DKT 756-1-2-3

Case 3:15-cv-03522-WHO Document 756-1 Filed 08/10/21 Page 1 of 611
EXHIBIT A
NAF Attorney Hours and Fees Through May 7, 2021
DATE TIMEKEEPER HOURS AMOUNT DESCRIPTION
1 7/22/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.25 2,762.50 Fact research regarding leaked videotapes and
potential claims NAF could bring against
Biotech; emails with Lisa Brown regarding
2 7/22/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Review case materials.
3 7/23/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.75 1,725.00 Research and prepare complaint.
4 7/23/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.50 3,712.50 Review case documents; research on jurisdiction

and causes of action; attend team meeting.
5 7/23/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.50 1,842.50 Attend meeting; research.
6 7/23/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 12.50 10,625.00 Conferences with J. Serrano and A. Laks

regarding ;
legal research regarding potential claims
against Biotech on behalf of NAF; prepare
outline of note regarding potential claims;
emails and phone calls with client regarding
; team meeting regarding
7 7/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.50 3,905.00 Attend kick‐off meeting; legal and factual

research in connection with Article III
standing issues and temporary restraining
order.
8 7/23/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.50 1,825.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding ;

meet with team regarding
; review diversity research and outline
of issues; review contracts and NAF documents;
research regarding California Penal Code
section 632 regarding recordings and emails
1 of 610
with A. Peck regarding same.
9 7/24/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 5.25 3,832.50 Research regarding case background and review

background materials; review videos; review
client call notes; confer with A. Peck
regarding
and review
research regarding same; research regarding
causes of action for complaint; confer with T.
Beyer regarding ;
review draft law professor letter to Attorney
General; meet with team regarding
; confer with D. Foran regarding
; confer
with C. Robinson regarding
10 7/24/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 650.00 Library research regarding compensation for Fox

news guests.
11 7/24/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Prepare for and attend conferences with client

regarding ; fact investigation regarding
defendants' activities; draft complaint; team
meeting regarding
12 7/24/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 6.00 4,050.00 Review case documents; research on diversity

jurisdiction and potential federal causes of
action; attend team meeting.
13 7/24/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 9.75 6,922.50 Legal and factual research in connection with

Article III standing issues and temporary
restraining order; prepare outline of potential
2 of 610
witness declaration in support of preliminary
injunction.
14 7/24/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,010.00 Research; conduct attorney support operations.
15 7/24/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.75 2,662.50 Conference with C. Robinson regarding
conduct research
in support of same; attend team meeting.
16 7/24/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.25 2,415.00 Assist in preparing complaint.
18 7/25/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.50 3,712.50 Research on federal and state causes of action;

calls with A. Serwin and D. Foran regarding
; work on draft
Complaint .
19 7/25/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Research.
20 7/25/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Draft complaint.
21 7/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.00 4,260.00 Prepare outline of NAF's temporary restraining

order and motion for preliminary injunction.
22 7/26/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.50 837.50 Organize documents; research; attorney support.
23 7/26/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.00 3,375.00 Research on federal and state causes of action;

work on draft Complaint .
3 of 610
25 7/26/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 12.50 10,625.00 Draft complaint; phone conferences with NAF
staff regarding
26 7/26/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.75 1,952.50 Conduct research for irreparable harm argument

in support of motion for temporary restraining
order.
27 7/26/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.50 1,095.00 Review draft of NAF complaint; research and

draft causes of action.
28 7/27/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.75 2,185.00 Research and prepare complaint and TRO.
29 7/27/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.50 5,062.50 Research jurisdiction, service and causes of

action; work on causes of action for Complaint;
attend team meeting.
30 7/27/2015 ANNA FERRARI 6.75 4,792.50 Attend team meeting; conduct research in

support of motion for temporary restraining
order.
31 7/27/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.75 1,591.25 Draft pleading shells; research; manage team

meetings; edit graphics for complaint.
32 7/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 12.50 8,875.00 Draft portions of NAF's temporary restraining

order and motion for preliminary injunction;
attend team meeting
; telephone call with client regarding
; review and revise complaint.
33 7/27/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 7.50 5,475.00 Meet with team regarding

confer with H.
4 of 610
Taye regarding ;
confer with A. Peck regarding
; research regarding breach of
contract and invasion of privacy; revise
complaint regarding causes of action; confer
; confer with team regarding
34 7/27/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 12.75 10,837.50 Finalize first draft of complaint;

teleconference with NAF legal counsel regarding

attend team meeting regarding
35 7/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 13.50 9,585.00 Attend team meeting

; prepare TRO task list;
draft portions of TRO motion and motion for
preliminary injunction; telephone call with
Professor Dunn; review and revise Dunn
Declaration; review and revise demand letter to
Defendants.
36 7/28/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.75 1,265.00 Assist in preparing TRO and complaint.
37 7/28/2015 ANNA FERRARI 7.50 5,325.00 Draft inserts to motion for temporary

restraining order; research in support of same.
38 7/28/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.00 1,675.00 Conduct attorney support operations; research.
39 7/28/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 9.50 6,412.50 Research TRO standard and causes of action;
5 of 610
work on causes of action for Complaint; work on
motion for TRO; work on supporting
declarations; attend team meeting.
40 7/28/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.25 8,100.00 Research RICO issues; revise complaint.
41 7/28/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 13.50 11,475.00 Conferences with client regarding

; confer with J. Bennett, N.
Napolitan et al regarding
revise
complaint; confer with C. Robinson regarding
; revise demand letter.
42 7/28/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.75 1,023.75 Research for complaint and TRO.
43 7/28/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.50 2,555.00 Review video regarding Planned Parenthood; meet

with team regarding
; revise declaration of M. Mellor
and confer with D. Foran, C. Robinson, and J.
Serrano regarding same; research false light
privacy claim and confer with J. Serrano and A.
Peck regarding same; review update from client
regarding ; review NAF
case documents and case‐related media reports;
review TRO punch list; confer with N. Napolitan
regarding
44 7/29/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.00 460.00 Research regarding procedures for filing temporary

restraining order and setting expeditious hearing.
45 7/29/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.00 2,190.00 Revise complaint; revise declaration of M.

Mellor in support of TRO and confer with team
regarding same; review declaration and confer
6 of 610
with C. Robinson regarding ;
review N.D. Cal. local rules regarding filing;
review client edits to complaint; confer with
C. Robinson regarding ; review
client documents and support for TRO and
complaint; review declaration for V. Saporta;
research regarding proposed order to show
cause; review complaint filed against CMP by
Plaintiff StemExpress; review draft filings and
case documents.
46 7/29/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.75 1,725.00 Prepare complaint and TRO.
47 7/29/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 15.50 13,175.00 Revise complaint; conferences with client

regarding ; conferences
with team regarding
48 7/29/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 15.75 11,340.00 Research RICO and First Amendment issues;

revise complaint.
49 7/29/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 11.25 6,581.25 Research for complaint and TRO.
50 7/29/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 9.75 4,485.00 Prepare complaint and TRO.
51 7/29/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.00 2,835.00 Work on filings for claim against Center for

Medical Progress.
52 7/29/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 16.00 11,360.00 Motion for temporary restraining order.
53 7/29/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 9.00 6,075.00 Work on motion for TRO; work on declarations;

coordinate filing and all papers; calls with
team regarding
7 of 610
54 7/29/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Revise filing documents; research; organize

p:drive.
55 7/29/2015 ANNA FERRARI 8.75 6,212.50 Draft inserts to motion for temporary

restraining order; research in support of same.
56 7/30/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 19.00 6,365.00 Assist with drafting and preparation of

documents for filing.
58 7/30/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 11.00 6,435.00 Research for complaint and TRO; draft expedited

discovery motion.
59 7/30/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 14.50 5,872.50 Work on filing complaint and motion for

temporary restraining order.
60 7/30/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 18.00 12,960.00 Research First Amendment issues and causes of

action; revise complaint; revise motion for
61 7/30/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 3.25 1,495.00 Prepare for filing of complaint, temporary

restraining order, and associated documents.
62 7/30/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.50 2,485.00 Revise insert to motion for restraining order;

attend team meeting; research statute of
limitations issue; analyze whether it is
necessary to move to seal pleadings that
contain redacted personal information.
63 7/30/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 16.25 13,812.50 Revise motion for temporary restraining order;

revise complaint; preparations for hearing on
8 of 610
TRO.
64 7/30/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 13.50 6,210.00 Prepare complaint and motion for temporary

restraining order.
65 7/30/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.75 2,737.50 Confer with C. Robinson regarding

; confer with A. Laks regarding
; confer with J. Serrano regarding
; draft
proposed order regarding temporary restraining
order and order to show cause and research
regarding same; revise motion for temporary
restraining order; review case documents.
66 7/30/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 13.00 8,775.00 Work on motion for TRO; work on declarations;

coordinate filing and all papers; calls with
team regarding
67 7/31/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.50 1,825.00 Meet with team regarding

; emails with team; review case documents.
68 7/31/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.00 1,380.00 Prepare for hearing on temporary restraining

order.
69 7/31/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 9.50 2,470.00 Assist with filing of complaint and motion for

temporary restraining order; prepare materials
for hearing; transmit electronic files to
client and opposing counsel.
70 7/31/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 8.00 3,680.00 Prepare complaint and temporary restraining

order.
9 of 610
71 7/31/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.00 7,650.00 Prepare for hearing on TRO; phone calls and
emails with client regarding ; phone
calls and emails with team regarding same;
review TRO; follow up phone calls and emails
regarding same.
72 7/31/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 10.25 4,715.00 Prepare complaint, temporary restraining order,

and related documents for filing; file all
documents; contact court to attempt to set
hearing; research regarding bond requirement;
attend to service issues; team meeting
regarding
73 7/31/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 12.75 9,180.00 Research First Amendment issues and causes of

action; revise complaint; revise motion for
temporary restraining order; prepare for TRO
hearing.
74 7/31/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.25 2,936.25 Prepare complaint and motion for temporary

restraining order; prepare for hearing on
75 7/31/2015 ANNA FERRARI 0.50 355.00 Attend team meeting.
76 7/31/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.00 4,680.00 Assist with filing TRO and complaint; prepare

for possible hearing.
78 7/31/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.00 4,725.00 Work on and prepare TRO motion and supporting

materials for filing; research on injunctive
relief and First Amendment standards.
10 of 610
79 7/31/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.00 1,675.00 File documents; assist with service of
documents.
80 8/1/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 4.00 2,700.00 Research on preliminary injunction standards

for upcoming PI hearing; research on fetal
tissue donation.
81 8/1/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Prepare for oral argument on NAF's temporary

restraining order.
82 8/1/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.00 670.00 Research, compile materials for attorney

review.
83 8/1/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.25 900.00 Prepare for TRO hearing.
84 8/1/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.00 7,650.00 Preparations for hearing on TRO (review case

law, prepare outline).
85 8/1/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.25 325.00 Prepare materials for hearing.
86 8/2/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.00 7,920.00 Prepare for TRO hearing; research issues

regarding contract law.
87 8/2/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.50 8,075.00 Preparations for hearing on TRO; phone call

with lawyers for planned parenthood regarding
; phone calls and emails with C. Robinson
regarding
88 8/2/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 1.00 405.00 Prepare for hearing on temporary restraining

order.
89 8/2/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.75 805.00 Research regarding Ninth Circuit cases applying

Madsen, in preparation for hearing on temporary
11 of 610
restraining order.
90 8/2/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.00 3,375.00 Research on preliminary injunction standards

for upcoming PI hearing; research on fetal
tissue donation.
91 8/2/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.00 920.00 Prepare for hearing on temporary restraining

order.
92 8/2/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.25 1,423.75 Compile documents for hearing preparation;

conduct attorney support operations.
93 8/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.00 2,840.00 Prepare for oral argument on NAF's temporary

restraining order; conference with D. Foran
regarding same.
94 8/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 8.00 5,680.00 Prepare for and attend hearing on NAF's motion

for a temporary restraining order; attend team
meeting; review and comment on NAF's proposed
discovery.
95 8/3/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.00 2,835.00 Attend hearing on temporary restraining order;

prepare for hearing on temporary restraining
order.
96 8/3/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.00 1,460.00 Review Defendants' response to order to show

cause and supporting papers; review case
filings and materials; meet with team regarding
97 8/3/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.00 1,420.00 Attend hearing on order to show cause; analyze

First Amendment issues in defendants' briefing
for same.
12 of 610
98 8/3/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.25 8,100.00 Prepare for and attend hearing; draft discovery

requests.
99 8/3/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 9.00 3,015.00 Prepare materials for hearing; attend hearing;

organize post‐hearing materials; conduct
attorney support operations.
100 8/3/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 8.25 3,795.00 Prepare for, attend, and debrief hearing on

101 8/3/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.50 690.00 Research regarding Judge Orrick's prior similar

cases; review and analyze opposition to motion
for temporary restraining order.
102 8/3/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.50 5,062.50 Research and prepare for TRO hearing; review

and draft responses to defendants' opposition
brief; attend TRO hearing before Judge Orrick.
103 8/3/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 15.00 12,750.00 Prepare for and attend hearing on TRO; meeting

with client regarding
104 8/3/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.50 1,950.00 Prepare materials for TRO hearing; attend

hearing; create availability calendar; transmit
electronic files of case materials to
co‐counsel.
105 8/3/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.50 3,802.50 Prepare for and attend TRO hearing.
106 8/4/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.50 3,802.50 Draft written discovery, including RFPs, RFAs,

and interrogatories.
13 of 610
107 8/4/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Transmit electronic files of defendants'
pleadings and other case materials to
co‐counsel; research and download SMP press
releases; prepare associational standing in
privacy materials for attorney review; attend
team meeting; prepare team case calendar.
108 8/4/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.75 8,460.00 Draft and revise discovery requests; research

contractual and first amendment issues.
109 8/4/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.50 1,687.50 Attend team meeting regarding

; research on preliminary
injunction procedures.
110 8/4/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.75 2,596.25 Attend team meeting; refile exhibits in support

of TRO;
112 8/4/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.00 6,800.00 Team meeting regarding ;

review and revise draft discovery requests;
emails with client regarding
phone call with lawyers for StemExpress
regarding latest developments.
113 8/4/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 2.00 920.00 Team meeting regarding
114 8/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 11.00 7,810.00 Review and revise discovery requests; attend to

sealing issues; prepare team task list; attend
team meeting; prepare task list; review and
revise document retention notice; conference
14 of 610
with litigation team regarding ;
review and revise discovery letter to opposing
counsel; email correspondence with client
regarding
115 8/4/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 10.00 4,050.00 Prepare discovery requests; work on responses

to defendants' discovery requests.
116 8/4/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 7.25 3,335.00 Meet with team regarding ;

prepare and file motion to remove; prepare
protective order; attend to fact issues.

; research regarding associatonal
standing in privacy cases; review new video
released by Defendants; meet with team
regarding ; review
case documents; review update from StemExpress
lawyers;
118 8/5/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.50 1,095.00 Emails with A. Laks and T. Beyer regarding
review corrected exhibits and court
filings; review Defendants' discovery requests;
review facts from NAF to respond to Defendant's
discovery requests; review facts for fact team.
119 8/5/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.25 1,955.00 Prepare protective order; prepare and file

motion to remove; review discovery charts.
120 8/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.00 4,970.00 Review and revise written discovery requests,

deposition topics, and discovery letter;
finalize and serve same; conference with
15 of 610
litigation team regarding
review and respond to email
correspondence from litigation team; prepare
for meet and confer with opposing counsel
regarding discovery; attend to sealing issues;
telephone call with client regarding
121 8/5/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 2.00 920.00 Attend to issues surrounding legal reach of

confidentiality agreements; research regarding
attorney‐client privilege in the associational
standing context.
122 8/5/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.75 1,265.00 Prepare protective order and motion to remove.
123 8/5/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.50 3,240.00 Revise discovery requests; participate in team

meetings; review incoming discovery requests.
124 8/5/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Revise and edit drafts of document requests,

interrogatories; review discovery served on NAF
by defendants; prepare for and attend common
interest phone call with planned parenthood and
stemexpress attorneys; prepare for meet and
confer call with defense counsel regarding
discovery.
125 8/5/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.25 2,307.50 Meet with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, N.

Roethlisberger and R. Zack regarding
; review defendants'
expedited discovery requests; conference with
J. Schurz regarding
16 of 610
; conduct research relating to
same; draft talking points for discussions with
potential experts; emails with J. Schurz
regarding same.
126 8/5/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 8.50 2,847.50 Compile witness files; conduct attorney support

operations regarding discovery.
127 8/5/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.00 1,350.00 Research and work on organizational standing

memo.
128 8/5/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 9.25 3,746.25 Prepare responses to defendants' discovery

requests.
129 8/5/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.50 1,950.00 Prepare witness dossiers; download YouTube

videos discussing Daleiden, Newman, CMP and
Planned Parenthood; Download CMP video
transcripts; prepare plaintiff and defendant
discovery materials for subsequent attorney
review; prepare motion for temporary
restraining order briefing for subsequent
attorney review; prepare court documents
materials for attorney review.
130 8/5/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.75 3,363.75 Review discovery requests from Defendants and

begin to formulate responses.
131 8/6/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.00 2,340.00 Revise discovery responses.
132 8/6/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.00 2,430.00 Prepare discovery responses and objections.
133 8/6/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.50 1,950.00 Prepare discovery case materials for subsequent

attorney review; prepare court documents
17 of 610
materials and index; download and organize CMP
released videos and related witness videos.
134 8/6/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,010.00 Witness files; compile documents for attorney

review; compile expert witness materials;
update case calendar.
135 8/6/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.50 1,065.00 Review D. Cohen articles and correspondence;

meeting with T. Goldstein (journalism expert).
136 8/6/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.75 1,265.00 Finalize confidentiality agreement and attend

to discovery issues.
137 8/6/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.75 7,437.50 Prepare for and attend meet and confer with

opposing counsel regarding discovery; phone
calls and emails regarding stipulation
extending time for PI motion and hearing;
revise and edit draft stipulation extending
time; phone calls with client regarding
; draft
letter regarding contempt.
138 8/6/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.00 720.00 Confer with team regarding ;

review declarations.
139 8/6/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.00 2,130.00 Conference with D. Foran and A. Laks regarding

; telephone call with J. Dunn
regarding ; meet and
confer with opposing counsel regarding
discovery; review and comment on draft
stipulation to extend PI hearing; review and
revise stipulation to extend briefing schedule.
18 of 610
140 8/6/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.00 460.00 Research regarding privilege for members in

associational standing context; conference with
C. Robinson regarding
141 8/6/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.25 912.50 Research regarding videos on Defendants for

deposition preparation; review Order on
stipulation.
142 8/6/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 6.00 5,850.00 Review pleadings; meet with D. Foran.
143 8/7/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.25 3,060.00 Review fact issues regarding contempt; research

legal issues regarding contempt; participate in
team meeting concerning ;
review draft discovery responses.

; meet with team regarding
; review research on
damages for breach of contract claim and emails
with N. Napolitan regarding same.
145 8/7/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 5.00 4,875.00 Review pleadings; team meeting.
146 8/7/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 607.50 Confer with C. Robinson regarding

; attend team meeting on same.
147 8/7/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 5,950.00 Conference with L. Shostak and C. Robinson

regarding ; conference with C. Robinson
regarding
phone call with client regarding
19 of 610
; prepare for and
148 8/7/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.00 1,840.00 Calendar deadlines, attend to discovery issues,

finalize Po, attend team meeting, discuss and
review fact issues.
149 8/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.00 4,970.00 Conference with team members regarding

; prepare for and
attend team meeting; draft contempt letter;
email correspondence with opposing counsel
regarding meet and confer scheduling; meet with
D. Foran, N. Neapolitan, and DJ. Serrano
regarding ;
review and comment on draft Protective Order;
meet with A. Dunn regarding
confer with litigation team regarding
150 8/7/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,010.00 Compile case law for attorney review; draft

outbound discovery chart; draft video chart;
attend team meeting; witness files.
151 8/7/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 1,430.00 Attend team meeting; prepare court documents

files for subsequent attorney review; update
CMP video release tracking chart.
152 8/7/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 1.50 607.50 Work on discovery responses.
153 8/7/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.50 877.50 Draft discovery responses and communicate with
20 of 610
client with regard to
154 8/7/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.50 1,775.00 Attend team meeting; conference with D. Cohen

(potential historical expert); prepare
engagement letter for same.
155 8/7/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.50 1,012.50 Attend team meeting regarding

; attend meeting with D.
Foran, N. Napolitan and C. Robinson regarding
156 8/7/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.25 575.00 Team meeting regarding
157 8/8/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.00 670.00 Review press articles; review redaction

protocol.
158 8/8/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.00 1,755.00 Revise discovery responses.
159 8/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.25 177.50 Review news reports regarding case.
160 8/8/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.00 2,300.00 Assist on discovery issues and protective

order.
161 8/8/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 2,975.00 Review prior restraint case law cited by

defendants in response to motion for TRO.
162 8/9/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,275.00 Confer with C. Robinson and N. Napolitan

regarding
163 8/9/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Draft internal e‐mail memorandum regarding
21 of 610
164 8/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.25 177.50 Review and respond to email correspondence

regarding
165 8/9/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.25 146.25 Correspond with client regarding
166 8/9/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.00 460.00 Research regarding document preservation

obligations for members in associational
standing context.
167 8/10/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.25 575.00 Additional research regarding obligations to

preserve documents; telephone conference with
N. Napolitan regarding
168 8/10/2015 ANNA FERRARI 0.25 177.50 Conference with A. Dale regarding
169 8/10/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 9.50 2,470.00 Review and redact documents for production.
170 8/10/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.00 2,345.00 Review documents; team meeting regarding
171 8/10/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.50 1,822.50 Correspond with C. Robinson regarding

; confer with A. Ferrari
regarding same; conduct legal research on first
amendment violations by private actors.
172 8/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.50 1,775.00 Telephone call with B. Chavez‐Ochoa regarding

motion to withdraw as counsel for D. Daleiden,
CMP, and Biomax; email correspondence with team
regarding same; email correspondence with
22 of 610
opposing counsel regarding meet and confer;
meetings with L. Shostak and N. Napolitan
regarding ; review
and comment on NAF's letter regarding contempt
proceedings; telephone call with client
regarding
173 8/10/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.00 3,240.00 Prepare letter to other side regarding contempt

of court; prepare discovery responses.
174 8/10/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.50 2,070.00 Research case law in support of contempt order;

research pro hac vice admissions limitation;
prepare for depositions.
175 8/10/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 14.50 10,440.00 Prepare draft motion for order to show cause;

research contempt issues; confer with client
regarding ; review videos and
transcripts posted on Defendants's website.
176 8/10/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 2,925.00 Order to show cause regarding contempt.
177 8/10/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.75 547.50 Review team correspondence; review letter from

Defendants regarding contempt; review
Plaintiff's response letter regarding contempt;
review case filings.
178 8/10/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.25 1,316.25 Draft discovery responses.
179 8/11/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 2.00 1,950.00 Order to show cause regarding contempt.
180 8/11/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.00 730.00 Review T. Newman's response letter regarding

contempt; review research regarding first
amendment; review update on motion for
23 of 610
contempt; review case filings; review materials
for fact team; review parties' email
correspondence; confer with A. Laks regarding
181 8/11/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.50 2,047.50 Review documents collected from client for

possible production.
182 8/11/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.75 1,487.50 Review draft motion for contempt, confer with

C. Robinson and N. Napolitan regarding same.
183 8/11/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 12.00 8,640.00 Prepare draft motion for order to show cause;

research contempt issues; confer with client
regarding ; review videos and
transcripts posted on Defendants' website;
participate in meet and confer call; draft and
revise discovery responses.
184 8/11/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Correspond with A. Ferrari and A. Lawrence

regarding ; correspond with D.
Foran, C. Robinson, Z. Randall, M. Smolen, D.
Coleman, N. Napolitan, J. Serrano, and A. Laks
regarding
185 8/11/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.25 101.25 Correspond with A. Lawrence, A. Ferrari, D.

Foran, and C. Robinson regarding
186 8/11/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.75 3,372.50 Email correspondence with team regarding

; conference with N. Napolitan
regarding ; email correspondence
with opposing counsel regarding meet and
confer; draft correspondence to C. Short
24 of 610
regarding violation of TRO; meet and confer
with opposing counsel regarding contempt of
TRO; review and comment on NAF's responses to
written discovery requests.
187 8/11/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 4.50 2,070.00 Contact Court regarding filing of ex parte

contempt motion; draft administrative motion to
file under seal to accompany ex parte contempt
motion; research regarding whether the contempt
motion is a dispositive motion.
188 8/11/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.75 2,328.75 Prepare motion to show cause why defendants

should not be held in contempt; review
discovery responses.
189 8/11/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.50 2,512.50 Review documents; cite check filing; update

case documents.
190 8/11/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.75 805.00 Assist with contempt motion.
191 8/11/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.50 1,950.00 Review and redact documents for production.
192 8/11/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.00 1,420.00 Meeting with T. Goldstein, L. Shostak and J.

Schurz; attend to identification of medical
expert; emails with C. Robinson and A. Dale
regarding same.
193 8/12/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 11.50 4,657.50 Review and revise motion to show cause why

defendants should not be held in contempt.
194 8/12/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 14.00 4,690.00 Prepare documents for filing; review and

compile press articles; assist with filing of
motion for contempt; organize case materials;
25 of 610
review documents.
195 8/12/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.25 1,365.00 Download YouTube videos of witnesses; assist

with filings of motion for order to show cause
for contempt.
196 8/12/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 10.50 7,455.00 Email correspondence with client and litigation

team regarding
; email correspondence with
StemExpress counsel regarding ;
meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding
discovery; review motion for clarification
filed by CMP and Daleiden; review and revise
NAF's motion for contempt and supporting
papers; review motion to seal and supporting
exhibits; attend to filing.
197 8/12/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.25 575.00 Additional research regarding dispositive

motions; telephone conference with N. Napolitan
regarding
; telephone conference with C.
Robinson regarding
198 8/12/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 6.75 3,105.00 Assist with drafting and filing of contempt

motion.
199 8/12/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 15.75 11,340.00 Finalize and submit motion for order to show

cause and supporting documents; confer with
client regarding ; review
videos and transcripts posted on Defendants'
website; participate in meet and confer call;
draft and revise discovery responses.
26 of 610
200 8/12/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,125.00 Emails and phone calls with C. Robinson and N.

Napolitan regarding
201 8/12/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.00 585.00 Review documents for possible production to

defendants.
202 8/12/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.25 912.50 Review motion for clarification on TRO and

supporting documents; review case filings.
203 8/12/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 2.00 1,950.00 Review pleadings.
204 8/13/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.50 1,825.00 Review case filings; prepare for and meet with

team regarding
; review materials for fact team
205 8/13/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 9.25 5,411.25 Research in support of opposition to motion to

clarify TRO.
206 8/13/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,275.00 Emails and phone calls with team regarding
207 8/13/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.25 2,415.00 Attend team conference and follow up with

motion to remove and redacting documents.
208 8/13/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 12.75 9,180.00 Confer with client regarding ;

participate in team meeting; revise discovery
responses; draft meet and confer letter; review
Defendants' filings; resolve ECF issues;
research subpoena issues; confer with S.
Freccero regarding
27 of 610
209 8/13/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.25 506.25 Attend team meeting; research and reach out to
potential consulting experts on training
abortion providers.
210 8/13/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,300.00 Prepare court filings and case law materials

for subsequent attorney review.
211 8/13/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.25 575.00 Read recently filed documents; attend team

meeting
212 8/13/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.00 2,025.00 Draft meet and confer letter to opposing

counsel; research whether NAF can block
subpoena.
213 8/13/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.25 5,147.50 Review and revise NAF's motion for contempt and

supporting papers; attend to filing; prepare
outline of discovery meet and confer letter;
telephone call with L. Shostak and N. Napolitan
regarding ; conference with Sealing
Team regarding ;
review and revise meet and confer letter;
214 8/13/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 8.00 5,400.00 Work on response to Defendants' motion for

clarification of TRO; research on
enforceability of state government subpoenas;
attend team meetings; draft administrative
motion to strike.
215 8/13/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.25 1,758.75 Attend team meeting; compile materials for

attorney review; organize case files.
28 of 610
216 8/14/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.00 1,675.00 Research and compile jury instructions; compile
and review materials for attorney review.
217 8/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,195.00 Review and analyze motion to clarify; review

and respond to correspondence from client and
litigation team; review and analyze Defendants'
response to our meet and confer letter; review
order on motion for contempt; conference with
sealing team regarding
; respond to Defendants meet and confer
letters; review and revise email correspondence
218 8/14/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.00 5,760.00 Draft letter to the Arizona Attorney General's

office; confer with client and team regarding
; revise discovery responses;
review protective order issues; review
Defendants' filings.
219 8/14/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.00 1,350.00 Attend team meetings; draft motion to strike

defendants' motion for clarification of TRO.
220 8/14/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.50 1,012.50 Prepare discovery responses.
221 8/14/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.25 575.00 Confer with N. Napolitan and C. Robinson

regarding
222 8/14/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 3,825.00 Preparations for meet‐and‐confer with

defendants regarding motion to clarify and
related matters.
29 of 610
223 8/14/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.00 1,560.00 Prepare motion regarding contempt and
supporting briefing; prepare motions to clarify
Nucatola transcript and all subpoenas briefing;
download CMP released videos and related
articles;
224 8/14/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.00 1,755.00 Review documents for possible production to

defendants.

defendants.
226 8/15/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.75 345.00 Review and summarize opposing counsel's

redlines to protective order.
227 8/15/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.25 1,316.25 Review documents in preparation for production.
228 8/15/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.75 2,700.00 Research agency issues; review and revise

discovery responses.
229 8/15/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Email correspondence with litigation team

regarding ;
review draft interrogatory responses and
provide comments and strategic guidance
regarding same.
230 8/16/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.50 3,960.00 Draft meet and confer letters; confer with

client regarding ; review
discovery issues.
231 8/16/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.75 4,792.50 Review and analyze production documents.
232 8/16/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.00 585.00 Review documents for possible production to
30 of 610
defendants.
233 8/17/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.00 4,680.00 Finalize written discovery; analysis of

defendants' motion to dismiss.
234 8/17/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 9.00 8,775.00 Address discovery issues; review filings.
235 8/17/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 9.75 6,922.50 Review document production and confidentiality

designations; conference with litigation team
regarding ;
draft meet and confer letter regarding
discovery; conference with team regarding
; meet and confer with CMP
defendants regarding purported stay of
discovery; email correspondence with litigation
team regarding
236 8/17/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 3,825.00 Prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer phone

call regarding motion to clarify, anticipated
motion to strike and motion to dismiss, and
related matters; conferences with L. Shostak,
C. Robinson, and others regarding same.
237 8/17/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.00 4,725.00 Work on briefs responding to defendants'

motions regarding discovery and SLAPP; attend
team phone call with D. Foran, C. Robinson, and
N. Napolitan; attend meet and confer call with
opposing call regarding discovery disputes and
scheduling.
238 8/17/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 6.25 2,875.00 Draft motion to remove, Robinson declaration in

support of Defendants' motion to seal, motion
to seal, declaration, and proposed order, and
31 of 610
touch base with team regarding
239 8/17/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.50 1,012.50 Prepare discovery responses; review defendants'

motions.
240 8/17/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 14.50 10,440.00 Revise letter to the Arizona Attorney General's

office; confer with client and team regarding
case developments; review Defendants' filings;
research anti‐SLAPP issues; plan for addressing
recently filed motions.
241 8/17/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.25 887.50 Attend to identification of medical expert;

conference with P. Blumenthal (Stanford)
regarding same.
242 8/17/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.75 547.50 Review recent news articles for facts team;

review videos for fact team.
243 8/17/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,300.00 Download and save CMP released videos and audio

transcripts; review and gather materials cited
in Judicial Council of California Civil Jury
Instructions Penal Code §§ 632, 637.2; prepare
joint discovery letter briefing for subsequent
attorney review.
244 8/17/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 8.75 2,931.25 Compile case law for attorney review; organize

client documents; draft e‐mail to client;
prepare documents for upcoming filings.
245 8/18/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,010.00 Compile press materials; draft one‐page chart

of D. Daleiden public statements; compile
materials for attorney review.
32 of 610
246 8/18/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.00 780.00 Assist with preparation of exhibits for filing

of joint discovery letter.
247 8/18/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.00 2,835.00 Research legal issues related to motion to

dismiss; draft and review joint dispute letter.
248 8/18/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 14.50 10,440.00 Confer with client and team regarding

; review Defendants' filings;
research anti‐SLAPP issues; revise motion to
seal and draft supporting documents; set up
teams for addressing defendants' recent
filings; review court order.
249 8/18/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 8.50 5,737.50 Legal research and work on briefs responding to

defendants' motions regarding TRO, discovery
and SLAPP; attend team meeting and phone calls
regarding
250 8/18/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,125.00 Emails and phone calls regarding
251 8/18/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 12.25 8,697.50 Review and revise discovery letter to

Defendants; meetings to discuss
; review and revise amended motion to
seal and supporting declaration; draft joint
discovery letter; telephone calls with L.
Shostak and D. Foran regarding
; telephone call with client regarding
33 of 610
252 8/18/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.00 2,300.00 Finalize and file motion to seal and assist
with discovery letter.
253 8/18/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.25 1,642.50 Review NAF letter to Defendants regarding

discovery and protective order; review
Defendants' anti‐SLAPP motion; review
Defendants' letter response regarding discovery
and protective order; review materials for fact
team.
254 8/18/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 4.50 4,387.50 Work on mastery of all open issues in NAF case;

meet with C. Robinson, J. Serrano, N.
Napolitan; review new order; meet with C.
Robinson and J. Serrano.
255 8/18/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.00 2,340.00 Research on defendants' motions to dismiss.
256 8/19/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.25 3,656.25 Research in support of joint discovery letter

to court.
257 8/19/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 4.00 3,900.00 Work on joint filing through many iterations.
258 8/19/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 11.25 7,987.50 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding

discovery issues; conference with litigation
team regarding ; review and
revise joint discovery letter; review and
comment on Defendants' joint discovery letter;
analyze case law anti‐SLAPP discovery stay;
analyze protective order issues; finalize and
file joint discovery letter.
259 8/19/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.50 230.00 Contact Judge Orrick's courtroom deputy

regarding status of contempt motion.
34 of 610
260 8/19/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 10.25 7,380.00 Review anti‐SLAPP motion; identify factual

issues; draft joint letter to the court
regarding discovery issues; confer with client
regarding
; outline protective order issues.
261 8/19/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.00 2,835.00 Research issues related to discovery disputes,

motion to dismiss, and anti‐slapp motion.
262 8/19/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.75 1,277.50 Review Defendants' notice of withdrawal of

motions; review Goldstein engagement letter;
review seventh released video; review case
correspondence and documents for fact team.
263 8/19/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 10.00 6,750.00 Legal research and work on briefs responding to

defendants' arguments on discovery stay and
motions for clarification; attend team meeting
and phone calls regarding ; attend meet
and confer call with opposing counsel regarding
discovery disputes.
264 8/19/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.75 1,242.50 Review authorities relating to Penal Code 632

and 637.2.
265 8/19/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 10.50 8,925.00 Prepare notes regarding opposition to motions

to clarify relating to Nucatola video and
subpoena requests; review and analyze motion to
strike and to dismiss; preparations for hearing
on discovery issues and conferences with L.
Shostak and C. Robinson regarding same.
266 8/19/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Confirm dates and deadlines and assist with
35 of 610
research needs.
267 8/19/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,300.00 Review and download CMP released videos and

related news articles; prepare caselaw cited in
joint discovery letter briefing; update chart
of Newman's public statements regarding NAF/CMP
case.
268 8/19/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.50 2,512.50 Compile Troy Newman public statements; prepare

documents for upcoming hearing;. compile case
law; research press articles.
269 8/20/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.75 1,755.00 Prepare joint discovery letter briefing;

prepare orders materials; prepare case
background materials for subsequent attorney
review; assist with discovery hearing
preparation.
270 8/20/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.00 920.00 Assist with research and preparation for

hearing.
271 8/20/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.75 1,113.75 Research legal issues related to anti‐slapp

motion and Motion to dismiss.
272 8/20/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.25 1,758.75 Update case calendar; prepare materials for

discovery hearing; compile case law; research.
273 8/20/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 10.75 9,137.50 Preparations for hearing on discovery matters;

legal research regarding defendants' claim that
a stay on discovery is in effect; prepare
outline of key points regarding same; meetings
with L. Shostak and K. Hubbard regarding same.
36 of 610
274 8/20/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 810.00 Research cases law on motions for a stay to be
granted where 26(d) discovery has already been
granted by the court; email correspondence with
R. Zak.
275 8/20/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 8.00 5,400.00 Work on opposition to defendants' motions for

clarification of TRO; attend team calls and
meetings regarding
276 8/20/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.75 6,300.00 Prepare for discovery hearing; review motions

filed by the defendants; research elements of
causes of action.
277 8/20/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.75 1,242.50 Outline medical expert declaration; review

recently‐filed docket items and discovery
correspondence.
278 8/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 9.75 6,922.50 Meeting with L. Shostak and D. Foran regarding

; review and revise
stipulation regarding briefing schedule; review
and analyze cases cited in the parties' joint
discovery letter; prepare talking points for
hearing; prepare cheat sheet of briefing
schedule and proposed extensions in preparation
for hearing.
279 8/20/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 10.50 10,237.50 Prepare for hearing.
280 8/20/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.75 3,363.75 Research on amending complaint; research on

litigation privilege for opposition to
defendants' motions to clarify TRO.
37 of 610
281 8/20/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.25 182.50 Review case correspondence.
282 8/21/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.75 3,948.75 Review proposed redactions; research in support

of opposition to motion to clarify TRO.
283 8/21/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 5.00 4,875.00 Prepare for hearing and attend hearing.
284 8/21/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.25 2,936.25 Attend hearing on discovery disputes; attend

meet and confer regarding discovery disputes;
discuss
285 8/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.00 4,970.00 Prepare for and attend hearing; team meeting to

discuss strategy and upcoming assignments;
286 8/21/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Research Fifth Amendment discovery issues.
287 8/21/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.50 6,840.00 Attend hearing regarding discovery and other

issues; research issues regarding the Fifth
Amendment; organize team for ;
review draft oppositions to motions for
clarification; confer with J. Serrano regarding
same.
288 8/21/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Prepare for and attend hearing in discovery

matters; meet and confer with opposing counsel
regarding lingering discovery disputes and
assertion of Fifth Amendment; conference with
client ;
team meeting
38 of 610
289 8/21/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 167.50 Compile press documents; research redaction

project for production.
290 8/21/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 6.50 2,990.00 Research and draft validity of contract issue

in support of opposition to motion to clarify
subpoena.
291 8/21/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Assist with discovery hearing preparation;

review potential production documents for
redactions, prepare hearing transcript order
form; prepare motions to clarify TRO and any
subpoenas briefing for subsequent attorney
review; prepare articles cited in August 20,
2015 CMP letter to Daleiden.
292 8/21/2015 ANNA FERRARI 0.50 355.00 Conference with J. Schurz regarding

; conference
with N. Napolitan regarding
293 8/21/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 12.00 8,100.00 Work on opposition to defendants' motions for

clarification of TRO; attend team calls and
meetings regarding
; attend court hearing regarding
discovery disputes.
294 8/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.00 4,260.00 Review and revise motion to clarify regarding

Nucatola transcript.
295 8/22/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.00 3,375.00 Work on oppositions to defendants' motions for

clarification of TRO.
39 of 610
296 8/22/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.25 3,780.00 Draft opposition to motion for clarification;

research subpoena issues.
297 8/23/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.25 5,940.00 Draft and revise oppositions to motions for

clarification; research subpoena issues;
research contract issues.
298 8/23/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.50 2,530.00 Provide research assistance on fact and legal

issues in support of opposition to motion to
clarify.
299 8/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.00 4,260.00 Review and revise motion to clarify regarding

300 8/23/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.50 5,062.50 Work on oppositions to defendants' motions for

clarification of TRO.
301 8/23/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.50 1,417.50 Research consequences of defendants pleading

the Fifth.
302 8/24/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.00 405.00 Confer with R. Zak regarding

; research waiver of Fifth
Amendment rights.
303 8/24/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 14.50 10,295.00 Revise stipulated protective order; review and

revise stipulation on briefing schedule; email
correspondence with opposing counsel regarding
same; supervise filing of same; telephone call
with client regarding ; review and
revise motion to clarify regarding Nucatola
transcript; meetings with team regarding
; review and analyze cases
40 of 610
cited in motion to clarify; query and review
case law in support of motion to clarify.
304 8/24/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.75 1,265.00 Research and assist in preparation of

oppositions; calendar deadlines.
305 8/24/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.50 5,062.50 Work on oppositions to Defendants' motions for

clarification of TRO and supporting papers;
attend team meetings.
306 8/24/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 10.50 4,252.50 Research legal issues related to the fifth

amendment.
307 8/24/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 15.00 10,800.00 Revise oppositions to motions for

clarification; confer with client regarding
308 8/24/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 11.00 9,350.00 Prepare stipulation and proposed order

regarding pending dates in light of assertion
of Fifth Amendment; revise opposition to motion
to clarify regarding "any subpoenas";
conferences with C. Robinson and N. Napolitan
regarding
309 8/24/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.25 3,071.25 Research on Fifth Amendment rights of

corporations.
310 8/24/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.50 2,730.00 Assist with preparation of filing of opposition

to defendants' motion to clarify temporary
restraining order as it relates to any subpoena
and Nucatola transcript; review and redact
41 of 610
documents on database; prepare case background
information for subsequent attorney review.
311 8/25/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.50 1,825.00 Review media and comments tracking from client;

meet with A. Laks regarding
; emails with N. Napolitan and C.
Robinson regarding ;
review fact tracker charts; review court
filings; review letter from HOR E. Cummings
requesting investigation materials from CMP;
review court order granting stipulation
regarding discovery; review materials for fact
team.

to defendants' motion to clarify temporary
restraining order as it relates to any subpoena
and Nucatola transcript; review potential
production documents for confidentiality
designations; archive client e‐mails regarding
313 8/25/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.75 3,363.75 Research into Fifth Amendment rights of

corporations.
314 8/25/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 0.50 487.50 Strategy session with D. Foran.
315 8/25/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.00 2,300.00 Prepare motion to seal and finalize documents

for filing.
316 8/25/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 4.50 3,037.50 Work on finalizing opposition briefs to

Defendants' motions for clarification and
supporting materials.
42 of 610
317 8/25/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 10.50 7,560.00 Finalize and file oppositions to motions for

clarification; research contract issues.
318 8/25/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.00 5,100.00 Prepare outline of notes regarding proposed

revisions to complaint; prepare for and attend
meeting with planned parenthood regarding
319 8/25/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.00 2,430.00 Confer with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, and R. Zack

regarding ; research
First Amendment arguments; research Fifth
Amendment privilege as applied to compelled
production of documents.
320 8/25/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 9.00 6,390.00 Review and revise NAF's opposition to motion to

clarify regarding Nucatola transcript; review
and comment on NAF's opposition to motion to
clarify regarding subpoena; review and revise
declarations in support of oppositions; review
and revise motion to seal, sealing declaration,
and proposed order; conference with counsel for
Planned Parenthood regarding ;
conference with litigation team regarding
; legal research in connection with
filings; analyze and distinguish cases cited in
CMP's motion to clarify.
321 8/25/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 9.50 3,847.50 Research legal issues related to the fifth

amendment; review and draft opposition to
motion for reconsideration.
322 8/26/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 2,975.00 Prepare for and attend phone conference with
43 of 610
counsel for Feminist Majority Foundation
regarding history of anti‐choice extremism and
violence; confer with Nick Napolitan regarding
323 8/26/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.25 1,721.25 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding

;
research same.
324 8/26/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.00 6,480.00 Outline facts for amended complaint; research

issues regarding amendment; prepare for oral
argument; participate in meeting regarding
; organize team for
; research jurisdictional
issues.
325 8/26/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.50 2,070.00 Prepare stipulation regarding extension of time

to file amended complaint, discuss and prepare
for amended complaint and perform research and
review facts in support of same.
326 8/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Meeting with Covington lawyers regarding
327 8/26/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.50 2,632.50 Research issues related to the fifth amendment.
328 8/26/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.50 1,012.50 Attend conference call with team and joint

counsel at Covington regarding
329 8/26/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.50 2,555.00 Review emails and attachments from R. Sarkis

regarding to Arizona folks; review Defendant's
44 of 610
withdrawal of response for motion to clarify
TRO; draft legal research task list; review
correspondence regarding legal research; review
legal research regarding associational privacy
and first amendment; review briefing.
330 8/26/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.50 2,730.00 Download and catalog CMP and Daleiden videos

and audio transcripts; update threat tracking
chart; catalog client e‐mails regarding
; prepare case materials regarding
opposition to motions to clarify temporary
restraining order regarding subpoenas and
Nucatola transcript; Archive Newman Operation
Rescue Microsoft Powerboat and audio; transmit
motion to strike briefing materials for
subsequent attorney review.
331 8/26/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.00 1,420.00 Conference with N. Napolitan regarding
research same; instruct L. Ray
regarding
332 8/26/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 9.50 5,557.50 Reseach into Fifth Amendment rights of

corporations.
333 8/27/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 12.25 8,820.00 Prepare for hearing; confer with team regarding

; outline complaint
revisions review appellate issues; review court
order; draft amended complaint.
334 8/27/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 9.00 5,265.00 Research into Fifth Amendment rights of

corporations.
45 of 610
335 8/27/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.75 1,952.50 Team meeting regarding ;

assist A. Dale with Fifth Amendment research;
gather materials for T. Goldstein's review.
336 8/27/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.00 2,600.00 Prepare briefing regarding motion for an order

to show cause regarding contempt; gather
materials cited in fifth amendment privilege
research memorandum; create chart fifth
amendment privilege research case law organized
by circuit; update threat tracking chart;
update court orders materials and index;
prepare defendants' motion to strike the
complaint to dismiss the case; transmit case
filings to client; download Covington
presentation; download news articles relating
to case.
337 8/27/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 4.00 2,920.00 Review stipulated protective order; review

documents and expert report outlining deceptive
video editing related to Planned Parenthood;
review list of complaint action items; attend
meeting with team regarding
; review Court order denying
Defendants' motion to stay discovery; review
materials for fact team.
338 8/27/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.00 1,620.00 Attend meeting regarding

; research case law on personal vs.
corporate emails in fifth amendment context.
339 8/27/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.50 230.00 Review order denying defendants' motion to stay

discovery.
46 of 610
340 8/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Confer with D. Foran and N. Napolitan regarding

; meeting with litigation team
; review and revise stipulation
on schedule for filing an amended complaint;
review order regarding anti‐SLAPP stay;
organize case files.
341 8/27/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.25 1,035.00 Meeting regarding , confer

, review correspondence regarding
stipulation.
342 8/27/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.75 1,518.75 Research issues related to fifth amendment.
343 8/27/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 337.50 Review Order denying defendants' motion to stay

discovery; correspond with team regarding same;
review stipulation regarding amended complaint.
344 8/27/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,125.00 Prepare for and attend meeting with C. Robinson

and N. Napolitan regarding
; phone conference with N.
Roethlisberger and R. Zack regarding
345 8/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Review and respond to email correspondence from

litigation team; analyze CMP's anti‐SLAPP
motion; attend to filing of stipulation
regarding amended complaint; review and analyze
complaint; analyze Defendants' reply to motions
to clarify.
346 8/28/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.25 2,762.50 Attend conference with P. Flum regarding
47 of 610
;
meet‐and‐confer correspondence with opposing
counsel regarding stipulation on amended
complaint; review reply briefs in support of
motions to clarify TRO.
347 8/28/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.75 303.75 Research other examples of defendant's use of

sting operation videos.
348 8/28/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 4.50 3,285.00 Review news articles regarding case for fact

team; research to support complaint
allegations; review stipulation regarding
filing amended pleading; review briefing.
349 8/28/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.25 575.00 Research and discussion on outstanding issues

regarding complaint.
350 8/28/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.50 2,730.00 Prepare confidentiality redactions to potential

production documents; prepare briefing
regarding reply to motions to clarify subpoenas
and Nucatola transcript; prepare cases cited in
defendants' reply to motion to compel temporary
351 8/28/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.00 1,215.00 Research issues related to diversity and the

fifth amendment.
352 8/28/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 4.00 2,700.00 Research on federal cause of action under

federal wiretapping statute; research on
anti‐SLAPP procedures and evidentiary burdens.
353 8/28/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.50 1,775.00 Analyze potential CFAA cause of action.
48 of 610
354 8/28/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.75 1,023.75 Draft motion for leave to amend complaint.
355 8/28/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 12.00 8,640.00 Draft amended complaint; prepare for hearing;

confer with team regarding ;
review case law regarding computer fraud
statutes; research potential causes of action;
review defendants' briefs in support of motions
to clarify.
356 8/29/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.75 7,020.00 Prepare for hearing; review cases cited in

briefing concerning motions to clarify; review
amicus brief; research abstention issues;
research case law regarding amicus briefing.
357 8/29/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.00 2,840.00 Review and analyze complaint in light of

proposed amended pleading; review and analyze
NAF documents for facts to add to amended
pleading.
358 8/29/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.50 1,417.50 Prepare for hearing on motion to clarify.
359 8/29/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.50 1,012.50 Review amicus brief submitted by four state

AG's; research and
360 8/29/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,300.00 Prepare reply to motion to clarify temporary

361 8/29/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.75 3,187.50 Preparations for hearing on motion to clarify

subpoenas; review amicus briefs and email
correspondence with team regarding same.
49 of 610
362 8/30/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 1.00 405.00 Prepare for hearing on motion to clarify.

to State AG's' Motion for Leave to File Amicus
Brief; review prepare confidentiality
redactions to potential production documents;
update NAF threat chart.
364 8/30/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 3.50 2,362.50 Work on opposition to four state AG's motion

for leave to file amicus brief.
365 8/30/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.50 2,485.00 Review and analyze federal RICO statute,

federal computer fraud statute, and federal
international terrorism statute in connection
with proposed amended pleading.
366 8/30/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.25 6,660.00 Prepare for hearing; draft response to amicus

brief; research abstention issues.
367 8/30/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Conferences with A. Laks et al regarding
; preparations for
hearing on motions to clarify.
368 8/30/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.25 2,307.50 Conduct research in support of complaint

amendments.
369 8/31/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.50 2,730.00 Prepare redactions for production documents;

organize case materials for subsequent attorney
review; cite‐check opposition to state's AG
motion for leave to file amicus brief.
50 of 610
370 8/31/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.00 2,130.00 Conduct research in support of complaint
amendments.
371 8/31/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.00 3,375.00 Review for filing opposition to four state AG's

motion for leave to file amicus brief; research
on federal cause of action under ECPA; research
on equitable authority of federal court to
enforce own orders.
372 8/31/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 11.50 9,775.00 Review brief in support of Fifth Amendment

assertion by CMP and confer with C. Robinson
regarding same; preparations for hearing on
motions to clarify; conferences with client
regarding ;
confer with N. Napolitan regarding
373 8/31/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.50 6,840.00 Prepare for hearing; review defendants' brief

concerning the Fifth Amendment; participate in
team meeting regarding ;
review case law regarding motions for
clarification; confer with client regarding
374 8/31/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.50 2,070.00 Prepare and file opposition to amicus brief;

review briefing in preparation for hearing;
attend to case management and fact development.
375 8/31/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 10.25 4,151.25 Review and research issues related to the Fifth

amendment; prepare for hearing on motion to
clarify.
376 8/31/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Confer with R. Zack regarding
51 of 610
; review defendants' opening
memorandum regarding invocation of Fifth
Amendment privilege by defendants.

litigation team; telephone call with M. Fowler
and L. Brown regarding
review and
analyze CMP's motion regarding Fifth Amendment
privilege; conference with R. Zacks and N.
Roethlisberger regarding
378 8/31/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.25 3,071.25 Research on ability to quash Arizona subpoena;

analyze motion on Fifth Amendment filed by
defendants.
379 9/1/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.00 405.00 Review caselaw regarding whether state or

federal procedure applies to Fifth Amendment
invocation and adverse inferences; review
defendants' motion regarding fifth amendment.
380 9/1/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.75 2,733.75 Attend hearing on motion for reconsideration;

review 5th amendment briefing; research 5th
amendment issues.
381 9/1/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.00 1,380.00 Meeting regarding pending to do items; attend

to case management issues; attend to fact
development issues; review authority regarding
modifications of subpoenas.
382 9/1/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.00 920.00 Attend hearing.
52 of 610
383 9/1/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.50 2,485.00 Attend hearing on motions to clarify; attend

team meeting regarding
; email correspondence with
384 9/1/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.00 3,375.00 Attend court hearing regarding defendants'

motions for clarification; research on federal
cause of action under ECPA; attend team meeting
regarding
385 9/1/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.00 5,100.00 Prepare for and attend hearing on motions to

clarify; conference with client regarding
; team meeting regarding
; conference with CN.
Neapolitan and C. Robinson regarding
386 9/1/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.50 5,400.00 Prepare for and participate in hearing; revise

amended complaint; research case law regarding
state power.
387 9/1/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 1,430.00 Request hearing transcript from court reporter;

prepare cases cited in defendants' 5th
amendment privilege memorandum; prepare
redacted documents for proposed production.
388 9/1/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.50 3,217.50 Attend hearing on motion to clarify (2 hr);

research regarding Fifth Amendment rights of
corporations (3.5 hr).
53 of 610
389 9/1/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.30 949.00 Review news articles for fact team; review new

CMP videos; meet with N. Napolitan regarding
390 9/2/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.75 3,363.75 Research regarding motions to quash in Arizona.
391 9/2/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.75 1,235.00 Prepare redacted documents for proposed

production.
392 9/2/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 10.00 7,200.00 Research issues regarding state authority;

manage research projects related to state amici
brief; draft response to amici brief.
393 9/2/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.00 4,725.00 Research and work on memo regarding federal

wiretapping claim; work on letter responding to
Louisiana Inspector General subpoena;
394 9/2/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.75 1,242.50 Conference with N. Napolitan regarding

; analyze same;
analyze L. Ray research regarding bounties
against abortion care providers.
395 9/2/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.50 2,530.00 Research in support of opposition to Attorney

Generals' amicus brief.
396 9/2/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 850.00 Conferences with C. Robinson and CN. Neapolitan

regarding
54 of 610
398 9/2/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.00 2,430.00 Research issues related to judicial admissions.
399 9/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.25 3,017.50 Propose redaction protocol to be applied to

NAF's production of documents and discuss with
litigation team; conference with R. Zacks
regarding ; conference
with D. Foran and N. Napolitan regarding
; review and analyze 5th
Amendment case law.
400 9/3/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.75 1,113.75 Research exceptions allowing for expedited

discovery before a 26(f) hearing.
401 9/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 8.25 5,857.50 Review and analyze 5th Amendment case law;

review and comment on Defendants' supplemental
5th Amendment waiver brief; draft NAF's
opposition to Defendants' 5th Amendment brief.
402 9/3/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.00 1,620.00 Research issues related to 5th Amendment.
403 9/3/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.25 2,762.50 Review supplemental brief in support of CMFP's

assertion of Fifth Amendment rights against
self‐incrimination; confer with C. Robinson
regarding ; review amicus brief filed by
Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press;
prepare draft response to amicus brief filed by
Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press;
confer with CN. Neapolitan regarding
404 9/3/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.50 2,530.00 Research and analysis in support of opposition
55 of 610
to attorneys' general motion to compel.
405 9/3/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.75 1,952.50 Review amicus request from Reporter's Committee

for the Freedom of the Press; email J. Schurz
regarding same; research regarding CFAA.
406 9/3/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 10.50 7,087.50 Research and work on memo regarding federal

wiretapping claim; call with A. Serwin
on Younger abstention; send response letter to
Louisiana Inspector General regarding subpoena;
research and draft section of brief on First
Amendment cases in connection with responding
to amicus curiae brief by Reporters
Association.

408 9/3/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.25 1,885.00 Prepare background case materials for

subsequent attorney review; prepare redacted
documents for proposed production; prepare
materials cited in defendants' supplemental
brief regarding compliance with subpoenas and
testimony privilege; transmit court documents
to client; cite‐check response to AC letter;
gather research regarding anti‐abortion
subpoenas for public records.
409 9/3/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.25 1,901.25 Research regarding motions to quash in Arizona

(2 hr); research regarding Fifth Amendment
rights of corporations (1.25 hr).
56 of 610
410 9/4/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.75 1,235.00 Assist with filing of response AC letter;

update NAF anti‐abortion threat tracker and
database.

planned parenthood regarding
; review and revise
draft brief in response to amicus brief filed
by Reporters' Committee for Freedom of the
Press regarding prior restraint arguments;
confer with CN. Neapolitan regarding

brief; draft response to amici brief; review
and revise brief in response to amicus brief.
413 9/4/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.75 1,923.75 Research issues related to how immunity affects

5th amendment right against self‐incrimination.
414 9/4/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.75 1,952.50 Research potential CFAA cause of action;

conference with N. Napolitan regarding same;
email with D. Foran regarding same; emails with
A. Serwin regarding same.

draft NAF's opposition to Defendants' 5th
Amendment brief.
57 of 610

Amendment brief.
418 9/5/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.00 720.00 Research issues regarding state authority;

419 9/6/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 650.00 Prepare exhibits in support of response to

Amici brief.

Amendment brief.
421 9/7/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.25 900.00 Research issues regarding state authority;

draft response to amici brief.
422 9/7/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 5.50 4,675.00 Review and revise draft opposition to Sate AG's

motion regarding defendants' response to
subpoenas.
423 9/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Review and revise NAF's opposition to

Defendants' 5th Amendment brief.
424 9/7/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 1.25 506.25 Review opposition to Defendants Fifth amendment

brief.
425 9/7/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Read news coverage of case.
426 9/7/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.00 1,350.00 Review and provide edits regarding response
58 of 610
briefs on 5th Amendment privilege and on State
Attorney General amicus brief.
427 9/7/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.50 1,065.00 Research in support of amended complaint.
428 9/8/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 7.50 3,450.00 Research and draft analysis regarding UCL

claims and perform follow up research; research
and analyze cases cited in opposition to
attorney general's brief.
429 9/8/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.00 1,040.00 Prepare redactions for proposed document

production.
430 9/8/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 2.00 1,950.00 Review present filings.
431 9/8/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.75 2,193.75 Review draft of opposition to Defendants

assertion of Fifth Amendment rights for the
corporate defendants.
432 9/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.50 4,615.00 Finalize attorney declaration supporting NAF's

Fifth Amendment opposition brief; review and
revise NAF's Fifth Amendment opposition brief
to address D. Foran's comments; review and
analyze Defendants' supplemental brief
regarding Fifth Amendment privilege; review and
analyze case law cited in same.
433 9/8/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.50 1,417.50 Research issues related to Fifth amendment

privilege and immunity.
434 9/8/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Finalize oppositions to State AGs' motion

regarding subpoenas and Corporate Defendants'
motion regarding assertion of Fifth Amendment
59 of 610
privilege.
435 9/8/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.00 4,725.00 Draft and circulate to team memo regarding

inclusion of federal wiretap claim in amended
complaint.
436 9/8/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 9.25 3,098.75 Cite check briefs; compile exhibits; assist

with finalization and filing of opposition to
5th amendment brief and response to motion to
clarify TRO.
437 9/8/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.50 6,120.00 Finalize and file brief in response to amicus

brief of state attorneys general; review
research and manage research projects regarding
causes of action; draft amended complaint.
438 9/9/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Correspond with R. Zack and N. Nepolitan; read

news coverage of case; read Reporters
Committee's reply brief.
439 9/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.50 5,325.00 Review and analyze CMP's supplemental Fifth

Amendment brief; confer with litigation team
regarding ;
draft NAF's response to CMP's supplemental
Fifth Amendment brief; review and revise NAF's
response to CMP's supplemental Fifth Amendment
brief to address D. Foran's comments; research
RICO predicate issues in connection with
amended complaint.
440 9/9/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.00 3,510.00 Draft motion to strike Reporters Committee

brief and accompanying papers (4 hr); review
Abortion Free by Defendant Newman (2 hr).
60 of 610
441 9/9/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.50 1,095.00 Review recent articles for fact team; review

NAF opposition regarding fifth amendment
privilege; review NAF response to Attorney
General brief regarding clarifying TRO; review
Reporters Committee's motion and reply to NAF's
response regarding amicus brief; review
Defendants' brief regarding subpoenas and
testimonial privilege.
442 9/9/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 2.00 1,600.00 Review complaint, preliminary injunction

filings, and discovery filings to get up to
speed on the case.
443 9/9/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.25 5,940.00 Review work product regarding computer fraud

claims; confer with team regarding pending
filings and complaint; oversee
complaint‐related research; draft amended
complaint.
444 9/9/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Discuss complaint with N. Napolitan.
445 9/9/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Fact research in support of complaint.
446 9/9/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.75 1,952.50 Conference with D. Foran and N. Napolitan

regarding ;
analyze same.
447 9/9/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.75 7,437.50 Review legal research notes regarding potential

Computer Fraud Act claim and confer with Nick
Napolitan and Anna Ferrari regarding same;
review reply brief in support of Press
Committee's motion for leave to file amicus
61 of 610
brief on First Amendment issues; correspondence
with counsel for Reporters' Committee regarding
same; draft supplemental brief regarding
defendants' invocation of Fifth Amendment and
extent to which it implicates responses to
Arizona AG subpoena; review key Supreme Court
cases regarding act of production doctrine and
extent to which corporation and assert Fifth
Amendment rights; phone call with Lisa Brown of
NAF regarding
; phone
conference with M. Hearron regarding
; conference with
C. Robinson, N. Roethlisberger, and R. Zack
regarding
correspondence with
counsel for Planned Parenthood regarding
448 9/9/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.75 715.00 Prepare redacted documents for proposed

production.
449 9/9/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.25 2,126.25 Research issues related to the Fifth Amendment;

discuss issues related to opposition to
defendants' supplemental brief
450 9/9/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.25 1,423.75 Distribute documents; organize press file;

e‐mail files to client; compile case law;
compile documents for attorney review.
451 9/10/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.50 1,172.50 Review media files; cite check brief; assist

with finalization of filing.
62 of 610
452 9/10/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.75 1,518.75 Research issues related to Fifth Amendment;
factual research related to Operation Rescue.
453 9/10/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.25 1,035.00 Research in support of complaint.
454 9/10/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.25 1,625.00 Prepare 5th amendment privilege briefing and

case law cited; update NAF anti‐abortion threat
tracking chart; download CMP released videos
and related press; update witness files;
prepare redacted documents for proposed
production.
455 9/10/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding

; confer with A.
Ferrari
456 9/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.25 5,147.50 Conference with D. Foran regarding
review and analyze RICO case
law and RICO predicate acts in connection with
amended complaint.
457 9/10/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.50 6,375.00 Revise and edit supplemental brief regarding

CMP's invocation of Fifth Amendment.
458 9/10/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.50 5,400.00 Review work product regarding computer fraud

claims; draft and revise brief regarding Fifth
Amendment issues; oversee complaint‐related
research; draft amended complaint.
459 9/10/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 2.00 1,600.00 Review complaint, preliminary injunction

filings, and discovery filings to get up to
speed on the case.
63 of 610
460 9/10/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 292.50 Review "Abortion Free" by Defendant Newman.
461 9/11/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.75 1,023.75 Review "Abortion Free" by Defendant Newman.
462 9/11/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.00 975.00 Review draft amended complaint.
463 9/11/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.50 2,520.00 Revise amended complaint.
464 9/11/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.50 3,712.50 Research and work on federal wiretapping claim

for amended complaint.
465 9/11/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.75 4,037.50 Confer with C. Robinson and N. Napolitan

regarding ; review
reply brief on Fifth Amendment and confer with
C. Robinson and L. Shostak regarding same;
confer with L. Shostak regarding
; confer with C. Robinson regarding
confer with Will Stern and
Ali Laks regarding
email correspondence with client
regarding
review court's order
requiring individual defendants to assert Fifth
Amendment invocation in writing as it relates
to document request and interrogatories; email
correspondence with L. Shostak regarding
466 9/11/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.25 2,126.25 Research issues related to Fifth Amendment
64 of 610
privilege.
467 9/11/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.25 1,035.00 Legal and factual research in support of

complaint.
468 9/11/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.00 780.00 Review video transcripts for NAF name

identifications; prepare redacted documents for
proposed production; prepare 5th Amendment
privilege briefing and supporting caselaw for
469 9/11/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.50 5,325.00 Review and analyze CMP's reply brief in support

of Fifth Amendment privilege; review court
order regarding individual Fifth Amendment
privilege; telephone call with conference with
D. Foran regarding ; research and
analyze case RICO case law; conference with L.
Shostak regarding
; conference with P. Oropeza
regarding ;
conference with N. Napolitan regarding
; review and comment on proposed
redactions to NAF production documents;
conference with J. Dunn regarding
470 9/11/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.50 1,065.00 Analyze potential ECPA cause of action.
471 9/12/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.50 1,012.50 Research availability and importance of

continuing education and training for abortion
providers.
472 9/12/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.75 4,860.00 Revise amended complaint.
65 of 610
473 9/13/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.50 1,775.00 Research potential ECPA cause of action.
474 9/13/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.25 1,955.00 Factual research and revisions to complaint.
475 9/14/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.50 8,075.00 Phone calls and correspondence regarding

potential Arizona counsel to quash Arizona AG
subpoena; review writ of mandamus and emergency
motion to stay; confer with C. Robinson and N.
Napolitan regarding
; confer with M. Hearron
regarding same; legal research for opposition
to emergency motion to stay; phone call with
476 9/14/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.00 1,350.00 Work on federal wiretapping cause of action for

amended complaint; review appellate briefing
materials filed by defendants; correspond and
calls with C. Robinson and N. Napolitan
regarding
477 9/14/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.50 1,822.50 Research availability and importance of ongoing

education for abortion providers; research 9th
Circuit case law on writs of mandamus.
478 9/14/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.00 2,130.00 Analyze potential ECPA cause of action
479 9/14/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 13.25 9,540.00 Review Defendants' writ and motion for a stay;

draft response thereto; draft amended
complaint; research case law regarding writ
proceedings.
66 of 610
480 9/14/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.50 1,610.00 Draft video sections of complaint.
481 9/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.00 3,550.00 Analyze RICO case law and prepare summary of

legal research and arguments supporting NAF's
amended RICO claim; review and respond to email
correspondence from litigation team; prepare
oral argument talking points; review and
analyze CMP's emergency motion for stay pending
appeal; prepare NAF's shell opposition to same.
482 9/14/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.50 1,842.50 Draft chart of third party document requests;

send documents to co‐counsel; research.
483 9/14/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.75 2,733.75 Research issues related to scope of Fifth

Amendment privilege; research issues related to
defendant's writ of mandamus.
484 9/14/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.75 1,608.75 Review "Abortion Free" by Defendant Newman.
485 9/14/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 5.00 4,000.00 Prepare opposition to emergency stay motion in

the Ninth Circuit.
486 9/14/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.00 1,560.00 Download and prepare Operation Rescue videos

for discovery production (2.5); Update NAF
threat tracker (2.5); prepare redaction
identification chart for discovery production
487 9/15/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 11.00 2,860.00 Download CMP released videos (2.50); Update NAF

threat tracking chart (3.25); Download NAF
threat articles and posts (.5); Gather and
transmit motion to clarify briefing and related
67 of 610
case materials for subsequent attorney review
(1.25); prepare redacted documents for
discovery production (2.5); prepare Daleidan
and Newman witness files (1).
488 9/15/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 1.00 800.00 Review and comment on draft of opposition to

emergency stay motion.
489 9/15/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 2,632.50 Research in support of response to Defendants'

motion to stay in Ninth Circuit.
490 9/15/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.00 810.00 Research issues related to fifth amendment;

listen to live podcast by defendants and their
attorneys.
491 9/15/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 9.00 6,390.00 Review and analyze CMP's mandamus petition;

draft portions of NAF's response to CMP's
emergency motion to stay pending appeal; legal
research in connection with same; email
correspondence with litigation team; confer
with L. Shostak regarding
; legal research in
connection with upcoming hearing on Fifth
Amendment issues; conference with D. Foran and
T. Beyer regarding
492 9/15/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.50 1,012.50 Research and provide summary to D. Foran on

district court discretion to issue discovery
orders in connection with response to stay
motion in Ninth Circuit.
493 9/15/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.75 2,261.25 Assist with research regarding amended
68 of 610
complaint; compile documents to send to
co‐counsel; research page limits; cite check
9th circuit motion.
494 9/15/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.25 1,955.00 Research and revisions in support of complaint.
495 9/15/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.75 8,460.00 Review Defendants' writ and motion for a stay;

draft response thereto; draft amended
complaint; research issues regarding First
Amendment.
496 9/15/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 10.25 8,712.50 Prepare opposition to emergency motion to stay

discovery filed in the Ninth Circuit;
conference with Arizona counsel regarding
potential to move or quash Arizona AG subpoena
in Arizona state court; confer with client
regarding ; review revised complaint and
comment on same.
497 9/16/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.25 1,495.00 Research and support of complaint; review

current status of briefings and filings.
498 9/16/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 675.00 Research and work on response to Plaintiff's

petition for writ of mandate in Ninth Circuit;
work on federal wiretap cause of action for
amended complaint.
499 9/16/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.00 1,620.00 Draft client update regarding live podcast by

defendants; review and revise amended
complaint.
500 9/16/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 11.00 7,810.00 Review and revise NAF's opposition to CMP's

emergency motion for stay of discovery;
69 of 610
supervise filing of same; confer with L.
Shostak and D. Foran regarding
; analyze Fifth Amendment
cases cited in CMP's reply brief; analyze and
prepare summary of case law and argument for
hearing; analyze and distinguish First
Amendment cases cited in CMP's mandamus
petition; draft insert regarding First
Amendment prior restraint case law for NAF's
opposition to mandamus petition.
501 9/16/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 10.50 8,925.00 Revise opposition to emergency motion to stay

discovery filed in Ninth Circuit; review Ninth
Circuit order regarding briefing schedule on
writ of mandamus; legal research for opposition
to writ of mandamus; begin drafting opposition
to writ of mandamus; conference with L.
Shostak, N. Napolitan, and C. Robinson
regarding
; prepare for
hearing.
502 9/16/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.25 101.25 Read news coverage of and new filings in the

case.
503 9/16/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 8.50 2,847.50 Assist with filing of 9th Circuit brief; insert

fact cites into answer to writ; create appendix
of cases for attorney review; index
supplemental appendix for filing.
504 9/16/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.50 2,485.00 Analyze choice of law issue in respect of

conference confidentiality agreements.
70 of 610
505 9/16/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 10.50 7,560.00 Draft amended complaint; review and revise
appellate filings.
506 9/16/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.25 182.50 Review respondent's opposition to petitioner's

emergency motion for stay of discovery pending
appeal.

509 9/16/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.50 1,950.00 Prepare redacted documents for discovery

production.
510 9/17/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 2.00 1,600.00 Prepare portion of opposition to mandamus

petition.
511 9/17/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.50 910.00 Prepare redacted documents for discovery

production.

514 9/17/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 12.25 8,820.00 Draft amended complaint; review and revise

appellate filings.
515 9/17/2015 ANNA FERRARI 0.25 177.50 Conference with D. Cohen (Drexel) regarding
516 9/17/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 11.50 3,852.50 Assist with preparation and filing of answer to
71 of 610
writ; research 9th cir rules; prepare
supplemental appendix accompanying answer; cite
check answer.
517 9/17/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 15.75 13,387.50 Draft answer to petition for writ of mandamus

in Ninth Circuit; conferences with C. Robinson
regarding ; review Ninth
Circuit order regarding emergency stay of
discovery in district court and phone call with
client regarding same; preparations for hearing
on Fifth Amendment/discovery/subpoena issues.
518 9/17/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.50 2,227.50 Review and revise amended complaint.
519 9/17/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.75 1,518.75 Read and review amended complaint.
520 9/17/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 14.00 9,940.00 Draft portions of NAF's opposition to mandamus

petition regarding First Amendment; conference
with D. Foran and T. Beyer regarding same;
conference with N. Roethesberger regarding
; review and analyze complaint;
conference with N. Napolitan regarding
; review and analyze case
law cited in CMP's mandamus petition; review
and revise NAF's opposition to mandamus
petition to address D. Foran's comments.
521 9/17/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Coordinate filing of complaint.
522 9/18/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.75 6,587.50 Prepare for and attend hearing in district

court on Fifth Amendment/Arizona subpoena
72 of 610
issues; revise answer to petition for writ of
mandamus; review court's answer to petition for
writ of mandamus; review and provide comments
on draft first amended complaint and
conferences with N. Napolitan regarding same.
523 9/18/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.00 1,840.00 Finalize and file complaint.
524 9/18/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 675.00 Review amended complaint for filing; review

day's district court and Ninth Circuit filings;
correspond with C. Robinson, N. Napolitan and
A. Laks regarding
525 9/18/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.75 3,372.50 Review and revise NAF's opposition to mandamus

petition to address D. Foran's comments; attend
hearing on CMP's assertion of Fifth Amendment
privilege; finalize and supervise filing of
NAF's opposition to mandamus petition in Ninth
Circuit; supervise filing of notice of same in
the district court; review and analyze J.
Orrick's answer to CMP's mandamus petition.
526 9/18/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.25 2,531.25 Review and revise amended complaint.
527 9/18/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.25 1,721.25 Attend hearing; review and revise amended

complaint.
528 9/18/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.25 5,940.00 Finalize and file amended complaint.
529 9/18/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.25 115.00 Review transcript of Fifth Amendment hearing.
530 9/18/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 8.00 2,680.00 Finalize answer to writ; order hearing

transcript; distribute files to client; assist
73 of 610
with filing of writ; compile case law in writ.
531 9/18/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.00 2,925.00 Attend hearing on Fifth Amendment rights of

corporations (2 hr); review opposition to writ
(1 hr); review amended complaint (2 hr).
532 9/18/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 5.00 4,875.00 Prepare for and attend hearing.

production.
534 9/19/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.25 753.75 Compile files and send to related counsel;

compile case law cited in answer.
535 9/19/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.25 1,062.50 Fact research regarding Troy Newman.

production.

production (8); Transmit written discovery
briefing for subsequent attorney review (.25)
538 9/21/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 1.00 800.00 Review CMP reply brief in support of mandamus,

and confer with D. Foran regarding same.
539 9/21/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.25 731.25 Review and revise draft interrogatory

responses.
540 9/21/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.00 1,350.00 Attend team meeting with D. Foran, C. Robinson

; work on schedule regarding subpoena
from Arizona Attorney General.
74 of 610
541 9/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.00 2,130.00 Confer with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, and J.

