Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Professional Practice and Ethics Part 1
Professional Practice and Ethics Part 1
K)
Preamble ………...………………………………..………………….…..........…. 2
Table of Contents………...…………………………………….………..........…. 3
(V) Others
- Kenya Constitution
- Etc.
1.1.0 DEFINITIONS:
QUESTION: Define the following:-
(i) Profession
It is a vocation or calling in some advanced learning or science.
It is a paid occupation that requires advanced education and training e.g. architecture,
law, medicine etc.
Involves a relationship with clients or patients where the subject matter is complex
and the client depends on the professional man to advise and enable the client make
informed judgment.
(ii) Professional(s)
People working in a particular profession.
Persons engaged in a specified occupation of advanced learning or science for pay or
as a means of livelihood and involve more mental than manual work.
Are persons qualified or employed in one of the professions such as Doctors, Nurses,
Lawyers, and Surveyors etc.
A person with specialised training and competence in a certain sector.
(iii) Ethics
A system of moral principles or rules of behaviour.
Moral principles that govern or influence a person’s behaviour
“Ethics” in philosophy is the science of moral values and duties; the study of ideal
human character and conduct and consequences of it. Ethics develop when men
began to study the motives behind their actions and results.
Ethics is about our actions and decisions.
When one acts in ways which are consistent with our beliefs (whether secular or
derived from a moral authority) we characterize that as acting ethically.
When one’s actions are not congruent with our values - our sense of right, good and
just - we view that as acting unethically.
Defining what is ethical is not an individual exercise however. If it were, then one
could have argued that what Hitler did was ethical since his actions conformed to his
definition of right, fair and good. The ethics of our decisions and actions is defined
societally, not individually.
If society is dominated by a single religious or cultural belief system, as is the case in
some countries, then what is ethical and what is moral may be defined as the same
thing. In societies where there is not a monolithic belief system, there can be very
wide differences in opinion in society as to whether a given action is ethical (or
moral).
Consider several debates that go on in different countries. Often the controversy is the
result of people coming to a question from different moral positions or from different
values. Take the very difficult question of abortion. If your religious belief system
defines abortion as taking a life then you cannot be ethical (acting in ways that are
consistent with your values) and support the position that abortion is a woman’s
individual choice.
If your personal value system holds that control of one’s body is an inviolable
personal right then the idea that others - individually or collectively - can impose their
will on you is antithetical to that right.
Culturally we also see differences as to how values are defined. In Kenya, society
stands against nepotism. People believe in fairness to all employees in large
businesses and protection of employees from unfairness inherent in the situation
where an individual supervisor favors a member of his or her immediate family.
Fairness demands that nepotism should not be tolerated. In the Arab world, nepotism
is often viewed as an illogical concern. The cultural obligation to look after one’s
family outweighs other concerns. One would favor family. That is what family does.
That is the right thing to do (according to Arab culture).
Although we may agree on values, we may disagree as to which values apply or
which actions best satisfy those values.
And of course we have ethical dilemmas, where the choice is not between what we
believe to be right and what we believe to be wrong, but between competing rights. Is
ethics “situational”? The classic case: “Is it ethical to steal a loaf of bread to feed a
starving child.” The answer, “It depends.”
(iv) Code of Ethics,
Is a set of dynamic principles guiding the members conduct and professional practice.
It is the duty of every member of a profession to practice his profession according to
the professionals’ code of ethics.
(v) Code of Practice,
– a set of professional standards agreed on by members of a particular profession.
(vi) Code of Conduct,
A set of moral principles accepted by society or a group of people.
A set of laws or rules arranged in a system
Professionals have self-imposed code of conduct intended to correct the imbalance in
the relationship between the professional man and his client which nurtures or sets
limits to the said relationship.
The code of conduct is also intended to resolve the inevitable conflict not only
between the interests of the client and the professional man but also the community at
large.
(vii) Professional body,
Normally professionals in the same sector form an umbrella body to govern their
operations in a harmonised manner that maximises on their interests as well as their
clientele. Such an umbrella body, for instance ISK, normally have express code of
ethics and ensures smooth operations without the bottlenecks
(viii) Professional Conduct,
Basic values applicable to any profession.
