Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 8

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)

Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017


ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

Farmers Participation in Irrigation


Management: The Case Study of Farmer
Organization Based Small-Scale Irrigation
Schemes in Trincomalee District Sri Lanka
Eng.M.T.M.Zuhail1 & Dr. Thanuja Ramachandra2
1
Divisional Irrigation Engineer, P/Irrigation Department, Trincomalee, Sri Lanka.
2
Senior Lecturer, Department of Building Economics, University of Moratuwa, Sri Lanka.

Abstract: The Agricultural policy of Sri Lanka gives 1. Introduction


high priority to the promotion of food sufficiency and
security through irrigated agriculture. The aim of Agricultural production in Sri Lanka is primarily
this study was to analyse major demographical, rain fed, so it depends on monsoonal seasonal
socio-economic and institutional factors influence rainfall. As a result, there are frequent failures of
the participation of farmers in small-scale irrigation. agricultural production. Irrigation has the potential to
The data were collected by distributing structured stabilize or improve the agricultural production and
questionnaire among farmers. The overall sample mitigate the negative impacts of variable or
size was 100 households, 50 from irrigation insufficient rainfall.
participant and 50 households from non-irrigation
participant. Trincomalee district consists of 11 This environmental degradation can reduce
divisions. Each division 5 households were selected agricultural productivity, which in turn worsens food
for irrigation participants and 5 for non- irrigation insecurity and poverty. In order to cater the growing
participants using stratified random sampling. The food demand, some proportion of the pressure could
respondents’ individual characteristics; labour be met by increasing productivity rather than
force, extension service and distance to water source extensive agriculture. The three methods to increase
had strong statistically significant relationship with food production are increasing agricultural yield per
the irrigation participation and age, gender, access a given plot, increasing the area of arable land, and
to market, and credit facilities had moderately increasing cropping intensity (number of crops per
significant relationship. On the other hand, size of year). According to previous studies (Nhundu et al
cultivated land, education did not have a statistically [5], Gebremedhin and Peden [3], Hussain [4])
significant relationship with the irrigation irrigation increases agricultural productivity and
participation. Hence, the study suggests that farm income per hectare. It insulates the national
communities need to put emphasis on implementing agricultural economic sector against weather-related
projects by involving farmers in irrigation shocks and provides a more stable basis for
participation. Extension services such as advice, economic growth and poverty reduction. It supports
training, and demonstration should be made the process of transforming traditional method of
available to farmers by providing the required agriculture into market oriented production of high
assistance to agricultural related projects. value crops (Asfaw [2]).
Communities need to be encouraged to establish
saving and credit facilities to help them finance The present irrigation systems operate under a
agricultural related activities and in addition, different social, economic and political system. The
governments should establish organized marketing performance of work in the present system is on the
channels. basis of wage labour and not on the principle of
‘Rajakariya’. Although the basic infrastructure
Keywords: Farmers; Small-scale Irrigation; (tanks, paddy lands, highland including settlements
Irrigation participants; Non-irrigation participants; and network of irrigation) was essentially the same,
Trincomalee. new dimensions have been adopted to the recent
constructions in response to external demands (ARTI
[1]). Farmers are merely concerned about receiving
water for their farm plots. Their knowledge about
characteristics of the irrigation system,

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 323


Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)
Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017
ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

administrative resources and water availability in the


tank is meager. The main reason for this is the lack The Trincomalee District is located in the Eastern
of effective communication between the farmers and Province, covering an area of 2,728 square
officers engaged in irrigation system management. A kilometers. The district has been divided into 11
well-organized Farmer Organization (FO) can play a Divisional secretariat Divisions. The DS Divisions
major role in connecting the communication gap are further sub-divided into 230 Grama Niladhari
between the farmers and the system operators. Divisions. As per the 2012 census, the total
population is 378,182. Among its population, 42
The Farmer Organization are functioning in almost percent are Muslims, while the Sinhalese and Tamils
all irrigation systems for a long time. These FOs are consist of 26 percent and 31 percent respectively.
held responsible for organizing the maintenance
work on the channels as well as the tank bund and
other structures. Operation and maintenance of
channels include cutting shrubs or weeding and earth
work on channels, lubricating and painting sluice
gates and clearing the spillway and turnouts. They
are also responsible for implementing the decisions
made at the cultivation meetings (Kanne meeting).
However, most of the FOs do not fulfill the
expectations regarding the operation and
maintenance of the irrigation works because of the
internal and external factors (Sivayoganathan et al
[6]).

