Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3.4. Transboundary Air Pollution: 1.1. It Is All Intertwined
3.4. Transboundary Air Pollution: 1.1. It Is All Intertwined
Transboundary air pollution (generated in one country and impacting in others) makes a Main findings
major contribution to acidification and summer smog (caused by tropospheric ozone), and
also to eutrophication of soil and water and dispersion of hazardous substances. The main
sources of this pollution are energy use and transport in which international shipping is of
growing importance. The cost-effectiveness of measures to reduce emissions from ships
has been demonstrated by the European Commission in its strategy to combat
acidification. However, sufficient measures are yet to be implemented.
Major emission reductions for sulphur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide adopted under the
Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution (CLRTAP) and EU legislation have
reduced the harmful effects of transboundary air pollution. Projected further reductions
fall short of EU targets for 2000 and 2010 and further intiatives are needed in the
framework of integrated abatement strategies.
Projections for 2010 suggest that, despite the projected emission reductions, areas of the
EU and (especially) the Accession Countries will continue to be affected by acid and
nitrogen deposition above the level defined as the ‘critical load’. Ecosystems in the EU
still receive 7% acid deposition and 39% nitrogen deposition above their critical loads.
European countries where over 70% of ecosystems will still be affected by excess
nitrogen deposition include the Czech Republic, Lithuania, Poland, the Slovak Republic
and Switzerland.
With respect to ozone, despite the considerable efforts in precursor emission reductions,
the long-term objective for protection of crops is expected to be reached only in the
north-west parts of Europe (Ireland, Scandinavia). The health-related ozone threshold
concentration will continue to be exceeded 50 days per year. The highest number of
exceedances will be found in the more densely-populated north-western part of Europe
(Netherlands, Belgium and northern France).
Moreover, despite reductions in precursor emissions, smog will remain a health threat due
to increases in ozone worldwide: this calls for action on a global scale to reduce emissions
of carbon dioxide, nitrogen oxides and methane.
1. Transboundary air pollution: a complex The main effects are manifested in acidifica-
problem tion of water and soil, summer smog caused
by tropospheric ozone, eutrophication of
1.1. It is all intertwined soils and waters, and dispersion of hazardous
Transboundary air pollution is a pan-Euro- substances (see also Chapter 3.3). The
pean problem, requiring pan-European environmental impacts caused by the main
solutions. The main causes are emissions pollutants SO2, NOx, VOCs, ammonia (NH3)
from transport and energy usage of sulphur and toxic substances are summarised in
dioxide (SO2), nitrogen oxides (NOx), Table 3.4.1.
volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and
various toxic materials such as heavy metals
Main air pollutants and their environmental impacts Table 3.4.1.
and persistent organic pollutants (POPs).
These pollutants (particularly carbon mon- Environmental Impact Caused by
oxide (CO) and methane (CH4)) can
remain in the atmosphere sufficiently long Acidification SO2, NOx, NH3
to be transported thousands of kilometres Eutrophication NOx, NH3
and thus to spread over the whole of Europe, Ozone VOCs, NOx
across national borders, far from the original
Bioaccumulation of toxic substances Heavy metals, POPs
sources of polluting emissions.
134 Environmental Issues
Table 3.4.1 is of course a simplified summary, change (see Chapter 3.1) and also reduce
which abstracts from a reality of complex SO2, NOx and CO emissions, with beneficial
interactions. For instance, all the acidifying impacts on acidification, tropospheric ozone
compounds are precursors of particulates and urban air quality (Figure 3.4.1).
which are harmful to human health, and
VOC species such as benzene also have toxic 1.2. Targets and policies at European level
effects and contribute to the formation of The UNECE Convention on Long-Range
harmful particulates. VOC and NOx emission Transboundary Air Pollution (CLTRAP)
controls vary in their effectiveness in reducing signed in Geneva in 1979 was the first multi-
ozone concentrations. As a rule of thumb, lateral treaty concerning air pollution. It has
ozone concentrations in highly polluted areas provided an important demonstration that
are most efficiently reduced by a combination international co-operation can achieve
of NOx and VOC controls. In regions with low results. During its first 10-15 years, the
NOx concentrations, both NOx and VOC CLRTAP resulted in protocols aiming at a
control reduces ozone levels but NOx control reduction in acidifying emissions and abate-
is more effective. In parts of north-west ment of ozone concentrations. Protocols on
Europe, reductions in NOx emissions alone heavy metals and persistent organic pollutants
will actually increase ozone levels, although a (1998) aim at a reduction of emissions of
reduction in NOx emissions is still desirable to these toxic materials. A second protocol on
mitigate effects of acidification and NOx and NH3 emissions is under negotiation.
eutrophication and to reduce ozone forma-
tion on the hemispheric and global scale. Parties to the CLRTAP were committed to a
stabilisation of NOx emissions at the 1987
Further complicating factors are the multi- level by December 1994. The VOC protocol
ple environmental impacts of human activi- signed in 1991 requires emissions to be
ties. Thus, for example, energy-saving either stabilised or reduced by at least 30%
measures to reduce CO2 emissions and the from the base year (usually 1988) in 1999.
ensuing pollutants released mitigate climate The second Sulphur Protocol signed in 1994
Source: EEA
NOX SO2 PM
NH3 NOX Fewer droughts, floods, storms,
and agricultural changes etc.
Urban air
Eutrophication quality
Energy Transport
Agriculture
Acidification
to multiple benefits Trophospheric
Ozone
has the objective to reduce the extent by EU air emissions reduction targets Table 3.4.2.
which critical loads are exceeded in Europe
by 60% in the year 2000; the various coun- SO2 NOx VOCs
tries are required to reduce their emissions
5EAP 35% (1985-2000) 30% (1990-2000) 30% (1990-99)
by different amounts. The Protocol also has
obligatory clauses regarding emissions CLRTAP 62% (1980-2000) stabilise 1987 emission 30% (1987-99)
standards, including application of ‘Best levels by 1994
Available Technology’ emission standards for COM(97)88 84% (1990-2010) 55% (1990-2010)
new plants. A further requirement is a (proposed targets)
reduction in sulphur content to 0.2% and to
Source: European Commssion, 1997; UN-ECE CLRTAP, 1998
0.05% respectively in gas oil for stationary
sources and in diesel fuel for road traffic.
