Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Change Management Module Participant Manual
Change Management Module Participant Manual
Change and uncertainty have always been part of life but what is
CHANGE shocking is the quantum and speed of change that is occurring in
MANAGEMENT today’s world. It is, undoubtedly, true that the impact of change has
affected the business and social life of human beings. As such, change
has become a primary characteristic of today’s world and those
seeking to survive, become successful and ahead of competition
should continuously seek and adopt new ideas or behaviors that allow
them to become leaders in their domains. It is the individual’s choice in face of change
to respond in one of the following manners:
Believe that we are victims of change.
Stand and wait for change to occur and then react accordingly.
Criticize the situation and never think of ways to handle change.
Navigate into various possible behaviors after anticipating the change and,
thus, take a proactive approach.
SOME FACTS ABOUT CHANGE
Change itself is a fact of life.
Change upsets the people’s understanding of the reality of things in addition to
initiating risks of failure when change occurs.
Change takes time and persistence.
Change is a universal phenomenon and those willing to succeed should be
proactive at all times.
Today’s world is characterized by a rapid and fast speed of change. Thus,
organizations seeking survival and prosperity should continuously be prepared
to quickly adapt to new situations.
Market changes are rapid and radical forcing organizations to reinvent
themselves.
Success in today’s world does not depend on just surviving.
Organization should anticipate change even when things are going right.
Change should be viewed as a tool for creating new opportunities for the
organization.
Successful change efforts require planning, organization, resources and actions.
Change is a sign of learning organizations.
Individuals go through different stages during change and thus have different
needs at different stages.
Change is a highly personal experience that is made by individuals and not
organizations.
Technological trends.
Changes in the nature of work.
COMMON SUCCESS FACTORS IN CHANGE PROJECTS
Planning: Developing and documenting the objectives that need to be achieved
by the change program and the means to achieve them.
Defined governance: Establishing appropriate organization structures, roles
and responsibilities for the change that engages stakeholders and support the
change efforts
Commitment: Ongoing commitment at the top and across the organization to
guide organizational behavior and leading by example. A committed workforce
is distinguished by the following characteristics:
A sense of belonging to the organization.
Confidence in management leadership.
Sense of excitement in the job.
Individuals willing to make things happen not just favoring change.
Informed stakeholders: Encouraging stakeholders’ participation & commitment
to change, by employing open and constructive communication approaches to
create awareness and understanding of change throughout the organization.
Aligned workforce: Identifying the human impact of change and developing
plans to align the workforce to support the changing organization.
LEVELS OF CHANGE
Individual level
Group Level
Organizational level
DEGREES OF CHANGE
Evolutionary: Continual improvement that takes place within already accepted
frameworks, value systems or organizational structures that is necessary for the
organizational survival and success. Therefore it is:
Concerned with incremental improvements
Based on existing systems
Fine tuning of already existing systems like for example process
improvement.
Revolutionary: This is a rapid change that alters accepted frameworks system
or organizational structures. For example, a breakthrough radical innovation
WHAT TO CHANGE?
Strategic change: This is an organizational renewal which involves change in
the company's strategy, mission and vision. This change would, undoubtedly,
have repercussions throughout the organization.
Cultural change: this involves adopting new values, what employees should or
should not do.
Procedural change: this involves reorganizing the company department
structure, coordination, span of control, reporting relationships, tasks, decision
making procedures.
Technological change: Organization development practitioners are involved in
changing the firm's structure, methods and job design using technologically
structural interventions, for example; employees collect data on the company's
current structure and then jointly redesign and implement the new structure.
CHANGE TEAM
Change committee: It must include:
Upper management.
Supervisors from affected areas.
Change leader/manager who will lead the committee.
Training and performance analyst who can determine the training needs
for the new implemented system.
Change agent: The person who as a catalyst assume the responsibility for
managing change activities i.e. anyone who possesses enough knowledge and
power to guide and facilitate change efforts. A change agent applies
transformational leadership in order to be able to:
Help develop a vision.
Communicate the vision.
Act consistently with vision.
Build commitment to vision.
To achieve the change agent role, the following skills:
Ability to solve complex business problems.
Excellent interpersonal skills with special emphasis on empathy,
perseverance and persuasion.
Strong communication skills.
Ability to work with challenge and ambiguity.
Deal with conflict constructively.
Analytical skills.
Project management skills.