More importantly, in Trincomalee district, where this


Figure 1: Coverage of Study Area
study has to be conducted, studies are scantly and
there no published works on the factors that
The major source of livelihood of the community is
determine farmers’ participation in small-scale
the agriculture and fishing. Paddy cultivation stands
irrigation and its effects. To fill this knowledge gap it
as the main agriculture crop in the District. The
needs to be backed up with research. Hence, this
Kanthale Tank, Wendrasawewa, Morewewa,
study addresses the potential incentives that promote
Mahadiwulwewa, and Galmittiyawa tank are some
small holder farm households participation and the
major tanks. There are three major irrigation
factors affects the irrigation participation in small-
projects; Kanthale, Alla Kanthale and Morewewa.
scale irrigation schemes. In general, there exists little
Livestock & cattle breeding is another livelihood. As
empirical evidence related to the determinants of
Trincomalee is one of the world renowned coast and
participation in small-scale irrigation and its effects.
tourist destination, tourism industry is another
Therefore, this study is aimed at primarily
important economic activity. Because of its excellent
identifying, analysing and documenting the
natural harbour and strategic positioning,
demographical, socio-economic and institutional
international companies like Prima Ceylon and
factors affecting the farmers’ participation in small-
Tokyo Cement, IOC have located their
scale irrigation. This would provide a base for policy
manufacturing plants and distribution centres at
makers and gives directions for further research,
Trincomalee.
extension and development schemes that will benefit
the schemes beneficiaries.
3. Methodology
2. Study Area Quantitative method of research approach was
applied for this study. Quantitative research approach
Trincomalee district, an attractive city with a
was adopted by statistical descriptive analysis such
natural harbour, attractive beauty, and military,
as frequency, percentage, chi-square test.
commercial and historical importance, is situated in
the Eastern coast of Sri Lanka. Trincomalee District
3.1. Data Collection
is surrounded by Mulaithivu District in North,
Anuradhapura District in West and Polonnaruwa and For this study both primary and secondary sources
Batticaloa Districts in South. Trincomalee history had been gathered to collect the quantitative data.
goes back to a time of ancient. The Mahavamsa & The conventional household survey was the main
Chulavamsa, the two great chronicles, mention the method used to collect quantitative primary
present Trincomalee as “Gokanna”, Gokarna, and information through a carefully designed structured
“Gonagamaka” during the Anuradhapura and questionnaire which was prepared for the study.
Polonnaruwa periods of island’s history. Information pertaining to households’ demographic,

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 324


Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)
Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017
ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

socio-economic characteristics and institutional institutional factors affecting farmers’ participation