Serrano regarding
; review and respond to email
correspondence from litigation team; review and
analyze CMP's Ninth Circuit reply brief; review
and respond to questions about revisions to
NAF's written discovery requests.
542 9/21/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.25 115.00 Conference with D. Foran and N. Napolitan

regarding
543 9/21/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.25 1,088.75 Review media file; distribute files; supervise

redaction project;
544 9/21/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.00 810.00 Review and discuss issues related to fifth

amendment.
545 9/21/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 607.50 Research when adverse inferences for pleading

the Fifth can be drawn; research whether state
or federal law applies to implications of
pleading the Fifth.
546 9/21/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.25 3,612.50 Review reply in support of petition for writ of

mandamus in Ninth Circuit; prepare for and
attend meeting with C. Napolitan and C.
Robinson regarding
; review legal research
regarding ability of corporate officer to claim
Fifth Amendment right not to produce corporate
records; review district court order setting
discovery schedule and schedule for
75 of 610
meet‐and‐confer over AG subpoenas.
547 9/21/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.00 4,320.00 Review document production; prepare documents

for production; prepare discovery schedule;
plan for discovery; prepare written discovery.
548 9/22/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.00 5,040.00 Review document production; prepare documents

for production; prepare discovery schedule;
plan for discovery; prepare written discovery.
549 9/22/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.75 1,487.50 Phone call with Lisa Brown regarding
confer with Javier Serrano
regarding
conferences with C.
Robinson and N. Napolitan regarding
; meet‐and‐confer
correspondence with counsel for defendants'
regarding discovery scheduling matters.
550 9/22/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.00 1,215.00 Prepare documents for production.
551 9/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.50 3,905.00 Review all documents subject to document

production; review and revise privacy
redactions in connection with same; email
correspondence with litigation team regarding
552 9/22/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 6.50 4,387.50 Attend meeting with D. Foran, N. Napolitan and

C. Robinson regarding
; research on challenges to third
party subpoenas; draft letter to Court
76 of 610
regarding modifications to discovery schedule.
553 9/22/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.50 2,512.50 Compile and review press file; redact documents

for possible production; distribute filings to
client.
554 9/22/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 2,632.50 Review documents for potential production to

Defendants.
555 9/22/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.25 1,035.00 Finalize documents for production.
556 9/22/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.60 1,136.00 Analyze procedural and substantive grounds for

opposing state attorney general subpoenas.
557 9/22/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 12.50 3,250.00 Gather and prepare documents for discovery

production (10); Revise redacted documents for
production. (2.5)
558 9/23/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 11.50 2,990.00 Gather and process documents for discovery

production.
559 9/23/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.70 511.00 Review news report regarding Stemexpress

discovery; review Ninth Circuit order regarding
stay; review case correspondence; review order
regarding Fifth Amendment rights of corporate
entities.

Defendants.
561 9/23/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.25 115.00 Review 9th Circuit ruling denying writ.
77 of 610
562 9/23/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 5,525.00 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding
discovery schedule; review Ninth Circuit's
order denying petition for writ of mandamus;
review district court's order denying CMP's
assertion of Fifth Amendment rights; prepare
letter to the court regarding scheduling and
responses to subpoenas; correspondence with
court staff regarding scheduling of telephone
conference; phone call with counsel for
StemExpress regarding status of that matter.

opposing state attorney general subpoenas;
summarize same.
564 9/23/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.25 575.00 Finalize documents for production.

schedule; prepare draft schedule for
circulation to opposing counsel; review privacy
redactions to document production; review
public domain documents added to document
production; conference with D. Foran and N.
Napolitan regarding
; review and analyze Ninth Circuit
order denying mandamus petition; review and
revise letter to the Court regarding scheduling
issues; confer with N. Napolitan regarding
; legal research in connection with
First Amendment issues.
566 9/23/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.25 3,341.25 Draft joint dispute letter in preparation for
78 of 610
discovery disputes over fifth amendment issues.
567 9/23/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.00 7,920.00 Conduct fact research; participate in meet and

confer call; review document production;
prepare documents for production; prepare
discovery schedule; plan for discovery; prepare
written discovery.
568 9/23/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.50 2,512.50 Update third party subpoena chart; redact

documents.
569 9/23/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 6.50 4,387.50 Research on State AG subpoenas and challenges

thereto; calls and correspond with A. Ferrari
and C. Magana regarding same; correspond with
D. Foran, C. Robinson and N. Napolitan
regarding ; review
Ninth Circuit order dissolving stay of
discovery.
570 9/23/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 5.30 2,782.50 Phone call with J. Serrano to discuss
; review
docket; review request letters from House
Oversight Committee and Senate Judiciary
Committee; review subpoena from House Oversight
Committee; review subpoena from Arizona
Attorney General; review subpoena from
Louisiana Inspector General; review briefing on
temporary restraining order and on motion to
clarify temporary restraining order; review
Ninth Circuit's ruling denying writ of
mandamus; begin research on quashing/limiting
79 of 610
scope of congressional subpoenas.
571 9/24/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.25 4,500.00 Conduct fact research; review document

production; prepare documents for production;
prepare discovery schedule; plan for discovery;
prepare written discovery.
572 9/24/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.75 921.25 Assist with compilation of production

documents; review press files.
573 9/24/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 8.00 5,680.00 Review and revise letter to the Court regarding

schedule; email correspondence with client and
litigation team regarding same; conference with
D. Foran and L. Shostak regarding
; review and respond to strategy
to respond to Congressional subpoena;
conference with J. Serrano and D. Foran
regarding same; gather and review public
documents for production; legal research in
connection with First Amendment issues.
574 9/24/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.00 4,725.00 Attend team meeting with D. Foran, C. Robinson,

A. Ferrari, and C. Magana regarding
; research on challenges to
state and federal subpoenas.
575 9/24/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.75 2,733.75 Draft joint dispute letter in preparation for

discovery disputes over fifth amendment issues;
prepare documents for production.
576 9/24/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.00 920.00 Assist with finalizing with productions.
80 of 610
opposing state attorney general subpoenas;
summarize same; conference with J. Serrano
regarding same; team meeting regarding same.

Defendants.
579 9/24/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.00 975.00 Team meeting and follow‐up drafts & emails.
580 9/24/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.25 2,762.50 Revise and edit draft letter to court regarding

discovery matters; meeting with N. Napolitan
and C. Robinson regarding
581 9/24/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 11.20 2,912.00 Gather and process documents for discovery

production (10); download video and audio files
for production (1.20)
582 9/25/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 2,550.00 Phone conference with L. Shostak, C. Robinson,

; final revisions to letter to court
regarding discovery matters; emails with
Arizona counsel regarding status; final
revisions to draft discovery responses; review
letter from T. Newsome to court regarding
necessity of Fifth Amendment privilege log.
583 9/24/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 5.30 2,782.50 Review articles on congressional subpoena

power; email exchange and telephone call with
J. Serrano to discuss
; meet with D.
81 of 610
Foran, A. Ferrari, C. Robinson, and J. Serrano
; discuss with J. Serrano
; continue researching and reading
case law on congressional subpoenas.
584 9/25/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.50 5,400.00 Conduct fact research; review document

production; prepare documents for production;
prepare written discovery.
585 9/25/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.50 1,462.50 Meet and confer with opposing counsel; draft

letter to the court.
586 9/25/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.75 1,926.25 Compile public documents for production; review

redacted documents;review and update press
file.
587 9/25/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.50 1,822.50 Research and discuss fifth amendment and

discovery issues.

Defendants.

discovery schedule; legal research regarding
First Amendment issues; review and analyze
public domain documents for production; review
and revise letter to the Court regarding
scheduling; supervise filing of same;
conference with L. Shostak, D. Foran, and N.
82 of 610
Napolitan regarding
conference with litigation team regarding
590 9/25/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.00 2,025.00 Research 9th Circuit case law on adverse

inferences from claim of Fifth Amendment
privilege; confer with R. Zack on same.
591 9/25/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 4.50 3,037.50 Research on procedures to challenge

congressional subpoena; correspond with team
regarding
592 9/25/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 7.00 3,675.00 Research procedural issues regarding potential

action against Congress to quash/limit
congressional subpoena, including issues
related to jurisdiction and venue; read Judge
Orrick's TRO; read google "alerts" regarding
client and defendants; read Congressional
Research Service report addressing
congressional subpoena power and relevant case
law.; email exchange with J. Serrano regarding
; read D. Foran letter to Judge Orrick
submitted in advance of Monday's status
conference.
593 9/26/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.50 1,012.50 Work on memorandum analyzing strategic options

to challenge congressional subpoena.
594 9/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Review and analyze Newman's letter to the Court

regarding objection to Fifth Amendment
83 of 610
privilege log; legal research in connection
with same; email correspondence with litigation
team regarding
595 9/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.00 4,260.00 Legal research regarding First Amendment and

prior restraint issues; prepare legal
memorandum of First Amendment issues associated
with preliminary injunction motion.
596 9/27/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.50 1,012.50 Research on challenges to congressional

subpoenas and correspond with team regarding
same.
597 9/27/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.10 1,491.00 Review memorandum regarding strategy for

challenging Congressional subpoena (.4);
analyze cases in support of same (1.7).
598 9/27/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 850.00 Preparations for telephonic hearing with court

regarding schedule and subpoena issues.
599 9/28/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.75 3,420.00 Participate in telephonic meet‐and‐confer call;

draft discovery letter; oversee preparation of
documents for production; research RICO issues.
600 9/28/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.90 1,014.00 Update team case calendar (.50); update and

review redacted documents for confidentiality
designations (1.25); organize additional
documents for production (.50); prepare draft
set of production documents for subsequent
attorney review (1.50).
601 9/28/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.00 405.00 Research state laws on use of adverse
84 of 610
inferences for invocation of Fifth Amendment
privilege.
602 9/28/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.50 1,687.50 Work on memo analyzing strategies to challenge

congressional subpoenas; calls and meetings
with D. Foran, C. Robinson, C. Magana, and A
.Ferrari regarding
603 9/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,195.00 Attend court conference call regarding

discovery schedule; confer with L. Shostak, D.
Foran, and N. Napolitan regarding
; review and respond to email
correspondence from litigation team; draft
email to opposing counsel raising anticipated
discovery issues; review recent news reports
regarding the defendants; legal research in
connection with First Amendment issues.
604 9/28/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.00 1,620.00 Fact and legal research in preparation for

discovery and preliminary injunction.
605 9/28/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.30 219.00 Review letter regarding Defendant Newman and

privilege log; review letter from D. Foran
regarding preliminary injunction schedule and
subpoenas; review news articles.
606 9/28/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.80 5,780.00 Prepare for and attend hearing with court

regarding discovery schedule and related
matters; phone calls and emails with Arizona
counsel re ;
confer with J. Serrano regarding
; phone conference with NAF
85 of 610
General Counsel regarding
607 9/28/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.60 1,560.00 Attend telephonic court hearing (0.8); meet

with team regarding follow‐up (0.8).
608 9/28/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.30 1,440.50 Update media file; assist with production of

documents; distribute documents to team and
client.
609 9/28/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.90 2,769.00 Conference with J. Serrano regarding

(.2); research
same (3.7).
610 9/28/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.30 760.50 Review "Their Blood Cries Out" by Defendant

Newman (.3 hr); review documents for possible
production to Defendants (1 hr).
611 9/28/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 5.00 2,625.00 Review letter filed by T. Newman's attorney in

advance of telephonic status conference; review
google "alerts" regarding NAF and defendants;
meet with N. Roethlisberger
phone call and email exchange with
J. Serrano regarding
; continue researching
caselaw addressing scope and limits of
congressional subpoenas.
612 9/29/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.00 1,170.00 Review transcript of congressional hearing on

Planned Parenthood (1 hr); research regarding
subpoena issued by Congress to Defendant (1
hr).
86 of 610
613 9/29/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.30 3,053.00 Research strategies for opposing Congressional

subpoena.
614 9/29/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.80 1,608.00 Assist with production of documents; compile

witness file; distribute documents to client
and team.
615 9/29/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 2,975.00 Conference with Don Rushing

; revise letter to defendants re
meet‐and‐confer over miscellaneous discovery
matters; preparations for deposition of CMP;
review transcript of discovery hearing.
616 9/29/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.00 780.00 Revise redacted documents for discovery

production (2.5); Download news articles and
video interviews for witness files (.50)
617 9/29/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.00 1,620.00 Fact research for preliminary injunction

motion.
618 9/29/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Calendar updates.
619 9/29/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.50 3,240.00 Revise discovery letter; review documents to be

produced; conduct fact related to based on
Defendants' recent press interviews; research
contract law issues.
620 9/29/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Legal research on protecting NAF confidential

information in response to Congressional
subpoena; confer with J. Serrano regarding
same; listed to portions of Congressional
hearing into Planned Parenthood and review
87 of 610
transcript of same.
621 9/29/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.50 3,712.50 Work on research memo analyzing strategy for

challenging congressional subpoena.
622 9/29/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 4.20 2,205.00 Read transcript from September 28, 2015

hearing; watch House Oversight Committee's
hearing questioning Cecile Richards; phone call
with J. Serrano regarding
; read and draft summaries of relevant
cases addressing Congressional subpoenas;
consult Congressional Research Services report
on congressional subpoena power.

litigation team (0.10); review public
admissions made by Daleiden (0.10); review and
analyze Defendants' forensic report regarding
missing clips from Planned Parenthood videos
(0.30); confer with D. Foran and N. Napolitan
regarding
(1.60).
624 9/30/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.70 5,544.00 Confer with team regarding system for tracking

defendants' public statements (.2 hours);
conduct research regarding contract law (1
hour); confer with team to develop discovery
strategy (1.5 hours); organize document review
team and create document/video review protocol
(2 hours); confer with client regarding
(.4 hours); confer
with IT specialists regarding
88 of 610
(.3
hours); research RICO case law (2 hours); draft
email to opposing counsel regarding document
production (.3 hours).
625 9/30/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 1,430.00 Download video and audio files for witness

files (1.20); Revise redacted documents for
discovery production (3.5); download and
archive news articles (.30); update public
statements tracking chart (.50)
626 9/30/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 6.80 4,590.00 Prepare for and attend meeting with D. Foran,

C. Robinson, and N. Napolitan regarding
(1.0);
Draft and circulate internal memo to team
regarding
(5.8).
627 9/30/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 5,950.00 Meeting with J. Serrano, C. Robinson, and N.

Napolitan regarding
conference with NAF
Communications Director Melissa Fowler
regarding
628 9/30/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.30 1,775.50 Update witness files; review press file; update

client document folder; research video review
platform and send inquiries to prospective
vendors.
89 of 610
629 9/30/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.80 1,278.00 Analyze strategies for
630 9/30/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.80 1,539.00 Develop NAF video review protocol (3.1); fact

research on Defendants' public statements (.7).
631 9/30/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 351.00 Review video review protocol for upcoming

review of video production.
632 9/30/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.30 598.00 Review relevant articles to qu for production

and ensure articles are filed in appropriate
location (.8); discuss
with N. Napolitan (.2); email J.
Cravett regarding case updates (.3).
633 9/30/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.70 367.50 Listen to D. Deletion interview regarding House

Oversight Committee hearings (0.5); review
congressional subpoena memorandum from J.
Serrano (0.20); discuss
with N. Napolitan (0.20).
634 10/1/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.10 781.00 Review and respond to email correspondence from

(0.60
hrs); analyze recent articles regarding Planned
Parenthood arsons for inclusion in document
production and preliminary injunction motion
(0.50 hrs).
635 10/1/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 337.50 Review and comment on draft discovery and

objections (0.5).
90 of 610
636 10/1/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.20 81.00 Read news coverage of case (.2).
637 10/1/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 1.00 405.00 Fact research on defendants.
638 10/1/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.90 414.00 Coordinate filing of relevant news articles and

confirm updates of chart tracking defendants'
public statements.
639 10/1/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.80 938.00 Compile documents for production (1.10) review

recent and archived news articles regarding T.
Newman and Operation Rescue (.90) Update D.
Daleiden witness file(.80)
640 10/1/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.80 2,736.00 Research case law regarding attorney fees (.8

hours); draft email to team regarding
(.3 hours);
research case law regarding First Amendment
privileges (.8 hours); revise written responses
to defendants' discovery requests (.5 hours);
review documents for production (.8 hours);
conduct fact research regarding defendants
(.6).
641 10/1/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.30 219.00 Review article regarding T. Newman's detention

in Australia (0.1); review article regarding
arson investigation at Planned Parenthood
(0.1); review article regarding interview with
D. Daleiden talking about discovery in this
case (0.1).
642 10/1/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 234.00 Review first edition of "Their Blood Cries

Out."
91 of 610
643 10/1/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.80 1,768.00 Prepare and process documents for production

(4.5); update Newman and Daleiden witness files
(2); update case files (.30).
644 10/2/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Prepare redacted documents for production.
645 10/2/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.10 2,398.50 Research in support of letter to court

concerning congressional subpoena.
646 10/2/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.10 6,552.00 Draft brief to court regarding letter from

congressional subcommittee to Daleiden (6.3
hours); participate in meet and confer call
regarding discovery (.9 hours); review case law
regarding congressional subpoenas (1.9 hours).
647 10/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding

discovery issues.
648 10/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Review and analyze CMP's letter and cited cases

regarding intent to produce NAF confidential
information to Congress notwithstanding the
Court's TRO.
649 10/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Confer with N. Napolitan, D. Foran, and J.

Serrano regarding
650 10/2/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.50 1,417.50 Review filings regarding defendants response to

congressional subpoenas (.5); fact research on
defendant Newman (3).
92 of 610
651 10/2/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.00 1,840.00 Review all public statements and revise chart

tracking same.
652 10/2/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 9.50 6,412.50 Research and work on response letter regarding

congressional subpoena requirements and federal
court authority to review scope (8.8);
correspond and calls with D. Foran and N.
Napolitan regarding
(0.5).
653 10/2/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 67.00 Compile documents for attorney review (.10)

review press file for potential production
documents (.30)
654 10/2/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.80 7,480.00 Prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer with

counsel for defendants regarding discovery
matters (1.8); review letter to Court regarding
intent to disclose material covered by TRO to
congress (0.4); conferences with C. Robinson,
N. Napolitan, and J. Serrano regarding
(0.6); legal research
regarding third party objections to
Congressional subpoenas and related matters
(1.7); draft response to Daleiden's letter
regarding disclosure to Congress (2.9);
conference with General Counsel for NAF
regarding (0.4); prepare letter to
Congress regarding subpoena and conferences
with C. Robinson regarding same (1.0).
655 10/2/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.30 121.50 Review today's court filings.
93 of 610
656 10/2/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.40 210.00 Read D. Daleiden letter to court regarding
congressional subpoena (0.10); read Rep.
Chaffetz letter to Daleiden regarding
congressional subpoena (0.10); email to J.
Serrano regarding
(0.10); read court's order directing plaintiff
to file response to D. Daleiden letter to court
by Monday, October 5 (0.10).
657 10/3/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Compile transcript of recording of J. Chaffetz

on CNN.

court authority to review scope (3.8).
659 10/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.20 2,982.00 Prepare detailed letter to Chairman Chaffetz of

the House Committee on Oversight regarding the
Committee's subpoena to CMP, background to the
NAF lawsuit, and the subject matter of the
video subject to the TRO.

hours); review case law regarding congressional
subpoenas (1.6 hours).
661 10/3/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.20 3,570.00 Review and revise draft letter to Court in

response to Daleiden's letter stating intent to
disclose material covered by TRO to House
Subcommittee.
662 10/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,195.00 Prepare detailed letter to Chairman Chaffetz of
94 of 610
the House Committee on Oversight regarding the
Committee's subpoena to CMP, background to the
NAF lawsuit, and the subject matter of the

court authority to review scope (2.4).

hours); review case law regarding congressional
subpoenas (.8 hours).
665 10/4/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.30 858.00 Cite‐check letter to court regarding

congressional subpoena.
666 10/5/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.30 2,678.00 Cite‐check and prepare caselaw cited in letter

to court regarding congressional subpoena
(5.5); organize exhibits in support of letter
to court regarding congressional subpoena
(2.3); organize and process documents for
production (2.5).
667 10/5/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.40 184.00 Read NAF response to subpoena letter.
668 10/5/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.00 6,800.00 Revise and edit opposition to Daleiden letter

regarding disclosures of material covered by
TRO in response to Congressional Subpoena
(4.7); meet‐and‐confer correspondence with
opposing counsel regarding schedule for
production of documents (0.3); draft letter to
court regarding stay of order allowing
95 of 610
disclosures of TRO material to Congress (0.3);
confer with Randy Zack regarding
(0.2); review legal
research notes regarding same (0.3); review
draft letter to Congress regarding NAF lawsuit
against CMP (0.6); preparations for deposition
of CMP (fact research) (1.6).
669 10/5/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.60 1,521.00 Review and edit letter brief regarding

congressional subpoena (1.8 hr); review video
review protocol for upcoming video review (.8
hr).
670 10/5/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.40 2,997.00 Review and revise letter to court regarding

congressional subpoena (.5); research on
defendant Newman (1.5); research on whether
state of federal adverse inference law applies
(3); research legal issues regarding stay of
district court's order pending write of
mandamus (2.33)
671 10/5/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.80 938.00 Compile news articles (.50) proofread letter

brief (.60) prepare documents for production (1.7).
672 10/5/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.30 4,536.00 Revise written discovery responses (1.2 hours);

review documents for production (.8 hours);
draft response letter regarding congressional
subpoena (3.2 hours); develop document review
protocol for reviewing defendants' video
production (1.1 hours).
673 10/5/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.10 850.50 Confer with N. Roethlisberger and R. Zack
96 of 610
regarding
(.3); conduct
research on state laws allowing and not
allowing for adverse inferences to be drawn
upon invocation of the Fifth Amendment in civil
proceedings (1.8).
674 10/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.50 1,065.00 Review and revise letter to Chairman Chaffetz

of the House Committee on Oversight regarding
the Committee's subpoena to CMP, background to
the NAF lawsuit, and the subject matter of the
675 10/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Review and comment on document review protocol,

issue tags, and video description log.
676 10/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Review, comment, and propose revisions to NAF's

opposition letter to Daleiden's statement of
intent to produce video to the House Committee
on Oversight in violation of the TRO.
677 10/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Review and revise letter to Chairman Chaffetz

to address D. Foran's comments.
678 10/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.90 639.00 Analyze case law cited in NAF's opposition

letter to Daleiden's statement of intent to
produce video to the House Committee on
Oversight in violation of the TRO.
679 10/5/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.20 1,485.00 Research and provide edits on letter to Court

regarding legal implications of congressional
subpoena (1.4); review and revise video and
document review protocols (0.8).
97 of 610
680 10/5/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.30 157.50 Email to J. Serrano regarding
(0.10); read D. Foran's letter filed
with the court in response to defendant's
professed intent to violate the temporary
restraining order by responding to
congressional subpoena (0.2)
681 10/6/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.10 445.50 Attend meeting regarding video review protocol

(.8); confer with R. Zack regarding
(.1); review
today's news coverage of the case (.1); review
court's order regarding congressional subpoena
(.1).
682 10/6/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 10.50 7,560.00 Review documents for production to defendants

(2.7 hours); identify and resolve issues with
image quality in production to defendants (1.1
hours); revise and finalize written discovery
(1.4 hours); revise letter concerning possible
stay of order (.4 hours); review court order
regarding congressional subpoena (.4 hours);
confer with team regarding congressional
subpoena (1 hour); confer with client regarding
(1 hour); confer
with opposing counsel regarding discovery
protocol (.1 hour); develop video review
protocol (1 hours); conduct team meeting
regarding (.8 hours); review and
analyze draft letter to congress (.6 hours);
683 10/6/2015 ANNA FERRARI 0.80 568.00 Attend team meeting regarding
98 of 610
684 10/6/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.90 1,111.50 Review order regarding congressional subpoena

(.5 hr); strategize regarding upcoming video
review (1.4 hr).
685 10/6/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.90 1,641.50 Compile recent news articles and distribute to

team (.60); facilitate review of production
documents (.50) review and revise documents (3.7).
686 10/6/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
687 10/6/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.70 1,917.00 Revise letter to Congressman Chaffetz in light

of the District Court's order permitting
disclosure of material subject to TRO in
response to congressional subpoena.
688 10/6/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.80 1,278.00 Review, analyze, and comment on documents in

NAF's proposed document production.
689 10/6/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.60 1,136.00 Telephone call with client regarding

litigation team.
691 10/6/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Team meeting regarding
99 of 610
692 10/6/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.30 1,058.00 Attend meeting discussing video review (1.2);

draft cheat sheet summarizing key players and
issues for video review (1)
693 10/6/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.90 1,957.50 Prepare for and attend meeting regarding
(1.0); review court order regarding
congressional subpoena (0.2); attend call with
client regarding
(1.0); review
and draft edits to letter to Congress regarding
protection of confidential NAF information
(0.7).
694 10/6/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 5,525.00 Revise letter to Court requesting stay of order

allowing disclosure of TRO materials to
Congress (0.8); conferences and emails with M.
Hearron regarding
(0.7); review
correspondence from opposing counsel requesting
preservation of materials regarding
communications with Cal AG and related matters
(0.2); correspondence with client regarding
same (0.3); correspondence and phone call with
client regarding
(0.6);
review correspondence from minority members to
Chaffetz regarding CMP and Daleiden (0.3);
prepare notice of appeal (0.2); review court
100 of 610
order allowing disclosure to Congress of TRO
materials (0.5); internal conferences regarding
(0.4); prepare for and attend phone call
(0.9); confer with N. Napolitan regarding
(0.3); revise letter to Congress regarding
Daleiden disclosures of TRO material (1.3).
695 10/6/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.80 2,754.00 Research legal issues related to motion to stay

(1.5); research legal issues related to
district court's authority over third‐parties
(3); review documents in preparation for
production (2.25)
696 10/6/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.80 2,808.00 Preparation of documents and videos for

discovery production (5.8); update case files
(2.5); download news articles and videos (2.5).
697 10/6/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.20 1,606.00 Prepare for and meet to discuss

(0.8); review
directions regarding video production review
(0.1); review order regarding congressional
subpoena (0.1); review letter from Counsel for
NAF in response to D. Daleiden letter (0.2);
review article and video regarding release of
new video on Glenn Beck Program and Texas
Planned Parenthood (0.3); review letter from C.
Short regarding document preservation (0.1);
review video regarding Planned Parenthood and
Glenn Beck (0.1); review recent case filings
(0.5).
101 of 610
698 10/6/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 4.30 3,440.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding

(1.0);
confer with client regarding same (1.0);
research appealability of order (2.3).
699 10/6/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 1.30 682.50 Attend meeting with N.

Napolitan, C. Robinson, A. Ferrari, N.
Roethlisberger, J. Serrano, A. Dale, A. Laks,
D. Coleman and Z. Randall (1.10); read daily
google alerts regarding client and defendants
(0.10); read Judge Orrick's order ordering
compliance with congressional subpoena (0.10)
700 10/7/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 14.00 3,640.00 Prepare documents and videos for production.
701 10/7/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.80 2,349.00 Review and discuss

(1); review defendant
Newman's discovery response (.25); research
legal issues related to adverse inferences (4.5).
702 10/7/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 202.50 Review today's news coverage of the case (.2);

correspond with R. Zack regarding
(.1); review Defendant
Newman's discovery responses (.2)
703 10/7/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.80 3,230.00 Phone conference with L. Brown regarding

(0.3); review and revise
draft letter to Congress regarding TRO
disclosures (2.8); conferences with N.
Napolitan and C. Robinson regarding
(0.2); review documents produced by
CMP (0.5).
102 of 610

litigation team.
705 10/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 923.00 Review and revise letter and verify accuracy of

footnotes to Chairman Chaffetz regarding
congressional subpoena.
706 10/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Review and finalize document production.
707 10/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Review and comment on NAF's written discovery

responses and objections.
708 10/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Conference with N. Napolitan regarding
709 10/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.80 1,278.00 Review and analyze Defendants' written

discovery responses and document production.
710 10/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Review protective order and prepare cover

letter for document production consistent with
terms of that order.
711 10/7/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.20 92.00 Review internal protocol for review of

defendants' videos in anticipation of upcoming
production (.20).
712 10/7/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 702.00 Review discovery responses from defendants.
713 10/7/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 8.00 2,680.00 Assist with the finalization; revision,

redactions and production of video, audio,
written and documents to opposing counsel.
103 of 610
714 10/7/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.40 945.00 Review Defendants' discovery responses (0.8);

review NAF conference program materials in
connection with preparing for review of videos
produced by Defendants (0.4); correspond with
C. Robinson and N. Napolitan regarding
(0.2).
715 10/7/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 10.80 7,776.00 Review documents to be produced (2.7 hours);

oversee production of documents (2.5 hours);
research protective order issues to facilitate
document review (.8 hours); confer with team
regarding (1
hour); review discovery produced by Defendants
(3.8 hours).
716 10/7/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.70 511.00 Review news articles regarding Judge Orrick's

order on Congressional subpoena and Troy Newman
Australian visit, and edited videos (0.3);
quick review of 2014 and 2015 NAF conference
programs to prepare for video review (0.4).
717 10/7/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 1.90 997.50 Review and log videos recorded April 6, 2014

and produced by defendant per order of the
court.
718 10/7/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.30 138.00 Review Defendants' discovery responses.
719 10/7/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 1.40 735.00 Read daily news alerts regarding client and

defendants (0.20); read forensic analysis of
publicly released videos (0.6); review
defendant Newman's responses to first set of
interrogatories and request for documents
104 of 610
(.10); begin reviewing documents provided by
CMF in preparation for video review expected to
commence on October 8 (0.5)
720 10/8/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.30 949.00 Emails with internal team regarding

(0.2); review video
production; review Congressional subpoena for
responsive video production categories (0.2);
review Daleiden's confidentiality designations
(0.2); review Thomas More Society communication
regarding D. Daleiden defense (0.1); review
article regarding GOP committee to target
Planned Parenthood (0.1); review of CMP
documents and Defendants' privilege log (0.5).
721 10/8/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.80 6,336.00 Manage video review team (3.2 hours); confer

with D. Foran and C. Robinson regarding
(2 hours); review documents
produced by Defendants (3 hours); confer with
client via email regarding (.6
hours).
722 10/8/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 10.50 4,252.50 Review video taken at NAF conference (.75);

review and discuss
(6.25); research legal
issues regarding Fifth amendment waiver and
insulated witness objection (3.5).
723 10/8/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.60 2,546.00 Copy production files to network drive (6.50);

facilitate review of video files (.60);
distribute discovery (..50)
724 10/8/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.10 3,568.50 Review videos and documents produced by
105 of 610
defendants.
725 10/8/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.30 7,055.00 Review defendants' written discovery responses

and prepare notes regarding objections (2.7);
meeting with C. Robinson, N. Napolitan, R. Zack
regarding
(2.5); phone call with General
Counsel for NAF regarding
(0.3); phone
conference with General Counsel for Planned
Parenthood regarding (0.2);
counsel regarding confidentiality designations
on audio and videotape (0.4); conferences with
(0.4); confer with M. Hearron regarding
(0.2);
draft outline for letter to Court regarding
defendants' objections and responses to NAF's
discovery requests (1.6).
726 10/8/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.10 1,491.00 Conferences with N. Napolitan regarding

(.4); conference with M. Smolen
regarding same (.2); assign files for review
and instruct team regarding same (.8); prepare
master log for same (.7).
727 10/8/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.30 121.50 Review Defendants' responses to

interrogatories.
728 10/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.60 1,846.00 Confer with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, and R.

Zacks regarding
106 of 610
729 10/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Email correspondence with client regarding
730 10/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Review and analyze discovery deficiencies in

Defendants' written discovery responses and
document production.
731 10/8/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 4.70 2,162.00 Review defendants' production of videos taken

by "Brianna" at 2014 San Francisco NAF
conference at panel discussion on Challenges in
Second Trimester Abortion (4.70).
732 10/8/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.20 810.00 Review documents and confidentiality

designations in Defendants' productions (0.8);
review video review protocol and background
materials (0.4).
733 10/8/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.70 2,162.00 Review CMP's document production (1.3); discuss

response to discovery letter and research needs
(1); review video and audio files (2.4).
734 10/8/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.80 1,508.00 Download, organize and prepare CMP production

for subsequent attorney review (5); upload and
transmit CMP production videos to client (.80).
735 10/8/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 8.20 4,305.00 Review and log videos recorded April 6, 2014

court.
107 of 610
736 10/9/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Prepare hard copy set of production for
subsequent attorney review (1.25); transmit CMP
production videos to client (2.75); update
threat tracking chart (2); organize case files
(1).
737 10/9/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.50 1,095.00 Review Defendants' video production.
738 10/9/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 4.80 2,520.00 Attend team meeting; review

Defendant's NAF video footage.
739 10/9/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.60 405.00 Attend meeting to discuss

(0.6).
740 10/9/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.30 6,696.00 Perform secondary review of video (2.1 hours);

lead team meeting regarding video review (1
hour); manage document review team (.6 hours);
draft timeline of case filings (1.4 hours);
prepare discovery material for transmission to
client (2.3 hours); review documents produced
by defendants (1.2 hours); confer with
defendants via email regarding meeting and
conferring (.2 hours); confer with D. Foran and
C. Robinson regarding (.5
hours).
741 10/9/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 5.80 4,930.00 Phone calls and emails with D. Rushing

regarding
(0.3);
email correspondence with C. Robinson and N.
Napolitan regarding
(0.3); emails and phone calls
with review team regarding
108 of 610
(4.7); phone call with N.
Napolitan regarding
(0.2); phone conference
with counsel for StemExpress regarding
(0.3).

744 10/9/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 7.40 3,404.00 Continue reviewing video and audio recordings

from San Francisco NAF convention 2014 (6.60);
(.80).
745 10/9/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.50 4,387.50 Review video produced by Defendant from NAF

conferences.
746 10/9/2015 ANNA FERRARI 7.00 4,970.00 Review videos (4.1); attend team meeting

relating to same (.8); instruct A. Nakamura
regarding (.5); coordinate
assignments for same (.7); respond to case team
inquiries with respect to same (.5); update
master template for review of same (.4).
747 10/9/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.60 2,673.00 Research issues related to insulated witness

objection and fifth amendment waiver (6.6)
748 10/9/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.10 2,043.50 Copy production files and distribute to client

(.5.20) Draft chart of court filings and result (0.9).
109 of 610
749 10/9/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.60 1,656.00 Review and log video and audio files.
750 10/9/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.40 184.00 Begin research in support of discovery letter.

court.
752 10/10/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.10 2,346.00 Research in support of discovery letter (2);

review and log audio and video files (3.1).
753 10/10/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.90 2,059.00 Review videos (2.3); instruct case team

regarding same (.4); respond to case team
inquiries with respect to same (.2).
754 10/10/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 2.50 1,150.00 Continue reviewing video and audio footage from

April 5, 2014 San Francisco NAF conference,
challenges in the second trimester panel
(2.50).
755 10/10/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.10 2,952.00 Confer with client regarding (.2

hours); manage video review team (1.1 hours);
perform secondary review of video production (2
hours); draft declaration in support of
discovery brief (.8 hours).
756 10/10/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.50 1,837.50 Review Defendant's NAF video footage.
757 10/10/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.00 2,925.00 Review video of NAF conference.
110 of 610
760 10/11/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 425.00 Further emails with team regarding
761 10/11/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.40 3,888.00 Review and log videos (4 hours); confer with

client regarding (.7 hours);
manage video review team (.7 hours).
762 10/11/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.50 1,417.50 Research issues related to properly signed

verifications (1.5); determine how many
objections defendants made to discovery
responses (2).
763 10/11/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 5.50 2,530.00 Continue reviewing video and audio files from

2014 San Francisco NAF conference, panel on
challenges in second trimester abortion (5.50).
764 10/11/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 8.10 3,726.00 Research in support of discovery letter and

draft responses (3.7); review audio and video
files and log review (4.4).
765 10/11/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 6.90 3,622.50 Review and log videos recorded April 6th and

8th of 2014 and produced by defendant per order
of the court.
766 10/12/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.40 6,290.00 Phone conference with N. Napolitan and J.

Serrano regarding
(0.7); phone conferences with
Arizona counsel for NAF regarding same (0.4);
review legal research regarding standard
governing responses to RFAs (0.8); prepare for
111 of 610
meet‐and‐confer phone conference with opposing
counsel regarding discovery disputes (3.4);
phone conference with counsel for StemExpress
regarding
(0.2); confer with A. Laks regarding
(0.2); confer with N. Napolitan regarding
(1.3); phone
conference with counsel for NAF regarding
(0.4).
767 10/12/2015 ANNA FERRARI 9.80 6,958.00 Review videos (6.4); conferences with N.

Napolitan regarding
(.5); instruct M. Ingram
regarding same (.2); coordinate assignments for
same (.7); analyze Louisiana Inspector
General's authority to issue CMP subpoena
(1.8); email to J. Serrano regarding same (.2).
768 10/12/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 11.30 8,249.00 Review Defendants' video production and prepare

log regarding same.
769 10/12/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.60 6,192.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding

(1.2 hours); review and
analyze material produced by defendants (1.4
hours); confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
(.4 hours); manage video review
team (1.4 hours); confer with P. Flum regarding
(.8 hours); research and contact local
counsel in Louisiana (.7 hours); review
exemplar confidentiality agreements for
112 of 610
attorneys general (.8 hours); perform secondary
review (1.9 hours).
770 10/12/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.70 2,622.00 Review audio and video files.
771 10/12/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 10.00 4,050.00 Determine whether defendants waived their fifth

amendment privilege (1); draft attorney
declaration in support of discovery dispute
letter (6.5); prepare for discovery dispute
meet and confer (.75); research issues
regarding how to properly respond to requests
for admission (1.75).
772 10/12/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.90 4,899.00 Draft motion to compel further written

discovery responses from Daleiden and CMP in
light of numerous objections and improper
withholdings of responsive records.
773 10/12/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Email with litigation team regarding
774 10/12/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 7.10 3,266.00 Finish reviewing audio and video recordings

from 2014 San Francisco NAF conference on 2nd
trimester abortion; begin reviewing footage
from 2015 NAF conference, discussion on Anti
Trends (7.10).
775 10/12/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.80 540.00 Calls with D. Foran and N. Napolitan regarding

(0.3); research on
cases limiting scope of state attorney general
subpoena in Arizona and Louisiana (0.5).
776 10/12/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.80 1,273.00 Create audio and video clips of footage
113 of 610
removing attorneys eyes only footage and audio
for 2014 portion of production.
779 10/12/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.00 1,560.00 Format and update CMP video review charts

(1.5); prepare website screenshot production
documents for subsequent attorney review
(3.25); download articles and related
information regarding other conspirators
(1.25).

court.
781 10/13/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.50 1,690.00 Format CMP video review chart (1.25); organize

NAF video review screenshots (1.25); organize
case files (1.5); download news articles (1);
update threat tracking chart (1.5).
782 10/13/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.10 2,346.00 Assist in preparing joint discovery letter

(3.1); review audio and video files (2).
785 10/13/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.30 1,775.50 Assist with letter brief (1.20); compile video

clips minus AEO portions (2.50); respond to
attorney request to inventory defendant
114 of 610
production (1.60)
786 10/13/2015 ANNA FERRARI 6.80 4,828.00 Review videos (3.3); instruct M. Ingram

same (.7); prepare master chronology from same
(1.8); analyze status of review (.6);
conferences with N. Napolitan regarding
(.2).
787 10/13/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 10.70 7,811.00 Review Defendants' video production (10.6);

review news article regarding Planned
Parenthood change in reimbursement policy for
fetal tissue donation (0.1).
788 10/13/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding

discovery disputes.
789 10/13/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.60 4,686.00 Draft joint discovery letter challenging CMP

and Biomax's objections and responses to NAF's
requests for production, interrogatories, and
other issues.

791 10/13/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 10.50 8,925.00 Prepare for and attend meet‐and‐conference

regarding defendants' written discovery
responses and document productions (2.6);
conferences with C. Robinson regarding
(0.7); revise
draft joint letter brief to the court (6.6);
conference with general counsel for NAF
115 of 610
regarding
(0.3).
792 10/13/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 12.50 9,000.00 Draft and revise joint letter regarding

discovery disputes (6 hours); research
discovery issues (2.2 hours); participate in
meet and confer call with defense counsel (1
hour); review discovery objections (.8 hours);
manage video review team (1.1 hours); conduct
secondary review of material produced by
defendants (1.4 hours).
793 10/13/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 13.70 5,548.50 Draft declaration in support of discovery

dispute submission (3.7); review and revise
discovery dispute filing (1.5); discuss
strategy related to discovery disputes (1.5);
discovery disputes (3); prepare for meet and
confer (.75); research legal issues related to
discovery disputes (3.25).
794 10/13/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Meeting with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, and R.

Zack regarding
795 10/13/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.50 2,485.00 Confer with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, and R. Zack

regarding
796 10/13/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 7.30 3,358.00 Review footage from 2015 NAF conference, Anti
116 of 610
Trends panel, Feminist Caucus panel, NAF CPG
panel (6.90); update master review log (.40).

court.

court.

800 10/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Email correspondence with opposing counsel

regarding joint discovery letter.
801 10/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Supervise filing of joint discovery letter.
802 10/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.80 1,988.00 Review and respond to Daleiden's insert to the

joint discovery letter.
803 10/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.50 3,905.00 Review and revise NAF's portion of joint

discovery letter.
804 10/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Confer with A. Laks regarding
805 10/14/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 11.90 10,115.00 Revise and edit joint statement regarding

discovery disputes (7.6); phone conferences
with C. Robinson, N. Napolitan regarding
117 of 610
revisions thereto (1.3); email correspondence
(0.4); phone
conference with counsel for PP California
regarding (0.2); correspondence with
opposing counsel regarding joint statement and
related discovery disputes (1.0); prepare for
hearing on discovery disputes (1.8).
806 10/14/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 12.70 5,143.50 Draft declaration in support of discovery

dispute submission (5.75); review and revise
discovery dispute filing (5.75); research legal
issues related to discovery disputes (1).
807 10/14/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.40 945.00 Analyze and distinguish cases cited in

Defendants' portion of joint discovery letter
brief (1.4).
808 10/14/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 6.60 3,036.00 Review footage from 2015 NAF conference CPG

panel, MAB panel, Defining Coercion panel
(6.30) ; telephone conference with A. Ferrari
regarding
(.30).
809 10/14/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.60 8,352.00 Draft joint letter regarding discovery (5.4

hours); oversee filing of joint letter
regarding discovery (.7 hours); review and
revise declaration in support of joint
discovery letter (.7 hours); review defendants'
contributions to joint discovery letter (.8
hours); conduct secondary review of material
produced by defendants (2.2 hours); review and
118 of 610
revise filings regarding NAF's motion to seal
(1.2 hours); investigate discovery issues
identified by defendants (.6 hours);
810 10/14/2015 ANNA FERRARI 7.40 5,254.00 Review videos (5.5); instruct M. Smolen

same (.4); prepare master chronology from same
(1.3).
811 10/14/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 12.50 4,187.50 Compile and organize exhibits (.2.10); cite

check letter brief (.3.60); compile case law
for attorney review (1.10); revise brief (.60)
assist with finalization and filing of document (5.1).

review article regarding CMP comments on
Planned Parenthood policy change (0.1); review
J. Chaffetz's statement regarding Congress'
investigation into Planned Parenthood and
subpoena (0.1).
815 10/14/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 9.30 4,278.00 Review audio and video files (2.3); assist in

drafting, reviewing, and filing joint discovery
letter.
816 10/14/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.00 1,560.00 Assist with filing of joint letter regarding

discovery (3); download and prepare research
regarding other conspirators (3).
119 of 610
court.
818 10/15/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 1,430.00 Prepare NAF screenshot production materials for

subsequent attorney review (2); review redacted
production documents (.5); prepare joint
discovery letter briefing (3).
819 10/15/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.40 2,414.00 Correspond and conferences with video and audio

file review team regarding
(.9); instruct R. Webb and R.
Barajas regarding (.8);
review video files (1.2); prepare master
chronology of same (.5).
820 10/15/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.00 1,840.00 Review audio and video files (1.2); create

cheat sheet for first amendment privilege
issues (2.8).
821 10/15/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.10 850.50 Review discovery dispute filings (1); factual

research on defendants.
822 10/15/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.10 703.50 Draft letter to J. Dunn (.50); compile

materials for attorney review (1.60)

review joint discovery letter and exhibits
(0.5).
824 10/15/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.00 2,340.00 Review audio of NAF conference produced by

defendant.
120 of 610
826 10/15/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.90 7,565.00 Prepare for hearing on multiple discovery

matters (8.5); phone conference with potential
local counsel for
(0.2); follow up email correspondence with Anna
Ferrari regarding
(0.2).
827 10/15/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 10.50 7,560.00 Prepare for oral arguments (4.2 hours); confer

with T. Beyer regarding
(.1
hours); research and confer with potential
local counsel (.8 hours); research
case law concerning hearsay (1.9 hours);
research case law regarding expedited discovery
(2.3 hours); prepare additional video reviewers
(.5 hours); confer with D. Foran regarding
(.7 hours);
828 10/15/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 7.20 3,312.00 Review video footage from 2015 NAF conference,

panels on Defining Coercion, Incarcerated
Women, and Hometown Advocacy (6.80) ; telephone
conference with A. Ferrari regarding
(.20); fill in master video assignment log
(.20).
829 10/15/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 337.50 Research and draft summary of analysis

regarding freedom of association rights (0.5).

court.
121 of 610
831 10/16/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.20 6,120.00 Prepare for and attend hearing in federal court

regarding discovery disputes with defendants
(5.5); phone calls and emails with general
counsel for NAF regarding
(0.3); prepare letter to court
regarding reference to Arizona clinic in
audio/videos (1.2); confer with Nick Napolitan
regarding
(0.2).
832 10/16/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 6.30 2,898.00 Review video footage of three separate

recordings of panel on second trimester
providers from NAF 2015 conference (6.30).

835 10/16/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.50 690.00 Review discovery order and calendar deadlines

(1.2); coordinate deposition scheduling (.3).
836 10/16/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.50 4,680.00 Prepare for and attend hearing (2.5 hours);

review and analyze material produced by
defendants (1.5 hours); draft letter to court
regarding material produced by defendants (.5
hours); draft letter to opposing counsel
regarding confidentiality designations (.3
hours); review materials to be produced to
defendants (.4 hours); confer with client
regarding (.4 hours); review
122 of 610
technical discovery issues raised by defendants
(.5 hours).

review summary from D. Foran regarding
(0.1).
838 10/16/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.90 2,059.00 Attend discovery hearing (1.); prepare

transcript order for same (.2); propose
revision to letter brief regarding response to
Arizona and Louisiana subpoenas (.5);
conferences with D. Foran and N. Napolitan
regarding same (.4); emails with J. Gaston
regarding
(.2); correspond with video and audio
file review team regarding
(.8).
839 10/16/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Prepare joint discovery letter briefing (.5);

assist with preparation for hearing (2);
transmit discovery letter briefing to client
(.25); assist with preparation of letter to
defendants' regarding upcoming production
(2.5); assist with preparation of letter to
Judge Orrick (.25); prepare and transmit
supplemental production to opposing counsel
(1.5).
840 10/17/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.80 2,016.00 Review material produced by Defendants (2.8

hours).
841 10/18/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.30 3,053.00 Review videos (2.6); prepare master chronology

with respect to same (1.7).
123 of 610
842 10/18/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 595.00 Prepare task list for preliminary injunction

motion and upcoming depositions (0.7).
843 10/19/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.90 7,565.00 Prepare for and attend team meeting regarding
(3.2); revise and edit
draft letter to Congress regarding disclosure
of audio/video from NAF meetings (4.6); phone
call with counsel for StemExpress regarding
(0.2); phone
conference with counsel for Camelback regarding
(0.2);
phone call with General Counsel for NAF
regarding
(0.5); email correspondence
with counsel for Planned Parenthood regarding
(0.2).
844 10/19/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 3.90 2,632.50 Prepare for and attend team meeting with D.

Foran, L. Shostak, C. Robinson, N. Napolitan
and A. Ferrari regarding
(1.2);
research regarding challenging state subpoenas
via section 1983 claim (2.7).
845 10/19/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.20 2,077.00 Attend team meeting (1.50) draft chart of

production corrections (4.20); send files to
vendor for processing (.50)
846 10/19/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 497.00 Meeting with L. Shostak and N. Napolitan

regarding
124 of 610
847 10/19/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.40 994.00 Meeting with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, A.

Ferrari, and J. Serrano regarding legal
strategy regarding
848 10/19/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.00 2,130.00 Review and revise letter to Chaffetz regarding

CMP's production of video footage
and perform fact research
regarding same.
849 10/19/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.00 2,340.00 Review audio of NAF conference produced by

defendant.
850 10/19/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.40 184.00 Discuss review of audio and video files and

update log.
851 10/19/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 6.70 3,082.00 Review video files from 2015 NAF conference

panel on TRAP restrictions and exhibit hall
footage (6.70).
852 10/19/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.90 4,248.00 Participate in team meeting (1.4 hours); draft

letter to court (.9 hours); review material
produced by defendants (.5 hours); prepare
material regarding NAF's production in response
to Defendants' meet‐and‐confer requests (.8
hours); perform secondary review on material
produced by Defendants (1.1 hours); review
protective order (.4 hours); draft
correspondences to opposing counsel regarding
confidentiality (.4 hours); prepare for
125 of 610
depositions (.4 hours);
853 10/19/2015 ANNA FERRARI 7.40 5,254.00 Attend team meeting regarding
(1.2); review video files (2.5);
coordinate assignments for video review project
(1.4); prepare master chronology for same
(2.3).
854 10/19/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.30 1,898.00 Prepare materials for Newman and Daleiden

depositions.
855 10/19/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.70 1,971.00 Review order on pending discovery disputes

(0.1); revise master log regarding video review
(0.1); review Defendants' video production
(2.5).
856 10/20/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.00 1,380.00 Meeting with D. Foran and T. Beyer regarding

(.6); draft declaration in support
of motion of preliminary injunction (1.4).;
assist in preparing letter regarding violation
of TRO (.7); assist with deposition preparation
and scheduling (.3).
857 10/20/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.50 1,690.00 Prepare documents for supplemental production

(2.5); prepare materials for Newman deposition
(4).
858 10/20/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.80 1,053.00 Review audio recordings of NAF conferences.
859 10/20/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.10 1,038.50 Assist with video review (.20); distribute

files to client(.30); meet with D. Foran
regarding (.30);
126 of 610
facilitate video conversion process (.80)
arrange for a process server and monitor
communications (1.50)
860 10/20/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 5.50 4,015.00 Review Defendants' video production.
861 10/20/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.50 3,037.50 Review transcript and order from discovery

hearing (1); discuss issues related to
(1);
research defendants (.5); research and draft
brief insert on Fifth Amendment scope and
standing (5).
862 10/20/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.50 6,120.00 Revise letter to attorneys from CMP regarding

subpoenas (.3 hours); prepare for deposition of
T. Newman (3.8 hours); review documents to be
produced to defendants (2.2 hours); draft email
to defendants regarding confidentiality (.4
hours); analyze, and confer with team
regarding, (1.8
hours).
863 10/20/2015 ANNA FERRARI 7.10 5,041.00 Review videos (6.2); prepare master log of same

(.9).
864 10/20/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 324.00 Review audio files
865 10/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 426.00 Telephone call with Planned Parenthood

regarding
866 10/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 497.00 Review October 16, 2015 transcript of

proceedings regarding discovery disputes.
127 of 610
867 10/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.60 1,136.00 Telephone call with D. Foran and N. Napolitan

service of process for Daleiden's friend who
leaked video.
868 10/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding
869 10/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.00 2,840.00 Prepare Daleiden deposition outline.
870 10/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Review and revise NAF's letter to Chairman

Chaffetz to address D. Foran's revisions.
871 10/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Conference with R. Zacks regarding
872 10/20/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 3.10 1,426.00 Review footage from 2015 NAF conference exhibit

hall footage and audio footage (3.10).
873 10/20/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.30 7,905.00 Call with StemExpress regarding

(0.4); call with
Roger Evans of Planned Parenthood regarding
same (0.3); conference with Randy Zack
regarding
(0.3); confer
with Ali Lacks and Tom Beyer regarding
(0.2); email
depositions (0.9); revise draft letter to
Congress; review legal research notes for brief
on associational privacy rights (0.9); emails
128 of 610
and phone calls regarding
(1.9); prepare letter to
court regarding same (2.1); prepare letter to
congress regarding same (2.3)
874 10/20/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 4.30 2,257.50 Review and log video and audio files from 2014

and 2015 NAF conventions.
875 10/21/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 810.00 Review internal documentation on discovery

review of audio and video files (.3); review
audio files and log findings (1.7).
876 10/21/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 11.30 4,576.50 Prepare for deposition of Newman (.75); draft

brief addressing First Amendment and Fifth
Amendment discovery issues (9.2); research
issues related to adverse inference in civil
cases (1.25)
877 10/21/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.30 7,905.00 Confer with A. Laks and R. Zack regarding
(0.3); phone calls and emails with client
regarding
(2.2); phone calls
and emails with C. Robinson and N. Napolitan
regarding
(1.5); revise letters to court and congress
regarding disclosure of confidential
information (2.8); phone conference with M.
Hearron and C. Robinson regarding
(0.6); prepare
outline for preliminary injunction outline
opposing counsel regarding response to State AG
129 of 610
subpoenas (0.2); phone conference with Roger
Evans regarding
(0.4).
878 10/21/2015 ANNA FERRARI 5.90 4,189.00 Review videos (3.7); instruct A. Dale regarding

same (.4); coordinate assignments for same
(.6); prepare master log for same (1.2).
879 10/21/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.00 5,040.00 Confer with process server (.6 hours); prepare

for deposition of T. Newman (3.5 hours);
analyze issues regarding leak of confidential
information (1 hour); confer with D. Foran and
C. Robinson regarding (.5 hours);
confer with client regarding (.3
hours); review material to be produced (1.1
hours).
880 10/21/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 5.10 2,346.00 Review video and audio files from 2015 NAF

conference (5.10).
881 10/21/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.50 1,507.50 Compile materials for witness file (.50); draft

communications with process server (.60); fact
check letter to court (.80) review and upload
audio files (1.10); coordinate redaction
project (1.50)
882 10/21/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.90 3,451.50 Research regarding service and contempt (4 hr);

review audio recordings from NAF conferences
(1.9 hr).
883 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Telephone call with J. Burns' regarding

accepting service of TRO on behalf of C.
Johnson.
130 of 610
884 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.50 1,065.00 Review attorney work product descriptions of

video and audio production in connection with
D. Daleiden deposition preparation.
885 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.10 1,491.00 Prepare Daleiden deposition outline.
886 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Review and revise letter to Court regarding

violation of TRO.
887 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Legal research in connection with letter to the

Court regarding violation of TRO.
888 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.10 2,911.00 Review and analyze production documents in

connection with Daleiden deposition outline.
889 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Telephone call with N. Napolitan regarding
890 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.10 781.00 Telephone call with D. Foran and M. Hearron

regarding
891 10/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Conference with N. Napolitan regarding

deposition (5); download CMP audio and video
files (4).
893 10/21/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 9.60 4,416.00 Research, draft, and revise brief regarding

first and fifth amendment (9); review and
131 of 610
coordinate deposition issues (.6).
894 10/21/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 1.00 800.00 Confer with D. Foran and C. Robinson regarding
895 10/21/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 6.50 3,412.50 Review and log video and audio files from 2014

and 2015 NAF conventions.
896 10/22/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.00 2,300.00 Revise first amendment brief and assist in

adding citations (1.7); draft and revise
sealing papers for brief (2); continue
reviewing audio files and updating log (1.3)
897 10/22/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 14.30 3,718.00 Process and organize documents for supplemental

production (8); prepare materials for Daleiden
deposition (6.3) .
898 10/22/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.30 1,741.50 Review audio files disclosed for discovery and

update internal discovery log (4.2); correspond
with A. Ferrari regarding
(.1)
899 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 497.00 Review video footage for inclusion in D.

Daleiden deposition outline.
900 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Review and revise sealing motion and supporting

papers; attend to filing under seal of NAF's
letter to the Court regarding violations of the
TRO.
901 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.90 1,349.00 Review and revise D. Daleiden deposition

outline.
132 of 610
902 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Review news reports regarding leaked video
footage in violation of TRO.
903 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 497.00 Revise letter to the Court and to Congress

regarding updates on leaked video by GotNews
LLC.
904 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Prepare letter to defendants regarding

depositions of additional declarants.
905 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Confer with N. Napolitan and D. Foran regarding
906 10/22/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 426.00 Legal research in opposition to the Reporter

Committee's brief requesting clarification
regarding the protective order.
907 10/22/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 6.40 2,944.00 Review audio files from 2015 NAF conference

(6.40).
908 10/22/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.30 3,361.50 Research Fifth Amendment adverse inference law

(1.5); review and revise First Amendment
associational privilege memorandum (3.5); fact
research on video leak (1.15); review audio
produced by daleiden (1.8).
909 10/22/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 13.00 4,355.00 Redact documents (10.80) cite check brief

(1.20); prepare documents for review and
production (2.0)
910 10/22/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 351.00 Review audio recorded at NAF meetings.
133 of 610
911 10/22/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.00 4,320.00 Prepare for deposition of T. Newman (2.9
hours); revise and finalize court filing
regarding leaks of confidential information
(1.3 hours); draft outline regarding deposition
of T. Newman (.8 hours); review brief
concerning inadvertent disclosure (.6 hours);
review material for production (.4 hours).
912 10/22/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 12.20 10,370.00 Revise and edit supplemental brief regarding

assertion of First Amendment right of
association to withhold information in
discovery (4.3); conferences with R. Zack
regarding (0.3); revise letter to
Congress regarding leaks (0.6); fact
investigation regarding further leaks for
Daleiden friend Johnson (2.3); preparations for
deposition of CMP (4.7).
913 10/22/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.10 2,201.00 Analyze content from video and audio review

relating to Arizona and Louisiana subpoenas
(1.3); correspond with review team regarding
(.4); prepare
master log for same (1.4).
914 10/22/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.80 420.00 Read NAF motion to file under seal and

accompanying letter regarding disclosure and
publication of NAF videos (.4); review NAF
videos published by "Weevl." (0.4)
915 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Email with client regarding
134 of 610
916 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Supervise filing and proper sealing of NAF's

brief regarding Defendants' assertion of a
First Amendment association privilege.

litigation team.
918 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.90 639.00 Telephone call with Congressional staff member

regarding video leak.
919 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Review and analyze Defendants' brief regarding

First Amendment associational privilege.
920 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Confer with L. Shostak, D. Foran, N. Napolitan,

and A. Ferrari regarding
921 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Confer with J. Dunn regarding
922 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 426.00 Review and analyze CMP and Daleiden's

supplemental discovery responses.
923 10/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.30 3,053.00 Perform secondary review to ensure reliability

and accuracy of confidentiality redactions to
NAF's supplemental document production.
924 10/23/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.80 2,349.00 Review audio files and update discovery log (5.80).
925 10/23/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 5.30 2,438.00 Review audio footage from NAF 2015 conference

(5.30).
926 10/23/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.30 5,355.00 Meet and confer correspondence with opposing
135 of 610
counsel regarding Arizona and Louisiana
subpoena (0.3); preparations for CMP deposition
(6.0).
927 10/23/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.00 7,920.00 Finalize production (5 hours); create list of

contextual information regarding documents
produced by NAF, per defendants'
meet‐and‐confer requests (2.5 hours); review
and revise brief on First Amendment issues (1.2
hours); confer with L. Shostak for
(.7 hours); research contempt
issues (1.1 hours); research issues concerning
leak of confidential information (.5 hours).
928 10/23/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.00 920.00 Finalize review of videos and update log.

deposition (3); update case files (.2);
download news articles (1); update threat
tracking chart (1); prepare materials for
supplemental production (4.3).
930 10/23/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.00 1,675.00 Redact documents (3.50); assist with completion

and filing of documents (1.50)
931 10/23/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 11.80 4,779.00 Discuss and determine next steps regarding

video leak (.9); review and prepare sealing
motions for first amendment privilege motion
(1); review supplemental document production
for privilege and confidentiality (3.5); review
and revise first amendment associational
privilege brief (5.1); review audio recording
produced by Dialed (1).
136 of 610
932 10/23/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.80 5,148.00 Review audio files recorded by defendants at

NAF conferences.
933 10/23/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.00 2,840.00 Conference with L. Shostak, D. Foran, N.

(.3); instruct team
members regarding video and audio review
project (1.6); prepare master log for same
(.8); analyze evidence relating to execution of
conference confidentiality agreements (.9);
emails with D. Foran regarding same (.4).
934 10/23/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.30 2,409.00 Draft log Review review of Defendants' video

production (0.7); review Defendants's video
production (2.6).
935 10/24/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.50 3,195.00 Review videos (2.7); prepare master log for

same (1.8).
936 10/24/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.20 2,916.00 Research whether Charles Johnson can be held in

contempt for acting in concert with Daleiden in
releasing videos.
937 10/24/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.40 3,124.00 Review videos (3.6); prepare master log for

same (.8).
938 10/24/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.30 3,096.00 Draft outline for deposition of T. Newman (4.3

hours).
939 10/24/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 5.80 3,045.00 Review Defendant's NAF video and audio footage.
940 10/24/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 2.10 966.00 Review audio files from NAF 2015 conference
137 of 610
(2.10).
941 10/24/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.10 850.50 Review audio files and update discovery log (2.1).
942 10/25/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.10 46.00 Review Daleiden deposition outline (.10).
943 10/25/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.40 2,592.00 Review audio files and update discovery log

(6.3); correspond with A. Ferrari regarding
(.1)
944 10/25/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.50 1,012.50 Review audio recording produced by Daledien.
945 10/25/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 5.10 4,335.00 Review defendants' supplemental brief on First

Amendment right of association issues (1.0);
further preparations for CMP deposition (4.1).
946 10/25/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 6.20 3,255.00 Review Defendant's NAF audio footage.
947 10/25/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.30 435.50 Assist with deposition preparation.

draft log regarding review of video production
(0.5).
949 10/25/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.50 3,412.50 Prepare for Newman and Daleiden depositions.
950 10/26/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 10.00 9,750.00 Prepare for Newman deposition (5.0); prepare

for Daleiden deposition (5.0).
951 10/26/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,300.00 Preparation of Newman deposition materials.
952 10/26/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.50 6,120.00 Prepare for deposition of T. Newman (6 hours);

138 of 610
(.8 hours); review Defendants'
discovery responses (.7); submit takedown
request to YouTube (.5 hours); confer with team
regarding (.5 hours).
953 10/26/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.70 3,337.00 Identify evidence from video and audio file

review for D. Daleiden deposition (1.8);
per C. Robinson request (.6);
correspondence with video and audio review team
regarding (.9); prepare
master log for video and audio file review
(1.4).
954 10/26/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 8.00 5,840.00 Analyze outline for D. Daleiden deposition

(0.2); draft summary of clips from Defendants'
video production relevant to D. Daleiden
deposition (0.5); review Defendants' amended
privilege log (0.1); review Defendants' audio
production (6.7); draft log regarding review of
Defendants' production (0.6).
955 10/26/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 5.00 2,300.00 Review audio files from NAF 2015 conference

(4.90).
956 10/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 426.00 Meeting with D. Foran, L. Shostak, and N.

Napolitan regarding
957 10/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.80 1,278.00 Legal research regarding scope of Fifth

Amendment waiver as to subject matter.
958 10/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.90 2,769.00 Meeting with L. Shostak regarding
139 of 610
959 10/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Legal research in connection with contempt

proceeding.
960 10/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.40 994.00 Review and revise Daleiden deposition outline

962 10/26/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.30 7,055.00 Phone calls, emails, and internal conferences

regarding
(3.2);
(0.6);
phone call with StemExpress counsel regarding
(0.3); phone conference with General Counsel
for NAF regarding
(0.3);
meet‐and‐confer correspondence with CMP
regarding responses to AG subpoenas (0.2);
preparations for CMP deposition (3.9).
963 10/26/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 12.70 5,143.50 Draft motion to show cause why defendants and

Johnson should not be held in contempt (10);
research issues related to motion regarding
contempt (2.7)
964 10/26/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.50 1,312.50 Review audio files.
140 of 610
965 10/26/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.20 2,412.00 Deposition preparation for Troy Newman (.70);
Deposition preparation for CMP (4.0) Deposition
preparation for David Daleiden (.50); create
audio clips (1.10); create video clips for
deposition (.30) compile documents for attorney
review (.60)
966 10/26/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.80 3,978.00 Research in support of motion to show cause

regarding contempt.
967 10/26/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.90 769.50 Review video files and update discovery log

(1.9).
968 10/26/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 10.20 5,355.00 Review and log video and audio files from April

6, 2014 and April 20, 2015, recorded at NAF's
annual convention.
969 10/27/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.70 7,395.00 Prepare for D. Daleiden and CMP depositions

(7.0); review and comment on draft contempt
motion (1.4); phone call with General Counsel
for NAF regarding
(0.3).
970 10/27/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 6.60 3,036.00 Review audio files from 2015 NAF conference

(6.60).
971 10/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.70 1,917.00 Review and revise Daleiden outline to address

L. Shostak's
972 10/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.90 1,349.00 Review and analyze production documents and

video footage in preparation for Daleiden's
deposition.
141 of 610
litigation team.
974 10/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.40 2,414.00 Meet with L. Shostak regarding
975 10/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Draft letter to LLDF regarding unauthorized

contact with NAF.
976 10/27/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.50 1,507.50 Prepare exhibits for production (2.70); compile

documents for attorney review (1.10); monitor
Newman deposition (.20); redact documents (.50)
977 10/27/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 3.30 2,640.00 Prepare draft of preliminary injunction motion.
978 10/27/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 2,632.50 Draft motion for contempt and expedited

discovery.
979 10/27/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.20 2,511.00 Review and revise motion to show cause why

defendants and Johnson should not be held in
contempt.
980 10/27/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.80 1,278.00 Update master chronology from video review

(1.6); conferences with N. Napolitan regarding
same (.2).
981 10/27/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 4.40 3,212.00 Review news articles regarding recent leaked

videos (0.2); review Defendants' audio
production and draft log regarding same (4.2).
982 10/27/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.30 6,696.00 Prepare for and participate in deposition of T.

Newman (5 hours); prepare for Daleiden
deposition (.4 hours); draft motion for
142 of 610
contempt (2 hours); review work product
concerning material produced by Defendants (1.9
hours).
983 10/27/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.50 1,950.00 Prepare redactions for supplemental production

(2); assist with deposition preparation for
Daleiden deposition (3); update threat tracking
chart (1.5); update witness files (.2);
download CMP released videos (.8).
984 10/27/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 10.80 10,530.00 Prepare for Newman deposition (2.0); take

Newman deposition (4.5); prepare for Daleiden
deposition (3.5); negotiate with opposing
counsel regarding Daleiden deposition (0.75).
985 10/28/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 2,925.00 Review Newman deposition transcript (1.0);

review Daleiden outline and discuss same with
D. Foran (1.0); review contempt motion and
discuss same with N. Napolitan and D. Foran
(1.0).

(2.5); prepare potential exhibits for motion
regarding contempt filing (2.5); update threat
tracking chart (.2); assist with preparation of
Daleiden deposition (1.8).
987 10/28/2015 ANNA FERRARI 6.30 4,473.00 Analyze files deemed by defendants as

responsive to the Arizona and Louisiana
subpoenas (3.8); conferences with D. Foran
regarding same (.2); conferences with N.
Napolitan regarding same (.2); update
spreadsheet with respect to same (1.6);
143 of 610
conferences with M. Ingram, M. Smolen and R.
Webb regarding
(.6).
988 10/28/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.70 8,424.00 Draft motion for contempt and for discovery in

aid of contempt proceedings (6 hours); research
facts concerning leak of NAF confidential
information (4.5 hours); prepare for deposition
of D. Daleiden (.5 hours); confer with R. Zack
regarding (.2 hours); research
case law regarding contempt (.5 hours).

litigation team.
990 10/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Review and revise draft Nucatola and Ginde

declarations.
991 10/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Email correspondence with litigation team

regarding strategy on
992 10/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Review and revise transcripts of video files

for Daleiden's deposition.
993 10/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Telephone call with D. Foran and L. Shostak

regarding
994 10/28/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.30 138.00 Follow up regarding documentation of review

audio and video files (.30).
995 10/28/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.20 2,511.00 Draft declaration in support of order to show

cause regarding defendants contempt.
144 of 610
996 10/28/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.30 1,207.50 Review video footage, research federal law

regarding section 1983 claims in the Ninth and
Fifth Circuits and the First Amendment
Privilege.
997 10/28/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 8.10 2,713.50 Prepared documents for deposition(3.50) convert

video files to mp4 format (2.0); assist with
upcoming filing (.90); prepare and redact
documents for production(1.10); produce
documents(.60)
998 10/28/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.20 1,872.00 Draft motion to show cause why defendants

should not be held in contempt.
999 10/28/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 11.70 9,945.00 Prepare for deposition of David Daleiden

(11.1); phone calls and emails with counsel for
Planned Parenthood regarding
(0.3);
(0.3).
1000 10/28/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.80 420.00 Review notes regarding defendant's regarding of

Insurance Panel at 2015 NAF conference (.6);
compose and send email to N. Napolitano
regarding
1001 10/29/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.70 994.50 Draft motion to show cause why defendant should

not be held in contempt.
1002 10/29/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 10.20 3,417.00 Prepare materials for upcoming D. Daleiden

video (2.0) Assist with deposition(8.20)
145 of 610
1003 10/29/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.90 639.00 Confer with NAF's counsel and Mofo team

regarding
1005 10/29/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Attend portions of Daleiden's deposition.
1006 10/29/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.20 92.00 Respond to queries regarding how certain

recorded panel discussions are not responsive
to the Congressional subpoena (.20).
1007 10/29/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 1,430.00 Preparation of redactions for supplemental

productions (1); prepare potential exhibits for
motion regarding contempt filing (1.5); assist
with preparation of Daleiden deposition (3).
1008 10/29/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.80 7,056.00 Prepare for and attend deposition of D.

Daleiden (2.2 hours); revise contempt motion
(3.8 hours); draft list of material produced by
Defendants that is not responsive to subpoenas
(2.3 hours); review transcript of deposition of
D. Daleiden (1.5 hours).
1009 10/29/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.50 8,075.00 Prepare for and attend deposition of D.

