EXISTING & PROPOSED DG SET COMPARISION SHEET

S.NO. PARTICULARS EXISTING DG SETS PROPOSED DG SET REMARKS

1 DETAILS
225 KVA (02 NOS.) 320 KVA 320 KVA +500 KVA

1.01 DIESEL CONSUMPTION PER HOUR (LTR) 30 44 35 +50 LTR 34 LTR/HOUR LESS DIESEL CONSUMPTION

1.02 AVERAGE EFFICIENCY (%) 60% 60% 90% EFFICIENCY INCREASE BY 30 %

135 PER D.G. SET

EFFECTIVE KVA 192 738 TOTAL OUTOUT IS HIGH
1.03 FOR TWO D.G. SETS:
135 X 2 = 270 kva
TOTAL EFFECTIVE KVA OF D.G. SETS 462 1476 Additional 1014 kva available

60 44
1.04 DIESAL CONSUMPTION PER HOUR LITER 70 We use only half the capacity i.e. for 738 KVA
104

1.05 Diesal Consumption per KVA per hour 0.23 0.05 Benefit of 0.18. ltr diesal per kva per hour

2. Annual Performance
2.1 LIFE SPAN ELAPSED 20 YEARS -

2.2 LIFE SPAN EXPECTED NO GURANTEE MINIMUM 10 YEARS

2.3 AVERAGE PER DAY OPERATION 4 HOURS 4 HOURS

2.4 ANNUAL OPERATION 4 X 30 X 12 = 1440 HOURS 4 X 30 X 12 = 1440 HOURS

2.5 ANNUAL DIESEL CONSUMPTION 149760 100800

3 EXPENSES CALCULATION

3.1 COST OF DIESEL @ 35.5/LTR. (INR) 5316480 3578400 Diesel cost decreaseds with increase in KVA
AVERAGE MAINTENANCE COST ANNUAL
3.2 100000 30000 MAINTENANCE COST DECRESES
(INR)
TOTAL OPERATION COST FOR D.G. SETS
3.3 5416480 3608400 Total cost reduction
(INR)
4 SAVINGS CALCULATION

