Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Study On The Psycho - Social Problems Faced by Transgenders With Special Reference To Nedumpuram Region."
Study On The Psycho - Social Problems Faced by Transgenders With Special Reference To Nedumpuram Region."
Study On The Psycho - Social Problems Faced by Transgenders With Special Reference To Nedumpuram Region."
Submitted by
JINSON RAJU
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that this dissertation titled, “A STUDY ON THE PSYCHO – SOCIAL
PROBLEMS FACED BY TRANSGENDERS WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO
NEDUMPURAM REGION.” is a work done by JINSON RAJU of VI semester, Bachelor of Social
Work under the guidance and supervision of Mr. Akhil Shaji Mathew and submitted to Mahatma
Gandhi University for the award of the Degree of Bachelor of Social Work.
Date: Principal
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that this dissertation titled, “A STUDY ON THE PSYCHO – SOCIAL PROBLEMS
REGION.” is a record of genuine work done by JINSON RAJU of VI semester Bachelor of Social
Work and submitted to Mahatma Gandhi University for the award of the Degree of Bachelor of Social
Work, under my guidance and the dissertation has not formed the basis of award of any degree/
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that this dissertation titled, “A STUDY ON THE PSYCHO – SOCIAL
Bachelor of Social Work and submitted to Mahatma Gandhi University for the award of the Degree of
Bachelor of Social Work, under my supervision and guidance and the dissertation has not formed the
basis of award of any degree/ diploma/ associate/fellowship or similar title to any candidate of any
university.
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that this dissertation titled, “A STUDY ON THE PSYCHO – SOCIAL
Bachelor of Social Work and submitted to Mahatma Gandhi University for the award of the Degree of
Bachelor of Social Work, under my supervision and guidance and the dissertation has not formed the
basis of award of any degree/ diploma/ associate/fellowship or similar title to any candidate of any
university.
Place: Kumily
Date:
Examiner 1: Examiner 2:
DECLARATION
I, JINSON RAJU hereby declare that this dissertation titled, “A STUDY ON THE PSYCHO –
NEDUMPURAM REGION.” is a record of genuine work done by me under the guidance of Mr.
Akhil Shaji Mathew and no part of this has been produced before any university for the award of
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I am grateful to God Almighty for having blessed me with his wisdom and knowledge.
First, I would like to thank the management, Sahyajyothi Arts and Science College headed by Prof.
M. J. Mathew (Principal) and Mrs. Thasneema M. Kabeer head of Social Work Department for
I am indebted with at most gratitude to Mr. Akhil Shaji Mathew my research guide who has been
instrumental in moulding my research work. I deeply acknowledge his timely interventions and
motivation he has showered upon me, which had been significant in completing the research in
successful manner.
I would also like to thank Mr. Akhil Shaji Mathew for his valuable class on research. Thasneema M.
Kabeer and Mr. Akhil Mathew Shaji, and Ms. Shilpa Mathew for their guidance and training
I also thank for the cooperation received from the students in other departments for providing me the
I thank my family who stood by me throughout the process and my friends for the support. I am
grateful to all who have in one way or the other helped me in accomplishing this work by contributing
The word ‘Transgender” has been derived from the Latin word ‘trans’ and the English word ‘gender’.
Different sorts of individuals come under this category. No particular form of sexual orientation is
This study aims to investigate the psycho-social problem faced by transgenders, their economic status
and also social empowerment through various governmental programmes and inclusion trends, the
The sampling method used for this study was convenience sampling. In like manner, survey forms
were prepared with unique set of questions for the transgender community members. The respondents
were randomly chosen from the Nedumpuram region to conduct survey. Furthermore, SPSS was
instrumented to data analyses and interpretation. A total of 60 people participated in this study from all
This study was able to find out about the psycho-social problem faced by transgenders, their
economic status and also social empowerment through various governmental programmes and
inclusion trends, the major problems faced by the community in the society.
TITTLE SHEET
CERTIFICATE
CERTIFICATE
CERTIFICATE
CERTIFICATE
DECLARATION
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
PREFACE
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF DIAGRAMS
CHAPTERIZATION
CHAPTER 1 – INTRODUCTION
CHAPTER 3 – METHODOLOGY
BIBLIOGRAPHY
APPENDIX
CHAPTER 1:
INTRODUCTION
1. INTRODUCTION
All societies assign specific adult roles based on sex which is emphasized in the process of socialization.
For many people, the terms sex and gender are used interchangeably. However, although sex and gender
are closely related, there is a subtle difference between the two. Sex refers to biological status as male or
female. It includes physical attributes such as sex chromosomes, gonads, sex hormones, internal
reproductive structures, and external genitalia.
Gender is a term that is often used to refer to the individual’s internal feelings and experiences of gender,
which may or may not resemble with the sex assigned at birth and ways that people act, or feel about
themselves, which is associated with boys/men and girls/women. While aspects of biological sex are the
same across different cultures, aspects of gender may not be.
Human society is a complex organization of human relationships. The implications of such a structural
conception are that the human being act and interact with each other in accordance with their role they
play. ‘TRANSGENDER’ is an umbrella term used to describe anyone whose gender identity does not
match with the assigned birth gender. It is a state of one's "gender identity" not matching one's "assigned
sex.
Transgender is a group whose identity is beyond the notion of conventional gender structures. The present
paper attempts to delve deep into sociological positions of transgender in the society i.e., their role
definitions with in family and within society. Being belonging to their category is treated as a curse to a
family and they are treated at the margins within the society. Their marginalized role looking at their lives
in the society.
In contemporary usage, "transgender” is used to describe a wide range of identities and experiences,
including but not limited to: pre-operative, post-operative and non-operative transsexual people; male and
female cross-dressers (sometimes referred to as "transvestites", "drag queens", or "drag kings");
intersexed individuals; and men and women, regardless of sexual orientation, whose appearance or
characteristics are perceived to be gender a typical. The term transgender does not imply any specific
form of sexual orientation; transgender people may identify as heterosexual, homosexual or as bisexual.
The term trans man refers to female-to-male (FtM) transgender people, and trans woman refers to male-
to-female (MtF) transgender people. Some transgender individuals experience their gender identity as
incongruent with their anatomical sex and may seek some degree of sex reassignment surgery, take
hormones or undergo other cosmetic procedures. Others may pursue gender expression (masculine or
feminine) through external self-presentation and behaviour.
Gender transition is the period during which transsexual persons begin changing their appearances and
bodies to match their internal gender identity. While in transition, they are very vulnerable to
discrimination and are in dire need of support from family and friends. However, many parents react
negatively when they reveal their gender identities. They are often rejected, neglected, or abused by their
guardians and choose a life on the streets rather than remain in hostile environments.
Recent developmental explorations of transgender identities suggest that trans people typically go
through a process of dissonance, exploration, and disclosures that, when successful, leads to identity
resolution. (Pardo,2008). Following initial feelings of gender dissonance, transgender individuals
typically experience a period of identity confusion and exploration.
This may be a time of excitement and struggle as the person seeks to develop a sense of true self while
balancing feelings of guilt and shame, pressures to conform, and the need for secrecy. Individuals may
adopt social modifications such as using cross- gender pronouns or gender-neutral names; other strategies
include immersion in transgender communities and disclosures about being transgender (Grossman &
D'Augelli, 2006; Pardo, 2008).
Most transsexual men and women suffer from great psychological and emotional pain due to the conflict
between their gender identity and their original gender role and anatomy. They find their only recourse is
to change their gender role and undergo gender reassignment therapy. This may include taking hormones
or having sex reassignment surgery (SRS) to modify their primary and secondary sexual characteristics.
require the patient to live as the opposite gender in all possible ways for at least a year (this is termed
"cross-living") prior to the start of surgery.
SRS consists of processes transsexual women and men take in order to match their anatomical sex to their
gender identity. Not all transgenders undergo sexual reassignment surgery (either because of the high cost
of such surgery, medical reasons, or other reasons), although they live constantly in their chosen gender
role; these people are often called non-operative.
Research on families with a transgender parent is scarce. An early study by Green showed that
children of transgender parents did not differ from children raised in more traditional settings.
A few studies examined changes in the parent-child relationship after transition; younger age at
transition and a positive relationship between parents proved protective. TGNC people’s work
life is also largely unexamined. Social stigma may disrupt or delay education and career
development, and transgender people worry about the impact of transition on the job. In a U.S.
national survey, 38% of transgender adults reported problems getting a job and 23% reported
losing a job because of being transgender. TGNC people are more likely to be unemployed
(33% vs. 12%) and live under the poverty level (31% vs. 9%).
Research is needed to better understand the challenges encountered in the workplace and how
these can be prevented or overcome. Incarceration is a public health concern disproportionately
affecting transgender women. Among a U.S. sample of 3,878 transgender women, 19%
reported incarceration. Transgender women of colour were 1.8 to 3.3 times more likely to
report incarceration than White women. The housing of TGNC people in custody in sex-
segregated facilities and their access to care remain contentious. Interventions are needed for
transgender women affected by the syndetic of incarceration, HIV, mental illness, and
substance use (e.g., R34DA038541).
MRI studies using voxel-based morphometry, cortical thickness, and diffusion tensor imaging
indicate that the transgender man’s brain phenotype consists of a mixture of feminine,
masculine and defeminized characteristics, whereas the transgender woman’s phenotype
consists of feminine, masculine and demasculinized characteristics.
fMRI studies have focused on sexually dimorphic characteristics, such as mental rotation,
handedness, and response to erotic stimuli. PET studies have addressed hypothalamic responses
to putative pheromones acting in a sexually dimorphic manner (Berglund et al, 2008). These
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
studies point toward the existence of distinct phenotypes of the brain for both transgender
women and men. More integrative work is necessary
to illuminate etiology and understand the effects of hormone therapy on the brain and related
health and quality of life indicators.
Among nontrangender women, menopausal oestrogen therapy has been associated with smaller
regional volumes in frontal, temporal and limbic regions as well as the hippocampus. Among
women aged 65 and older, oestrogen therapy was associated with greater brain atrophy. In
addition, female sex steroids increase the risk of meningioma. These data are relevant for aging
among TGNC people; the metabolic mechanism that produces changes in the brain of those
receiving lifelong hormone therapy needs to be better understood.
It is not uncommon for TGNC individuals to present for transition-related care in mid or later
life when social, identity, and biological forces appear to converge and affect the clinical
presentation. Changes in cortisol secretion and the down regulation of sex steroids and other
hormones possibly intensify gender dysphoria. The impact of these factors on quality of life of
transgender older adults has not been adequately studied. A review of research on end-of-life
care yielded no studies related to TGNC people in hospice or similar situations.
