Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diffusion and Reactions in Gold Films: John M. Poate
Diffusion and Reactions in Gold Films: John M. Poate
Diffusion and Reactions in Gold Films: John M. Poate
Gold Films
A REVIEW OF FUNDAMENTAL ASPECTS
John M. Poate
Bell Laboratories, Murray Hill, N.J., U.S.A.
Thin metal films occupy a position of crucial im- somewhat uncontrollably at metallurgically very low
portance in electronic circuitry, where they serve ex- temperatures. In Schottky barriers on silicon, gold
tensively as conducting paths and in connectors. The again finds wide application in the form of surface
prime requirement for such applications is that barrier detectors for charged particles. These devices
metallizations have an intrinsically high conductivity. have had considerable impact on nuclear spec-
Additionally they must be resistant to electromigra- troscopy and, as will be shown later, have thereby
tion and to corrosion failure. At first sight, gold contributed significantly to the study of thin film
which possesses these properties to an exceptional reactions.
degree would appear to be the ideal material, but Clearly, the key to successful application of thin
aluminium is, in fact, the most widely used metalliza- films is an understanding of the mechanisms of diffu-
tion in integrated circuits. One reason for this is clear- sion and reaction processes which occur in them. The
ly material cost. Another perhaps more important characterization of reactions between films only a few
reason is the inability of gold, as opposed to hundred nanometres in thickness calls for the analysis
aluminium, to adhere to oxidized silicon. This latter of layers 10 to 1 000 atoms in thickness located a
problem may be overcome by the introduction of in- similar distance beneath the surface. In the 1960's no
termediate 'bonding metals' such as titanium or experimental technique was available for doing this.
chromium. The resulting bi-layer structures are, It was therefore a happy circumstance that, as the
however, susceptible to corrosion, and a third 'bar- importance of thin film reactions in technological
rier' metallization of palladium or platinum has to be applications became increasingly evident in the
introduced between the gold and the adhesion layer. 1970's, such techniques became available.
It is not surprising that designers of integrated cir-
cuits, confronted with a choice between such complex Experimental Techniques
systems and metallization with a single layer of In the study of interdiffusion and compound forma-
aluminium, have opted largely for the latter. Never- tion in thin films, lateral uniformity of structure and
theless, as described by Pinnel (1) and Holloway (2) in composition is usually assumed. Such diffusion and
this journal, gold films are used extensively in cir- reaction processes therefore result in compositional
cuitry where a high degree of reliability is required changes in a direction normal to the plane of the films
and where the added complexity of fabrication is not and are particularly evident close to interfaces. The
an overriding consideration. latter can display either sharply delineated boun-
In addition to their application in conductor paths, daries, or layers of chemical compounds resulting
metal films are used in ohmic and Schottky contacts from reaction between the adjacent species, or regions
to semiconductors. Gold-based alloys are widely of interdiffusion (Figure 1). The essential determina-
employed in ohmic contacts to compound semicon- tion of composition as a function of depth is at pre-
ductors, the contact being formed by alloying the sent achieved predominantly by the two techniques
metallization directly with the underlying semicon- illustrated in Figure 2. The first (Figure 2(a)) employs
ductor. However, gold films are uncommon in ohmic beams of high energy particles, typically helium-4
contacts to silicon devices since gold and silicon react ions in the MeV range of energy, which during their
ION BEAM
300 ' _
100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10
Au
0
Al
years, using RBS or sputter-profiling, have further
clarified this situation. Before discussing these,
however, it seems useful to give an example of the ex-
GOLD, ATOMIC PER CENT
perimental methods which are associated with the
Fig. 3 Equilibrium phase diagrams for the gold backscattering technique.
silver, gold-silicon and gold-aluminium systems Figure 4 provides a schematic representation of the
RBS spectra of thin film gold-silver couples before
and silver films give separate peaks (these are shown AFTER ANNEAL
R3—
main peaks, thus revealing that interdiffusion has J
taken place. These scrambled spectra can be decon- UJ
Z
4He
voluted by computation to give the gold and silver Z
U
components shown as the overlapping flanks in Wa
Figure 4(a). The actual concentration profiles are z
then calculated from these. By reversing the order of Z
óU
the films, that is with the beam incident on the lighter
silver film (Figure 4(b)), and by the suitable choice of UJ
0.1
in diameter. Transmission electron microscopy tice diffusion takes place and the gold concentration
measurements indeed confirmed that the grains in increases very slowly. Indeed, Cahn et al. (7) have
our samples had a mean diameter of approximately recently shown that grain boundaries can migrate
this value. This experiment is an example of the need during diffusion, under a driving force supplied by
to combine measurements by several techniques in the free energy of mixing or alloying. This free
order to arrive at firm conclusions regarding the energy is generated by atoms which are deposited in
mechanism of interdiffusion. the lattice in the wake of the migrating boundary.
