Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation: Laboratory Manual
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation: Laboratory Manual
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation: Laboratory Manual
SOFTCOPY
AERIAL
TRIANGULATION
LABORATORY MANUAL
INSTRUCTOR
DR. HOWARD TURNER P.L.S.
1
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
In this exercise, you will learn how to setup a softcopy photogrammetric project for aerial
triangulation. This will include adding camera data, control data, photo and model data
to the project. You will be supplied with seven softcopy photogrammetry images of
Glendale, Arizona scanned at 15 microns. The camera data from the camera calibration
report is given in a table. The control data from a filed map is also given in a table.
OBJECTIVES
Upon completion of the exercise you will be able to perform the following functions;
2
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
3
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
2. Enter the Project Name as Arizona. Press TAB. Enter the Location as
C:\arizona. Press Next.
3. Select the Data Type as Aerial Photography. Select the File Type as ASCII.
4
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
4. Set the Linear Units to Feet (ft). Set the Angular Unit to Degrees (deg). Press
Next.
5. Set the Flying Height (AMSL) to 4200 ft above mean sea level (AMSL). Set the
Ground Elevation (AMSL) to 1500 feet. Press Next.
5
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
Max Sigma 10 µm
6
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
7
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
8
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
CAMERA DATA
Focal_Length: 152.928
Principal Point of Auto Collimation: x: 0.000 y: 0.000
Principal Point of Best Symmetry: x: -0.001 y: -0.006
Film_Format: 230 cm. X 230 cm.
11 Enter the Focal Length as 152.928 mm. Enter the Principal Point of Best
Symmetry as –0.001 for X and –0.006 for Y. Enter the Principal Point of Auto
Collimation as 0.000 for X and 0.000 for Y. Enter Film Width as 230 mm, and Film
Length as 230 mm. Press Next.
9
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
12. Complete the Fiducial Coordinate form using the data from the camera table
above. Enter the ID, X and Y values and then press Add. When all the data has been
entered press Next.
10
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
13. Check off Enable Lens Distortion. Set the Distortion Value Format to Table.
Set the Distortion Value to Angular. Set the Distortion Mode to Average. Press Next.
11
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
14. Enter the distortion values from the camera table above. Enter the Angle (deg)
value, and then the Distortion (µµm) and press Add. When the table is complete press
Finish.
12
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
The following window opens. Go to Camera Data and check that the entered data is
correct. Check the data associated with each of the other headings. Click OK to exit.
13
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
18. The following window opens. In Strip ID enter 1. In Photo ID enter 1. Turn
Composite Image off. For the Image File, enter the path C:\images\glen1-
1.cmp. For Exterior Orientation Information, set the View Geometry to
Vertical, and leave Camera Station Position and Camera Station Attitude off.
The Camera Name should be arizona, and the Camera Orientation should be
zero. Click Apply.
14
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
19. The following window appears. In Strip ID enter 1. In Photo ID enter 2. Turn
Composite Image off. For the Image File, enter the path C:\images\glen1-2.cmp. For
Exterior Orientation Information, set the View Geometry to Vertical, and leave
Camera Station Position and Camera Station Attitude off. The Camera Name
should be arizona, and the Camera Orientation should be zero. Click Apply. Repeat
this task until photographs glen1-1, 1-2, 1-3 , 1-4, 2-1, 2-2, and 2-3 are entered in the
project. Click O.K. Also click OK on the other forms that appear.
15
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
21. The following window appears. In Left Photo, to the right of the form, enter 1
for Strip and 1 for ID. In Right Photo, enter 1 for Strip and 2 for ID. Press
Generate Model ID from Photo Ids.
16
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
The following form appears. Press Yes. Then press O.K. on the Edit Model form to
exit.
17
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
24. The following window appears. Enter the control data from the table. After entry
of each line, press Add.
18
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
ID TYPE CLASS X Y Z
5019 Control Full 515937.87 127029.16 1171.65.
5018 Control Full 515921.58 124639.16 1165.07
133 Control Full 517459.42 124866.02 1172.77
5014 Control Full 518375.02 127094.17 1177.94
5015 Control Full 518367.14 124815.55 1170.66
143 Control Full 518804.77 124827.23 1174.04
153 Control Full 520224.86 124825.29 1178.83
5012 Control Full 521027.57 125751.38 1182.45
163 Control Full 521753.38 124940.5 1182.68
5011 Control Full 522605.19 127186.3 1190.27
5009 Control Full 523109.86 124767.09 1187.12
186 Control Full 524703.64 124794.82 1194.39
196 Control Full 526264.14 124823.85 1201.71
5006 Control Full 531569.30 127037.05 1225.68
1116 Control Full 528940.98 124927.4 1207.9
5002 Control Full 528923.16 126086.03 1211.6
1126 Control Full 530346.30 124890.81 1212.19
5005 Control Full 531551.87 124835.42 1216.44
19
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
20
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
In this exercise, you will learn how to setup part of a softcopy photogrammetric model.
