Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Engineering Geology For Society and Terr
Engineering Geology For Society and Terr
Daniele Giordan
Kurosch Thuro
Carlos Carranza-Torres
Faquan Wu
Paul Marinos
Carlos Delgado Editors
Engineering Geology
for Society and
Territory – Volume 6
Applied Geology for Major Engineering
Projects
Engineering Geology for Society
and Territory – Volume 6
Giorgio Lollino • Daniele Giordan
Kurosch Thuro • Carlos Carranza-Torres
Faquan Wu • Paul Marinos
Carlos Delgado
Editors
123
Editors
Giorgio Lollino Faquan Wu
Daniele Giordan Institute of Geology and Geophysics
Institute for Geo-Hydrological Protection Chinese Academy of Sciences
National Research Council (CNR) Beijing
Turin China
Italy
Paul Marinos
Kurosch Thuro Geotechnical Engineering Department
Department of Engineering Geology National Technical University of Athens
Technical University of Munich Athens
Munich Greece
Germany
Carlos Delgado
Carlos Carranza-Torres Escuela Universitaria de Ingeniería Técnica
Department of Civil Engineering de Obras Públicas
University of Minnesota Duluth Universidad Politécnica de Madrid
Duluth, MN Madrid
USA Spain
Cover Illustration: Pont Ventoux, Val di Susa, north western Italy. Tunnel Boring Machine(TBM) used during the
construction of the gallery used as deviation channel for a hydroelectric power plant. The TBM was used to drill a
gallery of 4.3 km long and with circular diameter of 4.05 meters. Photo: Giorgio Lollino.
It is our pleasure to present this volume as part of the book series on the Proceedings of the XII
International IAEG Congress, Torino 2014.
For the 50th anniversary, the Congress collected contributions relevant to all themes where
the IAEG members were involved, both in the research field and in professional activities.
Each volume is related to a specific topic, including:
1. Climate Change and Engineering Geology;
2. Landslide Processes;
3. River Basins, Reservoir Sedimentation and Water Resources;
4. Marine and Coastal Processes;
5. Urban Geology, Sustainable Planning and Landscape Exploitation;
6. Applied Geology for Major Engineering Projects;
7. Education, Professional Ethics and Public Recognition of Engineering Geology;
8. Preservation of Cultural Heritage.
The book series aims at constituting a milestone for our association, and a bridge for the
development and challenges of Engineering Geology towards the future.
This ambition stimulated numerous conveners, who committed themselves to collect a
large number of contributions from all parts of the world, and to select the best papers through
two review stages. To highlight the work done by the conveners, the table of contents of the
volumes maintains the structure of the sessions of the Congress.
The lectures delivered by prominent scientists, as well as the contributions of authors, have
explored several questions ranging from scientific to economic aspects, from professional
applications to ethical issues, which all have a possible impact on society and territory.
v
vi Foreword
This volume testifies the evolution of engineering geology during the last 50 years, and
summarizes the recent results. We hope that you will be able to find stimulating contributions,
which will support your research or professional activities.
Engineering geology, a relatively young field, emerged through recognition of the need for
geologic input into engineering projects. Today, this primary field has expanded as the statutes
of its learned society, the IAEG, define: “Engineering geology is the science devoted to the
investigation, study and solution of the engineering and environmental problems which may
arise as the result of the interaction between geology and the works and activities of man as
well as to the development of measures for prevention or remediation of geological hazards.”
The role of engineering geology for major engineering projects and infrastructure con-
struction is well represented in the papers included in this volume of the proceeding of the
12th IAEG congress, devoted to major engineering projects. The geologic input is not only
confined to the initial stage of such projects but the contribution of engineering geology
includes all stages for their completion, reflecting the present standing of engineering geology
in geotechnical engineering.
A retrospective review of the development of engineering geology shows that in the early
days, up to the 1950s or even the 1960s, what was understood as engineering geology was
restricted to assessments, with general and qualitative engineering descriptions. Then this is
followed by a second period of development until about the 1980s. The demands of the
development of society required more knowledge for the behaviour of the ground. Now
meaningful geological models could be provided. However, the quantitative component was
weak, and contributions to the design of structures were limited. Although improved, the
understanding of geology in the engineering milieu is not satisfactory. A third period starts
from the 1980s but mainly from the 1990s. Engineering geology, keeping the core values so
far developed, is now evolving towards geoengineering.
