacn]h h]o ]_pere`]`ao mqaoa`ao]nnkò lneknev]_eÅjaola_~be_ko*mqa_kjoe`an]j]ola_ò
hh]jajahnabane`k|i^epkcakcn|be_k*aolan]j`k pko_]n]_pan~ope_ko`a_]`]]_pere`]`a _kj Åi eò
BCPCAFM
hkcn]n_kjahhkqjiafkn`e]cjÅope_k`ahko]cajò _],&ranbecqn]1' KGLCPM*
?K@GCLR?J
WBCJMQ
pao _kjp]iej]`knao u qj] ]`a_q]`] naolqaop] PCASPQMQ
CLCPECRGAMQ
l]n]h]okhq_eÅj`ahkolnk^hai]o]i^eajp]hao, b' Mlknpqje`]`,

`' Deo_]hev]_eÅjaj ^]oa] are`aj_e], ?bej `ac]n]jpev]nqj] ejpanraj_eÅj klknpqj]*


oad] aop]^ha_e`k_ki kiap] mqahko ejbkniao
Qad]j ej_knlkn]`k_kjoe`an]_ekjaocajan]hao bej]hao `a h]o oqlanreoekjao na]hev]`]o ] l]npen
l]n]h]lneknev]_eÅj`aoqlanreoekjao*h]o_q]hao `aajank`ah0./5_kj_hqu]jaj qj i|teik`a
SB
k^a`a_aj]ejbkni]_eÅjna_kce`]ajoqlanreoekò _q]najp]u_ej_k&23'`~]o//, RH

jao`a]Äko]jpaneknao k ejbkni]_eÅj deopÅne_] :


v
mqa lani epa h] e`ajpebe_]_eÅj `a rq hj an]^ eheò Be_d] iap] c]n]jpev] mqa hko naoqhp]`ko `a h] k
S
`]`ao mqafqopebe_]j h] ej_klkn]_eÅj `a kpnko beo_]hev]_eÅjoak^pajc]j`ai]jan]klknpqj]aj :
]`iejeopn]`ko aj ah NJ?LCD? 0./5* _kjbkni a ^ajabe_ekp]jpk`ah]]qpkne`]`+mqeajlk`n|eilkò aj
oaiqaopn]ajah cn|be_k0, janh]ia`e`]mqa_knnaolkj`]l]n]naaop]^ha_an
JR
ĔĔ
h]hac]he`]`uiejeiev]nah eil]_pkjac]perkmqa M

1
a' Pacqh]_eÅj]lnkle]`], ]_]nnaa ah ej_qilheieajpk+ _kik h] `ah lnklek :
]`iejeopn]`k*]mqeajoaha_na]qj]_kjpejcaj_e]
Rajeaj`kaj_qajp]mqahkna_kiaj`]^haaod]ò ]l]npen`ah]ej_anpe`qi^na*oej`af]n`ah]`k]h_eqò
_anqj]`a_q]`k]j|heoeolkn_]`]]`iejeopn]`k `]`]jk*mqeaj`a^ana_kjk_anajh]]qpkne`]`qj]
k^fapk`abeo_]hev]_eÅj*oad]jaop]^ha_e`k_nepa+ klknpqj]uaba_per]]_pq]_eÅjl]n]_kjbe]najahh]/0,

DGE S P ? 18
D GE S P ? 08
Anepanekoaola_~be_ko`alneknev]_eÅjoacÇj
Akjoe`an]_ekjaocajan]haol]n]h]lneknev]_eÅj`a
]_pere`]`a_kjÅie_],
oqlanreoekjao/.,/


v ;WdUS`oSSÅdWSFSfgdS^HdafWY[VS

2DGAIN= v ;WdUS`oSS ÅdWSFSfgdS^HdafWY[VS


v =fSbSVW^bdaUWeabdaVgUf[ha

Akjbhe_pko 1 &
v JWeg^fSVaeS`fWd[adWe

"" Ciancaj_e]o
]i^eajp]hao

Tqhjan]rehe`]`
)
2
1
ÃĚĐĠFĎĊĠDĤĠFĢ
"
6
RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
v
v
v
v
;a_ba`W`fW Ud[f[Ua
;WdUS`oS S ÅdWS FSfgdS^ HdafWY[VS
LS_Spa VW USbSU[VSV [`efS^SVS
<W`g`U[Se