Daleiden (8.8); conference with GC for NAF
following deposition (0.7).
1010 10/29/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.20 2,982.00 Analyze files deemed by defendants as

responsive to the Arizona and Louisiana
146 of 610
subpoenas (3.7); instruct review team regarding
(.5).
1011 10/29/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.50 3,037.50 Draft declaration in support of order to show

cause (7); research adverse inference for
asserting the fifth amendment (.5);
1012 10/29/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 10.00 9,750.00 Meet with client and attend Daleiden

deposition.
1013 10/29/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 2.00 1,050.00 Read depositions of D. Daleiden and T. Newman.
1016 10/30/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 4.50 4,387.50 Various meetings with client throughout the day

regarding
(3.5); review
court order and strategize regarding same
(1.0).
1017 10/30/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.50 3,037.50 Draft sealing motion for order to show cause

(3); draft motion and sealing motion regarding
notice to Court of Daleiden deposition
transcript (1.5); discuss waiver and response
to Court's Oct. 30 order (1); draft subpoena
directed at Charles Johnson (2).
1018 10/30/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.70 892.50 Review NAF video and audio footage related to

defendants' Arizona and Louisiana productions.
147 of 610
1019 10/30/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.10 2,201.00 Conference with D. Foran regarding
(.2);
instruct document specialist regarding
(.4); update chart regarding subpoena
responsiveness (.8); review video and audio
files for responsiveness (1.7).
1020 10/30/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.10 2,983.50 Review deposition transcript of D. Daleiden (4

hr); draft motion to seal and accompanying
documents (1.1 hr).
1021 10/30/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.20 5,270.00 Prepare notice to court regarding Daleiden

deposition (0.2); review court order on pending
discovery disputes (0.3); review and revise
subpoena directed to C. Johnson (0.2);
preparations for meet and confer with AGs over
scope of disclosures in response to subpoena
(2.5); review Daleiden transcript (3.0).
1022 10/30/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.10 5,832.00 Revise motion to compel (1.2 hours); meet with

D. Foran, L. Shostak and L. Brown regarding
(2 hours); prepare
subpoena for C. Johnson (1.2 hours); prepare
and file notice of deposition and transcript
(.7 hours); prepare work product concerning
material produced by Defendants (.9 hours);
review court order (.4 hours); confer with team
regarding (.5 hours); prepare
for Saporta deposition (1.2 hours).
1023 10/30/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 11.30 2,938.00 Prepare redactions for supplemental review

(5.5); prepare potential exhibits for motion
148 of 610
for contempt filing (3.5); download and archive
news articles (1.3); update case file (1).

litigation team.
1025 10/30/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Review the Court's orders and other party

submissions regarding protective order issues,
First Amendment association privacy issues, and
Fifth Amendment issues.
1026 10/30/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Redact documents for production (.00); arrange

service of subpoena to Charles C. Johnson
(.00): compile documents for attorney
review(.00);
1027 10/31/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 1,430.00 Prepare Saporta e‐mails for subsequent attorney

review (3); prepare materials for supplemental
production (2); transmit supplemental
production to opposing counsel (.5).
1028 10/31/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 360.00 Prepare for Saporta deposition.
1029 10/31/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.00 810.00 Research fifth amendment waiver.
1030 10/31/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.50 1,462.50 Review Daleiden transcript.
1031 11/1/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Compile deposition materials for attorney

review.
1032 11/1/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.10 1,491.00 Review video and audio files for responsiveness

(1.7); update master log regarding same (.9).
149 of 610
1033 11/1/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 5.10 4,335.00 Prepare supplemental brief regarding Daleiden
Fifth Amendment right to withhold names of
co‐conspirators in discovery.
1034 11/1/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 144.00 Confer with team via email regarding
1035 11/2/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.60 2,592.00 Meeting with D. Foran and A. Ferrari to discuss

(.3); confer with N.
(.3 hours); confer with team regarding
(.8 hours); review motion to
quash (.3 hours); research issues regarding
motions to quash (.6 hours); participate in
deposition preparation with clients (1.3
hours).
1036 11/2/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.50 8,075.00 Preparations for depositions of Jennifer Dunn,

Vicki Saporta, Matthew Reeves (6.7); review
motion to quash Johnson deposition (0.3); phone
call and emails with M. Hearron regarding
(0.2); revise and edit supplemental breif
regarding Daleiden Fifth Amendment right to
withhold names of co‐conspirators (2.3).
1037 11/2/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.40 292.00 Review article regarding Gotnews.com editor

video release and NAF (0.1); review recent case
filings (0.3).
1038 11/2/2015 ANNA FERRARI 5.90 4,189.00 Conference with D. Foran and N. Napolitan

regarding
(.3); analyze same (2.4); update chart
150 of 610
regarding same (1.1); emails and conferences
with review team members regarding (.6);
instruct C. Magana and A. Dale regarding
(.2); respond to D.
Foran inquiry regarding
(.2); analyze video and audio
file content involving Planned Parenthood Gulf
Coast in connection with Louisiana Inspector
General request (1.1).
1039 11/2/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.40 2,592.00 Research fifth amendment waiver (1.5); draft

declaration in support of fifth amendment
waiver (.5); review and revise memorandum to
the court regarding fifth amendment waiver (4);
review deposition transcript of David Daleiden (0.3).
1041 11/2/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.80 368.00 Confer with A. Ferrari regarding

(.3); confer with R. Zach regarding (.5).
1042 11/2/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.50 1,837.50 Review NAF video and audio footage.
1043 11/2/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.90 2,866.50 Edit brief on Fifth Amendment privilege (2 hr);

review evidence for preliminary injunction
briefing (2.9 hr).
1044 11/2/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 607.50 Review video recording of Dr. Reeves and update

transcript (1.4); correspond with A. Ferrari
regarding (.1).
1045 11/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 923.00 Review and analyze legal citations in NAF's

brief regarding waiver of Fifth Amendment
151 of 610
regarding names of co‐conspirators; provide
revisions to brief regarding same.
1046 11/2/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 9.80 3,283.00 Compile deposition materials for attorney

review (1.30); draft evidence matrix (2.20);
redact documents (3.80); compile witness file
for C. Johnson (2.20); compile Dunn witness
file (.30)
1047 11/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Review Court order regarding Daleiden's request

for supplemental briefing.
1048 11/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Confer with R. Zack regarding
1049 11/2/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 13.30 3,458.00 Prepare and transmit supplemental production to

opposing counsel (1.3); prepare redactions for
supplemental production (10.5); download news
articles regarding threats on planned
parenthood (1.5)
1050 11/2/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 3.00 1,575.00 Review video and correct transcription of April

8, 2015 conversation between D. Daleiden and M.
Reeves.
1051 11/2/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 5.00 4,875.00 Prepare V. Saporta for deposition (4.0); Reeves

prep. (1.0).
1052 11/3/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 10.00 9,750.00 Defend deposition of V. Saporta (9.0); prepare

Reeves for deposition (1.0).
1053 11/3/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 11.50 2,990.00 Preparation of redactions for supplemental

production (9.5); update threat tracking chart
152 of 610
and case files (1.5); download case related
news articles (.5)
1054 11/3/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.10 1,228.50 Fact research regarding upcoming motion for

preliminary injunction.
1055 11/3/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.80 2,044.00 Review videos regarding responsiveness to state

subpoenas and complete log regarding same.
1056 11/3/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.70 2,664.00 Review and revise opposition to motion to quash

and related documents (3.7 hours).
1057 11/3/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.60 276.00 Respond to query from A. Ferrari regarding
1058 11/3/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.40 945.00 Review deposition transcript of V. Saporta

(0.4); review deposition transcript of D.
Daleiden (0.7); review deposition transcript T.
Newman (0.3).
1059 11/3/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.70 3,523.50 Draft opposition to motion to quash (.7); draft

sealing papers related to opposition to motion
to quash (2); review and revise opposition to
motion to quash (2); review redaction of
documents prepared for production (3); file
opposition to motion to quash (1).
1060 11/3/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.60 1,890.00 Review NAF video and audio footage related to

defendants' Arizona and Louisiana productions;
confer with A. Ferrari regarding same.
1061 11/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.10 781.00 Review V. Saporta deposition transcript.
153 of 610
1062 11/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.60 1,136.00 Meet with J. Dunn to
1063 11/3/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 3.20 2,560.00 Prepare preliminary injunction motion.
1064 11/3/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.20 552.00 Draft sealing motion for fifth amendment brief,

declaration in support, and proposed order (1);
review brief for errors and sealing issues
(.2).
1065 11/3/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.40 2,144.00 Assist with facilitation of depositions (.90);

compile documents for Reeves deposition
preparation(1.60); redact documents for
production(2.10); cite check 5th amendment
brief(1.0); organize documents from Saprota
deposition(.30); supplement C. Johnson witness
file (.50)
1066 11/3/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.30 219.00 Review motion to quash subpoena of C. Johnson

and related correspondence (0.1); review order
regarding October 30 order (0.1); review letter
from D. Daleiden regarding TRO transfer of
materials (0.1).
1067 11/3/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.60 1,846.00 Emails with M. Smolen regarding

(.3); analyze same (.8);
identify content from video and audio review
relating to M. Reeves (.4); conference and
emails with A. Nakamura, R. Barajas and S.
Dawson regarding
(.2); investigate video and audio
file content involving Planned Parenthood Gulf
154 of 610
Coast in connection with Louisiana Inspector
General request (.9).
1068 11/3/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 11.50 9,775.00 Preparations for deposition of Jennifer Dunn

(4.2); revise opposition to motion to quash
Johnson subpoena (0.8); phone conference with
counsel for Louisiana (0.3); draft motion for
preliminary injunction (4.7); meetings
regarding (0.3);
preparations for deposition Dr. Reeves (1.2).
1069 11/3/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 8.60 4,515.00 Phone call with D. Foran to discus

(0.10); read
C. Johnson's Motion to Quash Subpoena (0.20);
review and consult Federal Rules of Civil
Procedure and Committee Comments regarding
grounds for quashing subpoenas (0.80); research
cases involving subpoenas and reasonable notice
(3.0); draft opposition to motion to quash
(3.0); email and phone correspondence with N.
Napolitan regarding
(0.40); revise and edit draft
opposition (0.50); draft declaration of D.
Foran in support of opposition to motion to
quash (0.40); speak with R. Zack regarding
(0.20).
1070 11/4/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 10.00 8,500.00 Prepare for and defend deposition of Jennifer

Dunn (9.2); review and revise supplemental
brief regarding disclosure of identities of
individuals who gained access to NAF meetings
(0.8).
155 of 610
1071 11/4/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.90 2,808.00 Review and revise brief regarding Fifth
Amendment rights (2.3 hours); review work
product regarding material produced by
defendants (.8 hours); review motion for stay
(.8 hours).
1072 11/4/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.90 1,641.50 Assist with depositions (.50); distribute case

materials to client (.60); compile documents
for attorney review (1.20); redact documents (2.6).
1073 11/4/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.80 4,563.00 Analyze and assemble evidence for use in

preliminary injunction motion.
1074 11/4/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.00 3,240.00 Review and redact documents for production (3);

review and revise brief on fifth amendment
waiver (2.9); draft opposition to defendants
motion to clarify (2.1)
1075 11/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Review and analyze Professor Dunn's deposition

transcript.
1076 11/4/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 2.00 1,600.00 Review deposition transcripts for preliminary

injunction motion.
1077 11/4/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.10 577.50 Review NAF video footage; update master

chronology chart.
1078 11/4/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.90 1,349.00 Analyze Louisiana content from audio and video

file review (1.5); email to D. Foran regarding
same (.1); correspond with review team
regarding
(.3).
156 of 610
(6.5); update threat tracking chart (2.5)
1080 11/4/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 9.00 8,775.00 Review motion to stay (1.0); defend deposition.
1081 11/4/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.70 367.50 Review log for references to Planned Parenthood

Gulf Coast (.10); review video recordings of
members of Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast and
update log entry (.5); compose and send email
to A. Ferrari (.10).
1082 11/5/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 2,925.00 Review deposition transcripts.
1083 11/5/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.80 2,028.00 Cite‐check opposition to motion to stay

regarding first amendment (3.5); prepare
redacted documents for production (4.25)
1084 11/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Review Defendants' motion to stay First

Amendment privilege ruling pending appeal.
1085 11/5/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.00 920.00 Read and review NAF Opposition to Defendants'

stay motion for errors and sealing issues and
draft sealing motion, declaration, and proposed
order.
1086 11/5/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.10 3,280.50 Review and redact documents for production

(2.5); review and revise opposition to
defendants motion for stay pending appeal (5.6)
1087 11/5/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Review and analyze M. Reeves deposition

transcript.
1088 11/5/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.30 4,270.50 Draft opposition to motion to stay.
157 of 610
1089 11/5/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.80 420.00 Review NAF video and audio footage.
1090 11/5/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.80 2,016.00 Review and revise opposition to motion for stay

and for reconsideration (1.6 hours); confer
with N. Roethlisberger regarding same (.4
hours); review deposition transcripts (.8
hours)
1091 11/5/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 12.00 10,200.00 Review motion to stay court's discovery order

regarding disclosure of individuals who
received NAF confidential information (0.9);
prepare opposition to motion to stay (8.7);
review deposition transcript of J. Dunn (1.0);
phone call with counsel for Dr. Nucatola
regarding (0.2); phone call with
client regarding
(0.2); legal research for
preliminary injunction motion (1.0)
1092 11/5/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.60 1,206.00 Draft letter to vendor (.20); send hard drive

to vendor to be processed (.40); cite check
opposition(1.10); distribute files to client
(.30); Assist with filing (.50); compile files
for attorney review (.80); review processed
video files(.30)
1094 11/5/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 1.70 892.50 Read deposition transcript of Dr. Reeves.
1095 11/6/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.40 1,260.00 Review master chronology; review audio and

video footage.
158 of 610
1096 11/6/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 3,825.00 Prepare for and attend meeting regarding motion

for preliminary injunction (1.7); phone call
with counsel for Nucatola regarding
(0.2); phone call with counsel for StemExpress
regarding
(0.2); review reply on motion
to stay discovery order regarding disclosure of
individuals who received NAF confidential
information (0.7); prepare motion for
preliminary injunction (1.7).
1097 11/6/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 5.70 4,560.00 Prepare draft of preliminary injunction.
1098 11/6/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Team meeting regarding
1099 11/6/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.10 1,512.00 Meet with team regarding

(1 hours); review discovery
responses (.3 hours); review evidentiary issues
regarding preliminary injunction motion (.8
hours).
1100 11/6/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.50 3,037.50 Draft emails to opposing counsel regarding

protective order stipulation (1); draft
administrative motion to confirm scope of
protective order (3); draft other papers in
support of administrative motion to confirm
scope of protective order (1.3); review and
redact documents for production (.6); draft
stipulation regarding scope of protective order
(1.6).
159 of 610
1101 11/6/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.50 2,070.00 Finalize audio and video review.
1102 11/6/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.10 1,708.50 Teleconference with video vendor (.30) create

video clips of Nucatola footage to send to
counsel (3.20); draft letter to Nucatola
counsel (.20); send materials to Nucatola's
counsel (.20); file documents (.70); revise
third party distribution chart (.50)
1103 11/6/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.20 2,457.00 Analyze and assemble evidence for use in

1104 11/6/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.00 1,040.00 Create and update protective order tracking

chart and case file (1.5); prepare updated
production redactions for subsequent attorney
review (2.5)
1105 11/6/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.00 975.00 NAF team meeting.
1106 11/6/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 2.50 1,312.50 Review documents provided by client for

production for privacy redactions.
1108 11/8/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 2,720.00 Draft motion for preliminary injunction.
1110 11/9/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.20 1,742.00 Distribute case documents (.20); edit

transcriptions of Nucatola conversations (.30);
draft exhibits to motion for contempt (.20);
compile quotes for PI motion (.50) assist with
compilation of exhibits for upcoming filing
160 of 610
(1.50); edit video clips (2.50)
1111 11/9/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.30 8,136.00 Confer with D. Foran and C. Robinson regarding

(.3 hours); draft
motion for contempt (8.1 hours); research case
law regarding contempt (.7 hours); review
deposition transcripts (2.2 hours).
1112 11/9/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.70 7,395.00 Draft preliminary injunction motion.
1113 11/9/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.00 460.00 Review filing to determine we need to file

declaration in support of motions to seal.
1114 11/9/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.30 3,100.50 Assemble evidence for preliminary injunction

brief.
1115 11/9/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.10 781.00 Analyze authority from video review in support

of preliminary injunction motion (.9); emails
with N. Napolitan regarding same (.2).
1116 11/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Confer with D. Foran and N. Napolitan regarding
1117 11/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.80 4,828.00 Draft sections of NAF's preliminary injunction

motion.
1118 11/9/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.20 92.00 Analyze portion of audio recording in response

to query from N. Napolitan
(.20).
1119 11/9/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.10 2,470.50 Review documents for production (2); draft

Foran Declaration in support of order to show
cause (4)
161 of 610
1120 11/9/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 0.50 487.50 Consult with D. Foran regarding
1121 11/9/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.20 146.00 Review motion regarding protective order and

meet and confer (0.1); review Defendants' reply
in support of stay pending appeal (0.1).
1122 11/9/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 8.00 2,080.00 Prepare redactions for supplemental production.
1123 11/10/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.50 1,950.00 Prepare redactions for supplemental production.
1124 11/10/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.80 1,755.00 OSC regarding contempt review (1.0); call with

opposing counsel regarding settlement (0.3);
call with client regarding same (0.5).
1125 11/10/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 10.10 4,090.50 Work on declaration in support of motion for

order to show cause (1); work on declaration in
support of motion for preliminary injunction
(7.5); work on factual support for motion for
preliminary injunction (1.6)
1126 11/10/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.90 4,621.50 Assemble evidence for preliminarily injunction

brief.
1127 11/10/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.40 1,785.00 Research California contracts law for authority

to support the argument that one party's
undisclosed opinion that a contract is
unenforceable is irrelevant and the argument
that an agreement may be enforced against a
party who entered it fraudulently; draft
to D. Foran and C.
Robinson; confer with N. Napolitan and A. Laks
162 of 610
regarding
1128 11/10/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 5,950.00 Revise and edit preliminary injunction motion

(5.6); review and revise draft contempt motion
(0.6); phone conference with client re
(0.5); phone conference with counsel
for Newman re potential settlement (0.3).
1129 11/10/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.40 184.00 Review audio

per query of D. Foran (.40).
1130 11/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.10 2,911.00 Review and revise

1131 11/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Email correspondence
1132 11/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Review and comment on draft of NAF's

1133 11/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Meeting with D. Foran and N. Napolitan

regarding
1134 11/10/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.30 6,696.00 Review work product summarizing material

produced by defendants (1.7 hours); draft
motion for preliminary injunction and
supporting documents (7.6 hours).
1135 11/10/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.60 2,211.00 Create video clips of PPGC footage from NAF
163 of 610
conference footage (5.50) compile documents for
attorney review (.20); assist with supporting
documents to Preliminary Injunction motion(.60)
update protective order chart (.30)
1136 11/10/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.20 2,982.00 Analyze authority from video review in support

of preliminary injunction motion (3.6); email
queries to review team regarding same (.4);
emails with N. Napolitan regarding same (.2).
1137 11/10/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.10 506.00 Assist with identifying cites for preliminary

injunction motion and assist with sealing.
1138 11/10/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 2.30 1,207.50 Read case news alerts (0.50); read A. Ferrari's

email regarding
(0.10); review video logs
and videos for potential entrapment examples
(1.0); compose and send
to A. Ferrari (0.70)
1139 11/11/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.30 598.00 Assist in identifying citations for preliminary

injunction motion and assist in preparing
sealing motions.
1140 11/11/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.60 4,446.00 Collect evidence for use in motion for

1141 11/11/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.20 2,916.00 work on declaration in support of motion for

preliminary injunction (6.5); work on factual
support for motion for preliminary injunction
1142 11/11/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.60 2,546.00 Cite and fact check contempt motion (2.50)
164 of 610
organize and update exhibits to contempt motion
(1.30); edit video clips (3.80);
1143 11/11/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.00 7,920.00 Revise motion for contempt (2.1 hours); revise

motion for preliminary injunction and
supporting documents (8.9 hours).
1144 11/11/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.70 782.00 Telephone conference with N. Napolitan

regarding
(.20); analyze
video and audio files to find representative
conversations for preliminary injunction motion
(1.50).
1145 11/11/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.80 3,915.00 Work on and prepare for filing contempt motion,

supporting declaration, and sealing materials
(5.2); work on Section 1983 complaint to
challenge scope of Arizona Attorney General
subpoena (0.6).
1147 11/11/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Confer with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, and J.

Serrano regarding
1148 11/11/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Legal research in connection with NAF's

contempt motion.
1149 11/11/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.30 2,343.00 Review and provide comments on NAF's

preliminary injunction motion and Defendants'
likely arguments in opposition.
165 of 610
1150 11/11/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 4.60 2,415.00 Research Ninth Circuit case law for authority

related to a deposing party's right to
terminate a deposition and move to compel
responses when a deponent obstructs a
deposition; draft for D.
Foran; draft motion to seal certain portions of
NAF's contempt motion and declaration of D.
Foran in support thereof and accompanying
declaration and proposed order; confer with N.
Napolitan, J. Serrano, and A. Laks regarding
same.
1151 11/11/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.50 1,775.00 Emails with T. Beyer and R. Zack regarding

(.4);
analyze examples of "entrapment" from audio and
video file review (1.8); emails with N.
Napolitan regarding same (.3).
1152 11/11/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 2,925.00 Work on preliminary injunction motion (1.5);

work on contempt motion (1.5).
1153 11/11/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.10 6,885.00 Phone conference with counsel for Nucatola

regarding (0.3); phone
conference with counsel for Stem Express
regarding same (0.3); revise and edit draft
motion for preliminary injunction (5.9); review
and revise draft contempt motion regarding
overbroad disclosure to Congress (1.0);
preparations for Charles Johnson deposition
(0.6).
1154 11/11/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 10.30 2,678.00 Prepare exhibits in support of motion for
166 of 610
1155 11/11/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 5.30 2,782.50 Meet with N. Napolitan to discuss
(0.10); research N.D.
California rules and procedure for claiming
attorney fees in motions for contempt (2.10);
compose and send email to N. Napolitan
regarding (0.20); phone call
with D. Foran regarding
(0.10); research Ninth
Circuit panel assignment rules for "comeback"
cases (2.60); compose and send email to D.
Foran regarding (0.20).
1156 11/12/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 2.00 1,950.00 Work on preliminary injunction motion.
1157 11/12/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 13.80 3,588.00 Assist with preparation of motion for

preliminary injunction (10.5); Prepare
redactions for supplemental production (3.25)
1158 11/12/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 11.40 4,617.00 work on declaration in support of motion for

preliminary injunction (8.2); work on appendix
for motion for preliminary injunction (2); find
factual support for motion for preliminary
injunction (1.2).
1159 11/12/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 3.40 2,295.00 Review and finalize contempt motion and

supporting materials for filing (1.8); work on
sealing materials for preliminary injunction
motion (1.6).
1160 11/12/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.70 322.00 Additional review and analysis of files for
167 of 610
purpose of finding relevant quotations for
preliminary injunction motion (.70).
1161 11/12/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 13.10 9,432.00 Revise the motion for preliminary injunction

and supporting documents (13.1 hours).
1162 11/12/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.70 5,695.00 Legal research regarding standards for

directing second writ in Ninth Circuit to prior
panel as a "comeback case" under Ninth Circuit
rules (0.3); preparations for Charles Johnson
deposition (1.6); revise preliminary injunction
motion and supporting papers (4.2); review
initial draft of Foran Declaration in support
(0.5); correspondence with opposing counsel
regarding Arizona and Louisiana subpoenas
(0.1).
1163 11/12/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.40 3,744.00 Gather evidence for motion for preliminary

injunction.
1164 11/12/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 0.90 720.00 Look into whether subsequent mandamus petition

would return to the same panel and confer with
D. Foran regarding same.
1165 11/12/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 7.90 4,147.50 Research federal law related to the

journalist's privilege, it's scope, whether it
can be waived, and to whom it applies; draft
and revise NAF's administrative motion to seal
certain documents related to NAF's order to
show cause; declaration of D. Foran in support
thereof, and proposed order.
1166 11/12/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 10.10 3,383.50 Cite check contempt motion (2.10); compile
168 of 610
exhibits to contempt motion(2.80); compile and
revise exhibits to preliminary injunction
motion (4.20); team meeting (.50); compile
documents for attorney review (.50)
1167 11/12/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.30 1,633.00 Analyze content from video review in regard to

contempt motion (1.5); emails with N. Napolitan
regarding same (.3); prepare statistics
regarding video files responsive to Louisiana
and Arizona subpoenas (.3); conference with J.
Serrano regarding same (.2).
1168 11/12/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Assist in preparation of sealing motions.
1169 11/13/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.70 322.00 Assist in by

discussing with A. Nakamura and review items to
seal in papers to be filed.
1170 11/13/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.40 3,402.00 Review and revise Motion for Preliminary

Injunction (4.3); review and revise motion to
file under seal (.6); review and revise D.
Foran Declaration and Appendix in support of
Motion for Preliminary Injunction (3.4).
1171 11/13/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 10.20 5,355.00 Draft and revise NAF's administrative motion to

seal, declaration of D. Foran in support
thereof, and proposed order related to NAF's
preliminary injunction motion, and prepare for
filing; confer with N. Napolitan, J. Serrano,
N. Roethlisberger, R. Zack. P. Oropeza, and T.
Beyer regarding same;
with N.
Napolitan; review state and federal law related
169 of 610
to the journalist's privilege, the privilege's
scope, and any potential waivers.
1172 11/13/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.40 4,329.00 Revise motion for preliminary injunction and

accompanying documents.
1173 11/13/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 8.60 5,805.00 Review and finalize contempt motion and

supporting materials for filing (3.7); review
and finalize motions to seal contempt motion
and preliminary injunction motion for filing
(1.7); review and finalize motion for
preliminary injunction and supporting materials
for filing (3.2).
1174 11/13/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 11.10 3,718.50 Fact check preliminary injunction motion;

(2.30); assist with finalization of
exhibits(3.50); check legal cites in brief
(2.20) assist with finalization and filing of
brief (3.10)
1175 11/13/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.30 6,205.00 Final edits and review of preliminary

injunction and contempt motions (6.5);
conferences with Nicholas Napolitan regarding
(0.8).
1176 11/13/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 14.40 10,368.00 Revise the motion for preliminary injunction

and supporting documents (10.2 hours); oversee
filing of the motion for preliminary injunction
(4.2 hours).
1177 11/13/2015 ANNA FERRARI 0.20 142.00 Emails with R. Zack regarding
170 of 610
1178 11/13/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 12.80 3,328.00 Assist with preparation of filing of motion for
preliminary injunction (5); gather and prepare
exhibits in support of motion for preliminary
injunction(4.5); revise redactions for
supplemental production (3.25).
1179 11/13/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 3.20 1,680.00 Research Ninth Circuit rules and procedures

whether a formal motion or letter is sufficient
to request reconstituting an original panel in
a comeback case (1.0); review internal document
database and external sources for exemplars of
requests for original panels (1.2); Draft
letter to Ninth Circuit Clerk of the Court
requesting original panel (1.0).
1180 11/16/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.60 315.00 Finalize draft letter to Ninth Circuit

requesting original panel (0.5); compose and
send email to D. Foran
(0.1)
1181 11/16/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 117.00 Strategize about potential response to Arizona

subpoena.
1182 11/16/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.60 736.00 Update calendar based on last weeks filings

(1); research witness fees and coordinate
with T. Beyer (.6).
1183 11/16/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.60 2,268.00 Research issues related to California Penal

Code Section 632 (4.1); discuss with A.
Nakamura
(1.5).
1184 11/16/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 6.30 3,307.50 Research state and federal law related to a
171 of 610
journalist's privilege to withhold confidential
information, it's scope, whether it may be
waived, and when the federal law preempts the
state law; confer with D. Foran regarding same;
attend telephonic meet and confer with C.
Johnson's counsel regarding his deposition.
1185 11/16/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 0.30 240.00 Review letter regarding returning case to same

appeal panel.
1186 11/16/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.30 1,775.50 Prepare index and compile exhibits for Johnson

deposition (2.20); draft letter to accompany
service of documents (.60); create video clips
(2.0) distribute documents to client (.50)
1187 11/16/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.30 1,898.00 Prepare Charles C. Johnson Facebook posts for

Johnson deposition preparation (2.5); prepare
recent court filing materials for subsequent
attorney review (1.5); prepare StemExpress case
filings for subsequent attorney review (3.25).
1188 11/16/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 0.60 585.00 Consider Johnson claims regarding shield law.
1189 11/16/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.80 5,780.00 Preparations for deposition of Charles Johnson

(5.5); review motion to quash filed by Charles
Johnson (0.2); review legal research notes
regarding applicability of California Shield
Law to Charles Johnson's disclosure of TRO
materials (0.4); conference with Ashley
Nakamura regarding
(0.4); meet and
confer with counsel for Charles Johnson
regarding motion to quash (0.3).
172 of 610
1191 11/16/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 162.00 Review court filings regarding motion to quash

subpoena for Charles Johnson.
1192 11/17/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 2.40 2,340.00 Review Johnson transcript (1.5); consider

exhibits produced by Johnson (0.25); consider
Berkeley project (0.6).
1193 11/17/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.00 1,675.00 Prepare documents and assist with deposition of

C. Johnson(.80); Attend C. Johnson
deposition(4.20)
1194 11/17/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.20 7,820.00 Prepare for and attend deposition of Charles

Johnson (7.2); prepare for and attend team
meeting regarding
(1.1); review
legal research notes prepared by Randall Zack
regarding California Penal Code 632 and
exceptions thereto (0.7).
1195 11/17/2015 ANNA FERRARI 1.40 994.00 Review research memorandum regarding potential

claims against states attorneys and inspectors
general (.5); attend team meeting regarding
(.9).
1196 11/17/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.50 3,240.00 Participate in team meeting regarding

(1 hour); research case law on motions
to quash (1.3 hours); review documents produced
by C. Johnson (.7 hours); review deposition
173 of 610
transcript (.9 hours); review material related
to state attorneys general investigation for
reply brief in support of preliminary
injunction (.6 hours).
1197 11/17/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.30 2,551.50 Research legal issues related to 632 (3.7);

discuss strategy and review next steps (1.6);
work on issues related to motion to quash (1).
1198 11/17/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.70 892.50 Confer with NAF team regarding
; confer
with R. Zack regardin
1199 11/17/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.50 1,610.00 Coordinate creation of tracking chart regarding

status of planned parenthood investigations
(1.2); review preliminary injunction filings
(.5); draft stipulation to extend time to
challenge state subpoenas (.7); attend meeting
to
(1.1).
1200 11/17/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.80 1,134.00 Confer with A. Laks about

(.4); research status of state investigations
of fetal tissue research (1.4)
1201 11/17/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Review and analyze C. Johnson deposition.
1202 11/17/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Prepare for and meet with trial team regarding
174 of 610
1203 11/17/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Revise redactions for production.
1204 11/17/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.10 1,228.50 Gather evidence on state attorney general

investigations.
1205 11/18/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.40 210.00 Discuss

with A. Nakamura (0.10); research and
send to A. Nakamura
(0.3).
1206 11/18/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.80 1,248.00 Review and download StemExpress court filings

for subsequent attorney review (1.5); Prepare
caselaw regarding admissibility of evidence
(1.5); Prepare Johnson deposition transcript
with exhibits for subsequent attorney review
(.5); prepare deposition transcript materials
for subsequent attorney review (1.25).
1207 11/18/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 40.50 Review preliminary injunction exhibits related

to state investigations.
1208 11/18/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.10 506.00 Finalize stipulation to extend deadlines to

respond to state subpoenas (.4); draft motion
to remove (.7).
1209 11/18/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.10 2,470.50 Work on fact issues related to Defendants 632

argument (5.8); work on supplemental motion to
file under seal (.3);
175 of 610
regarding
1211 11/18/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Telephone call with A. Laks regarding
1212 11/18/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Review email correspondence regarding
1213 11/18/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 162.00 Review deposition transcript of C. Johnson (.4)
1214 11/18/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 5.10 2,677.50 Research state and federal law related to

applying federal privileges law and
journalists' privilege or shield laws, their
scope, and whether they can be waived; draft
and revise NAF's opposition to C. Johnson's
motion to quash; confer with J. Serrano and A.
Ferrari regarding
1215 11/18/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.30 4,536.00 Lock down documents on ECF, draft and file

motion to remove, draft and file supplemental
motion to seal (5.7 hours); research and review
first amendment case law (.6 hours).
1216 11/18/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.10 5,185.00 Email correspondence with Nicholas Napolitan

regarding
(0.3); prepare stipulation
regarding deadline for completing negotiations
with Arizona and Louisiana (0.2); phone
conference with CMP counsel regarding same
(0.4); correspondence with opposing counsel
regarding inadvertent filing of preliminary
176 of 610
injunction motion in public record (0.5);
same (1.5); review and revise motion to remove
incorrectly filed brief and related papers
(0.8); phone conference with client regarding
(0.3); further
legal research for reply on preliminary
injunction motion (regarding use of hearsay at
preliminary injunction phase of case) (2.1).
1217 11/18/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.10 703.50 Distribute files to client (.30) edit video for

judge's copy(1.20); assist with refilling of
documents (.60); draft letter to co‐counsel
(.50) File motion to remove documents from ECF
(.50); teleconference with ECF help desk (.20)
1218 11/18/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.00 975.00 Review Stem Express filing.
1219 11/19/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 2,925.00 Review Stem Express filings in anticipation of

opposition.
1220 11/19/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.00 1,560.00 Prepare StemExpress court documents for

subsequent attorney review (2); Revise
redactions for supplemental production (3.5);
download and store Johnson deposition
transcript and exhibits to online database (.5)
1221 11/19/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 5.10 4,335.00 Phone conferences and fact research regarding

(1.9); further fact
and legal research for replies on preliminary
injunction and contempt motions (3.2).
177 of 610
1222 11/19/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.40 2,187.00 Work on issues related to defendants'
California Penal Code 633.5 defense (4.7);
prepare excerpts of audio and video recordings
to submit to the Court (.7).
1223 11/19/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.70 5,544.00 Review opposition to motion to seal (.5 hours);

draft reply regarding motion to seal (2.6
hours); review material regarding attorney
general investigations (.6 hours); review
videos produced by defendants (1.8 hours);
prepare sealing papers for videos to be lodged
with the court (1.1 hours); review redacted
materials to be produced to defendants (1.1
hour)
1224 11/19/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.30 138.00 Coordinate
1225 11/19/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 5.00 2,625.00 Research state and federal law related to

applying federal privileges law and
journalists' privilege or shield laws, their
scope, and whether they can be waived; draft
and revise NAF's opposition to C. Johnson's
motion to quash; confer with D. Foran regarding
same.
1226 11/19/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.10 445.50 Confer with D. Foran regarding
(.1); confer with R. Zak on same (1.0).
1227 11/19/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Review email correspondence and recent news

articles regarding
178 of 610
1229 11/19/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Confer with D. Foran and N. Napolitan
1230 11/19/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 58.50 Review documents filed with the court.
1231 11/19/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.50 837.50 Edit video clips (1.20); draft manual filing

notice (.30); send documents to client (.50);
create CDs for lodging with the court (.50)
1232 11/20/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.40 469.00 Teleconference with Clovis Police Department

regarding (.50) draft
e‐mail to Quest Legal Services (.20) re‐label
CDs and prepare documents for service (.70);
1233 11/20/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 702.00 Review and analyze order from court regarding

discovery.
1234 11/20/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.40 1,022.00 Review order on stipulation on briefing

schedule of related motions (0.1); review order
regarding motion to stay Defendants' invocation
of 5th Amendment (0.1); review briefing on
motion to file under seal preliminary
injunction motion (0.2); review preliminary
injunction motion (0.4); review news articles
regarding case (0.2); review AG Ferguson memo
regarding Planned Parenthood and email
correspondence regarding same (0.3); review
179 of 610
correspondence regarding
(0.1).
1235 11/20/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.60 1,196.00 Confirm scheduling issues (1); draft

stipulation to move hearing (1); review order
and update calendaring (.6).
1236 11/20/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.00 2,430.00 Work on lodging excerpts of videos with Court

(2.5); draft motion to file under seal cd
lodged with court (2.5); work on fact research
related to defendants 633.5 claim (1).
1237 11/20/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.50 6,120.00 Revise reply regarding motion to seal (2.9

hours); draft sealing papers for videos to be
lodged with the court (2.5); oversee filing of
documents (1 hour); review order by the court
regarding first and fifth amendment privileges
(1.1 hours); review time note entries and
confer with team regarding same (1 hour).
1238 11/20/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.20 1,155.00 Draft and revise

(1.1); confer with D.
Foran regarding same (.3); research federal law
regarding the First Amendment associational
privilege (.8).
1239 11/20/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Review and comment on NAF's reply to CMP's

opposition to sealing motion.
180 of 610
1241 11/20/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.50 262.50 Read Judge Orrick's order regarding plaintiff's
motion to stay , certify or reconsider and
defendant's invocation of the Fifth Amendment.
1242 11/20/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.60 5,610.00 Phone conference with Arizona AG's office

regarding subpoena served on CMP (0.3); revise
and edit reply in support of supplemental
motion to file PI motion under seal and
same (1.2); review deposition of Charles
Johnson (1.7); revisions to opposition to
second motion to quash filed by Charles Johnson
(0.9); revise stipulations regarding briefing
schedules on motion to stay discovery and
meet‐and‐confer deadline regarding Arizona and
Louisiana subpoenas (0.2); fact and legal
research for reply on preliminary injunction
motion (2.3).
1243 11/20/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.20 81.00 Correspond with R. Zack regarding

; review preliminary
injunction.
1244 11/20/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 0.30 240.00 Review district court's order.
1245 11/20/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,300.00 Assist with preparation of filing of reply

motion regarding supplemental administrative
motion to file under seal NAF preliminary
injunction motion (4.5); Download StemExpress
court filings docket (.5).
1246 11/20/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.00 975.00 Review and discuss order from Judge Orrick.
181 of 610
1247 11/21/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Review and analyze the Court's order regarding
CMP's assertion of First Amendment and Fifth
Amendment privileges.
1248 11/21/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.10 2,065.50 Review NAF motion for preliminary injunction

(1.7); review deposition transcript for D.
Daleiden (3.3); correspond with D. Foran, C.
Robinson and N. Napolitan
(.1).
1249 11/21/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.90 472.50 Draft and revise NAF's opposition to C. Johnson

motion to quash subpoena
1250 11/22/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 2.70 2,295.00 Revise opposition to motion to quash Johnson

subpoena.
1251 11/22/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.60 243.00 Correspond with D. Foran, L. Shostak, and R.

Zack regarding
(.1); review
deposition transcript of C. Johnson (.5).
1252 11/22/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.50 1,837.50 Research federal law regarding the First

Amendment associational privilege (1); draft
and revise arguments regarding same for NAF's
preliminary injunction motion against the
Arizona attorney general (2.5).
1253 11/23/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.80 945.00 Draft and revise NAF's opposition to C. Johnson

motion to quash subpoena.
1254 11/23/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.80 1,944.00 First amendment research in anticipation of

Defendants writ (2.3); review depositions for
182 of 610
confidentiality and fact research (2.5)
1255 11/23/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.30 1,440.50 Compile 1st amendment case law (2.50); serve

documents to opposing counsel (.70); assist
with production of documents (.60); update
defendant counsel contact list (.50);
1256 11/23/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.70 994.50 Review CMP documents for potential

confidentiality designations.
1257 11/23/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.70 472.50 Draft edits to stipulation regarding extending

time to respond to Arizona AG and Louisiana IG
subpoena (0.2); review and edit opposition to
C. Johnson motion to quash (0.5).
1258 11/23/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.00 405.00 Review filings from StemExpress case (1.0).
1259 11/23/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.50 3,960.00 Review material to be produced to defendants

(.4 hours); confer with attorneys regarding
(.4 hours); plan for petition
for writ (1.2 hours); review and revise
opposition to motion to quash (1.7 hours);
confer with team regarding (.8
hours); review materials produced by defendants
for confidentiality and draft letter regarding
the same (1 hour).
1260 11/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Confer with Mofo litigation team regarding
1261 11/23/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.30 6,205.00 Revise opposition to motion to quash Charles

Johnson subpoena (6.6); email correspondence
with Arizona AG's office regarding
183 of 610
(0.2); conferences with
Nicholas Napolitan regarding
(0.3); revise stipulation extending
time to respond to Arizona AG subpoena (0.1).
1262 11/23/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.80 1,768.00 Prepare and transmit supplemental production to

opposing counsel (3.3); Review and prepare
StemExpress court documents for subsequent
attorney review (2); Prepare court orders for
subsequent attorney review (1.5).
1263 11/24/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 0.60 480.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding
1264 11/24/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 0.90 877.50 Consult with D. Foran regarding

(0.2); review opposition to motion and
comment on same (0.7).
1265 11/24/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 7.20 2,916.00 Review StemExpress court filings (3.8); review

statutes and case law related to partial birth
abortion bans (2.7); draft notes on arguments
to respond to defendants' claims regarding
belief that recordings would uncover proof of
violations of partial birth abortion bans (.5);
correspond with R. Zack on same (.1); review
new documents provided by counsel for C.
Johnson (.1).
1266 11/24/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 5,525.00 Revise and edit opposition to second motion to

quash Johnson subpoena (1.8); confer with Linda
Shostak regarding
(0.2); confer with Marc
184 of 610
Hearron regarding same (0.2); prepare draft
opposition to emergency motion to stay in Ninth
Circuit (4.3).
1267 11/24/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.30 1,552.50 Review and edit opposition to C. Johnson motion

to quash and supporting declaration (1.8);
prepare sealing materials for opposition to C.
Johnson motion to quash (0.5).
1268 11/24/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.80 1,638.00 Research regarding potential Ninth Circuit writ

petition by Defendants.
1269 11/24/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.80 1,768.00 Cite‐check opposition to Johnson motion to

quash subpoena (3.5); prepare exhibits in
support of opposition to Johnson to quash
subpoena(2); update threat tracking chart and
case folder (1.25).
1270 11/24/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.20 1,072.00 Draft two letters to opposing counsel (.70);

send documents to client(.30); compile
documents for attorney review (.50); cite and
fact check motion (2.30)
1271 11/24/2015 ANNA FERRARI 4.30 3,053.00 Analyze content from audio and video file

review for relevance to Arizona providers.
1272 11/24/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.40 1,782.00 Review deposition transcripts for

confidentiality and factual support.
1273 11/24/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.50 3,240.00 Confer with A. Nakamura regarding

(.6 hours); revise opposition
to motion to quash and supporting documents (2
hours); review material produced by C. Johnson
185 of 610
(.6 hours); oversee filing of stipulation (.3
hours); confer with D. Foran regarding
(.5 hours); research writ
issues (.5 hours).
1274 11/24/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 9.50 4,987.50 Draft and revise NAF's opposition to Johnson's

second motion to quash subpoena (1.8); draft
and revise Foran declaration in support thereof
(1.5); draft and revise NAF's administrative
motion to seal NAF's opposition (2.1); draft
and revise Foran declaration in support thereof
(1.5); draft and revise proposed order in
support thereof (.5); confer with paralegals
regarding
Napolitan regarding same (.5); prepare
documents for filing (1).
1275 11/25/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.70 3,995.00 Review emergency motion to stay and writ of

mandamus filed in Ninth Circuit (1.8); revise
letter to Ninth Circuit regarding comeback case
(0.3); confer with Marc Hearron regarding
(0.3); revise opposition to
emergency motion to stay (2.3).
1276 11/25/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.50 262.50 Draft and revise Foran declaration in support

of NAF's opposition to second motion to quash
Johnson subpoena.
1277 11/25/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.50 2,520.00 Review and revise opposition to motion to quash

(.7 hours); review appellate filings (1.8
hours); research appellate procedure (1 hour).
186 of 610
1278 11/25/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 4.30 1,741.50 First amendment research in preparation for

Defendants writ.
1279 11/25/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.30 1,775.50 Assist with filing in 9th circuit (5.25)
1280 11/25/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.60 2,673.00 Review (5.6);

correspond with R. Zack on same (.1); draft
notes on
(.3); research fetal tissue
collection procedures in scientific and medical
journals (.5); correspond with R. Zack and N.
Napolitan on
(.1).
1281 11/25/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 58.50 Review documents filed with the court.
1282 11/25/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.60 1,196.00 Calendaring and research regarding appellate

rules.
1283 11/25/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.20 1,170.00 Review Ninth Circuit filings by opposition.
1285 11/27/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 3.80 1,995.00 Review Ninth Circuit rules and practice guides

regarding how to submit evidence to an
opposition brief, grounds for filing under
seal, and logistics of filing under seal (3.6);
compose and send email to D. Foran, N.
Napolitan (0.2).
187 of 610
1286 11/27/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.50 1,417.50 Research on the "in concert" requirement for

preliminary injunctions and temporary
restraining orders.
1287 11/27/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.20 6,970.00 Phone conference with staff attorney for Ninth

Circuit regarding
(0.2); draft emergency
motion to stay (8.0).
1288 11/28/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.80 6,630.00 Draft emergency motion to stay district court's

discovery orders in Ninth Circuit.
1289 11/28/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.80 2,754.00 Review StemExpress court filings (5.4);

research case law on partial birth abortion
(1.4).
1290 11/28/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.50 2,520.00 Draft opposition to emergency motion to stay.
1291 11/29/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.90 8,568.00 Revise opposition to emergency motion to stay

(10.6 hours); research case law regarding First
Amendment privilege (1.3 hours).
1292 11/29/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 2.00 1,050.00 Research process Ninth Circuit requirements for

statement of related cases (1.0); draft
statement of related cases (0.10); draft
notification of sealing (0.8); send
N. Napolitan (0.10).
1293 11/29/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 4.00 2,100.00 Revise NAF's opposition to Johnson's second

motion to quash subpoena (1.8) and the Foran
declaration in support thereof (.4); draft and
188 of 610
revise NAF's administrative motion to seal
NAF's opposition (.9); review NAF's Ninth
Circuit opposition to stay motion (.9).
1294 11/29/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 765.00 Phone conferences and emails with N. Napolitan

regarding
1295 11/29/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.80 1,890.00 Revise and prepare for filing opposition to C.

Johnson motion to quash and supporting papers
(2.8).
1296 11/29/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.30 1,775.50 Compile exhibits to be filed with opposition to

emergency stay filed in 9th Cir. (1.0); draft
list of exhibits (.30) edit video clips for
Arizona subpoena (1.30); Fact and cite check
opposition to emergency stay (2.70)
1297 11/29/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 810.00 Research case law related to Partial Birth

Abortion Act (1.0); research scientific journal
articles on fetal tissue donation.
1298 11/29/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 3.50 2,800.00 Review and comment on draft of opposition to

stay motion.
1299 11/30/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 1.30 1,040.00 Review and comment on draft of opposition to

stay motion.
1300 11/30/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.20 1,170.00 Review appellate filing (1.0); consult with D.

Foran (0.2).
1301 11/30/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.70 5,695.00 Final revisions and edits to opposition to

emergency motion to stay filed in Ninth Circuit
189 of 610
(3.8); final revisions and edits to opposition
to Johnson's second motion to quash (2.4);
email correspondence regarding
(0.2); confer
with A. Laks et al regarding
(0.3).
1302 11/30/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.50 1,012.50 Research case law on partial birth abortion ban

(1.5); research secondary sources on same (.5);
draft notes on findings (.5).
1303 11/30/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.00 5,040.00 Revise opposition to emergency motion to stay

(4.8 hours); revise notice of filing under seal
(.5 hours); research sealing procedures (.8
hours); review and revise sealing papers for
opposition to motion to quash (.5 hours);
supervise filing of opposition to motion to
quash (.4 hours).

to motion to quash (2.5); prepare state
investigations of planned parenthood tracking
chart and case files (3.25); Assist with
preparation of filing of 9th circuit opposition
motion (1.5)
1305 11/30/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 8.80 4,620.00 Draft and revise NAF's opposition to Johnson's

second motion to quash subpoena (2); draft and
revise Foran declaration in support thereof
(1.5); draft and revise NAF's administrative
motion to seal NAF's opposition (2); draft and
revise Foran declaration in support thereof
190 of 610
(.5); draft and revise proposed order in
support thereof (.5); confer with paralegals
regarding
(.6); oversee filing
(1.7).
1306 11/30/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.20 1,287.00 Review documents for anticipated reply in

support of preliminary injunction.
1307 11/30/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 6.80 4,590.00 Revise, prepare for filing, and oversee filing

of opposition brief and supporting materials to
C. Johnson motion to quash (6.8).
1308 11/30/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.20 2,336.00 Review recent Ninth Circuit filings (0.1);

review Defendants' Ninth Circuit emergency
motion and mandamus petition to stay (0.4);
review D. Foran letter to Ninth Circuit
regarding case assignment (0.1); review news
articles regarding Planned Parenthood shooting
(0.2); review order granting stipulation
regarding deadline to negotiate subpoena (0.1);
review order on motion to file under seal
(0.1); review deposition transcript of D.
Daleiden (2.2).
1309 11/30/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.80 3,159.00 Review deposition of Charles C. Johnson (2.4);

research issues related to the causation
requirement for irreparable harm for
preliminary injunctions (5.4).
1310 11/30/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.70 2,244.50 Draft letter to Arizona AG (.30); assist with

filing of 9th Cir brief (4.80); assist with
filing of opposition to motion to quash (1.60);
191 of 610
1311 11/30/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.10 1,886.00 Calendar Ninth Circuit deadlines; review

documents for reply in support of preliminary
injunction motion; update tracking document for
planned parenthood investigations.
1312 11/30/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.80 420.00 Assist N. Napolitan in preparing for filing of

Ninth Circuit brief in opposition to
petitioner's emergency motion to stay by
proofreading brief and reviewing filing
procedures.
1313 12/1/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.50 1,462.50 Prepare for filing of answer to Defendants'

writ petition.
1314 12/1/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.20 1,701.00 Confer with R. Zack regarding
(.4); draft memorandum on
findings on same (3.8).
1315 12/1/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.10 2,043.50 Draft e‐mail to Arizona attorney (.10); refile

corrected exhibit 9 (.50) draft index for
appendix of record (.90); compile documents
cited in appendix of record (1.10) assist with
filing of motion in writ proceeding (3.50)
1316 12/1/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.40 5,440.00 Prepare answer to extraordinary writ petition

regarding district court's discovery orders
(5.5); revise and edit second opposition to
emergency stay motion in Ninth Circuit filed in
writ proceeding (0.8); correspondence with
opposing counsel regarding briefing on
192 of 610
1317 12/1/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 337.50 Oversee see filing of corrected exhibit to

Opposition to C. Johnson motion to quash and
draft email to chambers for correction of
docket (0.5).
1318 12/1/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.60 2,673.00 Research issues related to excess pages (.75);

review deposition of Charles C. Johnson (1.4);
research issues related to irreparable harm
under FRCP 65 (4.25).
1319 12/1/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.50 1,610.00 Research and revise tracking chart on planned

parenthood investigations as well as insert
describing the same, and include quotations
from key statements made by defendants that
would incite violence and send to D. Foran with
1320 12/1/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.00 3,600.00 Confer with team regarding

(1.5 hours); draft
correspondence to opposing counsel regarding
confidentiality (.5 hours); research Ninth
Circuit procedure (.8 hours); draft Ninth
Circuit filing (1.4 hours); research material
regarding defendants's public statements (.8
hours).
1321 12/1/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.90 657.00 Review recent case filings (0.7); review email

correspondence regarding
(0.2).

to Johnson motion to quash (3); update tracking
193 of 610
state investigations of Planned Parenthood (1);
research recent news articles regarding Planned
Parenthood investigations (1.5); Collect and
prepare news articles and blog posts regarding
attacks on Planned Parenthood (.5).
1323 12/1/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 8.00 7,800.00 Anticipate and prepare for opposition arguments

regarding so‐called "scientific proof."
1324 12/2/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 650.00 Research Planned Parenthood investigation

developments(1); Update tracking chart
regarding Planned Parenthood state
investigations (1.5).
1325 12/2/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 8.00 7,800.00 Anticipate and prepare for opposition arguments

regarding so‐called "scientific proof."
1327 12/2/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.20 92.00 Ensure all news articles are appropriately

saved in production folder.
1328 12/2/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.20 552.00 Discuss documents that need to produced and

included in the reply to preliminary
injunction.
1329 12/2/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.40 3,744.00 Research in anticipation drafting reply in

1331 12/2/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.90 3,199.50 Research California statutes using "reasonable
194 of 610
belief" language (1.8); Research Maryland
statute excluding surreptitiously recorded
videos from evidence (4); research issues
related to "irreparable harm" clauses in
contracts (.8); discuss and research factual
issues related to "intact cases." (1.2)
1332 12/2/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.50 1,507.50 File and serve document in the 9th circuit

(1.50) meet with team (.50); fill in cites for
opposition to petition to writ (2.50).
1333 12/2/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.20 1,296.00 Research Theresa Deisher and her qualifications

as an expert in fetal tissue procurement and
donation.
1334 12/2/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.70 6,545.00 Fact and legal research for reply on

preliminary injunction (5.6); prepare for and
;
draft outline for reply on preliminary
injunction (1.7); review reply in support of
emergency stay motion filed in Ninth Circuit
(0.4).
1335 12/2/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.20 1,296.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding

(.2); research enforcement of same
and of federal and state statutory distinctions
for when a fetus becomes a person (3.0).
1336 12/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.40 994.00 Prepare detailed task list and case planning

report in connection with multiple upcoming
filings.
195 of 610
1337 12/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 426.00 Meeting with Mofo associates regarding
1338 12/2/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.20 852.00 Meetings with Mofo team regarding
1339 12/2/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.10 1,417.50 Attend team phone call regarding
(1.0); review prior contempt motion
briefing and work on reply brief for motion for
contempt (0.7); review defendants' reply brief
in support of emergency stay in 9th Circuit
(0.2); provide
to D. Foran (0.2).
1340 12/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 426.00 Review Defendants' opposition papers to NAF's

PI motion for sealing issues.

regarding improper redactions and public
disclosure of sealed information.
1342 12/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Email correspondence with Mofo team regarding
1343 12/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Email correspondence with Mofo team regarding
1344 12/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.80 1,278.00 Review and analyze Defendants' opposition to

NAF's contempt motion and supporting papers,
including a review for proper redaction and
196 of 610
sealing of confidential information.
1345 12/3/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Review Ninth Circuit orders denying mandamus

petition and motion for emergency stay.
1346 12/3/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.40 644.00 Review and analyze briefing on emergency motion

for stay and review 9th Circuit ruling (1.25).
1347 12/3/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 6.70 2,713.50 Research issues related to "reasonable belief"

(3); research evidentiary issues at the PI
stage (2.3); research Maryland exclusionary
rule (1.5).
1348 12/3/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.90 971.50 Send documents to client (.20); compile

documents for attorney review(.30) Download
files from EEC and distribute (.50); compile
case law and organize into a binder (1.10)
organize preliminary injunction documents and
send to reprographics for printing (.80)
1349 12/3/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.20 6,970.00 Review Ninth Circuit order denying emergency

motion and writ petition (0.3); email
designations under protective order (0.2);
prepare opposition to application to Supreme
Court for emergency stay of discovery orders
(5.0); continue fact and legal research for
reply in support of preliminary injunction
(2.7).
1350 12/3/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.40 819.00 Research in anticipation drafting reply in

197 of 610
1351 12/3/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.50 1,150.00 Draft Foran declaration and revise draft by P.
Opreza and draft appendix for reply in support
of preliminary injunction motion.
1352 12/3/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.50 262.50 Read order from 9th Circuit denying

petitioner's motion for stay; read petitioner's
motion for temporary stay in order to seek writ
of mandamus from the Supreme Court
1353 12/3/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 360.00 Review appellate briefing and order.
1354 12/3/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.60 1,080.00 Review and draft outline of arguments

responding to defendants' opposition to motion
for order to show cause (1.6).
1355 12/3/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.70 511.00 Review orders denying motion for stay (0.1);

review reply in support of motion to stay
discovery (0.1); review Defendants' motion
requesting excess pages and order regarding
same (0.1); review case correspondence (0.4).
1356 12/3/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 160.00 Review Ninth Circuit's decision.
1358 12/3/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 2.00 1,950.00 Initial review of oppositions.
1359 12/3/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 11.50 2,990.00 Prepare materials regarding CMP opposition to

motion for preliminary injunction (5); prepare
caselaw cited in CMP opposition to motion for
preliminary injunction (3.5); prepare Foran
198 of 610
declaration in support of reply in support of
motion for preliminary injunction (1) ; assist
with preparation of reply in support of motion
for preliminary injunction (2).
1360 12/4/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Prepare materials regarding CMP opposition to

motion for preliminary injunction (4); prepare
motion for preliminary injunction briefing for
subsequent attorney review (1.5); prepare
caselaw cited in preliminary injunction
briefing (1.5)
1361 12/4/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 2.80 2,730.00 Review of opposition to Preliminary Injunction

(2.0); team meeting regarding
(0.8).
1362 12/4/2015 MARC A. HEARRON 1.50 1,200.00 Review emergency stay motion and sketch out

possible response.
1363 12/4/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.70 2,701.00 Review correspondence regarding

(0.3); review supplemental
discovery (0.2); review recent case filings
(2.2); review T. Newman video regarding
investigation and motivations (1.0).
1364 12/4/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 3.60 2,430.00 Work on reply brief in support of motion for

order to show cause (3.6).
1365 12/4/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 144.00 Review material produced by defendants.
1366 12/4/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.40 210.00 Review unredacted materials produced by

defendants pursuant to court order.
199 of 610
1367 12/4/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 6.60 3,465.00 Research California case law related to
California contract interpretation and the
enforceability of confidentiality provisions
(3.6); research Ninth Circuit law regarding the
civil contempt standard (3).
1368 12/4/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.80 1,748.00 Review Defendants' filings and begin drafting

declaration in support of sealing motion.
1369 12/4/2015 ANNA FERRARI 0.40 284.00 Conference with A. Nakamura regarding
1370 12/4/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 10.20 5,967.00 Drafting reply in support of motion for

preliminary injunction (8 hr); analyzing
discovery produced by defendants (2.2 hr).
1371 12/4/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 8.90 3,604.50 Research issues related to California Penal

Code section 632 and 637 (6.2); review
Plaintiffs' oppositions (2.8).
1372 12/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 923.00 Review and analyze Defendants' opposition to

NAF's PI motion and supporting Daleiden
declaration.
1373 12/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.50 1,065.00 Meeting with Mofo team regarding
1374 12/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 568.00 Prepare outline of NAF's reply brief regarding

irreparable harm.
1375 12/4/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 11.10 9,435.00 Review emergency application to stay discovery

orders filed in U.S. Supreme Court (0.9); phone
call with U.S. Supreme Court clerk's office
200 of 610
regarding denial of stay (0.1); email
discovery ordered by district court (0.2);
prepare for and attend meeting regarding reply
on preliminary injunction (2.3); draft outline
for reply on preliminary injunction (4.7);
review oppositions to preliminary injunction
and contempt motions (2.5); phone conference
with Javier Serrano regarding
(0.4).
1376 12/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Confer with A. Laks regarding
1377 12/4/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Prepare summary of analysis and Mofo team

comments regarding strategy on NAF's reply
brief.
1378 12/4/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.20 1,407.00 Distribute filings to client (.50) draft

indices of case law (1.0); compile binder sets
for attorneys (1.0) organize previous nights
filings by defendants (1.80)
1379 12/5/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.20 891.00 Research issues related to California Penal

Code 632 and 637.2 for reply in support of
1380 12/5/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.90 1,794.00 Draft declaration in support of sealing motion

and proposed order in support.
1381 12/5/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.00 2,925.00 Draft reply in support of motion for

201 of 610
1382 12/5/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.00 670.00 Research new potential defendants (1.50);

organize files (.50)



(.3 hours); confer with J.
Serrano regarding
(.5 hours); review and revise
reply in support of motion for order to show
cause (2.2 hours); research for and draft reply
in support of motion for preliminary injunction
(7.7 hours).

order to show cause and send draft to D. Foran
(6.8).
1387 12/7/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.40 1,474.00 Compile video times for addition to preliminary

injunction reply. (2.50); research and review
potential witness documents (1.90);
1388 12/7/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.70 4,504.50 Research in support of reply in support of

motion for preliminary injunction.
1389 12/7/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.00 1,380.00 Finalize filing of declaration and proposed

order.
202 of 610
1390 12/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Telephone call with J. Dunn regarding
1391 12/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.80 2,698.00 Review and revise declaration supporting

sealing of Defendants' PI opposition and
underlying materials.
1392 12/7/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.80 1,988.00 Draft portions of NAF's reply brief in support

of a preliminary injunction.
1393 12/7/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.60 2,268.00 Research legal issues related to reply in

1394 12/7/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 9.00 7,650.00 Draft reply in support of preliminary

injunction.
1395 12/7/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 6.00 5,850.00 Begin preparation for Preliminary Injunction

hearing.
1396 12/7/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.50 1,170.00 Download and prepare documents for supplemental

production (2); transmit NAF motion for
preliminary injunction briefing to client
(2.5).
1397 12/8/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,300.00 Transmit CMP opposition to motion for

preliminary injunction briefing to client
(0.5); prepare motion regarding contempt
briefing for subsequent attorney review (2.2);
download news articles and video transcripts
for supplemental production (2); organize
workroom (.2); Download and prepare CMP press
releases, videos and transcripts to database
(1).
203 of 610
1398 12/8/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.90 657.00 Review order on motion to stay (0.1); review

recent case filings (0.8).
1399 12/8/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.90 414.00 Prepare shells for sealing and discuss

with C. Robinson.
1400 12/8/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Continue drafting reply in support of

preliminary injunction (7.6); prepare for and
attend meeting with Christopher Robinson,
Nicholas Napolitan, and Javier Serrano
regarding
(0.9).
1401 12/8/2015 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.70 283.50 Research

and confer with D. Foran on same (.7).

1403 12/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.90 639.00 Legal research in connection with preliminary

injunction motion.
1404 12/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.70 1,207.00 Review, revised, and provide comments on NAF's

draft reply brief in support of its contempt
motion.
1405 12/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 426.00 Confer with D. Foran and J. Serrano regarding
1406 12/8/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.60 1,846.00 Draft portions of NAF's reply brief in support
204 of 610
of a preliminary injunction.
1407 12/8/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Compile case law for attorney review (.50);

meet with team regarding (.50)
1408 12/8/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 0.30 157.50 Read Johnson's reply in support of motion to

quash subpoena.
1409 12/8/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 14.50 10,440.00 Revise reply in support of motion for order to

show cause (2.1 hours); research for and draft
reply in support of motion for preliminary
injunction (12.4 hours).
1410 12/8/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.40 1,404.00 Revising reply in support of motion for


order to show cause (6.7); work on supporting
declarations and sealing materials (1.6).
1412 12/8/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.20 1,680.00 Draft and revise motion to seal NAF's reply

motion in support of motion for preliminary
injunction (.7); research federal case law
regarding admissibility of declarations
submitted by lay witnesses (1); research
California case law regarding whether the
defense of illegality is waived if it is not
brought as an affirmative defense (1.5)

injunction (2.5); draft Foran declaration in
support of same (2); draft proposed order of
205 of 610
same (.5).

order to show cause and supporting declarations
and sealing papers (4.6).
1415 12/9/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 14.10 10,152.00 Draft and revise reply in support of motion for

preliminary injunction and related papers.

support of order to show cause.
1417 12/9/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 11.50 3,852.50 Compile documents for attorney review (.90);

cite check preliminary injunction reply motion
(4.20); compile supplemental appendix exhibits
(1.90); assist with drafting of December 10
motions and accompanying documents (4.50)
1418 12/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Confer with D. Foran, A. Laks, and N. Napolitan

regarding
1419 12/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Email with J. Dunn regarding
1420 12/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 710.00 Review, revise, and comment on draft sealing

papers in connection with NAF's PI reply.
1421 12/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Confer with A. Nakamura and N. Roethlisberger

regarding
1422 12/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Confer with P. Oropeza and sealing team

regarding
206 of 610
1423 12/9/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Confer with N. Napolitan and J. Serrano

regarding
1424 12/9/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.90 4,621.50 Revise reply in support of preliminary

injunction motion.
1425 12/9/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.20 6,970.00 Revise reply in support of motion for order to

show cause regarding contempt.
1426 12/9/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 9.00 8,775.00 Work on reply brief for Preliminary Injunction.
1427 12/9/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.70 1,742.00 Transmit Daleiden deposition transcript (.2);

Cite‐check and assist with preparation of
filing of reply in support of motion regarding
Daleiden contempt (6.5).
1428 12/10/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 8.00 7,800.00 Work on the reply brief and prepare for oral

argument.
1429 12/10/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 8.00 2,080.00 Review CMP redacted court documents for

problematic redactions(2); prepare case law
cited regarding reply in support of motion
regarding contempt (2.5); prepare chart
regarding AEO designated individuals (1);
assist with preparation of filing of reply in
support of motion regarding contempt (2.5).
1430 12/10/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.40 292.00 Review recent NAF filings (0.2); review recent

press releases regarding NAF (0.2).
1431 12/10/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.20 2,457.00 Revise reply in support of preliminary

injunction motion.
207 of 610
1432 12/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 284.00 Confer with A. Nakamura and N. Napolitan

regarding
1433 12/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.20 852.00 Review and revise NAF's PI reply brief.
1434 12/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Review and revise NAF's sealing papers in

connection with NAF's PI reply.
1435 12/10/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Review sealing papers in support of NAF's

Contempt reply.
1436 12/10/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.30 5,256.00 Revise and finalize reply in support of motion

for preliminary injunction and related papers
(6.5 hours); oversee filing of brief (.8
hours).
1437 12/10/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.60 1,458.00 Review and revise reply in support of

1438 12/10/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 8.30 5,602.50 Finalize and oversee filing of order to show

cause reply brief, supporting documents, and
supporting declarations (7.8).
1439 12/10/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.80 2,613.00 Assist with finalization of reply briefing and

accompanying documents (4.50); compile
materials for attorney regarding upcoming
hearing (.80); draft index for case binder
(.30); compile case law for hearing (.90);
compile documents for attorney review (1.20)

208 of 610
injunction (1.8); draft and revise Foran
declaration in support of same (1.8); draft
proposed order of same (.4).
1441 12/10/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 6.60 5,610.00 Final review, revisions, and edits to replys on

preliminary injunction and contempt motion,
supporting declarations, and sealing papers.
1442 12/11/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Email correspondence with L. Shostak, D. Foran,

1443 12/11/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 497.00 Meeting with Mofo team to discuss
1444 12/11/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.80 1,638.00 Preparation for hearing on preliminary

injunction.
1445 12/11/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.30 1,679.00 Review Ohio AG news regarding investigation

(0.1); review recent NAF filings (2.2).
1446 12/11/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 8.50 8,287.50 Prepare for the oral argument.
1447 12/11/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 1,820.00 Prepare case law cited in opposition to motion

for preliminary injunction (2); prepare motion
for preliminary injunction briefing for
subsequent attorney review (5).
1448 12/11/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.80 938.00 Compile deposition testimony for attorney

review (.50); team meeting (.70); update
service list (.50); compile materials for
contempt motion (.90); draft index of same
1449 12/11/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.30 2,146.50 Review and prepare for hearing on order to show
209 of 610
cause.
1450 12/11/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.40 1,728.00 Confer with team regarding (1.3

hours); prepare for preliminary injunction
hearing (1.1 hours).
1451 12/11/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.30 1,058.00 Draft notice and stipulation to extend deadline

regarding moving to challenge subpoena.
1452 12/12/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 5.00 4,250.00 Preparations for hearing on motion for order to

show cause regarding contempt (review key
cases, begin preparing outline).
1455 12/14/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 650.00 Prepare briefing regarding second motion to

quash subpoena of C. Johnson (1.5); update
witness files with CMP press releases and
videos (1).
1456 12/14/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.00 1,170.00 Research in preparation for hearing on contempt

motion.
1457 12/14/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 142.00 Confer with Mofo team regarding
1458 12/14/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.30 7,055.00 Review and revise draft stipulation extending

time to response to Az subpoena (0.2); phone
calls and emails with counsel for StemExpress
regarding
(0.3);
210 of 610
preparation for hearing on contempt and
preliminary injunction motions (7.8).
1459 12/14/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.00 1,340.00 Draft and revise powerpoint slides (1.30);

compile documents for attorney review (.60);
compile stolen video times (.70); print case
law for attorney review (.30); compile hearing
materials (1.10);
1460 12/14/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 1.80 1,215.00 Review and provide

summary to D. Foran (1.8).
1461 12/14/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.50 1,012.50 Prepare for order to show cause.
1462 12/14/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.70 4,104.00 Prepare for and

confer with team regarding same (4.9 hours);
review confidentiality obligations (.2 hours);
confer with team regarding
(.3 hours); review draft stipulation and draft
email correspondence to defendants' counsel
regarding the same (.3 hours).
1463 12/14/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 7.70 3,542.00 Draft stipulation to extend deadline to

challenge state subpoenas (1); Coordinate,
review, and revise Powerpoint regarding
preliminary injunction hearing (2); confirm
standing order etc. regarding how to deal with
confidential documents (.5); research regarding
contracts and waiver (4.2).
1464 12/15/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 6.10 2,806.00 Coordinate and revise Powerpoint presentation

(2.1); finalize research and analysis related
contracts designed to suppress evidence (4).
211 of 610
1465 12/15/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.30 2,376.00 Research case law concerning Internet

publication (.6 hours); review issues regarding
confidentiality obligations (.3 hours); prepare
for and confer
with team regarding the same (2.4 hours).
1466 12/15/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.60 1,890.00 Review audio and video clips cited in

Defendants' preliminary injunction opposition
and draft chart comparing them to Defendants'
description of same in their opposition brief
(4); confer with L. Shostak regarding same
(.4).
1467 12/15/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.90 1,306.50 Compile documents for attorney review; (.60)

draft and update PowerPoint slides for
preliminary injunction hearing (1.70); draft
subpoena comparison chart (.30) send files to
opposing counsel (.50); compile hearing
materials (.80)
1468 12/15/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.30 6,205.00 Preparations for hearing on preliminary

injunction and contempt motions.
1469 12/15/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 213.00 Review opposing counsel's email correspondence

regarding alleged violation of protective
order; confer with D. Foran regarding same.
1470 12/15/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 0.80 540.00 Review evidence in record of violation of TRO

and to D. Foran (0.8).
1471 12/15/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.90 526.50 Research in support of motion on contempt

hearing.
212 of 610
1474 12/16/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.50 877.50 Review documents for possible use at contempt

motion hearing.
1475 12/16/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.50 2,177.50 Meetings with L. Shostak regarding

(1.0); compile case law for
attorney review (.50) draft and revise
PowerPoint slides (3.20); compile hearing
materials (.50); send files to opposing counsel
(.50); compile docket files for attorney (.80)
1476 12/16/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Review email correspondence from client

regarding recent news articles.
1478 12/16/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.20 6,120.00 Preparations for hearing on preliminary

1479 12/16/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 0.80 324.00 Prepare for hearing on motion for order to show

cause and preliminary injunction.
1480 12/16/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 4.40 2,310.00 Review audio and video clips cited in

Defendants' preliminary injunction opposition
and draft chart comparing them to Defendants'
description of same in their opposition brief.
1481 12/16/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.30 3,096.00 Research issues regarding defendants'
213 of 610
coconspirators (1.2 hours); prepare for
and confer with
team regarding same (2.6 hours); review
defendants' evidentiary objections and research
related law (.5 hours).
1482 12/16/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.60 2,576.00 Coordinate and revise Powerpoint presentation

(1.6); research and draft analysis regarding
challenging subpoenas (4).
1483 12/17/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.90 2,254.00 Finalize, copy, print, and revise Powerpoint

for preliminary injunction hearing.
1484 12/17/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.40 4,608.00 Prepare for preliminary injunction hearing and

confer with team regarding same (4.9 hours);
(meet with clients regarding
(.8 hours); review and
revise handout for preliminary injunction
hearing (.7 hours).
1485 12/17/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 7.90 6,715.00 Preparations for hearing on contempt and

preliminary injunction motions (6.9); email
release of audio/video to Arizona AG's office
(0.2); meeting with client regarding
(0.8).
1486 12/17/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.20 852.00 Meeting with NAF regarding
1487 12/17/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.70 1,574.50 Revise hearing Powerpoint slides (3.20);

compile documents for attorney review (1.0)
compile hearing preparation materials (.50)
214 of 610
1488 12/17/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 175.50 Preparation for hearing on contempt motion.
1489 12/17/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 6.00 5,850.00 Prepare for oral argument (5.0); meet with

client (1.0).
1490 12/17/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.00 1,040.00 Prepare preliminary injunction materials for

team meeting (1.5) ; Prepare case materials
regarding second motion to quash Johnson (1);
update NAF preliminary injunction power point
(2).
1491 12/18/2015 LINDA SHOSTAK 4.00 3,900.00 Prepare for and attend hearing.
1492 12/18/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.50 910.00 Prepare case law cited in second motion to

quash Johnson briefing (1) ; prepare CD disk of
recent court filings to opposing counsel (1) ;
assist with hearing preparation (1.5).
1493 12/18/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 4.70 3,995.00 Prepare for and attend hearing on preliminary

1494 12/18/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.10 73.00 Review order granting stipulation to extend

deadline.
1495 12/18/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,420.00 Attend NAF's preliminary injunction hearing.
1496 12/18/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 355.00 Travel to/from NAF's preliminary injunction

hearing.
1497 12/18/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.20 5,184.00 Prepare for and attend hearing regarding

preliminary injunction (4 hours); prepare for
hearing on motion to quash (1.2 hours); review
215 of 610
Johnson deposition transcript (2 hours).
1498 12/18/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 3.00 2,025.00 Attend lunch and post‐hearing de‐brief with

team and clients.
1499 12/18/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 2.00 1,350.00 Attend court hearing on preliminary injunction

and contempt motions (2.0).
1500 12/18/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 7.00 3,220.00 Prepare for and attend preliminary injunction

hearing and attend lunch thereafter.
1501 12/18/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.80 1,470.00 Attend preliminary injunction and order to show

cause hearing before Judge Orrick.
1502 12/18/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.60 3,861.00 Attend preliminary injunction hearing.
1503 12/18/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.20 1,407.00 Prepare for and attend hearing. (3.50); fill

out and file order for hearing transcript
(.50); assist with locking down documents (.20)
1504 12/20/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.90 2,088.00 Review case law regarding motions to quash and

California's shield law.
1505 12/21/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.80 1,134.00 Review transcript of preliminary injunction

hearing.
1506 12/21/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.50 4,680.00 Draft and revise sealing motion (.6 hours);

prepare for hearing on motion to quash (3.8
hours); research issues regarding motions to
quash (2.1 hours);
1507 12/21/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 4.30 2,257.50 Research California law regarding alternative

remedies to contempt that may apply if the
216 of 610
California shield law prevents a reporter from
being held in contempt (2); review federal law
regarding whether federal or state privilege
law applies when a federal order is violated
(2.3).
1508 12/21/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 702.00 File motions related to incorrectly redacted

document filed with preliminary injunction
briefing.
1509 12/22/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 409.50 Research in support of opposition to motion to

quash.
1510 12/22/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 5.70 2,992.50 Research California law regarding alternative

remedies to contempt that may apply if the
California shield law prevents a reporter from
being held in contempt (1.5); review federal
law regarding whether federal or state
privilege law applies when a federal order is
violated (3.1); confer with N. Napolitan
regarding same (.4); research the California
shield law privilege as set forth in the
California Constitution and the California
evidence code (.7).
1511 12/22/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.90 4,968.00 Prepare for quashal hearing (4.4 hours);

research case law on federal privileges (2.1
hours); review and revise declarations (.4
hours).
1512 12/23/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 201.00 Update chart of CDs sent (.30); fill out and

file transcript order (.30)
217 of 610
1513 12/23/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 6.60 4,752.00 Prepare for hearing on motion to quash (4.5
hours); travel to and attend hearing on motion
to quash (1 hour); confer with client regarding
(.5 hours); confer with team
and draft summary to team regarding
(.6 hours)
1514 12/23/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 3.70 3,145.00 Prepare for and attend hearing on Johnson's

motion to quash deposition subpoena.
1515 12/23/2015 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.10 1,102.50 Research federal and state privilege issues in

preparation for hearing (1.1); attend hearing (1).
1516 12/23/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.60 1,168.00 Review recent news articles..
1517 12/23/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 117.00 Review correspondence regarding
1518 12/28/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 58.50 Review correspondence regarding newly leaked

videos.
1519 12/28/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 1.30 1,105.00 Review and provide comment on draft

correspondence to court regarding proposed
declarations concerning Johnson disclosures
(0.9); prepare for and attend phone conference
with counsel for Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast
regarding (0.4).
1520 12/28/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.50 1,095.00 Review deposition transcript of J. Dunn.
1521 12/28/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.20 876.00 Review correspondence regarding hearing on

discovery (0.1); review CMP Press Release
regarding HHS Investigation (0.1); review
218 of 610
transcript of hearing (0.7); review recent case
filings (0.3).
1522 12/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Review recent case filings.