• Integrated Pollution Prevention and
EU limit, guide or target values for air Control Directive.
quality concentration levels of pollutants • Implementation of measures developed
including SO2, NO2 and ozone are now through the Auto-Oil Programme:
being revised through so-called ‘daughter • A two-step tightening of vehicle
directives’ to the Air Quality Framework emission limit values for passenger
Directive (96/62/EC). cars and light commercial vehicles
with the first step in the year 2000 and
The EU Fifth Environmental Action Pro- the second step in 2005;
gramme (5EAP) set emission targets up to • new environmental specifications for
the end of the century for reduction of petrol and diesel fuels to take effect
acidifying compounds and ozone precursors. from the year 2000; very low-sulphur
Further targets, up to 2010, were proposed fuels to be mandatory from 2005;
in the 1997 Community Strategy to combat • provision made for earlier phase-in of
acidification (European Commission, 1997; very low-sulphur fuels;
Table 3.4.2). This strategy emphasised the • phase-out of leaded fuels by 2000.
multi-pollutant multi-effect framework and • The Solvent Directive and the Directive
showed that, in terms of cost-effectiveness, to reduce emissions from storage and
there is more potential for reducing sulphur distribution of petrol aim at reduction of
rather than nitrogen emissions; this is VOC emissions from stationary sources
because SO2 is mainly emitted from a small and at all stages of the chain of petrol
number of relatively controllable large storage, distribution and usage.
sources (power plants) whereas NOx is also
emitted from a wide range of smaller Guided by the work done by the WHO on
sources, including vehicles. human-health effects and by UNECE on
effects on vegetation, the Commission has
New strategies for emission abatement face proposed new ozone reference levels (Table
the challenge of satisfying protection re- 3.4.3). In addition to the long-term objective
quirements from all inter-related effects for the protection of human health, thresh-
caused by tropospheric ozone, acidification old values to inform both the general and
and eutrophication. The Commission is informed population have been defined. For
currently developing an ozone-abatement the protection of human health, short-term
strategy. In line with the 5EAP, the aim is to concentrations (peak values over one to
address the ‘symptoms’ by setting interim eight hours) are of concern. For protection
and long-term air quality objectives and the of agricultural crops and forests, ozone
‘causes’ by developing strategies and meas- concentrations integrated over the growing
ures to reduce polluting emissions and also season are of importance.
to stimulate changes in society’s patterns of
behaviour. The new strategy will be linked
with provisional national emission ceilings 2. Trends in emissions
for SO2, NOx, NH3 and VOC.
2.1. Emissions of sulphur dioxide (SO2)
More specific measures for abating precur- Since 1980, SO2 emissions in Europe have
sor emissions are defined in a number of EU been reduced considerably: by approximately
Directives: 50% over the period 1980-1996 (Figure 3.4.2)
although in comparisons between countries,
• Large Combustion Plants Directive. allowance should be made for differences in
• Directives on Sulphur Content of Cer- initial emission rates and economic circum-
tain Liquid Fuels. stances. In the EU, the 5EAP target of 35%
136 Environmental Issues
Table 3.4.3. Ozone air quality reference levels proposed in the working EU draft Ozone Directive
Ozone concentrations integrated over a certain period of time are indicated as AOTxx-values where xx is a threshold value
expressed in ppb (1 ppb O3 = 2 µg/m3 O3). The AOT40, for example, is defined as the sum of all excess concentrations above
the threshold of 40 ppb (80 µg/m3). It is calculated by subtracting 80 µg/m3 from all hourly concentrations and subsequently
summing all positive values.
* In addition to the Long-term Objective, a Target value has been proposed: by the year 2011 a daily eight-hour maximum
of 120 mg/m3 may not be exceeded more than 20-25 times per calendar year averaged over 3 years. Current legislation (92/
72/EC) has the limit value 110 mg/m3 average over a fixed eight -hour period.
** In addition to the Long-term Objective, a Target value has been proposed: by the year 2011 the AOT40 value may not exceed
18 000 mg/m3.h averaged over 5 years. Current legislation (92/72/EC) has the limit value 65 mg/m3 average over 24 hours.
reduction from 1985 levels by the year 2000 tion in these countries. Since 1994, the 5EAP
was met in 1994. EU emissions were reduced target of 35% reduction has also been met
from 19 600 ktonnes in 1985 to 10 700 by Accession Countries, as result of the
ktonnes in 1995. The reduction, which will general European overfulfilment of the 30%
continue, is expected to meet the commit- emission reduction objective set by the First
ments of the Second Sulphur Protocol. Sulphur Protocol. At present, the relative
reduction in emissions from the Accession
The decrease in emissions from the Acces- Countries is similar to that in the EU, while
sion Countries is most notable since 1990, their total emissions amounts to approxi-
largely caused by the economic reconstruc- mately one-quarter of EU emissions.
Figure 3.4.2 Sulphur dioxide emissions were strongly reduced between 1980 and 1996 (1980 = 100%)
60
Source: EMEP/MSC-W,
Report 1/98 40
20
0
en ds
Sp ic
ak elg in
Es om
Sw land
er n
Lu F lic
ng rk
e
Fi tria
Li the land
pu m
pu a
m ce
Ire ain
Bu land
d
Th Sw Nor ny
n y
rtu a
G nia
15
N ze y
d nm y
ec lo nia
Ic gal
Po nia
La d
m a
e it wa
ite De gar
Hu Ital
Re ni
Po ari
Ro tvi
G ede
ec
ur
an
n
bl
ov B ste
Ki a
Re iu
b
a
ht n
xe ran
la
EU
a
Cz S to
h ve
ua
s
d
bo
m
re
ec rla
lg
el
Au
e r
th
Li
Un
Sl
2.2. Emissions of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and and 1987 for the VOC Protocol. For the year
ammonia (NH3) 1995, Accession Countries reported emis-
Emission targets for nitrogen oxides set in sions well on the way to complying with the
the 5EAP are far more restrictive than the VOC Protocol, while VOC emission reduc-
stabilisation at 1987 levels required by the tion in the EU amounted to 11% with
First NOx Protocol of the LRTAP Conven- respect to 1990 levels and 15% with respect
tion. By 1994, the average NOx emission to 1987 levels. EU emissions were reported
reduction for the EEA and the Accession to be 11 500 ktonnes in 1995, that is, six
Countries was 13%, thus complying with the times higher than the reported emissions
commitments of the First NOx Protocol from the Accession Countries (Figure 3.4.4).