This despite reports that transgender people fear that their gender identity will not be respected
in long-term care and hospice facilities. One case report outlined some of the challenges
transgender elders and their providers might face.
1.1.4. HIV
Research has shown disproportionate prevalence of HIV, AIDS-related mortality, and
uncontrolled viral load among transgender women. Transgender men who have sex with men
reported high rates of sexual risk behaviour. Few tailored interventions have been tested, yet
several trials are underway. There are no transgender-specific guidelines for Prep, despite
evidence suggesting unique barriers to uptake and adherence.
HIV-positive transgender women are less likely to receive Anti-Retroviral Treatment (ART)
and showed worse adherence than other groups. They face complex psychosocial challenges
Interventions need to address lack of adherence self-efficacy. Integration of hormonal and HIV
care may facilitate adherence and decrease self-administered hormone use.
It is also established that many transgender people are not living with their children under the
same roof (Fundamental Rights Agency, 2014; Grant et al., 2011). From a clinical practice and
research perspective, we know that, in many trans families, divorce is common when a married
partner starts a social gender role transition (Motmans, Ponnet, & De Cuypere, 2015). Studies
have shown that transgender people are often discriminated against, during legal custody
processes, because of their transgender identities (Grant et al., 2011; Lynch & Murray, 2000;
Pyne, Bauer, & Bradley, 2015; Stotzer et al., 2014).
Only recently, research has started to shed light on the experiences of children who have
witnessed the social gender transition of one of their parents (Dierckx, Mortelmans, Motmans,
& T'Sjoen, In review; Dierckx, Mortelmans, Motmans, & T’Sjoen, 2015; Dierckx, Motmans,
Mortelmans, & T’Sjoen, in review). Concern that children of transgender parents may exhibit
atypical gender behaviour, gender identity, and/or sexual orientation has not been clinically
proven (Green, 1998). Members of transgender families often criticize the narrow focus that
health care professionals have when a parent’s social gender transition takes place, and the fact
that there is a lack of family support and long-term follow-up (Dierckx, Mortelmans, et al.,
2015).
Many transgender people indicate they would like to see an increased level of support for those
close to them (Davies et al., 2013). When children are present in trans families, the need for
professional supportive services, including family therapy, is important, and the lack of family
therapists with knowledge of issues related to social gender role transition and being
transgender may be a major source of frustration and misunderstanding. Conflicting
information regarding how and when to inform children, as well as negative attitudes of some
Families of transgender people are often confronted with feelings such as loss, shame, grief,
betrayal, guilt, fear and anger and, at the same time, can be confronted with rejection and social
stigmatisation in their social surroundings (Church, O’Shea, & Lucey, 2014; Haines, Ajayi, &
Boyd, 2014; Sales, 1995). Social isolation and the fear of being rejected can cause high levels
of stress within transgender families. The medical, legal and administrative aspects of a social
gender role transition further compound the high stress levels within transgender families.
There are also personal issues for families to consider, which include the emotional responses
(positive and negative) from the trans person, the partner, the children, family and friends, and
questions about the well-being of the children, about one’s sexual orientation and about the
relationship with the partner.
There are many emotional issues to deal with. Transgender family members are quietly aware
of these emotional responses and their consequences, as research has shown that, among adult
transgender respondents, the average waiting time between the realization that they are trans
and the time of first contact with a professional to talk about these feelings was ten years. The
most cited reason not to act according to the felt gender identity was the relationship with their
partner and the fear of losing family ties and contact with their children (Motmans, 2010).
On many occasions, a burn out, depression, suicide attempt or other severe mental health
problem acts as a trigger for an adult transgender person to come out as trans and deal with the
aforementioned perceived emotional obstacles. Far less researched, but nevertheless important
to mention, are the situations in which an adult transgender person has a parent of a certain age.
Even when these parents have accepted the felt gender identity (and/or social gender role
transition) of their child, a re-emergence of shame and going back into the closet may occur
when the parent is placed in a residential or nursing home or other care facility.
Being confronted with new surroundings, other residents of a similar (older) generation, and
care staff, can make it a challenge to explain the trans identity and social gender role transition
of their adult child. Social workers and other care staff working in these care facilities are often
unfamiliar with such situations, and may benefit from information, education and training.
Given that trans individuals experience high rates of minority stressors irrespective of their
country of residence (Grant et al., 2011; Testa et al., 2012; Women and Equalities Committee,
2016), it is not inconceivable that the children of trans parents could also be considered
members of a minority group and may also experience minority stress. Connolly (2006) argued
that stigma surrounding trans identities may influence trans people’s immediate and extended
families in covert and overt ways, for example, family members may internalize transphobic
beliefs and this may influence their interactions with their trans family member.
Several studies have found that children with trans parents have experienced challenges related
to societal transphobia, including harassment by peers (Dierckx et al., 2017; Freedman et al.,
2002; Haines et al., 2014). Others have reported children’s fear of stigmatization and bullying
(Veldorale-Griffin, 2014) and those children may attempt to conceal their trans parent’s identity
to some extent (Church et al., 2014; Haines et al., 2014). Whereas all of these experiences could
potentially directly affect children’s psychological well-being as conceptualized by the minority
stress model, it is also possible that dyadic minority stress processes may be relevant in this
sample.
There is disagreement among transgender leaders about attempts to remove GID from the Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Some want it removed because it pathologizes gender variance,
while others want it to remain because a GID diagnosis can provide medical coverage and access to care.
According to Winter (2007) “the psychiatric theologisation of transgenderism may indeed be enhancing
the access of trans people in the developed world to subsidised medical care. But trans people worldwide,
with different needs, different priorities, are paying the price”
Bilodeau (2003) introduced a model of transgender identity development that closely mirrors D’Augelli
(1994) framework for homosexual individuals. There are six processes that transgenders work through on
the way to a healthy identity:
1. Exiting a traditionally gendered identity - involves recognizing that one is gender variant.
2. Developing a personal transgender identity- focusing on knowing oneself in relation to the gender
variance.
3. Developing a transgender social identity- creating a network of support for one’s identity.
4. Becoming a transgender offspring- coming out to family members and revaluating these familial
relationships.
5. Developing a transgender intimacy status- establishing intimate personal and emotional relationships.
6. Entering a transgender community- becoming involved politically and socially with transgender
communities. This model removes some of the stigma that has come with transgender research and
turned the focus back onto the transgender person as an individual. It validates what the person is feeling
and the many areas they must endure change in order to establish a healthy gender identity.
Today, researchers and advocates support an Eco developmental approach for exploring transgender
identity development. This framework is not limited by what is socially expected; instead, researchers
may consider multiple interacting systems of biology and environment (at home, in school, in a society,
etc.).
By considering interacting systems, researchers are better able to explore the meanings and
representations of changing identity labels over time (Grossman & D'Augelli, 2006; Pardo, 2008).
Transgenders in different cultures Transgender persons have been documented in many cultures and
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
societies from antiquity until the present day. However, the meaning of gender variance may vary from
culture to culture.
Every society contains individuals who do not fit into the culture’s dominant sex/gender categories -
persons born intersexed (hermaphrodites), those who exhibit behaviour or desires deemed appropriate for
the "opposite" sex/gender, or those who, while conforming outwardly to culturally normative gender
roles, experience themselves in conflict with these roles in some fundamental ways.
Historically, transgender communities have attempted to appropriate (with varying degrees of
success) rituals, folklore and legends in order to obtain a sense of self-validation and carve out a niche for
themselves in the traditional social structures. In various cultures, transgenders were seen as having
special powers due to their assumed ‘third sex’ dimension, and were allowed to take part in semi-
religious ceremonies.
Often, they were tolerated and allowed to live in the role of the other sex, to pursue their occupations
(including that of sex work), cross-dress, and display other forms of transgender behaviour. Nevertheless,
they were often segregated and excluded from many occupations and community practices, and even
traded as slaves.
The hijra, an alternative gender role in India, is culturally conceptualized as neither man nor woman.
Hijras are viewed with ambivalence in Indian society and are treated with a combination of mockery,
fear, and respect. Although hijras have an auspicious presence, they also have an inauspicious potential.
(Nanda, 2002)
Their traditional occupation is to collect payment for their performances at weddings and the birth of a
male child; today they also perform for the birth of girl children, collect alms from shopkeepers, act as
tax collectors, and even run for political office.
They also are widely known as prostitutes, both in the past and present. In terms of their gender identity
and role, Kothi’s like hijras are transgender persons who identify themselves with the feminine gender.
However, whereas hijras often settle into a fixed gender role after castration, Kothi’s display a dual
gender identity alternating between the masculine role of the husband demanded in the marriage
relationship and the feminine role in the same-sex relationship outside.
There are roughly one million Hijras in India, representing approximately one in every 400 post pubertal
persons born male. This very large prevalence (~1:400) of the Hijra in India, most of whom have
undergone ‘nirvan’ (a sex change by ancient surgical means), is strong evidence that the intense
transgender condition is far more prevalent than traditional western psychiatrists and psychologists have
ever been willing to admit.
Community members generally live-in groups of five to ten people who function as a family. The
community is organised around the 'guru-chela' (teacher-student or leader-follower) relationship, one
based on hierarchy and power. (Pisal & Bandewar, 2005).
In Thailand kathoey, defined as a third sex, a variant of male or female, having characteristics of both,
live and work openly both in rural and urban areas. Like the waria in Indonesia and the bakla in the
Philippines, kathoeys are particularly associated with feminine beauty and glamour and widely admired
for their feminine grace and elegance.
In Malaysia, the local term for male transsexuals is mak nyah, and pak nyah for females. According to
Teh (2001) they are labelled as sexual deviants and are generally shunned by society.
In 1972, Sweden was the first country to pass special legislation regulating surgical and legal measures
required for sex reassignment, thereby granting the sex-reassigned person the rights and obligations of the
new sex (Wålinder & Thuwe, 1976). Japanese have a positive attitude towards transgenders.
According to Israel and Tarver (1997), the most common mental health issues transgender persons
experience are depression as well as adjustment, anxiety, personality, and post-traumatic stress disorders.
While the transgender state itself is not any longer considered to be unhealthy, the stress of dealing with
the confusion and society’s negative response can lead to numerous other problems. They appear to be at
risk for mental health problems like other persons who experience major life changes, relationship
difficulties, chronic medical conditions, or significant discrimination on the basis of minority status.
Many transgender patients experience distress and anxiety about their gender identity, and may have less
familial and peer support as compared to non-transgender individuals (Bockting, Huang, Ding, Robinson,
& Rosser, 2005). Ettner (1999) stresses the devastating effect of shame on the development of a positive
identity.