7 ;a_ba`W`fW Ud[f[Ua

"" Gj_qilheieajpko
naepan]`ko

Mpnko
!
-EA?KID?D@=@
7 LS_Spa VW USbSU[VSV [`efS^SVS
7 ;WdUS`oS S ÅdWS FSfgdS^ HdafWY[VS
7 <W`g`U[Se

v
v
v
v

v
;WdUS`oS S ÅdWS FSfgdS^ HdafWY[VS
LS_Spa VW USbSU[VSV [`efS^SVS
JWeg^fSVae S`fW`adWe
<W`g`U[Se

A_bSUfa VW ^S SUf[h[VSV
:
S
JR
O+
0G@LJKID= v
v
v
<W`g`U[Se
LS_Spa VW USbSU[VSV [`efS^SVS
FgWhae SV_[`[efdSVae
aj
JR

/., Dqajpa8 Ch]^kn]_eÅj lnkle],


j
//, Akjoe`an]j`k h] lnkcn]i]_eÅj na]hev]`] l]n] _]`] qj] `a h]o _kkn`ej]_ekjao, A]^a `aop]_]n mqa aop] iap] aop|
oeaj`k ikjepkna]`] iajoq]hiajpa ] bej `a na]hev]n hko ]fqopao naola_perko aj ^]oa ] h] na]he`]` `a h] oqlanreoeÅj* 1
I
_kjoe`an]j`k mqa jk ateop~] qj] h~ja] `a ^]oa mqa ie`ean] aopko peailko ]jpanekniajpa,
/
/0, Ch `eoaÄk `a hko ej`e_]`knao mqa fqopebe_]j ah lnaoqlqaopk `a h]o ajpe`]`ao lÇ^he_]o oqaha aop]n ajbk_]`k ]Çj] iap] %
O
jqi}ne_]8 lkn afailhk* jÇiank `a oqlanreoekjao* oej atecen mqa }op]o `a^]j aop]n _kj_hqe`]o, Cj ah MCD? oa aj_kjpnÅ
qj l]oerk `a iehao `a ejbkniao lkn ah]^kn]n mqa _knnaolkj`~]j ] oqlanreoekjao na]hev]`]o `ao`a ah ]Äk 0./2,