Indeed, today engineering geology not only offers services but is also a substantial and an
integral component of geotechnical engineering in construction. It is present in all phases of
investigation, design and construction:
1. Engineering geology defines the geological conditions, provides the geological model
(formations, tectonics and structure), and translates it into engineering terms, providing
suitable ground profiles at the appropriate scale. Its role is decisive for detecting the
presence of geological hazards, in the selection of the site or the alignment of the engi-
neering structure and for the basic principles of the construction method. It makes no sense
to proceed without a sound knowledge of the geological model. Let us be a little dogmatic
here: in the absence or misinterpretation of the geological model the construction or
operation will almost certainly be associated with problems either small or large, as
accidents, delays, cost over-runs or even failures may occur. On the contrary, if this model
is known from the very beginning of the design, half the game has already been won … if at
the very start the geological structure of the site is misinterpreted, then any subsequent …
calculation may be so much labour in vain. (Glossop 1968, 8th Rankine Lecture).
Therefore: start from the forest and then look at the trees.
vii
viii Preface
2. After having understood the behaviour of the ground, engineering geology contributes to
the definition of the properties of the geometrical, the selection of suitable design para-
metres and of the appropriate criteria. This a stage with a close synergy with engineering.
An understanding of in situ stresses and groundwater conditions complete this stage.
3. Engineering geology is and should also be present at the design phase to ensure that
calculations and simulations do not misinterpret the geological reality. John Knill in his
first Hans Cloos lecture, in 2002, expressed strong concern that the effectiveness of the
integration of engineering geology within the geotechnical engineering remains to be
improved. This integration is a field of development in today’s engineering geology, and
papers in this volume contribute towards such advance.
4. Engineering geology is involved in construction in order to validate the assumptions of the
design, to contribute in the application of measures in unforeseen or unforeseeable cir-
cumstances and to secure the implementation of the contract.
And, undoubtedly, geological and engineering judgement should never be neglected in this
whole process of creating an engineering project. Next to knowledge, experience is needed for
this judgment. Mark Twain said Good judgment comes from experience. But where does
experience come from? Experience comes from bad judgment. However, the correct appli-
cation of geological and engineering principles means that experience can also come from
good judgement.
It is very satisfactory that this volume of proceedings of the 12th congress of IAEG
embraces all the above mentioned, and a large variety of cases of engineering works is
presented. Dams and tunnels are the majority of these cases but also foundations, offshore
structures, roads, railroads, slope design, construction material, tailings, repositories are dealt
with. Papers on engineering properties and geotechnical classifications, site investigation
issues and influence of groundwater are present together with contributions on the behaviour
of soft rocks and weak rock masses. Active tectonics also attract special attention.
The volume is expected to constitute a valuable and lasting source of reference in the field
of engineering geology, in particular, and in geotechnical engineering, in general.
Contents
Part I Keynote
ix
x Contents
42 Ground Stiffness Evaluation Using the Soil Stiffness Gauge (SSG) . . . . . . 259
Mário Quinta-Ferreira
106 Chontal HPP, Geological Features on Site Location and Dam Type. . . . . 591
Cristina Accotto, Giuseppe Favata, Enrico Fornari, Nikolaos Kazilis,
Marco Rolando, and Attilio Eusebio
110 The Geological Reference Model for the Feasibility Study of the
Corredor Bioceanico Aconcagua Base Tunnel (Argentina-Chile
Trans-Andean Railway). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 623
Marini Mattia, Mancari Giuseppe, Damiano Antonio,
Alzate Marta, and Stra Michel
116 Assessment and Risk Management for Integrated Water Services . . . . . . 653
Loretta Gnavi, Glenda Taddia, and Stefano Lo Russo
133 Mining with Filling for Mitigating Overburden Failure and Water
Inrush Due to Coalmining . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 749
Wanghua Sui, Gailing Zhang, Zhaoyang Wu, and Dingyang Zhang
134 Empirical Cutting Tool Wear Prognosis for Hydroshield TBM in Soft
Ground . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 753
Florian Köppl, Kurosch Thuro, and Markus Thewes
135 Risk and Mitigation of the Large Landslide of Brindisi di Montagna . . . 757
Giuseppe Spilotro, Filomena Canora, Roberta Pellicani, and Francesco Vitelli
Contents xxi
Part XIV Properties and Behaviour of Weak and Complex Rock Masses
in Major Engineering Projects
