Professional Documents
Culture Documents
538-Article Text-847-1-10-20201222
538-Article Text-847-1-10-20201222
cost. However, these alternative feed substitution of the complete feed did not
materials are not nutritionally balanced and modify biochemical and haematological
not always available all-year-round. parameters but caused an improvement in
Another option available to pig farmers is animal welfare and production of milk.
offering concentrate diet to their pigs to Sharif et al. (2013) observed increased
boost weight gain, this is however not digestibility by using sprouted grain in the
sustainable as a result of its high cost. There diet of broilers and large animals. Addition
is therefore a continuous search for diet of sprouted grain also improved milk yield
replacements or substitutes that will meet up to 8.7% in ruminant animals (Stür et al.,
the nutritional requirements of the animals 2006).
with all year round availability and which Maize grain is a good choice for production
are less expensive to ensure higher of hydroponics fodder due to its
economic gain for farmers. availability, low cost, good biomass
One of the possible ways of solving this production and quick growing habit.
problem of feed scarcity in the pig industry Hydroponically grown maize fodder can be
is through the exploration of the a better replacement or supplement for
hydroponic system to grow forages to be scarce feed stuffs because of its high
fed to pigs. Hydroponics is a technique for nutritive value, high digestibility and all
growing plants without using soil. It is a year round availability (Suraj et al., 2016).
technology for growing plants in nutrient Pigs are prolific monogastrics which have
solutions that supply all nutrient elements great ability in converting feed from various
needed for optimum plant growth with or sources into animal products. However,
without the use of an inert medium such as when pigs are not well fed from the early
gravel, vermiculite, rock wool, peat moss, stage of their life, it may have negative
saw dust, coir dust, coconut fibre etc to effect on their weight at maturity.
provide mechanical support (Aatif et al., Therefore, this research was carried out to
2014). It has been recognised as a viable d et er m i n e t he eff ec t o f f e ed i n g
method of producing vegetables (tomatoes, hydroponically grown maize forage on the
lettuce, cucumbers and peppers) as well as performance of weaned pigs.
ornamental crops such as herbs, roses,
freesia and foliage plants. Different types Materials and methods
of fodder crops such as barley (Reddy et al., Experimental site
1988), oats, wheat (Snow et al., 2008); The study was carried out at the Piggery
sorghum, alfalfa, cowpea (AI-Karaki and Unit of the Teaching and Research Farm,
AI-Hashimi, 2012) and maize (Naik et al., University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria. The
2011; Naik et al., 2012a) can be produced farm is situated in Southern Nigeria at
by hydroponics technology. Weldegerima 70201N, 30501E at an altitude of 200-300m
( 20 15) r epo r t ed t hat f eedi n g of above sea level.
hydroponically grown maize and barley Production of hydroponics maize fodder
fodder to growing goats increased the total The production of hydroponic maize fodder
dry matter intake, feed conversion was conducted under natural illumination at
efficiency, body weight gain and was the growth chamber of the project site. The
economically valid. Also, Miscera et al. chamber is composed of metal frame and
(2009) reported that the integration of shelves with plastic trays (56cm x 40cm
lactating Comisana sheep diet with x7cm) used for growing maize seeds. Clean
hydroponically germinating oat in partial seeds of maize were washed and soaked in
97
Adebiyi, Adefila and Adeshola
tap water for 20h and then distributed in with similar weights were grouped into
trays at 500g of maize seeds per tray. Trays three treatments with three replicates each
were irrigated manually with organic and four pigs per replicate. Pigs were fed ad
hydroponics nutrient solution twice daily libitum and cool clean water was also
(07:30hr and 17:30hr) at a fixed rate of 250 provided. The experiment lasted eight
ml/tray/day using a spray gun. The seed weeks. Pigs were housed in properly
sprouts were grown for a period of 7 days. disinfect ed pens and al l routi ne
The fully grown fodder was thereafter management practices were strictly
harvested and fed to the pigs as whole feed. observed. Treatment 1 was 50%
Samples of the green fodder were taken to hydroponically grown maize fodder + 50%
determine the dry matter and nutrient co n cen t r a t e; Tr e at m e nt 2 ( 1 00 %
contents. hydroponically grown maize fodder) and
Experimental animals, feeding and Treatment 3 (100% basal diet). Note-basal
management diet composition was conceived based on
A total of 36 weaned pigs with average conventional choice of feed of many pig
weight of ±9.5kg were purchased from a farmers. Such feed were fed without
reputable farm in Ibadan, Oyo state, addition of concentrate that might provide
Nigeria. After adaptation for 2 weeks, pigs possible nutrients balance for the animals.)