This will include interior (inner) orientation for aerial triangulation. You have set-up a
project file with camera data, control data, photo and model data. You have been
supplied with seven softcopy photogrammetry images of the Glendale, Arizona scanned
at 15.0 microns. The camera data from the camera calibration report is given in a table in
exercise 1. The control data is also given in a table in exercise 1.
OBJECTIVES
Upon completion of the exercise you will be able to perform the following functions.
21
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
22
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
23
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
24
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
6. The windows arrangement may not look exactly as above. Select Window New
Arrangement to activate the New Arrangement dialog box: The following dialog box appears.
7. Select the number of levels you want displayed for each photograph. Selecting 1 level
will display only the detail windows; selecting 2 levels will display the overview and the
detail windows; selecting 3 levels will display the overview, intermediate and detail
windows. Select the Number of Levels to be 3. Press OK. All exercises in these
laboratory manuals will use the three-window arrangement.
detail
overview
25
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
8. Once you have an arrangement you like, you can select Window Save
Arrangement… If you don’t do this, when you leave the orientation your arrangement will be
given the unimaginative name “New.” Note that these arrangements are saved per orientation. In
other words, IO, RO, AO and Resection all have separate sets of window arrangements.
9. If you don’t like the arrangement. Select Window Restore Arrangement. The
Restore Arrangement window appears as follows.
10. Choose the one you want. You will find a number of built in window arrangements to
choose from, many of them corresponding to screen resolutions. You can review or change your
screen resolution by selecting Start Settings Control Panel Display Settings
tab Desktop Area.
26
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
11 Select View Enhance or the icon. The following form appears. To adjust the
brightness of the image, drag the cross hairs to the appropriate position.
12 The first fiducial is located in the southwest corner of the overview. Use the cursor to
locate the first fiducial on the overview. The cursor is different in the photogrammetry software.
It appears as a diagonal cross.
27
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
13. When the cursor is located in the vicinity of the fiducial, click on the fiducial in the
overview with the data button. The fiducial. then appears in the intermediate window and the
detail view.
28
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
14. Click on the fiducial with the data button in the intermediate view. Then measure it
precisely on the detail window.
Measurements are taken only in the detail view (this is true of all orientations). It is not
necessary to precisely measure in the overview or intermediate view. They are used only
to center the detail view for measurement
29
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
15 The second fiducial mark is located in the northeast corner of the overview. Click in its
vicinity with the data button and the fiducial mark will appear in the intermediate and
detail views.
16 After this, the system should display the remaining fiducials accurately enough that you
will not need to use the overview or intermediate windows any more. Measure the
remaining six fiducial marks. Upon completion the interior orientation window should
look as follows.
30
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
17 If the system cannot find the third fiducial for you, then you probably misidentified one
of the first two. If the system finds the third fiducial but it seems to be misplaced a little
bit, then check your camera orientation in ImageStation Project Manager. Your
fiducials may be rotated to the wrong positions
18. Once you have measured all fiducials, sigma should be less than 5 microns and the
system will tell you that you have a good solution. If the solution is satisfactory, move
the cursor over an image window and select Next Photo from the shortcut menu (right
mouse button). Your measurements and results will automatically be saved. If this was
the last photo selected, select Apply to apply the results to a solution, then select Close.
If the solution is not satisfactory go to step 19.
31
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
19. If your sigma is greater than 5 microns, you will need to remeasure the points with
high residuals, or correct the blunders. First try remeasuring all the points that have a
residual greater than 5 microns, and observe if the residuals in the solution get smaller.
20. To find blunders in your IO measurements, click on the More button on the Interior
Orientation results dialog to bring up the Additional Interior Orientation Parameters
dialog box. Select Conformal, Affine and Projective from the pulldown list. Observe
the residuals from each transformation. Notice if one transformation works better than
others, and reduces the sigma below 5 microns. If one of the transformations reduces the
sigma below 5 microns, press Close, and exit the Additional Interior Orientation
Parameters dialog box. On the Interior Orientation dialog box, press Apply and then
Close. If a problem still exists go to step 21.
21 On the Additional Interior Orientation Parameters dialog box, there are Withhold,
Reinstate and Delete buttons. Find the measurement with the largest residual and
withhold it. Observe the other residuals, and the sigma. If their value drops, the
measurement you have withheld is bad. Continue withholding points until you obtain the
required accuracy. A conformal transformation requires 4 points. An Affine
transformation requires 6 points. A projective transformation requires eight points. . If
withholding points reduces the sigma below 5 microns, press Close, and exit the
Additional Interior Orientation Parameters dialog box. On the Interior Orientation
dialog box, press Apply and then Close. If a problem still exists go to step 22
22. The residuals that you get from running IO should reflect your pointing accuracy. The
Sigma value should be less than 5 microns. If your residuals are still too high, and
everything else has failed. The problem maybe that your calibrated fiducial coordinate
are entered wrong. Check them. It is also possible that you have not accounted for
camera orientation when identifying the first two fiducials. Remember that if your
camera orientation is not 0°, your fiducial positions will appear to be rotated. The
fiducials must be measured with regard to the calibration report for the camera, no matter
how the image is displayed on the screen.