137 Rock Mass Quality Rating (RMQR) System and Its Application to
the Estimation of Geomechanical Characteristics of Rock Masses . . . . . . 769
Ömer Aydan, Resat Ulusay, and N. Tokashiki
146 Deformation of Soil and Rock Transition Belt Caused by the Mining
Damage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 813
Qinghong Dong, Fei Liu, and Qiang Zhang
163 Direct Shear Strength Test on Opalinus Clay, a Possible Host Rock
for Radioactive Waste . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 901
Buocz Ildikó, Török Ákos, Zhao Jian, and Rozgonyi-Boissinot Nikoletta
185 Use of Rock Mass Fabric Index in Fuzzy Environment for TBM
Performance Prediction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1019
Mansour Hedayatzadeh and Jafar Khademi Hamidi
193 Modeling Optimized UCG Gas Qualities and Related Tar Pollutant
Production Under Different Field Boundary Conditions . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1063
Stefan Klebingat, Rafig Azzam, Marc Schulten, Thomas Kempka,
Ralph Schlüter, and Tomás M. Fernández-Steeger
Abstract
De-icing chemicals are the most effective and cheap method to prevent winter slipperiness on
pavement surfaces in urban settings. Analysis of existing experimental studies and theoretical
methods shows that solutions of de-icing chemicals run off surfaces and are deposited in
adjacent soils. However, there is a lack of knowledge about the effect of de-icing chemicals on
the engineering properties of pavement sub soils, where the de-icing agents may penetrate
beneath the pavement surface. This is a particular issue as pavement surfaces typically cool
and warm at a faster rate than surrounding areas. In particular, during seasonal freeze-thaw
cycles, the lower freezing point of the chemical solution may induce moisture migration
toward a freezing front within the sub soil, leading to increased heave potential, and
subsequent thaw collapse.The paper describes an experimental study that simulates the
movement of water and de-icing solution from the deposition area upward to the highway’s
sub base. The chemical effect of de-icing solutions on the strength characteristic, water and
chemical content of each 10 cm layer of tested soil column will be assessed by in situ
measurement and post-experiment analysis. In the long run the impact of the de-icing
chemicals precipitation on the bearing capacity and deformation of sub base soils of roads will
be evaluated.
Keywords
Roadside soil De-icing chemicals Engineering properties Moisture migration
G. Lollino et al. (eds.), Engineering Geology for Society and Territory – Volume 6, 243
DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-09060-3_39, © Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2015
244 A. Sarsembayeva and P. Collins
Deposition of de-icing salts in the roadside inevitably cold periods. Progressive, but slow freezing to below the
changes the chemical content and moisture regime of the eutectic point, such as occurs in areas like Central Asia and
subsoil. This may have a great effect on its bearing capacity, Siberia, is likely to induce cryosuction of the unfrozen soil
especially during seasonal freeze-thaw cycles. Furthermore, moisture, inducing frost heave (Hoekstra 1966; O’Neill
it keeps the moisture of the nearby soil in a liquid state 1983; Othman and Benson 1993; Qi et al. 2006; Bron-
(Kane et al. 2001). fenbrener and Bronfenbrener 2010a, b; Matsumura and
As the thermal conductivity of pavement materials is far Yamazaki 2012). This will enhance thaw-related loss of
and away higher than the adjacent soils the thermal gradient bearing capacity of highways in the spring.
causes significant migration of moisture upward the freezing In situ measurement of the migration, and cyclic freezing
front that is where pavement layers (O’Neill 1983; Othman and thawing of de-icing agents is problematic. Instead, a
and Benson 1993; Giakoumakis 1994; Kane et al. 2001; modified frost heave test methodology has been developed.
Vidyapin and Cheverev 2008). Figures 39.1 and 39.2
describe the moisture migration toward the freezing front in
winter period. 39.2 Development of a Laboratory Model
In the spring, when the swelled mass of sub soils starts to
thaw and drain, a loss of bearing capacity occurs, as shown in The laboratory method for frost heave and thaw weakening
Fig. 39.3 (Othman and Benson 1993; Simonsen and Isacsson susceptibility observations of soils is based on ASTM
1999; Qi et al. 2006; Vidyapin and Cheverev 2008). D5918-06 Standard, (2007). The installation scheme of this
We hypothesis that the ability of de-icing chemicals to test simulates the movement of water and de-icing solution
keep moisture in a liquid state at low temperature may from the deposition area upward to the highway’s sub base.
enhance moisture migration toward the highway subsoil in A series of identical insulated soil columns within a
Linear
Motion
Outlet Potentio
reservoir meter Cooling
with Surcharge system To
moisture temperature
supply bath
Insulation
Thermoc
filler
ouple
1497 mm
1000 mm
mm mm mm
100 100 100
mm mm mm
Monitoring
100mm
90 114 200 mm 180 mm
mm mm
on Fig. 39.4.