Schaefer and Wheeler (2004) identified guilt as underlying a host of psychological problems facing the
gender-variant individual. In addition, the process of transitioning to the other sex brings up a myriad of
specific challenges, some anticipated and others harder to predict.
Transgender clients face many possible losses in their lives. (Miller,1996). Choosing to be openly gender
variant, in particular the transition process for a transsexual, can result in the loss of family and friends
who disapprove or do not understand. The loss can be particularly traumatic if, as is often the case, the
disclosure or discovery of the person’s transgender status is unplanned. “In many circumstances, being
non-trans LGB peers. Reis and Saewyc (1999) reported that 80% of youth harassment originated in
judgments about gender expression, regardless of sexual orientation.
Gender-variant young people may have relationship difficulties with family and peers, depression, and a
high risk of being victimized by violence and harassment (Di Ceglie, Freedman, McPherson, &
Richardson, 2002). Winter (2009) found that many trans people in Asian countries who drop out of
education early, especially those drifting into the city with little education or few family contacts, find it
difficult to get a job.
They experience some form of victimization as a direct result of their transgender identity or
presentation. This victimization ranges from subtle forms of harassment and discrimination to blatant
verbal, physical, and sexual assault, including beatings, rape and even homicide. The majority of assaults
against transgender persons are never reported to the police. Available evidence suggest the need to
address alcohol and substance use among Hijras/TG communities.
Hijras provide several reasons justifying their alcohol consumption that range from the need to 'forget
worries' (because there is no family support or no one cares about them) to managing rough clients in
their sex work life. However, alcohol use is associated with inability to use condoms or insist their clients
to use condoms, and thus increase risk for HIV transmission and acquisition. (TGIssueBrief, UNDP, VC,
Dec2010)
Psychological problems are separate and individual. Not all transgender people have psychological
problems. Being transgender, itself is not a psychological problem
They might struggle with anxiety and depression possibly related to dysphoria, discrimination in
areas such as employment and housing, as well as discrimination by transphobic people in general.
They definitely face discrimination in dating relationships, as the majority of people say they
wouldn’t date transgender people regardless of sexual identification or orientation. Many transgender
people have a history related to suicidal ideation and possibly attempts.
Availability of treatment and insurance coverage is important for young transgender people is
important. Delaying puberty and/or beginning hormonal treatment to allow them to go through
puberty according to how they identify is critical. After puberty takes place, it can’t be reversed.
Expensive surgery later can’t come close to accomplishing the same things as going through puberty
the right way the first time. Of course, risks and costs of future related surgery are prevented as well.
Quality of Life
Quality of life is the subjective judgment of the extent to which one is living the good life. This
perception of the good life may be based on feelings of happiness, meaning in life, and inner peace. The
definition of quality of life is different for everyone. The main thing that determines quality of life is our
ability to enjoy all that life has to offer. For instance, the ability to walk, talk, see and feel all contributes
to our overall quality of life. A quality life is a life full of meaning and purpose. A high-quality life is
also a life of freedom from tyranny.
If a person is happy, has inner peace, and perceives that his or her life is meaningful, then the person
could be viewed as being successful and achieving a high quality of life. Quality of life (QOL) defined
as a person's perception of his or her physical and mental health (Wong, Cronin, Griffith, Irvine, &
Guyot, 2001), covers broad domains including physical, psychological, economical, spiritual and social
well-being. QOL is described by the World Health Organization (WHO) as “people’s perception of
their situation in the culture and the value system they live in related with their goals, standards,
expectations and ideas" (Alleyne, 2003).
It is a broad ranging concept affected in a complex way by the person's physical health, psychological
state, personal beliefs, social relationships and their relationship to salient features of their environment.
The term QOL is used to evaluate the general well-being of individuals and societies. The term is used
in a wide range of contexts, including the fields of international development, healthcare, and politics.
Standard indicators of the QOL include not only wealth and employment, but also the built
environment, physical and mental health, education, recreation and leisure time, and social belonging
(Gregory, Derek,2009).
It cannot be simply equated with the terms of health status, lifestyle, life satisfaction, mental state, or
well-being; it is rather a multidimensional concept incorporating the individual’s perception of those
and other aspects of life. Researchers at the University of Toronto's Quality of Life Research Unit
define QOL as “the degree to which a person enjoys the important possibilities of his or her life”. Their
Quality-of-Life Model is based on the categories “being”, “belonging”, and “becoming”, respectively
who one is, how one is connected to one's environment, and whether one achieves one's personal goals,
hopes and aspirations.
Self Esteem
Self-esteem reflects a person’s overall self-appraisal of one’s own worth. Self-esteem encompasses both
beliefs and emotions. Psychologists usually regard self-esteem as an enduring personality characteristic
(trait self-esteem), though normal short-term variations (state self-esteem) occur. Self-esteem can apply
specifically to a particular dimension or have global extent. Branden in (1969) defined self-esteem as "...
the experience of being competent to cope with the basic challenges of life and being worthy of
happiness". This two-factor approach, as some have also called it, provides a balanced definition that
seems to be capable of dealing with limits of defining self-esteem primarily in terms of competence or
worth alone.
Maslow (1954) states that no psychological health is possible unless the essential core of the person is
fundamentally accepted loved and respected by others and by himself. Self-esteem allows people to face
life with more confidence, benevolence and optimism, and thus easily reach their goals and self-
actualized There is accumulating evidence that positive self-esteem can be an antidote to depression.
Self-esteem serves as a buffer from the onslaught of anxiety, guilt, depression, shame, criticism and other
internal attacks. Rivas Torres and Fernandez (1995) examined the relationship among self-esteem, health
values, and health behaviours among adolescents.
They found a significant relationship between self-esteem and general health behaviour for both younger
and older adolescents, and that self-esteem accounted for a significant percent of the variance in mental
health behaviour, social health behaviour, and total health behaviour. Bernard, Hutchison, Lavin, and
Pennington (1996) found high correlations among self-esteem, self-efficacy, ego strength, hardiness,
optimism, and maladjustment, and all of these constructs were significantly related to health.
According to McKay and Fanning (2000) low self-esteem has its roots in early experiences of abuse or
abandonment thus highlighting the influence of home on self-esteem. Harter (1993) said that people’s
judgment about themselves is an important factor of self-esteem. An important basis for self-judgment is
how well one ‘stacks up’ against a reference group. The concept of social comparison has implications in
understanding differences in self-esteem of members in groups that are discriminated such as the gender
variant groups.
It is assumed that individuals who are clear about their gender identification draw referents from an
organized system of beliefs as to the psychosexual meaning of being a male or female. As a
developmental process, individuals incorporate the resultant composite of a set of beliefs about
For many individuals among the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community, several
factors could play key roles in causing their self-esteem to drop: rejection from family, friends or
religious organizations, the media and looks, ethnicity, financial status, drugs and/or alcohol, HIV/AIDS
as well as other health related issues, prejudice, discrimination, and stigmas (Riddle- Crilly, 2009). By
becoming aware of one’s personal identity and accepting who they are, many of them have gained a
higher self-esteem through their own self- efficacy. Some argue that self-views are connected to an
individual’s values and goals, and that they strongly influence their global self-worth (Pelham & Swann,
1989).
When a FtM transgender, for instance, sees his transition as his wholeness and this helps his self-esteem
increase, he becomes a happier, a more positive individual and can be much more productive.
Stonewall’s report, towards a Healthier LGBT Scotland (2003) found that “low self-esteem, anxiety and
depression are common experiences for many LGBT people.” The report finds that "problems associated
with homophobia and transphobia in early life, such as bullying and low self-esteem, can continue into
adulthood and have serious, long-term negative health and social consequences for individuals
affected".
The sting of emotional abuse carries the same effect on self-esteem as physical or sexual abuse.
Transgender has its own built in Catch 22. (Peters, 2005) since one need very high self-esteem to
successfully deal with being transgendered, but simply being transgendered is one of the great forces
sapping self-esteem.
Social anxiety
Anxiety, like worry, is a form of fear. It is a “persisting distressful psychological state arising from an
inner conflict”. The distress may be experienced as a feeling of vague uneasiness or foreboding, a feeling
of being on edge, or as any of a variety of other feelings, such as fear, anger, restlessness, irritability,
depression, or other diffuse and nameless feelings. In Social anxiety a person is afraid of social situations
and has a fear of being judged unworthy by others. Peer victimization is a social risk factor for internal
distress.
People with a diagnosis of social anxiety disorder find social situations nerve wracking, from mixing with
friends to speaking in public. A number of explanations have been proposed for why they feel this way,
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
including that they are pre-occupied with creating the right impression. Weisman and her colleagues
(2011) claim that people with social anxiety are overly concerned with social hierarchy, and struggle with
what's called the affiliative side of relationships. In simple terms this means they tend to perceive social
situations as being competitive and judge themselves as having a lower rank compared to others and they
also have difficulty forming close relationships.
Some researchers have explored the relationship between anxiety and various forms of bullying. It
appears as though some forms of bullying are more strongly linked to anxiety than other forms. Storch
(2003) has shown that overt victimization (i.e., experiencing attempts or threats to harm one’s physical
wellbeing), and relational victimization (i.e., experiencing attempts or threats to harm one’s peer
relationships), were both associated with heightened levels of social anxiety for males and females aged
13 to16 years. Students who were bullied in multiple forms endorsed higher social anxiety levels than
those who reported one form of victimization.
Students who reported relational victimization seemed to have higher levels of social anxiety. Boys 14-18
years of age who were bullied by being called “gay” endorsed higher levels of anxiety than their peers
who were bullied for other reasons? (Swearer, Turner, Givens & Pollack, 2008), Thus, being called “gay”
seemed to be more strongly linked to anxiety than other forms of victimization.
Research has indicated the role of ‘core’ or ‘unconditional' negative beliefs (e.g., I am inept) and
'conditional' beliefs (e.g., If I show myself, I will be rejected) in social anxiety. Some of the negative core
beliefs among transgenders are as follows
These are among the common core beliefs that generate problems like social anxiety, depression, and
self-esteem. Young people who sense they are in some way different easily learn some of these self-
destructive core beliefs.
For most children and adolescents, different is not good. Being accepted by peers is essential to young
people. For most young people, being different or non-conformist feels good only if theirs is a group of
similarly different and non-conforming friends who accept and value them.
Young people who sense they may be lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender (LGBT) are especially
vulnerable to this dynamic of social unacceptability resulting in negative core beliefs. They are often
being told that they are sick, sinful, disgusting and should not exist. Many who cannot hide their
differences become the target of violence.
Transgenders face this dilemma of being labelled everywhere they go. They are continuously conscious
of the way they appear towards the public, and hope that the public will perceive them for the gender they
want to be, without repercussions.