32
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
23. When you have reduced the sigma below 5 microns, on the Interior Orientation dialog
box, press Apply and then Close. The Select Photos form appears. It shows the results obtained
from Interior Orientation on Strip_id 1, Photo_id 1.
23. Select Strip_id 1, Photo_id 2 from the Select Photos form. Press OK. Complete the
inner orientation for the second photograph. The system should automatically drive to
the fiducial marks. A result of less than 5 microns is desired. Continue measuring
fiducial marks on the following photographs
Strip Photograph
1 3
1 4
2 1
2 2
2 3
33
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
In this exercise, you will learn how to setup part of a softcopy photogrammetric model.
This will include interior relative orientation. You have set-up a project file with camera
data, control data, photo and model data. You have been supplied with two softcopy
photogrammetry images of the Cal Poly campus scanned at 22.5 microns. The camera
data from the camera calibration report is given in a table in exercise 1. The control data
from a filed map is also given in a table in exercise 1. The inner orientation was
completed in exercise 2.
OBJECTIVES
Upon completion of the exercise you will be able to perform the following functions.
34
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
35
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
36
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
37
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
6. The windows arrangement may not look exactly as above. Select Window New
Arrangement to activate the New Arrangement dialog box: The following dialog box appears.
7. Select the number of levels you want displayed for each photograph. Selecting 1 level
will display only the detail windows; selecting 2 levels will display the overview and the detail
windows; selecting 3 levels will display the overview, intermediate and detail windows. Select
the Number of Levels to be 3. Press OK. All exercises in these laboratory manuals will use the
three-window arrangement.
38
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
detail
overview
8. Once you have an arrangement you like, you can select Window Save
Arrangement… If you don’t do this, when you leave the orientation your arrangement will be
given the unimaginative name “New.” Note that these arrangements are saved per orientation. In
other words, IO, RO, AO and Resection all have separate sets of window arrangements.
9. If you don’t like the arrangement. Select Window Restore Arrangement. The
Restore Arrangement window appears as follows.
39
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
10. Choose the one you want. You will find a number of built in window arrangements to
choose from, many of them corresponding to screen resolutions. You can review or change your
screen resolution by selecting Start Settings Control Panel Display Settings
tab Desktop Area.
11 Select View Enhance or the icon. The following form appears. To adjust the
brightness of the image, drag the cross hairs to the appropriate position.
40
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
12. Point distribution is critical in RO. The system will solve with six or more points. The
operator must ensure that the points measured are in the correct locations. The operator
must cover the photogrammetric model with the measured points
3 4
1 2
5 6
By covering the model with parallax points, you also ensure that some of these points will fall in the
overlap areas between models (pass points) and in the sidelap areas between strips (where they are
referred to as tie points). Six points are minimum that you should measure. You need at least 9 points to
ensure that you have cleared y-parallax.
Y-Parallax is the separation of the left and right measuring marks in the y-direction. The
following diagram illustrates the concept of y-parallax.
y-parallax
41
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
Point numbering is critical in aerial triangulation. The following gives a scheme that will be used
in these exercises.
41
31
11 21
Strip 1
32 42
12 22
33 43 4
23
1 13
14 24 34 44
Strip 2
35 45 3
1 25
15
13. The first relative orientation point is located at Position 12 shown in the diagram above.
Set the Id on the relative orientation form to be 1_12. In the left overview, select a point
with the cursor in the left overview located approximately in Position 12. . The cursor is
different in the photogrammetry software. It appears as a diagonal cross. Click with a
data point in the left overview. The location appears in the left intermediate view. Click
the middle mouse button in the left middle view and the view enters roam mode. Roam
until you find a good detail point to measure. A good detail point is one with a lot of
contrast (i.e. the end of the line marking a parking space). Click on the detail point in the
left intermediate view. The point appears in the detail view. Measure the point by
clicking the data button in the left detail view.
A letter M will appear in the relative orientation window under the left column.
14. In the right overview, select a point with the cursor in the right overview located
approximately in Position 12. Click with a data point in the right overview. The location
appears in the right intermediate view. Click the middle mouse button in the right
intermediate view and the view enters roam mode. Roam until you find a good detail
point to measure. A good detail point is one with a lot of contrast (i.e. the end of the line
marking a parking space). Click on the detail point in the right intermediate view. The
point appears in the detail view. Measure the point by clicking the data button in the
right detail view.
42
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
A letter M will appear in the relative orientation window under the right column as
shown below.
15. The second relative orientation point is located at Position 22 shown in the diagram above.
Set the Id on the relative orientation form to be 1_22. In the left overview, select a point
with the cursor in the left overview located approximately in Position 22. . The cursor is
different in the photogrammetry software. It appears as a diagonal cross. Click with a
data point in the left overview. The location appears in the left intermediate view. Click
the middle mouse button in the left middle view and the view enters roam mode. Roam
until you find a good detail point to measure. A good detail point is one with a lot of
contrast (i.e. the end of the line marking a parking space). Click on the detail point in the
left intermediate view. The point appears in the detail view. Measure the point by
clicking the data button in the left detail view.
A letter M will appear in the relative orientation window under the left column for
point 1_22.