ISK Professional conduct provision
- Every Member shall conform to the Rules of Professional Conduct as provided for
in the By-laws or as from time to time adopted by the Institution.
(ix) Discipline.
“Discipline” as defined in the Oxford English Dictionary means “Control or order
exercised over people, the system of rules used to maintain this control, the behaviour of
groups subjected to such rules, mental, moral or physical training, punish, chastise.
Page 5 of 88 By Valuer John Ikonya (August 2021)
Professional Practice and Procedures – Institution of Surveyors of Kenya (I.S.K)
(x) Surveyor
Definition: Oxford Advanced learner’s Dictionary - A person whose job is to examine a
building to make sure its structure is in good condition or to examine and record the
details of a piece of land. An official whose job is to check that something is accurate, of
good quality etc.
In the current ISK Constitution, unless the context requires otherwise, ‘Surveyor’ means a
person with the academic qualifications and technical expertise to conduct one, or more,
of the following activities:
i) To determine, measure and represent land, three-dimensional objects, point-fields
and trajectories
ii) To assemble and interpret land and geographically related information
iii) To use that information for the planning and efficient administration of land, the
sea and any structures thereon
iv) To assess the value and the management of property
v) To plan, measure and manage construction works
vi) To analyze, interpret and integrate spatial objects and phenomena in GIS,
including the visualization and communication of such data in maps, models and
mobile digital devices
vii) To manage, repair and maintain built environments and slum/urban renewal
viii) To manage housing and infrastructure development projects
ix) To sell and let property
x) To conduct research into the above practices and to develop them
(xii) Constitution
Definition: - A constitution is the system of laws and basic principles that a state, a
country or an organisation is governed by (Oxford Advanced learner’s Dictionary).
"The ISK Constitution" is the system of laws and basic principles that govern the
organisation.
"The ISK Constitution" sets out the Institution structure and policy orientation.
(xiii) By-laws
Definition: - (Oxford Advanced learner’s Dictionary).
A law or rule of a club or company.
A law that is made by a local authority and that applies only to that area.
"The ISK By-laws” sets out the laws and rules that apply to the Institution structure and policy.
Professional association
A professional association (also called a professional body, professional organization,
or professional society) is usually a nonprofit organization seeking to further a particular
profession, the interests of individuals engaged in that profession, and the public interest.
The roles of these professional associations have been variously defined: "A group of
people in a learned occupation who are entrusted with maintaining control or oversight of
the legitimate practice of the occupation;"
Organizations which "represent the interest of the professional practitioners," and so "act
to maintain their own privileged and powerful position as a controlling body."
This, in turn, places the burden of enforcing a Profession ban upon these associations as
well. Such bodies generally strive to achieve a balance between these two often
conflicting mandates.
Though professional bodies often act to protect the public by maintaining and enforcing
standards of training and ethics in their profession, they often also act like a cartel or a
labor union (trade union) for the members of the profession, though this description is
commonly rejected by the body concerned.
Therefore, in certain dispute situations the balance between these two aims may get
tipped more in favor of protecting and defending the professionals than in protecting the
public. An example can be used to illustrate this. In a dispute between a surveyor and
his/her client or between a patient and his/her doctor, the Institution of surveyors of
Kenya will inevitably find itself plunged into a conflict of interest in (a) its wish to defend
the interests of the client, while also (b) wishing to defend the interests, status and
privileges of the professional. It is clearly a tough call for it do both.
Many professional bodies are involved in the development and monitoring of professional
educational programs, and the updating of skills, and thus perform Professional
Certification to indicate that a person possesses qualifications in the subject area.
Sometimes membership of a professional body is synonymous with certification, though
not always.
Many professional bodies also act as learned societies for the academic disciplines
underlying their professions.
Professional associations and industry bodies have many purposes and functions.
They further the interests of the particular professional group or industry by serving as
a central ‘voice’ or advocate that communicates with government, other sectors and
the public at large on behalf of members.
They are often involved in research, policy and strategic development for the industry
as a whole.
They also regulate and guide the practice of professionals and may require certain
standards of training and ethics for membership.