Nnej_eleko `a qj] beo_]hev]_eÅj aba_per] k oq ]lhe_]_eÅj lkn ah knc]jeoik `a ar]hq]_eÅj k beo_]hev]_eÅj ]i^eajp]h + MCD? Q1/
Nknkpnkh]`k*aoei lknp]jpa`aop]_]nmqa`ao`a ĮJĪĘİKĠĮĠÏÍ ĮĘ IJĨÌĚ ĘÍ ĔĨÍĮĠĖĘİĚĔĠÏÍ ĘI ĠÌ ĪĚĔIJĨ
ahoalpeai^na`ah0./4]ba^nank`ah0./5*oaeiò ĖĘ IĨĮ ĠÍĔJÌ ĪIĠÌ ĠĘÍIJĨĮ ĖĘ IĚĮ ĨĒIĠĜĚĔĠĨÍĘĮ GĠĮĔĚŌ
lqoeankjraejpeÇj&0/'i a`e`]o]`iejeopn]per]o IĠĽĚĖIĘĮ ĬJĘ ĮĘ ĪJĘĖĚÍ ĖĘIJĘĔIJĚİ Ĺ IĚ ĪİĨĒĚĒĠIĠĖĚĖ
mqa d]jpaje`k lknk^fapk_kjpnkh]nah `]Äk]h ĖĘ ĮJ ĨĔJİİĘÍĔĠĚQO
]i ^eajpa+na]hkeji ejajpa+mqaraj~]jc aj aò
n]j`k ]hcqjko ]`iejeopn]`ko* aj hko oa_pknao Rajeaj`kaj_qajp]ahhk*hkoej_qi lhei eajpko
`a iejan~]*de`nk_]n^qnko*lao_]aej`qopne]/1, oa d]j _h]oebe_]`k aj ]' harao* ao `a_en*] m q a ò
hhko mqa nalnaoajp]j qj neaock hara naola_pk
c' Ah]ne`]` a ei l]n_e]he`]` aj hko lnk_a`e+ `ah ^eaj fq n~` e_ k  m q a  l nk pa c a j  k m q a okj
i eajpko-Papnk]heiajp]_eÅj, ej _q i l hei ea j pk o ] k ^ hec ]_ek j ao `a _]n|_pan
bkni ]h k `a kpn] j ]pq n]hav] m q a jk _]qo]
? bej `a c]n]jpev]n h] _h]ne`]` `a hko lnk_a`eò `]Äk ]hc q jk u ^' pn]o_aj `ajpao* mqa okj hko
ieajpko`aoqlanreoeÅj*ahMCD?]lnk^Åqjjqaò mqa c ajan]j  `]Äk* d ]^ e}j ` k oa aop]^ ha_e` k 
rkahPach]i ajpk`aQqlanreoeÅj/2mqalaniepeÅ mqa pn] p|j ` k oa  `a qj ej _ q i l hei ea j pk  mqa
h] i afkn] nac q h]pk ne]/3 u mqa atlnao]i ajpa _]hebemqa_ki kharau`ad]^anoa_knnace`kh]
P ar eo p]  a ` ep] ` ]  lkn ]hq i j k o `a h] D] _ q hp] `  `a B a na _ d k  `a h] S j er a no e` ] `  `a Jei ]

ej_knlkn] aj ah ej_eok b' `ah ]np~_qhk 2* _ki k _k j ` q _p] ]jpao `ah eje_ek`ah lnk _a` ei eaj pk 
lnej_elek h] oqlanreoeÅj kneajp]`] ] neaocko* o]j_ekj]`kn*oalk`n|`eolkjanah]n_derk`ah
oacÇj h] _q]h oaÄ]h] mqa8 QÂÍ ĘI ĘĤĘİĔĠĔĠĨ ĖĘ IĨ a t l a ` ea j pa /4,

/1, ?hnaola_pk*r}]oah]ojkp]o`alnajo]ajahlknp]hejopepq_ekj]h8:sss,kab],ck^,la<,

/2, Pach]iajpk `a QqlanreoeÅj ]lnk^]`k lkn Paokhq_eÅj LÑ ..3+0..5+MCD?* `a ba_d] 1. `a ajank `a 0./5*
ik`ebe_]`klknPaokhq_eÅjLÑ..5+0..5+MCD?+ABuPaokhq_eÅjLÑ./6+0./5+MCD?+AB,

/3, J]]lnk^]_eÅj `ah Pach]iajpk`aQqlanreoeÅj `afÅoej aba_pkah Pach]iajpk`aQqlanreoeÅj Bena_p]* ]lnk^]`k


lkn Paokhq_eÅj `a Akjoafk Bena_perk L Ñ./4+0./3+MCD?-AB9 ah Pach]iajpk l]n] h] oq^o]j]_eÅj rkhqjp]ne] `a
ej_qilheieajpko `a iajkn pn]o_aj`aj_e]* ]lnk^]`k lkn Paokhq_eÅj `a Akjoafk Bena_perk LÑ.24+0./1+MCD?-
AB9 ah Pach]iajpk `a QqlanreoeÅj ?i^eajp]h* ]lnk^]`k ia`e]jpa Paokhq_eÅj `a Akjoafk Bena_perk L Ñ .27+
0./3+MCD?-AB9 u ah Pach]iajpk `a QqlanreoeÅj `a Cjpe`]`ao `a Deo_]hev]_eÅj ?i^eajp]h* ]lnk^]`k ia`e]jpa
Paokhq_eÅj`aAkjoafkBena_perkLÑ./4+0./2+MCD?-AB*mqa]haop]n`eolanokojk^nej`]^]jh]]`a_q]`]_h]ne`]`
jeajpaj`eieajpk]hafan_e_ek`ah]bqj_eÅj,