16. In the right overview, select a point with the cursor in the right overview located
approximately in Position 22. Click with a data point in the right overview. The location
appears in the right intermediate view. Click the middle mouse button in the right
intermediate view and the view enters roam mode. Roam until you find a good detail
point to measure. A good detail point is one with a lot of contrast (i.e. the end of the line
marking a parking space). Click on the detail point in the right intermediate view. The
point appears in the detail view. Measure the point by clicking the data button in the
right detail view.
A letter M will appear in the relative orientation window under the right column for
point 1_22.
43
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
A letter M will appear in the relative orientation window under the left and right columns for points 1 to 6.
When 6 points have been measure the software computes a solution. Most of the time, this solution will look
pretty good. Don’t believe it. Six points are not enough to statistically assess an RO solution. You need at
least nine points.
44
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
18. Measure three additional points. These points can be randomly distributed in the model.
Every relative orientation solution generates a statistics report, starting with y-parallax for every
point and an overall pointing accuracy, sigma. The system will compare these to the project
limits you previously set up in Photogrammetric Project Manager and will indicate a warning
if the solution exceeds either limit. If you have a good solution, these statistics will be small.
However, the converse is not always true: having great statistics doesn’t mean you have a good
solution. The proof is in the y-parallax observed: Drive around the model, especially the edges,
and spot-check your parallax in the stereo views wearing the stereo glasses. More statistics are
shown on the Additional Relative Orientation Parameters dialog box (available by clicking on
the More button
45
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
20. Check that you have a good relative orientation solution, and that there is no parallax in
the model. Various problems can occur with relative orientation
♦= Bad Statistics
♦= Revisit the points you’ve measured. Sometimes a fresh look will reveal parallax or a
mismeasurement that you didn’t see before.
♦= If you have used buddy points, look at the residuals on buddy pairs. If the residuals in a
buddy pair are similar, then there are probably systematic errors affecting your solution.
Without systematic errors, the residuals will look much more random.
♦= Bad statistics but RO points look good
♦= This is a little unusual, but it can happen. First of all, measure at least nine points. The
parallax values from a weak RO solution really don’t tell you anything. But even with
plenty of measurements, a bad point may not have the largest parallax if it is at the edge
of the model. This means that the obvious strategy of remeasuring those points with the
highest parallax simply won’t work. The way to find the bad point is to withhold points,
one by one, reinstating each before withholding the next, until the solution suddenly
improves. The point you just withheld will now have a much larger parallax than the
others.
♦= After this, if all your points look good yet you still have poor statistics, there may be a
problem with your IO, fiducial coordinates, principal point coordinates or image
corrections.
♦= Good statistics but the model still has parallax
♦= If you haven’t measured at least nine points, do so. Measure extra points in the areas
where you see parallax.
21. The average operator can obtain an average parallax measurement of 5 microns. Re-
measure, withhold and delete your measurements until you have a solution with sigma
less than 5 microns with at least 9 points measured, The system will state Good Solution.
22. When satisfied with the solution, press Apply on the Relative Orientation window.
46
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
The Select Model window appears with the solution of the relative orientation entered.
24. Select Model Id 1~2+1~3. Enter O.K. and return to the Relative Orientation main
window.
47
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
25. The measurement technique used in relative orientation after the first model is different.
The points on one picture are frozen, and the conjugate point has to be measured on the second
41
31
11 21
Strip 1
32 42
12 22
33 43 4
23
1 13
14 24 34 44
Strip 2
35 45 3
1 25
15
image. For example points 11, 12, 13, 21, 22, and 23 were measured on the first model. In the
second model, points 21, 22, and 23 are fixed in position on the left photograph and measured
only on the right photograph. Points 31, 32 and 33 are measured on both photographs.
26. On the second model, the left picture is held fixed, and has marks on it as shown below.
All measurements are made on the right picture.
48
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
The following view shows points 1_11, 1_12, and 1_13 as being measured on the left photograph
only. There are no conjugate points to measure in the right photo of the second model. Points
1_21, 1_22, 1_23, 1_31, 1_32, and 1_33 are measured on both photographs in the second model.
The following view shows points 1_21, 1_22, 1_23, 1_31, 1_32, 1_33 measured on the second
model
49
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
27. Press the right mouse button to enter the short-cut menu. Select grab point and point to
the point you wish to measure. The system will position the Relative Orientation form on
the correct measurement. The Relative Orientation form will appear as below on the
second model.
27 Measure models 1~1+1~2, 1~2+1~3, and 1~3+1~4. There should be less than 5 microns
parallax in the whole strip. Exit the relative orientation process and return to the Select
Models dialog box.
50
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
29. The second strip does not automatically tie to the first strip. Lateral tie points 1_13 and
1_23 may occur in the first model on the second strip. They have to be measured independently
in the second strip. Locate each point and measure it. In the example shown here, point 1_13
only occurs in the left photograph of the first model. Point 1_23 occurs on the left and right
photograph of the first model.