4.1 NET SAVINGS ANNUALLY (INR) 1808080

4.2 SAVINGS PER MONTH (INR) 150673.333333333

4.3 COST OF NEW D.G. SET (INR) 320 |KVA 1600000

4.4 COST OF NEW DG SETS (INR) 500 KVA 2500000

4.5 Net Cost (INR) 4100000

4.6 SALE PRICE OF OLD DG SETS 2.5 LACKS X 3 = 7.5 LACKS

4.7 EFFECTIVE COST OF NEW DG SETS 3350000

5 EXPECTED PAY BACK PERIOD Month 22 COST REIMBURSEMENT IN APPROX 22 MONTHS

Prepared By:- Checked By :- Approved By :-

HOME
Rev Date:
29/11/10 TECHNO COMMERCIAL COMPARISION SHEET FOR D.G. SET
M/s Grand Marshall M/s Sudhir Gensets M/s Bhaskar Power M/s Greaves Cotton
Details
Engineers P. Ltd Limited Projects Pvt. Ltd. Limited
GMEPL/JIPR/0910/105, SGL/OFFER/J/ALIL/NJ/ BPPPL/JPR/10-11/HG,
Sr. No Offer No. & Date URS AS/BG-1/10-11/01, 16/10/10
20/10/10 0479A, 07/05/10 07/05/10
Mr. Padmendra Shekhawat, Mr. Neeraj Jain, Mr. Hemant Gupta, Mr. Abhinav Sharma,
Contact Person
09352000036, 09529561533 09001098967 09829969694 09717741458
1.00 DETAILS
1.01 DESCRIPTION 500 KVA Silent DG Set 500 KVA Silent DG Set 500 KVA Silent DG Set 500 KVA Silent DG Set
1.02 MAKE Supernova Sudhir Bhaskar Greaves Cotton
FUEL TANK MINIMUM 500
1.03 830 Liters 700 LITRES 900 LITERS
CAPACITY LITERS
VENDOR TO 6500(L) x 2000(W) x 5600(L) X 200(W) X 2200(H)
1.04 CANOPY SIZE 6240 X 2000 X 2570 mm
SPECIFY 2300(H) mm mm
VENDOR TO
1.05 NOISE LEVEL 75 db 75 db 75 db 75 db
SPECIFY
2.00 ENGINE DETAILS
VOLVO PENTA/ VOLVO PENTA DIESEL
2.01 ENGINE CUMMINS KOEL GREAVES
CUMMINS ENGINE
VERTICAL
2.02 TYPE VERTICAL INLINE VERTICAL VERTICAL VERTICAL
INLINE
2.03 BHP 600 600 600 608 604
2.04 NO. OF CYLINDERS 6 6 6 10
2.05 STROKE 4 4 4 4 4
2.06 RPM 1500 1500 1500 1500 1500
WATER/ OIL
2.07 COOLING WATER COOLED WATER COOLED WATER COOLED WATER COOLED
COOLED
VENDOR TO
2.08 RATING STANDARD ISO-3046, BS-5514 BS:5514 ISO 3046/ BS 5514 ISO 3046/ BS 5514
SPECIFY
Fuel Consumption @
2.09 Ltr./Hr. 72 Ltr/Hr. 77.4 Ltr/Hr. 75 Lt./Hr 72 Ltr/Hr.
75% Load
2.10 OVERLOAD UPTO 10 % 10% 10% 10% 10%
2.11 Alternator Make Stamford KIRLOSKAR GREEN
3.00 ELECTRICAL SYSTEM DETAILS
3.01 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE
Rev Date:
29/11/10 TECHNO COMMERCIAL COMPARISION SHEET FOR D.G. SET
M/s Grand Marshall M/s Sudhir Gensets M/s Bhaskar Power M/s Greaves Cotton
Details
Engineers P. Ltd Limited Projects Pvt. Ltd. Limited
GMEPL/JIPR/0910/105, SGL/OFFER/J/ALIL/NJ/ BPPPL/JPR/10-11/HG,
Sr. No Offer No. & Date URS AS/BG-1/10-11/01, 16/10/10
20/10/10 0479A, 07/05/10 07/05/10
Mr. Padmendra Shekhawat, Mr. Neeraj Jain, Mr. Hemant Gupta, Mr. Abhinav Sharma,
Contact Person
09352000036, 09529561533 09001098967 09829969694 09717741458
3.02 POWER FACTOR 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
3.03 FREQUENCY 50 HZ 50 HZ 50 HZ 50 HZ 50 HZ
3.04 SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM
VENDOR TO
3.05 BATTERIES 02 NOS, 180AH/ 12 V 02 NOS, 12 V, 100 AH 180 AH/ 12 V 180 AH/ 12 V
SPECIFY
4.00 COMMERICAL
4.01 UNIT RATE INR 2280000 242100 2480000 2266049
INCLUSIVE IN
4.02 EXISE DUTY @10.3 % 234840 24936.3
ABOVE PRICE 233403.047
4.03 TOTAL INR 2514840 267036.3 2480000 2499452.047
@2 % AGAINST NIL AGAINT 'C'
4.04 CST NIL AGAINT 'C' FORM 49600
'C' FORM FORM 49989.04094
FREIGHT &
4.05 INR NOT INCLUDED NOT INCLUDED NOT INCLUDED
INSURANCE NOT INCLUDED
4.06 GRAND TOTAL INR 2514840 267036.3 2529600 2549441.08794
5.00 PAYMENT TERMS, WARRENTY & DELIVERY SCHEDULE
VENDOR TO
5.01 ADVANCE 30% OF BASIC PRICE 30% OF BASIC PRICE 30% OF BASIC PRICE 30% OF BASIC PRICE
SPECIFY

BALANCE DD
BALANCE DD AGAINST BALANCE 70% TO BE BALANCE 70% TO BE
VENDOR TO AGAINST
5.02 BALANCE PERFORMA INVOICE PAID BEFORE PAID BEFORE
SPECIFY PERFORMA INVOICE
PRIOR TO DELIVERY DESPATCH DESPATCH
PRIOR TO DELIVERY
 Rev Date:
29/11/10 TECHNO COMMERCIAL COMPARISION SHEET FOR D.G. SET
M/s Grand Marshall M/s Sudhir Gensets M/s Bhaskar Power M/s Greaves Cotton
Details
Engineers P. Ltd Limited Projects Pvt. Ltd. Limited
GMEPL/JIPR/0910/105, SGL/OFFER/J/ALIL/NJ/ BPPPL/JPR/10-11/HG,
Sr. No Offer No. & Date URS AS/BG-1/10-11/01, 16/10/10
20/10/10 0479A, 07/05/10 07/05/10
Mr. Padmendra Shekhawat, Mr. Neeraj Jain, Mr. Hemant Gupta, Mr. Abhinav Sharma,
Contact Person
09352000036, 09529561533 09001098967 09829969694 09717741458