/4 Pach]iajpk`aQqlanreoeÅj8

?np~_qhk/3,+Qk^nah]oq^o]j]_eÅju_h]oebe_]_eÅj`ahkoej_qilheieajpko,

53,58T R^]U^a\ XSPS R^] [^ TbcPQ[TRXS^ T] T[ ?XcTaP[ U# ST[ 5aclRd[^ *-- ST[ GTgc^ w]XR^ BaST]PS^ ST [P ?Th Ap */,,,
% ?Th ST[ Ca^RTSX\XT]c^ 5 S\ X]XbcaPcXe^ ;T]TaP[$ P_a^QPS^ _ ^ a 8TRaTc^ Fd_aT\^ Ap ((.%*()/%>HF$ bX T[ PS\ X]XbcaPS^
PRaTSXcP [P bdQbP]PRXn] e^[d]cPaXP ST[ X]Rd\ _[X\ XT]c^ P]cTb ST[ X]XRX^ ST[ _a^RTSX\XT]c^ PS\ X]XbcaPcXe^ bP]RX^]PS^a$
bT SXb_^]Saj T[ PaRWXe^ ST[ Tg_TSXT]cT ST bd_TaeXbXn] T] TbcT TgcaT\^&

)-&* ?^b aT`dTaX\XT]c^b TUTRcdPS^b _^a [P 5dc^aXSPS ST Fd_TaeXbXn] ^ T[ bd_TaeXb^a \TSXP]cT [^b RdP[Tb SXb_^]VP
d]P PRcdPRXn] eX]Rd[PSP P[ X]Rd\ _[X\ XT]c^ ST d]P ^Q[XVPRXn]$ PRPaaTP] [P _kaSXSP ST[ RPajRcTa e^[d]cPaX^ ST [P
aTUTaXSP PRcdPRXn] `dT PRaTSXcT T[ PS\X]XbcaPS^& 9gRT_RX^]P[\T]cT$ T] RPb^ T[ X]Rd\ _[X\ XT]c^ RP[XUX`dT R^\^ [TeT h
T[ PS\ X]XbcaPS^ PRaTSXcT P]cTb ST[ X]XRX^ ST[ _a^RTSX\XT]c^ PS\ X]XbcaPcXe^ bP]RX^]PS^a [P R^aaTRRXn] ST [P R^]SdRcP
aT`dTaXSP _^a [P 5 dc^aXSPS ST Fd_TaeXbXn] ^ T[ bd_TaeXb^a$ [P Pdc^aXSPS R^aaTb_^]SXT]cT _^Saj SXb_^]Ta T[ PaRWXe^ ST[
Tg_TSXT]cT T] TbcT TgcaT\^&

)-&+ ?^b X]Rd\ _[X\ XT]c^b STcTRcPS^b bT R[PbXUXRP] T]2

P# =]Rd\_[X\XT]c^b [TeTb2 F^] P`dT[[^b `dT X]e^[dRaP]2 "X# d] aXTbV^ [TeT3 ^ "XX# X]Rd\_[X\XT]c^b ST d]P ^Q[XVPRXn] ST
5 8 I B 7 5 G H F  /13