(Figure 3.4.3). However, the EU (which had Therefore, as in the case of NOx emissions, it
a reduction of 11%) is unlikely to achieve is unlikely that the 5EAP VOC target emis-
the 5th EAP emission target for 2000 of a sion reduction can be reached by 1999.
30% reduction; in contrast, the Accession
Countries have already met this target In contrast to other pollutants, a large pro-
according to the most recent official emis- portion of VOCs are emitted by natural
sion estimate. processes. Biogenic VOC emission strongly
depends on temperature. During ozone smog
Reported ammonia emissions decreased by episodes, the natural contribution might be
14% in the EEA and the Accession Coun- as high as 60% (Slanina et al., 1998) while on
tries, from 5 000 ktonnes in 1990 to 4 300 an annual basis, biogenic emission contrib-
ktonnes in 1996. Again, emission reductions utes 40% of total VOC emissions over Europe
in Accession Countries are considerably (Simpson et al., 1999).
higher (28%) than those reported from the
EU (8%). At present, there are no emission
targets for ammonia, but these are expected 3. Photochemical smog
to be specified in the new multi-effect multi-
pollutant directives and protocols. Photochemical smog, or simply summer smog,
is formed in the lowest few kilometres of the
2.3. Emissions of volatile organic compounds atmosphere. It has adverse effects on human
(VOCs) health, agricultural crops, natural vegeta-
The requirements for reduction of emissions tion, and materials. The main component of
of non-methane volatile organic compounds smog is ozone, although levels of other
(VOCs) by 30% in 1999 are different on the aggressive oxidants are elevated as well.
choice of the base year: 1990 for the 5EAP There is, however, only limited information
Compared with 1987 (=100%) emissions of nitrogen oxides in 1996 show a reduction in most countries. Figure 3.4.3
60
40
20
0
Es blic
e s
he om
Lu Fi ein
Li A den
m nd
N ark
N ng d
Fr nd
Ic nia
Un Sw ng a
Th ted zer ry
en ria
G nce
n
Sp ly
Po nia
Po land
er ia
lg y
Sl aria
Be and
Sl ium
en g
Ire ay
15
th ia
m ia
ga
Sw nd
Bu an
Hu aki
ec
ai
D our
e Ki lan
Ita
G ton
Li atv
Ro an
i it a
w
ht st
xe nla
la
EU
a
e
m
st
rtu
et d
m
pu
re
rla
lg
or
l
ov
ec u
ov
e
L
b
Re
h
ec
Cz
Figure 3.4.4 Compared with 1988 (=100%) most countries have achieved the reduction in VOC emissions
60
Source: EMEP MSC-W
Report 1/98 40
20
0
ng s
ng lic
Li Sw om
Lu Fi ein
e rk
en n
m nd
N ain
Ic nd
Sl land
rtu ia
e
Sw enm ia
N er d
rla y
ec A ary
ite Re tria
ce
Sp ly
m ia
Po nia
Be and
Ire m
Fr rg
G gal
15
th ia
Sl ania
Hu nd
he an
wa
ht de
ec
e G rlan
Ita
Po en
D gar
Ro ak
Li atv
itz a
iu
u
Ki b
an
xe nla
la
EU
a
st
Un h us
bo
et m
d pu
re
lg
or
l
ec e
ov
u
ov
e
L
l
Bu
Cz
Th
available on concentrations and effects of the ozone situation during the relevant
these other oxidants. As no significant effects growing season. The AOT is a practical
have been observed at current ambient indicator for ozone effects on vegetation. It
levels, no international guidelines have been must be realised, however, that it is only a
set for the other photochemical oxidants first, crude estimate of the real ozone expo-
found in summer smog. sure of vegetation. Due to its simplifications,
the link between AOT and actual vegetation
Ozone and its precursors have an atmos- damage might be weak.
pheric residence time of several days or
more. Under average summer conditions, air First of all, the AOT gives a potential but not
pollutants are transported over distances of an actual exposure of vegetation. Under dry
400-500 km per day. Besides the and hot conditions, the plant protects itself
transboundary character, summer smog may by closing its stomata. Although ozone
show a more local character. For example, in concentrations are likely to be high under
the Mediterranean Basin, air masses re- these conditions, the closed stomata prevent
entering the source regions have been uptake of ozone and the damaging effects of
shown to raise pollution levels (Millan et al., ozone will be small. In the AOT concept this
1997). can be included by adding a constraint on
relative humidity. This makes it, however,
High levels of ozone occur during short more complex and less transparent.