situations were obtained directly through the in small-scale irrigation", the factors identified from
interview of sample household heads were the unit of first objective were taken as the hypothesis and those
analysis. Pre-testing of the questionnaire was carried factors were analysed using descriptive statistical
out and depending on the results, some adjustments techniques such as frequency, percentage and chi-
have been made to the final version of the square test. Those results were summarized and the
questionnaire and proper data collection was started. number of respondent (frequency) in each category
My personal observation of the site helped me to irrigation participant and non-participant and total
understand the over-all process of irrigation sample household were tabulated and presented with
development and data gathered through household frequency, percentage with the help of Bar Charts.
survey. In addition to primary data, secondary data Using the results obtained in above analysis, chi-
such as farmer’s fertilizer subsidy and land insurance square test was carried out to find out the significant
data were collected to distinguish the irrigation relationship with the factors. It is a statistical method
participants and non-participants. Irrigation assessing the goodness of fit between a set of
Department, Agriculture Department and Agrarian observed values and those expected values. The
Department, were some of the offices from which formula for calculating chi-square (χ2) is: Σ (O-E)
secondary data were obtained. 2/E. That was, chi- square is the sum of the squared
difference between observed (O) and the expected
3.2. Sampling Method (E) divided by the expected data in all possible
categories.
Stratified random sampling technique was used
and sample population was classified into two 4. Results
groups: irrigation participants and non-irrigation
participant households from each divisions of 4.1. The effects of demographic, socio-
Trincomalee district. Irrigation participants mean the
economic and institutional factors affecting
farmers who involve in irrigation management
activities and irrigate their agricultural land if the farmers’ participation in small-scale
rain is not persist. Non-irrigation participants mean irrigation
the farmers who do not involve in irrigation The findings Figure 2 show that total sample
management activities and entirely depend on rain household heads 75% of them are male headed while
water. Sample households were identified using 25% are female headed households. When we see the
stratified random sampling technique from the list of comparison with irrigation participants and non -
households except Town and Gravets division irrigation participants, irrigation participant
because this division contains very few farmers. The households 12% are headed by female and the
overall sample size was 100 households, 50 from remaining 88% is by male headed household. The
irrigation participants and 50 households from non- corresponding figure for non - irrigation participants
irrigation participants. Trincomalee district consists is 38% and 62% is by female and male household
of 11 division. In each division 5 household. Sample heads respectively.
households s were selected for irrigation participants
and 5 for non- irrigation participants using stratified
random sampling except Trincomalee Town and
Gravets division. The list of total farmers households
in the division and the lists of irrigation participants
and non- irrigation participants households in these
divisions were obtained from Irrigation Department,
Agriculture Department and Agrarian Department.

3.3. Analysing
In order to identify the first research objective of
"review of demographical, socio-economical and
institutional factors affecting the farmer’s Figure 2: Distribution of Gender of household
participation in small-scale irrigation in Trincomalee
district, Sri Lanka", a detail literature review was
carried out on books, past research papers and related The results in Figure 3 reveal that total sample
articles in the internet and other textual materials. house hold head 74% were between the age
categories from 18- 28 years to 51-61 years and 26%
To find the second research objective is to "identify were in the category of 62-72 years. If we compare
the effects of demographic, socio-economic and in detail classification with irrigation participants and

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 325


Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)
Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017
ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

non-irrigation participants, 92% of farmers who were According to the Figure 5, the distribution of total
participating in irrigation were between the age sample respondents in terms of man equivalent (ME)
categories from18- 28 years to 51-61 years and 8% of the economically active family labour has shown
were 62-72 years. On the other hand, 56% of farmers that, 19% total sample house hold were 0-2 ME,
who were not participating in irrigation were 47% were 2-4 ME, 30% were 4-6 ME and the
between the ages categories from 18- 28 years to 51- remaining 4% were 6-8 ME. Further, the result
61 years and 44% were in the category of 62-72 shows that 60% of farmers who were participating in
years. This analysis shows that, majority (92%) of irrigation management were in the category between
the farmers who were participating in irrigation were 4-6 and 6-8 of man equivalent (ME) of the
below 61 years of age while 44% of farmers who economically active family labour, on the other hand,
were not participating in irrigation were above 61 only 8% of farmers who were not participating in
years of age. This is due to the fact that farmers are irrigation management were in the category between
able to participate and take risk when they are young. 4-6 and 6-8 of man equivalent (ME) of the
economically active family labour.