RPajRcTa U^a\ P[ d ^caP `dT ]^ RPdbT SPm^ ^ _TaYdXRX^&

Q# =]Rd\_[X\XT]c^b caPbRT]ST]cTb2 F^] P`dT[[^b `dT X]e^[dRaP]2 "X# d] SPm^ P [P eXSP h'^ [P bP[dS ST [Pb _Tab^]Pb3 "XX# d]
SPm^ P [P U[^aP h '^ UPd]P3 "XXX# d] aXTbV^ bXV]XUXRPcXe^ ^ \^STaPS^3 ^$ "Xe# X]Rd\_[X\XT]c^b ST d]P ^Q[XVPRXn] ST RPajRcTa
U^a\ P[ d ^caP$ `dT RPdbT SPm^ ^ _TaYdXRX^&

CPaP [P STcTa\X]PRXn] ST[ aXTbV^ bT P_[XRPaj [P @Tc^S^[^VlP _PaP [P TbcX\PRXn] ST[ aXTbV^ P\QXT]cP[ `dT VT]TaP T[ X]Rd\_[X\XT]c^
ST [Pb ^Q[XVPRX^]Tb UXbRP[XiPQ[Tb _aTeXbcP T] T[ 5]Tg^ ,$ `dT U^a\P _PacT X]cTVaP]cT ST[ _aTbT]cT ETV[P\T]c^&

+10 Raoou Rknnao Q|j_dav


Copk l ani epa ej _kl k n]n h] n]v k j ] ^ ehe` ] ` /5 u h]k^hec]_eÅjej_qi lhe`]lqa`aoan`a_]n|_pan
lnklkn_ekj]he`]` ] h] p]na] `a beo_]hev]_eÅj* bkni]hk`akpnkpelk, 6
lkn_q]jpk_ki ku] daiko`e_dkaoqoq]hmqa TH
h]o_kj`q_p]oejbn]_pkn]ojkoad]u]jr]hkn]`k Cj ]i ^ko oqlqaopko* ah ej _ q i l hei ea j pk  ao ;D
O,
]`a_q]`]i ajpauoejd]^anpaje`kaj_qajp]h] pn]o_aj`ajpaokhkoe_]qo]`]Äkklanfqe_ek,Copa AM
;D
]ba_p]_eÅjmqaaopkoej_qi lhei eajpkocajan]j* `]Äk k lanfqe_ek jk aop| nabane`k ] hko ^eajao
BCPCAFM
fqn~`e_kolnkpace`ko+bhkn]ub]qj]*re`]uo]hq` KGLCPM*
h] _kjoa_qaj_e] lnareop] ao h] o]j_eÅj* hk mqa ?K@GCLR?J
TBCJMQ
k^hec] ] h] ]`i ejeopn]_eÅj ] ]oecj]n na_qnoko `ah]olanokj]o+u]i aj_ekj]`koajah]np~_qhk PCASPQMQ
CLCPEyRGAMQ
l]n]_kj_hqenajiqhp]oiq_d]ora_aoenneokne]o, ^]fk _ki ajp]nek* oejk ] hko i a_]jeoi ko mqa
`eolkjaah Cop]`kl]n]]oacqn]noq lnkpa__eÅj,
N]n]qj]]`a_q]`]lkj`an]_eÅj`ah]o_kj`q_ò R]haoah_]ok`ahkoej_qilheieajpkorej_qh]`ko
p]o* oa d] ah]^kn]`k qj] i apk`khkc~] l]n] h] ] h] abe_]_e] `a h] beo_]hev]_eÅj ]i ^eajp]h mqa
aopei]_eÅj`ahjerah`aneaock]i^eajp]hmqacaò c ajan]j lanfqe_ek ]h Ål pei k afan_e_ek `a h]o
jan]ah ej_qi lhei eajpk`aqj]k^hec]_eÅj*mqa bqj_ekjao `a beo_]hev]_eÅj ]i ^eajp]h* _kj h]o
e-e
peaja_ki k^]oahkoheja]i eajpkoaop]^ha_e`ko _q]hao oa ^qo_] ]oacqn]n ah _qi lhei eajpk `a D:
ée
aj h]Eq~] `a Cr]hq]_eÅj `aPeaock?i^eajp]h* h]o k^hec]_ekjao ]i ^eajp]hao beo_] hev ] na o, ?h :
0
lq^he_]`] lknah Kejeopanek`ah ?i ^eajpaajah lnaoajp]noaahnabane`klanfqe_ek*aopaej_qi lheò M
S
]Äk0.//*h]_q]hoaoqopajp]ajh] Lkni] Cqnkò i eajpkaopn]o_aj`ajpa, :
v
la]SLC/3...60..6*aiepe`]lknh]?ok_e]_eÅj ##
;D
Col]Äkh] `a Lkni ]hev]_eÅj Aanpebe_]_eÅj +aj J] Decqn] 2 &l|cej] oec qeaj pa' aomqai ]pev] AÁ