periods of two to four days. Threshold values
set for the protection of human health are In the newly proposed daughter directive on
exceeded regularly over large parts of ozone, the integration time of AOT is clearly
Europe. Smog episodes are often found defined: May to July using all one-hourly
during summer over most parts of the values measured between 8 AM and 8 PM
continent, during periods with clear skies, CET. This period may differ from the active
increased solar radiation and elevated period of the plants. Daylight hours, defined
temperatures (Map 3.4.1). The occurrence as solar radiation above a certain minimum
and duration of these episodes varies might be more appropriate. Also the grow-
strongly from one year to the next. ing season varies all over Europe and in
places extends beyond the three months
3.1. Accumulated exposure specified in the directive.
Based on a series of controlled exposure
experiments, the concept of AOT40 (accu- The simple and clear definition of AOT
mulated ozone hourly concentrations above suggests that monitoring will be easy. Unfor-
80 µg/m3) is chosen as an indicator for tunately, there are a number of complicating
exposure of ecosystems. The great advantage factors which make the observed AOT value
of the AOT concept is that it is indicative of sensitive to monitoring conditions:
Transboundary air pollution 139
• the measuring height: monitoring ozone 30˚ 20˚ 10˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚ 40˚ 50˚ 60˚
at a height of 1 m (crops) or at 10 m (at Arctic Ocean Mean of daily
summer maximum
crown level of trees) might result in a concentration of ozone
60˚
factor of 2-3 difference in AOT;
0 1000 km
• missing data will lead to systematic
60˚
underestimation of the AOT; an agreed
n
e a
Exceedance in µg/m³
correction method will be required. of the threshold 120 µg/m³,
O c
accumulated hourly values
North in the EMEP 150 – grid
For practical reasons, the time resolution Sea 50˚
i c
more than 104
n t
applied in the current atmospheric models is 50˚ 92 – 104
l a
six hours, which is too coarse to calculate an C h
a n n
e l
80 – 92
A t
AOT without further assumption on the 68 – 80
a
Se less than 68
ck
diurnal variation of ozone. This problem will Bla
40˚
be solved in the next generation of models. Modelled from 1990 level emissions.
Meteorology from selected years.
Notwithstanding these drawbacks, the 40˚
50˚
l a
150
3.4.6). A recent analysis of peak ozone data
100 submitted under the Ozone Directive (de
Leeuw et al., 1997) showed for 68 stations
50 over the period 1989-1997 a significant
upward trend at only two stations and a
0 downward trend at 22 stations. For the
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15
majority of the 68 stations analysed, no
Number of Member States
significant trend was detected.
year at a suburban station in Athens in the Ozone concentrations differ widely between
period 1984-1989. monitoring stations Figure 3.4.6
(ug/m3)
ozone levels. Further
calculations on a global scale support the 40 downwind, ozone levels will
findings of an ongoing change in chemical resume previous high levels.
composition of tropospheric background air 20
Source: de Leeuw et al.,
(Parrish et al., 1993; Collins et al., 1998; 1997
Berntsen et al., 1997; Hov and Flatøy, 1997). 0
Current daily mean concentrations of ozone 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997
are three to four times higher than in the Eupen (BE) Bottesford (GB)
Mont St. Nicolas (LU) Wijnandsrade (NL)
pre-industrial era mainly as a result of the Utrecht (NL)
considerable growth in NOx emissions from
industry and the transport sector.
Peak concentrations of ozone (98 percentile)
180
4. Acidification
160
4.1. Critical loads
140
(ug/m3)
C h
a n n
e l
criterion driving emission reductions.)
A t
a
Se
ck
Bla Pollution ‘hot spots’ can be identified, such
40˚
400 – 1 000 as the so-called Black Triangle (Box 3.4.1).
40˚
Exceedances of critical loads of acidification
200 – 400
M e d i
and eutrophication over Europe are at
t e
40 – 200 r r a n a
present mostly dominated by nitrogen
less than 40 e a n S e
50˚
more than 1 000 lar ecosystem whenever the actual deposi-
l a
e l
a n n
C h
tions fall outside the function.
A t
a
Se
ck
Bla
40˚
In preparation for the EU acidification
400 – 1 000
40˚
strategy, an ‘area of exceedance’ (AE)
concept was developed for scenario analysis.
200 – 400
M e d i t e
The alternative way to calculate exceedances
40 – 200 r r
less than 40
a n e a n S e a was to consider the area occupied by the
areas with 30˚ ecosystems, rather than the number of
no exceedance
30˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚ ecosystems with depositions exceeding their
critical loads.
30˚ 20˚ 10˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚ 40˚ 50˚ 60˚
Exceedance Arctic Ocean
Recently, a further refined measure for
of critical loads
evaluating ecosystem protection has been
for acidifying nitrogen 60˚
in 1996 developed. The so-called ‘average accumu-
lated exceedance’ (AAE) actually calculates
0 1000 km 60˚
the exceedance of critical loads for all
n
e a
50˚
more than 1 000
l a
C h
a n n
e l
each individual ecosystem in the grid cell.
A t
a
Se
ck
Bla
40˚
400 – 1 000
40˚
Map 3.4.3
200 – 400
M e d i t e
40 – 200 r r Map 3.4.4
a n e a
less than 40 e a n S
areas with 30˚ Map 3.4.5
no exceedance
30˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚
Source: EMEP
Transboundary air pollution 143
800 80
The long-term annual precipitation totals are in a
range of 500 mm in the basin to 1 350 mm at 600 60
higher altitudes. Annually, there are more than 50 400 40
days of continuous fog and 70% of the days are
cloudy. Situations of stagnant air often occur during 200 20
winter, causing accumulations and the highest
0 0
concentrations of air pollutants. 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996
,
Czech sources, as well as the reconstruction of Saxonian forest, and 22% of the Silesian forest
Turów Power Plant in Poland. There is also a remains undamaged (Hlobil and Holub, 1997). Air
remarkable decrease of coal consumption by small pollution has changed the ecosystem in North
sources and households, due to substitution with Bohemia, which resulted in soil acidification, loss of
gas and other types of fuel. base cations, changes in plant community
composition and forest damage. Deforestation
Concentrations of sulphate and nitrates in negatively influences availability and quality of water
precipitation show decreasing trends similar to those and soil erosion.
