GE1712

Names: Ferrer,Lyvelyn G. Section: BCSM

Date: October 1, 2021 Score:

Directions: Complete the Comparative Matrix table below.

Historical Source Author Event Date Event Objective Persons Involved Main Argument Bias
Tejeros Source: Santiago V. The assembly was The convention’s Secretary Jacinto The entire debate is about Ariston Villanueva,
Convention Alvarez, General of convinced on march 22, objective is to discuss on Lumbreras , Supreme to factions deciding what Secretary of War for the
katipunan 1897 how bolster the defenses Andres Bonifacio, type of government Magdiwang Received
in the areas still under Messrs. Mariano M. should be installed, confidential information
Magdiwang control. Alvarez, Pascual which leads to the that Mr. Tirona of
Alvarez, Ariston election of who will hold Magdalo was planning to
Villanueva , Mariano C. the authority of the undermine the
Trias , Diego Mojica, Katipunan Cavite assembly’s proceeding
Emiliano R. de Dios, and that he had already
Santiago V. Alvarez, succeeded in persuading
Artemio Ricarte, Santos many Magdiwang leaders
Nocon , Luciano San to ally with him.
Miguel ,Pablo Mojica,
Severino de las alas,
Santiago Rillo, Messrs.
Baldomero Aguinaldo,
Daniel Tirona, Cayetano
Topacio
Seeds of Discontent Source: Teodoro A. The assembly hall, the The Discontent objective Mariano Alvarez, Pascual The katipunan of cavite, Bonifacio was brought
Agoncillo, Filipino two factions met on is When cavite, led by its Alvarez, Emiliano Riego divided into two factions, by the rebel leaders to the
historian December 31, 1897 rival factions, de Dios, mariano trias, the magdiwang and the house of juan castaneda
successfully rose in ariston Villanueva, magdalo, immediately in imus, where he was
revolt, the leaders fell Santiago Alvarez, Diego proceeded to reorganize visitid by bladomero
into disputes arising from Moxica, Artemio Recarte the province along aguinaldo, Daniel tirona,
the desire of one group to Mariano Riego de Dios, partisan lines in the first vicente fernandez, and
lord it over the other. Baldomero Aguinaldo, flush of rebel victory, others. bonifacio blamed
since both groups were Candido Tirona, climaxing the him for the defeat in san
responsible for the rebel Cayetano topacio, Emilio simultaneous attacks on juan and as determined
victories, neither would Aguinaldo, Edilberto the spanish garrisons and that he should not go
bow to the other or allow Evangelista, Vito convents, followed by the unpunised. Magdalo
itself to be placed under Belarmino, Crispulo dismal failure of cieftains, to whom
its rival's command. The Aguinaldo governor-general blanco fernandez had run for
silent conflict, more to smash the insurgent shelter, refused to give up
ominous than it appeared power. Each faction ruled their man.
on the surface, threatened over a number of towns,
to wreck the unity that in including those in
beginning had done Batangas bordering
much to prevent the foe Cavite. Thus, Talisay, a
from overrunning the town in Batangas, was
whole province. administered by the
01 Worksheet 2 *Property of STI
Page 1 of 2
 GE1712
Magdalo government,
whereas Nasugbu, Tuwi,
and Look, also in the
same province, were
administered by the
Magdiwang. The leaders
of the two provincial
councils were never
recognized as
independent entities, the
leaders of the two
provincial councils never
got together to elect one
supreme council that ould
hold sway over the entire
province.

01 Worksheet 2 *Property of STI

Page 2 of 2
 HISTORICAL SOURCE ADVANTAGES
Source Material 1 On March 22, 1897, a convention was held in Tejeros in order to settle
the dispute between the two councils and to decide on what type of
government should be installed. During the early phase of the convention the
crowd became unruly, causing a recess. When the convention resumed,
Bonifacio was assigned to preside in the election of the officers of the new
government that was to be set up. Before this, he laid down the rule that the
Tejeros convention assembly should respect whatever would be the outcome of the election.
DISADVANTAGES
Bonifacio declared that all matters convened in the Tejeros Convention were
null and void. Bonifacio felt insulted and demanded an apology from Daniel
Tirona, who argued that a lawyer should handle the position of Secretary of
Interior rather than a politician.

Source Material 2

Seeds of discontent

Conclusion and Implication

For the Comparative Matrix: For the Advantages and Disadvantages:

CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS CRITERIA PERFORMANCE INDICATORS POINTS
Provided the correct information with pieces of evidence and supporting Provided a sound argument with pieces of evidence and supporting
Content 12 Content 20
details. details.
Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1 Grammar Used correct grammar, punctuation, spelling, and capitalization. 1
Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the Organization Expressed the points in clear and logical arrangement of ideas in the
6 8
of Ideas paragraph. of Ideas paragraph.
Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1 Format Adhered to the required style/appearance. 1
TOTAL 20 TOTAL 30