24 MONTHS FROM DATE

24 MONTHS FROM 24 MONTHS FROM
OF DESPATCH OR 5000
12 MONTHS OR 3600 DATE OF DESPATCH DATE OF DESPATCH
VENDOR TO RUNNING HOURS OR 18
5.03 WARRENTY RUNNING HOURS OR 5000 RUNNING OR 5000 RUNNING
SPECIFY MONTHS FROM DATE
WHICHEVER IS EARLIER HOURS WHICHEVER HOURS WHICHEVER
OF COMISSIONING
IS EARLIER IS EARLIER
WHICHEVER IS EARLIER

5.04 DELIVERY 5 WEEKS MAX 4-6 WEEKS 4-6 WEEKS 6-8 WEEKS 3-4 WEEKS
Techno Commercial Comparative Akash Kanwatia MKP CFT
REV DESCRIPTION DATE PREPARED CHECKED APPROVED
Rev Date:
29/11/10 TECHNO COMMERCIAL COMPARISION SHEET FOR D.G. SET
M/s Grand Marshall M/s Sudhir Gensets M/s Bhaskar Power M/s Greaves Cotton
Details
Engineers P. Ltd Limited Projects Pvt. Ltd. Limited
GMEPL/JIPR/0910/105, SGL/OFFER/J/ALIL/NJ/ BPPPL/JPR/10-11/HG, AS/BG-1/10-11/01,
Sr. No Offer No. & Date URS
20/10/10 0479A, 07/05/10 07/05/10 16/10/10
Mr. Padmendra Shekhawat, Mr. Neeraj Jain, Mr. Hemant Gupta, Mr. Abhinav Sharma,
Contact Person
09352000036, 09529561533 09001098967 09829969694 09717741458
1.00 DETAILS
1.01 DESCRIPTION 320 KVA Silent DG Set 320 KVA Silent DG Set 320 KVA Silent DG Set 320 KVA Silent DG Set
1.02 MAKE Supernova Sudhir Bhaskar Greaves Cotton
1.03 FUEL TANK CAPACITY 480 Ltr. 520 Ltr.
VENDOR TO 4900(L) x 2000(W) x 2180(H) 5300(L) x 1500(W) x 5700(L) x 2000(W) x 5950(L) x 2000(W) x
1.04 CANOPY SIZE
SPECIFY mm 2025(H) mm 2520(H) mm 2500(H) mm
VENDOR TO
1.05 NOISE LEVEL 75 db 75 db 75 db 75 db
SPECIFY
2.00 ENGINE DETAILS
VOLVO PENTA/ VOLVO PENTA DIESEL
2.01 ENGINE CUMMINS KOEL GREAVES
CUMMINS ENGINE
VERTICAL
2.02 TYPE VERTICAL INLINE VERTICAL VERTICAL VERTICAL
INLINE
2.03 BHP 377 380 386 396
2.04 NO. OF CYLINDERS 6 6 6
2.05 STROKE 4 4 4 4
2.06 RPM 1500 1500 1500 1500 1500
WATER/ OIL
2.07 COOLING WATER COOLED WATER COOLED WATER COOLED WATER COOLED
COOLED
VENDOR TO
2.08 RATING STANDARD ISO-3046, BS-5514 BS:5514 ISO 3046/ BS 5514 ISO 3046/ BS 5514
SPECIFY
Fuel Consumption @ 75%
2.09 Ltr./Hr. 50.4 Ltr/Hr. 51.1 Ltr./Hr. 51 Ltr./Hr. 50.4 Ltr. Hr.
Load
2.10 OVERLOAD UPTO 10 % 10% 10% 10% 10%
2.11 Alternator Make Stamford KIRLOSKAR GREEN
3.00 ELECTRICAL SYSTEM DETAILS
3.01 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 PHASE
3.02 POWER FACTOR 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8
3.03 FREQUENCY 50 HZ 50 HZ 50 HZ 50 HZ 50 HZ
3.04 SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM 4 WIRE SYSTEM
Rev Date:
29/11/10 TECHNO COMMERCIAL COMPARISION SHEET FOR D.G. SET
M/s Grand Marshall M/s Sudhir Gensets M/s Bhaskar Power M/s Greaves Cotton
Details
Engineers P. Ltd Limited Projects Pvt. Ltd. Limited
GMEPL/JIPR/0910/105, SGL/OFFER/J/ALIL/NJ/ BPPPL/JPR/10-11/HG, AS/BG-1/10-11/01,
Sr. No Offer No. & Date URS
20/10/10 0479A, 07/05/10 07/05/10 16/10/10
Mr. Padmendra Shekhawat, Mr. Neeraj Jain, Mr. Hemant Gupta, Mr. Abhinav Sharma,
Contact Person
09352000036, 09529561533 09001098967 09829969694 09717741458
VENDOR TO
3.05 BATTERIES 02 NOS, 135 AH/ 12 V 02 NOS, 12 V, 65 AH 200 AH/ 24 V 180 AH/ 12 V
SPECIFY
4.00 COMMERICAL
4.01 UNIT RATE INR 1457000 1528000 1325000 1349923
4.02 EXISE DUTY @10.3 % 150071 157384 136475 139042.069
4.03 TOTAL INR 1607071 1685384 1461475 1488965.069
@2 % AGAINST NIL AGAINT 'C'
4.04 CST NIL AGAINT 'C' FORM 29229.5
'C' FORM FORM 29779.30138
4.05 FREIGHT & INSURANCE INR NOT INCLUDED NOT INCLUDED NOT INCLUDED NOT INCLUDED
4.06 GRAND TOTAL INR 1607071 1685384 1490704.5 1518744.37038
5.00 PAYMENT TERMS, WARRENTY & DELIVERY SCHEDULE
VENDOR TO
5.01 ADVANCE 30% OF BASIC PRICE 30% OF BASIC PRICE 30% OF BASIC PRICE 30% OF BASIC PRICE
SPECIFY