Professional organisations and industry bodies may also advise educational institutes
on curriculum development, boost the public profile of the profession and provide
industry-related information resources.
Most professional organisations also offer professional development and training
activities for members. These activities are either directly related to the industry or
may be more generic in nature.
NOTE:
Professional organisations and industry bodies take a number of different forms. Some
may simply provide services to members for a fee. Others may oversee professional
certification that governs a member’s qualifications in an area. In other fields,
membership of a particular professional body may be a legal requirement to be able to
practice in the profession.
- Responsibilities, needs and opportunities that the professional body sets or defines in
its objectives.
- The type of discipline that constitutes its membership ( single or multi disciplinary);
- The philosophy of grouping these disciplines in divisions or chapters and the level of
autonomy they enjoy from the dictates of the main body;
- The need for efficiency and effectiveness in resolving the above into internal
administration or management (policy definition and execution of the same);
- Financial considerations;
- Balancing of the inevitable hostile brothers in private practice and public employment;
- Statutory surveillance on the affairs of the profession;
- The influences of the technological and social-economic, cultural and political climate
or changes.
Forming these organisations can be expensive in terms of office space rent, staff
remuneration and other office expenses.
Prohibitive set up costs which include registration of organisation, acquiring premises
to operate from, recruiting and remunerating staff, procuring furniture, equipment,
and other related costs.
Formulation of a constitution and/or rules and regulations that are acceptable to all
members by consensus may be difficult.
Bureaucratic registration procedures resulting to unnecessary delays and expenses.
Hostilities from other professions or members of public in both private and public
sector.
Lack of political goodwill.
Resistance from those practising but unqualified “professionals” e.g. unqualified
estate agents.
Legislation Challenges – when forming organisations like the ISK, it is important to
have a set of laws and principles which form the policy and framework for the
professional organisation. Coming up with a constitution which satisfies the
requirements of ISK is not easy because of challenges of implementation. Coming up
with bylaws of ISK also requires a lot of time and sacrifice which not many members
of the ISK are ready to offer as they are busy running other errands.
Financial Constraints – organisations like the ISK need a substantial amount of money
to conduct their day to day business and be able to cater for the salaries, expenses and
rent for the offices. The formation of an organisation therefore becomes very
challenging due to lack of enough funds.
Membership Issues – organisations like the ISK face a problem of lack of enough
members especially at the formation stage. Members are important to an organisation
to pay fees and subscriptions which help fund the activities. This fact tends to repel
some members which make formation of such an organisation a challenge.
A small capital base due to the fact that membership is still low.
Low membership.
Limited infrastructure in terms of plant and equipment.
A lot of sensitization and mobilization needed not only among the prospective
members but also with other professional bodies and with members of the public.
Ignorance and lack of awareness of the need for the organisation.
Firstly would be establishment of its membership. It is sort of difficult to know the to
be list of who are members. This is because the members would be spread all over
doing different engagements and therefore difficult to establish their members.
Some members may not be ready to join the organisation therefore may require sort of
explaining to them the importance of joining such organisations.
It costs time and money to establish an organisation. This may be a challenge
especially during the establishment since source of such funds would be an issue.
Lack of the necessary legislation to facilitate establishment of such an organisation.
When legal provisions are not fully established. Establishing an organisation becomes
challenging.
At the time of the establishment it may require personal passion and will to establish
such an organisation. If the initial members do not have passion for their profession
and see the need to establish the organisation, then it may be time to establish it.
Political goodwill of the nation in which such an organisation need to be established.
It is obvious that unstable governments have little time for such organisations as they
will make them to be for opposing sides or rebels, etc.
3. Education. Many professional associations offer their members the chance to update
their knowledge of business and trade basics or acquire new job skills through
seminars, workshops, break-out sessions at conferences and online courses. Typical
subject matter can run the gamut from tax tips and small business financing to advice
about hiring and staff management.
5. Conferences and seminars. Members are often given priority registration for their
organization’s convention and may receive discounts on conference fees or special
rates on related expenses, such as hotel reservations and car rentals.