In a bid to address the social stigma, the umbrella scheme would also provide monetary benefit
to families with transgender children and encourage them not to abandon them. The ministry of
social justice and empowerment is giving finishing touches to an umbrella scheme which would
be launched in the next financial year.
The umbrella scheme would have five components – pre-matric and post-matric scholarship for
transgender children, support for vocational training of transgenders, pension for out-of-work
transgenders in the age group of 40 to 60 years and monthly monetary support for families with
transgender children. At present, there is no substantial monetary support from the government’s
side. Central assistance only comes in the form of paltry pensions of Rs 200 to Rs 400 per
month. The umbrella scheme would provide this support to the transgender community. The
monetary benefits would also be enhanced.
SWEEKRUTI
The Government of Odisha formulated an umbrella scheme ‘Sweekruti’ to secure the rights of
transgender persons and ensure equitable justice. It recognises that transgender persons are
subject to discrimination and hardships in society.
The main objectives of the scheme are to create an enabling environment for transgender
persons, ensure their participation and social integration, strengthen the implementation of
various schemes and facilities, and promote measures for employment and socio-educational
services for transgender persons.
The scheme notes that there is no definitive data on the number of transgender persons in the
State.
It proposes that the State should conduct regular surveys of the number of transgender persons
with the assistance of transgender associations. This will ensure that transgender persons enrol
themselves in the schemes and programmes instituted for their benefit. A Multipurpose SMART
Card will be provided to all transgender persons.
This will enable enrolment in schemes and provision of services. It will also assist in monitoring
the benefits utilised and which services are required by transgender persons. The scheme
provides for scholarships for transgender students to help them complete their education.
Garima Greh:
o It has been opened in Vadodara, Gujarat and will be run in association with
the Lakshya Trust, a community-based organisation entirely run by the transgenders.
o The Scheme of ‘Shelter Home for Transgender Persons’ includes shelter facility,
food, clothing, recreational facilities, skill development opportunities, yoga, physical
fitness, library facilities, legal support, technical advice for gender transition and
surgeries, capacity building of trans-friendly organizations, employment, etc.
A basic part of their identity – gender – is unrecognized”. This recognition of their gender is
core to having their inherent dignity respected and, among other rights, their right to health
including protection from HIV. When denied, trans people face severe impediments in accessing
appropriate health information and care.
Recognizing a trans person's gender requires respecting the right of that person to identify –
irrespective of the sex assigned to them at birth – as male, female, or a gender that does not fit
within the male–female binary, a “third” gender as it were, as has been expressed by many
traditionally existing trans communities such as hijras in India.
Derogatory comments, breaches of confidentiality from providers, and denial of services on the
basis of gender identity or HIV status are some of the manifestations of prejudice. The right to
non-discrimination that is guaranteed to all human beings under international law must be
enforced against actions that violate this principle in the healthcare system. Yet, a multi-pronged
approach that supports this affirmation of trans equality together with a sensitized workforce that
is capable of delivering gender-affirming surgical and HIV health services is necessary.
Building on the commitments made by the UN General Assembly in response to the HIV
epidemic, the World Health Organization (WHO) developed good practice recommendations in
relation to stigma and discrimination faced by key populations, including trans people.
These recommendations urge countries to introduce rights-based laws and policies and advise
that, “Monitoring and oversight are important to ensure that standards are implemented and
maintained.” Additionally, mechanisms should be made available “to anonymously report
occurrences of stigma and/or discrimination when [trans people] try to obtain health services”.
Providing equal access to housing, education, public facilities and employment opportunities,
and developing and implementing anti-discrimination laws and policies that protect trans people
in these contexts, including guaranteeing their safety and security, are essential to ensure that
trans individuals are treated as equal human beings.
According to Anupama Sekhar (2008) transgender icons such as television host Rose and Noori of the
South India Positive Network have found a new visibility in the media. These new public faces of the
community are indicative of larger, fundamental changes in a group increasingly entering the
mainstream in Tamil Nadu. These emerging voices have been speaking not merely to the outside world,
but significantly, to each other as well.
One such safe space for sharing, dialogue and transformation is the Friends Club or Natpukoodam
attached to 22 Tamil Nadu AIDS Initiative (TAI)clinics across the state. At these drop-in centres, the
community has access to low-cost beauty services, food and clothes, banks as well as much-needed
information on safe sex practices. Tamil Nadu AIDS Initiative’s Peer Jeevan Collective, spread across
13 districts of Tamil Nadu comprises 1,650 peer educators (aptly called Peer Jeevans because of their
potential to give new life to their peers) reaching out to 30 transgenders in the locality with information
on STDs, HIV/AIDS and legal aid.
Additionally, the Jeevans distribute condoms, coordinate Self Help Groups and Friends Clubs and work
to address violence within 24 hours through the Araychi Mani rapid response mechanism. Vocational
training opportunities are increasingly becoming available. In November 2009, transgenders won the
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
right to be listed as ‘other’ rather than ‘male’ or ‘female’ on electoral rolls and voter identity cards.
Transgenders’ addition in the census of 2011 in the ‘others' category is hailed by the community
members and activists as a recognition which, they hope, will inch the "faceless people" closer to other
basic rights like voting and crimes against them being registered.
The Karnataka government has passed a resolution entitling them to 15% reservations under the 2A
category of the Backward Class Commission. National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) has included
the transgender in the definition of marginalised groups entitling them to avail of free legal aid
However, there are many challenges from within the community. The prevailing guru-chela system
prevalent in the community has often proved to be an obstacle for juniors seeking opportunities for a
better life. Senior community members have been slow in taking the lead.
1.14. CONCLUSION
Down the ages, our society has condemned and alienated people who do not conform to its norms.
Transgender persons are one such group of people who have been marginalized in many societies. Leading a
life as a transgender is far from easy because such people can be neither categorized as male nor as female
and this deviation is "unacceptable" to society's vast majority. Trying to eke out a dignified living is even
worse. Research shows that transgenders are even overlooked by the rest of the LGBT community.
Transgenders still float beneath the surface, most of them invisible, like the unseen portion of the iceberg.
One of the important problem’s transgenders face in the society is lack of social acceptance. Although they
have been part of every culture and society in recorded human history, they have only recently become the
focus of attention in psychological, medical and social research. Unchecked negative attitudes toward
transgender persons may result in transphobia as well as discriminatory treatment of transgender individuals
(Clamant, 2008).
As The (2002) puts it, ignorance is one of the reasons why people are prejudiced against transsexuals. As
the visibility of transgenders increases it is time to help them join the main stream of society. In order to
achieve this objective, it is necessary to understand the psychological issues and challenges they face as well
as examine the prevailing attitudes in the society. A major challenge in the mobilisation process has been
motivating the transgenders to actively demand rights and services.
There has been some progressive steps taken to improve their quality of life but this has come after years of
crushing social stigmatisation, abuse and general derision from the wider community. As one transgender
put it “They make documentaries about us and say all these interesting things, but when we walk out on the
street, we still get the calling and the whistles.”.
The study will also empirically examine the possibility of making a shift in the attitude by dealing with some
of the unexpressed fears towards this gender variant group. Discrimination is the anti-thesis of equality, and
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
it is the duty of all right-minded citizens to drive away discriminatory practices from all walks of life.
(Shukla, 2011)
CHAPTER 2:
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Review of literature is a systematic identification and summary of Britain materials that contain
information on research problem. It is a key step in research, it refers to an extensive, exhaustive and
systemic examination of Publication relevant to research project. By reviewing the literature, researcher
can easily find out the positive aspects to be studied and also provide wide knowledge about the topic.
It also helps to compare the past with the present situation and thereby further studies could be
conducted in the field. Each literature can be used to as an additional source that will provide clear idea
about the topic researcher is going to study. In this chapter we have include the empirical study done by
the various researches and the review of available study.
The review of literature contains the information about the psycho - social problem faced by transgender
Family, friends and romantic partners may not understand the transitional and not be able to provide the
needed support. There are many ways of dealing with the challenges that come with transitioning and
living as a transgender individual, some healthier than others. There are two primary coping styles that
people use to deal with difficult thing in life. Emotion-Focused and problem. Focused is also known as
facilitative and avoidant, respectively.
In this study participants held a variety of gender identities under the transgender rubric (e.g., cross
dresser, trans man, transwomen, butch lesbian). Interviews explored the participants’ experiences in
arriving at their gender identity. This paper presents three clusters of findings related to the common
processes of gender identity development.
This process was made possible by accessibility of transgender narratives that injected hope into what
was childhood replete with criticism and scrutiny. Ultimately, participants came to their identities
through balancing a desire for authenticity with demands of necessity-meaning that they weighed their
internal gender experience with considerations about their available resources, coping skills and the
consequences of gender transitions.
The implications of these findings are considered in terms of their contribution to gender theory,
research, and clinical support for transgender clients.
Study of psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity with a national sample of 552
transgender adults, tested hypotheses drawn from minority stress theory and positive psychology
research on stress –ameliorating processes. Specifically, the present study examined the relations of
minority stressors and individual-and group –level buffers of minority stress.
As expected, each minority stressor was positively correlated with psychological distress. In terms of
buffers, resilience– though not collective action- was negatively correlated with mediated the relation of
antitransgender discrimination with higher psychological distress. Moderation analysis indicated that
resilience did not moderate any of the relations of the minority stressors with psychological distress.
Additionally, stigma awareness –but not internalized transphobia-mediated the relation of anti-
transgender discrimination with higher psychological distress. Moderation analysis indicated that
resilience did not moderate any of the relations of the minority stressors with psychological distress.
However, contrary to prediction, collective action strengthened the positive relation of internalized
transphobia with psychological distress.
Furthermore, at high levels of collective action, internalized transphobia became a significant mediator
of the discrimination-distress relation. Strategies for developing individual and group level interventions
targeted toward transgender individuals who experience discrimination are discussed.
The hypothesized that mindful acceptance and self-esteem explains significant proportion of variance in
psychological quality of life of LGBT individuals, and that the relationship between stress and
psychological quality of life is moderated by mindful attention. The recruited 177 participants from the
Dallas/Ft. worth area Andrew performed both a linear regression analysis and two moderation analyses
to test our hypotheses.
Controlling for age and years of education, it is found that acceptance and self-esteem accounted for a
significant proportion of the variance in psychological quality of life. Moderation analyses revealed that
both mindful acceptance and self-esteem moderate the relationship between stress and psychological
quality of life of sexual and gender minorities.
2.5. Valentine SE
Transgender and gender non-conforming (TGNC) populations, including those who do not identified
with gender binary constructs are increasingly recognized in health care settings. Research on the health
of TGNC people is growing, and disparities are often noted. In this review, he examines 77 studies
published between January 1 ,1997 and march 22,2017 which reported mental health outcomes and
describe what gaps persist in this literature.