,
,
12˚ 13˚ 14˚ 15˚ 16˚ 17˚
Cottbus Deposition of sulphur
G E R M A N Y in the Black Triangle,
P O L A N D 1997
Halle
0 50 km
,
Leipzig
border of Black
S Wroc aw Triangle
Dresden y i
51˚
n l Loads in eqH/ha/yr
Gera Chemnitz e 51˚
more than 3 000
o s
Zwickau x Wa brzych
i 2 000 – 3 000
,
Ústí nad Dêcín
Labem
a Liberec a 1 500 – 2 000
Most
Trutnov 1 000 – 1 500
S
750 – 1 000
Karlovy
Vary e m i a Hradec
500 – 750
h Králové
less than 500
o Prague
50˚
B Pardubice
50˚ Map 3.4.6
The demarcation is that of
Plzen C Z E C H R E P U B L I C the EU PHARE-funded Black
12˚ 13˚ 14˚ 15˚ 16˚ 17˚ Triangle Project
Source: Phare Topic Link/AQ
144 Environmental Issues
a
Se
it e significant improvement
Wh improvement
Nor
wegia no clear trend
n Sea deterioration
significant deterioration
60˚
60˚
Map 3.4.7
n
Source: SC-DLO
e a
Sea
O c
ic
North
lt
a
Sea B
i c
n t
50˚
50˚
l a
e l
a n n
C h
A t
ack
Bl a
Se
A
dr
ia
tic
Se 40˚
40˚ a
an
Aege
Sea
Tyr rh en ia n
S ea
e d i t e Ionian
M r Sea
r
a
n
e a n S e a
30˚
30˚
0˚ 10˚ 20˚
There is a distinct cluster of deterioration in central slow deterioration in crown conditions between
and eastern Europe and in Spain. It is well known 1989 and 1995 with a peak in 1992. The fraction of
that the air pollution differs strongly between the trees with a defoliation of more than 50% increased
two regions, indicating that other factors than air steadily over the period. The fraction of healthy
pollution alone must be responsible for the trees (defoliation of 10% or less) decreased over
decrease. There is however, a clear coincidence the period from 47% in 1989 to 39% in 1995.
between the high air pollution in central Europe However, the deterioration slowed down after 1992
and the high deposition of acidity. In this area with little change in crown condition occurring in
critical loads are strongly exceeded (Klap et al., the period 1993-1995 (see also Chapter 3.11).
1997). The temporal changes in defoliation for the
Norway Spruce, one of the most common As an example of a typical Mediterranean tree, the
coniferous trees over Europe (Figure 3.4.8) shows a results for Holm oak (Quercus ilex) are shown in
... /...
146 Environmental Issues
60 21-30
50 11-20
40 0-10
30
20
10 Figure 3.4.8
0 Temporal changes in defoliation for the Norway
1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 Spruce
Source: SC-DLO
Holm Oak
100 % of defoliation
90
51-100
80
41-50
70
31-40
% of trees
60 21-30
50 11-20
40 0-10
30
20
10
Figure 3.4.9
0 Temporal changes in defoliation for the Holm
1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 Oak
Source: SC-DLO
of NH3 emissions from agriculture are pro- Projected emission reductions in Europe (in ktonnes) Table 3.4.4.
jected under the baseline scenario.
EU15 Accession Countries
Transport and other sectors, mainly solvent
Pollutant 1990 2010 reduction 1990 2010 reduction
use in industry and households, are the main
sources of NMVOC emissions. Under the SO2 16 300 4 800 71% 10 300 4 300 59%
baseline scenario, emission reductions are
NOx 13 200 7 300 45% 3 500 2 600 27%
mainly expected in the transport sector,
resulting in a lower share in 2010. NH3 3 600 2 900 14% 1 400 1 390 1%
Contribution to EU emissions of SO2, NOx, NH3 and NMVOC, per sector, in 1995 and in 2010 Table 3.4.6.
Energy 58 49 19 19 0 0 0 0
Industry 25 32 12 17 2 2 8 13
*) *)
Agriculture 0 0 0 0 94 95
Transport 7 7 63 55 4 3 40 29
*)
Other 10 12 6 10 0 0 52 58*)
*)
VOCs from agriculture is included in ‘other’. The dominating contribution in the sector ‘other’ is from solvent
use within industry and households.
148 Environmental Issues
Indexed EU development of various road transport These values are presently under re-evalua-
Figure 3.4.10
parameters in 2010, relative to 1990 tion, taking into account revised emission
estimates calculated by Lloyd’s Register of
Between 1990 and 2010,
Shipping. Since the latest emission estimates
passenger and freight 200 are more than a factor of two larger than
transport will grow by about before, the estimated cost-benefit could be
40% and 80% respectively. Index relative to 1990
Consumption of fuel will (1990 =100) 150 even higher than 1 000 million euros/year.
grow less, with the
introduction of more 100 6.4. Emissions from aircraft
efficient engines. With the
introduction of technical
Although aircraft NOx emissions are in
‘end-of-pipe’ measures, a 50 absolute terms small when compared with the
further reduction in NOx emissions from road transport, their
emissions will be achieved. 0
For NOx and VOC, a
impact on ozone formation is relatively large.
Passenger Freight
reduction substantially transport transport In the main flight corridors about 1-4% of the
below the 1990 levels is ozone in the upper troposphere and lower
projected. Volume of passenger/freight transport
stratosphere is formed from aircraft emissions
Fuel consumption
Source: European VOC emissions
(Brasseur et al., 1998). According to aircraft
Commission, 1999
NOx emissions scenarios the enhanced ozone formation will
increase between 1990 and 2015 by 50-70%
(Valks and Velders, 1999).
international ship traffic will have doubled 6.5. Damage to ecosystems and health
by the year 2010 (Figure 3.4.11). Under the baseline scenario, significant
improvements in the area of ecosystems
As a consequence, reductions of emissions which are protected against acidification and
from international ship traffic would trans- eutrophication will be achieved (Figure
late into considerable reductions of the 3.14.12). The acidification impact reductions
pressures/depositions in western European are concentrated in northern Europe: the
countries, with the additional advantage of UK, northern France, Belgium, the Nether-
reducing the costs for reaching the estab- lands, Germany, Poland, Czech Republic,
lished environmental targets. Slovak Republic and Austria (see section 4.3
in Chapter 3.11). For eutrophication, the
In 1997, the International Convention for improvements are more dispersed across
the Prevention of Pollution from Ships Europe.