(.3 hours); draft and revise
letter to court concerning declarations (1.8
hours); confer with client regarding
(.3 hours).
1524 12/28/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 2.40 972.00 Review deposition transcripts.
1525 12/28/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 File letter with court.
1526 12/29/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 5.80 2,349.00 Review deposition transcripts (2.25); review

documents and video in possible violation of
temporary restraining order (3.6).
1527 12/29/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 360.00 Organize review team for potentially leaked

material.
1528 12/29/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.00 2,190.00 Review deposition transcript of M. Reeves

(1.4); review deposition transcript of V.
Saporta (1.5); review letters (0.1).
1529 12/29/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 390.00 Organize case files in workroom.
1530 12/30/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 144.00 Oversee review team of potentially leaked

information.
1531 12/30/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 71.00 Review and analyze court order regarding
219 of 610
Patriotgeist declarations.
1532 12/30/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.80 3,159.00 Determine whether documents and video violate

temporary restraining order (4.25); review
video created by defendants and given to Texas
DA (3.5).
1533 12/30/2015 CHRIS MAGANA 1.30 682.50 Review materials provided to Texas District

Attorney's' office for potential TRO
violations by CMP.
1534 12/31/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 3.80 1,539.00 Review recent case law regarding injunctions

and prior restraints (.5); review videos we
received from planned parenthood not currently
covered by temporary restraining order (3.25).
1535 12/31/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.70 1,971.00 Review deposition transcript of T. Newman

(0.9); review deposition transcript of C.
Johnson (1.7); review order regarding
declarations (0.1).
1536 1/4/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.30 682.50 Meet with NAF team to discuss

(.6); review recent video and request that
video be saved and downloaded on P (.4);
discuss with R. Zach (.2).
1537 1/4/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 2.50 1,487.50 Meet with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, C. Robinson,

N. Roethlisberger, A. Laks, R. Zacks to discuss
; read transcript from deposition of D.
Daleiden from StemExpress proceedings.
220 of 610
1538 1/4/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.60 6,650.00 Prepare for and attend team meeting re
(1.3); phone
conference with Linda Shostak regarding
(0.2); review Daleiden and Merrit deposition
transcripts from StemExpress matter (5.7);
correspondence with counsel for NAF member
Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast regarding
(0.1); confer with Javier Serrano regarding
(0.3).
1539 1/4/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Compile correspondence for attorney review
1540 1/4/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.90 2,905.50 Review and revise correspondences regarding

leak of TRO material (1.1 hours); draft form
declarations in response to court order (1.3
hours); participate in team meeting (.8 hours);
confer with client via email regarding
(.3 hours); revise notice to court
regarding leak of TRO material (.4 hours).
1541 1/4/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Attend team meeting regarding
1542 1/4/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 7.90 3,673.50 Discuss with D. Foran, N. Napolitan, C.

Robinson, N. Roethlisberger, C. Magana, and A.
Laks
(.8); research recent decision submitted to the
Court by defendants (.7); draft letters and
221 of 610
notice to Court regarding Defendants disclosure
of temporary restraining order covered material
to Harris County District Attorney (6.4)
1543 1/4/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 2,880.00 Review declarations related to Johnson issue

(.5 hr); review transcripts of depositions in
StemExpress matter (4 hr).
1544 1/4/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.00 560.00 Download and distribute CMP press releases

(1.5); retrieve CMP video transcripts (.5).
1545 1/5/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.20 896.00 Update team timekeepers list (1.3); download

and distribute CMP press release videos (1.5);
Research CMP employees regarding declarations
for Judge Orrick's order (.5).
1546 1/5/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 1.30 773.50 Email team
review versions of Master Chron in
order to preserve most up‐to‐date copy; skim
deposition of Daleiden given in StemExpress
case and circulated by D. Foran.
1547 1/5/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.70 1,728.00 Revise amended complaint.
1548 1/5/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.70 1,255.50 Determine which videos were released to Harris

County DA (.75); draft and send letters to
Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast and Harris County
DA regarding temporary restraining order
violation. (1.80)
1549 1/5/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.80 2,086.00 Develop and implement plan for complying with

court order regarding declarations (1.1 hours);
222 of 610
revise declaration and instructions in response
to court order (.5 hours); review and revise
letters and notice concerning leak of
confidential information (.6 hours); confer
with J. You regarding (.2 hours);
review briefing regarding scope of injunctions
(.4 hours).
1550 1/5/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.40 833.00 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
(.3); confer with N. Napolitan and T. Beyer
regarding
(.3); confer with J. Serrano
regarding (.3);
research federal law regarding same (.5).
1551 1/5/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.20 1,925.00 Review and revise draft correspondence to

Harris County District Attorney and others
regarding disclosure of TRO materials (1.2);
phone conference with client regarding
(0.5); phone calls
and emails with Arizona Attorney General and
local counsel in Arizona regarding
(0.5).
1552 1/5/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.50 517.50 Draft list of declarants to comply with judges

recent discovery order;(.50) update protective
order list (.70) update service list (.30)
1553 1/5/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.40 210.00 Review video and check to determine if copy of

chronology is saved locally.
223 of 610
1554 1/6/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.30 139.50 Discuss
1555 1/6/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.40 483.00 Update protective order list (.20); research

potential defendants (1.20)
1556 1/6/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.60 3,150.00 Prepare for and attend phone conference with L.

Brown and Nick Napolitan regarding
; phone
calls and emails with counsel for Planned
Parenthood Gulf Coast regarding
1557 1/6/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.20 5,248.00 Research in support of drafting amended

complaint.
1558 1/6/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.20 2,384.00 Confer with L. Brown and D. Foran regarding

(1.6 hours);
revise declaration and instructions (.7 hours);
confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
(.3 hours); develop and
implement plan for complying with court order
regarding declarations (.6 hours).
1559 1/6/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.50 2,082.50 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
(.5); confer with T. Beyer
regarding same (.3); confer with potential
declarants regarding same (2); confer with N.
(.7).
224 of 610
1560 1/6/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 644.00 Review, download and organize CMP press release
videos.
1561 1/7/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 700.00 Download and distribute CMP press release

videos.
1562 1/7/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.20 119.00 Compose and sign declaration in response to

Court's request for declaration regarding the
leak of materials covered by the temporary
restraining order; provide signed declaration
to A. Nakamura.
1563 1/7/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.70 2,201.50 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
(.6); confer with potential
declarants regarding same (2.2); create and
maintain tracking chart of declarations (.9).
1564 1/7/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.80 1,323.00 Prepare declaration and supporting materials in

response to the Court's December 30, 2015
order.
1565 1/7/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.10 819.50 Confer with team regarding (.9

hours); confer with D. Foran regarding
(.2 hours).
1566 1/7/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.70 325.50 Review follow up regarding Harris County

District Attorney disclosure (.15); draft
declaration in response to Court's December 30
order (.4).
1567 1/7/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.20 105.00 Review new press release and coordinate

uploading on P drive.
225 of 610
1568 1/7/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.60 525.00 Review correspondence with Harris County

District Attorney regarding disclosures of TRO
materials (0.3); review correspondence from
opposing counsel regarding same (0.1); email
correspondence with counsel for Planned
Parenthood regarding
1569 1/7/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.90 1,856.00 Draft amended complaint.
1570 1/7/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.80 966.00 Draft declaration e‐mail to multiple vendors

(.50) research A. Rhomberg (1.0); Research R.
Ruddy(1.0) update service chart (.10); update
service list (.20)
1571 1/7/2016 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.20 105.00 Complete declaration responding to Court's

order regarding leaked videos.
1572 1/7/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 186.00 Review declaration and instructions for

completing declaration related to disclosure of
materials to Charles Johnson (.2); confer with
N. Napolitan on same (.1); complete declaration
(.1).
1573 1/8/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.00 745.00 Confer with D. Foran and D. Roumiantseva

regarding (.5 hours);
research factual issues regarding defendants
(.5 hours).
1574 1/8/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 34.50 Grant access to secured network drive to

attorney(.10)
226 of 610
1575 1/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Email correspondence with S. Wood regarding
stipulation over Arizona and Louisiana
subpoenas (0.2); email correspondence with K.
Short regarding motion to submit additional
evidence in opposition to preliminary
injunction motion (0.2).
1576 1/8/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.30 773.50 Confer with potential declarants regarding

declarations pursuant to court's December 30,
2015 order (.8); create and maintain tracking
chart of declarations (.5).
1577 1/11/2016 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.20 151.00 Review stipulation to extend deadline to

challenge state subpoenas (0.1); review
Defendants' motion to file TRO letter under
seal and supporting documents (0.1); review
Defendants' motion to supplement preliminary
injunction record and supporting documents
(0.1);
1578 1/11/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.50 425.00 Prepare declaration regarding TRO materials.
1579 1/11/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 5.10 4,462.50 Complete review of Daleiden and Merritt

transcripts and exhibits from StemExpress
matter (4.6); review
(0.2); confer with N.
Napolitan regarding same (0.2).
1580 1/11/2016 ANNA FERRARI 0.30 220.50 Prepare declaration in response to December 30,

2015 order.
227 of 610
1582 1/11/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.30 157.50 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
1583 1/11/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.30 217.50 Review and prepare for filing stipulation and

proposed order extending NAF deadline to
challenge state subpoenas (0.3).
1584 1/11/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 103.50 Draft chart of declarants who have submitted

declarations.
1585 1/11/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.10 654.50 Confer with potential declarants regarding
(.9); create and maintain tracking
1586 1/11/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.30 1,713.50 Review submissions of defendants (.5 hours);

research contract issues (.4 hours); conduct
factual research into potential defendants (.6
hours); research issues regarding filing
procedures (.3 hours); confer with
1587 1/11/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.50 297.50 Review court filings circulated by V. Smith.
1588 1/12/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.70 476.00 Review, download and distribute CMP press

release videos for subsequent attorney review
(1.5); prepare case files for subsequent
attorney review (.20).
1589 1/12/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.70 3,008.00 Review draft complaint from Planned Parenthood.
228 of 610
1590 1/12/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.90 4,287.50 Email correspondence with counsel for Arizona
AG regarding disclosure of audio/video
concerning Arizona providers (0.2); review
draft Planned Parenthood complaint ; conference
with N. Roethlisberger regarding same; phone
conference with counsel for Planned Parenthood
1591 1/12/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.10 1,564.50 Review declarations (.6 hours); review draft

complaint (.5 hours); confer with D. Foran
regarding (.5 hours); confer with
A. Laks regarding
(.5 hours).
1592 1/12/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.50 787.50 Draft, print, scan, and email declaration in

response to Dec. 30 order (.5); confer with N.
Napolitan regarding (.5); review
new video, coordinate uploading of video, and
discuss timeline for (.5).
1593 1/12/2016 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 0.10 52.50 Revise and print declaration per instructions

of A. Nakamura.
1594 1/12/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.10 1,844.50 Confer with potential declarants regarding

2015 order (2.7); create and maintain tracking
chart of declarations (.2); confer with N.
1595 1/12/2016 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.30 226.50 Draft declaration in response to Court order

and review correspondence regarding same.
1596 1/13/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Discuss with N. Napolitan.
229 of 610
1597 1/13/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.50 232.50 Review documents for confidential material.
1598 1/13/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 700.00 Emails and phone calls regarding
1599 1/13/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.70 241.50 Send documents to Planned Parenthood for

vetting.

2015 order (1.4); create and maintain tracking
chart of declarations (.4); confer with N.
1601 1/13/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.60 1,192.00 Review declarations (.5 hours); confer with L.

Brown regarding
(.5 hours); prepare and review
production of public documents to A. Bomse (.6
hours).
1602 1/14/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.00 745.00 Review declarations (.8 hours); review and

revise filing (.2 hours).
(3.4); create and maintain tracking
1604 1/14/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Update list of declarants.
230 of 610
1605 1/14/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Review and coordinate saving of new press
release.
1606 1/14/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.70 2,362.50 Conference with client regarding

(0.8);
phone call with opposing counsel regarding
production of TRO materials to Arizona AG
(0.2); review and comment on draft Arizona AG
complaint (1.7)
1607 1/14/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.00 560.00 Review, download and distribute CMP press

release videos and transcripts for subsequent
attorney review (1); Prepare declaration
pursuant to Judge Orrick's order (1).
1608 1/15/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.10 379.50 Create clips of Arizona Planned Parenthood

footage to send to opposing counsel(.80);
Organize related cases (.20) send clips to CMP
counsel (.10)
(1); create and maintain tracking
chart of declarations (.3); review omnibus of
declarations and prepare for filing (2.1).
1610 1/15/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.20 894.00 Review NAF declarations (.6 hours); review

submitted declarations (.4 hours); oversee
filing of declarations (.2 hours).
1611 1/15/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 700.00 Prepare case materials for subsequent attorney

review (1.5); download and distribute CMP press
release videos and transcripts (1).
231 of 610
1612 1/19/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Send video files to Arizona Assistant Attorney

General.
1613 1/19/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.00 745.00 Review material related to Arizona subpoena (.2

hours); research rules regarding relation of
cases (.3 hours); review declarations submitted
by defendants (.5 hours).
1614 1/19/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.40 833.00 Review Defendants declarations submitted

pursuant to Judge Orrick's December 30, 2015
Order (1.1); confer with N. Napolitan regarding
same (.3).
1615 1/19/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 279.00 Determine whether a motion of related case

needs to be filed.
1616 1/19/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.30 157.50 Review new press release and coordinate filing

on share drive.
1617 1/19/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 644.00 Prepare Daleiden and CMP declarations pursuant

to December 30, 2015 order tracking chart
(1.3); Organize CMP witness file (1).
1618 1/20/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.90 310.50 Send documents to Planned Parenthood counsel.

(.10) Respond to attorney requests regarding
declarations filed (.10) research lodging
documents in related case (.50) send videos to
Arizona Attorney General (.20)
1619 1/20/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 5.80 5,075.00 Meeting with Stuart Plunkett regarding
(0.9); confer with N. Napolitan
232 of 610
regarding
(0.3); prepare statement in support of
referral to Judge Orrick relating the two cases
(0.4); review and provide comments on revisions
to draft complaint for Arizona AG matter (3.1);
phone call with client regarding
(0.2); phone
call with counsel for Planned Parenthood
regarding same (0.2); review and provide
comment on Planned Parenthood's statement
regarding relating the two cases (0.4); email
production of materials to Arizona AG (0.1);
email correspondence with opposing counsel
regarding service of NAF's statement on
relating Planned Parenthood and NAF matters
(0.2).
1620 1/20/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.50 297.50 Review clips of audio and video files to be

forwarded to the Arizona Attorney General's
Office for relevance.
1621 1/20/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.90 1,415.50 Review and revise motion to relate cases (.6

hours); research rules regarding relation of
cases and service issues (.6 hours); confer
with D. Foran regarding (.3
hours); organize and oversee filing of related
case brief (.4 hours).
1622 1/20/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.80 476.00 Draft Response to Judicial Referral to

Determine Relationship to Planned Parenthood
case (.4); review filing requirements for same
(.4).
233 of 610
1623 1/21/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Research address for A. Rhomberg.
1624 1/21/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Review email correspondence regarding proposed

motion to shorten time on motion to modify TRO
to allow filing of amicus brief in Supreme
Court (0.3); prepare response thereto (0.2).
1625 1/21/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.30 968.50 Research service requirements (.4 hours);

prepare proof of service (.3 hours); confer
with D. Foran regarding
(.2 hours); review defendants'
request to modify TRO (.2 hours); confer with
D. Roumiantseva regarding (.3
hours).
1626 1/21/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Read and respond to email regarding Defendants'

proposed motion to shorten time.
1627 1/22/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.60 315.00 Oversee creation of shells for objection to

motion to shorten briefing schedule per request
of D. Foran.
1628 1/22/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.60 1,209.00 Review videos that Defendants want to submit

with amici brief.
1629 1/22/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.10 819.50 Review research regarding agency and contract

law issues (.3 hours); review brief submitted
by defendants regarding modification of TRO (.5
hours); confer with D. Foran regarding same (.3
hours)
234 of 610
with amici brief.
1631 1/25/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.80 420.00 Respond to N. Napolitan regarding

; review updates regarding indictments of
defendants.
1632 1/25/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.20 1,794.00 Assist with gathering information for

opposition motion (.50) fill in fact cites and
format opposition to Motion to Modify TRO (2.0)
draft administrative motion to supplement
record (1.20); revise documents for upcoming
filings (1.60)

with amici brief.
1634 1/25/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 9.40 8,225.00 Legal and fact research for opposition to

motion to modify TRO to allow publication of
TRO materials in Supreme Court record (1.9);
prepare opposition to motion to modify (5.5);
emails and phone calls with client regarding
(0.7); emails and
phone calls with counsel for Planned Parenthood
and StemExpress regarding same (0.5); prepare
motion to supplement preliminary injunction
record re Harris County indictment (0.6); email
indictments and motion to supplement the record
(0.2).
1635 1/25/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.20 1,309.00 Draft administrative motion to seal (1); draft

declaration of Derek Foran in support thereof
235 of 610
(.7); draft proposed order (.5).
1636 1/25/2016 ANNA FERRARI 1.00 735.00 Identify and review relevant entries from

conference video and audio file review log
regarding clips for proposed use in defendants'
amicus brief in Whole Women's Health case;
conferences with D. Foran regarding same.
1637 1/25/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 1.50 1,275.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding

(0.5); prepare draft of
portion of response (1.0).
1638 1/25/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.30 223.50 Organize team for filing response to motion to

modify TRO and sealing papers.
1639 1/25/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.30 2,458.50 Review and revise opposition brief regarding

defendants' motion to modify TRO.
1640 1/25/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.20 336.00 Research Daleiden and Merritt indictments (1);

prepare case materials for subsequent attorney
review (.2)
1641 1/26/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.90 1,415.50 Review and revise opposition brief regarding

defendants' motion to modify TRO (.8 hours);
confer with D. Foran and N. Roethlisberger
regarding same (.5 hours); oversee filing and
corrections for filing of opposition brief (.5
hours).
1642 1/26/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.40 5,376.00 Revise and file opposition to motion to modify

the TRO.
1643 1/26/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.00 1,400.00 Update Analysis of NAF membership in CMP press
236 of 610
release videos (2.5); research and catalog
online threats made to NAF members (2);
download and distribute CMP press releases and
videos (.50)
1644 1/26/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.40 1,785.00 Respond to N. Napolitan regarding

; review and analyze new videos.
1645 1/26/2016 LINDA SHOSTAK 1.00 1,000.00 Meeting with jury consultant.
1646 1/26/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 6,125.00 Prepare for and attend meeting with jury

consultant regarding
(2.1); revise and edit opposition to
modify TRO to allow publication of TRO
materials in Supreme Court record (3.7); phone
call with L. Brown regarding
(0.4); review
and revise motions to seal opposition to motion
to modify (0.3); revise motion to supplement
administrative record and supporting papers
(0.3); phone call with counsel for Planned
(0.2).
1647 1/26/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.80 837.00 Review videos that Defendants want to submit

with amici brief.
1648 1/26/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 276.00 Assist with filing of motions.
1649 1/27/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.80 420.00 Review updates to log and send to N.

Roethelisburger.
1650 1/27/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 1,540.00 Update CMP investigative footage tracking chart
237 of 610
(2.5); Update NAF threat tracking chart (2);
distribute Daleiden and Merrit indictments to
team (1).

with amici brief.
1652 1/27/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Compile documents for attorney review (.20);

circulate indictment (.10);
1653 1/27/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.40 298.00 Confer with D. Foran and N. Roethlisberger

regarding
1654 1/28/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Review research regarding contract law issues.

with amici brief.
1656 1/28/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 140.00 Prepare and transmit recently filed court

documents to L. Brown.
1657 1/28/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.00 525.00 Review documents and confirm calendar

deadlines, email D. Foran and team regarding
same, and calendar deadlines to challenge
confidentiality designations.
1658 1/28/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 2,800.00 Phone call with counsel for Planned Parenthood

regarding
(0.4); review
Protective Order and federal court rules
regarding challenging designations and
calculate due dates regarding same (1.1);
238 of 610
confer with N. Napolitan and A. Laks regarding
(0.3); legal research for
motion to consolidate (1.4).
1659 1/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 1,837.50 Conferences with M. Hearron, A. Lawrence, and

L. Shostak regarding
(1.2); review Court's order denying
motion to modify TRO to allow filing in Supreme
Court (0.7); correspondence with opposing
counsel regarding (0.2).
1660 1/29/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.30 178.50 Meet with N. Roethlisberger to discuss
1661 1/29/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.00 465.00 Review order regarding amicus brief (.5);

discuss strategy regarding
(.5).
1662 1/29/2016 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.20 151.00 Review CMP article alleging Planned Parenthood

violates Texas law.
1663 1/29/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.90 670.50 Review order regarding motion to modify the TRO

(.3 hours); confer with team regarding same (.2
hours); review proof of service for filing (.2
(.2 hours).
1664 1/29/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 69.00 Update protective order chart and save

documents to network drive.
239 of 610
1665 1/29/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.60 952.00 Research California case law related to

potential theories of liability (1.2); confer
with N. Roethlisberger regarding same (.4).
1666 2/1/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 186.00 Research appellate procedures following

district court order on preliminary
injunctions.
1667 2/1/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Phone calls and emails with L. Brown regarding
1668 2/1/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.00 745.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding

(.2 hours); review research
concerning Ninth Circuit procedures (.3 hours);
review research regarding contract law and
attorney fee issues (.5 hours).
1669 2/1/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.80 2,432.00 Legal and factual research in support of

amended complaint.
1670 2/2/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.90 576.00 Review draft of amended complaint.
1671 2/2/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.80 596.00 Research appellate court issues (.3 hours);

draft agenda for team meeting regarding
outstanding tasks and next steps (.5 hours).
1672 2/2/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 2,800.00 Correspondence with NAF regarding

(0.3);
(0.3); prepare for and attend
240 of 610
phone conference with counsel for NAF regarding
(1.1); prepare outline
for summary judgment motion on contract claims
(1.5).
1673 2/2/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 697.50 Review court order denying motion to modify

temporary restraining order (.2); confer with
R. Zack and N. Roethlisberger regarding
(.3); listen to
IStandWithDavid webinar (1.0).
1674 2/2/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.40 238.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
1675 2/2/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.60 315.00 Video updates.
1676 2/2/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.20 93.00 Discuss amended complaint.
1677 2/3/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.30 139.50 Confer with A. Nakamura regarding
1678 2/3/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Attend team strategy meeting.
1679 2/3/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.40 735.00 Prepare for and attend group meeting regarding

(1.2); update and finalize
view review (.2).

(1
241 of 610
hour); confer with C. Magana regarding
(.4 hours); review
material produced by defendants (.3 hours);
draft email to client regarding
(.5 hours).
1682 2/3/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.70 507.50 Prepare for and attend team meeting regarding
1683 2/3/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.30 1,069.50 Review and revise amended complaint (1.5);

strategize regarding (.7).
1684 2/3/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.50 2,082.50 Research civil conspiracy pleading requirements

in California (2.8); confer with N.
Roethlisberger regarding same (.3); confer with
A. Dale regarding same (.4).
(1.3);
prepare notes regarding potential issues to
address on breach of contract summary judgment
claim (0.4); legal research regarding rules
governing consolidation of matters under Rule
42 (0.8); legal research regarding viability of
summary judgment on contract claims before
pleadings are closed (0.8); confer with counsel
for Planned Parenthood regarding same (0.2);
phone call with Lisa Brown regarding
(0.2);
review motion to supplement preliminary
injunction record (0.2).
242 of 610
1687 2/3/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 103.50 Compile filings for attorney review.
1688 2/3/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.40 896.00 Research regarding potential amendment to

complaint.
1689 2/3/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 1.00 595.00 Attend team meeting led by D. Foran to discuss

; review materials
in production folder for materials responsive
to letter request; compose and send email to N.
Napolitan
1691 2/4/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 320.00 Revise complaint in anticipation of filing

amended complaint.
1692 2/4/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.10 819.50 Research material produced by defendants (.6

hours); confer with N. Roethlisberger and
regarding
(.5 hours);
1693 2/5/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.10 2,309.50 Review court order and preliminary injunction

record (1.9 hours); draft email to client
regarding
regarding (.4 hours); organize team
meeting (.3 hours).
243 of 610
1694 2/5/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Review and analyze federal court order granting

NAF's motion for preliminary injunction.
1695 2/5/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.30 682.50 Update videos (.3); read order (1).
1696 2/5/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.30 2,012.50 Review court's order on preliminary injunction

(1.9); email correspondence with client
regarding same (0.4)
1697 2/5/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 735.00 Review and analyze the Court's order granting

NAF's motion for preliminary injunction.
1698 2/5/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.30 773.50 Research California authority regarding civil

conspiracy and fraud causes of action.
1699 2/5/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.90 883.50 Review preliminary injunction order.
1700 2/5/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.40 340.00 Review opinion granting preliminary injunction.
1701 2/5/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Compile documents for attorney review(.50);

Review Preliminary Injunction motion (.50)
1702 2/5/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.10 704.00 Research regarding potential amendment of

complaint.
1703 2/6/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.20 105.00 Review and
1704 2/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.60 1,400.00 Continue review of preliminary injunction order

(1.3); prepare notes regarding appellate
strategy (0.3).
1705 2/8/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.60 952.00 Research federal law related to the irreparable
244 of 610
harm that must be established in the context of
a preliminary injunction for a Fourth Amendment
claim.
1706 2/8/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.50 1,117.50 Organize meeting for outstanding tasks (.2

(.3 hours); confer with A.
Nakamura regarding (.2 hours);
research issues regarding conspiracy law (.2
hours); revise amended complaint (.6 hours).
1707 2/9/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 735.00 Attend team meeting regarding
1708 2/9/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 725.00 Attend team strategy meeting regarding
(0.8);
correspond with S. Plunkett regarding
(0.2).

(.4).
1710 2/9/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.70 790.50 Determine upcoming deadlines.
1711 2/9/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 2,625.00 Conferences with L. Shostak and J. Bennett

regarding
(0.7); prepare for and attend team meeting
regarding
(1.3); phone conference with
client regarding same (0.6); meet‐and‐confer
correspondence with Arizona AG and Louisiana IG
245 of 610
regarding enforcement of subpoenas in light of

(.9 hours); confer with N.
Roethlisberger and A. Nakamura regarding
(.3 hours); review
material released by defendants (.6 hours);
confer with R. Zack and A. Laks regarding
(.2 hours).
1713 2/9/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 2.40 2,040.00 Read and analyze district court's preliminary

injunction opinion for appeal issues (1.5);
team conference call regarding
(0.9).
1715 2/10/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.20 1,309.00 Research federal law related to the irreparable

harm that must be established in the context of
a preliminary injunction for a Fourth Amendment
claim (2); confer with J. Serrano regarding
(.2).
1716 2/10/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.30 139.50 Determine upcoming deadlines.
1717 2/10/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.00 2,325.00 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding

(.3); review
same.
1718 2/10/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.30 223.50 Review recent filings in Planned Parenthood

matter.
246 of 610
1719 2/10/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 69.00 Review press file.
1720 2/11/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,750.00 Phone calls and emails with client regarding

(0.6); review
Ninth Circuit rules regarding expedited appeals
for preliminary injunction orders (0.5); confer
with N. Napolitan regarding (0.4); phone
conference with counsel for CMP regarding
(0.4).
1721 2/11/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.80 596.00 Confer with team regarding
1722 2/11/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.10 976.50 Review Defendant's deposition in StemExpress

case (2.0); correspond with J. Serrano
regarding (.1).
1723 2/12/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 149.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding
1724 2/12/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Correspond regarding latest video releases from

CMP.
1725 2/12/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 612.50 Correspondence with opposing counsel regarding

proposed stay of trial court proceedings
pending appeal (0.5); correspondence with
counsel for Arizona AG regarding subpoena and
schedule for litigation (0.2).
1726 2/16/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 73.50 Review court order granting C. Johnson's motion

to quash.
247 of 610
1728 2/16/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 149.00 Confer with K. Hubbard regarding
1729 2/16/2016 DANIELLE COLEMAN 0.10 75.50 Review certificate of interested entities.
1730 2/17/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.60 1,192.00 Revise draft stipulation (1 hour); research

appellate procedures (.4 hour); confer with D.
Foran regarding (.2 hours).
1731 2/17/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Emails with N. Napolitan regarding
(0.2); review and provide
comment on draft stipulation (0.2).
1732 2/17/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 170.00 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
1733 2/19/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.80 596.00 Review revised stay papers (.4 hours); file

same (.4 hours).
1734 2/19/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 725.00 Review and discuss
(1.0).
1735 2/19/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.40 238.00 Read email from S. Serrano regarding

; phone call to J. Serrano to
discuss request; review video log and forward
248 of 610
potentially relevant information to J. Serrano.
1736 2/19/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review stipulation filed with court.
1737 2/21/2016 ANNA FERRARI 0.80 588.00 Review master chronology of video and audio

files for entries regarding Advanced Tissue
Services and Tissue Biosource.
1738 2/21/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Review video spreadsheet and correspond with D.

Foran and team regarding

(.5 hours); draft email to client
regarding same (.5 hours); review materials
produced to Arizona (.4 hours).
1740 2/22/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Correspond with S. Plunkett regarding
(0.3); draft stipulation seeking to extend time
for NAF to respond to state subpoenas (0.2).
1741 2/22/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Email correspondence and phone call with

1742 2/23/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 700.00 Review order denying anti‐SLAPP motion in

StemExpress matter (0.4); confer with S.
Plunkett and N. Napolitan regarding
(0.4).
1743 2/23/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.80 476.00 Draft "comeback" letter for 9th Circuit;
249 of 610
compose and send to D. Foran
1744 2/23/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.90 765.00 Review and revise draft of letter to Ninth

Circuit regarding comeback appeal.
1745 2/23/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.30 223.50 Confer with client via email regarding

(.3 hours); draft emails
to client regarding same (.3 hours); confer
with A. Dale regarding (.2
hours).
1748 2/26/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Confer with S. Plunkett and D. Foran regarding

(0.2);
draft and send to opposing counsel stipulation
extending NAF time to challenge state subpoenas
(0.3).
1749 2/26/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.60 525.00 Confer with S. Plunkett regarding
(0.3);
emails with client regarding same (0.3).
1750 2/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Review correspondence with opposing counsel

regarding stipulation extending deadline to
respond to Arizona subpoena.
250 of 610
(.1); review discovery chart to identify
StemExpress related‐videos and review same (5.1).

(.2); review discovery summaries and
identify StemExpress related audio and video
files (1.5); filter StemExpress audio and video
files according to subject and people being
recorded (2.5); review video files (.6).
1753 3/1/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.30 223.50 Confer via email with A. Dale regarding
1754 3/2/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.50 1,117.50 Draft email to opposing counsel regarding

Arizona subpoena (.6 hours); confer with S.
Plunkett and J. Serrano regarding
(.3 hours); review confidentiality
issues (.6 hours).
1755 3/2/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.40 210.00 Discuss with G. Stenger.
1756 3/2/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Confer and correspond with S. Plunkett and N.

Napolitan regarding
1757 3/3/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.60 1,209.00 Review discovery chart for StemExpress related

files and filter according to relevance. (2.6)
1758 3/3/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.60 315.00 Train G. Stenger regarding tracking CMP videos.
1759 3/3/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.10 74.50 Draft email to opposing counsel regarding

Arizona subpoena.
251 of 610
1760 3/7/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 930.00 Review discovery logs for files related to

StemExpress and sort same according to topic
and speakers (2.0).
1761 3/7/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.10 59.50 Review "comeback letter' to be filed with 9th

Circuit and send edits to D. Foran; read 9th
Circuit filings and briefing schedule.
1762 3/7/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Review notice of appeal (0.1); revise letter to

Ninth Circuit clerk regarding treatment of
appeal as a "comeback" case (0.3); emails with
N. Napolitan regarding (0.1).
1763 3/7/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.40 298.00 Oversee filing of request for comeback panel.
1764 3/8/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.60 447.00 Draft email to opposing counsel regarding

appellate deadlines (.2 hours); confer with A.
Nakamura and A. Dale regarding (.4
hours).
1765 3/8/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.70 367.50 Calendar deadlines.
1766 3/8/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.10 654.50 Confer with N. Napolitan and A. Dale regarding

(.3); review
StemEx video and audio (.8).
1767 3/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Phone conference with Lisa Brown regarding
1768 3/8/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 930.00 Review

and categorize same (1.5); confer with N.
252 of 610
Napolitan and A. Nakamura on same and on
(.5).
1769 3/9/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.60 2,139.00 Confer with A. Nakamura regarding review of

(.2);
review StemExpress audio and video files to
identify files responsive to Arizona subpoena
(4.4).
1770 3/9/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.80 476.00 Confer with A. Dale regarding
1771 3/9/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.70 521.50 Confer via email with counsel for Planned

Parenthood (.3 hours); review documents
produced by defendants (.4 hours).
1773 3/10/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.00 1,395.00 Confer with A. Nakamura regarding

(.1); review videos for responsiveness
to Arizona subpoena.
1774 3/10/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Review CMP's letter to Ninth Circuit regarding

treatment of appeal as a “comeback” case.
1775 3/10/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.20 714.00 Confer with A. Dale regarding

(.2); review StemEx video and
audio (1).
1776 3/10/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review filing in Ninth Circuit.
1777 3/11/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 186.00 Confer with A. Nakamura and with N. Napolitan

regarding
253 of 610
1778 3/11/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.30 968.50 Review videos produced by defendants (.4

hours); review draft joint motion to continue
appellate deadlines (.4 hours); confer via
email with D. Foran regarding
(.2 hours); research appellate procedural
issues (.3 hours).
1779 3/11/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Review and provide comment on draft motion to

extend time to file appellate briefs in appeal
from preliminary injunction order.
1780 3/11/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.00 1,190.00 Review StemEx video and audio.
1781 3/14/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.30 2,012.50 Legal research regarding standard of review in

Ninth Circuit on an appeal from a preliminary
injunction order.
1782 3/14/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review filings in appeals court.

(.3); review StemEx
video and audio (.7).
1784 3/14/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.30 968.50 Confer with S. Wood regarding (.1

hour); revise draft joint motion (.2 hours);
review list of videos prepared by defendants
related to request of Arizona Attorney General
(.4 hours) confer with A. Nakamura and A. Dale
regarding (.4 hours); draft email
to client regarding (.2 hours);
254 of 610
1785 3/14/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 372.00 Confer with A. Nakamura and N. Napolitan
regarding
(.2); review
chart of same and update with internal
summaries for such videos (.6).
1786 3/14/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.10 85.00 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
1787 3/15/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.70 1,487.50 Further legal research regarding standard of

review and related matters for brief on appeal
of preliminary injunction order.
1788 3/15/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 372.00 Review recordings defendants identified as

responsive to Arizona subpoena (.80).
1789 3/15/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Review material produced by defendants.
1790 3/15/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Discuss with NAF presentation.
1791 3/15/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.70 416.50 Review StemEx video and audio.
1792 3/16/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.20 93.00 Confer with N. Nakamura regarding
1793 3/16/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.50 1,487.50 Review video and audio recordings related to

Stem Express.

Stem Express.
255 of 610
1796 3/17/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.30 223.50 Review recent filings (.2 hours); confer with

team regarding (.1 hour).
1797 3/17/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.20 105.00 Prepare for NAF presentation.
1798 3/18/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.90 670.50 Review work product regarding material produced

by defendants and identified by defendants as
responsive to subpoena.

(.3); review files defendants flagged
as responsive to Arizona subpoena and summarize
contents of same. (1.7).

Stem Express.
1801 3/21/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.90 535.50 Review video and audio recordings related to

Stem Express.
1803 3/21/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Prepare NAF Presentation.

subpoena (.1); compare list of files identified
by defendants as responsive to Arizona subpoena
against items identified as related to
StemExpress in internal discovery master log
(1.5); correspond with N. Napolitan and A.
Nakamura on same (.1).
256 of 610
1805 3/22/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.00 465.00 Confer with N. Napolitan and A. Nakamura
regarding
1806 3/22/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.20 870.00 Prepare for and attend meeting with D. Foran

(0.5); review and comment on
summary of video materials identified by
defendants to produce to Arizona (0.7).
1807 3/22/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.20 1,639.00 Review videos produced by defendants (1 hour);

meet with A. Nakamura and A. Dale regarding
(.8 hours); confer with D. Foran
regarding (.1 hour); draft email
to client regarding (.3 hours).
1808 3/22/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review CMC statement filed in Planned

Parenthood action.
1809 3/22/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.50 892.50 Conference with N. Napolitan and A. Dale

regarding
(1.25); revise chart of
relevant recordings (.25).
1810 3/23/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.80 1,071.00 Review

(1.5); confer with A. Dale
regarding same (.3).
1811 3/23/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.20 1,050.00 Phone conference with California AG's office

regarding
regarding
(0.5); conference with N. Roethlisberger
257 of 610
regarding same (0.2).
1812 3/23/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.10 74.50 Draft email to client regarding
1813 3/23/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.20 1,155.00 Prepare for and provide NAF Presentation.

(.2).
1815 3/24/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding
1816 3/24/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Compile files and send to client.

Stem Express.
1818 3/24/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.20 894.00 Confer with client regarding

(.5 hours); confer with team regarding same (.4
hours); review material produced by defendants
(.3 hours).
1819 3/25/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.40 2,100.00 Prepare for and attend conference call with

Washington AG's office regarding
(0.8); conference with counsel for Planned
(1.6).
1820 3/25/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.30 773.50 Review video and audio recordings related to

Stem Express.
258 of 610
1821 3/27/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Review legal research notes regarding defenses
to use of fake drivers license under California
law and phone call regarding same.
1822 3/28/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 3,062.50 Review district preliminary injunction briefs,

exhibits, and order granting preliminary
injunction (preparations for defending
injunction on appeal).
1823 3/28/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 NAF Scheduling.
1825 3/28/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,312.50 Further legal research regarding standard of

review applicable to preliminary injunction
appeals in Ninth Circuit (0.8); confer with K.
Hubbard regarding
(0.7).
1826 3/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 3,062.50 Prepare for and attend case management

conference in Planned Parenthood case (1.9);
prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer
teleconference with Arizona AG's office
regarding status of subpoena (0.8); phone
conference with client regarding
(0.3); confer with K. Hubbard
regarding
(0.3); phone
conference with M. Fowler regarding
(0.2).
1827 3/29/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.70 1,249.50 Travel to and attend case management conference
259 of 610
in Planned Parenthood v. CMP et al.

; confer with client regarding same (.1
hour).
1829 3/30/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 700.00 Confer with client regarding
(0.2);
review and revise draft meet and confer
correspondence to Louisiana Inspector General's
office regarding (0.2);
phone call to Louisiana Inspector General's
office regarding same (0.1); confer with N.
Napolitan regarding
(0.3).
1830 3/30/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 725.00 Draft correspondence to Louisiana Inspector

General regarding status of subpoena (0.2);
draft stipulation resolving state attorney
general subpoenas (0.8).
1831 3/30/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Review appellate rules for filing under seal

(.2 hours).
1832 3/30/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review civil minutes of CMC.
1833 3/31/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 700.00 Prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer phone

conference with counsel for Arizona AG
regarding subpoena issued to CMP.
1834 4/1/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Email correspondence with opposing counsel
260 of 610
regarding length of briefs on preliminary
injunction appeal.
1835 4/4/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Draft stipulation regarding resolution of

Arizona AG and Louisiana IG subpoenas (0.5).
1836 4/4/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 87.50 Meet‐and‐confer with opposing counsel regarding

briefing limits in Ninth Circuit (0.1); phone
calls and follow up email correspondence
regarding
(0.3).
1837 4/5/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 875.00 Confer with Planned Parenthood counsel

regarding (0.3); phone
call with L. Brown regarding same (0.2); meet
and confer correspondence and phone calls with
Louisiana IG and Arizona AG's office regarding
(0.5).
1838 4/5/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Correspond with opposing counsel regarding

stipulation to extend time to respond state
subpoenas and revise stipulation regarding same
(0.5).
1839 4/5/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Calendar motion to seal deadlines in the Ninth

Circuit.
1840 4/6/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 170.00 Review and comment on defendant's draft of

motion for extra words for appeal brief.
1841 4/6/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 262.50 Coordinate review of new videos.
1842 4/6/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.30 448.50 Research video clips sent to Arizona Attorney
261 of 610
general and update chart of same.
1843 4/6/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 875.00 Confer with C. Robinson regarding
(0.3);
meet‐and‐confer phone conference with Arizona
AG's office regarding same (0.3); review and
provide comments on draft joint motion to
enlarge word limits for Ninth Circuit briefs on
appeal from preliminary injunction order (0.3);
follow up correspondence with defense counsel
1844 4/6/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,470.00 Review case law regarding appellate standard of

review of preliminary injunction.
1845 4/6/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Prepare attachment of list of NAF files to

agreement to resolve Arizona subpoena (0.5).
1846 4/7/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Review correspondence from Arizona Attorney

General regarding subpoena issues (0.5).
1847 4/7/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.50 1,837.50 Legal research regarding appellate standard of

review of preliminary injunction (2hrs); draft
portions of NAF's appellate opposition brief
(0.5 hrs).

(.1 hour); review and revise complaint
regarding the Arizona subpoena (remainder).
1849 4/7/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 700.00 Meet and confer correspondence with counsel for
262 of 610
Arizona AG regarding subpoena served on CMP
(0.2); confer with client regarding
(0.2); confer with N.
Napolitan regarding
(0.4).
1850 4/7/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 128.00 Review search warrant documents related.
1851 4/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Phone conference with counsel for Planned

Parenthood regarding subpoena directed to NAF
(0.3); confer with C. Robinson regarding
(0.2).
1852 4/8/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.70 1,088.00 Prepare docket and case summary for client.
1853 4/11/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 256.00 Review law on sealing documents in the Ninth

Circuit.
1855 4/12/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.50 297.50 Review docket and create list of substantive

motions and responses to motions filed by
plaintiff.
1856 4/13/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 276.00 Compile Daleiden declarations for attorney

review.
1857 4/14/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.00 525.00 Discuss

with D. Foran (.2); correspond with G. Stenger
regarding (.3); draft
emails notifying opposing counsel and counsel
for planned parenthood that NAF received
263 of 610
subpoena for protected materials (.5).
1858 4/14/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Further email correspondence and phone calls

with potential amici regarding
1859 4/14/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 46.50 Review letter to California Attorney General.
1860 4/14/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 441.00 Prepare letter to California AG regarding

sensitivity of NAF materials.
1861 4/14/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 73.50 Review notice to opposing counsel regarding

subpoena.
1862 4/14/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 512.00 Revise slide presentation.
1863 4/15/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.20 1,408.00 Research revisions to proposed change in

statute (.7 hr); research law on
confidentiality agreements (1.5 hr).
1864 4/15/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 700.00 Review draft joint motion to file hard drive

with Ninth Circuit (0.2); internal email
correspondence regarding same (0.3);
changes thereto (0.3).
264 of 610
1867 4/15/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 276.00 Search Harris County District Court for

filings.
1868 4/15/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.70 1,266.50 Review filings in related cases (.5 hours);

hours); research sealing issues (.3 hours);
revise opposing counsel's draft motion to
transmit exhibit to the court of appeals (.6
hours).
1869 4/15/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.00 465.00 Review preliminary injunction order.
1870 4/18/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.00 1,035.00 Compile appeal documents and distribute to team

and client; compile case law.
1871 4/18/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 384.00 Review law on sealing in Ninth Circuit.
1872 4/19/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.90 2,496.00 Review defendants' opening brief on appeal.
1873 4/19/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.70 1,266.50 Review defendants' opening appellate brief (1.5

hours); confer with team regarding
(.2 hours).
1874 4/19/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.20 1,023.00 Review appeal.

(.2); correspond with C.
Robinson, N. Napolitan, and R. Zack regarding
same (.1).
1876 4/19/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.10 1,069.50 Compile case law; draft index; fabricate binder
265 of 610
of case law.
1877 4/19/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.50 1,837.50 Meeting with N. Roethlisberger regarding
(0.3 hrs); confer with N. Roethlisberger
regarding
(0.2 hrs); email
(0.5 hrs); review and analyze Defendants'
appellate brief (1.5 hrs).
1878 4/19/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.30 2,012.50 Review of defendant's opening brief on

preliminary injunction appeal.
1879 4/19/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 372.00 Review defendants' appeal brief (.80).
1880 4/20/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.80 837.00 Prepare for and discuss with C. Robinson, A.

Dale, and N. Roethlisberger issues regarding
1881 4/20/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.20 2,883.00 Confer with C. Robinson, N. Roethlisberger, and

R. Zack regarding
(.8); review defendants' appeal and
prepare chart regarding cited conversations and
statements from NAF members (5.4).
1882 4/20/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 875.00 Phone calls and email correspondence regarding
(0.9); review stipulation and order regarding
deadline for responding to Arizona and
Louisiana subpoenas (0.1).
266 of 610
1883 4/20/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.10 5,218.50 Prepare plan for amicus brief outreach (0.8

hr); confer with D. Cohen regarding
(0.2 hrs); prepare draft statement of
facts for NAF's appellate response (___);
meeting with A. Dale, N. Roethlisburger, and R.
Zack regarding
(1 hr).
1884 4/20/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Compile documents for attorney review.
1885 4/20/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.40 2,816.00 Analyze defendants' opening brief on appeal.
1886 4/20/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.90 670.50 Review defendants' opening appellate brief (.3

hours); confer with C. Robinson regarding
(.2 hours); review appellate
record (.4 hours).
1887 4/21/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.60 447.00 Review work product related to appellate brief

(.2 hours); review amicus communications
(.2 hours).
1888 4/21/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.80 2,432.00 Draft outline of response to irreparable harm

sections of defendants' opening brief.
1889 4/21/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
1890 4/21/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.50 4,042.50 Draft NAF's appellate response brief.
1891 4/21/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 3.40 1,581.00 Review and outline Defendants' appeal (2.8);
267 of 610
prepare for and participate in meeting with A.
Dale, C. Robinson, and N. Roethlisberger
regarding (.6).
1892 4/21/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.80 1,767.00 Review defendants' appeal and prepare chart

regarding cited conversations and statements
from NAF members (3.8).
1893 4/22/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.60 1,209.00 Confer with C. Robinson and R. Zack regarding

(.7); review defendants' appeal
and prepare chart regarding cited conversations
and statements from NAF members (1.9).
1894 4/22/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.50 232.50 Prepare for and participate in meeting with C.

Robinson and A. Dale regarding
1895 4/22/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.10 1,564.50 Review amicus briefs (1.2 hours); draft outline

for amicus responses (.4 hours); confer with
team regarding (.5 hours)
1896 4/22/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.90 3,601.50 Prepare outline of NAF's appellee brief (3.0);

confer with R. Zack and A. Dale regarding
(0.7 hrs); review and revise statement
of facts for NAF's appellee brief (1.2 hrs).
1897 4/22/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Arrange for attorney to review appeal briefing.
1898 4/22/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 384.00 Draft motion to seal documents.
1899 4/23/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.70 2,719.50 Review and revise statement of facts for NAF's

appellee brief (3.7 hrs).
268 of 610
1900 4/24/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.50 1,102.50 Prepare outline of NAF's appellee brief (1.5

hrs).
1901 4/24/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.80 837.00 Revise chart documenting recordings voted by

defendants in appeal brief (1.0); draft notes
on potential amicus briefs (.8).
1902 4/25/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.60 3,069.00 Participate in conference call with client

regarding (.8); confer
(.2);
confer with R. Zach and N. Roethlisberger
regarding
(.2); review amicus
brief from attorneys general and confer with R.
Zack on (.3); revise chart documenting
recordings voted by defendants in appeal brief
(.6); review defendants' claims regarding
recordings related to partial birth abortion
(3.0); review case law on partial birth
abortion (1.5)
1903 4/25/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.90 1,415.50 Participate in call regarding amicus briefs (.9

hours); review amicus briefs (1 hour)
1904 4/25/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.40 4,704.00 Review and revise amicus brief strategy (0.6

hrs); prepare draft of NAF's appellee brief
(5.8 hrs).
1905 4/25/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.10 976.50 Draft Opposition to 9th Circuit appeal.
1906 4/25/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 448.00 Draft motion to seal documents.
269 of 610

(1.1); review
cases cited in CMP's appeal brief (2.0).
1908 4/25/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 1.00 850.00 Telephone conference regarding
1909 4/26/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.40 3,850.00 Review CMP's motion to quash subpoena served by

Planned Parenthood on NAF seeking access to
discovery in NAF matter (0.2); phone call with
L. Shostak regarding (0.1); fact
research regarding potential candidates for
amicus brief concerning ethical journalism
(1.2); review amicus briefs filed in Ninth
Circuit to date (2.9).
1910 4/26/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.20 3,328.00 Draft motion to seal documents.
1911 4/26/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 3.90 1,813.50 Draft opposition to defendants ninth circuit

appeal.
1912 4/26/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Distribute appeal documents to team and client.
1913 4/26/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.50 787.50 Draft summaries of amicus briefs and coordinate

revisions to summary document.
1914 4/26/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.30 1,534.50 Review amicus briefs and draft summaries (2.9);

review defendants' appeal (.3); confer with N.
Napolitan regarding (.1)
1915 4/26/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.30 5,365.50 Prepare draft of NAF's appellee brief (4.3

hours); prepare talking points for amicus brief
270 of 610
outreach (1.0 hr); legal research on First
Amendment issues in connection with NAF's
appellee brief (2.0 hrs).
1916 4/26/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.60 447.00 Review amicus briefs and work product based on

amicus briefs (.4 hours); confer with team
1917 4/27/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.00 1,860.00 Review amicus briefs and draft summaries (.2);

review defendants' appeal with regard to
partial‐birth abortion claims and draft
summaries of arguments in response (3.7);
correspond with C. Robinson regarding
(.1).
1918 4/27/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 6.60 3,069.00 Draft opposition to ninth circuit appeal.
1919 4/27/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.70 4,924.50 Telephone call with Professor Cohen regarding

law professors' amicus brief (0.2 hrs); email
correspondence with client and counsel
regarding (0.3 hrs);
research potential amicus partners regarding
journalism ethics (0.3 hrs); legal research
enforceability of contractual promises in
connection with NAF's appeal brief (2.5 hrs);
draft NAF's appeal brief (3.4 hrs).
1920 4/27/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.80 1,792.00 Research regarding irreparable damages.
1921 4/27/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.20 894.00 Review amicus briefs and work product regarding

amicus briefs (1 hours); confer with N.
Roethlisberger regarding (.2 hours)
271 of 610
1922 4/27/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.80 966.00 Draft chart of documents filed under seal and
accompanying orders for appellate brief.
1923 4/27/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.60 5,775.00 Continue review of amicus briefs filed in

support of CMP (3.2); confer with N. Napolitan
(0.3); phone call with B. Parker regarding
(0.3); phone calls with potential amici for
brief on ethics of journalism (2.8).
1924 4/28/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.50 2,557.50 Review amicus brief from Attorneys General and

related case law and annotate same (3.0);
confer with D. Foran on (.2); draft
suggestions of potential firms to assist with
amicus briefs (.4); review case law related to
partial‐birth abortion (1.9).
1925 4/28/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 5,687.50 Fact and other online research regarding

potential drafters/amici for brief on First
Amendment/prior restraint issues (2.4); phone
calls to potential amici regarding same (0.9);
fact and other online research regarding
potential amici for brief regarding ethics in
journalism (3.2).
1926 4/28/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.90 670.50 Review amicus briefs (.8 hours); confer with C.

Robinson regarding (.1 hour).
1927 4/28/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.80 5,733.00 Legal research in connection with NAF's appeal

brief (3.0 hrs); draft NAF's appeal brief (4.0
hrs); confer with D. Foran and L. Brown
regarding (0.8 hrs).
272 of 610
1928 4/28/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.10 2,624.00 Draft motion to seal documents.
1929 4/28/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Assist with drafting of sealing motion.
1930 4/29/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.00 1,860.00 Review amicus brief from Attorneys General and

related case law and annotate same (3.8);
correspond with D. Foran and C. Robinson on
(.2).
1931 4/29/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.90 5,071.50 Draft NAF's appeal brief (5.1 hrs); confer with

D. Foran, M. Poe, and D. Cohen regarding amicus
brief strategy (0.8 hrs); legal research in
connection with NAF's appeal brief (1.0 hrs).
1932 4/29/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.40 4,096.00 Research regarding possible amicus briefs.

hours); review work product regarding amicus
briefs (.2 hours)
1934 4/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.80 6,825.00 Fact research regarding potential amici for

brief regarding ethics of journalism (2.6);
phone calls and emails with journalism
professors and other potential amici for brief
regarding ethics of journalism (4.7); phone
conference with counsel for amici on
journalistic ethics (0.5).
1935 4/29/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.80 1,302.00 Prepare time line of procedural history.
1936 4/30/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.50 2,572.50 Draft NAF's appeal brief (3.5 hrs).
1937 4/30/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 232.50 Review case law related to partial‐birth
273 of 610
abortion (.5).
1938 5/1/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.50 2,572.50 Draft NAF's appeal brief (3.5 hrs).
1939 5/2/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.50 3,022.50 Review case law and statutes related to partial

birth abortion (3.0); confer with R. Zack on
same (.8); review audio and video files cited
by defendants in appeal brief (1.0; draft
responses to defendants arguments on same (1.7)
1940 5/2/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 8.90 6,541.50 Draft NAF's appeal brief (6.2 hrs); legal

research in connection with NAF's appeal brief
(2.7 hrs).

(.2 hours); review materials related to
amicus briefs (.2 hours).
1942 5/2/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.90 6,912.50 Review and provide comment on initial draft of

fact section for Ninth Circuit brief (2.1);
phone calls and emails with potential amici for
brief addressing ethics of journalism (5.8).
1943 5/2/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.90 3,136.00 Research potential amici (2 hr); draft sealing

motion for Ninth Circuit (1.5 hr); research in
support of opposition to appeal of preliminary
injunction (1.4 hr).
1945 5/2/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 5.90 2,743.50 Review videos related to Plaintiffs Ninth

Circuit appeal; research legal issues related
274 of 610
to Ninth Circuit appeal.
1946 5/3/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.10 511.50 Review videos related to Plaintiffs Ninth

Circuit appeal.
1947 5/3/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.00 2,560.00 Draft sealing motion and prepare redacted

documents to submit as exhibits.
1948 5/3/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.60 6,650.00 Legal research regarding "journalist

privileges" under First Amendment (0.6); phone
calls and emails with potential amici for brief
addressing journalistic ethics (3.2); phone
calls and emails with constitutional law
professors regarding potential amicus brief
addressing prior restraint/First Amendment
issues (1.6); research regarding canons of
journalistic ethics in the United States (1.2).
1949 5/3/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.40 298.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding

(.2 hours); review amicus correspondences (.2
hours).
1950 5/3/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.20 558.00 Confer with D. Foran and N. Roethlisberger

regarding (.5); update internal
chart on amicus briefs (.2); correspond
internally regarding (.1);
prepare list of legal scholars who submitted
amicus briefs in recent supreme court case
(.4).
1951 5/3/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.80 5,733.00 Review and revise motion to seal (1.0 hrs);

prepare NAF's appeal brief (6.8 hrs).
275 of 610
1952 5/4/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.00 2,235.00 Review and revise draft complaint.
1953 5/4/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.20 558.00 Correspond internally regarding

(.2); research scholars who write on fetal
tissue research (.8); update charts regarding
amici (.2).
1954 5/4/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.80 3,712.00 Revise draft of opposition to appeal (3.3 hr);

revise sealing motion (1.4 hr); research in
support of inviting amicus briefing (1.1 hr).
1955 5/4/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.50 6,562.50 Phone calls and emails regarding
1956 5/4/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 8.50 6,247.50 Confer with L. Brown, D. Foran, and B. Parker

regarding (1.0 hrs); confer
with N. Roethlisberger and R. Zack regarding
(1.5 hrs); review and revise NAF's appeal brief
to address comments from team (6.0 hrs).
1957 5/4/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 5.60 2,604.00 Review and revise draft opposition to Ninth

Circuit appeal; discuss issues related to Ninth
Circuit opposition.
1958 5/4/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.50 517.50 Redact documents for filing.

(.1); confer with R. Zak and N. Roethlisberger
regarding (.4); review scholarship on
276 of 610
fetal tissue research (2.2); correspond with
potential amici (.5); update internal charts
with amici (1.6); review draft of Ninth Circuit
brief (.4).
1961 5/5/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.40 1,788.00 Review and revise draft filings regarding

sealing.
1962 5/5/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 147.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger and D. Foran

regarding
1963 5/5/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.00 3,500.00 Review and comment on draft motion to seal

(0.5); review initial draft of Ninth Circuit
brief (1.0); further phone calls and email
correspondence with potential amicus for brief
regarding benefits of fetal tissue research,
journalism issues (2.1) phone calls and emails
with L. Brown regarding
(0.4).
1964 5/5/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.30 3,392.00 Revise motion to keep documents under seal (2.6

hr); strategize about and research on amicus
briefs (2.7 hr).
(1.1);
conferences with J. Bennett regarding
(0.9); review
First Amendment cases cited by appellants
(3.2); further phone calls and email
277 of 610
correspondence with potential amicus for briefs
regarding benefits of fetal tissue research and
ethics of journalism (1.7).
1966 5/6/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.20 5,364.00 Meet with J. Bennett, D. Foran and C. Robinson

regarding (.8 hours); revise
motion to seal (4.1 hours); confer with N.
Roethlisberger regarding (.3
hours); review appellate excerpts of record
(1.2 hours); research sealing issues (.8
hours).
1967 5/6/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.40 186.00 Research legal issues related to Opposition to

Defendants' Ninth Circuit appeal.
1968 5/6/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,307.50 Confer with Mofo team regarding
(3.5 hrs); review
and revise redacted exhibits to NAF's motion to
seal (1.0 hrs).
1969 5/6/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 588.00 Confer with A. Dale regarding

(0.4 hrs);
review First Amendment case law (0.4 hrs).
1970 5/6/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.60 1,674.00 Confer with D. Foran, C. Robinson, N.

Roethlisberger, N. Napolitan, and R. Zack
regarding
(.8); research scholarship on fetal tissue
research (2.3); correspond with potential amici
(.5).
1971 5/6/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 279.00 Attend meeting with D. Foran, C. Robinson, N.
278 of 610
Napolitan, N. Roethlisberger, and A. Dale
regarding
1972 5/6/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.30 5,312.00 Research in support of answering brief in Ninth

Circuit (6.5); draft sealing motion (1.8).
1973 5/7/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 697.50 Research and correspond with potential amici

for brief on fetal tissue research.
1974 5/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 787.50 Review and revise draft motion to seal in Ninth

Circuit.
1975 5/8/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.60 1,209.00 Correspond with potential amici and with D.

Foran on same (.1); review audio and video
files cited in defendants' appellate brief and
annotate same (2.4); correspond with C.
Robinson, N. Napolitan, N. Roethlisberger, and
R. Zack regarding
(.1).
1976 5/8/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.20 558.00 Research legal issues related to Opposition to

1977 5/9/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 8.20 6,109.00 Confer with L. Brown regarding

(.3 hours); revise and finalize motion to seal
and redacted attachments (5 hours); oversee
filing of motion to seal (2.3 hours); confer
with team regarding appellate brief (.6 hours).

regarding
279 of 610
1979 5/9/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.60 5,775.00 Continue legal research regarding First

Amendment/prior restraint issues (1.3); prepare
outline of sections on likelihood of success
and irreparable harm for Ninth Circuit brief
(2.1); review final version of draft motion to
seal (0.2); follow up email correspondence
regarding
(0.4); confer with S. Song
regarding status of journalism brief (0.2);
revise fact section of Ninth Circuit brief
1980 5/9/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.50 1,627.50 Review defendants' appeal brief (1.2); review

draft of NAF response brief (1.3); research and
correspond with potential amici for fetal
tissue research brief (1.0).
1981 5/9/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.20 5,292.00 Review proposed redactions to V. Saporta

deposition transcript (0.8 hrs); review and
respond to email correspondence regarding
(0.4 hrs); confer with D. Foran
regarding (0.2 hrs); review
and revise NAF's appeal brief (5.8 hrs).
1982 5/9/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.90 5,056.00 Revise and file sealing motion (6.1); research

in support of answering brief in Ninth Circuit
(1.8).
1983 5/10/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 192.00 Review correspondence concerning potential

amicus.
1984 5/10/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.00 2,325.00 Correspond with D. For an and attorneys at
280 of 610
Crowell regarding amicus brief (.5); correspond
with potential amici for brief on fetal tissue
research (1.5); review excerpted record and
update chart regarding quoted conversations in
defendants' appeal brief (3.0).
1985 5/10/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.60 447.00 Confer with opposing counsel via email

regarding motion to extend word limit (.2
hours); confer with R. Zack regarding
regarding (.1 hour);
review order in related case (.1 hour).
1986 5/10/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.70 1,984.50 Review and revise NAF's appeal brief (2.7 hrs).
1987 5/10/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 3.80 1,767.00 Research legal issues related to Answer to


regarding
1989 5/11/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.10 2,309.50 Participate in team call regarding

(.6 hours); draft appellate brief (2.5
hours).
1990 5/11/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 962.50 Prepare for and attend conference call

regarding
(0.6); review
legal research regarding district court's
obligation to explain basis for decision on
motion for preliminary injunction (0.2); follow
281 of 610
up emails regarding same (0.2); confer with C.
Robinson regarding
(0.1).
1991 5/11/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.40 651.00 Correspond and confer with C. Robinson and D.

Foran regarding (.4); correspond
with potential amici for fetal tissue research
(.5); participate in conference call with D.
Foran and Crowell Moring attorneys regarding
fetal tissue research brief (.5).
1992 5/11/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.90 5,071.50 Telephone call with L. Brown and B. Parker

regarding (0.6 hrs); review and
revise NAF's appeal brief (4.3 hrs); analyze
transcripts of NAF video recordings discussed
in CMP's appeal brief (2.0 hrs).
1993 5/11/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.10 1,984.00 Research related to potential amicus briefs.
1994 5/12/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.90 3,776.00 Research in support of answering brief.
1995 5/12/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 3,937.50 Review revised draft of likelihood of success

on the merits section of appellate brief (1.0);
follow up legal research regarding standard of
review (0.4); revise standard of review and
likelihood of success sections of appellate
brief (2.3); phone conferences with potential
amici for brief concerning constitutional law
issues (0.8).
1996 5/12/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.10 2,309.50 Draft appellate brief (2.7 hours); review

legislative history research (.4 hours).
282 of 610
1997 5/12/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.40 2,046.00 Research legislative history and scholarship on
fetal tissue research (1.0); research potential
amici (.3); confer with and correspond with A.
Nakamura regarding
(.3); draft summary of legislative
histories and secondary sources related to
fetal tissue research regulations (1.4);
correspond with D. Foran and C. Robinson
regarding (.3); draft e‐mails
regarding consent to file amicus brief to send
to Crowell team (.1); update chart with list of
amici including summaries of their
qualifications and draft e‐mail to Crowell team
on same (1.0).
1998 5/12/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,470.00 Review and revise NAF's appeal brief (2.0 hrs).
1999 5/12/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 279.00 Draft word count enlargement.
2000 5/12/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.40 238.00 Confer with N. Napolitan and A. Dale regarding
2001 5/13/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.70 2,201.50 Research projects and publications involving

fetal tissue on NIH (1.5); confer with A. Dale
regarding same (.5); research academic
background and publishing history of
researchers currently involved in NIH projects
involving fetal tissue (1.7).

regarding
283 of 610
2003 5/13/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 955.50 Prepare for telephone call with M. Goodwin

regarding (0.2 hrs); telephone
call with B. Parker and M. Goodwin regarding
(0.3 hrs); prepare summary of call
with M. Goodwin (0.5 hrs); confer with N.
Napolitan and D. Foran regarding
(0.3 hrs).
2004 5/13/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 3,062.50 Follow up phone calls with potential amici for

brief regarding journalism ethics,
constitutional law issues, and impact of CMP's
campaign on providers (0.9); fact research for
Ninth Circuit brief (1.2); draft fact section
of Ninth Circuit brief (1.4).
2005 5/13/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.70 1,720.50 Correspond with D. Foran regarding

(.1); revise chart with amici for brief
on fetal tissue research and correspond with
attorneys at Crowell Moring on same (.7);
research case law citing to federal Partial
Birth Abortion Act (1.4); confer with A.
Nakamura regarding
(.4); research
case law related to fetal tissue regulations
(1.1).
2006 5/13/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Draft appellate brief.
2007 5/13/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 512.00 Research in support of answering brief.
2008 5/14/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.30 3,203.50 Draft appellate brief (3.2 hours); research

case law regarding injunctions (1.1 hours).
284 of 610
2009 5/14/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 232.50 Research potential amici for fetal tissue

amicus brief (.5).
2010 5/15/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 8.30 7,262.50 Revise brief on appeal.
2011 5/15/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.90 1,130.50 Research academic background and publishing

history of researchers currently involved in
NIH projects involving fetal tissue.
2013 5/16/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.80 837.00 Identify scientists using fetal tissue in their

reteach to identify potential amici and
correspond with same (1.7); confer with D.
Foran on same (.1).
2014 5/16/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 10.50 9,187.50 Confer with Keker & Van Nest regarding

potential amicus brief for Planned Parenthood
(0.5); conference with L. Brown regarding
(0.4); revise
brief on appeal (9.6).
2015 5/16/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.50 697.50 Research issues related to the district courts

decision to issue an unsealed order.

(.3 hours); confer with N. Roethlisberger
regarding (.2 hours); revise
appellate brief (7.6 hours).
2017 5/16/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.60 315.00 Assist in preparing subpoena response.
285 of 610
2019 5/17/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.70 3,008.00 Research regarding irreparable injury in

support of answering brief.
2020 5/17/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.00 595.00 Research academic background and publishing

2021 5/17/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.60 315.00 Assist in coordination of sending materials in

response to PPFA subpoena.
2022 5/17/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 4.50 3,352.50 Revise appellate brief.
2023 5/17/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 9.70 8,487.50 Revise draft appellate brief (9.5); phone call

(0.2).
2024 5/17/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 186.00 Research Scholarship on benefits of fetal

tissue research (.3); correspond with D. Foran
on same (.1)
2025 5/17/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 725.00 Calls and correspond with representatives of

Arizona AG regarding state subpoena (1.0).

(0.4 hrs); review revised
portions of NAF's appeal brief (0.2 hrs).
2027 5/18/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 930.00 Correspond with potential amici for fetal

tissue research breach (.7); correspond with D.
Foran, M. Hearron, and C. Robinson on same (4);
286 of 610
research potential amici (.8); confer and
correspond with outside counsel drafting amicus
brief (.1)
2028 5/18/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 697.50 Research case law related to fetal tissue

research (1.2); correspond with D. Foran and C.
Robinson on same (.1); correspond with
potential amici for fetal tissue research
amicus brief (.2).
2029 5/18/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 514.50 Review preliminary injunction record in

connection with NAF's appeal brief.
2030 5/18/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 8.70 7,612.50 Revise draft appellate brief (8.1); phone

conference with Keker & Van Nest regarding
potential amicus brief for Planned Parenthood
(0.6).
2031 5/18/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 170.00 Confer with appeal team regarding
2032 5/18/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.30 3,948.50 Revise appellate brief.
2033 5/18/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.00 525.00 Coordinate transmittal of materials in response

to PPFA subpoena.
2036 5/19/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.90 4,416.00 Research in support of answering brief (1.2);

research in support of reply to opposition to
sealing brief (5.7).
287 of 610
2037 5/19/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.20 714.00 Research academic background and publishing

2038 5/19/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.00 525.00 Coordinate submission of materials in response

to PPFA subpoena.
2039 5/19/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.20 1,639.00 Revise appellate brief (1.6 hours); review

opposition to motion to seal (.6 hours).
2040 5/19/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.50 232.50 Research factual issues related to Defendants

opposition to motion to seal.
2041 5/19/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Draft stipulation and correspond with opposing

counsel regarding extending NAF's time to
respond to state subpoenas (0.5).

(.3); correspond with potential
amici for fetal tissue research brief (.6);
research potential amici for same (.3);
research case law on Partial Birth Abortion Act (0.3).

(0.1 hrs); review legal research regarding
fetal tissue research in connection with NAF's
appeal brief (0.2 hrs).
2044 5/19/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 955.50 Review and revise NAF's appeal brief.
2045 5/19/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 8.90 7,787.50 Revise draft appellate brief.
288 of 610
2046 5/20/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.60 4,224.00 Research in support of reply to sealing
opposition.
2047 5/20/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.00 3,725.00 Draft portions of appellate brief (4.4 hours);

(.6 hours).
2048 5/20/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.50 2,557.50 Research scholarship on fetal tissue research

(3.0); research potential amici for fetal
tissue amicus brief and contact same (2.4);
correspond with D. Foran, C. Robinson, and N.
Napolitan on same (.1).
2049 5/20/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.40 833.00 Research federal law regarding motions to seal

before an appellate court where the denial of a
motion to seal would moot the appeal; confer
with N. Roethlisberger regarding same.
2050 5/20/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 9.10 7,962.50 Revise Ninth Circuit brief (7.4); emails and

phone calls with L. Brown regarding
(0.4); review opposition
to motion to seal record pending decision on
the merits (0.5); review court's order denying
motion to file oversized brief (0.1); phone
conference with clerk's office regarding same
(0.2).

tissue research amicus brief (.1); correspond
with L. Schwartz at Crowell Moring regarding
drafting of same (.1).
2052 5/21/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 6.00 5,100.00 Revise and comment on draft of appeal brief.
289 of 610
2053 5/22/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 6.00 5,100.00 Revise and comment on draft of appeal brief.

tissue research brief (.2)
2055 5/23/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.30 139.50 Draft motion to enlarge word count.
2056 5/23/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.40 5,600.00 Revise draft appellate brief in light of

comments received (4.7); phone conference with
N. Roethlisberger et al regarding
(0.5); review
court's order granting motion to seal (0.2);
review district court order regarding schedule
for challenging AG subpoenas (0.2); follow up
correspondence regarding same (0.2); meeting
with C. Robinson and N. Napolitan regarding
(0.6).
2057 5/23/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.20 1,309.00 Research federal case law for authority

supporting the proposition that a motion to
seal must be granted because the disclosure of
the sealed material would moot the appeal at
issue (1.2); research federal Ninth Circuit
case law for cases sealing material because
disclosure would gratify private spite or
promote public scandal (1).
2058 5/23/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Calendar deadlines regarding states subpoena.
2059 5/23/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.40 2,499.00 Legal research in connection with NAF's appeal

brief (0.7 hrs); confer with D. Foran and N.
290 of 610
Napolitan regarding
(0.8 hrs); prepare summary of sealing
motions and proposed redacted version of CMP's
Response to NAF's Motion to Seal (1.6 hrs);
confer with N. Napolitan regarding
(0.3 hrs).
2060 5/23/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Review and revise NAF's appeal brief.
2061 5/23/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.30 139.50 Correspond with amici for fetal tissue research

brief (.3).
2062 5/23/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.00 2,790.00 Research scholarship on fetal tissue research

(2.0); research and contact potential amici for
fetal tissue research brief (2.5); draft
biographies of amici for fetal tissue research
brief (1.5)
2063 5/23/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.80 680.00 Confer with appeal team regarding
2064 5/23/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 7.70 5,736.50 Draft appellate brief (5.9 hours); confer with

D. Foran and N. Roethlisberger regarding
regarding (1 hours)
2065 5/23/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.00 4,480.00 Draft reply in support of sealing motion (4.2);

analyze order from court regarding sealing
(1.1); research in support of answering brief
(1.7).
2066 5/23/2016 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 3,000.00 Work on 9th Circuit brief.
2067 5/23/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Teleconference with team.
291 of 610
2068 5/24/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.50 862.50 Draft index of documents cited in Plaintiff

brief filed in 9th Circuit.

cases related to appeal issues (1.3 hours)
2070 5/24/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.80 1,152.00 Research regarding notice to court regarding

sealing.
2071 5/24/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Follow up from opposing counsel regarding

subpoena.
2072 5/24/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.30 1,069.50 Confer with D. Foran and C. Robinson regarding
(.3); research scholarship on
intact D&E (2.0).
2073 5/24/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 5.10 4,462.50 Legal research regarding prior restraint issues

(1.2); revise appellate brief (3.5); conference
regarding (0.4).
2075 5/24/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.10 3,013.50 Review and revise NAF's appeal brief (2.4 hrs);

telephone call with M. Goodwin regarding amicus
brief process (0.3 hrs); confer with D. Foran
regarding (0.5 hrs); legal
research regarding likelihood of success on the
merits (0.9 hrs).
2076 5/24/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.90 535.50 Research Ninth Circuit preliminary injunction

standard (.6); confer with C. Robinson
292 of 610
regarding same (.3).
2077 5/25/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 3.50 2,082.50 Research Ninth Circuit preliminary injunction

standard related to the interpretation of
likelihood of success on the merits and
likelihood of irreparable harm (3.2); confer
with D. Foran regarding same (.3).