Figure 3: Distribution of Age of household head


Figure 5: Distribution of family labour force of
The distribution of total sample respondents in household
terms of literacy level in Figure 4 has shown that,
15% were illiterate, means at least they cannot read The result in Figure 6 shows that 90% of farmers
and write, 80% had attended elementary education in total sample household had the cultivated land size
from grade 1 to 6, 3% were exposed to formal under the categories of 0-2, 3-5 and 6-8 acres, the
education from grade 7 to 8 and the remaining 2% rest of 10% farmers had the cultivated land size
have succeeded in reaching higher levels of grade 9 under the categories of 9-11, 12-14, and 15-17 acres.
and above. The comparison by access to irrigation With the comparison of irrigation participants and
reveals that 10% of the participants and 20% of the non-irrigation participants, 84% of farmers who were
non-participants were found illiterate, 82% of the participating in irrigation had cultivation land size
participants household heads and 78% of the non- under the categories of 0-2, 3-5 and 6-8 acres, the
participants household heads attended elementary remaining 16% farmers had the cultivated land size
education from grade 1 to 6, 6% of the participants under the categories of 9-11, 12-14, and 15-17 acres.
and 0% non-participants attended junior education On the other hand, 96% of farmers who were not
from grade 7 to 8, 2% participants and 2% of non- participating in irrigation had the cultivation land
participants of small-scale irrigation were exposed to under the categories of 0-2, 3-5 and 6-8 acres, the
higher levels of grade 9 and above. rest of 4 % farmers had the cultivated land size
under the categories of 9-11, 12-14, and 15-17 acres.

Figure 4: Distribution of education level of


household Figure 6: Distribution of cultivated land of
household

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 326


Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)
Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017
ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

According to the Figure 7, the distribution of total


sample respondents in terms of distance to nearest As per the survey result in Figure 9 reveal that,
market, 56% of farmers were in categories of 0- 2 68% of the total sample households got extension
km and 3-5 km and other 44% farmers were in service. With regard to the frequency of extension
categories of 6-8 km, 9-11km and 12-14 km. In contact among the total respondents 12% contact
addition, the result shows that 84% of farmers who three times and above per month, 21% twice per
were participating in irrigation management had month, 35% once per month, and the remaining 32%
distance to nearest market were in categories of 0- 2 have no contact with extension agents. When we
km and 3-5 km and remaining 16 % of farmers were compare with irrigation participants and non-
in categories of 6-8 km, 9-11km and 12-14 km. On irrigation participants, majority of the irrigation
the other hand, only 28% of farmers who were not participant households get support from extension
participating in irrigation management had distance agents when compare to non-irrigation participants.
to nearest market were between 0- 2 km and 3-5 km According to the survey 92% of the participants
and rest of 72% of farmers were in categories of 6-8 (40% of farmers got once/month, 30% of farmers got
km, 9-11km and 12-14 km. twice/month and 22% of farmers got thrice/month)
and 44% of the non-participants (30% of farmers got
once/month, 12% of farmers got twice/month and
2% of farmers got thrice/month) got extension
services. On the other hand 8% of participants and
66% of non-participants didn’t get the extension
services. Extension service here refers to advice,
training, demonstration related to crop and
horticultural production.

Figure 7: Distribution of distance to nearest market


of household

The results of Figure 8 illustrate that 50 % of


farmers in total sample household were in the
category of 0-2 km distance to water source and
other 50% of farmers were in the categories of 3-5
km and 6-8 km distance to water source. Further to Figure 9: Distribution of access to extension services
that, 76% of farmers who were participating in of household
irrigation management had distance from water The survey results indicate in Table 1 that 63% of the
source in the category of 0- 2 km and remaining 24% total sample household utilized credit facilities while
of farmers were in the categories of 3-5 km and 6-8 37% of the total sample households did not take
km distance to water source. On the other hand, only credit due to various reasons. The comparison to
24% of farmers who were not participating in irrigation participants with non-irrigation participants
irrigation management had distance from the water disclosed that 78% of irrigation participants and 48%
source were between 0- 2 km and rest of 76% of the non-irrigation participants had utilized credit
farmers were in the categories of 3-5 km and 6-8 km facilities although the access is equal to all
distance to water source. households without any difference, while 22% of the
irrigation participants and 52% of the non-irrigation
participants did not take credit. This implies that
irrigation participants had better access to credit
compared to non-irrigation participants.