mm
70
Unlike the ASTM Standard, the height of the soil col-
umns was increased from 15 cm to 1 m, which allows testing
the thermal gradient after each 10 cm in detail. Nine soil
columns can be tested simultaneously, which permits trip- 100 mm 150 mm
licate tests. 114 mm 180 mm
The plastic mould for the soil column consists of 10
identical acrylic sectional rings which allow easy assembly Fig. 39.5 Plastic mould section and base plate for testing a soil sample
and dismantling of the soil column. Each acrylic ring has an
inside diameter of 100 mm, outside diameter of 110 mm, and
height of 100 mm. The soil is separated from the acrylic is connected to the sample by a flexible plastic tube joined to
rings by a long rubber sleeve. the specimen base plate (Fig. 39.5).
Each acrylic ring has a mid-height drilled hole for a Freezing from the top is implemented by chilling collars
thermocouple sensor which takes temperature readings at and metal surcharges which have good heat conductivity and
regular intervals, with up to 90 thermocouple readings at a cause isotropic chilling on the sample surface. The surcharge
time, collated using a data logger. weight by a circular disk with a 2.72 kg of mass is placed on
The constant head of supplied moisture is provided by a the top of the soil specimen to simulate natural overloads
Marriotte water supply reservoir, which has a vacuum tight from the upward layers of pavement. This cooling con-
fitting glass tube in the top of the reservoir to provide the struction allows the vertical sliding of the surcharge inside
equal water pressure. The reservoir also allows control of the the chilling collar and at the same time provides the equal
elevation of the reservoir liquid. The bottom of the reservoir effective vertical stress during the heave frost.
246 A. Sarsembayeva and P. Collins
21
22
23
17
18
19
20
16
14
15
24
25
10
11
12
13
8
9
6
7
2
3
4
5
0
1
12
10
8
6
4
2
Temperature, ˚C
0
-2
-4
-6
-8
-10
-12
-14
-16
-18
-20
Dreving VP (1954) The phase rule. Moscow State University, Moscow Norrström AC, Jacks G (1998) Concentration and fractionation of
Giakoumakis SG (1994) A model for predicting coupled heat and mass heavy metals in roadside soils receiving de-icing salts. Sci Total
transfers in unsaturated partially frozen soil. Int J Heat Fluid Flow Environ 218(2–3):161–174
15(2):163–171 O’Neill K (1983) The physics of mathematical frost heave models: A
Hoekstra P (1966) Moisture movement in soils under temperature review. Cold Reg Sci Technol 6(3):275–291
gradients with the cold-side temperature below freezing. Water Othman MA, Benson CH (1993) Effect of freeze-thaw on the hydraulic
Resour Res 2(2):241–250 conductivity and morphology of compacted clay. Can Geotech J 30
Kane DL, Hinkel KM, Goering DJ, Hinzman LD, Outcalt SI (2001) (2):236–246
Non-conductive heat transfer associated with frozen soils. Glob Qi J, Ma W, Song C (2008) Influence of freeze–thaw on engineering
Planet Change 29(3–4):275–292 properties of a silty soil. Cold Reg Sci Technol 53(3):397–404
Loch JPG (1981) State-of-the-art report—frost action in soils. Eng Geol Qi J, Vermeer PA, Cheng G (2006) A review of the influence of freeze-
18(1–4):213–224 thaw cycles on soil geotechnical properties. Permafrost Periglac
Lundmark A, Jansson P (2008) Estimating the fate of de-icing salt in a Process 17(3):245–252
roadside environment by combining modelling and field observa- Simonsen E, Isacsson U (1999) Thaw weakening of pavement
tions. Water Air Soil Pollut 195(1–4):215–232 structures in cold regions. Cold Reg Sci Technol 29(2):135–151
Lundmark A, Olofsson B (2007) Chloride deposition and distribution Vidyapin IY, Cheverev VG (2008) The hydraulic of freezing saline
in soils along a deiced highway—assessment using different soils. Earth Cryosphere 12(4):43–45
methods of measurement. Water Air Soil Pollut 182(1–4):173–185 West DRF (1982) Ternary equilibrium diagrams. Chapman and Hall,
Matsumura Shinji, Yamazaki Koji (2012) A longer climate memory London New York
carried by soil freeze–thaw processes in Siberia. Environ Res Lett 7
(4):045402