(MARPOL) proposed a new protocol to
reduce pollution from ships’ exhaust emis- In the EU, ecosystems that receive acid
sions. Reducing emission from international deposition above their critical loads could
ship traffic could be more cost-effective than decrease from 25% of the total (38.6 million
reducing land-based sources (Amann et al., ha) in 1990 to 7% in 2010 (10.6 million ha).
1997). The estimated savings are about 1 000 Ecosystems in several countries, such as
million euros/year. While the costs for France, Ireland, Italy, Spain are virtually no
limiting the sulphur content of marine longer exposed to exceedances of critical
bunkers in the North Sea and the Baltic to load. Other countries, where the proportion
1.5% (the maximum value accepted by of ecosystems affected by acidification was
MARPOL) were estimated at about 87 high in 1990 show considerable improve-
million euros/year, land-based sources ment. In 2010, the two countries with the
would experience a decline in their costs of highest proportion of ecosystems affected by
about 1 150 million euros/year. acidification remain Germany and the
Netherlands, although considerable im-
provement will be experienced; there will be
Contribution from international shipping in the
Figure 3.4.11 North Sea and north-east Atlantic Ocean to total reductions from 84% above critical loads to
European acidifying emissions 33% in Germany and 89% to 45% in the
Netherlands.
Nitrogen compounds and
15
In the AC10, the area of ecosystems with a
European emissions
10
ongoing acidification.
cation could decrease from 44% of all
5
Source: EMEP natural and semi-natural ecosystems (18.1
0 million ha) to 6%. In Norway and Switzer-
1990 1995 2010
land, these improvements are from 25% to
NOx SO2
13% and from 38% to 4% respectively. Very
Transboundary air pollution 149
large improvements in the impact of acidifi- Ecosystem damage in Europe: fraction of eco-
cation are projected for some Accession systems with depositions above their critical loads Figure 3.4.12
Countries. For example, the proportion of
ecosystems adversely affected by acidification
drops from 91% to 19% in the Czech Repub-
60
Eutrophication impact levels, however, reached in the north-west outskirts of Eu- Source: European
Commission, 1999
remain high in most of the EFTA countries rope (Ireland, Scandinavia). The target
and in the AC10. In the AC10, the value of 16 000 µg/m3.h will still be ex-
eutrophication indicator improves to a lesser ceeded in seven EU Member States.
degree from 84% of the area (33.4 million
ha) having a nitrogen deposition exceeding The reduction in the number of days with
the critical load to 72%. Countries where ozone above the health-related threshold of
over 70% of ecosystems will still be affected 120 mg/m3 varies over Europe (Map 3.4.8).
by excess nitrogen deposition include the Under the assumption of the most unfavour-
Czech Republic, Lithuania, Poland, the able meteorological conditions, the number
Slovak Republic and Switzerland. of days above the health-related threshold
falls from 67 in 1990 to 49 in 2010. There is
With respect to ozone, the reductions in however, a shift in location: in 1990 the
precursor emissions will lead to a reduction highest numbers of exceedances were found
of about 25% in AOT40 levels for crops in southern Italy; in 2010 the highest number
(Figure 3.4.13). Despite the considerable are found in the more densely populated
efforts in emission reductions, the long-term north-western part of EU (the Netherlands,
objective of 6 000 µg/m3.h will only be Belgium, and northern France).
Reduction in exposure of crops in 2010 in EU compared with the situation in 1990 Figure 3.4.13
Source: EMEP
20
18 1990
16 2010
Crop average ozone exposure
14
AOT40 (ppm.h)
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
United Kingdom
The Netherlands
Luxembourg
Belgium
Portugal
Ireland
Finland
Denmark
Italy
Austria
Greece
Germany
Spain
Sweden
France
EU 15
150 Environmental Issues
30˚ 20˚ 10˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚ 40˚ 50˚ 60˚ 30˚ 20˚ 10˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚ 40˚ 50˚ 60˚
Change in exceedance Arctic Ocean 1990 Arctic Ocean 2010
of ozone concentration,
1990 – 2010 60˚ 60˚
0 1000 km
60˚ 60˚
n
e a
e a
Number of days
with concentration
O c
O c
above the threshold
120 µg/m³ hourly average North North
Sea 50˚ Sea 50˚
i c
i c
in the EMEP 150 – grid
n t
n t
more than 40 50˚ 50˚
l a
l a
30 – 40 C h
a n n
e l
C h
a n n
e l
20 – 30
A t
A t
10 – 20 a a
Se Se
1 – 10 ck ck
Bla Bla
40˚ 40˚
areas with
no exceedance
40˚ 40˚
Map 3.4.8 M e d i M e d i
t e t e
r r
Number of days the WHO r a n e a
r a n e a
e a n S e a n S
criterion is exceeded for
30˚ 30˚
emissions in 1990 and for
projected emissions in 2010. 30˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚ 30˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚
Calculations represent the
maximum of the three-year
moving averages for the
five-year period considered
7. Future acidification and summer smog the requirements for ammonia emission
Souce: European policies reductions remain almost unchanged
Commission, 1999
(Amann et al., 1998).
7.1. Emission-oriented policies
An optimal emission-reduction strategy There is a – sometimes complex – relation
requires coordination of SO2, NOx, NH3 and between precursor emissions and environ-
VOC emission controls. At present, environ- mental quality. If a target on environmental
mental problems are treated separately, so quality is set, such as full protection of all
that acidification-related strategies empha- ecosystems from acidification, emission
sise reduction in SO2 and nitrogen emis- targets are implicitly set. So far, this interrela-
sions, ozone-related strategies prioritise NOx tion has been included in the development
and VOC measures, while eutrophication of EU policies using expert judgements.
strategies suggest the importance of NH3 Only recently have both the EU and UNECE
emission reductions. The focus on acidifica- adopted a broad approach which should
tion abatement is presently on nitrogen help to abate the problems of acidification,
compounds. NOx emissions are major eutrophication, as well as those of photo-
contributors to the acidification and chemical oxidants. This approach will seek
eutrophication of ecosystems and are at the to establish national emission ceilings for the
same time a precursor of ground-level relevant components that take into account
ozone. This implies that any emission reduc- the effect of the emission reduction in the
tion scenario should combine the evaluation various problem areas and the costs involved
of the consequences on health and vegeta- in emission abatement. For the first time,
tion due to ozone exposure together with agreements on abating NH3 emissions will be
their impacts in acidification. made at an international level.