In general, depressive symptoms, suicidality, inter personal trauma exposure, substance use disorders,
anxiety and general distress have been consistently elevated among TGNC adults we also used the
minority stress model as a frame work for summarizing existing literature. While no studies included all
elements of the Minority Stress Model, this summary gives an over view of which studies have looked at
each element. Findings suggest that TGNC people are exposed to a variety of social stressors, including
stigma, discrimination and bias events that contribute to mental health problems.
Social support, community connectedness and effective coping strategies appear beneficial. He argues
that routine collection of gender identity data could advance our understanding mental health risk and
resilience factors among TGNC populations.
Participants completed measures on transgender identity, family history mental health concerns,
perceptions of loss, coping, depression and anxiety. Results of the study: the rates of depressive
symptoms and anxiety within the current study far surpass the rates of those for the general population.
The SEM results suggest that the processes for transgender women and transgender men are primarily
similar for depression and anxiety; avoidant coping served as a mediator between transition status and
both distress variables. Social support was directly related to distress variables, as well as indirectly
related through avoidant coping.
And finally, the results suggest the need for practitioners to focus on interventions that reduce avoidant
coping strategies, while simultaneously increasing social support, in order to improve mental health for
transgender individuals. Individuals who are in the beginning stages of their transition will use different
coping strategies than those who are in later stages; interventions should be adjusted on the basis of the
transition status of transgender clients.
In a study on transsexualism a review of etiology, diagnosis and treatment by department of child and
adolescent psychiatry, it is said that Utrecht, The Netherlands. transsexualism considered to be the
extreme end of the spectrum of gender identify disorders characterized by, among other things, a pursuit
of sex reassignment surgery (SRS).
The origins of transsexuals are still largely unclear. A first indication of anatomic brain differences
between transsexuals and non-transsexuals has been found. Also, certain parental (rearing) factors seem
to be associated with transsexualism. Some contradictory findings regarding etiology, psychopathology
and success of SRS seem to be related to the fact that certain subtypes of transsexuals follow different
developmental routes.
The observations that psychotherapy is not helpful in altering crystallized cross-gender identify and that
certain transsexuals do not show severe psychopathology has led clinicians to adapt sex reassignment as
a treatment option.
IN many countries, transsexuals are now treated according to the standards of care of the Harry
Benjamin International Gender Dysphoria association, a professional organization in the field of
2.7. Kristen Clements, Rani Marx and Mitchell Katz, October (2008)
Attempted suicide among transgender person-The influence of Gender based discrimination and
victimization) says that the research's interviewed 292 male-to female and 123 females to make
Transgenders. Participants were recruited through targeted sampling, respondent-driven sampling, and
agency referrals in San Francisco. The prevalence of attempted suicide was 32%.
In a multivariate logistic regression analysis younger age i.e., less than 25% years, depression, a history
of substance abuse treatment, a history of forced sex, gender-based discrimination and gender-based
victimization were independently associated with attempted suicide. Suicide prevention interventions for
transgender persons are urgently needed, particularly for young people.
Medical, mental health and social workers should address this issue of depression, substances abuse, and
forced sex in attempt to reduce the suicidal behaviors among transgender. In addition, increasing societal
acceptance of transgender community and decreasing gender-based prejudice may help to prevent
suicide in this highly stigmatized population Mitchell Katz, October (2008)
Many shelters are physically unsafe for transgender people, fail to provide adequate protections for their
privacy, or do not respect their autonomy to define their own gender identity. This article provides
information about transgender people, their experiences with poverty and homelessness, and how shelter
can be made safe and welcoming for them.
Trans women were older than the other 4 groups. Transwomen, transmen and gender queers were more
highly educated than non-transgender sisters and non-transgender brothers, but did not have a
corresponding higher income. Other demographic differences between groups were found in religion,
geographic mobility, relationship status, and sexual orientation.
Transgender people were more likely to experience harassment and discrimination than non-transgender
sisters and non-transgender brothers. All transgender people perceived less social support from family
than non-transgender sisters. This is the first study to compare Trans people to non-trans siblings as a
comparison group.
relatives who came to the interview were mothers. While 85.1% of the families considered themselves as
secular Muslims, 14.9% were very religious. Gender identity disorder was first noticed during puberty
(70.2%) or pre-puberty (17%). In 63.8% it was remarked that it was a shocking experience. One-third of
them felt responsible for it.
While 65.9% tried to change the situation by coercion, only 27.7% adopted a supportive attitude. The
majority of families tried to conceal the situation from their immediate environment and one-third did
not even inform their closest relatives. For half of relatives the mass media was their only source of
information whereas one-third received information from doctors. 40.4% of the families accepted the
transgendered identity and approved the sex reassignment surgery as a final step.
Cluster analysis revealed that, based on their beliefs, 97.1% of the sample could be divided into three
groups. Most (61.2%) fell into a „biogenic‟ group, emphasizing the role played by inborn biology, while
29.4% believed took a „peer psychogenic‟ view, emphasizing the role played by friends in the
development of their transgender. A small „eclectic‟ group (6.5%) believed that biology, karma and
parents combined to account for their transgender.
LGBT young adults who reported low levels of family acceptance during adolescence were over three
times more likely to have suicidal thoughts and to report suicide attempts, compared to those with high
levels of family acceptance. High religious involvement in families was strongly associated with low
acceptance of LGBT children.
or day care teachers or scouting leaders. 74% say they would be OK working with a transgendered
person; 61% favour laws to prevent workplace discrimination; and 68% support hate crimes laws that
covert transgendered people.
After respondents were given the definition of what it means to be transgendered- an exercise that is
considered an abbreviated form of education- they had a somewhat less favourable attitude toward
transgendered people. Additionally, the poll found a very critical correlation between whether the public
sees being transgender as a moral issue and whether they think people have a choice about being a
transgender.
About 53.6% of the students gave correct answer to the definition of transsexualism. Most of the
students thought that transsexuals should have the possibility of legal change of name (67%) or
undergoing hormonal therapy (70%) and surgical treatment (63.5%). Student’s attitude toward legal and
surgical sex change in transsexuals was positive.
Female students showed greater understanding of transsexual needs than male students. Winter (2007)
and his team of researchers looked at transphobia in seven countries. The results of a factor analysis
identified core attitudes and beliefs. Five factors were identified together explaining 52.1% of variance.
They were,
1) the belief that transwomen suffer from a mental sickness;
2) the belief that transwomen are not women, should not be treated as such, and should not be afforded
rights as women;
3) rejection of contact with transwomen in a variety of social situations, including among family
members and teachers;
4) rejection of contact with transwomen within one's peer group, and 5) the belief that transwomen
engage in sexually deviant behaviour.
Particularly strong, and fairly consistent across the seven countries involved, were the links between, on
one hand, the belief that transwomen suffer from a mental sickness and, on the other hand, the refusal to
regard or treat them as women or to afford them rights as women, as well as an unwillingness to accept
the idea of any social contact with them at all, either within one's family group or outside.
Attitudes, assessed on both personal and institutional dimensions, were examined in relation to
participants' gender, age, educational level, religiosity, and previous contact with trans people. Results
suggest that previous contact with trans people was significantly associated with attitudes reflected in the
scale; decreased social distance, decreased social discrimination, and decreased transprejudice, increased
awareness of discrimination against trans people, increased support for equal opportunities, increased
support for post-operative transsexual civil rights, and increased support for anti-discrimination
legislation.
Participants rated one of two vignettes, which were paired with one of four different pictures. The
vignettes described either a male-to-female or female-to-male transsexual, and the corresponding picture
depicted an individual whose appearance was stereotypically consistent with either the vignette
character's post-operative sex or his or her biological sex.
Participants reported more positive general perceptions and more positive evaluations of the transsexual
character's attractiveness as a friend or romantic partner when his/her appearance was congruent with the
desired sex.
Compared to women, men rated the transsexual character more negatively. There was also a significant
interaction for gender of the participant and sex of the transsexual, such that females rated the
attractiveness of the FTM transsexual significantly more positively than the MTF transsexual, whereas
men's attractiveness ratings for the FTM and MTF transsexuals were not significantly different.
to peers with low levels of family acceptance. LGBT young adults who reported low levels of family
acceptance during adolescence were over three times more likely to have suicidal thoughts and to report
suicide attempts, compared to those with high levels of family acceptance. High religious involvement in
families was strongly associated with low acceptance of LGBT children
They were, 1) the belief that transwomen suffer from a mental sickness; 2) the belief that transwomen
are not women, should not be treated as such, and should not be afforded rights as women; 3) Rejection
of contact with transwomen in a variety of social situations, including among family members and
teachers; 4) rejection of contact with transwomen within one's peer group, and 5) the belief that
transwomen engage in sexually deviant behaviour.
Particularly strong, and fairly consistent across the seven countries involved, were the links between, on
one hand, the belief that transwomen suffer from a mental sickness and, on the other hand, the refusal to
regard or treat them as women or to afford them rights as women, as well as an unwillingness to accept
the idea of any social contact with them at all, either within one's family group or outside.
Participants rated one of two vignettes, which were paired with one of four different pictures. The
vignettes described either a male-to-female or female-to-male transsexual, and the corresponding picture
depicted an individual whose appearance was stereotypically consistent with either the vignette
character's post-operative sex or his or her biological sex.
Participants reported more positive general perceptions and more positive evaluations of the transsexual
character's attractiveness as a friend or romantic partner when his/her appearance was congruent with the
desired sex. Compared to women, men rated the transsexual character more negatively.
There was also a significant interaction for gender of the participant and sex of the transsexual, such that
females rated the attractiveness of the FTM transsexual significantly more positively than the MTF
transsexual, whereas men's attractiveness ratings for the FTM and MTF transsexuals were not
significantly different.
Analysis of quality-of-life health concepts demonstrated statistically significant diminished QOL among
the FTM transgender participants as compared to the US male and female population, particularly in
regard to mental health. FTM transgender participants who received testosterone (67%) reported
statistically significant higher quality of life scores than those who had not received hormone therapy.
Hancock, Krissinger and Owen (2010) explored relationships between self-perceived QOL and
perceptions of femininity and likability associated with transgender voice. For male-to-female
transgender clients, QOL is moderately correlated with how others perceive their voice. This study
complements previous research reports that subjective measures from clients and listeners may be
valuable for evaluating the effectiveness of treatment in terms of how treatment influences voice related
QOL issues for transgender people.