51
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
30. Measure relative orientation points in Models 2~1+2~2, and 2~2+2~3. Make sure that
all relative orientation results are below a sigma of 5 microns. At the completion of the
aerial triangulation process, the Select Models dialog box should look similar to that
shown below.
52
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
In this exercise, you will learn how to adjust the block of photography. This will include photo
triangulation. Photo Triangulation (PhotoT) has three areas of functionality: triangularion,
densify and bulk orient. Triangulation allows you to orient a block of photos simultaneously,
using standard least-squares techniques. The triangulation software comes with tools for quality
control, editing and reporting. Densify allows you to convert triangulated pass points to control
points. This, in turn, allows you to run RO and AO on individual models. Bulk Orient performs
IO, RO, AO or resection, on all photos. You have set-up a project file with camera data, control
data, photo and model data. You have been supplied with seven softcopy photogrammetry
images of Glendale, Arizona scanned at 15 microns. The camera data from the camera
calibration report is given in a table in exercise 1. The control data from a filed map is also given
in a table in exercise 1. The inner orientation was completed in exercise 2. The relative
orientation of the block was performed in exercise 3. The ground-control points were measured
in exercise 4.
OBJECTIVES
Upon completion of the exercise you will be able to perform the following functions.
53
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
54
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
5. Use the Select Photos dialog box to specify which photos to process. You may wish to
begin by triangulating sub-blocks rather than the entire project. Press O.K.
55
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
6. Select Options (lower left corner). The Photo Triangulation Options form appears.
Adjustment Mode: It is good practice to run in relative mode first, to search for blunders in your
pass and tie points, before running in absolute mode. If you have enough control for the
photos you can then set the adjustment mode to Absolute. Set the Adjustment Mode to
Relative.
Enable Given EO: If you have good approximate EO parameters, turn Enable Given EO on. If
you suspect that your given EO parameters are causing the solution to fail, turn it off.
Set Enable Given EO to on.
Enable Error Detection: This tells the system whether to automatically search for blunders while
it solves. This is normally left on, unless it seems to be eliminating good points. Points
that are removed from the adjustment are labeled “Blunder” in the Status column and
are treated as withheld points. Set Enable Error Detection to on.
Enable Matrix Inversion: To save time if you are processing large blocks, you may turn Enable
Matrix Inversion off to prevent the system from computing standard deviations until you
have a decent solution. Later, when you need them, you can turn it back on. Set Enable
Matrix Inversion to on.
Enable Compute On Edit: This determines whether a new solution is computed whenever you
make an edit. Whether you turn this on or off is a matter of convenience. Set Enable
Compute On Edit to on.
Enable 3d Approximations: This determines whether a approximations are used for the ground
control points. Set Enable 3d Approximations to on.
Threshholds for Display: These act as filters for the results screens and reports. With these
turned on, you will only see points with residuals that exceed these thresholds. Set
Thresholds for Display to off.
56
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
Decimal Precision Reporting: These values control the number of places displayed to the right of
the decimal place in dialog boxes and reports. Set Image Point Statistics to 1. Set
Object Point Statistics to 3.
57
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
9. Read the last line of processing results to confirm that the system was able to
compute the solution. If a solution was computed, then the Photo Triangulation
Results dialog box will show the new results. If no solution was computed, then all the
results will represent old solutions or approximations. In this case, read the notes in the
Solution Progress dialog box to find out why the solution failed. You can then make
corrections and try again.
10. After you have successfully computed a solution, select Summary Statistics on the
Photo Triangulation Results dialog box to review the statistics and parameters. Most of
these pages are self-explanatory. The Summary Statistics page is the first place to look,
to see if the solution might be acceptable: In addition to checking the statistics (sigma,
RMS values, etc.), be sure to look at Photos Used and Photos Not Used. If one or more
photos has not been used, scan through the Solution Progress dialog box to see what
photos and points were eliminated. The RMS values should be less than 0.1 foot.
58
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
11. Select the Photo Statistics tab. The Photo Statistics page shows all the points measured
on a given photo along with the statistics related to the image measurements:
12. Select Headings to control what columns are displayed. You can control the widths of these
columns in the following ways:
• By grabbing the dividers between column headings (with the data button or left mouse button)
and dragging left or right.
• Size a column automatically to fit the largest entry by double clicking on the right-hand
column heading divider.
• Sort all rows according the entries in an individual column by clicking on that column’s
header.
59
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
14. From the Photo Statistics, Object Statistics and Point Statistics pages you can select groups of
points and then Withhold, Reinstate and Delete to edit points.
15. Select the Object Statistics tab. The Object Statistics page shows all the object points and the
associated statistics: If you withhold a control point on the Object Statistics page of the Photo
Triangulation Results dialog box, only the control coordinates are withheld from the solution.
This has the same effect as converting it to a parallax point, so that its photo measurements are
still used in the solution.
60
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
16. Select the Point Statistics tab. The Point Statistics page shows all the points (not just
those measured on a given photo) and the associated statistics.
61
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
17. Select the Exterior Orientation tab. The Exterior Orientation page shows the EO parameters
for all photos:
18. Select Apply from the Photo Triangulation Results dialog box to save the results. This
writes the computed EO parameters to the data files and writes the tie points to a special
file called “triang” that can be used later for densification. To reset your results back to
when you last saved, select Reset. Select Reports to save results in a printable form.