Both the EU and UNECE have been working 7.2. Air quality, deposition standards, and target
since 1997 on a combined acidification/ levels
eutrophication/ozone abatement strategy, For the air pollutants causing acidification
seeking cost-effective solutions to minimise and summer smog, the WHO has recom-
the gap between critical load/level and mended air quality guidelines for protection
ambient levels. With the use of the new AAE of human health and ecosystems (WHO,
concept to calculate average accumulated 1995 and 1996 a, b). These recommenda-
exceedance to critical loads, significant and tions are applied to policy use in the Euro-
cost-effective reductions appear possible. pean Union as well as the UN-ECE. At
present the EU Council of Ministers has
The analysis of all these effects combined agreed on a common position on the pro-
increases the demand for further NOx posed daughter directives on ozone, PM10,
reductions, while the requirements on SO2 SO2, NO2 and other pollutants in the frame-
and VOC controls are somewhat relaxed and work of the Air Quality Framework Directive
Transboundary air pollution 151
Table 3.4.7. Global emissions in 1990 (Tg) and textiles. Recently, synergistic effects of
ozone in combination with the acidifying
Methane CO NOx (1) VOC (2) components SO2 and NO2 have been re-
ported to lead to increased corrosion. This
Fossil fuel production and 94 263 72 69
combustion affects in particular the materials most widely
used in our cultural heritage, such as mar-
Biofuel 14 181 5 31 ble, calcareous stone and rendering, medi-
Industrial processes 0.8 35 5 34 eval glass, copper, bronze and most construc-
tion metals.
Land use/waste treatment 211 496 20 44
Total anthropogenic 320 974 102 177.5 Recent results (ETSU, 1996) indicate that
the average cost of material damage is
European contribution (%)2 25 15 26 21 approximately 1 130 euros per tonne SO2
Natural emissions 160 70-280 23-131 1100 emitted, which implies a total damage cost of
13.5 billion euros per year for the EU in
(1)
in Tg NO2 1995. This probably underestimates the cost
(2)
incl. Newly Independant States (of former USSR)
of the damages if the enhanced corrosion
Source: Olivier et al., 1996; IPCC, 1996; EEA, 1995 levels resulting from the combined exposure
to O3 and acidifying compounds were to be
considered. There are two main reasons for
emissions of CO, methane and NOx will be this expected underestimation. First, the
necessary to control ozone concentrations in combination of SO2 and O3 increases the
Europe. actual corrosive attack on materials. Second,
the geographical distribution of potential
Ozone is also a greenhouse gas. The increase corrosion is expected to change when
in tropospheric ozone has potentially impor- synergetic effects are considered. Introduc-
tant consequences for radiative forcing (See ing the effect of ozone will probably enhance
Chapter 3.1). the corrosion levels in southern Europe, that
is, in areas with an extensive cultural herit-
8.2. Is our cultural heritage more in danger than age where the impact of corrosion will cause
our ecosystems? more damage.
Exposure to acidifying and photo-oxidant air
pollution increases the corrosion rate of The distribution of copper corrosion rates
materials. Gaseous SO2 has been considered illustrates well the above-mentioned geo-
to be the main explanatory factor for corro- graphical effect of the combined exposure to
sion damage to buildings and building SO2 and O3 air concentrations. Copper
materials. Ozone also affects materials such corrosion has been calculated from 1996
as natural and synthetic rubbers, coatings European levels of SO2, NO2 and O3. The
actual corrosion levels have been compared
to the corrosion caused by exposure to
background air concentration. Corrosion
30˚ 20˚ 10˚ 0˚ 10˚ 20˚ 30˚ 40˚ 50˚ 60˚
rates approximately 25% higher than back-
Exceedance Arctic Ocean
ground corrosion are considered acceptable,
of acceptable copper
above this corrosion levels are considered
corrosion levels 60˚
in Europe damaging. Acceptable corrosion rates are
exceeded all over Europe (Map 3.4.9), and
0 1000 km 60˚
decay rates are doubled in most central
n
e a
background value
North
reductions during recent years have reduced
Sea 50˚ corrosion damage in Scandinavia. In central
i c
50˚
100 – 150
l a
75 – 100
C h
a n n
e l
of SO2 pollution in areas of Germany, Poland
A t
50 – 75
25 – 50 a
and the Czech Republic where the corrosion
Se
acceptable less than 25 Bla
ck
rate still is more than three times the general
40˚
background for Europe. In southern Europe
40˚ the increased corrosion rate is mostly gener-
Map 3.4.9 e d
ated by the high ozone level, although SO2
M i t e
Note that the calculation will r r a a
may still contribute in some areas.
n e a n S e
underestimate the total
corrosion in the larger cities. 30˚
and the distribution of exceedances of Hjellbrekke A.G. (1997) Ozone measurements 1995.
EMEP/CCC-report 3/97, NILU, Kjeller, Norway
critical loads for acidification and
eutrophication brings the focus towards Hlobil, P. and Holub, J. (1997) Conference on the
southern and eastern Europe. This intro- Black Triangle. In Economy Press May 1997.
duces new elements in the discussion of the Hov, Ø. and Flatøy (1997) Convective redistribution of
harmful effects of transboundary air pollu- ozone and nitrogen oxides in the troposphere over
tion that will be worth analysing in the Europe in summer and fall. J. Atm. Chem. 28, 319-
337.
future.
IPCC, (1996). Second Assessment Climate Change
1995, Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on
References Climate Change. The Science of Climate Change,
Amann, M. et al., (1997) Cost-effective Control of Contribution of Working Group I. WMO, UNEP.
Acidification and Ground-Level Ozone. Second Cambridge University Press.
Interim Report, IIASA, A-2361 Laxenburg Austria.