• Political clout. Large national organizations often have committees to track federal
and state legislative developments that could have an impact on their specific business
or industry. Such organizations have a significant political presence that far exceeds
that of individual members. Joining this type of professional organization enables you
to tap into the group’s political influence and resources.
• Civic leadership. As an individual businessperson, you may not have the time or
resources to sponsor a charitable event, partner with an educational institution or
otherwise participate in community activities. But if your professional organization is
active in civic and philanthropic ventures, you can become involved in many
worthwhile projects. Associations contribute to their communities in a variety of
ways, from providing scholarships and hosting career days for students to supporting
important charitable causes.
5 Reasons to Join
When someone asks me, “Why should I join a professional association?” my short
answer is simply leverage and resources. Professional associations are service
providers. These associations can perform many tasks, such as advocacy, public
relations and “bulk-buying,” more effectively than individual practitioners could
otherwise carry out. In return, members pay membership dues and volunteer for
association tasks to carry out the needs of the association.
Boards of professional associations need to rapidly and frequently assess the needs of
their members, plan ahead while responding to existing trends and advocate to protect
existing privileges while remaining open to new opportunities and responding to new
threats.
There are five services I look for in a professional association. These include:
Humans are social animals. They grow up in families, go to school with chums and form
personal friendships, and in business, they join professional and business organizations.
While the benefits of joining includes networking with your peers, learning the latest
industry developments and attending educational seminars, there are disadvantages.
1. Fees
Most professional organizations require the payment of annual fees. There may also
be an initial application fee as well. These fees will differ depending on whether you
join one association or several professional organizations.
2. Time
National associations may have an annual meeting, while your state association has a
monthly meeting. That may only be one evening per month. However short the
meeting is, your time does have value. If you belong to more than one association,
you could end up with weekly meetings chewing up your time. Time is also involved
reading the monthly newsletter, emails and publications. These associations may have
benefits by keeping you on top of what's happening in your industry, but the downside
is you aren't meeting new potential clients.
3. Expenses
In addition to the applications and membership fees, you'll also be spending money on
association breakfasts, lunches and dinners as well as transportation costs or gas
expenses.
4. Socializing
As one of the characters in the movie "The Quiet Man" said "when I drink whiskey, I
drink whiskey; and when I drink water, I drink water." His point was to focus on one
objective at a time, not mix the two. If the professional meeting is primarily oriented
toward socializing, rather than business, it may not be of enough value to attend.
Some associations dedicate more meeting time for mixers, nibbling snacks and
sipping drinks than they do for business.
5. Pressures
Once you join, you may be blissfully left alone. On the other hand, you may receive
weekly or monthly reminders to increase your pledge, take a position on a committee
or recruit other members. The association may take a stance on a policy that you don't
agree with and assume that all members will support it. A profession includes people
with a wide variety of political alignments, religious beliefs and personal values.
Sometimes an association forgets that.
The membership can be costly to members – costs to seminars can be high thus not all
members can attend. Subscription (annually) fees are also a challenge to some
members.
Requires time – members are expected to attend meetings and it can be time
involving. The leaders also dedicate most of their time in running the organisation and
their private business can sometimes be affected negatively.
Due to the increasing number of membership not every member’s ideas or
suggestions can be listed to and acted upon.
Regulations within professional bodies discourages innovation (closed box thinking).
Professional bodies regulations are rarely amended hence majority.
A dormant organisation will only log back the profession, create a bad public image
and reduce confidence in the profession and professionals practising it.
Most organisations do not engage their members on day to day activities of their
organisation.
Statutory regulations may not be firm enough to protect the interest of the members
and the general public for instance the Estate Agents Act provides that anyone of
good conduct could be registered.
Lack of branches all over the country makes members of other towns to be inactive or
less involved in matters pertaining the institution. Currently there are only two
branches of ISK one in Nairobi and the other in Mombasa.
The roles and regulations, if too stringent, may encourage brain drain where qualified
members move to other countries where the rules are somehow relaxed.
No free hand to try new things – members have to constantly check the provisions of
the membership they have before venturing into new ideas.
No advertising – members of professional organisation are not allowed to advertise
for their services.