(Note that the settings in Options Thresholds for Display apply to the reports as well.)
19. Refine the adjustment process until you have a good solution. The RMS value set in the
project setup was 0.1 foot. The system will tell you when you have a satisfactory
solution.
20. When the solution is successful, select Reports. The following form will display.
62
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
21. Select Save to store the report to file, or Print to output to a printer.
63
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
FOOTNOTES
♦= Densify
Densification converts all triangulated pass points and tie points to control points:
If you wish to replace your Given EO parameters with the computed EO parameters, select
Overwrite Given EO. (Note: this does not affect the computed EO parameters, which were
already written to the data files when you selected Apply.)
In addition to converting pass points and tie points to control points, you can overwrite existing
control point coordinates with the adjusted coordinates from your last block adjustment. To do
this, select Overwrite Control Points. You should consider the following:
•= Before you overwrite your control points, be sure that you have the original coordinates
stored elsewhere.
•= By overwriting your control point coordinates with the adjusted values, you will have a more
consistent data set for further work.
By selecting the appropriate buttons, you can use computed or keyed-in standard deviations for
the control points that are written to the data files. In general, it is better to use the computed
standard deviations.
♦= Bulk Orient
This facility allows you to perform IO and Resection on all selected photos, and RO and AO on
all selected models. The workflow is simpler than the reasons for doing these things, so that’s
what we’ll discuss first.
Select Orientations Photo Triangulation Bulk Orient. Select the orientations to run. If
you need to review the results, you can do so through IO, RO, AO or Resection.
64
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
65
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
are not satisfactory, search for errors in the pass/tie points, using conventional editing and
analysis.
Next, if the pass/tie data is still erroneous, subdivide the block into sub-blocks, strips, or groups
of connected photos to isolate the errors. Within the smaller blocks of data, you continue to apply
blunder detection, conventional editing, and analysis to isolate errors. Finally, if the data is still
not satisfactory, search for errors in the lens distortion parameters, reseau measurements, earth
radius, and so forth. After finding errors and producing a satisfactory results, you will retrace
your steps by rebuilding your block and then running an absolute adjustment.
All of the recommendations given here depend on your having plenty of measurements. If you
have not measured enough points to withhold or delete points as recommended, you may have to
simply go back to RO and measure some more. The degrees of freedom (DOF), reported on the
Summary Statistics dialog box, indicates roughly how many extra measurements you have per
photo. As a rule of thumb, you should have at least three (3) degrees of freedom per photo in a
block adjustment.
Note: Even though you can use residuals on measured points to help identify bad points, you
should not eliminate any measured point simply because it has high residuals. Instead, if you
suspect that a point is bad, withhold it from the solution and then look at its residuals. If its
residuals (as a withheld point) are much higher, and especially if the quality of the remaining
solution improves noticeably, then it is not consistent with the rest of your data, and you should
consider removing it. (This applies only if the remaining solution has one or more degrees of
freedom.)
Another factor to consider is the effect that removing a point, or a group of points, will have on
the rest of the solution. For example, you should avoid removing all the points on one side of a
model or photo, or all the points near the top or bottom. If you encounter a situation where all the
points in such an area are bad, you should go back to RO and measure new points to replace the
bad ones, then return to PhotoT.
♦= Blunder Detection
On the Photo Triangulation Results form, select Options… Enable Error Detection.
Select Compute to run the block adjustment. On the Point Statistics page of the Photo
Triangulation Results dialog box, sort on the Status column to group the blunders, select them
all and withhold them. For each blunder, note both the point ID and the photos on which it is
measured. Go back to RO or AO and remeasure these points on these photos. Return to
PhotoT and recompute. If the solution is still unsatisfactory, go to the next step.
66
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
control points. Once you have a good set of control points, add two or three more to the
solution, maintaining a good distribution. Recompute the block adjustment. If the results are
worse, then there is a problem with one of your control points. Withhold each of these five or
siz points one at a time (reinstating before withholding the next) to see which point degrades
the solution, and leave that point withheld. Assuming that you now have satisfactory results,
i.e. a set of good control points, reinstate the withheld control points two or three at a time.
Any time the solution deteriorates suddenly, withhold the recently-reinstated points one at a
time and, as described above, remove any that are degrading the solution. As you proceed,
you may be able to isolate the worst control points. If so, leave them out of your solution. If
not (i.e., if the solution is still unsatisfactory), go to Correct Erroneous Parameters, below.
Method II, slower but more effective:
Exit the PhotoT environment by selecting OK (or Cancel) on the Photo Triangulation Results
dialog box. Select Edit Control Points and use the Edit Control Points dialog box to
convert all control points to check points. Select three well-distributed full (XYZ) points and
convert them back to control points. Exit this dialog box, return to triangulation, and set the
adjustment mode to Absolute on the Photo Triangulation Options dialog box. Recompute the
block adjustment. If the results are satisfactory, then these three control points are good. If
the results are not good, choose a different set of control points. Assuming that the results are
now satisfactory, scan the object points to see which check points are good and which ones
may have problems. (Hint: set your thresholds to filter out the good points, leaving only the
questionable points visible.) Choose a small number of well-distributed check points,
preferably with small residuals, reinstate them as control points, and recompute the block
adjustment. You will do this repeatedly, each time doing the following: assess the overall
adjustment to make sure that the control points are good, then assess the check points to see
which ones might be bad, then choose a few more good check points to add to the solution.