Klap J.M., de Vries W., Erisman J.W. and van Leeuwen
Amann, M. et al., (1998) Cost-effective Control of E.P. (eds.) (1997) Relationships between forest
Acidification and Ground-Level Ozone. Fifth Interim condition and natural and anthropogenic stress
Report, IIASA, A-2361 Laxenburg Austria factors on the European scale; pilot study. SC Report
150, DLO Winand Staring Centre, Wageningen.
AMAP (1997) Arctic Pollution Issues. A state of the
Arctic Environment Report. AMAP, Oslo, Norway. Lindskog, A., et al. EUROTRAC-2 Tropospheric Ozone
Research, TOR-2. Full proposal. (1998) IVL, Göteborg,
Beck J.P., Krzyzanowski M. and Koffi B. (1998) Sweden
Tropospheric ozone in the European Union. ‘The
consolidated Report’, European Commission Brussels. Millan, M.M., Salvador, R., Mantilla, E., Kallos, G.
Also available at http://eea.eu.int. (1997) Photooxidant dynamics in the Mediterranean
basin in summer: results from European research
Berntsen, T.K. et al. (1997) Effects of anthropogenic projects. J. Geophys. Res., 102, 8811-8823.
emissions on tropospheric ozone and its radiative
forcing. J. Geophys. Res. 102, 28101-28126 Müller-Edzards C., de Vries W. and Erisman J.W. (eds.)
(1997) Ten years of monitoring forest conditions in
Brasseur, G.P. et al., (1998) European scientific Europe. Federal Research Centre for Forestry and
assessment of the atmospheric effect of aircraft Forest Products, Hamburg.
emissions. Atmospheric Environment 32, 2329-2418.
NILU, Exceedances of acceptable copper corrosion
Collins W.J., Stevenson D.S., Johnson C.E., and levels in Europe due to the combined effect of SO2,
Derwent R.G. (1998) The European regional ozone NO2 and ozone concentrations in air (to complete).
distribution and its links with the global scale for the
years 1992 and 2015, to be published. Olivier J.G.J., Bouwman A.F., van der Maas C.W.M.,
Berdowski J.J.M., Veldt C., Bloos J.P.J., Visschedijk
De Leeuw F., Sluyter R. and van Zantvoort E. (1997) A.J.H., Zandveld P.Y.J. and Haverslag J.L. (1996)
Air pollution by ozone in the European Union; Description of EDGAR, version 2.0. Report 771060
exceedances of ozone threshold values in 1996 and 002, RIVM, Bilthoven.
summer 1997. EEA Topic Report 7-1997. EEA,
Copenhagen. Parrish D.D. et al., (1993) Export of North American
ozone pollution to the North Atlantic Ocean. Science,
de Leeuw and de Paus, 1998. Air Pollution by ozone 259, 1436-1439.
in Europe; 1997 - summer 1998. EEA Topic Report in
press, EEA, Copenhagen. PORG (1997), Ozone in the United Kingdom.
Photochemical Oxidant Review Group, DOE, London.
EEA (1995) Europe’s Environment: the Dobris
Assessment. Copenhagen. Posch, M., Hettelingh, J.P., de Smeet P.A.M.,
Downing, R.J. (eds.) (1997) Calculation and mapping
EEA (1998) Europe’s Environment: the Second of critical thresholds in Europe. Status report 1997.
Assessment. Copenhagen. Coordination Center for Effects. Report 259101007,
RIVM, Bilthoven, the Netherlands.
EMEP/MSC-W, Report 1/98. Transboundary Acidifying
Air Pollution in Europe. DNMI, Norway. Simpson, D. et al., (1997) Photochemical oxidant
modelling in Europe: multi-annual modelling and
ETSU (1996) Economic evaluation of the draft source-receptor relationships. EMEP/CCC-Report 3/
directive on incineration of non-dangerous waste;. 97, DNMI, Oslo, Norway.
report to EC-DGXI.
Simpson, D. et al. (1999) Inventorying emissions from
European Commission (1997), Community Strategy to nature in Europe. J. Geophys. Res. in press.
combat acidification COM(97)88 European
Commission, Brussels. Slanina, J. et al. (1998) Biogenic and anthropogenic
volatile organic compounds in the atmosphere. SPB
European Commission, 1999 (forthcoming). Economic Academic Publishing, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Assessment of Priorities for a European Environmental
Policy Plan (working title). Report prepared by RIVM, Tonneijk, A.E.G. et al., (1998) Economische aspecten
EFTEC, NTUA and IIASA for Directorate General XI van het effect van luchtverontreiniging op de
(Environment, Nuclear Safety and Civil Protection). gewasteelt in Nederland. Report 90, AB-DLO,
Wageningen, the Netherlands.
European Commission (1999b), draft Ozone Directive,
1998 (to complete). Tsyro, S. and Berge, E. (1997) The contribution of ship
emission from the North Sea and the north-eastern
European Community (1996) Council Directive 96/62/EC Atlantic Ocean to acidification in Europe. EMEP/MSC-
on Ambient Air Quality Assessment and Management. W Note 4/97, DNMI, Oslo, Norway.
154 Environmental Issues
UN-ECE (1998) 1998 Joint report of the international WHO (1996a) Update and revision of the WHO air
co-operative programmes and the mapping quality guidelines for Europe. Classical air pollutants ;
programme. EB.AIR/WG.1/1998/4. ozone and other photochemical oxidants. European
centre for environment and health, Bilthoven, the
UN-ECE (1998). Convention on Long-Range Trans- Netherlands.
boundary Air Pollution, Internet web site (http://
www.unece.org/env/lrtap_h.htm), UN-ECE, Geneva. WHO (1996b) Update and revision of the WHO air
quality guidelines for Europe. Ecotoxic effects, ozone
Valks, P.J.M. and Velders, G.J.M. (1999) The present- effects on vegetation. European centre for
day and future impact of NOx emissions from environment and health, Bilthoven, the Netherlands.
subsonic aircraft on the atmosphere in relation to the
impact of NOx surface sources. Annales Geophysicae
(in press).