The adult MtF group saw substance abuse treatment and HIV/AIDS care as being the key issue. The MtF
adult group said that endocrinology, mental health and primary care were their most important health
care needs. In all the focus groups, a constant theme was a perception of vast provider ignorance of trans
people and concerns. From the level of health care systems down to individual providers and frontline
staff, transgenders reported provider unawareness of, disrespect toward, and outright refusal of treatment
for their health needs, both basic and trans-related.
However, they also may be ridiculed at in some circumstances. In general Transgenders claim that in
northern India and in Pakistan they earn a lot more respect than in the Deep South. The highest respect
they still find in old cities with a rich Muslim heritage, especially Luck now which once was the seat of
the Nawab of Oudh. Indians, since colonial times confronted with European values and Western
exceptions, feel probably somehow unsure about their relationship to the Transgenders.
No one would ever dare to ridicule them face to face, but still people may make fun of them behind their
backs. Maybe the attitude that Transgenders have to face in India` s and Pakistan’s main entertainment
industry, the movie business, shows this ambiguity in attitude towards them in the best way.
In the past years there have been some serious Bollywood Movies in which Transgenders played the
main role in a dramatic plot (like in "Tamanna" and "Darmiyaan", describing the life of the mukhannath
Tikku), but they are also frequently hired to play "comical fun parts" in mainstream productions, giving
the reason for a "good laugh" in the audience. Actually, this reminds me a lot of how transgenders are
treated in western film industry.
Today Transgenders are very active in local politics. Especially in India, but also in Pakistan. And,
besides having been stigmatized during colonial times, many have an impressive number of voters. A
new slogan arose: "There is one solution to useless politicians, give the mandate to eunuchs."
In a town called Gorakhpur a Transgender with the name Asha Devi became mayor, another called
Kamala Jaan became mayor in Katni; nowadays there are many local Transgender politicians on the
Indian subcontinent, all following in the footsteps of "auntie" Shabnam (or Shabnam Mausi, as it is in
Hindi/Urdu), the first mukhannath member of the Madhya Pradesh Legislative Assembly. In Hindu-folk-
lore there is an old legend according to which "in the end of time there will be an age in which the
Transgenders will rule", because of a blessing from God. Many Transgenders believe this time has
come!
Transgender is an umbrella term for individuals whose self-identification transgresses the socially
established gender categories of male and female. To better understand the complexities of the
transgender identity, it is necessary to realize that while gender and sex are two terms that are often used
interchangeably, they have two very different meanings.
The American Psychological Association (2010) defines sex as assigned at birth, a reference to one’s
biological status as either male or female, and as associated primarily with physical attributes such as
chromosomes, hormone prevalence, and external and internal anatomy. Gender refers to the socially
constructed roles, behaviors, activities, and attributes that a given society considers appropriate for males
and females.
These expectations influence the ways that people act, interact, and feel about themselves. Traditionally
gendered people fall into binary categories of male sex and masculine gender identity and female sex
and feminine gender identity. While aspects of biological sex are similar across different cultures,
aspects of gender may differ. Gender expression is the outward expression of gender roles to society or
the performance of gender.
An example would be a woman with female sex traits and a feminine gender identity who wears
traditionally gendered clothing, such as skirts and blouses, and carries herself in a feminine by crossing
her legs while sitting.
This all-encompassing term can be used to refer to transsexuals, intersex persons, cross-dressers, gender
non-conforming individuals, drag queens, drag kings, and gender queers. The expression of one’s
transgender identity varies greatly from person to person. Transgender identified people may or may not
pursue medical or hormone treatment to alter their physical appearance to match their internal identity.
A transgender person, such as a drag king or drag queen, may dress as the opposite gender for the
purpose of entertainment. Someone who identifies as gender queer or gender non-conforming may not
self-identify as transgender, but may experience similar discrimination and oppression as someone who
is transgender identified.
With the diversity of identities within the term “transgender,” developing a singular definition and
prescription for all transgender individuals is impossible. The research and literature that does exist
surrounding transgender individuals and their experiences attempts to better understand the greater
influencing factors.
The study identified the paradox that in coming out as the opposite gender, transgender individuals
reinforce and reify the very two gender binary system they are trying to escape and change. This
conceptualization of the struggle experienced by transgender individuals is helpful in understanding the
power dynamics of gender and challenging the traditional notions of sex and gender.
Transgender people experience a dualistic challenge in expressing the transgender identity. One
challenge is to find language and expression to represent their individual identities in a society where
that individual identity may not exist or be recognized by the dominant social narrative. The second
challenge is to not be confined by the gender binary and the dominant social narrative in authentically
expressing the individual gender identity.
While traditionally gendered students struggle with identity, transgender students experience even
greater challenges. Colleges strive to provide safe and supportive campus environments; however, the
college campus is a microcosm of the society around it, and with that, come many of the same traditional
gendered expectations and stereotypes that exist in society.
Many of the services available on college campuses such as restroom access, dormitory living, group
memberships, and healthcare are based on the two-gender binary. Through participating in the two-
gender binary, basic needs, such as housing on a college campus, force transgender students to either
conform or to be at a disadvantage.
Through supporting students at the college level, the challenges and risks associated with being
transgender will decrease. College presents a unique opportunity for many students to begin to explore
their identity and their place in the world apart from their parents and their home communities. This is a
time when students on the social periphery can begin to express their identity and find like-minded
communities.
For transgender and gender non-conforming people, college is often the first opportunity for them to
question their ascribed gender and explore different facets of their identities. With this environment
comes a freedom to experiment with one’s gender expression (i.e., style of dress, mannerisms,
hairstyles) and one’s preferred pronouns and names (e.g., requesting to be called “Al” rather than
“Alison”).
While this period of exploration and identity development provides many opportunities for students to
grow and mature, transgender students can be most vulnerable to harassment, oppression, and
discrimination due to their transgender identity or expression.
CHAPTER 3:
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
“A STUDY ON THE PSYCHO – SOCIAL PROBLEMS FACED BY TRANSGENDERS WITH
SPECIAL REFERENCE TO NEDUMPURAM REGION”
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM
The study aimed at assessing the knowledge of transgender regarding coping strategies towards the
psychological changes in transgender. Stress is common problem facing by transgender across the world.
This study helps to provide them with good knowledge regarding stress and coping strategies. Transgender
is a general term applied to a variety of individuals, behavior and group involving tendencies to vary from
culturally conventional gender roles. Male to female and female to male are the two gender identities
which have been widely noted in the transgender literature. The study aims at Transgender face more
psychological problem and social exclusion is one of the most important.
GENERAL OBJECTIVE
To study social problems faced by transgender of Nedumpuram Region.
SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES
I. To know about social demographic features of Transgender
DEFINITION OF CONCEPTS:
1.TRANSGENDER
Theoretical definition: describing or relating to people whose sense of gender identity does not match
their biological sex or does not easily fit in with the usual division between male and female
Operational definition: People whose gender is inconsistent or not culturally associate with their
biological sex.
2. SOCIAL PROBLEM
Theoretical definition: connected with activities in which people meet each other for pleasure
Operational definition: needing companionship and therefore best suited to living in communities
3. PROBLEM
IDENTIFICATION OF VARIABLES
Dependent variables:
Education
Sex
Living
Independent Variables:
Name
Place
Religion
RESEARCH DESIGN
The research design used by the researcher is descriptive. It will help to narrate the facts and characteristics
concerning the beneficiaries. The major purpose of descriptive research is description of the state affairs,
as it exists at present, while studying the research problem, scientific method is followed.
SAMPLING SIZE:
The research took a sample of 60 transgender of Nedumpuram Region
SAMPLING TECHNIQUE:
Convenient Sampling is used for collecting data from the respondents since people from transgender
community were not very easy to find out for data collection
PILOT STUDY:
Pilot study will help to known the feasibility of the researcher topic. For the present study the researcher
conducted pilot study with the help of transgender community in the Nedumpuram Region
• Secondary sources
The researcher collected secondary data from journals, articles, books, websites etc.
INCLUSION CRITERIA:
Transgenders in Nedumpuram Region
EXCLUSION CRITERIA:
Transgenders in Nedumpuram Region other that Thiruvalla Panchayat.
PRETEST:
The pre- test was conducted on -/-/-/ with 10 transgenders to survey of the tool of data collection
ETHICAL RESPONSIBILTY
▪ The researcher assures that the data collected from respondents will be kept
confidential.
▪ The researcher will get approval from the authorities for data collection.
▪ The researcher will inform the respondents about the purpose and genuineness of the
study and get their prior consent.
▪ Data collected will be used only for academic purpose and for welfare of the destitute. After the
completion of the study, the researcher will give feedback to the respondents regarding the finding of the
study, if they ask for it.
CHAPTERIZATION
Chapter1: Introduction
Chapter 2: Review of Literature
Chapter 3: Research Methodology
Chapter 4: Data Analysis and Interpretation
Chapter 5: Findings and Suggestions.
CHAPTER 4:
DATA ANALYSIS
AND
INTERPRETATION
INTRODUCTION
This chapter includes the analysis and interpretation of the data on “THE PSYCHO – SOCIAL
PROBLEMS FACED BY TRANSGENDERS WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO
NEDUMPURAM REGION”.
Data analysis and interpretation are crucial aspects of this research. The process included, collection
of data which was entered into SPSS (statistical package for social science), coding and analysing
mainly in the terms of percentage, statistical tool was used in the analysis of the data and were
represented using bar diagram, pie chart and table.
The data, which is analysed, is the primary source of the data that is collected from 60 respondent
from the Transgender community of Nedumpuram region.
TABLE NO. 1
AGE OF THE RESPONDENTS
Sl. No Age group Frequency Percentage
1 Less than 15 2 3.3
2 15 – 25 11 18.3
3 25 – 35 31 51.7
4 Above 35 16 26.7
Total 60 100.0
FIGURE NO. 1
TABLE NO. 2
SEX OF THE RESPONDENTS
FIGURE NO. 2
TABLE NO. 3
RELIGION OF THE RESPONDENTS
FIGURE NO. 3
FIGURE NO. 4
TABLE NO. 5
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
ANNUAL INCOME OF THE RESPONDENTS
Sl. No Income Frequency Percentage
1 Below 100,000 49 81.7
2 100,000-200,000 9 15
3 200,000-250,000 1 1.7
4 More than 250,000 1 1.7
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows that 81.7 percent of the respondents’ income is below 100.000.
15 percent if the respondents earn 100,000-200,000. Categories with 200,000-250,000 and more than
250,000 both have 1.7 percent of responses.
FIGURE NO. 5
TABLE NO. 6
2 APL 45 75.0
Total 60 100.0
FIGURE NO. 6
TABLE NO. 7
OCCUPATION OF THE RESPONDENTS
FIGURE NO. 7
TABLE NO. 8
NEGLECT IN THE FIELD OF EDUCATION
This tables shows whether transgenders have faced neglect in the field of education.