(0.5 hrs); legal research
regarding appellate standard of review in First
Amendment preliminary injunction cases (0.3
hrs).
2079 5/25/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.60 279.00 Correspond with amici for fetal tissue research

brief (.2); update biographies of amici for
brief (.2); confer with outside counsel
drafting amicus brief (.2)
2080 5/25/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.30 5,512.50 Legal research regarding standard of review in

First Amendment preliminary injunction cases
(1.7); conferences with N. Napolitan regarding
same (0.5); revise draft appellate brief (4.1).

issues regarding appellate review (4.2 hours);
review appellate record (1.4 hours).
2083 5/25/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.00 2,415.00 Assist with drafting and revision of SER.
2084 5/26/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.30 2,518.50 Revise and update SER list and components.
293 of 610
2085 5/26/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.50 892.50 Review Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure and

Ninth Circuit rules regarding transmission of
physical exhibits to Court (.6); draft motion
to transmit physical exhibits to court (.9).
2086 5/26/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.70 5,568.00 Research in support of answering brief (7.2);

research and draft notice to court regarding
sealing (1.5).
2087 5/26/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.80 4,321.00 Confer with team regarding (.7

hours); research case law regarding First
Amendment (1.3 hours); confer with team
regarding (.4 hours); email
opposing counsel regarding motions (.2 hours);
review appellate record (.5 hours); draft
appellate brief (2.7 hours).

tissue research brief (.2); confer with contact
at Planned Parenthood regarding potential amici
for fetal tissue research amicus brief (.7);
confer with D. Foran on same (.1); confer with
(.3); research
potential amici (.5)
2089 5/26/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 9.60 8,400.00 Revise draft appellate brief (9.0); conferences

(0.6).
294 of 610
2092 5/27/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.10 1,906.50 Confer with contact at Planned Parenthood

regarding
(1.2); research
scientists using fetal tissue in their research
and correspond with same about fetal tissue
amicus brief (2.2); update biographies of amici
(.5); correspond with team at Crowell Moring
drafting the amicus brief (.2).
2093 5/27/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.00 4,410.00 Telephone call with B. Parker regarding

(0.5 hrs); review and comment on final
draft of NAF's appeal brief (5.2 hrs); confer
with N. Napolitan and D. Foran regarding
(0.3 hrs).
2094 5/27/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 10.30 9,012.50 Revise Ninth Circuit appellate brief (8.4);

phone conference with counsel for Planned
(0.4); further follow up correspondence
regarding requests for consent to file amicus
brief (0.3); legal research regarding arguments
made in Attorneys' General amicus brief and
draft response thereto for inclusion in
appellate brief (1.2).
2095 5/27/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.10 654.50 Draft motion to transmit physical exhibits to

court.
295 of 610
issues regarding appellate review (1.5 hours);
review and revise appellate record (1.1 hours);
participate in call regarding amicus brief (.6
hours).
2097 5/27/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.40 5,376.00 Editing and revising answering brief.
2098 5/27/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,070.00 Assist with preparation of opposition.
2099 5/28/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.00 1,725.00 Assist with preparation of opposition filing.
2100 5/28/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.20 2,384.00 Draft appellate brief.
2101 5/28/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.60 1,209.00 Review and revise Ninth Circuit brief (2.0);

research scientists using fetal tissue in their
research and correspond with same about fetal
tissue amicus brief (.3); update biographies of
amici (.2); correspond with amici regarding
brief (.1)
2102 5/29/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 46.50 Correspond with amici for fetal tissue brief

(.1).
2103 5/29/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.30 968.50 Draft appellate brief.
2104 5/29/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,070.00 Assist with preparation of opposition filing.
2105 5/29/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 4.00 3,400.00 Review and comment on draft of appeal brief.
2106 5/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,187.50 Review and provide comments on latest draft of

Ninth Circuit brief.
2107 5/30/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.90 1,662.50 Further revisions to Ninth Circuit appellate
296 of 610
brief.
2108 5/30/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 13.80 4,761.00 Assist with preparation and filing of

Opposition.
2109 5/30/2016 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 3,000.00 Work on 9th Circuit brief.
2110 5/30/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 13.50 10,057.50 Finalize appellate brief (9.3 hours); review

and finalize appellate record (3.2 hours);
finalize appellate motions (1 hours).
2111 5/30/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 12.50 5,812.50 Review and revise Answer to 9th Circuit appeal.
2112 5/30/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 8.20 3,813.00 Correspond with amici for fetal tissue research

brief (.1); revise Ninth Circuit appeal brief
(8.1).
2113 5/31/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.90 1,813.50 Revise Ninth Circuit brief (3.7); correspond

with amici for fetal tissue research amicus
brief (.2)
2114 5/31/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 8.90 5,696.00 Revising and filing answering brief.
2115 5/31/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 9.60 7,152.00 Finalize appellate brief and related filings

(7.8 hours); oversee filing of appellate
material (.9 hours); prepare redacted brief (.9
hours).
2117 5/31/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 7.90 2,725.50 Assist with finalization and filing of
297 of 610
opposition.
2118 5/31/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.90 535.50 Review unopposed motion to transmit physical

exhibit (.5); review unopposed motion to extend
answering brief word limit (.4).
2119 5/31/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.60 3,381.00 Confer with N. Napolitan regarding

(0.3
hrs hrs); email M. Goodwin regarding
appellants' contact information for requesting
consent to file amicus brief (0.2 hrs); review
NAF's appeal brief for sealing issues (3 hrs);
provide comments on journalism amicus brief
(0.9 hrs).
2120 5/31/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 2,800.00 Final revisions to Ninth Circuit brief (2.6);

conferences with C. Robinson and N.Napolitan
regarding
(0.6)
2121 6/1/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.00 525.00 Review subpoena and related correspondence,

calendar deadlines regarding subpoena, and
research and summarize issues related to
subpoenas (.7); review presentation materials
(.3).

(0.3 hrs).

(.1); research potential amici for amicus brief
on fetal tissue research and correspond with
same (4.7); confer with Laura Schwartz at
298 of 610
Crowell Moring regarding same (.1); confer with
contact at Planned Parenthood regarding
(.1).
2124 6/1/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.20 3,874.00 Prepare redacted brief (2.7 hours); confer with

K. Short et al regarding redacted brief (.3
(.4 hours); research appellate procedure
(.7 hours); review subpoena (.4 hours).
2125 6/1/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.30 448.50 Compile case law for attorney review;

organizing same into binder
2126 6/1/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.10 3,587.50 Review final version of brief filed in Ninth

Circuit (0.9); review proposed redactions to
public version of brief and conferences with N.
Napolitan regarding same (1.1); correspondence
with opposing counsel regarding third party
subpoena served on NAF (0.3); phone conference
same (0.2); preparations for oral argument
(1.6).
2127 6/1/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.50 1,600.00 Draft and file notice of sealing (1 hr); review

amicus briefs (1.5 hr).
2128 6/2/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.30 1,472.00 Review draft amicus briefs.
2129 6/2/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 1,837.50 Review draft amicus briefs (1.5); conferences

with counsel for amicus regarding same (0.3);
phone conference with Javier Serrano regarding
299 of 610
(0.3).
2130 6/2/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.00 2,235.00 Oversee filing of redacted brief (.6 hours);

review draft amicus briefs (1 hour); confer
with team regarding (.7 hours);
confer with team about preparing paper copies
for filing (.3 hours); transmit redacted brief
to amici (.4 hours)
2131 6/2/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 279.00 Review amicus briefs.
2132 6/2/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.40 1,116.00 Correspond with amici for fetal tissue research

brief (.7); correspond with Crowell Moring team
drafting the brief (.1); review draft of same
(.6); confer with N. Napolitan and N.
(.5); confer with N. Napolitan and
N. Roethlisberger, and with Laura Schwartz at
Crowell Moring regarding same (.3) update
biographies of amici (.1); confer with N.
(.1)
2133 6/2/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 147.00 Review and comment on journalism amicus brief.
2134 6/3/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.00 2,325.00 Confer and correspond with contact at Planned

Parenthood regarding fetal tissue research
brief (.4); confer internally regarding
(.2); correspond with amici for fetal
tissue research brief (.3); research effects of
recent controversy on availability of fetal
300 of 610
tissue for research (.3); draft and revise
biographies of potential amici (3.6); confer
with L. Schwartz at Crowell Moring regarding
status of amicus brief (.2).
2135 6/3/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.10 1,564.50 Review amicus briefs (.9 hours); confer with

team regarding (.4 hours); confer
with opposing counsel via email regarding
service of files (.3 hours); prepare for and
participate in call with client regarding
(.5 hours).
2136 6/3/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.90 310.50 Arrange for paper copies of brief; serve

documents on opposing counsel.
2137 6/3/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 875.00 Email correspondence regarding
2138 6/3/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 2.50 1,812.50 Call with client regarding
(0.5); work on NAF responses to
third party subpoena in Planned Parenthood
litigation (2.0).
2139 6/3/2016 LINDA SHOSTAK 3.00 3,000.00 Review amici briefs.
2140 6/3/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 256.00 Review draft amicus briefs.
2141 6/4/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 930.00 Correspond internally regarding

(.1); correspond with L. Schwartz at Crowell
Moring regarding status of amicus brief (.2);
correspond with potential amici for amicus
brief on fetal tissue research (.2); research
301 of 610
effects of recent controversy on fetal tissue
research (1.5).
2142 6/5/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.10 976.50 Correspond with L. Schwartz at Crowell Moring

regarding status of amicus brief (.1) ; review
drafts of amicus briefs (2.1).
2143 6/6/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 186.00 Correspond with L. Schwartz at Crowell Moring

regarding amicus brief (.1); confer internally
regarding same (.3)
2144 6/6/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 46.50 Correspond with N. Napolitan regarding

(.1).
2145 6/6/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.50 1,862.50 Review amicus briefs (.5 hours); confer with

team regarding (.4 hours); review hard
copy of appellate record and briefing (.9
hours); arrange copying and transfer of CDs for
appellate record (.4 hours); review appellate
procedures (.3 hours).
2146 6/6/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 3,937.50 Correspondence with miscellaneous amicus

regarding finalization of amicus briefs (0.4);
preparations for oral argument at Ninth Circuit
(review cases cited by parties in briefs)
(4.1).
2147 6/6/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 3.70 2,682.50 Work on NAF responses to third party subpoena

in Planned Parenthood litigation (2.3); work on
chronology of key events regarding state
subpoenas in connection with court status
conference (1.4).
302 of 610
2148 6/6/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.00 640.00 Review draft amicus briefs.

(0.1 hrs); email correspondence with amicus
regarding format of briefs (0.8 hrs); review
letter to J. Orrick requesting modification to
protective order (0.2 hrs).
2150 6/7/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.00 2,235.00 Confer with J. Serrano regarding

(.6 hours); revise draft discovery
responses and objections (.8 hours); review
amicus briefs (1.1 hours); review CDs and
arrange for CDs to be transferred to court and
served (.5 hours).
2152 6/7/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.10 6,212.50 Review amicus briefs filed in Ninth Circuit

(2.3); follow up correspondence regarding same
(0.6); continue preparations for oral argument
at Ninth Circuit (4.2).
2153 6/7/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 256.00 Review filed amicus briefs.
2154 6/7/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.70 790.50 Confer with L. Schwartz at Crowell Moring

regarding status of amicus brief and amici
(.3); confer internally regarding same (.2);
review drafts of amicus briefs (.7); contact
potential amici for fetal tissue research brief (0.5).

in Planned Parenthood litigation (2.7); work on
summary of key events in connection with court
303 of 610
hearing on status of state subpoenas (3.2).
2156 6/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.70 5,862.50 Confer with counsel for constitutional law

scholar amicus regarding motion for leave to
file late brief (0.4); review draft motion for
leave to file (0.2); confer with J. Serrano and
(0.3); preparations for court hearing regarding
status of Louisiana and Arizona subpoenas and
related matters (0.4); continue preparation for
oral argument at Ninth Circuit (5.4).

(.9 hours); review amicus briefs (1.3 hours);
confer with A. Dale regarding (.4
hours); research appellate procedure (.5
hours); confer with clients regarding
(.4 hours).

in Planned Parenthood litigation (0.5);
research on powers and limitations of Louisiana
IG (2.5); correspond with client regarding
(0.3); confer with D. Foran and N.
Napolitan regarding
(0.5).
(.4); correspond with Crowell Moring attorneys
regarding fetal tissue amicus brief (.1);
correspond with contact at Planned Parenthood
304 of 610
on same (.1); confer with J. Serrano regarding
(.2).
2161 6/9/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,750.00 Confer with N. Napolitan and J. Serrano

regarding
(0.4); phone call with counsel
for Arizona AG's office regarding same (0.2);
preparations for hearing in district court
regarding state AG subpoenas (1.1); phone
conference with counsel for StemExpress
regarding litigation status (0.3).
2162 6/9/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.80 1,767.00 Confer with J. Serrano regarding

(.4); research subpoena powers of the
Louisiana Inspector General (3.4).
research rules of the U.S. House, Energy
and Commerce Committee, and materials published
by the Select Investigative Panel; compose and
send email to N. Napolitan
2164 6/9/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.90 883.50 Correspond with J. Serrano regarding

(.1); research subpoena authority of
Louisiana Inspector General and correspond with
J. Serrano on same (1.8).
2165 6/9/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.20 2,384.00 Review and revise responses and objections to

discovery request (.9 hours); confer with team
regarding (.6 hours); confer
305 of 610
with C. Magana regarding
(.3 hours); coordinate
transmission of CDs to the court (.4 hours);
review amicus briefs (.5 hours); confer with
team regarding (.3 hours);
review work product regarding review of
documents produced by defendants (.2 hours).
2166 6/9/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Review and analyze Planned Parenthood's

opposition to Defendants' anti‐SLAPP motion in
related case for strategic overlap with issues
in NAF's case (0.5 hrs).
2167 6/9/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 4.40 3,190.00 Work on NAF objections to third party subpoena

in Planned Parenthood litigation (0.5);
research on powers and limitations of Louisiana
Inspector General and confer with A. Dale
regarding same 3.2); call with counsel from
Arizona Attorney General regarding subpoena and
confer with D. Foran and N. Napolitan regarding
same (0.7).
2168 6/9/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.40 186.00 Review amicus briefs.
2169 6/9/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.50 297.50 Review chart of video and audio files provided

by defendants referencing StemExpress.
2170 6/10/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.40 2,533.00 Prepare for and participate in call with client

regarding (.8 hours); draft and revise
objections and responses to discovery requests
(1.3 hours); confer with team regarding
(.3 hours); confer with
team regarding (.2 hours);
306 of 610
research discovery issue (.4 hours); review
work product regarding defendants' production
(.4 hours).
2171 6/10/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.30 773.50 Review chart of video and audio files provided

by defendants referencing StemExpress.
2172 6/10/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,312.50 Confer with J. Serrano and N. Napolitan re

(0.4); review
revised draft responses to subpoena issued in
Planned Parenthood matter (0.3); preparations
for court hearing regarding AG subpoenas (0.8).
2173 6/10/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.70 790.50 Correspond with D. Foran, J. Serrano, N.

(.3); review amicus
briefs submitted in support of NAF (1.4)
2174 6/13/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.30 604.50 Correspond with doctors contacted for amicus

brief (.1); correspond with N. Napolitan
regarding (.1);
review amicus briefs submitted in support of
NAF (1.1).
2175 6/13/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.60 1,192.00 Review and revise draft complaints (1.1 hours);

confer with J. Serrano regarding
(.1 hour); confer with team
2176 6/13/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Further revisions to objections and responses

to third party subpoena served on NAF in
Planned Parenthood matter.
307 of 610
2177 6/14/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.20 6,300.00 Prepare for and attend telephone conference
with court regarding Arizona and Louisiana AG
subpoenas (1.1); review draft complaints for
Arizona and Louisiana matters (1.2);
preparations for oral argument at Ninth Circuit
(4.9).
2178 6/14/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 279.00 Prepare for hearing on 9th Circuit appeal.
2179 6/14/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.00 1,490.00 Prepare for and participate in hearing (.9

hours); review court documents from related
cases (.4 hours); research subpoena issues (.4
hours); research Ninth Circuit procedural
issues (.3 hours).
2180 6/14/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 147.00 Email correspondence with amicus brief writers

regarding paper copy deadline (0.1 hrs); confer
(0.1 hrs).
2181 6/14/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Prepare for and attend status conference with

Court regarding state subpoenas (0.5).

(.1); confer with J.
Serrano regarding
(.2).
2183 6/14/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Review CMP blog post updates.
2184 6/14/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 128.00 Review amicus briefs filed with court.
2185 6/15/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 128.00 Review case schedule.
308 of 610

(.1).
2187 6/15/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.40 186.00 Review amicus briefs filed in support of NAF (.4).
2188 6/15/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 52.50 Re‐calendar deadlines.
2189 6/15/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 787.50 Review final draft of subpoena responses in

Planned Parenthood matter (0.2); prepare for
and attend phone conference with counsel for
Louisiana Inspector General regarding
(0.7).
2190 6/16/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 725.00 Review amicus briefs filed in Ninth Circuit

appeal on behalf of NAF.
2191 6/16/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.30 604.50 Confer with D. Foran and J. Serrano regarding
(.1); research state
investigations into fetal tissue procurement
and research (.2); correspond with D. Foran, C.
Robinson and R. Zack regarding
(.1); confer with D. Foran and C.
Robinson regarding (.5); confer
(.4).
2192 6/16/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,470.00 Confer with D. Foran and L. Brown regarding
(0.4 hrs); review CMP's reply
appeal brief for confidentiality concerns (0.6
309 of 610
hrs); analyze cases cited in CMP's reply appeal
brief (0.8 hrs); confer with A. Dale
(0.2 hrs).
2193 6/16/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.90 535.50 Read constitutional law professor's amicus

brief in support of preliminary injunction.
2194 6/16/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review case schedule.
2195 6/17/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.80 1,792.00 Review CMP's reply brief filed in Ninth

Circuit.
2196 6/17/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 232.50 Review news coverage of amicus briefs (.2);

review defendant's answer brief to Ninth
Circuit (.3)
2197 6/17/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.90 3,412.50 Email correspondence with counsel for Planned

(0.2); phone call with counsel
for Planned Parenthood regarding same (0.2);
review defendants' reply brief on appeal and
confer with N. Roethlisberger et al regarding
(3.5).
2198 6/19/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.00 465.00 Review defendants' reply brief (.9); correspond

with D. Foran and C. Robinson (.1).
2199 6/20/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.20 1,023.00 Review defendants' reply brief (1.8); confer

with N. Roethlisberger on (.1); confer
with N. Napolitan and R. Zack regarding
(.3)
310 of 610
2201 6/20/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.10 3,587.50 Review and analyze reply brief (2.3); legal

research regarding prior restraint cases cited
therein (1.0); confer with N. Napolitan
regarding (0.3); prepare notes for
oral argument (0.5).
2202 6/20/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.80 372.00 Prepare for hearing on 9th circuit appeal.

(.5); review reply brief (remainder).
2204 6/20/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.30 1,472.00 Analyze cases cited in CMP's reply brief filed

in Ninth Circuit.
2205 6/21/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.70 2,368.00 Analyze cases cited by CMP in reply brief.
2206 6/21/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 170.00 Confer with D. Foran.
2207 6/21/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.40 1,788.00 Review draft stipulation (.5 hours); review

record regarding protective order (.7 hours);
hours); review case law regarding first
amendment (.8 hours).

(0.2); review case law cited
in Ninth Circuit reply brief (0.9).
311 of 610
2210 6/21/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.20 1,488.00 Research laws regarding sale of human tissue
(.4); correspond with N. Napolitan and C.
Robinson on same (.1); prepare chart regarding
defendants' claims regarding excerpts.
2211 6/22/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.20 93.00 Review amicus briefs (.2)
2212 6/22/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 875.00 Further preparations for oral argument in Ninth

Circuit.
2213 6/22/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.40 1,788.00 Confer with A. Bomse regarding

(.4); participate in meet and confer regarding
protective order issues (.8 hours); review
record regarding protective order (.7 hours);
(.5 hours).
2214 6/22/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.60 1,024.00 Review cases cited by CMP in reply brief.
2215 6/23/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 128.00 Review cases cited in CMP's reply brief.
2216 6/23/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.60 1,192.00 Review draft stipulation regarding protective

order (.4 hours); prepare for oral arguments
(.5 hours); confer with A. Dale and R. Zack
regarding (.4
hours); research Ninth Circuit procedural
issues (.3 hours).
2217 6/23/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.00 2,325.00 Confer with J. Pazanno and J. Ramirez regarding

(.5); confer
(.1); update chart with analysis of cited video
and audio excerpts from defendants' briefs
312 of 610
(4.4).
2218 6/23/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Review court order regarding setting oral

argument on appeal (0.1); confer with N.
Napolitan regarding same (0.2).
2219 6/24/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.80 1,341.00 Review draft stipulation regarding protective

order (.3 hours); review hearing prep material
(.3 hours); review amicus briefs (1.1. hours).
2220 6/24/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 192.00 Review cases cited in CMP's reply brief.
2221 6/27/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.90 1,415.50 Review supreme court case regarding

reproductive rights (1.1 hours); confer with
team regarding same (.2 hours); review motion
to expedite (.6 hours).
2223 6/27/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.00 640.00 Review CMP's proposed motion for expedited oral

argument.
2224 6/27/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.20 93.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
(.1); correspond with J. Pazzano regarding
(.1).
2225 6/28/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.90 2,537.50 Revise opposition to motion to expedite appeal

(2.6); confer with L. Brown regarding
(0.3).
2226 6/28/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 697.50 Confer with A. Menzies to

(.5); review summaries of
313 of 610
amicus briefs (1.0)
2228 6/28/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.80 372.00 Research legal issues related to defendants

motion to expedite; prepare for hearing on
defendants' appeal.
2229 6/28/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Legal research in connection with NAF's

opposition to expedited oral argument (0.3
hrs); review and revise NAF's opposition (0.2
hrs).
2230 6/28/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 69.00 Distribute materials to client.
2231 6/28/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.10 3,904.00 Draft and file response to CMP's proposed

motion for expedited oral argument.
2232 6/28/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.30 968.50 Revise response to motion to expedite (1 hour);

review materials regarding congressional
subcommittee (.3 hours).
2233 6/29/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.90 1,415.50 Confer with counsel regarding

(.3 hours); review reply in support of
motion to expedite (.9 hours); review amicus
briefs (.7 hours).
2234 6/29/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.00 930.00 Prepare for hearing on Ninth Circuit appeal.
2235 6/29/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.40 651.00 Review summaries of amicus briefs and

correspond with J. Pazzano on same (.6); review
defendants' motion and reply to expedite and
confer with N. Roethlisberger on same (.6);
314 of 610
review letter from House Select Panel to New
Mexico Attorney General regarding fetal tissue
procurement and confer with R. Zack on same
(.2).
2236 6/29/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 0.10 59.50 Read appellants reply in support of expedited

review without oral argument.
2237 6/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 5.70 4,987.50 Review appellate record (5.6); review Ninth

Circuit order denying request to expedite oral
argument (0.1).
2238 6/29/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 448.00 Review CMP's reply in support of CMP's proposed

motion for expedited oral argument.
2239 6/30/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 3.00 1,395.00 Prepare for hearing on defendants' 9th Circuit

appeal.
2240 6/30/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 5,687.50 Review excerpts of record on appeal (6.1);

review reply on motion to expedite hearing
opposing counsel regarding subpoena served on
NAF in Planned Parenthood matter (0.1).
2241 6/30/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.90 472.50 Prepare for and attend meeting regarding NAF

presentation.
2242 6/30/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 207.00 Draft index of ER for attorney review.
2243 6/30/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.60 279.00 Review summaries of amicus briefs and

correspond with J. Ramirez on same (.6).
2244 6/30/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.40 298.00 Review amicus briefs.
315 of 610
2245 7/1/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Revise index.
2246 7/1/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.60 279.00 Review amicus brief summaries (.5); confer with

J. Ramirez on same (.1).
2247 7/1/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 875.00 Review and comment on draft index of excerpts

of record (0.5); continue review of excerpts of
record (0.5).
2248 7/1/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 3.00 1,395.00 Prepare for hearing on 9th Circuit appeal.
2249 7/1/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Confer with N. Napolitan and draft

correspondence to opposing counsel regarding
Lopez subpoena (0.5).
2250 7/1/2016 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 1.10 577.50 NAF presentation.
2251 7/1/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.30 223.50 Confer with J. Serrano regarding

(.3 hours).
2252 7/1/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review amicus brief summaries.
2253 7/5/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.90 1,415.50 Review work product regarding amicus briefs (.5

hours); draft response to inquiry regarding
third party subpoena (.4 hours); confer with D.
Foran regarding (.2 hours);
review appellate record (.4 hours); review
pending motions in related case (.4 hours).

(.3).
316 of 610
2255 7/5/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.40 1,863.00 Draft abbreviated indices of ER and SER
2256 7/5/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 6.70 3,115.50 Prepare for hearing on defendants 9th Circuit

appeal.
2257 7/6/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 1.70 790.50 Prepare for hearing on defendants 9th Circuit

appeal.
2258 7/6/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 5.80 4,321.00 Review pending motions in related case (1.5

hours); attend hearing in related case (3.5
hours); respond to inquiry regarding third
party subpoenas served on NAF from related case
(.2 hours); review protective order issues (.6
hours).
2259 7/6/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Email correspondence with N. Napolitan

regarding
2260 7/6/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 276.00 Revise ER/SER index.
2261 7/7/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.80 1,341.00 Review case law regarding preliminary

injunction (.8 hours); review work product
regarding same (.3 hours); research issues
regarding joint interest privilege (.5 hours);
confer with D. Foran regarding
(.2 hours).

appeal.
2263 7/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Review comments provided by N. Napolitan to
317 of 610
discovery letter in Planned Parenthood matter
regarding

appeal.
2265 7/8/2016 CHRIS MAGANA 3.90 2,320.50 Correspond with J. Serrano regarding

; research
and review legislation creating Inspector
General's Office; research and review court
cases addressing power of Louisiana subpoena to
compel production by out of state
third‐parties; email findings to J. Serrano.
2266 7/8/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.20 894.00 Review and revise work product for oral

argument (.6 hours); review draft letter brief
for related action (.6 hours).
2267 7/10/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 6.10 5,337.50 Review Excerpts of Record on appeal (5.9);

email correspondence with A. Dale Lauterbach
regarding (0.2).
2268 7/10/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 46.50 Correspond with D. Foran regarding
(.1).
2269 7/11/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 8.10 7,087.50 Review excerpts of record and prepare notes

regarding same (7.8); email correspondence with
A. Menzies regarding
(0.3).
2270 7/12/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.90 3,412.50 Continue review of excerpts of record and
318 of 610
prepare notes regarding same.
2271 7/12/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 372.00 Research legislative history of laws regulating

fetal tissue donation (.8)
2272 7/13/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 232.50 Research legislative history on fetal tissue

donation (.5).
2273 7/13/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 5.10 4,462.50 Continue review of excerpts of record and

prepare notes regarding same (4.7); email
correspondence with A. Menzies regarding
(0.2);
email correspondence with counsel for Planned
(0.2).
2274 7/14/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.90 3,412.50 Continue review of excerpts of record on

appeal.

appeal.
2276 7/14/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.70 1,720.50 Review Interim Report from House Committee on

Energy and Finance (3.5); correspond with D.
Foran regarding (.1); confer with N.
(.2).
2277 7/14/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 448.00 Review research regarding heckler's veto cases.
2278 7/15/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 192.00 Review exhibitor agreement language in

anticipation of appeals court hearing.
319 of 610
2279 7/15/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.70 1,720.50 Review Interim Report from House Committee on
Energy and Finance and draft summary of same
(2.0); research legislative history of fetal
tissue laws (1.6); correspond with D. Foran and
R. Zack on same (.1).

(.3 hours); review work product regarding RICO
(.2 hours).
2281 7/15/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 3.10 2,712.50 Continue review of excerpts of record.

appeal.
2283 7/18/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 276.00 Compile 9th cir documents for attorney review.

appeal.
(.2); coordinate
document preparations with T. Beyer (.1).
2286 7/18/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.10 2,309.50 Prepare for and attend meeting with counsel for

Planned Parenthood (1.5 hours); confer with
client regarding (.3 hours);
review work product regarding material produced
by defendants and prepare client proposal
regarding same (.8 hours); review work product
concerning RICO claims (.5 hours);
320 of 610
2287 7/19/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.30 832.00 Review research regarding heckler's veto cases.
2288 7/21/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 149.00 Draft email to client regarding
2289 7/21/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,187.50 Further review of excerpts of record on appeal.

appeal.
2291 7/25/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Continue review of excerpts of record on

appeal.
2292 7/25/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.20 894.00 Draft case status outline and prepare for

client meeting (1.1 hours); confer with D.
Foran regarding same (.1 hours).
2293 7/26/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.50 362.50 Provide comments to N. Napolitan regarding
2294 7/26/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Compile documents for attorney review; send

files to counsel for Planned Parenthood.
2295 7/26/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 512.00 Research regarding timing on appeals process.
2296 7/26/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.00 1,490.00 Confer with L. Brown regarding

(.2 hours); Confer with A. Bomse
regarding (.3 hours);
2297 7/28/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 448.00 Review research regarding heckler's veto.
2298 7/29/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review correspondence regarding research in

anticipation of Ninth Circuit hearing.
321 of 610
2299 7/29/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.50 697.50 Research legislative history of fetal tissue

donation laws.
2300 7/29/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 149.00 Draft email to A. Bomse regarding
2301 7/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 6,125.00 Travel to Washington to DC for client meetings

(6.0); prepare for client meetings (1.0).
2302 8/1/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 11.00 9,625.00 Meetings with NAF regarding
(4.0); travel from Washington D.C.
following client meetings (7.0)

(.3); research legislative history of
fetal tissue statutes (.7); correspond with D.
Foran on same (.1).

appeal.
2305 8/2/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.70 1,255.50 Research legislative history of fetal tissue

statutes (2.7)
2306 8/3/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 232.50 Research fetal tissue donation statutes (.5)
2307 8/8/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Review order regarding hearing and related

Ninth Circuit information (.2 hours); prepare
and file hearing acknowledgment form (.3
hours).
322 of 610
2308 8/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Review Ninth Circuit order regarding Ninth
Circuit oral argument (0.1); confer with client
regarding same (0.1); confer with N. Napolitan
2309 8/8/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 128.00 Review notice of oral argument.
2310 8/11/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 372.00 Review legislative history of fetal tissue

donation statutes (.5); review news coverage of
case (.3).

appeal.
2312 8/11/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.30 968.50 Revise and revise oral argument prep material.
2313 8/12/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 3.00 1,395.00 Prepare for 9th Circuit hearing on preliminary

injunction.

(.3 hours); review and revise oral argument
prep materials (.4 hours).
2316 8/15/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review order on protective order in related

Planned Parenthood case.
2317 8/16/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 1.20 1,020.00 Call with D. Foran regarding ;

collect materials for oral argument
preparation.
2318 8/17/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.10 74.50 Review correspondences from co‐counsel
323 of 610
regarding protective order in related case.
2319 8/17/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Phone call with L. Brown G1947
2320 8/19/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Review supplemental authority submitted by

appellants
2321 8/23/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.80 680.00 Prepare for oral argument.
2322 8/23/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 787.50 Prepare response to Rule 28(j) letter submitted

by CMP.

(.1); correspond with M.
Hearron regarding (.1); confer
with R. Zack on same (.2); research status of
reports from House Investigative Panel (1.0).
2324 8/24/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.20 93.00 Review news coverage of injunction and

litigation in Washington (.2).
2325 8/24/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.40 298.00 Review draft protective order (.2); confer with

A. Bomse regarding same.
2326 8/26/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.40 298.00 Review and revise letter to Ninth Circuit

regarding supplemental authority (.3 hours);
oversee filing of the same (.1 hour).
2327 8/26/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Confer with M. Hearron regarding

(0.1); revise response to
Rule 28(j) letter (0.4).
324 of 610
2328 8/26/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 1.70 1,445.00 Revise draft of Rule 28(j) letter; confer with
D. Foran regarding same; prepare for oral
argument.
2329 8/26/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 46.50 Review today's court filings and correspond

with D. Foran on same (.1).
2330 8/30/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 1.40 1,190.00 Prepare for oral argument.
2333 9/1/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.20 149.00 Review draft client contract.
2335 9/2/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.00 1,395.00 Research legal history of fetal tissue donation

laws (3.0).
2337 9/5/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.30 223.50 Review draft client contract.
2338 9/5/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.00 465.00 Research legislative history of fetal tissue

donation laws (1.0).
2339 9/6/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 372.00 Confer with N. Napolitan and A. Nakamura

regarding
Napolitan and A. Nakamura on same (.1); review
third party subpoena from Gerardo Adrian Lopez (.2).
325 of 610
2340 9/6/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.20 1,309.00 Review documents produced by NAF for
responsiveness to third‐party subpoena (1.8);
confer with N. Napolitan, A. Dale, T. Beyer, P.
Oropeza regarding same (.4).

(.5 hours); review records related
to third‐party subpoena (.4 hours); review
draft contracts (.2 hours); confer with L.
Brown regarding (.1 hour).
2342 9/6/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Assist in third party production.
2343 9/6/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 700.00 Prepare Lopez documents for production.
2344 9/6/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Review response to subpoena.

responsiveness to third‐party subpoena.

2349 9/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Conference with M. Hearron regarding
(0.4); email correspondence with client
2350 9/8/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Confer with team regarding oral argument
326 of 610
preparation.
2353 9/9/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.80 596.00 Review discovery issues (.4 hours); draft email

to A. Bomse regarding
(.4 hours).
2354 9/9/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Email correspondence with counsel for PP

regarding



2360 9/13/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.00 595.00 Review documents produced by NAF for

2362 9/13/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.80 966.00 Organize files.
327 of 610
2363 9/14/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Compile documents for Planned Parenthood's

counsel.
2365 9/14/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.80 1,302.00 Review defendants' appellate briefs and revise

chart cataloging excerpts cited and arguments
made on same (2.8).
2366 9/15/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.60 279.00 Review defendants' appellate briefs and revise

made on same (.6).
2367 9/15/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Meet with A. Nakamure regarding

; prepare documents for production.
2368 9/15/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Correspondence with counsel for Planned


hours); review documents to be produced (.4
hours).

responsiveness to third‐party subpoena (1.4);
confer with N. Napolitan regarding same (.4).
2372 9/16/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 420.00 Assist with preparation of Planned Parenthood

production documents.
328 of 610
2374 9/16/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.10 74.50 Confer with A. Nakamura regarding
2375 9/16/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 220.50 Review and revise NAF's letter to Governor

Brown regarding amending California's
anti‐wiretapping statute.
2376 9/16/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.30 1,483.50 Redact documents for production.
2377 9/17/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Review documents to be produced in response to

subpoena.
2380 9/18/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 1.20 714.00 Review documents produced by NAF for


responsiveness to third‐party subpoena and in
preparation for production (4.1); confer with
N. Napolitan regarding same (.6); review the
NAF and Planned Parenthood protective orders
related to disclosing witness names (.7);
2383 9/19/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.30 1,483.50 Assist preparing documents for production;

produce documents to opposing counsel; update
329 of 610
network drive.
2384 9/19/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.40 1,043.00 Review documents to be produced (.6 hours);

hours); revise cover letter (.2 hours); draft
email to L. Brown regarding (.2
hours).
2385 9/19/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 147.00 Telephone call with N. Napolitan regarding
2386 9/19/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 0.80 580.00 Call and correspond with Arizona AG office

regarding extension of time to challenge state
subpoenas; call with N. Napolitan regarding
(0.3); confer with A. Nakamura
regarding

made on same (1.4).
2389 9/20/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Review legal research notes prepared by A.

Nakamura regarding

330 of 610
made on same (2.1).
2392 9/20/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 103.50 Consolidate production materials.
2393 9/20/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 2.60 1,547.00 Research Ninth Circuit authority related to

whether communications between an association's
counsel and its members are covered by the
attorney client privilege or work product
doctrine.
2394 9/21/2016 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.80 476.00 Research Ninth Circuit authority related to

whether communications between an association's
counsel and its members are covered by the
attorney client privilege or work product
doctrine.
2396 9/21/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.10 1,564.50 Review motion to expand time for oral argument

and draft response to same.
2397 9/21/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 367.50 Review and comment on draft response to the

attorney generals' request for oral argument.
2398 9/21/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 725.00 Correspond with Louisiana IG regarding state

subpoenas; draft stipulation regarding
extension of time to respond to state
subpoenas; correspond with defense counsel
regarding same.
2399 9/21/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Correspondence with counsel for Arizona AG
331 of 610
regarding request for additional oral argument
time (0.1); review motion filed by Arizona AG
regarding same (0.2); review draft response
2400 9/22/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Participate in call with client regarding
2401 9/22/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 612.50 Phone conference with Lisa Brown et al

regarding
2404 9/23/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.40 298.00 Review appellants' motion regarding oral

argument.
2405 9/23/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.50 2,572.50 Prepare NAF's opposition to CMP's motion for

clarification regarding oral argument.
2406 9/23/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 262.50 Review motion to disclose enjoined materials at

oral argument (0.2); correspondence with
opposing counsel regarding same.
2407 9/23/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Produce documents.
2408 9/24/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Review draft opposition to motion to disclose

enjoined materials at oral argument and provide
comments on same.
2409 9/24/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.10 1,564.50 Draft preparation material for oral argument.
332 of 610

made on same (4.1).

made on same (3.0).
2413 9/26/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 220.50 Finalize NAF's response to CMP's motion for

clarification.

made on same (2.3).
2417 9/27/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 140.00 Update case calendar.
2418 9/30/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Compile ESI protocol for attorney review
2419 9/30/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 0.50 372.50 Review order in related case.
2420 9/30/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 256.00 Review order in Planned Parenthood case.
2421 9/30/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 0.80 372.00 Review motion to dismiss order in planned

parenthood case.
333 of 610
2423 10/2/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.20 1,639.00 Prepare for oral argument.

(.1); review and revise potential
questions for oral arguments (.4).
2426 10/4/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.60 279.00 Correspond with M. Hearron regarding

(.2); review and revise notes on
Partial Birth Abortion Act and congressional
investigations (.4).

appeal.
2430 10/5/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Research documents for appellate argument.
2431 10/5/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.10 2,309.50 Prepare for oral argument; participate in moot

oral arguments.
2432 10/5/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 930.00 Review and revise answers to potential oral

argument questions (1.4); confer with R. Zack
on same (.1); revise chart of excerpted
conversations cited by defendants in their
briefs (.5).
334 of 610
2434 10/6/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.90 1,415.50 Review motion to seal oral arguments (.3

hours); draft opposition to motion to seal oral
arguments (1.4 hours); confer with team
regarding same (.2 hours).
2436 10/6/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Compile materials for attorney review.
2437 10/6/2016 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 700.00 Prepare appeal and preliminary injunction

materials for subsequent attorney review.
2438 10/7/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 8.30 7,055.00 Revise opposition to motion to seal courtroom

and prepare for oral argument.
2439 10/7/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 437.50 Email correspondence with N. Napolitan and C.

Robinson regarding
2443 10/8/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 1.10 819.50 Prepare for Ninth Circuit oral argument.
335 of 610
2446 10/11/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.30 1,534.50 Participate in moot for oral arguments (2.1);

review court order on closed arguments (.1);
confer with M. Hearron regarding
(1.1).
2447 10/11/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 103.50 Compile video files and send to attorney.
2448 10/11/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 10.20 8,670.00 Prepare for oral argument; participate in first

moot.
2449 10/11/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 2.10 1,564.50 Participate in moot for Ninth Circuit oral

argument.
2451 10/13/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.60 744.00 Research laws regulating sale of human tissue

(.8); review news of new lawsuit against fetal
tissue procurement company (.2); correspond
with R. Zack on same (.1); research
investigations into Planned Parenthood (.5).
2453 10/13/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.50 517.50 Research and compile materials related to

Orange County lawsuit.
2454 10/13/2016 LINDA SHOSTAK 5.00 5,000.00 Prepare for mock argument.
2455 10/14/2016 LINDA SHOSTAK 4.00 4,000.00 Mock argument of NAF.
336 of 610
2457 10/14/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,750.00 Confer with M. Hearron re

(0.3); prepare for and
attend mock Ninth Circuit argument (1.7).
2458 10/14/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Download related complaint and distribute to

team.
2459 10/14/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.50 1,600.00 Prepare for oral argument at Ninth Circuit.
2460 10/14/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.70 1,255.50 Review complaint against Davinci Biologics

(.2); participate in moot court preparations
for oral arguments (2.5).
2461 10/15/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.50 232.50 Correspond with M. Hearron, N. Napolitan, and

C. Robinson regarding (.1);
correspond with research specialist regarding
resources on sales of human tissue (.1); review
same (.3).
2462 10/15/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 8.50 7,225.00 Travel to San Francisco for oral argument and

prepare for argument.
2464 10/16/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 4.00 1,860.00 Research fetal tissue donation statutes and

correspond with M. Hearron on same (.8); review
excerpts of record regarding conversations
related to intact D&E (1.8); correspond with M.
Hearron on same (.2); research laws regulating
sale of human tissue and correspond with M.
Hearron on same (1.0); review complaint against
Davinici (.2).
337 of 610
2466 10/17/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 1.80 837.00 Confer with M. Hearron regarding

(.7); review status of state investigations
into fetal tissue sales and summarize same
(.5); review video excerpts and correspond with
M. Hearron on same (.6).
2467 10/18/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 5.70 2,650.50 Commute to and from oral arguments (1.0);

attend oral arguments (4.0); confer with M.
Hearron regarding (.7).
2468 10/18/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.00 2,940.00 Attend Ninth Circuit oral argument on NAF's

2469 10/18/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 6.00 5,100.00 Prepare for and present oral argument.
2470 10/18/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 3,937.50 Attend Ninth Circuit oral argument.
2471 10/18/2016 LINDA SHOSTAK 5.00 5,000.00 Attend hearing and debrief with client.
2472 10/18/2016 JAVIER SERRANO 1.00 725.00 Attend Ninth Circuit oral argument.
2473 10/18/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.50 2,607.50 Prepare for and attend oral arguments; confer

with team regarding same.
2474 10/18/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 3.50 1,627.50 Prepare for and attend 9th Circuit argument.
2475 10/19/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 5.00 4,250.00 Travel to DC.
2476 10/28/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Email correspondence with J. Serrano regarding
338 of 610
2478 10/31/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.30 255.00 Confer with D. Foran and L. Hughes regarding
2479 11/3/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 1,837.50 Review closing arguments transcripts.
2480 11/3/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 787.50 Review correspondence from counsel for CMP

regarding latest congressional subpoena (0.2);
phone calls and emails with L. Brown and C.
Robinson regarding (0.7).
2481 11/4/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.70 1,487.50 Prepare correspondence to district court and

Ninth Circuit re latest congressional subpoena.
2482 11/4/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 172.50 Compile and print documents for attorney

review; send out calendar invites.
2483 11/4/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 46.50 Review Congressional subpoena and parties'

letters to district court on same (.3); confer
with N. Roethlisberger on same (.1).
2484 11/4/2016 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 735.00 Review and revise letters to Judge Orrick and

Ninth Circuit regarding Congressional subpoena
(0.5); telephone calls with P. Breen and D.
Foran regarding response to subpoena.
2485 11/4/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,750.00 Phone calls and emails regarding subpoena

issued by Select Panel and related matters.
339 of 610
2486 11/4/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 320.00 Research concerning Congressional subpoena.
2487 11/5/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 276.00 Draft protective order log.
2488 11/6/2016 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 3.00 2,235.00 Draft summary of production and confidentiality

issues.
2489 11/7/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 192.00 Research related to Congressional subpoena.
2491 11/7/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 10.00 8,750.00 Review latest correspondence from CMP to court

regarding Select Panel subpoena (0.3); draft
response to correspondence (0.4); legal
research for letter brief regarding Select
Panel subpoena (2.3); conferences with L. Brown
regarding
(0.5); draft letter brief regarding
Select Panel subpoena (6.5).
2492 11/7/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 69.00 Print discovery chart for attorney review.
2493 11/7/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 46.50 Review letters to district court regarding

congressional subpoena (.1).
2494 11/8/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 3,937.50 Revise and edit letter brief to court regarding

Select Panel subpoena.
2495 11/8/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.80 1,152.00 Research related to Congressional subpoena.
2496 11/8/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Cite check letter brief.
340 of 610
2497 11/9/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 2.80 2,380.00 Review legal materials in anticipation of
appeal of Congressional subpoena.
2498 11/9/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 7.90 6,912.50 Review correspondence from Fetal Life Panel

regarding subpoena for preliminary injunction
materials (0.5); conferences with L. Brown
regarding (1.1); prepare for hearing on
motion to modify preliminary injunction to
allow second disclosure to congress (5.2);
attend hearing regarding same (0.8); follow up
correspondence and phone calls with L. Brown et
al regarding
(0.3).
2500 11/10/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 962.50 Further conference with L. Brown regarding
2501 11/10/2016 MARC A. HEARRON 0.70 595.00 Review legal materials in anticipation of

appeal regarding Congressional subpoena.
2502 11/14/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.30 139.50 Review court filings.
2503 11/14/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,312.50 Prepare for and attend teleconference with L.

Brown et al regarding
(1.3); prepare
correspondence to court regarding same (0.2).
2504 11/14/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 192.00 Research related to Congressional subpoena.
341 of 610
2505 11/16/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Phone conferences with L. Brown et al regarding
2506 11/16/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.30 139.50 Review preliminary injunction out of Washington

state court (.3).
2507 11/17/2016 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.20 93.00 Review correspondence with the House Select

Investigative Panel (.2).
2508 11/21/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Email correspondence with Arizona local counsel

regarding status of Arizona AG subpoena and
related matters.
2509 11/25/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 87.50 Email correspondence regarding notice of

withdrawal for L. Shostak.
2510 11/28/2016 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 345.00 Draft notices of withdraw for L. Shostak.
2511 11/28/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger
2512 11/28/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 64.00 Draft withdrawal papers for L. Shostak.
2513 11/29/2016 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 256.00 Draft withdrawal papers for L. Shostak.
2514 11/29/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Review notices to withdraw for L. Shostak.
2515 12/7/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 350.00 Review opposition to motion to stay trial court

proceedings in related Planned Parenthood
matter.
2516 12/12/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Confer with L. Shostak regarding
342 of 610
2517 12/15/2016 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 175.00 Review stipulated order regarding stay of trial

court proceedings pending Ninth Circuit appeal.
2518 12/28/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.50 1,162.50 Research procedure to get permanent injunction

at motion for summary judgment.
2519 12/29/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.00 930.00 Research procedure to get permanent injunction

2520 12/30/2016 RANDY D. ZACK 2.00 930.00 Research procedure to get permanent injunction

2521 1/3/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 364.00 Phone conference with California AG's office

regarding NAF meeting attendees (0.2); review
court order in Planned Parenthood matter
denying motion to stay federal claims (0.2)
2522 1/3/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 3.90 2,106.00 Research legal issue regarding permanent

injunction on motion for summary judgment.
2523 1/4/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 1.60 864.00 Research legal issue regarding permanent

injunction on motion for summary judgment.
2524 1/5/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Email correspondence with L. Brown regarding
2525 1/9/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 364.00 Phone call with L. Brown regarding
2526 1/11/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 1.20 1,092.00 Review Rule 28(j) letter filed by CMP (0.3);

phone calls and emails with L. Brown regarding
343 of 610
(0.4); prepare for and
attend phone conference with M. Hearron and C.
Robinson regarding
(0.5).
2527 1/11/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Download and distribute CMP press release.
2528 1/11/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.50 1,177.50 Review CMP's statement of supplemental

authority (1.0); confer with D. Foran and M.
Hearron regarding (0.5).
2529 1/11/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 1.00 885.00 Read CMP's Rule 28(j) letter and confer with D.

Foran and C. Robinson.
2530 1/12/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 9.00 7,965.00 Read Congressional report and prepare Rule

28(j) letter.
2531 1/13/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 3.10 2,743.50 Revise Rule 28(j) letter and oversee filing.
2532 1/18/2017 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.50 1,350.00 Review recent Congressional report on fetal

tissue (2.5).
2533 1/18/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 364.00 Review recent Ninth Circuit case re invasion of

privacy and related matters for potential Rule
28(j) letter.
2534 1/19/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 364.00 Emails with N. Roethlisberger and C. Robinson

regarding
2535 1/19/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 556.00 Review recent decision for possible Rule 28j

letter to Ninth Circuit.
344 of 610
2537 1/31/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Phone conference with A. Bomse regarding

2539 2/10/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Emails with R. Evans regarding amicus briefs

filed in Ninth Circuit.
2540 2/13/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Review and provide comment on draft outline of

amicus briefs in Ninth Circuit prepared by A.
Dale‐Lauterbach.
2541 2/13/2017 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.90 486.00 Prepare summaries of amicus briefs for Planned

Parenthood (.8); confer with D. Foran on same
(.1).
2542 2/14/2017 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.10 54.00 Correspond with D. Foran and contacts at

(.1).
2543 2/14/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Emails with R. Evans regarding amicus briefs

filed in Ninth Circuit.
2544 2/15/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Phone conferences with A. Dale‐Lauterbach

regarding
345 of 610
(.1); confer with J. Chung at Legal
Voice regarding amicus brief for Washington
case (.4).
2548 3/8/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 273.00 Review case management statement filed in

2549 3/8/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 69.50 Review filings in Planned Parenthood case.
2551 3/14/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 157.00 Analyze discovery issues raised by Planned

Parenthood in their discovery letter to the
Court.
2552 3/14/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Review discovery motion filed in Planned

Parenthood related matter.
2554 3/21/2017 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.60 390.00 Draft withdrawal papers for N. Napolitan.
2555 3/24/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 1,020.50 Meet and confer with counsel for the Arizona

and Louisiana attorneys general (0.5); prepare
revised stipulation to extend deadline to
challenge state subpoenas (0.5); meet and
confer with defendants regarding requested
346 of 610
stipulation (0.3).

regarding stipulation to extend deadline to
challenge state subpoenas (0.1); revise
stipulation to address updated information from
defendants' counsel (0.2).
2557 3/27/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Review notices of withdrawal of counsel filed

in district court (0.1); review correspondence
with opposing counsel regarding stipulating
extending deadline for Arizona and Louisiana
litigation (0.1).
2558 3/28/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,820.00 Review Cal AG criminal complaint and supporting

affidavit (1.3); phone conferences with client
and L. Shostak regarding (0.7).
2560 3/28/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 36.00 Send out calendar invite.
2561 3/29/2017 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 60.00 Review Ninth Circuit decision.
2562 3/29/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 314.00 Review criminal complaint and affidavit file

against David Daleiden.
2563 3/29/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 392.50 Prepare Rule 28(j) letter regarding criminal

complaint against Daleiden.
2564 3/29/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 392.50 Conference with D. Foran and N. Napolitan
347 of 610
regarding
2565 3/29/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 785.00 Calculate timing of next steps on appeal and at

district court level.
2566 3/29/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 5.00 4,550.00 Review Ninth Circuit decision affirming

preliminary injunction and dissent therefrom
(1.0); phone conferences
with case team re
(2.5).
2567 3/29/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 3.00 1,620.00 Review Daleiden indictment; review Ninth

Circuit order; draft portal announcement
2568 3/29/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 72.00 Update team calendar.
2569 3/29/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 417.00 Review order affirming preliminary injunction.
2570 3/29/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.50 442.50 Review Ninth Circuit decision and confer with

Morrison team regarding
2571 3/30/2017 ASHLEY NAKAMURA 0.50 325.00 File N. Napolitan's withdrawal papers.
2572 3/31/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 471.00 Confer with D. Foran and M. Hearron regarding
2573 3/31/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 910.00 Prepare for and attend phone conference with C.

Robinson and M. Hearron regarding
348 of 610
2574 3/31/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.50 442.50 Telephone conference with D. Foran and C.
Robinson regarding
2575 4/3/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Assist with bill of costs for appeal.
2576 4/4/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Review bill of costs for appeal.
2577 4/4/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 69.50 Review filings in Ninth Circuit.
2578 4/6/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 108.00 Research D. Daleiden defense funding website.
2579 4/12/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 1.30 1,183.00 Review petition for panel or en banc rehearing

filed in Ninth Circuit (1.2); confer with C.
Robinson regarding
(0.1).
2580 4/12/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Convert recent news articles.
2581 4/12/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.40 354.00 Review petition for rehearing.
2582 4/12/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 347.50 Review petition for rehearing en banc.
2583 4/17/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 157.00 Email correspondence with Louisiana AG

regarding stipulation for extension to meet and
confer regarding state subpoenas.
2584 4/18/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 549.50 Prepare stipulation to extend deadline to

respond to state subpoenas.
2585 4/18/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 235.50 Email correspondence with defendants regarding

state subpoena deadline.
2586 4/18/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 2.20 2,002.00 Email correspondence with potential amici in
349 of 610
support of petition for rehearing en banc
(0.1); emails with C. Robinson regarding
(0.1); prepare for
meeting with clients regarding case status and
plans for trial court litigation (2.0).
2587 4/19/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.60 546.00 Correspondence with counsel for Arizona AG

regarding proposed amicus brief in Ninth
Circuit (0.2); phone call with counsel for
Planned Parenthood regarding (0.4).
2588 4/19/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 288.00 Perform searches in database for co‐counsel.
2589 4/20/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 78.50 Email with PP counsel regarding
2590 4/21/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 8.20 7,462.00 Travel for meetings with client regarding
2591 4/22/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,820.00 Attend client meetings regarding
2592 4/24/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 9.00 8,190.00 Return travel from meetings with client.
2593 4/25/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 1.30 1,183.00 Review amicus briefs filed in Ninth Circuit in

support of petition for rehearing.
2594 4/27/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 288.00 Review CMP website and draft e‐mail regarding

changes.
2595 4/27/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 273.00 Confer with client regarding
350 of 610
2596 5/5/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 637.00 Review order denying petition for rehearing en

banc (0.2); confer with C. Robinson and M.
Hearron regarding same (0.3); confer with L.
Brown regarding (0.2).
2597 5/21/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 273.00 Confer with J. Eisenberg regarding Life Legal

Defense Foundation.
2598 5/22/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Confer with L. Brown re
2599 5/23/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 6.20 5,642.00 Legal research in connection with potential

early summary judgment on contract claim (1.2);
legal research re standards governing permanent
injunction (4.8); confer with client re
(0.2).
2600 6/7/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.90 625.50 Review motion to disqualify judge.
2601 6/7/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 1.50 810.00 Legal and fact research related to Defendants

motion for judicial disqualification.
2602 6/8/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 1.20 648.00 Fact research in response to motion to

disqualify.
2603 6/8/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.30 265.50 Revise draft of letter to Judge Orrick

regarding disqualification motion and confer
with D. Foran regarding same.
2604 6/8/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 6.80 6,188.00 Review motion to disqualify Judge Orrick and

supporting affidavit (1.5); prepare letter to
351 of 610
the court regarding request to stay contempt
proceeding in light of motion to disqualify
(2.1); prepare draft outline for opposition to
motion to disqualify (0.7); legal research in
connection with motion to disqualify (1.9);
review court's initial order on motion to
disqualify (0.3); confer with client regarding
(0.3).
2605 6/8/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.70 2,571.50 Research related to motion to disqualify judge.
2606 6/8/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.50 1,050.00 Assist with preparation of motion to disqualify

judge Orrick.
2607 6/8/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 216.00 Research regarding disqualify motion.
2608 6/9/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.00 1,440.00 Review court orders; secure documents; compile

documents and send to attorney; send files to
client; conduct attorney support operations
regarding weekend support.
2609 6/9/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Review court order referring motion to

disqualify to Judge Donato.
2610 6/9/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 3,127.50 Research on motion to disqualify judge (4.5

hr.)
2611 6/9/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 6.20 3,348.00 Legal research related to sanctions for motion

to disqualify; review order on motion to
disqualify
2612 6/10/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 819.00 Confer with counsel for Good
352 of 610
Samaritan Family Resource Center regarding
2613 6/10/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.80 648.00 Compile case law cited in motion to disqualify;

compile and organize documents to be sent to D.
Foran.
2614 6/10/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.60 2,502.00 Condcut research regarding motion to disqualify judge.
2615 6/11/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,365.00 Prepare motion to seal Good Samaritan Family

Resource Center donor names and addresses
(1.3); confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
same (0.2).
2616 6/11/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Compile documents and send to attorney.
2617 6/11/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.00 1,390.00 Draft motion to seal document filed in support

of motion to disqualify judge.
2618 6/12/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.60 1,112.00 Finalize and file sealing papers

related to motion to disqualify judge (1.6 hr).
2619 6/12/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Draft Fowler declaration to opposition to

motion to disqualify.
2620 6/12/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 7.30 6,643.00 Prepare motion to seal Daleiden affidavit filed

in connection with disqualification motion
(2.1); prepare draft letter to Judge Donato
regarding disclosure of Judge Orrick's home
address on CMP counsel's website (0.9); emails
with M. Fowler regarding
(0.2);
353 of 610
review draft Fowler declaration (0.2); draft
background section for opposition to motion to
disqualify (3.9).
2621 6/12/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 9.10 4,914.00 Research case law and facts for

disqualification motion; review letter to Judge
Donato regarding Judge Orrick personal
information.
2622 6/13/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 6.10 3,294.00 Research for disqualification

opposition; draft part of disqualification
opposition.
2623 6/13/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 7.90 7,189.00 Review draft Paz declaration in support of

opposition to disqualification motion (0.2);
confer with M. Hearron regarding
(0.3);
revise draft opposition to disqualification
motion (5.1); phone call with V. Podberesky
regarding contempt proceedings (0.1); review
motion to disqualify Judge Orrick filed in
related Planned Parenthood matter (0.9); confer
with counsel for Planned
(0.6); review legal research notes prepared in
connection with disqualification motion (0.8).
2624 6/13/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.50 1,620.00 Revise declarations for motions to disqualify

judge; fill in fact cites in opposition to
motion to disqualify; arrange for declaration
of M. Paz to be signed and delivered.
2625 6/13/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.80 840.00 Download and organize court documents (2);
354 of 610
Organize court orders (.8).
2626 6/13/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 5.00 4,425.00 Prepare draft of opposition to disqualification

motion.
2627 6/14/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 5.40 4,779.00 Prepare draft of opposition to disqualification

motion.
2628 6/14/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 6.40 5,824.00 Revise opposition to motion to disqualify Judge

Orrick (5.2); confer with M. Mayo regarding
(0.3); confer with L. Shostak
regarding (0.2); confer
with M. Hearron regarding
(0.2); conduct legal research
regarding evidence issues in connection with
motion to disqualify (0.5).
2629 6/14/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 450.00 Assist with preparation of filing of opposition

to motion to disqualify Judge Orrick.
2630 6/14/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.70 252.00 Research fact cites for opposition to motion to

disqualify.
2631 6/15/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.00 2,100.00 Assist with preparation of opposition to motion

to disqualify Judge Orrick.
2632 6/15/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 5.20 4,602.00 Revise draft of opposition to disqualification

motion.
2633 6/15/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 364.00 Review statement of

non‐opposition to request to seal Schedule B
filed in connection with disqualification
355 of 610
motion (0.2); confer with counsel for Good
Samaritan regarding same (0.2);
2634 6/16/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 1.90 1,681.50 Revise and oversee filing of opposition to

disqualification motion.

to motion to disqualify Judge Orrick.
2636 6/16/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 1.40 1,274.00 Review and provide comment on revised

opposition to disqualification motion (1.2);
confer with counsel for Planned Parenthood
regarding
(0.2).
2637 6/16/2017 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 300.00 Review filings in relation to motion to

withdraw and motion to disqualify.
2638 6/18/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Confer with counsel for Planned

(0.2).
2639 6/19/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.80 840.00 Prepare and transmit materials regarding

opposition to motion to disqualify Judge
Orrick.
2640 6/19/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 4.10 3,731.00 Prepare for hearing on motion to disqualify

Judge Orrick (4.1).
2641 6/20/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 9.40 8,554.00 Prepare for hearing on motion to disqualify

Judge Orrick (7.9); review and analyze reply in
support of motion to disqualify Judge Orrick
356 of 610
(1.5).
2642 6/21/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 4.10 2,214.00 Prepare for hearing on motion to disqualify.
2643 6/21/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 450.00 Review and edit billing time notes.
2644 6/21/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 7.90 7,189.00 Prepare for hearing on motion to disqualify.
2645 6/22/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 4.70 4,277.00 Condcut final preparations for hearing on motion to

disqualify Judge Orrick (2.5); attend hearing
on motion to disqualify Judge Orrick (2.0); confer
with client (0.2);
2646 6/22/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 4.00 2,160.00 Prepare for and attend hearing on motion to

disqualify.
2647 6/26/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 819.00 Review order denying motion to disqualify Judge

Orrick (0.5); emails with L. Brown et al.
regarding (0.4)
2648 6/26/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 324.00 Review order on disqualification.
2649 6/26/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.30 265.50 Review order regarding disqualification motion.
2650 6/27/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.30 265.50 Review draft letter regarding decision on

disqualification decision and confer with team
regarding same.
2651 6/27/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 486.50 Review transcript from disqualification

hearing.
2652 6/27/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 455.00 Review Planned Parenthood's opposition to

motion to disqualify Judge Orrick (0.5).
357 of 610
2653 7/5/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 455.00 Review Daleiden's

reply in support of motion to disqualify Judge
Orrick in Planned Parenthood case (0.5).
2654 8/3/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Email with M. Hearron regarding
2655 8/3/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 1.90 1,681.50 Review certiorari petitions filed by Daleiden

and Newman.
2656 8/3/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 108.00 Review new videos from CMP; compile documents

for attorney review.
2657 8/3/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 392.50 Review and analyze Defendants' cert petitions.
2658 8/4/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 2,730.00 Review petitions for certiorari (1.8); review

objections to application for costs (1.2).
2659 8/4/2017 RANDY D. ZACK 1.50 810.00 Review Defendants response to attorneys fees

motion.
2660 8/5/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Review and compile defendant filings from

previous day (.50); send filings to client
(.20).
2661 8/7/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.40 354.00 Confer with D. Simon regarding
2662 8/8/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Review waiver of right to respond to certiorari

petition filed in Supreme Court.
2663 8/8/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 177.00 Oversee filing of waiver form in Supreme Court.
358 of 610
2664 8/11/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Review notice from Supreme Court regarding

(0.2).
2665 8/14/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Update case calendar and send out invitations.
2667 8/14/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Correspond with potential amici regarding
2668 8/16/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Review correspondence from counsel for Newman

et al. regarding
2669 8/17/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,820.00 Condcut further review of petitions for certiorari from

Ninth Circuit affirmance of preliminary
injunction.
(0.4); confer with L. Brown
regarding
(0.1);
correspond with amici in support of
Daleiden regarding request to file amicus brief
in Supreme Court (0.1).
2671 8/21/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.30 265.50 Email D. Foran regarding
2672 8/22/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Correspond with Arizona AG's office
359 of 610
regarding request to consent to filing of
amicus brief in Supreme Court.
2673 8/22/2017 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 60.00 Respond to email regarding
2674 8/23/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 72.00 Docket and update calendar.
2675 8/25/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Correspond with counsel for Mississippi

Justice Institute regarding intent to file
amicus brief in Supreme Court.
2676 8/27/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Review correspondence from counsel for Daleiden

regarding notice of filing of petition for
certiorari in Supreme Court.
2677 8/31/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 78.50 Review and analyze Court order regarding NAF's

application for attorney's fees and costs.
2678 9/5/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.60 531.00 Review amicus briefs.
2679 9/6/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 910.00 Review amicus briefs filed in Supreme Court.
2680 9/7/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 273.00 Correspond with defendants' counsel

regarding schedule for motions to stay (0.1);
email with L. Brown regarding
(0.1); email with
(0.1).
2681 9/20/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Docket calendar entries and distribute.
2682 9/26/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 180.00 Add calendar entries and distribute to team.
360 of 610
2683 9/26/2017 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.10 60.00 Review and respond to calendar invites.
2684 9/28/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 273.00 Confer with A. Bomse regarding
2685 9/28/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.10 88.50 Work on draft of response to motions for stay.
2687 10/6/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.10 88.50 Review and sign Supreme Court waiver.
2688 10/9/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.70 619.50 Oversee filing of waiver form in Supreme Court

and electronically serve form (0.3); review and
comment on draft notice of supplemental
material (0.4).
2689 10/11/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 273.00 Conduct phone calls and emails regarding

(0.3).
2690 10/13/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 455.00 Phone call with Financial Times regarding the NAF case.
2691 10/17/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 364.00 Review order denying disqualification motion in

Planned Parenthood matter and correspond
with L. Brown regarding
2692 10/23/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 177.00 Email N. Roethlisberger regarding
2693 10/25/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Email with L. Brown regarding
361 of 610
2694 11/1/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Correspond with counsel for Planned
2696 11/10/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Review joint status report submitted in Planned

Parenthood related matter.
2697 11/13/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 36.00 Distribute research project materials to

associate.
2698 11/13/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.60 531.00 Confer with D. Foran and B. Nelson regarding
2699 11/14/2017 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 36.00 Grant access to new associate.
2700 11/17/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 364.00 Confer with counsel for Planned Parenthood

regarding
(0.2); review email from B. Nelson
(0.2).
2701 11/20/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Email with B. Nelson regarding

(0.1); phone conference with L. Brown regarding
362 of 610
(0.2).
2703 11/27/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 177.00 Review orders calling for responses to cert

petitions and send to client and internal team.
2704 12/4/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 91.00 Email with B. Nelson regarding
2705 12/6/2017 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 314.00 Condcut email correspondence with PPFA's counsel

regarding
2706 12/6/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 273.00 Confer with A. Bomse regarding
2710 12/13/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.20 177.00 Confer with D. Simon regarding
2711 12/13/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 182.00 Review Ninth Circuit writ filed by Center for Medical

Progress and Daleiden from orders denying
disqualification motions (1.0); email correspondence
with L. Brown regarding (0.1).
2712 12/17/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 690.00 Prepare chart regarding notice of appearances

for Center for Medical Progress.
363 of 610
2713 12/18/2017 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.30 390.00 Update chart regarding notice of appearances

for Center for Medical Progress.
2714 12/19/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.40 354.00 Revise and oversee filing of letter seeking

extension of time for responses to certiorari
petitions.
2715 12/20/2017 MARC A. HEARRON 0.10 88.50 Review order granting extension of time for

certiorari oppositions.
2716 12/22/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 4.60 4,186.00 Research case law in connection with

response to petitions for certiorari.
2717 12/26/2017 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 347.50 Review petition for writ of mandamus on

disqualification of Judge Orrick.
2718 12/28/2017 DEREK F. FORAN 5.10 4,641.00 Research facts and legal background in

connection with pending oppositions to
petitions for writ of certiorari filed in
Supreme Court.
2721 1/8/2018 MARC A. HEARRON 3.00 2,775.00 Prepare opposition to certiorari petitions.
364 of 610
2729 1/16/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Print documents for D. Foran.
2730 1/16/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Correspond with opposing counsel regarding

deadline for response to cert petition.
2734 1/19/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Correspond with L. Brown regarding
2737 1/23/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Distribute materials to team and client.
365 of 610
2739 1/23/2018 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.30 1,039.50 Prepare Center for Medical Progress and Daleiden

opening briefing materials for subsequent attorney
review.
2740 1/24/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Send out calendar invites for appellate

deadlines.
2743 1/26/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Compile and distribute filings.
2745 1/29/2018 MARC A. HEARRON 0.60 555.00 Prepare opposition to certiorari petitions.
2746 1/30/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Research court documents to send exemplars to

counsel for parallel case.
2747 1/30/2018 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.30 1,354.50 Review potential new Center for Medical Progress

video footage and press releases.
366 of 610
2752 2/7/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.30 4,192.50 Confer with A.
Bomse regarding
(0.2); revise response to petitions for
certiorari (4.1).
2754 2/8/2018 MARC A. HEARRON 4.40 4,070.00 Prepare draft of certiorari opposition.
2755 2/8/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,950.00 Revise response to petitions for certiorari.
2756 2/9/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.70 2,632.50 Revise response to petitions for

certiorari.
2759 2/13/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.30 2,242.50 Review and revise

response to petitions for certiorari (2.3).
2760 2/13/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Organize network drive and send out calendar

invites.
2763 2/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.20 1,170.00 Review and provide comment on draft response to

petitions for certiorari.
2764 2/15/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.30 1,267.50 Review and provide comments on response to

petitions for certiorari.
367 of 610
2767 2/16/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Draft COS; serve documents and update network

drive.
2768 2/19/2018 MARC A. HEARRON 2.10 1,942.50 Prepare draft of opposition to certiorari

petitions.
2770 2/20/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.00 3,900.00 Review and edit draft opposition to petitions

for certiorari.
2771 2/20/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Compile documents for attorney review; send

motion to maintain seal to opposing counsel.
2772 2/21/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Update attorney access to network drive.
2773 2/21/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,950.00 Review and provide further comment on draft

opposition to writ of certiorari petitions.
368 of 610
2780 2/26/2018 MARC A. HEARRON 4.20 3,885.00 Revise and oversee filing of opposition to

certiorari petitions.
2781 2/28/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.50 570.00 Download documents from Pacer; create shell for

opposition; compile and distribute materials to
attorney team.
2782 2/28/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Review order from Ninth Circuit regarding writ

of mandamus from order denying motion to
disqualify Judge Orrick (0.2); confer with
(0.2).
2783 2/28/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.20 1,683.00 Review Petitioners' writ concerning

disqualification of Judge Orrick.
2784 3/1/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.80 1,444.00 Send out calendar entries; update distribution

list; cite check motion for extension; compile
materials for attorney review; assist with
filing of documents.
2785 3/1/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 6,825.00 Confer with counsel for Planned Parenthood regarding
(0.3); draft motion
to extend time to respond to writ on
disqualification order (0.8); confer with N.
(0.2); call with Ninth Circuit regarding
motion to extend time (0.3); confer with L.
369 of 610
Brown regarding
(0.3); draft opposition to
writ on disqualification order (5.1).
2786 3/1/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.40 1,071.00 Draft motion for extension for filing

opposition to writ petition.
2787 3/2/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Compile Ninth Circuit orders for attorney review.
2788 3/5/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 6.90 6,727.50 Confer with N.

(0.4); draft opposition
to writ from order denying motion to disqualify
Judge Orrick (6.5)
2789 3/5/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.80 1,824.00 Cite check motion to maintain seal; serve

documents to opposing counsel; meet with N.
Roethlisberger regarding ; add
fact cites to answering brief.
2790 3/5/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.80 2,907.00 Research in support of opposition to writ

petition on judicial disqualification.
2791 3/6/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.80 1,064.00 Arrange for service of hard copy documents;

fill in fact cites in answering brief; draft
insert for answering brief.
2792 3/6/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 8.10 7,897.50 Prepare opposition to writ on order denying

motion to disqualify Judge Orrick.
2793 3/7/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.50 1,710.00 Assist with drafting Ninth Circuit answering brief.
370 of 610
2794 3/7/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.70 5,890.50 Conduct research in support of opposition to writ
2795 3/8/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Review legal research notes prepared by N.

Roethlisberger for opposition to writ on order
denying motion to disqualify Judge Orrick
(0.3); confer with A. Bomse regarding
(0.1).
2796 3/8/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.00 1,520.00 Assist with answering brief; compile case law

cited in writ regarding judicial disqualification.

2798 3/9/2018 MARC A. HEARRON 0.50 462.50 Confer with team and counsel for Planned

2799 3/9/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Assist with answering brief.
2800 3/9/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.80 1,755.00 Revise response to writ on order denying motion

to disqualify Judge Orrick (1.5); confer
with A. Bomse regarding (0.2); review Ninth
Circuit order on briefing schedule for
disqualification writ (0.1).
2801 3/12/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 6,337.50 Review replies submitted by defendants in

support of petitions for certiorari and emails
with client regarding (0.3);
draft opposition to
mandamus petition from disqualification order
(6.2).
371 of 610
2802 3/12/2018 MARC A. HEARRON 0.70 647.50 Review certiorari replies filed by Center for Medical

Progress and T. Newman.

2804 3/13/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.20 1,216.00 Meet with N. Roethlisberger regarding

; compile dates and figures for attorney
review for answering brief; fill in fact cites
and compile documents in SER for answering
brief.

(0.8); revise draft
opposition to mandamus petition regarding
disqualification order (5.1).
2806 3/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 7.40 7,215.00 Review legal research notes prepared by N.

Roethlisberger for opposition to mandamus
petition on disqualification order (0.7);
confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
(0.6);
revise opposition to mandamus petition on
2807 3/14/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 3,442.50 Review petition on judicial disqualification.
2808 3/14/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Review and revise writ for judge disqualification.
372 of 610
2809 3/15/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Revise answer to writ for judicial disqualification
2810 3/15/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.20 3,978.00 Draft opposition to writ petition on judicial

disqualification.
2811 3/16/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.30 1,634.00 Revise answer to writ regarding

disqualification of judge.

disqualification.
2813 3/16/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
(0.1); review insert
provided by S. Brill for same (0.3).
2814 3/19/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,462.50 Revise

draft opposition to writ of mandamus regarding

disqualification.
2816 3/20/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 153.00 Revise opposition to writ petition on judicial

disqualification.
2817 3/21/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.90 1,453.50 Revise opposition to writ petition on judicial

disqualification.

disqualification.
373 of 610
2819 3/22/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.80 2,730.00 Email with opposing counsel regarding request
for extra time to file reply in support of writ
petition on disqualification order (0.1);
revise draft brief in opposition to mandamus
writ on disqualification order (2.7).

disqualification.
2821 3/25/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 382.50 Review Planned Parenthood draft opposition to

writ petition on judicial disqualification.

disqualification.
2823 3/27/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 5.30 5,167.50 Conduct initial review and revision of brief in response

to petition for writ of mandamus from order
denying motion to disqualify Judge Orrick.

disqualification.
2825 3/28/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.80 3,672.00 Revise and finalize opposition to writ petition

on judicial disqualification.
2826 3/28/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.60 585.00 Review district court's response to writ on

disqualification order and confer with client
regarding same.
2827 4/2/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 877.50 Review order denying petition for certiorari in

Supreme Court and phone calls and emails with
client regarding (0.9)
374 of 610
2829 4/5/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 780.00 Phone call with counsel for Planned Parenthood

regarding
(0.3);
phone call with counsel
for Arizona AG regarding subpoena (0.2)

(0.5); telephone call with A. Bomse
(0.5).
2831 4/5/2018 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 315.00 Update court documents database for subsequent

attorney review.
2832 4/5/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 668.00 Strategize with D. Foran and J. Korr regarding

(.4); analyze pleadings (.4).
2833 4/6/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Email with L. Brown

regarding
(0.3).
2834 4/9/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Confer with N. Roethlisberger and D. Maltzer

regarding
2835 4/9/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.70 1,419.50 Strategize with N. Roethlisberger regarding

(.8); prepare for and
attend meeting with N. Roethlisberger and C.
Robinson regarding (.5); review
news articles related to matter (.4).
375 of 610
2836 4/9/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.50 1,912.50 Research on possible summary judgment motion.
2837 4/11/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.10 1,753.50 Research permanent injunctions.
2838 4/12/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.20 1,002.00 Strategize with N. Roethlisberger regarding

(.4); research
statutory and case law related to permanent
injunctions (.8).
2839 4/12/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 459.00 Research on possible summary judgment motion.
2840 4/16/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 668.00 Research preliminary injunctions in the context

of summary judgment.
2841 4/17/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.40 2,004.00 Research preliminary injunctions in context of

summary judgment.
2842 4/17/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 334.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger and D. Maltzer

regarding
2845 4/20/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.70 584.50 Research case law related to preliminary

injunctions.
2846 4/24/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.20 1,837.00 Research preliminary injunctions in the context

of summary judgment motions.