By summing the number of gold atoms in the flat It is important to obtain quantitative data on gram
portion of the spectra (the 'WINDOW') in Figure 6, we boundary diffusion coefficients, since the rapid in-
can obtain the rate of interdiffusion as a function of terpenetration resulting from defect-enhanced diffu-
temperature, as shown in Figure 7. The first point of sion is dominant in many surface and thin film
interest is the initial dependence of room temperature phenomena. There are, at present, two general
diffusion on the square root of time. This corresponds methods of determining such coefficients. First, is the
to the diffusion of gold along silver gram boundaries. Whipple analysis, which predicts that the concentra-
The later, lower rate corresponds to lattice diffusion. tion of the diffusing species is proportional to X615,
On heating above room temperature, however, there where X is the distance from the interface. Figure 8
is initially a very rapid rise in the concentration of shows a Whipple plot of experimental data on
gold in silver, followed by much slower interdiffu- palladium diffusion through gold films, obtained
sion. As discussed earlier, the maximum concentra- by Auger sputter profiling. Within 40 nm of the
tion of gold arising from its presence in the silver interface erfc diffusion predominates, as predicted
gram boundaries only is of the order of 1 to 2 atomic by the Whipple model. (The apparent linearity of
per cent. Moreover, lattice diffusion from the gram ln(erfc(concentration)) with X 6 ' 5 is fortuitous in this
boundaries into the interior of the grains can, at most, range of concentration.) The presence of gram boun-
account for a few atomic per cent of gold under the dary diffusion is shown by the breaks in the curves
experimental conditions discussed here. We believe and by the linear regions beyond 40 nm. It is from the
that the high concentrations of gold result from the slopes of these lines that the gram boundary diffusion
movement of gram boundaries during annealing and coefficients are calculated. The most accurate values
the consequent introduction of gold throughout the for these coefficients are obtained when the gram
volume of the silver film. Once the network of gram boundaries are well separated, and this unfortunately
boundaries has reached equilibrium, only normal lat- occurs mainly in thick films rather than in the thin
Z 11t • • 1^
BACKGROUND • •
w
o 0.1 ♦ N, I `
Z ♦♦ • A
OER
• INTERFACE
t •^
0 `^` ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ - I `°°
• ❑ 78 DAYS _ ♦ `^ I 4
o 8.7 DAYS
WINDOW
°16h
•
•5h I ♦
♦ 17 min (rSILVER SURFACE
0.010 50 100
SII'VER THICKNESS, nm
films which are of primary practical interest. A Oxidation, Chemical and Barrier Effects
second, indirect method of determining grain boun- The experiments described in the previous section
dary diffusion coefficients consists of measurements were carried out under clean, vacuum conditions.
of the time dependence of the build-up of substrate The device engineer is concerned with the behaviour
material at the surface of the deposited films (9). of thin films in more hostile environments, where the
We are now in the position to estimate the rate of influence of oxidizing or corrosive contaminants can
grain boundary diffusion in gold films with some con- be quite complex. We will illustrate some of these
fidence (10). However, because of the complexities in- effects by reference to the gold/palladium/titanium
troduced by the motion of grain boundaries in solid system (11). Figures 9 and 10 show the effects of
solution systems, it is still quite difficult to arrive at annealing gold/titanium and palladium/titanium
accurate predictions of the quantities of interdiffused couples in air and in vacuum. Although the interdif-
materials. fusion of titanium and gold is faster than that of
TIME, (min) /2
0 10 20 30 40 Fig. 7 Mean concentration against time
0.5 50 r LEVEL OF of gold diffusing into a polycrystalline
z HOMOGENEOUS SAMPLES
Lv silver film at various temperatures. At
U room temperature (left), the initial pro-
w 0.4 40
portionality of concentration to the
0 ROOM 500°C 400'C
TEMPERATURE square root of time indicates grain
houndary diffusion; the later, slower
0.3 30
rise in gold concentration corresponds
0 to lattice diffusion. At elevated
1- temperatures (right), the initial very
X 0.2 20
z
rapid rise of gold concentration might
UZ well be caused by the displacement of
0.1
gold-containing silver grain boun-
150C daries; the subsequent, slower diffu-
0
°
c7
100°C sion rate again corresponds to lattice
diffusion once the network of gold-
100 200 0 0 5 10 15 saturated silver grain boundaries has
TIME, (min) /z stabilized
40
titanium and palladium, the general effects of vacuum
annealing are similar in both systems. When the
couples are annealed in air, however, their behaviour
1-
z is markedly different. In the case of the gold/titanium
20
w system, titanium diffuses along the grain boundaries
a
to the free surface of the gold where it is oxidized.
