Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A2SportsFront 4-21-11
A2SportsFront 4-21-11
SECTION C
Log onto our Web site
for additional stories, local
video and daily updates
on everything Ann Arbor.
Department
GENERAL
ADMISSION
Girls’
lacrosse
needs an
overhaul
MIKE LARSON
of
defense Huron shuts down rival
Skyline 1-0 in SEC opener
L
acrosse is a beautiful By Mike Larson
game. A2 Journal
O
Photo by Kelton Kaye/A2SPORTSPHOTOS.COM
It’s fluid, fast-paced and
high-scoring. Huron’s Casie Ammerman attempts n Saturday afternoon, experience defeated
It’s fun to play and it’s to get the ball past Skylines Rachel youth.
fun to watch, even if you aren’t Johnston. Or maybe it was a staunch defense that
an expert with the rules. shut down a dynamic offense.
In short, lacrosse is every- Any way you slice it, when the Ann
thing that a sport should be. Arbor Huron girls’ soccer team traveled across
But the sport is flawed, spe- town to play Skyline, it was the senior-laden
cifically in the girls’ game. River Rats that came away with the 1-0 victory
I know, I know. in the first Southeastern Conference Red game
I’m sure a red flag just went for both squads.
up in your brain and the words “Skyline did a great job,” Huron coach Reese
“sexist” and “pig” are flashing Richardson said. “But our defense was just a
through your grey matter like a little too much for them.”
neon sign. Huron (1-1-1 overall, 1-0 SEC), which recent-
But hear me out. ly played state finalist Plymouth to a 0-0 tie, is
It’s no secret that there are a team that is very defensive-minded.
several women’s sports that, “Our strength is our defense,” Richardson
even at the professional level said. “We know that. We know that we have to
get a bum rap because they are hold teams scoreless if we are going to give
perceived as boring or uninter- ourselves a good chance to win. And
esting. that’s what we did against Skyline.”
Think WNBA. Huron got on the board early, get-
Yeah, I’m sure those signs ting a goal from McKinlee
in your head we were talking Ward in the ninth minute of
about earlier are flashing dou- the first half.
ble time now, but think about it. After that, the River
Even when there was a Rats put the clamps on
WNBA franchise in this area and refused to give up an
(before it packed up and moved inch.
to the sports’ Mecca that is Huron kept its focus
Tulsa, Okla.), the team was largely on Skyline
playing for championships and freshman Cienna Real-
the franchise had to give tickets Whitsitt, who has been
away in area gas stations to a big playmaker for the
even get people to show up. Eagles.
But lacrosse isn’t like that. “A lot of their key play-
Lacrosse isn’t boring at the ers are underclassmen,”
men’s or the women’s levels and Richardson said. “So we
the girls’ game isn’t any less fun had to really work hard.”
to watch than the boys’ game. The Huron coach said he
My beef with girls’ lacrosse was happy with the way his
is that there are just too many team played defense over-
stoppages. all, but that he was really
The stoppages are because impressed with the play
the rules of the girls’ game of Becca Wurster.
allows little to no contact. Wurster, a senior cap-
In the boys’ game, players tain, did everything right,
wear helmets, shoulder and
PLEASE SEE DEFENSE/2-C
elbow pads and gloves.
They play a physical style
that almost rattles your teeth
just watching the game. GIRLS LACROSSE BOYS LACROSSE
The girls, however, with the
OVERHAUL
field. ers needs to be tossed.
The lack of contact also They aren’t made of glass;
allows teams that have speedy they aren’t going to fall apart if
FROM PAGE 1-C players to completely take they get bumped.
advantage of the rules. These girls are tough and
just wear goggles to protect In boys’ lacrosse the majority they are capable of playing a
their eyes and mouth guards. of the scoring happens because contact sport at a high level.
They are also prohibited from a team works the ball around The game as it is now is dis-
body checking. the goal using crisp passing to jointed and defective.
In fact, contact with the head get the ball to an open player. But it can be fixed.
is so out of bounds that even an In the girls’ game, a quick All it’s going to take is some
accidental brush with a stick or player can get the ball and liter- simple rule changes and a few
body part within a seven-inch ally take it the length of the helmets with holes in the back
“halo” of an opposing player’s field and score. for pony tails.
head is a major penalty. I saw it happen Friday dur- Mike Larson can be reached
And these brushes happen ing the Pioneer-Huron game. by email at Mlarson@A2Journal.
pretty frequently. Is that how games should be com. Check out his page on
How could they not? decided? Facebook at www.facebook.
And every time it happens the Fastest player wins? com/A2SportsGuy and follow
whistle blows and play stops. I don’t think so. him on Twitter at www.twitter.
The flow of the game suffers I think this idea that female com/A2JournalSports.
tremendously. It makes the athletes are like delicate flow-
game so much harder to take in.
It’s like watching some kind
of riveting action movie, only
somebody hit’s the “pause” but-
ton every 17 seconds.
I believe the lack of contact
actually hurts the game.
Are girls really that fragile?
Go watch a high school girls’
soccer game and try to tell me
with a straight face that high
school girls aren’t capable of
banging around on the lacrosse