Membership brings about the obligation of paying annual subscriptions and renewal
of licensing which is an expense to the member.
When an individual becomes a member of a professional organisation like the ISK
they become susceptible to the professional code of conduct if a member goes against,
the risk expulsion, reprimand and even paying of penalties.
Membership also requires that members must attend meeting and seminars failure to
which they will not have CPD points which are considered very key to a member in a
professional organisation. Attending meetings is not always easy for members
therefore a disadvantage to them.
Membership to any professional organisation like ISK calls for life long learning
(LLL) as long as one is a professional at whatever age. This is important as
continuous improvement as important for the professional to remain relevant.
The member is *** set of rules and the constitution limit the manner in which he/she
does business. In the *************
As a result, the ***** is less competitive ******************
The structure and policy guidelines are in brief determined by the following:-
Responsibilities, needs and opportunities that the professional body sets or defines in its
objectives.
The type of discipline that constitutes its membership ( single or multi disciplinary);
The philosophy of grouping these disciplines in divisions or chapters and the level of
autonomy they enjoy from the dictates of the main body;
The need for efficiency and effectiveness in resolving the above into internal
administration or management (policy definition and execution of the same);
Financial constraints;
Balancing of the inevitable hostile brothers in private practice and public employment;
Statutory surveillance on the affairs of the profession;
The influences of the technological and social-economic, cultural and political climate or
changes.
efficient accommodation for its staff and premises appropriate to its standing as
a corporate body.
e) Foundation.
Run by a board of trustees to offer scholarships, bursaries, research grants, give aid
to distressed members or their families.
a) To secure the advancement and facilities the acquisition of that knowledge which
constitute the profession of a Surveyor.
b) To promote the general interests of profession and to maintain and extend its usefulness
for the public advantage.
c) The institution shall be non-political.
d) The Institution shall encourage the formation of branches, but the headquarters shall be in
Nairobi.
LAND VALUERS:
1. A Valuer has done a rental valuation and is expected to submit a report to his client, which
he does not inspite of the fact that the client alleges to have paid the Valuer in full. After the
client is unable to get any response from the Valuer, he instructs an advocate to pursue. The
advocate does so without results. The advocate finally writes to ISK. On intervention by ISK,
the Valuer forwards the report to the client through the advocate. What would you expect of
the ISK Disciplinary Committee in a case like this?
2. The bank issues instructions to a valuer for a valuation report for mortgage purposes. The
valuer does not go to site himself but sends a trainee valuer who does not even work under
him. A report signed by the registered valuer is submitted to the bank, which lends money on
that strength. The client defaults on repayment so the bank instructs another valuer to do
valuation for forced sale purposes.
The report from the 2nd valuer indicates that the plot is vacant while that from the 1st valuer
indicates that is developed with a permanent house. While the 1st valuer puts the value of the
plot and developments to be Kshs. 270,000/=, the second valuer gives the value of the vacant
plot to be Kshs. 50,000/= in harmony with local values.
The bank therefore writes to ISK for determination of the case. It turns out that the described
permanent house belongs to the same client but on a totally different parcel from the one the
1st valuer returned a value for. The principal here is that firstly, the valuer did not himself go
to site neither did he use his direct employee. Secondly, the person who went to site ended up
relying on identification details given by the owner of the property. What decision would you
expect of the ISK Disciplinary Committee on a case like this?
3. The bank calls for a valuation report for mortgage purposes from a valuer who returns a
value of 5.2 million. Before the bank lends money to the customer, the later moves to a
different bank, which calls for another report from a different valuer who returns a value of
2.75million for the same property.
Both valuers indicate that there is a double storey residential building on the plot and they
appear to concur on the location of the property and the general description of the same and
the permanent development thereon.
The client disagrees with the 2nd valuer and asks the bank to request for a report from the 1st
valuer. The 1st valuer returns a report similar to the first one after his first visit-5.2 million.
Since the bank cannot lend due to the discrepancy, it requests the two valuers to reconfirm the
validity of their reports. They do so each defending their figure. The bank therefore refers the
matter to ISK for determination.