CHANGE MODELS
ADKAR MODEL (PORSCI)
It is related to the process for individual change and thus, it looks at the
psychological side of change.
It emphasizes that successful organizational change occurs only when each
person is able to transition successfully i.e. successful individual change leads to
organizational change.
Assumptions:
People change at different speeds.
Individual change must be customized and care must be given to
matching change project phases to people change phases.
Organizations must help employees during the transition phase
through:
Gathering information from people on what is working (systems,
processes …etc.) and problem areas.
Distinguishing between resistance to change and objections to
proposed solutions and design.
Ability:
Knowledge involves the theoretical part on how to change,
whereas actual performance reflects the ability to implement
change
This is achieved through coaching and putting theory into
practice.
Reinforcement:
Ensuring that the change will stay in place – sustained change –
and those individuals will not revert to old ways.
This is achieved through:
Positive feedback
Reward system
Recognition
Performance measurement and taking corrective actions.
Why use ADKAR model?
Focusing on the individual enables measurement of the progress of the
change project and the provision of assistance when needed.
Communication strategies can be focused as the model directs change
activities. In other words, it describes the outcome of each stage
(Awareness, Desire, Knowledge, Ability and Reinforcement)
It allows managers to identify specific roles. For example, an individual
struggling with change may:
Need knowledge and information on how to change and thus
training could be a means of providing the theoretical part of
change.
Individuals may lack the necessary skills and behavior to
implement the change initiatives and thus, managers may
need to work closely with the individual, coaching them and
giving them confidence.
FREEZE PHASES MODEL (KURT LEWIN)
A model that is used for planned change.
The freeze model suggests that change involves a move from one static state
via a state of activity to another static status quo through a three-stage process
of managing change: unfreezing, changing and re-freezing.
Stages:
Unfreeze: Creating motivation to change. Thus it involves the process
of letting go of certain restricting attitudes during the initial stages of
change project. The objectives of this stage are:
Encourage replacement of old behavior and attitudes with those
desired by the management of the organization.
Devising ways to reduce barriers to change and thus creating
psychological safety.
Demonstrating the need for change as well as communicating
desired future to engender commitment.
There are a number of techniques that can be used at this stage. Those
techniques aim at taking people from a state of being unready to change
to being ready and willing to take the first step. Such techniques
include:
Burning the platform: This techniques aims at creating a crisis.
Thus, it involves showing people that staying in the current
status is not an option and if no change is initiated, a disaster will
occur. This is done by looking for a crisis and drawing the
attention of others to it.
Challenge: A technique that aims at inspiring people to achieve
remarkable things. In order to do that, it is necessary to
stimulate people and show confidence in their ability to get out
of their comfort zone and do what has not been done before.
Evidence: This is based on finding information, data, statistics …
etc. that support the need for change. There is no doubt that
core hard evidence is an effective way of changing the minds
who are arguing against change.
Education: This involves teaching people about the need for
change, how embracing change is an effective life strategy, the
methods of change and how to be logical and creative in
improving the processes and the organization as a whole.
Management by Objectives (MBO): A management approach
that tells people what needs to be done and leaves them to
decide how it should be done. Consequently, the success of this
approach is highly dependent on setting specific, measurable,
attainable, realistic and timely objectives –SMART objectives.
Once this is done individuals are left to determine how to reach
those expected results. It is important, at this stage, to
Structure
Strategy Systems
Shared Values
Skills Style
Staff
Hard elements: These are elements that are easy to identify and define
besides the fact that management can directly influence them. These
elements are:
Strategy: The plan devised to maintain and build a competitive
advantage for the organization over its competitors. In other
words it provides the direction and scope of the organization
over a long period of time and, as such, it could be viewed as
means for creating a value for the organization.
Structure: The basic organization of the company, its
departments, reporting lines, expertise and responsibilities.
Therefore, it reflects the pattern of relationship among positions
in the organization and among members within the organization.
Systems: The formal and informal procedures that govern
everyday activities like, for example, the ordering system, capital
budgeting procedures …etc.
Soft elements: These are more difficult to describe because they are
intangible and are most often influenced by culture. These Elements
are:
Shared values: The values and beliefs of the company that guides
the employees towards “valued behavior” i.e. the fundamental
ideas of the values that organization members identify with and
abide by. Shared valued are considered central to the
development of all the other elements.
Style: This is related to the managerial and leadership styles and
their effect on the overall operating approach within the
organization.