(0.1); review
376 of 610
email correspondence regarding meet and confer
status with Arizona AG (0.1).
2848 4/25/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.20 1,002.00 Research permanent injunctions in context of

summary judgment.

summary judgment.

summary judgment.
2853 4/30/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.50 1,252.50 Meet and confer with Arizona and Louisiana AGs

regarding state subpoenas (.4); review and
revise proposed letter agreement with Arizona
AG (.2); review materials proposed for
disclosure to Arizona AG (.9).
2854 4/30/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Assist attorneys with research and collection

of documents for attorney general subpoenas.
2855 4/30/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Review Ninth Circuit order denying writ of

mandamus on recusal motion (0.1); confer with
C. Robinson regarding (0.3).
2856 5/1/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 780.00 Email and correspond with C. Robinson

regarding (0.4); confer with
Arizona AG's office regarding subpoena (0.4).
377 of 610
2857 5/1/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Edit video and audio for Louisiana Attorney
General subpoenas.
2858 5/1/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.50 1,252.50 Confer with L. Brown regarding
(0.6); review Arizona and Louisiana
files for responsiveness and confidentiality
(0.4); confer with T. Beyer and N.
(0.2); correspond with
Arizona AG regarding letter agreement (0.1).
2859 5/1/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 918.00 Draft stipulation on extension of time to

respond to AG subpoena.
2860 5/2/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Review and revise draft stipulation regarding

AG subpoenas.
2861 5/2/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 382.50 Draft stipulation regarding extension of time

on AG subpoena.
2862 5/2/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 File stipulation.
2863 5/3/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Email with court clerk regarding stipulation

concerning AG subpoenas (0.2); review order
setting case management conference (0.2).
2864 5/3/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Distribute calendar entries.
2865 5/4/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 334.00 Strategize with N. Roethlisberger regarding
378 of 610
2866 5/4/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 167.00 Email summary of proposed summary adjudication
and permanent injunction strategy.
2867 5/4/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Create and distribute calendar entries.
2868 5/4/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.30 1,267.50 Confer with L. Brown regarding

(0.5); review notes
prepared by C. Robinson et al regarding same
(0.5); email with counsel for Arizona AG
regarding subpoena (0.3).
2869 5/4/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 229.50 Research in support of upcoming CMC statement.
2870 5/7/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 306.00 Research on potential amendment to complaint.
2871 5/7/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Review meet‐and‐confer correspondence from

opposing counsel regarding amended complaint.
2872 5/8/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.10 3,997.50 Revise letter agreement with Arizona AG's

office related to subpoena directed to CMP
(0.4); prepare for and attend phone call with
counsel for Arizona AG regarding same (0.4); confer
with N. Roethlisberger et al regarding
(0.2); review legal research outlines prepared
by C. Robinson et al regarding
(1.0); conduct
legal research regarding summary judgment and
entry of permanent injunction requirements
(2.1).
2873 5/8/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.10 841.50 Draft agreement with Arizona AG regarding

subpoena compliance.
379 of 610
2874 5/9/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 153.00 Revise agreement with Arizona AG regarding

subpoena compliance.
2875 5/9/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Confer with L. Brown regarding

(0.2);
correspond with counsel for Arizona AG
regarding same (0.1); conduct meet‐and‐confer
status of pleadings (0.1).
2876 5/10/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Conduct follow up correspondence with counsel for

Arizona AG regarding letter agreement
concerning subpoena.
2877 5/11/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 228.00 Compile video files for attorney review.
2878 5/11/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 612.00 Review videos for possible production in

response to Arizona AG's subpoena.
2879 5/14/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 459.00 Condcut research regarding potential summary judgment

filing.
2880 5/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.10 3,022.50 Review outline regarding strategy for remainder

of trial court proceedings (0.8); prepare
outline of summary judgment motion on breach of
contract claims (2.3)
2881 5/15/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Seach NAF programs for Stem Express adds.
2882 5/15/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 5.90 5,752.50 Prepare draft summary judgment motion on breach

of contract claims.
380 of 610

2885 5/16/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.20 4,095.00 Emails with J. Lotwick regarding Louisiana IG

subpoena (0.3); revise draft motion for summary
judgment on contract claim (3.9).
2886 5/17/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 780.00 Confer with J. Lotwick regarding Louisiana

Inspector General subpoena directed to CMP
(0.5); email with J. Lotwick regarding letter
agreement relating to subpoena (0.3).
2887 5/17/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.20 2,356.00 Prepare documents to comply with Arizona and

Louisiana subpoenas.
2888 5/17/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.80 1,377.00 Review videos for possible production in

response to Louisiana subpoena (.6 hr); draft
agreement with Louisiana IG office (1.2 hr).
2889 5/18/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Email with B. Roysden regarding Arizona AG

subpoena.
2890 5/21/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 76.50 Correspond with client concerning
2891 5/21/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Correspond with J. Lotwick regarding

Louisiana subpoena (0.1); email with L. Brown
regarding (0.1).
381 of 610
(0.1); correspond with
counsel for CMP regarding response to Arizona
subpoena (0.3); email with Arizona AG's office
2893 5/22/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Send files to Defendant's counsel.
2897 5/29/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.60 585.00 Correspond with J. Lotwick regarding

Louisiana subpoena (0.2); correspond
with counsel for CMP regarding Arizona subpoena
(0.2);
email with
N. Roethlisberger et al regarding
(0.2).
2898 5/29/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.20 456.00 Compile case law and organize for attorney

review (1.0); compile video files and send to
Arizona attorney general (.20).
2899 5/29/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 306.00 Finalize videos for production to Arizona AG.
2900 5/30/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 382.50 Review revisions to Louisiana IG's agreement

concerning subpoena.
382 of 610
2901 5/30/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 487.50 Review and provide comment on draft letter
agreement with Louisiana Inspector General's
office (0.3); confer with L Brown regarding
(0.2).
2904 5/31/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Review comments provided by L. Brown on draft

agreement with Louisiana Inspector General's
office (0.1); email with Louisiana Inspector
General's office regarding draft agreement (0.2);
correspond with counsel for CMP
regarding agreement with Louisiana Inspector
General's office (0.1).
2905 5/31/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 76.50 Review changes to Louisiana IG's agreement.
2906 6/1/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.50 950.00 Review footage and compile for attorney review;

compile orders and send to attorney.
2908 6/1/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Convert and edit video files.
2909 6/1/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.80 2,730.00 Prepare for and attend meeting with C.

Robinson et al regarding
(1.5);
draft letter to Judge Orrick regarding
conclusion of meet‐and‐confer with Arizona AG
383 of 610
and Louisiana IG (0.3); email with Arizona AG
and Louisiana IG regarding same (0.1); review
discovery orders in related Planned Parenthood
matter (0.5); review Judge Orrick's standing
orders related to content of case management
conference statements (0.2); correspond
with counsel for CMP regarding scope of
production to Arizona AG's office (0.2).
2910 6/1/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 1,085.50 Prepare for and attend team meeting to discuss

case strategy.
2911 6/1/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.00 835.00 Strategize with N. Roethlisberger, D. Foran,

2912 6/1/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.90 1,453.50 Review factual record in preparation for

summary judgment motion.
2913 6/3/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.50 570.00 Convert videos for editing.
2914 6/3/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.30 494.00 Create case binders of TRO and other case

related materials.
2915 6/4/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.40 912.00 Search hard drive and compile videos for

attorney review (.50); covert video files (.90);
edit videos (1.0)

(.2); strategize regarding and
assign research project to J. Finley
(.4).
2917 6/4/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 229.50 Review videos for possible production to
384 of 610
Arizona attorney general's office.
2918 6/4/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 6.20 6,045.00 Review

district court orders regarding Arizona and
Louisiana subpoenas (0.2); conduct legal research in
connection with summary judgment and permanent
injunction on contract claim (2.2); prepare
draft outline of summary judgment and permanent
injunction motion (3.8).
2919 6/5/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.90 751.50 Analyze case docket in preparation for drafting

motion for summary judgment.
2920 6/5/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 6.00 5,850.00 Review TRO, Preliminary Injunction, and

Contempt declarations and papers (for use on
summary judgment for contract claim) (3.1);
review Daleiden deposition transcript for same
(2.9).
2921 6/5/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 228.00 Edit video in compliance with subpoena.
2922 6/5/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.00 760.00 Download video files and create clips for

Arizona subpoena (.70); Research D. Daleiden
quotes in news and social media (1.3).
2923 6/6/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.20 836.00 Review video (1.10); compile documents for

attorney review (1.10).
2924 6/6/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.20 1,002.00 Strategize with N. Roethlisberger, D. Foran,

and C. Robinson regarding (.5);
analyze preliminary injunction papers in
preparation for drafting summary judgment
motion (.7).
385 of 610
2925 6/6/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.60 4,485.00 Conduct legal research regarding admissibility of

online comments on motion for summary judgment
and permanent injunction on contract claim
(0.5); confer with D. Maltzer regarding
(0.2); continue review of exhibits and
declarations in support of preliminary
injunction for use on permanent injunction
and emails with D. Maltzer et
al regarding same (1.0); review violence and
harassment statistics compiled by NAF for
2015‐17 (0.4).
2926 6/6/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 535.50 Review videos for possible production to

Arizona attorney general's office.
2927 6/7/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.40 1,365.00 Revise outline for summary judgment and

permanent injunction motion (1.2); emails with
L. Brown regarding
(0.2).
2928 6/7/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 38.00 Compile documents for attorney review
2930 6/8/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.40 2,004.00 Strategize with N. Roethlisberger, D. Foran,

and C. Robinson regarding (1);
analyze preliminary injunction papers in
preparation for drafting summary judgment
motion (1.4).
386 of 610
2931 6/8/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 835.00 Attend weekly team meeting.
2932 6/8/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,950.00 Meet with C. Robinson et al regarding
(1.4); confer with L. Brown
regarding
(0.3); write follow up
emails with C. Robinson et al regarding same
(0.1); email with counsel for Planned
(0.2).
2933 6/8/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.30 994.50 Conduct legal research concerning timing of motion for

attorney's fees.
2934 6/11/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 382.50 Discuss production of videos with Arizona

attorney general's office.
2935 6/11/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Email with counsel for Planned Parenthood

regarding
(0.2); email with N.
(0.1).
2936 6/11/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Create video clips in compliance with Arizona

subpoena.
2937 6/12/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.30 494.00 Review CMP production and send to attorneys for

(.20); send videos to NAF for review (1.10).
2938 6/12/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 167.00 Review video for proposed production to Arizona
387 of 610
AG.
2939 6/12/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 612.00 Review videos for possible supplemental

production to Arizona attorney general's
office.
2940 6/12/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 6,825.00 Review stip and proposed order in Planned

Parenthood case regarding
(0.4); email with counsel for
(0.3); review additional
videotape to be provided to Arizona AG (0.7);
emails with N. Roethlisberger regarding same
(0.2); draft motion for summary judgment on
contract claim (6.1).
2941 6/13/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.40 1,071.00 Conduct legal research concerning the admissibility of

evidence on a motion for summary judgment.
2942 6/13/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 6,825.00 Review research notes prepared by N.

(0.3); review legal research
notes prepared by N. Roethlisberger regarding
(0.3); review
set of online comments made by Daleiden
regarding threats to release more tapes (0.5);
continue drafting of summary judgment motion on
contract claim and request for permanent
injunction (5.9).
2943 6/13/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.70 646.00 Review news articles and twitter feeds for D.

Daleiden quotes.
388 of 610
2944 6/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 3,120.00 Continue drafting motion for summary judgment.
2945 6/14/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.10 2,371.50 Conduct legal research in support of case management

conference statement.
2946 6/18/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 306.00 Review correspondence with client concerning

and
correspond with Arizona AG's office concerning
same.
2947 6/19/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.60 1,224.00 Draft CMC statement.
2948 6/20/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Email with opposing counsel regarding

production of videotape to Louisiana IG.
2949 6/21/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.70 1,300.50 Correspond with Louisiana concerning production

of videos in response to subpoena (.2 hr);
draft CMC statement (1.5 hr).
2950 6/21/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Email with opposing counsel regarding case

management conference.
2951 6/22/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 153.00 Correspond with Louisiana Inspector General's

office concerning subpoena.
2952 6/25/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 306.00 Discuss subpoena and production of videos in

response with Louisiana Inspector General.
2953 6/26/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.70 266.00 Produce files to Louisiana Attorney General.
2954 6/26/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 459.00 Review videos for production in response to

Louisiana Inspector General's subpoena.
389 of 610
2955 6/27/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.10 841.50 Prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer phone
call with opposing counsel concerning upcoming
CMC.
2956 6/27/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.30 250.50 Attend meet and confer with Defendants.
2957 6/27/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.90 1,852.50 Prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer with

opposing counsel in advance of case management
conference (1.4); review and provide comments
on draft case management conference statement
(0.5).
2958 6/28/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.60 1,989.00 Revise draft CMC statement.
2959 6/28/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 38.00 Review docket for certificate of interested

parties.
2960 6/29/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.40 152.00 Produce videos to Arizona attorney general.
2961 6/29/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 535.50 Revise draft CMC statement.
(0.1).
2963 7/2/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 487.50 Confer with D. Maltzer regarding

(0.3); conduct
meet‐and‐confer
correspondence with opposing counsel in advance
of case management conference (0.2).
2964 7/3/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 584.50 Review and revise joint CMC statement.
390 of 610
2965 7/3/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.00 2,505.00 Conduct legal research regarding CMC proposal (1.5);

review recent correspondence and filings in NAF
case (1.5).
2966 7/3/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 877.50 Review revisions to draft case management

statement proposed by C. Robinson (0.2); review
correspondence from defense counsel and respond
thereto (0.3); confer with L. Brown
regarding
(0.2); confer with C. Robinson
regarding
(0.2).
2967 7/3/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.40 1,169.00 Revise case management conference statement

(.3); research scope and discretion of stays
(.4); analyze and discuss settlement offer from
Defendants (.4); strategize with team regarding
(.2).
2968 7/5/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.30 1,085.50 Prepare for meet and confer regarding CMC

statement (0.9); confer with L. Brown
regarding (0.4).
2969 7/5/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.90 2,827.50 Prepare for and attend phone call with L. Brown

regarding (0.5); prepare for and attend
phone call with opposing counsel regarding case
management conference (0.7); review notice of
withdrawal of opposing counsel K. Short (0.1);
review correspondence for counsel for T. Newman
regarding case management plan and confer with
L. Brown regarding (0.2); revise case
management conference statement (0.9); phone
391 of 610
call with D. Maltzer regarding
(0.2); confer with counsel for
planned parenthood regarding
(0.3)
2970 7/5/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.90 1,586.50 Strategize with L. Brown regarding

(.5); meet and confer
with Defendants regarding
(.4); strategize with D.
Foran and C. Robinson regarding
(.4); research case law related to
anti‐SLAPP and summary judgment motions (.6).
2971 7/6/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 835.00 Review and revise Joint CMC Statement (0.7);

email correspondence with Mofo regarding
(0.2); conduct email
CMC Statement (0.1).
2972 7/6/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 2,047.50 Prepare for case management conference (1.5);

revise case management conference statement
(0.6).
2973 7/6/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.60 608.00 Research discovery issues.
2974 7/9/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.90 342.00 Respond to attorney requests regarding document

productions.
2975 7/9/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 167.00 Meet and confer with defendants regarding joint

CMC statement.
392 of 610
2977 7/9/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 1,072.50 Prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer phone

call with opposing counsel regarding case
management conference (0.5); review defendants'
insert for case management conference statement
(0.2); email with counsel for
2978 7/9/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.20 2,672.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding

(.2); correspond with
co‐counsel regarding
(.4); research and draft case management
conference statement (1.9); analyze NAF
production of documents (.7).
2979 7/10/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.00 5,010.00 Research, revise, and file case management

conference statement (5.1); communicate with L.
Brown and co‐counsel regarding
(.5); correspond with
Defendants regarding case management conference
statement (.4).
2980 7/10/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.40 2,004.00 Review and comment on draft CMC statement

(0.1); condcut legal
research regarding Defendants' assertions
regarding effect of anti‐SLAPP motion (1.0).
393 of 610
2981 7/10/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Proofread and file joint statement.
2982 7/10/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 877.50 Review and revise draft case management

conference statement (0.5); correspond
with D. Maltzer and C. Robinson
regarding
(0.4).
2983 7/11/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.50 3,757.50 Review news updates.
2984 7/11/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 487.50 Review finalized case management conference

filed with court (0.2); prepare for case
management conference (0.3).
2985 7/11/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 380.00 Compile court documents for attorney review.
2986 7/12/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Correspond with counsel for Planned Parenthood

regarding
2987 7/12/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.70 584.50 Discuss with D. Foran regarding

(.2); prepare for case
management conference (.5).
2988 7/13/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.80 1,503.00 Research motions to stay, motions to strike,

and motions for summary judgment in preparation
for Case Management conference (1.8); review
pleadings in preparation for Case Management
Conference (1).
2989 7/16/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.00 4,175.00 Prepare for and meet with A. Bomse and D. Sterk

regarding (.5);
draft outline and prepare for case management
conference (3.8); review motion for judicial
394 of 610
reassignment (.7).
2990 7/17/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.30 4,425.50 Prepare for, attend, and strategize with team

regarding Case Management Conference.

conference (2.5); confer with C. Robinson et al
regarding
review motion for judicial
reassignment on remand from contempt appeal and
prepare outline of opposition for same (0.7);
confer with S. Brill and N. Roethlisberger
regarding
(0.3)
2992 7/17/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.40 152.00 Compile documents for attorney review;
2993 7/17/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,670.00 Conduct legal research regarding effect of voluntary

dismissal of claims on statute of limitations.
2994 7/17/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Travel to and from case management conference.
2996 7/17/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 835.00 Attend case management conference.
2997 7/18/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Draft calendar entries.
2998 7/18/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 584.50 Prepare Rule 41(a) notice of voluntary

dismissal.
395 of 610
2999 7/18/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.30 1,759.50 Draft opposition to motion to reassign case on

remand.
3000 7/18/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.70 1,657.50 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding
comment on draft notice of dismissal of
non‐contract and fraud claims in district court
(0.3); correspond with L. Brown regarding
comment on draft request for extension of time
to file opposition to motion for judicial
reassignment on remand from contempt appeal
(0.4); correspond with opposing counsel
3001 7/18/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.90 751.50 Communicate with L. Brown regarding

(.4); strategize with D.
Foran and C. Robinson regarding
(.5).
3002 7/19/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 501.00 Review case management conference order and

order transcript (0.3); strategize regarding
case (.3).
3003 7/19/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 1,072.50 Confer with N. Roethlisberger and S. Brill

regarding
(0.3); review legal research notes regarding
standards governing motion for judicial
reassignment (0.4); confer with N.
396 of 610
(0.2); review case management
order issued by Judge Orrick and confer with C.
Robinson regarding same (0.2).
3004 7/19/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.30 994.50 Review and finalize request for extension of

time to file opposition to motion to reassign
case on remand.
3005 7/20/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.80 1,377.00 Research possibility of dismissing claims.
3006 7/20/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Revise calendar entries.
3007 7/20/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,462.50 Prepare for and attend phone call with L. Brown

regarding
(0.6); conduct legal research in connection with
stipulated dismissal of certain claims and
confer with N. Roethlisberger et al
regarding same (0.8); review Ninth Circuit
order granting extension to file opposition to
motion for judicial reassignment on remand from
contempt appeal (0.1).
3008 7/20/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.40 1,169.00 Prepare for and discuss with L. Brown
(.5); conduct legal research regarding
dismissal (.5); strategize with D. Foran, N.
Roethlisberger, and C. Robinson regarding
(.4).
3009 7/23/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 334.00 Review case management conference ruling and
397 of 610
notes (.2); strategize regarding protective
order across Planned Parenthood and NAF cases
(.2).
3010 7/24/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 334.00 Strategize regarding dismissal of claims and

criminal action.
3011 7/24/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 612.00 Draft opposition to motion to reassign case on

remand.
3012 7/25/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Confer with B. Parker regarding
3013 7/25/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.30 1,759.50 Draft opposition to motion to reassign case on

remand.
3014 7/26/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.80 612.00 Draft opposition to motion to reassign case on

remand.
3015 7/26/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 417.50 Strategize with D. Foran, N. Roethlisberger,

3016 7/26/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.70 2,632.50 Confer with Planned Parenthood in‐house counsel

regarding (0.3); review and provide
comment on draft opposition to motion for
judicial reassignment on appeal from contempt
order (1.5); communicate regarding
(0.9).
3017 7/30/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 76.50 Revise opposition to motion to reassign case on
398 of 610
remand.
3018 7/31/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.20 1,002.00 Review and comment on NAF's response to CMP's

recusal motion.
3019 8/1/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.40 1,071.00 Revise opposition to motion to reassign case on

remand from Ninth Circuit.
3020 8/1/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 1,072.50 Confer with counsel for planned parenthood

regarding
(0.5); review
correspondence from defendants regarding
discovery (0.6).
3021 8/1/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 835.00 Review T. Newman's and D. Daleiden's letters

requesting discovery from NAF.
3022 8/2/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 535.50 Review discovery letter from opposing counsel.
3023 8/2/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 1,950.00 Review and revise opposition to motion for

judicial reassignment on remand from contempt
appeal (1.3); confer with S. Brill regarding
(0.2); email with L. Brown regarding
(0.2); review
notice of new evidence and case law filed by
defendants in Ninth Circuit in support of
motion for judicial reassignment (0.3)
3024 8/3/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.00 2,505.00 Review public documents produced in related

Planned Parenthood civil action.
3025 8/3/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Communicate with D. Foran and N.

399 of 610
3026 8/3/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.30 2,524.50 Revise opposition to motion to reassign case on

remand from Ninth Circuit.
3027 8/3/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.40 1,365.00 Communicate with C. Robinson and N.

; email
regarding same (0.2); review revised opposition
to motion for judicial reassignment filed in
contempt appeal (0.3).
3028 8/6/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.00 4,175.00 Analyze amended complaint in NAF, Motion to

Strike and Motion to Dismiss in Planned
Parenthood; strategize with N. Roethlisberger
regarding ; research law of the case
as related to preliminary injunctions.
3029 8/6/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.20 4,743.00 Review factual record in anticipation of making

alter ego arguments regarding T. Newman.
3030 8/7/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.30 4,054.50 Conduct legal research regarding alter ego in

anticipation of filing opposition to motion to
dismiss.
3031 8/7/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.60 3,841.00 Research law related to Defendants' potential

motion to dismiss, motion to strike, and motion
to modify preliminary injunction.
3032 8/8/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 835.00 Confer with L. Brown regarding

(0.8); confer
with D. Maltzer and N. Roethlisberger regarding
400 of 610
(0.2).
3033 8/8/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 918.00 Prepare for and attend phone call with L. Brown

regarding
3034 8/8/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.40 4,131.00 Conduct legal research in anticipation of opposition to

anti‐SLAPP motion.

motion to dismiss, motion to strike, and motion
to modify preliminary injunction.
3036 8/9/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.40 4,131.00 Conduct legal research in anticipation of drafting

opposition to anti‐SLAPP motion.
3037 8/9/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.30 3,590.50 Research law related to and strategize

regarding Defendants' potential motion to
dismiss, motion to strike, and motion to modify
3038 8/10/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.40 4,896.00 Draft opposition to anticipated anti‐SLAPP

motion on first prong of anti‐SLAPP analysis.
3039 8/10/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,757.50 Prepare letter responding to T. Newman's and

Defendants' discovery requests (1); conduct legal
research regarding relevance of discovery
requests in light of claims and defenses (1).

motion to modify preliminary injunction;
strategize with N. Roethlisberger regarding
401 of 610
3041 8/13/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.40 2,839.00 Prepare response to Defendants' discovery

letter.
3042 8/13/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Organize network drive.
3043 8/13/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.80 1,377.00 Review documents for possible future production

to Defendants.
3044 8/13/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.20 1,170.00 Review and provide comment on draft letter to

opposing counsel regarding appropriate scope of
discovery.
3045 8/13/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.20 4,342.00 Order and review pleadings and transcripts from

criminal matter (1.1); research and draft
anticipatory opposition to motion to dissolve
preliminary injunction (3.4); correspond
with A. Bomse of Arnold & Porter regarding
(.3); strategize with team
regarding (.4).
3046 8/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 1,072.50 Confer with C. Robinson regarding
(0.7); revise
and edit draft discovery letter (0.4).
3047 8/14/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 334.00 Review and revise discovery letter to address

D. Foran's comments.
402 of 610
3049 8/14/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.80 1,377.00 Research on alter ego liability in anticipation
of arguments from T. Newman.
3050 8/15/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Review D. Daleiden declaration in support of

motion to dissolve preliminary injunction.
3051 8/15/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.00 3,900.00 Conduct final edits to discovery letter (0.3); review

motions to dismiss, motion to strike and motion
to dissolve preliminary injunction (3.7).
3052 8/15/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.20 5,177.00 Revise discovery letter (.2); research and

draft stipulation regarding protective orders
in NAF and PP matters (1.6); revise motion to
modify preliminary injunction (.7); research
law related to Defendants' potential motion to
dismiss, motion to strike, and motion to modify
preliminary injunction (1.5); review motions to
dismiss, strike, and dissolve preliminary
injunction filed by Defendants (2.2).
3053 8/15/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.10 2,371.50 Review and make edits to discovery letter.
3054 8/16/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.90 6,043.50 Research personal jurisdiction for

opposition to T. Newman MTD (2.2 hr); research
subject matter jurisdiction issues for
opposition to Defendants' anti‐SLAPP and MTD
(3.3 hr); review and analyze breach of contract
arguments in Defendants' MTD (2.4 hr).
3055 8/16/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.40 912.00 Compile filing and distribute to team (.30)

send filings to client (.20); compile potential
exhibits to opposition to motion to dismiss
(1.0); draft list of filings by T. Newman and
403 of 610
appearances on record.(.90)
3056 8/16/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.70 3,607.50 Confer with N. Roethlisberger et al regarding
(0.7); legal research in connection with issues
raised in motions to dismiss and anti‐SLAPP
motion (1.5); prepare outlines of oppositions
to motions to dismiss and anti‐SLAPP motions
(1.5).
3057 8/16/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.90 751.50 Review Defendants' motion to dissolve

injunction.
3058 8/16/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.30 5,260.50 Research and analyze news and social media

content related to Defendants (1.6); strategize
regarding collection of criminal case pleadings
(.4); analyze motion to dismiss (1.9); analyze
motion to dissolve preliminary injunction
(.2.4).
3059 8/17/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 7.10 5,928.50 Strategize with team regarding

(1.2);
correspond with Defendants' counsel
regarding (.4);
research and revise declaration in
support of motion to seal (.6); analyze motions
to dismiss (4.9).
3060 8/17/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.90 495.00 Participate in conference call to discuss

responses to recent motions from defendants
(.8); confer with N. Roethlisberger on same
(.1).
404 of 610
3061 8/17/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.20 456.00 Compile documents in preparation for opposition
filing.
3062 8/17/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.70 4,360.50 Research in support of opposition to T. Newman's

motion to dismiss (4.6); draft declaration
for D. Foran to keep documents under seal (.6);
strategize about
with D. Foran (.5).
3063 8/17/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.70 1,657.50 Review motion to dissolve preliminary

injunction (0.9); participate in phone conference with C.
Robinson et al regarding
(0.6); write follow
up emails regarding same (0.2).
3064 8/20/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 975.00 Email with opposing counsel regarding
(0.4); review and
provide comment on draft declaration in support
of sealing documents (0.1); review Ninth
Circuit reply brief in support of motion to
re‐assign case following contempt appeal (0.5).
3065 8/20/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.20 5,508.00 Draft opposition to Newman's motion to dismiss

(6.1); draft stipulation to extend time for
response to motion to dissolve preliminary
injunction (1.1).
3066 8/20/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.30 5,260.50 Research and draft unopposed motion to enlarge

time (2.2); strategize with D. Foran and N.
405 of 610
(.4); research and analyze cases
cited in motion to dismiss (3.2); revise and
file declaration in support of motion to seal
(.5).
3067 8/20/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 0.80 440.00 Correspond with N. Roethlisberger regarding

(.1); confer with D.
Foran regarding
to dismiss (.2); review CMP motion to dismiss
(.5).
3068 8/20/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Compile documents for attorney review (.20);

compile and send documents to client (.20)
3069 8/20/2018 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 724.50 Prepare service of summons for Newman.
3070 8/20/2018 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.80 567.00 Research Newman service of summons for

3071 8/21/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 3,442.50 Draft opposition to Newman's motion to dismiss

(3.8 hr); draft declaration for D. Foran in
support of stipulation to change briefing
schedule for motion to dissolve preliminary
injunction (0.7 hr).
3072 8/21/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 682.50 Call with L. Brown regarding
(0.5); review and
provide comment on stipulation regarding
schedule for motion to dissolve preliminary
injunction (0.2).
3073 8/21/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.20 5,177.00 Research and draft opposition to motion to
406 of 610
dismiss (5.8); draft and file stipulation
regarding extension of time (.4).

dismiss.
3075 8/22/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.20 1,210.00 Review CMP motion to dismiss (.5); research

case law related to diversity jurisdiction for
non‐profit organizations (1.7).
3076 8/22/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.00 5,355.00 Draft opposition to Newman's motion to dismiss.
3077 8/22/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Review order regarding schedule for motion to dissolve

3078 8/23/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 228.00 Research video files for duration report;

compile documents for attorney review.
3079 8/23/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.50 1,375.00 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding

(.4); research
knowledge and intent requirements in civil
conspiracy cases (2.1).
3080 8/23/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 487.50 Correspond with opposing counsel regarding

discovery in district court in light of
anti‐SLAPP motion (0.4); confer with C.
Robinson et al regarding same (0.1).
3081 8/23/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.30 2,755.50 Draft opposition to motion to dismiss.
3082 8/23/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.50 4,207.50 Draft opposition to Newman's motion to dismiss.
407 of 610
3083 8/24/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.70 2,830.50 Draft opposition to Defendants' anti‐SLAPP

motion.
3084 8/24/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.30 3,590.50 Draft opposition to motion to dismiss (3.4);

strategize with D. Foran, C. Robinson, and N.
(.6); correspond with J.
Trissell regarding letter to the court
regarding discovery stay (.3).
3085 8/24/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 2,925.00 Confer with L. Brown regarding
(0.4); confer with C. Robinson et al
regarding
(0.5); review and provide comment on
draft opposition to Newman motion to dismiss
(2.1).t
3086 8/24/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.00 1,100.00 Participate in conference call to discuss
(.4); correspond with N. Roethlisberger
regarding ;
research intent and knowledge requirements for
conspiracy civil liability (1.5).
3088 8/24/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 304.00 Search for on‐line video with D. Daleiden

(.10); Draft list of video durations (.70).
3089 8/25/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.10 1,606.50 Draft opposition to Defendants' anti‐SLAPP
408 of 610
motion.
3090 8/27/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 7.90 6,043.50 Revise opposition to Newman motion to dismiss

(5.1 hr); draft opposition to anti‐SLAPP motion
(2.8 hr).
3092 8/27/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,670.00 Review and analyze CMP's motion to dismiss and

cited cases.
3093 8/27/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 6.80 3,740.00 Research case law related to elements of civil

conspiracy and confer with N. Roethlisberger
(4.2);
research applicability of personal jurisdiction
admission from related cases for Newman motion
to dismiss (2.6).
3094 8/27/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.10 418.00 Compile documents for attorney review; research

previous filed documents.
3095 8/27/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.30 5,260.50 Draft opposition to motion to dismiss (6);

strategize regarding opposition to motion to
strike (.3).
3096 8/28/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.60 1,430.00 Research applicability of personal jurisdiction

admission from related cases for Newman motion
to dismiss (1.5); confer with N. Roethlisberger
on same (.1); review previous court orders
(1.0).
409 of 610
3097 8/28/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.60 4,676.00 Draft NAF's opposition to CMP's motion to
dismiss.
3098 8/28/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.90 1,852.50 Further revisions to opposition to Newman

motion to dismiss (1.6); confer with N.
Roethlisberger regarding same (0.2); correspond for
meet‐and‐confer with counsel for Newman regarding
(0.1).
3099 8/28/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.50 5,427.50 Draft opposition to motion to dismiss (6.1);

strike (.4).

(4.3 hr).

(6.8 hr).
3102 8/29/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.80 5,678.00 Research and revise opposition to Daleiden's

motion to dismiss (6.3); strategize regarding
(.5).
3103 8/29/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.30 2,242.50 Email with C. Robinson regarding
(0.1); review and
provide further comment on revised opposition
to Newman motion to dismiss (0.9); confer with
N. Roethlisberger
410 of 610
(0.3); legal research in connection with
opposition to motion to strike (review Planned
Parenthood orders in district court and on
appeal) (1.0).
3104 8/29/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.00 5,845.00 Draft NAF's opposition to CMP's motion to

dismiss.
3105 8/29/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 250.50 Confer with E. Zimmerman regarding

Newman's discovery disputes.
3106 8/29/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 2.70 1,485.00 Correspond with N. Roethlisberger and D.

Maltzer regarding
(.1); review same to
identify language for inclusion in responses to
motions to dismiss (2.6).

motion to dismiss.
3109 8/30/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,757.50 Conduct legal research in connection with Daleiden's

contract and fraud arguments in motion to
dismiss.
3110 8/30/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 304.00 Prepare network drive for three motions being

filed September 5; organize network drive.
3111 8/30/2018 ALLISON LAUTERBACH DALE 3.30 1,815.00 Correspond with N. Roethlisberger and D.

Maltzer regarding
(.1); review same to
identify language for inclusion in responses to
411 of 610
motions to dismiss (3.0); correspond with T.
Beyer regarding (.1);
confer with N. Roethlisberger on same (.1).
3112 8/30/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.70 4,759.50 Revise opposition to motion to dismiss (5.1);

strike (.6)
3113 8/30/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Email with C. Robinson and N. Roethlisberger

regarding (0.4);

(3 hr); draft opposition to anti‐SLAPP motion
(4.9 hr).

(2.4 hr); draft opposition to Defendants'
motion to dismiss (2.4).
3116 8/31/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.70 4,759.50 Revise opposition to motion to dismiss (5.2);

strategize regarding
(.5).
3117 8/31/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.20 4,095.00 Review and provide comments on draft opposition

to motion to strike (1.9); review and provide
comments on draft opposition to Daleiden and
CMP's motion to dismiss (2.3)

motion to dismiss.
3119 8/31/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 167.00 Confer with D. Foran and N. Roethlisberger
412 of 610
regarding
3120 9/2/2018 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 724.50 Assist with filing of opposition to Newman's

motion to dismiss complaint.
3121 9/3/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.50 570.00 Cite check opposition to D Daleiden Motion to

Dismiss.
3122 9/3/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.00 4,175.00 Revise opposition to motion to strike (3.9);

revise opposition to motion to dismiss (.8);
discuss with D. Foran regarding (.3).
3123 9/3/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,437.50 Review and revise draft oppositions to Daleiden

motion to dismisss and anti‐SLAPP motion (2.5).

(.7 hr); revise opposition to anti‐SLAPP motion
(4.2 hr); revise opposition to Defendants'
motion to dismiss (1.7 hr).

Daleiden's anti‐SLAPP motion.
3126 9/4/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Review and revise NAF's opposition to

Daleiden's motion to dismiss.
3127 9/4/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Review and revise NAF's opposition to Newman's

motion to dismiss.
3128 9/4/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.00 1,140.00 Cite check opposition to Newman motion to

dismiss (2.30); revise same (.70)
413 of 610
3129 9/4/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.90 342.00 Revise opposition to anti‐slapp motion.
3130 9/4/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.90 722.00 Cite check anti‐slapp motion.
3131 9/4/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.70 4,759.50 Revise oppositions to Newman and Daleiden

motions to dismiss, and motion to strike.
3132 9/5/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.50 1,330.00 Assist with finalization of oppositions to

motions to dismiss.
3133 9/5/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.10 418.00 Assist with finalizing the anti‐slapp motion.
3134 9/5/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 7.00 5,845.00 Revise, finalize, and file oppositions to

motions to dismiss and motion to strike.
3135 9/5/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 250.50 Conduct legal research regarding result of appeal of

Anti‐SLAPP motion on further district court
trial proceedings.
3136 9/5/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Conduct final review of all NAF's oppositions to all

Defendants' pleading motions.

(3.2 hr); revise opposition to anti‐SLAPP
motion (4.8 hr); revise opposition to
Defendants' motion to dismiss (1.2 hr).
3138 9/5/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 2,925.00 Provide final comments on draft oppositions to

Daleiden motion to dismiss (0.9); provide final
comments on draft opposition to Daleiden
anti‐SLAPP motion (0.8); provide final comments
on draft opposition to Newman motion to dismiss
(0.9); correspond with L. Brown regarding
414 of 610
(0.4).
3139 9/6/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Organize P:drive.
3140 9/6/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 250.50 Review and analyze NAF's motion to dissolve

3141 9/6/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.40 1,169.00 Analyze Motion to Dissolve Preliminary

Injunction (1.4).
3142 9/6/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.60 2,535.00 Conduct legal research in

connection with Daleiden motion to dissolve
preliminary injunction (1.5); review exhibits
submitted in support of Daleiden motion to
dissolve preliminary injunction (0.9); confer
(0.2).
3143 9/7/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.40 2,004.00 Conduct research regarding motion to dissolve

preliminary Injunction (2.4).
3144 9/7/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.40 152.00 Compile case law in anti‐slapp motion.
3145 9/7/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 228.00 Compile case law in Oppositions and motions to

dismiss.
3146 9/10/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.40 3,315.00 Confer with C. Robinson regarding
(0.7); confer with
L. Brown regarding
415 of 610
(0.6).
3147 9/10/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.80 3,173.00 Research related to opposition to motion to

dissolve preliminary injunction.
3149 9/11/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 2.00 1,670.00 Review and analyze Daleiden's motion to

dissolve injunction and supporting evidence.
3150 9/11/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 501.00 Prepare NAF's portion of joint letter to the

Court regarding discovery disputes.
3152 9/11/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 682.50 Review

and provide comment on draft joint discovery
letter due with district court (0.5); review
district court order regarding discovery in
light of anti‐SLAPP motion (0.2).
3153 9/12/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 8.40 7,014.00 Draft NAF's opposition to Defendants' motion to

dissolve the injunction.
3154 9/12/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 668.00 Revise opposition to motion to dissolve


416 of 610

3157 9/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 3,412.50 Review and

provide comments and edits on draft opposition
to motion to dissolve preliminary injunction
(3.5).


Daleiden's motion to dissolve injunction to
address D. Foran's comments.
3160 9/17/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.90 722.00 Assist with finalization and filing of brief.
3161 9/17/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.20 836.00 Cite and fact check motion to dissolve.
3162 9/17/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.40 532.00 Draft D. Foran Declaration and compile exhibits.
3163 9/17/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 682.50 Conduct final review and comments on draft opposition

to motion to dissolve preliminary injunction

Defendants' motion to dissolve the injunction
3165 9/17/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.30 1,920.50 Strategize regarding
3166 9/17/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 918.00 Review draft of opposition to motion to

dissolve the preliminary injunction.
417 of 610
3167 9/18/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 334.00 Strategize regarding
3168 9/19/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 417.50 Review reply in support of motion to dismiss.
3169 9/19/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.80 3,705.00 Review replies submitted in support of Daleiden

and Newman motion to dismiss and Daleiden
anti‐SLAPP (2.7); provide comments to N.
Roethlisberger et al regarding same (0.3);
confer with A. Bomse regarding
(0.5); email with L.
Brown regarding
(0.3)
3170 9/19/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.60 1,336.00 Review and analyze reply briefs filed by

Daleiden in support of motion to dismiss and
anti‐SLAPP motion to strike.
3171 9/19/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.10 4,666.50 Research in preparation for oral argument on

Defendants' anti‐SLAPP motion.
3172 9/20/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 668.00 Analyze reply in support of motion to dismiss.
3173 9/20/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.40 152.00 Compile documents in related case and

distribute to attorneys.


3176 9/21/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Organize p:drive.
418 of 610
3177 9/21/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.50 1,252.50 Analyze reply in support of motion to dismiss.
3178 9/21/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 8.20 7,995.00 Prepare for hearing on motions to dismiss,

anti‐SLAPP motion, and motion to dissolve
injunction.
3179 9/24/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 1,072.50 Review Daleiden's reply in support of motion to

3180 9/24/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.20 1,837.00 Analyze Reply to Motion to Dismiss.
3181 9/25/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.00 3,340.00 Prepare for hearing on Newman Motion to Dismiss

(3.3); meet with D. Foran, N. Roethlisberger,
(.7).
3182 9/25/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.20 4,095.00 Meet with C. Robinson et al regarding
(0.7); prepare for hearing (3.5).
3183 9/25/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 334.00 Review and analyze Daleiden's reply brief in

support of its motion to dissolve the
3185 9/25/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 918.00 Research in preparation for oral argument on

419 of 610
3186 9/26/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 76.50 File notice of appearance.
3187 9/26/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.40 2,004.00 Prepare for hearing on Newman Motion to

Dismiss.

Dismiss.
3189 9/27/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Organize documents from related case.
3190 9/28/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.40 4,896.00 Prepare for oral argument on Defendants'

anti‐SLAPP motion.

Dismiss.

Dismiss.
3193 10/1/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 167.00 Prepare for hearing on Daleiden's motion to

dismiss.

Dismiss.
3195 10/1/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Email with A. Bomse regarding
3196 10/1/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 5.40 4,131.00 Prepare for hearing on anti‐SLAPP motion.
3197 10/2/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 7.80 7,605.00 Call with C. Robinson et al regarding
420 of 610
(0.7); confer with L.
Brown et al regarding
(0.2); prepare for hearing (6.9).
3198 10/2/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.40 3,674.00 Prepare for and argue hearing on Newman Motion

to Dismiss (3.9); meet with D. Foran and N.
3199 10/2/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Assist with hearing preparation.
3200 10/2/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.60 3,006.00 Prepare for hearing on Daleiden's motion to

dismiss.
3201 10/2/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.60 1,224.00 Prepare for hearing on anti‐SLAPP motion.
3202 10/3/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Conduct post‐hearing debriefing with client.
3203 10/3/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 835.00 Prepare for hearing on Daleiden's motion to

dismiss.
3204 10/3/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.00 2,505.00 Travel to and from courthouse and attend court

proceedings on Defendants' anti‐SLAPP motions
and motions to dismiss.
3205 10/3/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 6.20 6,045.00 Prepare for and attend hearing on motions to

dismiss, anti‐SLAPP motion, and motion to
3206 10/3/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.80 4,843.00 Prepare for and argue hearing on Newman Motion

to Dismiss.
3207 10/3/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.50 4,972.50 Prepare for and attend hearing on anti‐SLAPP
421 of 610
motion.
3208 10/4/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.20 167.00 Confer with D. Foran and C. Robinson

regarding
3209 10/5/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.40 306.00 Review letter brief filed by Defendants

regarding discovery.
3210 10/5/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.60 585.00 Review emails from B. Parker regarding

(0.2); review letter brief
submitted by Daleiden in connection with
anti‐SLAPP stay (0.4).
3211 10/5/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 334.00 Review Defendants' letter brief (.2); discuss

with D. Foran, N. Roethlisberger, and C.
Robinson (.2).
3212 10/5/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 83.50 Schedule meet and confer and discovery

deadlines.
3213 10/5/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 83.50 Review and analyze Defendants' letter to the

Court.
3214 10/6/2018 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 337.50 Review draft opposition to motion for summary

judgment.
3215 10/9/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.20 167.00 Discuss with D. Foran,

N. Roethlisberger, and C. Robinson.
3216 10/9/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Review order regarding discovery and anti‐SLAPP

stay (0.1); confer with N. Roethlisberger
422 of 610
3217 10/9/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 76.50 Discuss upcoming meet and confer phone call
with Defendants.
3218 10/11/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 153.00 Review letter brief regarding discovery and

minute order regarding discovery.
3219 10/17/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.40 1,836.00 Conduct research regarding discovery in response to

Defendants' letter brief.
3220 10/18/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 459.00 Conduct research regarding discovery in response to

Defendants' letter brief.
3221 10/18/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Email with N. Roethlisberger regarding
3222 10/19/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Email with C. Robinson regarding
3223 10/19/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 4.50 3,442.50 Draft letter brief regarding discovery.
3224 10/22/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.50 1,147.50 Prepare for and attend meet and confer call

with Defendants' counsel regarding discovery.
3225 10/22/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 3.50 2,922.50 Confer with N. Roethlisberger regarding

(0.3); meet and confer with
Defendants (0.7); brief Mofo team
(1); prepare meet and confer letter to
Defendants (1.5).
3226 10/22/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Review and provide comment on draft

counsel regarding
423 of 610
3227 10/22/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.30 250.50 Discuss meet and confer on discovery.
3228 10/23/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.30 250.50 Strategize regarding discovery meet and confer.
3229 10/23/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 229.50 Review correspondence regarding discovery meet

and confer.
3230 10/26/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Review motion to compel filed in related

3231 10/30/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 682.50 Email with team regarding
(0.3); conduct phone calls regarding same
(0.4).
3232 10/31/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.50 1,912.50 Draft letter brief regarding discovery.
3233 11/2/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Review third party responses to motion to

compel brought by plaintiffs in Planned
Parenthood matter.
3234 11/6/2018 KAREN LEUNG 0.50 230.00 Meet with C. Robinson, N. Roethlisberger, and

S. McManus
3235 11/6/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 535.50 Draft letter regarding anti‐SLAPP discovery

stay.
3236 11/7/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.20 918.00 Draft letter regarding anti‐SLAPP discovery

stay.
3237 11/7/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 322.00 Read opinion from Judge Orrick regarding
424 of 610
defendant's motion to dismiss and anti‐SLAPP
motion.
3238 11/7/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.90 751.50 Review and analyze Judge Orrick's order denying

Defendants' motions to dismiss and motion to
strike.
3239 11/7/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 1.80 1,755.00 Review and provide comment on draft letter to

court regarding scope of appropriate discovery
in light of anti‐SLAPP motion (0.5); review
order denying motions to dismiss, anti‐SLAPP
motion, and motion to dissolve or modify the
preliminary injunction and emails with client
3240 11/8/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Email regarding revisions to letter to court

regarding discovery in light of anti‐SLAPP
order.
3242 11/8/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.70 2,065.50 Draft letter regarding anti‐SLAPP discovery

stay.
3243 11/9/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 459.00 Research regarding "First Amendment privilege."
3244 11/9/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 83.50 Review and analyze Defendants' email regarding

discovery issues.
3245 11/9/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Review meet‐and‐confer correspondence from

opposing counsel regarding scope of discovery.
425 of 610
3246 11/12/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Meet and confer with Defendants regarding
Wednesday's joint letter regarding discovery
disputes (0.4); prepare summary of meet and
confer call for Mofo team (0.1).
3247 11/12/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 7.40 6,179.00 Email correspondence with Defendants regarding

joint letter brief (0.4); prepare NAF's portion
of letter brief regarding discovery (7.0).
3248 11/12/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 459.00 Research regarding potential to participate in

discovery in related action.
3249 11/12/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Confer with C. Robinson regarding
3250 11/13/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 487.50 Review and provide comment on draft joint

letter regarding discovery disputes.
3251 11/13/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.60 1,989.00 Revise letter regarding participating in

discovery in related case.
3253 11/13/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.60 1,336.00 Review and revise NAF's letter brief regarding

discovery disputes.
3254 11/13/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.20 1,002.00 Review and revise NAF's letter brief regarding

effect of appeal on discovery stay.
3255 11/13/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 501.00 Review and analyze Daleiden's discovery letter

brief.
426 of 610
3256 11/14/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 668.00 Prepare joint letter for filing (0.3);
correspond with opposing counsel regarding
revisions to joint letter (0.5).
3257 11/14/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.40 1,169.00 Review and revise NAF's joint letter brief to

address Defendants' positions.
3258 11/14/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 668.00 Review and revise NAF's letter brief regarding

discovery stay to address D. Foran's comments.
3259 11/14/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.10 841.50 Review joint discovery letter.
3260 11/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 487.50 Review and provide comment on draft submission

to court re anti‐SLAPP.
3261 11/14/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Create calendar entries and distribute to team.
3262 11/15/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 334.00 Prepare for hearing on discovery disputes.
3263 11/15/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.40 532.00 Compile hearing materials.

Newman's counsel regarding extension to answer.
3265 11/16/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 76.50 Review correspondence regarding deadline to

answer complaint.
3266 11/19/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.10 76.50 Review Ninth Circuit filing by Defendants.
3267 11/19/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Review correspondence from counsel for Newman

concerning deadline for answering; email
with C. Robinson regarding same.
427 of 610
3268 11/26/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Respond to Newman's email regarding failure to

file answer.
3270 11/26/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Email regarding deadline for Newman to respond

to complaint.
3271 11/26/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.60 1,224.00 Review appeal of denial of motion to modify

3272 11/27/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.20 1,683.00 Review filings for upcoming CMC hearing.
3273 11/28/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 153.00 Strategize regarding upcoming joint CMC

statement.
3274 11/28/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Research case management statement.
3275 11/28/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Email regarding draft case management

statement.

opposing counsel regarding Newman's answer.
3277 11/29/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.10 1,606.50 Draft joint CMC statement.
3278 11/30/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.70 535.50 Revise draft CMC statement.
3279 11/30/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 390.00 Phone call with counsel for Planned Parenthood
428 of 610
regarding
3280 11/30/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 584.50 Review and review draft Joint CMC Statement.
3282 12/3/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 153.00 Draft joint CMC statement.
3283 12/4/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.50 1,912.50 Finalize joint CMC statement.
(0.4); provide comments on
revised case management statement (0.2).
3285 12/4/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 334.00 Discuss with N. Roethlisberger regarding
3286 12/4/2018 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 276.00 Meet with N. Roethlisberger and S. McManus

about
3287 12/4/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 250.50 Review and comment on Defendants' proposed

insertions into joint CMC statement.
3288 12/4/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.10 1,886.00 Discuss

with N.
Roethlisberger; discuss
K. Leung; research case law governing closure
of courtroom in California criminal cases.
429 of 610
3289 12/5/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 417.50 Confer with NAF team regarding
(0.2); review joint case management statement
in related Planned Parenthood action in
preparation for December 11 hearing (0.3).
3290 12/5/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 382.50 Prepare for upcoming CMC.
3292 12/6/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 230.00 Begin review of anti‐SLAPP and modify or

dissolve preliminary injunction briefing from
N.D. Cal. and companion Planned Parenthood case
in 9th Circuit; discuss
with K. Leung.
3293 12/6/2018 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 414.00 Call with S. McManus ; prepare and

organize personal background documents binder.
3295 12/7/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.80 368.00 Continue review of anti‐SLAPP and modify or

N.D. Cal. and companion Planned Parenthood case
in 9th Circuit.

N.D. Cal. and Planned Parenthood case in 9th
430 of 610
Cir.

N.D. Cal. and 9th Cir. in Planned Parenthood
case.
3299 12/10/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.50 2,530.00 Continue review of anti‐SLAPP and modify or

N.D. Cal. and 9th Cir. in Planned Parenthood
case; prepare for case management conference.
3302 12/10/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,437.50 Prepare for CMC.
3303 12/11/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.00 3,900.00 Prepare for and attend CMC in federal court.
3304 12/11/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.40 2,601.00 Prepare and appear at CMC.
3305 12/11/2018 KAREN LEUNG 3.00 1,380.00 Attend case management conference for NAF and

Planned Parenthood cases.
3306 12/11/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.30 1,978.00 Attend case management conference at N.D. Cal.

Continue review of anti‐SLAPP and dissolve,
modify, and clarify preliminary injunction
briefing in N.D. Cal. and 9th Cir. in Planned
Parenthood case.
431 of 610
3308 12/11/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Compile deposition times for attorney review.
3309 12/12/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.20 1,012.00 Review 9th Cir. brief filed in appeal of denial

of anti‐SLAPP and dissolve, modify, and clarify
3311 12/12/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 167.00 Review Defendants' appeal brief regarding

3312 12/12/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 382.50 Review opening brief on anti‐SLAPP appeal.
3314 12/13/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 3.60 2,754.00 Review opening brief on anti‐SLAPP appeal.
3315 12/13/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 4.90 4,777.50 Review case management order (0.3); emails with

team regarding same (0.2); review Ninth Circuit brief
appealing orders denying anti‐SLAPP motion and
motion to dissolve preliminary injunction order
(3.1); confer with J. Sigel and N.
3316 12/13/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.90 1,334.00 Review defendants' 9th Cir. filing; meet with

N. Roethlisberger, J. Sigel, and
K. Leung to discuss
3317 12/13/2018 KAREN LEUNG 1.70 782.00 Read defendants' 9th circuit appellate brief;

meet with J. Siegal, N. Roethlisberger, and S.
432 of 610
McManus
3318 12/13/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 114.00 Compile documents and send to client; create

calendar invites.
3319 12/13/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.00 835.00 Analyze Ninth Circuit filings of Defendants

(.6); strategize with N. Roethlisberger
regarding (.4).
3320 12/14/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 966.00 Research and draft response to

defendants' 9th Cir. anti‐SLAPP and preliminary
injunction appeal.
3321 12/14/2018 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 138.00 Read appellants' 9th Circuit appellate brief.
3322 12/14/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 2,925.00 Prepare outline of arguments for opposition to

Ninth Circuit appeal regarding anti‐SLAPP and
motion to dissolve preliminary injunction.
3323 12/15/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 230.00 Call K. Leung to discuss

; research
and draft state court section.
3324 12/15/2018 KAREN LEUNG 4.60 2,116.00 Read and research arguments against Defendants'

claim to right to violate the Preliminary
Injunction based on the Sixth Amendment.
3325 12/16/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.30 1,058.00 Research and draft state court

section of 9th Cir. response brief; review
materials from Planned Parenthood case to
prepare for upcoming CMP document production.
3326 12/16/2018 KAREN LEUNG 3.00 1,380.00 Draft response to Defendants' appellate brief
433 of 610
regarding the Sixth Amendment.
3327 12/17/2018 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 138.00 Discuss with N. Roethlisberger;

edit draft response.
3328 12/17/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Compile materials and send to Arnold Porter..
3329 12/17/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 6.80 5,202.00 Draft opposition to anti‐SLAPP appeal.
3330 12/17/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Review and provide comment on draft motion for

extension of time to file Ninth Circuit brief.
3332 12/18/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.60 608.00 Compile documents for motion to maintain seal.
3333 12/19/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.70 2,162.00 Meet with C. Robinson, N. Roethlisberger,

and K. Leung
;
continue research and drafting for portion of
9th Cir. response brief.

extend time to file Ninth Circuit opposition
brief.
3336 12/20/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.60 459.00 Draft opposition to anti‐SLAPP appeal.
3337 12/20/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.60 1,196.00 Finish drafting state court portion of 9th Cir.

answering brief; begin drafting letter to
Judge Hite explaining need for limited
434 of 610
courtroom closure and sealing.
3338 12/20/2018 KAREN LEUNG 0.80 368.00 Revise and edit draft section of 9th Circuit

brief.
3339 12/21/2018 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 184.00 Confer with S. McManus
3340 12/21/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.10 1,886.00 Finalize state court section of 9th Cir. Brief;

continue drafting letter to Judge Hite on
protecting NAF confidentiality interests in
state criminal trial.
3342 12/24/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 292.50 Correspond with N. Roethlisberger

regarding
3343 12/26/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 97.50 Correspond with J. Sigel regarding
3344 12/26/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 230.00 Revise state court section of 9th Cir. response

brief.
3345 12/26/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.20 167.00 Review correspondence with Defendants regarding

proposed discovery.
3346 12/27/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.10 1,886.00 Review NAF and PPFA background material to

prepare for receipt of PPFA discovery documents
from defendants.
435 of 610
3347 12/27/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 76.00 Compile materials and send to Planned

Parenthood counsel.
3349 12/27/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 487.50 Correspond with A. Bomse regarding

(0.2); review Daleiden excerpts
(0.3).
3350 12/28/2018 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.70 1,702.00 Review NAF and PPFA background material to

prepare for receipt of PPFA discovery documents
from defendants.
3351 12/28/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 780.00 Review PP discovery received from Newman (0.5);

confer with C. Robinson et al regarding same
(0.3).
3352 12/28/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 501.00 Review Defendant Newman's discovery responses

(.4); correspond with C. Robinson and D.
Foran regarding
3353 12/28/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.70 1,419.50 Comment on Newman's production (0.2); review

and revise letter to Judge Hite regarding
courtroom closure.
3354 12/28/2018 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.30 229.50 Revise Ninth Circuit brief regarding

anti‐SLAPP.
3355 12/29/2018 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 835.00 Review procedural history of related PP case

and subsequent appeals and writs.
436 of 610
3356 12/30/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 190.00 Cite check motion to maintain seal.
3357 12/31/2018 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 334.00 Review court orders related to discovery.
3358 12/31/2018 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.30 874.00 Cite and fact check motion to maintain seal;

compile exhibits for same; research document
3359 12/31/2018 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 195.00 Confer with J. Sigel regarding

seal.
3361 1/2/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.30 663.00 Strategize with D. Foran, C. Robinson, D.

Maltzer, and K. Leung regarding
begin review of Newman
production.
3362 1/2/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 240.00 Download Newman production and distribute; set

up database.
3363 1/2/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 828.00 Team meeting regarding
3364 1/2/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.80 408.00 Meet with D. Foran, C. Robinson, D. Maltzer,

and S. McManus on next steps regarding
3365 1/2/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.90 765.00 Attend weekly team meeting to discuss case
437 of 610
strategy.
3366 1/2/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.70 1,445.00 Manage importation of Defendants' document

productions (.4); discuss with
team (.8); review draft appellate brief (.5).
3367 1/3/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 103.50 Review correspondence from opposing counsel re

discovery issues.
3368 1/3/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Revise letter to J. Hite regarding protective

order.
3369 1/4/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 680.00 Manage importation of production from

Defendants (.4); strategize regarding
(.4).
3370 1/7/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.60 2,210.00 Research and revise letter to J. Hite (1.3);

manage document discovery (.5); correspond
(.3); strategize with N.
Roethlisberger regarding (.5).
3371 1/7/2019 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.50 417.50 Review status of Ninth Circuit answering brief

regarding anti‐SLAPP.
3372 1/8/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.90 1,615.00 Manage processing of production from Defendants

(.6); discuss with N.
Roethlisberger and D. Foran (.5); review
appellate procedures (.5); correspond with
(.3).
438 of 610
(0.4);
review and revise letter to Judge Hite (0.1).
3374 1/8/2019 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 0.20 167.00 Review status of Ninth Circuit sealing motion.
3375 1/9/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,071.00 Strategize with C. Robinson, D. Maltzer,

N. Roethlisberger, and K. Leung

;
begin review of 9th Cir. brief draft for
redactions.
3376 1/9/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 1.00 850.00 Attend team meeting to discuss
3377 1/9/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 561.00 Meet with C. Robinson, N. Roethlisberger, D.

Maltzer, and S. McManus
3378 1/9/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.80 2,380.00 Confer with team regarding (.7);

manage document importation and analysis (.6);
review subpoenas in Planned Parenthood matter
(.2); review draft Ninth Circuit brief (.5);
review work product related to prior Defendant
productions (.8).
3379 1/9/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,552.50 Review and provide comment on draft Ninth

Circuit brief on anti‐SLAPP and motion to
dissolve appeal.
3380 1/9/2019 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 2.20 1,837.00 Strategize with D.

Malzer and C. Robinson.
439 of 610
3381 1/10/2019 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.00 835.00 Review draft of Ninth Circuit answering brief

regarding anti‐SLAPP.
3382 1/10/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.10 935.00 Manage importation and review of documents from

productions (.6); attend team meeting regarding
(.5).
3383 1/10/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 357.00 Review Daleiden deposition to prepare for

review of documents from PP case.
3384 1/10/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 153.00 Begin reviewing

email from C. Robinson.
3385 1/11/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.30 2,703.00 Begin research and drafting of NAF's reply to

defendants' opposition to NAF's motion to seal.
3386 1/11/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.20 3,672.00 Begin redactions in answering brief in 9th Cir.

appeal; begin writing motion to seal answering
brief for 9th Cir. appeal.
3387 1/11/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 85.00 Review and comment on proposed sealing strategy

in Ninth Circuit.
3388 1/11/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.00 1,700.00 Research and analyze Petitioner's opposition to

motion to seal (1.2); manage importation and
review of production (.3); discussion with K.
Leung regarding
(.5).
3389 1/13/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.50 2,805.00 Draft NAF's reply to Defendants' opposition to

the motion to maintain portions of the record
under seal.
440 of 610
3390 1/14/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 510.00 Review and comment on NAF's appeal brief

regarding anti‐SLAPP and injunction.
3391 1/14/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 255.00 Conference with S. McManus regarding
3392 1/14/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 561.00 Edit NAF's reply in support of the motion to

maintain portions of the record under seal
based on S. McManus's suggestions; proofread S.
McManus's draft of the 9th Circuit sealing
brief.
3393 1/14/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 8.20 4,182.00 Draft motion to seal 9th Cir. answering brief

and related appendices and discuss
with H. Chaisson. Discuss
with K. Leung. Begin review of Newman
productions.
3394 1/14/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.00 850.00 Review pleadings related to Motion to Seal

(.5); manage document importation and review
(.2); strategize with team
(.3).
3395 1/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.10 935.00 Strategize regarding subpoena in criminal case

(.4); review pleadings related to motion to
seal (.7)
3396 1/15/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.00 2,550.00 Finish draft of motion to seal 9th Cir.

answering brief and related SER documents.
Coordinate with H. Chaisson
441 of 610
Revise letter to Judge Hite on sealing NAF
videos in state court criminal proceedings.
3397 1/15/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.70 867.00 Reviewed motion for summary judgment outlines

and notes; read D. Daleiden's deposition
transcript in preparation for document review.
3398 1/16/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Review new draft of letter to Judge Hite and

confer with H. Chaisson
Continue review of
Newman documents.
3399 1/16/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 102.00 Discuss with D. Maltzer

; discuss with S. McManus the
and begin
reviewing documents.
3400 1/16/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 120.00 Organize related case documents.
3401 1/16/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.20 1,870.00 Review pleadings and revise reply in support of

sealing (1.9); manage importation of document
production (.3).
3402 1/17/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.50 4,675.00 Research, revise and file reply in support of

motion to seal.
3403 1/17/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 714.00 Revise motion to seal 9th Cir. answering brief

and review compiled SER.
3404 1/17/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.20 612.00 Separately discuss with D. Maltzer, J. Sigel,

and S. McManus
442 of 610
3405 1/17/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 85.00 Review and comment on case summary.
3406 1/18/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 714.00 Revise motion to seal 9th Cir. answering brief

and supplemental appendices of record.
3407 1/18/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 85.00 Confer with S. McManus regarding
3408 1/18/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.10 1,785.00 Manage importation of productions from Planned

Parenthood matter and from Defendants (1.2);
review and revise contract from ediscovery
vendor (.5); discussion with team
(.4).
3409 1/20/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.30 2,703.00 Continue to review Newman document production.
3410 1/21/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 714.00 Finish review of Newman production.
3411 1/22/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 425.00 Review and comment on appellate sealing motion

(0.4); telephone calls with clerk regarding
filing letter for J. Hite (0.1).
3412 1/22/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.10 1,640.00 Organize file repository and print documents

for attorney review; review documents.
3413 1/22/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 414.00 Emails with L. Brown regarding

(0.2); phone calls with Ninth Circuit
regarding sealing motion (0.2).
3414 1/22/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.90 765.00 Manage review of document production (.3);

analyze documents in electronic database for
relevance (.6).
443 of 610
3415 1/23/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.60 1,326.00 Continue review of CMP documents. Complete

filing of letter to Judge Hite in state
criminal court.
3416 1/23/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 85.00 Review and approve filing of NAF's appellate

brief.
3417 1/23/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 320.00 Review documents.
3418 1/23/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.10 1,071.00 Review first pass for documents produced from

Planned Parenthood litigation.
3419 1/23/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.00 1,700.00 Strategize with team

(.6); manage
importation of documents from Planned
Parenthood matter (.5); review discovery order
in planned parenthood matter (.5); analyze
documents produced by Defendants (.4).
3420 1/24/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 170.00 for M.

Fowler.
3421 1/24/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.10 2,040.00 Review production documents.
3422 1/24/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.50 3,825.00 Correspondence with Defendants and co‐counsel
(.4); discussion with D.
Foran
(.5); analyze Defendants' production in
electronic database (3.2); manage document
review (.4).
444 of 610
3423 1/25/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.90 2,360.00 Review documents.
3424 1/25/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.20 1,020.00 Revise and execute contract with Innovation

(Arnold & Porter ediscovery vendor) (.3);
strategize with team regarding
(.3); analyze documents produced by Defendants
(.6).
3425 1/27/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.80 2,380.00 Analyze documents in electronic database from

Defendants' production.
3427 1/28/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.10 935.00 Strategize regarding document review of

Defendants' productions (.3); analyze documents
in electronic database (.8)
3428 1/29/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 510.00 Continue reviewing CMP documents.
3430 1/30/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.30 1,173.00 Continue review of CMP documents.
3431 1/30/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 765.00 Review first pass for documents produced from

3433 1/30/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.50 1,275.00 Discussion with S. McManus

(.2); review correspondence
(.2); analyze documents produced by
Defendants in electronic database (1.1).
445 of 610
3435 1/31/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 310.50 Emails regarding

(0.3).
3436 1/31/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.50 2,125.00 Analyze documents produced by Defendants in

electronic database (2.1); review
Parenthood and counsel for Defendants (.4).
3437 2/1/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.10 4,335.00 Analyze documents produced by Defendants in

electronic database (4.9); strategize regarding
depositions in Planned Parenthood matter (.2).
3438 2/4/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Review correspondence with Planned Parenthood

parties regarding deposition schedule (.2);
manage importation of production from CMP (.2).

3441 2/4/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Discuss with K. Leung.
3442 2/5/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 120.00 Organize related case documents; send video

link.
3443 2/5/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Discussion with D. Foran

(.2); discussion with D.
Sterk (.2).
446 of 610
3444 2/6/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 255.00 Review CMP's request to use D. Reeves'
deposition at preliminary hearing.
3445 2/6/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Review correspondence with parties

(.2);
discussion with D. Foran and C. Robinson
(.2).
3446 2/7/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 310.50 Emails with P. Breen regarding request to

modify protective order.
3447 2/7/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.10 1,640.00 Download related case documents; review

documents.
3448 2/7/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.60 1,326.00 Research Marsy's law and sealing procedures in

California state court based on defendants'
opposition to California AG's sealing request.
3449 2/7/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 255.00 Review and revise proposed stipulation

regarding Reeves deposition transcript.
3450 2/7/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Review correspondence with parties to Planned

Parenthood Action (.3); discussion with D.
Foran regarding (.3).
3451 2/8/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.20 1,020.00 Review correspondence in Planned Parenthood

matter (.2); manage document review (.2);
analyze Plaintiffs' production (.8).
3453 2/11/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Confer with D. Foran
447 of 610
3454 2/11/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 400.00 Organize documents produced in related criminal
case; update production database.

3456 2/11/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Manage document review (.3); review

correspondence in Planned Parenthood matter
(.2).
3457 2/12/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Review appellant's 9th Cir. motion to maintain

seal.


3461 2/13/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 714.00 Draft response to CMP's motion to maintain seal

in 9th Cir.

3465 2/14/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Finalize and file response to CMP motion to
448 of 610
maintain seal in 9th Cir.
3467 2/14/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.20 3,570.00 Analyze documents produced by Plaintiffs in

electronic database.

3470 2/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 680.00 Manage document review (.4); review order from

Judge Hite (.4).


3473 2/19/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,400.00 Review documents; download productions and

process.
3476 2/20/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.00 850.00 Correspondence with team regarding
(.4); analyze documents
in electronic database in preparation for
depositions (.5).
449 of 610
3477 2/21/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.00 4,140.00 Prepare for Planned Parenthood depositions.
3478 2/21/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.20 612.00 Meet with D. Foran about ;

pull briefs and orders from the USA v. Stone
case.
3480 2/22/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.80 918.00 Summarize legal holdings from the USA v. Stone

gag order and the government's briefing on the
initial gag order.
3481 2/22/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.60 640.00 Organize related case files; review documents.
3482 2/22/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 5.50 5,692.50 Prepare for Planned Parenthood depositions.
3483 2/25/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Correspondence with D. Sterk of Arnold &

Porter, D. Foran, and C. Robinson regarding
3484 2/25/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 153.00 Review CMP request for judicial notice and

discuss with D. Foran.
3485 2/25/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.90 1,960.00 Review documents
3486 2/26/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Strategize with D. Foran and C. Robinson

regarding
(.2); manage document review team (.3).
3487 2/26/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,552.50 Phone call with L. Brown regarding

(0.3); phone call with A. Bomse
(0.3); emails regarding
450 of 610
(0.9).
3488 2/26/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.80 918.00 Discuss

with D. Foran. Draft response to request for
judicial notice.

3491 2/27/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 102.00 Meet with S. McManus to discuss
3492 2/27/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.20 170.00 Correspondence with counsel in Planned

Parenthood matter regarding
3493 2/27/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.70 2,397.00 Draft response to 9th Cir. request for judicial

notice. Continue reviewing CMP document
production.

Planned Parenthood litigation; meet with S.
McManus and T. Beyer to
; meet with D. Maltzer for
3496 2/28/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.60 2,346.00 Continue review of CMP documents. Review CMP

filing in 9th Cir. appeal of motion to
dissolve/modify PI.
451 of 610
3497 2/28/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.10 1,240.00 Review documents; meet with K. Leung and S.

McManus regarding
3498 3/1/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.30 1,955.00 Prepare for and attend meeting with team

regarding
(1.3); analyze pleadings in Planned
Parenthood matter (.4); manage deposition
logistics (.6).
3499 3/1/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 6.40 6,624.00 Prepare for and attend team

meeting regarding
(1.9); phone call with A. Bomse
regarding (0.3); phone calls and
emails with A. Kleine regarding
(0.3); prepare for depositions
(3.9).
3500 3/1/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 8.20 4,182.00 Finalize and file responses to CMP motions for

judicial notice in 9th Cir. cases. Team
meeting to discuss
Continue review of CMP documents. Begin
preparation for Rhomberg deposition.
3501 3/1/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.50 2,200.00 Review documents; download 9th cir filings;

assist with filing documents in 9th Circuit;
circulate calendar entries.
3502 3/1/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 170.00 Confer with S. McManus regarding
3503 3/1/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 680.00 Team meeting to discuss
452 of 610
Planned Parenthood litigation; meet with D.
Foran, C. Robinson, D. Maltzer, and S. McManus
to discuss
3505 3/3/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 561.00 Read T. Newman's first deposition transcript,

T. Newman's motion to dismiss, NAF's opposition
to T. Newman's motion to dismiss in preparation
for deposition preparation for T. Newman's
deposition.
3506 3/4/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.80 612.00 Prepare background materials for subsequent

attorney review.
3507 3/4/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.60 3,876.00 Finish review of CMP documents. Begin

reviewing and categorizing documents for
Rhomberg deposition. Review Daleiden writ of
mandate filing.
3508 3/4/2019 KAREN LEUNG 6.60 3,366.00 Gather relevant documents for D. Foran in

preparation for T. Newman's deposition.
3509 3/4/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.50 2,200.00 Review video log and create Bettesworth clips

for deposition; review documents; compile
documents for attorney review.
3510 3/4/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 170.00 Identify videotape needed for deposition

preparation of A. Bettisworth.
3511 3/4/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.40 2,890.00 Correspondence with counsel in Planned

Parenthood matter (.6); discussion with D.
Foran, S. McManus, and K. Leung regarding
453 of 610
(.7); manage document
review (.4); manage deposition schedule (.4);
prepare for deposition of A. Rhomberg (1.1);
correspondence with L. Brown regarding
(.2).
3512 3/5/2019 KAREN LEUNG 7.40 3,774.00 Meet with D. Foran to discuss

; research 5th Amendment
adverse inferences in the 9th Circuit; research
agency theory of liability at the motion for
summary judgment stage.
3513 3/5/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.10 1,581.00 Finish initial review of Rhomberg documents

(1.0); discuss with D.
Maltzer (0.3); begin review of Bettisworth
documents for deposition (1.5).
3514 3/5/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.80 2,720.00 Covert videos in preparation for Bettisworth

deposition; create deposition clips.
3515 3/5/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.60 3,726.00 Prepare for T. Newman deposition.
3516 3/5/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.90 4,165.00 Discussion with S. McManus and D. Foran

regarding
(.4); review Rhomberg documents (3.1);
correspondence with D. Sterk of Arnold & Porter
regarding (.2); draft
budget and litigation plan (1.2).
3517 3/6/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 255.00 Review new document production from CMP.
3518 3/6/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.10 2,440.00 Convert video files for deposition clips.
454 of 610
3519 3/6/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 3,622.50 Prepare for T. Newman deposition.
3520 3/6/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.50 2,805.00 Research alter ego and agency theories in

motion for summary judgment context; review
latest batch of produced documents from CMP and
flag relevant ones for T. Newman's deposition.
3521 3/6/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 680.00 Prepare strategy for scope and timing of

Daleiden's deposition in the PP case in light
of prior narrow deposition in the NAF case.
3522 3/6/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 9.60 8,160.00 Revise budget for matter (1.3); review

correspondence with counsel in Planned
Parenthood matter regarding (.4);
manage importation of documents produced by CMP
(.4); correspondence with counsel for Planned
(.7); analyze documents and draft
outline for deposition of A. Rhomberg (6.8).
3523 3/7/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 7.60 6,460.00 Prepare for deposition of A. Rhomberg (6.1);

strategize with D. Foran, S. McManus, and K.
Leung regarding
(1.2); correspondence with D. Sterk
of Arnold & Porter regarding
(.2).
3524 3/7/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.40 3,519.00 Prepare for T. Newman deposition (2.6); attend

team meeting regarding
(0.7).
3525 3/7/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.80 2,320.00 Convert under cover videos; update deposition

database; compile Newman witness file.
455 of 610
3526 3/7/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.60 2,856.00 Research and draft outline on alter ego and

agency theories; research and draft outline on
5th Amendment and adverse inferences; meet with
D. Foran, D. Maltzer, and S. McManus to discuss
3527 3/7/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.60 3,366.00 Review Rhomberg documents (3.0); meet with D.