0 The surface oxidation of the titanium, by creating
z a chemical potential sink, continually enhances
o 10
the interdiffusion. In the case of air-annealed
Zw palladium/titanium couples, however, very little in-
U terdiffusion is observed. The following competing
0€
U processes occur simultaneously during annealing
ó
under oxidizing conditions: (1) interdiffusion of the
J 4
J
titanium and palladium, (2) diffusion of oxygen
á through the palladium, and (3) oxidation of titanium
near the palladium-titanium interface. As soon as the
latter process reaches a critical stage, most likely
when a continuous titanium oxide layer is formed
along the palladium grain boundaries in the vicinity
of the interface, further diffusion of titanium in
palladium is blocked. Therefore, oxygen enhances
diffusion in the gold-titanium system, but ultimately
X%, nm% blocks diffusion in the palladium-titanium system.
The very rapid diffusion of titanium through gold
films and the formation of titanium oxide at the free
surface explains some of the problems experienced
with gold/titanium metallizations. What is the role of
an intermediate barrier metalliza-
tion of palladium? Figure 11 shows
AS DEPOSITED
the RBS spectra of a gold/palladium/
o 389°C, 40 min, VAC. titanium metallization before and
Ti Au 4He • 389°C,40min, AIR
Zz after annealing, where the dashed
x
lines are the deconvoluted concen-
U 10 tration profiles. The same diffusion
w
patterns are observed irrespective of
z 8
0 whether annealing is carried out in
^^
:
z
0
0 1á air or in vacuum. It is remarkable
0 •o that no diffusion of titanium is evi-
d 1.0 t •o dent in this three-layer system,
w •o
• • o despite the copious diffusion
z
W observed in isolated palladium-
i
0.1
Au
Ti 75 nm I—I Fig. 9 Rutherford backscattering spec-
190nm
tra for gold/titanium thin film couples
annealed in air and in vacuum. Note
001 .
the diffusion of titanium to the surface
150 200 250 300 350 400
of the gold
ENERGY, CHANNEL NUMBER
w
temperatures as low as 200°C.
w Au
AI,Al,
Conclusions 0
0
Al
m
Au22Al
U) t Au
be required.
Fig. 13 Schematic representation of compound for-
mation in gold-aluminium thin film systems. The
References stoichiometry of the final compounds is determined
by the annealing temperature and by the propor-
1 M. R. Pinnel, Gold Bull., 1979, 12, (2) 62-71
2 P. H. Holloway, Gold Bull., 1979, 12, (3), 99-106 tions of the starting materials. After (14)
3 J. W. M. DuMond and J. P. Youtz, Phys. Rev., 1935, 48, 703
4 J. W. M. DuMond and J. P. Youtz, J. Appl. Phys., 1940, 11,
357-365
5 `Thin Films — Interdiffusion and Reactions', edited by J. M.
Poate, K. M. Tu and J. W. Mayer, John Wiley, New York, 11 J. M. Poate, P. A. Turner, W. J. DeBonte and J. Yahalom, 1.
1978 Appl. Phys., 1975, 46, 4275-4283
6 R. G. Kirsch, J. M. Poate and M. Eibschutz, Appl. Phys. Lett., 12 M. A. Nicolet, Thin Solid Films, 1978, 52, 415-443
1976, 29, 772-775 13 S. U. Campisano, G. Foti, E. Rimini, S. S. Lau and J. W.
7 J. W. Cahn, J. D. Pan and R. W. Balluffi, Scr. Metall., 1979, Mayer, Philos. Mag., 1975, 31, 903-917
13, 503-509 14 G. Majm, G. Ottaviani and E. Galli, 5'. Cryst. Growth, 1979,
8 P. M. Hall, J. M. Morabito and J. M. Poate, Thin Solid Films, 47, (4), 583-588
1976, 33, 107-134 15 R. G. Kirsch, J M. Poate and M. Eibschutz, unpublished
9 J. C. M. Hwang and R. W. Balluffi, J. Appl. Phys., 1979, 50, work
1339-1348 16 A. K. Sinha and J. M. Poate; see (5), Chapter 11
10 D. Gupta, D. R. Campbell and P. S. Ho; see (5), Chapter 7 17 K. N. Tu, Appl. Phys. Lett., ,1975, 27, 221-224