76.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they have faced neglect in the field of education; 23.3
percent have answered that they haven’t felt any neglect.
The following graph shows whether transgenders have been neglected in the field of education.
FIGURE NO. 8
TABLE NO. 9
PROBLEMS EXPERIENCED BY THE HOUSEHOLD AFTER THEY CAME TO
KNOW ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE IN GENDER IDENTITY
Problems experienced
Sl. No Frequency Percent
by the household
1 Yes 45 75.0
2 No 15 25.0
Total 60 100.0
This table shows whether transgenders have faced any problems by the household after they came about the
difference in gender identity.
The following graph shows whether the respondents have experienced problems by the household after they
came to know about the difference in gender identity.
FIGURE NO. 9
TABLE NO. 10
OBJECTIONS FROM RELIGIOUS BELIEFS
Objections from
Sl. No Frequency Percent
religious beliefs
1 Yes 31 51.7
2 No 29 48.3
Total 60 100.0
The above tables whether transgenders have faced any objections from religious beliefs.
51.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they have faced objections from religious beliefs while
48.3 percent of the people have answered that they haven’t faced any objections.
FIGURE NO. 10
TABLE NO. 11
SUFFERED MENTALLY BECAUSE YOU ARE A TRANSGENDER
Ever suffered
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
mentally
1 Yes 48 80.0
2 No 12 20.0
Total 60 100.0
The above tables shows whether the respondents have suffered mentally being a transgender
80 percent of the respondents have answered that they have suffered mentally for being a transgender, while
20 percent have answered that they haven’t suffered.
The following tables shows whether the respondents have suffered mentally being a transgender.
FIGURE NO. 11
TABLE NO. 12
OPPOSITION FROM GENERAL PUBLIC
Opposition from
Sl. No
general public Frequency Percent
1 Yes 33 55.0
2 No 27 45.0
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents have faced any opposition from the general public.
55.0 percent of the respondents have answered that they have faced opposition from the general public,
while 45.0 percent have answered that they haven’t faced any opposition.
TABLE NO. 13
OPPORTUNITIES DENIED BECAUSE YOU ARE A TRANSGENDER
Sl. No Opportunities denied Frequency Percentage
1 Yes 49 81.7
2 No 11 18.3
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether any opportunities were denied being a transgender.
81.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they have been denied opportunities being a transgender,
while 18.3 percent have answered that they haven’t been denied any opportunities.
The following table shows whether any opportunities were denied being a transgender.
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
FIGURE NO. 13
TABLE NO. 14
SATISFIED WITH YOUR OWN GENDER IDENTITY
Satisfied with
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
own gender
1 Yes 46 76.7
2 No 14 23.3
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents are satisfied with their own gender.
76.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they are satisfied with their gender identity, while 23.3
percent have answered that they aren’t satisfied with their gender identity.
The following graph shows whether the respondents are satisfied with their own gender.
TABLE NO. 15
FAMILY OF OWN
Want family of
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
own
1 Yes 31 51.7
2 No 29 48.3
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents want to have a family of their own.
51.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they want to have a family of their own while 48.3
percent have answered that they do not want to have a family of their own.
The following graph shows whether the respondents want a family of their own.
FIGURE NO. 15
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
TABLE NO. 16
OTHER TRANSGENDER PEOPLE IN FAMILY
Transgender in
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
family
1 Yes 6 10.0
2 No 54 90.0
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether there are any other transgenders in the family of the respondents.
90.0 percent of the respondents have answered that there isn’t any other transgender in their family while
10.0 percent of the respondents have answered that there are other transgenders in their family.
The following graph shows whether there are any other transgenders in the family of the respondents.
FIGURE NO. 16
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
TABLE NO. 17
TOILET FACILITIES AVAILABLE
The following graph shows the toilet facility available to the respondents.
FIGURE NO. 17
TABLE NO. 18
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
SOCIETY CHANGED COMPARED TO PAST
Ever felt society has
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
changed
1 Yes 35 58.3
2 No 25 41.7
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents ever felt that the ways society looks today has changed
compared to the past.
58.3 percent of the respondents have answered that the society has changed compared to the past while 41.7
percent answered that the society hasn’t changed compared to the past.
The following graph shows whether the respondents ever felt that the ways society looks today has changed
compared to the past.
FIGURE NO. 18
TABLE NO. 19
CONSIDERATION GIVEN IS INADEQUATE
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
Inadequate
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
consideration
1 Yes 54 90.0
2 No 6 10.0
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents have ever felt that the consideration given to you as a
transgender is inadequate.
90.0 percent of the respondents have answered that the consideration given to them as a transgender is
inadequate while 10.0 percent has answered that they haven’t felt any inadequacy in consideration.
The following graph shows whether the respondents have ever felt that the consideration given to you as a
transgender is inadequate.
FIGURE NO. 19
TABLE NO. 20
DIFFICULT FOR OTHERS TO INERACT WITH YOU
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
The following graph shows whether the respondents ever felt that others find it difficult to interact with you.
FIGURE NO. 20
The following graph shows whether the respondents know about the gender reassignment surgery.
FIGURE NO. 21
Want to be treated
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
as equals
1 Yes 56 93.3
2 No 4 6.7
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the
respondents want to be treated equally as others in the society.
93.3 percent of the respondents have answered that they want to be treated as equals in the society while 6.7
percent has answered that they do not want to be treated as equals.
The following graph shows whether the respondents want to treated equally as others in the society.
FIGURE NO. 22
More likely to be
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
sexually abused
1 Yes 25 41.7
2 No 35 58.3
Total 60 100.0
The above tables shows whether
transgender people are more likely to be sexually abused in the society.
41.7 percent of the respondents have answered that transgender people are more likely to be sexually abused
while 58.3 percent have answered do not think that transgender people are more likely to be abused.
The following graph shows whether transgender people are more likely to be sexually abused in the society.
FIGURE NO. 23
The following graph shows whether the respondents ever felt suicidal because of the psychosocial issues
faced due to gender identity.
FIGURE NO. 24
The following graph shows whether the respondents think that the public is preparing to hear and understand
their problems openly.
FIGURE NO. 25
The following graph table shows whether the respondents think that a friend from the transgender
community are more helpful in cases of stress than general public.
FIGURE NO. 26
The following graph shows whether the respondents have ever felt stigmatized when neglected by the
society.
FIGURE NO. 27
The following graph shows whether the respondents have ever faced any medical problem being a
transgender.
FIGURE NO. 28
The following graph shows whether the respondents have ever faced any mental pressure being a
transgender.
FIGURE NO. 29
The following graph shows whether the respondents have ever felt afraid or ashamed being a transgender.
FIGURE NO. 30
The above table shows whether the respondents are satisfied with their personal life.
80.0 percent of the respondents have answered that they are satisfied with their personal life while 20.0
percent has answered that they aren’t satisfied.
The following graph shows whether the respondents are satisfied with their personal life.
FIGURE NO. 31
The following graph shows whether the respondents are satisfied with their social life.
FIGURE NO. 32
The following graph shows whether the respondents are satisfied with their vocational life.
FIGURE NO. 33
The above table shows whether the respondents have ever sought the help of a counsellor to overcome their
problems.
33.3 percent of the respondents have answered that they have sought help from counsellors while 66.7
percent has answered that they haven’t sought any help.
The following graph shows whether the respondents have ever sought the help of a counsellor to overcome
their problems.
FIGURE NO. 34
The following graph shows the ways the respondents have taken to overcome their mental difficulties.
FIGURE NO. 35
The following graph shows whether the respondents have felt the need for rehabilitation centres.
FIGURE NO. 36
TABLE NO. 37
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
REDUCTION OF STRESS THROUGH JOB OPPORTUNITIES
Can stress be reduced
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
through job
1 Yes 53 88.3
2 No 7 11.7
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents can reduce their stress through job opportunities.
88.3 percent of the respondents have answered that they can reduce their stress through job opportunities
while 11.7 percent has answered that they can’t reduce their stress through job opportunities.
The following graph shows whether the respondents can reduce their stress through job opportunities.
FIGURE NO. 37
TABLE 38
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
SHARE MENTAL PROBLEMS
Sl. No Want to share mental problems Frequency Percentage
1 Yes 25 41.7
2 No 35 58.3
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents want to share their mental problems with others.
41.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they want to share their mental problems with others
while 58.3 percent has answered that they do not want to share their mental problems.
The following graph shows whether the respondents want to share their mental problems with others.
FIGURE NO. 38
TABLE NO. 39
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
FRIENDSHIP HELPS GET RID OF MENTAL CONFLICTS
The above table shows whether the respondents think that friendship helps get rid of mental conflicts.
85.0 percent of the respondents have answered that friendship helps to get rid of mental conflicts while 15.0
percent has answered that friendship doesn’t help get rid of mental conflicts.
The following graph shows whether the respondents think that friendship helps get rid of mental conflicts.
FIGURE NO. 39
TABLE NO. 40
INSPIRED BY SOMEONE FROM THE TRANSGENDER SOCIETY
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
Ever inspired by someone from the
Sl. No Frequency Percentage
transgender society
1 Yes 43 71.7
2 No 17 28.3
Total 60 100.0
The above table shows whether the respondents have you ever been inspired by someone from the
transgender society.
71.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they have been inspired been someone from the
transgender society while 28.3 percent has answered that haven’t been inspired by someone from the
transgender society.
The following graph shows whether the respondents have you ever been inspired by someone from the
transgender society.
FIGURE NO. 40
CHAPTER 5:
FINDINGS, SUGGESTIONS AND
CONCLUSION
FINDINGS
51.7 percent of the respondents belong to the age category of 25-35.
55.0 percent of the respondents are male.
33.3 percent of the respondents belong to the Hindu group.
41.7 percent of the respondents have completed their 12th grade.
81.7 percent of the respondents have an annual income below 100,000.
75.0 percent of the respondents belong to the APL group.
23.3 percent of the respondents work in the private service.
76.7 percent of the respondents have answered that they have faced neglect in the field of
education.
75.0 percent of the respondents have faced problems by the household after they came to
know about the difference in gender identity.
51.7 percent of the respondents have faced objections from religious beliefs.
80.0 percent of the respondents have suffered mentally being a transgender.
55.0 percent of the respondents have faced opposition from the general public.
81.7 percent of the respondents have been denied opportunities being a transgender.
76.7 percent of the respondents are satisfied with their gender identity.
51.7 percent of the respondents want a family of their own.
90.0 percent of the respondents do not have any other transgenders in their family.