BALANCE DD
BALANCE DD AGAINST BALANCE 70% TO BE BALANCE 70% TO BE
VENDOR TO AGAINST
5.02 BALANCE PERFORMA INVOICE PAID BEFORE PAID BEFORE
SPECIFY PERFORMA INVOICE
PRIOR TO DELIVERY DESPATCH DESPATCH
PRIOR TO DELIVERY

24 MONTHS FROM
DATE OF DESPATCH
24 MONTHS FROM 24 MONTHS FROM OR 5000 RUNNING
12 MONTHS OR 3600 DATE OF DESPATCH DATE OF DESPATCH HOURS OR 18
VENDOR TO
5.03 WARRENTY RUNNING HOURS OR 5000 RUNNING OR 5000 RUNNING MONTHS FROM
SPECIFY
WHICHEVER IS EARLIER HOURS WHICHEVER HOURS WHICHEVER DATE OF
IS EARLIER IS EARLIER COMISSIONING
WHICHEVER IS
EARLIER

5.04 DELIVERY 5 WEEKS MAX 4-6 WEEKS 4-6 WEEKS 6-8 WEEKS 3-4 WEEKS
Techno Commercial Comparative Akash Kanwatia MKP CFT
Rev Date:
29/11/10 TECHNO COMMERCIAL COMPARISION SHEET FOR D.G. SET
M/s Grand Marshall M/s Sudhir Gensets M/s Bhaskar Power M/s Greaves Cotton
Details
Engineers P. Ltd Limited Projects Pvt. Ltd. Limited
GMEPL/JIPR/0910/105, SGL/OFFER/J/ALIL/NJ/ BPPPL/JPR/10-11/HG, AS/BG-1/10-11/01,
Sr. No Offer No. & Date URS
20/10/10 0479A, 07/05/10 07/05/10 16/10/10
Mr. Padmendra Shekhawat, Mr. Neeraj Jain, Mr. Hemant Gupta, Mr. Abhinav Sharma,
Contact Person
09352000036, 09529561533 09001098967 09829969694 09717741458
REV DESCRIPTION DATE PREPARED CHECKED APPROVED
 Autolite (India) Limited
D.G. SET CAPABILITY ANALYSIS
MAJOR M/C PRESENT PROD. LOSS
PRESS SHOP
MECHANICAL ON
Presses
HYDRAULIC OFF
PROCESS SHOP
Powder Coating ON
Buffing ON
Washing ON
Phosphating ON
1 Coat
ST
ON
2 Coat
nd
OFF
Lacquer
Top Coat ON
Spray Lacquer ON
CP-1200 ON
CP-900 ON
Metallizing
CP-1200 ON
CP-600 ON
Plating ON
De-Lacquer OFF
ASSEMBLY SHOP
Line 1 ON
Line 2 ON
Line 3 ON
ASSEMBLY LINES Line 4 ON
Line 5 ON
Plastic Line ON
LED Line ON
MOULDING
SP-130 ON
SP-300 OFF
MOULDING M/C'S
SM-250 (BMC) ON
NATRAJ ON