Staff: The organization human capital and how they are
developed, trained and motivated i.e. the employees and their
general capabilities and competencies.
Skills: The dominating attributes or capabilities of an
organization i.e. capabilities and competencies that exist within
the organization and reflects what the organization can do best.
7S Checklist Questions: These are some questions that are needed to explore
and helps in understanding the current situation of the organization as well as
the proposed situation.
Strategy:
What is our strategy?
How do we intend to achieve our objectives?
How do we deal with competitive pressure?
How are changes in customer demands dealt with?
Skills:
What are the strongest skills represented within the
company/team?
Are there any skills gaps?
What is the company/team known for doing well?
Do the current employees/team members have the ability to do
the job?
How are skills monitored and assessed?
Using the information gathered, an examination of where there are gaps and
inconsistencies between elements is performed.
The analysis process:
Start with Shared Values: Are they consistent with organization
structure, strategy, and systems? If not, what needs to change?
Then look at the hard elements: How well does each one support the
others? Identify where changes need to be made.
Next look at the other soft elements: Do they support the desired hard
elements? Do they support one another? If not, what needs to change?
An adjustment and alignment of the elements is made, one needs to
use an iterative -and often time consuming - process of making
adjustments, and then re-analyze how that impacts other elements and
their alignment.
The end result of better performance will be worth it.
The analysis matrix: A matrix that can be used to check off alignment between
each of the elements as one goes through the above mentioned analysis steps.
The matrix is made for the current and proposed situation.
Shared
Strategy Structure System Style Staff Skills
Values
Share
Values
Strategy
Structure
System
Style
Staff
Skills
CONGRUENCE MODEL
It is based on the principle that an organization’s performance is derived from
four basic elements, namely tasks, people, structure and culture.
It looks at the organizational components contributing to the organization
overall performance and create congruence in and between the four elements.
This will result in having people who are more satisfied and work will be done
more effectively.
The higher the congruence or compatibility amongst the four elements the
higher the performance.
The model offers a systematic way to consider the root elements that drive
organizational performance.
Culture
People
Steps:
Step 1: Analyze each key element separately
Tasks: This involves looking at the critical tasks that are done
with the organization from two perspectives: What work is done
and how it is processed. This involves answering the following
questions:
Remove obstacles
Mrs. Hala Abdel Meguid Omar CM - 18
Create short term wins
Anchor the changes in corporate culture
Denial
Anger
Bargaining
Depression
Acceptance
Shock:
It is the first reaction to a change projected that is announced to
people.
The initial reaction to an announced change starts when people
realize what the change means to them personally.
This is a critical stage for communication:
It is essential not overwhelm people with information as they
will only be able to take in a limited amount of information at
a time.
People need to know where to go when they want to know
more information
Enough time should be given to answer any questions that
come up.
At this stage, people need:
More information about the change initiative.
To understand what is happening and how to get help.
Denial:
Denial is a conscious or unconscious refusal to accept facts,
information, reality, etc., relating to the situation concerned.
It's a temporary natural defense mechanism: people may resist
change actively or passively.
Some people can become locked in this stage when dealing with
a traumatic change that can be ignored.
Anger:
It is recognition that denial cannot continue and thus a person
would experience misplaced feelings. For example, a person
would pose questions like:
Why me, it is not fair
How can this happen to me?
Who to blame
People dealing with emotional upset can be angry with
themselves, and/or with others.
This is considered a “danger zone” for the organization” and if
managed ineffectively may lead to a serious crisis or chaos.
At this stage, change leaders need to:
Carefully plan and prepare for the change project taking into
consideration the impacts and objections that people may
have.
Clear communication and support is required to minimize
the problems that people may experience.
The reaction to change may be personal and can be
emotional. Consequently listening skills are required.
Development of mechanisms that help in responding to the
unexpected.
Bargaining:
The hope that the individual can somehow postpone, delay or
neutralize the change or get an adequate compensation. For
example, the individual would ask questions like:
What is in it for me?
What can I do?
It is at this stage that individuals seek to find compromises for
the situation.
Depression:
It is at this stage that people start to understand the certainty of
change. Therefore, it is a state of emotional acceptance.
At this stage people may:
Become silent.
Refuse dialogue and much time with peers who feel the
same.
It is an important time for grieving that must be processed and
individuals, at this stage, may pose questions like:
Why bother with anything?
What is the point and why are they doing this?