]`ah]jpa* ?CLMP +, ah bhqfk `a `a_eoeÅj ]jpa lnaoqjpko ej_qi lheò M
F
1
ieajpko, :
Ch jerah `a neaockaop] ]ok_e]`k ] h] lnk^]^eheò
`]``ah]k_qnnaj_e]`ahlahecnkk]iaj]v]mqa A]^a`aop]_]nmqah] i apk`khkc~] d]oe`kpn]oò
cajan] ah ej _qi lhei eajpk u h] _kjoa_qaj_e] h]`]`] ] qj ]lhe_]perk ]h mqa oa]__a`a `ao`a
mqaaopada_dkpaj`n~]ok^naahajpknjkj]pqò ah lknp]h ejopepq_ekj]h/7 u mqa laniepa mqa hko
n]h udqi ]jk, ]`iejeopn]`ko d]c]j oqo lnkleko afan_e_eko `a
r]hkn]_eÅj*bknp]ha_e}j`koa]o~h]lna`e_pe^ehe`]`,
?o~* jk okhk oa `apani ej] ah neaock ]i^eajp]h*
oejk oa aopei ] _q]h ao ah jerah mqa ]h_]jv]8 d' Nnkbaoekj]heoik,
hara k oecjebe_]perk, N]n] ahhk ao ja_ao]nek mqa
ah oqlanreokn k^pajc] ejbkni ]_eÅj ok^na h]o ?bej`a]oacqn]nui ]jpajanh]o_]l]_e`]`aou
_kjoa_qaj_e]o `a hko ej_qi lhei eajpko ok^na _ki lapaj_e]o* jk oÅhk `ah lanokj]h `ah MCD?*
hko _ki lkjajpao `ah ]i ^eajpa* h] bhkn]* b]qj] oejk `a kpnko ]_pknao nahar]jpao mqa _kjpne^qò
u lanokj]o mqa lq`eankj oan ]ba_p]`ko lkn ah uaju]lknp]jajahafan_e_ek`ah]obqj_ekjao`a
ej_qi lhei eajpk `a h] k^hec]_eÅj* _qi lheaj`k beo_]hev]_eÅj* oa _naÅ h] ?_]`ai e] `a Deo_]hev]ò
_kj ahhk _kj ah lnej_elek `a napnk]hei ajp]_eÅj _eÅj?i ^eajp]h+aj]`ah]jpa ?D? +,
`ah]bqj_eÅj`abeo_]hev]_eÅj,
J]?D?^qo_]bknp]ha_anh]o_]l]_e`]`ao*^nej`]jò
:
Sj oac q j`k lqjpk ao ah nah]_ekj]`k _kj ah `kqj]atlaneaj_e]`a]lnaj`ev]faajbk_]`]aj S
D:
`]Äk k lanfqe_ek ]jpa ah ej _qi l hei eajpk `a ahafan_e_ekln|_pe_k]pn]r}o`aoanre_ekoa`q_]peò ?J
e-h
k^hec]_ekjaobkni]hao q kpn]o,R]jpk aj hko ejò rkoaola_e]hev]`ko_kjh]bej]he`]``aa`q_]n`a ;D