As you proceed, you may be able to isolate the worst control points. If so, leave them out of
your solution. If not (i.e., if the solution is still unsatisfactory), go to Correct Erroneous
Parameters, below.
Comparison of methods I and II:
The reason why method II is more effective than method I is that you get more information
about the points you have just removed (i.e. withheld or converted to check points). As check
points, they will have object space residuals, and you can use these to more intelligently add
them back into the solution. When you withhold them, you then have to simply experiment
and watch the quality of the solution.
67
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Softcopy Aerial Triangulation Laboratory Manual
This technique will not isolate mismatched points between sub-blocks. For this reason, when
you rebuild your original block you should add only a few sub-blocks at a time, watching
your results as you go. If the solution is now satisfactory, go to Find and Correct Errors in
Control Points, above. If the solution is still unsatisfactory, go to the next step.
68
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Aerial Triangulation Training Manual – Laboratory
APPENDIX I
Parameters
Parameter X Y Z XY
RMS Control 0.001 0.002 0.000 0.001
RMS Check 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
RMS Limits 0.100 0.100 0.100
Mean Std Dev 0.000 0.000 0.000
Max Residual 0.001 0.004 0.001
Residual Limits 0.100 0.100 0.100
RMS Image 3.9 4.6
Key Statistics
Sigma: 8.1
Number of iterations: 3
Degrees of Freedom: 38
Solution Successful.
Current Count
Control Points: 6
Check Points: 0
Photos Used: 7
Photos Not Used: 0
Observations: 70
Project Settings
Atm Refraction: On
Earth Curvature: On
69
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Aerial Triangulation Training Manual – Laboratory
Photo Statistics
Point Id Status Type Class Vx Vy V(xy) # Rays SVx SVy rx ry x-coord y-coord
1_11 Measured Pass 4.6 -0.2 4.6 2 -92.6 14.2
1_12 Measured Pass -5.9 0.2 5.9 2 1.4 -1.8
1_13 Measured Pass 4.8 5.4 7.3 3 88.1 -6.5
1_21 Measured Pass -2.9 -0.4 2.9 3 -87.3 88.1
1_22 Measured Pass -0.3 8.9 8.9 3 6.3 83.1
1_23 Measured Pass -2.3 -12.9 13.1 5 95.1 77.5
5018 Measured Control XYZ 3.4 2.1 4.0 5 99.3 72.7
5019 Measured Control XYZ -1.5 -3.1 3.4 3 -50.3 80.4
Point Id Status Type Class Vx Vy V(xy) # Rays SVx SVy rx ry x-coord y-coord
1_11 Measured Pass -4.6 0.0 4.6 2 -93.0 -72.7
1_12 Measured Pass 5.9 -0.1 5.9 2 0.9 -86.3
1_13 Measured Pass -6.1 0.4 6.1 3 87.8 -89.7
1_21 Measured Pass 3.7 0.9 3.8 3 -89.7 0.8
1_22 Measured Pass -0.7 -17.6 17.6 3 3.6 -1.9
1_23 Measured Pass 1.7 11.5 11.6 5 92.6 -5.8
1_31 Measured Pass 2.6 -0.9 2.8 3 -87.2 89.5
1_32 Measured Pass -1.8 3.9 4.3 3 -14.0 79.7
1_33 Measured Pass -3.0 1.2 3.3 3 79.5 90.5
5018 Measured Control XYZ 3.7 -6.0 7.1 5 97.0 -10.2
5019 Measured Control XYZ -1.3 6.5 6.6 3 -52.8 -5.8
Point Id Status Type Class Vx Vy V(xy) # Rays SVx SVy rx ry x-coord y-coord
1_21 Measured Pass -0.8 -0.5 0.9 3 -88.4 -86.8
1_22 Measured Pass 1.2 8.7 8.8 3 4.7 -89.0
1_23 Measured Pass 5.4 -8.7 10.2 5 94.4 -93.0
1_31 Measured Pass 0.6 1.7 1.8 3 -87.0 1.6
1_32 Measured Pass 1.9 -7.8 8.0 3 -14.0 -7.9
1_33 Measured Pass 3.6 -2.4 4.4 3 79.9 3.7
1_41 Measured Pass -2.9 0.0 2.9 2 -101.7 96.3
1_42 Measured Pass -0.4 0.0 0.4 2 -8.5 82.4