When called before the PPDC of ISK, each valuer defends their method/value upon which
they are advised to revisit the property. After the revisit the 1st valuer returns an open market
value of 4.0 million and forced sale value of 3.2 million. The second valuer returns a higher
value of 3.155 million as opposed to his first of 2.75 million.
Details reveal that the 1st valuer had used wrong details of comparison in deriving his final
value while the second valuer had understated the plinth area of the building by over 700sq ft.
Again what would you expect of the ISK Disciplinary Committee on a case like this?
MONEY: A surveyor had failed to account for institutional money since 1994 and refused to
respond to ISK correspondence all through-what decision would you expect of the ISK
Disciplinary Committee in a case like this.
From the above members should appreciate the complex nature of the complaints forwarded
to ISK. The committee is trying the best it could to make decisions on each of the forwarded
complaints within the facts and circumstances noted.
LAND SURVEYORS
After a newspaper advertised the suspension and reprimands issued to some members, a
complainant has written highlighting what he refers to as improper practice of a licensed land
surveyor. He alleges that the surveyor operates through agents who never carry out actual
surveys on the ground. He also pre-signs mutation documents.
Council has written for hard evidence to help in further investigations before a decision is
made. Some licensed surveyors are known to append their signatures on survey records as if
they had done the job. Such unethical practices eventually come to light when cases of
disputed boundaries arise. You can well imagine the embarrassment the licensed surveyor
suffers when he losses his professional credibility in the eyes his/her clients and professional
colleagues.
BUILDING SURVEYORS
The current council has not addressed any complaints on this discipline (that I know of).
Understandably, misconduct under this discipline could include:
Irregular condemnation of Government buildings for purposes of disposal.
Under-or over-quotation of cost of repairs required while taking over or handling over
buildings between different owners (Landlords).
Delays in advising building owners to renew their plot leases in good time which leads
to loss of value of property.
Failure to advise building purchasers about the correct state of buildings at the point of
purchase. This has led to situations where at times the cost of repairs may exceed the
stated worth of a building.
Please note that these surveyors too do not operate under statute. They operate under the
general ISK code of Conduct.
CONCLUSION
There is need to restore public confidence in our profession if we are to continue to be
effective in our important contribution towards national developments.
i. Surveyors should join Professional Associations, which provide a useful forum in
which they can exchange views and chart out the future of the profession for the
benefit of all.
ii. The infiltration of unqualified persons in the profession particularly in the building and
property management discipline is a major concern and there is need to formulate a
legislation to cater for these chapters.
iii. Closer co-operation to be encouraged between surveyors, planners and other
stakeholders in the provision of services by land development professionals.
iv. The advances in science and technology and the increasing sophistication of clients
demand that the professional up-dates his knowledge. Hence the need to emphasize
continuing professional development (CPD) by, for example organizing Seminars.
v. The issue of professionals who operate as Government servants and are also running
their private offices needs to be addressed. We are aware that, at independence, there
were indeed very few professionals. Current statistics however reveal that the position
has since changed and there is now “an adequate supply” of professionals within and
outside the civil service. Should professionals in public service engage in private
practice despite the attendant conflict of interest?
Corruption: is defined as the abuse of offices of trust for private gain. It generally occurs when
actors in the private sector interact with holders of offices of trust in the public sector.
“Grand Corruption” which involves huge sums of money paid by major business to high
level politicians or Government officials.
Systemic Corruption: Which takes the form of substantial bribes paid to public officials in
order to obtain favours for example obtain licenses or permits or to by pass regulations.
Petty Corruption: Which involves modest payments to avoid delays, jump queues or obtain
goods in controlled markets.
1. Ethics and integrity in the public and private sectors: Reforms are required to
eliminate high level political (Grand) corruption and measures proposed include the
imposition of appropriate and adequate controls on the funding of political parties.
4. The Judicial and Legal Systems: An independent and competent judiciary which is
impartial, efficient and reliable requires objective criteria for selection, promotion,
removal, remuneration, security of tenure, accountability, independence etc.
5. Civil Society: Governments should regularly consult and collaborate with, and to listen
to civil society, who should be seen as an independent and creative partner in the
development of effective conditions to improve governance and combat corruption.