Table 1: Distribution of access to credit facility of


household
Respondents Participants Non- Total
Participants

Access to
Credit No (%) No (%) No (%)
Facilities
Figure 8: Distribution of distance from the water
source of household

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 327


Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)
Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017
ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

Yes 39 78 24 48 63 63 water source were found to be significantly related to


No 11 22 26 52 37 37 the level of participation. Similarly, independent
institutional variables, namely, extension contact and
Total 50 100 50 100 100 100 access to credit facilities, were found to be
significantly related to the level of participation of
Respondents reported in Table 2 about problems respondents in irrigation management. The
revolving around credit were related to many factors. remaining factor, namely, education and size of
20% of total sample respondents refrained from cultivated land did not have significant relationship
credit because of high interest rate, 9% because of its with the level of participation of the respondents.
unavailability on time, 8% because of shortage of
money for down payment, and 0% of the sample
households said that they didn’t want credit. The Table 3: Chi-square test results
comparison to irrigation participants with non-
irrigation participants, 12% irrigation participants Factors/ Chi- P- Level of
and 28% non-irrigation participants had not used the Independent Square Value Significant
credit facilities because of the high interest rate, 4% Variables (χ2)
irrigation participants and 14% non-irrigation Demographic
participants failed to get the credit facilities because Factors
Gender 4.51 0.033 Moderate
of non- availability on time and finally 6% irrigation
participants and 10% non-irrigation participants Age 9.95 0.041 Moderate
didn’t use the credit facilities because of shortage of
Socio-Economic
money for down payment. This results reveal that,
Factors
high interest rate is the main reason the farmers Education 2.36 0.501 Weak
refrained to get the credit facilities in both categories. Labour Force 15.27 0.001 Strong
Size of cultivated 4.87 0.432 Weak
land
Table 2: Distribution of problems in credit facilities Access to market 16.67 0.002 Moderate
of household
Distance to water 14.05 0.001 Strong
Respondents Participants Non- Total
source
Frequency Participants Frequency
Frequency
Institutional
Problems to
Factors
Credit No (%) No (%) No (%)
Extension service 15.45 0.001 Strong
facilities
Credit Facilities 4.82 0.028 Moderate
High interest 6 12 14 28 20 20
rate
Above results show that Labour force, Extension
Not available 2 4 7 14 9 9 service and Distance to water source are P ≤ 0.001
on time
significant level. This information shows those
Shortage
factors have strong significant relationship with
money for 3 6 5 10 8 8 irrigation participation.
down payment
Age, Gender, Access to market, and Credit
No need 0 0 0 0 0 0 facilities are P ≤ 0.05 significant level. This
information shows those factors have moderately
Total 11 20 26 52 37 37 significant relationship with irrigation participation.

Size of cultivated land and Education factors


4.2. Chi- square test results of factors affect failed to show any significant relationship with
the irrigation participation of households irrigation participation.

Table 3 shows a summary of Chi- square (χ2) test 5. Conclusions and Recommendations
results of factors affect the irrigation participation of
households, based on the results obtained from The first objective was to review the literature, on
previous analysis. Two independent demographical demographical, socio-economical and institutional
factors namely gender and age were found to be factors affecting the farmer’s participation in small-
significantly related to the level of participation. scale irrigation in Trincomalee district Sri Lanka. It
Three independent socio- economic variables, was found that, factors of demographic: Gender and
namely labour force, access to market and distance to Age, Socio-economic: Education, Labour force, Size