_qilheieajpkoharao_ki kajhkopn]o_aj`ajpao* bkni]d|^eha~jpacn]ajbeo_]hev]_eÅj]i^eajp]h,

JM
n<

/5, Akiajp]nek ]l]npa iana_a h] ik`ebe_]_eÅj ejpnk`q_e`] aj h] Jau Eajan]h `ah Nnk_a`eieajpk ?`iejeopn]perk Ö
mqa _kjoe`an] _kik ateiajpa `a naolkjo]^ehe`]` h] _knna__eÅj rkhqjp]ne] `a h] _kj`q_p] ejbn]_pkn] ]jpao`ah
eje_ek`ahlnk_a`eieajpko]j_ekj]`kn*aj_kjpn]raj_eÅjé `ao`ajqaopnklqjpk`areop]é ]hlnklekNnej_elek`a
0
P]vkj]^ehe`]`aop]^ha_e`kaj`e_dk_qanlkhac]hmqaaop]^ha_amqajk`a^anaoqhp]ni]orajp]fkok]h ejbn]_pkn
%
O
ejbnejcenmqa]oqienh]o_kjoa_qaj_e]o`aoqo]_pko,

Nnej_eleko `a qj] beo_]hev]_eÅj aba_per]u oq ]lhe_]_eÅj lknah knc]jeoik`a ar]hq]_eÅj ubeo_]hev]_eÅj]i^eajp]h+MCD?
DGESP? 2, Dhqfk`apki]`a`a_eoekjao`ah] Bena__eÅj`aQqlanreoeÅjMCD?/6,
P areop] a ` ep] ` ]  lkn ] hq i j k o `a h] D ] _ q hp] `  `a B a na _d k  `a h] S j er a no e` ] `  `a Jei ]

e' Papnk]hei ajp]_eÅj aj l nk c naok  h] ei l ha i a j p] _ eÅ j  `a p a _ j k ò


hkc~]o `a ejbkni ]_eÅj mqa _kj pne^ q u]j  _kj
AkikoaÄ]h|n]ikolnare]iajpa*h]_]he`]`nacq+ _kjp]n_kj `]p] aj h~ja] `a h]o oqlanreoekjao
h]pkne]jkoeailnaaoh]e`Åja]u*]qjmqahkbqan]* _kj h] bej]he` ]`  `a a r] hq ] n l aneÅ ` e_] i aj pa 
`a^ana]hev]noaahikjepknakuh]ar]hq]_eÅjmqa ah _q i l hei ea j pk  `a h] nacqh]_eÅj u _k i l nk ò
ei lkja qj ]`a_q]`k _e_hk `a bkniqh]_eÅj `a ieoko ]i ^eajp]hao u lk` an napnk]hei ajp]n h]
lkh~pe_]olÇ^he_]o*l]n]mqa] l]npen`ahkonaoqhò beo_]hev]_eÅjp]j pk _kjahQeopai ] L ]_ekj]h`a
p]`ko oa] lkoe^ha r]he`]n k nalajo]n h] kl_eÅj Cr]hq]_eÅj`aGi l]_pk? i ^eajp]h_ki kah`a
nacqh]pkne]ãilhaiajp]`], EaopeÅj ?i ^eajp]h,

?_pq]hi ajpa* oa aop| `ao]nnkhh]j`k qj oeopaò J] Decqn]3*iqaopn] h] nah]_eÅjajpnahkolnej_eò
i] `a naceopnk `a ejbkni ]_eÅj ^|oe_] `a h] leko]jpaoiaj_ekj]`koajahi]n_k`ahlnk_aok
oq l a nreoeÅ j 9 ] ` e_ ek j ] hi a j pa * oa a j _q a j pn] `aoqlanreoeÅjubeo_]hev]_eÅj,