Acceptance:
The organization starts to come out of the “danger zone” and is
on the way to making a success of the changes.
People buy-in and start to become proactive i.e. people’s
acceptance grow as they will need to test and explore what the
change means.
Individuals become emotionally objective.
Changes start to become second nature and people embrace the
improvements to the way they work.
Uninformed optimism:
In the first stage of positive change, the person is excited and
intrigued by the change. They look forward to it with eager
anticipation, building a very positive and often over-optimistic
view, for example that it will be much easier for them and
resolve all of their current issues.
Though people are positively happy with the change but
unfortunately this honeymoon period does not last for a long
period of time.
Informed pessimism:
Individuals find that things have not all fallen into place:
Other people have not magically become as cooperative as
they expected
Things are just not as easy as they had expected.
This pushes them over into a period of gloom when they realize
that perfection is not that easy to attain. This may evidence itself
in mutterings and grumblings, but still does not reach the depths
of the depression stage of negative change perception unless
the person flips into a delayed negative cycle.
Informed optimism:
The original optimism starts to reassert itself, now tinted by a
resignation to the reality of the situation because a positive
sense of potential begins to come back.
People start making realistic plans and move forward with an
informed sense of optimism.
Completion:
Things reach a relatively steady platform of realistic and
workable action.
The person is probably happier than they were before the
change started and, with their realistic vision, have the potential
to reach higher levels of happiness as they achieve more of their
potential.
WHY CHANGE INITIATIVES FAIL?
The organization had not been clear about the reasons for the change and the
overall objectives.
Organizations had failed to move from talking to action quickly enough. This
leads to mixed messages and gives resistance a better opportunity to focus.
The leaders had not been prepared for the change of management style
required to manage a changed business or one where change is the norm. "
The mentality of "now we're going to do change and then we'll get back to
normal" causes the failure. Change as the cliché goes is a constant; so a one off
program, which presumably has a start and a finish, doesn't address the long-
term change in management style.
They had chosen a change methodology or approach that did not suit the
business.
The organization had not been prepared and the internal culture had 'pushed
back' against the change.
The business had 'ram raided' certain functions with little regard to the overall
business i.e. they had changed one part of the process and not considered the
impact up or downstream. In short they had panicked and were looking for a
quick win or to declare victory too soon.
They had set the strategic direction for the change and then the leaders had
remained remote from the change leaving the actual change to less motivated
people.
RESISTANCE TO CHANGE: A MAJOR REASON FOR CHANGE EFFORTS FAILURE
Definition of Resistance: It is any conduct that tries to maintain the status quo
in face of pressure to change.
Why people resist change?
Announcing what the change will be and expecting people to comply:
Failure to recognize that people are creatures of habits who are
usually satisfied with their status quo. Hence, people initially
resist change.
People may have had past negative experience with change
efforts.
Organizational change initiatives involve changing people who
have to take the decision to change.
Distinction between the change situation and transition period:
Change is a situational event that occurs as a result of new
technology introduction or new policy initiation or new team
roles …etc. As such, it involves a transition – a psychological
process that people go through to come to terms with the new
change.
Organizations generally fail to minimize the negative
consequences of transition because of the following reasons:
Employees fear to succeed in the post change work
environment.
Consequences:
What is in it for the individual personally if he/she
demonstrates compliance with the proposed change
initiative?
MANAGING ORGANIZATION CHANGE DEVELOPMENT
Definition: A special approach to organizational change in which employees
themselves formulate and implement the change that is required, often with
the help of a trained consultant and handled by Human Resources.
Characteristics
Involves action research which includes:
Data collection about groups, departments and/or the
organization
Feeding information back to employees to analyze it and
develop a hypothesis about what the problem might be.
Behavioral science knowledge application to improve organizational
effectiveness.
Changes in the organization directions, especially in improving problem
solving, responsiveness, quality of work and effectiveness.
CATEGORIES OF ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE DEVELOPMENT
Human process application:
They aim at improving human relations skills through providing
employees with skills to analyze their own behavior and the behavior of
others.
Tools:
Sensitivity training (laboratory or t-training) is the most widely
used technique in human process application. Its process is as
follows:
1. 10 – 15 people meet away from work with no specific
agenda for the meeting; rather the focus is on feelings
and emotions of the group members during the meeting.
2. The facilitator encourages open expression of feelings
and participants are asked to portray themselves as they
are.
3. The success of t-group depends on the feedback each
person gets from other members of the group.