Table 1: Gross composition of experimental concentrate feed
Ingredient Inclusion (%)
Maize 43.00
Soyabean meal 15.00
Wheat offal 15.00
Groundnut cake 7.00
Palm kernel cake 15.00
Palm oil 3.00
Limestone 1.25
Salt 0.50
Premix 0.25
Total 100.00
Calculated Nutrients
Crude protein (%) 19.03
Metabolizable energy (Kcal/kg) 2905.20
calculated using the formula: and means were separated using Duncan
Apparent Digestibility (%) = Multiple Range Test of the same software
(Nutrient in feed – Nutrient in faeces) x100 package.
Nutrient in feed
Feeding costs was estimated by recording Results and discussion
the cost of basal and concentrate diets, Proximate composition of hydroponics
maize seed, hydroponics nutrient, labour maize fodder
etc per kg of diet and fodder grown. Proximate composition of hydroponics
Blood samples for haematological analysis maize fodder used in this experiment is
was collected into EDTA-sample bottles shown in Table 3. The average DM content
and analysed for packed cell volume of hydroponic maize fodder (HMF) was
(PCV), haemoglobin, red blood cell (RBC), 25.00%. Lower % DM of HMF is due to the
white blood cell (WBC), lymphocytes, large uptake of water which initiated an
monocytes, eosinophils and neutrophils increase in metabolic activity of resting
according to methods described by Sastri seeds and led to complete loss of dry weight
(1985) while blood samples for serum (starch) during germinating cycles of
biochemical analysis was collected into hydroponic fodder (Naik et al., 2014).
plain sample bottles and allowed to clot at Closely related result was observed by
room temperature. The clotted samples Thadchanamoorthy et al. (2012) with HMF
were spun in a centrifuge to separate the of 26.07% DM. The crude protein content
blood cells from the serum and this was observed in HMF was 13.75% highly
analysed for serum total protein, serum superior as compared to 8.7-10% in maize
glucose, serum total cholesterol, urea, seed. Sprouting alters the amino acid profile
albumin, creatinine, Aspartate Amino of maize seeds and increases the crude
Transferase (AST) and Alanine Amino protein content of hydroponic fodder
Transferase (ALT). Serum total protein was (Morsy et al., 2013). In this study, ether
determined using the SP400UV/VIS extract of HMF was 3.55% which was
spectrophotometer (Lowry et al., 1951), slightly higher than the result obtained by
serum glucose and serum total cholesterol Naik et al. (2013) which ranged from 3.27-
concentrations were determined using 3.49% but was lower than the observed
colorimetric procedure (Lindner and Mann, value (6.42%) by Thadchanamoorthy et al.
1960). Albumin was analysed using (2012). Similar results (1.75-3.80%) were
bromocresol green method (Doumaset al., reported by Naik et al. (2013). NFE value
1971) while aspartate amino transferase (60.72%) was lower than what was
(AST) and alanine amino transferase (ALT) observed by Singh (2011) which ranged
activities were determined using the from 66.7-75.3%. The crude fibre content
method of Reitman and Frankel (1957). (14.77%) was however comparable to the
Experimental design and statistical value (14.10%) obtained Naik et al. (2013).
analysis Cuddeford (1989) noted that the increase in
The experimental design was a completely the crude fibre of hydroponics maize fodder
randomized design. Data were subjected to is due to the buildup of cellulose, varied
Analysis of Variance of SAS (2010) at α0.05 proportions of hemicelluloses and lignin.
99
Adebiyi, Adefila and Adeshola
Table 3: Proximate composition of hydroponics maize fodder
Parameters Percentage (%)
Dry Matter 25.00
Crude Protein 13.75
Ether Extract 3.55
Crude Fibre 14.77
Ash 3.33
Nitrogen Free Extract 60.72
Nutrient digestibility and performance of Significant differences (P<0.05) were
weaned pigs fed hydroponics maize fodder observed among the treatments in feed
Nutrient digestibility of pigs fed intake, final body weight, weight gain and
hydroponics maize fodder is shown in Table FCR of the pigs. Significantly higher values
4. Significant differences (P<0.05) were (P<0.05) for final weight (13.83 kg), feed
observed in the digestibility of nutrients in intake (12.79 kg) and weight gain (3.83 kg)
all the dietary treatments. T1 had higher were observed in T3 closely followed by
(P<0.05) crude protein digestibility T2. However, T1 had the highest FCR (3.68
(65.76%) while the lowest (55.27%) was kg), followed by T3 (3.38 kg). Least values
observed in T2, same trend was observed in were observed for T2 in all parameters.
crude fibre digestibility. Ether extract Difference was also observed in feed cost
digestibility was highest (P<0.05) in T2 among the treatments with T1 having
(68.43%) and lowest in T3 (65.47%) while highest cost (61.96 ₦/kg) closely followed
ash digestibility was highest (P<0.05) for T2 (53.73 ₦/kg). Feed cost/weight gain for
T3 (46.08%) and T2 had the lowest T1 (228.01 ₦/kg) was relatively higher than
(42.41%) ash digestibility. T3 (166.60 ₦/kg) while T2 recorded a
Table 5 shows the growth performance and negative ratio as loss of weight was
cost analysis of diets fed to weaned pigs. observed in pigs fed 100% HMF diet.