DGESP? 3,
Gjpan]__eÅj`ahkolnej_elekol]n] qj]beo_]hev]_eÅjaba_per]0.,

á Ah]ne`]`aj hko
lnk_a`eieajpko
á Cre`aj_e]
á Cjbkmqa`a e
neaock
á Nnkbaoekj]heoik
5 8 I B 7 5 G H F  /13

/6, Dqajpauah]^kn]_eÅj8MCD?,

/7, K|oejbkni]_eÅjaj8:dppl8--sss,kab],]k^,la-]reoko-aopei]_ekj+neao]ko<,

0., Dqajpa8ah]^kn]_eÅjlnkle],

+12 Raoou Rknnao Q|j_dav


Cj^]oa]hkatlqaopk*_]^a`aop]_]nmqahkopna_a unapnk]hei ajp]_eÅjl]n]_na]nah_e_hkrenpqkok
lnej_elekoajhkomqaoaaji]n_]qj]beo_]hev]_eÅj `ah lnk_aok `abeo_]hev]_eÅj, 6
aba_per]ejpan]_pÇ]jajpnao~*_kilhaiajp]j`kqj K
_~n_qhkrenpqkok`ahi]_nklnk_aok`abeo_]hev]_eÅj, M CD?  r ea j a  ] l he_ ] j ` k  ` e_d k o  l nej _ el ek o  u ;D
O,
`ao]nnkhh] ah i ]_nk lnk_aok `a beo_]hev]_eÅj ;>
ĂC
GT, AMLAJSQGMLCQ `ai ]jan] k l k npqj ]uoaha_per]_kj ^]oa] h]
BCPCAFM
are`aj_e]*paj eaj`kaj_qajp]h]o_]n]_pan~opeò KGLCPM*
?K@GCLR?J
WBCJMQ
J]ejpanraj_eÅjlÇ^he_]]pn]r}o`ahafan_e_ek`a _]o lnkle]o`a_]`]]_pere` ]` u]`i ejeopn]`k PCASPQMQ
CLCPEyRGAMQ
h]beo_]hev]_eÅjaobqj`]i ajp]hl]n]r]he`]nh]naò u *`a i ]jan] _kk n`ej]`]* ajpna hko `eranoko
cqh]_eÅju]oacqn]noqabe_]_e]*uaj_kjoa_qajò beo_]hev]`knao ] i ^ ea j p] ha o  _kj a j bk m q a  `a
_e]*]h_]jv]nhkok^faperko`alkh~pe_] lnareopko, neaock,

J] M A B C d] ` a o ] nnk hh] ` k  qj _ k j fq j pk  `a Jk]jpanekn`a^a_kilhaiajp]noa_kj h] iafkn]


l nej _ el ek o  l]n] qj] beo _ ] hev ] _ eÅ j  a ba _ per ]  aj h] `ebqoeÅj `a h] ejbkni]_eÅj mqa oacajana
ajpna hko mqa nao]hp]j8 beo_]hev]_eÅj aj ^]oa `ao`a ah MCD? u ah QGLCD? + Qeopai] L]_ekj]h
] are`aj_e]* oaha_pere`]`* ajbkmqa `a neaock* `a`aCr]hq]_eÅjuDeo_]hev]_eÅj?i^eajp]h +9]o~
reoeÅj `a h]nck lh]vk* lnkbaoekj]heoi k*pn]joò _kik_kjahbknp]ha_eieajpk`ah]oaopn]pace]o`a
l]naj_e]* lnki k_eÅj `ah _q i lhei eajpk* ] hko _qilheieajpk]`e_ekj]hao]hafan_e_ek`ah]lkpaoò
mqa oa]Ä]`aj  hko lnej_eleko`aklk npqj e`]` p]`o]j_ekj]`kn], ĘÍ
ĐĄ
RR
M

:

U
-
%O

Nnej_eleko`aqj] beo_]hev]_eÅj aba_per]uoq ]lhe_]_eÅj lknah knc]jeoik`aar]hq]_eÅj ubeo_]hev]_eÅj ]i^eajp]h+MCD? +13

You might also like