56.7 percent of the respondents have answered that toilet facilities are available to them.
58.3 percent of the respondents have felt that the society has changed compared to the past.
90.0 percent of the respondents have felt that the consideration given to them as transgender is
inadequate.
81.7 percent of the respondents have felt that others find it difficult to interact with them.
61.7 percent of the respondents do not know about gender reassignment surgery.
Majority of the respondents wants to be treated as equals in the society.
58.3 percent of the respondents do not think that transgender people are more likely to be
abused in the society.
53.3 percent of the respondents have felt suicidal because of the psychological problem faced
by them.
55.0 percent of the respondents think that the public isn’t prepared to hear and understand
their problems openly.
Sahyajyothi Arts & College
Bachelor of Social Work
81.7 percent of the respondents think that a friend from the transgender community is more
helpful in cases of stress than general public.
80.0 percent of the respondents have felt stigmatised when they are neglected by the society.
68.3 percent of the respondents have faced medical problems being a transgender.
78.3 percent of the respondents have faced mental pressure being a transgender.
65.0 percent of the respondents haven’t ever felt afraid or shamed of being a transgender.
80.0 percent of the respondents are satisfied with their personal life.
68.3 percent of the respondents aren’t satisfied with their social life.
50.0 percent of the respondents are satisfied with their vocational life.
66.7 percent of the respondents haven’t ever sought any help of a counsellor to overcome their
problems.
38.4 percent of the respondents have taken spiritual means to overcome their mental
difficulties.
83.3 percent of the respondents have felt the need for rehabilitation centres.
88.3 percent of the respondents can reduce their stress through job opportunities.
58.3 percent of the respondents do not want to share their mental problems with other.
85.0 percent of the respondents thinks that friendship helps get rid of mental conflicts.
71.7 percent of the respondents have been inspired by someone from the transgender
community.
SUGGESTIONS
You don’t have to understand someone’s identity to respect it. Some people haven’t heard a
lot about transgender identity, or have trouble understanding what it means to be trans, and that’s
okay. But all people, even those whose identities you don’t fully understand, deserve respect.
Rethink gender on forms and documents. When creating forms and documents, consider
whether you need to include gender at all. Many times, we default to asking for gender without
considering why or how that information will be used.
Ensure everyone has access to bathrooms and other facilities. Everyone should be able to
safely and comfortably use bathrooms and other gendered facilities. In addition, providing
gender-neutral or private bathrooms is a great way to provide safe and comfortable space for
everyone
Call your elected officials. Call your elected local, state, and federal officials to thank them
when they do support transgender rights and to provide important criticism when they don’t.
Work to pass laws in your city or state, and on the federal level, that outlaw discrimination in
employment, housing, public accommodations, and education based on gender
identity/expression.
Change the curriculum of medical, health, crisis response and social work programs, or bring in
trainers, to teach these providers about transgender people and how to treat transgender people
with respect and professionalism. Include information about the rejection, discrimination and
violence that transgender people face and how to provide services and support to transgender
clients.
Work with suicide prevention, HIV prevention and treatment, alcohol and drug abuse
treatment, and anti-smoking programs to ensure that their work is trans-inclusive and their
staff is knowledgeable about transgender issues. Find trainers and teach them how to deal
sensitively with trans people seeking assistance.
Work with police departments to have fair written policies with regard to interacting with
transgender members of the public, regardless if they are seeking assistance or being arrested,
and make sure all police officers are trained on following the policy and treating transgender
people with respect.
Listen to transgender people. The best way to be an ally is to listen with an open mind to
transgender people speaking for themselves.
Take a step back. Transgender people come from every population, and are of all races,
religions, ages, and more. There are transgender immigrants, employees, prisoners, sex workers,
and every other category imaginable. Make an effort to be as inclusive as possible of all kinds of
transgender people when working to support transgender communities.
Start an online community or a blog that deals with an issue that is important to you. The
internet has created so many new ways for people, including transgender people, to connect. The
world of blogs provides an avenue for new voices to be heard and opinions to be shared with
others.
Educate a local homeless shelter about how to be trans inclusive. Homeless shelters can be
very challenging places for those who need them; this is especially true for transgender people.
Most shelters are gender segregated and many do not have policies that deal with issues of
gender identity and expression.
CONCLUSION
It is suggested that still we need to address their problems on a large scale. Although, government
and law have made some provisions on paper, but still it need to be implemented on ground level.
People need to understand that they are the part of our society not a person to be hate, discriminate,
harass and treat them in a different way. They can contribute our society or even our nation like us.
The study indicates a lower level of resilience among transgender persons which further reflects poor
mental health status of the community. There is huge scope for research in exploring and
understanding the unique mental health and psychological aspects of the transgender community in
the Indian context.
In spite of various hardships in day-to-day life, the transgender community has a tremendous amount
of resilience which needs to be explored further and strengthened. Moreover, the factors (protective
factors such as acceptance, social support, education, employment, health-care services, and social
inclusion) which facilitate them to develop resilience toward life have to be identified and enhanced
further. In this regard, the mental health professionals, social workers, and the society as a whole
have a great responsibility to respond to this and initiate appropriate interventions.
Thoughtful scientific research and careful, circumspect interpretation of its results can advance our
understanding of sexual orientation and gender identity. There is still much work to be done and
many unanswered questions. We have attempted to synthesize and describe a complex body of
scientific research related to some of these themes. We hope that this report contributes to the
ongoing public conversation regarding human sexuality and identity. We anticipate that this report
may elicit spirited responses, and we welcome them.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
1. Lee H, Turney K. Investigating the relationship between perceived discrimination, social
status, and mental health.
2. Paradies Y. A systematic review of empirical research on self-reported racism and health.
3. Williams DR, Mohammed SA. Discrimination and racial disparities in health: evidence and
needed research.
4. Williams DR, Neighbours HW, Jackson JS. Racial/ethnic discrimination and health: findings
from community studies. Am J Pub Health 2003;93(2):200-8.
5. Grant JM, Mottet L, Tanis JE, Harrison J, Herman J, Keisling M. Injustice at every turn: A
report of the national transgender discrimination survey. National Centre for Transgender
Equality; 2011.
6. GLAAD Media Reference Guide. Transgender Issues, GLAAD. 2011.
7. Kalra G. Hijras: the unique transgender culture of India.
8. Nanda S. The Hijras of India: J Homosexuality.
9. Bradford J, Reisner SL, Honnold JA, Xavier J. Experiences of transgender-related
discrimination and implications for health: results from the Virginia Transgender Health
Initiative Study.
10. Kosenko K, Rintamaki L, Raney S, Maness K. Transgender patient perceptions of stigma in
health care contexts.
11. Abdullah MA, Basharat Z, Kamal B, Sattar NY, Hassan ZF, Jan AD, Shafqat A. Is social
exclusion pushing the Pakistani Hijras (Transgenders) towards commercial sex work? A
qualitative study.
12. Moran LJ, Sharpe AN. Violence, identity and policing: The case of violence against
transgender people.
13. Witten TM, Eyler AE. Hate crimes and violence against the transgendered.
14. Friedman MS, Marshal MP, Guadamuz TE, Wei C, Wong CF, Saewyc EM, Stall R. A meta-
analysis of disparities in childhood sexual abuse, parental.
15. Sen Gupta A. & Singh AK. Mental Health Battery (MHB), Lucknow: Ankur Psychological
Agency. 1983.
16. Allport G. The Nature of Prejudice. Basic Books, New York.1979.
17. Koken JA, Bimbi DS, Parsons JT. Experiences of familial acceptance–rejection among
transwomen of colour.
18. Chakrapani V, Babu P, Ebenezer T. Hijras in sex work face discrimination in the Indian
health-care system.
APPENDIX
APPENDIX
2. SEX
A. MALE
B. FEMALE
C. OTHER
3.RELIGION
A. HINDU
B. CHRISTIAN
C. MUSLIM
5. QUALIFICATION
A. SSLC
B. PLUS TWO
C. DEGREE
D. PG
6. ANNUAL INCOME
A. ABOVE 10000
B. 15000-25000
C. MORE THAN 25000
7. ECONOMIC STATUS
A. APL
B. BPL
8. OCCUPATION
10. HAVE ANY PROBLEMS BEEN EXPERIENCED BY THE HOUSEHOLDERS AFTER THEY CAME TO
KNOW ABOUT THE DIFFERENCE IN GENDER IDENTITY?
A. YES
B. NO.
12. HAVE YOU EVER SUFFERED MENTALLY BECAUSE YOU ARE TRANSGENDER?
A. YES
B. N O
13. HAS THERE BEEN ANY OPPOSITION FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC?
A. YES
B. NO.
14. HAVE YOU BEEN DENIED ANY OPPORTUNITIES BECAUSE YOU ARE TRANSGENDER?
A. YES
B. NO.
18. HAVE YOU EVER FELT THAT THE WAY SOCIETY LOOKS AT YOU TODAY HAS CHANGED
COMPARED TO THE PAST?
A. YES
B. N O
20. DO YOU FEEL THAT THE CONSIDERATION GIVEN TO YOU AS A TRANSGENDER PERSON IS
INADEQUATE?
A. YES
B. N O
21. HAVE YOU EVER FOUND IT DIFFICULT FOR OTHERS TO INTERACT WITH YOU BECAUSE YOU
ARE TRANSGENDER?
A. YES
B. N O
24. DO YOU THINK TRANSGENDER PEOPLE ARE MORE LIKELY TO BE SEXUALLY ABUSED IN
SOCIETY?
A. YES
B. N O
26. HAVE YOU EVER FELT THAT THE PUBLIC IS PREPARING TO HEAR AND UNDERSTAND YOUR
PROBLEMS OPENLY?
A. YES
B. NO.
27. DO YOU THINK FRIENDS FROM THE TRANSGENDER COMMUNITY ARE MORE HELPFUL AND
HELPFUL THAN THOSE FROM THE GENERAL PUBLIC IN SITUATIONS OF STRESS?
A. YES
B. NO.
28. HAVE YOU EVER FELT STIGMATIZED WHEN YOU ARE NEGLECTED BY SOCIETY BECAUSE
YOU ARE TRANSGENDER?
A. YES
B. NO.
36. WHAT ARE THE WAYS YOU HAVE TAKEN TO OVERCOME MENTAL DIFFICULTIES?
ENTERTAINMENT (MUSIC / READING)
A. SPIRITUAL MEANS
B. ALCOHOL AND DRUGS
C. OTHERS
D. WHAT ABOUT OTHERS?
37. DO TRANSGENDER PEOPLE FEEL THE NEED FOR REHABILITATION CENTRES IN TODAY'S
SOCIETY?
A. YES
B. NO.