If pigs are to fully express their potential for observed by Reddy et al. (1988) for rations
weight gain, feed intake must meet their containing hydroponically sprouted grains.
nutritional requirement. Though, the The non-significant difference observed for
experimental pigs were selected at random, FCR in pigs fed basal diet and combination
they had almost the same live weight at the of HMF and concentrate diet showed that
beginning of the experiment. At the end of although at a slightly higher price,
the experiment, pigs in T1 and T3 had hydroponic maize fodder in combination
similar weight gains while feeding of with concentrate can be substituted for
hydroponics maize fodder reduced the total basal diet during scarcity of the basal
dry matter intake of the pigs. This is in ingredients without loss of weight of pigs
support of the findings of Naik et al. (2014) which could result to economic loss to the
who reported a decrease in the dry matter farmer. The cost of producing hydroponic
intake of the animals due to dry matter loss fodders is mainly influenced by the seed
in hydroponic sprouts which resulted in low cost and the cost of hydroponic solution as
performance of the animals. During they contribute about 90% of the total cost
sprouting, starch is catabolised to soluble of production (Naik et al., 2012b).
sugars for supporting the metabolism and Haematology and serum biochemistry of
energy requirement of the growing plants weaned pigs fed hydroponic maize fodder
for respiration and cell wall synthesis, Haematology and serum biochemisty of
therefore, any decrease in the amount of weaned pigs fed diets containing HMF is
starch causes a corresponding decrease in presented in Table 6 and 7, respectively.
dry matter and organic matter (Naik et al., Significant differences (P<0.05) were
2014). Early researchers found lower observed among the treatments for PCV,
weight gain when pigs were fed 10-day RBC, WBC, platelets, lymphocytes,
sprouted maize relative to ground maize, heterophils, eosinophils and basophils
but when beef cattle were fed with except for haemoglobin and monocytes
hydroponics green fodder, an average of (P>0.05). Similar values were obtained for
200g higher daily gain was obtained in PCV and lymphocytes in T1 and T2 while
comparison to those fed with a maize- higher values were obtained for RBC in T1
control diet (Leitch, 1939). Peer and Lesson and heterophils in T2. Lowest values were
(1985) found lower growth rate in pigs obtained in T2 for PCV, RBC and
when fed sprouted barley compared to lymphocytes. Significant differences
ground barley. Fazaeli et al. (2011) found (P<0.05) were also observed among the
no significant difference in live weight gain treatments for cholesterol, triglycerides,
or feed conversion efficiency between a LDL, VLDL, total protein, globulin and
fodder diet and a control diet, consisting of albumin for the serum biochemical indices,
barley grain. Farlin et al. (1971) also found while glucose and HDL showed no
no difference in performance of cattle fed (P>0.05) difference.
sprouted or non-sprouted grain. Haematological parameters are good
The cost of producing hydroponic maize indicators of the physiological changes in
fodder diets was higher than the cost of animals (Adenkola and Durotoye, 2004).
producing the basal diet. This therefore The blood consisting of blood cells and
translated into the high feed cost/weight plasma fulfil the transport, regulatory,
gain in animals fed the diets compared to protective and homeostatic functions
those fed the basal diet. This was also (Nasyrova et al., 2006). From the results of
101
Adebiyi, Adefila and Adeshola
haematological parameters in this study, the normal range of 8-13g/dl and 2-10%
haemoglobin and monocytes of the pigs fed respectively, as documented by Research
the different dietary treatments were within Animal Resources (2009).
Apart from the toxic constituent in a diet, a eosinophils and basophils of the pigs but all
key factor that has been documented to observed values fell within the normal
affect WBC counts and its differential physiological range reported by Research
component is the level of protein in the diet Animal Resources (2009).
(Unigwe et al., 2016). High level of protein Significant differences were observed in
was recorded in T3 resulting in low level of the values for serum cholesterol
white blood cell count in the treatment. concentration, total protein, globulin and
High levels of WBCs in blood indicate albumin of the pigs. There was a significant
increased antibody level with increased reduction in the serum triglycerides and
lymphocytes count (Frandson, 1986). VLDL concentrations with decreasing level
Significant differences were observed in of HMF in the diets.