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 328


Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)
Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017
ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

of cultivated land, Access to market and Distance to ownership (e.g. motor pump) to female-headed
water source, Institutional: Extension service and households and provide subsidized credits are some
Access to credit facilities were identified as the mechanism of increasing female-headed household’s
influence factors of participation in small-scale participation in small-scale irrigation.
irrigation.
Furthermore earning from irrigation are affected
The second objective was to identify the effects of by the marketing channel, in part because the main
demographic, socio-economic and institutional irrigated crops are harvested at similar times by
factors affecting farmers’ participation in small-scale farmers and are perishable. Since there is quality
irrigation. It was found that, Labour force, Extension deterioration of their products due to lack of efficient
service and Distance to water source were found in storage and post-harvest processing mechanisms,
chi-square test results that 0.001. This results imply farmers sell their products by cheap price during
that they have a strong significant relationship with harvest period. Therefore, an effective marketing
irrigation participation. Age, Gender, Access to system will facilitate irrigation participation.
market, and Credit facilities were found as 0.041,
0.033, 0.002 and 0.028 respectively. Those factors Hence, the concerned bodies like governmental
have the moderately significant relationship with extension services, farmers’ cooperatives and non-
irrigation participation. Size of cultivated land, governmental market organizations should support
Education had failed to show the significant the further development of the efficient marketing
relationship with irrigation participation and their systems in the study area. This may include
chi-square test results were 0.432 and 0.501 provision of marketing facilities and information
respectively. In addition, Labour shortage was one of provision. In addition to this the government should
the problem faced by respondents for weeding, establish irrigation co-operative and integrate to
harvesting, threshing, watering, livestock herding market is crucial in order to the farmers get
and ploughing.64% of irrigation participants and reasonable price for their produce.
34% non-irrigation participants faced labour shortage
problem. Because comparatively irrigation
participants cultivate more land and they use 6. Acknowledgements
irrigation, so they need more labours than non-
participants. The respondents who didn’t get the Author wishes to acknowledge the assistance
credit facilities, they reported because of high given by the University of Moratuwa and Irrigation
interest rate, not available on time and shortage of Department, E.P for this study.
money for down payment were reasons.

Extension service is a corner stone of agricultural 7. References


practices in general particularly for irrigation
[1] ARTI, (1991). The Integrated Management of Major
development. Access to extension services was Irrigation Schemes. An Assessment Research
positively and very significantly related to both farm
households’ participation in small-scale irrigation. [2] Asfaw, D. (2007). Scaling up Agricultural Water
We recommend Agricultural faculties around Sri Development in Africa, the Case of Ethiopia. Minister of
Water Resources, Federal Republic of Ethiopia Australian
Lankan Universities and colleges to train quality
Journal of Agricultural and Resource Economics, 49, 159–
development agents especially irrigation experts in 175.
adequate number to the rural areas would increase
the contact and flow of information between the [3] Gebremedhin, B. and Peden, D. (2002) Policies and
Agriculture Inspector and farm households to Institutions to Enhance the Impact of Irrigation
Development in Mixed Crop-Livestock.
increase their participation in small-scale irrigation,
EARO/IWMI/ILRI Workshop; Addis Ababa,Ethiopia.
thereby enhance the production and productivity of Available from: http:// publications.iwmi.org.
the rural sector.
[4] Hussain (2006). Irrigation and Poverty Alleviation:
The gender difference of household heads in Review of the Empirical Evidence. Irrigation and
irrigation participation indicated female-headed Drainage, 53(2), 1-15.http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ ird.114.
households face shortage of labor and market [5] Nhundu, K. (2010). Analysis of irrigation development
information, made them rent or share out their land post fast track land reform programme. A case study of
to the male headed household heads. As a result the Goromonzi district, Mashonaland East Province,
likelihood of participation of female headed Zimbabwe. Joint 3rd African Association of Agricultural
household heads are less than the male headed Economists (AAAE) and 48th Agricultural Economists
Association of South Africa (AEASA) Conference, Cape
household heads. Therefore, the government has to
Town, South Africa, pp. 19-23.
find out ways to increase their probability of
participation. For instance, ensuring property

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 329


Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR)
Vol-3, Issue-5, 2017
ISSN: 2454-1362, http://www.onlinejournal.in

[6] Sivayoganathan. C., Devarajah. K., & Robuchon.G.,


(2003). Impact Assessment of the Minor Tank
Development Programme. Integrated Food Security
Project, Trincomalee.

Imperial Journal of Interdisciplinary Research (IJIR) Page 330

You might also like