Maltzer to discuss (0.5);
begin developing Rhomberg deposition outline
(2.1); weekly team meeting (1.0).
3528 3/8/2019 KAREN LEUNG 3.00 1,530.00 Review documents in preparation for S.

Merritt's deposition.
3529 3/8/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.10 1,581.00 Finish reviewing Rhomberg docs (0.7); review

Planned Parenthood filings (0.3); review
Daleiden deposition for alter ego evidence
(1.5); continue review of Bettisworth documents
(0.6).

strategize with D. Foran, S. McManus, and K.
Leung regarding
(.4); correspondence with D. Sterk of
Arnold & Porter regarding
(.2).
3531 3/8/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 2.80 2,898.00 Prepare for Newman deposition (2.1); phone

calls and emails with counsel for Planned
(0.7).
456 of 610
3532 3/8/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.90 1,160.00 Convert video files.
3533 3/9/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 663.00 Review and evaluate documents in preparation

for S. Merritt's deposition preparation.
3534 3/11/2019 KAREN LEUNG 7.80 3,978.00 Discuss

with D. Foran and S.
McManus; pull and prepare package of flagged
documents for D. Foran ahead of T. Newman's
deposition.
3535 3/11/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.40 2,244.00 Call with Arnold & Porter to discuss

(0.6); continue review of
Bettisworth documents (3.4); meeting with D.
Foran and K. Leung to discuss
(0.4).
3536 3/11/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.10 840.00 Create deposition clips; update calendar

entries; update LiveNote database.
3537 3/11/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 170.00 Review and analyze recent court orders

regarding scope of depositions.

discussion with D. Sterk regarding
(.4); manage
database of documents produced by Defendants
(.3); review recent orders in Planned
Parenthood case (.5).
3539 3/11/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 7.90 8,176.50 Prepare for upcoming depositions.
3540 3/11/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.30 1,462.00 Compile tracking chart of chains of instant
457 of 610
messages for subsequent attorney review.
3541 3/12/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 5.70 5,899.50 Phone calls and emails with A. Bomse regarding
(0.5); prepare for T. Newman deposition (5.2).
3542 3/12/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.30 2,805.00 Prepare for depositions of T. Newman and A.

Rhomberg (2.6); correspondence with counsel for
Planned Parenthood regarding (.4);
correspondence with counsel in Planned
(.3).
3544 3/12/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 340.00 Confer with J. Kamras and D. Foran regarding
3545 3/12/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.20 480.00 Finalize video clips for Bettisworth

deposition; update calendar entries; organize
deposition notices; Bettisworth deposition
preparation.
3546 3/12/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.40 1,734.00 Continue preparation for Bettisworth deposition

(2.2); analyze CMP tax documents (1.2).
3547 3/12/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.80 1,428.00 Discuss with D.

Foran; review and finalize set of documents to
bring to T. Newman's deposition.
3548 3/13/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.00 2,040.00

discuss with M. Linch (0.5); finish initial
458 of 610
preparation for Bettisworth deposition and
discuss with C. Robinson (1.5);
discuss
with D. Maltzer (1.0); begin preparation for
Lopez deposition (0.7); review rough draft of
Newman deposition outline (0.3).
3549 3/13/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 170.00 Conference with S. McManus
3551 3/13/2019 KAREN LEUNG 9.00 4,590.00 Attend T. Newman's deposition.
3552 3/13/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 320.00 Compile and share materials with Arnold and

Porter.
3553 3/13/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 8.20 8,487.00 Attend and take deposition of T. Newman.
3554 3/13/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.80 4,080.00 Analyze outline of Arnold & Portner for

deposition of A. Rhomberg (1.4); prepare for
deposition of A. Rhomberg (3.3); correspondence
with team regarding
(.7); discussion with D. Foran
regarding (.4).
3555 3/14/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 7.50 7,762.50 Phone call with A. Bomse et al regarding

(1.0); phone
calls and emails with D. Maltzer regarding
(1.3); prepare for
depositions (5.2).
459 of 610
3556 3/14/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 10.50 8,925.00 Prepare for, attend, and take deposition of A.
Rhomberg.
3557 3/14/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 10.00 5,100.00 Finish preparation for Rhomberg deposition

(1.0); attend Rhomberg deposition (9.0).
3559 3/15/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 714.00 Team meeting to discuss

(0.7); begin drafting joint discovery letter
about lack of 1st Amendment testimonial
privilege (0.6).
3560 3/15/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.60 510.00 Telephone call with Mofo and Arnold Porter

regarding
3561 3/15/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 255.00 Confer with NAF team regarding
3562 3/15/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.70 1,080.00 Organize deposition files; download files from

co‐counsel.
3563 3/15/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.40 160.00 Revise calendar entries.
3564 3/15/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 510.00 Meet with D. Foran, A. Kleine, D. Maltzer, C.

Robinson, and S. McManus about
3565 3/15/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 5.40 5,589.00 Phone call with counsel for Planned Parenthood

regarding
460 of 610
(1.3);
(0.9); confer with M. Smith
regarding
(0.3); prepare
for depositions (2.9).
3566 3/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.10 1,785.00 Analyze deposition transcripts of J. Holman, A.

Rhomberg, and T. Newman.
3567 3/16/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 357.00 Begin review of Lopez documents for deposition.
3568 3/17/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 204.00 Begin drafting letter to Judge Ryu on discovery

dispute about testimonial privileges in
depositions.
3569 3/18/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.80 918.00 Continue Bettisworth and Lopez deposition

preparation.
3570 3/18/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.60 3,726.00 Prepare for Lopez deposition.
3571 3/18/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.60 1,440.00 Review orders; research deposition cites;

revise video logs for deposition
3572 3/18/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 6.10 5,185.00 Research and draft motion regarding Defendants'

improper objections during deposition (4.8);
develop strategy with D. Foran regarding
(.8); discussion with M. Smith
regarding
(.5).
3573 3/19/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 6.00 6,210.00 Review and provide comments on draft motion to

compel additional testimony from Rhomberg
461 of 610
(1.0); emails regarding
(0.3); confer with A. Kleine
regarding (0.5); prepare for
upcoming depositions (4.7)
3574 3/19/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 9.40 4,794.00 Continue Bettisworth preparation (7.4); confer

with C. Robinson about
(0.5); coordinate
(1.0); confer with D. Foran
and T. Beyer
(0.5).
3575 3/19/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 8.60 3,440.00 Compile documents for attorney review; meet

regarding ; review
depositions for cites.
3576 3/19/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 340.00 Confer with Arnold & Porter regarding
3577 3/19/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,825.00 Prepare for A. Bettisworth deposition (4);

confer with S. McManus regarding
(0.5).
3578 3/19/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.80 3,230.00 Research and revise motion to compel (3.5);

discussion with D. Foran regarding (.3).
3579 3/20/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 4.50 3,825.00 Prepare deposition outline for A. Bettisworth.
3580 3/20/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.70 3,145.00 Develop strategies with D. Foran regarding
(.5); revise discovery brief related to
462 of 610
motion to compel in Planned Parenthood matter
(2.8); correspondence with counsel for Planned
(.4).
3581 3/20/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.10 1,581.00 Coordinate filing of 9th Cir. oral argument

availability (0.2); review Bettisworth
documents and video clips and send to
deposition site in North Carolina (1.8); review
Lopez documents and clips and coordinate
transcription (1.1).
3582 3/20/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.90 2,760.00 Convert video clips; create deposition cites;

cite check work motion.
3583 3/20/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 2,173.50 Prepare for depositions (1.5); prepare outline

for motion to compel Merritt to sit for
additional deposition time (0.6).
3584 3/21/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.90 3,315.00 Develop strategy with D. Foran and counsel for

(1.1); research motion in support of
additional time for deposition of S. Merritt
(2.3); review deposition of A. Rhomberg (.5).
3585 3/21/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.30 1,122.00 Prepare deposition video and audio clips.
3586 3/21/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.20 1,680.00 Organize files for depositions; convert

deposition clips;
3587 3/21/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.30 2,193.00 Review and compile Lopez documents (2.5);

review and compile Baxter documents (1.8).
463 of 610
3588 3/21/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.00 4,250.00 Travel to Jacksonville, North Carolina for A.
Bettisworth deposition.
3589 3/21/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 10.20 8,670.00 Prepare outline for A. Bettisworth deposition.
3590 3/21/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.60 1,326.00 Review and select documents for S. Merritt

deposition.
3591 3/22/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 9.30 7,905.00 Attend and take deposition of A. Bettisworth.
3592 3/22/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.70 595.00 Prepare outline for A. Bettisworth deposition.
3593 3/22/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.90 5,071.50 Prepare for upcoming depositions in Planned

Parenthood matter.
3594 3/22/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.70 1,445.00 Discussion with D. Foran and C. Robinson

regarding (.5);
discussion with team regarding
(.3); prepare for
deposition of B. Baxter (.9).
3595 3/23/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 10.30 8,755.00 Travel home from A. Bettisworth deposition.
3596 3/25/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.30 2,805.00 Revise motion related to assertion of first

amendment at deposition (.6); research motion
related to extension of time for depositions
(.8); correspondence with counsel for Planned
(.4); prepare for deposition of A. Lopez (1.5).
3597 3/25/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.70 4,864.50 Conferences regarding

(1.5); prepare for depositions (3.2).
464 of 610
3598 3/25/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.20 2,142.00 Review and compile Bettisworth deposition
materials (2.5); confer with D. Foran and D.
Maltzer regarding
(0.5); begin Baxter deposition
preparation (1.2).
3599 3/25/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.30 520.00 A. Lopez deposition preparation.
3600 3/25/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.30 1,462.00 Prepare Adrian Lopez and Brianna Allen

deposition clips.
3601 3/26/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.10 561.00 Final preparation for Lopez deposition (0.7);

continue preparation for Baxter deposition
(0.4).
3602 3/26/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 7.20 6,120.00 Preparation for the deposition of Defendant A.

Lopez (3.2); travel to the deposition of A.
Lopez (4).
3603 3/26/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.90 5,071.50 Prepare for depositions.
3604 3/27/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.20 1,242.00 Emails with team regarding
3605 3/27/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 14.00 11,900.00 Preparation for and taking of the deposition of

Defendant A. Lopez (10.8); travel from
deposition home (3.2).
3606 3/27/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 306.00 Review CMP's "security expert" report and

prepare summary.
3607 3/27/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 13.80 7,038.00 Travel from home to deposition (3.0); prepare

for and second chair deposition of Lopez
(10.8).
465 of 610
3608 3/27/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.80 2,652.00 Prepare deposition clips for Brianna Allen

deposition.
3609 3/28/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 782.00 Preparation of Brianna Allen deposition video

and audio clips.
3610 3/28/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 8.40 4,284.00 Send recap of Lopez deposition (0.4); prepare

for Baxter deposition (4.6); team call to
(0.4); travel home
from San Diego (3.0).
3611 3/28/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 306.00 Meet with D. Foran, C. Robinson, D. Maltzer,

and S. McManus to discuss
3612 3/28/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 425.00 Meeting with NAF team regarding
3613 3/28/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.70 1,080.00 Cite check joint letter; create video clips for

Allen deposition; Daleiden and Merritt
deposition preparation.
3614 3/28/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.10 4,335.00 Prepare for and attend team strategy meeting

(.6); research and draft request for additional
time in deposition of S. Merritt (3.3); prepare
for deposition of B. Baxter (.7); revise motion
related to improper deposition objections
(.5).
3615 3/28/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,035.00 Attend weekly team meeting regarding
466 of 610
3616 3/29/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.60 640.00 Organize deposition files; Nucatola deposition
preparation.
3617 3/29/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.40 1,224.00 Continue preparation for Baxter deposition.
3618 3/29/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.60 1,656.00 Review and provide comment on draft motion to

compel additional deposition time from Merritt
(1.2); confer with S. McManus regarding
(0.4).
3619 3/29/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.30 1,173.00 Meet With S. McManus on

; identify potential documents
to use as exhibits for upcoming depositions;
confer with A. Kleine on
3620 3/29/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.00 2,550.00 Correspondence with counsel in Planned

(.4); revise motion for additional time at
deposition of S. Merritt (1.4); prepare for
deposition of B. Baxter (.8); discuss strategy
with D. Foran regarding (.4).

3622 3/30/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.90 360.00 Create video clips for Nucatola deposition.
3623 3/30/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 204.00 Prepare video clip for upcoming deposition and

work with T. Beyer to
3624 3/30/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 714.00 Continue Baxter deposition preparation.
467 of 610
3625 3/31/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Continue preparing for Baxter deposition.
3626 3/31/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 714.00 Review and identify documents to use at D.

Nucatola and D. VanDerhei's upcoming
depositions.
3627 3/31/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.10 440.00 Update deposition calendar; create deposition

clips.

3629 4/1/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.20 880.00 Compile materials and send to Arnold & Porter;

review video files; create video clips.
3630 4/1/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.40 1,224.00 Search and prepare documents for upcoming

doctor depositions; meet with A. Kleine to
; meet
with S. McManus to
3631 4/1/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.70 1,377.00 Locate and review Vanderhei videos for use at

deposition (2.0); review Merritt video logs to
prepare for deposition (0.7).
3632 4/1/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.70 595.00 Develop strategy with Planned Parenthood

counsel regarding
(.4); revise motion related to additional time
for deposition of S. Merritt (.3).
3633 4/1/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 3,105.00 Emails and phone calls regarding
468 of 610
3634 4/1/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 510.00 Assist with Merritt deposition preparation.
3635 4/2/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Develop strategy with Planned Parenthood

counsel regarding
3636 4/2/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 2.60 2,691.00 Meeting with A. Kleine et al regarding
(0.4); review Merritt documents for deposition
prep (2.2).
3637 4/2/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.40 1,224.00 Discuss

with D. Foran, A. Kleine, and K. Leung (0.4);
compile video for Nucatola and Vanderhei
depositions (0.5); review video logs for
Merritt videos (1.5).
3638 4/2/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 170.00 Conference with K. Leung regarding
3639 4/2/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.10 1,071.00 Meet with D. Foran, A. Kleine, and S. McManus

to discuss
3640 4/3/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 3.80 1,520.00 Convert video files; create deposition clips

for Merritt deposition.
3641 4/3/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.20 4,347.00 Meeting with M. Fowler et al regarding

(3.0);
emails with A. Kleine regarding
(1.2).
469 of 610
3642 4/3/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.90 1,479.00 Attend client meeting with D. Foran (2.9).
3643 4/3/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Discussion with team regarding

(.2); discussion with team and Arnold
& Porter regarding
(.4).
3644 4/4/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 5.80 6,003.00 Attend team meeting via telephone regarding
(0.5); review deposition testimony
of planned parenthood doctors deposed to date
(4.9); phone call with counsel for planned
parenthood re
(0.4).
3645 4/4/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.20 2,652.00 Research right to refuse to answer depo

question under California right of privacy
(3.8); finish compiling notes from client
meeting (0.4); attend team meeting (0.5); begin
reviewing documents for Daleiden deposition
(0.5).
3646 4/4/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 357.00 Meet with D. Foran and S. McManus to
3647 4/4/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.50 2,600.00 Create S. Merritt deposition clips.
3648 4/5/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 612.00 Review Merritt video and audio clips to prepare

for Merritt deposition.
3649 4/5/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.30 920.00 Create video clips for depositions;
470 of 610
3650 4/6/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.80 1,428.00 Read and summarize key points from S. Ginde's
book; prepare outline for S. Ginde's
deposition.
3651 4/7/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 153.00 Revise outline for S. Ginde's deposition.
3652 4/7/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 310.50 Emails with K. Leung regarding
3653 4/8/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.60 1,040.00 Organize expert files; organize deposition

materials.
3654 4/8/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 765.00 Confer with D. Foran on

; review S. Merritt video
clips and update transcripts; meet with S.
McManus on
3655 4/8/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.40 1,734.00 Review Merritt videos and transcripts (1.6);

review Daleiden video log (1.0); review
Daleiden documents (0.6); prepare for
telephonic hearing on Merritt deposition
dispute (0.2).
3656 4/9/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.00 1,530.00 Plan for depositions of Daleiden and Merritt

(0.6); review Daleiden clips from T. Beyer
(1.0); review Daleiden documents (1.4).
3657 4/9/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.50 1,800.00 Create deposition clips for Daleiden

deposition.
3658 4/9/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.00 1,020.00 Attend phone hearing with D. Foran; meet with

D. Foran, D. Maltzer, and S. McManus
471 of 610
3659 4/9/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 4,657.50 Prepare for and attend telephonic discovery

hearing before Judge Ryu (2.0); prepare for
depositions (2.5).
3660 4/9/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Correspondence with D. Sterk of Arnold & Porter
(.3); manage travel arrangements for
attendance at deposition of D. Daleiden (.2).
3661 4/10/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.90 360.00 Update calendar; revise deposition clips.
3662 4/10/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.20 3,570.00 Prepare for deposition of D. Daleiden (2.5);

discussion with Arnold & Porter regarding
(.5);
analyze transcript of A. Lopez (.7); develop
strategy for Daleiden deposition with team
(.4).
3663 4/10/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.40 2,754.00 Review Daleiden documents in preparation for

deposition.
3664 4/11/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 255.00 Review and comment on strategy for deposition

of CMP video editor.
3665 4/11/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.20 3,162.00 Review Daleiden documents to prepare for

deposition.
3666 4/11/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 5.10 4,335.00 Attend strategy meeting with team (.5);

(.4);
prepare for deposition of D. Daleiden (4.2).
472 of 610
3667 4/11/2019 KAREN LEUNG 7.70 3,927.00 Review produced documents in preparation for D.
Daleiden's deposition;
for A. Bomse of Arnold & Porter.
3668 4/11/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 5.00 5,175.00 Review and provide comment on outline for

deposition of video editor (1.0); prepare for
and attend weekly team meeting regarding
(0.5); prepare for S. Tennenbaum deposition
(3.5).
3669 4/11/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.50 1,190.00 Transmit case materials to Arnold Porter,
3670 4/12/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.30 1,462.00 Prepare Daleiden deposition preparation media

clips for subsequent attorney review.
3671 4/12/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 510.00 Transmit case materials to co‐counsel.
3672 4/12/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 8.30 7,055.00 Prepare for deposition of D. Daleiden (7.8);

(.5).
3673 4/14/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.60 240.00 Compile and organize appellate documents;

process production documents.
3674 4/14/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Review new production from CMP.
3675 4/14/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 4.40 3,740.00 Prepare for deposition of D. Daleiden.
3676 4/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 10.70 9,095.00 Preparation for (7.4) and travel to (3.3)

deposition of D. Daleiden.
473 of 610
3677 4/15/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 6.90 7,141.50 Review and provide comment on stipulation
extending deadline to conduct discovery in
Planned Parenthood case (0.3); phone calls and
emails with L. Brown regarding
(0.5); phone
call with counsel for Planned Parenthood
regarding (0.4);
confer with D. Maltzer regarding
(0.5); prepare for
Merritt deposition (2.0); prepare for
preliminary hearing (3.2).
3678 4/15/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.00 2,040.00 Finalize materials for Merritt deposition.
3679 4/15/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.90 1,160.00 Organize production files; deposition

preparation.
3680 4/15/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 663.00 Confer with D. Foran and S. McManus on

; prepare
documents for depositions.
3681 4/16/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Review Orrick order and prepare to review

materials requested to be used in criminal
hearing.
3682 4/16/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 13.20 11,220.00 Preparation for and taking deposition of D.

Daleiden (10.6); preparation for taking
deposition of Center for Medical Progress
(2.6).
3683 4/16/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,552.50 Phone call with M. Fowler regarding

(0.5);
phone call with D. Maltzer regarding
474 of 610
(0.5); review motion to modify
protective order (0.5).
3684 4/16/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.40 560.00 Organize expert witness files; send files to

co‐counsel; review production documents.
3685 4/17/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 14.30 12,155.00 Preparation for and taking of deposition of

Center for Medical Progress (9.8); travel home
(3.9); draft analysis of depositions of D.
Daleiden and Center for Medical Progress (.6).
3686 4/17/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 6.00 6,210.00 Travel to Orange County for Merritt deposition

and final preparations for deposition (5.0);
review and provide comment on draft declaration
in response to motion to modify protective
order (1.0).
3687 4/17/2019 KAREN LEUNG 4.90 2,499.00 Review NAF produced documents in anticipation

of defendants' declaration; review and
summarize transcript that defendants want to
use through modification of the Protective
Order.
3688 4/17/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.20 3,162.00 Review defendants' declaration requesting

modification to PO for use of discovery in
criminal hearing (0.5); review documents
defendants seek to use (2.6); confer with D.
Foran about (0.3); begin
drafting responsive declaration (2.8).
475 of 610
3690 4/18/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 8,797.50 Take deposition of Susan Merritt and return
travel from Orange County to Bay Area following
deposition.
3691 4/18/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.00 2,040.00 Finalize and file declaration regarding

modifying protective order for use of discovery
in criminal preliminary hearing.
3692 4/18/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 340.00 Review and comment on Foran declaration

objecting to use of NAF confidential materials
at preliminary hearing.
3694 4/18/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Revise draft declaration of D. Foran regarding

modifying preliminary injunction.
3695 4/18/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.50 600.00 Assist with filing of declaration.
3696 4/18/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.20 612.00 Confer with S. McManus on

; review cited
documents and declaration in response to
defendants' request to modify the Protective
Order.
3697 4/19/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.80 1,428.00 Prepare for telephonic conference on modifying

PO for preliminary hearing.
476 of 610
3699 4/19/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.80 680.00 Attend teleconference with J. Orrick regarding
3700 4/19/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.10 440.00 Deposition preparation.
3701 4/19/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.10 1,071.00 Identify and excerpt video recorded of

in preparation for preliminary hearing.
3702 4/19/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 5.00 5,175.00 Prepare for and attend telephonic hearing on

motion to modify protective order (2.5); phone
calls and emails regarding
(2.5).

(.3);
Parenthood regarding (.2);
analyze court order in criminal matter (.2).
3704 4/22/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 310.50 Review and provide comment on draft case

management conference statement.
3705 4/22/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.70 595.00 Correspondence with D. Sterk of Arnold & Porter

regarding (.2); review
transcript of deposition of D. Daleiden (.5).
3706 4/22/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 510.00 Draft joint case management statement (0.8);

send to counsel
for Planned Parenthood (0.2).
3707 4/22/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.20 170.00 Comment on draft joint CMC statement.
3708 4/23/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.60 1,360.00 Discussion with team regarding
477 of 610
(.3); review
correspondence in Planned Parenthood matter
regarding deposition schedule (.3); analyze
deposition transcript of D. Daleiden (1).
3709 4/23/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,035.00 Phone call with L. Brown regarding

(0.5); confer
with S. McManus regarding
(0.5).
3710 4/23/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.70 867.00 Draft and edit case management statement (1.0);

send statement to opposing counsel (0.5); file
case management statement (0.2).
3711 4/23/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 200.00 Organize deposition files.
3712 4/24/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Review CMP fundraising letter.
3713 4/24/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,587.50 Prepare for case management conference.
3714 4/25/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 200.00 Organize Supreme Court filings.
3715 4/26/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.50 200.00 Organize case files.
3716 4/26/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.30 255.00 Review correspondence in Planned Parenthood

matter.
3717 4/29/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 724.50 Phone calls and emails regarding
3718 4/29/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.20 170.00 Correspondence with D. Sterk regarding
478 of 610
3719 4/29/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.70 867.00 Begin drafting motion to quash Davis subpoena
(0.4); prepare for joint case management
conference (1.3).
3720 4/30/2019 KAREN LEUNG 7.20 3,672.00 Meet with D. Foran to discuss

attend Case
Management Conference hearing; conduct legal
research for joint letter regarding unsealing
exhibits.
3721 4/30/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.40 3,264.00 Prepare for joint CMC (1.0); travel to and

attend joint CMC (2.5); research issues for
Davis deposition subpoena (1.0); draft motion
to quash Davis deposition subpoena (1.9).
3722 4/30/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Correspondence with D. Sterk, counsel for

Planned Parenthood, regarding
(.2); analyze documents proposed by
Defendants for public filing (.3).
3723 4/30/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 6.30 6,520.50 Prepare for and attend CMC (4.0); meet and

(0.3); correspondence with opposing
counsel regarding request to unseal PI
materials (0.5); prepare for N. Davis
deposition (1.5).
3724 4/30/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.80 320.00 Compile case law for attorney review; contact

co‐counsel
3725 5/1/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.80 918.00 Begin preparing for Nichelle Davis deposition.
3726 5/1/2019 KAREN LEUNG 7.70 3,927.00 Conduct legal research for joint letter; draft
479 of 610
NAF's statement for the joint letter regarding
unsealing exhibits; confer with D. Maltzer on
3727 5/1/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 80.00 Calendar depositions.
3729 5/2/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.00 1,700.00 Analyze deposition transcripts of S. Merritt

and R. Davin.
3730 5/2/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.30 255.00 Conference with D. Foran and K. Leung regarding
3731 5/2/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.10 2,601.00 Draft and revise NAF's statement for the joint

letter regarding unsealing exhibits; confer
with C. Robinson on
3732 5/2/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.10 440.00 Organize deposition files; create deposition

clips.
3733 5/2/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 714.00 Continue compiling documents and video for

Nichelle Davis deposition (1.3); review filings
in Planned Parenthood (0.1).
3734 5/3/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.30 2,703.00 Revise NAF's statement for the joint letter

regarding unsealing exhibits; confer with D.
Foran on
480 of 610
3735 5/3/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.10 1,640.00 Compile deposition documents.
3736 5/3/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,071.00 Review and revise Nichelle Davis documents.
3737 5/3/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 7.90 8,176.50 Review and provide comment on draft joint

letter regarding sealing of CMP report
concerning 2014 NAF infiltration (1.0); prepare
for N. Davis deposition (6.9).
3738 5/6/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.30 663.00 Compile materials for Nichelle Davis deposition

preparation binders.
3739 5/6/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 40.00 Create calendar entries.
3740 5/6/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 714.00 Prepare deposition exhibit index.
3741 5/6/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.20 170.00 Review notice of hearing regarding appeal.
3742 5/7/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.80 408.00 Prepare deposition exhibit index.
3743 5/7/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.20 2,652.00 Compile and send Nichelle Davis deposition

materials.
3744 5/7/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.30 120.00 Compile and duplicate deposition clips.
3745 5/8/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.90 969.00 Confer with D. Foran about

(0.2); confer with M. Martin at
Arnold & Porter to
(0.5); continue Brianna Baxter
deposition preparation (1.2).
3746 5/8/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Review correspondence with counsel for Planned
481 of 610
Parenthood and Defendants regarding
(.3); correspondence with counsel for
(.3).
3747 5/9/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.00 1,530.00 Prepare for Baxter deposition.
3749 5/10/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.70 2,907.00 Prepare for Baxter deposition (4.9); confer

with S. Mayo of Arnold & Porter about
(0.3); confer with C. Robinson about
(0.5).
3750 5/10/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Correspondence with S. McManus regarding

(.2); review
correspondence between counsel in Planned
Parenthood matter (.4).
3751 5/11/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.50 3,315.00 Take deposition of Brianna Baxter.
3752 5/13/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Review transcript of deposition of B. Baxter

Balint.
3753 5/13/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.10 40.00 Organize deposition files.
3754 5/13/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 357.00 Meet with and discuss

K. Nesbit;
to K. Nesbit.
3755 5/14/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 3,312.00 Prepare for N. Davis deposition.
482 of 610
3756 5/14/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 0.20 80.00 Organize discovery files.
3757 5/14/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 680.00 Review transcripts of Defendants.
3758 5/15/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.20 480.00 Organize discovery files; compile files and

send to co‐counsel.
3759 5/15/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Discuss with D.

Foran (0.2); send Nichelle Davis materials to
counsel for Planned Parenthood (0.4).
3760 5/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.30 255.00 Review correspondence with counsel regarding
3761 5/15/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 2.00 2,070.00 Phone calls with N. Davis regarding ;

further preparations for deposition.
3762 5/16/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.00 4,140.00 Prepare for N. Davis deposition.
3764 5/16/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Analyze correspondence regarding depositions

and document production.
3765 5/16/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 153.00 Summarize
3766 5/16/2019 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.20 480.00 Make deposition arrangements; compile documents

483 of 610
3767 5/16/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.80 408.00 Prepare for Nichelle Davis deposition.
3768 5/17/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Review correspondence with Planned Parenthood

parties regarding deposition schedule.
3769 5/19/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.00 4,140.00 Meeting with N. Davis
3770 5/20/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 8,797.50 Defend N. Davis deposition.
3771 5/20/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 255.00 Prepare for Nichelle Davis deposition.
3772 5/20/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 680.00 Correspondence with team

(.2); analyze deposition
transcripts (.6).
3773 5/21/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Review filings in Planned Parenthood related

case.
3774 5/21/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.70 1,445.00 Review summary judgment pleadings in Planned

Parenthood.
3775 5/22/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 2.30 1,955.00 Analyze motions for summary judgment filed in

3776 5/22/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.00 850.00 Analyze deposition transcript of B. Baxter

(.8); correspondence with D. Foran regarding
(.2).
3777 5/23/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.60 1,326.00 Confer with D. Maltzer regarding
484 of 610
strategize for NAF's declaration in
support of the Motion to Seal.
3778 5/23/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.80 3,230.00 Analyze motions for summary judgment filed in

3779 5/23/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.60 816.00 Review Planned Parenthood motions for summary

judgment.
3780 5/24/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 3.00 2,550.00 Analyze summary judgment pleadings in Planned

Parenthood matter (2.5); develop strategy
regarding declaration in support of sealing
summary judgment pleadings (.5).
3781 5/24/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.80 408.00 Review PP motions for summary judgment.
3782 5/24/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 310.50 Confer with K. Leung re
3783 5/24/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.60 2,856.00 Confer with D. Foran

draft declaration
in support of maintaining materials under seal;
review Motions for Summary Judgment in related
3784 5/28/2019 KAREN LEUNG 4.90 2,499.00 Draft and revise declaration

; confer with D.
Maltzer ; meet with D.
Foran ;
read Defendants' Motions for Summary Judgment
485 of 610
in related PPFA case.
3785 5/28/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Discussion with K. Leung regarding
3786 5/29/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Analyze discovery demands of C. Dyer of Stem

Express in Planned Parenthood matter.
3787 5/29/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.10 935.00 Analyze updated pleadings from Planned

Parenthood matter.
3788 5/29/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 153.00 Review motions and documents submitted to the

court in related PPFA case; discuss
with S. McManus.
3789 5/29/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Review Cate Dyer filings in Planned Parenthood

(0.1); research stay from appeal of denial of
anti‐SLAPP motion in federal court (0.5).
3790 5/31/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 680.00 Analyze summary judgment pleadings in Planned

Parenthood matter.
3791 5/31/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 510.00 Review video uploaded on Facebook that violates

the Preliminary Injunction; strategize options
on asking Facebook to remove the video; meet
with D. Foran
3792 6/3/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 6,727.50 Prepare for Ninth Circuit argument on

anti‐SLAPP appeal.
3793 6/4/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Review 9th Circuit argument from September 2018

to prepare for July 2019 anti‐SLAPP appeal
argument.
486 of 610
3794 6/11/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.50 1,275.00 Review motions and documents submitted to the

court in related PPFA case.
3795 6/17/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.30 102.00 Update court document files.
3796 6/17/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 204.00 Review and strategize response to A. Rhomberg's

revised portion of the joint statement
regarding the unsealing of Exhibit G.
3797 6/18/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.70 867.00 Confer and strategie with D. Foran regarding
revise NAF's portion of the joint statement
opposing A. Rhomberg's request to unseal.
3798 6/19/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 357.00 Review Defendants' Motion to Seal, declaration,

and exhibits relating to their opposition to
PPFA's Motion for Summary Judgment.
3799 6/20/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 357.00 Review Defendants' Motion to Seal, declaration,

and exhibits relating to their opposition to
PPFA's Motion for Summary Judgment; draft NAF's
Declaration regarding Defendants' Motion to
Seal.
3800 6/20/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.30 255.00 Develop strategy with K. Leung regarding
3801 6/20/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 310.50 Review and provide comment on motions to seal

in PP case filed in connection with summary
judgment motions
487 of 610
3802 6/21/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 310.50 Emails with counsel for Rhomberg regarding
3803 6/21/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Manage filing in Planned Parenthood matter

related to motion to seal.
3804 6/21/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 153.00 Review draft of joint discovery letter

regarding exhibit in Planned Parenthood case.
3805 6/21/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.50 425.00 Review and comment on opposition to motion to

unseal NAF records associated with A.
Rhomberg's summary judgment motion.
3806 6/21/2019 KAREN LEUNG 4.00 2,040.00 Revise NAF's portion of the joint letter

regarding the unsealing of Exhibit G; draft and
revise declaration relating to Defendants'
Motion to Seal.
3807 6/24/2019 KAREN LEUNG 3.50 1,785.00 Draft and revise declaration relating to

Defendants' Motion to Seal; meet with D.
Maltzer, S. McManus, C. Dierolf, R. Brandel, C.
Deb, and K. Miller to
; meet with C. Dierolf to discuss
3808 7/1/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 4,657.50 Prepare for moot argument in connection with

Ninth Circuit appeal from denial of anti‐SLAPP
motions.
488 of 610
3809 7/2/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 4,657.50 Prepare for Ninth Circuit oral argument on
anti‐SLAPP appeal.
3810 7/8/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.90 1,479.00 Review Youtube video for enjoined materials;

review 9th Circuit filings in preparation for
moot.
3811 7/8/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Review Ninth Circuit panel assignment for

anti‐SLAPP & dissolve PI appeal (0.2); review
Daleiden GoFundMe for potential PI breach
(0.4).
3812 7/8/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 724.50 Review and revise draft letter regarding

sealing of secret report.
3813 7/9/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 170.00 Transmit Nichelle Davis deposition transcript

3814 7/9/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 517.50 Review order on anti‐SLAPP appeal and

conferences with L. Brown regarding
3815 7/9/2019 KAREN LEUNG 3.00 1,530.00 Meet with D. Foran

revise
draft letter regarding Exhibit G.
3816 7/9/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Review 9th Cir. notice of case submitted on the

briefs (0.2).
3817 7/10/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 663.00 Revise and review joint letter to be sent to

Judge Orrick regarding the public filing of
Exhibit G; meet with D. Foran and C. Dierolf to
discuss
489 of 610
3818 7/11/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 357.00 Review final draft of joint letter to be sent

to Judge Orrick regarding the public filing of
Exhibit G.
3819 7/12/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 153.00 Review new anti‐SLAPP opinion from California

Supreme Court and evaluate applicability to
NAF.
3820 7/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 1.00 850.00 Discussion with C. Robinson regarding
(.3); revise draft opposition to
motion to stay (.7).
3821 7/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Discussion with D. Sterk, counsel for Planned

Parenthood, regarding
3822 7/15/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.60 816.00 Review Planned Parenthood motions for summary

judgment (1.0); begin drafting attorney
descriptions for fees motion (0.6).
3823 7/17/2019 KAREN LEUNG 3.30 1,683.00 Attend PPFA Motion for Summary Judgment

hearing.
3824 7/22/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 request

by Arnold & Porter for
3825 7/22/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.10 85.00 Confer with J. Kamras (Arnold Porter) regarding
3826 7/31/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.80 408.00 Draft and file notice of appearance in N.D.

Cal.
490 of 610
3827 8/2/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Send documents to Arnold & Porter for
3828 8/7/2019 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 0.40 340.00 Telephone call with Attorney General's office

regarding Daleiden's subpoenas for PP
deposition transcripts.
3829 8/8/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.20 170.00 Discussion regarding
3830 8/9/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 510.00 Download Davis deposition transcript.
3831 8/23/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.80 1,428.00 Analyze documents and prepare direct

examination outline for M. Fowler witness
preparation (2.6); review order on motions for
summary judgment in Planned Parenthood case
(0.2).
3832 8/23/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 153.00 Review and summarize Judge Orrick's order

regarding PPFA Motion for Summary Judgment.
3833 8/23/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Analyze summary judgment order in Planned

Parenthood matter.
3834 8/24/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding
3835 8/26/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.20 2,142.00 Review Planned Parenthood motions for summary

judgment (2.0); review Planned Parenthood
motions in limine (1.0); confer with D. Foran
and California attorney general's office
regarding NAF witnesses at preliminary hearing
(0.4); gather and analyze documents from NAF
production for witness prep for preliminary
491 of 610
hearing (0.8).
3836 8/27/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 510.00 Confer with D. Foran, M. Fowler, and L. Brown

regarding
(0.5); confer with D. Foran and C. Robinson
regarding (0.2);
review materials sent by L. Brown regarding
congressional investigations (0.3).
3837 8/28/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Review motions in limine and pretrial

conference statements in Planned Parenthood
matter.
3838 8/28/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 714.00 Read and review Judge Orrick's order on PPFA

Motion for Summary Judgment.
3839 8/28/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.80 1,863.00 Preparations for preliminary conference.
3840 8/29/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.90 459.00 Confer with M. Martin at Arnold & Porter

regarding
(0.3); begin gathering exhibits (0.6).
3841 9/1/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 207.00 Meet‐and‐confer with P. Breen regarding

documents covered by protective order and use
in criminal case.

(.4);
review unsealing proposed by A. Rhomberg (.3).
3843 9/5/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.60 1,326.00 Confer with D. Foran and D. Maltzer regarding
492 of 610
;
call with M. Martin of Arnold & Porter
regarding
review and prepare
documents regarding Exhibit G ahead of upcoming
meet and confer.
3844 9/6/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.90 459.00 for

Arnold & Porter and correspond regarding

(.2); review
Planned Parenthood trial brief (.4).
3846 9/6/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 510.00 Prepare and transmit case materials for
3847 9/9/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.30 102.00 Calendar upcoming case deadlines.
3849 9/9/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.50 2,295.00 Attend Planned Parenthood pretrial conference

(2.5); travel to and from same (0.7); confer
with D. Foran and L. Brown regarding
(0.6); review Planned Parenthood motions in
limine (0.7).
3850 9/10/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.70 595.00 Correspondence with M. Martin of Arnold &

Porter and defense counsel regarding
(.5); discussion with K. Leung regarding
(.2).
493 of 610
3851 9/11/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.70 867.00 Confer with P. Jonna regarding bond (0.2);

confer with D. Foran regarding same (0.2);
draft proposed language for notice of bond and
bond (1.5).
3852 9/12/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.50 765.00 Gather materials for Reeves witness preparation

(1.2); review order on pretrial motions in
Planned Parenthood case (0.3).
3853 9/12/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 680.00 Correspondence with M. Martin of Arnold &

Porter regarding (.4); revise
exhibit to motion to seal (.4).
3854 9/13/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.80 680.00 Review pretrial filings.
3855 9/13/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Confer with opposing counsel regarding bond and

notice to court.
3856 9/16/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 510.00 Review correspondence and filings regarding the

dispute about Exhibit G; review motions and
filings from related PPFA case in advance of
impending trial.
3857 9/17/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Analyze filings in Planned Parenthood pretrial.
3858 9/18/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Analyze filings in Planned Parenthood pretrial.
3860 9/20/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 4,657.50 Witness prep meetings with M. Fowler and M.

Davis for PP trial.
494 of 610
3861 9/23/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.10 2,601.00 Confer with D. Foran on

; attend PPFA pretrial conference;
summarize pretrial conference and distribute to
team.
3862 9/23/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.30 1,683.00 Travel to and attend second Planned Parenthood

pretrial conference.
3863 9/23/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.30 102.00 Organize client files on electronic database.
3864 9/23/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.60 510.00 Review and analyze Planned Parenthood pretrial

filings.
3865 9/23/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 3,622.50 Preparations for M. Fowler and M. Davidson

testimony at PP trial (prepare outlines, review
documents).
3867 9/25/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 204.00 Review Planned Parenthood requests for adverse

inferences for Newman, Baxter, and Davin.
3869 9/26/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Review Planned Parenthood adverse inferences

requests.
3870 9/26/2019 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 850.00 Prepare deposition transcripts for Arnold &

Porter.
3871 9/27/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 255.00 Gather materials on NAF Violence statistics for

Planned Parenthood trial.
495 of 610
3875 10/1/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Review correspondence on scheduling of

testimony of M. Fowler and M. Davidson in
3877 10/3/2019 KAREN LEUNG 4.30 2,193.00 Attend opening arguments for PPFA v. CMP trial.
3878 10/3/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.20 2,142.00 Attend opening arguments in Planned Parenthood

trial.
3879 10/7/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 204.00 Review filings in Planned Parenthood case

regarding playing of NAF injunction materials
(0.3); confer with D. Foran regarding
(0.1).
3880 10/8/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 153.00 Review filings in Planned Parenthood case

regarding exhibit 72.
3881 10/9/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.70 3,927.00 Draft and file letter to Judge Orrick regarding

Exhibit 72 (1.0); attend witness preparation
for M. Fowler (6.7).
3882 10/9/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 102.00 Confer with D. Foran and
496 of 610
3883 10/9/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 3,105.00 Prepare M. Fowler for trial testimony on

3884 10/10/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Discussion with M. Fowler
3885 10/10/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.40 3,774.00 Attend M. Fowler testimony (6.4); lunch with

client post‐testimony (1.0).
3886 10/10/2019 KAREN LEUNG 6.30 3,213.00 Attend PPFA trial for M. Fowler's deposition.
3887 10/16/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Confer with clients regarding
3888 10/21/2019 KAREN LEUNG 4.50 2,295.00 Attend PPFA trial.
3889 10/21/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.50 2,805.00 Travel to and attend day 1 of David Daleiden

testimony in Planned Parenthood trial.
3890 10/22/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.00 2,550.00 Travel to and attend Daleiden cross examination

in Planned Parenthood trial.
497 of 610
3894 10/25/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Confer with client and D. Foran regarding
3895 10/28/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 306.00 Confer with client and Arnold & Porter

regarding
3896 10/30/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.80 2,958.00 Witness prep for M. Davidson.
3897 10/30/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.00 3,570.00 Attend witness preparation for M. Davidson.
3898 10/30/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,035.00 Meeting with L. Brown and M. Davidson regarding
3899 10/31/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 204.00 Confer with client regarding
3900 10/31/2019 KAREN LEUNG 6.50 3,315.00 Attend PPFA trial and send out summary email

update.
3901 11/1/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.90 1,989.00 Attend testimony of M. Davidson.
3902 11/1/2019 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 3,105.00 Attend Planned Parenthood trial.
3903 11/4/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 153.00 Review ruling on adverse inferences.
3904 11/4/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 51.00 Review and summarize the Court's order on

adverse inferences.
3905 11/5/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Review Planned Parenthood filings related to

NAF breach of contract claims.

NAF contracts.
498 of 610
3907 11/6/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.70 595.00 Analyze Planned Parenthood trial materials for

relevance to NAF.
3908 11/7/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Review Planned Parenthood trial materials for

relevance to NAF.

NAF contracts.
3910 11/8/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 357.00 Review Planned Parenthood rulings regarding NAF

agreements (0.2); confer with D. Foran and C.
Robinson regarding same (0.5).
3911 11/11/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 612.00 Review verdict forms and Judge Orrick order

regarding judgment as a matter of law on breach
of NAF agreements.
3912 11/12/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.10 3,111.00 Attend closing arguments in Planned Parenthood

trial (5.9); confer with D. Foran regarding
same (0.2).
3913 11/12/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.50 425.00 Discussion regarding Planned Parenthood trial

and relevance to NAF claims.
3914 11/12/2019 KAREN LEUNG 5.40 2,754.00 Attend PPFA trial; debrief with D. Maltzer on
3915 11/15/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.70 867.00 Review and confer with team regarding

(0.5); review Ninth
Circuit opinion in appeal of anti‐SLAPP and
motion to dissolve (0.7); confer with client
regarding (0.3); confer
499 of 610
with client about
(0.2).
3916 11/15/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 357.00 Review 9th circuit memorandum in NAF v. CMP;

review PPFA trial verdict.
3917 11/15/2019 DIANA MARIKO MALTZER 0.40 340.00 Analyze Planned Parenthood trial verdict;

correspondence with client and team regarding
3918 11/18/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Review jury verdict transcript from Planned

Parenthood case.
3919 11/21/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Confer with D. Foran
3920 11/25/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Review bill of costs in anti‐SLAPP & dissolve

preliminary injunction appeal.
3921 12/2/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 51.00 Review correspondence.
3922 12/2/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Review filing in appeal of motion to dissolve

3923 12/3/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 153.00 Review Daleiden lawsuit against Dr. Savita

Ginde.
3924 12/3/2019 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 663.00 Review latest correspondence and filings for

updates on case.
3925 12/5/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 102.00 Review Daleiden lawsuit against Dr. Savita
500 of 610
Ginde.
3926 12/9/2019 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 153.00 Review most recent PPFA trial filings.
3927 12/11/2019 KAREN LEUNG 3.20 1,632.00 Review PPFA trial transcript.
3928 12/12/2019 KAREN LEUNG 2.70 1,377.00 Review PPFA trial transcript.
3929 12/13/2019 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 51.00 Review Planned Parenthood briefing schedule on

UCL claim.
3930 1/1/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.30 832.00 Confer with opposing counsel (0.2); update team

regarding same (0.1); strategize with team
regarding stay (0.2); draft stipulation to stay
case pending Planned Parenthood appeal (0.8).
3931 1/2/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Review mandate from appeal of denial of

anti‐SLAPP motion; confer with team regarding
3932 1/2/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review latest appellate updates for NAF.
3933 1/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Review order setting case management conference

(0.1); confer with D. Foran about
(0.2); confer with opposing counsel regarding
(0.1); draft stipulation to continue case
3934 1/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Draft stipulation to continue case management

conference and send to opposing counsel.
3935 1/8/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Read and review email correspondence and
501 of 610
filings regarding
3936 1/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 448.00 Finalize and file stipulation to continue case

3937 1/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 896.00 Confer with L. Weekes regarding

(0.4); review prior case
management statements for statements regarding
summary judgment and permanent injunction
(1.0).
3938 1/10/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Confer with L. Weekes regarding
3939 1/14/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 5.90 3,776.00 Review previous filings in this and related

cases in preparation for research on issue
preclusion; research whether NAF can
offensively argue issue preclusion against CMP,
BioMax, and Daleiden, as to NAF's breach of
contract claims.
3940 1/15/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 4.00 2,560.00 Research whether NAF can offensively argue

issue preclusion against CMP, BioMax, and
Daleiden, as to NAF's breach of contract
claims; draft memorandum email for D. Foran
3941 1/16/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 5.80 3,712.00 Draft memorandum for D. Foran regarding issue

preclusion.
502 of 610
3943 1/17/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Review memo from L. Weekes regarding issue
preclusion (0.3); confer with D. Foran
regarding
3944 1/17/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.70 1,088.00 Draft memorandum for D. Foran regarding issue

preclusion.
3945 1/22/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Confer with S. McManus regarding
3946 1/22/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.80 2,432.00 Draft case management statement (2.0); confer

with D. Foran regarding (0.5);
confer with Arnold & Porter to
(0.5); draft case management statement (0.8).
3947 1/23/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.20 2,048.00 Revise case management statement (2.8);

research post‐trial motions (0.4).
3948 1/24/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 64.00 Revise case management statement.
3949 1/24/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review and provide comments on draft CMC

statement.
3950 1/27/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Revise case management conference statement.
3951 1/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Confer with S. McManus on and

review draft CMC statement.
3952 1/27/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.50 1,600.00 Revise case management conference.
3953 1/28/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.90 2,496.00 Revise and submit joint case management
503 of 610
statement.
3954 1/29/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review filed joint CMC statement.
3955 2/3/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.10 1,984.00 Research granting permanent injunction

concurrently with motion for summary judgment
(2.0); prepare for case management conference
(1.1).
3956 2/4/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.60 2,304.00 Prepare for and attend case management

conference.
3957 2/4/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.00 1,280.00 Attend CMC hearing.

conference.
3959 2/5/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 768.00 Confer with opposing counsel regarding answer

to counterclaims (0.2); draft letter to court
regarding same (0.2); draft proposed permanent
injunction (0.8).
3960 2/5/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 448.00 Read and review draft proposed permanent

injunction and email correspondence.
3961 2/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,344.00 Revise proposed permanent injunction (1.0);

draft and revise letter to court regarding
answer to counterclaims (1.1).
3962 2/6/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review and provide comment on draft permanent

injunction order.
3963 2/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 896.00 Draft and file stipulation to stay NAF's
504 of 610
deadline fo respond to potential counterclaims.
3964 2/8/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Emails with M. Fowler regarding
3965 2/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Review Planned Parenthood defendants's

opposition to injunctive relief.
3966 2/12/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Revise proposed permanent injunction.
3967 2/13/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Confer with M. Fowler regarding
3968 2/14/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise proposed permanent injunction (0.2);

confer with client regarding (0.4).
3969 2/18/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 640.00 Revise and file proposed permanent injunction.
3970 2/19/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Review defendants' answers to First Amended

Complaint.

(1.0); review Planned Parenthood injunction
briefing (0.4).
3972 2/25/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Review and update court documents files.
3974 3/2/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Confer with S. McManus regarding
3975 3/3/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 896.00 Review defendants' requests for discovery on
505 of 610
proposed permanent injunction (1.2); confer
with D. Foran regarding same (0.2).
3976 3/4/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Draft response to defendants' request for

discovery.
3977 3/4/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review statements filed by defendants in

connection with request for permanent
injunction and conferences with S. McManus
regarding same.
3978 3/4/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Prepare materials for client meeting.
3979 3/5/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Collect and organize client declarations in

support of TRO.
3980 3/5/2020 KAREN LEUNG 6.30 4,032.00 Research use of prior testimony in subsequent

proceeding.
3981 3/5/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.10 1,984.00 Revise response to defendants' requests for

discovery.
3982 3/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.90 2,496.00 Revise response to defendants' requests for

discovery.
3983 3/6/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Phone calls and conferences regarding
(0.5); revise
statement (0.5).
3984 3/6/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Prepare for and call with D. Foran and S.

McManus regarding
506 of 610
3985 3/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise response to defendants' requests for
discovery.
3986 3/7/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Emails with S. McManus regarding
3987 3/8/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 337.50 Review and revise submission in connection with

request for permanent injunction and discovery
regarding same.
3988 3/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise response to Defendants' requests for

discovery.
3989 3/9/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Revise response to defendants' requests for

discovery.
3990 3/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 448.00 Revise, finalize, and file response to

defendants' requests for discovery.
3991 3/10/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review NAF's statements regarding defendants'

requests for discovery.
3992 3/10/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Review and catalog relevant testimony for

3993 3/12/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.90 576.00 Draft portion of joint case management

3994 3/16/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review correspondence from colleagues
; review correspondence regarding:
507 of 610
3995 3/16/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review Judge Orrick's order regarding Exhibit

G; email contacts at Arnold and Porter
regarding
3996 3/16/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise portion of joint case management

statement.
3997 3/17/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,344.00 Revise and file joint case management

3998 3/17/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review of joint case management statement.
4000 3/18/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.80 512.00 Review court orders regarding rescheduled case

management conference (0.4); confer with team
4001 3/18/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.20 2,048.00 Review recent filings and correspondence

regarding
4002 3/20/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review and communicate with M. Martin of Arnold

& Porter regarding

sealing issues.
4004 3/23/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 64.00 Schedule weekly team meetings.
508 of 610
4006 3/27/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.60 384.00 Team call with D. Foran and S. McManus.
4007 3/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.90 1,216.00 Call with M. Martin from Arnold & Porter to

confer regarding ;
call with D. Foran, S. McManus, L. Weekes, and
P. Fernandez regarding
4008 3/27/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 448.00 Team call to
4009 3/27/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Attend team weekly call to
4010 3/27/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Meet and confer with team regarding
4011 3/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.20 128.00 Reviewing materials from S. McManus relevant to

legal research on law that will govern analysis
of issue preclusion argument in motion for
summary judgment.
4012 3/30/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Review and prepare for letter to submit in

support of sealing Exhibit G.
4013 3/30/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Confer with L. Weekes regarding
509 of 610
4014 3/31/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.70 1,088.00 Draft letter to submit in support of sealing
Exhibit G.
4015 4/1/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.20 2,048.00 Draft and revise letter to Judge Orrick

regarding the sealing of Exhibit G.
4016 4/2/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Confer with P. Fernandez regarding

;
correspond with M. Martin of Arnold & Porter
regarding
4017 4/3/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Review cite checking and cases from P.

Fernandez for letter to submit to Judge Orrick
in PPFA matter.
4018 4/3/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.30 474.50 Assist with preparation of filing of letter to

Orrick regarding Sealing Exhibit G
4019 4/6/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Gather and transmit preliminary injunction

briefing materials for subsequent attorney
review.
4020 4/6/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.90 1,216.00 Revise draft letter to Judge Orrick and review

PPFA's Motion to Seal.
4021 4/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 64.00 Confer with P. Hernandez regarding
4022 4/6/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.10 704.00 Research into whether California or Federal law

would govern determination of whether an issue
on appeal was final for issue preclusion
purposes,
510 of 610
4023 4/6/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Confer with K. Leung regarding
4024 4/7/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.10 704.00 Researching whether CA law applies to

determination of "finality" for issue
preclusion purposes.
4025 4/7/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.30 1,472.00 Revise letter to Judge Orrick regarding Exhibit

G; confer with M. Martin of Arnold & Porter
regarding ; review and
finalize letter and documents in preparation
for filing.
4026 4/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Review research regarding issue preclusion.
4028 4/7/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 6.30 2,299.50 Assist with preparation of filing of letter

regarding maintaining Exhibit G under seal.
4029 4/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 768.00 Revise letter to Judge Orrick regarding sealing

of Daleiden First Quarter Report.
4030 4/8/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 5.50 2,007.50 Assist with preparation of filing of letter

regarding maintaining Exhibit G under seal.
4032 4/8/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.20 1,408.00 Revise and finalize letter and attachments for

letter to Judge Orrick regarding Exhibit G;
review Defendants' unsealed documents in PPFA
matter.
511 of 610
4033 4/8/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review emails regarding:
4034 4/9/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Create shell for motion for summary judgment

and permanent injunction.
4035 4/9/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 7.20 4,608.00 Research regarding: choice of law for issue

preclusion.
4036 4/10/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.80 512.00 Team call regarding:
4037 4/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.10 704.00 Team call regarding

(0.7); revise same
(0.4).
4038 4/10/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.80 512.00 Call with D. Foran, S. McManus, L. Weekes, and

;
review shell and materials for Motion for
Summary Judgment.
4039 4/10/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Prepare for and attend weekly phone call with

team regarding
(0.5); review memo prepared by L.
Weekes regarding
(0.5).
4040 4/14/2020 KAREN LEUNG 5.40 3,456.00 Review res judicata memos and cases; review

deposition and trial transcripts; organize
materials in preparation for transcript
highlighting for motion for summary judgment
and motion for permanent injunction.
512 of 610
4041 4/14/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.30 1,569.50 Review deposition transcripts revealing threats

and harm and compile data for subsequent
attorney review.

and harm and compile data into tracking chart.
4043 4/15/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Attend weekly team meeting.
4044 4/15/2020 KAREN LEUNG 5.50 3,520.00 Review materials and organization of

transcripts and work product for motion for
summary judgment and motion for permanent
injunction.
4045 4/15/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Confer with team regarding
4046 4/15/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.00 640.00 Research CA law on issue preclusion;

participate in team call.
4047 4/15/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Prepare for and attend weekly team meeting

regarding
4048 4/16/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review outline of Motion for Summary Judgment

circulated by K. Leung
4049 4/16/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Review deposition and trial transcripts; review

outline and materials for Motion for Summary
Judgment/Permanent Injunction.
4050 4/17/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Look for exemplar Motions for SummaryJudgment
513 of 610
dealing with issue preclusion.
4051 4/17/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Review tracking spreadsheet and transcript

organization.

and harm and compile data into tracking chart.
4053 4/19/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Attend to scheduling matters.
4054 4/20/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.30 832.00 Drafting issue preclusion section of Motion for

Summary Judgment.
4055 4/20/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Call with P. Fernandez regarding
4056 4/20/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 64.00 Research permanent injunction case law.
4057 4/20/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Preparation of deposition tracking chart

monitoring threats and harm.
4058 4/21/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Preparation of deposition tracking chart

regarding threats and harm and circulate to
team for feedback.
4059 4/21/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,344.00 Draft letter to court regarding CMC statement

(0.5); research permanent injunction case law
(1.6).
4060 4/21/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.10 112.50 Review and provide comments on letter in

advance of CM Conference.
4061 4/21/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.40 256.00 Continue outlining portion of motion for
514 of 610
summary judgment that addresses breach of
contract.
4062 4/22/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 768.00 Revise agenda for team call (0.4); research

alter ego case law for motion for summary
judgment (0.8).
4063 4/22/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.30 1,204.50 Review and prepare deposition transcripts in

support of motion for summary judgment and
motion for preliminary injunction.
4064 4/22/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.80 512.00 Review highlighted transcript and tracking

document for transcript excerpts.
4065 4/23/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 640.00 Review highlighted transcript and tracking

document for transcript excerpts; call with D.
Foran, S. McManus, L. Weekes, and P. Fernandez
on
4066 4/23/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Prepare for and attend weekly team meeting

regarding
4068 4/23/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.80 512.00 Team call to discuss
4069 4/23/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.60 384.00 Outline motion for summary judgment section on

breach of contract.
4070 4/24/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise letter regarding case management

515 of 610
4071 4/24/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Prepare for case management conference.
4072 4/27/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.30 1,204.50 Review deposition transcripts and update

tracking chart regarding threats and harm.
4073 4/27/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.00 1,280.00 Draft MSJ section on breach of contract; email

with K. Leung regarding:
4074 4/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.20 768.00 Review highlighted deposition transcripts.
4075 4/28/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 192.00 File letter regarding case management

conference.
4076 4/28/2020 KAREN LEUNG 4.40 2,816.00 Review highlighted transcripts; review and

compile adverse inference, agency, and alter
ego research.
4077 4/28/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Review deposition transcripts and update

4078 4/29/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 912.50 Review and prepare deposition transcripts in

4080 4/29/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 787.50 Weekly team meeting regarding

regarding Fifth Amendment (0.2).
4081 4/29/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.40 1,536.00 Call with L. Weekes regarding
516 of 610
; team call with D. Foran, S. McManus,
L. Weekes, and P. Fernandez; research and
review adverse inference, agency, and alter ego
research.
4082 4/29/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.70 1,728.00 Team call to discuss

(1.0);
research use of depositions from Planned
Parenthood case (1.0); prepare for case
4083 4/29/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.60 2,304.00 Draft breach of contract section of Motion for

Summary Judgment brief; NAF weekly team call.
4084 4/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 4.20 2,688.00 Work on breach of contract section in Motion

for Summary Judgment; additional research about
law governing issue preclusiveness of judgment
entered by federal court exercising
supplemental jurisdiction over state law
claims.
4085 4/30/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.80 1,387.00 Review deposition transcripts and update

4086 5/1/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.10 1,344.00 Draft motion for summary judgment brief section

dealing with breach of contract.
4087 5/1/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Emails with counsel for Planned Parenthood

regarding
4088 5/4/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 5.00 5,625.00 Phone call with Planned Parenthood regarding
517 of 610
4089 5/4/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Read emails regarding
4090 5/4/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 4.70 3,008.00 Draft breach of contact section in Motion for

Summary Judgment.
4091 5/4/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.40 3,456.00 Prepare for case management conference.
4092 5/4/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 547.50 Download and circulate joint case management

conference filings for subsequent attorney
review; research Judge Orrick's guidelines for
case management conference.
4093 5/4/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Update court documents file database.
4094 5/4/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.30 474.50 Review deposition transcripts and compile

threats and harm tracking chart.
4095 5/5/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Update court file database for subsequent

attorney review.
4096 5/5/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 7.30 2,664.50 Review 2015 deposition transcripts and compile

threats and harm excerpts for tracking chart.
4097 5/5/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.80 1,792.00 Prepare for and attend case management

conference.
4098 5/5/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 5,062.50 Prepare for and attend Case Management

Conference (4.0); conference with team
regarding
(0.5).
518 of 610
4099 5/5/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.30 192.00 Review and respond to email from D. Foran
regarding:
4100 5/5/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Review highlighted transcripts; review issue

preclusion correspondence.
4101 5/6/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Meet with D. Foran, S. McManus, and L. Weekes

regarding ; review highlighted
transcripts.
4102 5/6/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.70 448.00 Team meetings; email
to D. Foran.
4103 5/6/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.60 675.00 Attend weekly team conference re

(0.5);
review court's minute order following case
4104 5/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.40 2,176.00 Attend weekly team meeting (0.6);
(1.0); draft and send recap
to client (1.0); draft permanent injunction
portion of dispositive motion (0.8).
4105 5/6/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Review deposition transcripts and compile

threats and harm tracking chart.
519 of 610
4107 5/7/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.00 1,920.00 Research rules and prior Judge Orrick rulings

for alter ego.
4108 5/8/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.50 1,600.00 Draft breach of contract section in motion for

summary judgment.
4109 5/8/2020 KAREN LEUNG 5.30 3,392.00 Research alter ego for motion for summary

judgment.
4110 5/11/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.90 576.00

send to Spencer M. and
Karen L. for comments.
4111 5/11/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.70 1,088.00 Research alter ego for motion for summary

judgment.
4112 5/11/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Draft permanent injunction section of motion.
4113 5/13/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.70 1,728.00 Confer with team regarding (0.5); draft

permanent injunction section of motion (2.2).
4115 5/13/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.80 1,152.00 Team meeting;correspondences with team

regarding
; legal research regarding:
alter ego law in California.
4116 5/13/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 2,362.50 Attend team conference (1.0); follow up emails

regarding
(1.0); review and revise notice of
withdrawal of D. Maltzer (0.1).
520 of 610
4117 5/14/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Draft permanent injunction section of brief.
4118 5/14/2020 KAREN LEUNG 6.60 4,224.00 Research and outline alter ego and agency

arguments.
4119 5/14/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.20 2,048.00 Legal research and correspondence with K. Leung

regarding:
4120 5/15/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 896.00 Draft permanent injunction section of motion

(0.4); confer with client regarding
(1.0).
4121 5/15/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.00 1,280.00 Review orders and research on alter ego and

BioMax.
4122 5/15/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.30 1,472.00 Legal research and correspondence with K. Leung

regarding:
4123 5/15/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.20 1,350.00 Zoom conference with NAF regarding
4124 5/18/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.50 1,277.50 Update court documents database (1); Review

deposition transcripts and update tracking
chart (2.5)
4125 5/18/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Draft permanent injunction section of motion.
4126 5/19/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.60 1,664.00 Draft permanent injunction section of motion.
4127 5/19/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Review 2019 deposition transcripts and update
521 of 610
threat tracking chart.
4128 5/20/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.00 2,560.00 Review highlighted deposition transcripts

(3.2); draft permanent injunction section of
motion (0.8).
4129 5/20/2020 KAREN LEUNG 4.00 2,560.00 Review draft MSJ section on issue preclusion;

review highlighted deposition transcripts;
review T. Newman documents for MSJ.
4130 5/20/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Confer with K. Leung regarding:

;
review comments on issue preclusion section of
Motion for Summary Judgment.
4132 5/21/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.30 1,472.00 Call with L. Weekes regarding

; review T. Newman documents.

4134 5/22/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.40 1,536.00 Review alter ego rules; review T. Newman docs

for alter ego support; draft alter ego section.
; update outline for that portion of
brief.
522 of 610
4136 5/22/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 547.50 Gather production documents for subsequent
attorney review.
4137 5/22/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Update deposition tracking chart tracking

threats and harm.
4138 5/26/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.60 1,024.00 Review new Center for Medical Progress videos.
4139 5/26/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 448.00 Review and draft alter ego rules for motion for

summary judgment.
4140 5/26/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review communications regarding: new videos of

depositions posted by Center for Medical
Progress.

4142 5/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.50 2,240.00 Review T. Newman documents for alter ego; draft

alter ego rules and section.
4143 5/27/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.50 320.00 Review of documents in order to identify facts

showing that the Center for Medical Progress
and/or Daleiden were agents of Troy Newman,
4144 5/27/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Edit preliminary injunction section of motion.
4145 5/28/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.20 2,048.00 Review deposition transcripts and edit

preliminary injunction section of motion.
4146 5/28/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 896.00 Send NAF contempt motion materials to Arnold &

Porter (0.4); review Planned Parenthood filings
(1.0).
523 of 610
4148 5/29/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.30 192.00 Team meeting regarding: drafting of motion for

summary judgment; settlement offer.
4149 5/29/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.30 1,472.00 Draft permanent injunction section of motion.
4150 5/29/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.30 1,569.50 Review 2019 deposition transcripts and update

4151 5/29/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Team conference regarding

;
phone call with counsel for T. Newman regarding
(0.5).
4152 5/29/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.90 2,496.00 Review T. Newman documents; team call with D.

Foran, S. McManus, L. Weekes, and P. Fernandez;
review highlighted transcripts; request
from M. Martin.
4153 6/1/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Read and review draft settlement.
4154 6/1/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.40 2,816.00 Draft settlement agreement for Newman.
4155 6/1/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 450.00 Correspondence with counsel for T. Newman

regarding (0.1); review
and provide comments on draft settlement with
T. Newman (0.3).
4156 6/2/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.30 474.50 Download deposition transcripts for subsequent

attorney review.
524 of 610

4158 6/2/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.90 2,496.00 Draft settlement for Newman and corresponding

motion papers.
4159 6/2/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Confer with L. Weekes regarding
4160 6/2/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review and provide comments on revised draft

settlement agreement with T. Newman.
4161 6/3/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 896.00 Review transcript.
4162 6/3/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.00 2,560.00 Review Planned Parenthood testimony for

permanent injunction motion.
4163 6/4/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 640.00 Review transcript and binder materials.
4164 6/4/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.60 2,304.00 Confer with team regarding ; draft

permanent injunction section of motion.
4165 6/4/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 6.00 6,750.00 Review Planned Parenthood record for use on

summary judgment and entry of permanent
injunction.
4166 6/5/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 8.00 9,000.00 Review proposed revisions to settlement

agreement with Newman and conferences with S.
McManus regarding same (0.5); correspondence
and emails with team regarding
525 of 610
same (2.0); emergency request to YouTube in
connection with potential violation (0.3);
review Planned Parenthood record for use on
summary judgment and request for entry of
permanent injunction (5.2).
4167 6/5/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.00 730.00 Download ProLife Youtube videos for subsequent

attorney review.
4168 6/5/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 640.00 Call with D. Foran and S. McManus regarding

; review YouTube video of
potential violation; call with L. Weekes to
discuss
4169 6/5/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.40 3,456.00 Review counterproposal from Newman for

settlement (1.3); review videos for possible
contempt proceedings (4.1).
4170 6/5/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.90 576.00 Draft letter to Judge Orrick regarding: release

of footage of in Pro‐Life SF YouTube
videos; confer with K. Leung on phone
regarding:
4171 6/6/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.40 896.00 Review videos posted to YouTube by ProLife SF

for content potentially covered by preliminary
injunction; draft letter to Judge Orrick
describing perceived breach of preliminary
injunction by D. Daleiden.
4172 6/6/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 787.50 Additional emails and phone calls regarding
526 of 610
4173 6/8/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 6.80 7,650.00 Additional review of Planned Parenthood record
for use on summary judgment and entry of
permanent injunction.
4174 6/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.20 2,048.00 Research service and proof of service and

effects on time to respond in Central District
of California (2.2); review filings in Planned
Parenthood case (1.0).
4175 6/9/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Draft update of case for pro bono committee.
4176 6/9/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,344.00 Review docket updates in CMP suit against NAF

(0.2); revise permanent injunction section of
motion (1.9).
4177 6/9/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review Planned Parenthood record for use on

summary judgment and in connection with
4178 6/9/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Review and highlight 2019 trial transcripts for

4179 6/10/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.20 1,168.00 Review and update 2019 trial transcripts for

4180 6/10/2020 KAREN LEUNG 4.20 2,688.00 Review trial transcript highlights.
4181 6/10/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.30 192.00 Participate in weekly team meeting.
4182 6/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 768.00 Attend team call (0.6); review settlement

counteroffer from Newman (0.6).
4183 6/11/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,344.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding
527 of 610
(0.1); revise motion for summary
judgment (2.0).
4184 6/11/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Review correspondence from counsel for T.

Newman regarding
4185 6/15/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.80 1,792.00 Send edited settlement to counsel for Newman;

review Planned Parenthood record for motion for
4186 6/16/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 7.30 8,212.50 Review and provide comments on draft settlement

agreement with Newman (1.0); emails with Newman
counsel regarding same (0.5); review and
provide comment on draft opposition to motion
for judgment as a matter of law in PP case
(0.5); review documents and testimony from PP
case for use on summary judgment and entry of
4187 6/16/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,344.00 Review C.D. Cal. and California rules regarding

appearance of in‐house counsel, pro hac vice
admission, and signing stipulations.
4188 6/17/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 5,062.50 Correspondence with Newman counsel regarding

;
conferences with S. McManus regarding same
(0.5); confer with S. McManus regarding
; review and provide comment on
outline for draft summary judgment (2.7).
528 of 610
4189 6/17/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.00 1,280.00 Attend team call (0.5); review declarations
(0.5); review Planned Parenthood record for
4190 6/17/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.80 1,752.00 Review and highlight 2019 Planned Parenthood

trial transcripts and track for threats (3.3);
Gather and circulate client declarations (1.5)
4191 6/17/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.40 2,176.00 Review trial transcripts; call with D. Foran,

S. McManus, L. Weekes, and P. Fernandez.
4192 6/17/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.40 256.00 Weekly team meeting.
4193 6/18/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Assist with preparation of Nichelle Davis

deposition review.
4194 6/18/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Coordinate with P. Fernandez regarding
4195 6/18/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.60 1,664.00 Review counterproposal for settlement from

Newman and related correspondence (1.0); review
Planned Parenthood record (1.6).
4196 6/18/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Additional correspondence with Newman's counsel

regarding draft settlement agreement;
correspondence with NAF counsel regarding
4197 6/19/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Emails and phone calls regarding
4198 6/22/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Review trial transcript; review transcript

binder.
529 of 610
4199 6/22/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.20 1,350.00 Prepare for phone conference with counsel for
NAF regarding
4200 6/22/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 4.30 1,569.50 Preparation of PPFA trial testimony materials

4201 6/22/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.20 2,048.00 Draft and send welcome email to summer

associates; devise assignments for summer
associates.
4202 6/23/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.70 2,368.00 Confer with client regarding

; revise Troy Newman settlement and
send to opposing counsel.
4203 6/23/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.80 1,387.00 Review and prepare highlighted 2019 deposition

transcripts

counsel for NAF regarding
; phone calls and emails with S.
McManus and opposing counsel regarding same
(0.5); continue review of PP trial materials
for use on summary judgment and entry of
4205 6/23/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 704.00 Coordinate update of N. Davis' deposition

testimony played at trial for binder review.
4206 6/24/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.80 512.00 Attend weekly team meeting.
4207 6/24/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Attend weekly team meeting to discuss
530 of 610
4208 6/24/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 704.00 Team meeting with D. Foran, S. McManus, L.
Weekes, P. Fernandez, Anissa Chitour, and Q.
Vu; coordinate with P. Fernandez
4209 6/24/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.60 1,024.00 Confer with team and summer associates

regarding

regarding
4211 6/29/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 576.00 Meeting with NAF team and summer associates

regarding ; confer
with Q. Vu regarding
4212 6/29/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.70 448.00 Participate in Zoom meeting with summer

associates regarding
4213 6/29/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.40 2,176.00 Confer with summer associates regarding

(1.0); review Planned
Parenthood filings (1.3); review Supreme Court
decision in June Medical (1.1).
4214 6/30/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Confer with Q. Vu regarding

; review letter sent by P.
Jonna.
4215 6/30/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.90 2,496.00 Draft article regarding June Medical Services

(2.8); review discovery letter from defendants
(1.1).
531 of 610
4216 6/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review defendant's discovery letter and email

with team regarding:
4217 6/30/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 450.00 Review discovery correspondence from

plaintiffs' counsel (0.3); correspondence with
Newman counsel regarding settlement (0.1).
4218 7/1/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.60 384.00 Participate in team call regarding:
4219 7/1/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.60 3,584.00 Write and revise article about June Medical.
4220 7/1/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Call with D. Foran, S. McManus, and L. Weekes

regarding
4221 7/1/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Review letter from plaintiffs regarding

discovery in connection with motion for summary
judgment.
4222 7/2/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 450.00 Emails with client regarding
4223 7/2/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.00 1,280.00 Draft and revise joint motion for dismissal of

Troy Newman.
4224 7/2/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.00 730.00 Review and highlight responsive 2019 deposition

transcript exhibits regarding potential threats
and harm.
4225 7/2/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.90 1,216.00 Draft letter responding to defendants'

discovery request.
532 of 610
4226 7/3/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.20 768.00 Correspond with D. Foran regarding:
4227 7/3/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review and provide comments on draft discovery

letter.
4228 7/6/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Read discovery letters.
4229 7/6/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review discovery letter sent from P. Jonna to

D. Foran.
4230 7/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 192.00 Revise joint motion for dismissal of Newman and

confer with client regarding same.
4231 7/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.50 2,240.00 Attend team meeting (1.0); revise joint motion

for dismissal of Newman (2.5).
4232 7/7/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.20 1,408.00 Participate in team call regarding:
draft NAF's
portion of joint discovery statement.
4233 7/7/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.10 1,344.00 Meet with S. McManus, L. Weekes, A. Chitour, Q.