1_43 Measured Pass 0.3 0.0 0.3 2 90.4 86.0
5014 Measured Control XYZ 1.3 3.9 4.1 2 -54.5 59.0
5015 Measured Control XYZ -8.3 -0.4 8.3 4 89.6 58.2
5018 Measured Control XYZ -1.5 3.0 3.3 5 98.9 -97.1
5019 Measured Control XYZ -0.4 2.6 2.6 3 -51.5 -92.9
Point Id Status Type Class Vx Vy V(xy) # Rays SVx SVy rx ry x-coord y-coord
1_31 Measured Pass -3.1 -0.8 3.2 3 -92.4 -85.2
1_32 Measured Pass 0.0 3.9 3.9 3 -18.4 -95.6
1_33 Measured Pass -0.6 1.2 1.4 3 75.1 -85.0
1_41 Measured Pass 2.8 -0.1 2.8 2 -106.2 10.6
1_42 Measured Pass 0.4 0.0 0.4 2 -12.0 -5.3
1_43 Measured Pass -0.3 0.0 0.3 2 86.0 -3.6
5014 Measured Control XYZ -2.1 -4.0 4.5 2 -58.7 -27.7
5015 Measured Control XYZ 3.0 -0.2 3.0 4 85.0 -30.9
70
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Aerial Triangulation Training Manual – Laboratory
Point Id Status Type Class Vx Vy V(xy) # Rays SVx SVy rx ry x-coord y-coord
1_13 Measured Pass 1.4 -6.0 6.1 3 -93.5 -53.4
1_23 Measured Pass 1.5 -0.2 1.5 5 -88.7 30.4
1_24 Measured Pass -5.0 0.1 5.0 2 -14.7 29.3
1_25 Measured Pass -3.6 0.0 3.6 2 102.8 22.7
1_33_1 Measured Pass 3.5 0.3 3.6 3 -82.5 96.9
1_34 Measured Pass -2.3 1.8 3.0 3 -10.0 99.3
1_35 Measured Pass 5.6 -3.4 6.6 3 98.9 85.9
5017 Measured Control XYZ -1.6 5.1 5.4 2 60.1 21.5
5018 Measured Control XYZ 0.5 2.3 2.3 5 -83.7 25.9
Point Id Status Type Class Vx Vy V(xy) # Rays SVx SVy rx ry x-coord y-coord
1_23 Measured Pass -6.8 10.5 12.5 5 -87.1 -60.1
1_24 Measured Pass 5.0 0.0 5.0 2 -13.6 -59.9
1_25 Measured Pass 3.5 0.0 3.5 2 105.4 -64.5
1_33_1 Measured Pass -5.4 -0.7 5.4 3 -82.2 7.1
1_34 Measured Pass -7.9 -3.5 8.6 3 -9.7 10.8
1_35 Measured Pass -5.9 6.6 8.8 3 101.3 -0.4
1_43_1 Measured Pass 4.1 0.0 4.1 2 -83.0 77.4
1_44 Measured Pass 1.9 0.0 1.9 2 -19.4 78.5
1_45 Measured Pass -0.9 0.0 0.9 2 93.1 74.6
5015 Measured Control XYZ -2.1 -1.1 2.4 4 -91.9 88.0
5016 Measured Control XYZ 8.5 -2.0 8.7 2 63.8 84.6
5017 Measured Control XYZ -2.0 -2.3 3.1 2 61.9 -66.3
5018 Measured Control XYZ 8.1 -7.5 11.0 5 -82.2 -64.2
Point Id Status Type Class Vx Vy V(xy) # Rays SVx SVy rx ry x-coord y-coord
1_33_1 Measured Pass 1.8 0.3 1.8 3 -86.5 -87.4
1_34 Measured Pass 10.1 1.6 10.3 3 -12.9 -83.7
1_35 Measured Pass 0.3 -3.3 3.3 3 98.3 -94.7
1_43_1 Measured Pass -4.0 0.1 4.0 2 -86.1 -16.1
1_44 Measured Pass -1.9 0.0 1.9 2 -22.0 -15.5
1_45 Measured Pass 0.9 0.0 0.9 2 89.8 -19.3
5015 Measured Control XYZ -0.5 3.8 3.8 4 -95.0 -5.4
5016 Measured Control XYZ -6.9 -2.6 7.4 2 60.8 -9.4
Object Statistics
Point Id Status Type Class VX VY VZ V(XYZ) Std Dev X Std Dev Y Std
Dev Z # Rays Computed X Computed Y Computed Z Given X Given Y Given Z SVX SVY
SVZ RX RY RZ
1_11 Pass
2 514846.087 127655.701 1178.287
1_12 Pass
2 514663.073 126137.951 1163.902
1_13 Pass
3 514654.135 124754.915 1169.516
1_21 Pass
3 516030.225 127623.623 1182.112
1_22 Pass
3 516020.625 126125.273 1170.717
1_23 Pass
5 515990.434 124714.856 1174.266
1_24 Pass
2 516003.089 123534.180 1168.219
1_25 Pass
2 515943.722 121610.362 1154.138
1_31 Pass
71
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Aerial Triangulation Training Manual – Laboratory
Point Statistics
72
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Aerial Triangulation Training Manual – Laboratory
73
Copyright Howard Turner 1998
Aerial Triangulation Training Manual – Laboratory
Exterior Orientation
74
Copyright Howard Turner 1998