RBC counts, lymphocytes, heterophils,
Table 7: Serum biochemistry of weaned pigs fed hydroponic maize fodder
Parameters T1 T2 T3 SEM
Glucose (mg/dl) 67.48 66.43 68.01 0.16
Cholesterol (mg/l) 93.64ab 95.38a 88.93b 0.64
Triglycerides (mg/dl) 148.50a 144.75a 136.10b 1.22
HDL (mg/dl) 50.37 47.02 57.41 1.02
LDL (mg/dl) 5.75b 5.82b 7.26a 0.16
a a
VLDL (mg/dl) 29.70 28.95 27.22b 0.11
Total Protein (g/dl) 5.75b 4.96c 6.82a 0.18
Globulin (g/dl) 3.09b 2.54c 3.71a 0.11
b b
Albumin (g/dl) 2.53 2.42 3.12a 0.07
ab
Means with different superscript on the same row are significantly different (p<0.05)
Treatment 1: Pigs fed 50% hydroponically grown maize fodder + 50% concentrate
Treatment 2: Pigs fed 100% hydroponically grown maize fodder
Treatment 3: Pigs fed 100% basal diet
HDL- High density lipoprotein LDL- Low density lipoprotein VLDL- Very low density lipoprotein
102
Hydroponic maize fodder and conventional basal diet on performance, digestibility and blood profile of weaned pigs
Lowry, O., Rosebrough, N., Farr, A. and 2014. Effect of feeding hydroponics
Randall, R. 1951. Protein maize fodder on digestibility of
measurement with folinepherol nutrients and milk production in
reagent. Journal of Biological lactating cows. Indian Journal of
Chemistry 193: 255-273. Animal Science84 (8): 880-883.
Marisco, G. Miscera, E. Dimatteo, S., Nasyrova, D. I. Y. A., Sapronova, A.,
Minuti, F. Vicenti, A. and Zarrilli, Nigmatullina, R. R. and Ugrumoy,
A. 2009. Evaluation of animal M. V. 2006. Changes in blood
welfare and milk production of goat plasma volume in rats during
fed on diet containing ontogenesis. Russian Journal of
hydroponically germinating seeds. Developmental Biology. 27: 1062-
Italian Journal of Animal Science 3604
8(2): 625-627. Peer, D. J. and Leeson, S. 1985. Feeding
Miscera, E., Ragni, M., Minuti, F., value of hydroponically sprouted
Rubino, G., Marisco, G. and barley for poultry and pigs. Animal
Zarrilli, A. 2009. Improvement of Feed Science Technology 13: 183-
sheep welfare and milk production 190.
fed on diet containing Perez, R. 1997. Feeding pigs in the tropics,
hydroponically germinating grains. FAO Animal production and Health
Italian Journal of Animal Science Paper. Rome. 132.
8(2): 634-636. Reddy, G. V. N., Reddy, M. R. and Reddy,
Morsy, A. T., Abul S. F. and Emam, M. S. K. K. 1988. Nutrient utilization by
A. 2013. Localized hydroponic milch cattle fed on rations containing
green forage technology as a climate artificially grown fodder. Indian
change adaptation under Egyptian Journal of Animal Nutrition 5(1):
condition. Journal of Agriculture 19-22.
and Biological Sciences 9 (6):341- Reitman, S. and Frankel, S. 1957.
350 Glutamic-pyruvate-transaminase
Naik, P. K. 2012a. Hydroponics assay by colorimetric method.
technology for fodder American Journal of Clinical
production.ICAR News.18: 4. Pathology, 28: 56.
Naik, P. K. 2012b. Effect of soaking time Research Animal Resource (RAR). 2009.
on yield of hydroponics maize Reference values for laboratory
fodder.(Un-published). animals: Normal haematological
Naik, P. K. 2013. Yield and dry matter values. RAR Websites, University of
content of hydroponics maize Minnesota. Retrieved from
sprouts (Un-published). http://www.ahc.umn.edu/rar/refvalu
Naik, P. K., Dhuri, R. B. and Singh, N. P. es.html.
2011. Technology for production and Sastri, G. 1985. Veterinary Clinical
feeding of hydroponics green Pathology. Salish Kumar Jain for
fodder.Extension Folder No. 45/ CBS Publishers and Distributors.
2011, ICAR Research Complex for Delhi -32, India.
Goa, Goa. Sharif, M., Hussain, A. and Subhani, M.
Naik, P. K., Dhuri, R. B., Karunakaran, 2013. Use of sprouted grain in the
M., Swain, B. K. and Singh, N. P. diets of poultry and ruminants.
104
Hydroponic maize fodder and conventional basal diet on performance, digestibility and blood profile of weaned pigs
105