Vu, and P. Fernandez regarding
4234 7/7/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Attend weekly team meeting to discuss
533 of 610
4236 7/8/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Review joint discovery letter.
4237 7/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise and confer with client regarding
4238 7/8/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.70 2,368.00 Draft joint letter brief regarding: discovery

dispute; conduct legal research with aim of
identifying additional supportive case law to
cite in joint letter brief.
4239 7/9/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.80 2,025.00 Review and provide comments on draft motion to

dismiss Newman (0.2); emails and Newman counsel
regarding same (0.1); review and provide
comments on draft letter to court regarding
discovery in connection with motion for summary
judgment (0.5); prepare for meet and confer
(1.0).

(0.2); revise joint motion for dismissal
of Newman.
4241 7/9/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.90 576.00 Discuss with D. Foran and

edit joint letter brief.
4242 7/9/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.50 320.00 Talk with A. Chitour about
4243 7/10/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.60 2,304.00 Call with S. McManus, Q. Vu, and A. Chitour

;
attend team meeting before meet‐and‐confer;
attend meet‐and‐confer; debrief with summer
534 of 610
associates; review and provide feedback to Q.
Vu on her research assignment.
4244 7/10/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 4.00 2,560.00 Revise joint letter brief and send to D. Foran

for review.
4245 7/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.30 1,472.00 Confer with team regarding (1.0);

discovery issues (0.6); review letter from
copyright counsel for CMP and confer with team
4246 7/10/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 6.30 7,087.50 Prepare for and attend meet and confer

conference with counsel for defendants
regarding discovery in connection with summary
judgment and injunctive relief (2.0); legal
research regarding copyright objections raised
by Daleiden counsel (2.0); phone calls and
emails regarding (1.0);
prepare for and attend meet‐and‐confer with IP
counsel for Daleiden in connection with
copyright objections to injunctive relief and
related matters (1.3).
4247 7/13/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 6.30 7,087.50 Phone calls and emails regarding

(1.7); revise joint discovery
letter (0.4); additional research in connection
with copyright objections to injunctive relief
and related matters (3.5); phone call with P.
Goldstein and J. Liou
4248 7/13/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.10 2,624.00 Confer with team regarding
535 of 610
4249 7/13/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.30 2,112.00 Review trial exhibits; review and provide

feedback to A. Chitour on ;
meet with P. Goldstein, D. Foran, J. Liou, S.
McManus, L. Weekes, A. Chitour, and Q. Vu
regarding
4250 7/13/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.60 2,304.00 Prepare joint letter brief on discovery issues

and communicate with opposing counsel about its
filing.
4251 7/13/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.00 730.00 Review and highlight 2019 deposition transcript

exhibits tracking potential threats and harm.
4252 7/14/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Call with A. Chitour regarding

; revise A. Chitour's work product.
4253 7/14/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Confer with team regarding research.

draft motion for summary judgment and permanent
injunction (1.6).
4255 7/15/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.70 1,912.50 Prepare for and attend NAF weekly team meeting

regarding
(1.0); review research prepared by summer
associates regarding admissibility and
evidentiary issues (0.7).
4256 7/15/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 704.00 Meet with team to discuss
discuss
536 of 610
4257 7/15/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.40 896.00 Participate in team teleconference; review and

finalize motion for summary judgment section
addressing breach of contract claim; circulate
; participate in call
with summer associates and S. McManus and K.
Leung regarding
4258 7/15/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Attend team meeting.
4259 7/16/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.70 448.00 Participate in call with client regarding:

(0.6); confer with team regarding
(0.5); draft motion (2.1).
4261 7/16/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.20 768.00 Team call with client (T. Camp and M. Fowler);

with summer associates
and discuss
4262 7/17/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 704.00 Team call with summer associates regarding

; review research work
product from A. Chitour.
4263 7/17/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 640.00 Confer regarding (0.5); revise motion

(0.5).
537 of 610
4264 7/17/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.80 512.00 Participate in team call regarding:
4265 7/17/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Prepare for and attend phone conference

regarding summary judgment and permanent
injunction.
4266 7/20/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 576.00 Respond to M. Martin's emailed request

regarding NAF discovery; confer with A. Chitour
and Q. Vu regarding
4267 7/20/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.20 128.00 Correspond with D. Foran regarding:
; review
correspondence with summer associate regarding:
4268 7/20/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.30 4,837.50 Review and revise draft motion for summary

judgment and entry of permanent injunction.
4269 7/21/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.80 900.00 Phone call with L. Weekes regarding

;
review order staying discovery (0.1); review
order granting motion to dismiss Newman (0.1).
4270 7/22/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Review transcript highlights; review letter

submitted by defendants regarding T. Newman
dismissal.
538 of 610
4271 7/22/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.60 384.00 Phone call with D. Foran regarding:
; review letter from Jonna to Judge
Orrick regarding: CMP's position on Judge
Orrick's granting of NAF's motion to dismiss
Newman from case.
4272 7/22/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.90 2,137.50 Review letter brief regarding order granting

motion to dismiss Newman and cases cited
therein (1.9).
4273 7/22/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.20 438.00 Preparation of materials cited in letter

regarding Newman's settlement agreement.
4274 7/22/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Review letter from defendants regarding

dismissal of Newman.
4275 7/23/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review order regarding dismissal of Troy Newman

and emails regarding same.
4276 7/23/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.30 192.00 Call with D. Foran regarding
4277 7/23/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review and circulate updated order regarding
4278 7/24/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.20 128.00 Call with D. Foran regarding

; review of summer associates' emails
concerning
4279 7/24/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.10 1,344.00 Review and circulate Defendants' Response to

Joint Dismissal of T. Newman; research
settlement disclosures.
539 of 610
4280 7/24/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 7.20 8,100.00 Review opposition to motion to dismiss Newman

and cases and authorities cited therein (1.5);
review issue preclusion research for summary
judgment motion (1.7); phone conference with M.
Fowler regarding
; review and
provide comment on draft injunctive relief
section of brief (1.9).
4281 7/24/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 547.50 Assist with preparation of materials cited in

letter regarding Newman settlement agreement.
4282 7/27/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 640.00 Review opposition to motion to dismiss Newman.
4283 7/27/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Preparation materials cited in Defendants'

response to motion to dismiss defendant Newman;
assist with preparation of filing of Newman
settlement.
4284 7/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 7.30 4,672.00 Meet with T. Newman's counsel; confer with L.

Weekes regarding ; call with D. Foran
regarding ; research settlement
agreements being filed publicly/under seal.
4285 7/27/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.80 5,400.00 Prepare and for and attend conference with K.

Leung and L. Weekes regarding
conference with counsel for Newman
regarding same (0.5); additional research for
reply in support of motion to dismiss (2.7);
correspondence with client regarding status
(0.2); review research notes prepared by K.
540 of 610
Leung in connection with opposition to motion
to dismiss Newman (0.4).
4286 7/27/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.80 2,432.00 Conduct legal research regarding Rule 41

dismissals as well as joint and several
liability in context of breach of contract and
alter ego liability.
4287 7/28/2020 KAREN LEUNG 8.70 5,568.00 Research sealing settlement agreements and

filing documents for in camera review; draft
declaration and proposed order for motion to
seal.
4288 7/28/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.50 320.00 Conduct and share legal research regarding

voluntary dismissals under Rule 41(a)(2) and
joint and several liability for breach of
contract.
4289 7/28/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.30 1,462.50 Legal research in connection with reply on

motion to dismiss Newman.
4290 7/29/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.20 4,725.00 Draft reply in support of motion to dismiss

Newman.
4291 7/29/2020 KAREN LEUNG 7.30 4,672.00 Draft and revise motion to seal; review draft

reply in support of Newman dismissal; confer
with L. Weekes regarding
4292 7/29/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.50 1,600.00 Conduct legal research for D. Foran regarding:

joint and several liability in fraud cases;
proofread motion to
541 of 610
4293 7/29/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 547.50 Organize court documents and case law into
database.
4294 7/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.40 896.00 Participate in call with D. Foran and K. Leung

regarding ; conduct legal
research regarding "compelling reasons"
standard for sealing documents.
4295 7/30/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 640.00 Call with D. Foran and L. Weekes regarding

; call with
D. Foran and E. Zimmerman regarding
4296 7/30/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.00 730.00 Cite‐check reply regarding motion to dismiss

Newman.
4297 7/30/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 3.60 4,050.00 Phone conference with counsel for Newman

regarding revisions to reply in support of
motion to dismiss (0.5); phone conference with
L. Weekes and K. Leung regarding same (0.3);
revise reply in support of motion to dismiss
(2.3); review and provide comments on draft
motion to seal (0.5).
4298 7/31/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 3.50 3,937.50 Finalize reply in support of motion to dismiss

(1.0); review motions to dismiss malicious
prosecution case filed by Daleiden in Central
District (2.5).
4299 7/31/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.30 474.50 Assist with preparation of filing of reply in

support of Newman dismissal.
4300 7/31/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Review draft reply; circulate to T. Newman's
542 of 610
counsel for review and approval; prepare reply
filing.
4301 8/3/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Confer with K. Leung regarding
4302 8/3/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Review S. McManus's draft of the dashboard.
4303 8/3/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 5.90 6,637.50 Prepare detailed outline for summary judgment

motion (4.1); legal research for same (1.8).
4304 8/4/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Revise issue preclusion section of motion for

summary judgment.
4305 8/5/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.80 512.00 Revise section of motion for summary judgment

on issue preclusion per D. Foran instructions.
4306 8/5/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Attend team meeting to discuss
4307 8/6/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.90 3,262.50 Review letter from plaintiffs' counsel

regarding
(0.3); review protective order and emails with
team regarding same (0.7); further research in
connection with Daleiden's copyright claims
over enjoined materials and process for
application for copyright protection (1.9).
4308 8/6/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Review letter from P. Duplessis and Orrick's

protective order.
4309 8/6/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.20 128.00 Review letter from CMP's intellectual property
543 of 610
lawyer and protective order; email with team
regarding: same.

(0.6); review protective order regarding
communication from copyright counsel for CMP
(0.6).
4311 8/7/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.80 512.00 Participate in team meeting; review and provide

feedback K. Leung draft of letter from D. Foran
to D. Daleiden's intellectual property counsel.
4312 8/7/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.80 1,792.00 Call with D. Foran, L. Weekes, S. McManus, and

; review Preliminary Injunction and
Protective Order regarding disclosure of
confidential materials; draft response letter
to

regarding
(0.5); prepare for hearing on motion to
dismiss Newman (6.2).
4314 8/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise letter to copyright counsel for

Daleiden.
4315 8/7/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 547.50 Preparation of materials in support of motion

for dismissal of Newman.
4316 8/7/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Weekly team meeting to discuss
544 of 610
4317 8/10/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 3.50 1,277.50 Preparation of hearing on motion to dismiss

newsman materials for subsequent attorney
review.
4318 8/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 768.00 Compile and send confidential settlement with

Newman for in camera review.
4319 8/10/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.40 896.00 Conduct legal research to identify examples of

federal courts stating that California applies
federal rules to evaluate finality of district
court judgment.
4320 8/10/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Call with D. Foran regarding ;

revise and update response letter to P.
Duplessis.
4321 8/10/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Review order on motion to dismiss Newman and

follow up emails and phone calls regarding same
(0.4); review and revised letter to Daleiden's
copyright counsel (0.4); phone call with K.
Leung regarding (0.2).
4322 8/11/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 3.90 4,387.50 Further legal research in connection with

copyright claims on motion for permanent
injunction (1.9); further legal research for
motion for summary judgment and entry of
4323 8/11/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.10 704.00 Revise issue preclusion section of motion for

summary judgment; conduct legal research
regarding granting of summary judgment on issue
preclusion grounds in breach of contract cases.
545 of 610
4324 8/12/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.40 256.00 Review letter from Daleiden's IP counsel and

communications among team regarding response;
review and comment on K.Leung draft letter
responding.
4325 8/12/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise letter to copyright counsel for David

Daleiden.
4326 8/12/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.60 1,024.00 Draft and revise response letter to P.

Duplessis.
4327 8/12/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Review correspondence from Daleiden's copyright

counsel regarding request to access enjoined
materials.
4329 8/13/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 337.50 Revise letter to Daleiden's copyright counsel

regarding request for access to PI materials.
4330 8/13/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.10 64.00 Review letter to copyright counsel for

Daleiden.
4331 8/13/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review draft letter from D. Foran to P.

Dupleissis.
4332 8/13/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Edit response letter to P. Duplessis; review

from T. Camp.
4333 8/14/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Call with D. Foran regarding

; respond to T. Camp's email
546 of 610
regarding
4334 8/14/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review emails from K. Leung and T. Camp

regarding:
4335 8/14/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Revise response to copyright counsel for

Daleiden.
4336 8/17/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Confer with D. Foran and courtroom deputy

regarding hearing on motion to dismiss Newman.
4337 8/17/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.50 960.00 Revise issue preclusion portion of summary

judgment motion.
4338 8/18/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.10 1,344.00 Revise issue preclusion section of Motion for

Summary Judgment.
4339 8/18/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Review court order regarding motion to dismiss

(0.2); confer with team and client regarding
(0.4).
4340 8/18/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review Judge Orrick's order granting T. Newman

dismissal.
4341 8/18/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Download and update court documents database.
4343 8/19/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.70 1,088.00 Review Planned Parenthood decision on

post‐trial motions (1.0); confer with team
regarding (0.7).
547 of 610
4344 8/19/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 787.50 Review correspondence from Daleiden's counsel

regarding copyright issues (0.2); phone
conference with team regarding
(0.5).
4345 8/19/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.10 1,344.00 Participate in team meeting; revise issue

preclusion motion for summary judgment.
4346 8/19/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.80 1,152.00 Meet with team regarding

; draft response
letter regarding copyright matter.
4347 8/20/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Revise letter to Daleiden's copyright counsel.
4348 8/20/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Review response to copyright counsel for

Daleiden.
4349 8/20/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 4.60 2,944.00 Revise issue preclusion section of motion for

summary judgment; conduct legal research in
connection with issue preclusion argument.
4350 8/20/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Review and revise letter to P. Duplessis.
4351 8/21/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 576.00 Review draft motion for summary judgment about

issue preclusion.
4352 8/21/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.70 448.00 Finalize

circulate to K. Leung and S. McManus for
review.
4353 8/21/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Revise letter to Daleiden's copyright counsel.
548 of 610
4354 8/24/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.00 1,920.00 Draft permanent injunction section of brief.
4355 8/24/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.00 1,280.00 Update

and send to D. Foran; discuss
with K.
Leung.
4356 8/24/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.20 768.00 Draft case management statement.
4357 8/24/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 640.00 Review issue preclusion section of motion for

summary judgment.
4358 8/25/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.50 1,600.00 Draft case management statement and circulate

to team; participate in call with client
regarding:

; prepare materials for
client declarations (1.3).
4360 8/25/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.90 3,262.50 Prepare for and attend client meetings re
(1.9); review and provide comment on revised
motion for summary judgment (0.9); review and
provide comment on draft CMC statement (0.1).
4361 8/25/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.30 1,472.00 Review, strategize, and draft permanent

injunction research and brief; meet with T.
Camp, M. Fowler, D. Foran, S. McManus, and L.
549 of 610
Weekes regarding ; meet with S.
McManus regarding
4362 8/26/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.90 2,496.00 Review, strategize, and draft permanent

injunction research and brief; meet with team
regarding
; collect and organize materials to send to
M. Fowler; review excerpted/highlighted
transcripts and tracking sheets.
4363 8/26/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Attend weekly team conference regarding

strategy for
comment on draft CM statement (0.5).
4364 8/26/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 4.10 2,624.00 Participate in team teleconference; conduct

legal research concerning issue preclusion as
to intermediate facts; revise Case Management
Statement.
4365 8/26/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.50 960.00 Team meeting (0.7); discuss with K.

Leung (0.8).
4367 8/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.70 2,368.00 Review and revise deposition and trial

transcript highlights and tracking sheet;
and send to M. Fowler.
4368 8/27/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 337.50 Revise draft case management conference
550 of 610
statement.
4369 8/27/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.10 704.00 Revise case management statement; review

correspondence.
4370 8/27/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 384.00 Revise joint case management statement.
4371 8/27/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.00 730.00 Update deposition and trial testimony tracking

chart and highlighted transcripts for
4372 8/28/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.80 1,792.00 Revise motion for summary judgment and entry of

a permanent injunction.
4373 8/28/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review correspondence regarding: testimony

collection necessary in connection with request
for preliminary injunction.
4374 8/28/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.20 2,048.00 Draft permanent injunction section; review

transcript highlights and tracking sheet.
4375 8/28/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Update deposition and trial testimony tracking

chart.
4376 8/29/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 448.00 Revise case management statement.
4377 8/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Review letter from P. Duplessis, defendants'

intellectual property counsel.
4378 8/31/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.80 512.00 Discuss

with S. McManus and K.
Leung; send draft case management statement to
opposing counsel.
551 of 610
4379 8/31/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.10 2,624.00 Draft permanent injunction and motion for

summary judgment.
4380 8/31/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Meet with S. McManus and L. Weekes regarding
4381 8/31/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 912.50 Research 2019 notice of deposition

correspondence for subsequent attorney review.
4382 9/1/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.20 768.00 Finalize and file joint case management

statement.
4383 9/1/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Revise joint case management statement.
4384 9/1/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review P. Duplessis letter and correspond with

team regarding
4385 9/3/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Review letter to judge from P. Duplessis

regarding access to copyright materials; read
team emails regarding
4386 9/3/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.30 192.00 Schedule team call; review letter brief filed

by P. Duplessis.
4387 9/4/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.20 2,048.00 Prepare for case management conference (0.9);

revise preliminary injunction motion (2.3).
4388 9/4/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Meet with team

; review Protective Order and L.
Weekes' research on access to the materials.
552 of 610
4389 9/4/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.00 1,280.00 Participate in team call regarding:

; draft email responses to
questions regarding: protective order from D.
Foran.
4390 9/4/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 1,237.50 Team phone conference regarding

(0.4); review
letter to Court from Daleiden's copyright
counsel and emails and conferences regarding
same (0.7).
4391 9/5/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 787.50 Review and provide comments on draft

declarations in support of request for
4392 9/5/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Read NAF declarations for MSJ.
4393 9/7/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Revise and revise letter to submit to Judge

Orrick regarding copyright issues.
4394 9/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 896.00 Review client declaration drafts (0.6); revise

letter to Judge Orrick regarding copyright
claims (0.8).
4395 9/7/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 3.90 4,387.50 Prepare letter to Court in response to

correspondence from Daleiden's copyright
counsel regarding motion for summary judgment
and permanent injunction.
4396 9/7/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.10 704.00 Draft "public interest" section of request for

permanent injunction; add citations to D.
Foran's letter to court regarding: copyright
553 of 610
issues.
4397 9/8/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.20 768.00 Attend case management conference before Judge

Orrick; participate in team call following case
4398 9/8/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 6.10 6,862.50 Prepare for and attend CMC (4.9); phone

conferences regarding preparations for summary
judgment (1.2).
4399 9/8/2020 KAREN LEUNG 4.70 3,008.00 Attend Case Management Conference; meet with D.

Foran, S. McManus, and L. Weekes to
; draft part of
permanent injunction brief.
4400 9/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.90 3,136.00 Attend case management conference (1.0);

prepare for case management conference (1.2);
draft update email to client (1.0); confer with
team regarding
(0.5); revise motion for summary judgment
(1.2).
4401 9/9/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.00 1,920.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction and

summary judgment (1.5); review evidence chart
(1.5).
4402 9/9/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.90 1,856.00 Draft part of permanent injunction brief.
4403 9/9/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Attend team meeting regarding
4404 9/10/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 640.00 Draft part of permanent injunction brief;

confer with P. Fernandez regarding
554 of 610
4405 9/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.30 832.00 Revise motion for summary judgment and entry of

permanent injunction (0.4); revise draft client
declarations (0.9).

revise motion for entry of a permanent
injunction (2.7).
4407 9/11/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.20 768.00 Meet with team regarding next steps to prepare

for MSJ and permanent injunction brief; confer
with S. McManus regarding ;
forward
to L. Weekes.
4408 9/11/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.00 640.00 Team call regarding: ;

correspond with K. Leung regarding:
; review correspondence
regarding: staffing for preliminary injunction
filing.
4409 9/12/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 640.00 Review evidence chart and draft motion for

4410 9/13/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.50 320.00 Draft part of permanent injunction brief.
4411 9/14/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.10 1,984.00 Review and revise highlights and tracking

spreadsheet of testimony regarding irreparable
harm; coordinate with P. Fernandez.
4412 9/14/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.00 640.00 Review filings we may wish to ask the court to

take judicial notice of; conduct legal research
555 of 610
regarding: judicial notice of indictments and
plea agreements.
4413 9/14/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.70 3,008.00 Confer with team regarding (1.0); draft

motion for permanent injunction (3.7).
4414 9/15/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.70 3,008.00 Draft motion for permanent injunction.
4415 9/15/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.50 5,062.50 Review Planned Parenthood exhibits and

testimony for use on summary judgment motion.
4416 9/15/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.50 547.50 Assist with preparation of NAF production

4417 9/16/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.30 2,112.00 Review and revise transcript highlights and

tracking sheet; coordinate
with P. Fernandez;
attend meeting with T. Camp, M. Fowler, D.
Foran, L. Weekes, and S. McManus regarding
4418 9/16/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.60 1,664.00 Confer with client regarding declarations

(1.0); confer with team regarding (1.0);
revise motion for permanent injunction (0.6).
4419 9/16/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 7.10 7,987.50 Internal meeting regarding preparations for

summary judgment (0.5); review draft client
declarations and prepare for and attend phone
conference with M. Fowler regarding
(2.3); continue review of prior
testimony and documents for use on summary
judgment (4.3).
556 of 610
4420 9/16/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.70 1,088.00 Review filings we are considering asking court
to take judicial notice of; conduct legal
research regarding: requests for judicial
notice; participate in call with client
regarding:
4421 9/17/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.30 1,472.00 Draft motion for permanent injunction.
4422 9/17/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Assist with preparation of PPFA trial testimony

4423 9/18/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 0.50 182.50 Assist with preparation of updated Planned

Parenthood transcript materials for subsequent
attorney review.
4424 9/18/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.90 576.00 Call with clients regarding:
4425 9/18/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.00 1,280.00 Draft motion for permanent injunction and

related declarations (1.0); confer with client
regarding (1.0).
4426 9/18/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 6.80 7,650.00 Prepare for and attend zoom conference with

client regarding
(1.9); review Daleiden testimony and
declarations for use on summary judgment (3.7);
prepare revised outline for summary judgment
motion (1.2).
4427 9/18/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 576.00 Attend meeting with T. Camp, M. Fowler, D.

Foran, L. Weekes, and S. McManus regarding
557 of 610
4428 9/21/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.50 960.00 Draft motion for permanent injunction.
4429 9/21/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 576.00 Revise and draft section of permanent

injunction brief.
4430 9/21/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,812.50 Prepare list of materials from Planned

Parenthood trial for use on summary judgment
and emails with team regarding same (2.0);
phone conference with S. McManus regarding
4431 9/22/2020 KAREN LEUNG 3.10 1,984.00 Meet with S. McManus and L. Weekes regarding

; revise and draft
permanent injunction section of brief.

; compile evidence for motion.
4433 9/22/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.70 448.00 Draft request for permanent injunction.
4434 9/23/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.10 1,344.00 Draft permanent injunction motion.
4435 9/23/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Team meeting regarding
4436 9/23/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 2.50 687.50 Teleconference with team regarding

;
4437 9/23/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.40 1,536.00 Prepare request for permanent injunction; NAF

weekly meeting.
558 of 610
4438 9/23/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 896.00 Meet with team regarding next steps for brief;

review irreparable injury section of brief;
call with L. Weekes regarding
4439 9/23/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Team meeting to discuss
4440 9/24/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.30 839.50 Preparation of deposition transcript excerpts

in support of motion for summary judgment.
4441 9/24/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Gather exhibits for motion for permanent

injunction.
4442 9/24/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Organize and circulate division of brief for

drafting to L. Weekes.
4443 9/24/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Prepare request for permanent injunction.
4444 9/24/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.90 3,262.50 Draft summary judgment motion.
4446 9/25/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.40 1,536.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction.
4447 9/25/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 3,600.00 Review and revise draft motion for summary

judgment.
4448 9/26/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 704.00 Draft and revise section of motion for entry of

4449 9/26/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 787.50 Review revised client declaration in support of
559 of 610
summary judgment motion and emails regarding
same.
4450 9/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 4.60 2,944.00 Draft and revise section of motion for entry of


4452 9/28/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.50 960.00 Review revised Davidson Declaration (0.8);

draft motion for permanent injunction (0.7).
4455 9/29/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.30 4,672.00 Draft facts section of motion for summary

judgment and entry of a permanent injunction.

4457 9/29/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.80 5,400.00 Review and provide additional comments on draft

client declarations for summary judgment motion
(1.9); revise draft summary judgment motion
(2.9).

; draft and revise section of motion for
entry of permanent injunction.
4459 9/30/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Prepare for and attend weekly team meeting re
560 of 610
4460 9/30/2020 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 1.00 365.00 Team meeting to discuss

; organize
and assemble documents and exhibits for filing.
4462 9/30/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 10.80 6,912.00 Draft factual background section of motion for

permanent injunction (10.4); confer with team
regarding (0.4).
4463 9/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.10 1,344.00 Participate in team call; draft request for

4464 10/1/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 5.50 1,512.50 Organize and assemble documents for upcoming

filing; review and profile documents from
related cases and cases in appeals into the
case management database.
4466 10/1/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.10 2,624.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction; revise

Davidson declaration; draft request for
judicial notice; draft sealing documents.
4467 10/2/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.80 3,072.00 Revise Davidson declaration.
4469 10/2/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 640.00 Meet with L. Weekes and revise draft brief.
561 of 610
4470 10/2/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 2.50 687.50 Review and profile documents for related cases
and cases in appeals into the case management
database.
4471 10/2/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 5.30 5,962.50 Prepare for and attend phone conference with S.

McManus re
(1.0); revise issue
preclusion section for summary judgment brief
(2.2); review and revise initial draft of fact
section for summary judgment brief (2.1).
4472 10/3/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 832.00 Review and revise draft brief for motion for

4473 10/5/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.50 2,240.00 Revise facts section of motion for permanent

injunction (1.2); revise Davidson declaration
(2.0); confer with D. Foran regarding
(0.3).
4474 10/5/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Confer with L. Weekes regarding
4475 10/5/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.70 1,088.00 Prepare request for a permanent injunction.
4476 10/5/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.40 4,950.00 Revise motion for summary judgment (4.1);

review and provide comments on draft client
declarations (0.3).
4477 10/6/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 3.90 4,387.50 Review and revise motion for summary judgment

(2.9); prepare for and attend zoom conference
regarding (1.0).
4478 10/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 8.40 5,376.00 Draft and revise motion for preliminary

injunction, Fowler declaration, and Davidson
562 of 610
declaration.
4480 10/6/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Confer with L. Weekes ;

discuss transcript excerpts for filing; review
draft declarations.
4481 10/7/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.40 256.00 Participate in team call.
4482 10/7/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Meet with team regarding
4483 10/7/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 5.90 1,622.50 Teleconference with team regarding

; organize and assemble documents in
document management database; confer with D.
Ridnell regarding
4484 10/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Revise Fowler declaration.
4485 10/7/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Zoom conference with team regarding
4486 10/8/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Emails with T. Camp regarding
4487 10/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 768.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction and

Fowler declaration.
4488 10/8/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 192.00 Read and review draft Motion for Summary

Judgment and Motion for Entry of Permanent
Injunction brief.
563 of 610
4489 10/8/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.60 384.00 Review draft of request for permanent
injunction before S. McManus sends to D. Foran.
4490 10/9/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction.
4491 10/12/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 5.30 5,962.50 Revise summary judgment draft.
4492 10/13/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.60 1,024.00 Prepare Request for Judicial Notice.
4493 10/13/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction.
4494 10/13/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 5.50 1,512.50 Organize and assemble documents and exhibits in

document management database.
4495 10/13/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review and provide comments on draft RJN in

entry of permanent injunction.
4496 10/14/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.50 3,520.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction (4.4);

revise Davidson Declaration, Fowler
Declaration, and related documents (1.1).
4497 10/14/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.20 768.00 Participate in team teleconference; call with

S. McManus and K. Leung regarding:
4498 10/14/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.80 512.00 Meet with D. Foran, S. McManus, L. Weekes, and

S. Ascencio on
4499 10/14/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.20 2,475.00 Review and provide final comments on draft

motion for summary judgment (1.5); attend
weekly team meeting re
(0.7).
564 of 610
4500 10/14/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 2.20 605.00 Organize and assemble documents and exhibits in

document management database; teleconference
with team regarding
4501 10/15/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 6.10 1,677.50 Organize and assemble exhibits cited in the

motion for summary judgment brief;
teleconference with S. McManus and D. Ridnell
regarding
; update dockets in document database for
related matters.
4502 10/15/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.80 2,432.00 Conduct legal research regarding: California

issue preclusion; prepare motion to seal.
4503 10/15/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.80 512.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction and

Appendix of Exhibits.
4505 10/15/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Phone call with S. McManus regarding
4506 10/16/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.30 832.00 Revise Appendix of Exhibits and Foran

Declaration (0.5); confer with L. Weekes
regarding (0.8).
4507 10/16/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 6.90 4,416.00 Prepare administrative motion to file under

seal.
4508 10/16/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 7.90 2,172.50 Cite‐check the motion for summary judgment
565 of 610
brief; draft Appendix of Exhibits for the brief
and for the Request for Judicial Notice;
teleconference with S. McManus regarding same.
4509 10/17/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.70 3,008.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction (0.5);

review Appendix of Exhibits (2.5); review email
reports to Department of Justice (1.2); revise
Foran Declaration and Request for Judicial
Notice (0.5).
4510 10/17/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 3.20 880.00 Cite‐check the motion for summary judgment

brief; finalize draft of the Foran Declaration
and Appendix of Exhibits for the brief.
4511 10/18/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.80 1,792.00 Revise Appendix of Exhibits, motion for

preliminary injunction, and related
declarations (1.9); collect backup documents
for declarations (0.9).
4512 10/18/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.40 256.00 Prepare administrative motion to file under

seal.
4513 10/19/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.20 2,688.00 Revise Davidson and Fowler declarations (1.2);

gather supporting materials (1.1); revise
administrative motion to file under seal (0.8);
revise motion for permanent injunction (1.1).
4514 10/19/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 7.00 1,925.00 Cite‐check the motion for summary judgment

brief; correspond with D. Ridnell and S.
McManus regarding same.
4515 10/19/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,125.00 Zoom conference with S. McManus et al
566 of 610
4516 10/19/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.80 1,152.00 Participate in team meeting regarding:
; prepare administrative motion to
file under seal.
4517 10/19/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.80 1,152.00 Attend team meeting regarding

; email M. Martin of Arnold &
Porter regarding
; review D. Daleiden's 2015
transcript.
4518 10/20/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.90 1,216.00 Read and review D. Daleiden's 2015 deposition

transcript and circulate relevant excerpts to
the team.
4519 10/20/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.20 330.00 Teleconference with D. Ridnell regarding

; organize and
update documents in related court cases'
database.
4520 10/20/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.60 2,925.00 Final review and comments on draft motion for

summary judgment and related papers and
exhibits.
4521 10/20/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.70 2,368.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction,

Appendix of Exhibits, Fowler and Davidson
declarations, and administrative motion to file
under seal.

seal.
567 of 610

seal.
4524 10/21/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.00 2,560.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction,

Appendix of Exhibits, Fowler and Davidson
declarations, and administrative motion to file
under seal.
4525 10/21/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 6.40 1,760.00 Teleconference with team regarding

; finalize edits to
the Appendix of Exhibits to our Motion;
organize and update documents in related court
cases' database.
4526 10/21/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.40 4,950.00 Prepare for and attend conference with clients

(0.7); team zoom
conference regarding
(0.4); review and provide comments on
draft motion to seal in connection with summary
judgment (1.2); further review and comments on
near‐final motion for summary judgment and
4527 10/21/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 896.00 Attend team call with D. Foran, L. Weekes, S.

McManus, and S. Ascencio regarding
; discuss
with L. Weekes; review excerpts of
deposition transcripts played at trial.
4528 10/22/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.00 4,480.00 Revise motion for permanent injunction, client

declarations, Appendix of Exhibits,
administrative motion to file under seal, and
568 of 610
related documents.
4529 10/22/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Review and revise motion to seal.
4530 10/22/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 8.40 2,310.00 Finalize edits to the Motion for Summary

Judgment brief; confer with S. McManus and D.
Ridnell regarding same; review and redact
exhibits to be sealed in filing; confer with L.
Weekes regarding same.
4531 10/22/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.80 220.00 Review and finalize edits to the Administrative

Motion to File Under Seal (AMFUS) and the
Declaration in Search of AMFUS.

seal.
4533 10/23/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 2.60 715.00 Review final copies of exhibits for filing;

update and organize documents from related
cases and cases in appeals into the case
management database; assemble court‐stamped
documents from today's MSJ filing for client
review.
4534 10/23/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.80 3,072.00 Review, finalize, and file motion for summary


seal.
4536 10/23/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Review filed brief for redactions.
4537 10/26/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Zoom conference with S. McManus et al regarding
569 of 610
4538 10/26/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.30 82.50 Assemble and organize documents from related

management database.
4539 10/26/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 256.00 Meet with D. Foran, S. McManus, and L. Weekes

regarding
4540 10/26/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.40 256.00 Participate in team teleconference regarding:
4541 10/26/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.70 1,728.00 Gather discovery materials for possible

production.
4542 10/27/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Confer with R. Zack regarding (0.2);

confer with client regarding (0.2).
4543 10/27/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Respond to M. Martin emails about

;
; review R.
Trotter's declaration in support of motion to
seal.
4544 10/28/2020 RANDY D. ZACK 1.40 1,134.00 Familiarize self with last three years of

proceedings.
4545 10/29/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.60 1,024.00 Review client calendar for possible production

(1.0); confer with R. Zack regarding
(0.2); confer with team regarding
(0.4).
4546 10/29/2020 RANDY D. ZACK 1.20 972.00 Familiarize self with last three years of
570 of 610
proceedings.
4547 10/30/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 640.00 Review documents and prepare for discovery

conference.
4548 10/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.50 320.00 Arrange and prepare for discovery meet and

confer.
4549 10/30/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 704.00 Review prior CMC statements; confer with S.

McManus and L. Weekes about
4550 10/30/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 337.50 Conferences with L. Weekes et al regarding
4551 11/2/2020 RANDY D. ZACK 0.20 162.00 Review background regarding defendants'

copyright claim.
4552 11/2/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.80 1,152.00 Prepare for meet and confer with defense

counsel; review letter regarding
; call with D. Foran, S. McManus, and
L. Weekes regarding
; debrief about
with D. Foran and L. Weekes.
4553 11/2/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.50 960.00 Participate in discovery meet and confer;

prepare NAF's portion of joint letter to Court
regarding: discovery disputes.
4554 11/2/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 787.50 Conferences with L. Weeks and K. Leung

regarding
571 of 610
4555 11/2/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.10 704.00 Draft portion of joint letter and confer with

team regarding
4556 11/3/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review and provide comments on initial draft of

discovery letter to court.
4557 11/3/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.60 1,664.00 Prepare NAF's portion of joint letter brief to

court regarding: discovery issues

4559 11/4/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.80 1,152.00 Prepare NAF's portion of joint letter to Court

4561 11/5/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Revise discovery letter.

letter to court.
4563 11/5/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.80 1,792.00 Prepare NAF's portion of joint letter to Court

4564 11/6/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.40 256.00 Review and revise joint discovery letter.

letter to court.
572 of 610
4566 11/6/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.80 512.00 Revise and finalize joint discovery brief
letter.
4567 11/9/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.10 704.00 Review and redact backup evidence to prepare

for production.

management database; correspond with D. Ridnell
regarding same.
4571 11/10/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.30 82.50 Organize case documents in the case management

database.
4572 11/10/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.70 1,088.00 Review and redact backup documentation

supporting declarations.

supporting declarations.
4574 11/11/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 192.00 Attend to document review related to motion for

summary judgment.
4575 11/12/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.80 1,152.00 Prepare for discovery hearing.
4576 11/12/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 5.90 6,637.50 Prepare for hearing on summary judgment

discovery (5.2); review order on disputes
concerning summary judgment discovery (0.2);
573 of 610
phone conference regarding
(0.4).
4577 11/12/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.80 512.00 Call with MoFo team regarding ; review

Judge Orrick's order on discovery; read Judge
Stanton's order transferring CMP v. PP
litigation.
4578 11/12/2020 RANDY D. ZACK 0.70 567.00 Review discovery order; prepare for and attend

meeting with D. Foran and team regarding

supporting declarations; participate in team
teleconference.

; organize case documents in the case
4581 11/13/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 3.80 1,045.00 Review redactions in files located in the

production database; correspond with L. Weekes
regarding same.
4582 11/13/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Confer with L. Weekes about the
4583 11/13/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.60 384.00 Prepare backup documents in support of Davidson

and Fowler declarations for production.
4584 11/16/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,812.50 Prepare for depositions in connection with

summary judgment
574 of 610
4585 11/16/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.60 384.00 Prepare backup documents in support of Davidson

and Fowler declarations for production.
4587 11/16/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Review documents to be produced.

summary judgment.

cases into the case management database.
4592 11/18/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.40 256.00 Redact backup documents supporting claims in

Fowler and Davidson declarations in preparation
for production.
4593 11/19/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.80 1,792.00 Redact backup documents in preparation for

production.

cases into the case management database.
4595 11/19/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.90 2,137.50 Prepare for summary judgment depositions.
4596 11/20/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 3.00 3,375.00 Prepare for summary judgment depositions.
575 of 610
4597 11/20/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.70 1,728.00 Review backup documents supporting Fowler and

Davidson declarations and redact for privacy.
4598 11/23/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.50 137.50 Retrieve and organize documents from related

cases in the case management database.

summary judgment.
4600 11/23/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.20 128.00 Review backup documents supporting Fowler and


4602 11/24/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 4.00 1,100.00 Review redactions for documents in production

database on behalf of L. Weekes; organize files
in document database.
4603 11/24/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.60 1,024.00 Review proposed document production in

preparation for injunctive relief declarant
depositions.

4605 11/25/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Review correspondence from P. Duplessis

regarding
4606 11/30/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.70 3,648.00 Redact and review documents for production.
576 of 610
with D. Foran, S. McManus, L.
Weekes, and K. Leung.
4608 11/30/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.10 1,984.00 Review backup documents supporting Fowler and

4609 11/30/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.50 960.00 Meet with D. Foran, S. McManus, L. Weekes, and

R. Zack regarding ;
draft and send response email to P. Duplessis;
review documents to be sent out for
production.
4610 11/30/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 1.10 1,237.50 Review correspondence from Deleiden's counsel

regarding copyright issues in connection with
summary judgment (0.4); confer with K. Leung et
al regarding same (0.2); prepare for
depositions in connection with summary judgment
(0.5).
4611 12/1/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 128.00 Prepare for injunctive relief declarant

depositions.
4612 12/1/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 5.40 1,485.00 Review the redactions for documents in

production database; review and organize the
production redaction log.
4613 12/1/2020 KAREN LEUNG 4.00 2,560.00 Review documents to be produced to Defendants;

attend meet and confer with L. Weekes, P.
Duplessis, and B. Luehrs.
4614 12/1/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.50 960.00 Review and finalize documents in preparation

for production to defendants.
577 of 610
4615 12/1/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.30 337.50 Phone calls and emails regarding
4616 12/2/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.50 1,600.00 Review document redactions in advance of

documents' production to defendants.
4617 12/2/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Email with L. Weekes and S. McManus regarding
4618 12/2/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.00 1,280.00 Prepare document production for injunctive

relief declarant depositions.
4619 12/3/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.40 1,536.00 Prepare document production for injunctive

4620 12/3/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 2,812.50 Prepare for upcoming depositions.
4621 12/3/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.00 1,280.00 Review document redactions in advance of

documents' production to defendants.

; look for deposition preparation
work product and outlines from 2015; email S.
Ascencio
4623 12/4/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 6.50 7,312.50 Review NAF production in connection with MSJ

(2.0); prepare for depositions (4.5).
4624 12/4/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.20 330.00 Review documents in the case management

database in preparation for depositions;
correspond with K. Leung regarding same.
578 of 610
4625 12/4/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.30 192.00 Prepare documents for production to Defendants.
4626 12/4/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.10 704.00 Prepare and produce documents for injunctive

4627 12/7/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.80 1,152.00 Prepare for injunctive relief declarant

depositions.
4628 12/7/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 7.00 7,875.00 Prepare for depositions of M. Fowler and M.

Davidson.
4629 12/8/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 8.00 9,000.00 Prepare for depositions of M. Fowler and M.

Davidson.
4630 12/8/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 8.40 5,376.00 Attend deposition prep sessions for M. Fowler

and M. Davidson.
4631 12/8/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.60 165.00 Review and update documents in document

4632 12/8/2020 KAREN LEUNG 7.50 4,800.00 Attend deposition preparation sessions for M.

Fowler and M. Davidson.
4633 12/8/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 4.60 2,944.00 Deposition preparation of Michelle Davidson and
4634 12/9/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.70 448.00 Correspond with M. Martin regarding
; summarize Highly Confidential issues
for deposition exhibits and circulate to the
team.
579 of 610
4635 12/9/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 8.90 5,696.00 Attend deposition of
4636 12/9/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.20 55.00 Review and update documents in document

4637 12/9/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 9.50 10,687.50 Prepare for and defend deposition of M. Fowler.
4638 12/10/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 9.50 10,687.50 Prepare for and defend deposition of M.

Davidson.
4639 12/10/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 5.30 3,392.00 Prepare discovery related to injunctive relief

declarants.
4640 12/10/2020 KAREN LEUNG 5.90 3,776.00 Attend M. Davidson deposition; send follow‐up

email to court reporter and videographer
regarding marking deposition as Highly
Confidential.
4641 12/10/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 3.60 2,304.00 Michelle Davidson deposition.
4642 12/11/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 768.00 Prepare documents for potential production.
4643 12/11/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 128.00 Confer with S. McManus on

with D. Foran, S. McManus, L.
Weekes, and K. Leung.
4645 12/11/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.10 27.50 Update and organize court documents in the

580 of 610
4646 12/11/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Emails with S. McManus et al regarding
4647 12/14/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 2.50 1,600.00 Conduct legal research on scope of court's

equitable powers; participate in team
teleconference.
4648 12/14/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 576.00 Attend team meeting

; revise meeting notes.
4649 12/14/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Attend weekly team meeting regarding
4650 12/14/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Emails with counsel for defense regarding page

limits on summary judgment briefing.
4651 12/14/2020 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 486.00 Prepare for and attend meeting regarding motion

for summary judgment.
(0.8); confer with team
regarding (0.5); review documents
sent by client (2.5).
4653 12/15/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.40 110.00 Organize and prepare binder of the M. Folwer

deposition for D. Foran; correspond with vendor
regarding same.
4654 12/15/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 832.00 Revise stipulation for extension of schedule

and page limits and send to opposing counsel;
581 of 610
review L. Weekes' email regarding
4655 12/15/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.90 1,216.00 Review transcripts of depositions of injunctive

relief declarants and confer with team
regarding
4656 12/15/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 4.10 4,612.50 Emails and conferences with defense counsel re

proposed revisions to summary judgment schedule
(0.5); review deposition transcripts of M.
Fowler and M. Davidson (3.6)
4657 12/15/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 1.40 896.00 Conduct legal research on scope of court's

equitable powers; participate in team
teleconference.
4658 12/16/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 896.00 Confer with opposing counsel regarding

extension of time for opposition (0.3); prepare
for filing of reply brief (0.2); confer with
team regarding (0.5); review
deposition transcripts (0.4).
4659 12/16/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 64.00 Read email regarding from

T. Camp.
4660 12/16/2020 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.10 27.50 Review and update document database.
4661 12/17/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 896.00 Read M. Fowler's deposition transcript.
582 of 610
4663 12/21/2020 RANDY D. ZACK 1.30 1,053.00 Research issue preclusion for upcoming reply in
support of motion for summary judgment.
4664 12/21/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.90 1,856.00 Review M. Fowler's deposition transcript.
4665 12/21/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.10 64.00 Correspond with R. Zack regarding:
4667 12/22/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 320.00 Review Planned Parenthood order granting motion

for attorneys' fees.
4668 12/22/2020 A. LORRAINE WEEKES 0.50 320.00 Participate in call with R. Zack regarding:

; review
before call with R. Zack.
4669 12/22/2020 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 486.00 Review fees order (.15); talk to L. Weekes

about
(.45).
4670 12/22/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.40 896.00 Read PPFA's motion for attorney's fees; read

Judge Orrick's order granting PPFA's motion for
attorney's fees.
4671 12/22/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review order granting fees and costs in related

Planned Parenthood action.
4672 12/23/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 225.00 Phone call with K. Leung regarding
583 of 610
4673 12/23/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Read M. Davidson's deposition transcript.
4674 12/23/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 192.00 Review Planned Parenthood attorneys' fees

order.
4675 12/28/2020 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 384.00 Read M. Davidson deposition transcript.
4676 12/29/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.70 1,088.00 Coordinate with S. McManus and R. Lim
; request M. Davidson's full and
condensed deposition transcripts from Veritext;
read M. Davidson deposition transcript.
4677 12/29/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.70 2,368.00 Review Fowler transcript for errata and

confidentiality designations (3.4); review CMP
motion to disqualify in companion case (0.3).
4678 12/30/2020 KAREN LEUNG 2.30 1,472.00 Read and designate confidentiality in M.

Davidson's deposition transcript.
4680 12/31/2020 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.10 704.00 Review deposition confidentiality designations

and errata for M. Davidson.
4681 12/31/2020 KAREN LEUNG 1.80 1,152.00 Read and designate confidentiality in M.

Davidson's deposition transcript.
4682 12/31/2020 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 562.50 Review and provide comment on deposition

designations under protective order.
584 of 610
4683 1/2/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 149.00 Review P. Breen's request to disclose
deposition transcripts to experts and circulate
requirements from protective order.
4684 1/3/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 240.00 Correspondence with plaintiffs' counsel

regarding expert access to deposition
transcripts.
4685 1/4/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.60 1,192.00 Read and review Judge Orrick's order excluding

F. Smith as an expert witness and J. Perkins's
trial testimony; confer with D. Foran regarding
4687 1/5/2021 KAREN LEUNG 3.20 2,384.00 Review Judge Orrick's order J. Perkins's trial

testimony and expert report and summarize key
points.
4688 1/5/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.90 265.50 Review Planned Parenthood's docket and our

document database; retrieve documents for K.
Leung.
4689 1/6/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 968.50 Review Judge Orrick's order regarding F. Smith;

review J. Perkins's PPFA expert report and
rebuttal report and summarize key points.
4690 1/7/2021 KAREN LEUNG 3.30 2,458.50 Read Defendants' Opposition; read Defendants'

expert reports.
4691 1/7/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 1.70 2,040.00 Phone calls and emails with S. McManus re
585 of 610
(0.7); conduct initial review of
opposition to summary judgment (1.0).
4692 1/7/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 2.10 619.50 Review, update, and organize document database.
4693 1/7/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.80 3,576.00 Review Defendants' opposition to motion for

summary judgment and entry of permanent
injunction and begin drafting reply.
4694 1/8/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 1.50 1,387.50 Review opposition to motion for summary

judgment; discuss with D. Foran, S.
McManus, and K. Leung.

draft and research outline for reply brief
(3.1); review sealed materials and draft
declaration in support of sealing (3.0).
4696 1/8/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.50 442.50 Review, update, and organize document database;

4697 1/8/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 4.10 4,920.00 Review opposition to summary judgment (2.9);

prepare for and attend phone conference with S.
McManus et al regarding
(1.0); review and provide comments on draft
declaration in support of sealing materials
submitted in opposition to motion for summary
judgment (0.2).
4698 1/8/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.80 2,086.00 Read Defendants' Opposition; meet with MoFo

team to discuss
586 of 610
4699 1/9/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.50 372.50 Review Defendants' opposition and NAF's draft
reply outline.
4700 1/9/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 745.00 Research issue preclusion.
4701 1/11/2021 KAREN LEUNG 5.20 3,874.00 Draft and research for outline to reply brief.
4702 1/11/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.80 2,086.00 Revise and research outline of reply in support

of motion for summary judgment (2.2); revise
and file declaration in support of sealing
(0.6).
4703 1/11/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 240.00 Review and provide comments on draft

declaration in support of motion to seal
summary judgment materials
4704 1/12/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 2,520.00 Review and provide comment on draft outline for

reply on summary judgment (1.6); conference
with S. McManus et al regarding same (0.5).
4705 1/12/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.20 2,384.00 Revise outline of reply in support of motion

4706 1/12/2021 KAREN LEUNG 6.80 5,066.00 Draft and research for outline to reply brief;

meet with P. Goldstein, J. Liou, D. Foran, and
S. McManus about
4707 1/12/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.40 118.00 Review, update, and organize document database

for appeals and related cases.
4708 1/13/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.80 531.00 Research and collate supporting documents in
587 of 610
the volumes of the Planned Parenthood trial
transcript for further attorney review;
correspond with K. Leung regarding same;
teleconference with team regarding
4709 1/13/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 2.80 2,590.00 Discuss with D. Foran et al.

(1.5); draft reply in support of motion for
summary judgment (1.3).
4710 1/13/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.20 1,639.00 Review outline for reply brief; meet with D.

Foran, R. Zack, S. McManus, D. Ridnell, and S.
Ascencio regarding ; meet
with R. Zack and S. McManus regarding
4711 1/13/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.90 3,650.50 Revise outline of reply in support of motion

for summary judgment (2.9); confer with team
4712 1/14/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.20 1,639.00 Draft reply in support of motion to dismiss.
4713 1/14/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 3.80 3,515.00 Draft reply in support of motion for summary

judgment.
4714 1/14/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 2.10 2,520.00 Review Perkins expert report submitted in

opposition to motion for summary judgment and
testimony from Planned Parenthood trial (1.9);
phone call with S. McManus regarding same
(0.2).
4715 1/14/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 298.00 Review at J. Perkins' trial testimony and send

to D. Foran.
588 of 610
4716 1/15/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.60 1,937.00 Draft and research for reply in support of

4717 1/15/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.50 147.50 Collate court documents and update document

database for further attorney review.
4718 1/15/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 670.50 Review N. Davis full deposition and excerpted

deposition that was played at PPFA trial and
send to S. Terry from CA DOJ on D. Foran's
behalf.
4719 1/19/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.40 3,278.00 Draft reply in support of motion for summary

4720 1/19/2021 KAREN LEUNG 5.70 4,246.50 Draft reply brief; call with R. Zack and S.

McManus regarding
4721 1/19/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 3.40 3,145.00 Draft reply in support of motion for summary

judgment.
4722 1/20/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 2.40 2,220.00 Legal research in support of issue preclusion

for reply in support of motion for summary
judgment; draft reply in support of motion for
summary judgment.

4724 1/21/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.90 670.50 Draft reply in support of motion for summary

4725 1/21/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.50 147.50 Update and organize court documents in document
589 of 610
database.


4728 1/25/2021 KAREN LEUNG 3.60 2,682.00 Research for and revise draft reply.
4729 1/25/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 3.30 3,052.50 Draft and revise reply in support of motion for

summary judgment.

judgment.
4731 1/26/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.00 2,235.00 Revise reply in support of motion for summary

judgment.
4732 1/26/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 3,000.00 Review and provide comments on draft reply on

summary judgment.
4733 1/27/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 3.80 4,560.00 Review cases cited in draft reply brief (1.0);

additional legal research concerning copyright
issues (1.1); prepare for and attend zoom
conference with S. McManus et al regarding
(1.7).

judgment.
4735 1/27/2021 KAREN LEUNG 5.70 4,246.50 Meet with team regarding ;

call with R. Zack regarding ;
590 of 610
revise draft reply brief.
4736 1/27/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 6.20 5,735.00 Review and revise reply in support motion for

summary judgment; legal research regarding
same; call with D. Foran et al.
4737 1/27/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.50 442.50 Collate supporting documents cited in Reply in

Search of Summary Judgment brief for further
attorney review; attend team teleconference
regarding
4738 1/28/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 9.10 8,417.50 Review and revise NAF reply in support of

4739 1/28/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.50 2,607.50 Revise reply in support of motion for summary

judgment.
4740 1/28/2021 KAREN LEUNG 4.90 3,650.50 Research and revise reply brief.
4741 1/28/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 3.70 4,440.00 Conduct additional fact and legal research for

reply brief on motion for summary judgment
(2.9); emails with R. Zack regarding
(0.8).
4742 1/29/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 3.20 3,840.00 Additional research in connection with reply on

summary judgment (2.8); phone calls and emails
regarding (0.4).
4743 1/29/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.30 968.50 Revise reply in support of motion for summary

judgment.
4744 1/29/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 2.20 2,035.00 Review and revise NAF reply in support of
591 of 610
4745 1/29/2021 KAREN LEUNG 3.00 2,235.00 Revise draft reply brief.

judgment.
4747 2/1/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 5.90 7,080.00 Revised draft reply in support of motion for

regarding (0.5); prepare for and
attend zoom conference with client regarding
(0.7).
4748 2/1/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 819.50 Call with R. Zack regarding ; revise

draft reply.
4749 2/1/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.80 236.00 Research and collate supporting documents

needed for the response brief for further
attorney team review; organize files in
4750 2/1/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 7.50 6,937.50 Legal research for and revisions of reply in

4751 2/2/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 3.80 3,515.00 Legal research for and revisions of reply in

4752 2/2/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.40 413.00 Review NAF's reply brief in search of motion

summary judgment, supplemental appendix of
exhibits, and D. Foran's supplemental
declaration.
592 of 610
4753 2/2/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 2.90 3,480.00 Final review of and revisions to draft reply
brief (1.9); phone conferences and emails with
S. McManus regarding
(1.0).

judgment.
4755 2/3/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 298.00 Review M. Davidson's testimony excerpts for

reply brief.

judgment.
4757 2/3/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.40 370.00 Determine whether a motion to seal is

necessary.
4759 2/3/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 6.60 1,947.00 Review and fact‐check NAF's reply brief in

search of motion summary judgment.
4760 2/4/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.60 472.00 Assemble exhibits for filing; review and

fact‐check NAF's reply brief in search of
motion summary judgment; correspond with S.
McManus and A. West regarding same.

judgment and related documents.
4762 2/4/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.10 819.50 Review and edit reply brief.
4763 2/4/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.20 185.00 Review reply in support of motion for summary
593 of 610
judgment.
4764 2/4/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,200.00 Provide additional comments and edits to S.

McManus for
4765 2/5/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.90 2,905.50 Finalize and file reply in support of motion

4766 2/5/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.40 118.00 Finalize edits to NAF's reply brief in search

of motion summary judgment; organize document
database management.
4767 2/5/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 1.50 1,800.00 Final review and comments on reply in support

of summary judgment (1.0); emails regarding
(0.5).
4769 2/8/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.80 1,341.00 Prepare for argument on motion for summary

judgment.
4770 2/8/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 3.60 4,320.00 Phone calls with T. Camp regarding

(0.2);
prepare for hearing on summary judgment (3.4).
4771 2/9/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 2.50 3,000.00 Prepare for hearing on summary judgment.

judgment.
594 of 610
4774 2/10/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.20 185.00 Discuss issues regarding

judgment.
4776 2/11/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.30 5,438.50 Prepare for oral argument on motion for summary

judgment.

judgment.

judgment.
4779 2/15/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 1.50 1,387.50 Prepare for and attend meeting with D. Foran et

al. regarding
4780 2/15/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 4.10 3,054.50 with

team (1.0); prepare for oral argument (3.1).
4781 2/15/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,200.00 Prepare for and attend zoom conference with S.

McManus regarding

judgment.
4783 2/17/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 5.00 6,000.00 Prepare and attend hearing on motion for

595 of 610
4784 2/17/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 7.80 5,811.00 Prepare for and argue at hearing on motion for

summary judgment (6.8); confer with team and
client regarding (1.0).
4785 2/17/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.30 88.50 Organize and update document database.
4786 2/18/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 3.10 2,867.50 Draft letter for court regarding Rule 54(b);

discuss with D. Foran and team
4787 2/18/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.40 118.00 Attend teleconference regarding
4788 2/18/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.20 1,639.00 Draft motion for attorneys fees and related

documents.
4789 2/18/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.50 1,862.50 Team meeting regarding ; prepare

draft motion for attorneys' fees and review
related PPFA motions.
4790 2/18/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.50 600.00 Meeting with J. McManus et al regarding
(0.3); emails and phone calls regarding
(0.2).
4791 2/19/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 521.50 Coordinate motion for attorneys' fees.
4792 2/19/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.90 2,160.50 Revise motion for attorneys' fees; meet with C.

Dierolf and M. Willis regarding
596 of 610
4794 2/22/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.80 740.00 Legal research for motion for attorneys' fees.
4795 2/22/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.60 1,192.00 Draft and revise attorneys' fees motion.
4797 2/24/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.30 277.50 Discuss declaration in support of motion for

attorneys' fees.

(0.2); compile fees data from timenotes
(1.4).
4800 2/24/2021 KAREN LEUNG 4.90 3,650.50 Draft and revise attorneys' fees motion; review

C. Dierolf and M. Willis's research and
to team.
4801 2/25/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.20 59.00 Organize and update document database.
4802 2/25/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.80 1,341.00 Review amended administrative motion to seal

(0.4); draft declaration in support of sealing
(1.2); confer with team regarding (0.2).
597 of 610
4804 2/25/2021 KAREN LEUNG 5.50 4,097.50 Draft and revise attorneys' fee motion; review
research and cases from C. Dierolf and M.
Willis regarding same and send
4805 2/26/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 149.00 Revise declaration in support of motion to

seal.
4807 2/27/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.90 670.50 Draft and revise attorneys' fees motion.
4808 2/28/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 968.50 Draft and revise attorneys' fees motion and

read PPFA defendants' appellate brief.

4810 3/1/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.70 2,011.50 Draft and revise attorneys' fees motion; review

C. Dierolf and M. Willis' research findings.
4811 3/1/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 745.00 Review fees documentation.
4812 3/2/2021 KAREN LEUNG 7.40 5,513.00 Draft and revise attorneys' fees motion; send

C. Dierolf and M. Willis' new research tasks.
4813 3/3/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 745.00 Discuss research findings with C. Dierolf; call

with R. Zack regarding ; send
email to C. Dierolf and
M. Willis.
4814 3/3/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.30 277.50 Legal research regarding attorneys' fees.
598 of 610
4816 3/5/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,200.00 Confer with K. Leung et al regarding

(0.5); phone call with A. Bomse et
al regarding
(0.5).
4819 3/8/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 447.00 Meet with team regarding

compile fees spreadsheet for motion (2.0).
4821 3/9/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.50 147.50 Collate court documents from related matters

and update document database for further
attorney review.
4822 3/10/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.20 59.00 Collate court documents from related matters

for further attorney review.
4824 3/15/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 223.50 Review spreadsheet of timenotes.
599 of 610
4826 3/16/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 149.00 Review timenotes for attorneys' fees motion.
4828 3/17/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 223.50 Review timenotes for attorneys' fees motion.
4832 3/19/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.60 1,192.00 Meet with S. McManus, C. Dierolf, and M. Willis

regarding
4833 3/22/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.20 149.00 Confer with C. Dierolf regarding
4834 3/23/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 968.50 Revise attorneys' fees motion.
4835 3/23/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.20 149.00 Revise motion for attorneys' fees.
4836 3/24/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 240.00 Emails with K. Leung et al regarding
4837 3/24/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.90 1,415.50 Attend CMP v. PPFA et. al hearing; revise

attorneys' fees motion.
4838 3/24/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.70 1,266.50 Compile timenotes data.
4839 3/25/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.00 2,235.00 Compile attorneys fees data and revise motion

for attorneys fees and related documents.
600 of 610
4840 3/25/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 745.00 Revise attorneys' fees motion and declaration.
4841 3/26/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.40 4,768.00 Gather attorneys' fees data and revise motion

and related documents.
4842 3/26/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.50 1,862.50 Revise motion for attorneys' fees and

declaration.
4843 3/28/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 6.00 4,470.00 Compile attorneys' fees data and revise motion

for attorneys' fees.

(1.0); revise motion for
attorneys' fees and supporting declaration
(1.8).
4845 3/29/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.30 968.50 Prepare for meeting and meet with S. McManus,

C. Dierolf, and M. Willis regarding
4846 3/30/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 223.50 Revise motion for attorneys' fees and

accompanying declaration.
4847 3/30/2021 KAREN LEUNG 4.10 3,054.50 Revise draft motion for attorneys' fees and

declaration.
4848 3/30/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.60 472.00 Review and collate information regarding

attorneys who worked on matter and are no
longer at the firm; correspond with C. Dierolf
regarding same; review and update court
documents from related matters in the document
601 of 610
4850 3/31/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 2.20 2,640.00 Review and provide comment on draft motion for

attorney fees and supporting declaration.
4851 4/1/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.70 2,756.50 Revise motion for attorneys' fees and backup

documentation.
4852 4/1/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 745.00 Meeting with D. Foran, S. McManus, C. Dierolf,

and M. Willis regarding
4853 4/1/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.90 1,080.00 Review and provide comments on draft motion for

attorney fees in connection with summary
judgment.
4855 4/7/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 1.90 2,280.00 Review order on summary judgment and permanent

injunction (0.9); phone calls and emails
regarding
(1.0).
4856 4/7/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.90 2,160.50 Review ruling on motion for summary judgment

and entry of a permanent injunction (2.0); plan
and confer with team regarding
(0.9).
4857 4/7/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.40 1,788.00 Read Judge Orrick's order granting motion for

summary judgment and requests for permanent
602 of 610
injunction; discuss
with R. Zack; review and revise draft motion
for attorney's fees and declaration.
4858 4/7/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.10 29.50 Collate court documents for further attorney

review.
4859 4/7/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.20 185.00 Review attorneys' fees motion.
4860 4/8/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 1.30 1,202.50 Review and revise attorneys' fees motion.
4861 4/8/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 240.00 Emails and phone calls with S. McManus
4862 4/8/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.00 1,490.00 Read Defendants' PPFA filing; meet with R. Zack

regarding ; review
and revise draft motion for attorney's fees and
declaration; review and revise M. Willis's
email and spreadsheet for costs to S. Ascencio.
4863 4/8/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.00 745.00 Draft proposed judgment and stipulation

dismissing other claims.
4864 4/9/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.70 840.00 Team meeting regarding
4866 4/9/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 1.60 1,480.00 Review and revise motion for attorneys' fees.
4867 4/9/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.10 1,564.50 Attend team meeting regarding
603 of 610
; review and revise draft motion
for attorney's fees and declaration; read
Defendants' PPFA filing.
4868 4/12/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 3.40 1,003.00 Review and collate information accounting

records and invoices for Bill of Costs.
4869 4/12/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.60 1,192.00 Revise proposed judgment and stipulation and

fees motion.
4870 4/12/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.60 555.00 Review and revise draft judgment and

stipulation of dismissal.

; call S. Terry at CA DOJ;
discuss
with R. Zack; discuss
with C. Dierolf.
4872 4/13/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.50 372.50 Revise proposed judgment.
4873 4/13/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 1.10 1,017.50 Review and revise declaration in support of

motion for attorneys' fees.
4874 4/13/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.00 745.00 Review and revise draft declaration in support

of motion for attorneys' fees; call with R.
Zack regarding same.
4875 4/14/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 2.00 590.00 Review and collate information accounting

4876 4/14/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.70 521.50 Review proposed judgment and stipulation of

dismissal.
604 of 610
4877 4/15/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.40 1,043.00 Revise proposed judgment and stipulation and

send stipulation to opposing counsel.
4878 4/15/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 240.00 Review and provide comments on draft proposed

judgment and stipulation regarding remaining
claims.
4879 4/15/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 2.50 737.50 Review and collate information from accounting

4880 4/15/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.30 223.50 Call with S. Terry of CA DOJ and send D. Foran

email update regarding
4881 4/16/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 3.20 944.00 Review and collate information accounting

4882 4/19/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.10 92.50 Discuss status of attorneys' fees motion.
4883 4/19/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.60 447.00 Review bill of costs materials and respond to

M. Willis's email regarding same.
4885 4/20/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.20 894.00 Revise attorneys fees motion and related

documents.
4886 4/21/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.20 894.00 Read M. Martin's emails regarding

; meet with S. McManus, C. Dierolf, and
M. Willis regarding ; read
proposed judgment and stipulation to dismiss
605 of 610
claims.
4887 4/21/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.20 1,639.00 Revise attorneys fees motion and confer with

team regarding
4888 4/22/2021 KAREN LEUNG 4.20 3,129.00 with R. Zack; review

and revise draft motion for attorneys' fees and
declaration.
4889 4/22/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 223.50 Revise attorneys fees motion.
4890 4/22/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 0.20 185.00 Discussing status of attorneys' fees motion.
4891 4/23/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 3.60 1,062.00 Review and collate information from accounting

records and invoices for Bill of Costs;
consolidate information regarding same into an
appendix for filing.
4892 4/23/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.10 74.50 Discuss with R.

Zack; discuss with
C. Dierolf.
4893 4/23/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.10 819.50 Attend to sealing issues.
4894 4/23/2021 RANDY D. ZACK 1.30 1,202.50 Review, revise, and comment on attorneys' fees

motion.
4896 4/24/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.80 2,086.00 Revise draft motion for attorneys' fees; revise

C. Dierolf's email to D. Foran.
606 of 610
4898 4/27/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.60 1,192.00 Review sealing chart; meet with S. McManus, C.

Dierolf, and M. Willis regarding ;
discuss with C. Dierolf.
4900 4/27/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 1.00 295.00 Prepare exhibits and table of costs for Bill of

Costs filing.

(1.5); review sealing papers (0.5).
4902 4/28/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 3.10 3,720.00 Review and provide comments on draft motion for

attorney fees and supporting papers (2.3);
conference with K. Leung et al regarding same
(0.8).
4903 4/28/2021 KAREN LEUNG 3.50 2,607.50 Meet with D. Foran, S. McManus, C. Dierolf, and

M. Willis regarding ;
call with C. Dierolf regarding ;
call with M. Willis regarding ;
review sealing chart and excerpts for sealing.
4904 4/29/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.40 1,788.00 Meet with C. Dierolf and M. Willis regarding

review draft emails and sealing
chart; review email and documents from J.
Trissell regarding sealing chart; send email to
M. Martin (Arnold & Porter) regarding
; send email to D. Foran regarding
607 of 610
4905 4/29/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.30 223.50 Revise joint sealing chart.
4906 4/29/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 240.00 Conferences and emails regarding
4907 4/30/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 1.30 968.50 Revise fees and sealing papers.
4908 4/30/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 1.00 1,200.00 Prepare for and attend meeting with K. Leung et

al regarding
4909 4/30/2021 KAREN LEUNG 1.70 1,266.50 Meet with D. Foran, C. Dierolf, and M. Willis

regarding ; review sealing chart;
send to M. Martin
(Arnold & Porter).
4910 5/3/2021 KAREN LEUNG 3.70 2,756.50 Meet with C. Dierolf regarding

; call with D. Foran regarding
; review deposition
transcripts and send email with
; coordinate with C. Dierolf and M. Willis
regarding
4911 5/3/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.20 240.00 Confer with K. Leung regarding
4912 5/3/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 0.60 447.00 Revise motion for fees and declaration in

support.
4914 5/4/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 3.40 2,533.00 Revise motion for attorneys fees and
608 of 610
accompanying declaration.
4915 5/4/2021 KAREN LEUNG 4.60 3,427.00 Review and revise sealing chart; confer with S.

McManus regarding ; call with M.
Martin (Arnold & Porter) regarding
; send sealing chart to Defendants;
confirm with C.
Dierolf and M. Willis; send email to MoFo team
regarding
4916 5/5/2021 SPENCER MCMANUS 2.70 2,011.50 Revise motion for fees.
4917 5/5/2021 KAREN LEUNG 2.70 2,011.50 Review and revise sealing chart; review and

revise motion for attorneys' fees; meet with M.
Willis and C. Dierolf regarding
4918 5/6/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.30 88.50 Finalize the itemization of costs spreadsheet

for the Bill of Costs filing; correspond with
M. Willis regarding same.
4919 5/6/2021 DEREK F. FORAN 0.40 480.00 Emails with C. Dierolf regarding
4920 5/6/2021 KAREN LEUNG 3.60 2,682.00 Call with D. Foran and C. Dierolf regarding

; call with M. Martin (Arnold &
Porter) and C. Dierolf regarding ;
review and revise sealing chart; revise and
revise motion for attorneys' fees.
4921 5/7/2021 SANDRA J. ASCENCIO 0.10 29.50 Organize the court documents in the document

609 of 610
4924 5/7/2021 KAREN LEUNG 0.40 298.00 Respond to email from J. Trissell; meet and

confer with Defendants; send email
610 of 610

DKT 756-1-2-3

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

DKT 756-1-2-3

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Case 3:15-cv-03522-WHO Document 756-1 Filed 08/10/21 Page 1 of 611

2 7/22/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 0.50 230.00 Review case materials.

3 7/23/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.75 1,725.00 Research and prepare complaint.

4 7/23/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.50 3,712.50 Review case documents; research on jurisdiction

5 7/23/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.50 1,842.50 Attend meeting; research.

6 7/23/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 12.50 10,625.00 Conferences with J. Serrano and A. Laks

7 7/23/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 5.50 3,905.00 Attend kick‐off meeting; legal and factual

8 7/23/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 2.50 1,825.00 Confer with D. Foran regarding ;

9 7/24/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 5.25 3,832.50 Research regarding case background and review

10 7/24/2015 PRISCILLA R. FERNANDEZ 2.50 650.00 Library research regarding compensation for Fox

11 7/24/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Prepare for and attend conferences with client

12 7/24/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 6.00 4,050.00 Review case documents; research on diversity

13 7/24/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 9.75 6,922.50 Legal and factual research in connection with

14 7/24/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 6.00 2,010.00 Research; conduct attorney support operations.

15 7/24/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.75 2,662.50 Conference with C. Robinson regarding

16 7/24/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 5.25 2,415.00 Assist in preparing complaint.

17 7/25/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 7.25 3,335.00 Assist in preparing complaint.

18 7/25/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.50 3,712.50 Research on federal and state causes of action;

19 7/25/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Research.

20 7/25/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 8.50 7,225.00 Draft complaint.

21 7/26/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 6.00 4,260.00 Prepare outline of NAF's temporary restraining

22 7/26/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 2.50 837.50 Organize documents; research; attorney support.

23 7/26/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 5.00 3,375.00 Research on federal and state causes of action;

24 7/26/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.25 1,035.00 Assist in preparing complaint.

26 7/26/2015 ANNA FERRARI 2.75 1,952.50 Conduct research for irreparable harm argument

27 7/26/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 1.50 1,095.00 Review draft of NAF complaint; research and

28 7/27/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 4.75 2,185.00 Research and prepare complaint and TRO.

29 7/27/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 7.50 5,062.50 Research jurisdiction, service and causes of

30 7/27/2015 ANNA FERRARI 6.75 4,792.50 Attend team meeting; conduct research in

31 7/27/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 4.75 1,591.25 Draft pleading shells; research; manage team

32 7/27/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 12.50 8,875.00 Draft portions of NAF's temporary restraining

33 7/27/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 7.50 5,475.00 Meet with team regarding

34 7/27/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 12.75 10,837.50 Finalize first draft of complaint;

35 7/28/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 13.50 9,585.00 Attend team meeting

36 7/28/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 2.75 1,265.00 Assist in preparing TRO and complaint.

37 7/28/2015 ANNA FERRARI 7.50 5,325.00 Draft inserts to motion for temporary

38 7/28/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 5.00 1,675.00 Conduct attorney support operations; research.

39 7/28/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 9.50 6,412.50 Research TRO standard and causes of action;

40 7/28/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 11.25 8,100.00 Research RICO issues; revise complaint.

41 7/28/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 13.50 11,475.00 Conferences with client regarding

42 7/28/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 1.75 1,023.75 Research for complaint and TRO.

43 7/28/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.50 2,555.00 Review video regarding Planned Parenthood; meet

44 7/29/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 1.00 460.00 Research regarding procedures for filing temporary

45 7/29/2015 DANIELLE COLEMAN 3.00 2,190.00 Revise complaint; revise declaration of M.

46 7/29/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 3.75 1,725.00 Prepare complaint and TRO.

47 7/29/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 15.50 13,175.00 Revise complaint; conferences with client

48 7/29/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 15.75 11,340.00 Research RICO and First Amendment issues;

49 7/29/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 11.25 6,581.25 Research for complaint and TRO.

50 7/29/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 9.75 4,485.00 Prepare complaint and TRO.

51 7/29/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 7.00 2,835.00 Work on filings for claim against Center for

52 7/29/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 16.00 11,360.00 Motion for temporary restraining order.

53 7/29/2015 JAVIER SERRANO 9.00 6,075.00 Work on motion for TRO; work on declarations;

54 7/29/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 1.00 335.00 Revise filing documents; research; organize

55 7/29/2015 ANNA FERRARI 8.75 6,212.50 Draft inserts to motion for temporary

56 7/30/2015 THOMAS E. BEYER 19.00 6,365.00 Assist with drafting and preparation of

57 7/30/2015 CHRISTOPHER L. ROBINSON 18.00 12,780.00 Motion for temporary restraining order.

58 7/30/2015 NICHOLAS ALAN ROETHLISBERGER 11.00 6,435.00 Research for complaint and TRO; draft expedited

59 7/30/2015 RANDY D. ZACK 14.50 5,872.50 Work on filing complaint and motion for

60 7/30/2015 NICHOLAS S. NAPOLITAN 18.00 12,960.00 Research First Amendment issues and causes of

61 7/30/2015 MOLLY A. SMOLEN 3.25 1,495.00 Prepare for filing of complaint, temporary

62 7/30/2015 ANNA FERRARI 3.50 2,485.00 Revise insert to motion for restraining order;

63 7/30/2015 DEREK F. FORAN 16.25 13,812.50 Revise motion for temporary restraining order;

64 7/30/2015 ALEXANDRA E. LAKS 13.50 6,210.00 Prepare complaint and motion for temporary